The NXR Podcast - March 28, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - What About Constantine, Martyrs, and Persecution?

Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - How the Statue of Liberty Lost Its Meaning THE LIVESTREAM - Daily Wire Bankruptcy & The Future Of Conservative Media w Dominic Tripi

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 49 minutes

Words per minute

181.45

Word count

19,830

Sentence count

600

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

27

sentences flagged

Hate speech

99

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, the Right Response Ministries team challenges the notion that the state has a role to play in suppressing heresies, protecting true religion, and safeguarding the Christian faith. They argue that if the state is supposed to correct the church in certain matters, why all of the errors and excesses?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's news feeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 Much credit is given to Constantine for his role in calling together the church at Nicaea
00:00:33 and helping facilitate the foundational creed of the Christian church.
00:00:37 But did you know that a mere ten years later, in 335 AD, at the Council of Tyre,
00:00:45 Constantine exiled one of the fiercest defenders of the faith at that time, Athanasius?
00:00:53 See, Athanasius remained in exile until Constantine's death
00:00:57 and was only welcomed back by his son who restored him as a bishop,
00:01:03 who then went on to exile him again a year later.
00:01:08 Constantine the Great also continued to permit the continuation of pagan temples and rituals
00:01:15 and retained the title Pontifex Maximus, meaning the great priest of the Roman cults.
00:01:23 Sounds a lot like America's principled pluralism today, doesn't it?
00:01:28 Now, at first glance, these facts are pretty inconvenient for someone who just recently argued
00:01:35 that the state has a normative role in correcting the church.
00:01:39 If, after all, one of the greatest supposed examples was an emperor who exiled faithful bishops and continued to permit pagan worship, then the batting average doesn't look that great.
00:01:53 This is to say nothing of the countless martyrs of the Catholic Church, the supposedly terrible Spanish Inquisition, and even Martin Luther and other zealous reformers.
00:02:05 Now, if the state really is supposed to correct the church in certain matters, why all of the errors and excesses?
00:02:15 This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reese Fund, as well as our Patreon members and our faithful donors.
00:02:24 You can join our Patreon by going to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries or you
00:02:33 can donate by going to right response ministries.com forward slash donate. So today we're going to
00:02:41 answer those questions. We've made the claim right alongside the Westminster Confession of Faith and
00:02:48 the Belgic Confession that the state has a role to play in suppressing heresies, protecting true 0.72
00:02:54 religion and safeguarding the Christian faith. Now we are going to defend this view against the
00:03:01 most common objections that we've heard. All right, welcome, welcome. Michael is just being
00:03:20 a humble servant and getting me a glass of water real quick um ga it is friday afternoon we are
00:03:25 very very happy to have you all with us uh so we in the providence of god produced and the episode
00:03:33 was written by our very own wesley todd god bless you did a great job um got a couple dates wrong
00:03:39 turns out uh that absolutely changes our overall argument how much well we got one date wrong by
00:03:45 10 years so i really scrub it like we need to pull this episode we pay millions of dollars to
00:03:50 pull it everywhere it is on the internet exactly yeah so it changes the argument zero uh but the
00:03:55 dates do matter and it's you know as soon as you figure that out correction here and who did you
00:03:59 it was michael reeves who who was it yeah so just um kind of setting the stage the first thing we
00:04:05 talked about was constantine and constantine's conversion as the roman emperor and it's in
00:04:09 330 ad not 320 as i said that he enters and he enters and goes to church in the hagia irene
00:04:15 which is not the Hagia Sophia, which I said.
00:04:18 The reason I said Hagia Sophia, and even in my mind, I was like,
00:04:21 I feel like that's much later, is because one of the lectures I reviewed as I studied
00:04:24 was from Gordon Conwell, professor, Gordon Conwell Theological Seminary.
00:04:29 He was the professor of church history, Ryan Reeves, who said Constantine went into the Hagia Sophia.
00:04:34 So on that one, I was wrong, but I was wrong because someone else is wrong.
00:04:38 And so should have double-checked that, but ultimately, wrong church, Hagia Irene,
00:04:42 instead of the Hagia Sophia. It was in 330 AD, not 320 AD, that Constantine attends church there.
00:04:48 Perfect. So yeah, so the overarching thesis that we presented is changed zero by that detail. But
00:04:59 the details do matter. We want to get it right. And here's the thing, and I know it's shocking,
00:05:04 you know, especially for older generations, particularly the boomer generation. They're
00:05:08 like we got them now we got them now um because there's you know there's a tool in our toolkit
00:05:15 that um sadly the older generation is completely unaware of that it even exists and it's called
00:05:21 um just admitting you were wrong yep so that's you know it's like i thought we had them i thought
00:05:27 we nailed them to the wall and they're still going and people are still listening how what
00:05:31 is the superpower uh the superpower is called an apology yep hey my bad uh we we got these
00:05:38 details wrong here's how we'll switch them if it actually did change the argument then we'd
00:05:43 reintroduce okay so and this is actually a decent counter to but it doesn't change the argument at
00:05:47 all any good argument is resting on tons of different pillars of evidence it's resting on
00:05:51 confessions it's resting on reformers upon different history in the medieval ages it's
00:05:56 going to the modern time none of it is dependent on any single pillar so if you take one of them
00:06:00 out well my whole thing falls apart a good odd argument especially on a topic like this which
00:06:05 we did is going to be built on dozens of pieces of evidence that bolster it and strengthen it and
00:06:10 give it its vitality right and i it's just something that i'm encouraged there are plenty
00:06:15 of weaknesses with um the younger generation like you know no generation is faultless every
00:06:20 generation has its its weak points and all those kinds of things and so we're perfectly aware of
00:06:24 that but i like that is something that encourages me um in general is i do feel like younger
00:06:30 generations are just more comfortable with saying, oh, we missed that. Whereas I feel like older
00:06:36 generations, this doesn't mean each and every boomer. I'm speaking in generalities, group
00:06:41 dynamics. I'm not, you know, there are always exceptions and praise God for them. But what
00:06:45 we're saying that is in general, a lot of times, sadly, like the older generation and even older, 0.88
00:06:51 you know, Christian ministers, they, you know, it's always, it's never an apology. It's just
00:06:58 a clarification or it's a doubling down or, you know, like, um, and, and I really think
00:07:02 that's, that's one of the reasons why, you know, not the only reason, but one reason
00:07:06 why I'm bullish on Christian nationalists is that most of the Christian nationalists
00:07:11 that there is a generational divide.
00:07:12 So most of them are on the younger side, most of them, you know, 45 years or younger
00:07:16 and, um, and, you know, just kind of returning to, um, some, you know, some older thoughts
00:07:23 and older writers and those kinds of things.
00:07:25 And for whatever reason, the younger generation doesn't seem to have at least the same degree of aversion towards just saying, oh, yeah, I missed that.
00:07:35 My bad.
00:07:35 Let me let me fix that real quick.
00:07:37 And OK, let me I'm going to weigh it now.
00:07:39 Does that change the substance of the overarching argument?
00:07:42 Yes.
00:07:42 OK, so let's go this way or no, it doesn't.
00:07:46 But it's still important to get the details right.
00:07:48 Sorry, I missed that.
00:07:49 um it's you know a movement that that's um that's that's okay with admitting
00:07:56 like ever that they were wrong is uh pretty hopeful pretty hopeful we've never made the
00:08:04 claim like notice the difference for example so we did an episode on genetics i have a bachelor's
00:08:08 degree and i have a master's degree in health and biology and all of these things we probably
00:08:12 spoke about genetics for about 40 minutes during that episode i maybe talked about constantine for
00:08:16 maybe 10. I don't have a degree necessarily in church history. So none of us here have claimed
00:08:20 we are the be-all, end-all authority on church history. We can go deep on every single topic.
00:08:25 We are qualified to lecture all through the early church, into the Middle Ages,
00:08:28 into the Reformation. We literally don't do that. We've never produced an hour and a half episode
00:08:32 where we're just talking about history because at the end of the day, we're not church historians.
00:08:37 In fact, we've talked about how we would like to tackle some topics, but we just don't feel
00:08:41 like we are expert enough or have the time to do the required amount of research.
00:08:46 right there's uh plenty of things that we hope to get to eventually yep um but as uh our friend
00:08:52 dr steven wolf would say uh do the reading so you'll suggest great episodes and i'll be like
00:08:57 that's great i just need 10 hours right to make sure i'm informed exactly to actually speak on it
00:09:02 so we'll get there eventually so anyway so uh we wanted to correct that right off the bat but then
00:09:05 we wanted to deal with some of the objections so this was kind of the talk of the town um for the
00:09:10 last few days was our episode it was a fan favorite and the people loved it and when i say that
00:09:16 of course i mean that um people lost their minds the right people loved it like really did like
00:09:21 they appreciated it and said thank you for like pointing out how historical this is right a lot
00:09:25 of people did appreciate it but a lot of people were like what this is backwards you know this
00:09:29 is completely untrue tell me you've never read the bible you know without saying you've never
00:09:33 read the bible tell me that you don't know um you know anything about church history like aren't you
00:09:38 like remember the um what what uh what what's that show with uh tobias he's uh arrested
00:09:46 development yeah remember the scene where he's like uh there are dozens of us like that's what
00:09:52 i always think of when it's like you know don't you know that they they drowned baptist there
00:09:55 were dozens of us dozens by the way steven wolf's tweet on that the other day was fantastic about
00:10:02 how baptists um will be allowed to worship in the new christian nationalism but but they can
00:10:09 optionally as an elective sign up for persecution if they want which is perfect because that is like
00:10:14 that is the baptist the great baptist dilemma is like baptists are they're more terrified of
00:10:19 persecution than anything in the world um being you know uniquely persecuted for being baptist
00:10:24 which is like like not even close to happening so like their greatest fear is something that
00:10:29 that's uh there's no signs of whatsoever um and yet and this is the the thing that's so peculiar
00:10:34 about baptists and yet it's also like their their their secret fantasy the greatest hope their
00:10:40 greatest hope they're like yeah so it's like on one hand they're like no baptists would be 0.93
00:10:44 persecuted on the other hand they're like and the greatest desire of my heart is to be drowned to be
00:10:51 like john bunyan steven wolf as a wonderful christian prince you know i think he he mapped
00:10:56 out a very amicable you know um accommodating position where he said uh you can have both
00:11:02 like uh you have my word yeah baptist will not be drowned but if you would like you can be
00:11:08 you can sign up for afternoon drownings and that's exactly what baptist in their heart of hearts
00:11:13 that's what they want um yeah so anyways all that being said we wanted to deal with some of the
00:11:18 objections and bring a little bit more details uh to the floor uh but i've got to say right here
00:11:24 real quick from the outset if you want to live stream our conference it's happening next week
00:11:28 thursday friday saturday april 3rd 4th and 5th and we are really really excited we've got
00:11:33 you know 15 different speakers everybody's flying in everybody's making their last arrangements and
00:11:39 and and we're up to about a thousand people that are going to be there in person and so i think
00:11:44 it's like 950 960 so really excited about that it's going to be a great time but for those of
00:11:50 you who are unable to come in person and you'd like to live stream, have all the content made
00:11:55 available to you online. You need to, we're making it available, but exclusive for our Patreon
00:12:01 members. So you need to go to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries. It's, it's
00:12:07 available only for our Patreon members and you have to sign up for the gold tier. Silver tier
00:12:11 gets you ad free early access to our Friday special, but this gets you the live stream for
00:12:16 the conference if you sign up for the gold tier so gold tier patreon.com forward slash right
00:12:22 response ministries and also uh we have for the very first time uh michael belch uh his book is
00:12:28 sitting here on the table he's going to be uh signing and selling uh physical copies at our
00:12:33 conference uh but it's also available that you can purchase on amazon do you want to tell them
00:12:37 just real quick name of the book the title is in defense of christian nations and you can find it
00:12:43 on amazon under that title we have it for kindle softcover and hardcover if you're coming to the
00:12:52 conference it will be slightly discounted as a promotional rate at the conference so if you want
00:12:56 to get a copy wait and get it there it'll be a little bit cheaper for you otherwise yeah it's
00:13:01 available on amazon right now awesome okay guys go ahead and take us all right so with any topic
00:13:06 there's the objections that you just like said like well this is a nitpicking point of history
00:13:10 doesn't really make a big difference. But I do want to say, like, there are people that have
00:13:14 genuine disagreement with us and bring up good points. So to the individual that would ever say,
00:13:18 like, hey, I see what you're saying. I understand where you're coming from. Historically, I take
00:13:22 difference here. I would say, by all means, like, you're fine to disagree with us. The only ask
00:13:27 would kind of be to say, okay, I disagree, but I do see where you're coming from. I understand
00:13:32 that's in the confessions. I understand how other reformers taught that. And so there were some
00:13:35 good faith objections, and I kind of categorized it into three buckets that we'll treat here in
00:13:39 these three segments. And the first one would be the objection to Constantine, to his status as
00:13:44 emperor, the things that he did. There's some modern scholarship that really casts doubt on
00:13:48 Constantine's status as a defender of Christianity, as a defender of the faith. So it'd be casting
00:13:52 doubt upon Constantine. We'll hit this here in the first segment. The second one would be kind of a
00:13:57 mention of, under the Catholic Church, all of the persecutions that happened in the Middle Age. So
00:14:02 if you say, well, the state should be involved and the state should care and meddle even in
00:14:06 spiritual affairs. Well, we kind of had about a thousand years of that and weren't there tons of
00:14:11 martyrs and everything like that. Spoiler alert, even on its worst day, honestly, it probably was
00:14:16 better than what we have going now on now in its best day. So we'll get into some of the statistics,
00:14:21 all of that. And then the final one, and it is valid, is, well, you say all of this, but ultimately
00:14:25 that's not our American tradition. The American tradition has always had a bit of a firewall
00:14:30 between church and state. Never true separation. There's always going to be a religious interest
00:14:35 of the state but we have the law congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of
00:14:40 religion we have the ban on no religious tests for public office and so people will say well
00:14:44 that's not american or even that's not baptist i'm well aware of the baptist faith and message
00:14:49 what it says about the civil magistrate i'm well aware of the 1689 and its differences from the
00:14:53 westminster confession of faith which is primarily the deliberate choice of silence yeah exactly
00:14:59 yep so we'll get into all of that but let's start off with constantine so as i already mentioned if
00:15:03 if you're just tuning in now, it was 330 AD, not 320 AD, as I said earlier this week, 330 AD that
00:15:09 he attends church in the Hagia Irene. Now the Hagia Sophia, which actually was the Holy Church
00:15:14 of the Apostles, which he did attend church at one point. So he literally went to the site that
00:15:18 it eventually became. Hagia Sophia is not built until later on. So he attends church at the Hagia
00:15:23 Irene. One of the big contentions with Constantine is that ultimately because he's an emperor and
00:15:30 because he has a political interest, and this is brand new in church history. I mean, the church
00:15:33 has always been persecuted, all the way up through Diocletian in the early 300s, like, to varying
00:15:38 degrees, some less, some more, but she never has an establishment. She never has any relationship
00:15:43 to power and to political power, and so there really is a view, and this would be more Anabaptist
00:15:49 in those who would hold this position, that Constantine comes in, in many ways, he ruins
00:15:53 Christianity, that Christianity was pure, and it was home church, and it was the church being the
00:15:59 church and feeding the poor and caring for these. But Constantine comes in and he begins getting
00:16:03 bishops together and caring about articles of faith. And he gives a political aspect to
00:16:07 Christianity that has really ever since, the argument would be since the 300s, since the
00:16:13 Edict of Milan in 313, that it's always had a political bent to it. Now, again, even some of
00:16:17 our detractors, they wouldn't go so far as to say that. But there certainly really is a perspective
00:16:21 that, man, he just, he wedded the religious and the political. And some would even go farther and
00:16:27 say that Constantine, when he brings the church together, for instance, and where he claims to
00:16:31 convert, that it wasn't genuine. That what Constantine's really doing here is he's got
00:16:36 these warring factions. I'm going to do my best to steal man the argument, but it's a bad one.
00:16:41 He's got the warring factions, he's got the pagans, and he has the Christians. And as
00:16:45 somehow get them to make peace with each other, he converts to Christianity, extends the olive
00:16:49 branch so that his kingdom, I mean, remember, the kingdom he forms by 324 when he defeats
00:16:55 licentious. It's a huge empire. You've got a lot of people to keep happy with each other. So he has
00:17:00 these squabbles, he has his religious differences, and he makes kind of a half-hearted conversion to
00:17:04 Christianity. He lets it onto the official roster of religions that can be practiced, and as an
00:17:10 attempt, again, not a genuine conversion, not because he really believed in the truth of
00:17:14 Christianity, but because he was trying to make peace. The best resource I have for this, this
00:17:19 would be Peter Lightheart's book, Defending Constantine. He does a great job engaging with
00:17:23 the scholarship on this. And I'm going to read a couple of quotes from this book that I think are
00:17:27 helpful. And so the first objection we'll get to right here is Constantine as the politician.
00:17:33 Didn't he come in and he give a political slant, a political bent to Christianity?
00:17:38 Nate, you can pull up this first quote here. So Peter Lightheart says this,
00:17:43 he, that is Constantine, was a politician preacher and his sharp language also pacified
00:17:48 militant Christians in his empire who muttered that their pseudo-Christian emperor was soft
00:17:53 on idolatry. His law against sacrifice was part of an effort to clear public spaces of that aspect
00:17:58 of the pagan cult considered most unacceptable in the eyes of Christians. And by the 350s,
00:18:03 sacrifice was rare enough that it took some daring to perform ones. You're talking really
00:18:07 only 37 years from the legality of Christianity to the point where sacrifice is becoming rare.
00:18:12 Constantine did not have to take up the sword against pagans. His legislation created an
00:18:17 atmosphere in which sacrifice gradually faded away. People are always products of their time.
00:18:25 When we talk about the conversion of Constantine, which is a huge moment in the history of 1.00
00:18:28 Christianity and the history of the West, it changes it forever. We have to remember that 0.95
00:18:32 Constantine is coming from a long line of emperors that literally were the head, not just of the
00:18:38 state. So it's not just the emperor and he has this political thing, and then there's pagan cults
00:18:42 and there's gods and this, that, or the other. Constantine comes in and the title he inherits
00:18:45 is head of the church and, or head of the state and the church, that the emperor is literally
00:18:51 considered the head of the pagan rituals, the head of the pagan cults. And so, yes, he comes
00:18:56 in as a politician. And yes, as we mentioned in the cold open, he doesn't necessarily do away with
00:19:01 immediately all of the false worship. He doesn't come in and shut down the temples. I think of
00:19:06 Josiah. I mean, he raises them, he salts the earth, he executes the priest. Constantine doesn't do 0.66
00:19:12 that. And it's funny because, you know, like we mentioned later on in our episode, we think a
00:19:15 Christian prince would do something about false religion. But there's a huge difference in an 0.96
00:19:20 American context. In a president, for example, I mean, every single one of our presidents, I believe,
00:19:25 have been Christian. Some Protestants, some Catholic, all of them have been Christian.
00:19:29 So you have a line of presidents that have been Christian, a people that have been Christian,
00:19:33 a society, a culture, an expectation. There's a huge difference between a president or even
00:19:38 someone stronger than that coming in and doing something about the Christian faith in that
00:19:43 context, 2,000 years removed from its origin to a literal pagan emperor who from one day to the
00:19:50 next is converted, who is the inheritor of all these rights. There just is a difference. And so
00:19:55 we give a strong defense of Constantine and yet understand that his sons and those that followed
00:20:00 him would have to take successive steps. And none of that means, well, he ruined it. He came in,
00:20:06 He didn't go all the way. He was like Josiah. No, God did an incredible work through him that was
00:20:11 intended to continue. It wasn't just going to be, I mean, you think about Rome, you think about how
00:20:15 big it was, how deeply ingrained the pagan practices were, other wicked practices, abandoning 0.96
00:20:20 children, homosexuality. I mean, these are ingrained in the culture for hundreds and hundreds of years. 0.73
00:20:26 Ordinarily, God takes time to fix things like that. So Constantine, I believe in his life,
00:20:31 especially from the writings of Eusebius, did an incredible job. Was a faithful man. He had his
00:20:37 flaws. He had his shortcomings. He exiled Athanasius. Even that is in many ways political.
00:20:43 Different enemies of Athanasius got to him first. They convinced him. And even then,
00:20:47 he doesn't excommunicate him, try to excommunicate him from the church, or execute him. He simply
00:20:52 exiles him. So we're well aware that Constantine had his shortcomings, as I have my shortcomings,
00:20:58 all of us have our shortcomings but in the sum total you look across his life and you really see
00:21:04 i think an incredible man an incredible leader and one who very politically savvy very politically
00:21:11 minded set the foundation for the glorious christendom that was going to be built later
00:21:16 on in the middle ages well said even the athanasius thing i mean there is it depends on um kind of how
00:21:25 you read it, like you said, Wes, Constantine helped call together the Council of Nicaea,
00:21:34 out of which the orthodox doctrine of the nature of Christ came to be. And still, the Aryans didn't 0.95
00:21:41 just go away, right? They continued to push, to put pressure on the empire and on the emperor, 0.96
00:21:49 both religiously but also politically. And so in one case, Athanasius was actually exiled five
00:21:54 different times as kind of the winds of public favor switched and swirled and came back and
00:22:01 forth. And one of the times he was exiled almost entirely on political reasons. And
00:22:06 the Arians were able to convince Constantine that as the Bishop of Alexandria, he was
00:22:13 pausing or halting grain shipments to Rome. He was exerting his political influence as a bishop
00:22:22 to keep Rome from being supplied by grain.
00:22:26 Another time, the Arians also claimed him
00:22:28 of having murdered a bishop.
00:22:29 It was surprising to everyone when the bishop
00:22:31 who was supposed to have been murdered
00:22:32 showed up at the defense of Athanasius, still alive.
00:22:35 Always inconvenient for the witnesses.
00:22:37 That's right.
00:22:37 The point is, there were a lot of factors
00:22:43 playing into some of the perceived persecution
00:22:46 of Athanasius in the church.
00:22:47 Some of them, yes, were on theological grounds
00:22:50 and heretics gaining political favor.
00:22:54 And some of them were just lies
00:22:56 and outright political fabrications
00:22:57 by Athanasius's enemies.
00:23:00 And all of that was part of the mix at the time.
00:23:03 It's very difficult.
00:23:03 When we espouse a principle,
00:23:08 the real world application of every single principle
00:23:11 is always going to be a little bit tricky,
00:23:14 a little bit muddy, a little bit cloudy.
00:23:16 Even the principles of wives submitting to husbands, 0.97
00:23:18 which we would all agree with. 0.58
00:23:20 In the real world, you start getting, well, what about this?
00:23:23 What about this situation?
00:23:24 What about, like, there are absolutely rock-solid principles, but the implementation of them,
00:23:29 sometimes it gets a little muddy and sometimes even can be applied too far or not far enough.
00:23:34 That's all we're saying with this principle of whether or not the state has some vested interest
00:23:39 and even authority to correct the church at times.
00:23:42 Yep.
00:23:42 I'm going to read this.
00:23:43 This is Peter Lightheart.
00:23:45 Psalm chapter 2, right?
00:23:46 It says, it doesn't just say to the people, right?
00:23:49 Peoples of the earth pay homage to the sun.
00:23:52 It says rulers of the earth kiss the sun.
00:23:54 And so this is extended.
00:23:56 Nathan, I didn't give you the quote.
00:23:57 It's a little bit long.
00:23:58 But I want to read this as the end of the first segment, where he really makes the case that
00:24:02 even in these excesses, which are true or even true of Constantine himself, they don't
00:24:07 imply a structural deficit.
00:24:09 That in the structure of it, there's nothing implied there that this is wholly unworkable.
00:24:13 So it's a little bit long, but track with me here.
00:24:15 Peter Lightheart says this,
00:24:45 her issues. A queen's bodyguard ought to keep his hands off the queen. But what does he do when she
00:24:49 turns harpy and starts scratching her face, scratching the face of her lady-in-waiting?
00:24:54 Once they noticed there was a queen in their midst, so his conversion, the Edict of Milan,
00:24:58 some emperors and kings were not satisfied with kissing the son. Some could not keep their hands
00:25:02 off her. Some wanted to steal a kiss or two from the bride and seduce her. Plenty did. There were
00:25:07 plenty of excesses, but it's important to notice the difference. Adorning and protecting someone
00:25:12 else's queen even protecting her from herself is not the same as violating her and the queen had
00:25:17 some responsibility to be true to her king she was not supposed to be flattered by the blandishments
00:25:22 of a constantine or justinian or charlemagne she was not to look wistfully at the emperor's court
00:25:26 as she too often did and remodel her own couriers in the image of the emperor's if the emperor tried
00:25:32 to steal a kiss he should be greeted with a good hard slap that happened as we have seen but did 0.94
00:25:37 not always happen and at times the queen was only too happy to take a tumble with the emperor
00:25:41 her provided he paid her handsomely for the pleasure there's a good biblical word for that
00:25:45 see revelation 17 and 18 and neither Wycliffe nor Dante nor Luther was afraid to use it all of these
00:25:52 were real and often horrific acts of unfaithfulness but they do not imply a structural flaw once the
00:25:58 emperor has kissed the son should he not honor the son's bride I think that was really well said
00:26:04 really really well wait good way to put that yeah the state we said in the first episode the state
00:26:08 has been given a physical sword and it's not for decoration paul literally says don't think he
00:26:13 holds this in vain right and the church has been given a real spiritual sword the church has not
00:26:18 been given the physical sword and the state not given the spiritual sword so in physical matters
00:26:22 like paul even says like i've handed a handed over hymenaeus and alexander real flesh and blood
00:26:28 physical people that they would be taught not to blaspheme right he doesn't say like i've handed
00:26:33 over the spirit and the idea and the entity of blasphemy real people handed over to satan he
00:26:39 says elsewhere in corinthians about the adulterer uh handed over for the destruction of the body
00:26:43 that power that sword has been given as we know from romans 13 to the state that's not lock that's
00:26:51 not hume like well maybe the state does this kind of thing god established it that way the state
00:26:56 does not wield the spiritual sword but he does have a physical one he can go too far but ordinarily
00:27:01 when he enforces the first table, within his bounds, he's doing what he's called to do.
00:27:07 Yep. Let's go to our first commercial break and we'll be right back.
00:27:11 Our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants to help you with one money move that'll implicate itself
00:27:16 in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day. They help you to avoid taxation
00:27:22 and to draw compound interest to your money. Now, if you're a high net worth individual,
00:27:28 someone who has maybe even 10 million dollars in net worth then they can help you even more
00:27:33 w2 workers contract workers business owners it's all about cash flow and making tax deferred gains
00:27:42 on all your money for the rest of your life don't avoid this it's a big move but it's a great time
00:27:48 to make it click the link below and you can get on chuck de la dorante's calendar and he'll go over
00:27:53 your background and what you want to accomplish. And he's going to help model a program that
00:27:59 exactly fits your needs. So go ahead and send an email to chuck at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:28:06 Again, that's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com. Or you can click the link below. Make a free
00:28:12 discovery call now. Private Family Banking invites you to join their email list right now to enter
00:28:19 into a drawing to win two free admission tickets to our Christ is King How to Defeat Trash World
00:28:26 conference that's taking place April 3rd, 4th, and 5th of the year of our Lord 2025. Now, you can
00:28:34 enter to win by simply sending an email to banking at privatefamilybanking.com. Again, send an email
00:28:43 to banking at privatefamilybanking.com with the subject line that says April Ticket Giveaway.
00:28:53 Okay, then provide simply your full name and your phone contact information, and you'll be entered
00:29:00 into the contest to win not one, but two free tickets for our conference. America is a country
00:29:06 that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty before God and not
00:29:10 have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:29:13 Rees Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied
00:29:17 not just as a plaque on the wall but to actually be used in business
00:29:21 as though they're commandments from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:29:24 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:29:29 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can
00:29:32 maintain our capacity to do things here.
00:29:35 Rees Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
00:29:40 all right so moving on to the second common objection i think it's a good faith objection
00:29:47 or at least it could be good faith it's okay you've said that the state has an interest in
00:29:51 spiritual things but what we've often seen again and again is what would be seeming abuses of that
00:29:56 is that when they get into it because they're imperfect they go about and they persecute men
00:30:01 that we find in the final analysis well hang on we we love that guy i think of john bunyan and
00:30:05 pilgrim's progress he spent 12 years in prison under the authority of the british crown he wasn't
00:30:11 even it wasn't even like it was a catholic catholic crown and he was protestant he was
00:30:16 protestant they were protestant but he didn't have the authority to be a preacher he refused to step
00:30:20 down from his views and he spent 12 years in prison and i mean he wrote pilgrim's progress so
00:30:25 obviously he was uh he was busy while he was in there but we look at those and it's and i get it
00:30:30 and it's hard for people to fathom but like but wait we we see the abuses we see this going on
00:30:36 uh shouldn't that mean that we just we leave that be but it's the classic conundrum it's not whether
00:30:42 but which the state will always have its interest in morality and by extension religion so you look
00:30:49 at that and here's what i want to do to look at that you say that's bad but here's the question
00:30:53 okay bad in comparison to what a hypothetical perfect world a world with no sin a world with
00:30:59 no fallenness, a world of a perfect state. Well, of course, the state executing Wycliffe, for
00:31:04 example, its persecution of Luther, of course, those are bad things if our comparison is to
00:31:10 a perfect sunny day where nobody sins. But guys, we live in a fallen world and we will until the
00:31:15 return of Christ. And so let's use this example, the Spanish Inquisition. So in Spain, late 1400s,
00:31:23 the pope and he was compelled to do so but he by holy writ wrote to the civil leaders for the
00:31:29 carrying out of an inquisition the inquisition was basically testing people's faith we want to see
00:31:35 professions of faith we want to see the avoidance of heresies through all of today what we would
00:31:40 call spain and it lasted a good amount of time it lasts until the early 1800s like 400 years it was
00:31:45 about 350 years depending when you you kind of market and of course we always hear about it like
00:31:50 well, you know, things are bad now, but I mean like the Catholic Church and the Spanish Inquisition.
00:31:56 Let's actually get into the numbers. Nate, you can pull this source up. There's a bunch of
00:32:01 different, a bunch of back and forth, but I think this is the best summary of the different things
00:32:05 I read. This is quote number four. So quote number four, this is from William D. Rubenstein
00:32:14 back in 2004, and he says this, the Inquisition was only formally abolished in the early 19th
00:32:20 century, early 1800s. Yet it also seems clear that the number of victims of the Inquisition
00:32:25 can easily be exaggerated. Juan Antonio Llorente, in the 1700s, a fierce enemy of the Inquisition,
00:32:32 whose critical history of the Inquisition of 1817 and 1819, remains the most famous early
00:32:36 work attacking everything connected with it. So this guy, Juan Antonio, big critic of the
00:32:42 Inquisition, estimated the number of executions carried out during the whole of the period that
00:32:47 the spanish inquisition existed was 300 years from 1483 until its abolition by napoleon at 31 912
00:32:55 individuals with 291 000 condemned to severe penances most recent historians regard even this
00:33:02 figure as far too high you were talking about before the break there's uh sometimes what is it
00:33:08 i've heard a million yeah even thrown around yeah that during the middle ages the catholic church
00:33:13 was executing millions of supposed heretics i read that somewhere i don't have the source for
00:33:18 it so the way it's described it's kind of like uh you remember during like george floyd and people
00:33:22 were like there must be thousands of unarmed black men being shot by the police in the street right
00:33:26 the number was literally 19 yeah which is about equivalent to probably the number annually that
00:33:32 the inquisition actually formally executed 34 for us for heresy the highest estimate people a year
00:33:38 the highest estimate would be about 90 if we went with those 31,000 figures most estimate between
00:33:44 30 and 40 individuals across the whole kingdom a year executed for heresy and most of them executed
00:33:50 for heresy were not individuals that was like oh my goodness they called me to recite the apostle's
00:33:55 creed i stumbled over the words i called the son a created being within 15 seconds i was up in the
00:34:00 scaffolding these were hard-hearted heretics who had repeatedly obstinately refused to be corrected
00:34:07 so even in those cases we have i mean the church and the state wedded together they're going through 0.60
00:34:13 they expose jews out of land muslims they're going through not just christians like well you say you
00:34:17 profess christ we want to hear details and we want to test your life and we there's a grace period
00:34:22 they kind of gave so they'd come to a town and they would have like 40 days where someone could
00:34:26 come forward and they were promised the punishment would be lesser but it's often not clear who was
00:34:30 actually accusing them what they were being accused of what their recourse was and so certainly in
00:34:36 that we could say well there was some things maybe that were done wrong but but compare 40 50 90 at
00:34:44 most 90 executions across a whole year the population's estimated at about four to five
00:34:50 million so pretty small percent obviously it's smaller than our population population of what
00:34:54 of spain population of spain at the time so four to five million so you have 40 to 90 about a year
00:34:59 executed formally by the church by the state for heresy inquisition coming to people's house
00:35:04 grilling them on doctrine all that compare that to the body count of what we have today compare
00:35:11 that to the body count of abortion i mean right there is an easy one compare that to the body
00:35:16 count i mean which is about a million which is about a million annually 60 70 million across
00:35:23 the time since roe v wade uh compare that even to children that are castrated through surgeries
00:35:29 those numbers are in the thousands for each state of transitions a year 10 20 times multiples
00:35:37 compare the death count right here in austin texas about three weeks ago an illegal immigrant was
00:35:43 driving in the early hours a semi-tractor trailer and was intoxicated plowed into a section of stop
00:35:51 cars killed an infant killed a four-year-old i think three or four other people he shouldn't
00:35:57 have been here. He shouldn't have been driving. And that's just here, right here in the last two
00:36:02 weeks. Obviously, there's the Lakeland Rileys of the world, the individuals, but by the sheer
00:36:08 numbers, like, okay, I get it. But the Spanish Inquisition, yeah, maybe we don't go to people's
00:36:13 homes and grill them on doctrine. Maybe we assume the best of their confession. And so, well,
00:36:19 not the best look. But guys, you have got to get a grip of the picture when we talk about that.
00:36:25 it would be better, all else being equal, if these are the only two options to choose from.
00:36:29 A bit of an overzealous church and state. They're a little, as Peter Lightheart said,
00:36:33 they're a little entangled. They're a little close. They're taking too much of a romp together.
00:36:38 He's not protecting her. Even in those cases, better that than the state telling, dictating
00:36:45 these precepts that we have now that have body counts, not in the tens, not in the twenties,
00:36:51 not in the hundreds but of thousands of things that would have been unthinkable in that time 0.83
00:36:56 that really would have yep not to mention aside from just like abortion and uh transgenderism
00:37:03 and all those kinds of things but um just thinking of 2020 alone and you know the state shutting down
00:37:10 every single church in america for right weeks and weeks and then you know and then some states
00:37:15 you know for months um like like we're like oh man we can't you know we can't have christian
00:37:21 nationalism we can't have you know the state can't have the the kinds of powers that and here's the
00:37:26 deal like we we did this in the episode that we did on monday we didn't just say oh here's what
00:37:31 was going on with constantine but we quoted the westminster you know confession not the american
00:37:36 confession but you know the the the former confession which the difference is what like
00:37:41 about 100 years or so prior yeah philadelphia i think it's even maybe even later yeah yep so
00:37:48 uh the belgic confession as well the belgic and the belgic and so like and all and all of these
00:37:55 you know like with the westminster especially you know it says that it is the civil magistrate's
00:38:00 duty to suppress um all heresies and and blasphemies uh that that the state actually
00:38:06 has an obligation under God and a vested interest in helping to keep the church pure.
00:38:12 Now, that doesn't afford to the state the ability or the right to administer the sacraments
00:38:18 or to preach from the pulpit or any of these things, or even to dictate the forms of worship
00:38:24 of the church. 0.84
00:38:25 You know, like when you had the original Covenanters and, you know, people, you know, Puritans 0.97
00:38:31 that were coming to America,
00:38:34 the civil magistrate at that time in England, 1.00
00:38:37 he wasn't suppressing Trinitarian blasphemies like Arianism, 1.00
00:38:42 but he was telling them that they had to, 0.93
00:38:45 that it was mandated that they read the scoreboard
00:38:49 out of the sports almanac on Sunday morning
00:38:52 in their worship. 0.95
00:38:54 He was just being a troll.
00:38:58 He knew that that offended their conscience in a breach of the Christian Sabbath to talk about sports and recreation from the pulpit on a Sunday morning during the worship service.
00:39:11 And so he was abusing his power.
00:39:13 Let me use the example of the king of England now.
00:39:15 So you had a king then who was abusing his power.
00:39:18 We would agree those have no place on the Lord's Day in public worship.
00:39:22 But the king of England right now has largely abdicated his role in relation to the church.
00:39:26 and what he's basically served as is a rubber stamp for all the terrible reforms that the
00:39:31 church of england has undergone he's been supportive of its inclusion and giving of
00:39:36 blessings on same-sex marriage same thing with it was i think in the 70s at the anglican church
00:39:42 at least in england began to ordain women and the king stood right along and let it happen
00:39:47 so in these systems again like okay well he had some problems there to be sure those actually
00:39:53 pale in comparison to even today's king not in their positive doing not in his actual reforms
00:39:59 that he's instituted but the duty he's abdicated so you have the king there and he has a responsibility
00:40:04 in this case he took it too far he was errant totally get that but today he's largely abdicated
00:40:09 and the result has not been and because he's abdicated he stepped back he's not restraining
00:40:14 he's not suppressing man the church in england is doing really well it's doing terrible my brother
00:40:21 in christ england and the church especially as the king at least in that context and not every
00:40:26 nation not every country will have this set up will have a monarch reigning over the the church
00:40:31 and probably even ideally that's not the case as it is right now that's what they've had they've
00:40:36 had it for hundreds of years and right now you have a king abdicating right as the church is
00:40:40 imploding the numbers of the church of england it is going to be extinct in 50 years the church
00:40:46 of martin lloyd jones the church of uh john stott the the church is so the church of the
00:40:53 westminster divines yeah so much great theology so many wonderful architects so many treasures
00:40:59 of the faith that were handed down the king as steward is watching the royal family is watching
00:41:05 as they all go down the drain we don't look at that and say well thank goodness he stepped back
00:41:10 from his role thank goodness the state's not interfering no the king needs to get in there
00:41:13 and clean house yes i'm i'm sure glad that there aren't going to be any abuses from you know the
00:41:18 civil magistrate in england like there won't be christianity in england right the whole those 0.99
00:41:26 churches will be occupied by muslims yeah like they're all turning into muslim mosques and so
00:41:32 yes but but that's what you said earlier is just important for the listener to understand
00:41:37 And it's not whether but which, not whether but which.
00:41:42 You're going, so long as we live in a fallen world, until the final physical return of Christ, you're going to have sin.
00:41:49 You're going to have abuses of power.
00:41:51 All these kinds of things are going to happen.
00:41:53 And when we look at a whole over Western civilization, just in the last 50 years, 70 years, 130 years, and really stretching back even to the Enlightenment,
00:42:04 you know what we have is secular humanism and you know just like you know the scriptures that you
00:42:11 know saul has killed his thousands but david is tens of thousands it's like yeah like uh sacralism
00:42:16 has killed its dozens yep uh annually and it really martyred uh early reformers who were
00:42:23 literally just trying to take the scriptures and put them in the common tongue right that was wrong
00:42:27 So, like, sacralism has burned dozens at the stake, and secular humanism has vacuumed out 70 million babies.
00:42:37 And that's just a start.
00:42:39 That's just a start.
00:42:40 An entire millennium of Christendom is being leveled right now at the hands of secular humanism.
00:42:45 We all know it's easier to destroy something than to build something.
00:42:49 Wes, I have a question.
00:42:50 I'm going to give you a minute to think about it because I'm going to make another point.
00:42:52 But there's an objection that people will raise.
00:42:55 they'll say, well, the person being, the people being run over by the illegal immigrant, that is
00:43:01 not directly because of a state and religion connection. So some of your examples were related
00:43:07 to maybe people would categorize them as purely political decisions. And so maybe it would be good
00:43:13 to answer that. But I wanted to mention one other thing about the Spanish Inquisition. And well,
00:43:17 two things one is those numbers of 40 to 90 a year it is true that the inquisition kind of came
00:43:25 in cycles and some popes would push for it and some popes would pull back on it and so it's not
00:43:32 like they were meeting a quota every year like uh like a policeman is meeting a quota on the number
00:43:37 of you know um speeding tickets that he's giving out so there would have been times where perhaps
00:43:43 the violence or the torture would have been more pronounced than at other times and so it is
00:43:48 possible that you would look in the history of the spanish inquisition and you would see some
00:43:52 times where it was more frightful more torturous things like that and many more thousands that
00:43:57 weren't executed were yes they were they were put to the question as it were yeah but that proves
00:44:03 the opposite too that means that the spanish inquisition was not a constant in spain for those
00:44:08 350 years there were times where that really wasn't happening much at all now still people
00:44:15 will object and say well it still makes me shudder that there were whole machinations of power and
00:44:21 machinery of church and state and they had you know these places set up to interrogate and put
00:44:27 people to the question and they developed a whole theology of justifying torture because if you're
00:44:33 tortured and you're righteous God will preserve your faith and you know if you're not righteous
00:44:38 then you will die and god didn't preserve you and that was admittedly a bad um you know there was a
00:44:45 whole machinery as it were that was set up last west you mentioned remembering the time the 0.76
00:44:51 inquisition started what late 1483 yeah 1483 the reconquista historically didn't even end until 0.91
00:45:00 1492 officially which was the period where spain was driving the moor and the muslim back out of
00:45:06 spain back into africa they were literally still in the process of fighting for their existence 0.95
00:45:13 as a people as a religion as christendom and so yeah they were they were kind of jumpy about that
00:45:20 at the time right but they were coming out of uh what was it 700 years almost of literal constant 0.78
00:45:28 warfare trying to win back and beat back the the the muslim invasion of southern europe like and 0.92
00:45:35 Typically Jews that were helping them, and that's why they went then to expulse them. 0.98
00:45:39 And so the fact that they were trying to figure out how can we prevent this from happening again, 0.95
00:45:44 let's make sure that everyone in the nation is Christian, was a political consideration
00:45:48 because they were fighting a political war as much as they were a religious war. 1.00
00:45:53 And so the state said, we have a vested interest in making sure that the people here are not working with the Muslims 0.95
00:46:01 to counter our efforts of winning back our country. 0.98
00:46:05 Yep, absolutely.
00:46:07 Let's go to our next commercial break
00:46:08 and then we'll be back.
00:46:09 All right.
00:46:10 All right, the clock is running out.
00:46:12 You need to go and register now
00:46:14 for our Christ is King,
00:46:15 How to Defeat Trash World Conference.
00:46:18 It's happening the year of our Lord, 2025,
00:46:21 April 3rd, 4th, and 5th.
00:46:23 That's a Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.
00:46:26 And by God's grace,
00:46:27 we're able to provide for you an all-star lineup.
00:46:30 We've got Steve Dace, Calvin Robinson,
00:46:32 Oren McIntyre, Dr. Stephen Wolfe,
00:46:35 Eric Kahn, David Reese, Andrew Isker, John Harris, A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, Dusty Devers,
00:46:42 Ben Garrett, C.J. Engel, and yours truly, Pastor Joel Webin. Come on out. Join us April 3rd,
00:46:49 4th and 5th, 2025, Thursday through a Saturday. Go to rightresponseconference.com to register
00:46:57 today. Again, that's rightresponseconference.com. Listen, guys, you probably listened to Right
00:47:04 Response Ministries because you take the Dominion mandate offered to us in Scripture
00:47:09 seriously. Well, unsurprisingly, so does Dominion Wealth Strategist. As the only distinctly reformed
00:47:17 financial consulting firm, they help Calvinistic, covenantal, and confessional Christians to steward
00:47:24 their resources faithfully in a way that actually aligns with God's Word. Dominion Wealth leverages
00:47:30 all corners of the financial service industry as independent brokerage agents, matching you
00:47:36 with suitable products and services from dozens of top industry providers. Their mission is to
00:47:43 equip believers to secure their family's future and build a legacy that glorifies God by building
00:47:50 holistic financial strategies that include budgeting, insurance, debt management, retirement
00:47:57 planning, estate planning, and more. In order to make wealth Christian again with a portfolio that
00:48:04 might even put King Solomon to shame, go and take dominion over your finances today by visiting
00:48:11 www.reformed.money and book an introductory overview right now. All of Christ for all of life
00:48:20 and all of finance for chrysidom all right all right well welcome back here's the last objections
00:48:28 we had we tackled constantine real quick let me just put you on the spot right now you snap your
00:48:34 fingers um status quo what we have today secular humanism ruling the day or roman catholic christian
00:48:43 nationalism and uh you're not allowed to baptize your babies or you're not allowed to do a
00:48:50 believers baptize baptism you have to baptize your babies it's not even a question not that
00:48:54 both are perfect i i have a conviction but like right yeah oh my goodness like that's what like
00:49:01 i'm just i'm watching the chat and i'm trying not to um because sometimes it's just trying not to
00:49:06 crash out well yeah i mean there's there's a couple guys that most of the chats doing a great
00:49:10 job you know they're they're taking care you know take care of our light work right we've got you
00:49:15 know patriots in control we've got like you know true christian nationalists in the chat dealing
00:49:18 with um uh the you know the guys who are ngmi i'm not gonna make it but um but i'm reading it and i'm
00:49:28 and i'm like what like what world i just don't understand it i don't understand like what world
00:49:34 do you think we're currently living it you know like what we we have drag queen story out you know
00:49:40 like we we don't we don't even have america first we have israel first we have like you know like
00:49:46 we're it's globalism it's um we're giving you know we're a tax farm for ukraine and it's like
00:49:55 no we're going to be america first like so we're not going to be a tax farm for anyone no still
00:49:59 israel but not like vivek ramaswamy he's like campaigning and he tries to kind of take that
00:50:04 america first slogan right what does america first mean that means millions more h1b visas
00:50:09 because we have to fix our declining birth rate problem right how is this american first again
00:50:14 right can you help me out here connect some pieces so that we have globalism multiculturalism
00:50:19 tax farm for you know all the other nations of the world uh transgenderism drag queen story hour 0.96
00:50:25 lgbt mafia and and if all of that wasn't enough you know we have uh 70 million babies dead you 0.96
00:50:35 know conservatively just in the last half century just in the last 50 years and and baptists are 0.88
00:50:42 concerned that um that christian nationalism might mean that like what if what if it's really bad
00:50:49 and we have more than ever before we have 200 baptists over the course of the century
00:50:57 that die i'm like you mean 200 million no 200 the worst we've ever had in all of human history
00:51:05 uh it's like what are you talking about i don't i just i don't get it even fundamentally i would
00:51:11 say, and Daryl Cooper makes this point, how Christendom was formed, there was hierarchy
00:51:16 built in. There's hierarchy built into the Catholic Church. We're not Catholic, but you have a Pope
00:51:20 who's the first among the bishops. And then you have, I mean, even the peasant coming into church. 0.96
00:51:25 They come into church where it's not just an ordinary commoner who's preaching, but a man
00:51:29 who's been to seminary and has a whole life devoted. He's on an elevated stage above the people
00:51:33 giving out the words of God that they don't have. And in many ways, as imperfect as it was,
00:51:38 it just inculcated in a people the hierarchy and the orders that the spiritual was great and above
00:51:44 and that's what we aspired to and that within those churches and within that not everyone
00:51:48 was the same not all were capable of teaching not all were capable of the that life not all
00:51:54 were capable of being a pope the higher in service of the lesser cared and stewarded and and so that
00:52:00 hierarchy that we had the american one we have it just in our bones like the most successful
00:52:06 denominations in the united states are very flat as far as their structure they don't hardly any
00:52:12 of them have bishops if they do it's like methodism where the bishops don't really have any
00:52:15 local power they'll do a presbytery one level that's about it but honestly like methodist
00:52:20 baptist assemblies of god very flat structures that have no hierarchy to them has been the
00:52:26 american experience and i'm not talking in the last 20 years like 200 years right like those
00:52:32 have been the ones that have succeeded most over and against the roman catholic system
00:52:36 or not catholics but a structure that did have higher and lower superiors inferiors structure
00:52:44 to it and that also had um substance um rather than the subjective um that that was one of the
00:52:55 things one of the appeals still to this day i think with roman catholicism is the idea of
00:53:01 not having to question and wonder you know that like it's you know it's these robes and these
00:53:07 tassels and this candle and this incense and this cathedral and this stained glass and this bread
00:53:13 and this wine and this you know and it's um you know you come and you do confession in this booth
00:53:19 with this man who wears this you know these robes um and and you know like seven sacraments that are
00:53:26 all very, they're objective rather than subjective, they're tangible. You know, it's like, I'm, you
00:53:33 know, my children are going to be baptized in the Roman Catholic Church, going to get married in the
00:53:38 Roman Catholic Church, I'm going to take the Eucharist in the Roman Catholic Church, and I'm
00:53:42 also going to do confession from time to time in the Roman Catholic Church, I'm going to have last
00:53:47 rites read to me, you know, when I die, you know, dying, being blessed by the Roman Catholic Church.
00:53:51 You would grow up in one church, you would see a cemetery that your parents are buried in,
00:53:55 You would return to that seminary to be buried there?
00:53:58 Yeah, cemetery.
00:53:59 Cemetery, yep.
00:54:00 And so there was an objectivity.
00:54:03 And you know what?
00:54:03 To steal, man, to give the most charitable defense of the federal vision guys,
00:54:12 that's what they were looking at.
00:54:14 They were like, yeah, there has to be some objectivity of the covenant.
00:54:18 there has to be some kind of something that people can look to um and have some sense well it's you
00:54:27 know it's kind of timely that like right now there's you know a clip going viral with john
00:54:30 piper um which honestly i'm just kind of like surprised to see john piper you know in the
00:54:38 discourse again i haven't you know heard anything from john piper in a very long time yeah he entered
00:54:42 the chat it's been a while and um but it was basically you know him talking about uh the
00:54:48 warning passages like he's just quoting scripture and it's absolutely true but like hebrews 6
00:54:53 hebrews 10 and just saying like be careful you know brothers lest any of you right you know
00:54:59 should be found to have an evil unbelieving heart that would cause you to fall away from the living
00:55:04 god and he wasn't saying he's not denying the doctrines of grace and saying that you would
00:55:08 lose your salvation but he's saying that you could prove that you never had it to begin with
00:55:11 like for people who are a part of the visible church you know and and he's saying yeah and
00:55:16 and then he says you could fall away any one of you could fall away and he's like i could fall
00:55:20 away um and that's he's been consistent in that before that's something i i have never really
00:55:25 liked about um a particular point of piper's doctrine that i've never appreciated because he's
00:55:30 uh basically what he's saying is that um that you can never really have assurance right not full
00:55:37 assurance so you know to be fair to piper like he wouldn't say you can have uh the christian can
00:55:43 only ever have no assurance but he would just say you can grow in varying degrees of assurance but
00:55:49 you can never have full assurance in this life um and he would say that for himself he's like i could
00:55:54 fall away tomorrow right and uh and so that you know that's that is one of the weaknesses of
00:56:01 Protestantism is that everything is examine yourself, the conscience, the private life
00:56:11 of the individual, you're standing before God, and there's not many external, visible
00:56:19 monuments that you can point to, that you can lay hold of, that would provide a sense
00:56:26 of certainty and uh and confidence that this person is in this person is out this person is
00:56:32 a christian this person is not a christian like and and so as you know everything so that's just
00:56:38 matters of soteriology and ecclesiology but then beyond that you know like when it comes to um
00:56:45 clergy and ordination and those kinds of things you know like that's that's even my own story
00:56:50 which everybody now knows you know but like um yeah like especially within baptist tradition
00:56:56 not all protestants but but particularly baptists it's like we have all these non-denominant
00:57:02 non-denominational churches and it's like anybody can just start a church right you know and has
00:57:08 that been particularly good for the u.s now to but to be fair like we've seen you know other countries 0.99
00:57:15 that are Catholic, predominantly Catholic, and they suck too. 0.97
00:57:18 It hasn't been there. 1.00
00:57:20 So I'm not saying that it's a fail-safe because it's not by any means.
00:57:25 But the point is, whether it's Protestantism or whether it was Catholicism
00:57:30 or even within Protestants, if we had Baptist Christian nationalism
00:57:33 versus Anglican Christian nationalism or Presbyterian Christian nationalism, 0.78
00:57:39 what I want Christians to realize is I just want them to wake up 0.56
00:57:43 and see that any form, literally any form of Christian nationalism would be an immediate 0.69
00:57:50 and massive improvement on no Christian nationalism, on secular humanistic globalism.
00:57:59 That's the problem.
00:58:01 Go ahead.
00:58:01 And Wes, before we move to your point, the thing that, you know, as I've followed this
00:58:06 discussion a little bit, what is so strange to me is that, Wes, you said it at the beginning.
00:58:12 You said it's not whether but which.
00:58:15 We learned that from the Christian National Theonomists.
00:58:19 And to then imagine that the situation is this,
00:58:27 that we live in a society where the church is not enforcing,
00:58:31 or sorry, where the state is not enforcing a religion, is false.
00:58:36 The point is, every nation is fundamentally religious.
00:58:39 The state always enforces and promotes and protects a religious perspective and religious toleration or persecution to some degree.
00:58:53 It just so happens that our state currently is enforcing and promoting secularism and rapidly paganism.
00:59:01 And so when we say, yeah, of course the state has, say, a role to play in the public expression of religion, we're taking that almost as an a priori assumption.
00:59:12 We're not even taking that necessarily as an art—like, we are arguing for it, for the historical position of it.
00:59:18 But also, that is just the nature of nations and peoples.
00:59:22 They have a religious perspective.
00:59:24 Whoever is in power in that nation will enforce and promote and defend a certain religious perspective.
00:59:30 it is inevitable hey it's almost like a black pill like really it's this simple
00:59:35 it's a lot of it is just downstream of political will nate can you show this the one image that i
00:59:40 have this is a great example good brother flag of this to me on x this is from the michigan penal
00:59:46 code so the state of michigan here in the united states on the books section 750.102 still currently
00:59:52 on the books as i understand it still currently on the books blasphemy punishment section 102
00:59:57 Any person who shall willfully blaspheme the holy name of God
01:00:01 by cursing or contemptuously reproaching God
01:00:04 shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.
01:00:06 705-103, cursing and swearing.
01:00:09 Any person who has arrived at the age of discretion 0.88
01:00:11 who shall profanely curse or damn or swear
01:00:13 by the name of God, Jesus Christ, or the Holy Ghost
01:00:17 shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.
01:00:18 No such prosecution shall be sustained
01:00:20 unless it shall be commenced within five days
01:00:23 of the commission of such an offense.
01:00:25 Now, as I'm sure in Michigan,
01:00:26 they're patrolling the streets they hear you the cop get a little mouthy at the bar no there's no
01:00:32 will to enforce it the same thing with arizona they had books laws on the books yes for a long
01:00:37 time against abortion nobody enforced it had sodomy laws on the books i think all the way up
01:00:42 until i think at least the 70s if not the 90s and i hear like i don't think it's public information
01:00:50 but I've heard from some legislators
01:00:53 that in the
01:00:55 great republic of Texas we still have
01:00:57 sodomy laws on the books
01:00:58 but at the end of the day we're not
01:01:01 a nation of laws as Steve Dace
01:01:02 often says but we're a nation of
01:01:04 political will
01:01:05 the supreme court 0.99
01:01:09 overrode our laws
01:01:10 the supreme court overrode our laws
01:01:12 when we were in high school 0.51
01:01:13 activist judges took it upon themselves
01:01:16 to dictate morality
01:01:17 the state
01:01:19 dictated the morality of a people yep but the point is that like all these things that people
01:01:26 think is just so outlandish and foreign and that could never happen and that would be terrible and
01:01:31 i can't believe um we're not this is not a pipe dream this is not um this is not just some random
01:01:37 hypothetical we're talking about something that has happened before and it happened here yeah and
01:01:43 and not just hundreds and hundreds of years ago we're talking about decades world we're talking
01:01:48 about decades ago not that long decades ago and then the question is okay so how you know let's
01:01:54 just do a quick assessment how we've been doing you know like we changed courses uh we you know
01:01:59 we we stopped um being a christian nation and we started being a secular nation um and how how's it
01:02:08 going for us like do we have you know like are there less more trusting prosperous happy healthier
01:02:15 than we'd ever i would say so it's just you look at that it's like what what has the abandonment of
01:02:21 of christian nationalism gotten us it's gotten us no borders a full-fledged invasion of the third 0.63
01:02:28 world uh that is r-a-p-i-n-g you know uh women children um abortion on mass on demand for any 0.95
01:02:39 reason anytime um lgbt mafia uh exploitation of children that like all and and done by you know 0.80
01:02:49 it's given gotten as human trafficking you know with surrogacy um right from like federal politicians
01:02:56 bragging about it conservative pundits political pundits bragging about it and other conservatives
01:03:02 writing like congratulations this is great you know um and to michael's point earlier a lot of
01:03:08 ngos non-governmental organizations that were spiritually affiliated and churches particularly
01:03:13 the catholic church and the lutheran church were heavily involved in the use of state funds to
01:03:18 settle refugees and immigrants here so churches took it upon themselves to twist the scriptures
01:03:23 and to be overly welcoming and to bring in as many people as possible they took the state's 1.00
01:03:28 dime to do it again you have the state influencing the church and these churches and these spiritual
01:03:33 organizations took that money and shuttled them in by the millions and settled them and gave them
01:03:38 everything they need and supported them and taught them the language churches did that they did it on
01:03:43 the state's dime yeah nathan's back there eating chips because uh west just had a great point for
01:03:49 about three minutes straight and the camera was on me the entire time you were nowhere to be found
01:03:54 no nathan's just he's like i'm done i've checked it's friday well let's get to that last objection
01:04:00 because it's a good one and then let's deal with this uh the super chats also go ahead
01:04:04 so the final objection that that we saw to that is that that's just not the american way to do
01:04:10 things that in our history we have been very conscious of putting a wall between the church
01:04:16 and the state for example again the first amendment congress right there is congress
01:04:21 Unfortunately, there is a Supreme Court case that ruled that in Congress there's actually implied as well state Congresses.
01:04:26 So it's not as though, well, federal can't restrict speech, but the state of Oklahoma could.
01:04:31 So at the state and the federal level, we have the First Amendment, which does say Congress shall make no law respecting the free expression of the other things are allowed to exercise and then religion being one of them.
01:04:43 Same thing.
01:04:43 I think it's Article 6.
01:04:44 There's no religious tests required for public office.
01:04:47 And it's hard to face, and it's even sometimes hard to hold as a good citizen of the United States.
01:04:53 But ultimately, our allegiance is not first to the United States.
01:04:56 It's God, it's family, it's country, I think would be a good kind of ordering of those three.
01:05:00 And when the duty to God, the duty to uphold righteousness, the duty of the state to do good,
01:05:05 when that conflicts with, well, what about my constitution?
01:05:08 What about the will of the people? 0.97
01:05:10 And even the constitution, it's just so silly.
01:05:12 It's like, what's the first word? 0.87
01:05:13 Congress.
01:05:14 so congress cannot determine we're going to have the anglican church of america at the federal
01:05:19 level uh there's nothing in the constitution that doesn't that says that individual states
01:05:25 could not determine and i'm not even saying that that's necessarily a good idea but what i've
01:05:29 advocated for years now at least two or three years i helped in writing you know the statement
01:05:33 on christian nationalism and the gospel um but what i've advocated for is at the federal level
01:05:37 like we should we should declare ourselves formally declare ourselves as a christian nation
01:05:42 and it should not be confessional, but rather creedal.
01:05:45 It should be creedal.
01:05:46 And that would also, by virtue of being creedal,
01:05:49 Apostles' Creed, Nicene Creed, Chalcedon,
01:05:51 it would necessarily include not just all Protestants,
01:05:54 but it would include Roman Catholics as well.
01:05:57 So that's at the federal level, creedally, a Christian nation.
01:06:00 And then we should adopt formally some kind of preamble to the Constitution
01:06:05 that publicly and clearly, explicitly declares the name of Jesus
01:06:11 and the triune God.
01:06:12 as a preamble to the Constitution. And none of that would contradict the First Amendment. You
01:06:17 would not have to revise the Constitution at all. The First Amendment, Congress, so then you don't
01:06:23 have a federal national church of whatever, Presbyterian or Baptist or Anglican or Catholic
01:06:32 or whatever. But credibly, it is a Christian nation at the federal level. Then individual
01:06:37 states actually could, without any breach of the Constitution, could set up state churches.
01:06:42 I personally don't think that's a great idea, but states could do that.
01:06:46 The point is, people don't realize, people just don't know our history, not just Christian church history, but even American history.
01:06:55 They don't realize how Christian this country really was.
01:06:59 They're like, well, you can't do that because of the Constitution.
01:07:02 It's like, my friend, the Constitution would allow state churches, it would allow the adopting of a preamble to the Constitution.
01:07:10 it would allow creedal declaration not not you know at the federal levels a church but um but
01:07:18 but still at the federal level christian in a creedal sense an adoption of a christian preamble 0.95
01:07:25 state churches and putting all the homosexuals in prison that's your constitution that you're like 0.76
01:07:33 well i just want the constitution like no you don't want the constitution blasphemy laws like 1.00
01:07:37 michigan blasphemy laws like somebody calls jesus uh the bastard son of a whore jail right who would 0.95
01:07:44 say that a lot a lot of people would say that um but that like jail right away right um breaking 0.98
01:07:53 the sabbath blue laws on the books in many states still on the books jail there's states where like
01:07:59 shopping is not allowed in that county parameters new jersey one example not allowed on sunday and
01:08:03 that's my point that's what i want i just want the detractors to be honest and say because they're
01:08:08 like well we just love the constitution no you don't you love the de facto the de facto
01:08:16 veil that has covered the constitution since the heart seller act since the civil rights act like
01:08:23 what you love is not america's founding what you love is not america's constitution what you love
01:08:29 is 20th century post-war liberalism.
01:08:36 That's what you love.
01:08:37 Right-wing watch is a subsidiary of people for the American way.
01:08:41 We're people for the American way.
01:08:42 Right.
01:08:43 Their American way sounds a lot different than our American way.
01:08:45 And ours is more historical. 0.55
01:08:47 Who's in charge of the people for the American way?
01:08:50 Who founded it?
01:08:51 Who funds right-wing watch that clips us out of context
01:08:54 and tries to make us sound extremist.
01:08:55 I'm just curious, who is it?
01:08:56 You already know.
01:08:57 Is it an every single time kind of situation?
01:08:58 It's an every single time.
01:08:59 Back in the 80s, and the ERLC...
01:09:02 I was hoping maybe it wasn't this time, you know?
01:09:04 Well, disappointing.
01:09:06 The ERLC actually collaborated with them during Clinton's administration for a religious liberty bill.
01:09:10 Guys, things have been bad for a while.
01:09:12 But the point is, to your point, Joel, they haven't always been.
01:09:16 It's not as though we were an agnostic, democratic, come-as-you-are, open board...
01:09:22 We weren't that for a long time.
01:09:25 Amen.
01:09:25 And here's the point that we've been making for quite a while ad nauseum, but I'm going to make it again.
01:09:30 So, it wasn't that long ago.
01:09:32 It happened here, and it happened recently.
01:09:36 Christian nationalism. 0.61
01:09:38 So, here's the point.
01:09:40 Not only was it recent, and not only was it here, but here's the other thing.
01:09:44 People think, like, yeah, okay, so you're convincing me that, like, yeah, this might be our history,
01:09:49 and yeah, it might even be somewhat of our recent history, but it'll never happen again. 0.94
01:09:55 And this is the last piece of the puzzle that I think is a major white pill and that we should be encouraged by, 0.89
01:09:59 is, um, all of it got undone in the last 50 to 70 years, 50 to 80 years. Um, it's actually easier
01:10:09 to go back. It actually took billions and billions and billions of dollars to artificially
01:10:17 manufacture and propagandize and lobotomize, uh, a nation of people to, to remove themselves
01:10:27 from what comes logically reasonably naturally like to convince people that boys are girls and
01:10:34 girls are boys to convince people that you know a baby in the womb well i don't know i mean is it
01:10:39 really human maybe you know maybe uh it's a snail maybe it's a snail yeah maybe it's you know like
01:10:44 uh like who's to say that it's a human being it becomes human when it passes through the birth
01:10:48 canal yeah like until then you know it's it's as far as we know it's a potential you know uh you
01:10:53 know blue whale you know what like um and that like do you know how much money like how much
01:11:00 money at from the universities to television programs to um you know legacy media to um
01:11:09 to like the medical establishment like and that's not even to begin to talk about like
01:11:14 the politicians and all like do you have any idea how much money and manpower and intentionality
01:11:23 that it required in these last still only possible in the wake of a catastrophic world war that reset
01:11:30 the entire world that's the only way it happened so in these last 50 to 80 years um it's not just
01:11:35 like hey we've had christian nationalism here and we've had it recently like because that is
01:11:41 encouraging makes it seem less preposterous but people the last piece of the puzzle is people
01:11:45 could still say yeah but it'll never happen again it's like no no no you know what people thought 0.92
01:11:50 would never happen this right 70 million mothers murdering their their own children transgender 0.89
01:11:58 it's your drag queen story hour like if you had told people in the 1950s nightmares yeah that 0.87
01:12:04 this would happen they'd be like no yeah no the men storming the beaches at normandy like this is
01:12:10 what you're defending yeah this is what you're fighting for you are fighting for uh principled
01:12:14 pluralism so that we can have drag queen story hour yeah the blessings the british men like 0.74
01:12:19 you're there so your country can be hollowed out 60 years later this is what you're fighting for 0.99
01:12:24 and if you told them that they like i'm telling you you think there's no way we could get back
01:12:30 to a moral foundation um but but they and never in a million years would have believed that we
01:12:37 could have gotten to this because it's not just anti-christian it's not just anti-christ
01:12:42 it's anti-nature it's anti-reality it's anti-reason it's anti-logic it's it's it's
01:12:49 anti the natural world that god established it's a revolt what we've been experiencing
01:12:54 is a revolt against the natural order and nature will not like nature won't won't allow it not
01:13:02 not perpetually not indefinitely it will snap back the natural order will snap back nature
01:13:08 will find a way. Nature will win. And so it's going to snap back. So the only question is,
01:13:14 when this happens, this great reversal, which will happen, it is happening, whether you like
01:13:20 it or not, what is it going to snap back to? It's going to snap back to nature, but will it snap
01:13:25 back to a Christian view of nature, or an Islamic view of nature, or a pagan view of nature?
01:13:31 And because it's in our own history, and because Christianity happens to be true,
01:13:35 the triune god is the real god um snapping back to christian natural principles and natural law
01:13:43 and christian nationalism would be the most sensical it would be the most natural it would
01:13:49 be the most uh fluid you know transition that you could possibly have but my only concern is that
01:13:56 there's like 14 christians talking about it right seriously like so all these people you're you're
01:14:03 worried right you're christians and you're saying well i'm worried that there'll be abuses of power
01:14:07 or it's going to be roman catholic you know catholic integralism you know where you know
01:14:12 like okay well one way maybe to avoid that is maybe you could help us out and we could have
01:14:19 more than 14 protestants right talk about these things um but right now like you're right like
01:14:26 it's going to snap back to nature but it probably won't be protestant christian natural you know
01:14:32 worldview it probably won't be that because every single protestant has stood up and said
01:14:37 no right no we are like there's a lot of things we're uncertain about there's a lot of subjectivity
01:14:44 when it comes to protestantism but there's one thing that we universally and unanimously have
01:14:49 decided together and uh that's that protestants will lose we've decided that we are committed
01:14:55 to make sure that when things snap back to the natural order um by golly uh we're doing
01:15:02 everything we can to make sure that it's muslim pagan or catholic i'm like like this is your
01:15:10 legacy this jeff halfley this is the legacy of protestant boomers had a great yes quote
01:15:15 super chat and then yeah counterpoint let's do it well if you could go back nate so i can see
01:15:20 what he followed it up with so 499 super chat thanks jeff always great to see you baptist
01:15:25 complain about christian nationalism but as soon as 10 20 years ago it's like the 2000s baptists
01:15:30 enforced bans on alcohol sales and localities where they were strong enough in number go down
01:15:34 they oppose christian nationalism but have no problem in imposing baptist nationalism 1.00
01:15:39 or an issue that only baptists feel strongly about yeah it's a great point like of course
01:15:44 they did it they just they had the will then and what we lack now is the will but it was
01:15:48 it was something they cared about that's right so like blasphemy people saying that jesus is a 0.99
01:15:54 bastard of a whore baptists don't care about that right drinking there could be dancing right we're 0.99
01:16:01 talking the drinking and the dancing could be happening now no seriously and it's it's sad 1.00
01:16:05 we're baptists okay so we're not just trying to pick on the but like let's just admit that for a
01:16:09 second like when it like anybody can do you can like everybody is constantly saying you can just
01:16:13 do things that's right like if you have enough people with the political will you can just do
01:16:19 things. So, when Baptists have political will, they just do things. And what do they do? 0.98
01:16:26 They make sure that no one has a good time. They have the political will to make sure that there
01:16:32 is, you know, like regional misery. Like, we want to make sure everyone's bored. That's what Baptists
01:16:38 have the political will for. My own grandparents, you know, like my mom grew up, they would always 0.75
01:16:44 play 42 dominoes right they would have tournaments in the church um people bet on dominoes all the
01:16:49 time right and they were betting on dominoes back then but dominoes were allowed and uno
01:16:54 and was allowed and that's right and skip bow yep um but not playing cards and and it's not that
01:16:59 they banned gambling but the playing cards even without gambling just playing spades or playing
01:17:04 hearts or playing you know or playing war the highest card weren't allowed to do and my
01:17:08 grandfather who who is a wonderful christian man with the lord now in glory uh who i deeply love
01:17:13 and deeply respect it didn't matter like like baptists like when they had the numbers and they
01:17:20 actually still have the numbers little known you know secret but uh but when they had the numbers 0.74
01:17:24 and they and they had the political will um they joined together to do what to ban spades
01:17:32 and hearts and playing cards and beer and to be fair there were not as big of issues as we have
01:17:42 of the day that's true so the drag queen wasn't rolling into the library and they're like hey 0.96
01:17:46 don't go in there there's a book on alcohol it's gonna be fair but you are right like they they
01:17:50 do how to wield power everyone does that's the point that's the point they knew how to assert
01:17:54 themselves they knew people are political animals everyone is political it's not whether but which
01:18:01 everyone is political and you can stop something the moment that you want to like with covid
01:18:07 right well the science changed nope the political science changed covid and the lockdowns and the
01:18:13 jabs and the mask and it all stopped when when uh there was a new strain that wasn't as contagious
01:18:19 you know no it stopped the second that the american people said yeah we're done with that
01:18:25 yep that's all it takes the moment the american people are done with something and now we're done
01:18:31 with we're done with transgenderism we're done with wokeism we're done with it yeah yeah seriously
01:18:36 that's all it will take that's all it takes which is already in about a two-year process of people 0.94
01:18:40 dropping it like a hot potato that's right leaving the human rights council the new snow white movie
01:18:44 is like bond like i think it's like the worst rated movie second worst disney bomb so far
01:18:49 it like ever ever in a hundred year history that disney has been making movies they've been setting
01:18:53 money on fire lately i'll tell you what some some men just want to watch the world burn
01:18:58 but the point is like the moment that you're it's political will everybody is a political animal the
01:19:03 moment that you're you're had enough that you're done with something you can just be done with it
01:19:07 and you can do that with um you can do that with bourbon or you can do it with blasphemy
01:19:14 the choice is yours you know you can do it with playing cards you know or you can do it with
01:19:21 drag queen story hour um the choice is yours this is a little bit of a white pill because it means
01:19:26 that they could do it right they could do it yeah they know how to do always could have done it yep
01:19:33 And they, again, being Christians, broader than just Baptists, but like Christians at
01:19:38 any moment, you can just do things.
01:19:41 You can just wake up and say, no, yeah, we want a Christian nation.
01:19:44 We actually want a Christian nation.
01:19:45 We want public celebrations that recognize Christian holidays that are distinctly Christian.
01:19:53 And we can still have some of the things that are part of our heritage.
01:19:56 It's become a part of our culture.
01:19:57 Santa Claus, like each private family, they get to decide according to their conscience
01:20:02 and what they're going to do and yeah pastors probably shouldn't preach a sermon on santa they
01:20:06 should preach the scripture but in the public sphere like we're going to have some santa stuff
01:20:09 but we're also going to have christ and we're going to have santa bowing down to king jesus
01:20:14 we're going to reenact saint nick punching uh yeah and it'll be santa punching aries you know
01:20:18 like you can correct the behavior you don't want i was in the library it was maybe about a month or
01:20:22 two ago at this point i had a nasty shirt on my kids were there and i told him he couldn't come
01:20:26 around there like you can't be in the kids section yeah and he went and changed it i stood up to him
01:20:31 said he's like well that's just your opinion i said no it's not that is that objectively disgusting
01:20:35 shirt don't come around my kids you can start correcting people don't play that language don't
01:20:40 or don't play that music rap beautiful use that language don't wear that shirt you're not allowed
01:20:44 to do it who says me me and every other parent agrees with me like we have young children we go
01:20:50 out to eat and if there's a transgender server who's like obvious in their attire and and turns
01:20:55 out that they're going to serve our table and they come up to the table our family gets up and we 0.60
01:20:59 we leave two men holding hands hey don't do that not around my children yep yep all it takes is
01:21:05 the political will and um there are millions and millions and millions of christians in our nation
01:21:12 and they just need to be encouraged that you can you can just do things you can actually have a
01:21:18 christian nation you're allowed to have a country you're allowed to have a christian nation that is
01:21:22 our nation's heritage our nation's heritage is not just um it's not atheism it's not that's like
01:21:30 there were some deists in there there were some deists in there although i read an interesting
01:21:34 statistic last night that argued hard that it was maybe three or four it was five percent of them
01:21:42 and they went through the official registries of what church now some of them maybe went to church
01:21:47 and didn't share the conviction, but they were members, all but three of them, of established
01:21:52 local churches.
01:21:53 Right.
01:21:54 And that's just, even that, like, so one, it was minimal.
01:21:57 And even that, that's at the time of the founding.
01:22:01 You know, this is like late 1700s.
01:22:03 That's not even to begin to speak of, like, people forget that American history stretches
01:22:07 back further than just, you know, 1776.
01:22:09 Yeah, yeah, yeah, 100%.
01:22:10 So you get to the Covenanters, you know what I mean?
01:22:12 And you get to the pilgrims and the Puritans and you get into like the 1600s, you know, and earlier 1700s and the colonies, 13 colonies.
01:22:22 And there's no debate to be had. 0.66
01:22:25 It's distinctly Christian, unapologetically Christian.
01:22:29 And for the most part, other than I think, what was it, Rhode Island or something that was Catholic, other than Protestant.
01:22:34 Maryland.
01:22:35 Or Maryland. 0.81
01:22:36 It's distinctly Protestant.
01:22:37 And so, yes, you can have a Christian nation in America.
01:22:41 that is that is its foundation it's its heritage it's its history and the people the american
01:22:48 people the christians in america absolutely um have the ability the potential uh to get that
01:22:55 back it just requires the political will and people just saying that's it we've had enough
01:23:00 to confront people a little bit of will a little bit of spine and a little bit of testosterone
01:23:03 like the world doesn't end when you do that it's a little bit awkward
01:23:06 right and then life goes on right yep okay super chats here we go all right jeremy kearns great
01:23:14 brother looking forward to seeing him at the conference 999 thanks jeremy good afternoon
01:23:19 gentlemen i find some baptists impulse to cast doubt on the roman catholic church and cultural
01:23:23 christianity goes against the classical reformers argument that the lord has preserved his church
01:23:29 yes yeah yeah i agree like we are we are not that kind of baptist uh we
01:23:37 we actually think that there were christians before um martin luther
01:23:41 yep um the bar is someone asked me roman catholic like do you think i'm saying
01:23:46 i don't obviously know their heart but i said have you repented of sin and placed faith in jesus
01:23:50 like that is what's preached by the apostles in the epistles right repent of sin trust in jesus
01:23:56 right obviously we want to expand what that trust means what jesus who jesus actually is well he's
01:24:00 the you know he's the creative being like well hang on we got a problem there yeah but like that bar
01:24:05 that is the bar you and i really speaking you're right you and i have had this conversation several
01:24:11 times and it's a distinction that most people don't notice but when you see it it's it's you
01:24:15 can't unsee it and it's vitally important but there's a distinction in being saved by faith
01:24:20 alone versus being saved by faith and understanding and believing that we're saved by faith alone
01:24:25 right saved by faith in faith alone right are we saved by faith alone or are we saved by
01:24:31 affirming the doctrine of faith alone right like that actually is different like there are plenty
01:24:36 of of people well no child would be saved exactly they don't because they don't understand they can't
01:24:41 articulate you know the doctrine of sola fide and like um but but there are there are children
01:24:47 and even before you know the reformation like plenty of people who had faith saving faith and
01:24:54 they were saved by that faith alone without ever knowing of the doctrine of sola fide and you know
01:25:00 salvation by faith alone and so like that's that's what like when we get into soteriology it
01:25:06 absolutely matters we're not saying it doesn't matter and we're not saying that the bible doesn't
01:25:09 speak to it the bible does speak to how we're not just that we need to be saved but how we're saved
01:25:16 the bible absolutely addresses these things ephesians 2 um you know that we're saved by
01:25:20 grace alone through faith. And this is the gift of God. It is not your own doing. So, that no man
01:25:26 can boast. This is God's doing. And so, the Bible speaks to these things and we hold as Protestants
01:25:33 these doctrines for a reason. However, understanding being able to articulate the five
01:25:42 solas is not, it's ironic actually. It actually goes against the five solas if you hold adherence
01:25:49 and understanding of the five solas as a prerequisite for salvation right that actually
01:25:54 goes against because there's not a sixth sola that says and the sixth sola is being able to
01:25:59 affirm understand and articulate the previous five solas that's no it's it's faith alone trust faith
01:26:07 in faith alone is what saves when it's placed in christ right it's not uh like faith alone
01:26:13 it's just it's not other things attached to it it's faith it's the only thing that counts
01:26:18 towards christ and people wrongly in time there is a level of idolatry that we would see in the
01:26:22 roman catholic church they add some things on top of it sure but those things don't i would say they
01:26:28 don't necessarily invalidate the faith because it's faith not even the strength of the faith
01:26:31 but the object of the faith that's right so it's that faith alone that in christ that actually
01:26:35 saves and in his kindness in many ways in his kindness he counts that faith even when it's
01:26:40 marred with and i added this on top of it and i went to mass every monday tuesday and wednesday
01:26:44 and I did the Hail Mary. Those things can be added on top and someone still, not in every case,
01:26:49 but they can still be saved because the object of their faith at the core of it is Christ. It may be
01:26:54 a weak faith, a faltering faith, a faith, Lord, I believe, help my unbelief. But that faith placed
01:27:00 in the right object, jumping out with a parachute, that actually works. You don't have to know
01:27:04 everything about it. A divided faith, I believe, help my unbelief, and certainly a small faith.
01:27:09 it's not. Jesus doesn't say the faith of a mountain. A mountain-sized faith could move
01:27:14 a mustard seed, but it's a mustard seed can move a mountain. So, small faith, divided faith,
01:27:21 weak faith, faltering faith. But the question is simply, is it true faith? And what makes the
01:27:28 faith true is its object. Is it Christ crucified? Do you believe that Jesus is the only begotten
01:27:34 son of God? Do you believe that he lived a sinless life? Do you believe that he died as a substitute,
01:27:41 that he died in your place, the wages of sin is death, and he took your sin and took your wage
01:27:48 for sin, the punishment, the just punishment, the wrath of God in his death on the cross? Do you
01:27:52 believe that he bodily rose from the dead? Do you believe that he ascended to the right hand of the
01:27:56 God, the Father Almighty? Do you believe that he's going to return to judge both the living and the
01:28:01 debt? Do you believe these things? And are you trusting in Jesus? And do you agree in what he
01:28:09 calls sin? And are you seeking, to the best of your ability, by God's grace and the empowerment
01:28:15 of the Holy Spirit to repent of your sin and to turn to Christ, knowing that you are a sinner and
01:28:20 that you continue in this life to sin, but you're seeking to put your sin to death? Do you believe
01:28:25 these things? So that doesn't mean every Catholic is saved. Certainly not. Every Protestant is not
01:28:30 saved there are plenty of professors only who are not uh truly saved but like when we look you know
01:28:37 all this back to jeremy kern's super chat but when we look at church history we don't believe
01:28:43 that it begins in the 1500s um we believe that god has preserved throughout all of time he's
01:28:49 preserved faithful remnant in every and and even with you know when you look at catholicism
01:28:56 There are ages where there were extreme excesses, and then there were times where there was less excesses.
01:29:03 There were good times and there were bad times.
01:29:05 The time of the Protestant Reformation was a particularly bad time. 0.57
01:29:08 And it's not the only bad time.
01:29:10 There were also some other bad times.
01:29:13 But there were plenty of moments, centuries, before the 1500s, where there were lots of faithful Christians who loved the Lord.
01:29:24 Yep.
01:29:24 All right.
01:29:25 Go ahead, Nathan.
01:29:26 Scroll up there, Nathan.
01:29:28 So we have Rubicon, 499.
01:29:30 Thanks very much, Rubicon. 0.61
01:29:32 As a bat, my independent fundamental Baptist disfee bros drive me nuts. 0.87
01:29:37 They are anti-knowledge and church history. 0.99
01:29:40 Ruckman and his crowd.
01:29:42 Why is this and how to fix it?
01:29:44 Love the show.
01:29:47 Anti-church history?
01:29:48 Yeah.
01:29:49 You have to be to be an independent fundamental Baptist. 0.92
01:29:51 Well, that's it.
01:29:52 And he wants to know how to fix that.
01:29:53 I don't know how to fix that.
01:29:56 I don't think you can.
01:29:57 I think you literally have to stop being independent fundamental Baptist.
01:30:01 There is a reason why IFB is particularly known as despising church history.
01:30:08 In many ways, obviously they would despise Mormonism, Jehovah's Witness, and those kinds of things.
01:30:13 But in many ways, the great irony is that they share so much in common.
01:30:17 that they legitimately believe that basically everybody was faithless
01:30:24 until all of a sudden, in a very recent history,
01:30:29 that we finally went back to the Bible.
01:30:32 And we're the only ones who have.
01:30:36 So, yeah, I don't...
01:30:37 No assumptions. No high priorities.
01:30:39 We got to...
01:30:41 Right. And that's what I always...
01:30:43 That was one of the winning arguments for myself, even personally.
01:30:47 and wanting to become confessional and creedal was realizing, you know,
01:30:53 like somebody helped me understand.
01:30:54 They said, Joel, everyone, again, it's the old adage, it's not whether but which,
01:30:59 everyone's confessional.
01:31:00 It's either historic confession that's tried and true and written by better men than you,
01:31:04 or it's your own confession that you're making up as you go along that's in your head.
01:31:10 And that's what I realized is because that's how the independent fundamental Baptist wants to,
01:31:15 that's how they want to frame the debates
01:31:17 and it's a false dichotomy
01:31:19 they want to say, you know, on one hand
01:31:20 we have the Westminster divines
01:31:22 and on the other hand
01:31:24 we have the pure unadulterated word of God
01:31:26 in the King James Version
01:31:29 words of man versus the words of God
01:31:30 contained for us in the King James Version
01:31:33 and you know, if it was good enough
01:31:35 for King James, it's good enough for me
01:31:36 and that's not the debate
01:31:38 nobody is arguing
01:31:39 the Westminster Confession of the 1689
01:31:42 over and against the Bible
01:31:44 the question and here's what they're saying it's just the pure bible no it's not right every time
01:31:51 an independent fundamental baptist steps into the pulpit and begins to preach he's unless he's
01:31:56 simply opening up the bible and reading word for word the book of hebrews or the book of galatians
01:32:01 the book of ephesians and then without any interjection any commentary any addition and then
01:32:08 and then sitting down unless he's doing that and calling that the sermon then what he's doing is
01:32:13 he's interpreting everyone interprets it's so it's not on on in on one side we have the bible
01:32:20 and on the other side we have man's interpretation it's always man's interpretation the only question
01:32:25 is which man not whether but which so so that it's either um athanasius or fred and george and
01:32:36 bubba in alabama do they do they know greek and latin who who have why would you bother
01:32:44 like yeah so that's right i mean but that's like at the end of the day like literally like that you
01:32:48 have to understand that like when the independent fundamental baptist uh is saying it's the word of
01:32:52 god versus you know the doctrines of men no um it's the word of god interpreted by you versus
01:33:00 the word of god interpreted by people who were intelligent oh that's the difference so no you
01:33:06 don't fix independent fundamental baptist you leave independent fundamental baptist all right
01:33:11 i'm gonna go rapid fire since i think a lot of these are just thanks jeremy kearns 499 blessed
01:33:15 is the nation whose god is the lord and people whom he hath chosen for his own inheritance psalm
01:33:20 33 12 king james version love it john inman great brother 20 super chat thank you john love you
01:33:27 gents we love you too john hopefully we'll see it's guys night tonight so yeah we'll see him
01:33:32 there john yeah jeff halfley uh 499 since world war ii the baptists fought the hardest to stop
01:33:37 liquor and protect segregation they almost privatized public schools to prevent the latter
01:33:42 yep that's true that the baptists they know how to potluck and they know how to mobilize
01:33:47 i they do i don't know what happened where we lost they know how to stop alcohol and stop 0.69
01:33:52 right they went to uh uh to keep segregation right that's what they were for yeah yeah yeah
01:33:57 yeah uh five dollars from rob another great brother met him here great stream guys thanks
01:34:01 thank you rob and then 4.99 jeff halfley mega red pill considering that 90 of the population
01:34:08 believes things on the basis of what they think is popular and will do them good in real life
01:34:12 i don't know what the second half of it is but basically um people are easily swayed yeah yeah
01:34:18 it was uh it was funny it was uh josiah lip and kai so like really honestly like most people it
01:34:23 could be a democrat party sign or swastika in their front yard they wouldn't really care either
01:34:27 way like people really are that influenceable so malleable you just have to win that's that's all
01:34:33 it takes you just have to win and it does not take a majority to win it takes um it takes a few
01:34:39 powerful influential strategic organized individuals um to just to win a popularity
01:34:48 contest and then all the npcs which is 90 95 percent of the population they'll just fall in
01:34:54 line like i mean you know we've said it before but i mean the the the turnaround how quick it
01:35:00 was the turnaround from she's so brat to doing the trump dance and i'm not talking about like
01:35:07 with conservatives i'm talking like like teenage girls right in public high school what like like 0.50
01:35:15 i i remember i witnessed it i i saw you know like like yeah i'm uh kamala like trump is uh
01:35:23 trump is uh uh colluding with putin you know and like the the russian collusion you know back from
01:35:30 2016 all like i know like i know those people they believed it they were passionate but here's
01:35:37 the deal like they didn't have any real conviction they didn't have real any real information and the
01:35:42 moment that all of a sudden trump won like all of a sudden people were embarrassed people are
01:35:48 still embarrassed that they voted for kamala or that they said anything positive about her right
01:35:54 like he won so scrub the tweets yeah exactly so then just it's just you change the chip in the
01:35:59 back of the npc's head that's what most people are they're non-player characters they're robots
01:36:05 And all you have to do, you don't have to, right?
01:36:07 Like when you're arguing with people, you have to remember, you're arguing with the
01:36:10 television.
01:36:11 Like it's not a real person.
01:36:14 They are not independent, self-thinking people.
01:36:17 That doesn't mean they're not made in the image of God.
01:36:19 That doesn't mean we don't love them.
01:36:20 That doesn't mean they don't have dignity, that we don't treat them with respect.
01:36:22 But you just have to realize, like if you think that through facts and logic and long
01:36:29 conversations that you have to actually convince and persuade 51 of the population in order to
01:36:36 enact change then you don't understand politics you don't you just said they'll all change on a
01:36:42 dime the moment that you win and you do not need the majority to win never have jeff followed up
01:36:48 that first half another super chat we have to take control of the institutions of influence
01:36:52 otherwise tens of millions of people will go to hell they follow the strong and popular right
01:36:56 That's right on.
01:36:58 And that's why Christian culture matters.
01:37:00 Well, Christian culture, there's a bunch of people who have false assurance and think they're saved and they're not.
01:37:05 Christian culture lends towards, you know, false conversions.
01:37:10 But what does secular humanistic culture lend towards?
01:37:14 What does Islamic culture lend towards?
01:37:16 What does Jewish culture lend towards? 0.56
01:37:18 Well, what it lends towards, and those is like, well, in those contexts, you know, the few, the proud, the genuine, the authentic Christians, you know,
01:37:25 and their faith is purified you know like gold and like yeah that's true uh-huh there's um in
01:37:31 those cultures there are some people who are bold as lions with genuine faith that go to heaven
01:37:36 and 95 of the population goes to hell in christian culture yes there are some false conversions and
01:37:45 there is some false assurance um but the vast majority of people and this gets back to like
01:37:52 what is salvation what does it take to be saved faith of a mustard seed the in in christian
01:37:58 cultures um i like i i am of the persuasion and i got so much flack for this you know we did that
01:38:04 clip where it's like more people will be in heaven than hell and people lost their minds they're like
01:38:07 tell me you've never read the bible without telling me like you're a heretic and then i just
01:38:11 just retweeted them and put a quote from spurge right and then of course what they did was they're 0.81
01:38:16 like well you know like i guess i was wrong this time but you're still a wolf and i'll get you next 0.53
01:38:20 time yeah i'll get you the least genuine apologies i've you know you know like you're still a wolf 0.96
01:38:25 and you're going to hell and we hate you but also yes yeah i guess you're correct um so but the but 0.82
01:38:31 the point is like what what spurgeon spurgeon believed that there were time periods uh where 0.98
01:38:36 it was gin you know like the majority of people were christian right the majority like the jeff
01:38:44 half lee is absolutely correct the majority of people follow the what's popular they follow
01:38:51 whoever's in in leadership and even believe what they're told to believe that's right
01:38:57 yes better 20 of your populace is christian truly regenerate and 80 profess it then 20
01:39:03 is regenerate and that's the only 20 professing it same amount of people heaven and hell
01:39:07 but that 80 percent professing going to make for a much better ordered society orienting people
01:39:14 towards in the future right heavenly and earthly good and what i want to say is i i personally i
01:39:21 would like i want to say it's even better than that i reject that premise i don't believe in
01:39:25 the 1950s i just don't believe i don't believe uh that the vast majority of people were professing
01:39:31 only and that and that they're all in hell i actually don't believe it i actually believe
01:39:35 that the average person
01:39:36 was a born-again Christian.
01:39:39 And they may have not had
01:39:40 the most robust doctrine.
01:39:42 They may have had 0.88
01:39:42 some legalistic, silly things
01:39:45 that we'd be like, 0.71
01:39:46 that's not in Scripture.
01:39:47 Where do you get that?
01:39:48 They may, but a childlike faith,
01:39:51 like you sit them down,
01:39:53 tie them to a chair
01:39:54 and give them truth serum.
01:39:56 And they genuinely would say,
01:39:57 even though a lot of it 0.99
01:39:58 is just cultural morays, 0.99
01:40:00 but they genuinely would say, 0.98
01:40:02 yes, I actually believe
01:40:04 that Jesus is the Son of God.
01:40:05 I'm trusting in him that he died on the cross for my sin.
01:40:09 I believe that. 0.86
01:40:10 I believe that when Christianity wins the day, 1.00
01:40:13 in moments of Christendom, in the Dark Ages, 0.99
01:40:15 he had all these people who were uneducated,
01:40:18 most of them couldn't read,
01:40:20 they didn't know the ins and outs of Christian doctrine,
01:40:23 but they knew the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit,
01:40:28 because those battles were fought by the minority once upon a time,
01:40:32 and they won.
01:40:32 And then it became dominant.
01:40:34 And then all these post-generations were able to take those precious truths for granted.
01:40:41 They believed the triune God, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
01:40:46 Jesus is the Son of God.
01:40:47 He was born of the Virgin Mary.
01:40:49 He lived a sinless life.
01:40:50 He died on the cross for my sin.
01:40:51 He bodily rose from the dead.
01:40:53 He ascended to the right hand of God the Father.
01:40:56 And I'm trusting in Him and repenting of my sin.
01:40:59 And those people were Christian. 1.00
01:41:03 and to live in a world like that again 0.97
01:41:06 where there's some
01:41:08 bad theology, there's
01:41:10 a bunch of Catholics, there's a bunch of 1.00
01:41:12 independent fundamental Baptists 1.00
01:41:14 who's to say what's worse 0.72
01:41:15 there's crazy
01:41:18 views on all sides that we
01:41:20 would disagree with but there's a
01:41:22 universal sense of
01:41:24 Christ is King
01:41:25 Jesus is Lord
01:41:27 and yeah that is
01:41:30 a much better society temporally
01:41:32 And it also is far more conducive to heavenly good eternally.
01:41:37 Genuine conversion.
01:41:38 Yep.
01:41:39 Tyler, thanks very much.
01:41:41 499.
01:41:41 Looking forward to reading your book.
01:41:42 Thanks very much, Tyler.
01:41:44 We will look forward to seeing you too at the conference next week.
01:41:47 And Jeff puts a cap on his discussion.
01:41:49 499 again from Jeff.
01:41:51 Kids believe because of the influence of their parents.
01:41:53 Nations believe because of the influence of the leaders.
01:41:55 The only thing I would add to that is ultimately everyone believes because the Holy Spirit moves in their heart.
01:42:00 It just so happens to be that he often moves in the heart of children through the teaching and training of their parents and in a nation through the influence of the leaders.
01:42:10 Right.
01:42:11 We're not denying the way that God saves.
01:42:12 He saves sovereignly as a work of the Spirit.
01:42:14 But the Spirit sovereignly moves through providence and human agency.
01:42:20 It's like, well, if it's just the Spirit, then why even evangelize at that point?
01:42:25 But we would all say, well, yeah, but the Spirit is pleased to work with the gospel being proclaimed.
01:42:29 So the same way that the Spirit uses prayer, the Spirit uses evangelism, well, the Spirit also uses governments and cultures that are Christian.
01:42:40 Because, yes, it is. 0.86
01:42:42 You're talking about first and second causes.
01:42:45 They're not pitted against each other.
01:42:46 There's no contradiction.
01:42:47 So in the ultimate sense, the Spirit.
01:42:50 But in the temporal human agency, human sense, people, culture, parents, Christian governments, school, was it a Christian school or not?
01:43:05 And of course that's true, because if it's just a crapshoot, spirit, you know, like just whatever, you know, he just randomly does things, you know, and it's like, yes, he does sovereignly do things, but he does it through human means. 0.76
01:43:19 And if you don't acknowledge that at all, then what benefit is there in being Western rather than being born in Iran? 0.96
01:43:33 So I guess there's literally no tangible or eternal benefits whatsoever in being born in a Christian country versus a Muslim country. 0.99
01:43:43 But we all know that there are. 1.00
01:43:45 Of course there are.
01:43:45 I want to acknowledge this question.
01:43:47 i don't i'll say i'm not an expert and so i'll not answer but do acknowledge the question what
01:43:52 do you know about the catholic literature saying that they changed the sabbath to sunday
01:43:56 constantine made it happen i know that was one of the topics debated early on it was the date
01:44:00 of easter as well as the transition from saturday to sunday but because i'm not well read enough on
01:44:06 it i don't have anything to offer but at some point we could definitely talk about the sabbath
01:44:10 i do know that in the new testament already they were meeting on the lord's day yep which was the
01:44:15 first day of the week so that we yeah i i can't speak to the same as west i can't speak to
01:44:19 constantine and what he did and how much the catholic literature but we do know that in the
01:44:24 first century church there was already the pattern of meeting on the lord's day right and we see that
01:44:30 even you know in scripture you know like paul saying like when you gather together on the first
01:44:34 day of the week taking a collection you know for the saints and so like we we know that that like
01:44:38 they were daily breaking bread and that's not a reference to the lord's supper communion but
01:44:42 but community and potlucks and just being together relationally.
01:44:47 So they were daily getting together to submit themselves,
01:44:50 breaking bread, sharing a meal, the apostles' teaching, and prayer.
01:44:53 So we know that. The early church was doing that daily.
01:44:56 But then we also know that there was something particular
01:44:59 that was happening on the first day of the week.
01:45:00 There was probably a larger gathering,
01:45:02 and that's why the apostle Paul says that that would be
01:45:05 the most conducive context for taking this offering.
01:45:08 And then, of course, we also know that Jesus, the resurrected Lord,
01:45:11 appeared to his disciples on the first day of the week.
01:45:15 So he resurrected on the first day of the week,
01:45:16 and then a week later appeared to them again on Sunday,
01:45:20 the first day of the week.
01:45:21 So that's why we call it the Lord's Day,
01:45:22 the day that the Lord rose from the dead.
01:45:24 And from that pattern of twice, not just once, but twice,
01:45:27 the Lord being resurrected and appearing to the apostles
01:45:29 on the Lord's Day, first day of the week,
01:45:31 and then doing it a week later on the first day of the week,
01:45:33 not on the Jewish Sabbath, but on the first day of the week.
01:45:36 And then Paul, still already in his lifetime,
01:45:39 And when Peter's still alive, you know, some of the many of the apostles still alive is already referencing that, yes, there's a daily congregating of believers that seems smaller and more organic.
01:45:50 But there's a more official, formal congregating of believers that happens on the first day of the week.
01:45:55 And that's where it makes sense to take a collection of alms for other Christians that are suffering and are poor and in need. 0.65
01:46:03 This pattern was already well underway.
01:46:06 But what hadn't happened yet was the temple hadn't yet been destroyed. 0.86
01:46:11 And so Christians were still, many of them, though, to be fair, had been progressively one by one, would get banned and kicked out of the synagogues and wouldn't be able to. 0.81
01:46:23 But for those who still could and hadn't been kicked out yet, they would be meeting on the first day of the week as Christians.
01:46:28 but they would also be going to the synagogue on the last day of the week um the jewish sabbath
01:46:34 on saturday so that they could um evangelize and and talk to you know to you know their kinsmen
01:46:42 according to the flesh jews and tell them about the gospel and reason from the scriptures as paul
01:46:47 did um he he did that you know and would do that in any city that he was in any jewish city he was
01:46:52 in and as long as they would have him until they would kick him out so um i i don't view it as like
01:46:57 for me from what i've read definitely theologically and in terms of historically i'd have to study
01:47:02 more but i don't see it um from the study that i have done as like this clear transition of it was
01:47:07 saturday and now it's sunday it but it was actually um that in the first century church with the
01:47:14 apostles it wasn't that sunday replaced saturday it was uh that that sunday came alongside saturday
01:47:20 So you still had the Sabbath until 80-70 and the final completion of that old covenant
01:47:27 was wrapped up and done away.
01:47:28 So you had like this interim period of 40 years from the resurrection of Christ and
01:47:32 his appearance to the apostles to the full completion and doing away with the old covenant
01:47:39 given to Israel in 80-70.
01:47:41 So you had a whole generation, 40 years of this overlap, and it was both days.
01:47:45 So it wasn't that Sunday just replaced Saturday.
01:47:47 is Sunday for the Christians came alongside in addition to Saturday. And then Saturday was done 0.68
01:47:54 away with by force, by virtue of there's no more temple and we're all dispersed. And a bunch of us
01:48:01 are, you know, a bunch of Jews are now dead, you know, as Titus has destroyed Jerusalem and the
01:48:05 temple's gone. And that just became the pattern. So, all right. Well, thank you guys for tuning 0.94
01:48:11 in. And we hope to see you guys at the conference this next week. Very much looking forward to it.
01:48:17 April 3rd, 4th, and 5th. And make sure, if you're not able to make it, make sure that you're able
01:48:21 to catch the live stream by going to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries,
01:48:26 patreon.com forward slash right response ministries, and you got to sign up for the gold
01:48:31 tier. Sign up for the gold tier and you'll be able to live stream the conference, seven main
01:48:35 sessions, three panels, all happening next week. And we look forward to seeing you soon.
01:48:47 Thank you.