The NXR Podcast - July 24, 2024


THE LIVESTREAM - Rewarding Friends, Crushing Enemies, and the Will to Win

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE INTERVIEW - Abolitionists & Voting For Trump with Ben Garrett THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - Burning Man with Cultish

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 37 minutes

Words per minute

190.72

Word count

18,652

Sentence count

399

Harmful content

Misogyny

21

sentences flagged

Toxicity

10

sentences flagged

Hate speech

55

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Things are changing and quickly. In the last 27 days, we ve witnessed a flurry of assassination attempts, coups, resignations, and encouraging political social and institutional developments such as Elon Musk stating that he is a cultural conservative. Join us today as we discuss the principles that must guide this next stage if we are to have any hope of lasting victory and change.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 things are changing and quickly in the last 27 days since the trump biden debate we have
00:00:09 witnessed a flurry of assassination attempts coups resignations and encouraging political
00:00:16 social and institutional developments such as elon musk stating that he is a cultural christian
00:00:22 momentum seems to clearly be on the side of conservatives who are starting to reclaim power
00:00:28 credibility, and social hegemony that has long been lost. Join us today as we discuss the
00:00:35 principles that must guide this next stage if we are to have any hope of lasting victory and change.
00:00:52 Man, a week just in this single space of time doesn't feel enough to get caught up on
00:00:57 everything that's been going on as you mentioned the opening 27 days since really the roller
00:01:03 coaster kind of went off the tracks it's funny because i feel like a lot of us knew joe biden
00:01:08 was he was close to death yeah we've known that for a couple years yeah so for most of us who
00:01:12 just didn't only watch cnn we were like yeah this is this is how he is he's obviously
00:01:16 shambling along uh but for the rest of the country they got to wake up uh then the deep
00:01:22 state fix was in like well if our guy's not going to make it there can be another guy that just
00:01:26 doesn't have to make it that was the assassination attempt then on sunday i'll be honest i almost bet
00:01:31 michael fifty dollars he wouldn't take me up on it that biden wouldn't be the nominee come uh come
00:01:36 november i thought they're really going to ram him through i thought they were going to make it
00:01:39 happen uh they didn't so now uh really i described it as that in the opening that i wrote it was a
00:01:44 coup it was a very quick attempt because because here was the play if you draw it out and you kind
00:01:49 of make it as though like this this open primary we're transparent it could be this person could
00:01:53 be that person we want to honor the democratic wishes of the convention you're not going to end
00:01:58 up with kamala harris she is in my opinion and i'm an optimist right people like oh i'm not a
00:02:03 pessimist i'm a realist no you're a pessimist i'm an optimist i don't think she's electable
00:02:08 and i don't think in an open primary in the democratic convention in late august that she
00:02:14 would get that and so to to maintain control for it to not to go to someone like rfk jr to go to
00:02:18 someone else the clintons the obamas the bidens don't like uh the move had to be quick they had
00:02:23 to signal complete support do a flurry of fundraising and try to get across to the whole
00:02:28 democratic convention get in line now at the end of the day my opinion i don't know maybe you guys 1.00
00:02:33 would disagree i don't think it's going to work whatsoever uh she is an unlikable individual uh 1.00
00:02:39 she once the two things she's managed really in the the biden administration have been the border
00:02:45 got to tell you that's that's going well i feel like we talk about it rewriting that right now
00:02:50 too oh really they're saying she wasn't actually in charge of any policy she was just in charge of
00:02:54 administrative it's administrating certain key things so the gaslighting on her being the border
00:02:59 czar is already is already going on the fix is in fully underway i feel like we're talking about
00:03:03 the border like every other week here so great job on that and then the thing she picked up and
00:03:07 this is because biden is a catholic and so it's a little tough for him from an optics perspective
00:03:11 not from a conscience perspective is to lead the the fight for abortion rights that's been the
00:03:16 other thing that she's been very visible in thinks in since the repeal of roe v wade so she doesn't
00:03:21 have a great track record i mean already the biden administration track record was bad she herself a
00:03:25 worst track record in it very unlikable actually the most liberal track record most liberal track
00:03:30 record the worst track record um so in god's grace i would say our enemies are in disarray
00:03:35 that's not to say there's not things to fix within the republican caucus uh but but this is good and
00:03:40 i would say even encouraging so i'm encouraged two days ago now elon musk the richest man in
00:03:45 the world. He said, look, the contributions of Christianity to Western society, they're
00:03:50 undeniable. And he said, I am a cultural Christian. Now, there's another step that he needs to take
00:03:55 there, and we pray by God's grace he will. But he also noted that he's going to dedicate his life,
00:04:00 in a sense, to the destruction of, it's a little bit of a corny term, the woke mind virus. He
00:04:05 talked about his son, how his son thought that he was a girl and needed puberty blockers, which,
00:04:10 for the record, puberty blockers, that term, these are the drugs that are used to castrate men in
00:04:14 prison and then he talked about that sterilization drugs exactly so these would be the drugs not to
00:04:20 just pause puberty but to sterilize an individual uh so his son he says my son is dead he was killed
00:04:26 by wokeness and says that he's dedicating his life to that uh so many other i think just encouraging
00:04:31 uh political cultural uh sociological changes that have happening tucker carlson's a calvinist now
00:04:37 apparently tucker carlson's a calvinist and and ascendant to the trump inner circle i think it
00:04:41 was it tim scott at the rnc it was jd vance trump tucker and uh and tim scott so this is awesome
00:04:48 it's great to see guys on the show to talk about the problems with scofield and now to be fair
00:04:54 the guy on his show is uh is a dispensationalist he doesn't know it but he is uh the only difference
00:05:00 is that he's post-trip that's it he's a pre-mill dispensational post-trip which is so funny but
00:05:07 i'll take it you know i was about to say we'll take the if dispensationalism you know if
00:05:11 dispensationalists want to self-own i'm here for it i'll watch that you know 2.2 million views yeah
00:05:17 so you've got you've got that you've got thomas massey coming out you know and and admitting uh
00:05:23 right before his wife dies you know that there's an apac uh handler for every single person who's
00:05:29 in american government every single person in the gop except for him um all these things coming out
00:05:33 And one of the things that's important for people to realize is the reason why we know about these things is because of alternative media.
00:05:39 It's because Tucker Carlson left Fox.
00:05:43 If he was still with Fox, he'd be pushing the line as far as it goes, as far as he could. 0.65
00:05:47 But he would not be having Thomas Massey on Fox News to say, yes, the U.S. government is in a stranglehold from Israel. 0.55
00:05:55 That show doesn't air on Fox.
00:05:58 now right um also not just so you've got tucker uh you know carlson you know uh network um
00:06:04 alternative media uh you also have just uh twitter so many things think about this people always
00:06:09 talk about the conspiracy of the jfk you know assassination and i think there's a ton of funny
00:06:14 business there i do think there is a conspiracy um but here's uh one of the primary differences
00:06:20 that you people still don't realize um i think we get to the bottom of this one and you know why
00:06:26 because of elon musk and twitter yep right that is the singular reason why is because uh they cannot
00:06:32 uh simply gloss over it they cannot uh gaslight they can't memory hole they can't like they
00:06:39 actually have to give an account and um the public will see it yeah the public will see
00:06:46 what actually happened and that's because elon musk bought twitter um and and so there's so many
00:06:52 things that, it's not just that like, well, we should be grateful for the providence of God,
00:06:58 that being malcontents, being ingrates is actually a sin that God detests. There's all those 1.00
00:07:05 theological reasons and moral reasons. That's absolutely true. But also, if you're blackpilling
00:07:10 right now, it's not just that it's immoral and it's not just that you're being an ingrate and
00:07:14 you're actually not trusting in God's providence and obeying the scripture, but also you just,
00:07:19 you are it's it's almost like publicly advertising to the world that you have an 85 iq
00:07:25 if you are blackpilling right now it's not just that you're making an immoral choice and it is
00:07:31 immoral you are in sin number two not only are you morally sinning um you you you are publicly 0.76
00:07:40 telling everyone that you're unintelligent you are not an intelligent person because here's the
00:07:44 here's the great thing about purity spiraling um purity spiraling doesn't take careful thought
00:07:50 yeah it doesn't um purity spiraling is exactly it's likened to a pit bull with a bone right
00:07:56 right you don't so you don't have to be a genius you don't have to be a savant all you have to do
00:08:01 is have just raw instinct so it's just i want the bone i'll grab the bone and anything and everything
00:08:06 that gets in my way i'm i'm just not gonna let it happen you know the pit bulls you can't reason
00:08:13 with a pit bull right and by the way under project 2025 all pit bulls will be put to death you know
00:08:18 so but you know but that being said you know you can't reason so so somebody could come and try to
00:08:22 and pit bulls are sometimes helpful right and in real life they're not in this analogy they are
00:08:27 in real life again c c point a put them all to death but in in you know in this analogy there
00:08:32 are times where it's like okay like there's the proverbial bone and it needs to be guarded at all
00:08:36 cost right so release the hounds you know release the crack and the pit bull and let it get its
00:08:42 it's jaws on that bone and never let go that's great um but here's where a pit bull is not
00:08:48 helpful um any scenario no matter how positive it could possibly be the pit bull will not be
00:08:54 reasoned with so somebody could walk in and say uh pit bull please put down the bone if you put
00:08:58 down the bone i'll give you this nice steak the pit bull won't do it right it won't it can't be
00:09:02 reasoned with it can't because it doesn't have cognitive thought right it's just raw instinct
00:09:08 And so purity spiralists are helpful in the sense that, you know, there's different pieces
00:09:13 on the board.
00:09:13 You got rooks, you got bishops, you got pawns, you got all these things, and I'm grateful
00:09:17 for the whole lay of the land.
00:09:18 I'm grateful for the whole board.
00:09:20 And on this board, you've got the proverbial pit bull.
00:09:22 And he grabs a bone, and that is his role.
00:09:27 That's his role.
00:09:29 Now, when Trump gets elected, and I think it's a when, not an if, and huge things start
00:09:34 happening in terms of not trump being this amazing christian prince but in terms of the regime being
00:09:40 toppled that puts forward opportunities for things like christian nationalism to rise as a phoenix
00:09:46 from the ashes when those things happen um you don't think the pit bull because he he had no
00:09:52 hand in making it happen um he was just holding his bone and growling um that's what he does um
00:09:58 but that still has a purpose um there's still all these things so my point is this don't black pill
00:10:05 so elon and this these are the kinds of things you'll hear um i i appreciate you know andrew
00:10:10 torba um i i was you know andrew torba has been nothing but positive for the last two weeks and
00:10:16 andrew torba typically his mo is more of a black pill right yeah you know andrew torba would be
00:10:22 the kind of guy who would you know who would post you know um a meme you know that says like uh the
00:10:27 outcome of the 2024 election it's a picture of bibi you know uh netanyahu from israel you know
00:10:33 going like this like ah you know and then it shows the map of the u.s and they're all you know the
00:10:37 color of israel flag you know like he swept the nation all you know 400 something electoral votes
00:10:43 um that's your typical andrew torba post uh but you know you got to give him props the last two
00:10:49 weeks it's been it's been the exact opposite he's been um he's been propping up elon musk and and
00:10:55 giving him uh some due thanks and uh he's been um he's been encouraging people uh to to to take
00:11:03 heart that uh trump wasn't assassinated uh to rightly view trump's vp pick which is huge that
00:11:10 is a a huge white pill um if trump here's the thing if trump is controlled opposition in the
00:11:16 deep state i know that's cute and if you want to be cute that's fine you can have that take
00:11:19 but if that's what he is then um then nikki haley is your vp tim scott is your vp chrissy no is your
00:11:26 vp um the one guy you would not pick right out of and here's the thing it was like well he should
00:11:32 have picked dusty deevers no i'm talking about go back pitbull grab the bone okay but for everyone
00:11:37 else logical thought the one guy um within politics which is the realm of the possible so hang hang
00:11:44 with me here guys um put on the big boy pants but within the realm of the possible is what i'm
00:11:48 talking about the real world not never ever land uh the one guy that you want to pick who among
00:11:53 real options real choices is jd vance that pick is number one is an insurance plan uh because if
00:12:01 he picked anybody else right then he basically just signed the warrant for his uh his assassination
00:12:05 the one that actually works right the one that is successful um but now it's a little bit less
00:12:11 appealing to assassinate donald trump because you get vance who is trump but with more years of life
00:12:17 and uh didn't his background his story arc is uh it's not the uh right not the billionaire it's 0.99
00:12:24 not your bruce wayne you know uh you know silver spoon story arc it's your uh trailer park trash
00:12:29 rise hillbilly elegy and it's right it's enjoyable i recommend reading it it's a good story right and
00:12:34 i'm going to crush everything that has despised yeah people like me right you know so i mean it's
00:12:40 beautiful so there's so many things elon coming out saying i i made it my life's mission to crush
00:12:45 the woke mind virus the fact that he bought twitter um the fact that free speech there
00:12:51 actually is a place for free speech and i understand that like well what about rumble
00:12:54 why aren't you guys on rumble uh we're not on rumble for the same reason uh that nobody else
00:12:58 is on rumble right you know like um we we're on youtube and doing our best on youtube and it's
00:13:04 like well that's because you guys are sold out and compromised and that's the only reason that
00:13:07 no we're um most of the guys i'm just going to shoot you straight this one's going to hurt uh
00:13:11 some of my close friends, I won't name them, but do you know why your favorite based podcaster
00:13:17 gets kicked off of YouTube? Because he doesn't know how to read. That's why. It's because they
00:13:23 click monetization. Let me just be honest with you for a second. They monetize every single video
00:13:28 and YouTube has very clear print. The reason we have not been kicked off of YouTube yet,
00:13:33 we might be one day, but so far we have not been kicked off of YouTube because we're compromised.
00:13:38 nope uh we were speaking out against the vax we were speaking out against masks we've been
00:13:42 speaking out against uh uh we've we've done whole episodes against israel we've done like we have
00:13:47 done plenty of things we went hard pride month we went hard sharing all the statistics talking
00:13:51 we talked about um aids we talked about you know uh you know all these different things
00:13:56 um the reason why we're not kicked off of youtube is one reason um because we're not greedy
00:14:02 that's it uh and what do i mean by that i mean uh when i talk about things that nancy pelosi
00:14:08 doesn't uh won't care about like bigfoot and nephilim we click monetization
00:14:13 because uh the regime does not care about bigfoot because bigfoot's not a threat 0.72
00:14:20 now under project 2025 we will domesticate bigfoot in oklahoma dusty deevers will be
00:14:27 the bigfoot captain and we will storm all of the left regime now but you know in the real world
00:14:33 uh bigfoot is not a threat and it's that's that's not going to get you canceled off of youtube
00:14:39 talking about nephilim talking about you know mermaids and those kinds of so when we talk about
00:14:43 those things and get 50 000 views because sadly that just shows you right there the state of the
00:14:48 country we get 10 times as many views about mermaids than we do about um things that matter
00:14:53 immensely um but you know what the mermaid conversation is interesting and uh here's here's
00:14:59 a little known fact um as a christian and even as a pastor i am not mandated to talk 24 7 about uh
00:15:08 politics culture and theology right i'm allowed to talk about mermaids i'm actually allowed to do
00:15:12 that did you know that the bible actually allows me to talk about atlantis and those things so i
00:15:16 do talk about it knowing it'll get 10 times a viewership and that's where we click youtube
00:15:21 commercials on uh episode like this we click off and one of the reasons why is because nathan i'll
00:15:28 boast on with him for a second not myself because it wasn't me nathan our tech director knows how
00:15:34 to read and so what nathan did was he read youtube's policy youtube if you click yes on their
00:15:41 monetization over 85 percent of the companies that advertise with youtube have specifically said we
00:15:47 want zero association because they're all blue they're all left-leaning right we want zero
00:15:52 association with guns zero association with uh with abortion zero association with like any of
00:15:59 these things that you say and um and we as an advertiser we are going to drop youtube as a
00:16:07 platform where we advertise now what does youtube not want to lose money their advertisers so then
00:16:11 what youtube will do because they want to keep their advertisers is they will get rid of their
00:16:16 content creators who are who are ticking off the advertisers because they're talking about the
00:16:21 things that these companies these blue left-leaning companies don't want to be associated with
00:16:25 so um if you're like you know people like pearly things you know like pearl davis is not a christian
00:16:32 you know but you know but says some conservative talking points and sometimes is insufferable and 0.96
00:16:36 sometimes you know is right and and blah blah blah but pearly things i got nothing against her
00:16:40 i got nothing really for her but she she's out there she's doing her thing okay um well she's
00:16:45 you know constantly talking about i was kicked off of youtube again or i was kicked off of this
00:16:48 or i got another strike or we got demonetized right there hone in that's the key demonetized
00:16:53 right because she's clicking monetize on on every single video clip anything everything always um
00:17:03 and what we do is we've made a calculated decision at the very beginning of the year when we present
00:17:09 our budget to the board at the end of the year and all these things uh we make a calculated decision
00:17:13 that we're probably only going to monetize
00:17:15 about a third of our content on YouTube.
00:17:18 Why?
00:17:19 Because we're not greedy and we know how to read.
00:17:22 And we want to win.
00:17:23 And we want to win.
00:17:24 So we're going to talk about the things
00:17:25 that need to be talked about
00:17:26 that YouTube advertisers won't like
00:17:28 that would get us canceled off of YouTube.
00:17:30 And we're going to talk about them for free.
00:17:31 We're going to talk about them without getting revenue.
00:17:34 And then we will get YouTube revenue
00:17:36 from 10 times the revenue
00:17:38 in terms of number of viewers
00:17:40 because we'll come and talk about something
00:17:42 that nancy pelosi and the bidens and the obamas and all the regime don't fear at all aka mermaids
00:17:47 and i know you watcher viewer um i know that i'll get 10 times um your views when i talk about
00:17:54 mermaids that don't really matter and so i'll get youtube's money because you will come and watch
00:18:00 my mermaid video and then for the real patriots for the real maybe well the real christians please
00:18:06 stand up that's you guys who are watching right now who watch the wednesday live stream yeah um
00:18:11 we get you know there's only a tenth of you it's it's only a tenth the amount of views so why not
00:18:16 forfeit the ad revenue anyways because we're only going to get 5 000 views instead of 50 000 so it's
00:18:21 not going to be that much money so we turn it off because we know how to read and uh and then we're
00:18:26 able to stay on youtube so all that being said the point was elon musk twitter that's a real
00:18:31 platform that's a big deal that is a big and now you see remember how people were losing their
00:18:37 minds when he was going to when he tried to when he tried to buy it people were losing their minds
00:18:41 do you know why because they wanted to kill trump and they wanted to get away with it it's all these
00:18:48 things that people the regime had in the back of their mind they're like why was it such a big deal
00:18:53 if if a private entrepreneur right businessman wants to own a business oh i'll tell you why it's
00:19:00 a big deal because there has not been free speech in this country with any major legacy media
00:19:06 organization for decades for decades and that's how you can assassinate kennedy and have the
00:19:12 government involved and get away with it that's how you can rig an election in 2020 and get away
00:19:19 with it that's how you can uh force the entire country all of your citizens into their homes
00:19:25 and and and getting foreign substances jabbed into their arms and wearing masks for a year and a half 0.66
00:19:32 and get away with it but you know what you can't get away with it anymore if people are allowed
00:19:36 to speak freely like what what has pushed also all the white pills in the introduction everything
00:19:41 that you laid out west all these white pills what has been the domino effect what where are we seeing
00:19:46 all these white pills where oh all of a sudden the head of the secret service uh i'm not going
00:19:51 to resign week later she's gone yep you're gone uh why what uh oh uh it might be an inside job
00:19:58 there might be a second shooter oh that the slope through thing like um all these things um oh you
00:20:03 You know, Trump, you know, picking Vance as his VP or all the statistics coming out about 0.72
00:20:12 the transgender madness, you know, or all the truth coming out about the vax. 0.99
00:20:17 Where is that happening? 0.99
00:20:19 It's happening on X.
00:20:21 That's where it's happening. 0.64
00:20:22 So, well, but Elon Musk is a cultural Christian, and if he doesn't repent of his sins and 0.97
00:20:27 believe upon the Lord Jesus Christ, he's going to die and go to hell. 0.99
00:20:30 No doubt. 0.90
00:20:31 Who's arguing with that?
00:20:32 right who's arguing what we're saying is that an unregenerate man as far as we know who is for the
00:20:38 record low-hanging fruit you want to talk about fields that are white for the harvest it's 0.66
00:20:43 conservatives it's on the right it's not on the left right right they want to kill you but people
00:20:48 on the right um so if you actually care about evangelism and all these kind of here's a crazy
00:20:53 thing uh you could do what andrew isker's doing you know people giving him a hard time for leaving
00:20:57 minnesota as though there's no lost people in tennessee right gave me a hard time you abandoned
00:21:02 the mission like there's no lost people in texas no there's lost people there's lost people in
00:21:07 texas and tennessee just like there are in california and in minnesota here's the difference
00:21:11 um in texas and tennessee some of them get saved
00:21:14 the the left that's the difference about it before there's something about when you just
00:21:21 take a man or you take a woman you just strip them of their purpose they're almost harder to
00:21:25 evangelize i think of uh defending boyhood i forget the author but uh catholic guy but he
00:21:30 notes just a catholic or he notes uh anthony what's his name nathan anthony esalen he notes
00:21:37 that a cowboy who came to christ that the first had to be nature for grace to restore a man has
00:21:41 to know his purpose a woman has to know her purpose and then they understand i need grace
00:21:45 to complete this purpose you take an atrophied video gamer and you tell them that that here's
00:21:49 what a man should be and here's responsibility and here's initiative why would i need to do that
00:21:53 that's what california is full of and uh the fields are ripe for the harvest yeah on the right
00:21:58 so white pills all over the place uh trump can be dead and uh his enemies are your enemies
00:22:06 that's the thing that you have to understand the friend enemy distinction it is a serious
00:22:10 it's it is a good distinction in the realm of politics right it absolutely is um so the same
00:22:16 people that hate you and your way of life your wife and your children are the same people that
00:22:21 hate trump the same people who were lamenting publicly out loud lamenting the fact that the 0.94
00:22:27 assassination attempt failed right so uh the same people who want you dead also want him dead and
00:22:33 they were not successful white pill um trump had a ton of rhinos and regime players to choose from
00:22:41 and picked the one guy who has been to the wall he's wore the tiny hat uh he has retracted uh some
00:22:49 of the stalwart strong position he's had on abortion he's walked some of that back and
00:22:53 compromise all those things are true um but within the realm of possible not peter pan but the realm
00:22:58 of possible which is what politics is not the realm of the perfect but the possible he was the
00:23:03 best pick bar none absolutely and trump picked him so one trump survives two he picks jd vance
00:23:10 uh three uh elon musk uh declares that he's going to uh his his goal in life is to destroy the woke
00:23:18 mind virus right elon musk is allowing porn on twitter terrible right terrible uh-huh but there
00:23:26 is one major platform that people actually go to that has free speech right uh also porn bots 0.96
00:23:32 yeah that sucks right and we need to pray that god would change elon's heart and we need to pray
00:23:37 that maybe uh we might have some more conservative businesses in the future that aren't embarrassed
00:23:42 to advertise on a free speech platform so that uh elon doesn't have to make twitter profitable
00:23:47 from porn right that's part of the problem um the porn bots are there because all the advertisers
00:23:53 got out because all the companies are blue right um so and if we got a little bit more spying with
00:23:59 some of these companies that are conservative and they stopped being private secret conservatives
00:24:03 closet conservatives and actually said you know what we're not embarrassed to give our advertisement
00:24:07 uh money and our budget uh for this this annual calendar to elon musk and to advertise exclusively
00:24:14 on twitter if some conservative companies came out and did that uh i guarantee you you'll see
00:24:18 uh some of the porn bots start to disappear so uh all these things so jd vance kissing the wall
00:24:23 jd vance uh retracting some of his his position on um on on you know pro-life and and elon musk
00:24:30 the fact that he's a cultural christian and yes he as far as we can tell he's not born again he's
00:24:33 not regenerate and there's porn on twitter um all all these things um if if if your headline is um
00:24:43 Israel wins no matter what, and all Americans are Zionist, and there's no hope, then just do us a favor and get off of social media and just spend a touch grass, spend time with your wife and kids, and you can come back out after November.
00:25:00 Joel, there's another reason why people might be blackpilling, and that is because they have the wrong definition of winning. 0.63
00:25:06 And for the record, the topic today is winning, which is a weird word to evangelical Christians.
00:25:12 That's true.
00:25:12 sounds dirty i've coached i've coached a couple elementary soccer teams and i can think of a few
00:25:17 where winning was not a common occurrence on our team and when i would start talking about winning
00:25:22 it was like what is this word that that coach is talking about right nevertheless we're talking
00:25:27 about winning and one of the reasons why people blackbill is their definition of winning is wrong
00:25:31 and as i was researching some for today's um discussion uh i was i was listening to a guy who
00:25:37 was talking about modern critiques of liberalism and he said that one of the promises that
00:25:42 liberalism makes is that under classical liberalism there will no longer need be a need
00:25:48 for friend enemy distinction in other words liberalism is going to flatten the playing
00:25:53 field between all people and all nations such that we are all so similar in our utopian vision
00:26:00 that there is no friend there's no enemy there's just the comrade or the npc next to you right and
00:26:08 so one of the things that we are saying is winning is that trump forms coalitions that call people
00:26:16 enemies in fact i think looking back at 2016 that's probably the biggest reason he lost is he
00:26:23 was willing to gather people himself and say y'all are my friends they are the enemy right and so
00:26:30 many americans evangelical christian americans don't have the stomach for this is a good group
00:26:37 that's a bad group over there we've talked about that that you know evangelicals keep praying that
00:26:42 god would give us hearts for revival we need that but we also need stomachs yeah for revival and so
00:26:47 part of winning is we have to have an enemy that we're winning over and we have to be doing better
00:26:53 being more strategic having more power having more influence than than our enemy is and what
00:26:58 we're saying is there's a point in a sports game a football game something like that where the tide
00:27:04 shifts and we're saying we think we are on the edge of a tide shifting where the the one team
00:27:10 has been beating up on us and it seems like the tide is shifting and we are starting to see what
00:27:17 winning might actually look like amen and that doesn't um winning doesn't mean that everything
00:27:23 game has been one that's right um but but what it does is it uh winning one game lets you play
00:27:29 another yep it lets you you know winning on one day lets you see the next day yep it gives you
00:27:35 an opportunity to uh to regroup to re-strategize to restructure and uh and then and then to win
00:27:42 more yep and to win more and to win more and to win more so um i don't i don't know what's
00:27:46 going to happen uh trump has um he's campaigning um a good deal to the left of uh where he was in
00:27:54 2016 that's true uh there's no denying that however let's just remember and i don't have
00:28:00 a crystal ball i'm not predicting this but let's just remember that uh trump campaigned uh far to
00:28:07 the left from how he governed even in his first term right um he did and this is crazy especially
00:28:13 for evangelicals i know this is crazy uh but did you know that politicians sometimes lie
00:28:19 don't believe it it's crazy i know um but did you know that sometimes politicians will say something
00:28:28 because they'll have their fingers on the pulse of the base and they'll actually know i i'll say
00:28:34 this uh donald trump has a a much better and jd vance for that matter they have a much better
00:28:40 understanding of where america is currently at than evangelicals do yeah that is 100 right they
00:28:47 have a much better finger on the pulse of and you know why they're not running a pro-life
00:28:51 campaign right now because america is not pro-life yes uh conservatives in america are not pro-life
00:28:59 they are not running that campaign because that campaign won't win and that's a tragedy yep it's
00:29:03 an absolute tragedy but that is the state of affairs and so my prayer is that they win
00:29:08 and then they begin to govern far to the right of how they campaigned and that that begins to set
00:29:15 the stage for new judges like he did last time right new laws new legislation and then the law
00:29:21 of god in a biblical fashion would function in its second use or a third use as a tutor
00:29:25 that better judges produce better laws and that better laws over time it doesn't happen
00:29:32 overnight but over time began to shape the populace tutor the people in the same way that 0.54
00:29:38 a burger fell as a law it tutored uh the people and said oh gay marriage uh actually isn't bad
00:29:45 yep right so it was both and it was cultures getting more progressive that gave you a progressive
00:29:50 law a burger fell but then once you got the uh progressive law a burger fell that began to shape
00:29:56 the moral consciences of people even more to thinking gay marriage is fine yeah and so what
00:30:01 we want to see is the reverse of that. That's what we saw with kings of Israel. We would see 0.91
00:30:05 good king comes in. He doesn't come in through an electoral vote. He doesn't come in through
00:30:10 our sacred democracy. He comes in by the right of kings through noble birth, and God gets a hold of
00:30:18 his heart from a young age, someone like Josiah, and he comes in and he says, people, what do you
00:30:22 want? Nope. He comes in and he says, the high places are coming down. And there's weeping,
00:30:28 right the the suburban moms are weeping uh over josiah's intolerance how could he how could he
00:30:35 and josiah says don't care you know and he tears them down by law by fiat as king and then over
00:30:42 time the hearts of the people follow and the people become righteous because the people follow
00:30:48 the king people follow leaders donald trump like it or not right this i mean i think this is much
00:30:54 indictment and judgment as it is mercy and i think it's both i think there's a hand there's a white
00:30:59 pill the black pill they're they're both there together but it is god's mercy and it's also an
00:31:04 indictment on our nation but donald trump is the leader of these united states of america he's not
00:31:09 currently the president but he is the leader people don't follow titles they follow leaders
00:31:14 they follow courage he is the leader and he's a leader for a reason he accurately reflects where
00:31:20 i think the nation is at yeah that's where the nation is at um which means um further right than
00:31:26 donald trump is what we want but further right than donald trump is not where we are right not
00:31:31 today but getting donald trump is a step and getting further right of him and part of that
00:31:37 may come through trump himself governing to the right of how he campaigns because crazy i know
00:31:42 politicians lie uh but then also uh that sets the stage for what comes after trump right yeah and
00:31:49 And for better or worse, the GOP is Trump's party and will be until one of two things happen.
00:31:55 He gets a second term or he dies.
00:31:57 That's just the way it is.
00:31:58 So you've got to get through a second term of Donald Trump before we can do anything else.
00:32:03 And I see that as a blessing.
00:32:05 It's not everything I want, but I think it's most of what I want within the realm of the possible.
00:32:12 All right, let's go to a commercial break and then we'll come back.
00:32:14 right response ministries 2025 conference is a go this is three days full jam-packed conference
00:32:26 with eight main sessions three to four hour and a half long panels and an all-star super based
00:32:32 lineup of speakers 15 speakers in all who are they steve dace jeff durbin oran mcintyre steven
00:32:40 Wolf, Brian Sauve, Andrew Isker, John Harris, Eric Kahn, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, the Christian
00:32:47 Prince himself, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, David Reese, and yours truly, Pastor Joel Webin. Again,
00:32:54 this is April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, 2025, and the early registration is open right now. This is
00:33:02 the longest conference with the most speakers we've ever offered, and yet it is our all-time
00:33:08 lowest price. The early registration available today is only 140 bucks for an adult. So go to
00:33:15 rightresponseconference.com. Again, that is rightresponseconference.com to register right now
00:33:23 because the early registration will not last long. Are you a Christian struggling to find
00:33:29 companies that align with your values and beliefs? Well, then Squirrely Joe's has you covered for all 0.99
00:33:34 your coffee needs. All of their coffee is hand-selected and roasted fresh every day by a
00:33:40 family of fellow believers. Try them out and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing
00:33:45 that your investment supports a company committed to following God's teachings and upholding truth
00:33:51 and righteousness, ensuring that your hard-earned money contributes to the growth of God's kingdom.
00:33:58 Stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans who support evil. Right Response listeners have
00:34:03 access to an exclusive deal. Your first bag of coffee is free. All you have to do is cover the
00:34:10 shipping. So head on over to squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response. Again, that's
00:34:16 squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response to claim your first free bag of coffee today. 0.81
00:34:24 Visit the word soap.com today. Again, that's the word soap.com. Everyone needs soap. So wash
00:34:32 yourself in the word all right well welcome back uh we're gonna go ahead and talk about enemies
00:34:41 just real quick though if you're enjoying this video helps us out give it a thumbs up boost the
00:34:46 algorithm gets it out to people give a thumbs up uh if you're enjoying it i forget we did it last
00:34:50 week we said guys we just want to experiment we've never asked people to smash the like button
00:34:54 every youtuber does it we've never done it it seems insufferable but we caved we did it we said
00:34:59 please do it and we got like double abuse it helps that's awesome yeah yeah because i'll watch
00:35:02 a video like this and i'll i'll just be watching it enjoying it i don't think about thumbs up so
00:35:06 so do that if you're you're appreciating this joel well first of all eschatology so someone
00:35:11 could be watching this they're pre-mill they're all mill uh and they say you guys you're excited
00:35:15 you're seeing these white pills because you must think that the golden christian age is just about
00:35:19 15 minutes away so your eschatology is informing all this and we just want to say for the record
00:35:24 pre-mill, ah-mill, post-mill, there can be reason to be excited. So maybe you're pre-mill,
00:35:28 you think that the end of history leads towards an increasing apostasy. There are still high 0.67
00:35:34 places, high highlights along the way. Christendom 1.0 was great. And if you're pre-mill, you have
00:35:40 to acknowledge, yeah, America was 98% Christian. Europe was to be, Europe was to be Christian. So 0.72
00:35:46 even the pre-mill that thinks towards the end of history, that things go downhill, there's a great
00:35:50 apostasy, the enemies grow and grow, you can still recognize that there can be highlights.
00:35:55 So maybe you're pre-milt, you can still be excited in this moment. Same thing for amil,
00:35:58 there's not necessarily a high or a low to it. You can be excited, and by God's grace,
00:36:02 that things are improving for you, but also for your posterity. And if you're post-milt,
00:36:07 it's my caution that there's going to be dips along the way, that it's going to take time for
00:36:12 the gospel to saturate, to get into the soil, to cover the earth with the knowledge of God.
00:36:17 So we're optimistic.
00:36:19 We're fighting hard in our current moment.
00:36:21 Doesn't mean long-term that America does last.
00:36:24 We don't know this land, this United States, who will ultimately occupy it when Jesus returns.
00:36:30 But still, Christ is king.
00:36:32 He's ruling and reigning.
00:36:34 Psalm 110.1 is the most quoted verse in the Old Testament, in the New Testament, from the Old.
00:36:39 Jesus will reign.
00:36:41 My Lord said unto my Lord, sit in my right hand till I make all your enemies a footstool for your feet.
00:36:45 Christ is putting his enemies under his footstool.
00:36:48 We all know Jesus wins in the end, but whether the church in this age win, lose, or draw,
00:36:53 I'm excited that what God is doing.
00:36:56 I love the optimism.
00:36:57 I think it's the second 300 movie where they're about to attack. 0.98
00:37:00 I think it's, is it the Greeks, the Persians?
00:37:03 And he says, they outnumber us a paltry three to one. 0.76
00:37:05 So they're about to go charge them.
00:37:07 He's like, guys, we have got them on the ropes.
00:37:09 They only outnumber us three to one.
00:37:11 So that's the type of energy we're trying to bring.
00:37:13 All right.
00:37:15 so we were in ogden about a month ago at least me and you were uh gave an excellent talk if you
00:37:19 guys haven't heard it yet go to new christendom press it's on youtube you talked about righteous
00:37:22 balkanization i think it was more controversial than wolves i believe it or not they were so
00:37:27 such different talks his was academic yours was rousing they were both really good never going
00:37:31 to be academic because it's me well i was being nice about it yeah i appreciate it uh so very
00:37:36 briefly in that talk though you mentioned you said uh i want to i maybe give the i'm trying to
00:37:41 think of the broader context but you essentially said i want to win i want to win conservatives
00:37:46 christians uh we need to stop seeing power as icky it's not inherently evil nor is it inherently good
00:37:52 um it is uh power is inevitable right it's a uh and the whole illustration you know or analogy of
00:37:58 you know uh lord of the rings you know frodo destroying the ring um is terrible uh when it
00:38:03 comes to uh power uh when it comes to power in this world especially political power or cultural
00:38:09 power because um it's not whether but which um so the idea of like you know conservatives that
00:38:15 you know classical liberals the insufferable incessant trope of like well what if the the
00:38:20 tables were returned if we did that and they would set a precedence you know that one day
00:38:25 when our enemies when when those who disagreed with us when they came into office they might
00:38:29 do the same thing to us shut up shut up are you are you serious uh we're not talking about the
00:38:35 one ring that needs to be destroyed in mordor and they're going to do that anyway they're going to 0.97
00:38:40 do it anyway we're not talking about the one ring that actually that there's actually the fires of
00:38:44 that can destroy it no the ring in this case the ring that we're talking about is uh romans 13
00:38:51 the civil magistrate it is a ring that has been instituted by the god of heaven and it will exist
00:38:59 like it or not, until Christ returns. So, cast it back into the fires from whence it came
00:39:08 is not a feasible option. That's not on the table. We're talking about the government,
00:39:14 civil magistrates, civil government, which is instituted not by man, but by God,
00:39:19 and by God's design, bears swords. It has the sword. It has power. So, it's not whether we
00:39:27 have power uh but which direction will power be wielded but who will wield it and in which direction
00:39:32 will they wield it so power is inevitable and so i was saying conservatives and christians are you
00:39:37 know constant that power is icky and you know the way of the cross jesus you know he laid down his
00:39:42 life yeah he laid down his life because it was it was predestined before the foundations of the
00:39:47 world were laid that he would die as the lamb of god but here's the thing he's not dead anymore he
00:39:52 didn't stay dead he died so that he might raise again and then ascend in power and authority to
00:39:57 the right hand of god the father and he said the last thing he said before ascending to god's right
00:40:02 hand he said all authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me you now the church as my hands
00:40:09 and feet the body of christ on earth you have been vested with my authority to carry out and push for
00:40:16 the crown rights of jesus over every single square inch so i was talking about that and in all of that
00:40:21 I said, we need to win.
00:40:24 We need to wield power righteously.
00:40:26 The Christian mantra as it comes to power is not to forsake power, but to rule righteously.
00:40:35 It's not to forsake rule, but to rule righteously.
00:40:39 And so in that, I said, I want to win.
00:40:41 I want Christians to have power. 0.98
00:40:43 And with that power, I want it to be wielded righteously. 0.99
00:40:47 What does that mean?
00:40:48 It means crushing our enemies and rewarding our friends.
00:40:52 And to be clear to Steel Man, you said, I want to crush my enemies and I want to reward my friends.
00:40:57 Now, just think about it for a moment. 0.90
00:40:59 So if you're trying to give the benefit of the doubt, who the Christian's enemies, they're being conformed to the image of Christ.
00:41:04 Who are the Christian's enemies? 0.72
00:41:06 The enemies of Jesus.
00:41:08 That's right.
00:41:08 So you're speaking, you're saying, I want to reward friends, family, community, church.
00:41:13 I want to bless them.
00:41:15 I want them to be rewarded.
00:41:16 I want them to hold positions of power to be established, and then the enemies, not your personal enemy who didn't cut your grass or got their grass clippings on your lawn, the enemies of God, the wicked.
00:41:27 I mean, how many psalms?
00:41:28 Psalm 37, I think Psalm 137 as well.
00:41:31 Do I not hate them with a perfect hatred?
00:41:33 Perfect hatred.
00:41:34 There is a category of, and this would be the distinction between a private enemy and a public enemy.
00:41:39 Right.
00:41:39 There is the public enemy that is not in view.
00:41:42 Literally in, so in the Greek and in the Latin, there are two different words for private
00:41:46 enemy and public enemy.
00:41:47 The word for private enemy is inimicus and the public enemy is hostess.
00:41:52 So you said...
00:41:52 Like hostility.
00:41:54 Exactly.
00:41:54 Like a foe, I think would be another way.
00:41:56 The King James translated it.
00:41:58 So you said, I want to punish my enemies and I want to reward my friends.
00:42:01 And people said, well, Jesus said, love your enemies.
00:42:05 Now, specifically in view there is not...
00:42:09 This is not New Testament Christianity.
00:42:11 As if there's a distinction between Old Testament and New Testament.
00:42:14 But you know what? God bless him.
00:42:14 I bet he got so many boomer donations by that virtue tweet.
00:42:19 And that's it.
00:42:20 But Owen Strand, he seriously is going to have to have, 1.00
00:42:23 he's going to have to get a job in 10 years when there's no more boomers. 1.00
00:42:27 When they all die. 1.00
00:42:27 I know.
00:42:28 You know what I mean?
00:42:29 I'm sure the Dobson Center has a lot of funding.
00:42:31 Yeah, that's true.
00:42:33 Go ahead.
00:42:34 Anyhow, so as Jesus says, he says, love your enemies.
00:42:36 And that is in there.
00:42:37 Love your enemies.
00:42:37 Pray for those who use you. 1.00
00:42:39 Those are absolutely true, and they're absolutely binding on the Christian.
00:42:42 Those are the words of the Lord Jesus Christ.
00:42:44 The question is, what enemy?
00:42:46 I'm going to read this.
00:42:46 This is from Thomas Aquinas, so mid-century scholar, mid-century Catholic scholar.
00:42:51 So he says of the term immicus, this is the private enemy.
00:42:54 It is lawful to attack one's enemies that they may be restrained from sin.
00:42:59 And this is for their own good and the good of others.
00:43:01 Consequently, it is even lawful in praying to ask that temporal evils be inflicted on
00:43:05 our enemies in order that they may mend their ways. Carl Schmitt, he says something interesting.
00:43:10 He says, never in the thousand-year struggle between Christians and Muslims did it occur
00:43:15 to a Christian to surrender rather than defend Europe out of love towards the Saracens or the
00:43:20 Turks. Christ's command, that is the command to love your enemies, certainly does not mean that
00:43:25 one should love and support the enemies of one's own people. And so when we think about enemies,
00:43:30 talk about enemies, refer to them. Private, public. Private, public. Public enemy. Democrats.
00:43:38 We talked about them. Abortion doctors. I'm not naming a specific individual. I'm naming 0.85
00:43:42 groups of people. Those that are wicked over and over again. This is the struggle in Scripture.
00:43:48 The wicked prophet and the righteous pushing back. David and Moses and others. What are we to do
00:43:56 with the wicked and the answer is never to lay down and take it to surrender to let them plunder
00:44:01 your house plunder your country uh do what they will with your family that's never the answer
00:44:06 now personal private ethics an individual that tests you an individual that's difficult to work
00:44:11 with uh there is or turn the other cheek or one who wrongs you exactly turn the other cheek go
00:44:17 the extra mile but that is of course not referring to the people that would decimate your homeland
00:44:22 ravage your family plunder your goods that that's no nobody thought like this so if they heard you
00:44:28 talking about enemies and again not your neighbor that's personally offended you but talking about
00:44:33 enemies any decency any giving of the benefit of doubt would recognize that what you're saying is
00:44:37 that we talk about enemies we're talking about collectives that threaten our way of life i've
00:44:43 been doing some some research into multiculturalism and globalism and um one of the one of the realities
00:44:50 that we live in now and this is something that we need to actively fight against but one of the
00:44:55 realities that we live in now is we are told over and over and over again there is no better or
00:45:02 worse culture there's no better or worse nation multiculturalism promises that it's really
00:45:08 multiculturalism is really like um extreme individualism on a group level where we say
00:45:17 how dare you judge someone's behavior? How dare you judge their gender expression or their 0.92
00:45:22 LGBTQ expression? I'm an individual, I can do whatever I want. Multiculturalism is the same
00:45:27 principle on a group scale, where it says, how dare you say that this culture is worse than that
00:45:33 culture, or that there's any sort of objective line that we could say we ought to prefer our
00:45:40 culture over another culture. And even, and here's the really thing that we've got to get
00:45:47 past, even if there are two cultures that are not necessarily morally inferior and morally 0.93
00:45:53 superior, but they're just very different, it is still okay for a Christian living in 0.55
00:45:59 one and a Christian living in the other to say, this is my culture, and I'm going to
00:46:04 protect this, and this Christian to say, great, this is my culture, and I'm going to protect
00:46:09 this.
00:46:10 And that sort of thinking has been so eradicated, so eroded, and it really makes me sad, because
00:46:16 really what we're saying is, I have no love or duty or honor for the people that God gave me to
00:46:23 and gave to me. And really what we say is, God, your sovereign choice in giving me to this people
00:46:30 or that people is completely meaningless. And it would be like saying, I don't need to love my
00:46:37 family more than the family down the road. God didn't give me my children as a special gift to
00:46:41 me or me to them as their father, as an act of grace and love to them.
00:46:46 And that's a violation, too, of the fifth commandment.
00:46:48 So the fifth commandment, honor your father, mother, that it may go well for you in the
00:46:51 land that I'm giving you, repeated by Paul.
00:46:53 Well, it's not as though you only honor your father, but then grandfather, great-grandfather,
00:46:57 that it just stops at that first level of family.
00:47:00 No, we honor our grandfather, our great-grandfathers, those that came before us, especially those
00:47:05 that came before us in stalwart faith.
00:47:06 But then if you go back long enough and you go back broad enough, oh, that's referring
00:47:11 to a collection of people that typically would occupy the same space so my family came from a
00:47:16 lineage and heritage that lived in this state that did this for a vocation and we are called
00:47:21 not to not to ignore it not to turn our back on it not to forget it but to honor and to venerate
00:47:26 and of course the good things about it uh if you're uh jd vance just listening to his family
00:47:30 there was some violent people in there his grandmother she said uh if her her husband
00:47:35 came back drunk one more time she'd kill him he comes back falls asleep drunk on the couch
00:47:39 covers him in gasoline throws a match onto his chest and his daughter has to put the fire out
00:47:43 if that's in your legacy it's okay to maybe not include that in the book to recognize that not
00:47:48 the best part of uh of me ma's character but generally speaking the good the hard work the
00:47:53 labor that your ancestors put in should be honored and should be respected we speak highly of the
00:47:58 things that can be spoken highly of and and generally cover the things like maybe setting
00:48:03 your spouse on fire but all that to say to ignore and just allow allow its erosion is to violate
00:48:09 one of the Ten Commandments, which is to honor your father and your mother.
00:48:13 Yeah.
00:48:13 Yeah.
00:48:14 Yeah.
00:48:14 I think about, you know, even fellow brothers in Christ, different Christians, like you
00:48:20 think of historic, you know, wars and like World War I and World War II and regardless
00:48:25 of all the, you know, the things we'll never know about what was right and, you know, all
00:48:30 this, you know, there's so many things that, we'll just say Elon Musk had not yet bought
00:48:34 Twitter.
00:48:35 So, you know, we have what we have.
00:48:37 uh but the point is that uh you know there were people fighting on both sides and there were
00:48:41 christians yeah on both sides and there were you know some wars i even like i think of you know
00:48:45 the war for independence you know and uh with you know against you know the brits you know and then
00:48:51 you've got the the american patriots and there were christians on both sides and there are you
00:48:55 know even um instances you know in history where you have you know um you have record of where
00:49:01 like on christmas day they they called you know both sides called a ceasefire and you even have
00:49:06 like fellowship between you know these opposing sides um and and fellowship around the gospel
00:49:12 and around the person and work of jesus christ and christmas day and his incarnation and like
00:49:17 they shared in common faith and then and then yet it was still completely proper and permissible
00:49:22 but not only permissible but proper and even right uh the next day that they picked back up arms
00:49:28 that they actually had temporal enemies they had corporate national public enemies so everything
00:49:38 that you guys are saying i completely agree with um if if it's at an individual private personal
00:49:44 enemy somebody um all the time i'm turning the cheek you know all all the time you know i get
00:49:49 slandered on social media by by people and um you were lied about or whatever and uh there's so many
00:49:58 times that i just i don't respond at all or if i you know i respond far more charitable charitably
00:50:04 than the person was towards me um that's turning the other cheek um but uh if china uh tries to
00:50:12 destroy you know in like an act of war with the united states um that's that's not a turn the
00:50:19 other cheek scenario that's not uh that's not what jesus is talking about uh it's simply not
00:50:25 And if you believe that it is, then you have to be a globalist, universalist, pacifist.
00:50:32 At that point, you're just a progressive.
00:50:36 Well, or you're an incredibly bad theologian because I think to be charitable, most Christians, 0.58
00:50:45 what they've done is they've taken the personal enemy category or the personal piety and holiness 0.53
00:50:51 that we are to have as Christians, and they have said, well, if we're going to be a nation of
00:50:55 Christians, our national and international policies have to look exactly like what I would do in
00:51:01 generosity or compassion or forgiveness or kindness on a local level to the man on the
00:51:06 street next to me. And again, I know we say it all the time, it's just a category here.
00:51:12 There's a different way to be a ruler and a leader of a nation who is Christian and enacting
00:51:18 Christian principles than to be a neighbor with someone next door and to be a Christian in that
00:51:23 setting. Yeah. There needs to be some epistemic humility, too. So if you're just a 28-year-old
00:51:29 woman, you're like, well, my opinion on theonomy is this. Like, hold that, sit down, sweetheart.
00:51:34 Men, great men, learned men, I think of Johann Alstad or Althusias, Turretin, have thought
00:51:39 at length for their entire lives about Christian political systems and what is proper and right
00:51:46 and good and you barely read through the new testament last year but you have an opinion like
00:51:51 oh they're wrong on that and that even goes for myself there's there's things that i'm still
00:51:55 learning so i've learned hopefully by god's grace i continue to do it more if there's something i
00:51:59 don't know or an area i'm not experienced in to to step back to not take a strong opinion to not
00:52:05 because some people they treat like like they'll read a book or read something they're like i have
00:52:09 the key to knowledge they're really just there's not a replacement for doing the reading for being
00:52:15 well read for for versing yourself especially in the protestant magisterial reformers for versing
00:52:20 yourself in that history being familiar with it interacting with the arguments that they've made
00:52:24 and coming to a conclusion so there needs to be some humility of like yeah i actually haven't
00:52:29 thought a lot about the political i've never read any political books i have no familiarity with the
00:52:34 magisterial reformation and what they thought calvin addressed the king maybe i'll take a
00:52:39 back seat to this and i'll let stephen wolf do most of the thinking or all that you guys uh
00:52:43 import some thoughts in that that can be helpful if you are just coming to this for the first time
00:52:48 just take a seat and and you will thank yourself if you take an opinion in the heat of the moment
00:52:53 not a good look when nine months later you have to walk it back yeah yep got that wrong and let's
00:52:58 be honest nine months later uh most people don't walk it back that's right they double down so many 0.95
00:53:03 exactly so many of the divisions that we have had you know i call them the the great cn wars
00:53:08 of 2022 and 2023 the christian nationalism wars so much of those divisions um were not calculated
00:53:15 they were not thoughtful um it was uh one of my close friends who was associated with
00:53:22 you know my denomination or my organization or whatever um just threw something out
00:53:29 you know just threw something out in you know into the ether and uh and then that obligated
00:53:36 me from a relational say i gotta go get my boy so then i hopped in and then you know two years
00:53:42 later um we still we can't we can't come back and actually say that we were wrong and so now
00:53:48 for all of time uh we are the guys who disagree with john calvin we are the guys who agree with
00:53:55 the reform tradition uh in terms of soteriology and reject everything else and um that's sad it
00:54:03 honestly breaks my heart that uh because one guy comes out with a tweet without thinking and says
00:54:10 you know john gill essentially is wrong and baptists can't legislate the first table of the
00:54:15 law baptists can have nothing to do with christendom and you you say that without thinking
00:54:21 and that one tiny thing um from one guy then all his you know co-belligerence and and i get it i'm
00:54:29 sympathetic like that that's our guy we love our guy i get that and so then there and then there's
00:54:34 this huge battle and then there's fallout and there's never really uh not true not deep uh
00:54:40 reconciliation and not just that it uh that you now have inevitable perpetual relational fractures
00:54:45 but you also have now um a commitment a dogged commitment to bat theology right we must be
00:54:52 against legislating the first table of the law we must be against uh blasphemy laws uh we must be
00:54:58 against uh from all for all of time uh we must win so now like you know a year and a half after 0.68
00:55:04 the fact when elon musk comes out and says i'm a cultural christian richard dawkins and those
00:55:08 kinds of things and then you hear the testimonies of of their uh famous atheist assistant who was
00:55:13 a cultural christian and moved because of covid and moved to a more conservative town and wanted
00:55:18 to make friends because they didn't know anybody so they started going to a cowboy church and
00:55:21 cultural christianity led to their actual regenerate christianity and you can't affirm
00:55:25 can't say anything like because because one guy um just randomly without giving it much thought
00:55:32 said uh baptist i can have nothing to do with chrysidom like it's really sad when you think
00:55:37 about like these are not and you need to know that listener you need to know um and that goes
00:55:42 for everybody myself myself included um you need to know that so many things that go down these
00:55:47 last few years um this like in so many positions of guys you're listening to these are not guys
00:55:53 doing the work of a theologian in a vacuum with a blank piece of paper sitting in front of them
00:55:58 thinking clearly uh it's so much of it you just have to recognize is uh providential it's
00:56:05 contextual it's relational you'd like to think it's objectively theological it's not it's
00:56:10 relational i can tell you right now um i can tell you what your theology will be um 12 months from
00:56:17 now i can tell you to the t what you will believe theologically what convictions you will hold
00:56:21 if you simply provide for me your your top five podcasts that you listen to and your top five
00:56:26 friends um we we like to think that we're just that we're making these objective unbiased
00:56:34 decisions in a vacuum with with sheer objectivity that's not uh that is not just like politics it's
00:56:40 the realm of the possible well that's not human life that's not the world that god created we
00:56:45 we don't live in a vacuum we live in a context and and within the providence of god we've been
00:56:50 place in a particular time a particular place um we have particular friendships um and and things
00:56:58 happen and sometimes uh your theology you'd like to think that you did the reading on both sides
00:57:03 and that you objectively came to this because of that and that because of this uh when in reality
00:57:08 it's uh no i just happened to i started following this person and then i became friends with that
00:57:15 person and then this person you know started slandering this person and i came to his defense
00:57:20 And now I'm Thomistic instead of Vantillian.
00:57:25 It has nothing to do with the reading.
00:57:27 Or now I'm Vantillian instead of Thomistic.
00:57:30 You have to recognize that.
00:57:32 So real quick, we'll go to our last commercial break, but I want to take a couple questions.
00:57:39 So let me throw this out to those of you who are actually following the live stream.
00:57:44 We will, at the end of this episode, take a couple questions, two or three questions.
00:57:47 I've noticed, you know, I'm following it as we're talking as hard to, you know, to multitask.
00:57:52 But you guys are saying, why do a live stream if you're not going to interact with the audience?
00:57:57 And the answer is because the live stream helps with the algorithm.
00:58:01 It pushes out to more people.
00:58:03 The live stream is not all live streams have to be Q&As.
00:58:07 So the purpose of a live stream is not solely to interact with the audience.
00:58:10 But we love you guys.
00:58:12 And if you have a legit question, then we're happy to answer it.
00:58:16 But let's go to a commercial break.
00:58:17 Wes, I'll hand it back to you for a couple more points
00:58:20 and then that gives you guys who are listening live
00:58:23 to take some time and to think about a good question.
00:58:27 Are you desiring to change your financial trajectory
00:58:30 and build multi-generational wealth
00:58:32 for your children and grandchildren?
00:58:34 Our sponsor, Private Family Banking Partners,
00:58:37 invites you to join a growing number
00:58:39 of like-minded individuals, families, and entrepreneurs
00:58:43 who are working together to form a unique part
00:58:46 of the parallel economy. With private family banking, you will learn how to establish a
00:58:51 privatized banking system that will increase the value of the money and savings that you already
00:58:57 have flowing through your life. Join this growing community today as a part of putting post-mill
00:59:03 talk into post-mill action by contacting a private family banking partner today by emailing them at
00:59:10 banking at privatefamilybanking.com. Also see the show notes below to schedule a discovery call and
00:59:17 get a free copy of the ebook, Protect Your Money Now, How to Build Multigenerational Wealth Outside
00:59:23 of Wall Street and Avoid the Coming Banking Meltdown. Our beef supply is under attack.
00:59:32 More than ever, the industry for fake industrial produced meat is underway. As reformed post-mill
00:59:38 Christians, the founders of Dominion Ranch, seek to honor Christ's rule and continue building his
00:59:45 kingdom on earth by supplying Christians with high quality beef for the journey. We believe
00:59:51 in excellence and that is why Dominion Ranch works as a collective with multi-generational
00:59:58 ranchers across Texas to bring you the best in great tasting and nutritious beef. Our motto is
01:00:05 that kingdoms were never built on salads alone eat beef and subdue the earth and one more thing
01:00:11 don't forget to enter the dominion ranch super summer giveaway for some delicious wagyu beef
01:00:17 a mouth-watering addition to your freezer click the link in the description and enter to win
01:00:22 all right welcome back time to land the plane we we laid out enemies we laid out friends i want to
01:00:31 give the conditions for victory uh these are i'm borrowing them from rn mcintyre for the record
01:00:35 you need to be aaron mcathire maxing he's one of the best voices there is right there right now
01:00:39 out there on politics he's gonna be at our conference which would be awesome i'm really
01:00:42 excited to hear him speak so i'm borrowing from him as many good things have happened we have not
01:00:47 even taken back one percent i would say the cultural capital that we need to so we are not
01:00:52 we're over halfway there whoa we're halfway there no there's a lot of ground to be taken up and uh
01:00:58 and some of the criteria i i think are really helpful to lay out so i think of it was 2023 i
01:01:03 think we got dylan mulvaney off the beer can and bud light stocked anheuser bush their stock tanked
01:01:07 that's it man we had a cultural victory no we didn't we didn't whatsoever how did that change
01:01:14 at all a social dynamic yes we penalized a company maybe maybe target stock went down but that didn't
01:01:20 get our guys into power it didn't change society's values so arm mcintyre lays out four conditions
01:01:25 for victory i think these should be be used uh really frequently as we're thinking about winning
01:01:30 taking back institutions here they are four conditions for victory enemies fired friends
01:01:36 hired money to our patronage network and society pushes our values so one more time these are the
01:01:42 conditions for victory enemies fired friends hired money to our patronage network and society pushes
01:01:48 our values i said dylan mulvaney already it's not enough i think of brent leatherwood who was
01:01:52 removed for a grand total of 12 hours we removed brent leatherwood we did it right we'll know if
01:01:57 If he's replaced by someone even further to the left of Russell Moore, we haven't won anything.
01:02:02 It's getting our enemies, real people that are subversive and wicked in positions of power, getting them out, getting our guys in.
01:02:10 Getting good, godly men to take those civil magistrate positions, institutional leadership positions, those SBC positions, back up.
01:02:17 So it's enemies fired, friends hired, and then it's cash and it's capital.
01:02:21 You were talking about Elon Musk.
01:02:22 Why was he able to purchase Twitter?
01:02:24 he was able to purchase it because he made a ton a ton a ton a ton a ton of money right he slept on
01:02:32 the floor of his office if you read uh isaacson's uh biography of him incredible uh the hardest
01:02:38 working man probably any of you have ever heard of which gave him the money to actually make the
01:02:43 change most christians maybe they would make the change they they would take over twitter and they
01:02:47 would maybe even i don't know if do a better job but they get pornography off it right they don't
01:02:51 have a a shot at it why because they don't have any money because they haven't built anything
01:02:56 so it's it's enemies fired it's hiring friends it's money to these networks to build up things
01:03:02 like new founding things like ridge render things like uh the center for baptist leadership so they
01:03:07 can have staff and put out more resources money to your patron network and then society pushes
01:03:12 your values the end of pride month the end of dei right society reinforcing these things that
01:03:18 we talk about as good. Reinforcing not just agnostic or ethereal virtues, Christian virtues,
01:03:24 Christian values. So when you see those four things, our enemies fired en masse, friends hired
01:03:31 ascendant to positions of power all over as judges, as appointments by the Senate, as vice president,
01:03:37 money flowing to our networks, and then society reinforcing those values that those leaders and
01:03:43 those friends and those networks are pushing, that's when you know we've made good progress.
01:03:47 And so those are the tangible things to push for.
01:03:50 So when you see those things happening,
01:03:51 that's when you know that we're making tangible progress,
01:03:54 that we're winning.
01:03:55 To get there, though,
01:03:56 first step is you have to at least even want those things to happen.
01:04:01 And right now, sadly,
01:04:03 there are many conservatives and Christians,
01:04:06 evangelicals especially,
01:04:07 that don't even want those things.
01:04:08 So like you said,
01:04:09 enemies fired was one of them.
01:04:13 A woman who laments the failed attempt 0.57
01:04:17 of uh trump's assassination and and not just that if you look at the tweet celebrates right that a
01:04:23 trump supporter died using his body as a human shield to protect his daughters uh she celebrated
01:04:30 that and she gets fired and uh conservatives immediately waste zero time doing everything
01:04:36 they can to uh to clutch you know to to to just snatch victory out of the the you know or to snatch
01:04:44 defeat out of the jaws of victory they're like we we might win uh quickly is there anything that
01:04:49 we as evangelical christians can do to lose um and what do they do they say this is cancel culture
01:04:56 we don't we don't like it and uh we we don't want uh they they start doing the ring thing they're
01:05:01 like the ring needs to be thrown into the fire of mordor you know what what if the left does it
01:05:06 what do you mean what if the left the left has been doing it that's all they've been doing this
01:05:10 canceling us for four years and much longer than that but just in in broad daylight how many
01:05:16 fathers lost their jobs over the vaccine fathers not just single women how many fathers lost their
01:05:21 children over transgenderism right how like at at every level um this is what they've been doing
01:05:27 one woman gets fired and it wasn't just like you know she literally celebrated the death
01:05:33 of a trump supporter who was a father a firefighter shielding his daughters from bullets
01:05:38 and she loses her job the solution isn't to prevent that the solution by the grace of god
01:05:45 is that that would multiply by 10 000 exactly we need so much more of that which goes back
01:05:51 to an earlier point um you can pray for hearts for revival all day long um my prayer and we should
01:05:59 my prayer in addition to that is that god would give us stomachs for revival and you know what
01:06:04 that prayer essentially what that prayer means um at some level what it means is um that that we
01:06:12 would not have female leadership because women aren't actually supposed to that's a prayer god
01:06:18 won't answer because that's a prayer basically asking god to to grant something that goes against
01:06:24 his natural good design uh part of the reason we don't have the stomachs for revival um is because 0.99
01:06:29 um women weren't weren't supposed to they women are supposed to think like when a husband comes
01:06:36 home and says yeah this woman lost her job at home depot um the the the correct natural response 0.95
01:06:43 from your wife um is oh that's sad i feel bad for her that's good that's a good instinct for her to
01:06:49 have um it becomes a bad instinct though if she's got her own podcast and she's wearing a pantsuit 0.76
01:06:55 She's got a blog and a million followers of other suburban moms, and all of them have 1.00
01:07:00 a vote, and all of them actually make more money than their husbands, and the court system 1.00
01:07:04 is in their direction to where if they ever divorce their husband, they get all the stuff 1.00
01:07:07 and they get the kids. 1.00
01:07:09 So in a gyneocracy, in a woman-led nation and culture, which is what we currently have, 1.00
01:07:15 there's only two types of leaders, women and those who are women adjacent. 1.00
01:07:19 That's it. 1.00
01:07:20 Women of both genders. 1.00
01:07:21 And women adjacent.
01:07:21 so in that society um it's going to be really hard for us to get friends hired um you know
01:07:29 enemies fired you know those kinds of things because those are things that men do and uh and
01:07:34 it requires spine fortitude uh stomach so i will say i was encouraged i would say it was about a
01:07:40 50 50 of conservatives i think of charles haywood example like no this needs to happen yeah he came
01:07:45 out immediately and said stop it yep there's a woman peachy keen who was like oh we can't we
01:07:50 can't do cancel culture in the verse i know no we can no we should and we will and we've done one
01:07:55 percent of what we need to do yes one percent we lament i i was sad when i heard the news i was sad
01:08:01 to hear that it was one employee yep my brothers by god's grace i pray for 10 000 more jobless
01:08:08 people uh that's so that's that's not yes jobless people i pray for 10 000 more my enemies to be
01:08:15 fired and i'm talking about people who celebrate the death of fathers yes yes we want those people
01:08:22 to to be fired because because we want there to be a mechanism a a restraining mechanism socially
01:08:31 and culturally that says this behavior is bad yeah yeah so that people change the law of god
01:08:37 working and beginning to tutor a people any any other thoughts west or michael before we
01:08:42 do a couple, couple questions? No, just, I mean, the, the constant reminder that we need to have
01:08:49 in the, the liberal multicultural society that we live in, that the existence of enemies
01:08:56 is not a bad thing, right? The idea that we are going to, I was just, I was doing some writing
01:09:02 earlier this week, and post-millennialism does not teach that there will be no enemies. It teaches
01:09:10 that until Christ comes back, we will be, he will use us, his people, to destroy enemy after enemy
01:09:18 after enemy after enemy. And so even with post-millennialism, we're not after a utopia
01:09:22 where we all just sit around and eat chips and watch Netflix, right? The post-millennial hope
01:09:28 is that one enemy after another after another will be destroyed. And often what we don't like
01:09:34 to do is put feet on that idea because often enemies that the church is destroying are backed
01:09:42 by people who support godly and wicked ideas and so that means the church is going to be removing
01:09:48 people from power through preaching the gospel and through godly leadership civil magistrates
01:09:54 and it's going to have real impacts on real people they're not just theoretical enemies or
01:10:01 just the enemies of ideas because people they are but people believe ideas and they act on ideas and
01:10:08 they are the ones that need to be corrected or punished as righteousness increases through the
01:10:12 land yeah in deuteronomy it says again and again when it talks about the law your eye shall not
01:10:17 that one of our inclinations injustice is to is to pity and there's a place where uh paul talks
01:10:23 about bowels of mercy compassion those have a place uh but it's not in the realm of justice
01:10:27 All right, let's take some questions. So here we go. This is Stryker, and Euclid, he has a similar question, but let me read Stryker. He says, Joel, how do you feel associating with Wolfe, talking about Stephen Wolfe as a self-proclaimed general equity theonomist when Wolfe called theonomy 20th century garbage?
01:10:46 I'll answer this, and then I want Wes to pipe in.
01:10:50 I'll go ahead and also read real quick Euclid, his question, because they're both over the
01:10:54 same kind of thing, the Thomistic versus Vantilian persuasion.
01:10:58 You know, which side are you on, Joel?
01:10:59 So Euclid says, Joel, your public theology is a mix of Thomas and Vantil, and when it
01:11:06 comes to the Christian prince, even a bit of Hegel.
01:11:09 That's not true.
01:11:10 do you not see Thomism and Vantillianism as contradictory? Yes, I definitely think that
01:11:20 there are certainly, Thomism, not everything that Thomas Aquinas said, but Thomism, those aspects
01:11:26 of his writing, there are certainly major factors that stand directly contradictory to Vantillian,
01:11:35 the Vantillian position, which Bonson and Gary North and Rush Dooney and all those guys held,
01:11:39 and we'll get into that in a second but uh with striker uh in terms of william wolf
01:11:44 or i'm sorry steven wolf i'm sympathetic uh so steven is a friend and uh no i i don't feel
01:11:51 how do i speaking at the conference yeah how do i feel associated with him uh so short answer
01:11:55 great feel fantastic about that um so he's a friend i spoke with him in ogden uh he's speaking
01:12:00 at our conference uh this this coming april um and i'm no shame whatsoever uh to speak to him
01:12:06 about that uh or to partner with him on that um in that conference i think what steven wolf is
01:12:13 getting at um i wouldn't word it the same way i don't hold all the positions that he holds
01:12:17 um but steven wolf really that it's he's frustrated you see it from time to time on twitter he comes
01:12:25 out like every and he and he does both every now and then you'll see he'll have a post we'll say
01:12:28 all right we're all on the same team like let's just you know let's just win let's freaking win
01:12:32 something, please, you know, and he'll say, all right, you know, like, you know, the Vantillians,
01:12:37 you know, the Theonomists, you know, we'll take them, you know, like, happy to be, and, you know,
01:12:42 he canon published their book, you know, like canon published his book, and, you know, most of 0.70
01:12:47 the, you know, Moscow folk are more Vantillian than they are, you know, than they are Thomistic,
01:12:54 and so Stephen Wolfe did not start, here's my point, he did not start out when he published 0.94
01:13:00 his magnum opus of you know the case for christian nationalism he did not start out um making jabs
01:13:07 right at uh at um theonomist um the problem is so when he says that it's 20th century garbage i
01:13:15 would disagree with that i don't think that van till is garbage uh by any stretch i think he's
01:13:19 brilliant um so i don't think it's 20th century garbage but i got asked this same kind of question
01:13:23 by eric khan at the ogden conference where he said all right joel like we're sitting here on
01:13:27 stage and we're talking about these things and what you know what is you're you're the only guy
01:13:31 on stage who claims to be you know a general equity theonomist joe rigney was on stage but
01:13:35 even joe rigney he's a moscow man uh but he is a classical two kingdom guy um he is a protestant
01:13:42 magisterial reformed position he is not um he's not uh a general equity theonomist guy and so
01:13:50 they asked me being the only guy on the stage brian's not and just for the record ogden was
01:13:56 If you had been in the halls of Ogden in the basement, you know, as they're recording some of their first, you know, episodes of King's Hall, you know, or in a staff meeting, you know, Deacon Ben Garrett, you know, and Dan and Eric and if it was 2020 and you would, they, they would have, you would have heard them saying, how could anybody not be a theonomist?
01:14:16 Absolutely.
01:14:17 They were saying that pretty much everybody who wanted to fight was saying that.
01:14:23 Right.
01:14:23 because that was the only really known position of of god's law of fighting because um the classical
01:14:34 two kingdom calvin position uh had been hidden from us well and co-opted co-opted right and and
01:14:43 i mean even some of these guys who claim to love the puritans i'm talking about not just not just
01:14:47 the uh the pastors but i'm talking publishers right were were literally uh uh taking out whole
01:14:54 portions right of of the reformers when they would publish their books so we didn't know exactly what
01:15:00 calvin thought politically because nobody was ever going to talk about it and if they did they would
01:15:04 you know say it was bad and if you read calvin you know that part might have been edited out
01:15:08 depending on which publisher you got your reformation puritan books from and so um my
01:15:13 point is nobody really knew and so they're looking at theonomy they're saying well theonomists seem
01:15:18 to be you know the only ones who want to fight back who actually want the law of god to be the
01:15:23 law of the land and um and so that that's where a lot of that came from and steven wolf it wasn't
01:15:28 giving theonomist a hard time at that at that point and published his he was willing to publish
01:15:31 his book with canon with moscow theonomist guys and wilson was willing to publish it knowing that
01:15:37 that it was not that you know wilson it's not like he didn't read the book he read the book
01:15:41 he knows it's not van tillion he knows it's tomistic wilson said all these things up front
01:15:46 before the book even came out you know and he did videos you know preparing for the launch with with
01:15:51 steven wolf and so that that partnership was fine are there contradictory positions doctrinal
01:15:58 positions there will will there have to be an eventual showdown between aquinas and van till
01:16:04 yes um but right now living in clown world um and just trying to get a man on first base um there
01:16:12 there is no war necessary and there what here's my point there wasn't a war there only started to
01:16:18 be a war when all the theonomists that's true started dogging stephen wolf constantly for two
01:16:25 years so it's it wasn't until the theonomist and i'm still of that tribe i am a general equity
01:16:31 theonomist whether they'll have me or not that is my position i am more van tillion than i am
01:16:36 of of atomistic persuasion uh far more and yes to answer your question you click uh absolutely i see
01:16:42 that they uh directly contradict um in certain areas and they are areas that matter so yes i'm
01:16:48 aware of all that um i am still a theonomist and i like theonomy um i am coming very quickly not to
01:16:56 like theonomist though because what i'm realizing is that theonomists don't actually want to win
01:17:01 theonomists want the 1980s theonomists don't want um they don't want christ rule they don't
01:17:08 theonomists want to argue over um whether or not we should have prisons which the bible actually
01:17:14 we shouldn't have prisons right that's true uh but but uh when when there's actually real
01:17:19 legislation on the table we need to lock up criminals who are raping women right theonomists
01:17:26 want to talk about uh the hypothetical realm of theory and whether or not we should have prisons
01:17:31 instead of talking about actually locking up criminals um theonomist here's another why do
01:17:37 they like the 1980s usury i'm just going to say it straight up because they some of the theonomist
01:17:44 make a lot of money and they want to be able to continue to charge high interest rates period
01:17:50 um gary north was wrong about usury i like i like the theonomist i like rush duney i think they're
01:17:56 right about 95 and general equity theonomist when i will i will never stop claiming that because it
01:18:02 is the confessional position whether you're westminster or 1689 so yes i believe that the
01:18:07 moral commandments of god the decalogue exodus 20 applies for all people in all times in all places
01:18:13 and when i go to the civil magistrate i don't need to point to a migration pattern of deer
01:18:17 or the constellation of the stars i can say god wrote a book special revelation it doesn't just
01:18:23 apply to the church it applies to all peoples in all places kiss the sun lest he be angry psalm 2
01:18:29 it applies today it applies for you so i will always be a general equity theonomist the bible
01:18:33 is for all people not just god's people all people and we i'm a theonomist in the sense that
01:18:38 we're allowed to use the book we're allowed to use the book i don't have to point to examples
01:18:43 in nature to make an argument i can say god wrote a book and he wrote it for you kiss the son lest
01:18:48 he be angry so yes i am a general equity theonomist 100 it's the confessional position and i'm not
01:18:54 going to back down but i'll tell you what um it is in becoming increasingly embarrassing
01:19:00 to be publicly known as a theonomist why because steven wolf no because of theonomist
01:19:06 because of theonomist um i i don't know hardly any group that is shooting itself in the foot
01:19:12 with more fervor and vigilance than theonomist and i personally do not believe that theonomy
01:19:20 has to be intrinsically tied to boomer con post-war sentiment right but right now it is
01:19:26 it is and you just have to realize that if you're a theonomist here's your crew here's your team
01:19:32 andrew sandlin right david bonson which by the way that apple fell far from the tree yeah so so
01:19:41 So I don't know what to do.
01:19:44 So yes, I'm going to have Stephen Wolfe speak at my conference and be a friend, of course,
01:19:47 because Stephen Wolfe has eyes in his head.
01:19:51 Stephen Wolfe knows what time it is.
01:19:53 Stephen can read a book and write a book and read the Bible.
01:19:57 Yeah, I'm going to have Stephen Wolfe.
01:20:01 I need to know, what's the difference between Bonson, David Bonson, and Michael O'Fallon?
01:20:07 Because at the end of the day, their doctrine is different.
01:20:09 but in terms of uh their their latest tweet and how and and what to do about politics right now
01:20:16 it seems as though they have the same guiding force it's not their different theology because
01:20:21 then they'd have a different guiding force but their same guiding force is one of them has a
01:20:24 cruise line and the other one has a hedge firm and it seems like that guides their sentiment
01:20:32 So, yeah, I love theonomy.
01:20:35 But the theonomists are really starting to frustrate me.
01:20:40 I'll give another name.
01:20:41 Someone asked, like, who?
01:20:42 John Reasoner is another guy who sparred with a ton on Twitter.
01:20:45 Has some of the worst takes, my goodness.
01:20:48 Joel McDermott, too, back in the day.
01:20:50 Joel McDermott.
01:20:50 Yep.
01:20:51 And he would say he's still a theonomist.
01:20:54 Theonomy, sadly, I think theonomy, great.
01:20:58 But the theonomists, the people, they have proven to have no...
01:21:04 Stephen Wolfe talks about bulwarks.
01:21:08 The theonomists have proven to have very little bulwark.
01:21:12 Very little bulwark.
01:21:13 And let me give an example of not.
01:21:15 Jeff Durbin.
01:21:15 Jeff Durbin is out there on the streets.
01:21:18 Because he's not doing the ivory tower thing.
01:21:20 So guess who else I invited to speak at my conference?
01:21:23 Jeff Durbin.
01:21:24 Because he's great.
01:21:25 So at the end of the day...
01:21:26 And guess who else I have?
01:21:28 So I've got Andrew Isker.
01:21:29 He's going to come. 0.83
01:21:31 And he's currently writing a book about why Zionism is a sire. 0.97
01:21:36 Right. 0.74
01:21:37 And I'm also going to have Steve Dace.
01:21:39 Steve Dace. 0.97
01:21:40 Who is borderline a Zionist. 0.90
01:21:41 No, no, no.
01:21:42 He said he is.
01:21:43 Okay.
01:21:43 Then he's not even borderline. 0.92
01:21:45 He's a Zionist. 0.97
01:21:46 And why? 0.97
01:21:47 How?
01:21:47 How could you?
01:21:49 Here's the common denominator.
01:21:50 With all the guys that I have.
01:21:52 Whether it's Warren McIntyre or Steve Dace or Jeff Durbin, who's a theonomist.
01:21:56 David Reese, who's a theonomist.
01:21:57 uh dusty deavers the christian prince who's the theonomist or steven wolf who is not right um
01:22:02 in all cases here's the common denominator uh what do they have in common i don't understand
01:22:07 how's he coming up with his team where's he at what how does how does he formulate his position
01:22:11 um show me your friends and i can tell you what your doctrine will be in a year
01:22:14 my friends um as i choose them um are guys who kick butt and take names that's how i i pick my
01:22:23 friends they want to win i pick my friends by people who want to win uh people who don't just
01:22:28 have pietistic hearts for revival but stomachs for revival guys who are fighting uh steve days
01:22:34 is pre-mill ish i think he's pre-mill dispensational ish and zionist ish although he's
01:22:44 using sproles material he is god bless him yeah exactly you know he's open he's open he's winnable
01:22:49 But the point is, even if Steve Dace ends up in the next six months before the conference saying, I'm going to become a Zionist, even harder.
01:23:00 I mean, that'll be unfortunate.
01:23:02 I wish he wouldn't.
01:23:03 I wish he wouldn't.
01:23:04 But if Steve Dace continues to do what he's done for 20, I don't know what he'll do in the next six months, but I know what he's done for 20 years.
01:23:11 And for 20 years, Steve Dace has been fighting real battles, not hypothetical 17th dimension theoretical battles.
01:23:19 about whether or not we should get rid of prisons of course of course we should but first we need
01:23:24 to actually build more prisons see that's where i'm starting to part ways not with theonomy yeah
01:23:28 but with our current boomer uh theonomist uh i'm willing to say uh here's the goal and where we
01:23:36 need to get but right now um we're just we're simply not at the place we're going to start
01:23:40 flogging people for assault right lynching people um for for you know a capital offense
01:23:47 and then enslaving people for double restitution, for theft.
01:23:52 We're just not there right now.
01:23:53 And so because we're not there right now,
01:23:55 with the current system that we have,
01:23:58 in order to stop the epidemic of crime
01:24:04 and to make it safe for our own wives and children,
01:24:08 right now we don't get rid of prisons.
01:24:09 Right now we build more.
01:24:12 We fill them up.
01:24:13 We fill them up. 1.00
01:24:14 We need old Kamala back. 1.00
01:24:17 right old kamala was she was happy to put 1500 people in jail for just smoking weed not even 1.00
01:24:23 selling it and while her herself uh was smoking weed on the regular and then when questioned 1.00
01:24:28 about it did went into her typical uh kamala cackle laugh once that laugh gets out to the 1.00
01:24:34 public it's over for the campaign two to three on two to three of those which um even even by her 1.00
01:24:40 own side and they and they have hardly any standards and even then when they start to
01:24:45 the reason you know the reason why people thought that joe was great because um they just believe
01:24:50 the legacy media so as soon as she gets out there to the public and they have to see her like the
01:24:55 honeymoon is over it's gonna be terrible all right so anyway so that's where i'm at so i am
01:25:00 vantillian i am um a general equity theonomist what i mean by that is that um i think it's
01:25:05 perfectly compatible and i think it's not just compatible it is the confessional position both
01:25:10 for the 1689 and the Westminster,
01:25:12 I always emphasize general equity
01:25:14 because I don't necessarily want to refer to myself
01:25:17 as a reconstructionist.
01:25:19 Because I love, Rush Juni is my favorite.
01:25:22 Bonson would be right up there.
01:25:24 Gary North, appreciate him.
01:25:25 Not quite as much of a favorite,
01:25:27 primarily because Gary North started to take the ethics.
01:25:30 So Bonson, first he took Van Til
01:25:32 and applied it to the realm of apologetics.
01:25:34 Then he applied it to the realm of ethics.
01:25:36 And then Gary North started to apply it
01:25:37 to the realm of economics,
01:25:38 which does need to be done we do need a biblical application for uh economics but i i think that
01:25:44 um that you didn't just see uh gary north channeling his his inner uh theonomy but i
01:25:51 think also his inner boomer and so um and and so i you know i've just yeah so i i'm you know i'm
01:25:57 not going to say i'm a reconstructionist because i would have some differences uh with the
01:26:02 reconstructionist like i don't think that usury is uh moral the big premise of the reconstructionist
01:26:08 was that there's going to be some cataclysmic event
01:26:10 that's going to level the playing field, 0.98
01:26:12 and a Christian society should be reconstructed from it. 1.00
01:26:15 A lot of those guys were banking on Y2K. 0.99
01:26:18 I was about to say Y2K.
01:26:19 And it just never materialized, and I think we realized, 0.94
01:26:21 we're in for the long haul here.
01:26:23 There's not going to be some meteor Y2K that's going to set everything.
01:26:27 If there's another comment, Nate, you can scroll to it.
01:26:29 One more distinction on the Thomism piece.
01:26:31 So I think we would all reject,
01:26:32 especially Thomas' conception of nature grace.
01:26:34 That is to say, Adam in the garden was lacking.
01:26:38 He had a cupiscence and problems, and that even then he still needed what Thomas would
01:26:43 call a donum superaditum, that would be an infusion of grace, to raise him above nature.
01:26:47 We would all reject that in line.
01:26:49 This would probably be more bobbin than Van Til, that would say it's covenantal in that
01:26:53 Adam had an original righteousness.
01:26:54 So in the garden, Adam's nature did not need grace added to it to lift him up beyond his
01:26:59 natural impulses, his humanity, his limitations.
01:27:02 He had that in the form of an original righteousness that played out, would have buried him heaven.
01:27:07 And then as Christians, we receive grace not through the sacraments infusing grace to us and raising us up closer and closer to participate in the divine being.
01:27:16 We receive grace through union with Christ, through covenant.
01:27:20 So when we have union with Christ, it's that grace that forgives us of our sins, gives us the righteousness that we lack, that we lost in the fall of Adam.
01:27:27 instead of, again, a system where more sacraments, more grace,
01:27:32 pile up as much as you can, make purgatory as short as possible
01:27:34 to eventually get to the point where you share in the divine being,
01:27:37 overcome nature, its concupiscence, its limitations, all of that.
01:27:40 So I think I can speak for all three of us and say we would reject
01:27:42 that Thomistic conception of being and of grace
01:27:44 and affirm a Reformed, pretty more closely to Dutch Reformed,
01:27:49 Bavink and as well as Gahardes Vos.
01:27:51 Very well said. Way to go.
01:27:53 um and then van till correct me if i'm wrong but he he's directly down the stream from directly
01:27:59 yeah yeah and and he expands like bonson would be like you know van till's protege and van till was
01:28:06 the protege of voss yep exactly and and he expands definitely like you read voss and read him and
01:28:10 it's unfortunate that van till wasn't a better writer and that's some of the difficulties he'll
01:28:15 use terms and they'll just be they'll just be difficult to map to uh historical philosophical
01:28:21 terms because van tiller does a lot in philosophy so voss was the theologians theologian there at
01:28:26 princeton van tiller really takes and applies it to philosophy and then as you mentioned bonson
01:28:30 and others are taking it and applying to ethics and to god's law and society that's kind of the
01:28:34 the the development there right but big boving fans here yep right okay well um hopefully that's
01:28:42 was there one more question from i think joash was his name nate scroll up a little bit oh jonas
01:28:47 Jonas, generally speaking, in what situation should we reject natural means to any degree in order to hope and expect a miracle from God?
01:28:58 The reduction of Gideon's army.
01:29:00 Okay, generally speaking.
01:29:02 What is he asking?
01:29:03 He's saying, I think the problem in the question is Gideon didn't voluntarily reduce his army.
01:29:09 God told him to do that.
01:29:10 Right, okay.
01:29:11 Right?
01:29:11 And so...
01:29:12 Yeah, I preached on that recently.
01:29:14 Yeah, yeah.
01:29:14 Stop committing suicide.
01:29:16 Like, it would not be wrong for Gideon to have gone with the entire army into that battle, except that God intervened supernaturally and spoke to him and said, don't do it.
01:29:28 Right.
01:29:29 Right?
01:29:29 And so if God makes the conditions as such that it is obvious that he has set something up where, don't take me wrong, God is always sovereign behind everything that happens.
01:29:41 so even when you know a superior basketball team destroys an inferior basketball team god was still
01:29:47 sovereign over that victory nevertheless um it unless god sets up those conditions so that it
01:29:53 will be obvious to all it cannot be missed that god intervened like with gideon or like with
01:29:59 hezekiah and um the the assyrians um i don't think there's a reason to by default reject natural
01:30:08 means that god has given to us right i'm about to backstab everything i just said about thomas but
01:30:13 aristotle's four causes are helpful because there's the formal cause and the efficient cause
01:30:17 right so if i were to ask you michael yes or no right did gravity cause the collapse of the world
01:30:21 trade center right well you could say no and you could say yes it was technically the plane that
01:30:25 did it but gravity would have been the formal reason that objects fall when their structures
01:30:29 are destroyed so there's formal causes behind things but then the actual mechanism that they're
01:30:34 accomplished and so i think the question is on that efficient cause when is there a time to retire
01:30:39 that at least i would say uh almost never sometimes god will bypass the efficient cause say step to
01:30:45 the side i'm going to wipe them out myself right but typically ordinarily especially in the gospel
01:30:49 age he makes use of prayer preaching worship discipleship all of those different things as
01:30:55 efficient causes real people uh accomplishing real things doing like a lot of the people we've
01:31:01 lauded they studied for decades to do the work of exegesis to do political thinking those should
01:31:07 always be held in high regard business education discipleship personal growth high regard recognizing
01:31:14 underneath it all is god giving the increase building the house uh giving you the means the
01:31:20 gifts the equipment to make it happen so underneath that god but we have a responsibility to work
01:31:25 not dependent as if it's oh it comes back to me lose win lose or draw god ultimately is the one
01:31:30 who gives the increase gives the victory uh but we we labor like when we pray that kingdom come
01:31:34 we're expected to i think you've said this to me to then go and and bring the kingdom through
01:31:39 through striving dependence on grace yes but actually working towards thy kingdom come right
01:31:45 last thing i'll say on that is um i i think that you know a lot of times i think about how did
01:31:50 these things happen you know so like you know people ask the um the question about are you
01:31:55 tomistic or are you theonomic and you know and i answered the question by saying you know giving
01:31:59 people a um a reminder of how things went down over the last three years how things happened like
01:32:05 this is why theonomy started boom ticking up um and people were coming into that position you know
01:32:10 because they're like we need a standard right like think like tom askel was a part of this that by
01:32:15 what standard documentary right that founders did you know so like it was during a time there was
01:32:20 this huge up wave of theonomic thought because because relativism reigned the day right and and
01:32:26 so um it ruled the day and so everybody was thinking you know we need a standard and it
01:32:30 needs to be immutable it needs to be god's standard of course of course it does and so
01:32:33 um that's that's what was on the scene yeah um but then unfortunately a lot of the og theonomists
01:32:40 not the new theonomists who are persuaded you know like we need to you know we need to stand
01:32:46 up to the regime and to you know uh the branch covidians and all you know and lockdowns and
01:32:51 and this and that a lot of new guys came into theonomy and i was one of them but a lot of the
01:32:55 old guys right um are you know as committed as they are to the reconstructionists they are equally
01:33:01 if not more committed to the post-war consensus and being a boomer and everything that comes with
01:33:05 it um including economics and so um that's you know so as as time pans out you know we start to
01:33:11 see okay you know what's actually going on so let me give you you know one more answer in terms of
01:33:17 pragmatism i think that's part of what's going on this idea of you know uh natural means versus
01:33:22 you know supernatural you know so that god gets the glory and doing miracles um one of the things
01:33:28 again giving you guys a reminder of like where we've been recent history talking about the reformed
01:33:33 church and some of the things that happened that were big shaping things um the rise of seeker
01:33:39 sensitive churches bill hybels and and uh you know and stephen furtick and and the laser lights and
01:33:45 the fog machines and the you know and the 20 minute tech talks and the you know and the hill
01:33:50 song you know and and uh concerts you know the lights turned down and all this kind of stuff
01:33:54 so so then what happened within the reformed church um a full-on you know uh assault against
01:34:01 pragmatism but here's part of the problem i didn't realize it either i had to realize this in
01:34:07 hindsight because i was i hopped on that too and i was like yeah pragmatism pragmatism is from the
01:34:11 pit of hell and it's the worst you know and and but really what what we were saying is um we believe
01:34:18 that the bible and the reformed tradition church history supports the regular principle of worship
01:34:23 aka no pragmatism in lord's day worship in the sphere of the church um we don't worship according
01:34:31 to the devices and inventions and preferences of men right it's not about what you want in worship
01:34:36 it's about what god wants in worship we worship in spirit that is with zeal and holy affection
01:34:41 and passion but also in truth that is according to what god has prescribed in his word so no
01:34:48 pragmatism no human pragmatism well this will get seekers this will you know win converse this no
01:34:55 no no worship is not for man it's not for the goats that's for dang sure it's not for the goats
01:35:00 it's not actually even for the sheep right first and foremost it's for god worship is for god the
01:35:06 sheep are always blessed because god never receives our worship without also in his generosity and his
01:35:11 uh his merciful condescension also reaching out his hand and feeding his sheep um so so the sheep
01:35:17 do get blessed in worship but first and foremost that worship is for god so what the question is
01:35:23 not how do i want to worship or and it's certainly not how do non-christians want to worship the
01:35:27 answer to that is they don't they don't um but but how does god want to be worshiped so that's
01:35:32 what was going on it was a church conversation as a church was becoming more and more carnal
01:35:38 right this is in the paul washer days and shocking youth message and these kind of
01:35:42 right you have to remember where we came from guys remember the history i'm this is one of my
01:35:47 gifts is reminding people how we got here um this was the rise of secret sensitive mega church
01:35:52 the reformed church was a bulwark against it praise god and but one of the tactics that we
01:35:57 utilized was making a full uh full attack on pragmatism but then what happened though is that
01:36:04 that then became um we we did that generally without probably as much specific specification
01:36:10 as we should have had should have been more specific and so then it just became an overall
01:36:15 general demonization of pragmatism that pragmatism has always been uh but i i can't i can't drive to
01:36:23 my house without being pragmatic i can't i can't put on my shoes in the morning without being
01:36:29 pragmatic and you certainly are not going to change the country without being pragmatic
01:36:34 pragmatism is a way of life pragmatism is uh it is inescapable it is strategy that's all it is
01:36:42 it's being shrewd it's being strategic it's being thoughtful pragmatism is being intentional
01:36:46 intentional it's it's being practical um so no we don't want any pragmatic strategies for lord's
01:36:53 day worship in the sphere of the church to try to win non non-believers over no we don't we don't
01:36:59 want that um but yes we we are going to have pragmatic approaches um in the realm of politics
01:37:06 and in the realm of culture or even evangelism or even evangelism yep yep and so um outside as
01:37:12 an individual christian outside of the church institute especially the lord's day worship so
01:37:16 back to the gideon question of um uh no we we are not um we do not need to purity spiral we do not
01:37:24 need to self-sabotage we do not need to make it harder on the lord do not put the lord your god
01:37:29 to the test yeah it was only right that gideon's army was narrowed down whittled down to 300 because
01:37:35 the lord did it if gideon had done it it would have been sin yeah it would have been foolishness
01:37:39 it would have been putting the lord to the test um so yeah all right well thank you guys for
01:37:45 tuning in and we hope to see you again next week