The NXR Podcast - April 16, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - Traducianism: The Fascinating Idea That Explains So Much w⧸Ben Garrett of Haunted Cosmos

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - A Tale of Two Easters & Trump’s Antisemitism Taskforce THE LIVESTREAM - Military Service in a Nation That’s Lost Its Way

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 11 minutes

Words per minute

181.39

Word count

13,040

Sentence count

494

Harmful content

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Traducianism is the belief that the souls of children are inherited from their parents, like two candles coming together to light another candle. In this view, parents give not just their genetics to their children, but pass on a unique personal component as well.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 time memorializes place embodied memory and places generates a connection between the past
00:00:34 present and future our activity with loved ones elevates sites to place of intergenerational love
00:00:41 such that through them we experience these places as deposits of familial affection a trace of love
00:00:49 remains. Stephen Wolfe, The Case for Christian Nationalism, from the chapter Loving Your Nation.
00:00:57 In recovering honor for our fathers and a sense of national identity, one of the most important
00:01:03 things will be to forge a connection to our past. We often speak of this connection in terms of
00:01:10 knowledge, values, and history. It is something objective and measurable. But what if we are
00:01:16 bound together to our family, our home, and our country in even deeper ways. Traducianism is a
00:01:25 historic Christian belief that has been a minority view throughout church history, although it was
00:01:30 held by some notable church fathers like Tertullian and reformers like Luther. Traducianism
00:01:37 is the belief that the souls of children are inherited from their parents, like two candles
00:01:43 coming together to light another candle. In this view, parents give not just their genetics to
00:01:50 their children, but pass on a unique personal spiritual component as well. In this way,
00:01:57 memories, affections, vitality, and other spiritual qualities are passed down through
00:02:02 the families and time, shaping each family and nation into a distinct ethnos with its own unique
00:02:10 spiritual properties even myths and archetypes that we know so well in the west live on in our
00:02:18 deepest memories their details lost to time but their form continually re-presented in our stories
00:02:26 ideas and even dreams traducianism is a compelling framework that offers a biblical and enchanted view
00:02:34 of the world where families, homes, and history are not merely material matter, but have a
00:02:41 spiritual connection to everything that came before and are an essential part of our hope
00:02:48 for the future. This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and
00:02:54 Reese Fund, as well as our Patreon members and our faithful donors. You can join our Patreon by
00:03:01 going to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries or you can donate by going to right
00:03:09 response ministries.com forward slash donate coming on now to discuss traducianism is ben
00:03:17 garrett from haunted cosmos tune in now for a discussion that you won't want to miss
00:03:22 all right all right all right ga title this episode it's a blood memory there it is all
00:03:39 right west you kick it off and then uh and then let's go ahead and get ben all right so we got
00:03:43 ben garrett with us we're going to be talking about an idea uh i've known about it for a while
00:03:48 I remember reading, it was actually Gerhardus Voss, his reformed argmatics, and he could
00:03:52 contrast this view with creationism.
00:03:55 And it was funny at the time, because Voss doesn't actually believe in traducionism,
00:03:58 so he argued for the creationist view.
00:04:00 But he had this image, and he said, one of the ways that traducionism is described is
00:04:04 it's like a flame being carried on.
00:04:06 And in a sense, there is a new flame, but it's also a continuance, a likeness to the
00:04:11 old.
00:04:11 So you think about generation, you think about the continuance of it.
00:04:14 And so I remember that image always stuck with me, and it's been in the last six months that the two smartest people I know, Ben Garrett and C.J. Engel, have both said, yeah, we're kind of traditionists.
00:04:24 And I said, well, that's enough proof for me.
00:04:27 So I really like this view.
00:04:28 I think it explains a lot and doesn't just have theological import, theological importance, but I think practically.
00:04:34 I talked about legacy.
00:04:36 We talked about history and even here at America and here in the West.
00:04:39 What does it mean to be American?
00:04:40 And well, of course, there's history and all the different things that we could point to objectively that we could put in a textbook.
00:04:46 But I think being American is something deeper than that.
00:04:49 And even more so, not just to make it about race as if it's just only about genetic lineage, but a spiritual lineage as well.
00:04:56 And so to talk about all of this, to give us the details, we have Ben Garrett.
00:04:59 Ben, thanks for coming on the show.
00:05:01 Hey, thanks for having me.
00:05:02 And thank you for that high praise.
00:05:04 CJ is very smart.
00:05:05 And so are all of you.
00:05:06 So, yeah, I feel like I'm in good company.
00:05:10 Awesome. Well, Ben, I'll hand it over to you. I've done a lot of the reading on this,
00:05:14 but I would love for you to explain in your own words, traducianism, how it contrasts with
00:05:19 creationism, and even historically, how the thought along that has fallen. I know Augustine
00:05:24 was back and forth on it, but one of the big advantages of it is as it relates to original
00:05:28 sin. So I'll kick it to you. Yeah, thanks. So traducianism is definitely the minority report
00:05:34 among the reformers, the reformed Orthodox, and then even up into the American Presbyterians,
00:05:40 as far as I can tell. I think among the medieval Christians as well and the scholastics, it was
00:05:45 a minority position, sort of a split bag. But that doesn't mean it's unorthodox. It is actually
00:05:52 a perfectly orthodox position that you can defend from scripture. Now, creationism, maybe I'll start
00:05:57 there. Creationism is this view of the generation of the soul that says that at the time of
00:06:03 conception or sometime soon thereafter, depending on who you read, God creates a unique soul for
00:06:10 that created person, ex nihilo, in time, it's brand new. It comes from nothing, God makes it.
00:06:18 Now, the Traducian point of view is a little bit different. It says, no, we actually don't want to
00:06:23 get into that because it presents some problems that we can talk about in a little bit. And
00:06:27 Instead, what we should see is that man as a species, as a kind, is an embodied soul.
00:06:34 And so in order to reproduce after its own kind, it has to be able to reproduce not only
00:06:38 the body, but the soul that it has as well.
00:06:41 Otherwise, it stops being an embodied soul as a species.
00:06:44 And so Traducianism says that, just like how you said, just like how a baby gets its genetic
00:06:50 code from its parents, it also gets the soul as an inheritance from its parents at the
00:06:55 time of conception.
00:06:57 got it that's kind of the elevator pitch absolutely i remember this would have been a couple years
00:07:03 ago but joe biden for example like well where practically does this matter i remember joe
00:07:07 biden talking about abortion and he talked about how thomas aquinas viewed in soulment that is the
00:07:12 impartation of the soul to the body he viewed in soulment as something that happened 45 days
00:07:17 after conception so joe biden literally made the case well hey i'm a catholic and one of our
00:07:22 greatest catholic scholars he says well the soul isn't there necessarily early on so we're not
00:07:26 actually ending a life and so practically speaking i mean that's a great argument against abortion
00:07:31 that there's no not even a millisecond from that moment of conception the egg and the sperm meeting
00:07:37 and forming that fertilized egg there's not even a moment it's lacking a soul that we're not talking
00:07:42 about a five minute wait time or 45 days as aquinas maybe argued till god puts the soul in
00:07:47 there and it's that full human being i want to turn it to original sin ben uh how would this
00:07:52 also affect because this has been difficult for the creationists how do you account for original
00:07:56 sin when what god creates ex nihilo would theoretically be a soul that's untainted by
00:08:02 sin it comes from him it's generated from him i mean couldn't that soul theoretically be made
00:08:06 unfallen and without sin yeah why is god why is god making sinful souls right yeah i think that's
00:08:13 actually the bigger thing is it's really hard to reason your way to a position where god would
00:08:18 create ex nihilo, totally original, something that is already corrupted and tainted and depraved.
00:08:24 And so from my understanding, I think the creationists would answer, they wouldn't try
00:08:30 to avoid original sin, but they would try to say something like, well, that is something that we
00:08:34 don't understand. That's a portion of the soul's generation that we actually aren't privy to,
00:08:39 but they're unwilling to accept the inheritance and the propagation of some unseen life force
00:08:47 that you inherit from parents instead of from god and so i but the thing that tradition does really
00:08:53 well is it provides for original sin almost like from jump street as just organically yeah where
00:09:01 it says well if you're you know you only start sinning sometime after you're born or after you're
00:09:07 conceived in fact there's a whole period of nine months where a human being exists and as far as
00:09:13 we can tell, they're not sinning. They have no opportunities to sin or the faculties thereof.
00:09:17 And yet they still have a sinful nature. Everyone would confess that. And so how do we account for
00:09:22 that? Well, the tradition has a very simple answer. It's because the child inherited a soul
00:09:26 and that soul was already tainted with sin and a sinful nature from its parents. And so that's how
00:09:32 we're able to maintain the doctrine from the moment of conception and of birth, especially
00:09:37 of someone who is born in sin and who is therefore guilty of adam's fall but who has not yet sinned
00:09:44 himself yep it also makes sense of um the incarnation in the case of christ that because
00:09:50 he didn't have an earthly biological father but rather was conceived by the holy spirit
00:09:55 um that this sin nature uh not only in terms of his body but even his soul
00:10:01 was not passed down, and that the Holy Spirit even was not only able to provide, you know,
00:10:11 this soul that's untainted, but also purifying even his body to where, you know, Christ was
00:10:17 conceived without a sin nature. Yeah. Well, what does the view do, Ben, with the idea of
00:10:24 federal headship which we are sinners in adam um versus the idea that the soul is is the combination
00:10:32 of the soul of the mother and the father i mean i hear what you're saying joel but also i could
00:10:37 see that being an argument actually that if mary was a sinner which she was um part of her sin
00:10:43 would have been passed through in some way so what ben have you have you looked into or are you
00:10:48 familiar with what the tradition view unless it does with that issue pardon me unless it's through
00:10:52 the Father. Well, that would have to be the view, probably. Yeah. I think that there's two views.
00:10:58 One of them is that it is through the Father. The other one, though, is that Christ's incarnation
00:11:04 was sort of like a recapitulation and an inversion in some way of the creation of Eve. So when Eve
00:11:11 is created, Adam is put to sleep. And this is after Adam's been raised from the dust and the
00:11:16 Lord breathes the breath of life into him. He's put to sleep. A rib is taken from his side. And
00:11:21 from that rib, we receive the total Eve. We're not told that once Eve's body was made, God breathed
00:11:27 the breath of life into her again. And yet she's a full human being. She's an embodied soul.
00:11:34 So that tells us in the first pages of scripture that within man's body is all the constituent
00:11:39 parts necessary to make a total person, an embodied soul. And so the other view of Christ,
00:11:45 apart from it being purely an inheritance of the father, although I think that's compelling,
00:11:49 is also that since Christ was an inversion of Eve and a betterment of Eve, Mary was sort of the
00:11:58 vessel in that situation. She's put to sleep, so to speak, and the Holy Spirit forms a full person
00:12:06 in Mary with a human soul, human mind, all these things, and yet also the divine nature as well.
00:12:13 And so I think that the other view has been that Christ was kept miraculously safe from
00:12:19 the inheritance of a corrupted soul, despite gaining a fully human soul.
00:12:24 And of course, he had one.
00:12:26 Yeah, absolutely.
00:12:27 One of the things we talked about, and I think it's compelling as well, C.S.
00:12:31 Lewis, The Great Divorce.
00:12:32 I love his descriptions.
00:12:34 And obviously, he gets a little bit funny with these things, but he's an author and
00:12:36 he's telling stories.
00:12:38 But he describes, obviously, that first stage of the book where, if you haven't read it,
00:12:41 the author wakes up and he's in this gray languid dark kind of place and it's not terrible and it's
00:12:48 not awful but it's a place that's empty for the most part and what happens to the people there
00:12:53 is that they spread out it's an infinite regression i think it's napoleon you mentioned ben the people
00:12:58 look out and all they can see is just a tiny little light as he recedes from all everything
00:13:03 that could possibly be heaven all other people all the other places he just leaves it and he
00:13:08 infinitely regresses into the darkness there but then as we see with the author he takes the bus
00:13:14 up and he ascends to what would be as he has Lewis's view a type of purgatory obviously we
00:13:19 would in our framework we just have heaven and hell no intermediate state but then he ascends
00:13:23 to what would be the first stages of heaven but it's not static so his soul does not have the
00:13:28 option of residing in one place like I could stay at one home or I could stay at the other but every
00:13:34 soul is in a type of process and so for the soul that from creation from conception generated by
00:13:40 the parents is uh fallen is sinful that what that soul does short of repentance short of the new
00:13:49 life short of rebirth through the holy spirit he infinitely continually regresses into darkness he
00:13:56 denies the light of god he denies righteousness but for the believer what has happened is the
00:14:02 Holy Spirit has come and it's made them alive, but then they're too also not static. Think of Lewis
00:14:07 again, further up and further in. At the very end of great divorce, it's not like he arrives, I'm
00:14:12 here, I've made it, we've done it. No, he's looking at the mountains of the mysteries of God there is
00:14:16 to further press in and press out, press into, and in that way too you have an organic sense that
00:14:20 every soul has the choice. Will I indulge in, revert, go back to, and disappear into the nothingness
00:14:28 that is hell or will I press into that which is real and concrete and so every soul has that
00:14:33 choice in front of them and their stories ultimately which one they will choose obviously
00:14:37 aided by Christ who comes and makes us new creations in Christ Jesus but that is what's
00:14:42 kind of laid before and I love how organically it thinks of the options in front of us and what we
00:14:47 become that we never become what we don't want to be we never become something it's like well I
00:14:51 really really want to love God I really want to love people and I really want to love the light
00:14:55 well if you would you would press into that and love it and enjoy it however you don't you've
00:15:00 retreated from all of that what are some of your thoughts on that yeah no i i think i think that
00:15:04 it's in the great divorce where lewis has that great quip where one of the uh heavenly spirits
00:15:10 is talking to the visitor and and he says at the end of all things it will either you will either
00:15:16 say to god thy will be done or god will say to you thy will be done and so the corral will get
00:15:22 exactly what it wants, which is just more and more and more corruption. But I think one of the
00:15:27 pitfalls that we can fall into, and I'm glad you brought that up, Wesley, is because we're
00:15:31 emphasizing the fact that, yes, we inherit this soul from our parents, but it's still our own soul.
00:15:37 Like, you know, society isn't made up of individuals. It's made up of households, but
00:15:42 households do contain individuals. And so it's important that we remember that within the
00:15:48 tradition framework we're not denying the individuality of each and every soul uh and so
00:15:54 so what we're not saying is that it's just an amalgamation of two and if you do uh if you do
00:16:01 enough of a like differential equation you'll eventually be able to get to a brute determinism
00:16:05 even at the level of the soul no like it's spirit it is individual and so it can always
00:16:10 be its own it can break away from the memories and and the mythos and the ethos of the ones
00:16:17 that came before it. It's just that that's done through the power of the gospel. And so even
00:16:23 there, in traditionalism, I think, you get a far more potent view of how powerful the gospel is
00:16:29 when it works in someone's heart. And that not only is it changing that individual soul that
00:16:35 was just created ex nihilo a few years back into this new uncorrupted thing, it's actually
00:16:41 changing entire lines of people i even think it's in uh it's very telling that in the pentateuch
00:16:49 god says things like you know to the to the righteous i will i will bless them to the
00:16:53 thousandth generation but the wicked will visit the sins of the wicked on the third and fourth
00:16:58 generation right and then we also see in leviticus this language of blood being the life of a thing
00:17:03 and so we can think in in a conceptual framework at least of blood being this representation of
00:17:10 the soul. It's this life force. It's this embodiment of this unseen thing that actually
00:17:14 keeps us going. And so when you get blood connections with people, it tends to be that
00:17:21 the faults of the blood and the virtues of that blood compound with the generations. So if you
00:17:27 have a father who's a drunkard, you would expect the son to at least be tempted with that same
00:17:33 kind of sin, both because what God said is true, that he visits the iniquities of the father to
00:17:38 the third and fourth generation, but also because there's a mechanic in creation behind that,
00:17:42 that is the transfer of blood. And in the transfer of blood, you get the transfer of
00:17:47 the soul as well. And so even at a soul level, there's a predisposition to certain vices and
00:17:54 virtues. Right. Because spiritual properties are not necessarily, we couldn't speak of them
00:18:00 purely mechanicalistically. We talked about genetics a while ago. We talked about oxytocin,
00:18:05 which is bonding and monogamy and all those things we've talked about impulse control
00:18:08 predisposition to diabetes but it would be brute materialism like you just mentioned ben
00:18:14 it'd be pretty crude to try to break all that down and people have done this well what's the
00:18:18 gene that predisposes to violence or what's the the you know this passed on or what's the line
00:18:23 what's the race you could do all of that and you end up with a very mechanical mathematical world
00:18:29 and god didn't make that world he didn't make a world of statistics he made a world of of people
00:18:34 but what those people have, what makes them people, like we can make things that move around
00:18:38 and interact with the environment. They have no personality to them. They're not interesting.
00:18:42 What makes people people, what makes the world enchanted is the spirit that brings it all to life.
00:18:49 Yeah. I think actually Carl Jung has, he doesn't have really like good insights into this,
00:18:56 but he's really good at noticing this in nature. And so his, his, his works on mythology are really
00:19:01 helpful here because he's essentially noticing what what we're saying that uh that a man many
00:19:08 many generations removed from those that came before him has the side of these kind of unconscious
00:19:13 memories or images of the things that his great great great great great forefathers were concerned
00:19:20 with and dealt with now to him he tries to make it brutally materialistic and so what he says is
00:19:26 uh that i mean i don't know actually how jung gets away from like a pre-existence of the soul
00:19:32 but he's essentially saying that all of the collective unconscious of all mankind
00:19:37 is in one primordial soup and every once in a while the the brain in a type of recreation from
00:19:44 normal everyday life will either daydream or nightdream diving back into that primordial soup
00:19:50 and recovering images of a, he wouldn't call it this, but of the soul that actually helped
00:19:56 ancient man develop mythologies that explained the world that we live in at an enchanted level.
00:20:03 Now, his thesis that we've actually graduated beyond that, he doesn't necessarily say that's
00:20:09 a good thing, but he says that we've graduated beyond that into hyper-rationalism. But in so
00:20:14 doing, we have lost something that makes us human. Now, we would say we've denied the fact
00:20:20 that man is an embodied soul. At least that's part of the problem. And Jung might say something
00:20:24 different. But I thought it was so fascinating that he was picking up on that kind of trope
00:20:29 that you can have like a great-great-grandson who goes back to the place where his great-great
00:20:37 grandfather lived. And his family hasn't lived there for generations. But he goes back and he
00:20:43 feels an incredible sense of belonging that transcends his ability to rationally explain
00:20:49 where you go back to this farm or this city or whatever and this this man knows that somehow
00:20:55 somewhere along the line he belongs there that place formed him and the reason he thinks
00:21:02 well to me not to young he would go off on this but the reason he thinks that to me is because
00:21:09 that place helped form the soul of his great, great, great, great grandfather into what it was
00:21:15 when he had his great, great, great grandfather and then his great, great grandfather. And so
00:21:20 he's receiving these kind of lingering memories at a soul level and a blood level of the place
00:21:28 that helped form his forefather into the man that he became for better or for worse. And so I think
00:21:34 that it really gives us great explanatory power for some of the things that we both see and all
00:21:39 experience in nature ubiquitously which is reading stories or going to places or even hearing songs
00:21:45 that for whatever reason have a profound effect on us that far exceeds our ability to explain
00:21:51 with purely materialistic tools and this would also help to explain why families and by way of
00:21:58 consequence extended families nations ethnos um are different why they have different inclinations
00:22:08 different gifts different strengths different weaknesses because that's all a nation really is
00:22:14 it's just an extension of families and and one particular nation it's you know entirely plausible
00:22:21 and historically you know it bears out that some individual nations are made up of you know
00:22:26 multiple families you know that there were you know italians and there were also you know there
00:22:31 were multiple different families present but there's still there's still an extension of of
00:22:36 one group of people shaped by um by tradition by rituals by certainly by religion by worship
00:22:45 liturgy but then also by the land itself that you know different you know even the way that god
00:22:50 designed sovereignly you know the the the world geographically that um that a particular people
00:22:56 who have lived in a particular place for centuries or even millennia um that they would be shaped by
00:23:03 that. Are they a seafaring people? Are they a mountainous people? Are they people of a desert
00:23:08 or a plain? Are they people from the north where it's cold or the equator where it's hot? And so
00:23:13 even the land itself, in addition, of course, to liturgy and worship, do they, you know, for 0.96
00:23:19 millennial worship demons? Or are they coming off of the heels of a thousand years of Christendom?
00:23:24 You know, all these kinds of things. But all that shapes the people, ancestors, passed down
00:23:30 generation to generation to generation and eventually that that gets down to you and it
00:23:35 affects you and to pretend i think it's arrogant i'll just say it i think it's an arrogant presumption
00:23:42 to assume that that i'm just this unique little snowflake made from the ether you know that that
00:23:50 has that that all my lineage has no bearing and no shaping force on me whatsoever that i'm
00:23:58 completely individual completely unique uh that i'm the master of my own destiny 100 percent um
00:24:06 that i'm just the the summation of of the individual um choices that i made in a vacuum
00:24:15 without any presuppositions or biases whatsoever that just to me that that seems silly and and
00:24:24 it's and it's nice because everything that i just articulated there um gives an explanation for
00:24:30 nations and distinctions between peoples um that that it's it's not less than things like race which
00:24:39 are controversial and genetics um but it at least articulates that it's more that there's a spiritual
00:24:46 component so genetics are real so it is there's a biological element but there's not only a
00:24:52 biological element. There's a spiritual element as well, and there's actually theological language
00:24:57 that God provides for us in order to explain these things. Let's go to our first commercial
00:25:02 break, and then we'll come back, and I know, Ben, you'll want to respond to what I just said.
00:25:06 Our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants to help you with one money move that'll implicate itself
00:25:12 in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day. They help you to avoid taxation
00:25:18 and to draw compound interest to your money.
00:25:21 Now, if you're a high net worth individual,
00:25:24 someone who has maybe even $10 million in net worth,
00:25:27 then they can help you even more.
00:25:30 W-2 workers, contract workers, business owners,
00:25:33 it's all about cashflow and making tax deferred gains
00:25:37 on all your money for the rest of your life.
00:25:40 Don't avoid this.
00:25:41 It's a big move, but it's a great time to make it.
00:25:45 Click the link below
00:25:45 and you can get on Chuck DeLautorante's calendar
00:25:48 and he'll go over your background
00:25:50 and what you want to accomplish.
00:25:52 And he's going to help model a program
00:25:54 that exactly fits your needs.
00:25:56 So go ahead and send an email
00:25:58 to chuckatprivatefamilybanking.com.
00:26:01 Again, that's chuckatprivatefamilybanking.com.
00:26:05 Or you can click the link below.
00:26:07 Make a free discovery call now.
00:26:10 America is a country that was founded 1.00
00:26:11 for the purpose of allowing Christians
00:26:13 to do their duty before God
00:26:14 not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:26:18 Rees Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied,
00:26:22 not just as a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business
00:26:25 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:26:29 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:26:33 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them
00:26:36 to make sure that we can maintain our capacity to do things here.
00:26:40 Rees Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
00:26:44 so ben i would love if you could respond to what i just said but then as soon as you're done and
00:26:51 we'll keep it you know as short as possible i want to give it to uh to michael because he i think has
00:26:56 um as we were just talking together brainstorming a little bit during the commercial break he's got
00:27:01 some insightful questions that he'd like to be able to ask you yeah no i was actually going to
00:27:06 say i think that michael could talk to this a lot because i think that traditionism like it's not a
00:27:12 it's not this like donut hole that fits perfectly within the the hole of the donut that suddenly
00:27:17 makes everything make sense there are still things that uh we can't explain and that we should look
00:27:21 for but i think that traditionism helps us recognize that propositional nations are absurd
00:27:28 um and and that's because an that's because an ethnos like like similar to what you said joel
00:27:36 an ethnos because you're racist ben that's why i know but go ahead continue
00:27:40 just kidding the uh like an ethnos is formed it is formed by things like
00:27:46 external practices and shared experiences and shared stories and in genetics these things that
00:27:53 are material uh to varying degrees internally to externally but it is also formed by uh the way
00:28:02 that the i believe the way that the souls of the people have developed in that land over time and
00:28:06 So I do think that land exerts an influence,
00:28:09 not only over the body, but also over the soul.
00:28:13 And I promise I'll keep this quick.
00:28:15 Just one thing, one example that I think is helpful here
00:28:19 is that when you start to say 0.99
00:28:21 that propositional nationhood is stupid, 1.00
00:28:25 one rebuttal might be, well, how do we do that anymore? 1.00
00:28:28 Like in this highly connected world,
00:28:30 in this global quote unquote world,
00:28:33 how do we see that when different people groups
00:28:36 almost always are living in the same place. It's very rare that that's not true, in the first world
00:28:41 at least, that we don't have different people groups living in the same place. And I would say
00:28:45 you can actually look to the founding of America and see that different people groups founded the
00:28:51 same place. They were formed not only by a shared experience and shared history and a shared
00:28:56 mythos that formed by the founding of the country, but then they also lived with each other for long
00:29:03 enough to the point where some of those distinctions started to get less sharp, started to get less
00:29:08 clear. And yet what they didn't lose is their unwavering commitment to the nation that their
00:29:14 fathers had founded. And they began even to appreciate some of the ways in which other
00:29:20 fathers helped their fathers find the nation. And I think that that's done by the soul passed down
00:29:27 through generations, given time to mature in a single place with the shared history, the shared
00:29:32 religion the shared experience and all that we speak of the old world and the new world there's
00:29:37 old world wines old world flavors old world architecture and then there's new world go ahead
00:29:43 michael um ben i think one of the things that would be helpful is uh to define what we mean by soul
00:29:49 because and maybe this is what you do mean but um what i hear being said is there is the the soul
00:29:58 part of a human that can be directly like like traducianism as i understand it is the idea that
00:30:07 the soul is is created by the union of the mother and the father um okay that's all well and good
00:30:14 but when we now start saying that the land that a people live in now directly come to bear on the
00:30:24 soul and and the my question is it sounds like what we're saying is even the caliber of the soul
00:30:30 like we could have resilient or we could have you know just less less resilient and adventurous
00:30:37 exploring all of those things seafaring people but but when i hear that i think okay so what
00:30:43 we're saying is depending on where someone's ancestors are determines where whether they
00:30:49 have a the japanese have the idea of the those with a shriveled soul a hollow soul um and
00:30:56 so what what is it like are we talking the immortal redeemable soul and if so is there no
00:31:03 like like does redemption change that because one of the lines that we use in our movement a lot is
00:31:10 um uh grace doesn't destroy destroy nature it it elevates it it renews it um what we're saying
00:31:18 kind of is people are just stuck with the soul that they have, because it's inherited through
00:31:22 land, through people. So what is the soul that we're talking about? What is the role of grace
00:31:27 and redemption? And I guess that's where I'll leave it for now.
00:31:34 Yeah, no, I think that's a really good question. Of course, it's not brute determinism.
00:31:41 So just because you are born in a certain place with certain fathers and forefathers
00:31:46 doesn't mean that your soul is now stuck in this immovable place where it can't go,
00:31:52 it can't ever be in flux. The soul is always in flux in the same way that the body is always in
00:31:57 flux. You're born with a certain genetic code, but that genetic code alters over time with
00:32:02 environmental factors, with nutrition, with fitness, with things like that. You actually do
00:32:08 change slightly over time. The same is true of the soul. I like to think of the relationship
00:32:13 between the body and the soul, like the body being an instrument, like a viola or a piano or
00:32:18 something. And then the soul is the one that plays it. And so if you have a, maybe you have a,
00:32:26 actually, this is how we've thought through mental illness and like mental retardation before. 0.98
00:32:31 If you have a body that's broken, whether that's in the brain or in the limbs or whatever, 0.96
00:32:37 it's like a piano that's missing some of the keys or something like that.
00:32:40 now the player of the piano is still responsible to play the piano as best as he can but it's going
00:32:47 to be more difficult for that uh soul or that player because of the missing pieces i think
00:32:53 i i don't know if i would use terms like more difficult um because no one is saved by their
00:32:58 own effort but i do think that there are factors of the soul uh where where like if a to joel to
00:33:05 something that Joel said. If someone is born in a society that has been worshiping demons for
00:33:10 centuries, they will be at a soul level more disposed to that in terms of what we should
00:33:17 expect. Now, grace not only perfects nature, but it also is exalted over nature. And so it is more
00:33:22 powerful. And so there's always redemption. The Lord can do what he wills. And in fact, he does.
00:33:27 And he often saves people who, if it were left up to a man who's betting like on a horse race,
00:33:32 may not have bet on that man being saved. So there's always that category. But I think what
00:33:38 I'm talking more about is like how, and I'm taking it a little bit further than traducianism. Like
00:33:44 you're right, traducianism is simply the idea that the soul is passed via the mother and father
00:33:49 at conception to the child, to the new person. But the point that I'm making or kind of the
00:33:54 thesis that I'm positing is that since that's true, and because I believe this other thing is
00:34:00 true, that history and land and story affect not only the body, but also the soul. That means that
00:34:07 where you live can affect, even if it's just at the level of affections, the souls that come after
00:34:13 you. The way that I've illustrated it before is, and this is like, I was writing a dusty tome,
00:34:20 so it was totally spitballing and I didn't think about it at all after, but I'll stand by it for
00:34:24 now is one time when I was in college, I went on a trip with my dad and we were mountain biking in
00:34:32 North Carolina and we had done it for years. We used to go to North Carolina to ride mountain
00:34:36 bikes all the time. And on that one trip, it was the first time that I had ever actually
00:34:41 beaten my dad in a downhill race. He was always like full throttle. I mean, I really admired how
00:34:48 fearless he was on a mountain bike going down a mountain. And it was the first time I'd ever
00:34:52 beaten him. And he comes down and we get back to the parking lot. And he's just so proud of me.
00:34:58 He like, he's like, man, that was, that was so impressive. Like, I'm so proud of you.
00:35:02 I know it's this small thing, but like, you're my son and you just beat me at something. And
00:35:07 what father wouldn't want that? And that moment has always stuck with me, even so much so that
00:35:14 I feel like I do have a connection to those mountains in North Carolina, to DuPont State
00:35:19 Forest and Pisgah National Forest because a part of me was formed there. I had this incredible
00:35:25 experience with my father at that place. And it wasn't just that it was my father that was
00:35:30 important and that mattered. It was also that it was at that place that was important and that
00:35:34 mattered. Another illustration that is more abstract is let's say you have an oak tree
00:35:41 and you think of the oak tree like a soul. And it's this old oak tree. It's very beautiful. And
00:35:47 it's chopped down by loggers. And let's say the loggers are like the land, okay? And the loggers,
00:35:53 they chop down the tree, they cut off all of its branches, they send it to the lumberyard where
00:35:57 it's processed and it's dried and all this stuff, okay? And the lumberyard is also the land. It's
00:36:02 having an effect on the oak tree. And then some carpenter comes in and he buys every single piece
00:36:08 of wood that came from that oak tree, which would never happen, but let's just say that it would for
00:36:12 the sake of the argument that carpenter is also like the land it's buying all of the oak tree
00:36:17 it's taking all of that soul and it's doing something with it now let's say further that
00:36:23 that carpenter makes that oak tree that has been chopped down that the branches have been lopped
00:36:28 off it's been pruned so to speak and prepared for something and the carpenter then makes it into a
00:36:34 bunch of beautiful you know a shaker style furniture for this home that's going to house
00:36:41 a wonderful family. And the home is going to be beautified by this oak tree. That oak tree
00:36:48 has lost itself in one sense. It has lost branches. It's lost leaves. It's lost its
00:36:55 reproductive capability. And we don't need to take this too far, but just the point is it's changed.
00:37:00 But in being changed, it actually became what it was supposed to be. It became this beautiful
00:37:06 furniture this glorified version of that though cut and though diminished quantitatively has
00:37:12 actually increased qualitatively i think that land exerts a similar effect on mankind not only
00:37:19 at the level of the body of course it does that but also at the level of the soul and the reason
00:37:24 i think that is because i think that the metaphor of the instrument and the player is actually
00:37:28 incomplete i think that the soul and the body are more connected than that uh such that they're
00:37:33 like a tapestry that is, you know, they're weaved together so that when you tug on the one,
00:37:39 the other is pulled as well. And that's what makes death such a tragedy. It's the sundering
00:37:43 of the body and soul. And so it's not just the player getting up and walking away from the
00:37:48 instrument. It's the instrument being destroyed because it was made for that player. And now the
00:37:55 player is gone from it. And so the instrument has no reason to exist anymore. And so I think that
00:38:01 That's why they exert major influences on one another, such that when land affects the
00:38:06 body, it also affects the soul, and vice versa.
00:38:09 You can have a soul that is very virtuous, whether it's by the grace of God or whether
00:38:13 it's a civic virtue that just comes from the society in which you're in, that also
00:38:17 exerts a visible effect on the land that that soul lives upon.
00:38:22 Yeah.
00:38:22 Michael?
00:38:22 do you do you are you using soul similarly to personality or like moral fiber or uh because
00:38:31 to me that's where um i think i just think the definition needs to be careful because usually
00:38:38 when we talk about soul we i think of it as the part of the the man that is um you know when we
00:38:46 think about for instance what paul says like our our souls in a sense right now are the only part
00:38:51 of us that have been redeemed um and our bodies we have the old man the old flesh um but i think
00:38:59 you're using the the word soul more broadly when you are talking about the things that i think i'm
00:39:06 not even sure where i stand on this but i think some people would say well personality um things
00:39:11 of that nature are are more products of the physical body than of the soulish spiritual part
00:39:17 of the body. So are you using the term soul pretty broadly, Ben? Yeah, yeah. My understanding
00:39:25 of the soul is fairly broad, partly because of my conviction that they are so closely intertwined.
00:39:32 So I certainly think that there are elements of genetics that help us explain personality traits,
00:39:39 of course, like sicknesses and strength and things like that. But I also think that the soul
00:39:44 is more personal than merely a life force i think that the soul um i think that my soul
00:39:51 would be discernible from yours you know if we could see them i think that and part of why i
00:39:56 think that is is because of first samuel when uh saul gets the witch of endor to summon up samuel's
00:40:02 ghost so you know presumably that's samuel's soul made visible by god's providential working
00:40:09 and he's able to discern, that's Samuel. And so I think that I do adhere to a more broad
00:40:17 definition of soul than merely like a life force and things like that. I think that
00:40:22 it is personal to the body that it's contained within. Yeah. On relating too to environment and
00:40:29 place affecting the person, Calvin talks about this is one of the reasons the Lord's Supper
00:40:33 is not just spiritual. It's not simply a moment of silence. It's not prayer. He gives us literal
00:40:38 physical things because we are embodied soul. We're not just abstract and the body has an impact
00:40:44 that the body can shape the soul. And so God gives to us two means of grace. He gives to us
00:40:49 the Lord's Supper, which we physically literally consume something. It symbolizes, it communicates
00:40:54 the reality of Christ given for us and the same thing for baptism. We speak of those as means of
00:40:59 grace, meaning that they have some level of spiritual import and yet still they're provided
00:41:05 to us practically. Ben, I want to get to nations and myth and stories, but one thing I do have to
00:41:10 say that I also appreciate about this view is it helps us make sense of the great man. I think of
00:41:16 men, you've heard the saying, you know, larger than life, that there's just some characters and
00:41:20 there's something about them that they are just, they're big. They have energy, they have joy,
00:41:25 they have life, they have all of that. There's just something about them that we couldn't break
00:41:28 down. We couldn't say, well, to be like Steve, you know, the guy that would witness to everybody
00:41:32 at the gas station and the guy who would only sleep four hours you know you had to do his
00:41:36 morning regimen or you have to work out like him it helps us to say that there's something about a
00:41:40 person that we can't put our finger on that we can't just break down to a diet or we can't just
00:41:45 break down to habit that there's actually something spiritual about them and it's funny because
00:41:49 there's people some of them literally their body gives out there's so much exuberance so much joy
00:41:54 so much love for life that they're 50 they're 60 and their body just gives out or it helps to keep
00:41:59 them going for a long time. You know, you read those stories about people that smoked a pack a
00:42:03 day, drank excessively, and they lived till 96. Well, they just loved life. They weren't alone.
00:42:08 They weren't just sitting in their room. They weren't just doing nothing. They weren't just
00:42:12 meditating. They were alive. They were vibrant. And we're not saying that that's only a spiritual
00:42:16 component, that only the spiritual component makes the man. If you're not this, at the beginning,
00:42:21 there's nothing you can do. Same thing with living longer. Most certainly is a taking care
00:42:25 of the body that matters but we are saying is in addition to that and on top of it it's a spiritual
00:42:30 component I mean think about couples where they both pass away within days of each other that
00:42:34 their lives have become intertwined and even spiritually when their spouse passed they said
00:42:39 I've lost a reason and a will to live and will to live is not a mechanical materialistic thing
00:42:45 any thoughts on that before we go to nation story myth yeah yeah no thing I think uh and maybe this
00:42:51 will help answer Michael a little bit better. I'm using soul in a more broad scope, and I'm also
00:42:59 using really concrete terms that we would normally use for material things like genetics and stuff
00:43:04 like that. But I'm fully assuming this whole time, the soul is a very abstract thing that we can't
00:43:11 measure and quantify and really put our finger on. It's more so just using words that I'm familiar
00:43:17 enough with to describe similar effects and causes that I'm seeing or that I think I'm seeing
00:43:22 at a soul level. I think one of the ways that maybe this can be explained is, I've said before,
00:43:32 we live in Utah. Y'all don't, but we do. We live in Utah. It's only ever been a pagan place. It
00:43:37 has never, ever, ever been Christian. Even now, it's like less than 2% Protestant or something
00:43:43 like that. And Catholics, I think they're like another 2%. And so one of the things that I tell
00:43:47 people, and I genuinely believe this, is that when Utah is a Christian place, when it proclaims
00:43:53 the true Christ is Lord, the state will get better. Like not just its policies, but like
00:44:00 the actual land will be better. The sky will be bluer. The water will be cleaner. The air will
00:44:07 have less smog. The crop will yield better. I think that'll be more fruitful. And part of why
00:44:14 I believe that is because I think that C.S. Lewis, until we have faces, when he's drawing this very
00:44:19 sharp parallel between someone who is beautiful, having a beautiful soul, and Orwell who has an
00:44:26 ugly soul, obviously he's taking it very, very far. And I'm not saying that he took it that far
00:44:31 because that's the way it is but it is reflecting something true like the more pure the more redeemed
00:44:37 the soul is in a place the soul of the individual and the people that that are around it the more
00:44:44 beautiful that place will be so the the redemption of the soul through the vehicle of the body will
00:44:49 have a visible tangible effect on the beautification of the place okay so that i'll this will be my
00:44:57 last question then that helps clarify quite a bit so one of the things that we've been wrestling
00:45:02 and i even have a chapter or two in my book about civic good right and how how modern christianity
00:45:10 has really dropped the ball on the idea that there could be civic good but it sounds like you're
00:45:18 making the connection or the the step that there can be soulish good that is not a product of grace
00:45:27 but merely a product of time, place, inheritance, things like that.
00:45:31 And I think that's going to be, that's the thing I'm thinking through.
00:45:34 And I think that's going to be the thing that some people are going to have to think through
00:45:38 with what you're saying.
00:45:39 Like, are we saying that there are actual, because when I think of soulish good, I think
00:45:46 of the intangible actual moral good that comes about through really exclusively through the work
00:45:58 of grace in our life. Like all our righteous acts are as filthy rags. Okay, that doesn't mean that
00:46:02 we can't do good for our nation. It just is not a good that necessarily pleases the Lord in a
00:46:07 salvific sense. So are you saying that there would be souls because they can be affected by genetics,
00:46:14 land place things like that that can have a sort of intrinsic good that is not ultimate good um
00:46:21 that that pleases the lord that actually now that you said that is really my the core of my question
00:46:27 that i've been trying to to articulate to you yeah no and and i would say yes so long as we understand
00:46:34 that good uh for the unredeemed is only it only ever reaches the pinnacle of civic good it cannot
00:46:41 appeal in pure goodness to God. I don't think that there's such a thing as a soul that is born 0.99
00:46:49 and that is a Christian without being regenerated. Total depravity is very real. 1.00
00:46:56 But I do think that within, and let's just look at pagan societies, I think that within pagan
00:47:01 societies, you see differing levels of civic good. Some of them are extremely barbaric, 0.80
00:47:09 like the Muslims, or even the Carthaginians. The Carthaginians, extremely barbaric people, 1.00
00:47:16 and they were pagans. And then you look at the Romans, especially before Christ, 0.95
00:47:20 they were also pagans, but they were less barbaric. Even in their paganism, it was less
00:47:25 barbaric. There was less human sacrifice, less blood. There was still a lot of blood. There
00:47:29 was still some human sacrifice, but less. There was more beauty, even in the civic objective
00:47:35 sense of architecture and things like that than you got in Carthage. So I think, yeah, as long as
00:47:41 I'm not trying, I don't want to get myself in any, I'm not saying that there's divine good
00:47:46 in the natural soul, not at all. But I think that even in the unregenerate people groups of the
00:47:52 world and in the unregenerate soul, there can be a type of civic good that has been
00:47:58 like inherited by the history of the civic good of a people. And they have an equal and opposite
00:48:04 effect on each other. So the more civic good that even a pagan society pursues, you have reason to 0.98
00:48:13 believe that that civic good would continue, or it would fall under just incredible judgment, 0.96
00:48:20 and that judgment would either crush them into repentance, which would lead to true civic good
00:48:24 and divine good, or it would crush them into basically nothingness, and they would cease to
00:48:30 exist. Well said. Let's go ahead and go to our last commercial break, and then we're going to
00:48:34 come back and as quickly as possible, give some concluding thoughts. And then I want to make sure
00:48:40 that we have some time to get to the chat. Are you a Christian struggling to find companies that
00:48:44 align with your values and beliefs? Well, then Squirrely Joe's has you covered for all your 0.97
00:48:49 coffee needs. All of their coffee is hand selected and roasted fresh every day by a family of fellow
00:48:55 believers. Try them out and you'll savor exceptional coffee while knowing that your investment
00:49:01 supports a company committed to following God's teachings and upholding truth and righteousness,
00:49:07 ensuring that your hard-earned money contributes to the growth of God's kingdom. Stop giving your
00:49:13 hard-earned dollars to pagans who support evil. Right Response listeners have access to an
00:49:19 exclusive deal. Your first bag of coffee is free. All you have to do is cover the shipping. So head
00:49:25 on over to squirrelyjoes.com forward slash right response again that's squirrelyjoes.com forward
00:49:33 slash right response to claim your first free bag of coffee today all right welcome back so ben one
00:49:41 thing i alluded to we talked about it a good bit so if you have souls and then in the process and
00:49:46 their expansion and everything and they're in one place and not the other necessarily the western
00:49:51 the spirit of the west you could say in one way in a totalizing sense would be different than the
00:49:55 spirit of the east the spirit of america as new as we are is different than the spirit of europe
00:49:59 and the spirit of africa and the spirit of india but one of the things that that you you hit on
00:50:04 and it's true and i'm trying to do it to connect is that there's stories that shaped us and there's
00:50:10 a purpose and a meaning to getting back to them so to look at the odyssey and to look at that not
00:50:16 even just necessarily the characters and the involvement of it but what is it if not the epic
00:50:20 story of the sun that leaves home and goes on a great journey and faces great peril.
00:50:25 These are stories that shaped us if we're going to have a future of the West, that if
00:50:29 the West is going to look in a way that we would recognize and would have the same characters
00:50:33 and the same art and aesthetics and values, if it's going to look in the future like that,
00:50:38 then that also means in a sense of spiritual connection to what came before.
00:50:42 Can you elaborate on that?
00:50:43 Yeah, this is really where I'll start to probably get confusing.
00:50:48 So apologies. I just need to work these more. But so this is where I really break from just the
00:50:54 root definition of Traducianism. And I'm running with this idea that is undergirded by Traducianism.
00:51:02 And it is that if what I've said so far is true, that the soul is inherited from the father and
00:51:10 mother, and it includes, it's not just an item that has nothing already on it, but it includes
00:51:15 some kind of soulish memory, then that means that within people groups, you have shared memories
00:51:23 that become myth. And so this is why I say that myth is a type of history.
00:51:32 And what you're getting in myth, like if you read like Dostoevsky, for example,
00:51:36 and you read Crime and Punishment, great book, everyone should read it.
00:51:39 you're getting the ethos of Dostoevsky. He is giving you a piece of his own soul, so to speak,
00:51:46 a piece of himself in the fullness of that word. He's pouring his pathos, ethos, telos out on the
00:51:53 page, but it's just Dostoevsky. If you read the Iliad, if you read Theogony by Hesiod,
00:52:00 if you read Virgil's Eklogues, and if you read the Aeneid, all these things, you're not just
00:52:07 getting the ethos of that author. You're getting the ethos of people. So Homer is writing down
00:52:15 the myth that he received from the Greeks, all the Greeks up to his day. Hesiod's doing the same
00:52:21 thing. They're not inventing this whole cloth. These are stories maybe mixed with real memories
00:52:28 and real historical events that are then passed down from generation to generation, not just in
00:52:34 the Greek lands, it transcends that and goes to all the West that give us an abstract foothold
00:52:44 in the virtues and the vices of the West and why we are what we are. This is why Western 0.60
00:52:51 civilization classes don't just study the history of Western civilization, the brute history, but
00:52:57 also the mytho history of Western civilization. Because these myths had the ability to form
00:53:04 people, even at a level of affections in the soul. And so that's why I think that in order to
00:53:11 reclaim and save Western civilization, we have to resurrect the Western ethos.
00:53:19 And that means that we have to reclaim, re-appreciate, and re-embody in our own time
00:53:27 as redeemed Christians, the virtues of the Western canon. So we have to read the ill,
00:53:32 not just entertainment. We have to read the Odyssey, the Aeneid. We have to read Beowulf.
00:53:38 These things are not just literature. They are glimpses into the ethos of the people that made
00:53:45 us who we are. And by reading those things and letting them get into our bones, we will, I think,
00:53:53 do the good work of not just becoming a Christian nation again. That's, of course, like we have to 0.95
00:54:00 do that, but a Western Christian nation. It's not enough that we are just Christians. We are
00:54:07 Western Christians. And that means something different than it does to an Indian Christian 0.80
00:54:12 or an Eastern Christian, like Eastern Orthodox, or like a Russian Orthodox Christian. These are
00:54:17 all different things. And so in order to become a Western Christian again, first you have to be a 0.98
00:54:21 Christian. So everyone repent and believe, but then also you have to be a Westerner. Now, how do 0.94
00:54:26 you become a Westerner? Well, it's by eating the same food that our forefathers gave us that they
00:54:31 also ate. And that's the Western myth. C.S. Lewis has this great quote, and I'm going to butcher it,
00:54:37 but it's something like, man is torn between two ways of thinking. We can either ponder the
00:54:45 abstract. Like we can say, what is the nature of pain? You know, what is pain? Or we can experience
00:54:52 the concrete and react to it. So, ow, that hurt. But when you're getting your finger chopped off,
00:54:59 you're not thinking, wow, what is pain? What is this philosophical phenomenon of pain? You can
00:55:04 only do that when you're separated from the concrete experience. Myth is different. The
00:55:08 reason that I say all, you know, it's been said before, all art aspires to the condition of music.
00:55:14 And I've said all music aspires to the condition of myth. The reason that I say that is because
00:55:19 myth is the only place where we get the bridge between the abstract and the concrete such that
00:55:25 when you get to the end of the iliad even if you haven't understood a lot of what's happened and
00:55:29 you're overwhelmed with names and things like that you'll read the last line thus ended hector
00:55:35 breaker of horses and you are a westerner it will affect you it will affect you the reason for that
00:55:42 is because in consuming the myth,
00:55:45 you've consumed the concrete in the form of the abstract.
00:55:50 And if you're a Westerner,
00:55:51 that will almost elicit a kind of memory in you.
00:55:56 This is why I encourage people to read Paradise Lost
00:55:58 if they're Christians, Western, Eastern, whatever.
00:56:00 Because in reading Paradise Lost,
00:56:02 when you get to the end,
00:56:04 Adam has seen the vision up to Christ.
00:56:06 That in itself is powerful enough.
00:56:08 But then when they're expelled from the garden
00:56:10 and they're finally going into the wilderness,
00:56:12 you, and it's not just because Milton is a good writer, you experience a profound sense of loss.
00:56:19 You start thinking to yourself, like, look at what I did. Look at what I left behind. I feel like I
00:56:26 remember that place and I miss it. And I want to go back to it. The reason for that is because
00:56:32 you have drank from the pool of myth. In that case, it's the true myth of Christianity.
00:56:40 like the bible is given to us in a mythic form it's all true it all really happened but it's
00:56:45 also mythical and the great uh triumph of myth is the incarnation god made man myth became fact
00:56:52 the abstract was the concrete and it changed everything and so now i i do think that uh just
00:56:59 to just to reiterate what i already said i think that myth has um because of what i said about the
00:57:04 soul. I think that myth has the power to transfer abstract ethos of an entire people group in the
00:57:12 form of a concrete story that then helps shape our own ethos such that if used rightly, we can
00:57:18 not only be a Christian nation again, but we can be a Western Christian nation. We can be Western
00:57:22 Christians. That's great. All right. We're short on time today, so we're going to do our best to
00:57:27 get to at least all the super chats. So Nathan, if you could go ahead and organize all those for us.
00:57:33 right here's the first one this is from daniel woodard he gave us five dollars thank you daniel
00:57:38 he said it was awesome to meet you guys in person at the conference the crisis king conference that
00:57:42 we just had a couple weeks ago one question if adam was not born with a sin nature how did he
00:57:49 end up sinning i'll take a crack at that we believe that adam and eve were created in a state
00:57:56 of integrity or a state of innocence so that they could not sin but they also could sin
00:58:03 that both options were actually available to them
00:58:05 in the sense of the human agency.
00:58:07 We also believe, in line with the Westminster Catechism,
00:58:11 that says that everything that takes place
00:58:14 is that which God has ordained him.
00:58:17 And so we believe that God did, in fact,
00:58:20 ordain that sin would enter the world.
00:58:22 And he did so because the final result
00:58:24 would be better, not worse,
00:58:26 that he's actually shaping and orchestrating all things
00:58:29 to the praise of his glorious grace
00:58:31 and also to the maximum eternal happiness
00:58:35 and joy and good for his image-bearing creatures
00:58:38 that eons and eons into eternity,
00:58:42 that we would be able to look back and say,
00:58:44 I wouldn't have changed a thing.
00:58:45 I thank God that things were planned in this way
00:58:49 because angels even long to look
00:58:52 into the mysteries of the gospel,
00:58:53 but they look as outsiders.
00:58:56 They don't experience it.
00:58:57 It's abstract, like what Ben was saying,
00:58:59 but it's not concrete.
00:59:00 but we are actual recipients. Those of us who are Christians, human beings who have been saved and
00:59:07 redeemed, we're actual recipients of God's grace. So we believe that the fall was something that
00:59:12 God actually ordained, and we believe that Adam and Eve were made and created in a state of
00:59:18 integrity so that they were able to sin. They were also able not to sin, but they were not created
00:59:24 in a state of immutable integrity. And I believe, you know, now speaking for myself, I don't know
00:59:30 what the other guys would say but um i believe that uh that this state of integrity that adam
00:59:35 and eve were created in um that adam and eve they also had their own eschaton uh something that god
00:59:41 according to his ordination he he knew that it wouldn't take place in this way but um but
00:59:46 theoretically there was um an eschatology that adam had had he not sinned um that he would have
00:59:52 eventually entered into um not only a state of integrity which he was already in but a state of
00:59:58 immutable integrity that he would have been as the angels are now uh which is unable to fall
01:00:04 and that he would would have eventually entered into that because when you think
01:00:08 um you know the tree of life like what was the tree of life for um why why why would there even
01:00:14 be an incentive to um to somehow attain to being able to eat and being granted you know um access
01:00:21 to the tree of life because Adam already had a means of not dying, of forever life, namely by
01:00:29 simply not sinning. You know, God said the day that you eat of it, the tree of the knowledge of
01:00:34 good and evil, by eating of that tree, that he would surely die. So Adam already had a pathway
01:00:40 to life, a pathway to forever life, not dying. And he didn't have to eat from the tree of life
01:00:46 to not die. He just had to abstain from eating of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.
01:00:51 all he had to do is avoid sin. In other words, if Adam had avoided sin, then he would have lived
01:00:56 forever and death would have never entered the world. But what I believe is that there was a
01:01:01 probationary period and that that's meant to be implied and that Adam probably had a sense of
01:01:06 that and that if he had resisted evil and done what God set him up to do to keep and work the
01:01:11 ground, expanding and working and cultivating, but also protecting and defending and keeping the
01:01:17 ground, which would include keeping the serpent out of the garden and standing guard, that if
01:01:21 Adam had done this well after a prolonged period of time that God had set, that eventually he would
01:01:27 have been able to eat of the tree of life. And although, again, he already would have had forever
01:01:33 life simply by avoiding sin, that the tree of life would have actually brought him into not
01:01:38 just forever life, but eternal life, a state of immutable integrity to where now not only would
01:01:44 be in a state of integrity, but he would be permanently placed into that state of integrity
01:01:48 and never able to fall. So that's my view of Adam and Eve. No, they did not have a sin nature. They
01:01:55 were made in a state of integrity. There was no sin nature, but in that state of integrity was
01:02:00 not an immutable state, and they were able to fall, and God also ordained it. Anything to add
01:02:07 to that question nope nope okay uh let's keep going uh michael can you read the next one
01:02:15 yep here we go uh this is from josiah cooper uh josiah says uh thank you for the ten dollars
01:02:21 josiah asking a prayer request my wife and i are pregnant and our first ultrasound came back
01:02:25 empty hormone levels say we are pregnant uh we are praying for god's favor with our fourth child
01:02:31 christ is king okay let's uh let's just go ahead and pray real quick uh father we thank you for
01:02:36 Josiah and his wife. And Lord, we pray that if there is a baby in her womb, that you would
01:02:46 protect the life of that baby and that maybe the tests were just inaccurate. And in a couple weeks
01:02:51 and giving it a little bit more time that the baby and its heartbeat and its life would be
01:02:55 detected and that the baby would be healthy. And if there's not any baby, Lord, I pray for just peace
01:03:01 and encouragement and hopefulness
01:03:04 that you would guard and protect
01:03:05 against disappointment and discouragement
01:03:07 and those kinds of things.
01:03:09 We pray this in the name of Jesus.
01:03:11 Amen.
01:03:11 Amen.
01:03:12 Wes, you want to do the next one?
01:03:13 All right.
01:03:14 So Victory in Christ emailed you.
01:03:16 $5 Super Chat.
01:03:17 Thank you.
01:03:18 Emailed you on Full Preterism Conversation.
01:03:20 This is a follow-up from Monday.
01:03:21 Thanks for the consideration.
01:03:22 Hopefully that last video is getting some traction.
01:03:25 These guys don't mess around.
01:03:26 Ben, do you know much about Full Preterism?
01:03:28 Are we going to have to have you on in a couple weeks?
01:03:30 I know it like adjacently, yeah.
01:03:34 Adjacently?
01:03:35 I'm not like very well versed on it now.
01:03:38 Fair enough, fair enough.
01:03:40 Joel, I'll pass it back to you, SoCal Preston.
01:03:42 SoCal's got a few.
01:03:43 SoCal Preston, he's got a bunch of super chats.
01:03:46 Thank you for the super chats.
01:03:47 Yeah, thank you, SoCal Preston.
01:03:48 We appreciate it.
01:03:49 So he said, when are you going to debate me on dispensationalism?
01:03:52 His next one says, I need the arrow to move.
01:03:56 You guys misrepresent dispensationalism.
01:03:59 The third one says, no one was regenerated in the Old Testament.
01:04:04 Are there any more, Nathan?
01:04:06 Nope.
01:04:07 Yep, so I would just, my response is, wrong, wrong, wrong.
01:04:10 Dispensationalism ruined the world, and I will not give any press time to ideologies
01:04:15 that have caused as much damage as dispensationalism.
01:04:18 God bless, and we'll see you later.
01:04:20 All right, next one.
01:04:21 Alex Fick, just $5.
01:04:23 Super Chat, thanks for the support, Alex.
01:04:25 Jeff Halfley, I love this.
01:04:26 This was a thread I didn't get to pick up on earlier, but Super Chat, 499, one of our greatest supporters, Jeff.
01:04:32 He said, I went to New England, my ancestors, after were there for 300 years and felt at home in an eerie way that is hard to describe.
01:04:40 And absolutely, because, I mean, I have my background in neuroscience, so memories have a real place.
01:04:45 Like, they're a real structure.
01:04:46 You could damage someone's memory.
01:04:48 There's also short-term memory, long-term memory.
01:04:51 So people are able to form short-term memories, but in impairments, they can't form long-term.
01:04:55 the point is we know that there are certainly memories that are biological but but just talking
01:04:59 not just about a memory about an episode not just a memory about knowledge but but a feeling and a
01:05:05 sensation and um and that's real the places that we've done life and we're familiar we think i think
01:05:11 ben and i talked about this that they do feel home in a way that's hard to articulate that's hard to
01:05:16 describe that you can't pin down to just well it feels like home because x y and z ben anything to
01:05:22 to that yeah i mean in in the same way that i think i think if we could all go back and and
01:05:28 walk in the garden of eden for a day we would feel at home uh and it would be a very profound
01:05:34 sense of sorrow that we lost it yeah tolkien talks about that that we're we're soaked in exile even
01:05:41 in our best days we know we're still missing something we're not where we should be all right
01:05:47 let's give uh is it okay if i say one more thing it's all right yeah yeah no it's even going back
01:05:53 to what belt brought up like um what role does redemption have to play in this i think you can
01:05:59 even say the same about certain places in scripture that are not the garden of eden like
01:06:03 why do i feel a draw to the holy land uh well it's because that's where my lord died and that's
01:06:09 where he saved me so in a sense like a major the better part of my soul lives there um and so i
01:06:16 want it to be filled with christian singing and to be fair ben your ancestors probably hacked 0.93
01:06:21 apart infidels in the holy lands for hundreds of years on end right more likely than not there's 0.96
01:06:27 also some other memories there yep uh let's go ahead and give this uh last question uh i'll give
01:06:33 it to michael to you first and um and then maybe ben can um can give a final thought so this is
01:06:39 from alex fick michael do you want to read that alex says any indication of how this might apply
01:06:45 to language someone of german ancestry not having spoken for three generations but they could pick
01:06:52 up the language more naturally i don't know i know from um talking to some um people who studied
01:07:00 language learning at a phd level um that the at least when i talked to this guy the the theory
01:07:07 was that the brain forms a new neural net with every language learned it's kind of net on top
01:07:14 of net um this is not really going to support the thesis i'm just throwing it out there
01:07:20 anecdotally my grandfather study stuttered terribly growing up he thought it was because
01:07:25 he was left-handed and when he was born that was a taboo thing they forced him to write
01:07:29 this or sorry yeah with his right hand um when he learned a second language which in this case
01:07:35 happened to be spanish it fixed his stuttering in his english language and he didn't stutter
01:07:40 stutter in spanish i don't know um there might be something there i just know as a linguist and as
01:07:47 someone who's traveled around the world um progressively learning languages makes it easier
01:07:51 um language is so much a product as someone who teaches it of just like types of intelligence
01:07:58 um so i don't know i don't i have never uh considered language in that point of view so
01:08:05 i'm not saying it's not possible i just i i have never looked into that connection at all so
01:08:10 i'm not saying it's not there i don't know ben any thoughts yeah i i am not a philologist or
01:08:16 nor a linguist i speak english and that's actually it i'm terrible but uh but i have heard um at
01:08:24 least anecdotally that when people uh go and they do like the immersive learning like they go to
01:08:29 italy and they learn it and just by living there they uh they eventually start to think in that
01:08:34 language when they're there and then when they go back to where they're from they switch back
01:08:40 into thinking in their native tongue um which i i don't know if that has any bearing whatsoever
01:08:45 on the question but i do think it's really fascinating yep all right wes any uh final
01:08:51 thought for today not really this is definitely something um i think that i'm new to you'll
01:08:56 notice with this episode we didn't come out and say guys guys you just gotta you gotta replace
01:09:00 everything we've got the view it explains it all but this is definitely something to think about
01:09:04 and the reason i chose it is because we're losing a sense of place and a sense of home right a condo
01:09:09 500 feet above the ground in suburbia like that's not really home that's not land that's not soil
01:09:16 you're not actually taming the ground and so in a time where we've lost so much of a sense of place
01:09:20 so much of our connection to our to our soil so much of where we live it's good to remember who
01:09:26 we are where we came from and the importance of as the mission was given to Adam to toil to labor
01:09:33 and to put everything under dominion and subdue it. And so, Ben, could you tell us where to find
01:09:39 you? And also, if you plan on saying any more, speaking any more on this topic in the future?
01:09:46 Yeah, you can follow me on Twitter at Tom Pondbidil. I tweet maybe once a month,
01:09:53 and it's usually pretty disappointing. That makes me so happy because that's about my tweet rate as
01:09:58 well yeah yeah uh yeah at time it's like tom bombadil but pawn instead of bomb um and then
01:10:06 uh you can of course listen to haunted cosmos which is the show that brian suvey and i do
01:10:11 and it's a bi-weekly show we try to just explore the the very strange world that god made with the
01:10:17 with the truth of knowing that the world is not just stuff um i am hoping to uh write a book
01:10:23 called The Constellation of Mythology that will, at least in the early chapters, touch heavily on
01:10:28 this idea and then go into explaining motifs in Western myth that helped shaped us as Western
01:10:37 Christians so that people can hopefully go and read those for themselves and kind of reclaim
01:10:41 the virtues of a Western man. I hope to write that and finish a manuscript this year, but
01:10:47 who knows? Who knows? It may be a while. And no, I don't plan on speaking anywhere anytime soon.
01:10:53 but, uh, I certainly would be open to it. Um, and then we, we will be having our new Christian
01:10:58 and press conference in June of this year, safety third, recovering the American will to greatness.
01:11:04 Uh, and I'll be emceeing that. So if you just can't get enough of me, you know, uh, you can,
01:11:09 you can hear me introduce speakers at that conference. Awesome. Love it. Well, Ben,
01:11:14 there is a way to preach announcements. It can be done. That's true. I've seen it done.
01:11:21 i've seen it done i've seen it done yeah yeah it's like oh i'm just tasked with the announcements
01:11:26 you know i don't really get to say anything or do you you can find a way yep all right well thanks
01:11:32 for coming on the show ben and thank you to the listeners um we appreciate and um yeah we're just
01:11:36 really grateful for everybody who follows the channel and supports the ministry and lord
01:11:41 willing we will see you guys again on friday
01:11:51 You