The NXR Podcast - May 15, 2024


THE LIVESTREAM - Responding To Right Wing Watch | “American Caesar” & The Constitution

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE CONFERENCE - Postmillennialism - Session 8 - Doug Wilson | Blueprints for Christendom 2.0 2024 THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - The Biblical Case For The Existence of Mermaids | Episode 7 w @hauntedcosmos_

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 17 minutes

Words per minute

183.24

Word count

14,229

Sentence count

476

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

28

sentences flagged

Hate speech

62

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Joel and Michael discuss the loss of the Christian ability to think categorically, and how this has led to division and division among believers. They discuss the possibility of an American Caesar, and what that means for the future of America.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome. We have lost the ability as Christians to think categorically. Christian discourse 0.97
00:00:09 around the family and politics endlessly conflate personal versus public, necessary versus possible,
00:00:16 and descriptive versus prescriptive categories. This renders us unable to think historically,
00:00:24 consider what the future might hold and properly discern what course of action we should take
00:00:31 tune in now as we discuss thinking shrewdly and what america's political future might hold
00:00:39 all right good to be back for another wednesday live stream we'll be discussing
00:00:54 the possibility of an American Caesar and the U.S. Constitution, how they all come together.
00:00:59 We'll get into some history, especially at the end, so stay tuned for that for sure.
00:01:03 But to set the introduction, to get down to the root of what's causing some confusion,
00:01:07 a lot of confusion, this would be not just among unbelievers or maybe Christless conservatives,
00:01:12 but among believers themselves. What's causing a lot of division and rivalry
00:01:16 would be the ability to think in different categories. So to give an example of this,
00:01:21 In the Sermon on the Mount, the Beatitudes, Jesus says a number of things.
00:01:25 But one of the things he says, for example, is blessed are the merciful, for they shall receive mercy.
00:01:29 And I've heard this cited when it comes to things like immigration and helping the homeless and this, that, or the other.
00:01:35 But we have to think about it for a second.
00:01:36 So blessed are the merciful, for they shall receive mercy.
00:01:39 Certainly personal ethics.
00:01:40 So a neighbor that I may have some strife with, a family member.
00:01:43 There should be a degree and measure of mercy that we should show that will be returned to us.
00:01:48 But if a cop, for example, was arresting someone who committed a crime, would that be the verse
00:01:53 that we jump out, stop, blessed are the merciful, for they shall receive mercy.
00:01:57 Would you say to a judge who's about to sentence someone that did something terrible to your
00:02:00 family, judge, I know he did this.
00:02:02 I know he said he'll go back on the streets and do it again.
00:02:04 But after all, blessed are the merciful, for they shall receive mercy.
00:02:07 And the answer would be, of course not.
00:02:09 We have to have specific categories of thought for different things that the Bible says.
00:02:13 The Bible is a long book.
00:02:14 There's many different strains of thought, of examples, of stories that are contained
00:02:17 within it. And so something that's really been lost and needs to be regained is thinking
00:02:22 categorically politics, family, church, what belongs to what, what is most proper here,
00:02:29 and then certain things in the political arena, for example. So this week, Joel, a clip of yours
00:02:34 was posted one or two times on the internet of you discussing the possibility that a people like
00:02:39 America who have become degenerate may eventually lose our right to self-governance, as in someone
00:02:45 else could come in and say, no, you will be ruled, be that someone external or someone even coming up
00:02:50 through America itself. And there were people saying, by even suggesting, not that this should
00:02:55 happen, but that this could happen, this is a denial of the gospel. I saw someone else saying,
00:03:00 where was the gospel in this? There was no hope. We're not talking about the gospel. We're talking
00:03:06 about politics. We're talking about the political sphere, what would be not even required. You're
00:03:11 not even saying it should be like this uh but what may be possible for the future so i've said a lot
00:03:16 uh welcome thoughts thinking categorically what is possible what is permissible what is maybe
00:03:22 descriptive prescriptive etc right no that's good um i want to play the clip yeah michael is there
00:03:28 anything that you want to say no let's jump in let's jump okay this is the clip that a right
00:03:31 wing boost uh also known as right wing watch basically it's a lib you know uh account on
00:03:38 Twitter and YouTube and things like that, that clips out. They're one of my biggest fans. And so
00:03:44 they watch a lot of our content and clip out different sections of a podcast or sermon. They
00:03:51 also kind of double down with, oh, and here's one of his recent sermons. And so another clip from
00:03:56 that. But they clip out different guys who are conservative and Christian and put it out there
00:04:02 for everybody to see. Sometimes it's out of context and sometimes it's not. And the clip
00:04:07 that i'm about to show you um you know there was more context uh but it's not terrible it's fairly
00:04:13 accurate to what i was saying um even though it's just a snippet of the conversation that i was
00:04:17 having with oran mcintyre on the uh topic and so they put that stuff out to kind of say you know
00:04:23 look at this scary right wing far alt-right you know terrible whatever and um so this is the clip
00:04:31 that uh obviously liberals leftists marxists don't like right wing watch is doing what right
00:04:37 right wing watch does um but there were plenty of christians that picked it up as well and uh had 0.72
00:04:43 the same uh pearl clutching oh my goodness response as um as a leftist baby killer like
00:04:52 in terms of their response i'm not saying they hold the same position of course not but um in
00:04:55 terms of their response they both responded pretty much the same oh my goodness i can't believe this
00:05:00 he's denying the gospel i mean constitution so here's a clip check it out we're degenerates
00:05:06 we're not even close to we're degenerates the constitution is not um it's not suited
00:05:14 for governing degenerates uh for governing governing degenerates and i'm curious your
00:05:21 thoughts on this if you agree disagree um but i i think for our population that is degraded
00:05:29 uh, morally and culturally, uh, as far as religiously, as far as we have, um, you need
00:05:37 power. Um, men must be governed. You need, you need a Caesar type, you know, now, if you're 0.60
00:05:44 asking me my preference, that, that would probably be my preference would be a constitutional
00:05:48 republic. Um, but I think the, um, the, the conditions for that is a moral people. So I
00:05:55 think you can you can work towards that in the future uh but i don't think um constitutioning
00:06:01 even harder is going to get us out of our our current uh mess uh i i don't see us getting out
00:06:09 of this apart from things getting worse and worse and then eventually um like a caesar type rising
00:06:17 through the ranks of populist you know figure and the people you know the political will the people
00:06:24 the people are desperate and they're like yes do it so and so and and then so and so constitution
00:06:31 be damned just rules with an iron fist and uh and you know like a cromwell type and then and then
00:06:38 you you know hopefully don't get his son maybe then you're able and then you you maybe it's just 0.97
00:06:42 a one generation one guy kind of thing and then you you have to move back to you know aristocracy
00:06:49 or some other form. All right, that's the clip. So, like Wes is saying, we need to be able to
00:06:59 think categorically. There's a difference between descriptive and prescriptive language. So, there
00:07:04 is a difference in saying, this is what Christians should be working towards versus saying, I think
00:07:10 this is probably what's going to happen. And basically, in that clip, some of you who are
00:07:15 astute and historically knowledgeable. You'll probably recognize that I'm really just channeling
00:07:19 my inner atoms, that the constitution is only fit for a moral and religious people and wholly fit for
00:07:26 any other. And so what I'm saying in that is we don't have that populace any longer. We are not
00:07:32 a moral and religious people. I mean, you can just look at the statistics. They come out annually
00:07:37 every single year that say, you know, the rise of the nuns, nuns being N-O-N-E, in terms of
00:07:43 religious affiliation, that more and more people every single year are saying, yeah, I'm not
00:07:46 Catholic, I'm not Protestant, I'm not, you know, nothing, nothing, nothing, nothing. So as we become
00:07:52 more and more pagan as a society, and we continue in the general public to apostatize from our 0.78
00:07:59 Christian heritage, we have found that we are spiraling into more and more degeneracy. And in 0.68
00:08:07 that kind of populace with those kinds of people, then yes, men must be governed. The whole idea of
00:08:16 a constitutional republic and a democratic republic is that there would be some measure,
00:08:23 in fact, I would argue a great measure of self-governance. And that's what America was
00:08:28 all about. That is our founding. That's true. No one's denying that. And no one's even denying
00:08:33 that as even the ideal in terms of forms of government. But you can't just do that whenever
00:08:40 and with whoever you want to do it, right? We've tried that. America has tried exporting democracy,
00:08:46 our sacred democracy, again and again and again. The cost of billions of dollars.
00:08:50 Billions of dollars and lots of lives, lots of blood of our own sons in order to export something
00:08:57 that people don't want. And even if they did, well, it's like, well, the people do want it
00:09:02 over there in the Middle East in this, you know, random place. But it's the warlords who don't
00:09:06 want it. Well, even the people who do want it, there's enough people with power who don't want
00:09:11 it that it doesn't work. For a constitutional democratic republic to work, you have to have
00:09:17 a certain type of people. So I'm channeling in that clip, my inner Adams, the constitution was
00:09:22 for religious and moral people. And then also, you know, kind of, you know, the famous Franklin
00:09:28 end quote, where he comes out of session and, you know, somebody asked him, you know, what did you
00:09:33 give us? What did you secure for us? What did you accomplish? And he says, a republic, if you can
00:09:38 keep it. And we didn't. We're not keeping that republic. And I think just constitutioning even
00:09:45 harder, that would be great. And just the last thing I'll say real quick, and I'll turn to you,
00:09:48 Michael, is I love the constitution. Absolutely love it. If there was anything that I would do
00:09:53 to the Constitution at all. If revival swept through the land or we got an American Caesar
00:09:59 and he was Christian and through him and the law of God and its second or third use functioning as 0.99
00:10:05 first and third use, revealing the wickedness of the people and then gospel preachers and churches
00:10:11 doing their ministry and a bunch of people get saved. And we say, hey, you know what? We want
00:10:14 to set things straight because there was a lot that was good in our founding, but a little bit
00:10:18 was missing. One of the first things that I would advocate for is not even changing the Constitution
00:10:23 but simply adopting to the constitution a preamble of like the apostles creed right
00:10:29 to actually say that this god is the triune god and giving more specificity other than that my
00:10:35 point is other than that i love the constitution people that well you don't love the first
00:10:39 amendment uh yes i do congress congress can make no law at the federal level that the united states
00:10:45 as a country as a whole would be episcopalian right but as we all know nine it's either nine
00:10:50 or 10 out of the first original 13 colonies had declared churches. And so there's a difference
00:10:56 between an ecclesiocracy and a theocracy. I don't want a church-run state. I don't want the pope or
00:11:02 bishops or pastors or whatever, the SBC convention in charge. I don't want J.D. Greer in charge of
00:11:08 the United States government at a state level, at a federal level, none of that. So that's an
00:11:13 ecclesiocracy, a church-run state. But a theocracy is simply saying that it should be a God-run state.
00:11:20 We do believe in a separation of church and state, and that gets back to the categories
00:11:25 that we're talking about.
00:11:26 What we reject entirely is a separation of Christ and state.
00:11:29 Every state is going to be inherently religious. 0.89
00:11:33 It's going to be the religion of drag queen story hour and mutilating kids and abortion 0.95
00:11:39 as the sacrament to Molech, or it's going to be the Christian religion. 0.99
00:11:44 And so I want a separation of church and state. 0.92
00:11:47 I do not want a separation of Christ in state.
00:11:50 I want our civil magistrates at the state level, at the federal level, to acknowledge
00:11:54 not just God in an ethereal, vague sense, but the Lord Jesus Christ, the triune God.
00:12:00 Other than that, though, the Constitution is wonderful.
00:12:02 And one day, I would love to have a population of fellow citizens, my neighbors, who could
00:12:08 actually exercise self-governments in such a way that we could live up to it again.
00:12:14 But to pretend as though that's where we are right now is to be so clueless about what time it is that it's hard to even help.
00:12:25 I don't even know what to do for you.
00:12:27 So, Mike.
00:12:27 Well, so talking about Adam's quote, and it's famous, but it really only presents us with two options.
00:12:34 So, Constitution was made for a moral and religious people.
00:12:38 It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other. 0.95
00:12:41 So, we only have two options here.
00:12:42 If our people is not moral and religious anymore, which it's not, the only two options are somehow pull the people back towards morality and religion or be left with the conclusion that the Constitution as it stands is not sufficient to govern that people.
00:12:58 and it's not for lack of trying in a lot of ways a lot of us would love if the american population
00:13:06 citizenry moved radically in a christian truly christian god-honoring virtuous direction
00:13:13 but barring that happening the logical the only other logical option is that we are living in a
00:13:21 society that actually can no longer be governed by that constitution that the founding fathers
00:13:27 gave to us right and when we think about categories um one of the one of the analogies that that helps
00:13:34 me is uh freedom which is in a lot of ways our new civic um paradigm not paradigm what's the apex
00:13:44 freedom is is the thing that we want the most but that is the wrong thing to want what we ought to
00:13:50 want is virtue right and and i think what's happened in america and i don't know where it
00:13:55 would be an interesting historical question, is the goal that the Puritans had of piety
00:13:59 and virtue in everything that they did, which led to people who were self-governed and self-disciplined
00:14:08 and righteous switched somehow where the fruit of their piety and virtue, which was freedom,
00:14:17 became the thing that we pursue at all costs. And you cannot get freedom by pursuing freedom.
00:14:23 if you pursue freedom then you're left with human autonomy exclusively if you pursue piety
00:14:30 and anarchy and anarchy eventually if you pursue piety and virtue the fruit can be freedom but
00:14:38 that can never actually be and that's why exported democracy to other countries doesn't work
00:14:43 is because when you give people freedom who are unregulated in their passions
00:14:47 all you get is anarchy and wanton pleasure-seeking and chaos right no said yeah that was insightful
00:14:55 arvin mcintyre he had a great tweet this week i'll i'll be vague in the way i describe it but
00:14:59 somewhere in belgium there's new restrictions on uh brothels and and basically the state getting
00:15:05 really involved and saying no you have to do this if you're a worker here and it's so funny how the
00:15:09 french revolution which which posited this idea exactly that of freedom emancipation from all
00:15:14 bonds not continuously chosen that if you don't want to be responsible and bonded to your family
00:15:20 you don't have to you don't want to be bound to this ideal you don't have to you should be able
00:15:23 to be emancipated from all these different things we've gone from that ideal and where it actually
00:15:28 has ended up is the state telling you this in the most private in the most terrible way possible
00:15:34 we think like you just said we can pursue freedom we will be free well what that's actually gotten
00:15:40 us i think of the video this week of a transgender man uh being given the infant that was born
00:15:47 through surrogacy yeah how do you to someone who would disagree with us how do you intend to fix 0.98
00:15:52 that what remediation steps are there that that evil pure abject evil doesn't happen how are you
00:15:59 going to fix it how are you going to enforce it you need power to enforce it you can't just say
00:16:04 don't do it there needs to be a bite behind it there needs to be a law that actually is enforced 0.99
00:16:08 how do you propose to fix a people that are so evil that gay men would purchase a child rent out 0.77
00:16:15 a woman's womb and then strip that child away the minutes that is born that's where the question 0.89
00:16:19 becomes practical and rapidly our list of options as our own lawmakers that we vote in continue to 0.96
00:16:26 do nothing about it or lag behind or drag their feet your list of options grows thin i think
00:16:31 gandolph said that lord of the rings right especially you know it's like with uh with
00:16:36 friends like this who needs enemies you know so like like what are you going to do about it when
00:16:39 even on the conservative side of the aisle right um they're condemning this video of you know this 0.99
00:16:44 gay man and his you know sodomite you know let's use the term a sodomite man with his you know 0.99
00:16:50 sodomite partner who um are buying you know it's human trafficking they're buying a baby 1.00
00:16:55 and depriving that baby of a mother um and then your conservatives um are condemning it
00:17:02 when just a few months back about a year i guess at this point yeah um those same conservatives
00:17:07 prager you dennis prager looking at you yeah um a lot of guys from the blaze looking at you
00:17:13 chris rufo looking at you like those those guys came out when uh when dave rubin did the exact
00:17:18 same thing with two babies two babies so they they purchased they human trafficked two kids
00:17:24 and everyone was like this is great congratulations and that's the conservatives
00:17:28 right so the point is just to say that we've got a problem on our hand and the only solution that
00:17:34 i hear a lot of um a lot of guys from you know the reformed world uh offering is i you know if i had
00:17:42 a dollar every time i heard this phrase um a mass move of the spirit of god great mass move praise
00:17:47 the lord that would be awesome all all about mass moves of the spirit of god but here's a fun thing
00:17:51 since we're speaking in categories um it's kind of like the cessation is charismatic argument you
00:17:55 know, the charismatic always says, so you're going to limit what God can do. God can do whatever he
00:18:00 wants. And it's like, yeah, I know I'm a Calvinist. You're the one who's typically Arminian.
00:18:04 So I'm down with God doing whatever he wants. I understand the sovereignty of God, but the
00:18:10 category that is always operated in is what God can do. Here's a helpful question that I think
00:18:16 we should ask more often as Christians, not just what can God do in a hypothetical speculation,
00:18:23 but what if we asked what has God done and what does God do instead of what can God do what does
00:18:31 God do ordinarily and what has he historically in this New Testament era this you know this gospel
00:18:37 era the church age that we currently live in what has God done for the last you know
00:18:43 2,000 years again and again and again are there any patterns right is it random is it arbitrary
00:18:49 Is it a little bit of this, a little bit of that?
00:18:51 Or are there certain patterns that seem to reoccur throughout history again and again
00:18:57 and again?
00:18:57 And here's one of the ones that I've noticed.
00:19:00 I'm preaching through the book of Ezra, and before that, we were in the book of Joshua.
00:19:03 Looking at the Old Testament, and then also just looking at history, there are far more
00:19:09 cases.
00:19:10 I'm not saying that there's never a ground-up change within a people, but there are far
00:19:16 more cases of what i would call top-down revival than there are bottom-up revival and what i mean
00:19:22 by that top-down revival is uh the people are degenerate and then all of a sudden josiah becomes
00:19:27 king and he says uh you know what the idolatry will stop yep yeah by penalty like there will
00:19:34 be a penalty if you continue to dug up the he dug up the bodies of the false priest and burn
00:19:38 them publicly i mean it was yep so you've got josiah and then you know even like jehu you know
00:19:43 who is not, he's not quite Josiah status, but you've got multiple kings varying degrees. You
00:19:48 know, you got bad kings in Israel, you know, it's like a three to one ratio of bad kings,
00:19:51 but among the good ones, some are better, some are not quite as good, but, you know,
00:19:55 still in this general good category. In virtually every single case, it is a civil magistrate. It
00:20:02 is a king, a ruler who comes in with real political power and he begins to legislate
00:20:10 the law of god and as the law of god becomes uh legislated not just preached in pulpits a
00:20:17 different category the church but it becomes actually the law of the land legislated from
00:20:22 um from the the palace uh in in the sphere of of the civic uh sphere then what that does is it one
00:20:30 it immediately begins to curb outward manifestations of evil so that at the level of the
00:20:35 heart there's still plenty of evil to go around right total depravity is a thing people are still
00:20:39 totally depraved. But did you know there's a lot of people who are totally depraved that don't
00:20:44 murder because there's a penalty and would otherwise, right? That's one of the things
00:20:48 that the law does. That's the second use of the law, that it functions as a shield, that it
00:20:53 actually, it curbs and holds back, restrains, not evil at a spiritual level, not evil of the heart,
00:21:01 not total depravity, but it does restrain outward manifestations of evil.
00:21:05 And it needs to be said that that is objectively good.
00:21:09 That is good.
00:21:10 That is not the eternal righteousness of God.
00:21:13 That's the whole purpose of the civil magistrate.
00:21:13 But that is objectively good.
00:21:15 Yes.
00:21:15 That is what the civil magistrate does.
00:21:18 That's why they're given the sword.
00:21:20 That is their job.
00:21:21 To do anything less than that is wicked on the civil magistrate's part.
00:21:26 And so the second use of the law, a shield, legislating God's law in such a way that it
00:21:30 The immediate effect is it begins to restrain outward manifestations of evil.
00:21:36 We've seen this in some South American countries.
00:21:40 I was literally about to give the story of El Salvador.
00:21:42 So if you're five years old, this has happened in your lifetime.
00:21:45 2019, Naid Bukele was, I probably didn't pronounce that perfectly, was elected. 0.51
00:21:51 We get it. 1.00
00:21:51 They had the highest murder rate, I believe it was, in the world.
00:21:55 It was a violent place to live.
00:21:56 he came in through the army so through control of a centralized army locked down gangs uh he's a
00:22:02 christian he supports not a single exception for abortion for example and in the space now this
00:22:08 was about i think it was last year that his re-election was held he went to the highest
00:22:12 approval rating of all known leaders in the world he rewrote the constitution to get term limits to
00:22:17 kick out old politicians that were standing in the way to also allow himself to serve i think
00:22:21 is either a second or a third term they're melting down statutes of communists propaganda and making
00:22:27 them sewer hubcaps he says this is what we're going to do with communism it is the safest it
00:22:32 has ever been yeah he put millions of the dollars millions of dollars worth into bitcoin and the
00:22:37 country is flourishing they're flourishing economically they're safe the people love it
00:22:42 there's been i know someone went down i think 90 something like that it's like 90 there's someone
00:22:47 there's a massive christian movement there as people are able to be safe to have jobs to provide
00:22:53 for their families this is objectively good right and this is not 200 years no and this was recently
00:22:59 right not in bible times when he was inaugurated if you go and watch his speech he gives a william
00:23:06 wallace you know war speech to the troops before they basically unleash them on the gangs and the
00:23:13 and the criminals in the country and he says to them you are doing god's work yes we are going to
00:23:19 kill the gangs and we are going to imprison them and this is god's work right and it was incredible
00:23:24 right it is god's work because it's uh christians work and christians work is different than saying 0.98
00:23:30 the church's work yes again we have to put on our big boy pants we need to grow up and learn how to
00:23:36 speak like adults. There are categories. The church is word and sacrament. The church is not
00:23:43 locking people up. It's not exercising the sword. But to say that's not the church's work is not to
00:23:50 say that it's not Christian's work. We, if we are working towards this mass move of the Spirit,
00:23:56 where a whole bunch of people get saved, and ideally, if God would be so kind, a majority
00:24:01 of the population, then guess what? A lot of your Christians, they're not all going to be pastors.
00:24:06 I hope, by God's grace, maybe we could stop taking people. 0.96
00:24:10 Every single time, Votie Bauckham said this once upon a time.
00:24:12 He said, every time you find a young man in the church who loves Jesus and has some sort
00:24:17 of gifting and intellect and is theologically, you know, has a bent, he's astute theologically,
00:24:24 everyone in the church immediately says, you should go to seminary.
00:24:26 You should be a pastor.
00:24:27 You should be a pastor.
00:24:28 And you know what they're doing?
00:24:29 And Votie Bauckham is super insightful on this.
00:24:31 He said what they're recognizing is they immediately have to elevate him to some kind of special category in order to absolve themselves of the fact that they all have been Christians for 40 years and still don't know anything about the Bible. 0.94
00:24:44 They're lazy. 0.96
00:24:45 They've been theologically apathetic and lazy. 0.86
00:24:49 And so what they have to do, instead of admitting, hey, you've been a Christian for eight months and you're studying systematic theology by Bovink, you know, and so what I have to do is I have to say, well, you must be just a different strain of DNA. 0.85
00:25:00 You know, you're just like a, a super sane elect, you know, you know, exactly. 0.60
00:25:06 You're, you know, and so you must be supernaturally called to the pastorate.
00:25:09 That's good.
00:25:10 Or here's an alternative.
00:25:11 Maybe they are.
00:25:12 I'm not ruling that out, but to assume that necessarily is, I think it's presumption.
00:25:17 Here's another possibility.
00:25:19 It's a young man who's a Christian who loves the Lord, is ferocious in his hunger and appetite
00:25:24 for the things of God, wants to love the Lord, his God, not just with all his heart and all
00:25:28 soul, but also as we're commanded with all his mind. And that guy could be a great pastor if
00:25:33 that is the Lord's calling. He could also be a great governor. He could be a great city council
00:25:38 member. He could be a great doctor. We need Christians in every single realm. So the church,
00:25:43 the work of the church is word and sacrament, but the work of Christians is whatever that work looks
00:25:49 like in that vocation, wherever it's found. So the work of Christians in the church is word
00:25:56 in sacrament. The work of Christians in the civil magistrate, if it's El Salvador the last five
00:26:01 years, it's chopping heads to the glory of God. Praise be. And that is a blessing. That is loving 1.00
00:26:07 your neighbor when you're chopping off the heads of wolves in order to spare the sheep. That is a
00:26:13 good thing. So we have to be able to speak in categories. We have to understand the times. We
00:26:18 have to understand separation of church and state, that we don't want the president ruling the Pope
00:26:24 And we don't want the Pope ruling the president.
00:26:26 And from our persuasion, we'd like to not have much stuff going on with the Pope, period.
00:26:31 But you get the expression.
00:26:34 My point, we don't want the church over the state.
00:26:36 We don't want the state over the church.
00:26:38 Separation of church and state. 0.94
00:26:39 Yes and amen. 0.67
00:26:40 But there is no separation.
00:26:42 There should be no separation between God and state.
00:26:45 Every single country is going to have a governance.
00:26:48 It's going to have a civil governance.
00:26:49 and that civil governance is going to pay credence to some form of orthodoxy, some form of God.
00:26:55 We would like it to be the triune God, the God who actually exists. And if the state bows the
00:27:02 knee to King Jesus, and just like the Roman soldiers that came to Jesus and said, we're
00:27:08 saved now, we're your disciples, how should we live? And he says, well, you have to immediately
00:27:13 quit being soldiers in the Roman army because Christians can't do that, said Jesus never. 0.83
00:27:18 that's not his response he says no you need to act righteously you can stay in this role and
00:27:23 that's with rome in the first century right and jesus still says you know what this for christians
00:27:28 is a viable option crazy crazy uh paul writes to i think it's either philippians right servants in
00:27:35 caesar's house was it nero's household servants in his letter hey greet those that are servants
00:27:40 in nero's home yeah right perfectly and so what jesus says is um you can do this uh but you have
00:27:46 to do it righteously you can't rip people off anymore you need to be content with your wages
00:27:49 don't uh don't practice extortion and bribes and all these things those are the kinds of things
00:27:54 that underline all the crime and murder in places like el salvador and you get in you say no more
00:28:00 and that's one of the things that um that you know the the new um you know the new caesar of
00:28:05 el salvador uh has said is he didn't just crack down on crime he cracked down on his own fellow
00:28:12 civil magistrates that's one of the first things that he did was he looked around the room i've
00:28:16 listen to some of the hearings and he says um i will i will find you out if anyone is lying or
00:28:23 cheating or stealing he he did one recently where he called them all in and he said we're announcing
00:28:28 announcing a new anti-corruption campaign no one no one in the room knew that this was coming right
00:28:33 is this the one you're talking about he says we're announcing a new anti-corruption campaign
00:28:37 it's going to be across the entire country and by the way it's starting in this room all of you are
00:28:42 going to be investigated with a fine-tooth comb. And then he leans into the mic and he said,
00:28:46 that shouldn't be a problem with any of you, right?
00:28:48 Right. No, it was based. It was awesome. So that, yeah. So we want separation of church and state,
00:28:54 not a separation of Christ and state. We're going to have Christians. Not every young man who loves
00:28:59 the Lord is called to be a pastor. The only reason it's looked like that for so long is because
00:29:03 the church has been in such disarray and we've had such a low bar for zeal for the Lord and
00:29:07 especially knowledge of the scripture. But as things continue to change, and I hope by God's
00:29:13 grace that they do, then we should have Christians in the pastorate, but we're also going to have
00:29:19 competent, gifted, zealous Christians in business and markets and all these different arenas and
00:29:25 in the civil magistrate. And in that category of the civil magistrate, they have been given power
00:29:31 and they need to wield that power. And so here's the whole thing, top down. Okay, so bottom up,
00:29:36 mass move of the Holy Spirit where, you know, God just saves 51%, you know, and then we vote in,
00:29:42 you know, better rulers. Maybe, I hope, I really hope, I'm not against that. I'm doing, you know,
00:29:49 I'm doing my part, right? As a local pastor, preaching the gospel, going through books of
00:29:53 the Bible, expositional preaching, and encouraging men in our church to run for office, and many have.
00:29:59 So we're doing that. And maybe God will do that. Maybe God will sin revival, bottom up,
00:30:05 mass move the spirit in such a way that a simple majority of the population of our country
00:30:10 loves Jesus and understands the scripture and how to apply it to every realm of life
00:30:15 and therefore begins to elect righteous rulers and the country starts to change. That would be
00:30:20 great. But what I was saying earlier is you read the Bible and you look at history, Bible and
00:30:26 history. Those are two books, very important. If you look at that more often than not, it's not
00:30:31 bottom up. It's top down. It's somebody, God gets a hold of somebody's heart in power. And whether
00:30:41 it's Nebuchadnezzar, and that doesn't even mean Nebuchadnezzar was regenerate. I'm not even making
00:30:44 that argument. Or Cyrus, or whether it's somebody who is truly righteous, David, Josiah, and then
00:30:52 in history, whether it's King Alfred or Richard the Lionheart or this guy or that guy. And it's
00:30:58 history is is filled with all these examples where things are not great and and the people's
00:31:04 appetite for god and for righteousness as at fairly low levels and then someone comes in with
00:31:11 power and god gets a hold of that heart he guides the heart of the king like many waters in whatever
00:31:16 direction he he wills and then that person says um as for me and my extended house aka this whole
00:31:24 nation we will serve the lord whether you like it or not well that's forced conversions no
00:31:30 no he's saying outwardly we will serve the lord your own heart you can't force conversion you
00:31:38 can't even if you tried you can't only the holy spirit sovereignly can regenerate a heart but what
00:31:44 you can do is you can say outwardly um we are going to behave as a christian people and what
00:31:51 does that mean? It means we're going to ban pornography. It means we are going to ban
00:31:56 no-fault divorce. It means we are going to absolute, utterly abolish abortion, including
00:32:03 in vitro, including the hormonal birth control pill, every single one of its forms, not just
00:32:09 the Planned Parenthood Clinic in Texas, but we're going to go down to the local CVS and we're going
00:32:14 to start knocking those pills off the shelf no more human sacrifice so a civil magistrate can do
00:32:22 that yeah he can and should do that and um and here's the thing that i was saying earlier and
00:32:28 i'll leave it here and get to you guys one that's the second use of the law of god curbing outward
00:32:32 manifestations of evil the evil could still be there at the heart the person has to get saved
00:32:36 for that to change and even then you still have you know within the members of my being you know
00:32:41 sin still resides within the members of my being. So I find this law at work with, you know, when I
00:32:44 want to do good, evil is right there present with me. I think Romans 7, this is post-conversion.
00:32:48 I don't think this is Paul speaking as a Jew before he saved. I love the law of God because
00:32:52 I was a Pharisee. No, I think he's saying as a Christian after conversion, I delight in my inner
00:32:56 being. I delight in the law of God, but I still have this ongoing lifelong battle in sanctification
00:33:01 where I continue to wrestle with sin. So the Christian has the flesh. The non-Christian has
00:33:05 not only the flesh, but it also, the non-Christian has a heart of stone, an unregenerate heart, 0.99
00:33:10 a sin nature. But even for the non-Christian with the flesh and its various temptations and 0.97
00:33:16 an unregenerate heart, a Christian magistrate legislating God's law in such a way that it 0.98
00:33:22 becomes the law of the land, what it does is it says, you may still be totally depraved internally, 0.97
00:33:27 but externally, you are no longer going to behave in that way. Not all sins are crimes. So coveting
00:33:34 is not going to get a civil penalty, but a lot of stuff is. Abortion is. Peddling pornography is. 0.99
00:33:40 These kinds of things. There are going to be penalties, and lo and behold, you do that in
00:33:44 El Salvador, and people change. People respond to carrots and sticks. They do. They do. And so you
00:33:50 do that, and then the last thing is the first use of God's law. Here's the other thing, and here's
00:33:54 the irony. The beautiful, I think, divine irony is it's not just the second law of God when it's
00:33:59 legislated rightly, curbing outward manifestations of evil. But the first use of God's law is that
00:34:04 the law functions as a mirror. It reveals to us because the law is holy, it shows us that God is
00:34:09 holy. And by way of contrast and seeing, staring into the thrice holy God, his holy nature, his
00:34:15 holy character, by seeing his holy law, we see by contrast our lack of holiness, our sinfulness.
00:34:21 And what that does, as Charles Spurgeon said, a man cannot appreciate the beauty of Christ lest he
00:34:26 first come to see the necessity for Christ. A lot of people are not. Part of the reason we're not
00:34:31 having this mass revival and a mass move of the Spirit of God is because a bunch of people are 0.60
00:34:37 degenerates, and here's the worst part about it, they don't think they are. They don't know
00:34:41 they're degenerates. But one thing that happens when you get a strong civil magistrate who
00:34:46 legislates God's law righteously, like a Josiah, is not only does it keep people from outwardly
00:34:51 doing these heinous, wicked sins and crimes, but it also begins, the law begins to function as a
00:34:58 tutor. So the law, not only does it function as a shield restraining my outward manifestation of
00:35:03 evil, but it also then functions as a tutor. It begins to inform me, disciple me, teach me about
00:35:09 righteousness and wickedness. So then when I walk into church and hear that gospel preaching,
00:35:15 That gospel preaching is now like a baseball-sized diamond that properly is contrasting with the
00:35:23 conducive backdrop of the black velvet to where the diamond actually shines and it sparkles now.
00:35:30 I can appreciate and I run to Christ because I see myself as a sinner and I recognize my need
00:35:35 for him. That's top-down revival, historically and biblically. If we're talking statistics,
00:35:41 It happens far more often than bottom-up revival.
00:35:44 And if you're going to say everything I just said then, that that's somehow antithetical
00:35:50 to the gospel and to revival and to the Bible, then brother, you need to just sit the bench
00:35:57 for a little while and let us take it from here.
00:35:59 Let the big boys play.
00:36:01 You sit the bench. 0.93
00:36:01 I know you're a good company man, but your Jesus jukes and your little pietistic quips, 0.78
00:36:08 we don't have time for those anymore. 0.95
00:36:09 i know that it plays well with the fan base and your female audience but it's time to sit down
00:36:15 and uh and let some christian men talk so all right go to our first commercial break here on
00:36:21 that note yeah all right at private family banking our mission is to help you set up your own
00:36:27 privatized banking system so that you can prosper and pass along tax-free wealth to the next
00:36:32 generation and teach them to be financially responsible with that wealth your system will
00:36:37 guarantee positive and continuous growth of your money, income tax protected, for the rest of your
00:36:43 life and beyond. Additionally, you will create a pool of capital that can be used to grow additional
00:36:49 wealth using the same money in more than one place at the same time. For families, investors, and those
00:36:57 near or already in retirement, your system will provide a buffer against market volatility to
00:37:03 help you avoid selling off your investment portfolio during prolonged market downturns.
00:37:09 Now, for those who are struggling with paying off high interest bearing credit cards or car loans or
00:37:16 student loans, there's no worries. We'll teach you how to use your private family bank to accelerate
00:37:22 the payoff of your consumer debt, including a monthly step-by-step guide, turning post-mill
00:37:28 thinking into post-mill action with private family banking. Now that's a good thing. Find
00:37:34 out how this powerful approach to a multi-generational wealth building can work for you and your family
00:37:41 by emailing banking at privatefamilybanking.com. You'll receive a free ebook and a link to schedule
00:37:48 your free 30-minute consultation today. All right. Well, welcome back. Joel, I think those last few
00:37:56 things you said, those probably added 15% to my bench right there. I can go through a wall right
00:37:59 now and just, we're getting rid of this evil. We're getting rid of it. I'm going to hit just
00:38:04 quick two comments. We read the comments. Appreciate everyone who has questions, genuine
00:38:09 questions, shows out to support. One of the comments was, well, there's no king but Christ,
00:38:13 and so Christians should have no allegiance to other kings. Paul explicitly says, 1 Timothy 2,
00:38:17 I command then that men have public prayers for kings and rulers. Christ is king of kings. There
00:38:24 has to be other kings for him to be king over them. There is no king but Christ, but there are real
00:38:28 rulers, presidents, kings in this earth that Christians acknowledge. Grace does not restore 0.95
00:38:32 nature. Your argument is dumb. Second one, someone mentioned, well, a top-down government. Sorry, 1.00
00:38:37 grace does restore nature. Grace does restore nature. Exactly, it doesn't subvert nature.
00:38:42 Top-down government. So you said it could be bottom-up revival, but it also could be top-down.
00:38:45 Someone mentioned, well, that could come with its excesses. And typically in the past when there's
00:38:49 been some type of Christian government, oftentimes it's really it's church and government that are 0.79
00:38:53 combined, they persecute other Christians. So they'll persecute the Baptists or they persecute 0.91
00:38:57 this other group. And so we should be, we can't do that because of the excesses. But going back 0.71
00:39:02 to El Salvador for a minute, they had the highest murder rate in the world from gangs. Do you know
00:39:08 how violent gangs are to torture, to take people from their family and say, if you don't give us 0.99
00:39:13 $2 million, we're going to just chop their head off. They do not care. There's not an ounce of 0.99
00:39:18 empathy so probably of the tens of thousands of gang members that the president imprisoned some
00:39:24 of them might not have been that really is possibly true uh but you know what that is
00:39:28 much better it's not like you get to have a perfect world when none of those things happen
00:39:32 that you don't accidentally maybe jail an innocent person or you have terrible gang violence you have
00:39:37 to pick one or the other and you could talk to any single citizen in el salvador and they would
00:39:42 laugh in your face if not be offended that you would suggest that the excesses that are real
00:39:46 that really would happen even a christian prince would come with excesses we'll probably get to
00:39:50 that in the third section to suggest that those excesses that men buying infants for example that
00:39:56 we can't have a christian nation that might not look well in baptist because well of this no it's
00:40:02 which excess will you have and i would much rather christians doing their best sinning in the right
00:40:06 direction the excesses that would come with that than the blessings of classical liberalism
00:40:12 blessings. They are not blessings. They're evil and degeneracy. All right. Self-governance. So
00:40:18 we talked about we are a nation of degenerates. And if we are a nation of degenerates that cannot 0.98
00:40:23 rule ourselves, we will be ruled. I think of a toddler. Toddlers do not get to choose their meal. 0.91
00:40:28 They don't get to choose their bedtime. They don't get to choose a lot of things at all
00:40:31 because they're not capable. They're impulsive. They're governed by the emotion, the heat of the
00:40:36 moment. Writer Mark Horn, he's a Christian. He wrote a commentary, short one, on Proverbs for
00:40:41 young men. He said this, if you do not learn to govern yourself, you will be governed by others
00:40:46 and your impulses will be the reins they use to lead you. I had a pastor years ago, it wasn't you,
00:40:52 he said, the unbeliever will go to the Christian and will say, oh, you're so constrained because
00:40:56 you can't do this and you won't do that, but I'm free. And so, well, hang on, wait a second.
00:41:01 You're enslaved to pornography. You're enslaved to the approval of man. You would never talk back
00:41:06 to your boss or push back because you're afraid of their approval. You love money. You spend your
00:41:11 day and night thinking about money, how to get more, scheming. So it's not as though the Christian 1.00
00:41:16 is bound, the Christian is constrained, and they just have all these things, don't look, don't 0.98
00:41:21 taste, don't see, don't touch. But the unbeliever is just out there living their best life. No, 1.00
00:41:25 the unbeliever is absolutely enslaved. Jesus says whoever commits sin is a slave to sin.
00:41:31 So we have a people right now that are absolutely in bondage and enslaved.
00:41:35 And a people that are in bondage like that, the same way a toddler is bound by his emotions,
00:41:40 they're not capable of self-governance.
00:41:42 Self-governance is the privilege of those that have learned to control their passions,
00:41:46 control their impulses, and to govern themselves and say,
00:41:49 I'm going to do this thing, for example, that is in the long term more beneficial.
00:41:53 I'm going to deny myself here.
00:41:55 I'm going to deny myself there.
00:41:57 I love what you said, Michael.
00:41:58 Freedom is the fruit of virtue.
00:41:59 it's you can't pursue freedom is not an end in itself it's not that um we pursue freedom
00:42:06 you know hell or high water at all costs right no you pursue virtue and righteousness to be
00:42:13 pleasing to god and the fruit of that is as we grow and mature um freedom is one of the blessings
00:42:21 that we receive it's the same as children in a home 100 as my children pursue virtue and obedience
00:42:28 to god first and then to me and their mother um as the first human authorities designated by god
00:42:35 in their lives for their instruction and their blessing and their good as our children get older
00:42:40 um and have proven time and time again uh improving by god's grace their track record
00:42:47 of obedience to our human authority then they naturally everything i don't even have to think
00:42:53 about it it's just like hey you know what let's um let's have some more privileges you know you
00:42:57 can do this now i think you can do it way to go um well what happens with right that's in a home
00:43:03 now just take that yep and apply it with a country what happens if you got america is like uh
00:43:09 america is like uh like watching benjamin button right you know it's like you know like we started
00:43:16 off you know like all these like wise sages and christian you know and then you just get younger 0.99
00:43:21 and dumber and stupider um and that's that's these united states of america um and and so 0.99
00:43:29 what do you do like what would you do as a parent if your children were actually devolving rather 1.00
00:43:35 than developing they were actually at the level of both virtue and intellect and competence they
00:43:40 were becoming more and more and that's what's happening with our population like and i mean
00:43:45 both degrees not just the moral uh category but also in terms of iq iq has been going down for
00:43:51 quite a while health iq because it's yeah fertility at every single level you see like like the you
00:43:58 know the wally movie you know that like like that's that's what's happening um you know and 0.93
00:44:03 and so uh we're getting uh dumber literally i mean statistically dumber fatter and more wicked 0.54
00:44:09 so so then what do you you you at some point you have to reign it like oh well then you you don't 0.95
00:44:16 get as much freedom yeah you you can't have it now i understand one of the pushbacks that i
00:44:21 thought was fair it was saying well but if you have this degenerate populace that you're so
00:44:24 convinced of joel and yes i am convinced i mean that's the easiest thing to prove in the world
00:44:28 the sky is blue jesus is lord and america is filled with degenerates right like i mean that's
00:44:33 not a hard argument to make but um a good pushback that i received was well then um where do you
00:44:39 think this you know this caesar would come from and again categories prescriptive versus descriptive
00:44:45 right we're using descriptive language and saying i think this might be what happens
00:44:49 um not saying hey let's work for it tomorrow and form the secret alliance or whatever
00:44:54 right right wing watch would love that they'll probably clip what i just said out of context
00:44:58 and make it sound like we're doing but my point is um it's descriptive language predicting what
00:45:02 we think may happen uh what god not what god can do but looking at what god has done so and and
00:45:08 then with that if that happens sure out of a degenerate population you could get a really bad
00:45:14 caesar right no one's saying that that may not happen we would we would be just would god would
00:45:18 be just that would be the judgment option which would be justice there's the justice option where
00:45:24 we get that kind of of tyrant um and but then the mercy option um all i'm trying to to espouse
00:45:31 is it in the judgment option you get a tyrant caesar and he persecutes just the heck out of
00:45:37 the country but he probably enforces a basic morality probably that aligns with some sort of
00:45:44 god in his sovereignty that would be his justice and simultaneously in his sovereignty could be
00:45:48 used to get us on the right track uh but then in the mercy category if god gives us the mercy
00:45:53 option all i'm saying is that that mercy option can come about not just in one way but two
00:45:58 it's not as though the only merciful option is um grassroots bottom up mass move of the spirit
00:46:05 revival individual hearts being regenerate by the preaching of the gospel till you get 50 plus one
00:46:10 and then electing better leaders that could happen but historically that has not been god's mo um
00:46:17 another act that would be merciful is you get the strong authoritarian leader um but he's a christian
00:46:26 right and he loves the lord jesus christ and he's imperfect and like wes was saying uh earlier
00:46:31 there will be sins. He will sin. There will be excesses, but he vastly improves the situation,
00:46:39 just like El Salvador. He works to outlaw abortion. He works to esteem the church again, 1.00
00:46:47 all these things. And that becomes the backdrop of not just curbing outward manifestations of
00:46:52 wickedness, second use of the law, but in the first use of the law, it teaches the people
00:46:57 that we actually are sinners and we need christ and then it leads towards a bunch of regenerate
00:47:02 hearts and then maybe you can get back to more freedom and more self-governance and for the
00:47:08 last thing that i should probably say is um and none of that actually requires necessarily
00:47:13 that you do away with the constitution yep so that's not a constitutionalist option
00:47:19 or ron mcintyre on your show i thought it was so insightful he said we've had points in american
00:47:26 history where presidents have temporarily taken almost dictatorial power right he cited fdr he
00:47:33 cited lincoln right lincoln yeah um and that was a time this this was this was the pattern from the
00:47:40 roman um republic as well where in time of crisis they would appoint someone that was called a
00:47:46 dictator who would give dictates that was the whole point he could just give dictates that had
00:47:51 to be followed they didn't have to be laws passed by the two houses really three of the roman system
00:47:56 he could just give dictates and then when the crisis was gone he was required to step down now
00:48:01 caesar never stepped down he was executed but um he was required to step down so this this this
00:48:07 precedent hits true this precedent in the western republican capital r tradition has already been
00:48:14 laid there's already historical president going back millennia and going back in our own
00:48:20 constitutional framework where that sort of thing has happened yeah i wanted to say one other thing
00:48:26 to, Joel, when you said earlier the question of what God has done, and then connecting
00:48:31 that to Wes's comment about the privilege of self-governance.
00:48:37 For those who think that God would care more about liberty and personal liberty than about
00:48:44 virtue and worship, consider the example of Israel when they came out of Egypt.
00:48:52 God cannot lie, and so when he said through Moses to Pharaoh,
00:48:57 let my people go that they may go out and worship me rightly.
00:49:02 There was a sense where in Egypt they could not worship God
00:49:07 the way God deserved to be worshiped by his people.
00:49:10 And partly that was because God's definition of worship
00:49:13 was not just offering a sacrifice on a particular day.
00:49:15 It was a whole lifestyle.
00:49:18 James White, when he preached through the Holiness Code in Leviticus,
00:49:21 he just pounded in so much.
00:49:24 There's almost no distinction in that section
00:49:27 between worship and service.
00:49:29 It is the same idea.
00:49:31 And so when God says,
00:49:33 my people are not free to worship me
00:49:34 under your rule, Pharaoh,
00:49:37 let them go so that they may be free to worship me.
00:49:41 They go out and the first thing that God does
00:49:44 is he gives them a law.
00:49:46 Why does he give them a law?
00:49:47 A law to govern themselves.
00:49:49 They had no law under Pharaoh.
00:49:51 He gives them a law to regulate their self-governance and their right worship to God.
00:49:56 And yet, though that was good and the ideal, as soon as Joshua faded off the scene, Israel
00:50:04 used their self-governance, their freedom for living the way that they wanted to, to 0.61
00:50:10 worship pagan gods.
00:50:12 And boom, God removed that freedom of self-governance from them almost immediately, right? 0.97
00:50:18 He brought in time and again oppressors and the Philistines, and then the people would 0.95
00:50:23 kind of learn their lesson. 1.00
00:50:24 They'd say, okay, God, you're right.
00:50:25 We should worship you, and he'd send a judge.
00:50:27 But this idea that self-government and self-governance and freedom is tantamount in God's mind
00:50:34 is not a biblical idea.
00:50:38 God's greatest virtue for a person, for a society, for a nation, for his church, is
00:50:45 right and proper worship.
00:50:46 And if they will not achieve it through their own self-governance, then he's going to take matters into his own hands.
00:50:53 Well said.
00:50:54 We should talk a little bit about representative government.
00:50:59 Just briefly, this could just be a small point, but just that the idea that in a monarchy, like there was just some thoughts, you know, as we were preparing for this episode.
00:51:09 And even the whole monarchy idea, like one point that I would want to make is, you know, people, you know, they have this idea like, you know, the constitutional, you know, representative, democratic, you know, republic, America's, you know, original system of governance, that that's the best.
00:51:30 um i think that that is debatable although i i like it and i think it's really really good
00:51:36 i think it's the ideal um but it you know it it assumes um a certain kind of people we've
00:51:42 already talked about that we don't have that kind of people so i don't think it's working
00:51:45 uh right now um the constitution uh didn't stop all the uh covet abuses right i did you know like
00:51:52 i like the constitution i wish that my civil magistrates did right that's the whole thing
00:51:57 People are like, Joel's against the Constitution.
00:51:59 No, I'm just pointing out the fact that we have not been a constitutional republic for a very, very long time.
00:52:05 Let me read a quote that backs that up because I meant to read it earlier.
00:52:07 And before we move on, it goes exactly what you're saying.
00:52:10 Benjamin Franklin said, only a virtuous people are capable of freedom.
00:52:14 And then he said this, as nations become corrupt and vicious, they have more need of masters.
00:52:19 And that really is where we are.
00:52:21 We need more need of masters because we are more corrupt and more vicious.
00:52:24 There's one of the founders.
00:52:25 They understood.
00:52:26 these things um your neo-conservative you know post-war sentiment whatever you know 2024
00:52:35 guy he doesn't get it um but what i was going to say is if you think of like governments
00:52:40 like an evolution of governments um evolution is terrible you you understand how i'm using the word
00:52:47 but like you know this development of governments evolving and maturing with um a populace a society
00:52:54 a culture as it evolves and matures um that to me seems to make sense and when you think of
00:53:00 america's form of government my whole point is to say it's not as though um there was just this
00:53:05 random group of people like i want to be kind in the way that i say this but um the native americans
00:53:13 did not form a constitutional republic who did uh it was westerners steeped for centuries
00:53:23 in the christian worldview as well in addition to the christian worldview just western civilization
00:53:30 and its rich tradition from plato and athens and rome and all this collective for centuries
00:53:37 centuries it was not a 15 minute project and and we just we start the clock with america we start
00:53:44 start the clock with 1776 right no no um who were those where did those guys come from right these
00:53:50 these guys who are larger than life you know that like george washington who's just and i mean he
00:53:56 really is just a god's honest hero just a mountain of a man physically but then also just i mean an
00:54:02 amazing man um but where what orchard did these apples come from right um it wasn't that there
00:54:10 was just this random plot of land you know over there in the americas and some native indigenous
00:54:16 people one day decided uh we're going to be self-governed right and we're going to set up
00:54:21 this form of government and we're going to do things really well no uh no i'll leave it there
00:54:28 just not even close well there was still rule it was violent rule it was that's what i was going
00:54:33 to say it was tribal warfare might makes right you're slaughtering each other smoking peyote
00:54:38 and worshiping demons that's that's what you had okay um but but guys steeped in christendom
00:54:46 for hundreds of years now here's my point you you get eventually over in america but we we think
00:54:52 that that's like it is the new world it was you know at that time um but but it wasn't new people
00:54:58 it's a new world that's what i'm trying to say but it wasn't new people these people were growing on
00:55:02 a tree that had been planted long ago and so this is this constitutional republic democratic republic
00:55:08 that we get with a lot of representative uh governance and self-governance um but it comes
00:55:15 an apple that rolls a little bit from the tree and sprouts a new tree over here that's an even
00:55:20 i would argue a better tree um but but the tree that it came from it didn't just grow out of the
00:55:25 ground magically it came from another tree that had been growing for hundreds of years and what
00:55:29 tree was that um it was christian first and foremost it was western anglo-saxon but it was
00:55:36 also here's a crazy one it was a monarchy it was not a democracy and so these guys who had
00:55:44 virtue intellect love for god um the kind of men who were able to start such a glorious form of
00:55:53 government that we have appreciated so much and i think now are unworthy of but have appreciated
00:55:58 so much and i hope that we can get back to it but these guys that we love and that we honor
00:56:03 they grew on the tree of monarchy and what i'm saying is that as as you had westerners
00:56:10 begin to embrace the gospel of the Lord Jesus Christ and begin to formulate and solidify the
00:56:19 Western tradition and the Christian religion, Christendom, in Europe over centuries. As that's
00:56:26 happening, government is evolving right there along with it. And it's a monarchy, but then
00:56:33 eventually there's parliament and there's different things and it's not all power control
00:56:39 concentrated centralized and what and it begins to as the people are maturing just like a father
00:56:44 raising children in his home and then it comes over to america with some of the best of the best
00:56:49 who are willing to sacrifice and make the trip in the first place and yeah it makes logical sense
00:56:54 and i think biblical but logical sense that the best of the western tradition after centuries
00:57:00 arguably arguably a millennium um steeped in monarchy that was becoming more constitutional
00:57:06 and democratic that the very best and brightest and most godly could go over somewhere else
00:57:12 and that they could start a constitutional republic yeah that's that makes sense but if you
00:57:18 think in 2024 with porn hub and just the i'm not even talking about the average man this is mean
00:57:27 i'm gonna say it's it's mean but i love you and you need to hear it i'm not talking about the
00:57:31 average american i'm talking about the average christian the average christian is not mature
00:57:36 enough uh for self-governance they should be they have it don't get me wrong i'm not crossing
00:57:42 wires here theologically they have the ability to self-govern because they have the fruit of
00:57:47 the spirit which is self-control but the average christian right now is so doctrinally and 0.97
00:57:54 theologically and and politically and outside of just the like anemic and and and uh dim-witted
00:58:03 that they just they can't do it i was gonna say john doyle he has a great video on why 0.95
00:58:09 conservatives struggle to make culture and some of the problem is that so much filth and perversion
00:58:14 has flowed down that it's as if you gave a toddler mcdonald's every meal for years and then you said
00:58:21 we're going to change your diet and we're going to set up here some grilled chicken and some apples
00:58:25 and some homemade organic macaroni which one would he choose they've been fed a diet we've
00:58:32 been fed a diet i think pornography was protected as free speech i mean since the 70s you have
00:58:38 hollywood you have music subversive forces that flooded them into our culture and then smartphones
00:58:43 gave everyone the ability to have it into their hand the damage that that has done the diet that
00:58:50 has given people because nobody hooked up to the Netflix, Hulu, Pornhub machine is going
00:58:55 to wake up without God's grace, pull the IV off, some good law preaching, pull the IV
00:59:00 off and say, nah, I've had enough of that.
00:59:02 No, you've been inculcated, trained, even bred now since we're several generations in
00:59:07 to just live off the drip of cheap dopamine and entertainment.
00:59:11 And that type of people, it is going to need power to bring them back and say, you are
00:59:16 killing yourselves. 0.62
00:59:17 Literally, the West here, you are committing suicide. 1.00
00:59:20 And if we don't radically amputate, radically detox, get you off of this cheap dopamine, of all of this stuff that is destroying your taste, you're going to kill yourself. 0.88
00:59:30 You're going to destroy yourself. 0.71
00:59:31 And because we love you, no more. 0.99
00:59:34 No more of this.
00:59:34 Like abortion, it's downstream of us thinking that every young person has a right to spend their 20s having sex with no consequences.
00:59:42 That's the only way you get a culture where people say, I don't want this baby right now.
00:59:45 So it's downstream of telling young women, especially, you should be able to do this without consequences. 0.99
00:59:52 We don't have to start here like, oh my goodness, we've got to get rid of abortion. 0.72
00:59:55 We've got to get rid of a lot more than abortion when we're going to turn that clock back.
01:00:00 Some of the verses that gave rise to the American system of government are verses that specifically address the inward man first.
01:00:12 For instance, 1 Peter 2.16 says,
01:00:16 And these verses, political thinkers thought through, and they said,
01:00:31 what does it mean to live as a free man, right, where my obligation is only and primarily to God?
01:00:37 They said, well, that means that you have to have a lot of autonomy in your life.
01:00:40 You have to have a lot of ability to offer God the sacrifices that he has due without compulsion, with goodwill, with hard work, with effort, with reverence, with fear.
01:00:51 But the Galatians 5 verse haunts us as a society.
01:00:54 It says, for you brothers were called to freedom, but do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh.
01:01:00 And that is exactly, I know it's not specifically addressed to America, right?
01:01:05 But that is exactly what we've done.
01:01:06 We've taken the freedom that we were given.
01:01:08 In the Trump Bible it is.
01:01:10 god bless and we've used that as um an opportunity for the flesh and paul knew that that was a
01:01:17 tendency paul knew that was a tendency yeah yeah so all that being said i i guess maybe last thing
01:01:23 i want to say and then west maybe you can bring us home um do we have one more commercial break
01:01:27 we do more we do okay well let me say this we'll go to a commercial and then we'll just round out
01:01:32 our final thoughts but um some of you might be thinking well i thought you guys were post-millennial
01:01:36 i thought you were you know you're bullish you're optimistic you know and i would say uh-huh i'm
01:01:41 bullish uh in in the long game and uh bearish in the short um post-millennialism does not presuppose
01:01:48 it doesn't insist upon this perfect trajectory going you know steadily up up up with no dips
01:01:55 along the way of course there are dips along the way um and i think we're in a pretty big dip and
01:02:01 and for the record i don't think just you know for a lot of us who've woken up you know in god's
01:02:06 mercy he woke us up recently you know a lot of people like woke up in 2020 and um you know so
01:02:12 uh but just for the record i don't think we're in a a four-year dip since 2020 i think you know
01:02:18 we're in like a 300 year dip and arguably even longer but i'm thinking you know enlightenment
01:02:22 i'm thinking you know i'm thinking it's a long dip and a lot of this is the chickens coming home
01:02:28 to roost a lot of these things are actually uh old ideas that are finally just coming to fruition
01:02:33 ideas have consequences and um and we're and we're starting to experience some of those
01:02:37 consequences but uh all that being said i i think we're in you know a good 300 year dip
01:02:42 and right now we're in you know i mean we're we're at the bottom of that dip and that said
01:02:48 don't you think for a second it can't go lower um i don't i don't think that we've necessarily
01:02:52 quite found the bottom yet so i think uh things could stay bad and even get worse in the short
01:02:57 term um but you look at you know the last three years and then you look at the last 300 um and
01:03:05 you're like ah not great um but look at the last 2000 you know i think sometimes it's just helpful
01:03:10 to uh to zoom out um both in terms of um geography and history so don't just look at one country
01:03:21 don't just look at your country in the last 50 years right that's i mean you take that away from
01:03:26 the dispensation list and then you know they've got nothing left so you're like don't take that
01:03:29 from me pastor america in the last 50 years um okay but what about every country in the whole
01:03:35 world over the last you know 2 000 years um no it hasn't just been worse and worse and worse and
01:03:42 worse and worse uh that that logically does it just not even it's not even possible it's not
01:03:47 possible that every country on the planet has gotten progressively worse for 2 000 years
01:03:52 from first century Rome. That's just, it's not possible. We would all be dead. There'd be no
01:03:58 more humanity. It's just not possible. But it is possible that God has done a mighty work for
01:04:04 centuries, but the devil came into the master's field and along with his good seed, sold bad seed.
01:04:12 And that some of that bad seed, those tares have been growing for 300 years and now they're getting
01:04:17 pretty big. And some of the wheat is getting choked, but the wheat will prevail and the Lord
01:04:24 in His timing will remove those tears. And in the meantime, we seek to be faithful,
01:04:32 whether things turn back around towards the Lord in our generation or our children's or our great,
01:04:37 great grandchildren's. We still want to be faithful to do our part. And a big thing that
01:04:41 we're trying to argue in this episode and many episodes that we do is we just want to be faithful,
01:04:45 but that faithfulness needs to be a faithfulness across the field. It needs to be a full-orbed
01:04:51 faithfulness. It is not just a Sunday morning church faithfulness. It is not just word and
01:04:57 sacrament faithfulness. That may be the church's job, but it is not the Christian's job. The 1.00
01:05:02 Christian is a church man, to be sure, all of us, church member. But then you also have a station
01:05:09 of life that you were in when the Lord called you. And maybe that's politics. Maybe that's
01:05:14 markets, maybe that's education, whatever it might be. But your faithfulness is not just at the local
01:05:21 church level, but all of Christ for all of life. And as we do that, things still might get worse
01:05:26 for a while, but we're bullish in the long run. So none of the things that we've been saying in
01:05:31 this episode, I guess this is my point, none of these things are necessarily a contradiction to
01:05:37 a hopeful eschatology. All right, let's go to a commercial. We'll come back and land the plane.
01:05:42 The danger of centralized power is often represented by the word king.
01:05:47 As Americans, we hate the word king.
01:05:50 Civilian ownership of body armor is about helping people to have increased power to resist tyrants and criminals.
01:05:59 And so Armored Republic is about helping you to preserve your God-given rights to the honor of the Lord Jesus Christ
01:06:05 because he is the king of kings, and he governs kings and he will judge them.
01:06:10 this is armored republic and in a republic there is no king but christ
01:06:16 we are free craftsmen and we are honored to be your armor spread of choice
01:06:22 all right we're aware of a little bit of an irony with that commercial
01:06:41 uh playing right after we say it's possible that we might need a caesar for for a time and uh and
01:06:49 we we agree with david reese yeah 100 100 but i think even david would say yeah but we might um
01:06:55 we have not uh been worthy of this republic and we might lose it yeah a republic if they can keep it
01:07:02 if they can keep it um that's our whole argument is not we don't like republics no i i like
01:07:07 republics um but we're losing ours yep yeah so as we're landing the plane i just have one last
01:07:14 thing i wanted to say and it's right along those lines and uh it is this if you love the american
01:07:20 republican system form of government the constitutional republic that we have had
01:07:25 your goal and your longing and what you hope happens in our nation is that we would be pushed
01:07:36 to become a virtuous people again amen and so if we want to live again where we can have a republic
01:07:42 can have no king but christ our goal is a virtuous people a moral people and sometimes when you lose
01:07:51 the privileges mom and dad ground you right or they spank you or they take away whatever it is
01:07:57 that you were abusing right and for me i think what we're saying is it seems like that's where
01:08:04 we are at our point in history however i want a christian nation more than a republic i want a
01:08:13 christian virtuous nation a people who will honor god with their customs with their laws with their
01:08:20 sense of morality more than i want a sense of freedom under a constitution that cannot um
01:08:26 govern a lawless people amen i'd rather have a christian monarchy than our current state of
01:08:33 affairs and so i looked up just for fun and i just compared it's almost ridiculous to do the taxes
01:08:38 that we pay now compared to what the founding fathers were objecting to i mean it's not it's
01:08:44 like comparing apples and oranges because they didn't have an income tax they didn't have
01:08:47 payroll but but but they were they were rioting and throwing things in the river over two dollars
01:08:54 a two dollar tax in our time on molasses and an eight dollar tax on a pound of tea which that's
01:09:01 a lot of tea a pound of tea and and if you were to ask them okay would you rather have a christian
01:09:06 constitutional monarchy or have what america has now i guarantee you they would have all said we've
01:09:15 got you you've got to get a king back in order you've got to come back you've got to get someone
01:09:19 to shape up those people right now right and so if you love republics if you love the idea of
01:09:26 men being free to pursue the fruit of their labor, then you ought to long and look for
01:09:34 something that will propel our people to become a virtuous people again.
01:09:38 Amen. And God can do that anyway. Again, in terms of the question, what can God do? God can do that
01:09:44 bottom up, gospel preaching, one heart at a time, eventually regenerating. And it's not just enough
01:09:51 to regenerate. Because I am of the persuasion that not that long ago, I think that we have
01:09:56 had numbers on our side of regenerate because yes because people would always say oh well but
01:09:59 that's just because the churches were filled with false converts and they weren't really
01:10:03 there were plenty plenty of that i think two things can be true at once i think we had plenty
01:10:08 of false converts but i think we also still legitimately had um over 50 of the country
01:10:14 in the big scheme of things not that long ago um but with that 50 of the country truly regenerate
01:10:21 not just church attending, but saved, we were not discipling them to think like what we're
01:10:28 trying to advocate for today in categories. 0.97
01:10:32 It was just, it was a lot of pietism. 0.71
01:10:35 It was, you know, it was coming off of World War II, I'm thinking 1950s.
01:10:40 It was a lot of pietism, a lot of nihilism, kind of just, you know, there was a little 0.81
01:10:45 bit of a YOLO mentality coming off of World War I and II, you know, you only live once
01:10:50 And it's just, you know, let's just comfort and freedom and safety for the kids.
01:10:55 Give them a better life than the one that we had.
01:10:57 We've seen the atrocities, you know, of the world.
01:11:00 And here we are.
01:11:01 And we go to church on Sunday.
01:11:02 We put on our Sunday best and we honor the Lord.
01:11:04 And it just kind of stays there.
01:11:05 That's religion.
01:11:06 We do religion.
01:11:07 We do religion.
01:11:08 And I'm not even saying these people weren't saved.
01:11:10 I think we had numbers on our side, but the numbers we had were impotent numbers.
01:11:14 And so my whole point is to say, what can God do?
01:11:18 God can give us the numbers again, and we can have more properly equipped numbers that
01:11:24 are suited to the task to apply all of Christ to all of life, to not just have regenerate
01:11:29 hearts in pews on Sunday with 50% plus one of the country, but then have those same hearts
01:11:35 applying the scripture to markets and economies and politics and the whole nine yards.
01:11:41 God can do that.
01:11:42 What can God do?
01:11:43 But I think it's helpful to also at least consider the question, what does God do?
01:11:49 And in terms of history, both biblically and during the last 2,000 years of this gospel age,
01:11:55 top-down revival is a thing.
01:11:58 It most certainly is a thing.
01:12:00 And I think you can make a fairly strong argument that it's the majority report.
01:12:06 God does that more often than he does just this bottom-up revival.
01:12:10 And if God chooses to do that, and he gives us a Caesar-type individual, and we don't
01:12:17 have the freedoms we've had before because we've abused those freedoms, and our hearts
01:12:20 have turned from the Lord, and all those kinds of things, but God in his sovereignty uses
01:12:24 that guy, and maybe the first Caesar's terrible, but then a new one replaces him, and God gets
01:12:28 a hold of his heart, and he begins to mandate righteousness, just like kings in Israel that
01:12:32 would go back and forth.
01:12:33 And then we have a few generations of that that restores this Western culture and Christendom and people are mature again.
01:12:42 It's like, all right, then David Reese, run that commercial back, an armored republic, no king but Christ, yes and amen.
01:12:50 And all of that, for the record, again, is talking descriptively of what does God do, what has God done, and what might God do in the future.
01:12:59 none of that is saying um so let's form a secret alliance and go and storm the white house and um
01:13:07 and put in a king right yeah so just for the record right wing watch wes you got two thoughts
01:13:13 to close um i don't think it's a coincidence that the civil war um regardless of what you think
01:13:18 about it we lost over 600 000 anglo-saxon protestants good men not all of them not all
01:13:24 of them christians but some of the best robert e lee is probably the best man as far as character
01:13:28 and virtue this country has ever produced we lost so many of those kinds of men it's not a coincidence 0.57
01:13:33 that marxism communism and zionism really begin to rear their heads there at the end of the 19th
01:13:39 century that you lose that there's the destruction of the south during the reconstruction economic
01:13:44 destruction and then you have quickly arrive on the scene those marxism zionism world war one world
01:13:50 war two those things happen very quickly and how would the world be different if we had the
01:13:55 magnitude of millions of more sons and daughters that those men could have produced instead of
01:13:59 fighting the war that we did and consolidating everything under the federal government that i
01:14:04 mean that was really pretty early in our nation i'm reading a book on him and i just good night
01:14:09 each page i go farther and i'm like i don't know man i like like biden's looking kind of villain
01:14:17 status we'll have to do we'll have to do an episode because a couple people outside of the
01:14:21 like in irl as the as the youths say a couple people have said wait a minute abe lincoln so
01:14:26 we might have to tackle that yeah yeah like you know the expression lying lying abe right isn't
01:14:31 that what they called him i think so honestly no yeah abraham lincoln and the the civil war
01:14:37 it was terrible and none of that's to justify slavery but it's just to say that um to end that
01:14:43 um to try to end slavery uh with a war with the blood of our sons and daughters
01:14:49 um half a million of them half a million over yeah 650 000 um to do all that and uh for so
01:14:57 much of it to be uh actually not even just about slavery but um the guise of slavery in many ways
01:15:04 not saying that that wasn't a sincere motive but it was also a sincere motive uh to take away rights
01:15:10 from the states to actually undo that was one of the big first big significant undoings of our
01:15:16 republic that we're talking about this republic has been crumbling for quite some time that's
01:15:21 the point and i but i never thought of it like that west that's insightful to draw out uh not
01:15:26 just the the curse of the civil war i think the civil war was god's judgment um in in many ways
01:15:31 but um not just to draw that out but to say hey maybe it's not a coincidence that you have that
01:15:36 and then you get world war one world war two zionism infiltrating marxism infiltrate yeah we
01:15:43 get all those and and now you know it's like you you watch the news and it's like israel
01:15:51 or it's like sodomites for palestine you know and it's like it's it's literally it's just 0.73
01:15:59 neo-marxist or crazy zionist right um our our elected officials care more about ukraine and
01:16:06 israel than they do us and yeah and all ideas have consequences and they're not just hanging 0.59
01:16:13 and midair there there's a succession there's um yeah there's a line but here's here's the white 0.68
01:16:19 pill when jesus rose from the dead he had 11 cowards in an upper room i mean you get in a bus
01:16:24 crash that's the end of the movie that's the end of it and they conquered the west in a thousand
01:16:28 years they conquered the violent anglo-saxons the vikings they conquered the west not in 5 000 years 0.94
01:16:34 but in less than a thousand years to be western was to be christian yeah so he could do that with 0.97
01:16:39 11 uneducated fishermen that were by and large cowards in the first century underneath the
01:16:46 violent strong rule of a godless uh empire like rome there's not a question with as many millions 0.92
01:16:53 of god-fearing christians as we have that if he so wills he could do it again it wouldn't even be
01:16:58 hard it's white pill wednesday west i know white pill wednesday all right let's leave it there
01:17:02 white pill walmart wednesday all right later
01:17:09 Thank you.