The NXR Podcast - October 16, 2024


THE LIVESTREAM - The Many Blessings Of Colonialism

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE INTERVIEW - Biblical Giants Were Way Bigger Than You Think - ICYMI with @hauntedcosmos_ THE SERMON - Men Sin, But Devils Tempt | The 7th Commandment

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 10 minutes

Words per minute

180.49

Word count

23,486

Sentence count

591

Harmful content

Misogyny

15

sentences flagged

Toxicity

42

sentences flagged

Hate speech

122

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Pastor Andrew Isker and I discuss our new series, The History, the Scripture, the Bible, the Big Shebang, the whole big shebang. This series is a nine-part series exploring the history of the Bible and the Bible in relation to the modern world.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it.
00:00:04 It's annoying.
00:00:05 Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm so that
00:00:12 our podcast shows up on more people's news feeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries
00:00:20 aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:27 You're doing a great job.
00:00:28 We've got several hundred reviews so far, but we'd like to reach a thousand reviews by the end of this year, the year of our Lord, 2024.
00:00:37 If you haven't left a review yet, take a moment and help us achieve our goal.
00:00:41 In recent decades, a growing course of voices has attempted to vilify Western colonialism, painting it as a system of pure exploitation, cruelty, and oppression.
00:00:52 Figures such as Christopher Columbus, once hailed for their exploratory and pioneering spirit
00:00:59 Have seen their reputations tarnished by claims of atrocities
00:01:03 But was Western colonialism a pure and unmitigated evil?
00:01:08 No 0.55
00:01:09 In fact, it was a largely Christian impulse and endeavor 1.00
00:01:13 And the world is much better for it 0.99
00:01:16 And if the gospel is going to spread across the entire globe 1.00
00:01:20 Christian nations may need to colonize un-Christian nations again. 1.00
00:01:26 Tune in now. 1.00
00:01:34 All right, I'm going to be honest with you.
00:01:37 This one, it's going behind the paywall.
00:01:39 It's not something we typically do.
00:01:40 In fact, thus far, every single piece of content that we've produced here at Right Response Ministries
00:01:46 has eventually been made available to you for free publicly.
00:01:51 This is an exception, though.
00:01:53 First two episodes will launch publicly.
00:01:55 The next seven episodes will exclusively be available
00:01:58 for our members at patreon.com forward slash
00:02:02 Right Response Ministries.
00:02:04 Why?
00:02:05 Well, I'll give you the reason.
00:02:07 Because right now, the vast majority of evangelical Christians
00:02:11 are not ready for the conversation that we have in these episodes.
00:02:15 And frankly, you and I both know that many of those individuals are actually bad faith
00:02:21 actors who will seek to slice it up, take us out of context, put it out there for the
00:02:27 world wide web in order to discredit this ministry and see to it that we're canceled.
00:02:33 And honestly, I'm not willing to let that happen.
00:02:36 What conversation am I even talking about?
00:02:38 I'm talking about nine-part series between myself and Pastor Andrew Isker on Israel.
00:02:46 The history, the scripture, the whole big shebang.
00:02:50 Check it out at patreon.com forward slash right response ministries.
00:02:55 You can get every single episode available now, all of it ad-free.
00:03:00 And here's a couple clips just to whet your appetite.
00:03:03 And so our entire moral framework is based around 1930 and 1940. 0.83
00:03:06 and every bad thing is Hitler.
00:03:10 Every failure to confront the bad thing is Neville Chamberlain. 0.73
00:03:15 And Saddam Hussein, Hitler.
00:03:17 Vladimir Putin, Hitler.
00:03:19 Donald Trump, Hitler.
00:03:20 That's the only moral framework that we have that is operable. 0.52
00:03:25 So the moment that a young man crosses the aisle
00:03:27 and the don't-believe-your-lying-eyes rhetoric doesn't work any longer
00:03:32 and he's just noticed too much
00:03:35 because it really is that blatantly obvious.
00:03:36 And he has nowhere else to go.
00:03:37 And he crosses the aisle.
00:03:38 Well, the moment he crosses the aisle,
00:03:39 there's no reasonable, wise, mature leader over there.
00:03:42 You would just have the guys on the TV telling them,
00:03:45 this is what the Bible says.
00:03:47 You have to believe this, right?
00:03:48 On the radio, the Christian radio stations,
00:03:50 you'd only hear those guys preaching that particular thing.
00:03:55 When that is actually,
00:03:57 when you look at all of church history,
00:03:59 that's the minority view, a tiny minority view.
00:04:02 the rest of theological history in the church is that, you know, is the kind of stuff that we're
00:04:10 saying. Yeah, this one's a banger. Again, go to patreon.com forward slash Right Response Ministries
00:04:17 to get all nine parts ad-free right now, available today.
00:04:26 All right, welcome, gentlemen. Good to see you again.
00:04:28 Another Wednesday afternoon. Glad to be here. I just want to be the first one to belatedly wish
00:04:34 you all a happy Indigenous Peoples Day on Monday. I'm sorry I forgot to text that to you.
00:04:39 No, no. Happy Columbus Day. So that's kind of the springboard for our topic today. Before we
00:04:43 get started, we do want to encourage and ask you all to like the video. And if you have not
00:04:49 subscribed, please do. That really does help things out. And so please subscribe, please like the
00:04:55 video click the bell if you want to be notified every single time we put out new content and of
00:05:00 course uh chats are welcome helps boost it and we like seeing your comments and even you know we
00:05:04 like following along the the little skiffs and debates that you all are having privately in the
00:05:09 chat amongst each other so and if you put questions in and our we try in our third segment we do three
00:05:14 segments and by the third segment we try to um engage with you guys with the chat absolutely
00:05:19 Yep. All right. So the topic on hand today is, was colonialism an unmitigated evil?
00:05:25 Our answer in the cold open was no. So how do we, how do we substantiate that claim? What do we
00:05:30 want to say about colonialism? And like so many things in the West, there is always a shade of
00:05:38 truth, right? Because you can't tell outright lies. You have to tell 90% lies. And so, yes,
00:05:44 of course, there were abuses, people died, there were, you know, slaughters and things like that
00:05:51 throughout history. But the point is, the point is, those things were already going on in a lot
00:05:56 of the countries and nations and peoples that we're going to talk about. And so our goal with
00:06:01 this episode is to talk about how actually colonization, Christian colonization, which
00:06:06 historically was different than pure conquest, the record for most of history, for a lot of
00:06:12 history, not all of it, but a lot of history had been a strong nation emerges or a strong empire
00:06:17 emerges, and it engages in conquest, right? It engages in going in and just taking over,
00:06:25 leaving nothing in its track. And colonization, in the Western sense, was actually something of
00:06:32 a novel idea, where it was a desire to go in to acquire resources, but also to spread
00:06:39 civilization, proper governance, proper order, proper social structure for a variety of reasons,
00:06:45 whether it was so that those nations could be more productive and produce more goods that
00:06:50 then could be brought back to Europe, or because of Christian missionary endeavors as well,
00:06:54 they wanted to instill some sort of moral order, godly society among other nations as they
00:07:01 believed they were commanded to through the Great Commission. And so colonialism, Western
00:07:05 colonialism as it developed, 1600s, kind of, 1600s, 1700s especially, I think England's first
00:07:12 colony was 1604, Barbados, I think it was, a first official colony. So coming 1600s into the 1700s,
00:07:20 Europe spreading out, our claim is that it was largely a positive force for good in the world,
00:07:26 and it was, in many ways, the product of a Christian mindset and a Christian impulse.
00:07:30 One of the things that we want to do here at the beginning is one of the claims that is made about colonialism is that these peoples who were oppressed or taken advantage of or harmed would have been totally fine.
00:07:45 They were living this kind of idyllic, Edenic lifestyle on their own.
00:07:50 They were one with nature.
00:07:51 They were in harmony with each other and with their neighbors.
00:07:55 They had good social order.
00:07:56 It was kind of this golden age of indigenous peoples around the world, and then all of a sudden, the colonizers show up, and just because they hated everything that they saw, they just torched it all, right? 0.90
00:08:11 And so one of the things that Wes did was he looked into a couple little vignettes and stories about what life was actually like in some of the places that the colonials, the colonists, went to, and why it prompted them in some cases to say, we actually have a duty to these people to set up some sort of order because horrific things are happening here that we as Christian people cannot countenance, we cannot excuse, and now that we've seen it, we can't turn a blind eye to.
00:08:40 So the backdrop of colonialism was not peaceful, harmonious living.
00:08:46 In a lot of places, it was really horrific and uncivilized and barbaric behavior that
00:08:52 Wes is going to take us through a couple examples of that.
00:08:55 Yeah.
00:08:56 Just a warning.
00:08:57 I'm not going to try to be too graphic with it, but these are pretty horrific stories
00:09:00 for the next five minutes if you have young kids.
00:09:03 Just be aware.
00:09:03 Maybe screen it before.
00:09:04 I just wanted to say, too, the Bible provides this framework and this foundation.
00:09:10 We know that from scriptures that men are wicked, that bound up in the heart is all types of malice and hatred and violence.
00:09:17 And so using a Christian anthropology, even without the stories, you could know that unless the gospel comes to a land and doesn't work upon it,
00:09:24 that what you're going to encounter there is not peace and harmony, man loving his fellow man horizontally, man worshiping God truly.
00:09:31 No, men are wicked since the fall, and it's the gospel and it's grace that restore and perfect nature.
00:09:37 So I'm going to read just two stories.
00:09:38 There are hundreds from here in the U.S. and the native tribes, from Africa, from the Far East.
00:09:44 But I'm just going to read two.
00:09:45 So this first one, this is what in present-day Nigeria.
00:09:51 Benin City lies to the west of the Niger and is near the sprawling delta of that mighty river. 0.99
00:09:56 These days, Benin is just another ramshackle Nigerian town filled with mud-walled houses and tiny shops. 0.98
00:10:02 But Benin is different from the others in its history. 0.97
00:10:04 All of southern Nigeria was a land of oppression, terror, and fiendish cruelty, and of slave trades. 0.96
00:10:10 But Benin surpassed them all as, quote, the city of blood. 0.90
00:10:14 Hundreds of people were tortured to death regularly in Benin's juju rituals.
00:10:19 These blood-stained orgies went on for centuries and were only halted in 1897 when the British captured the city.
00:10:25 For the record, the reason they captured that city was because they had sent an envoy to enforce a treaty of 250 people.
00:10:30 they're mostly unarmed and the natives there fell upon them murdered all but two that managed to
00:10:35 escape so the british had to come back in 1987 with about 5 000 men and actually retake the city
00:10:40 and avenge the couple hundred men that had died and been murdered one man who entered the city
00:10:46 in the british expedition gave this description altars were covered with streams of dried human
00:10:51 blood the stench of which was awful huge pits 40 to 50 feet deep were found filled with human
00:10:57 bodies, dead and dying, and a few wretched captives were rescued alive. Everywhere sacrificial trees
00:11:03 on which the corpses of the latest victims, everywhere on each path were newly sacrificed
00:11:07 corpses. On the principal sacrificial tree, facing the main fate of the kingdom, the king's compound,
00:11:13 there were two crucified bodies. It is said that the crucifixion idea was all that remained of a
00:11:18 Portuguese attempt early in the 16th century to convert Benin from Juju to Christianity.
00:11:23 A Portuguese seafarer had visited Benin in 1485, and the first white man known to have done so.
00:11:29 Missionaries were sent out later, but the mission eventually had to be recalled because so many missionaries died.
00:11:34 Fetish worship and juju rituals returned, and in time, Christianity's only permanent solution was to give the Benin the crucifixion idea for its mass ritualistic murders.
00:11:47 This is a letter notes on Nigeria to a journal, the Institute of Current World Affairs. 0.90
00:11:52 So you're saying that the only Christian influence that survived, that they were like, yeah, we'll take that, was A New Way to Kill People? 0.86
00:11:57 A New Way to Kill People. 0.99
00:11:58 So a slew of missionaries went over there. 0.98
00:12:01 Many were killed.
00:12:01 And they did take ideas from them.
00:12:03 And that was crucifixion is a particularly violent way for us to put our own fellow countrymen to death. 1.00
00:12:13 So that's Nigeria. 1.00
00:12:14 That's across the ocean. 1.00
00:12:15 Here in America.
00:12:16 So this is from a book, Ancient America's Great City on the Mississippi.
00:12:21 Cahokia was a large Indian city located near where St. Louis, Missouri is today.
00:12:26 There, the natives practiced ritual human sacrifice in and around 950 AD.
00:12:30 This would be about 1,000 years after Christ.
00:12:33 You can visit the Cahokia Mound still today.
00:12:36 The ritual sacrifice in Cahokia began with a selection process where certain individuals, including teenage girls, were chosen for their symbolic significance.
00:12:44 These girls, perhaps virgins or of noble lineage, represented purity and fertility, qualities highly valued in ancient sacrificial rites.
00:12:51 In Mound 72, so a specific mound here in these burial hills, archaeologists unearthed a mass grave of 272 teenage girls and young women.
00:13:00 The bodies of the women, for the most part, showed no signs of blunt force trauma.
00:13:04 They were also all not buried at once.
00:13:06 Scholars estimate that based on how they were buried, at least one group of girls was sacrificed every generation,
00:13:12 meaning there must have been something in their tradition that required a large number of young women to be sacrificed periodically.
00:13:18 The age and state of the women suggested that their sacrifice was a ritual surrounding fertility.
00:13:22 Given the position of some fingers digging in the soil,
00:13:24 it is suggested that some victims might have been buried alive or suffocated.
00:13:30 One thing that struck me just reading that, there's wickedness and there's violence, 1.00
00:13:35 but there's also stupidity. 1.00
00:13:37 So this is a tradition supposed to for fertility. 1.00
00:13:40 Lord, please, the gods, please bless us with children and mighty warriors. 0.78
00:13:44 and to bring that about what we're going to do is we're going to take young women and we're going 0.99
00:13:49 to kill them so they can't have any children right like that's what sin and demon worship like this 1.00
00:13:53 is what this is that's what sin and demon worship does to people doesn't just make them uh violent 1.00
00:13:57 and and hateful and spiteful it makes you dumb they do dumb things like that right sin yeah 0.96
00:14:04 there's always a correlation throughout the scripture especially the proverbs between sin 0.98
00:14:07 the wicked person and the foolish person and likewise also you know the righteous person and
00:14:13 the one who is wise and um and and so there certainly is a correlation that uh as a person
00:14:21 as an individual or especially over generations with the society as a whole give themselves over
00:14:26 and over further and further to wickedness um you know even romans chapter one um towards the end
00:14:32 uh it culminates you know it's this progression of being handed over sovereignly by god
00:14:36 man choosing wickedness god handing him over to further wickedness him choosing that further
00:14:41 wickedness, God hand him over to even further wickedness. And it culminates in being inventors
00:14:47 of evil is one of the phrases that the Apostle Paul uses in Romans 1. So I look at that as
00:14:53 that, you know, that there's a sense in which sin no longer satiates. And so you're trying to
00:15:01 invent even higher degrees of wickedness and evil in order to satiate your appetite for wickedness.
00:15:09 And then, you know, another phrase that's used in Romans 1 is God handed them over to a debased mind.
00:15:15 And the idea that you could have a brilliant mind that's brilliant in terms of intellect, but completely debased in terms of morals, I think is a misnomer.
00:15:27 I think that eventually one side does win out and the other side will follow.
00:15:33 So eventually, over time, a person who is completely perverse and a person who is murderous and filled with malice and hungry for blood, that person is not going to be brilliant. 1.00
00:15:52 That person is going to be—that perversion and that wickedness is going to warp the entirety of his mind, and sin really does make you stupid. 1.00
00:16:00 But the last thing that I want to say on that point, though, is so there is a stupidity in murdering children to get children, right? 1.00
00:16:08 So it's certainly illogical. 1.00
00:16:09 So there is a stupidity there. 1.00
00:16:12 At the same time, though, I want to say that I have no doubt that there really was stupidity among savages who were murderous and sinful. 0.99
00:16:23 But I also think, to be fair, that there's also an argument to be made for it not all being stupidity, but that part of the reason why human sacrifices and these kinds of things occurred is because they really were worshipping gods, lowercase g gods. 0.98
00:16:41 And I think that, you know, with the expansion and culmination of Christendom and the Christian gospel, moving from, you know, Jerusalem to Antioch and then from Antioch to Ethiopia and these different places, and then eventually this massive expansion of Christianity in the West and in Europe, I think that, you know, real demonic powers, the old gods, would flee.
00:17:07 i think of you know i've said it before but jesus who gives it's not really a parable it's really
00:17:13 more of just a description of what happens in the spirit realm he says that you know if if somebody
00:17:18 is exercised a demon is exercised from a person uh that it's utilizing this individual as a host
00:17:24 and the demon is cast out it first goes through arid places or some translations say waterless
00:17:29 places and so it's um it's traveling through the air and but it's looking for a host just like
00:17:35 the demons that were cast out and said, send us into the pigs. They prefer, you know, to be in
00:17:40 a person, but they'd rather take pigs than being in arid places. And so, and there's a lot of
00:17:46 arguments to be made for, you know, what is a demon? Is it a fallen angel versus are these
00:17:51 Nephilim spirits that didn't go above or below because they weren't entirely human? And so 0.89
00:17:56 they're trapped in the world and they were once embodied, but they died out in the flood. And so
00:18:01 they want to be embodied again. And so being in arid places, going through the air in waterless
00:18:07 places without a host, without a body is torture for them. So they want to have a host. But the
00:18:12 point is this, Jesus says, if you cast a demon out, it goes through arid places. But eventually,
00:18:18 if the person now empty, the demon is gone, if the house, that person, that person's self is
00:18:25 swept clean and put in order, but it's not filled ultimately with the Spirit of God, then the demon
00:18:30 will come back and not only himself, but he'll come back, find the house, swept clean and put
00:18:34 it in order and bring with him seven other friends, seven other demonic hosts, even worse
00:18:39 than himself. And so my point is, I think that that's true, the words of Christ on an individual
00:18:44 basis, but I think it's also true collectively. And so as whole nations and whole societies and
00:18:49 cultures began to worship the triune God and began to apply all of Christ to all of life
00:18:55 in every single facet of their culture, many, many demons were driven out. I think many,
00:19:02 many demons were driven out. But the question is, where did they go? Even these demons with Jesus,
00:19:08 they appealed to him and say, have you come to torture us before the appointed time? And Jesus
00:19:12 doesn't really answer, but I think implicitly we can tell that the answer is no, that there is an
00:19:17 appointed time and that that time is not yet. And so they have to go somewhere. So when demons are
00:19:23 uh expose uh um from you know a whole society or country uh they i i believe they actually
00:19:32 geographically travel somewhere else and i think that many uh many demons uh went even across
00:19:37 oceans to the americas and so i think that these people or down you know south to um to uh you
00:19:45 know certain african sub-saharan african nations and nigeria and these places and they spread out
00:19:50 And so when these places were eventually colonized by Christians bringing the Christian gospel, I believe that there were, very likely, there were demonic manifestations.
00:20:01 And just like the demons reacted when Jesus was coming or the apostles were coming, I have no doubt that demons began to, you know, their hosts foam at the mouth a little bit as they see Christopher Columbus coming in the name of the Lord. 0.85
00:20:16 With crosses and banners.
00:20:17 proclaiming the christian gospel that they you know and so i so my point is one sin does make 1.00
00:20:24 you stupid uh so stupid that you would you would be your your logic would be completely you know 1.00
00:20:29 reversed and opposite that like we're going to kill children young teenage girls in order to 1.00
00:20:33 get more children on the other hand uh there is an argument to be made that oh maybe it wasn't 0.99
00:20:37 stupid maybe it actually worked maybe there really were these these demon gods um that actually had 0.81
00:20:44 power some power over fertility and actually would grant the people's request if they if the people 1.00
00:20:50 gave them blood and uh but i in either case whether it's sin making them stupid or whether it's uh 0.85
00:20:56 being in in covenant and and packs blood packs with demons uh both options i think we can all 0.96
00:21:03 agree are pretty bad yeah we talked about before but it's funny the two drugs that would be most
00:21:08 associated with south america north america indigenous peoples would be a wayahaska and
00:21:13 peyote which are both psychedelics i would believe i think you would say the same thing
00:21:18 that in the psychedelics realm individuals who take them in and consume them and have these
00:21:22 rituals they're not just in their head only they're communing with spiritual realities and
00:21:27 so you have two broad obviously within different tribes there's differences but south america
00:21:32 north america inhabited by hundreds of years by people that consumed these drugs in ritual
00:21:36 communed with demons, with benevolent spirits, and those spirits giving to them their hatred for
00:21:42 the image of God. Satan hates the image of God in man. Demons hate the image of God in man. That's
00:21:47 why Molech demanded these ancient gods, throw your children into the fire, consume them. Because 1.00
00:21:53 in every child and in every human being, you can see, in a sense, this is what the scriptures say,
00:21:59 what God is like. You can see his justice and his rule and his glory and his magnanimity.
00:22:04 so you can see all that in the image of god these demons hate it and so then these cultures that
00:22:08 communed with them with ritual and dance and psychedelic and all those things to your point
00:22:13 not at all unthinkable that part of that communion part of that the instructions part of the this is 0.98
00:22:19 what you should do included massacre as many of your people as possible if face and destroy the 0.95
00:22:25 image of god as much as you can with the violence that you're capable of partaking in yep and it was 0.95
00:22:30 also the case i think of um when the spanish conquistadors discovered the aztec empire right
00:22:39 and the aztec empire had developed it was it was a huge massive empire right and they weren't
00:22:45 necessarily killing themselves but they had totally enslaved the people around them right
00:22:51 and there were ritual days where the line of human sacrifices was over a mile long down the temple
00:22:58 And when Cortez and some of these conquistadors saw this,
00:23:02 actually some of the tribes that had been subdued
00:23:05 and were being exterminated by the Aztecs,
00:23:08 they pled with the Spanish conquistadors,
00:23:11 please save us from this.
00:23:13 We are being destroyed.
00:23:15 And so they actually saw it as their Christian duty 0.69
00:23:18 to end that extermination of those people. 0.67
00:23:21 I mean, can you imagine a mile?
00:23:23 Like think about a mile long, right?
00:23:24 A mile long of one person lined up after another, after another for human sacrifice.
00:23:31 I think one of the legends, or one of the bloodiest data they recorded was something
00:23:34 like 80,000.
00:23:36 That's the equivalent of like three times the size of your town, Hutto.
00:23:39 It's almost more than half of Georgetown where I live. 0.98
00:23:42 An entire medium-sized U.S. town sacrificed by these people.
00:23:48 So one of the points that we're trying to make here is even before we look at 0.97
00:23:52 whether colonialism was a Christian impulse. Historians, and this guy Bruce Gilley that I
00:24:00 kind of relied on for the article this week, he points out that just, he's not a believer,
00:24:05 but just from a non-Christian kind of objective point of view, many of the colonial structures
00:24:12 of governance and rule were more fair, more efficient, more productive, and more fruitful
00:24:21 than the systems of rule that existed in those places before the colonizers arrived.
00:24:29 And many, he has a really interesting phrase.
00:24:32 He says that colonization spread as much through the push of the colonizers
00:24:38 as much as the pull of those being colonized.
00:24:41 They were in many cases welcoming, please come here.
00:24:45 So the way that it kind of initially set up was the British would go
00:24:49 and they would establish a fort just for trading and they would build a fort with walls and it
00:24:55 would be safe they would have it armed and then they would start to trade and they had to have
00:24:59 it secured and armed because goods would be coming in um valuable goods that they were trading would
00:25:03 be going out but many of the people especially consider india who are of the lower caste started 0.97
00:25:09 moving towards these forts because their life as the lowest caste in india was horrific and they 0.99
00:25:15 would come and and the british would offer them jobs and it may not have been a glamorous job it 0.99
00:25:19 was better than what they had before right they would offer them security they weren't going to
00:25:23 be killed right they were going to be fed and so the the the western impulse was welcomed into a
00:25:31 lot of these lands as much as it was pushed into the lands by the west right and even then it 0.99
00:25:37 started to transform society so people who were part of the lowest caste in india all of a sudden
00:25:42 were treated. And that's one of the things that even a secular historian noticed. He said,
00:25:48 Western European colonization differed from previous conquests because it offered, 1.00
00:25:55 not immediately, but the hope that eventually those barbaric pagan nations could become 0.99
00:26:02 civilized. And so they saw, even in the Africans or the Indians or the indigenous Americans, 0.99
00:26:08 maybe some in fact in the 1700s jonathan edwards wrote that he that he hoped that centuries down
00:26:15 the line um great works of theology would be written in africa right and so there was this
00:26:22 there's this western colonialism perspective that said okay there is savagery there is barbarism
00:26:28 and that's the case right now but but over time we are going to work to bring order structure
00:26:34 religion and and uh stability to these places and uh gilly talks about um western colonialism
00:26:41 always had as its desire preparation for proper self-government which i thought was really
00:26:48 interesting preparation for proper self-government because then they could be trade partners they
00:26:54 could be allies they could be you know a lot of uh just just from a purely non-christian point of
00:26:59 view, the Western colonial experiment and push was markedly different than what we had seen
00:27:06 throughout all of history. Yeah. I was gonna say, compared to the gospel accounts where Rome has
00:27:12 occupied Judea and the broader region, you don't see anything in there about Rome coming in. It's
00:27:17 like, you know, we want you to get to a point where you're self-governed and you're running
00:27:19 your own things. It's, we're here. We're gonna crush you with taxes. We're gonna make your own
00:27:24 people tax collectors to sell you out. And that's really all we're interested in. You're a province
00:27:28 that we are going to manage we're going to put down slave revolt if they show up we're going to 0.99
00:27:32 tax the living daylights out of you that's really it we have no no design for your improvement we 1.00
00:27:38 have no religious program for you um you're just another annexed colony like alexandria all like
00:27:44 these great kingdoms that's that was the extent of their care for the provinces that they conquered
00:27:49 right yeah you're a tax foreign um okay well let's go to our first commercial break and then we'll
00:27:55 come right back all right that's it guys i tried to warn you the time has finally arrived our early
00:28:01 bird pricing is gone but don't despair we've gone above and beyond to make this conference affordable
00:28:07 to all so even now it's only 170 bucks for an adult it's cheap for teenagers and free for kids
00:28:15 what am i talking about well i'm talking about the christ is king conference how to defeat trash
00:28:20 world. It's happening April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, the year of our Lord, 2025. That's a Thursday,
00:28:27 Friday, Saturday, three full days, jam-packed with eight main sessions, three panels, and an
00:28:33 extraordinarily based lineup of speakers. We've got Steve Dace, Orrin McIntyre, Andrew Iskert,
00:28:39 David Reese, Stephen Wolf, Eric Kahn, John Harris, Aidy Robles, Dan Burkholder, Ben Garrett, Dusty
00:28:47 Devers, the Christian Prince himself, and yours truly, Joel Webber. Sign up today. Don't miss
00:28:53 this conference. And I'll give you a little bit of a secret here. There's a couple more potential
00:28:58 speakers in the wings. Haven't completely confirmed yet, so I cannot disclose, but I'll say this.
00:29:05 If it happens, it's going to blow your mind. So register at rightresponseconference.com. Again,
00:29:10 that's rightresponseconference.com. Register today. Are you a Christian struggling to find
00:29:15 companies that align with your values and beliefs well then squirrely joe's has you covered for all
00:29:21 your coffee needs all of their coffee is hand selected and roasted fresh every day by a family
00:29:27 of fellow believers try them out and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing that your
00:29:32 investment supports a company committed to following god's teachings and upholding truth
00:29:38 and righteousness ensuring that your hard-earned money contributes to the growth of god's kingdom
00:29:44 Stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans who support evil.
00:29:48 Right Response listeners have access to an exclusive deal.
00:29:52 Your first bag of coffee is free.
00:29:55 All you have to do is cover the shipping.
00:29:57 So head on over to squirrelyjoes.com forward slash Right Response.
00:30:02 Again, that's squirrelyjoes.com forward slash Right Response
00:30:06 to claim your first free bag of coffee today. 0.97
00:30:11 Visit thewordsoap.com today.
00:30:13 again that's the word soap calm everyone needs so so wash yourself in the word
00:30:23 all right real quick welcome back do us a favor give us a thumbs up for the
00:30:29 video that means like the video as much as you want comment in the chat leave
00:30:34 us questions we'll try to get to that in the third segment if you're tuning in
00:30:37 right now we're in the second segment we'll try to address your questions
00:30:40 maybe a little bit this segment but definitely the third segment so leave comments that helps
00:30:44 the algorithm give us a like and subscribe to the channel a lot of you guys are new and you
00:30:49 started listening but subscribe to the channel um we appreciate that that way you don't just
00:30:53 get the 12 second clip you know a week from now you can get a full two hours of you know
00:30:58 absolutely controversial content you know a whole week and a half in advance so all right
00:31:02 uh one of the one of the comments in the chat a bit ago was um who started the narrative of
00:31:09 European colonialism as oppressors? What was their motive? I'm certainly not an expert. I did some
00:31:13 research for this week's article. But it came up actually largely after World War II. And there was
00:31:22 a couple things that I discovered as I researched. One was this growing sense of an idyllic state of
00:31:31 nature that had existed before the West showed up on the scene. So the idea that what the West was
00:31:37 doing was inherently bad and that what existed before them was inherently good. And so kind of
00:31:43 this really a not historical idea that the West had caused all the evils in these places where
00:31:53 they had colonies. Secondly, there was just a fatigue in Europe after the wars. And so when
00:31:59 people and scholars and a lot of the Marxists began to say, well, you know, the problem is
00:32:06 colonialism. And so foreign powers, Western imperial powers need to divest themselves
00:32:13 of their colonies. There wasn't a lot of reserve or stamina left among some of the European nations
00:32:21 to say, no, no, no, hold on. Let's have an accurate telling here. There was just a fatigue,
00:32:25 a tiredness from the two world wars. And there wasn't a lot of really even kind of moral fiber
00:32:31 left for them to try to defend their record. And so the decolonialism movement began around that
00:32:39 time, and there was a push very quickly for England and other European powers to divest
00:32:45 themselves of the colonies. My question, though, is why that push? What's the incentive? What's
00:32:51 the motive for Marxists or whoever to say, let's stop? Well, you notice that the Marxists were not
00:32:58 returning those countries to a sort of native,
00:33:02 primitive, pre-Western form of government.
00:33:04 They're importing a Marxist government there, right?
00:33:07 And so if we want to get rid, if we want to spread Marxism
00:33:11 to Vietnam or to, you know, Korea or wherever it is,
00:33:17 well, we've got to get rid of the imperial powers there 0.71
00:33:19 because the imperial powers are Western, Christian, etc.
00:33:22 I see.
00:33:23 And so I don't know if that was all of it.
00:33:25 I'm not well-versed in it.
00:33:26 So part of the motive being that we need you out so we can come in?
00:33:31 Yes.
00:33:31 Okay.
00:33:32 Yes.
00:33:32 That makes sense.
00:33:33 And the irony there, of course, we all see it, is that we're merely importing an even worse Western idea upon the world, which is Marxism.
00:33:41 Right.
00:33:41 The really sad record, and maybe, Wes, you can talk about Rhodesia for a moment here, too, but as the pressure was mounting and organizations like the UN and other organizations, League of Nations, were trying to get rid of the colonies
00:33:56 and trying to kind of give them back over to self-government,
00:33:59 there's a record of many of them asking the British or the Belgian people,
00:34:09 please don't leave yet.
00:34:10 We are not ready.
00:34:11 If you leave, our nation is going to descend into chaos and insanity again. 1.00
00:34:16 It makes me think of Afghanistan. 0.99
00:34:18 A hundred percent, yeah. 0.59
00:34:20 And so I guess maybe even if everyone could have agreed at that time
00:34:25 that colonialism is bad and that the colonies need to be given back even if that was agreed
00:34:32 upon which it wasn't a numerous um colonies and nations third world nations were saying we're not
00:34:40 ready yet if you leave there's going to be nothing to hold society together there's going to be
00:34:45 nothing to hold uh violence or exploitation at bay and in check and in fact that did happen
00:34:51 in many of the in many of the colonies yeah and i it seems like to me it seems like um because
00:34:58 part of you can start to think okay well we don't want to have forever wars and i completely agree
00:35:03 with that um but there these things just take so much more time than we're willing to admit like
00:35:10 so like earlier you said that you know a lot of the western impulse uh with you know colonization
00:35:15 was well we don't want to just rule uh as you know some province of of you know the monarch
00:35:22 overseas indefinitely but we're actually our our our long-term aim is that you would become
00:35:27 self-governing and um and i think that i think that that's good but i think we just forget how
00:35:35 long it takes that's not a that's not a one political term project that's a generations
00:35:39 and centuries project exactly because like that's it's something that um well you know like i i
00:35:46 talked for like an hour with stephen wolf today and uh and we were talking about you know um
00:35:51 the constitutional republic and our you know our thoughts and ideas of what would happen you know
00:35:56 in the near you know future for america you know here with our country and we were just we both
00:36:02 agreed that you know we think constitutional republics are great you know if you can have it
00:36:06 um but uh it's like you know you kind of like it's um it's like a husband and wife you know
00:36:13 that have toddlers you know and everything in the house you know breaks you know like
00:36:17 if you have like nice you know uh vase or something that's on a coffee table that's low
00:36:22 you know and your two-year-old can get and it's like you know you look at each other and it's like
00:36:26 we um why can't we have nice things and the answer is um you can't have nice things in about
00:36:32 five to ten years yeah like uh you can't have nice things right now because you have your house is
00:36:36 filled with children right well our house is as a nation is filled with children yeah um we are a
00:36:43 country of degenerates and uh a constitutional republic is a nice thing and uh and uh children
00:36:50 um aren't ready for nice things right so right now it's like i i would love to have a constitutional
00:36:55 republic we used to have one we don't anymore right and anybody who thinks well we you guys
00:36:59 are advocating that we move away from a constitutional republic you friend you you just
00:37:04 you need to wake the heck up what what nobody is advocating for for moving it we're saying the
00:37:09 constitution has been shredded already right and we didn't do that the the christian right did not
00:37:15 do that the left has done that that has been done i mean you can argue that's been done 130 years
00:37:20 ago but certainly since the 60s and the civil rights movement read age of entitlement by
00:37:25 christopher caldwell there's so many different things that you can look at the constitution
00:37:28 is dead it's dead um not because i want it to be dead i love the constitution i really do i mean
00:37:35 the first amendment i think even the first amendment is fine because the first word is
00:37:38 congress and and all you have to do is you don't have to revise that you just get back to authorial
00:37:43 intent i'd like to at most i would like to adopt um a christian preamble like like the apostles
00:37:49 creed to the constitution and some of the latter amendments not the bill of rights not the first
00:37:54 10 um i i do think that we need to have a discussion about some of those um other than that
00:38:00 constitution is great i think i honestly think other than the bible which is inspired by god
00:38:05 it's one of the best documents ever written so we we all love the constitution we're just willing
00:38:11 to call a spade a spade and say that um these united states uh the constitution is um it's
00:38:17 it's fitting that it's in a museum because that's really all it is it's just something that people
00:38:21 look at it's a relic but it's not it's not uh actively being adhered to not not any longer
00:38:27 there's all these three-letter agencies and all these all these different things that started
00:38:31 either in the cold war or in the 60s with the civil rights movement all these different things
00:38:36 that um have have been placed over the constitution right because it's too obvious to just you know
00:38:42 torch the constitution you know then then you would have some pushback from america but
00:38:45 instead what they did was you put you put a lens on top of it then a lens on top of the lens and
00:38:50 then a lens on top of that lens and that and by the time you get done with it you you know you're
00:38:54 reading the constitution and and what was once beautiful and christian um and now now is
00:39:01 interpreted to say the very opposite of what it was intended to say and so uh constitutional
00:39:05 republics are great but back to my conversation with steven wolf the point was um we think that
00:39:10 america like just sprung up uh naturally from the soil or something like it just like it just
00:39:16 materialized out of the ether you know just like in a vacuum you know there was nothing there and
00:39:21 then and then god said let there be america right and there was america you know and and
00:39:26 benjamin franklin you know and and john adams and uh that's not how it worked like so you think of
00:39:31 like well constitutional republic you know there are guys on the right who are entertaining the
00:39:36 idea of a monarchy okay well let's just for a second can we just recognize america didn't come
00:39:42 out of the ether america uh came largely from great britain which means america was i would
00:39:49 argue a constitutional representative uh republic is the high watermark for a society and uh and
00:39:57 what was required to get there 1500 years of monarchy yeah 1600 that the the british isles
00:40:03 that christianity lands begins to establish yeah and and i'm arguing all the way back to
00:40:08 constantine but but you know but you can argue from uh alfred you know king alfred so so then
00:40:12 in that case like six seven hundred years uh but no matter how how you slice it um if i if i'm
00:40:18 arguing from constantine then again at the founding of america it wouldn't be 1500 it'd be you know
00:40:22 1100 1200 but the point is a millennium you know like give or take maybe a little less maybe a
00:40:28 little more but you know without being too technical on the numbers the point is it's not
00:40:32 decades and and it's arguably not even a couple centuries but it's it's a millennium so how long
00:40:39 does it take for people uh how long does it in in a home with a family how long does it take to have
00:40:45 a vase on the coffee table you know that's expensive and nice um five to ten years you know
00:40:49 like like you got to wait till you're out of the little years with the toddlers that are running
00:40:54 around and um and then you can have nice things well what about uh societies as a whole how long
00:40:59 does it take to have nice things and the constitutional republic is i would say is a
00:41:03 nice thing um i like it i just you know but how long does it take um approximately a thousand
00:41:08 years i i would say joel the 700 the only caveat there that i would add is the first person to
00:41:15 develop a scientific theory studies his whole life too and then you can teach it to high schoolers
00:41:19 after that like there is some something to be said because the work has been done that's right
00:41:24 i do agree with that i do agree with that but um i think that there's there's the the intellectual
00:41:29 um formula or whatever you want to you know like there's there's the um the constitution has
00:41:35 already been written and and you don't have to write it again like so you're right like there
00:41:38 are tools that are there and you don't have to make the tools anymore right that's huge but
00:41:44 there's also something to be said not just for the system of government um and and for the tools
00:41:49 and documents of government.
00:41:51 There's something to be said for the people.
00:41:54 And the people, that's my point. 0.96
00:41:56 The French and the Venezuelans 0.73
00:41:58 basically copied the U.S. Constitution. 0.98
00:42:01 Very different. 1.00
00:42:02 The French became totally godless. 1.00
00:42:05 Venezuela was Catholic, I guess. 1.00
00:42:08 But to your point, it's not the tool by itself.
00:42:11 And that's what I'm saying,
00:42:12 is that it's the tool.
00:42:14 So maybe we can cut that 1,000 years down.
00:42:17 I'm totally, I think you're right.
00:42:19 I think that's a fair point to say, well, it doesn't have to take a thousand years now that
00:42:22 we've had it at least once. Maybe it can be replicated a little bit faster in the future.
00:42:27 I agree. But what I would say, my caution would be, I think we can cut that time down
00:42:32 and make it faster, but not too fast, because what we've seen even just in latter American
00:42:39 colonialism and the American empire, as we've tried to expand and import our sacred democracy
00:42:47 you know in the middle east and in different countries what we found is um the the moment
00:42:53 that we pull out it reverts back to chaos and and that's like like john doyle uh is you know
00:43:00 i've talked to him some offline and i think he's he's a good guy i appreciate him and enjoy his
00:43:05 videos with his youtube channel and uh but like he he recently did a video where he just was trying
00:43:11 to get people to recognize because we just as americans we just don't get it we don't we don't
00:43:16 understand how fortunate we are and how blessed by god we've been and he was just saying guys you
00:43:20 don't understand uh civilization western civilization is an anomaly yep if you look at
00:43:28 two things the world as a whole um and then also human history as a whole so if you look at the
00:43:34 the full the full scope of time and then the full scope of humanity across the globe uh this is
00:43:41 an anomaly it's almost like like if you were if you study you know all 6 000 years of history
00:43:48 around the world like you um you know for the first 4 000 years you would you would think uh
00:43:54 you if someone said and then there's going to come a nation that's like this and they're going
00:43:58 to have cathedrals and they're going to have um ballet and opera yeah and uh the mona lisa and
00:44:05 the sistine chapel and you would like if you were watching like a time lapse of the first 4 000 years
00:44:10 of every continent in the world
00:44:12 and the way that society was developing,
00:44:14 you'd say, no way.
00:44:16 No freaking way.
00:44:17 That's impossible.
00:44:19 And yet, what is impossible with man
00:44:20 is possible with God.
00:44:22 It is a miracle.
00:44:23 It is a miracle.
00:44:23 And it's God's work.
00:44:25 And it's God's glory.
00:44:26 God did that.
00:44:28 And he did it with a particular people.
00:44:30 He did.
00:44:31 And that doesn't mean he can't do it with other people.
00:44:33 But the point is, he did it, and it took time.
00:44:37 And the default, you know, like to reset to factory settings, like what John Doyle, the point he was making is the factory settings for a fallen world marred by sin, the factory settings is the Aztec empire.
00:44:52 The factory settings is like, this is before, exactly, this is before, you know, wokeness.
00:44:58 It wasn't that long ago.
00:44:59 I'm 38 years old.
00:45:00 I'm not that old, a little old, but like 38 years old.
00:45:03 And I remember learning in the sixth grade, uh, and, uh, Bay city middle school, uh, grew
00:45:08 up in Bay city.
00:45:09 Bay city was, uh, it was like a 20, I think 22 miles or 29 miles, something like that
00:45:14 from, um, uh, the Matagorda beach.
00:45:16 We were in Matagorda County, one of the poor counties, um, in Texas.
00:45:20 And, uh, and I was in, in, uh, going to public school in, in the sixth grade and in public
00:45:25 school, but small town, 18,000 people, population, small Texas, you know, rural town, uh, even
00:45:31 in the public school district um they as they were teaching history in my history class uh they
00:45:36 apparently you know basically texas in um in in the 90s had not gotten gotten the memo yet
00:45:43 they were supposed to be woke and so they were still teaching actual history um you know whoops
00:45:49 and so what they taught was you know we're teaching texas history and part of the texas
00:45:53 history for us because we were in matagorda county near the gulf coast was learning about
00:45:57 the indigenous people near the gulf coast of texas uh before it was colonized by westerners
00:46:03 and um and so one of it was the caronkawa indians and i always i thought it was so cool you know i'm
00:46:08 12 year old you know and learning about the caronkawa indians i was like this is fascinating
00:46:13 like right here you know on the soil where we currently are um before western civilization
00:46:18 and and these kinds of things happened um if you were alive today uh you would be eaten 1.00
00:46:23 and like my history teacher is teaching me this and the croco indians were you
00:46:27 like well i was about to say uniquely but that's not the case they were um they were uh common
00:46:33 savages common l for the entire world of all of human history until western civilization
00:46:38 common l uh it was it was it was universal they were savages like everybody else they sacrificed
00:46:44 people and they ate them and they would even like take hearts out of their victims and eat the heart
00:46:48 you know and um and that's that's just what people do so john door the point he was making
00:46:53 is just that uh savagery and barbarism um and anarchy um is that's the factory setting that's
00:47:02 right and and he said you you think you think that you can just uh import the third world
00:47:08 he said if you import too much of the third world you get the third world they bring the third world
00:47:14 with them this is not see here's the thing we're so we're we're not um uh pagan norse god worshiping
00:47:22 far right you know what like uh a little far right but you know but we're not um those people and so
00:47:29 and and so because we're not those people in terms of our views we don't think uh that uh the soil
00:47:34 here in america is magical and that if you take someone from haiti or 590 000 people uh from haiti
00:47:41 and drop them wholesale in america that the second that their feet hit the soil that all of a sudden
00:47:47 they're going to become uh thomas soul and uh you know and clarence thomas it doesn't work like that
00:47:52 and and likewise in terms of that's you know importing the third world exporting the first
00:47:56 world likewise that's my point is you um this takes centuries because yes we have the tools
00:48:03 so maybe we can cut down that thousand years and make it a little faster than that but you're not 0.91
00:48:07 going to cut it down to where it's like hey you know 20 years and afghanistan will be a
00:48:11 constitutional republic no yep like oh you know we'll give it uh we'll give it 30 years in haiti 0.91
00:48:17 um and no like 30 years in haiti and um and and they're eating cats and eating dogs and and that's 0.95
00:48:25 on a good day and on the bad days they're eating people and eating missionaries mission like white
00:48:31 missionaries going to haiti and being killed and sometimes eaten these these are not this is not 0.68
00:48:36 hyperbole this is this is the default factory settings of the world we have no idea how blessed
00:48:42 we are and it's important i just my point is it's important to realize that um that this did not
00:48:48 spring up overnight this is this is arguably from from constantine all the way till you know
00:48:55 till the founding of america this this is a centuries and centuries long project and um and
00:49:03 I think we're destined to colonize the stars, and I think we're destined also to colonize
00:49:11 the world.
00:49:12 I think we are.
00:49:13 And when I say we're, I mean Christians.
00:49:16 I think God has given—
00:49:18 Christian civilization.
00:49:18 Christian civilization.
00:49:19 God has given us dominion.
00:49:21 The world is ours. 0.95
00:49:23 It was given to Adam.
00:49:25 Adam forfeited to Satan, and then Jesus took it from Satan, and he gave it back to his
00:49:30 disciples of which we are his disciples and so the the world dominion over the world and i believe
00:49:37 the cosmos which includes even beyond the world and the stars it belongs to christians it really
00:49:43 does and um and so i i think it is our destiny but i think we have to realize that this is um
00:49:50 it has to be one uniquely christian it has to be uniquely christian and two um it's a long
00:49:56 and tedious work you cannot just go and say here are the principles of right of xyz government
00:50:05 democracy or whatever i'm not a fan of democracy but whatever um you know like here are the
00:50:09 principles of a government and we're going to be here you know with boots on the ground for 20 years
00:50:13 and we're going to teach you and then you guys can take it from there no they can't no they can't
00:50:18 you know what's interesting joel is a lot of the early kind of proto-colonial models
00:50:23 because initially it was not the British government or the Belgian government.
00:50:30 It was private trade companies who were kind of going to Africa
00:50:34 to look for resources to trade for and things like this.
00:50:36 A lot of the kind of management of the area where trade was developing
00:50:41 was managed initially by these private organizations.
00:50:45 And in some ways, the British government stepped in
00:50:48 because the private entities, number one,
00:50:52 they weren't equipped to manage a people, to rule a people. And number two, they weren't
00:50:57 necessarily upholding the same principles of jurisprudence and legal fairness and things
00:51:02 like that. And we have this idea that the British government or the Spanish government,
00:51:08 the French government, they decided to go there just to destroy. But really, it was the opposite.
00:51:15 This was going to happen anyway. Europe was developing ships. It was developing technology,
00:51:20 guns and crossbows and all that sort of stuff it was going to spread around the world and i think
00:51:25 especially the case can be made for the british government that they they had to step in in a
00:51:29 governmental sense because private trading companies were not equipped to handle the
00:51:35 management of entire foreign countries and themselves defend themselves yeah things like
00:51:40 that the other thing i wanted to say that you're exactly right about is the early missionary efforts
00:51:44 in the 1600s, 1700s, they considered spreading the gospel to be almost synonymous with spreading
00:51:51 Christian civilization. And it's one of the reasons why they began translating the Bible
00:51:58 into native languages. And to do that, they, in often, many cases, they had to write the language.
00:52:05 Which is quick. Think about that for a second. We're talking about people who,
00:52:08 they're not just committing human sacrifices and cannibalism and all kinds of savagery,
00:52:13 But you're going in, you don't have to merely learn their language, but you have to learn their language and then find a way to translate it into a written form.
00:52:25 Because this people has existed for a very long time, and they have still not compiled a written form of their language.
00:52:35 Everything is simply oral tradition.
00:52:40 It's not that they don't know how to read English.
00:52:42 they don't know what reading is that's right they don't know what writing there's even broader
00:52:46 concepts like sacrifice covenant even time i did a high level african philosophy course
00:52:52 time in in those cultures was the near immediate and the far distant past so when you give them
00:52:58 conditionals like going to heaven in the future that if you place faith in jesus at a later date
00:53:03 when you die you'll go to heaven you're even teaching that concept of covenant the idea of
00:53:08 of someone being put in your place because they'd show that's why the jesus movie was kind of
00:53:13 helpful but like which is not a great evangelism tool but at least it gave a visual that didn't
00:53:18 exist in the language to try to get across this was for you this is what will happen if you trust
00:53:23 in jesus etc yeah yeah and there was one missionary named john elliot he was in new england
00:53:29 and he actually was called as a presbyterian pastor outside of boston and he maintained that
00:53:36 presbytery his entire career but on the side he was reaching out to this um indigenous people in
00:53:42 the area and he learned their language he translated it he developed it and he didn't
00:53:47 just translate the bible and the catechisms he started translating things like the christian
00:53:51 commonwealth right because he's like these people need laws they need a foundation for how to order
00:53:56 their society and you know obviously it wasn't going to happen immediately right but he was
00:54:01 already thinking it's not just the gospel it's civilization it's order it's logic it's rule
00:54:06 it's productivity it's accountability it's structure like all of these things yeah i'm
00:54:12 just sitting here thinking i've had this thought before but it just feels like clearer than i've
00:54:16 ever had it before you know you know what you know what i think is wicked i think it is so wicked
00:54:22 that um revisionist history of you know all these you know colonizers were oppressive
00:54:31 and mean and malicious and like everything that we're discussing when you think of the
00:54:37 Caronco Indians or you think of the Aztecs or you think of you know all this you know 0.51
00:54:41 and then you think of the Africans and and savagy and and and then you think of like 0.92
00:54:46 no written language and you have to teach them you have to create their language and put it in
00:54:52 written form and then teach that language to these people and it's their own language and
00:54:56 you're having to teach it's not you just have to learn their language you have to teach them
00:55:00 their language and how to write it um and and the fact that like we would we would read the history
00:55:07 of our ancestors in western civilization our fathers in light of the fifth commandment we
00:55:13 were commanded to honor them and we would read someone like rl dabney you know or we we would
00:55:19 read you know some of these guys and and we would read some of the things that they that they said
00:55:25 about other peoples and we would say oh my goodness how arrogant how uh how racist how
00:55:31 and it's like we we weren't we weren't there right these these guys um all these uh you know 0.59
00:55:39 america is a very diverse nation it is it in my opinion is a little bit too diverse in terms of
00:55:46 continuing to import the third world but for heritage america and those who who really can
00:55:51 track back their family lines multiple generations and and that that includes more than just
00:55:56 europeans more than just white people so um but the point is you um you look at at different people
00:56:03 um different ethnicities within our nation um and many of them doing um incredible things
00:56:09 wonderful things um but but then you know together collectively we then look back and scoff
00:56:16 at guys from the 1700s and 1800s
00:56:19 and the things that they wrote
00:56:20 and the things that they believed and thought
00:56:23 because they had firsthand accounts
00:56:25 and observed them.
00:56:27 And we say, how could they?
00:56:28 And when the reality is,
00:56:30 the reality is that the reason
00:56:32 why we are as developed as we are
00:56:35 and are as civilized as we are
00:56:38 and multiple different ethnicities,
00:56:41 able to live together 0.66
00:56:44 and worship the triune God 0.94
00:56:46 and all these things is because of Dabney. 0.75
00:56:49 It's because of Edwards working among indigenous tribes.
00:56:55 You know, he spent,
00:56:55 after he was wrongfully excommunicated from his church,
00:56:58 he devoted the rest of his life as a missionary.
00:57:00 Like these guys, they saw the savagery.
00:57:03 These guys, they saw the barbarism
00:57:05 and they gave their lives for it.
00:57:08 And the reason why a lot of other,
00:57:11 you know, a rising tide lifts all the ships
00:57:13 as Christendom began to rise more and more and expand across the world, all these different
00:57:19 peoples were caught up in the wake and everybody, every society, every culture began to improve 0.62
00:57:26 and not all equally, not every culture is equal, but every culture did improve because of the West
00:57:34 and predominantly because of Christendom. And so now we're sitting here at like a high watermark
00:57:40 of looking at the most developed the world has ever been
00:57:46 and all these different peoples
00:57:49 who have gone from not even having a written language
00:57:54 to now they're studying and going to Yale
00:57:58 and American citizens and all these different...
00:58:01 And then we look at our fathers
00:58:03 and we say that they were the bad guys.
00:58:06 um no that like that that is in that's insane they i mean what what would you do what would
00:58:14 you think like it's so easy to be arrogant and puffed up but what would you think if um if you
00:58:21 if you were born into a civilization in let's say the 1600s and already from constantine to the
00:58:28 1600s or even alfred you're still looking at 500 years like a thousand to 500 years and and you've
00:58:34 got cathedrals and art and philosophy um and the christian religion and and human sacrifice
00:58:43 is um is a thought that that you can't even fathom yeah and you know and and uh and and
00:58:51 you're sitting here it's the 16 1700s and then you know through technological innovation and
00:58:58 developments you know uh you begin to explore the rest of the world and as you as you begin to be
00:59:06 introduced to other peoples in the rest of the world and you've known cathedrals and and and
00:59:12 fresh baked goods and this and ballet and operas and shakespeare and then you go to the rest of
00:59:19 world yeah and you think um that your your people are superior yeah like it's that's not a crazy
00:59:30 thought you know now now why would be the question and how can we fix it why and how can we help
00:59:37 right but the but the but the mere idea the mere thought of um superiority that's it's it's i it's
00:59:46 quite an arrogant thing on this side of history after these guys who thought that they were
00:59:51 superior, and many of them did not mean anything malicious by that. They're like, it's just a fact.
00:59:57 It's just a fact. There's mud huts, and then there's cathedrals, right? We're learning Latin,
01:00:04 and we're having to write a language for them. We eat baked goods, they eat each other. 0.97
01:00:11 like you come in you think you're superior because you objectively are and i want to argue
01:00:20 by the grace of god you objectively are by the grace of god and then and then you write about
01:00:26 that and your thoughts are are written down and you're the one who had to literally in in many
01:00:30 case dodge spears thrown at you right you're you're the one who who and and and you could 0.79
01:00:36 have just wiped them all out but you didn't because you wanted to spread the christian
01:00:40 gospel and you wanted to be benevolent and you actually protected them from themselves and from
01:00:45 neighboring tribes that were at war constantly endless wars you you actually were benevolent
01:00:49 you were kind like i'm thinking of columbus you know these kinds of guys you were benevolent
01:00:54 you were kind altruistic and more than all that more important than all that you were an evangelist
01:00:59 and you shared with them the heart of jesus christ while also just writing down objectively
01:01:05 in a scientific way what you observed and what you observed at that time was that your people
01:01:12 and your culture were superior vastly superior to theirs and and because of your work your altruism
01:01:18 your benevolence your kindness and your christian faith and work of evangelism among these people
01:01:24 over the next 400 years 500 years god in his mercy and grace many of those people
01:01:30 uh are elevated and cultures are are radically elevated and and developed and now after they're
01:01:38 developed now we go back and say oh wasn't it racist of christopher columbus to say xyz wasn't
01:01:44 it racist of david like what a just a jerk thing of us to that's just yeah i like it's one of the
01:01:53 common themes i think people probably pick up with right response ministries but um man i just i 0.66
01:01:57 don't know i i red pilled pretty hard in 2020 and then a lot of people that that was it you know
01:02:02 they're like i'm you know i'm just not going to be woke you know and um i'm not going to be woke
01:02:06 and i'm not going to wear a mask and and then that was kind of the extent of their journey and
01:02:10 but for me it was like 2020 like you know i was already taking some red pills leading up to that
01:02:14 so that that might have been the problem but i was already on this train and then 2020 was a big a
01:02:19 big red pill but then they just kept coming and for me like i'm at the point now where i feel like
01:02:24 when I think of, you know, what are guiding principles for life? You know, what are like
01:02:27 strong, innate core convictions? One of them for me is, I want for me and my wife and my children
01:02:36 and my church that I pastor and my descendants and great-grandchildren, I want us to be a family
01:02:44 and a people that no matter how much gaslighting,
01:02:49 no matter how subversive the psyop,
01:02:54 no matter how convincing the narrative,
01:02:57 I want me and my house to be the type of people
01:03:03 who cannot ever be convinced to hate our fathers.
01:03:08 I feel like that's a commitment.
01:03:10 It's similar.
01:03:11 It's not the same, not on the same level, not even close.
01:03:14 But similar to when I became a Christian,
01:03:17 as for me in my house, we will fear the Lord.
01:03:20 And my descendants in my house,
01:03:22 we are going to serve the Lord.
01:03:25 And it doesn't matter what, you know,
01:03:27 James Lindsay, 1990s, new atheist comes our way.
01:03:30 They're not going to be able to convince us to hate Jesus.
01:03:34 We love Jesus.
01:03:36 And in a similar fashion, a lower degree in terms of priority,
01:03:41 but same principle similar principle concept as i'm older now i i feel a similar zeal in saying
01:03:49 um i i will not hate my fathers i just i won't i won't hate them uh they were good men and uh and
01:03:56 the reality is they were flawed men but they were good men and they're better than the men we have
01:04:00 today and and if we ever are going to criticize guys like dabney um i think we're going to have
01:04:06 to wait a couple generations we're gonna have to wait a couple a couple centuries until we have
01:04:12 the caliber of men who are qualified to criticize dabney because currently in 2024 with a bunch of 0.99
01:04:19 queers i'm sorry the queer generation does not get to criticize dabney right so we're gonna need 0.98
01:04:27 better men for that i wanted to add that was great i do want to add one note to the person who asked
01:04:32 Why the sudden anti-colonial sentiment?
01:04:35 You mentioned some of the cultural changes, Britain holding together an empire.
01:04:40 But man, World War I and World War II, politically it did a number on the way we used to think, but also theologically.
01:04:46 Towards the end of the 18th, 19th century, so late 1800s in the U.S., you have efforts beginning to revise the Westminster standards to get more of God's love in there and less of his judgment.
01:04:56 The Enlightenment does a number.
01:04:58 You have humanism doing a number.
01:04:59 and then the horror of world war one that goes right against communism so you have then you
01:05:05 have millions that die we think we're civilized right so we're we're spreading the gospel we're
01:05:09 sending missionaries like we've done this a horrific war tears apart europe and then communism 0.58
01:05:15 you have half of the world shut off in communism and then 20 years later you have world war ii
01:05:19 that's why the swith swiss theologian carl bart he writes the epistle to the romans and it's so
01:05:25 radical because to men in those days, after all of that destruction, God was just something that
01:05:30 was like very imminent, maybe a little bit better than us on his best day, but he wasn't the
01:05:34 transcendent, wholly different God. And that's kind of Bart obviously overcorrects to the other
01:05:39 end. But theologically too, we lost so much of what we had from the Reformation due to the
01:05:44 Enlightenment, due to humanism, due to these wars. And so then you get to the 60s and people
01:05:49 no longer believe we're a force for good. So as Britain lets go of these colonies, as their empire
01:05:54 shrinks are we really that much of a force for good is there really a great commission to be
01:05:58 fulfilled is it really worth holding all of that together so think about too how world war one and
01:06:02 world war two and communism how all of those then created the seedbed that by the 1950s 1960s war
01:06:09 in vietnam war in korea and that's also like british like just with eschatology like that's
01:06:15 when post mill right like takes you can look at like post mill trending up you know and like many
01:06:19 of the puritans were post-millennial and then but then it's like when you know when did uh
01:06:23 post-millennialism uh just become the minority eschatological position and and the rise of
01:06:30 dispensationalism is yes schofield and yeah that you know mid mid 1800s um that that's you know
01:06:35 there's a rise there uh but then there's also this massive drop um after two world wars yeah yeah you
01:06:42 know like like everybody went to war they saw incredible atrocities and a lot of people came
01:06:46 back and they're like there is no god you know like this is just the end is near and there's a
01:06:51 very reductionistic model of evangelism where they got this idea that if we if we just finish
01:06:55 up right we we brought the ball to the 10 yard line if we finish up and evangelize the rest of
01:07:00 the world like when the gospel has been heard by all the world that's when the end will come right
01:07:03 man we're within like 10 years of it so let's just you know top three things jesus died for you
01:07:08 you're a sinner trust in him let's go out and do that destroyed our evangelism because we didn't
01:07:13 Give them a rooted, grounded, not just faith, but civilization, a way of life, all of Christ. 0.88
01:07:19 It wasn't about that.
01:07:20 It was just like, let's make sure the savages ask Jesus into their heart, and they can keep 0.95
01:07:24 living in the mud huts. 0.97
01:07:25 Show them the Jesus movie, get some raised hands. 0.99
01:07:27 Right. 0.54
01:07:28 We did it. 0.98
01:07:28 And they can stay in the mud huts, and maybe we'll also send some money and some doctors
01:07:32 for immediate diseases.
01:07:34 If they have malaria, we'd like them to live.
01:07:37 But we're not thinking of how to transform them for the next 500 years.
01:07:41 We're not, we're not thinking, we're thinking the personal Christian gospel for the soul
01:07:45 and some immediate physical needs, like some shoes, some food, and some vaccines, which
01:07:51 turns out they didn't need, you know, but some kind of medical assistance.
01:07:56 But we weren't thinking, we weren't thinking about, and how will they have highways?
01:08:03 Yep.
01:08:04 150 years.
01:08:04 And to be fair.
01:08:05 I'm not sure the missionaries themselves are the ones to do that.
01:08:08 No, I'm not saying that.
01:08:09 they didn't plant that seed that that we're evangelizing you young man you became a christian
01:08:16 what is your how is your nation getting more civilized and christian in four generations
01:08:21 right right like that seed was not planted and then the best of them you know the best of of
01:08:26 different peoples from all over the earth yeah they came here they leave yeah like that's part
01:08:32 of it too is like and you think of this happens this is a phenomenon i've been thinking about
01:08:36 this too but this is a phenomenon even like in our country so you can be on a global scale or even
01:08:40 just a national scale so like have you are you guys familiar with the concept of iq shredders
01:08:44 shredders yeah shredders um so like it's you know the idea that basically like uh your your highest
01:08:51 functioning highest caliber people um are usually going to go to big cities um and the reason why
01:08:58 is because that's where the most opportunity within their field is going to be so in terms
01:09:02 of universities uh universities are you know usually not in the middle of nowhere the most
01:09:06 prestigious universities because you want to study under you know the the most um you know
01:09:11 credentialed so-and-so professor who's written you know this many volumes on this topic or whatever
01:09:15 um that he's going to be at this university this big university it's not going to be in timbuktu
01:09:19 it's going to be in manhattan or it's going to be you know uh chicago or you know some and so
01:09:24 that's the university level but then also you know industry and so like you're going to get a job and
01:09:28 then you also just uh the things that you know would attract you know high functioning you know
01:09:33 highly intelligent people like uh symphonies and operas like like nathan over there in the closet
01:09:39 like his you know his uh nathan's our technician um uh his brother you know who um and nathan is
01:09:46 a family member so we're cousins and so uh his brother my cousin um is an incredibly incredibly
01:09:53 gifted and talented and and intelligent um pianist um but he you know his whole life until
01:10:00 very recently he well sadly he finally had to kind of leave because you just you you have to leave
01:10:05 and part of that's just because of the decline of western civilization like you can't be he would
01:10:10 play for symphonies and he would play you know he's played at the the lincoln what is it nate
01:10:15 the lincoln lincoln center you know all these different places um and and so his his whole
01:10:23 young adult life was you know after getting his phd and all these like was just basically every
01:10:27 six months to to a year he has to go somewhere else you know and he's following an orchestra
01:10:32 around or following a symphony and it's only a few cities like he he's going to be in new york
01:10:37 he's going to be you know in san francisco he's going to and my point is he's going to be in um
01:10:44 he's limited to a very very limited scope he's not he's not going to get to um he's never going
01:10:51 to get to live in georgetown right you know um he's he's not he's he's not going to spend uh he's
01:10:57 not going to have any of his tenure be in oklahoma we'll say that and yeah i love oklahoma you know
01:11:01 but it's just it's not going to happen not with that not with that his his vocation his field and
01:11:06 so you're going to those kinds of places but then in those kinds of places um you're you're pursuing
01:11:11 you know uh universities pursuing certain fields and and then pursuing arts and philosophy and all
01:11:17 the in cuisine and all the kinds of things that big cities have to offer and but then that kind
01:11:22 of life it wasn't always this way but that kind of life became um it became incompatible with uh
01:11:30 child rearing with family with marriage and children so these people pursuing phds which
01:11:37 take time so like you're not you're you're you're you're in school until you're 27 28 29 30 years
01:11:43 old if you start early enough if you start early enough so that whole time you're in school you're
01:11:48 not making money you're accruing debt and then you've got to get out of debt um and so now you're
01:11:54 trying to get out of debt and let's let's be honest like a lot of these people like highly
01:11:58 intelligent people but it doesn't necessarily um pay a lot right like you know if you're a piano
01:12:03 performance guy like right you know you're working for peanuts and and why and why is that not a
01:12:08 viable vocation um because um c.a we are a nation of degenerates people are listening to
01:12:17 i don't know i don't know who do they listen to now who's a they're listening to taylor swift
01:12:23 you know or and and that might even be on the better end other than you know maybe the divine
01:12:28 feminine and goddess worship but uh which is kind of a big one but i you know like hip-hop and rap
01:12:33 you know which um it's like hip-hop right this is just subjective nope uh it's absolutely
01:12:38 objective hip-hop and rap is inferior it's absolutely inferior to opera to symphonies
01:12:43 to um and it is it is degrading um it absolutely has degraded western civilization um that like
01:12:51 music actually does matter it actually does matter and so we have debased our appetites
01:12:56 and and uh and so there's there's no my point is there is there's no market there's no market
01:13:02 for symphonies except for you know three or four cities in the country and and it's even there it's
01:13:08 dying it's like 90 year old women right and the only way it's surviving is because they were super 0.98
01:13:12 rich and they have trust set up so that you know because they believe that the next generation
01:13:16 they'd like to see one opera you know that their grandkids might be able to watch you know which
01:13:21 is somewhat of a noble endeavor these you know some of these rich benefactors that leave you know
01:13:26 an endowment to you know the the san francisco you know symphony but then here's the problem 1.00
01:13:32 all the musicians there in the san francisco uh symphony they're all they're all queers and so 1.00
01:13:39 none of them have kids right so that like they play beautiful music for one generation and never 1.00
01:13:43 have kids because they all want to have butt sex and then and then the symphony's dead and so my 0.98
01:13:48 point is the iq iq shredder kind of mentality is that basically it takes our best and our brightest 1.00
01:13:54 and takes them to hell holes, 0.85
01:13:56 blue, progressive, big city hell holes 0.95
01:14:00 that are designed,
01:14:02 they're literally designed to be incompatible
01:14:04 to family, marriage, and children.
01:14:06 And so your brightest, your 160, 170 IQ people
01:14:10 don't procreate.
01:14:11 They don't have children.
01:14:13 And who does have children is a bunch of farmers. 0.97
01:14:18 God bless them.
01:14:18 And I'm not seeing this as a negative thing,
01:14:21 but a bunch of, it's more blue collar people.
01:14:24 that will have families will have children will raise them in the fear and admonition of the lord
01:14:29 to where they actually value marriage and family they have children and so there's something to be
01:14:33 said for like within and i don't know how it happened or why it happened it's something i'm
01:14:37 exploring but western civilization there there was like a like a a bell curve i think of um even
01:14:45 not just christianity and the religious side of things but even at the side of intelligence of
01:14:49 like uh growing within western civilization more and more brilliant people more innovations more
01:14:55 uh inventors and more scientists and more philosophers and and it's getting because
01:15:00 marriage and family was normative within the culture but now that academia and and the the
01:15:07 more uh the higher institutions and elements of culture have normalized um perpetual single
01:15:14 singleness and um that then your your brightest people um don't procreate and and and so now uh
01:15:23 i i think not only do we have actually a decline because we're under the the you know the
01:15:28 replacement rate of reproduction uh so not only a population decline which presents its own problems
01:15:34 but also uh iq you can map it uh lifespans have been going to we hit the high the high mark
01:15:40 in western uh lifespans are decreasing for the first time um in in centuries um and iq is
01:15:48 decreasing and i think what i just said the iq shredder mentality is i think one uh has some
01:15:53 explanatory power for that um and and then of course uh uh church attendance and and religion
01:15:59 is decreasing and then over up a young young men though young men are an actual bright spot and
01:16:05 that's because of people like us yeah it really is i'm not trying to brag but it's because
01:16:09 of people like us who say we're not going to be big eva we're not going to despair as young men
01:16:13 and we're going to talk to them right um but but iq declining lifespan declining and then overarching
01:16:19 uh population declining and then on the macro scale uh with if you think of the world as a
01:16:24 whole so that's just within our country uh but then if you think of the world as a whole your
01:16:29 best and brightest they they they leave uganda they don't like they we we go in a we have you
01:16:35 know it's one thing to colonize that i think can there's merits right especially christian
01:16:41 colonization you can look and say there's a lot of great fruit and argue that it's part of the
01:16:46 christian gospel to go and do that again and it's not going to be a 20-year project but centuries
01:16:50 to eventually people are capable of self-governance um and and that's a great thing um that said
01:16:56 though there's a difference between colonized christian colonization and um and uh secular
01:17:02 culling yep culling is different c-u-l-l-i-n-g yeah yeah it's different than um colonization
01:17:09 uh colonization is pushing civilization into other geographic regions and nations and peoples
01:17:15 uh culling is coming in doing something getting some oil and and killing one dictator so that a
01:17:23 worse one can take a space you know and being there for 20 years and then leaving them with
01:17:27 billions of dollars of, of, of weapon grade, you know, uh, military grade weaponry, uh, to be sold 0.87
01:17:33 on the black market, you know, that ultimate, like, so that we can now see, you know, uh, Iran,
01:17:39 uh, my tax dollars in Israel also somehow my tax dollars, you know? Um, and so, you know, like,
01:17:45 so that's what we do now instead of 200 year, uh, colonization projects, we do 20 year in the name
01:17:51 of benevolence where we really just come in we get some oil we uh we uh uh end a war start a worse
01:17:58 war and then and then take the best and brightest out with us so the guys who helped us who who
01:18:04 were translators you know learn the language who learned the language so now uh the best people
01:18:09 uh come out and if we won't let them out they try to get out by hanging on to the wheel wells
01:18:14 of the airplane like we saw like which is tragic you know um but my point is and and then afghanistan 1.00
01:18:20 just becomes a hell hole you know and same as it was 20 years ago when we burned billions of 0.96
01:18:26 dollars our sons our sons died and our daughters because we're wicked and we send daughters to war
01:18:31 but um but our sons and daughters died um and billions of taxpayers you know we used the tax
01:18:37 farm of america and wasted their money so wasted lives wasted money and uh and the final thing is
01:18:43 it ends up being uh just as bad if not give it time i predict it might be worse um you know and
01:18:50 And so my point is, and the IQ shredder, you take the, you know,
01:18:58 a J.D. Vance is a perfect example, actually.
01:19:01 And now by God's grace, he's procreating. 1.00
01:19:05 I wish it was a Christian woman and not a Hindu woman. 1.00
01:19:10 Is she Christian? 1.00
01:19:11 Does she convert to Catholicism?
01:19:12 She attends Mass with him.
01:19:14 But does she still maintain?
01:19:15 Is it like Vivek, who's like, which God, Vivek?
01:19:18 Yeah.
01:19:19 which of the three million guys i don't think she's converted and he got serious about his
01:19:23 faith a little later so it might be something where give it time realizes i married an unbeliever
01:19:28 so we'll give it to yeah so he probably yeah he probably did that without realizing that you know
01:19:31 but hopefully she converts if she hasn't already and becomes a christian and then great um but my
01:19:37 point is that uh most most examples of your jd vance type like jd vance is probably a pretty
01:19:44 high iq the dude yeah seems sharp like i bet he's probably 160 you know something something
01:19:51 140 150 okay one get a little weird at 160 yeah the wheels off the car you can't communicate with
01:19:58 normal people that's true he he talks to uh he ironically much to the chagrin of the the leftist
01:20:05 jd is not that weird right right if he if he was as weird as they said then he might be like 171
01:20:11 yeah but so you're right but the point is here's a brilliant guy from flyover country
01:20:15 and um and he's not going to stay stay there and he doesn't have to he's because he's going to do
01:20:22 by god's grace hopefully more good for flyover country than than he would if he stayed um but
01:20:27 most people like that the point is most people like that they move to the cities they get
01:20:31 vasectomies yep they uh they never marry they hook up and sleep around and write you know for
01:20:38 scientific journals and and then that their high iq dies with them and it's not biologically passed
01:20:45 down to anybody else and then the rest of the world same thing the best and the brightest
01:20:47 we take them out of their countries and so we actually are on a path right now so yes it's
01:20:53 first and foremost about the gospel it's first and foremost about religion the spiritual aspect
01:20:57 but that's one of the marks i think is quickly becoming maybe it wasn't from the beginning but
01:21:02 maybe like i said i'm just red pilling i think that's becoming one of the marks of this ministry
01:21:06 of Right Response Ministries, is never over and against the gospel
01:21:11 and the spiritual reality.
01:21:13 The world is not just stuff.
01:21:14 But we're saying alongside it is nature.
01:21:17 And nature is just undefeated.
01:21:21 You're not going to defeat nature.
01:21:24 And Gnosticism does not work, and pietism does not work.
01:21:27 It's God's truth, which is a spiritual reality and timeless and eternal,
01:21:31 but then in his created order and and and the natural peace um it's it's not going away so we
01:21:39 have to find a way with the christian gospel to work with nature and not against it working with
01:21:45 god's design and what the fabric that he's built into the world and when you look at that it means
01:21:50 yeah let's go and do the work of evangelists and preach the gospel um but it also means yeah it's
01:21:56 going to be 200 year works not 20 year works it's going to be colonization it's going to be 0.55
01:22:01 and it can't just be iq shredders and and calling the best and brightest and then teaching them a 0.88
01:22:08 godless worldview of secularism to where they don't procreate we are right now uh in a natural
01:22:13 sense we are on uh we are we're on a death sentence we are are spiraling into lower lifespans
01:22:21 lower populations and lower iq i don't know about you but that doesn't sound like like a win that
01:22:28 that sounds pretty negative and so those things have to be fixed and it and and it's not going
01:22:34 to be just um uh the romans wrote in personal evangelism like that doesn't like these conversations
01:22:42 have to happen these kinds of conversations of of nature and civilization and iq and government
01:22:49 um and and even getting into things like like what we've talked about in the past like talking
01:22:55 about health and like uh that we shouldn't be fat and right um these kinds of things over time
01:23:00 like there's a reason i like the last thing i said i know i've been talking too much last thing i'll
01:23:06 say is this um the gospel affects everything we all say that we all we believe that but we but
01:23:14 do we like because when i say the gospel affects everything i'm talking highways and cathedrals
01:23:19 and philosophy and art but i'm also talking about one thing that it certainly affects is
01:23:23 food diet religion is uh or to say the opposite way diet what people eat what cultures eat
01:23:32 is incredibly religious always has been like in india not not everyone in india but
01:23:40 india is a pretty big place what a billion people 1.3 yeah 1.3 billion people there are millions
01:23:47 and millions and millions and millions of indians who um are using cow feces not eating the cow one 0.82
01:23:55 of the most nutritious animals out there because making use of the feces right so we're going to 0.98
01:23:59 use the the the cow crap uh but we won't eat the cow right that's religious that's religious 0.89
01:24:07 that is religious cannibalism like we already talked about it was in worship of demons 0.99
01:24:12 religious uh so whether you're eating other people or eating or using cow feces but but
01:24:21 missing the cow like all these are religious things and and so then back to my point of the
01:24:27 gospel change and everything what happens like honestly like what happens over generations
01:24:33 generations centuries of um i mean one of the big things with england that that made you know
01:24:40 made it superior and it was and it's all related to religion and christianity it was
01:24:44 as christianity took over and there was innovations one great innovation was the sewer system
01:24:49 yep uh it turns out a whole lot of less people die if if a society doesn't have trash laying
01:24:57 everywhere like we talk about oh our carbon emissions and you know it's just not fair you
01:25:01 know because we have such a developed world but we're making the world work nah you you go watch
01:25:06 of video of the rest of the world they're literally wading through bottles of trash
01:25:12 like they literally like walking it's just in the streets everywhere everywhere no no it's it's not
01:25:19 like oh but you know but your pollution with your factories they are burning trash um if and that's
01:25:26 if they take the time to burn it uh most of the time it's just sitting there or in the ocean
01:25:32 or in the u.s sending piles and islands of trash islands it's the eastern world mostly yes the 0.91
01:25:39 non-christian world um is is it's a hellscape that is the factory settings the factory settings
01:25:47 apart from jesus is a hellscape and so at every level my point is um with uh communicable diseases
01:25:54 a lack of sanitation lack of functioning sewer systems lack of medicine lack of nutrition and 0.97
01:26:01 all this being religious eating cow dung instead of cow pretty basic but religious right all of it 0.65
01:26:09 is religious what does that do and you might say well that doesn't have an effect what does it do
01:26:13 over 10 generations yep would that affect um your great great great great grandchildren's health
01:26:20 yes could it affect in terms of their health could it affect their uh like every part of their body
01:26:28 including their brain yes could affect their capacity with with their mind to have high
01:26:36 intellect and high functioning and yes is joel right now making an argument for the christian
01:26:42 gospel affecting iqs over the course of a millennium yeah the psalm 19 the law of the
01:26:48 lord makes wise the simple yes yeah yes so we we're what we're playing for keeps is what i'm
01:26:54 saying this is this is a the fight that we're fighting against marxism communism the left um
01:27:01 the the third world fighting for the third world but also in some sense against the third world
01:27:07 but for but for their their their good and for their welfare this is um this is a fight uh winner
01:27:14 keep keep all this is a fight to the death um we're this is not just so that uh people will go
01:27:20 to church on sunday right but here's the thing it all starts with people going to church on sunday
01:27:26 the beachhead is the christian church right and out of that little thing that the west and our
01:27:32 secular humanism has decided doesn't really matter uh with the loss of that has been the loss of
01:27:37 everything else and we will fall just like the rest of the world with and it's already happening
01:27:43 with lifespans and iqs and population um unless unless we repent of our sins and turn to christ 0.67
01:27:50 and when we have i think of what jesus says to peter you'll deny me three times
01:27:54 um you know and and or he says satan has asked to sift you like wheat but i have prayed for you
01:28:01 and when you um and when you have been strengthened after you've fallen you've been restored
01:28:05 then go and strengthen your brothers also the west needs to be restored my prayer is that christ
01:28:12 in his priestly prayers would sustain the christian west amen and that we would be strengthened even
01:28:18 though satan has been actively seeking to sift us like wheat but that we'd be strengthened by
01:28:23 christ returned to christ and after we have returned that we would go and strengthen our
01:28:27 brothers also meaning our our brothers in india our brothers and and all all over the world in
01:28:32 uganda and and burkina fasa and and that we would go and strengthen our brothers also and that the
01:28:38 entire world would rise and experience the kind of christendom that and and knowing that for many
01:28:43 of our brothers uh it's going to take centuries but that we would come alongside them as kind of
01:28:48 like the scaffolding you know like the the brace supports that they can't and i'm not trying to be
01:28:53 demeaning but this is just they can't do it they can't do it not for a while um but we can brace
01:28:59 them until they can't until they and and that's that is what we've seen for 2 000 years of history
01:29:06 and the spread of the Christian gospel
01:29:08 and with it, the spread of innovation,
01:29:11 of civilization,
01:29:13 of the very life from the dead.
01:29:15 And I want to see that happen again,
01:29:18 but it's not going to happen
01:29:18 until one, we repent of our sin
01:29:20 and turn to the Christian gospel.
01:29:21 And two, we have to be able
01:29:23 to put on our big boy pants
01:29:25 and have a serious talk about nature.
01:29:27 We have to be able to say,
01:29:28 yeah, not all nations are currently equal.
01:29:31 Yeah, not all cultures are equal.
01:29:35 uh yeah um cannibalism is inferior to um to soufflés like and if we until we can serious 0.55
01:29:44 have serious conversations about these and that's one of the marks i hope by god's grace of this
01:29:49 ministry whether it's you know i i know that we upset people you know with the controversy but
01:29:54 we don't want to be unhinged we want to be godly we want to be rooted in scripture but we do want
01:29:58 to be the kind of ministry that will talk about something that everyone else is thinking about
01:30:01 like israel or that everyone else is thinking about like racism or that everyone else like
01:30:07 we want to be able to talk about those things and talk about them in christian ways christian
01:30:12 ways not pagan ways we don't want to talk about it the way that um the the way that you know some
01:30:18 some of the you know uh a guy like you know like bronze age pervert or you know i i don't hold
01:30:24 his views um but he is noticing something that's real and so we want to go or the red pill guys 0.65
01:30:30 right like they're they're giving the wrong solutions but they are right and recognizing
01:30:35 yeah it is incredibly dangerous for a man to get married today and have kids and and and the
01:30:40 the big eva uh solution to that to just say well the red red pill guy you know like that's not 0.96
01:30:48 they just don't get it they don't get it women are great no they're not no they're not women today
01:30:55 um that in general not talking about every single woman i married one she's great my wife is great
01:31:02 uh women are not my wife's great your wife's great your wife's great but women on the whole
01:31:07 are not and my point is men aren't aren't doing too fabulous either um but but the point is that
01:31:12 um we are so so drenched in feminism that uh that right now it is uh you are taking the moment you
01:31:20 say i do and choose to get married you have just given over to this woman who has been indoctrinated
01:31:26 by feminism from the womb you have just given to her legal and financial right over your entire 1.00
01:31:32 life the entire court systems in our nation are geared towards her the entire financial incentives 1.00
01:31:37 in our nation are geared towards her everything's like you are literally uh casting yourself at her 0.98
01:31:43 mercy and the red pill guys are right that is a massive risk she will be able to ruin your life
01:31:47 you do it the moment you enter marriage and that that's when you you start the process of of casting
01:31:52 yourself at her mercy and then especially the moment you have a kid as soon as you have a kid
01:31:55 uh she she has if she wants to if she if she wants to uh to utilize this power legally financially 1.00
01:32:02 culturally the moment that you have a kid with her she owns you she owns you and she can enslave you 1.00
01:32:08 and ruin your life the rest of your life cause you to go bankrupt make sure that you can't ever 0.67
01:32:13 be employed make sure everything she can ruin your that's that's where we currently live um 0.77
01:32:18 that's what we chose we chose feminism and so uh the the big eva and medieval for that matter the
01:32:23 typical evangelical christian response to that um young men are just not gonna that that doesn't
01:32:30 help them to say well just um just servant leadership a little bit harder you know just
01:32:37 happy wife, happy life a little bit harder. Just lay your life down for your bride as Christ, 0.60
01:32:43 like a little bit harder. No, we've got to also talk about the sins of women. And we've got to 1.00
01:32:52 call women to repentance. And we've got to be able to talk about all these things. And so anyways, 0.97
01:32:58 I just think that that, to me, is shaping up to be a consistent theme and a mark of why I think
01:33:04 this ministry continues to grow and be a blessing to people is because we're willing to talk about
01:33:09 spiritual matters alongside that which is natural and recognizing that the two are not opposed to
01:33:16 one another. Grace does not destroy nature, but elevates and restores nature. And having real
01:33:22 conversations with nature about men and women, about different races, about like these things
01:33:32 have to be talked about and you've got uh the the the right far right wing cesspool online that
01:33:40 talks about them but it's it's christless it's godless and then you've got the christians but
01:33:46 they they won't address it at all and when they do it's just it's a it's a some little pietistic
01:33:53 um cliche that just drenched in apologies and they just having yeah that just glosses over
01:33:59 and just says you know really everybody's you know like like the disparity between crime you
01:34:04 know in america with you know different demographics it's just it's really just because
01:34:08 at the end of the day you know christians haven't done a good enough job and you know it's mainly
01:34:13 white people's fault right it's like is it though is it can we talk about there are massive
01:34:21 disparities we have to be able to talk about these things and then we need to talk about them
01:34:26 in Christian ways with a solution.
01:34:29 And colonization, I feel like, fits into that theme.
01:34:32 Like, I feel like that's in our wheelhouse.
01:34:33 You guys came up with the idea.
01:34:35 It's Columbus Day on Monday.
01:34:36 It's a perfect fit. 1.00
01:34:37 Like, that's, you know, everybody's saying,
01:34:40 well, this is bad.
01:34:40 And I'm looking at the world, I'm saying,
01:34:43 right about the time we started deciding
01:34:45 that colonization was oppressive,
01:34:47 it was also right about the time that IQs went down,
01:34:49 lifespans went down, population went down,
01:34:50 and things, you know, and we started, you know,
01:34:54 uh having furries um so i i think you know make colonization great again
01:35:01 it's how it's not just all right we're not going to rebrand it to indigenous people's day we're
01:35:05 not going to make right it's a bad guy it's an actual positive celebration yeah it's not just
01:35:09 the negative well we're not going to tear him down we're not going to get rid of his statute
01:35:12 we're not going to rename the holiday don't do those things and positively not all the time
01:35:17 i think maybe one in about 365 days you know thank god for the men yeah think about this
01:35:22 set sail across an ocean with no idea what was on the other side.
01:35:26 Thank God for that spirit of adventure and for saying,
01:35:29 and I'm going to do it and I'm going to bring the Christian gospel with me.
01:35:31 I'm going to bring, as it were, expand the kingdom of God.
01:35:34 I think this is good to take one day a year and say,
01:35:36 praise God for Columbus and for those men and for that spirit.
01:35:40 Yeah.
01:35:41 All right, let's do one more commercial break
01:35:43 and then we'll just do some questions.
01:35:45 You have heard it said that cash is king.
01:35:47 Well, our sponsor, Private Family Banking,
01:35:49 wants you to know that cash flow is the key to building wealth.
01:35:53 The partners at Private Family Banking are experts at teaching you
01:35:57 how to implement a new way of thinking about money.
01:36:01 This powerful and innovative approach provides a fail-safe method
01:36:05 for redirecting the cash flow you already have
01:36:08 into a privatized banking system that you now own and control.
01:36:12 This new system places you and your family on the wealth curve
01:36:16 for continuously compounding tax-protected gains
01:36:20 now and unto future generations.
01:36:23 You may also be familiar with the age-old wisdom
01:36:26 that the best time to plant a tree for shade
01:36:29 was 10 years ago, but the second best time is today.
01:36:33 So start your journey
01:36:35 of building your financial legacy right now.
01:36:38 The sooner you start, the better.
01:36:40 Let a private family banking partner
01:36:42 help you put post-mill talk into post-mill action.
01:36:46 Contact them today by emailing banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
01:36:52 Again, that's banking at privatefamilybanking.com
01:36:56 and request a free step-by-step wealth building plan
01:37:00 that will be the game changer that you have been looking for.
01:37:04 Lastly, a complimentary discovery call can be scheduled
01:37:08 by using the link in this episode's show notes.
01:37:11 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians
01:37:14 to do their duty before God and not to have their consciences ruled
01:37:16 by the doctrines and commandments of men.
01:37:19 Rees Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied,
01:37:22 not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business
01:37:26 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
01:37:29 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
01:37:34 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them
01:37:37 to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here.
01:37:41 Rees Fund, Christian capital, boldly deployed. 0.73
01:37:46 fellas i'm not going to sugarcoat it i'm going to shoot you straight it is high time to get off 0.89
01:37:53 of gay email join paxmail.cc instead we all know that these other companies support the exact 0.97
01:38:00 opposite of everything we believe so keep your money with the brothers we've got email check 0.96
01:38:07 we've got docs drive calendar appointments project management check so help us in the fight to end 0.96
01:38:14 abortion and to stop the expansion of the gay global communist agenda. Join us today at 0.97
01:38:20 paxmail.cc. Again, that's paxmail.cc. All right. Well, welcome back. We had a good question. So
01:38:34 this is from Semper Reformanda. He asked, why, I'm just kind of paraphrasing,
01:38:41 Why isn't it that the founders, why is it that the founders, they weren't more, yes, the American founders, the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, why weren't they more explicit about the specifically Christian nature of the United States?
01:38:54 Like, doesn't that seem like if they were all Christian, we had this robust Christian founding, that in our Constitution, in our foundational documents, they would have imbued it with language about the Lord Jesus, language of the Trinity, that wouldn't that have been more present?
01:39:07 And we were talking about it.
01:39:09 I think there's two kind of things that cause them to have to take some broader language.
01:39:13 The only reference you would have to God would be in the Constitution that all men are created by their creator with inalienable rights.
01:39:22 To get some of that language in there, the creator, that's about the only acknowledgement.
01:39:26 One of them is the Enlightenment.
01:39:28 There's, coming from the French Revolution, there is a starting to have a turning away from God, a turning away from,
01:39:34 it's kind of this idea that we can use reason to arrive at these conclusions of spiritual and
01:39:39 natural things. We don't need the scriptures. So first it's, well, they're kind of on par, right?
01:39:43 Scripture, nature, natural revelation, they teach us equally. And then they kind of let the scripture
01:39:48 fall out of the way. And it's all reason and it's all nature and it's all reasoning to these
01:39:52 conclusions. So the Enlightenment does a number on that. And many of these men, some of these men,
01:39:56 they felt, well, we don't need scriptures. And deism is a valid premise for a nation.
01:40:04 So some of the founders, some of them were seminarians, a small number, some of them
01:40:08 were deists, and that meant the second element, so first element, you have the enlightenment,
01:40:12 you have the receding of Christianity, the second element is you, it's tough to bring
01:40:17 coalitions of people together.
01:40:19 So you had 39 signers out of the 55 delegates, it's tough to get 40, almost 40 people to
01:40:25 come together and agree, and so to broadly kind of get as many to sign, get the Constitution
01:40:30 ratified, I think there was definitely some concession, whereas those that had seminary
01:40:34 degrees, those that were staunch Christians, which were many of them. Washington was a little
01:40:38 too private about his faith. I wish he had been more like Lee or Jackson. So some of the guys 0.75
01:40:43 are willing to say, hey, we can keep it broad. But what this does, though, because we don't have
01:40:48 that language you see in some court cases, like Holy Trinity versus United States, it's more
01:40:52 difficult later on for the United States to hold to and justify that Christian foundation that we
01:40:59 all know we had there were state churches in many of the original colonies we've been a christian
01:41:04 nation without question since our inception but that that not getting the language in there not
01:41:09 explicitly calling out by name not just the creator but the lord jesus christ and the triune god
01:41:15 those things they've cost us and now it's more deniable that yeah well maybe we were always just
01:41:22 kind of a broadly deistic liberty fraternity justice for all kind of hodgepodge of people
01:41:28 So it was a compromise, I would say, stemming apart from the Enlightenment, stemming apart from pragmatic needs, and it goes on to hurt us in the long run.
01:41:37 I hear what you're saying, Wes. I have just one counterfactual for that, is that Canada was an explicitly Christian charter from the beginning. 0.62
01:41:47 I mean, they quote Psalm 72, their mission statement was to extend the glory of Christ from sea to sea.
01:41:53 Like, that was in their original governmental charter.
01:41:56 But their charter doesn't have the teeth that the Constitution has.
01:41:59 I agree with that.
01:42:00 So my point is, they had explicitly Christian language,
01:42:05 and they have fallen faster than we did in a lot of ways. 0.94
01:42:08 So Canada's like Big Eva,
01:42:10 in the sense that wrapped in Christian language,
01:42:15 but the actual principles didn't actually articulate
01:42:18 and have as strong of a muscular defense for the freedom of men.
01:42:24 whereas like the constitution the principles are all christian deeply christian so better better
01:42:30 actually theological principles in the you know the american constitution um but but uh you know
01:42:38 these better principles but uh not um but not you know not the explicit christian language of you
01:42:44 know um the lord jesus christ the triune god uh those kinds of things and i you know i've thought
01:42:49 often like well if only they had written explicit things like defining marriage and the reality is
01:42:55 the other reality is evil and perverse ideas and wicked ideologies are always going to attack and
01:43:02 part of what happened was we stopped being vigilant right we stopped being vigilant and
01:43:08 um there's lots of reasons for that historically um but i think that the founders also couldn't
01:43:14 really imagine a time where the church wasn't fighting to keep people truly Christian. I don't
01:43:20 think they could have imagined a time when the church was flying rainbow flags and apostatizing
01:43:25 on mass. We're talking close to 98% of the United States was Christian in 1900. So 124 years ago,
01:43:33 basically could have been your great-grandparents. 99, 98, maybe 95% of the nation professing. Now,
01:43:40 regenerate would be a smaller subset of that but right probably the majority i would have to think
01:43:44 and what an incredible place yeah yeah i can answer this question so vlad yakobets yakobets
01:43:53 um was columbus jewish i'm 30 minutes into the stream may have missed the answer i did a little
01:43:59 bit of digging on this uh my background's in biology and genetics so when we say is someone
01:44:03 of a certain lineage of a certain race we're looking for genetic markers and so the big news
01:44:08 about columbus being jewish jewish was the presence of a haplogroup so this will be like
01:44:13 a group of genetics that are only signaturely carried with uh just certain individuals so if
01:44:17 only a certain lineage contains a certain genetic mutation and someone has that then you could say
01:44:22 at least part of their lineage was this as i understand it uh the haplogroup that have been
01:44:26 identified uh is is certainly many people who are jewish have it but it's also more broadly european
01:44:32 so we would say no it doesn't appear that he would have been there you go columbus he's not
01:44:39 a jew that's science yep um all right let's see um who is your best uh favorite colonizer
01:44:49 in history is another one of the questions i don't know i don't know columbus is pretty great
01:44:57 is pretty let's just honor him it's columbus day any other good questions nathan i think he already
01:45:02 put them up there okay all right okay cool all right well thank you guys so much for tuning in
01:45:09 while i have your attention we got 130 people uh right now on the live stream help us out uh go
01:45:14 ahead and like the video we have 88 likes i would love if we could go ahead and just get it to
01:45:18 i don't know 120 150 would be phenomenal so uh right now i know the stream is always a little
01:45:24 bit behind so by the time i'm saying this you will be hearing it about three minutes from now
01:45:30 or so but i'm going to keep saying it for a second and uh you guys are going to start liking the
01:45:35 video not just a thumbs up as a comment in the chat although that helps too so if you want to
01:45:40 be active in the chat that certainly helps if you want to put in a comment for the algorithm we
01:45:44 appreciate it but right now there it comes there it comes give us the thumbs up that means like
01:45:48 the video if you like this video it's going to trigger the algorithm it's going to get it out
01:45:51 to more people and uh guys again we're not we're not trying to be prideful we're not trying to be
01:45:58 arrogant um we're made from the dust there's there's nothing special about uh the three men
01:46:03 in this room um this is this is not uh making much of joel uh wes and michael um this is making much
01:46:12 of jesus on the one hand and on the second this is making little of the evangelical church as a whole
01:46:18 guys it is rough out there you guys know it you guys do you follow this ministry um because you
01:46:25 can't find a church you know or you follow this ministry because nobody else talks about these
01:46:31 kinds of things and by god's grace you know what there are you know if we were to do a follow
01:46:34 friday we'll call it a follow wednesday but uh john harris talks about these kinds of things
01:46:38 adi robles yeah talks about these kinds of things uh stephen wolf talks about these kinds of things
01:46:43 uh let me think who else uh andrew whisker and cj uh ingle on contramundum check them out uh
01:46:50 steven wolf has a youtube channel now so look up steven wolf and i just today i you know when i
01:46:55 was talking to him that was you know he's asking me for some some youtube uh advice uh but but
01:46:59 help him out the channel's small but steven wolf is um he's a sharp guy gosh he's brilliant and
01:47:05 and um well worth your time so check out steven wolf check out a contramundum check out conversations
01:47:11 that matter with John Harris.
01:47:13 Check out Aidy Robles.
01:47:15 Who else can we plug?
01:47:16 Center for Baptist Leadership.
01:47:18 Center for Baptist Leadership with William Wolfe.
01:47:21 He's doing great work.
01:47:22 Check him out.
01:47:23 Has Dusty Devers started his podcast yet?
01:47:25 He's going to for a while, I think.
01:47:27 So if he ever does, then check out Dusty Devers.
01:47:29 If not, feel free to move to Oklahoma
01:47:32 and vote for Dusty Devers.
01:47:34 He'll be up for re-election soon.
01:47:37 Backwards Belief.
01:47:38 Backwards Belief, yeah.
01:47:39 Jeff Wright.
01:47:40 Put out an episode.
01:47:41 yeah they do from like like once a month not super often but backwards belief um these guys
01:47:47 you know there's there's about i don't know 50 of us uh west probably like 50 of us that like
01:47:53 we try to we try to collaborate and stay just stay in relationship stay in friendship
01:47:58 and um and sharpen one another iron sharpens iron and um there's there's about 50 guys and
01:48:05 we've just named some of them but there are others that i would say man when i think about these
01:48:10 names these men um i feel um i feel particularly bullish on american christianity when i look
01:48:17 outside of those 50 names i get really really discouraged really discouraged uh but there are
01:48:24 some good guys so uh we got 92 people right now guys that that that's pretty weak um help us out
01:48:30 go ahead and like the video subscribe to the channel again subscribe to the channel and click
01:48:35 the bell that way you'll be notified so what we do is every wednesday at about 4 p.m central time
01:48:41 we do the live stream every friday there's some off days in between but typically every friday
01:48:46 we do our uh friday special right now we've got running me and isker um on on all things israel
01:48:52 getting really just into the covenant theology and dealing with biblical text and so um that's
01:48:57 on fridays at 4 p.m a lot of them though are behind the paywall you'll have to become a member
01:49:01 at patreon so go over to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries but that's wednesdays
01:49:07 and fridays and the mondays i do an interview with different guys and that's again 4 p.m so
01:49:12 it's monday wednesday friday three shows a week 4 p.m central time if you click the bell you'll
01:49:17 be notified all three times every week when our show comes out we want you guys to be able to
01:49:21 follow along also if you're able to we ask that you would be willing to uh to donate and help
01:49:29 us support this ministry. A one-time gift makes a world of difference. But the biggest difference
01:49:34 is honestly, you guys who are willing to sign up and support us monthly. To do that, I think,
01:49:42 Nathan, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think it's rightresponseministries.com forward slash donate.
01:49:51 rightresponseministries.com forward slash donate. And you'll find there's a couple of different
01:49:56 options to where you can be a monthly supporter you even get a gift we'll send you a free book
01:50:00 we'll send you a shirt uh right response shirt um and by supporting us monthly it helps tremendously
01:50:06 uh we're uh in the works right now we've got some big things some of the things i can't really
01:50:11 talk about yet but we're we're building a new studio we're excited about that um we're hiring
01:50:16 um well michael and west we want to compensate them um nathan needs a raise and we want to get
01:50:23 an administrator, a part-time administrator with Right Response to help us. And so we're trying
01:50:30 to continue to grow. But basically what I've noticed, eventually I want to do a whole episode
01:50:35 on this. I told you guys about this, but I'll tease it right here at the end. I kind of want
01:50:40 to do like an episode where the thumbnail, it's like a silhouette with a question mark. And it
01:50:45 says uh the most um like the uh the most valuable person or that like you know envy uh mvp um in uh
01:50:53 in in all of christendom you know or in the new christendom and and basically the case that i
01:50:58 would make is and i know it sounds sappy uh but the case i would make is it's you and what i mean
01:51:03 by that is um the total state that like oran mcintyre talks about that the the regime the
01:51:11 left i mean it's just it's captured everything um and basically here's the deal it really is
01:51:18 playing for keeps i'm not trying to use hyperbolic language or or be exaggeratory uh but but really
01:51:24 being objective here um if you say the kinds of things you guys you guys have seen it just the
01:51:30 last week and a half and before that you know if you go back so you know two weeks ago it's this
01:51:35 you know and then two months ago it's uh joel talking about white and black doctors you know
01:51:39 like it's always something it's always something and um and all the things that i'm saying are
01:51:45 biblically defensible um they're they're not racist they're not anti-semitic they're not
01:51:52 misogynist right like the first thing that i first went viral for was um telling my wife that i didn't
01:51:58 want her to read a particular book and the larger point was talking about different spheres of
01:52:02 authority the state has authority over a lot of people but not that much authority and then you
01:52:07 know a church pastors have authority over less people but a little bit more authority and in a
01:52:11 home a father and a husband has a lot of authority and not just authority but also a responsibility a
01:52:17 duty to protect to provide and protect and that's physical and spiritual and part of that spiritual
01:52:22 protection is is being um being observant and and monitoring uh what is the spiritual intake uh the
01:52:31 spiritual diet of my children and my wife and my family. Well, I said that, and it went viral
01:52:38 because, you know, there was a pastor who was losing the debate about Christian nationalism
01:52:43 on the merits of the theological arguments. And when you can't, you know, beat me in a theological
01:52:48 argument, what you do is you take something that's not related to it whatsoever and try to make that
01:52:52 go viral. And so that was Andy Woodard. And so he shared that clip because he was losing the
01:52:57 conversation about christian nationalism in my book fight by flight and then you know that put
01:53:02 me on the map and people started canceling me because of that and then you know since then he's
01:53:06 completely you know blown up his life and is no longer pastoring that church and it's really sad
01:53:11 um less than a year from a front runner in the anti-christian nationalism discourse and now
01:53:16 extremely disqualified from ministry yep from ministry uh i'd like to say rare l but that
01:53:23 would be a common L. That's a common one. So lesson from that is one, be faithful to the
01:53:31 Lord and your family. And lesson number two, don't be an idiot and try to blow up other 1.00
01:53:38 people's ministries because vengeance belongs to the Lord and he will have it. I left that 1.00
01:53:44 one to the Lord. And I probably should have taken vengeance on my own because it would
01:53:51 have been more merciful it would have been far more merciful but uh i left that one to the lord
01:53:55 and uh the lord uh has crushed andy um blessed be the name of the lord so uh all that being said
01:54:02 the point is this we we are constantly um in the crosshairs of being canceled constantly whether
01:54:09 it's hey uh husbands have authority over the spiritual diet of their wives and children
01:54:15 radical misogynist canceled right or uh hey d.e.i. an affirmative action has radically
01:54:24 trans uh transformed the way americans have to think about merit and whether or not people
01:54:30 are qualified for positions radical racist canceled at every single level um people you
01:54:39 if you can't if you haven't picked that up guys i'd really again i'm not trying to be
01:54:44 self-serving and i'm not trying to be hyperbolic have have you noticed maybe you can just put in
01:54:49 the chat right now help me help me realize i'm not crazy have you noticed that uh there might
01:54:55 be a few people or perhaps let's say a few million people that want to cancel right response ministries
01:55:02 am i crazy nope is that fair i think i think that's pretty fair i think they're trying to
01:55:06 keep us alive they keep putting our stuff out there they keep publishing it for free that's
01:55:10 true they keep both but the point is like and here's the deal what like why would they do it
01:55:14 oh you know but here's here's the point i'm trying to make they're trying to do it because
01:55:19 it works it works that's true on the one hand it's like oh well you guys are just getting you
01:55:24 know mileage and this and that and the other it's like yeah we're getting mileage and people are
01:55:27 coming to us but 12 second clips taken out of context really do do damage they really do and so
01:55:34 for every every uh person who who who sees that in good faith and then goes and watches the full
01:55:42 length video and realizes oh he's just a christian who thinks like every other christian has thought
01:55:47 in the entire world until the 1960s you know like oh like um and all this is perfectly defensible
01:55:53 and oh he gave that clarification and that you know disclaimer and that caveat um for every
01:55:58 person who actually comes and watches the full video at least a hundred if not a thousand people
01:56:03 don't and they just and they just write you off um and those people here's the point those people
01:56:10 don't want us to be employed right those people they like we're talking about wicked people and
01:56:15 yes about half of them profess to be christians sadly um so so i'm talking about even christian
01:56:24 people uh there are thousands tens of thousands of christians who would love if i couldn't feed
01:56:30 my children he would absolutely love it like they would be elated they would be laughing and giggling
01:56:36 with glee christians if if if my wife megan and my children starved like they won't say it out loud
01:56:44 but that's their heart they hate this ministry they hate god's word they hate the truth the
01:56:52 eternal universal truth of god being applied in practical ways to the topics that matter because 0.98
01:57:00 and here's the deal here's here's the thing that is so sad and pathetic it's weak it's weak um 0.96
01:57:07 the thing that they hate they hate me for they will because we will win they will be saying 0.93
01:57:13 those things as though they always believed them themselves right and just five years five to ten
01:57:19 years from now right and yet they wanted my family to be destroyed five to ten years earlier for
01:57:25 saying it i'll put it like this they always killed the prophets in israel but the people of israel
01:57:33 didn't kill the prophets because the prophets were right they killed the prophets because the
01:57:37 prophets were first everybody it wasn't because because later on everybody claimed to agree with
01:57:43 jeremiah everybody claimed to agree with isaiah everybody they built tombs and monuments to the
01:57:48 prophet it's not being right that gets you into trouble it's being first that's my point and and
01:57:54 here's the deal. You want all your medieval favorite pastors and ministries, which I'm
01:58:02 trying to be charitable today, so I'm not going to name some of them. You want them to come out
01:58:06 and take some strong stands. I'll tell you how it's going to happen.
01:58:11 It's going to happen by us first going and clearing the room. Special ops, go in, clear the
01:58:18 room, and then everybody else can follow up. So we're going to go in with night vision,
01:58:22 under the cover of darkness,
01:58:25 specially trained with real courage
01:58:27 and take out the baddies
01:58:29 and go into the real risk,
01:58:31 the real danger,
01:58:32 when it's actually costly to do so.
01:58:34 And once we've cleared the room
01:58:36 and once it's safe for Medeva to come in,
01:58:39 they will.
01:58:40 And then once Medeva has come in, 1.00
01:58:42 then Big Eva will come in. 1.00
01:58:43 So you want to win? 1.00
01:58:45 You need Medeva to step in. 0.98
01:58:48 Medeva won't step in
01:58:49 Until we've already dived into uncharted waters that were dangerous and tumultuous and cleared away and acted in real courage and made it safe.
01:59:03 And here's the whole point.
01:59:04 Who's the most valuable, the MVP of the new Christendom?
01:59:07 Because it sounds like, Joel, you're saying it's you guys.
01:59:09 No, it's you.
01:59:10 Here's the deal.
01:59:11 We can only do what we do because everyone right now wants to cancel us.
01:59:16 But you can actually make us bulletproof.
01:59:19 you want to win if you want to win this we need numbers you know how you get the numbers first
01:59:26 you get some guys to say it and then in five years everyone will say it this is what happened
01:59:32 in the push against wokeness this is what happened in the push against covet this is what will always
01:59:36 happen is some guys say it then everyone says it but for the some guys to say it they have to be
01:59:42 able to say it and if they say it and get crushed a week later and disappear then that that's the
01:59:50 sign that's like noah with the ark sending out the dove and it never comes back you know uh or or
01:59:55 you know it it's not a good analogy it drowns right it's the canary in the coal mine you know
02:00:00 it's that's your sign that's your sign that um that oh i guess it's not time i guess it's too
02:00:05 risky i guess it's too dangerous to say these things because because i watched the right response
02:00:09 say it and they got crushed and and we never heard from them again well here's here's the
02:00:12 commitment that i'm making to you um i won't quit i won't quit um and we will continue to to have
02:00:20 the hard conversations that need to be had um but what we're asking from you is um will you
02:00:26 collectively and anonymously you can do it so you get to i'm the face so i'm the guy who who uh
02:00:33 risk getting punched in the face when i walk down the street because 10 million people hate me
02:00:36 okay i will bear that risk um what we're asking from you is that will you financially help us to
02:00:44 bear that risk because uh big evil will come if medieval uh hold holds the line and medieval will
02:00:51 come if we uh go and clear the room and we can keep cleaning the room and be bulletproof and
02:00:59 never canceled if uh if you won't let um if you won't let the demons cancel us that's all that's
02:01:06 all it takes like if we could get my my goal if we can and i'm not saying it's going to happen next
02:01:12 year but over time my goal is that uh that both wes and michael could be a full-time employed with
02:01:18 right response and that it would predominantly be um individual donors the salt of the earth
02:01:25 that the widow's mites collected um all all you you you know far right-wing anons you know who
02:01:32 are starting your own business and raising your kids and working hard and and you know blue collar
02:01:37 guys that you pitching in a hundred dollars a month especially i'll just say this especially
02:01:42 you guys who don't have a church uh number one first get a church if there's no church in town
02:01:49 plant one if you're not qualified to plant one then you have to move i don't care what it costs
02:01:55 being churchless indefinitely is not a viable option that is not has not been afforded to you
02:02:01 by Jesus Christ in his word. You don't get to do that. You don't. So you guys who don't have a
02:02:07 church, get a church. Find one. Well, Joel, I've looked in a 60-mile radius. Now do 70.
02:02:13 We've got people driving two and a half hours to our church. So drive further, move, or start a
02:02:19 church. But you can't be churchless. That said, so that's first and foremost. That said. Secondly,
02:02:24 until you get a church, though, why are you not supporting this ministry? You email me,
02:02:31 I, you know, you tell me how much you appreciate us, like, as you're churchless, so why don't,
02:02:39 I understand the economy's not great, I understand it's difficult, and we're not a church, and so
02:02:44 there's not a biblical obligation to tithe, so while you're churchless, why don't you give some
02:02:49 of the money that you would be tithing to this ministry, and save the rest for your kids? And
02:02:53 then also, C.8, be active and diligent, and find a church, and stop being churchless. So those
02:02:59 kind of things my point is if you guys supported us monthly then the mvp as far as i'm concerned
02:03:04 of the new christendom is you you guys in other ministries like brian silvey and and eric khan
02:03:09 like they are saying things that need to be said and everyone wants to cancel them people hate eric
02:03:17 khan they hate steven wolf yeah they hate him and i'm talking about good people christians they hate
02:03:23 Stephen Wolfe. They hate Andrew Isker. They hate Eric Kahn. They hate Joel Webin. They hate John
02:03:30 Harris. They hate A.D. Robles. They want us crushed. And the reality is we live, like we've
02:03:37 talked about, the spiritual but also the natural, we live in a real world. And the reality is that
02:03:42 it is possible to crush us. It is possible to leverage influence and to actually financially
02:03:51 crush someone to where they have to be silenced. Canceling is a real thing,
02:03:59 but it's not possible if you guys just say, we won't let it happen. We are going to rally around
02:04:08 not just watching and benefiting ourselves, but we're actually going to make this a mutually
02:04:13 beneficial relationship. You guys have been a blessing to us, and so we're going to commit in
02:04:17 2025 to be a monthly blessing to you and maybe it's 20 bucks and maybe for some of you it's 200
02:04:23 bucks but if enough of you guys who follow this ministry and claim to have been so blessed by it
02:04:30 do that then guess what everybody else who's trying to cancel us can pound sand they can just
02:04:37 they can they can squeal and and screech and wail into into the void as much as they want 0.78
02:04:44 But this ministry can't be stopped if individual Christians like you say,
02:04:52 we won't let it be stopped. 1.00
02:04:53 This ministry will end the second that you say, we're going to let it end.
02:04:59 But if you say, no, we're not going to let that happen.
02:05:02 We're going to make sure that these guys continue to have a voice.
02:05:08 Then we'll continue to talk.
02:05:10 Our commitment is we'll continue to talk about these things,
02:05:12 and we'll do it with courage.
02:05:13 but we can only do it if you guys help to insulate us because apart from that what i'm saying is
02:05:19 apart from that the stuff that we're talking about it's like well why don't you guys just
02:05:25 work another job because the stuff that we're talking about when it goes viral to two million
02:05:30 people it makes you unemployable you can't get another job that's what they want to do that's
02:05:39 what that's what the left regime and sadly many christians and many reform christians you know
02:05:45 who i'm talking about that's what they want to do they want to make us unemployable they want to
02:05:50 um they actually the the left starts screeching and then they join the left and and they want to
02:05:57 ultimately drop an anvil and crush uh this ministry to where we like it's just it's too high
02:06:05 Because at the end of the day, our obligation is to our wives and children.
02:06:08 If we have to choose, we're going to choose our families.
02:06:10 And so, yeah, if I have to choose, then I'm going to go into obscurity and I'm going to
02:06:15 drive a FedEx truck or whatever and do what I have to do to feed my kids, because that's
02:06:21 what God calls me to do.
02:06:22 I only get to do this if enough people commit to financially insulating me.
02:06:29 That's it.
02:06:30 That's how it works.
02:06:31 And these guys only get to do this if people will commit to financially insulating them.
02:06:37 Because if not, then it's suicide.
02:06:40 And it's actually unbiblical to just put your neck out and not just to be killed,
02:06:47 but financially destroyed and blacklisted when you have a wife and children
02:06:54 that you're obligated to defend and protect and provide for.
02:06:57 um so we will be as courageous as you will be generous
02:07:02 and that's kind of the way it works so you guys have anything you want to say
02:07:08 no that was good it's good yeah okay i think that that eventually should be like a full episode like
02:07:14 even mapping out some of the statistics and and cancel culture and how it like because you can
02:07:18 see like the guys who are are they're just they're invulnerable they're they're like um
02:07:24 they're they just can't be immune to canceling they're the guys who have the most committed
02:07:30 followers who just i talked to stephen wolf at the ogden conference and uh he's like i'm i'm
02:07:36 untouchable like the way his life is set up i won't give details there's nothing anyone can do
02:07:40 from to him so he's able to write any book he wants to say anything he wants on twitter to go
02:07:44 on his his channel on his podcast and say anything because nobody can touch any aspect of his life
02:07:51 and significantly affect it that's the ideal i would say for every christian that's the ideal
02:07:54 and and there's so many guys like i mean it really is that simple it's sad but this is the truth so
02:08:00 many guys who are not uh it's like why i thought that guy was so solid why'd he why did he um
02:08:07 why why did he choke on this why why did he why did he cower on this why did like um
02:08:16 because he's not insulated that's a big part of it um some of these guys that you admire that are
02:08:22 are so courageous that is what that's one of the common denominators is that uh yes part of it is
02:08:28 is just sanctification and spiritually that they love the lord and these kinds of things and they
02:08:32 but also part of is one thing that they all have in common is like like steven wolf is uh they live
02:08:39 um they live on land they're a little bit away from society um like geographically they're
02:08:46 insulated financially they have some kind of uh they have they either own their own business
02:08:51 like andrew isker you know like how is he so courageous well he works for andrew torba
02:08:56 and and half of his salary is going to be covered by gap and now the other half is going to be with
02:09:04 the new founding guys and going to
02:09:07 Ridge Runner and you know and those kinds of like
02:09:08 so like those 0.67
02:09:10 those things make you bulletproof
02:09:12 without those things what you get is
02:09:15 Russell Moore
02:09:15 and you get Russell Moore saying
02:09:19 well I'm going to go to the people
02:09:20 you know who will
02:09:23 who will promise to take care of you get David
02:09:25 French you get you know
02:09:26 Francis Collins yeah so you guys
02:09:29 get it that's enough but thanks
02:09:31 for tuning in and we'll see you next time
02:09:34 as you continue the economy.
02:09:37 Thank you.