The NXR Podcast - March 14, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - Practical Parenting Principles

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Trump Dissolves The Department of Education? THE LIVESTREAM - The Power to Win: Why Conservatives Must Stop Surrendering

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 40 minutes

Words per minute

181.3

Word count

18,168

Sentence count

774

Harmful content

Misogyny

27

sentences flagged

Toxicity

13

sentences flagged

Hate speech

60

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, the Right Response Ministries team talks about practical parenting, training, and everything in between. In this episode of the podcast, the team discusses practical parenting and how to deal with it in the real world.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 king solomon basically once said that of the writing of parenting books there shall be no end
00:00:36 from shepherding a child's heart to all the gospel centered centered gospel movement books of the
00:00:43 2010s there are plenty of books out there on the theology or the principles of parenting but
00:00:51 parenting is unique in that the Bible offers little practical instruction. Yes, of course,
00:00:58 the Bible instructs us on what we are to teach our children. And yes, it lays out for us the
00:01:04 tools of discipline. But the Bible says surprisingly little to nothing of all the practicals that make
00:01:13 up the day in and day out experience of actually being a parent. This is also what books on
00:01:20 principles of the goals of parenting, they typically fail in this area as well. This is
00:01:27 because the goal of parenting is not actually to follow a precise formula, be it from the Bible or
00:01:34 the latest and greatest parenting book, but rather the goal is to learn wisdom. The Bible doesn't
00:01:41 make robots out of parents or children for that matter, but rather it provides for us the
00:01:47 instructions and principles to shape our souls to love and adore the good, the true, and the
00:01:55 beautiful. And much of that learning and wisdom is practical in nature, not merely theoretical.
00:02:02 Now, this episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reese Fund,
00:02:08 as well as our Patreon members and our generous donors. You can join our Patreon by going to
00:02:15 patreon.com forward slash Right Response Ministries, or you can donate by going to
00:02:22 rightresponseministries.com forward slash donate. So today, let's dive into practical lessons on
00:02:30 parenting, training, discipline, and everything in between.
00:02:35 all right all right you saw his handsome face in the stinger but he is not here
00:02:47 michael is engaged in i would say the reputable art would be an art of camping or in other words
00:02:55 pretending to be homeless yeah when i pay my mortgage and lay down on my nice king bed you
00:02:59 know what i think to myself i should go outside i should go get eaten alive by mosquitoes yeah
00:03:03 and sleep in a tent and part of you know like maybe we'd be singing a different tune if we
00:03:08 lived you know in wyoming or montana or sure we live in texas if you did like an airbnb with a
00:03:13 cabin without wi-fi air conditioning sure yeah i'll camp there and people are like okay you guys
00:03:18 are soft and that's fair maybe you know guilty as charged but uh we're talking about texas guys
00:03:23 texas is it is not the place where you want to sleep outside there are bugs the size of horses
00:03:29 Like they can, I feel like I've witnessed fire ants physically pick up my young children
00:03:35 and begin to carry them away and I have to run after them and save their lives.
00:03:39 Texas is bug infested.
00:03:41 We're also a border state, you know, so it's, you know, there's an invasion, not just of 1.00
00:03:45 bugs, but illegal immigrants. 1.00
00:03:47 You know, there's all sorts of things. 1.00
00:03:49 And there is also most importantly, unbearable heat and humility, it makes you humble, humidity.
00:03:57 So Michael's camping.
00:03:58 we don't know why um but it's the two of us today he didn't get the call he saw crisis king can't do
00:04:03 it because i can't do it we've done this too many times can't do it again but when we talk about
00:04:07 parenting which it's actually kind of a bummer he's not here because he's raised i would say
00:04:10 three wonderful children they're great friends to our family uh joel you have five children correct
00:04:16 five i lose count sometimes so just confirm it's five i myself have two children so we're in the
00:04:21 younger years for sure we don't have teenagers although michael does and so i don't think we
00:04:26 would sit here and say we've got parenting all figured out this is what you do here's a little
00:04:30 formula but there's things that we've talked about many times in the show that can be timely advice
00:04:34 instead of timeless so what we'll say today here i don't think at 500 years you know someone will
00:04:40 be really struggling with a problem child and they'll uncover in the vault this episode on
00:04:44 practical parenting to be like every single thing they said was so relevant and pertinent and
00:04:49 practical honestly probably not and that's not the goal but for right now for evangelical
00:04:55 Christians in the year of our Lord, 2025, in a time when it's tough for two parents, tough for
00:05:00 the dad to keep the mom at home. In times like this, what are some practical things, some trends
00:05:05 maybe, some reactions to ways that things have been done in the past that we can talk about,
00:05:10 that we can hopefully offer some advice to? Again, that's not necessarily timeless. For all time,
00:05:15 we've got lots of books, the theology, the principles, the ideas, the foundations of
00:05:19 parenting. We've got that. Read those books. Those are good. But ultimately, what we need to lay on
00:05:24 top of that, to build on top of that foundation, is the practical day-in and day-out wisdom.
00:05:28 Amen.
00:05:29 I want to lay out just a little bit of how we got here, especially if you, probably a
00:05:34 lot of our listeners came from a bit of fundamentalist background.
00:05:37 So if you're American evangelical and your parents or your grandparents were fundamentalist,
00:05:41 if you remember in the 70s and 80s, so this would be, well, in many ways, the children
00:05:45 of the boomer generation, getting into the 80s and the 90s, those were a time of a lot
00:05:50 of rebellion.
00:05:50 So this was rock and roll, free love, drugs, Woodstock, anti-war movement.
00:05:56 The 80s and the 90s is, of course, coming on the heels of the Civil Rights Act, the 0.60
00:06:00 Heart Cellar Immigration Act.
00:06:01 There's a lot of upheaval and turmoil.
00:06:04 And this is kind of the soil that you would have, for example, Bill Gothard come out of.
00:06:07 And I remember Bill Gothard and his teaching and his books and all of that.
00:06:12 So he actually is not a parent.
00:06:13 He wasn't a parent, which is funny.
00:06:15 It's really funny.
00:06:16 We're sitting here with seven more kids than he ever had.
00:06:18 But a lot of people came out of that and they said, look, parents, you're scared about losing
00:06:24 your kids. You're scared of losing them to this. You're scared of them becoming communists or
00:06:29 socialists or hippies or whatever it is like that. And what he offered, and I think what some other
00:06:33 writers in the time, I think of Michael and Debbie Pearl, as they said, it's scary. I get that. But
00:06:38 here's a formula that if you follow, you can do your best to kind of guarantee these outcomes.
00:06:43 I know it's scary. I know all of this. I'm not even a parent. But if you follow, I mean, Bill
00:06:48 authored it was literally called basic life principles blp and it was seven different
00:06:53 principles like the authority principle and things like that and his guarantee to parents was follow
00:06:57 this do this and you'll your kids will turn out okay the question on everyone's mind how do i
00:07:04 keep my kids was what he came in and said this is your solution same thing with the pearls i would
00:07:09 say in many ways yeah mike on debbie pearl real quick in the chat i just it's a helpful question
00:07:13 G.K. Chesterton, he said, is rebellion inevitable with some children? I would answer that simply by
00:07:19 saying, yes, but not only with some children, but all children. The Bible teaches that a rebellion
00:07:25 is bound up in the heart of a child, but the rod will remove it far from them. So every child is
00:07:31 rebellious. Not every child is going to manifest their rebellion in the same way. So some children
00:07:41 are externally more compliant. And other children, particularly boys, might be, you know, externally
00:07:48 more. That rebellion is seen on the exterior. It's more manifest. It's more obvious. But every child
00:07:56 is rebellious. You know, the question is simply to what degree and in what areas and through what
00:08:04 avenues, what methods. But every child is rebellious by virtue of being a sinner. In sin, 0.50
00:08:10 did my mother conceive me in iniquity, I was brought forth. That's what David says
00:08:14 in the Psalms. And so because of total depravity, because of the doctrine of original sin,
00:08:19 we are all fallen in Adam. And so we are physically born in this life as sinners,
00:08:25 and therefore we are rebellious. Romans chapter 8 says that the mind of the sinful man is hostile
00:08:30 towards the things of God. He cannot, he will not submit to God's law, nor can he. It's not just
00:08:36 what he's unwilling to do, but he's unwilling because he is unable. And so apart from salvation
00:08:41 that comes by grace alone, through faith alone, and Christ alone, from day one of your children,
00:08:47 unless they're regenerate in the womb, like a John the Baptist kind of situation, which I would say
00:08:52 is exceedingly rare, then what you should presuppose and assume is that your child is
00:08:59 hostile towards the things of God and rebellious towards the authority that God has put in place,
00:09:05 which chiefly in those early years and stage of life would be parents and so yes your child
00:09:12 not just some children but all children are rebellious and so that's something that you
00:09:17 should not just consider as a possibility but you should you should bank on it and then the
00:09:23 question of course and the things that we'll be talking about today is okay so then what shall we
00:09:27 do how do how do we deal with that kind of rebellion yep absolutely so i give all that
00:09:32 background to say, I really think 2000s, 2010s, people now that are in their 20s and their 30s,
00:09:39 if you grew up fundamentalist, you probably came out of that movement. So there's a lot of emphasis
00:09:43 on spanking and discipline and all of those different things. But to the point being that
00:09:48 we may now be in a time, I don't know, Joel, maybe you disagree with me on this, that if you grew up
00:09:52 and you agree with all of that, that now the time is not necessarily to continue to put re-emphasis
00:09:58 on the foundation, which is the explicit commands of scripture as it relates to discipline. Those
00:10:03 are well and good, and those form the foundation of good parenting. But there's many different
00:10:08 things that are not just a spreadsheet of what type of spankings, in what scenario do I give my
00:10:14 child. A great example of this would be, say, you have two siblings that fight again and again
00:10:18 over toys. Now, certainly the answer is, well, they're hitting, they're punching, they're yelling,
00:10:23 They're losing their temper, applying discipline, but also there might be something more underneath
00:10:28 that.
00:10:29 You might have too many toys.
00:10:30 We'll get to this in the second segment, a little bit of consumerism, but there's tons
00:10:34 of different tools and ways of thinking about it where if all you're limited to, if the
00:10:37 only tool in your toolbox is physical discipline, corporal punishment, if that's your only
00:10:43 tool, then that doesn't necessarily in and of itself take a lot of wisdom to apply to
00:10:49 shape the soul.
00:10:49 That is certainly the foundation because the Bible lays it out.
00:10:52 he who spares the rod spoils his child, but we then take that and you build on top of that to
00:10:57 build the complete child, the godly child, training and instruction. Some people will say,
00:11:03 that's made up, the Bible doesn't say he who spares the rod spoils the child. You're right, 1.00
00:11:07 the Bible what it exactly says is he who spares the rod hates his child, so it's even worse.
00:11:12 Exactly. And so that would be the first bit of emphasis is on that, and then to the tools,
00:11:20 And then the big thing, and this is, I think, a form of encouragement.
00:11:25 Another big thing coming out of that movement was very dogmatic blanket assertions, right?
00:11:29 So my parents used to hear back in the day, you know, like, if your kid's five and they're
00:11:33 not well-trained, then you've lost the child.
00:11:35 And they're very much so our children that by five, they're well-trained, they're behaved,
00:11:41 they're not getting spankings, they're doing well.
00:11:43 And then there's firstborn boys where that just isn't going to happen.
00:11:46 and if you think in your mind like like all children this gets into blank slate and things
00:11:50 we talk about with genetics all children are blank slate they come out of the womb and it's
00:11:54 your instruction and you're nurturing and you're training it makes them how they are and they get
00:11:59 to three and you look at your son you're like holy cow he's terrible compared to my friends
00:12:04 you compare him to other kids you compare maybe girls to boys you could very easily and i know
00:12:09 moms who have had this they look at their kid and they're like i am disciplining so much i'm doing
00:12:15 all of this and I look at this other parent and they say they say a strong word and the kid breaks
00:12:20 down and cries you have to get out of that idea of this is what the kids should look like these
00:12:26 are the benchmarks that fit every child and instead say how is this child made how am I
00:12:33 uniquely equipped to train to guide and to steer and honestly it just straight up takes longer for
00:12:40 some kids than other and that doesn't mean you're failing as a parent you could look and say yeah
00:12:44 My kid, he's taken a while to learn this compared to this other one.
00:12:48 And it's not necessarily, it could be, but it's not necessarily that I failed at a child.
00:12:52 It's the way God made them.
00:12:53 For boys, for example, ambition, energy, even aggression to a certain point, those aren't
00:12:59 bad things.
00:13:00 It's not a bad thing to be a boy and have tons of energy.
00:13:03 And sometimes the energy overflows into knocking things down in the house, causing a ruckus,
00:13:08 bowling over your siblings.
00:13:09 You're not disciplining him for being a boy.
00:13:11 And so taking each child, it's so important.
00:13:14 How is this child made?
00:13:16 What is their inclination?
00:13:17 Where is the rebellion?
00:13:18 And where is their sin?
00:13:19 How does it manifest?
00:13:20 Where do they lose their temper?
00:13:21 How do I have to shape that?
00:13:23 And then understanding it could look completely different from another parent.
00:13:27 And that doesn't necessarily mean that you're failing.
00:13:31 Right.
00:13:31 Yeah, train up a child in the way he should go.
00:13:34 And when he is older, he will not depart from it.
00:13:36 certainly there's a general truth there that every child, there is a general path that's
00:13:44 applicable to all children. So there is the way, train up a child in the way, the way that he
00:13:50 should go. All children are to be trained and oriented towards Christ, his law, his principles,
00:14:00 principles, the gospel, salvation, grace. And so there are general universal principles
00:14:07 that must be applied for every single child. But I think there's also, it's not at the expense of
00:14:14 that, it's not either or, I think it's both and. There's also, I think, a faithful way of
00:14:19 interpreting that verse to say, train up a child in the way he should go, in referencing the fact
00:14:26 that there is some degree of variance, that children are different, like what you just
00:14:31 said, Wes. For our children, you know, they're very young, but we have, you know, a seven-year-old,
00:14:36 a five-year-old, a four-year-old, a two-year-old, and an infant. And already, with the four older
00:14:45 one, the baby, you know, is a baby, but the four older children already, like, it's blatantly
00:14:51 obvious that they're not the same. They're different. Um, one of our children, uh, one of
00:14:57 our girls, it's our second oldest, uh, is we, you know, we've known for years now, she's only,
00:15:03 you know, um, she's only five years old, but we've known since she was, uh, three, um, for at least
00:15:10 a couple of years now, we've known that she just has a, a higher propensity towards, uh, the things
00:15:18 of the world worldliness like she we have to be extra careful with her because um she will you 1.00
00:15:25 know if we go out in public um and you know and you know we're at a restaurant and girls are dressed 0.61
00:15:32 in a immodest way we'll find you know that it catches her her gaze and her attention um in a 0.85
00:15:40 way that you know our oldest and our and then our third child um are you know they they don't really 0.81
00:15:46 care, you know, so like our oldest, like is a sinner as well. And she has, you know, things, 1.00
00:15:51 you know, her own propensities and inclinations. Um, but she's not as naturally worldly. Um,
00:15:58 she's not as concerned with, um, being cool or, um, or being the prettiest or being, you know,
00:16:07 this or that our oldest is also a girl. Um, whereas, you know, she has her own struggles,
00:16:12 struggles of you know approval very much she would be more tempted to be compliant but not
00:16:20 really out of a desire necessarily to please the Lord but simply for the approval of mom and dad
00:16:26 and so so she's very approval driven whereas our second is more is more worldly like the the lust
00:16:34 of the eyes like I see something it's shiny it's pretty all all the you know all the other cool
00:16:41 kids are doing it, and she's very tempted by that. And so early on, identifying, and things also
00:16:48 change. Children develop, they grow, they're not static. And so being able to see, you know,
00:16:54 train up a child in the way that they should go. All children should go the way of Christ. And so
00:16:58 there are some universal principles that apply across the board, but there's also particulars
00:17:03 that are individual to each specific child. And not all children are the same. Children are
00:17:10 different. They have different dispositions. And so as a parent, trying to use discernment and
00:17:16 quickly to the best of your ability to identify what those particular inclinations are and then
00:17:24 to be able to act accordingly. Yeah. And that's not something you can read in a book. There's no
00:17:28 book written about anyone's children that's going to lay out a formula for identifying what makes
00:17:33 them tick. You have to be a good, you'd almost say student of human nature. What motivates this
00:17:38 child even at a younger age what makes what interests them same thing for boys how am i
00:17:44 steering them like there's boys just straight up you could try to push them into sports and
00:17:47 baseball and like do this do this they're just guys that are more geared towards engineering
00:17:52 art music and the point being god made them that way and us as parents were given them to then
00:17:58 steward it with wisdom it's not a blank slate that then we plug them into a formula and we do it this
00:18:03 way, they'll all turn out X, Y, and Z, clones one, clone two, clone three, but managing and caring
00:18:09 for them. Just in a way, I think of Peter where he says, husbands, do not be harsh with your wives.
00:18:16 And what he's literally saying there is the word is according to knowledge, live your wives in
00:18:21 understanding way. So do not be harsh, but live with them in an understanding way. Literally the
00:18:24 word there is according to knowledge. So Peter to wives, husbands, living with your wives, 0.97
00:18:29 Husbands, live with your wives according to knowledge of God's word and a knowledge of 0.62
00:18:33 how they are. 1.00
00:18:34 Women as the weaker vessel. 1.00
00:18:35 Know your wife. 1.00
00:18:36 Exactly.
00:18:37 And so what is it for your children, too, that makes them despondent, destroys them,
00:18:42 crushes them the way maybe other kids don't?
00:18:44 And then understanding that is, of course, the key to caring for it well.
00:18:48 Yep.
00:18:49 All right.
00:18:49 We'll go to our first commercial break, and we'll be right back.
00:18:51 Okay.
00:18:53 Our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants to help you with one money move that'll implicate
00:18:58 itself in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day. They help you to avoid
00:19:03 taxation and to draw compound interest to your money. Now, if you're a high net worth individual,
00:19:10 someone who has maybe even $10 million in net worth, then they can help you even more. W-2
00:19:16 workers, contract workers, business owners, it's all about cash flow and making tax deferred gains
00:19:24 on all your money for the rest of your life.
00:19:27 Don't avoid this.
00:19:28 It's a big move, but it's a great time to make it.
00:19:31 Click the link below
00:19:32 and you can get on Chuck DeLaterante's calendar
00:19:34 and he'll go over your background
00:19:36 and what you want to accomplish.
00:19:38 And he's going to help model a program
00:19:40 that exactly fits your needs.
00:19:43 So go ahead and send an email
00:19:44 to chuck at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:19:48 Again, that's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com
00:19:51 or you can click the link below.
00:19:54 Make a free discovery call now.
00:19:56 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God
00:20:00 and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:20:04 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied,
00:20:08 not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business
00:20:11 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:20:15 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:20:20 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain
00:20:24 our capacity to do things here.
00:20:26 Reese Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
00:20:32 All right.
00:20:34 So this is a little bit of a personal point of emphasis of mine.
00:20:38 We talked about it a little bit.
00:20:39 This would have been our usury episode where we talked about commercialism and everything
00:20:42 like that.
00:20:43 But there's a really good book called Simplicity Parenting that's really helpful on this.
00:20:47 But the amount of toys, the amount of stuff, and the amount of consumerism that our children
00:20:53 are exposed to is incredibly high.
00:20:56 So we talked about timely principles, a timely principle that you, parent, in the year of
00:21:00 our Lord, 2025, you have to be aware of, is that your children, if you're not vigilant,
00:21:06 if you're not watchful, they're going to be bombarded day in and day out with the inclination
00:21:12 to buy, the inclination to consume.
00:21:16 I'm going to read a couple of statistics here.
00:21:18 This is all from peer-reviewed research.
00:21:20 This first one is incredible.
00:21:22 On average, preschool children see nearly 25,000 television commercials.
00:21:27 So we're not talking kindergarten, first, second, third grade.
00:21:31 Preschool children, so leading up in the preschool time, on average, see 25,000 television commercials.
00:21:37 I'll tell you what, when I watch television, you know I look at those ads and I think,
00:21:40 this would be great for my two-year-old to see.
00:21:43 Not, not quite.
00:21:45 There's tons of research on the negative effects of screens for children,
00:21:49 so parking in front of the screens.
00:21:51 The more times preschool children spend with screens,
00:21:53 the less time they spend engaged in creative play.
00:21:55 That's one study, the foundation of learning.
00:21:58 Another study, constructive problem solving and creativity.
00:22:02 Direct exposure to TV and overall household viewing
00:22:04 are associated with increased early childhood aggression.
00:22:08 Screen time for children under three is linked to irregular sleep patterns
00:22:11 and delayed language acquisition.
00:22:13 there's tons of different statistics on this obviously screen exposure goes up and this is
00:22:18 even before all the terrible things that a kid could see when they're exposed to television this
00:22:23 is aside from the movies aside from the music aside from all those things that would be negative in
00:22:28 and of themselves just this exposure them in and of itself just plopping of kid in front of the tv
00:22:34 just seeing them especially a boy taking a boy with energy and ambition and creative play
00:22:41 parking them in front of something that's highly stimulating like why is coco melon why is it so
00:22:47 loud why are there so many colors to keep your kid engaged to keep them focused so they look at it
00:22:53 watch it more like all of these different things be it uh like there's milk for example strawberry
00:22:59 milk in the store it has your disney cartoon characters on that why because it makes it
00:23:04 taste better no so your kids beg their parents to buy it at the store all of it geared towards
00:23:12 consume consume consume now the answer is of course not zero toys zero screen time you get
00:23:20 your first phone you're 18 although to be fair that's not the worst approach but uh you really
00:23:25 have to think especially today how is consumerism how is stuff how are toys how is this impacting
00:23:34 my child. There's a lot of research, for example, on the more toys a child has, the more overwhelming
00:23:39 it can be, and the more it stifles creative play. Boredom is a great source of, I need to figure out
00:23:45 how to do something. I need to figure out how to play pretend, to imagine, to learn to do. When you 0.65
00:23:52 fill up a toy room full of junk, and I know grandma and grandpa do it too. They bring stuff in.
00:23:57 when you do that you rob children of boredom you rob them of imagination you put a bunch of plastic
00:24:05 in there for one that's probably toxic and not good for them put a bunch of plastic in there
00:24:09 and you just try to get them to be stimulated to death overwhelmed to death like i was citing in
00:24:15 some of those statistics it's borne out in other ones it's not good for children now it's not the
00:24:19 end of the world if you have a lot of toys and your kids see some tv but by and large on the
00:24:25 whole what is our family consuming is it youtube tv is it secular music is it junky plastic toys
00:24:34 or we have invested in spending time outside christian music wholesome entertainment good
00:24:40 stories especially for boys like a lot of disney me and nathan were talking about it a lot of disney
00:24:45 movies as good as they are especially the old ones which even then there's problems mostly
00:24:50 focus on princesses if we're honest what are what are my boys taking in well they're watching you
00:24:55 know like a small amount of movies a week and all those movies are about princesses all the books
00:25:00 we read are about this you have to be thinking on the whole what is my child taking in
00:25:06 yep well said i agree um we could briefly talk you know i want to be somewhat careful because
00:25:16 we live in a world that that hates christianity and hates the bible and hates children unfortunately 0.98
00:25:22 If they can't kill the child in the womb by persuading the parent to get an abortion 0.99
00:25:31 or convincing them that somehow that's a wonderful thing to do
00:25:36 then they're going to try, in biblical terms, according to the Bible's definitions
00:25:40 they're going to try to ensure that at least the child
00:25:43 it's regretful that the child was born
00:25:46 but now we can still at least ensure that the child is not loved
00:25:52 by any meaningful biblical definition.
00:25:54 The Bible talks about discipline being loving.
00:25:58 In Hebrews chapter 12, God disciplines us as his children,
00:26:01 and he does so in love.
00:26:04 And then we already quoted earlier in the episode,
00:26:06 the one who spares the rod hates his child.
00:26:10 And so the absence of discipline is a form of hatred and neglect and apathy.
00:26:19 And so indifference.
00:26:22 towards the child so um we could talk a little bit about spanking um let me just say it's something
00:26:28 that we need to do carefully because you know we live in a world that like i said hates children
00:26:33 and therefore hates what god has prescribed it is if you're thinking about moving it is legal in
00:26:38 texas so it's legal and even in texas too some states have laws against this but one parent
00:26:43 can't be mad that the other parent did so and use the law against them so texas is fully said 0.91
00:26:49 obviously abuse of course not or like damage or anything like that but spanking as a means of
00:26:54 discipline is legal in texas one parent can't tell the other parent no i don't want you to do it 0.81
00:26:59 and you know making the case for texas texas is great on homeschooling we're about to get school
00:27:04 choice which will provide several thousands of dollars for private schools that'd be christian
00:27:09 school or homeschooling it's good on spanking so if you're a family and you live in i mean we've
00:27:14 had families from europe that have said like homeschooling is illegal these things are illegal
00:27:18 we literally can't do them uh move to the united states same thing uh there are different states
00:27:23 that straight up have laws against it or they're really strict on homeschooling requiring standardized
00:27:27 tests and paperwork and all of that so texas is a very pro-family state which is awesome praise
00:27:32 the lord we hope it stays that way but even then on the topic of spanking the texas law does allow
00:27:36 for parents to administer that and has no problems with it right yeah name of the game you know my
00:27:42 My wife and I, you know, we always say that, you know, the name of the game with spanking
00:27:46 is hurt, not harm.
00:27:47 You know, like you said a second ago, you know, bifurcating abuse from biblical discipline
00:27:53 that, you know, one of the distinctives of abuse is damage.
00:27:59 You use the word damage, you know, or lasting harm.
00:28:02 The name of the game is hurt. 1.00
00:28:05 Like spankings are supposed to hurt. 0.98
00:28:07 If it doesn't even hurt, then there's no sense in doing it.
00:28:09 So it is supposed to hurt, but it's not supposed to harm.
00:28:13 That's why, you know, traditionally, like, you know, you spank a child's bottom because it's, you know, resilient and there's, you know, extra padding and all those kinds of things so that it's not going to do lasting harm or damage.
00:28:29 You're not trying to harm the child.
00:28:30 You are trying to give them a momentary, right?
00:28:33 So Hebrews 12 also tells us that no discipline is pleasant for the time, but in the moment where it's unpleasant, that moment is fleeting, it's momentary, and so too should parental discipline, it should be something that hurts, it's uncomfortable, it's not pleasant in the time, but it should be something that quickly is fleeting.
00:28:57 Hopefully the memory and the lesson is lasting, but the pain is not.
00:29:01 Can I wax eloquent, too, on the biological reasons that we would do that and why God instructs it?
00:29:06 So the prefrontal cortex, you have the motor cortex, which is in the center of your brain.
00:29:10 The prefrontal cortex in the front is what controls inhibition.
00:29:13 So the reason we like alcohol is because when we take alcohol, one of the byproducts of it suppresses the function of your premortar cortex.
00:29:21 You're more likely to dance or to talk to strangers and be friendly because the things you're normally inhibited from doing,
00:29:26 I'm self-conscious, I don't want to dance in front of people, that's then inhibited chemically.
00:29:30 it's a chemical reaction it's not mysterious or spiritual it's a chemical reaction that causes you
00:29:35 to be less inhibited and the things that you want to do you carry out and ultimately a lot of times
00:29:39 do things you regret but in the same way you have two and three year old boys for instance they are
00:29:44 the most statistically they're the most violent by any age of child and now obviously their violence
00:29:50 is not very powerful because they're little but that's because of brain development their
00:29:54 prefrontal cortex has not yet developed and learned behaviors that it needs to inhibit so
00:29:59 when you're spanking a child say a child loses his temper he throws things he acts out and you
00:30:04 administer controlled pain that's short not lasting not abusive not destructive when you
00:30:11 administer that again and again over years what you're literally doing is you're helping them
00:30:15 form the connection that when i lose control of my emotions when i lose control and hit when i yell
00:30:22 when i stop when i do these things it brings pain it hurts because if you don't get that skill if
00:30:29 you're never inhibited and you're never disciplined and you never experience what that looks like
00:30:32 you'll be an adult you'll be 25 and you'll have no inhibition and you won't be able to save money
00:30:37 you won't be able to keep a relationship you won't be able to show up on time because you
00:30:40 have not learned the skill of resisting the things you want to do and saying no i have to be in
00:30:46 control of my emotions and it's a mercy two three four years old right at that stage to administer
00:30:52 something that in the moment is painful for them to learn i have to control my emotion because if
00:30:58 i don't it hurts and it'll hurt at adulthood if you don't learn that lesson in much more damaging
00:31:03 ways right or you can learn it in 20 minutes right that's three years old that's the key that um
00:31:09 all of life is filled with consequences for bad decisions and bad behavior um you never outgrow
00:31:15 that the only thing that changes is what you just said the consequences become increasingly
00:31:20 exponentially more severe and so what you're doing it is a mercy what you're doing is you're
00:31:26 hoping to teach that young boy, to teach him, you know, inhibition and self-control and, you know,
00:31:34 good behavior and those kinds of things when the stakes are much lower, rather than him learning
00:31:39 those things later when the stakes are much higher. And so he, yes, he's experiencing pain
00:31:44 in discipline for bad choices, for bad behavior, but the pain in discipline that he's experiencing
00:31:50 as a young man, as a boy, that pain is low stakes pain. It's fleeting. It's minimal.
00:32:00 The pain that he'll experience later in life, it won't be a spanking, but it'll be far more
00:32:06 severe than that. And so it is a mercy. It is a grace to children. One thing that I was going to
00:32:11 say just practically, because we opened the episode saying, you know, we wanted to be practical.
00:32:15 one thing that was really helpful for my wife and I was, um, was having like two categories of, 1.00
00:32:23 of, uh, spankings. Um, and so we, you know, the language that we use, um, is we, we say, 1.00
00:32:32 you know, there's spankings and then there's swats is what we say, uh, spankings and swats.
00:32:38 And we place those in two different categories. And what we mean by that is, you know, for
00:32:42 the first couple of years when we were new parents, um, we, you know, we were persuaded and,
00:32:48 and, you know, we had been taught that basically every time you do discipline,
00:32:54 it's, uh, it's a big event, you know, it's, it requires a lot of intentionality and it's going
00:33:01 to, at the practical level, it's just going to require a lot of time. Um, you know, and so like
00:33:06 from a lot of the gospel centered books. So it's like, yes, you know, like a lot of those guys,
00:33:11 you know, they would say, you know, yeah, I mean, the Bible does talk about spanking. And so we
00:33:15 can't, you know, we can't say that's not a thing, but, you know, you need to be sure that, you know,
00:33:20 it's not just a spanking. It's that you're going back to the room, to a bedroom. It's private.
00:33:25 You're explaining to the child on the front end what it is that they did that was wrong.
00:33:31 And then, you know, you're preaching the gospel to them and reminding them, you know,
00:33:34 you're telling them what was wrong. You're getting, you know, some kind of admission of guilt. Can you,
00:33:39 can you see that that was wrong?
00:33:41 And I need you to acknowledge that you did sin.
00:33:43 I need you to apologize.
00:33:45 Okay, now we're going to have a consequence. 1.00
00:33:47 Here comes the spanking. 0.99
00:33:48 Okay, and now we're going to do
00:33:49 the second half of our lecture,
00:33:51 you know, and we're going to, you know,
00:33:53 and now we'll focus on grace.
00:33:54 You know, you are forgiven.
00:33:56 It's been made right.
00:33:58 I love you.
00:33:59 And ultimately, you know, dad, he sins also.
00:34:02 And we're only forgiven because of the grace of God.
00:34:05 And none of us can do anything to earn it.
00:34:07 It's very evangelistic.
00:34:08 Every spanking is like that.
00:34:09 evangelistic opportunity. Yeah, a call to Jesus. Which I get the inclination, but continue.
00:34:14 And I think that's good. I think that that's a right sentiment. However, this is what my wife
00:34:20 and I noticed. What we realized is that if that's the prerequisite, the minimum expectation for
00:34:28 spanking, what my wife and I noticed is that we would just be tempted because of our own sin,
00:34:35 and our own apathy. And then even just practically, as we had more kids, it was easier.
00:34:40 You know, when we were new parents, and we only had one child, and then two.
00:34:43 Well, now we have five, you know, and, and if that's what it is, especially when I'm gone at
00:34:49 work, you know, so when I'm working, and it's my wife with five young children,
00:34:54 she realized that like, you know, she would go the whole day. And, and the children would,
00:35:00 you know, there would be occasions where they disobeyed, and they misbehaved. 0.73
00:35:03 but she wouldn't spank them because spanking meant going privately with one child into a 1.00
00:35:09 bedroom for at least 10 minutes to have five minutes talk on the front end you know spanking 1.00
00:35:14 then a five minute talk on the back end and you could say well it doesn't have to be 10 minutes 0.72
00:35:18 like you could do all that in two minutes you know a minute on the front end like but even two
00:35:22 minutes like when when you have a three-month-old who's who like in that in that moment it's like
00:35:27 the kid just disobeyed. But the seven-year-old is asking you questions. The five-year-old is
00:35:34 asking you questions. The four-year-old is crying. He's about ready for the next spanking.
00:35:42 Right. The four-year-old is crying, just got hurt and somehow playing. And then the two-year-old
00:35:50 needs discipline, and then the baby is also screaming, then you just can't. You can't do it.
00:35:58 And so what we recognize is that, again, bifurcating spankings and swats, that if spankings,
00:36:06 if that was it, if that was the only form of discipline, then what would happen is that
00:36:12 there would be plenty of occasions that one or two or three or five of the children just
00:36:18 wouldn't get discipline and uh and some discipline we eventually realize is that some discipline is
00:36:24 still better than no discipline and so it's great to have a high bar i still i still agree with the
00:36:29 basic premise of all those things like explaining to the child um that they actually sinned and what
00:36:35 that sin was and getting an acknowledgement from the child that they would admit like yeah i did
00:36:39 disobey i'm sorry an apology from the child spanking and then reminding the child of the
00:36:44 gospel of free grace and that the only hope there are some kids so stubborn they get spanked and
00:36:49 i was actually like this so encouragement to any mom that's like this first born boy is trouble
00:36:53 well i was that and i got spanked a lot i wouldn't be sorry so my mom would have to spank again and
00:36:58 again it's like do i literally have to spend every day like go through this process because they
00:37:02 wanted exactly that like they wanted to spank and then have reconciliation and just as me not every
00:37:08 kid is like this but me as a kid i was just like not sorry sometimes not even crying defiant and
00:37:14 think by god's grace i turned out okay but uh but to your point like well if mom wants to do that
00:37:19 but what if you have a strong-willed boy that's just in that moment not gonna have it right every
00:37:24 day do we have to like do the same song and dance and administer 20 30 40 50 smackings
00:37:29 yeah well that's a more complicated question we can maybe address you know later but but back to
00:37:37 real quick the the spanking versus swats is that's what we realized is that like okay sometimes
00:37:41 There's a lot going on, and we're at the dinner table, for instance, and all the children are talking to us.
00:37:47 There's five of them, and there's only two of us, and one of the kids is sinning.
00:37:56 It's clear objective disobedience is something that we've commanded several times.
00:38:00 They know what they're doing.
00:38:02 They're throwing their food on the floor, and they're not three months old.
00:38:05 They're three years old, and we've established that rule.
00:38:08 They know it, and they're deliberately doing it otherwise.
00:38:11 But we're not able to go back privately in the room.
00:38:17 And so on those occasions, I do think that having that extra tool in your tool belt,
00:38:23 there are spankings, and that's more intentional, and there's a talk that's involved in that.
00:38:28 And there are other times where there's a SWOT, and it's kind of an on-the-go discipline.
00:38:33 It's a quick on-the-go discipline where you can still say,
00:38:36 hey, I told you not to throw your food on the floor.
00:38:39 You know this.
00:38:39 you know that this is disobedience
00:38:41 and so you're going to get a swat
00:38:43 and there's just a little swat right there
00:38:45 at the table
00:38:46 and the other children
00:38:50 are present but they know
00:38:51 that it's done in love and then you can explain it in front
00:38:54 of all of them without having to leave the room
00:38:55 and get up and interrupt dinner
00:38:57 and I think that that
00:38:59 is helpful and without that
00:39:01 it's been my experience
00:39:04 and I've heard from
00:39:05 many many many other parents
00:39:07 It's not just unique to me, but this seems to be a universal experience that if the bar is set too high for discipline, that it has to be a spanking, it has to be private, it has to be isolated in a room.
00:39:19 It requires a talk on the front end, a talk on the back end, and this, that, and the other.
00:39:24 And it requires a very specific, the child must eventually, this gets into your thing, they have to respond by saying X, Y, and Z.
00:39:32 And if they don't respond by saying X, Y, and Z, then it must continue.
00:39:35 Then what will happen is if you have more than one kid, and we're supposed to be fruitful multiply,
00:39:40 then you'll be privately with one kid in the bedroom for an hour.
00:39:46 And your other four kids, you know, are like next in line, you know, like, and well, yeah, next in line, or even, you know, God forbid worse,
00:39:55 like there's some kind of accident and one of the kids, you know, gets hit or cuts themselves with scissors.
00:39:59 Like you can't do that as a parent.
00:40:01 You can't go back in a room with one child and leave four little children alone in the house for, you know, for 30 minutes or 20 minutes.
00:40:08 And so, yeah, so that just can't be it.
00:40:12 That can't be it.
00:40:12 So we know that the Bible, this gets back to the, you know, the cold open.
00:40:15 We know that the Bible tells us, you know, what it is, the what, the curriculum, the big ideas, the principles and virtues that we're trying to instill in our children.
00:40:24 And we know that the Bible in a general sense provides the how.
00:40:27 We know that at least one, not that it's exhaustive, that it's exclusive, the only,
00:40:32 but we know that it should be one of the tools in our arsenal is spanking, corporal punishment.
00:40:38 So we know virtue, Christian virtue, needs to be instilled in our child by teaching them,
00:40:43 and we know that when they fail, that one of the tools made available to us in Scripture
00:40:47 that we're supposed to use is spanking.
00:40:50 We know that.
00:40:51 But the Bible does not.
00:40:52 it is not so particular that it specifies, and this is how many spankings, and this is what tool
00:40:59 you have to use to spank. You need to use a spoon, or you need to use your hand, or you need to use 1.00
00:41:03 this, or you need to use that. It doesn't say how many spankings. It doesn't say how hard the 1.00
00:41:07 spanking should be. It doesn't say what the spanking should be with. It doesn't specifically, 0.99
00:41:12 the Bible doesn't actually specifically prescribe. I think it's a good instinct. There's a general
00:41:15 wisdom there whenever you have the time to do it. But the Bible doesn't say that you can never
00:41:20 spank a child unless you are privately alone with that child in the room, unless you talk for at
00:41:24 least five minutes on the front end and then talk five minutes on the back end. No spanking can ever
00:41:29 be administered without also a gospel presentation and an altar call for salvation. The Bible doesn't
00:41:35 actually say that. And so the Bible actually does give us a fairly significant degree of liberty as
00:41:43 we're able to exercise prudence and wisdom and figuring out what is best for that child and
00:41:48 what is best for our family in that stage of life and with however many kids we have and what
00:41:53 practically works. Right. Because otherwise God would be essentially tempting you and saying,
00:41:58 this is what you have to do for every moment of discipline. And also you follow my commands. You
00:42:05 had a number of children and now you're stuck between a rock and the hard place. You feel like
00:42:08 you have two commands. Well, I've got to take care of them. I've got to watch them. I've got to make
00:42:11 sure they don't get hurt. And then also I'm supposed to take this 10 minutes. God doesn't
00:42:16 put us between that rock and the hard place and it's wisdom that splits the difference between the
00:42:20 two and says well actually in this case in scenario i'm not going to the back room i'll administer it
00:42:24 here and now to your point so let's do this um nathan have we done all our commercial breaks
00:42:31 for today we have one more let's go a little bit early here let's go to our last commercial break
00:42:36 and then because we're trying to be practical we're trying to be as practical and helpful as
00:42:40 possible. Uh, we've gotten just the nature of this conversation parenting. It's just,
00:42:46 it's just so needed. And so we've gotten every episode, we get maybe, you know, five questions,
00:42:51 10 questions. And from the little bit that I've gleaned from the chat, we've probably gotten like
00:42:54 20 questions, maybe more. So I think we should just get right to the questions and just trying
00:42:59 to give, you know, practical advice and counsel as best we can. Um, so let's go early to our final
00:43:04 commercial break of the day. We'll come back exclusively deal with questions. We'll start
00:43:09 with the Super Chats and then get to as many questions beyond that as we can. And then because
00:43:14 we've already done one video today, we did one surrounding the Christ is King controversy that's
00:43:21 resurged over the last couple of days. Go and check out that video if you get a chance. But we
00:43:25 did that video already and we're doing this video. So we'll do the commercial break and we'll just
00:43:29 focus on questions and then we'll go ahead and call it a day since we're doing two videos today
00:43:33 and it's a lot.
00:43:35 All right, the clock is running out.
00:43:36 You need to go and register now
00:43:38 for our Christ is King,
00:43:40 How to Defeat Trash World Conference.
00:43:42 It's happening the year of our Lord, 2025,
00:43:46 April 3rd, 4th, and 5th.
00:43:48 That's a Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.
00:43:50 And by God's grace, we're able to provide for you
00:43:53 an all-star lineup.
00:43:55 We've got Steve Dace, Calvin Robinson,
00:43:57 Oren McIntyre, Dr. Stephen Wolfe,
00:44:00 Eric Kahn, David Reese, Andrew Isker,
00:44:02 John Harris, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, C.J. Engel, and yours truly,
00:44:10 Pastor Joel Webin. Come on out, join us April 3rd, 4th and 5th, 2025, Thursday through Saturday. Go
00:44:18 to rightresponseconference.com to register today. Again, that's rightresponseconference.com.
00:44:26 Listen, guys, you probably listen to Right Response Ministries because you take the Dominion
00:44:31 mandate offered to us in Scripture seriously? Well, unsurprisingly, so does Dominion Wealth
00:44:38 Strategist. As the only distinctly reformed financial consulting firm, they help Calvinistic,
00:44:45 covenantal, and confessional Christians to steward their resources faithfully in a way that actually
00:44:52 aligns with God's Word. Dominion Wealth leverages all corners of the financial service industry
00:44:58 as independent brokerage agents, matching you with suitable products and services from dozens
00:45:04 of top industry providers. Their mission is to equip believers to secure their family's future
00:45:11 and build a legacy that glorifies God by building holistic financial strategies that include
00:45:18 budgeting, insurance, debt management, retirement planning, estate planning, and more. In order to
00:45:26 make wealth Christian again with a portfolio that might even put King Solomon to shame, 0.75
00:45:31 go and take dominion over your finances today by visiting www.reformed.money and book an
00:45:40 introductory overview right now. All of Christ for all of life and all of finance for Christendom.
00:45:49 All right. Well, like we promised, we're going to go ahead and get to some chats. Nate,
00:45:54 which one do you want us to hit first maybe scroll to the top all right this is a good one
00:46:00 oh go ahead let's do let's do magnus connor's question quick do you think preventing having
00:46:06 kids is a sin magnus connor do you think preventing having kids is a sin so most of
00:46:11 this comes from onan uh in the old testament uh genesis i believe it's chapter 38 tamar um
00:46:19 Um, she, uh, was married to Judah was her father-in-law.
00:46:23 She was married to his oldest and, uh, we don't know exactly what he did, but, um, it
00:46:29 was displeasing.
00:46:29 The Lord, you know, supernaturally took his life from him.
00:46:32 And so then she was given a marriage to, uh, the second oldest boy, Judah's second oldest
00:46:37 son.
00:46:38 Um, and, uh, his name was Onan and Onan didn't want to fulfill, uh, his brotherly obligation
00:46:46 and duty and furthering his now-deceased older brother's biological line, his family line,
00:46:55 by giving to Tamar, who's now his wife, a child in his brother's name, a son in his brother's name.
00:47:03 And so when they would be intimate together, you know, the famous story goes that he would
00:47:10 he would spill his seed on the ground in order to not impregnate her. And it was wicked in the
00:47:17 sight of God is what the text says. And so the Lord killed him too. And so, you know, put him 0.82
00:47:23 to death. And we don't know exactly how he died, how the Lord did that, but we know that the Lord
00:47:28 was displeased and found it to be a sin and severe enough to be worthy of the Lord taking his life.
00:47:36 So that's kind of where this comes from, the sin of onanism is the idea.
00:47:42 And so there are some Christians that have gleaned from that that there should be no form of family planning whatsoever, that you have as many children as the Lord gives to you.
00:47:56 And in that family planning, not just no to birth control, no to barrier methods, no also to any type of timing, rhythm, natural family planning.
00:48:06 None of that even as well.
00:48:08 Yes.
00:48:08 So there are some Christians who take that position that to inhibit procreation in any way is wrong.
00:48:17 So we certainly agree, and we've talked about it before, that birth control in terms of the hormonal birth control pill, that we have big problems with that because of the ethics and that it risks aborting a child, that you actually have an egg that has been fertilized.
00:48:41 We believe that life begins at conception.
00:48:43 Conception is not implantation, but fertilization and the hormonal birth control pill does actually risk.
00:48:51 It can inhibit fertilization, but it also could fail where fertilization does occur,
00:48:57 but then the thinning of the uterine wall takes place in such a way that you now have a fertilized egg,
00:49:04 human being conceived and made in the image of God that has no hospitable environment to go,
00:49:08 and the woman's body ultimately aborts the child.
00:49:13 And so, you know, from the pill to, you know, what is it, IUD?
00:49:20 Yep, like a copper IUD.
00:49:22 Yeah, so there's several things like that that we believe we could speak, you know, dogmatically to
00:49:30 because of the issue of life and taking the life of a child.
00:49:34 But in terms of condoms, which are merely preventative and they're not abortifacient, or whether it be timing of the month and those kinds of things, that's where the Bible speaks with less clarity.
00:49:52 and so we would give some room for conscience there.
00:49:57 But what I've consistently taught
00:49:59 is that the general idea is that
00:50:04 the Bible teaches us that children are a blessing,
00:50:07 a heritage from the Lord
00:50:09 and that the man whose quiver is full
00:50:11 is exceedingly blessed.
00:50:14 So children are inherently a blessing
00:50:17 and the man who has a lot of children
00:50:20 is particularly blessed by God.
00:50:21 And so we want to affirm the scripture. We just have to recognize that we live in a culture today that hates children and that idolizes convenience and all these different things, money, materialism, and just simply does not have the view of children that God has and that we should have.
00:50:40 And so we need to be aware that what we might call family planning or I'm just being wise is entirely possible and very likely in many cases, especially with modern Westerns, even Christians, that what we're calling wisdom really may be fear, it may be idolatry, it may be our own comfort, our own convenience.
00:51:05 I think that that's highly likely. We live in a society, we don't have large families. They're
00:51:11 exceedingly rare. And when I say large families, I don't mean five kids. I have a family of seven.
00:51:17 We have five kids. In our church, we are a medium-sized family. So when I say large family,
00:51:23 I'm talking eight, nine, 10, 11, 12 kids. And we know plenty of families with that many kids.
00:51:30 and it's awesome. It's a blessing. And we have to believe it's a blessing because one, we see it,
00:51:35 we've witnessed that it really is objectively good and there's joy and there's warmth and
00:51:40 all those things. But also because God's word objectively says it. So in terms of that, this is
00:51:46 kind of where I've landed is what you're talking about with family planning is you're talking
00:51:52 about if children really are a heritage from the Lord, a blessing, then you're talking about the
00:51:57 mitigation of blessing. So, so then when I, when I pan out beyond children, I look at other
00:52:03 blessings. Um, you know, material provision is a blessing from the Lord. The Lord is the one who
00:52:09 gives increase. The Lord is the one ultimate, we work, but the Lord is the one who ultimately
00:52:13 provides through our work. Um, so money, um, material provision, um, is a blessing that
00:52:21 ultimately comes sovereignly from the Lord. And so the question would be, um, do we seek to
00:52:27 mitigate that blessing? Like, do we get called in by, you know, um, a supervisor at work and he
00:52:34 says, I'd like to give you a raise. And he says, I'm, you know, I'm going to give you an additional
00:52:37 $10 an hour. And you say, you know what, let's make it five because I just don't want too much
00:52:43 blessing. Well, kids add difficulty and like, you don't think a raise doesn't come with
00:52:47 responsibility and difficulty that's right it comes with money blessing it also comes with
00:52:51 responsibility all these blessings always come with a pair of resources all your great responsibility
00:52:56 it's a double-sided coin with every additional resource that the lord gives to us um there is
00:53:02 both uh both the privilege and also the duty the responsibility so more money uh means more
00:53:10 responsibility will be held uh those who who are richer and have been given more uh financially
00:53:15 will be held more accountable for that, for those resources and how they stewarded them for the
00:53:23 glory of God. If you have a higher, you know, more influence, so it doesn't just have to be
00:53:27 monetary, but more influence, a higher station of life, you know, with your job or this or that,
00:53:33 like whenever we're given more by God, it is both a blessing, a greater blessing with more,
00:53:41 more of anything, anything that the Bible says is good and not inherently evil. And money is not
00:53:47 inherently evil. It's the love of money and greed that is the root of all kinds of evil. But money
00:53:52 in and of itself is not inherently bad, not at all. And so it is a blessing. And whenever we
00:53:57 receive more of something that the Bible says is good, a blessing, then we are going to be held
00:54:05 to a higher account and there will be more obligation and responsibility for how we
00:54:10 steward that. So that's kind of how I've thought about it is, is there any other blessing in our
00:54:16 life that we would be thinking, you know what, I'd really like, you know, the blessing just
00:54:23 keeps coming. And it's just, you know, it's just too much. And I'd really like to slow that down.
00:54:27 I'd really like to make sure I have less of this blessing. And I'm asking that, you know,
00:54:33 like, it's a little tongue in cheek, but I'm asking that, I'm not saying that that would be
00:54:38 impossible. Like I actually do think that there could be scenarios, some scenarios where it's
00:54:42 like, uh, you could make twice as much money, but it would take you away from the home just too
00:54:47 much. And so you actually, you sit there, you do the calculus and you actually decide, no,
00:54:52 I'm going to actually mitigate that, that, uh, financial blessing. I'm going to say no to that
00:54:56 financial blessing because it's going to take me away from some other things. So there are like
00:55:00 some legitimate reasons, um, to mitigate blessing. But what I'm trying to say is that there are very
00:55:08 few times that even among mature, godly Christians, there are very few times that we will mitigate
00:55:14 the blessing of financial prosperity. And yet, it is almost universal. It's so prevalent
00:55:23 that we are mitigating children. And so, I think that that, to me, that signifies
00:55:30 that we have almost universally as a culture
00:55:36 adopted an unbiblical view of children
00:55:40 and what children represent.
00:55:42 So could there be any cases?
00:55:43 Yeah, I think there are a number of cases.
00:55:46 One could be your wife's health, right?
00:55:48 So like if your doctor says,
00:55:50 hey, you know what?
00:55:51 You almost died in childbirth on your last pregnancy,
00:55:54 like your last delivery with your sixth child. 0.78
00:55:57 And if you try to have a child again,
00:55:59 it might kill you okay well then yeah that's that now that that needs to be taken seriously
00:56:06 into consideration that's that's different or if it's uh look we don't we don't want to just have
00:56:11 a quiver full of arrows but we want arrows that are sharp and straight because let's be honest
00:56:15 like christians you know christian parents from the 80s and 90s like they had some arrows i mean
00:56:20 they were mitigating children you know most of you know the average of you know two kids
00:56:24 but even the two arrows that they did have
00:56:26 most of those arrows were so
00:56:28 so bent
00:56:31 instead of being straight
00:56:32 that those arrows 1.00
00:56:34 all those Christians did was actually provide 0.86
00:56:36 ammunition for the enemy 1.00
00:56:38 all those kids grew up and went to some godless 0.88
00:56:40 university, became atheists
00:56:42 and joined Antifa
00:56:45 in 2020 and worked for BLM
00:56:47 so that doesn't do any good
00:56:49 Samuel had two
00:56:51 sons, the prophet Samuel
00:56:52 He had two sons, but they both took bribes.
00:56:55 In Israel, they go to Samuel when he's old,
00:56:57 and they're like, you don't have a successor. 0.76
00:56:59 You don't have a successor because your sons are deadbeats.
00:57:02 And so it didn't benefit Samuel to like, you know what?
00:57:07 Instead of two, I should have had six.
00:57:10 Yeah, exactly. 0.85
00:57:11 I'd be in better shape if I had six kids who took bribes.
00:57:16 No, so quality matters is my point.
00:57:19 So the Bible does speak to quantity.
00:57:21 blessed is the man whose quiver is full. So that is biblical. That's explicit. It's not just, you
00:57:25 know, far-fetched or stretching the text. So children are inherently a blessing, heritage
00:57:31 from the Lord, and many children are an even greater blessing. That's quantity. That's clear
00:57:37 from scripture. But I think that we can assume quality. And quality, you can say, well, a lot
00:57:43 of that quality is up to us and how we raise them. And that's absolutely true. The Bible certainly
00:57:48 affirms that, but I think knowing, um, and this is what's hard. And honestly, I don't trust,
00:57:54 I don't trust Western modern Christians to, to make this calculus. I think like whatever you 0.99
00:57:59 think is probably a good idea. You should probably just add like two or three kids to it. Like
00:58:04 seriously, because I don't trust us. Like we, like, um, we, for decades, we have done everything
00:58:10 we can to make sure that we don't have a lot of kids. Like if any, it's so clearly idolatry. It's
00:58:17 so clearly sinful. And so that's the calculus that we're working from. But what I was going to say
00:58:21 is, I do think that there is an allowance for Christian parents to consider their frame. The
00:58:27 Lord considers our frame that we're made from dust. Like considering your frame and knowing like,
00:58:32 okay, what, what can we, what amount of children can we have and steward properly? And what pace
00:58:39 can we go at? Because there are added challenges when each of your kids, you know, is, you know,
00:58:45 the age difference between each of them is 18 months is much more difficult when you know when
00:58:50 the age difference is three years that makes a huge difference right having having a three-year-old
00:58:57 one and a half year old and a newborn is much more challenging than having a six-year-old a
00:59:02 three-year-old and a newborn much more challenging and so the pace that you go at and the number
00:59:08 um of children like i think considering your frame like um is your wife a quadriplegic you
00:59:16 know like okay well then yeah that should be considered uh how is her health um also your 0.94
00:59:22 emotional uh frame and your your christian edwards she had like 13 kids and right in the middle of
00:59:27 it just straight up broke down like snapped at one point right so like do you have do you have 0.97
00:59:32 the mental and emotional framework for that. But all that, and hear me on this, all that has to be
00:59:39 tempered with the reality. It's an inescapable reality, and we just have to admit it. We live
00:59:45 in a time and a culture that hates kids. So as you're doing the calculus, you say, well, we're
00:59:50 just trying to be wise, or we're just considering, I'm considering my wife's frame, or we're just,
00:59:56 you know, we, you know, quality, you know, matters, and it does no good. You know, you yourself,
01:00:01 Joel, you said, you know, it would do no good to have six bad children, you know, it'd be better to have three good children. All those things are true. All those things are true. And also, we live in a culture and a time that hates children. So whatever you're calling wisdom, you just need to be, you need to be like, like, painfully, acutely aware that your flesh is probably factoring into that equation, much more than you're willing to admit.
01:00:28 i probably i don't have a position i'll defend yet i would probably go farther than you
01:00:33 and i will say church history up till about 1930 said that all forms of birth control besides
01:00:38 family planning were wrong both catholics and protestants up till about 100 years ago did
01:00:43 fully say so that's that's a calculus i've taken in as i've prayed and worked through it
01:00:47 like nobody before 100 years ago would have affirmed that these have a place for the christian
01:00:53 yeah that and that's a serious calculus like when you are when you're the anomaly um that's
01:00:59 standing outside of the witness of you know a millennia and a half or two millennia almost
01:01:06 of church history and what the church has ascertained like you should you should be
01:01:10 in a time period that built christendom like things haven't been so great since 1930 when
01:01:15 catholics and protestants stopped having as many kids yeah yeah there's like we think of like well 0.86
01:01:21 what's the downfall, you know, to our society? And, you know, and like, 0.93
01:01:24 we think, you know, there's like, you know, there's the Jews,
01:01:26 you know, but there's all these things that people, you know,
01:01:29 that's the crisis King controversy. It's like,
01:01:31 that's what people are trying to do. They're trying to account.
01:01:33 And many times, you know, we're trying to blame, but like,
01:01:36 but we're trying to account for like, where do we get off the rails?
01:01:38 How do things get so bad? And the reality is there's a ton,
01:01:41 there's a ton of answers to that question. You know, like media is,
01:01:46 is part of that degenerate filth on the television, you know, that we're,
01:01:49 you know, like they were submerged in, you know, from a very young age and all, you know,
01:01:55 all these different things, um, churches, their doctrine being watered down, you know, um, uh,
01:02:01 you know, uh, government schooling, you know, that's, that's godless and atheistic, you know, 0.71
01:02:06 public schools, um, corrupt politicians, uh, multiculturalism, bringing in, you know,
01:02:13 false religions and false gods without a cohesion of people who are united together. 0.94
01:02:19 There's all these different things that have contributed to the decline of morale,
01:02:23 the decline of virtue among our nation.
01:02:28 But part of it is, it really does come down to from the get-go, from the earliest years of life.
01:02:37 Like one thing that we don't always point to is like, well, how could people be so degenerate?
01:02:41 And how have things gotten so bad?
01:02:43 It's back to what you were talking about earlier with training a young child, especially young boys, with discipline from a young age so that they develop that healthy sense of inhibition and they're able to exercise self-control.
01:03:02 Gentle parenting is kind of what I'm building up to.
01:03:06 That's what it's called.
01:03:09 Whatever, I didn't pick the label, but that's what it's known as.
01:03:13 But gentle parenting, which means there's no corporal punishment.
01:03:17 There's never, there's never, I just talk to the kid, basically.
01:03:20 I just talk to the kid and try to get them to, you know,
01:03:23 I'm basically like appealing to my two-year-old to try to get them to empathize with me.
01:03:26 Like, how do you think this makes me feel? 0.80
01:03:28 Mom's just having a really rough day.
01:03:30 Could you be more considerate?
01:03:31 You know, or I'm preaching the gospel. 1.00
01:03:32 But there's no spanking. 1.00
01:03:34 There's no spanking.
01:03:36 And it's like, you know, how do things get so bad?
01:03:39 Well, we're sitting on like 30 years of, statistically,
01:03:45 like 30 years of the vast majority of adults that we currently have in our nation
01:03:50 have never been spanked a single time in their life.
01:03:54 Not once.
01:03:55 Like, would that affect the populace?
01:03:57 Would that have a negative effect on virtue and morale?
01:04:00 Yeah, I think so.
01:04:02 So parenting is key.
01:04:03 How many kids you have, but also the quality of kids that you have.
01:04:07 and your willingness to raise him
01:04:10 in the fear and admonition of the Lord.
01:04:12 All right, we've got to move quick
01:04:13 because we've got some good super chats.
01:04:14 So let's go Rubicon first.
01:04:17 $10 super chat, thank you.
01:04:19 Great profile picture.
01:04:19 That kind of looks like Caesar on a horse
01:04:21 crossing the Rubicon.
01:04:22 I think it's Trump.
01:04:24 You think it's who?
01:04:25 I think it's Donald Trump.
01:04:26 Oh, there you go.
01:04:28 Age of accountability.
01:04:29 Some Lutherans, LCMS, Lutheran Church,
01:04:32 Missouri Synod,
01:04:32 do not believe in an age of accountability. 0.97
01:04:34 Thus, they must be baptized as an infant 0.77
01:04:36 into the church as a Baptist. I do not believe that. Correct. So, as Baptists, we wouldn't agree
01:04:41 with infant baptism. We would say, so the Old Testament, circumcision is given upon physical 0.94
01:04:46 birth, but it precedes and anticipates the fullness, which is baptism upon spiritual birth.
01:04:52 So, circumcision, a physical act upon physical birth for boys, anticipating, foreshadowing,
01:04:59 looking forward to spiritual rebirth, the spiritual sign of baptism into the invisible
01:05:05 church upon not physical birth but the spiritual new birth as signified by profession of faith
01:05:10 right um yeah and lutherans are a little bit funny um not all there's there's different
01:05:19 stripes and breeds but i remember talking to one lutheran minister once upon a time and
01:05:24 and he was you know he's like well i'm i'm a calvinist joel you know like uh i you know i
01:05:30 believe in predestination and election and these kinds of things but but he also you know believed
01:05:36 in baptismal regeneration so it's not like so to to distinguish a little bit like it it is
01:05:42 different than you know our presbyterian brothers and sisters that you know are also paedo-baptist
01:05:47 they apply infant baptism but they don't believe that um there's regenerative um whereas within
01:05:54 lutheranism and i'm not sure i mean there's so many different it's just like baptists like well
01:05:59 what kind of Baptist are you? What kind of Presbyterian? What kind of Lutheran are you?
01:06:02 But from my understanding, many Lutherans do hold not just infant baptism, but baptismal
01:06:09 regeneration, meaning that the baptism in the literal and immediate sense actually saves. So
01:06:17 that child upon being baptized is regenerated and is a Christian. And so that's something that
01:06:27 you would find you know within roman catholicism it's something that you would find uh within
01:06:31 which catholicism is to distinguish is cleansing of original sin specifically so i would say
01:06:40 because they don't have as much focus on the regeneration that's a good emphasis of
01:06:43 protestanism so for roman catholicism cleansing original sin for lutheranism regeneration is
01:06:49 that what they say uh venial i think is the uh the unimportant ones there's mortal and venial
01:06:56 mortal sins are sins to fall from a state of grace right baptism puts you in a state of grace
01:07:02 that's right which venial sins can't take you from but mortal sins could that's right
01:07:06 yeah no you're right uh and in that sense it's kind of funny that um you know people say baptists
01:07:13 are the outliers you know when it comes to their um their doctrine of baptism but really
01:07:17 presbyterians are actually um in many ways the outliers and and i love presbyterians sure but
01:07:23 But they're the outliers in the sense that the Baptist believes that the Baptist is going to link baptism with regeneration.
01:07:34 So, God, like, you know, a believer's baptism, that God saves, regenerates, and we baptize them.
01:07:41 Catholics, baptism and regeneration, you know, or at least like there's something.
01:07:45 State of grace.
01:07:46 State of grace.
01:07:47 Like it happens in, you know, Episcopalians, Eastern Orthodox, Lutherans.
01:07:53 Anglicans, every single Christian tradition links either a state of grace or regeneration or salvation, something like that, with baptism, except for Presbyterians. 0.83
01:08:10 They're actually the outlier.
01:08:13 So they would say Baptists are the outlier because they're the ones who aren't practicing infant baptism.
01:08:19 But even though we're not doing it with infants, we are actually keeping in step with, in a loose sense, with Catholics and Eastern Orthodoxy and certainly with Episcopalians and Lutherans and Anglicans in the sense that we're saying, no, baptism is linked to salvation.
01:08:39 It directly correlates with regeneration.
01:08:42 Yep.
01:08:43 This one, it's not a super chap, but it's a frequent supporter and I think a really important personal question.
01:08:48 So BJJ Wins again said, my firstborn son is an embryo adoption.
01:08:52 The wife gave birth.
01:08:53 His wife gave birth.
01:08:54 So it's not adoption after birth, but adoption of the embryo, which his wife then gave birth
01:08:58 to.
01:08:58 And then we had a natural child.
01:09:00 My wife is very worried about him.
01:09:02 That is the firstborn son, the embryo adoption.
01:09:04 Not feeling as loved as our natural kid.
01:09:06 Any advice?
01:09:08 He said, I imagine Joel has some insight.
01:09:11 Yeah.
01:09:11 So people know, um, that I was adopted, not as an embryo, but, um, but as a baby, I, you
01:09:20 know, Voodie Bauckham had, I think, you know, one time I, I, uh, saw something that he said
01:09:24 about adoption that I thought was helpful.
01:09:27 Um, he was talking about, you know, he's adopted, I think seven boys.
01:09:30 Um, right.
01:09:33 I think it's seven, I think it's seven kids.
01:09:34 He has a couple of girls, I think, but.
01:09:35 Well, he, yeah.
01:09:36 So he has two kids, a boy and a girl, that are biological, and then they didn't have any more children, and it wasn't until later in life that they went back and entered that stage of parenting again and adopted seven children that I believe are all boys, but maybe not.
01:09:53 I didn't know that.
01:09:53 But I think it's seven kids.
01:09:56 And so there might be a couple girls.
01:09:58 But people asked him a similar question.
01:10:00 And they said, like, do you love your biological kids more than your adopted kids?
01:10:09 And he said, no. 0.99
01:10:11 But then he was honest.
01:10:12 And I appreciate him giving this answer.
01:10:15 He said, no, I love my children equally.
01:10:17 He said, but what I will say is that the effort required to love my children equally is not the same.
01:10:25 So, my love for my adoptive children is equal to my love for my natural-born children.
01:10:31 But I have to work harder in my love for, like, with my natural-born children, I have nature working for me, which is a powerful thing.
01:10:42 He said, like, but it requires intent and grace and will.
01:10:48 I can't just rely on nature in the case of my adopted children.
01:10:52 So with my adoptive children, it requires more of a supernatural and conscience, deliberate decision that I have to make again and again and again.
01:11:03 Not that he wouldn't love them at all, but he loves his adoptive children.
01:11:07 But I'm having to make this conscience, deliberate choice again and again.
01:11:13 No, I've adopted these children.
01:11:15 They don't have my blood, but they bear my name.
01:11:17 They belong to me.
01:11:19 God adopted me.
01:11:21 He made that choice in his election and adoption of me.
01:11:25 He loves me, and I'm going to seek to love them as God loves me.
01:11:28 And so, does he love his adopted children less?
01:11:31 Well, in his own words, like only the Lord knows his heart, but in his own words, no.
01:11:35 He loves them deeply and profoundly, just as he loves his biological children.
01:11:40 They are his children.
01:11:42 Legally, by name, they are his children.
01:11:45 He loves them just as much as his natural-born children.
01:11:47 But I appreciate his honesty and being willing to admit that although he loves them just as much as his naturally born children, the effort required to love them that much is greater, that it doesn't come naturally.
01:12:02 It came with required more intentionality.
01:12:07 So that's what I would say to BJ.
01:12:10 BJJ wins again, as I would say.
01:12:13 His wife is very worried about him, the adopted embryo child,
01:12:22 not feeling as loved as the natural kid. 0.91
01:12:24 And so I would just say, tell your wife not to worry. 0.67
01:12:29 Wives tend to worry more than husbands. 0.92
01:12:32 So encourage your wife, wash her in the word.
01:12:34 encourage her not to worry, to be anxious for nothing, but with prayer and supplication to
01:12:38 make all her requests known to God. And the particular request that she should pray and
01:12:42 ask the Lord to help her with is, Lord, help my oldest son not to feel this way because
01:12:49 help it not to be true. Help me to love him the same way that I love our younger biological son
01:12:58 and knowing that it may require more effort and more intentionality because I can't just
01:13:04 bank on nature working for me, but I have to simply rest and rely upon that which is supernatural
01:13:12 as a Christian in grace. And so, yeah, so I'd encourage her not to worry, but whenever she
01:13:19 is tempted to worry, instead to pray and to ask the Lord that that older child would not feel
01:13:26 less love than the younger child precisely because it wouldn't be true. Ask the Lord to increase her
01:13:33 capacity for love and that she and you as the husband and father would be intentional
01:13:38 and loving both of your children yep good answer kevin ice a ten dollar super chat i'm going to
01:13:46 put some names in here just to kind of keep it straight so the question kind of makes sense
01:13:50 because he's asking about a friend situation and there's a couple people involved so kevin ice
01:13:54 thanks for the super chat he said a friend and let's call this doug's family a friend has a
01:13:59 brother we'll call this bob so doug his friend doug has a brother bob who is a man who thinks
01:14:05 he's a woman just put it that way bob's parents are allowing doug and bob doug and bob's parents
01:14:12 are allowing bob the brother who thinks he's a woman to live with them my friend that would be
01:14:17 doug is married with two kids so doug his friend has two children is it wrong to keep the kid away
01:14:23 from kids away from his parents and i think he's saying the grandparents grandparents because if
01:14:29 they're with the grandparents then if they're with then bob's parents the grandparents they're
01:14:33 also then bob will be there too the man who thinks himself a woman uh and doesn't just think but i
01:14:39 i think we're meant to assume from the question also is dressing like a dressing yeah uh no they
01:14:44 should not be around that individual no um i can give a biological reason for it so men uh we have
01:14:50 a number of receptors in our body. They're androgen receptors, and they're tuned to testosterone. So
01:14:54 there's some estrogen in a man's body, but he is tuned thoroughly, top to bottom, to receive,
01:14:59 respond, and be hormonally balanced with testosterone. Women, in the same way, it's
01:15:03 inverted. They have EHR1 and EHR2, estrogen hormone receptors, and they're tuned to estrogen. 0.86
01:15:09 When you introduce estrogen into a man's body, a body that is not tuned to take it into large
01:15:14 amount so the hormone transition you destroy him psychologically that is why these individuals
01:15:20 are typically violent you've taken everything that's about a physiological balanced state in
01:15:26 a man his energy his mood his emotions his regulation all those different things you've
01:15:33 taken them and the way they're supposed to be arranged the delicate balance that exists in the
01:15:37 brain and the body and the endocrine system you've taken it and you flooded it with something
01:15:42 absolutely foreign and these people generally are violent so just at that level taking that thing
01:15:49 you see this when people call them the wrong names or whatever they lash out it is not physically
01:15:55 safe to be around and I think someone else brought the spiritual component it is also terrible to be
01:16:00 around as an adult male who's perfectly safe I've gone on work trips and seen individuals like this
01:16:06 and I am disturbed and if I was in I've said this online before if I was in a restaurant and someone
01:16:11 like this came out to be our server i would leave if i was with my kids i wouldn't be around it and
01:16:17 so i get that it's grandparents but i also think especially because bob is in this case being
01:16:22 allowed to live with them you say we can't come over and we won't go over and we think that you
01:16:27 should encourage bob to stop living this lie right and and hold it as a prerequisite that if he
01:16:33 chooses not to then i'm sorry we love you you're our child but um we cannot support you in this
01:16:40 life sense. So if you're not willing to change, then you have to move out. And in the meantime,
01:16:45 what you could do also with the grandparents is you said, we can't come there because
01:16:48 Bob is there, but, uh, but you can come and visit the grandkids without Bob here at our house,
01:16:53 you know, so you could have some kind of, you know, honoring your, your parents in that sense.
01:16:58 And then the only thing that I was going to add to it is just, um, more of, um, a little bit more
01:17:04 of like the, the spiritual theological side, but, um, it's, you know, uh, just, just like with
01:17:09 anything else so like you know families extended family can always be uh challenging and um but
01:17:16 like let's say you have you know you have kids and then you have a brother you have a sister
01:17:22 let's say a brother you have a brother and so it's your kid's uncle and you only see him once
01:17:26 or twice a year and let's say that he's not a christian he's not a believer and he curses like
01:17:31 a sailor well you can talk to him you know before the next thanksgiving you know when when you're
01:17:38 all going to be together and the kids are going to be, you know, in his presence for, you know,
01:17:42 three days straight or whatever it is. And you can talk to him, you know, preemptively and say,
01:17:46 hey, look, our kids, we have young children and we are respectively requesting that you would
01:17:53 honor our kids and honor us by not cursing in front of our kids. And you can say that. And
01:18:00 hopefully, you know, even as a non-Christian, hopefully he would be respectful enough to 0.95
01:18:04 oblige and say, okay, you know, that's fair. That checks out. I understand. I won't be 0.99
01:18:09 dropping F-bombs in front of your three-year-old. It's like, thanks. And so then you can go to
01:18:14 Thanksgiving, and here's the deal. On the inside, internally, he's still an unbeliever. He hates 0.90
01:18:22 God. He's going to hell, and he is someone who curses like a sailor. And so he's still a sinner, 1.00
01:18:29 and for that matter we're all sinners
01:18:31 but he's particularly a sinner
01:18:33 and in a state of sin
01:18:35 but he's not actively sinning
01:18:38 he's not actively sinning
01:18:40 in front of your children
01:18:41 so you have a sinner 1.00
01:18:43 who's going to be with you
01:18:45 being present as well
01:18:46 who's going to be in the presence of your children
01:18:48 but you're not permitting him 1.00
01:18:50 you're permitting a sinner 0.94
01:18:51 to be present with your children
01:18:53 but you're not permitting someone to sin
01:18:56 in the presence of your children
01:18:58 and there is a difference, right?
01:19:00 So, like, we've talked about this even, you know,
01:19:02 as elders and deacons with our church.
01:19:05 We even had, you know, some of the members of our church ask,
01:19:07 like, what would our policy be?
01:19:08 Like, if somebody, you know, if someone, again,
01:19:11 trying to avoid the word for the sake of the algorithm
01:19:13 with social media and all that kind of stuff,
01:19:14 but if a man who thinks he's a woman
01:19:17 and dresses like a woman, if he shows up to church,
01:19:20 if somebody like that shows up to church, 0.97
01:19:23 what are we going to do, you know?
01:19:25 Like, would we pull them aside?
01:19:27 and what we've told them
01:19:30 and what we've decided
01:19:31 is there's a difference
01:19:32 in somebody who is gay
01:19:33 if a gay man comes to church
01:19:37 and assuming he's not there 1.00
01:19:38 to be hostile
01:19:41 but he's like
01:19:42 I actually want to see
01:19:44 what this is about
01:19:45 I'm not a Christian
01:19:46 I'm a gay man
01:19:47 but I'm going to show up 1.00
01:19:49 and I'm going to sit
01:19:49 and I'm going to listen to the sermon
01:19:50 and I want to see what's going on
01:19:52 well a gay man
01:19:54 can show up to church
01:19:56 as someone who is in a state of sin, in that lifestyle, but he's not sinning at church.
01:20:02 In that moment.
01:20:03 In that moment, exactly. Like, he can show up alone, and he's not, you know, in a public,
01:20:11 visible, external way, sinning in front of everybody who's present. But the person who
01:20:19 thinks that they're the opposite sex, and walks, and talks, and dresses as though they're of the 0.67
01:20:24 opposite sex, that person, it's not just that they're in a lifestyle of sin, but they are 0.50
01:20:31 sinning, actively sinning in the church service. And so it applies across the board, even for 0.93
01:20:38 Christians, for members of the church. Like, everybody who goes to our church, and any church
01:20:43 for that matter, is a sinner, including me. Everybody's a sinner. So sinners get to go to
01:20:49 church, but you don't get to sin at church, certainly not publicly and in a witnessable,
01:20:56 visible fashion. So we have people in our church who, everybody's a sinner, but nobody, even if
01:21:02 you're a Christian and you're heterosexual and you're a member in good standing, you don't get
01:21:07 to go to church and shout the F-bomb in the middle of the sermon. Nobody gets to do that.
01:21:13 And so in the same way, you don't get to visibly, publicly sin.
01:21:20 There's a difference in being a sinner versus sinning.
01:21:23 Nobody gets to visibly, publicly sin at church in a way that would be distracting and jarring for everyone who's there.
01:21:37 And so that's what makes the situation unique when it comes to not just, you know, this person, you know, occasionally steals or this person occasionally curses or this person even is, you know, is gay or this, you know, like what's so unique about this particular sin is you're talking about with this particular sin, you're not just in a state of sin, but you are 24-7 actively sinning all the time.
01:22:06 lying about who you are and who God made you to be. That's right. You are publicly, visibly, 0.65
01:22:12 for every single person who can see you, you are actively sinning. You are portraying something
01:22:19 that is perverse, something that is unnatural, something that is against the Word of God.
01:22:25 You are lying. You are practicing deception. You're being manipulative. You're being confusing
01:22:31 and deceiving. And so I think that is a fair, I will leave it there, but just a rule of thumb,
01:22:39 pretty simple, pretty fair, but rule of thumb for parents is nobody, whether it's your family
01:22:48 member who's a Christian or a family member who's not a Christian, whether it's this or that,
01:22:52 it doesn't matter. As a parent, nobody, no person has the right, nobody is permitted the right to 0.67
01:23:05 sin in front of your kids. You as a parent are allowed to say, no, I'm not going to allow a
01:23:14 bunch of people who are blackout drunk to come over to the house in front of our kids. I'm not
01:23:20 going to allow you won't be here or i won't be there that's you're leaving or i'm going exactly
01:23:25 and unfortunately with this particular sin that's what it's the equivalent of it's the equivalent
01:23:29 not just of being in a state of sin but it's the equivalent of actively continually sinning
01:23:35 and uh and there's your kids will notice my i've been in those environments um unfortunately and
01:23:43 my my three-year-old i remember my distinctly like it's etched in my mind my three-year-old
01:23:49 daughter looking, you know, kind of tilting her head and confused and not understanding why is
01:23:55 there, I know that that's a man, but he's wearing makeup and yeah, you don't subject your children
01:24:02 to that. That is, that's their problem. That's their fault. They made that choice. Uh, and,
01:24:07 and you are not being hateful or disrespectful. Um, your obligation is not to a deluded person's
01:24:14 fantasies and
01:24:16 assuaging their conscience. Your
01:24:18 obligation is to your children.
01:24:21 And dads, this is why you need to be
01:24:23 big and intimidating and
01:24:25 carry that when that happens
01:24:26 you can stand up and
01:24:29 kids, go to the car.
01:24:31 And I'm going to do whatever needs
01:24:33 to be done. Say no. Ask them to
01:24:35 back off. Ben
01:24:36 Huffstether. A steady,
01:24:39 generous,
01:24:41 wonderful man. Ben is just,
01:24:42 he's the man single-handedly funding right response ministries hundred dollars super
01:24:46 super chat thank you ben all right ben said stay strong brothers appreciate you all appreciate you
01:24:51 as well ben question can a divorced man be above reproach to obtaining eldership or pastoral
01:24:56 leadership again divorce it sounds like in this case was forced on him by unbelieving x
01:25:01 that's a tough one i've thought about that and spoken to it a little bit in the past um
01:25:08 So, you know, the qualification that it comes down to is husband of one wife.
01:25:12 And so, like, what does that mean?
01:25:13 Some people take it to mean that elders have to be married, you know, because if, so even if you're not divorced, but you have no wife, you're just a single man, that a single man can't be an elder because he doesn't have one wife.
01:25:24 He has zero wives.
01:25:25 And then others take it to apply to, you know, a prohibition against polygamy, you know, that would, you know, would be relevant.
01:25:33 And if you're, for instance, you're doing, you know, church planting in, you know, an Islamic nation and somebody has, you know, or for that matter, you know, back in the day in Utah, you know, with Mormons, you know, somebody happens to have, you know, three wives or whatever.
01:25:49 Right.
01:25:49 And you would say, okay, well, you can come to Christ.
01:25:51 You can be, you can be a Christian.
01:25:53 You can even be a church member, but you can't be an elder.
01:25:56 I was about to say, probably in those cases, too, the man would stay in those marriages and continue to provide for those women.
01:26:01 He just could never be an elder.
01:26:02 Exactly.
01:26:02 Yep.
01:26:03 So what does Christ call me to?
01:26:05 I'm a man who's been married three times.
01:26:08 I currently have three wives.
01:26:10 What does the Bible say to me?
01:26:12 And the answer would be, and I know it offends our sensibilities,
01:26:16 but as far as I can ascertain from the scripture,
01:26:18 the answer would be, okay, well then you need to be a faithful husband
01:26:21 to all three of your wives without showing favoritism
01:26:24 and providing and protecting all three of them equally and fairly
01:26:29 as the Lord would have you, willing to lay down your life
01:26:31 for, for all three of them as Christ loves the church. Uh, but this is a terrible picture of
01:26:36 the gospel because Christ has one bride. Um, and, uh, and, and also your hands are full. You've got
01:26:43 three women to please three, you know, like, like the Bible talks about the, you know, the man who's 0.94
01:26:47 married, his interests are divided. Well, your, your interests are divided three times. Can you
01:26:51 imagine? Exactly. So, so you don't get to be a pastor. So, so one woman, man, what does that
01:26:56 mean? You know, elder must be, you know, the man about one wife. Some would say, well, he's got to
01:27:01 be married. You can't, you can't be single. Some would say, well, he can't be in a polygamous
01:27:05 marriage. He has to have one wife. And then others would say, not just, you know, having zero wives 0.99
01:27:10 or simultaneously two or three wives, but that he can't have had more than one wife, even not
01:27:16 simultaneously, but over the course of his life by virtue of divorce and remarriage. You know,
01:27:22 And so some take that approach.
01:27:24 And then others, what's probably the most common interpretation, at least in modern times, is that it's just the mark of a man, that he's a one-woman man.
01:27:34 He's the type of person who models fidelity and those kinds of things, which I get.
01:27:44 For myself personally, early on, I got married when I was 29 years old.
01:27:52 And, uh, and early on, you know, me and my college buddies, when we moved across from
01:27:57 Texas, you know, to California, cause we wanted a church, you know, church plant, we, we weren't
01:28:01 church planters.
01:28:02 We were LARPing.
01:28:03 It was all a joke.
01:28:03 But when we did that, um, I was not, you know, I didn't get married until later.
01:28:08 And, uh, and I just, you know, looking at that, I would say like, yeah, that, that was 0.99
01:28:12 stupid. 1.00
01:28:12 That was foolish. 1.00
01:28:13 Could anybody do it? 1.00
01:28:15 Like, could somebody do it?
01:28:17 You're saying could some single man be an equipped pastor?
01:28:20 I couldn't, but could someone do it? Maybe. I think the gift of celibacy is exceedingly rare. I think it's abundantly rare, but there is a biblical category for it.
01:28:33 um, it does exist. Um, you know, and so I, I think, you know, so I'm hesitant. My point is,
01:28:39 I'm hesitant to, to make a, an ironclad, you know, rule that, um, that no single man,
01:28:46 there can never be any circumstance ever in any place at any time where a single man,
01:28:50 um, you know, could be an elder. So I'm not sure, uh, in terms of the divorce,
01:28:55 particularly to the question that was asked, I don't know. It's, it's tough because it's like,
01:29:00 you've had one wife, you've divorced and remarried. And I'm assuming, you know, like your wife left
01:29:05 you. So you go to like first Corinthians, I think it would be chapter seven, you know, like if you're
01:29:10 married to an unbeliever, you know, but they're willing to remain with you, then you should 0.99
01:29:13 remain with them. You know, but if they leave you, uh, allowing them to go in order to strive to be 0.98
01:29:19 at peace with all men. And so there's a difference in, you know, them leaving you abandonment.
01:29:24 I see those as the two biblical clauses for divorce is, um, adultery and abandonment,
01:29:30 adultery and abandonment. So if they've abandoned you, um, and, and you were patient, right? You
01:29:36 didn't just turn around the next day, you know, but like, but you've been patient and you've been
01:29:40 waiting and, um, and, you know, calling them to repentance and you've pursued and all these kinds
01:29:46 of things, but it's been years and they, they legally divorced you. I think in the state of
01:29:50 Texas. Uh, it can be not only no fault divorce, but one party, uh, you can divorce the other
01:29:55 without ever having their consent. They don't have to actually agree. And so they've, they've
01:30:00 legally divorced you. Um, you tried, you did everything you can. And, uh, and so it was,
01:30:06 you know, adultery and abandonment. Um, it was, you know, a biblical, um, allowance for that
01:30:12 divorce. Um, you know, are, are you free first? Are you free to remarry? Uh, I've, I did a whole
01:30:18 sermon on divorce, and I gave my opinion on this, but short answer is yes. Calvin held, actually,
01:30:24 John Calvin held yes as his position as well. So I would say yes, you are in those cases free to
01:30:29 remarry. If it was not a biblical divorce without biblical cause, then no, you're not free to
01:30:33 remarry. But in those cases where it was, then you can remarry. So then the final question is,
01:30:38 and then can you be a pastor? And I don't know. You're now on your second wife. You've had two
01:30:45 wives. You don't have two wives simultaneously, so you have one wife, and that first covenant 0.95
01:30:52 has been sufficiently severed and ended by your spouse, not by you, but your spouse. They cut off 0.82
01:30:59 that covenant, they ended the covenant, and then you entered into a new covenant. You don't have
01:31:04 two open covenants simultaneously, a new covenant, one wife. I don't know. I've heard guys argue both 0.97
01:31:11 sides and um i'm not completely convinced one way or the other what do you think i mean i do hold i
01:31:18 would say that an elder has to be married like you said well what about apostle paul paul wasn't
01:31:23 doing local church ministry right he was an apostle he was an apostle yeah so uh i and again
01:31:28 speaking from practical experience it's tough to imagine i've never met a man that's single and has
01:31:34 met all those qualifications across time and you just look back and like that was a great idea five
01:31:38 years really good job um as far as the divorced same as you it's it's tough to tell like it does
01:31:45 violate the the one woman like at one point the man was bound to multiple and someone severed it
01:31:52 and uh i i think situation would dictate too you know like are you getting someone from from
01:31:58 seminary you know or i guess i should say are there a number of candidates and this is one of
01:32:03 them or are you on the mission field and the best person in the village that's qualified in every
01:32:07 other respects happens to be divorced for one reason or another so wisdom prudence would dictate
01:32:12 um bible nor church history seems to clearly say one way or the other yep yep all right next we've
01:32:22 got philip schneider he's been super active in the chat 10 pounds 10 pounds he said this is from
01:32:29 philip thanks philip i want to know your opinions on children having electronic devices especially
01:32:33 below and during teenage years thank you for being a role model to me in the rest of the chat thanks
01:32:38 philip i appreciate that um there does come a point once your teens are driving that they
01:32:42 probably do need a phone um it doesn't have to be a smartphone maps
01:32:47 you think printers are reliable enough today
01:32:57 to print out maps to go to my friend's house um that's a tough one yeah kids do not need
01:33:05 unfettered access to the internet that's like 14 and below 15 and below yeah kids no kids for sure
01:33:11 when you get into those later years i do think there's something to be said for like the last
01:33:16 couple of years um saying okay like we're not going to officially have a curfew we're not
01:33:21 officially going to do and you're basically allowing the child um a greater degree of freedom
01:33:27 but while they still are within the confines of having the safety of mom and dad and suicide
01:33:32 so that way it's it's not just like their first time of unfettered freedom is also you know synced
01:33:38 up with a stage of life where mom and dad are are not there you know so you're actually allowing
01:33:43 them to practice liberty and to practice you know responsibility you're taking the guardrails off
01:33:50 before they're out from underneath your eye, you know, so while they're still there, when you can 0.98
01:33:55 still run to their defense and their protection and their help, uh, but, but removing the bumpers
01:34:00 and allowing them to, um, to practice. And so I think, you know, there, there can be an argument
01:34:04 for that. I've heard that applied to curfew, you know, for like the last two years, uh, that a
01:34:09 child's under your roof or whatever. Um, in terms of applied to smartphones, um, I, yeah, I don't
01:34:18 know i i don't know i that's kind of how we start off with the episode is like my oldest is seven
01:34:24 right your oldest is what two three three three and a half and we we preface the episode by saying
01:34:30 like that's you know that's kind of like what we would need michael for you know but he's out of
01:34:33 town this week so i don't i don't want to speak you know too michael did something cool he has a
01:34:37 son and a daughter that are about that age and they actually share a phone and just in the kind
01:34:41 of way that there'd be nothing that they could hide he's also not you know having to go through
01:34:44 it so there's different things like that you can say hey i've got twins or i've got two kids that
01:34:48 are coming of age they work they drive to friends houses like they just they need to be able to take
01:34:53 calls see where they're at but you'll share a phone and that way there's a kind of accountability
01:34:57 built in so it depends on the kid it depends on the phone like a gab phone that has phone
01:35:03 messages and location no internet browsing no video that that could be 12 or something like
01:35:08 that every kid goes to a christian school to text mom and daddy pick me up there isn't a blanket
01:35:12 age there isn't a blanket requirement it's not like you can have it at 14 and a half and you
01:35:17 have to have covenant eyes which is a good idea that just it really depends and so there's not
01:35:21 a hard and fast answer but the later i would say the better generally speaking more cautious with
01:35:27 boys than with girls and um also paired probably with with other liberties and being careful with
01:35:34 all right am i giving them a phone and curfew and they have their driver's license and they have
01:35:38 money and a job this is all happening in one month or is there a way to leading up to it
01:35:42 kind of give that freedom yeah yep all right let's see if we can hit one more we had a number
01:35:48 of super chats apologies to anyone we weren't able to get to let's get to a jeff halfley question
01:35:52 okay good old jeff jeff thanks for the super chat 999 i think another 299 one elsewhere
01:35:57 jeff asked parents use the least amount of force in history today are we moving towards a better
01:36:02 form of highly restrained corporal punishment as the ideal are we in sin for not using the
01:36:07 old-time methods followed up is that our christian great-grandparents would cause total wimps for not
01:36:12 using belts on bare skin were they wrong or are we both are correct i think as in a hundred years
01:36:21 ago your grandparents worked on a farm you were out there milking cows at 6 a.m and moving hay
01:36:26 bales putting up fence stacks and then you ran off or whatever and grandpa you know did what he did
01:36:32 and took you to the woodshed,
01:36:34 in that hypothetical scenario,
01:36:36 there's totally scenarios where that would make sense.
01:36:39 And then today, not at all using those means
01:36:41 because you don't work on a farm,
01:36:42 your kids aren't hardy,
01:36:43 and all of those, also not wrong either.
01:36:46 So I think in a sense,
01:36:47 there's a time and place
01:36:48 where our grandparents lived a harsher life,
01:36:50 and so the means of disciplines they used
01:36:52 look harsher to us now,
01:36:54 but they were not necessarily wrong,
01:36:56 and yet we too are not necessarily wrong.
01:36:59 We're being biblical, we're doing it well,
01:37:01 as we said you're applying something temporary
01:37:03 instead of any type of permanent harm
01:37:05 abuse or damage I think both could be
01:37:07 wrong and also or both could be
01:37:09 right and both could be wrong
01:37:10 grandpa could have been too hard and then we could have been
01:37:13 too soft even now
01:37:14 yeah that's probably fair
01:37:16 we're definitely too soft
01:37:19 so that one I think for sure
01:37:20 today we just
01:37:23 we hate kids
01:37:24 the bible says the one who doesn't
01:37:27 discipline and spares the rod hates 1.00
01:37:28 the child and so I think
01:37:30 you know, on the whole, in general, we are in a generation of parents that, according to biblical
01:37:38 definitions, really do hate their children by sparing and neglecting. Ultimately, it's neglect
01:37:44 and a lack of love, discipline. So I think, you know, I don't know. I mean, I look at, you know,
01:37:51 the history and the things that I am able to find from past generations, and overall,
01:37:57 they were better than us on basically every single metric. So, um, overall, whatever they
01:38:04 were doing, uh, I don't think it's as bad as what we're doing today. Um, so I think, uh, but that
01:38:09 doesn't mean what they were doing was perfect and had no room for improvement. So I don't feel
01:38:13 comfortable just saying, you know, like, yeah, like whatever, you know, whatever they did was
01:38:17 absolutely infallible and perfect. And we have to do exactly that. So I, that would not be my
01:38:22 position. But I would say that, um, that, uh, in general, you know, obviously you're always going
01:38:29 to be able to find, you know, exceptions and isolated cases where it really was abuse or it
01:38:33 really was this, or it really was that. But in general, the generation, um, that, that disciplined
01:38:39 their kids and use spanking and some of them a little bit less, you know, orthodox means of
01:38:45 spanking than others, that generation still on the whole, I think produced in their children
01:38:50 a greater degree of virtue um and responsibility and duty and sacrifice and not just due to the
01:38:59 way they discipline but more broadly yeah their education and their teaching and instruction and
01:39:04 and uh christian christian character but it produced it produced um better people than i
01:39:10 think what we're producing today so yeah so i think you know probably uh probably some problems
01:39:16 on both sides um but i think the the bigger problem is uh the problem of no discipline at all
01:39:24 and honestly like if that was our biggest problem we'd probably be in better shape but today like
01:39:31 that's not even our biggest problem isn't just no discipline at all our like we quickly are getting
01:39:35 to the point where our biggest problem is no no children at all right we don't even have kids
01:39:40 much less you know neglect to discipline them so all right well that's uh that's our episode
01:39:46 i hope you guys enjoyed it hope you found it helpful uh michael will be back with us next
01:39:51 week uh tonight uh there's no friday special this week we're in between seasons we'll pick
01:39:56 the friday special up with the first friday of april season two with dr stephen wolf and myself
01:40:01 on christian nationalism and uh in the meantime the next thing that you'll see from us will be
01:40:07 our live stream on Monday at 3 p.m. Central Time. We hope to see you there. God bless.