The NXR Podcast - November 21, 2024


THE LIVESTREAM - What Is A Nation?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE INTERVIEW - Does Theonomy Have A Mechanism For Mitigating Immigration? with David Reece THE SERMON - Dont Be Hasty And Make A Foolish Vow

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 15 minutes

Words per minute

181.81

Word count

24,616

Sentence count

748

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

53

sentences flagged

Hate speech

140

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In Reagan's final speech as president, he famously said, "Anyone can come from any corner of the earth and become an American. You don't have to be born in one country, you can live in any country, but there's only one country where you can be a citizen. And that's America."

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it.
00:00:04 It's annoying.
00:00:05 Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm so that
00:00:12 our podcast shows up on more people's news feeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries
00:00:20 aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 You're doing a great job.
00:00:28 We've got several hundred reviews so far, but we'd like to reach a thousand reviews by the end of this year, the year of our Lord, 2024.
00:00:36 If you haven't left a review yet, take a moment and help us achieve our goal.
00:00:44 Since the Reagan era, even so-called conservatives have euphorically championed the idea that anyone, absolutely anyone, can become American.
00:00:55 In practice, this means that America amounts to little more than a set of civic convictions and ethical principles that almost anyone can agree to.
00:01:07 This view of a nation is almost completely absent to scripture, world history, and the founding fathers.
00:01:15 Nations are composed of a distinct people, occupying a distinct place.
00:01:20 and assimilation is not merely a matter of intellectual assent and enjoying apple pie.
00:01:28 Tune in now as we discuss what is a nation.
00:01:40 Last speech that I will give as president, I think it's fitting to leave one final thought,
00:01:46 an observation about a country which I love.
00:01:49 It was stated best in a letter I received not long ago.
00:01:53 A man wrote me and said,
00:01:55 You can go to live in France, but you cannot become a Frenchman.
00:01:59 You can go to live in Germany or Turkey or Japan, 0.67
00:02:02 but you cannot become a German, a Turk, or Japanese.
00:02:05 But anyone from any corner of the earth
00:02:10 can come to live in America and become an American.
00:02:14 one is the one that i share which is that there's a shared set of civic ideals that brought together
00:02:23 a divided polyglot group of people 250 years ago enshrined in the declaration of independence
00:02:28 and operationalized in the u.s constitution and that's what unites america and your commitment
00:02:32 to those ideals is what defines whether or not you're an american i think there are two other
00:02:36 competing visions there's more of a blood and soil conception of american identity which is
00:02:41 that you vest into how American you are
00:02:43 based on how many generations your family
00:02:45 and your lineage has been attached
00:02:46 to the soil of this nation.
00:02:48 Yeah, how many people are in your Kentucky cemetery plot,
00:02:50 for instance?
00:02:51 For example, you know, and the blood,
00:02:53 you are inextricably linked to this land.
00:02:55 On this view, you'll have the view, you know,
00:02:58 that people won't be willing to fight for abstractions
00:03:00 or abstract ideals, but they will fight for their homeland.
00:03:04 I disagree with that.
00:03:05 This is J.D. Vance's convention speech.
00:03:06 Well, I think it's representative
00:03:08 of a broader worldview in some segments
00:03:10 of the NatCon world. And in my NatCon speech, I rejected that view because I actually think
00:03:15 the American Revolution was fought for a set of abstract ideals, actually.
00:03:21 All right. Welcome. Here we are. So you got to see, well, I was going to say a rare Reagan-L,
00:03:28 but sadly, the more I learn about Reagan, I feel like it's fair to say a common Reagan-L.
00:03:34 He was aspirational, but I think idealistic.
00:03:36 Yeah. And we were just saying during the clip, we were whispering back and forth to each
00:03:40 other. And none of the three of us think that Reagan was nefarious in that. I don't think that
00:03:47 he was malicious, that he actually intentionally behind the scenes was like, I'm going to ruin
00:03:51 the country. I don't think they realized, Michael, you said, I don't think they realized that what
00:03:58 America was and what they had that was precious was actively in the process of being lost. And
00:04:04 I don't think he realized how statements like that were actually sealing the future destruction
00:04:09 and doom of the country so for him to say that you know that uh that america i mean he essentially
00:04:15 says reagan says um that america is the only nation so every other nation on the planet and
00:04:22 he's not just talking about somalia or uganda or or japan he's talking about western european
00:04:29 nations you know that um you can go to france and you can become a legal citizen but it doesn't make
00:04:34 you a frenchman you know or same thing with germany or you know you you can't be a brit
00:04:39 by simply moving there as an immigrant and becoming you know a legal citizen but there's
00:04:44 one country in the whole world uh where anybody can come from he says any corner of the earth
00:04:50 anywhere anyone can come at any time from anywhere and um simply by standing on the magical soil
00:04:59 and repeating the magical incantation
00:05:01 and watching the Super Bowl and eating apple pie,
00:05:05 you don't live in America
00:05:07 and you're not just a legal American citizen.
00:05:10 You are an American.
00:05:13 You can't do that in Great Britain.
00:05:14 But he said something interesting there. 0.97
00:05:15 You can't do that in Germany.
00:05:16 You can't do that in France.
00:05:18 Reagan is wrong and we're going to talk about that.
00:05:20 Go ahead.
00:05:21 He said they can become an American
00:05:23 and I still think this is the blindness of that generation.
00:05:27 When they read their history,
00:05:29 They saw people come and they saw people assimilate into America, like actually become, you know, over time marrying and adopting the culture and to give it a charitable read.
00:05:39 I think he would say, yeah, like America is such a society.
00:05:42 Now, I would still disagree with him.
00:05:43 But that word become an America, not just show up and automatically be an American, I think is important.
00:05:49 That's helpful.
00:05:50 And I would just want to go even further than that and say that you can come and that your grandchildren can be an American.
00:05:56 and we would have a biblical precedent to make a statement like that it's not just an unhinged you
00:06:02 know firing from the hip it wasn't until the third generation that someone who had immigrated
00:06:07 into israel it wasn't until the third generation that they were fully considered to be a part of
00:06:14 israel and to be fully assimilated and have full rights as a citizen of israel especially as it
00:06:21 pertained to worship in the temple and those kinds of things and so we've talked about that before
00:06:25 and advocated with a general equity of that passage, within a general equity theonomic,
00:06:31 and also we think it makes sense with natural law. So you can get there, I think, through
00:06:35 natural revelation or special revelation, which are not at odds against each other.
00:06:40 Two books that God has written, both are God's Word, Him speaking to us. And so by good and
00:06:47 necessary reason and prudence, and also by the Word of God, I think that the general equity
00:06:53 applied to today's standard would i would advocate for um that if somebody immigrates number one 0.71
00:06:58 we got to get rid of all illegal immigration number two uh we need to radically radically
00:07:04 shrink even legal immigration because uh it's been insane uh we we have you know in the last 0.92
00:07:10 50 60 years almost 100 million people who have come into the nations way too much so you need 1.00
00:07:16 to put a cap um even with legal immigration for the next 50 years is what i would advocate for
00:07:22 and then have maybe some immigration those who really want to be americans and then with that
00:07:28 the general equity applied is i would advocate for uh that they can attain some form of citizenship
00:07:33 but it will not be until the third generation their grandchildren um that they actually are
00:07:39 able to vote in federal elections um and have full rights uh as americans so all that being said
00:07:45 reagan is right in one sense that i do believe but that's not unique to america i think that
00:07:51 that's the case for every nation and it has happened over that's how nations have been formed
00:07:55 to begin with every nation involves some kind of migration of people and and then in in not every
00:08:02 case but in many cases um a further migration of other people that eventually intermingled
00:08:09 intermarried mixed and became one people but none of that happens in 15 minutes all those things
00:08:15 happen over centuries and to pretend that you could just export the third world and at the
00:08:21 moment that you know 500 000 uh haitians touch american magical soil that they'll become 0.93
00:08:28 americans and stop eating people's pets that is naive right that's not the way the world works 0.86
00:08:35 we have this problem too because so many people want to come to america yeah we we the the people
00:08:40 that founded it were supremely blessed by god and we created something so harmonious so safe so
00:08:46 profitable a place where truly i mean we talk about the american dream right you could work
00:08:50 hard and be blessed and be safe and all these things but now we have the problem that prosperity
00:08:54 brings all the people that want a piece of the pie so it's really unique because we have this nation
00:09:00 and with all the problems that it has and things we're dealing with and everybody else wants to
00:09:05 be in it too right i would bet 80 of india and we would understand why yeah frankly right like i can't
00:09:11 blame them none of that's wrong we just have to say no exactly yeah darryl cooper said you want
00:09:16 to be here it makes total sense love you guys we don't wish any harm on you also no yeah he said
00:09:21 really well like there's tons of sob stories of people escaping wars and if you have those people
00:09:26 coming to you and you don't have a heart for them and say oh i really feel for your circumstance
00:09:30 like you wouldn't be human but that line is infinitely long all of them have a story all of
00:09:35 them have a reason right many of them would be good workers at what point there's 1.3 billion
00:09:39 people in india do we owe all of them have a sob story place in america we can't there would be no
00:09:45 america left right real quick so let's talk about vivek now so that's reagan um with sorry real
00:09:51 quick please like and subscribe thanks make a comment for the algorithm appreciate it helps a
00:09:56 lot right now yeah guys uh uh those of you who are watching live uh nathan can you give us a
00:10:01 running count so we can see how many on youtube and if possible if you could just give us an
00:10:06 update from time to time on twitter so right now we're streaming live if you're joining us both
00:10:10 on x and on youtube okay all right so it didn't it didn't go live on um on x uh so we'll repost
00:10:20 it as soon as we're done on x so we'll be behind there but those of you who are watching live
00:10:24 on youtube go ahead and give us a thumbs up like the video please uh that helps the algorithm
00:10:29 feel free to comment that helps the algorithm as well and then subscribe to our youtube channel
00:10:35 if you can and follow us on x also because um it's not just uh you know random tweets throughout
00:10:41 the day but all of our videos uh post to x as well so there's nothing on youtube um there's
00:10:46 nothing on x that you'll be missing uh from youtube you'll get all of it so real quick with
00:10:51 vivek what i was going to say is um so he i appreciate it in the sense that um i don't feel
00:10:58 like he straw manned uh jd vance because he's that's who he's referencing you know jd vance
00:11:03 had said uh right before that interview uh in one of his speeches during the campaign
00:11:08 that people are willing to to die uh to defend a home they're not willing to die to defend an
00:11:15 economic zone or a set of propositions but they are willing to die for a home in a home
00:11:21 i would argue michael west we would all argue it's more than this but it can't here's the point
00:11:26 it cannot be anything less than this a home um is lineage and land um in other words particular
00:11:35 people and particular place and so michael is in the process of publishing a book right now we'll
00:11:40 let you guys know when it's uh available to the public um but he's over the course of this past
00:11:45 year has been writing a book and uh stephen wolf is reading it and just messaged me today and he's
00:11:50 going to do a blurb for it i think john harris is going to do uh an endorsement so different guys
00:11:55 We're getting it out there, and Michael's going to be doing the final editing and things
00:11:59 like that.
00:12:00 But the whole thing is on the biblical case for nations, for Christian nations, and basically
00:12:06 trying to answer the question that we're delving into today, what is a nation?
00:12:11 What is a nation?
00:12:12 And so you came up with five things, and we can maybe add a six.
00:12:15 Someone from the chat, if you're listening, messaged in and gave me the sixth L.
00:12:19 And it was amazing.
00:12:20 Yeah.
00:12:20 Liturgy.
00:12:21 Yep, so Michael says, you know, defining a nation in a biblical sense would be land, lineage, but in addition to that, so it can't be less than that, land and lineage, that's soil and blood, is what Vivek is saying.
00:12:36 We prefer to use the language, particular place and particular people, or land and lineage, and I'll talk about blood and soil and why I think that's unhelpful language here in just a moment.
00:12:44 But land and lineage, and in addition to that, it's law, and it's loves.
00:12:50 language language and and then we could add liturgy worship um is really important so there
00:12:56 needs to be a monoculture that a nation shares monoculture that doesn't mean that everybody has
00:13:01 the same skin pigment but it it does mean that um there is one culture we believe america that
00:13:07 culture is an anglo-protestant culture that it's unified around uh the protestant christian faith
00:13:14 So there's your liturgy, your religion, English, speaking the king's tongue, that's your language.
00:13:21 There are certain laws, biblical case law system that really tracks all the way back to King Alfred.
00:13:28 So there's a history there, a legacy there.
00:13:31 The people, the lineage was predominantly Anglo-Saxons.
00:13:35 And then there were waves throughout American history.
00:13:38 This has always been the case for America because it's discovering this new world, a massive landmass.
00:13:46 And so you had constant waves of immigration.
00:13:48 None of that is new.
00:13:50 But, you know, the Italians come, the Irish come, the Germans come, you know, the Dutch and all these different things.
00:13:56 But it was always to assimilate and still to maintain the dominant hegemony of this Anglo-Protestant culture.
00:14:07 So the Germans come and they're not, we don't, the nation doesn't say, and now we speak German. 0.83
00:14:12 No, the Germans have to learn English.
00:14:15 They have to speak English.
00:14:16 And so anyway, so all that being said, land, lineage, that's a place and people, and then laws and loves and language, and we could add liturgy.
00:14:29 And so what Vivek is saying that we would disagree with is, first I want to say I appreciate that he says blood and soil.
00:14:38 I wouldn't use that language.
00:14:39 I'll tell you why.
00:14:40 But notice he says blood and soil, and he doesn't immediately launch into, you know, his eyes don't roll back in his head, and he doesn't launch into a rant where he starts calling J.D. Vance a Nazi.
00:14:53 Praise God. 0.97
00:14:53 I wish that some Reformed ministers had the same level of maturity and tact as Vivek Ramaswamy.
00:14:59 sadly they do not so he was able to steal man rather than straw man and he didn't do bulverism
00:15:07 you know he didn't get this logical fallacy of saying instead of telling you what you believe
00:15:14 is wrong and arguing on the merits and the substance i'm going to assume your motives for
00:15:20 why you believe what you believe and i'm going to prove that your motives the why is wrong without
00:15:25 ever having to deal with what. That's what bulvarism is. It's a logical fallacy that
00:15:30 oftentimes, you know, the reason why people engage in it is because the opponent, what they believe,
00:15:38 the substance, is something that they actually are not able to prove false. And so instead,
00:15:44 what they do is they assume the motives for why somebody would believe that. So if somebody
00:15:49 believes that nations are composed of lineage and land, and you don't like that, and you can't
00:15:54 disprove what the person believes, then what you do is you immediately demonize your assumptions
00:16:00 for why they believe that. And so I can't, I can't tell you, I can't explain, I don't have
00:16:07 the explanatory power to say why a nation is not composed of land and lineage. But what I can do
00:16:14 is I can call you a racist. And so I'm going to do that. So I appreciate Vivek not doing that.
00:16:20 I hope that other reformed ministers would be able to have the same maturity of a Hindu who's 1.00
00:16:26 Christless. It's sad when those who worship false pagan gods are making reformed ministers look 1.00
00:16:33 inferior in terms of their character. So hopefully the reformed church can learn from that and grow
00:16:39 up a bit. In addition to that, I said I don't like the blood and soil language. The reason why is
00:16:46 because everybody does track that back to Hitler. The reason why we would say, like J.D. Vance,
00:16:51 home, particular place, particular people, or land and lineage instead of blood and soil is
00:16:57 because Hitler's conception of blood and soil is not what people on the right are saying today,
00:17:05 on the new right are saying today. He wasn't just saying that, you know, Germany is its own
00:17:10 sovereign nation, and it's distinct because it's a particular geographic region, land, and it's
00:17:17 particular people with a heritage and a lineage. What he was saying with blood and soil is it was
00:17:24 wrapped up, he was saying that, but in addition to that, he went further and was saying that this
00:17:30 is wrapped up in a kind of a Norse pagan kind of mythological conception that this particular land,
00:17:39 in his case, Germany, was a magical, a superior soil. It was actually in an ontological,
00:17:46 magical, mythological way. It was a superior land, a magical soil, and that out of the soil,
00:17:54 it produced a superior blood, a superior race of people. And so that we would disagree with.
00:18:02 That's not, our position isn't saying that America is magical and that it produces those who are
00:18:07 born here are therefore ontologically, you know, superior to people anywhere else. That's not our
00:18:14 argument. But we do think that blood and soil are two of the five or six components of what make a
00:18:23 nation. And because blood and soil, that rhetoric will always be tracked back to Hitler and people
00:18:27 instinctively think Thor, pagan mythology, we choose not to use it. There's certain things
00:18:34 that are worth redeeming because they've been hijacked. And there are other things where it's
00:18:37 just not worth the fight. You know, and so blood and soil, yes, but much better to say land and
00:18:45 lineage or particular people, particular place. And a nation, again, is more than that. It's not
00:18:51 just land and lineage. It's also law, liturgy, language, loves, but it can't ever be less than
00:18:59 that. It's not just an economic zone. It's not just a set of propositions. And the final thing
00:19:03 i'll say about levesque is one um he didn't call jd a nazi i think that's good too um he actually
00:19:10 i think steel manned the argument it was brief but but he didn't uh use a straw man conception
00:19:15 of of the people in place uh conception of a nation uh but then the third thing i'll say
00:19:21 about levesque is that in the final analysis he does say and i reject this right and i think i'd
00:19:27 be remiss if I didn't say, um, he rejects it likely because he's Indian. And I just think
00:19:34 that that's worth saying. It's, um, like, I think we're, I just think we're being silly. I'm not 0.94
00:19:40 trying to, you know, get clicks here or, or be, um, or be obnoxious. Um, but I, I really think
00:19:47 we're being silly if we don't acknowledge um that the uh the the hindu indian guy um doesn't like 0.96
00:19:56 the idea of defining nations as a particular people in particular place well of course he
00:20:02 doesn't right of course he doesn't like that um because that doesn't particularly work in his
00:20:08 favor now to see point a back to the you know the previous arguments that we made um i think that
00:20:15 vivek does embody a lot of america's virtues and i'm grateful for him in many ways and with each
00:20:22 generation um vivek his children and grandchildren and like um that they will they'll be able to lay
00:20:31 claim to lineage and land um so so that's not something that's like you can never have and
00:20:37 your descendants can never have um but to argue that that it's not even a part of of conceiving
00:20:44 of a nation is not helpful because if vivek wins that argument you don't get um a billion viveks
00:20:52 that's right you get a billion people who poop in the street that's what you get um you won't get 1.00
00:21:00 if vivek wins this argument you won't get more viveks you'll get more haitians eating cats and 0.88
00:21:06 dogs right and that's why it matters okay yeah if we could title this first segment it would be
00:21:12 really trying to narrow down and insist on a much more narrow definition of american than even we've
00:21:17 been offered reagan would be the conservatives of the past vague would be the conservative of
00:21:21 today the conservative of the future really insisting on a much more narrow definition
00:21:26 let's get into some straight just definitions because nation race ethnicity lineage they're
00:21:31 all closely intertwined and sometimes you'll be talking with someone and you realize you're both
00:21:35 using the same word you're talking about ethnicity the way they're using it is totally different
00:21:39 you're talking past each other. So we're going to lay out some definitions here. These are from
00:21:42 people smarter than we are. They're from scripture. And hopefully it's helpful. Even if you disagree
00:21:46 with us, you can say, okay, that's where my disagreement is on this definition. This is
00:21:51 where I think this plays a bigger role, et cetera. So starting off, let's start with the foundation,
00:21:55 which is race. Michael, you bring up a good point in your book. This is a newer word. We don't
00:22:00 really see it used as much in the Bible, I would even say. We see actually race is pretty close to
00:22:06 nation, that the two would be almost synonymous. I think of the children of Israel. Literally,
00:22:10 there was a man named Israel who had children that became the nation of Israel. They were his
00:22:15 offspring. They were his lineage. They were the nation of Israel. But race is something. It's not
00:22:20 everything, but it's not nothing. I offer this definition. Physical traits passed down from
00:22:24 ancestry that delineate people into distinct groups. So their physical traits, it's not culture,
00:22:30 we'll get to that in a second, passed down from your ancestors, the people you're related to,
00:22:34 and they delineate, they separate people into distinct recognizable groups.
00:22:39 It's a little bit tricky here.
00:22:40 You'll see some people emphasize one side of it.
00:22:42 Some people emphasize the other.
00:22:43 There's a very real sense in which scripture speaks of men belonging to the one human race
00:22:47 and to distinct races.
00:22:50 So Acts 17, 26, it's on your screen.
00:22:52 God hath made, this is Paul, of one blood, all nations, all races, you could transliterate
00:22:59 it as, of men for it to dwell in the face of the earth.
00:23:01 God made of one blood, of one seed from Adam, all the nations, all the peoples to dwell in the face
00:23:07 of the earth. So that's the one human race. And people will say, well, there's no race. There's
00:23:10 just the one human race. That's a half truth. It's not the full story. You're going to say 0.97
00:23:15 something, Michael? No. There are also distinct racial groups. This is Deuteronomy 32.8. When the
00:23:21 Most High divided to the nations their inheritance, when he separated the sons of Adam, he set the 0.91
00:23:29 bounds of the people you see three times repeated he separated he he divided them he made them
00:23:35 distinct uh how did he make them distinct in what way well i don't know there's a big ocean between
00:23:40 america and between europe right there's mountain ranges mountains rivers deserts oceans yeah
00:23:46 intended for people to be separated remember babel everyone's trying to wait you're saying
00:23:51 the land separated them the land that god made that he set up that he made in in uh
00:23:58 impassable so again race it's not everything but it's not nothing uh so my background i actually
00:24:04 am on my dad's side anglo-saxon uh we can trace our name back to about 1300 um in literally the
00:24:11 anglo-saxon english area which is why i'm so based uh wes has been a racist for 800 years
00:24:17 it's a long-standing tradition he thought the world war was going to fix that uh and then on
00:24:21 my mom's side german so i have those two things i have english i have german but here's the deal
00:24:26 And this is why we have to have another category than race.
00:24:29 That doesn't tell you the actual experience.
00:24:31 It doesn't tell you the language I speak.
00:24:33 That's where ethnicity is a helpful term.
00:24:35 So Stephen Wolfe, in his book, 0.96
00:24:36 This is the Case for Christian Nationalism,
00:24:38 he then goes on to say ethnicity. 0.63
00:24:40 This is really important, guys.
00:24:42 So big picture real quick.
00:24:44 Race and ethnicity are both helpful terms
00:24:46 and they don't mean the same thing.
00:24:47 Exactly.
00:24:48 Go ahead.
00:24:48 At least in this way of describing them.
00:24:50 Two different terms.
00:24:51 They used to.
00:24:52 They used to.
00:24:53 In the classic theological sense before Darwin.
00:24:56 they actually did mean even today to be japanese racially is to be japanese ethnically but that's
00:25:01 not always the case for every nation it's not helpful exactly so historically you could conflate
00:25:07 these two words but for today's purposes they should be separate and that's not um a nefarious
00:25:13 hijacking of the english language um it's actually uh language evolving and developing in a helpful
00:25:20 way because we need more than one term to describe two different things because we have a certain
00:25:26 phenomenon that exists today that that previously um i mean you could say it existed in some
00:25:33 conception within the roman era and things like that but not like it does today today we have
00:25:38 because of airplanes and and boats and ships and technology and all these kinds of things
00:25:44 we are propaganda and propaganda is that multiculturalism and globalism and marxism
00:25:50 So because of nefarious ideologies and technological innovations, for these purposes and these reasons, we have nations like Japan, which its race and ethnicity are virtually synonymous. 0.59
00:26:06 It's an ethno-national state.
00:26:09 But then we have places like America that are not.
00:26:12 And in America, we have different races and we have different ethnicities. 0.72
00:26:16 ethnicities and what we're going to argue is that different races within measure is perfectly
00:26:22 permissible but we should actually have one culture and from that culture and the way that
00:26:30 we're going to define here with steven wolf ethnicity in that sense it should be one ethnicity
00:26:35 one that culture is is um is paramount to the way that steven wolf and others it's not just him
00:26:43 in our modern era because of the globalism and a new, we have just a whole new world. And so it
00:26:49 has to be defined carefully. The way that ethnicity is being used by, I think, really good thinkers on
00:26:55 the right today in our modern time is ethnicity translates more to culture, whereas race would
00:27:02 translate more to your actual lineage and your ancestry. And that, of course, would include
00:27:09 color and pigment things like that okay all right so this is steven wolf's definition and again
00:27:13 listen here we're not talking about physical traits and genetics although i will say they
00:27:17 are typically closely related we'll get to that ethnicity is shared language manners customs
00:27:23 histories that's a big one history time rituals calendars by fourth social expectations duties
00:27:32 loves and religion steven wolf says this in his book i modified it a little blood relations matter
00:27:37 They do matter, but they do not directly establish the boundaries of one's ethnicity.
00:27:43 I mentioned English and German.
00:27:44 None of those tell you what language I speak.
00:27:46 They don't tell you what denomination I belong to.
00:27:49 It doesn't tell you all Lutheran or Anglican.
00:27:51 So you have that genetic component.
00:27:54 It matters.
00:27:55 It gave me my skin color, my height, my bone structure, my disposition.
00:27:58 But then ethnicity, culture, all of those things actually then filled in what it looks
00:28:03 like for me now to be here.
00:28:04 200 years later is about my ancestors came over distinctly american in my ethnicity so try to
00:28:10 think in those categories i think it's helpful genetics and race and then like you said that
00:28:13 that ethnic component of that actual experience and with that nathan go ahead and put the
00:28:18 definition back on the screen but with that we were you know talking just as a thought experiment
00:28:22 as a case study about um african americans here in the united states so when you think of the
00:28:29 black population the black community um notice that the way that ethnicity is being defined here
00:28:36 by steven wolf and we're adopting this definition we think it's helpful um it is entirely conceivable
00:28:42 impossible even plausible that um if you think of the south you know and confederates and things
00:28:49 like that you can have um well let's let's even go a little bit you know past that so not all the
00:28:56 way back to the civil war but but some of what came out eventually descendants of the south and
00:29:01 things like that booker t washington booker t washington would be the same ethnicity as george
00:29:08 washington right according to this definition again let me read it here ethnicity shared language
00:29:13 they're both speaking english manners customs and notices even histories so that doesn't happen in
00:29:21 15 minutes but over time so by by the time you get to booker t washington and you're looking at
00:29:26 you know originally this the settling not immigration but settling of america by anglo
00:29:31 protestants george washington being one of them and then also the transfer of slaves because of
00:29:37 the slave trade um it is entirely conceivable that you could have someone like booker t washington
00:29:43 who could say well my ancestors my blood ancestors have been here for 200 years right and george
00:29:50 Washington, you know, and some white guy that partners with Booker T. Washington to accomplish
00:29:55 lots of good things. Both Christians, Booker T. Washington was a man who loved the Lord. He was
00:30:00 a good Christian man. So he could have his white friend and, you know, Booker T. Washington as a
00:30:05 black man. And then his white man, who's his friend, could be a descendant of George Washington.
00:30:12 And Booker T. Washington, I'm not saying this is a fact, but let's just say hypothetically that
00:30:16 he's a descendant of one of george washington's slaves but by the time you get there history is
00:30:22 actually included we're not we're not just fabricating that that's a real history that's
00:30:26 a 200 year history so you would actually have between booker t washington and some white guy
00:30:31 who's partnering with him you'd have shared language you'd have manners you'd have customs
00:30:35 you'd have history and it's entirely possible that you could have a black guy 100 years after
00:30:40 the civil war who has the same shared history uh with a white guy who was a confederate because
00:30:45 he actually fought for the south because he actually was a good christian man believed in
00:30:50 those values um didn't want his entire all of his customs and all to be completely uprooted and all
00:30:57 those like yeah he wasn't a fan of slavery but but he believed that that was coming to an end
00:31:01 regardless eventually and um and he loved the south and he loved those people so you could have
00:31:07 two guys like that a white guy and a black guy who share language they share manners customs and
00:31:12 a history, a 200-year-old history, plus rituals, calendars, social expectations, duties, loves,
00:31:18 and the Christian Protestant religion. And so the point is, our desire, what we would like to see
00:31:26 for America, is the same thing that we believe God desires, and that God actually planned and
00:31:34 has prescribed through his authoritative command in Scripture, what God's planned for every single
00:31:40 nation on the planet um it is not actually a blessing of liberty it's not actually um a brag
00:31:47 or a boast for america to say um god says this about nations and we reject it yep um it's actually
00:31:55 that doesn't mean that we have transcended or that we're somehow above it all we're not above
00:31:59 it all we're beneath it all we're actually in rebellion against the lord god almighty we desire
00:32:06 for america to be a monoculture and that be an anglo-protestant culture or you could use
00:32:11 if defined this way the term also ethnicity we would like to be an ethnos state with this
00:32:18 definition of ethnicity that does not mean that we will be a monoracial state so america because
00:32:25 it is unique in its founding and in its history with various waves of immigration after immigration
00:32:32 whether it be the germans or the italians or the irish yeah let's let's finish this thought and
00:32:39 then we'll do it um but because there's various ways of immigration um and from the from the
00:32:45 onset because of slavery um you have a black population there's still a dominant race at
00:32:52 least in our founding there was a dominant race and it was english people it was people from
00:32:58 england that was the dominant race but you did still have at a certain point and not just 15
00:33:03 minutes ago but a few hundred years ago there was a point in america in early on where um you could
00:33:10 say there were 20 percent um of america was black right and so um for those um people that now that's
00:33:19 different than haitians immigrating last week but for those people who track back there they're
00:33:25 american and we would like for them to be american and we'd like for us too to be american in in a
00:33:33 in a true sense and michael made a great point we were talking about this as a case study before we
00:33:38 started recording but um black america was heading in many ways by by virtually all metrics they were
00:33:47 heading in that direction and were hijacked yep by the frankfurt school by marxist by
00:33:53 civil rights act by the uh the heart seller act by all these different things um but you look
00:34:00 before that and you look at the harlem of the south and you look at um the advancements of the
00:34:05 guys like booker t washington and and the advancements that they were making um and and
00:34:11 what they were trying to do was head overall there's always individual you know bad actors
00:34:17 but overall they were heading in the direction of we we just want to be american um we want to
00:34:23 love Jesus, love the Christian Protestant religion. We're not asking for special handouts or this or
00:34:31 that. We just want to be American, just like everybody else, with shared history, shared
00:34:36 customs, shared manners, and a shared religion, most importantly, and of course, a shared language.
00:34:42 But that got hijacked. And there's a reason why today, when you look at voting patterns,
00:34:48 like even this is something, I'll take just a moment to do this. When we get things wrong,
00:34:52 it's good to correct it publicly and publicly repent, right?
00:34:56 That's what repenting is changing.
00:34:58 So I remember saying about the election
00:35:00 just a couple of weeks ago that the big divide-
00:35:03 You were before the election?
00:35:04 Yeah, when we did our live stream, I think.
00:35:07 It was either the week before or the live stream
00:35:08 when we were live streaming the election.
00:35:10 But I remember saying that the big divide nowadays
00:35:12 is between men and women. 1.00
00:35:14 And I was right in the sense that the divide
00:35:17 between the sexes has enlarged. 1.00
00:35:19 That is true.
00:35:20 But then looking at the metrics,
00:35:22 post-election once they were all posted uh the reality is um that the biggest divide that the
00:35:29 gap is getting bigger especially with the younger generation like gen z between men and women
00:35:33 however it still stands that uh the biggest divides in terms of voting pattern is not sexes
00:35:40 right and it's also not religion it is race it is and by god's grace uh trump was able to get
00:35:48 the highest turnout of any republican since reagan so 20 of black men voted for trump praise god
00:35:54 uh when it comes to latino men it was i think 47 or highest number almost half like in latino
00:36:01 so amazing praise god for that um but just again to use black and white as a case study here 0.69
00:36:07 um black women i think was less than 10 92 to 8 yeah for kamala yeah so eight percent of black
00:36:14 women voted for trump right 20 of black men so if you split the difference there then if my math is
00:36:19 right that's 14 and then if you look at uh the white vote so so what i want to what i'm recanting
00:36:27 here is um white women um in the younger generation gen z are splitting more and more from white men
00:36:35 but women are more liberal than men that's right uh-huh but on the whole white women married and
00:36:41 single combined every generation from boomer all the way down to gen z white women on the whole 0.56
00:36:46 was i think 59 was for trump um and and 59 white women for trump is a lot more than 20 black men
00:36:57 for trump right so the biggest divide is still not men and women right the biggest divide i have to
00:37:02 be honest is is still black and white and my point in bringing that up is just as an example
00:37:06 to to prove my point um there is a big because what you're one of the things you're voting on
00:37:12 uh in a national election like that is you're voting on the vision of the country that it's
00:37:17 uh what is the country going to be what what is its culture what culture do i want and right now
00:37:24 um the average black person not all of course not all but the average black person wants america to
00:37:30 be something very different and so my point in bringing that up is to say um that's actually
00:37:35 a new development. So we don't believe that that's proof. So therefore, black people aren't
00:37:41 Americans or can never be Americans in a monoculture sense. No, we're actually very 0.92
00:37:47 hopeful about that because of the power of the gospel and because we believe all the nations
00:37:51 will flock to Mount Zion and will be Christianized, and that'll include all the people that make up
00:37:55 those nations. So we're very hopeful for black America in a future sense from biblical grounds,
00:38:01 but we're also hopeful because we can look at it from historical grounds and we can point back and 1.00
00:38:06 say they were on their way and it got hijacked and it was hijacked by a bunch of marxist it was it
00:38:14 wasn't hijacked by you know that all the black people decided together we're gonna you know what 0.86
00:38:19 we've decided we want to stop working and we're just going to get on welfare and uh and we don't
00:38:23 really you know uh want to be you know we don't like protestant anglo culture anymore and we're
00:38:28 going to do things our own way and we're going to vote for democrats who want to destroy the nation 0.95
00:38:31 that's that's not what happened actually it was um a bunch of marxists who used as a puppet guys 0.64
00:38:39 like michael king martin luther king um and and used him to absolutely through the civil rights
00:38:46 act and all these things destroy the black population in america um but it wasn't always
00:38:51 that way and because it wasn't always that way i'm hopeful that it doesn't always have to be
00:38:55 that way. And I think Trump in this most recent election is a sign that maybe it's moving the
00:39:01 right direction. So anyways, all that is to say that you can have Booker T. Washington and George
00:39:09 Washington and them be, in the way we're conceiving of it, in this definition of ethnicity,
00:39:16 the same ethnos. And historically and biblically, certainly, nations are ethnos. That's what they
00:39:23 are right and if it's not then you don't actually have a nation you have an empire and empires
00:39:29 eventually whether it be uh being overly altruistic or or whatever every story of the rise and fall
00:39:37 of empires is eventually they spread out too thin they cover too many too much ground in too many
00:39:43 tribes too many different ethnos and um and they eventually implode uh empires rarely are taken
00:39:50 over from the outside forces, whether it's the Babylonian Empire. Well, that one actually was,
00:39:55 the Persians and the Bees. I mean, literally God's divine judgment. 0.99
00:39:59 Exactly. But if you think of Rome, and you think of Byzantine, or you think of Ottoman,
00:40:05 or you think of all these different empires, they eventually accrue so much power that they're
00:40:10 rarely actually toppled by an outside power that's stronger than their own. They usually
00:40:18 actually implode. And they implode because they begin to eventually think that, you know,
00:40:26 everybody can be a Roman, you know, and we can just, you know, all we have to do is just go over
00:40:32 to this country and make a deal. And then, you know, and that's what America has been doing. 0.53
00:40:38 And so we would like for America not to be an empire. We would like for it to be a nation.
00:40:43 And if it's going to be a nation, then we need to have one ethnos, not one race, not one color, but one ethnos. 0.94
00:40:52 And right now we don't.
00:40:53 And so right now we fit the metrics of an empire in many ways more than a nation, and we think that that's a bad thing.
00:40:58 I would offer two. 0.99
00:41:00 Why was there so much flourishing, even in the black community, the 40s, 50s, and 60s?
00:41:04 We had, by and large, a Christian nation.
00:41:07 So our laws, there was rule of law, there was enforcement of it.
00:41:10 uh not even then enshrined in law but there's a social expectation for example against wedlock
00:41:15 so all of those things surrounded for wedlock uh yes yeah right like the expectation was that
00:41:23 you didn't have children out of wedlock uh so all that being said that surrounded the people
00:41:27 and then the different peoples inside of it flourished they had families they were productive
00:41:31 members of society but as those have receded as we've lost the christian identity the christian
00:41:36 social power now these groups that were beginning to come together and to live harmoniously
00:41:40 separated out more so much more distinct and especially black culture we have to be honest
00:41:45 yeah like rap is not european in its origin no right rap music did not you know come from italy
00:41:50 and it's entirely and i've said it before and i'll say it again like people say beauty is in
00:41:55 the eye of the beholder no um that's true in the sense if we're saying that the one true beholder
00:41:59 that's the final arbiter of beauty is god then sure then beauty is in the eye of the beholder
00:42:04 if the beholder is god and he gets to objectively decide uh but art is not subjective um jackson
00:42:09 pollock eventually i believe as as our nation becomes more christian and repents of its sin
00:42:15 our great grandchildren will go to museums to look at jackson pollock to laugh and say isn't that
00:42:20 funny when the nation was in rebellion against christ embraced secularism embraced marxism 0.98
00:42:24 and they actually thought that this was art this piece of crap right here that's a joke uh this 0.97
00:42:28 this uh relativism abstract you know reductionist you know whatever and i would say the same thing 0.97
00:42:34 about rap and i'm and i'm not saying that black people are this way across the board or certainly
00:42:39 not that they have to be this way or that they were always this way. But the idea of rap being
00:42:44 a legitimate source of art and music, I reject. So I'm not just saying, oh, I don't like it
00:42:49 because I'm white and art is perceived by the beholder and it's subjective and different people
00:42:54 have different tastes. No, I'm going to go on record saying objectively, if you think that
00:42:59 Mozart and, I don't know, 50 Cent or whatever, Jay-Z, that it's just tomato, tomato, then you 0.98
00:43:08 You have a low IQ. 1.00
00:43:09 You are a stupid person. 1.00
00:43:11 Do you know how I know this is true? 1.00
00:43:12 Do you know where they-
00:43:12 One is superior in the objective sense.
00:43:14 I think I mentioned this before.
00:43:16 Do you know where the greatest renaissance
00:43:18 of classical music is right now in the world?
00:43:20 Where?
00:43:21 Japan.
00:43:22 They love classical music.
00:43:25 They train to play the violin. 1.00
00:43:27 Common Japan W. 1.00
00:43:28 Seriously, right?
00:43:29 And it is exploding there right now.
00:43:32 I believe it.
00:43:33 So all, but that being said, you know,
00:43:34 like you are what you eat.
00:43:35 And in some sense you are what you consume 0.96
00:43:37 in terms of what you listen to and hip hop has been terrible for the black 0.87
00:43:42 community. Absolutely. Like the morals, all these,
00:43:45 but it's also as an art form. It's like, well,
00:43:47 and then we just need Christian hip hop. No, it's, it's not just the lyrics.
00:43:51 It's not just the values.
00:43:53 There's actually something virtuous in certain instruments and, and,
00:43:57 and being conducted and composed in certain ways.
00:44:00 There is a way that certain music, even without lyrics,
00:44:04 that a symphony stirs the soul in a way that uh drop that beat man uh does not syncopated beats
00:44:11 yeah that does not stir the soul and these are not just a matter of opinion and subjective
00:44:16 um these are objective i think objective truths and so anyways uh it's funny in the 70s and the
00:44:21 80s the fundamentalists they were really sounding the alarm about rap music right right yeah they
00:44:26 were right and you grow up and you're like oh those fundies and then you get older you're like 0.95
00:44:30 Turn that trash off. 0.99
00:44:31 Turn that trash off. 0.99
00:44:32 They were right. 0.96
00:44:33 Let's go to our first commercial break, and we'll come back.
00:44:35 We'll talk more about nations and nationalism.
00:44:36 When we come back, we're going to listen to the clip that we referenced.
00:44:39 So we have one more clip.
00:44:40 It's Martyr Maid with Daryl Cooper. 0.97
00:44:44 Sounds good. 0.99
00:44:44 We'll do that.
00:44:45 Yep.
00:44:46 You have heard it said that cash is king.
00:44:48 Well, our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants you to know that cash flow is the key to building wealth.
00:44:54 The partners at Private Family Banking are experts at teaching you how to implement a new way of thinking about money.
00:45:02 This powerful and innovative approach provides a fail-safe method for redirecting the cash flow you already have into a privatized banking system that you now own and control.
00:45:13 This new system places you and your family on the wealth curve for continuously compounding
00:45:19 tax-protected gains now and unto future generations.
00:45:24 You may also be familiar with the age-old wisdom that the best time to plant a tree
00:45:29 for shade was 10 years ago, but the second best time is today.
00:45:34 So start your journey of building your financial legacy right now.
00:45:39 The sooner you start, the better.
00:45:41 Let a private family banking partner help you put post-mill talk into post-mill action.
00:45:47 Contact them today by emailing banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:45:53 Again, that's banking at privatefamilybanking.com and request a free step-by-step wealth building
00:46:00 plan that will be the game changer that you have been looking for.
00:46:04 Lastly, a complimentary discovery call can be scheduled by using the link in this episode's
00:46:11 show notes. America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their
00:46:15 duty before God and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
00:46:19 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied, not just as a
00:46:24 plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business as though they're commandments from God
00:46:29 that we're supposed to obey. Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:46:35 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our
00:46:39 capacity to do things here.
00:46:42 Reese Fund, Christian capital, boldly deployed.
00:46:46 Are you a Christian who struggles to find companies who align with your convictions?
00:46:51 Do you wish that you could work with Christian brothers rather than pagans who hate everything
00:46:55 you love?
00:46:56 You shouldn't have to dedicate your hard work to men or women who support evil.
00:47:01 At Top Knot Alpaca Care, we're looking for mature men who desire hard work and long days
00:47:07 building the kingdom.
00:47:09 your vocation is more important than just the income you bring in for your family
00:47:14 your work should equip you with better life skills and deeper relationships than you could
00:47:20 ever get from college now if you can't handle overwhelming smells of things like urine feces
00:47:26 and ammonia wrestling 500 pound llamas and traveling for months at a time or being pushed
00:47:32 to grow physically, emotionally, and spiritually,
00:47:36 then you need not apply.
00:47:38 We're a growing company with a variety of open positions.
00:47:41 So contact us today
00:47:42 before our interview window closes in January.
00:47:45 Call Elijah at Top Knot
00:47:47 with the phone number that's listed
00:47:49 in the description for this show.
00:47:51 Go to the description.
00:47:52 The phone number for Elijah with Top Knot
00:47:54 will be right there.
00:47:55 Give him a call today.
00:47:58 All right, welcome back.
00:48:00 We mentioned a clip we're gonna play.
00:48:01 This is from Daryl Cooper.
00:48:02 he's for one uh he's he's based he's our guy this is not some harvard intellectual trying to sell
00:48:08 you the idea of a propositional nation uh great dude and an incredible historian i think when
00:48:13 the story is written of the the 2000s his podcast and his history and his writing and his study
00:48:18 will be very very highly regarded but i took this clips from the jay burden show uh to just kind of
00:48:23 show that what we're saying that america really fundamentally in its conception in its founding
00:48:28 has been different in Iceland, in Japan, in Uganda, that are almost exclusively monoracial,
00:48:33 is that America just hasn't from its founding been that. We've talked about we don't want to 0.99
00:48:37 be idealistic. Like in an ideal world, this is exactly what we do. We live in the world that
00:48:42 God has made. God is sovereign over how he arranged and apportioned these peoples. And this
00:48:47 is just the facts of it. Now, America is young. Our identity could change. Remigration is a real
00:48:52 thing. But as it is right now, this is our history. And this is what has happened leading up to this 1.00
00:48:56 250th year. So we'll go ahead and play the clip. Um, you know, people have idea that, uh, there
00:49:04 was this kind of strong, stable, longstanding American identity that, um, existed before
00:49:13 1968 or whatever. Um, and then everything came apart because of the cultural revolution and the
00:49:18 hard seller act and everything. And that's just not true. You know, I mean, the, the, the Anglo
00:49:25 population that, that fought the civil war, uh, fought the, the revolutionary war was getting
00:49:30 displaced, uh, in the cities by Germans and Irish within a generation. Um, you know, the big East 0.56
00:49:36 coast cities were like a lot of them were majority Irish and German, uh, and the Germans were
00:49:40 assimilating to the Anglo class. So it wasn't quite as like, you know, sort of visible maybe
00:49:44 in that sense, but, but nevertheless, like these were people who were still reading German language
00:49:48 newspapers at home. And no sooner did those people get worked into the system. We built a public
00:49:57 school system to put these crazy Irish kids through so that they could grow up and become 1.00
00:50:00 flag-waving citizens. Then we just got an even bigger influx of Southern and Eastern Europeans 1.00
00:50:05 just a generation later. And we had to go through this whole process again. And that went on from 0.82
00:50:10 the early 1880s up until the 1920s. We cut off immigration again. But then as soon as we did 0.98
00:50:16 that, you started to get the great migration of six, seven million blacks coming out of the South 0.89
00:50:20 into the Northern and Western cities, which, so again, like just, you know, the other, they're
00:50:24 not coming from a quote unquote different country, but on, you know, on one level, like if you're 0.65
00:50:28 coming from, if you're an African-American coming from the rural South, you were a sharecropper and
00:50:32 you're moving to Detroit in 1945. I mean, a lot of ways you're more foreign than somebody who's 0.96
00:50:38 coming from Berlin to, to Detroit, you know, much more familiar, at least with the urban environment
00:50:42 and so forth. So like, you know, uh, America's a big ass country. So people come from one side 0.98
00:50:47 to the other, especially back then when there were major regional differences, uh, you know,
00:50:51 it was like a new, uh, a new migration from another country basically. Uh, and that went
00:50:56 on up until the 1960s and petered out, uh, you know, at that point, and then it was replaced
00:51:01 with the heart seller act, which is the world we're in now. And so we've been in this, we've
00:51:05 been in this state where we've had to redefine ourselves and we've had to reshape our story to
00:51:15 include new people in it and over and over again throughout our history. And there really was no
00:51:20 long period of time where that was not the case. It was pretty much from the beginning. And one of
00:51:26 all right all right yeah so the reality is uh god profoundly blessed america like even with
00:51:38 those things even though it was at first majority english and then german and then irish and later
00:51:43 the black like god profoundly blessed our nation even despite the way we've been different from a
00:51:48 lot of other nations on earth and so see that's the key though is like did god bless our nation
00:51:54 because we're different or did he bless our nation despite yeah like and i think a lot of people
00:51:59 think like god blessed our nation because like this is what all the democrat liberal progressive
00:52:05 marxists think is like diversity is our strength he like uh we've been blessed we've been so strong
00:52:10 so successful because no uh and it's like no no no no no we were blessed because of our founding
00:52:17 and initially in that founding it was not um diversity is our strength it was yeah it was
00:52:24 an anglo-protestant yeah um founding an anglo-protestant nation and they're having waves
00:52:29 of immigration since but even with those waves of immigration at least initially for the first
00:52:34 couple hundred years really were settlers not just immigrants and they actually assimilated
00:52:40 to that anglo-protestant thing and that's why we've been so blessed and as we've lost that
00:52:45 the blessing is evaporating go ahead yeah i was just kidding who was it in that podcast that you
00:52:50 sent us was it our honor cj who was saying even you know people immigrants would come and they
00:52:54 would rename their children or they would name the next generation with traditional american names
00:53:00 that's right they're not german names but edie roble said the same thing recently he said um
00:53:04 he said i'm glad that my dad um you know because he's half puerto rican and he said when my dad
00:53:09 you know came here um he really wanted to be an american and that's why he named me adam yeah
00:53:15 um which by the way ad robles is uh his name is adam and his wife calls him adam all of his
00:53:22 friends call him adam um ad was a joke because he just noticed that every like christian author
00:53:27 would use like their uh first name initial name initial rc sproul exactly so he did it you know
00:53:34 aw tozer or whatever uh he did it as a joke but now everybody like calls him ad like but it's not
00:53:39 even his preference he's like i remember asking him you know a couple years ago i was like is it
00:53:43 okay if i call you adam he's like yeah that's my name but anyways so he was making a point and i
00:53:48 can't remember but he gave he gave like a puerto rican equivalent of adam which i i don't know
00:53:52 what that is because i'm not puerto rican and i don't care um and 80 would support that 100
00:53:57 but he was like i'm glad my dad didn't give me the puerto rican equivalent of adam as a name
00:54:03 but instead he moved to america because he didn't want to be a puerto rican in america he wanted to
00:54:08 be an american right and he is puerto rican but he wanted to be an american and he sure as heck
00:54:13 wanted his kids to be american and so he gave us american names that's what's so powerful about
00:54:19 assimilation is if you properly assimilate and you take on the characteristics of a nation
00:54:23 you're leaving the one of your fathers you you're like ruth does your people will be my people
00:54:29 like something does does die you leave behind a language you leave behind habits you leave behind
00:54:34 maybe even family members to cling to a new nation like that's the seriousness of assimilation
00:54:39 nationalism like even patriotism the word comes from patre which means fatherland it's it's so
00:54:46 eventually as time goes on your fathers lived there that's serious we've got to stop we do this
00:54:51 with marriage well no fault divorce if you want out of it well patriotism it's like you like the
00:54:55 flag and you go to the cookout on july 4th but you're going to anyway because they were grilling
00:54:59 No, no, no. It's deep-seated commitment and a willingness to say, I'm going to leave behind
00:55:05 this other thing that conflicts with it. I'm going north, which means I don't get to see
00:55:09 what's south. Right. That's well said. Real quick, this is just an interjection, but some of you guys
00:55:15 will probably notice by the time, some of you may have noticed in the live chat, but you'll
00:55:21 definitely notice as people watch this video in the coming days, but the Antioch statement has
00:55:26 just been uh released and posted on twitter by uh doug wilson and and joseph boot and it's basically
00:55:33 ezra moscow and apologia so it's your james white jeff durbin joe boot um andrew sandlin uh doug
00:55:40 wilson and there's some other signers and tobias is one of them um he's the the pastor in frankfurt
00:55:45 germany and so anyways um people are already asking like somebody said uh it's curious that
00:55:52 Joel hasn't signed it. And like, I had literally been aware of it for 15 minutes. So, you know,
00:55:59 people are probably going to wonder, you know, like, are you going to sign it? And what I'm
00:56:03 going to do, I can tell you this right now, what I'm going to do is I'm going to first read it
00:56:09 carefully. Before we started recording, I read some of it. And some of it was good. And some of
00:56:14 it I don't like. But I'm going to read it carefully. And I'm going to do I'm going to do it the same
00:56:20 way, I do everything, which means I'm going to do it in community. I'm going to co-discern this
00:56:27 statement on its merits. Is it biblical? Does it honor the Lord? Is it truthful? And what does it
00:56:36 actually say? And I'm going to do it together. So I'm going to do it with Michael. I'm going to do
00:56:40 it with Wes. I'm going to do it with my co-elder, Connor. I'm going to see what he thinks about it.
00:56:45 But then I'm also going to be doing this with Ogden, right? Response is not going to come out
00:56:49 and sign this, if Stephen Wolfe and Andrew Isker and C.J. Engel and Brian Sauve and Eric Kahn,
00:56:58 and we're already in communication. We're aware of it. It was leaked to us a little bit early,
00:57:04 and so we saw it. And so we're already, communication is already underway. Me and
00:57:09 Brian and Eric and Andrew and all the boys, the boys are talking, and we'll read it. But here's
00:57:16 what we will do that I think will be a blessing to the body of Christ at large. It may cause a
00:57:21 division. We'll see. It depends what we ultimately conclude. And we don't have any final conclusions
00:57:27 as of yet. We'll need some time. But this is one thing that I can promise you. What we won't do
00:57:33 is we won't be gay like Al Mohler and Mark Dever. And yes, I think gay is the appropriate word. 1.00
00:57:40 um when they didn't sign the statement on social justice and the gospel they refused to tell people
00:57:47 why right they never told people why i remember i was there in person right because i was pastoring
00:57:52 california at the time this is march 2020 and i was there at shepherd's conference with the
00:57:58 infamous panel it was phil johnson and john mccarthur were on stage and phil johnson was
00:58:04 kind of moderating this conversation and then you know with him and mccarthur you also had
00:58:08 al moeller and lig duncan and uh and mark dever and phil johnson was kind of saying like guys why
00:58:16 you know like i just we don't understand you know the macarthur crew we came out and signed it the
00:58:21 g3 crew we came out and signed it this is an obvious problem uh rising through the ranks even
00:58:28 in reformed churches this wokeness this neo-marxist uh crt wokeness and we both this and al moeller
00:58:36 and Mark Dever and Lig Duncan would not give an answer.
00:58:40 The closest any of them got to giving an answer
00:58:42 was Lig Duncan.
00:58:43 Which was a terrible answer.
00:58:44 Which was a terrible answer,
00:58:45 where he basically said,
00:58:46 well, I need to fold on race 0.99
00:58:48 so that my kids don't become gay. 0.99
00:58:53 And so when I, so like earlier I said, 0.98
00:58:55 like I called them gay. 1.00
00:58:56 Gay is the appropriate word. 1.00
00:58:58 They gave very gay answers. 0.97
00:59:01 And so what they never did is they never told you why. 0.97
00:59:04 The closest they got to saying why they didn't sign it,
00:59:06 is they said, well, I would have worded it differently.
00:59:09 Let me say this.
00:59:10 I've never heard anyone ever say anything in my life
00:59:14 that I would not have worded differently.
00:59:17 Everybody, you know how many times I've been told
00:59:19 that people will have some kind of complaint
00:59:22 with something I said in the sermon or something.
00:59:24 And I'll just keep asking questions
00:59:26 and trying to, what's the problem here?
00:59:28 What's the real problem here?
00:59:29 And they don't oftentimes have any real substance
00:59:32 or whatever substance they did have.
00:59:34 I then give an explanation.
00:59:35 I show them in scripture why that's wrong.
00:59:37 So then they get rid of that.
00:59:39 And then what it usually boils down to is always this, but was it necessary?
00:59:43 Or, but your tone, and then we press harder and we press harder.
00:59:46 And then the conversation almost always, 99% of the time ends like this.
00:59:50 They say, well, I wouldn't have said it like that.
00:59:53 Yeah, because you're not me.
00:59:55 I wouldn't say things the way you say them.
00:59:57 You want to say them the way I say them.
00:59:58 Like nobody says anything the way that other people say them.
01:00:01 That's part of what makes us unique.
01:00:02 Of course you want to say it like me. 1.00
01:00:03 That's so stupid. 1.00
01:00:04 So, I will not be Al Mohler gay, Ligon Duncan gay, Mark Dever gay. Me and the Ogden boys and 1.00
01:00:12 Stephen Wolf and Andrew Isker and C.J. Engel and A.D. Robles, all the boys, we will read the
01:00:18 statement. We will read it carefully. We will pray. We'll wait. We'll pray. We'll think. We'll
01:00:24 deliberate. We'll study, looking at scripture, looking at history. We'll talk together, and then
01:00:31 we will come out and we will either sign the statement which is probably unlikely or we will
01:00:37 not sign the statement and in not signing the statement we will produce hours of content
01:00:43 explaining precisely why we're not signing the statement and our answer i guarantee you will not 0.84
01:00:49 be well we wouldn't say it that way because that's a gay effeminate fake answer that's a that's when 0.97
01:00:56 a coward knows that something's true can't blatantly he can't blatantly say that it's not 0.97
01:01:02 true because he knows it's not that it's true but he can't put his name behind something if we don't
01:01:07 sign this statement we will tell you exactly why exactly why um substance not just wording why i
01:01:15 want to say it that way uh we will tell you why the statement is either objectively wrong in its
01:01:21 substance it's actually wrong or we'll sign it right simple as that all right good word just
01:01:29 want to define so we talked about nation it's a people it's a place there is one criticism this
01:01:33 is typically guys farther to our right and they would they would make the argument and there's
01:01:37 good art good justification for from history nation can never be reduced to less than race
01:01:42 and so technically speaking there would be multiple nations within the u.s uh here's the
01:01:46 deal that's a good conversation to have i think we would all at this point too yeah it's possible
01:01:51 At this point, we disagree.
01:01:52 But here's the deal, and here's why Christian nationalism,
01:01:54 we don't just want to be correct in theory and have academic discussions.
01:01:58 We want to win.
01:01:59 Whether we are 5, 10, 11 nations contained here in this continental United States
01:02:04 or one single one with some people that have to go back
01:02:07 because they just got here five minutes ago,
01:02:09 whether it's multiple or one, here's the deal.
01:02:10 We are all under one law, and then those residing in the states are under state law.
01:02:16 Those laws, right now, the short-term goal is for them to be Christian. 0.68
01:02:19 Let me just define nationalism. 0.88
01:02:22 You wouldn't hear nationalism in the Bible.
01:02:24 You wouldn't hear that word.
01:02:25 It's the French Revolution, where the people decided their identity wasn't going to be bound to a monarch,
01:02:30 but they were going to be bound to the national ideals.
01:02:33 This is nationalism.
01:02:34 This is, again, from Stephen Wolf.
01:02:35 He says this.
01:02:36 Nationalism is a totality of national action to procure for itself, that is the nation, both earthly and heavenly good.
01:02:43 Simply put, nation is for itself. 0.75
01:02:45 Now, how does Christian nationalism modify that?
01:02:47 It's not brand new.
01:02:48 it doesn't come in
01:02:49 in a totally different category.
01:02:50 It is nationalism.
01:02:51 It's a nation.
01:02:52 It's for itself, 0.99
01:02:52 but it's Christian.
01:02:54 Christian nationalism,
01:02:55 as defined by Stephen Wolf,
01:02:57 a totality of national action
01:02:58 conducted by a Christian nation
01:03:00 to procure for itself
01:03:02 both earthly and heavenly good
01:03:04 in Christ.
01:03:05 It's the same thing
01:03:06 as the nation looking out for itself.
01:03:07 It always says it's just 0.92
01:03:07 conducted by a Christian nation 0.89
01:03:09 and then at the end,
01:03:10 in Christ.
01:03:11 Exactly.
01:03:12 So, because nations will always,
01:03:14 peoples will always see
01:03:15 they're good.
01:03:16 They want to see their crops flourish.
01:03:17 there's one there's one nation currently that's not yeah right america doesn't but yeah but
01:03:23 nations with a head on their shoulders you would hope um so the christian nation seeks that good
01:03:29 but it does so in christ it says we want these blessings and we want not just earthly but
01:03:34 heavenly blessings and so we do so self-consciously someone put in the comments and it's a great
01:03:38 rebuttal there's christian universities there's christian families there's christian schools
01:03:42 there's christian businesses all of these things can be christian why not i ask you
01:03:47 the nation oh it can be it says we are christian its laws are christian its identity is christian
01:03:53 and even on the protestant thing i don't know what you guys think about this we're not just
01:03:57 anglo-christian we would be anglo-protestant now catholics and eastern orthodox i would
01:04:02 personally say they can stay but here's the deal maybe you don't get a parade down washington dc
01:04:07 with a statute of mary right we're a protestant nation right and even a catholic nation like
01:04:12 italy they could say uh we're not on reformation day gonna have a march for mark luther right
01:04:17 The nation can actually do that. 0.58
01:04:18 Now, Protestantism, we of course believe, is true, and Catholicism has a lot of errors to it.
01:04:24 So it's not about an ultimate true-false thing, but the nation in itself that says we're Protestant, we're Catholic, we're Eastern Orthodox, can then say it will only be public practice exclusively of the Christian religion.
01:04:36 Well, and that's one of the things with Catholicism here in America is that many different historians and even theologians have said that the Catholic priests in America frequently got in trouble with the larger diocese and with the Pope and the Cardinals and the Vatican and all those kinds of things on a regular basis with Catholicism globally because the Catholic priests in America were so Protestantized.
01:05:06 by the larger American hegemony,
01:05:09 which was an Anglo-Protestant,
01:05:10 not Catholic, but Protestant culture.
01:05:13 And so simply by virtue of being
01:05:15 a Catholic priest in America,
01:05:18 they couldn't help but assimilate
01:05:20 to some degree, some fact.
01:05:21 And so even Catholicism in America,
01:05:23 while distinct from Protestantism, 0.53
01:05:26 still kind of like an amoeba absorbed, 0.57
01:05:29 it couldn't help itself, 0.63
01:05:30 but to absorb some of these Protestant virtues
01:05:33 and ways of thinking and stuff like that.
01:05:35 Joel, I've lived in a Catholic South American country.
01:05:38 There you go. 1.00
01:05:38 And it is true.
01:05:40 It's not the same.
01:05:41 I mean, obviously, the fundamental tenets are going to be,
01:05:45 but the practice of it and its assumptions and its cultural,
01:05:49 the way it weaves through the culture is totally different.
01:05:51 Catholicism in America is a little stitious,
01:05:53 but Catholicism elsewhere is superstitious,
01:05:55 as Michael Scott would say.
01:05:58 But yeah, no, you go to Mexico,
01:06:00 and you look at Catholicism in European places,
01:06:03 and you look at it, especially in America,
01:06:05 uh versus like in in mexico it's like um it's very much like if you ever watched the movie coco
01:06:10 right the disney movie like it's you know day of the dead like it's magical mystical superstitious
01:06:16 yeah syncretism yeah it's syncretism with false mexican gods you know and pagan you know so let
01:06:21 me say this too before we'll head to the break for encouragement for some of you that are like 0.90
01:06:25 we've got muslims we've got jews and hindus and all these things here's the deal short-term goal 0.99
01:06:30 christian nation when you establish a christian nation and you say no more mosques no more 0.84
01:06:34 synagogues not no more giant statues in texas not conversion at the at the point of the sword
01:06:38 stephen wolf has a whole chapter on that you can't command the conscience so you're not going
01:06:42 into people's homes holding a gun to them recite the apostle's creed right but you are saying
01:06:46 public worship none of these things are allowed how many somalis that came into minnesota when 0.77
01:06:52 that's done say you know what i think i'm going to go back how many jews if pornographers were 0.86
01:06:58 executed in the town square would pack their bags and head to israel right penalties for usury and 0.51
01:07:03 not every jew not everyone not every jew but um yes uh west you know west saying uh pinpointing 0.92
01:07:11 jews there and saying you know like notice he said one thing for somalians but he chose pornography
01:07:16 as an example when he said jews um yeah that's fair guys that's fair um of course it's not all
01:07:23 jews um but but yes there is i mean you can just look at the books it's on paper the statistics
01:07:31 are there there is an outsized disproportional amount of jews involved uh when it comes to
01:07:38 pornography and so that i i said this on a podcast months ago i think it was the the green green
01:07:45 tavern tavern dragon tavern or something like that green dragon yeah um it's it's the guys with
01:07:50 the sentinel great guys um and and so they they graciously had me on the show and we were talking
01:07:55 And they're like, well, you know, like a Christian, you know, Christian nationalism is, you know, the divide is, if you haven't noticed by now, the divide is getting wider.
01:08:05 So even with the Antioch statement, it's like, well, who's on one side and who's on the other?
01:08:09 Like, okay, well, you know, one side is we're very, very, very concerned about Jews.
01:08:14 And then the other side is, well, we're not so concerned.
01:08:19 We love Jews as we love all people, and we wish them a very pleasant conversion to Christianity. 0.94
01:08:25 But for those who refuse to convert and those who are actively involved in things that are nefarious, like usury or like pornography, then yeah, we would like them to leave our nation because we like our country.
01:08:37 So there's that side. 0.96
01:08:39 And then there's the other side that's, we really, really love Jews.
01:08:44 And so you can look at the distinction there.
01:08:47 But there are always other distinctions.
01:08:49 That's what I like to do when I'm kind of looking at some kind of argument that's happening online.
01:08:53 All right, let's get down to common denominators.
01:08:55 what are other things that separate these two groups well here's another thing that separates
01:08:58 everybody with the antioch statement is a theonomist yeah they're all theonomists whether
01:09:05 it's ezra apologia or moscow they're all og theonomist um but you look at ogden more general
01:09:12 equity some stricter but still under that broad umbrella right um but you look at ogden stephen
01:09:18 wolf andrew isker cj and me um pretty much all of us except for cj and wolf have used
01:09:25 uh the theonomy moniker ogden has uh used that language right um if it was 2020 and 2021 right
01:09:32 um you would be hearing the ogden boys talking about theonomy um andrew isker was a part of
01:09:39 gray friars with doug wilson absolutely you you know he has described himself as a theonomist
01:09:45 i have absolutely described myself as a theonomist you may have noticed over the past year year and
01:09:51 a half. Every time I describe myself as a theonomist, I always take the time to say
01:09:56 general equity, theonomist. I am, in some sense, I'll admit it publicly, I am distancing myself
01:10:05 a little bit. To be fair, Joel, I've been listening to you for a couple of years, and
01:10:09 I've heard general equity come from you almost from the beginning. So you may be more intentional,
01:10:14 but I actually think you're being consistent. Because you're the Bruce Dooney flavor of
01:10:18 theonomy too which he is i wouldn't call myself one anymore but he is he is one of the best 0.98
01:10:23 thinkers really we don't have a great record 50s to the today not a lot of bright brilliant c.s
01:10:30 lewis's uh augustine's calvin's we don't got many rush duny was brilliant and even my disagreements
01:10:36 that i would have with him his application his his interpretation his exegesis his application
01:10:42 to current events was incredible and so i think you're you were drawing a lot from that and rush
01:10:47 junies is awesome yeah and i think that's part of part of what changed my mind was uh reading
01:10:53 stephen wolf and having conversations with him um and then number two was um getting to know
01:11:00 theonomist because when i came into theonomy i you know i read a couple rush junie books i read
01:11:06 greg monson you know and by what standard and and i was like this is great right um and i still
01:11:13 stand by that i really like theonomist the dead ones verse duny too i like the dead theonomist
01:11:18 so much of this comes from he reads van till when he's ministering as an opc minister in a native
01:11:23 american settlement yeah and in the settlement he's seeing rampant alcoholism he's seeing
01:11:28 degeneracy and perversion and so he's seeing all of this and he manages to pick up a copy of
01:11:32 cornelius's van till on christian ethics a book on ethics and he sees the connection of wait we're
01:11:38 lawless we're godless we're wicked we need to return to god's standard so 2020 the reason a
01:11:43 lot of us love theonomy was because again the state got tyrannical and we realized like whoa
01:11:47 the state is under christ and under his moral commands just like any other institution like
01:11:53 the family and everything like that but there's good reason why we saw the need for well we can't
01:11:57 just do this a la carte or shoot from the hip as far as the state there is a standard that god
01:12:02 requires the state to do that's a good right to carry out so my point is you know with this
01:12:07 Antioch statement that just came out. One of the dividing lines, it's like, you know, you're seeing
01:12:11 it coming to head with the issue of the Jews. But under the surface, you're seeing in terms of
01:12:18 theological distinctions, it's kind of theonomy versus Christian nationalism. That's becoming a
01:12:22 bigger divide. At first, it was like, well, we can all do this together. I mean, after all,
01:12:26 Canon, Moscow published, Stephen Wolf, The Case for Christian Nationalism. And so I thought,
01:12:32 you know, Christian nationalism is kind of just like the big banner, and theonomy would be a
01:12:36 subset within that but now it's becoming more and more increasingly two distinct groups and so all
01:12:42 the way back to you know west's comment about the jews uh what i was going to say is you know when i
01:12:46 went on that that uh podcast the green uh dragon tavern or whatever whatever uh it is but the
01:12:52 sentinel guys great guys um when i went on their podcast i said no like um my position would not be
01:13:00 you know, in a Christian nationalist conception, my position would not be that Catholics have to
01:13:07 leave, Jews have to leave, atheists have to leave. No. But what you would do is you would enact
01:13:16 just Christian laws, just Christian laws. So in the public sense, in a legislative sense,
01:13:22 and in terms of public rituals, things that are celebrated, virtues, holidays,
01:13:28 all those kinds of things, the public square, legislatively and culturally, it would all,
01:13:36 it would absolutely, unapologetically play favorites. And there would be one favorite,
01:13:42 but it would be Anglo-Protestants. That would be the favorite. So there would be no public 0.99
01:13:48 Catholic parade, but you could have a public Protestant parade. And there would be no law
01:13:55 that says jews can't live here but what there would be is uh anybody to hold public office
01:14:00 would have to make a christian profession of faith right a christian profession of faith
01:14:05 so not just a 15 minute profession of faith and the profession over time and they would have to
01:14:11 have a track record of it that's right um so um no practicing jew who hasn't converted to 0.51
01:14:18 christianity right uh would be able to serve in public office also you ban porn you ban usury 0.90
01:14:24 um and what would happen is uh jews you can't have political power without recanting repenting 0.79
01:14:33 and converting you can't make money through porn you can't make money through uh usury what would 0.88
01:14:38 happen is it good jews who do exist hear me there are good jews good jews would stay many would 0.67
01:14:46 convert some wouldn't convert but they just say you know what um even as a jew i'd rather be a 0.98
01:14:52 jew in america than a jew in israel yep right which to be honest would probably eventually
01:14:58 lead in their towards their conversion because they'd be like well why is america better than 0.75
01:15:02 israel oh maybe the christian god is the true god blah blah so good jews would stay bad jews would 0.79
01:15:08 leave and that's my concern yep my concern is not that uh no jews live here and no catholics live 0.95
01:15:14 here and no buddhists live here no my concern is um that that there be no quarter for wickedness 0.83
01:15:23 no quarter for wickedness you um no you don't get to be a dual citizen of israel in the united 0.92
01:15:30 states and serve in our federal government or in congress no way right no way and no you don't get 0.88
01:15:36 to do pornography whether you're a jew or whether you're anglo i don't care just it would be
01:15:42 disproportionate the effect it would be and we should acknowledge that but it's across the board 0.56
01:15:48 it affects so what you do is you don't outlaw people you outlaw wickedness but here's the deal
01:15:54 this is where i get in trouble christian nationalism doesn't outlaw people it outlaws
01:16:00 immorality but in outlawing immorality it will affect certain peoples more than others
01:16:07 and that's what i think some of my brothers on the theonomous side of the aisle refused to
01:16:17 acknowledge but that's part of the divide here point like israel was commanded to never forget
01:16:24 some of the things that the amalekites and one of the other tribes had done like there was a
01:16:29 there was an eternal grudge that god put in place because they had done and been more wicked towards 1.00
01:16:35 israel than any other people group like right that's straight out of yep the army and same 0.90
01:16:41 thing baltimore and detroit you need rule of law yeah gangbangers and murderers and rapists 0.73
01:16:45 you need to have as the bible requires public justice after a fair trial that would have a
01:16:50 huge impact just in a year of getting people to see because that's what the law does is it teaches
01:16:55 oh this lifestyle will actually lead to quick severe justice like many people's i believe they
01:17:03 they would go back yeah that's all all we're talking about it's a meritocracy voluntarily
01:17:07 voluntarily yes nobody's rounding them up they're saying deporting all we're talking about is a
01:17:13 meritocracy and then what what wolf is conceptualizing is is a christian meritocracy um and
01:17:19 the beauty of like because people say like well you know like you know some of the race essentialist
01:17:24 and guys who you know they'll get and say like uh well i just don't think that um any black person
01:17:30 could ever xyz i'm like well first that's just wrong like i've talked to vody bacham i've read
01:17:38 thomas soul i've read clarence thomas is single-handedly saving the nation right now
01:17:44 so it's just it's wrong i understand what you're saying from a group dynamic i'm with you i'm not
01:17:49 one of those i'm not joel barry i'm the good joel praise god you know so i'm not joel barry and so
01:17:54 i'm not going to pretend like well clarence thomas and that proves that there's no difference between
01:17:58 white but no there there are differences i wish there weren't i wish there weren't but there are
01:18:03 right there weren't in behavior god did make in terms of behavior yes yes but yeah hold on though
01:18:08 even right now even israel had 12 tribes and they had cultural and even linguistic differences
01:18:14 like there are going to be differences right but like west said that's what i meant is um i wish
01:18:21 there weren't um moral in terms of morality i wish there weren't even in israel that happened
01:18:26 right right and so i believe that number one the deck can be shuffled um so i'm not a fatalistic
01:18:32 guy when uh when i think of when i conceive of race so i i believe there are disparities between
01:18:38 races as it currently stands moral disparities i believe there will always be distinctions
01:18:44 natural distinctions always because that's god's design that's a good thing um
01:18:49 because heaven will be diverse not every nation on the planet here on earth in this temporal life
01:18:57 are supposed to be diverse but heaven will be because it will be composed of different nations
01:19:02 that throughout this gospel age somehow maintain their distinctions that's the only way you get to
01:19:08 the final end game of heaven nation tribe diverse you can't have a diverse heaven if everybody just
01:19:13 folds in and becomes one blob so that that assumes revelation and the final end game of
01:19:21 the diverse heaven nation tribe and tongue assumes that distinctions will be kept and upheld as good
01:19:27 things decided by god now all that said that's natural distinctions right now there are moral
01:19:33 distinctions that i don't believe is is um is etched in the stars and always has to be
01:19:40 that i believe can change um europe can um morally become radically inferior to zambia
01:19:49 morally over time if zambia continues to bow the knee to christ and europe and america continues
01:19:57 to reject christ so that the debt can shuffle in that sense and out of morality when a nation
01:20:04 changes morally i do believe that that also affects other attributes of humanity as well
01:20:11 we've talked about this before the gospel affects everything religion affects everything including
01:20:16 diet and so that gets into things like epigenetics and all these different ideas that
01:20:20 okay what if they bow the knee and you stop being cannibals and you stop eating raw meat you know
01:20:25 or using cow dung instead of actually eating the cow looking at you india you know when you make 0.56
01:20:30 these kinds of changes does that affect somebody's physical being does that affect their health and
01:20:36 and over the course of 10 20 30 generations looking at even a millennia would that affect
01:20:42 not just their physical health but as it's passed down from generation to generation could that
01:20:46 affect even their their whole physical body including their brain and iq right i i believe
01:20:53 that all these kinds of disparities but here's the deal the christian ministers who who are looking
01:21:00 you in the eye right now and saying these disparities don't exist every young man in the 0.71
01:21:06 world can pick up their phone and in 15 seconds can see that the average iq in haiti is 67 right
01:21:13 and any christian minister who denies that will not have any credibility they won't credibility 0.99
01:21:20 but it is a sin to god is because you're a liar manifested reality you're a liar it's not true 0.99
01:21:25 You cannot be a minister of the gospel and be a public liar. 0.98
01:21:30 You're disqualified from ministry, from lying. 0.52
01:21:34 You can't be a liar and be a minister of the gospel.
01:21:38 So we're simply willing over here with Right Response Ministries and other guys like Ogden and guys like,
01:21:45 we're not saying, oh, this is how it is and we like it.
01:21:49 And we're also not saying this is how it is and it always will be.
01:21:53 We're acknowledging all the different disclaimers that I've given, all the caveats, all these
01:21:58 things, but we're also, we want to be one of the very few, and it's sad that it's so
01:22:03 few, but we want to be one of the very few ministries that doesn't talk to you like 1.00
01:22:08 you're stupid. 1.00
01:22:10 We want to talk to you acknowledging that you probably have a smartphone in 15 seconds 1.00
01:22:17 of spare time and uh and if we sit here and lie to your face it's not gonna go well
01:22:25 and and all that establishes in your mind is joel levin can't be trusted so so all that being said
01:22:34 my point is um there are moral disparities there don't have to be and i believe because i'm
01:22:41 post-millennial eventually there won't be eventually i believe all the nations will
01:22:46 flock to Mount Zion, bow the knee to Jesus Christ, and love God's law, and legislate and enact and
01:22:54 enforce God's law. It's like Isaiah 2 talks about. Nations being drawn. Nations, races, peoples,
01:22:59 groups. And if they're all drawn to the law because they're being saved, and then they start
01:23:04 enacting the law, and the law shapes them, it functions as a tutor, it sharpens them, and all
01:23:10 the nations will be moral they will all be more and you won't have a disparity between uh well
01:23:16 this society um based on race is high trust which high trust right is a moral component this society
01:23:24 is high trust this other society of another race is low trust everything even the tables in a park 0.80
01:23:31 have to be chained down to concrete because somebody will pull up a truck and steal them 1.00
01:23:36 um that's that's not just a different different races are different no that's that's objective
01:23:41 that's one is better morally better the other is worse that doesn't mean each and every individual
01:23:47 but speaking in group dynamics on the whole and using general language what i'm saying is that
01:23:54 not only can that change but because i'm post-millennial i believe not only can it change
01:23:59 it will i believe it will change in the meantime though in the meantime one of the things that
01:24:07 it drew me to more of the christian nationalist side of the aisle getting back to you know this
01:24:12 theonomist christian um is i i have always i remember uh even as a kid i couldn't play with
01:24:20 action figures um you know other kids in the neighborhood would want to couldn't do it because
01:24:25 it's not real like i understood i could see the incentive to collecting action figures or something
01:24:32 but i wanted to build a tree house i wanted to jump on the trampoline i wanted to ride bikes
01:24:38 i would i wanted to go down to we lived in a neighborhood that had a river i wanted to ride
01:24:42 bikes down to the river jump in the river i remember we want i wanted to go to the the junk
01:24:46 yard local junkyard and collect big um those big uh drums that hold air and build a raft and do
01:24:54 like a you know tom sawyer thing you know i wanted to do things that were i was not good at pretend
01:24:59 i've never been good at pretending um and and i think that's where i struggle sometimes with my
01:25:07 theonomist brothers and sisters is like i've never been good at pretending um and and that's part of
01:25:14 the appeal with stephen wolf what and how is they pretending stephen wolf ogden these kinds of guys
01:25:23 on the more christian nationalist side of the aisle what i was trying to get to is um they deal
01:25:29 with they deal with the world as it is i see as it actually is not not in hypotheticals not not
01:25:35 what we wish the world was but as the world really is and stephen wolf will be the first one to tell
01:25:41 you like if you talk to him like are you a race essentialist or do you think do you just think 0.76
01:25:46 that uh we should get rid of every person of color and like he'd be the first to tell you
01:25:50 privately or publicly be like no and then you say well then what is your prescription what's your 0.99
01:25:55 advice what should we do and he's like meritocracy and then with his definition of christian nationalism
01:26:01 all the way back to the definitions that wes shared um he would say uh meritocracy and ideally
01:26:07 a christian meritocracy right um because here's the deal so so if if people are saying well there's
01:26:14 iq disparities and blah blah blah i acknowledge that i acknowledge and again it's on the whole
01:26:18 not each and every individual.
01:26:19 C. Thomas Sowell, C. Vodipakum, C. Clarence.
01:26:22 But on the whole, there are disparities.
01:26:27 There are moral disparities right now.
01:26:28 I don't think that'll always be.
01:26:29 There are intellectual disparities.
01:26:31 I think that part of that stems from moral
01:26:32 because like I was saying earlier,
01:26:34 I think that the gospel affects everything.
01:26:36 But here's the deal.
01:26:37 You got to deal with the world as it is today.
01:26:39 You got to have a plan.
01:26:40 I think sometimes the theonomists,
01:26:42 they read Isaiah 2, Isaiah 65,
01:26:44 and they say, here's Z.
01:26:46 It's like, okay, but we're at A.
01:26:48 give me B. Z's great. Give me B. Stephen Wolf is giving us B. And so what Stephen Wolf would say
01:26:56 is, no, you don't need to be an all-white nation. You don't send every person of color away.
01:27:02 What you do is you get back to what we did previously. You get back to a meritocracy.
01:27:07 And then what happens? What happens is that, yeah, to quote something I said that blew up
01:27:13 in the past, and I'm fine with it blowing up again, because it's true. I don't care how many
01:27:17 people attack me. I'm going to say things that are true. So meritocracy. A meritocracy will mean
01:27:24 you have less black doctors than white doctors. One, because the percentage of black America is 1.00
01:27:30 less than the percentage of white America. But I think that it might temporarily, for a while,
01:27:36 even be less than the percentages. So if black America is, let's say, 13% and white America is,
01:27:43 let's say 57 59 percent and that's roughly i don't know what that's there's basically one for
01:27:51 every five black people in america is that about shakes down i think you might end up seeing one
01:27:56 for every seven one black doctor for every seven white doctors well wait a second what are you
01:28:03 getting at joel you know what i'm getting at i don't think it'll always be that way right i don't
01:28:09 But it might be that way for now.
01:28:11 But here's what you don't do.
01:28:13 This is why I get in trouble, because I'm not ambiguous.
01:28:17 Because ambiguity saves you from controversy, but it doesn't help the people of God.
01:28:22 You guys are listening.
01:28:23 You want to learn.
01:28:25 You're like, I don't know what he's saying. 1.00
01:28:28 The blim-blam.
01:28:29 I don't know what that is.
01:28:30 I don't know what he's actually saying.
01:28:31 What is this person saying?
01:28:33 The thing about Joel, you may not like what I say, but you know what I'm saying.
01:28:37 right you know what i'm saying i'm clear this is what i'm saying um if there is a disparity 0.99
01:28:44 in terms of iq the solution is not to say well then people of color don't get to be doctors 0.75
01:28:50 right no what you say is um doctors have to be this good they must be this tall to ride the ride 0.88
01:28:58 you know not you must be this color right no you must be this smart this disciplined
01:29:04 this knowledgeable this skilled to ride the ride this virtuous yeah this virtuous uh-huh amen
01:29:12 and i think that as it stands today with a meritocracy in high level positions politically
01:29:21 and vocationally you will see disparities of people holding those positions today over time
01:29:29 though, by holding to truth and not just kowtowing for people's feelings or white guilt or this or
01:29:36 that, and most importantly, preaching the gospel and nations flocking to Mount Zion and being
01:29:42 changed over generations, I think you'll see less disparities. I think you will. I think you'll still
01:29:48 see natural distinctions, but I think you'll see zero, eventually in the end game, zero moral
01:29:55 disparities and fewer intellectual disparities that's my belief but still cultural distinctions
01:30:03 that's if you want to know joel wevin's views on race there you have it and here's the deal i'm
01:30:09 i'm not trying to toot my own horn but the last thing i'll say here and and all that means that
01:30:13 christian nationalism i think the christian nationalist guys they can have that conversation
01:30:18 in a way that theonomists just are unwilling to and if the theonomist rush duny was willing to
01:30:23 yeah yeah but the modern theonomist he didn't play great with others to be fair if anything
01:30:27 that was his one downfall but he was willing to apply and deal with things as they as they existed
01:30:32 and the theonomist today are unwilling to have to talk about what is they're unwilling to say
01:30:39 okay but like okay um there's some great jews praise god um but disproportionately yeah this
01:30:48 does exist with porn and and so you know and so anyways so i i think um that's if you're wondering
01:30:55 that's part of my gravitation towards ogden um isker wolf some of these guys is um they're not
01:31:03 just saying we're at a and here's z isaiah 65 leopard and the lamb lying down together beating
01:31:10 you know the spears into plowshares and the nation's no longer no war lifespans are elongated
01:31:15 And praise God, I believe all those things.
01:31:18 But what I like about the Christian nationalists
01:31:20 is they're not just saying today and tomorrow, Isaiah 65.
01:31:25 Or sadly, like a lot of theonomists,
01:31:27 today is today and 50,000 years from now,
01:31:30 we'll get Isaiah 65. 0.66
01:31:32 But the Christian nationalists actually want to take
01:31:35 real tangible wins today, today.
01:31:40 And I never played with action figures,
01:31:43 back to what I was saying.
01:31:44 I'm not good at pretending. I've always been more of a realist. And so it appeals to me.
01:31:51 And all that back to, you know, there's my position on race. There's my, you know, I give
01:31:54 you guys, the reason I get in trouble is because I tell you the truth. I tell you what I think
01:32:01 in clear, non-ambiguous language. But here's the thing that you should know about our ministry,
01:32:07 right? Response Ministries, and you should know about me.
01:32:09 um there's nothing else under the surface so so what you hear from me i will tell you what i
01:32:18 actually think and that's why i get in trouble i will say the things that other guys won't say
01:32:22 but here's the deal i'm not winking and nodding i'll say what i actually think
01:32:27 and anything beyond what i've said if i thought it i'd say that too so what you hear is what you
01:32:36 get there there so i don't go any further than what you've heard me publicly say so you can say
01:32:43 well i think that joel really under the surface deep down he's super anti-semitic and he wishes
01:32:49 that all the jews would die but no if i thought that i would say it i can vouch for this we talk
01:32:57 all the time and it's never like we'll say it there and then we'll get here and like oh we
01:33:00 got a button up and not like right we talk about we'll disagree and then we like movies we go to
01:33:06 movies and before during the previews we're always talking and it's like me and west theater get mad
01:33:10 at us and they get mad at us but me and west will be talking before a movie and i'll be telling him
01:33:14 like yeah i think i'm going to say this on the podcast and this is usually how the conversation
01:33:18 goes i'll say i think i'm going to say this this week and west will say probably shouldn't and then
01:33:22 i'll say i think i will and uh and then i end up saying it you know and and it's exactly what we
01:33:27 discussed offline they're like this is why we ended up you know this is why the uh the recorded
01:33:35 zoom call with me and the member in our church and tobias and his elders um this is why it
01:33:41 exonerated me um i don't mind being recorded i actually didn't record it right my member did and
01:33:49 i i wasn't even sure about that um but these things the reason i don't get in trouble is
01:33:58 because this is who i am this is you can you can bug me or my house you know whatever and you'll
01:34:04 hear, you'll just end up hearing an extra episode of Right Response Ministries. It'll be the same
01:34:09 kind of content. This is how I talk with my wife. This is how I talk with my friends. This is what 0.93
01:34:15 I believe. And so anyways, all that being said, yeah, Christian nationalism has appealed to me
01:34:19 more and more because I want to win. I want to make a difference. I don't know how to get from
01:34:26 A to Z. So I need someone who's going to give me B. I think a meritocracy is the way to do it. I
01:34:32 I think particularly a Christian meritocracy,
01:34:35 a society, a nation that morally and also culturally
01:34:40 with customs and celebrations and holidays
01:34:43 and all these things favors an Anglo-Protestant tradition.
01:34:49 And for whatever reason in America,
01:34:51 we have always been the out group.
01:34:53 Every other nation. 1.00
01:34:54 Right, Anglos of their own nation. 1.00
01:34:56 Yes, of our own nation. 0.88
01:34:58 Every other nation, Japan, if you go visit Japan, 0.98
01:35:01 you're the out group. Japanese are the in-group. If you go visit Uganda, every other nation, 1.00
01:35:09 the majority of people there is the in-group. We are the only people who take the majority
01:35:15 population of our nation and say, you're the out-group. And everybody else, we will give 0.99
01:35:22 favors to them. It actually been in America. That's what was so wrong with wokeness. Not only
01:35:28 was it a lie it was the opposite of the truth it tried to say that you somehow benefited by being
01:35:34 white in america that you had privilege when it is actually the opposite the direct opposite of
01:35:40 the truth in america you get more benefits by being anything in everything other than 0.60
01:35:48 anglo-protestant right yeah you have the least benefits the least rewards the least recognition
01:35:56 by being a white christian on average that is our besetting sin is a lack of love for our own
01:36:02 and that's why you see on twitter and it's like i don't understand why they're always arguing
01:36:06 that's why you're going to see us continue to talk about um the order of morris um the the order of
01:36:14 loves um love for your own um that's why you saw me back with the abolitionist um arguments you
01:36:22 know with voting for trump i said i love my already born children more than my enemies unborn
01:36:28 children i love my people i love my people because i'm a christian because i'm a christian
01:36:37 and loving your people does not require you to hate those who are not your people i do not hate
01:36:42 jews i do not hate muslims i do not hate atheists i hate the wicked but as groups it's not i hate 0.59
01:36:51 every single one of these. 0.99
01:36:52 We're supposed to have biblical hate
01:36:53 for the wicked, the evil.
01:36:55 Right, and I want all these people 1.00
01:36:57 to convert to Christianity. 1.00
01:36:59 And those who convert
01:37:00 and have already been here for a while
01:37:03 and not just 15 minutes,
01:37:05 then you can stay.
01:37:06 And those who do not convert,
01:37:08 but they have a heritage, a lineage,
01:37:10 and have been here for a while,
01:37:12 but they don't convert,
01:37:13 but they're willing to recognize
01:37:14 that this is an Anglo-Protestant nation,
01:37:17 a Christian nation,
01:37:18 and play by those rules 0.98
01:37:19 and don't expect any favors,
01:37:21 then you also can stay.
01:37:24 But any who want to stay and get special privileges
01:37:27 and be favored while, meanwhile,
01:37:33 actively trying to destroy our nation 0.89
01:37:36 and use us as a tax farm to get billions to Ukraine 0.60
01:37:39 or billions to Israel 0.55
01:37:41 or flood everybody's phone with pornography, 0.78
01:37:46 then, yeah, you can get the hell out of our country.
01:37:50 Amen. 0.53
01:37:50 Get out.
01:37:52 No, you don't belong here. 0.98
01:37:54 So, yeah, that's, I don't know if that's theonomy or Christian nationalism or both. 0.83
01:37:59 But whatever that is, that's my position.
01:38:02 That's the next step.
01:38:03 All right.
01:38:03 Let's hit our last commercial break.
01:38:04 I saw a great question on meritocracy.
01:38:06 So we'll hit that.
01:38:06 Maybe hit any burning questions in the chat.
01:38:08 That'll be it.
01:38:09 All right.
01:38:10 All right.
01:38:11 That's it, guys.
01:38:11 I tried to warn you.
01:38:13 The time has finally arrived.
01:38:14 Our early bird pricing is gone.
01:38:17 But don't despair.
01:38:18 We've gone above and beyond to make this conference affordable to all.
01:38:23 So even now, it's only $170 for an adult.
01:38:26 It's cheap for teenagers and free for kids.
01:38:29 What am I talking about?
01:38:30 Well, I'm talking about the Christ is King Conference, How to Defeat Trash World.
01:38:34 It's happening April 3rd, 4th, and 5th, the year of our Lord, 2025.
01:38:40 That's a Thursday, Friday, Saturday, three full days, jam-packed with eight main sessions,
01:38:45 three panels, and an extraordinarily based lineup of speakers.
01:38:50 We've got Steve Dace, Orrin McIntyre, Andrew Isker, David Reese, Stephen Wolfe, Eric Kahn,
01:38:56 John Harris, Aidy Robles, Dan Burkholder, Ben Garrett, Dusty Devers, the Christian Prince himself,
01:39:03 and yours truly, Joel Webbett.
01:39:05 Sign up today.
01:39:07 Don't miss this conference.
01:39:08 And I'll give you a little bit of a secret here.
01:39:10 there's a couple more potential speakers in the wings haven't completely confirmed yet so i cannot
01:39:16 disclose but i'll say this if it happens it's going to blow your mind so register at right
01:39:22 response conference.com again that's right response conference.com register today are you
01:39:28 a christian struggling to find companies that align with your values and beliefs well then
01:39:33 squirrely joe's has you covered for all your coffee needs all of their coffee is hand selected and
01:39:38 roasted fresh every day by a family of fellow believers. Try them out and you'll savor exceptional
01:39:45 coffee while knowing that your investment supports a company committed to following God's teachings
01:39:51 and upholding truth and righteousness, ensuring that your hard-earned money contributes to the
01:39:57 growth of God's kingdom. Stop giving your hard-earned dollars to pagans who support evil.
01:40:02 Right Response listeners have access to an exclusive deal.
01:40:06 Your first bag of coffee is free.
01:40:09 All you have to do is cover the shipping.
01:40:11 So head on over to squirrelyjoes.com forward slash Right Response.
01:40:16 Again, that's squirrelyjoes.com forward slash Right Response
01:40:20 to claim your first free bag of coffee today. 0.97
01:40:25 Visit thewordsoap.com today.
01:40:27 Again, that's thewordsoap.com. 0.89
01:40:30 Everyone needs soap. 1.00
01:40:32 So wash yourself in the word.
01:40:38 All right, welcome back.
01:40:40 We had some good questions.
01:40:41 I'm going to start with this one.
01:40:43 This is from Terry, if you could pull it up, Nate.
01:40:46 Scott Terry.
01:40:46 Scott Terry. 1.00
01:40:47 Can a meritocracy be Christian?
01:40:49 And he followed up, my parents, for example, may not be the best parents.
01:40:53 I not have the most merit, but I love them anyway.
01:40:56 So what is the extent of the range of meritocracy?
01:40:59 We're talking in every single thing.
01:41:00 i've thought about this and uh that's where natural affection i think is helpful like your
01:41:04 kids objectively speaking i love you love your kids but whoever you are your kids objectively
01:41:10 are not perhaps the the best students the best athletes like we talk about viewing reality as it
01:41:16 is it's objectively true my son is not the tallest but because he's tied to me and he's my son and i
01:41:22 love him it's not a question of merit in that private relationship same with my town i love
01:41:27 georgetown is it literally the best town in the united states right it is debatable it is pretty
01:41:34 awesome probably probably not we have a confederate statue at the courthouse that is true yes it looks
01:41:41 like a hallmark movie downtown if you're thinking of moving to georgetown it's quaint it's it's
01:41:46 quintessential texas yeah as soon as they stop tens of thousands of people from moving here
01:41:51 not even immigration just generally like people are flocking to georgetown a couple years ago
01:41:55 because that's an awesome town town in america but all that being said natural affections those
01:41:59 are not meritocracy meritorious yeah when that when the kid buys the mug for his dad that says
01:42:04 world's greatest dad he's not lying there's there's a natural affection there but in public
01:42:10 i think the best distinction would be public distinctions you don't get to be mayor because
01:42:14 you're from a discriminated class because you're native american used to live in this land
01:42:17 the most qualified right and virtuous person should be mayor pastor same thing it's not we
01:42:24 hand out participation trophies like he tried really hard at preaching he's got a lot of heart
01:42:27 no the most qualified godly man should be a pastor should be the lead pastor senior pastor
01:42:32 whatever terminology you want to use in that public position the church so privately with
01:42:37 your family and natural relationships that's not where you apply the meritocracy i love my most
01:42:41 talented kid the most but publicly in jobs in positions of office in the state and judges
01:42:48 that's where you say that's what i was talking about and that's why i use doctors as an example
01:42:51 yep exactly like we moved away from a meritocracy i think if we move and i the only reason i was
01:42:57 saying is because i've heard some guys say that like well the solution is um it's genetics it's
01:43:02 race for vocation for positions right like for and and i would just say no the solution is a
01:43:08 meritocracy well that's the exact opposite may the best man the opposite right now it is race
01:43:13 red and yellow black and white right right now they're precious in the sight like if you're an
01:43:17 indian doctor and you're good great yeah great but that said also um in terms of ethnicity or race
01:43:27 race you can be indian um but you need to um if you live here in america and you're and you're
01:43:35 smart and gifted be a doctor great um but also you should convert to christianity
01:43:42 and uh and you should love america yep and name your kids american name your kids american names
01:43:49 um like that whole clip with the uh you know given the choice between a white and black doctor
01:43:54 but my whole point in that was that i would choose a white doctor if both were complete strangers if
01:43:59 i didn't know if you had no other if i had yeah um if i knew the black guy like he was a member
01:44:04 of my church and i knew that like i knew his scores on his sats and how he did in med school
01:44:08 and all that kind of stuff there's a guy here in georgetown he goes to an anglican church that
01:44:11 we've met before a black man yeah incredible i would go and see sharp dude 100 absolutely yep
01:44:15 absolutely so i wasn't talking about him but i'm saying if there's two strangers one is a white guy
01:44:20 i don't know from adam and one is a black guy i don't know from adam i'm going to choose the white
01:44:24 guy and here's my point because we as a country have moved away from a meritocracy right with a
01:44:30 meritocracy you don't actually have to uh have that debate you wouldn't have to have that debate
01:44:35 if we still had a meritocracy that's my point so a meritocracy that's you know when you're thinking
01:44:40 a to z that's a good a to b that's a good b it's all right first let's re-establish a meritocracy
01:44:46 next what what steven wolf is saying let's make it a christian meritocracy and all all i mean by
01:44:52 that a christian meritocracy is just adding the christian component to the meritocracy so
01:44:57 you wouldn't necessarily add that for every single vocation under the sun it wouldn't be like hey
01:45:02 we need him to be a gifted plumber and has he memorized the book of matthew right like but
01:45:07 what i am saying is especially for um public positions of of you know of office you know
01:45:14 governmental office um then yes they need to be may the best man win in terms of merit and skill
01:45:20 and knowledge and intellect and also that dude needs to be a christian um and in terms of a
01:45:27 christian meritocracy may the best christian win a guy who's been a christian for two weeks
01:45:32 should lose to the guy who's been a christian and his dad and his grandpa right that's what i'm
01:45:37 saying by christian meritocracy i was in pre-med for a little bit in college really like should i
01:45:41 go to medical school and my goodness the people of other races the the benefit and the leg up they
01:45:48 got compared to white men compared to white men i mean as a white man you practically had to have
01:45:54 landed on the moon to have a shot i'm like an average school but i mean there's people with
01:45:58 bad mcat scores bad um bad grades which all those are proxies for intellectual capacity right with
01:46:05 terrible grades that were they were being welcomed to the top medical schools and they did study
01:46:09 obviously and everything like that but but just the the disparity was huge we completely uh inverted
01:46:15 it there's another question this one was on theonomist i don't know if it was striker who
01:46:20 said it yeah it's all right nate the question basically was we talk about some of the theonists
01:46:28 passed a striker and he's been posting that are uh they're not willing to go there who are the
01:46:33 names who are there oh like bad the honor i think you just passed it so when you say like yeah i
01:46:39 might some of my the honest brothers i can't get behind uh they don't have good answers to these
01:46:43 questions they're living who are we talking about yeah yeah okay so striker he says i'm just wondering
01:46:47 who are these guys uh who these guys are that joel is describing because it sounds like a bunch
01:46:52 of boomers that aren't actually theonomist but i don't know um john andrew reasoner i'll give one
01:46:59 john andrew reasoner would be an example of a bad theonomist yep theonomist and committed to it but
01:47:05 his application of it here and now and the current like situation we've talked about with the
01:47:09 different peoples in america terrible let's let's i i could say it like this if you're a theonomist
01:47:15 and you find yourself retweeting um uh kevin young oh yeah not kevin young kevin young kevin young 0.98
01:47:25 who is a heretic, gay-affirming. 0.96
01:47:28 So if you find yourself as a theonomist 0.97
01:47:30 retweeting Kevin Young
01:47:32 positively just because he said
01:47:35 something negative about Stephen Wolfe
01:47:37 and you can't help yourself
01:47:38 but hate Stephen Wolfe
01:47:39 and so you'd rather side 0.98
01:47:41 with a guy who affirms sodomites
01:47:44 than Stephen Wolfe.
01:47:47 Then you might be a bad theonomist.
01:47:49 If you're that same theonomist
01:47:51 and you also find yourself
01:47:52 retweeting Mike Cosper
01:47:53 you know or you find yourself um siding with mike pence and saying that jd vance is a shame 0.99
01:48:00 then you're a bad theonomist and uh could the same guy be so dumb as to do all three of those 0.74
01:48:08 examples that i just gave yes his name is david bonson so then why does he like what yeah why is 0.98
01:48:16 he a big name well one because his dad was great and the apple sadly fell far from the tree and two
01:48:22 um he's rich yeah but we don't get money from david bonson so i can say that yeah next week
01:48:32 you see a bonson group ad the content might be a little different there's uh p andrew sandlin
01:48:37 counter signals uh being physically fit and for your body a lot a lot which is that's been a
01:48:42 hard one for me because i i there was some stuff earlier as i was moving out of disby whatever that
01:48:48 was super helpful from him just personally and he advocates for if not saying like he'd be happy for
01:48:53 his daughter to serve as a police officer most certainly saying that women could serve could
01:48:57 perfectly fit in that role that is a great example she does serve as a police officer it's a great 0.96
01:49:03 example of not being able to see rights and right what's right in front of your eyes god designed 0.91
01:49:07 men yeah force and enforcement and protection you know did not design women for that scripture's
01:49:13 clear about that nature's clear about that and it's only possible if you take both eyes you cover 0.96
01:49:17 them you could ever come to the conclusion that it's a perfectly valid profession for a woman
01:49:20 full-time just be carrying a gun enforcing the law um yeah so that that would be another example
01:49:27 i wouldn't people asked about david reese if you're going after david reese with that i love
01:49:31 david reese and and one of the reasons i love david reese is um and since i mentioned this
01:49:36 about david bonson just in in the spirit of being forthright and honest david reese you know i said
01:49:41 David Bonson doesn't support our ministry.
01:49:45 David Reese does.
01:49:45 Yeah, he does.
01:49:46 He's one of our sponsors on our,
01:49:48 you guys have seen his ads,
01:49:50 Reese Fund and Armored Republic.
01:49:53 And so he has been generous
01:49:54 and he does support our ministry.
01:49:57 But it's not just that.
01:49:59 If it was just that,
01:50:01 but he was, you know,
01:50:04 had the same takes as David Bonson,
01:50:06 then it just, it wouldn't work.
01:50:07 And we just have to say no
01:50:09 and trust the Lord that he provide.
01:50:11 financially through another source um but the reason why i love uh david reese and we're
01:50:17 becoming good friends is um because he in my experience has been the most um humble and honest
01:50:25 of any of the theonomists that i've met or or you know um conversed with that um whether it's race
01:50:34 like i had a phone call with him last week and i said hey you should know you know i like you you've
01:50:40 seen since you've partnered with me i've been in like 17 controversies you know in the last month
01:50:45 and um and like with each one you know so like uh with the whole thing about the jews you know
01:50:52 when tobias uh dropped his video on eschatology matters and praise god that eschatology matters
01:50:58 when they saw the zoom call and listened to that they took it down and realized that it was filled
01:51:02 with slanders and lies um and they they did the right thing but um but that was a big ordeal and
01:51:08 a lot of people were trying to cancel me and uh david reese could have easily i mean most guys
01:51:14 would just they would they would just click into self-preservation mode that's just that's what you
01:51:18 do like why why um why commit suicide public suicide you know like just you know joel is
01:51:25 um a landmine and i i'm just gonna back away you know but he didn't he just he did what nobody
01:51:33 else has done like he called me he called me um that's not fair i shouldn't say nobody else has
01:51:41 done um james white did eventually call me and we had a good conversation and and i appreciate that
01:51:48 we still disagree there's still probably going to be some some beef here and there back and forth
01:51:54 i wish there wasn't i love james white but but he did actually reach out to me he did call me
01:51:59 it was a couple weeks after the fact i wish it had been sooner but he did and he was kind he was
01:52:05 reasonable i'd like to see some more things publicly but he was kind and i appreciate that
01:52:11 uh doug wilson i called him and he was kind so there were two guys that um that there were phone
01:52:18 calls um with doug wilson and james white still some some differences and disagreements but um
01:52:25 but they were both kind um but um but but david just he james white and doug make a little bit
01:52:35 more sense because they shared the tobias video i would argue there was some obligation
01:52:39 you know and and preferably a call maybe before you know sharing the video um but but in the case
01:52:47 of uh david reese he didn't share the video he didn't he didn't owe me he didn't he didn't mess
01:52:53 up he didn't sin against me um and he's giving our ministry money to promote to promote his you
01:53:00 know the reese fund and armored republic and uh so he could have just backed out like we we benefit
01:53:07 more with this this relationship i would argue we benefit more um from david reese and he benefits
01:53:12 from us i want it to be a symbiotic you know mutual like so i'm looking for ways um to to
01:53:19 give as much benefit as I can to that good Christian man as he deserves. And so I'm working
01:53:26 on that because I want it to be a mutual relationship. And I don't want... Because
01:53:29 sometimes guys like David Reese, I'll be honest, he probably would never say this because he's a
01:53:37 good man. But I bet you, if I had to guess, I bet you most of his relationships, it's people who
01:53:43 take more than they give to him. Yeah. When you're at that position.
01:53:46 Yeah, he's rich, he's successful, he's smart, and he's generous. And I bet he gets taken
01:53:55 advantage of. And I'd like for our ministry not to be a ministry that takes advantage of David
01:54:00 Reese. But all that being said, my point is, so David Reese is an example on the positive
01:54:05 side of the aisle that I think very highly of. We do have some differences, but we have a lot
01:54:10 in common and um but so much of it i i think like and this is why and i know it's like it gets old
01:54:17 it's like post-war consensus you're made up word you know or whatever like um i don't know how to
01:54:22 describe i don't know how to describe it because it's not it's not just on the basis of the
01:54:29 doctrinal differences right there's something else going on there there really is and i don't know
01:54:36 how exactly to make it tangible and how to describe it but there's an ethos there's a there's a vibe
01:54:42 there's um a sentiment there's it's it's it's not just theological it's political and cultural
01:54:50 and psychological i think it's generational i think that's a big part i think it's a generational
01:54:56 divide because at the end of the day it's not just like uh well the the the actual tenets of
01:55:02 of the theological tenets of theonomy are um wholly incompatible with um with christian
01:55:10 nationalism and it's really that's not what it is and i think that's why on the face of it just
01:55:16 looking at it theologically that's why canon i was perfectly comfortable publishing steven wolf's
01:55:20 book but then as time goes on now we're two years in it feels like this big divide and i don't think
01:55:26 it's the substantive tenets of the theological differences. I think it's more than that. It's
01:55:33 this intangible, whether you call it the post-war consensus or whatever, but David Rees doesn't have
01:55:39 it. He doesn't have it as much. Yes, he is a theonomist, and sometimes I think, like many
01:55:44 theonomists, he's overly idealistic, more idealistic than I would be willing to be. I'm
01:55:48 probably more of a realist, and he's more of an idealist. And when it comes to, when the rubber
01:55:56 meets the road and me and him are arguing about something charitably as friends but we're arguing
01:56:00 about i remember there was one moment we were sitting around a fire at the ogden conference
01:56:04 and he was saying well i think this could happen and this can and i remember i i objected and i
01:56:09 said david but from a practical standpoint what would be the incentive i don't think people i
01:56:14 think you may be right but i don't think you're going to be able to get enough people on your
01:56:17 side in order practically to to get the victory to get the substantive substantial win that you
01:56:23 need to get in order for that idea to work i said like what is uh what is going to win people over
01:56:28 and i remember his answer and a lot of people you know it would be a jesus juke with david i don't
01:56:33 think it's a jesus juke i think i genuinely believe he means it and he looked at me and he
01:56:37 like leaned forward in his in his chair and he said uh joel what's going to incentivize them
01:56:42 is the spirit of god that moves the hearts of men to virtue and i was just like i was like well
01:56:49 well damn yeah that's convicting you know but that i can't argue with you that falls in line
01:56:54 with my theory and my theory is um theonomists for a long time it's kind of like the republican 0.97
01:57:01 party i'm not saying they're like the republicans i'm i'm telling a side story to illustrate the
01:57:06 point when newt gingrich came in as a as a young congressman he asked the republican minority
01:57:15 leader um he said what's the plan for us to take over and get and get power and the minority leader
01:57:21 said to him there is no plan we're the minority and we're pretty happy doing that and we just we
01:57:27 give them some concessions they throw us some concessions and he from that you know whatever
01:57:31 you think of newt greenrich he decided from that point on i'm taking over the republican party and
01:57:35 we're going to win and you know what they did have some victories under his leadership the point is
01:57:39 I think that there's a sentiment where theonomists have had to propose ideals from the Bible that had no chance of getting traction in the practical world, in the world that they lived in, that you kind of resign yourself to, well, this is just an idea out there.
01:57:57 And I think the Christian nationalists are willing to say, and maybe to their detriment,
01:58:02 maybe not, this goes to the abolition versus non-abolition argument, we are willing to
01:58:07 deal with reality.
01:58:07 And reality means maybe not having the ideal situation right away, but we're willing to
01:58:11 work towards that as a step towards another one.
01:58:13 And part of it is we're willing to deal with reality, but the criticism is dealing with
01:58:19 reality means making perceived or real compromises on the ultimate good to make an advance in
01:58:25 that direction.
01:58:26 Right.
01:58:27 that's well said if you're training for a marathon imagine you hurt yourself you have to do surgery
01:58:31 you have to take eight weeks off you could think like wait this is so counterproductive eight weeks
01:58:35 off the training yeah i'm preparing to run this thing i can't take that time off i need to be out
01:58:39 there but you can have temporary setbacks to achieve a long-term goal and it's not the same
01:58:44 as a moral compromise it's not the same as i'll cheat on my wife just once that's moral and that's
01:58:49 a compromise and that's off limits but politics is the art of the possible what's the goal how do i
01:58:54 practically function to get there and does it take
01:58:56 going the long way around on this one
01:58:58 does it take a setback here that's the difference
01:59:01 well said
01:59:02 were there any other questions that we
01:59:04 had that we wanted to get to
01:59:06 oh
01:59:08 I answered someone
01:59:10 I just actually messaged someone
01:59:12 an answer to this the other day actually they were
01:59:14 Slavic and they asked about this
01:59:16 the question was in last week's chat too
01:59:18 yes that's who I messaged
01:59:19 I'm an American with a Slavic heritage and I love both America
01:59:22 and the land of my grandparents I've been wondering
01:59:24 about how i can honor my fathers and be an american first any pointers uh it and probably
01:59:29 the tension is how do i you know the language the heritage the customs the habits the familiarity
01:59:34 that i have with my parents my grandparents how do i then bridge that and i think what you do is
01:59:38 you decide that um as far as it goes honoring your parents absolutely attend any type of dinner do
01:59:44 any type of custom that honors them and they agree with but then in your own home as you're going
01:59:48 forward making it distinctly american so in your home maybe the only language spoken is english
01:59:53 You could teach your children maybe, maybe you're bilingual, you know a certain language,
01:59:58 you know Spanish, you could teach it to them, they could continue it, but you make the conscious
02:00:01 choice and say, well, no, actually, we're American, and we speak English, not forcing 0.97
02:00:06 on your parents, not telling them, I'm not going to speak this language around here,
02:00:09 we only want to hear this, but saying, at this point, as far as I'm concerned, and what
02:00:13 I'm passing down to the next generation, it's going to be distinctly American, it's going
02:00:17 to be the language, it's going to be the holidays, it's going to be the values, it's going to
02:00:20 be the vacations instead of vacationing back to maybe this land that we came from we vacation to
02:00:25 another part of the united states or in 2025 you go to iowa and the great american fair right making
02:00:30 the choice not necessarily impressing on your parents and dishonoring them because they love
02:00:35 their land and they love their heritage not dishonoring them but at the same time not
02:00:39 continuing and making a future generation kind of make that break and really commit to assimilating
02:00:43 i would tell esteeming stories of your parents um things that make your children's grandparents
02:00:49 look honorable and tell stories about how they were honorable and um how they you know maybe
02:00:55 maybe part of their story was they put money aside or worked extra hard so that the move
02:01:00 could be made for a lady you know you you honor the things that you can honor yep um and they're
02:01:04 all true yeah yeah praise god for real real quick uh cam cameron stevenson said um thanks striker
02:01:11 they were going back and forth in the chat i thought joel was more of a specific uh i think
02:01:16 special revelation guy than a natural law guy um at least that's what i heard him saying back in
02:01:22 2021 that's true um i guess his position has shifted a bit so i would say on that like that's
02:01:28 why i still am willing to wear the the moniker of general equity theonomist um yeah i think
02:01:34 wherever uh wherever scripture speaks then you go with scripture um so that hasn't changed for me
02:01:41 um cameron stevenson that's a good good question um i'm i'm always going to side with special
02:01:47 revelation um wherever the bible speaks clearly you know i've used like the analogy like
02:01:53 i i would rather use exodus 20 than you know the migration of certain you know patterns of deer
02:01:59 um like i you know like and sabbath laws yeah like and one of the things to consider when when
02:02:05 it comes to natural revelation natural revelation is god speaking um but the bible is infallible
02:02:11 and um and natural revelation you have to remember that nature itself is under a curse
02:02:17 so nature um is not totally destroyed uh by sin um it still remains intact in the same way that
02:02:26 human beings a vestige if it was totally destroyed then humans would no longer maintain the image of
02:02:31 god the imago dei the reason why the image of god we theologically speaking would say it's been
02:02:36 tarnished by sin right um but a vestige of the image of god remains intact even for uh for all
02:02:43 people even for the unregenerate so every time a child is knit together by god in their mother's
02:02:47 womb um they they bear the image of god from from the womb and uh so the image of god uh remains
02:02:55 despite the fall, despite living in a post-lapsarian world, so nature does still speak
02:03:01 true things about God and about the world that he's made and about human nature and about God's
02:03:07 design and purpose for human beings and how to flourish and all those things. But nature, it
02:03:15 speaks um it speaks truthfully but um there is uh sometimes both an ambiguity uh that exists within
02:03:26 natural revelation um and that's not to say that you know we we hold to the perspicuity of scripture
02:03:31 which means clarity not all scripture we believe scripture is sufficiently clear not all passages
02:03:37 of scripture are um equally clear so there are some passages of scripture that are more difficult
02:03:42 to understand, but even the most difficult passages of Scripture when it comes to perspicuity
02:03:47 and understanding them and interpreting them rightly, I think ours still maintain more clarity
02:03:52 than natural revelation as a whole. So natural revelation speaks truthfully about God, even
02:03:59 though nature itself is under a curse. But I don't believe it speaks with the same degree of clarity
02:04:04 as special revelation. And because of the curse of sin, there are certain points and certain moments
02:04:10 and certain aspects of nature that can steer us,
02:04:13 man's reason, unregenerated,
02:04:15 can steer us in the wrong direction.
02:04:17 So as a general equity theonomist,
02:04:19 I'm always going to prefer special revelation
02:04:21 to natural revelation.
02:04:23 But my point in being more sympathetic
02:04:26 towards natural law and embracing natural law,
02:04:29 probably to a larger degree than I had in the past,
02:04:31 is simply coming to the point
02:04:33 and seeing that within special revelation,
02:04:36 there are certain things that are just,
02:04:37 they remain unsaid.
02:04:38 So like immigration, for instance, I believe from special revelation, we can ascertain that a Christian nation should require a Christian profession.
02:04:49 It should require that the people actually want to be, they're Christian, they want to be American, they want to hold, you know, your people shall be my people.
02:04:58 Your God, my God.
02:05:00 I'm going to love Yahweh, and I'm also going to love Israel. 0.99
02:05:03 I'm saying goodbye to false pagan gods. 1.00
02:05:06 I'm not bringing them with me. 0.99
02:05:07 But I'm also saying goodbye to my people, the Moabites, and I'm actually going to be an Israelite. 0.97
02:05:14 And my grandchildren will experience the full benefits of having assimilated over generations of being full Israelites.
02:05:20 I'm thinking of Ruth. 0.98
02:05:22 So Christian profession would be necessary for immigration, desiring to actually hold to America's history and its customs and its culture and its values. 1.00
02:05:31 Wanting to be an American would be necessary for immigrating here. 1.00
02:05:34 doing it legally going through legal channels that would be necessary abolishing within a 0.60
02:05:41 theonomic concession and looking at special revelation you can make an argument for abolishing
02:05:44 the welfare state and so that would get rid of the financial incentives of we want to just free
02:05:50 money and a handout so you can do all those things but here's the deal people don't just
02:05:55 move to america because they want free money it is it is entirely possible that if america really
02:06:01 became the the full ideal christian nation that it could be and that i believe eventually it will
02:06:06 be um what it what if in in the nations flocking to mount zion all the nations being saved in this
02:06:11 great post-millennial hope what if america beats the rest of the nations by a thousand years right
02:06:16 and and america doesn't have welfare anymore but but what it does have is a christian nation is
02:06:21 safety it has safety uh much lower levels of crime and the and so you don't come and get a free check
02:06:26 But what you do get is economic opportunity for a fair wage and safety from mobs and gangs and violence and war and all these things.
02:06:34 Well, it would still be appealing. 0.94
02:06:36 So then what happens if America Christianizes a thousand years before all the other nations on the planet? 0.72
02:06:41 And what happens in that conception, which is possible if four billion people, half the planet, wants to move to America and they make a Christian profession and they're willing to go through legal channels and they're willing to get a job and try to work hard.
02:06:54 and they want to start loving apple pie
02:06:56 and George Washington and the heritage
02:06:58 and forsaking their people,
02:06:59 your people will now be my people, 0.98
02:07:01 your God, my God,
02:07:01 but four billion people want to do it.
02:07:04 The theonomist doesn't have a mechanism to say no.
02:07:07 The natural law guy can say,
02:07:09 no, nature just doesn't allow for four billion people
02:07:12 to immigrate to one country.
02:07:14 And the Bible doesn't speak to that one way or the other.
02:07:18 The Bible does, it does speak to you. 0.83
02:07:22 Well, you need to, if you're going to be in Israel,
02:07:23 don't know false gods so you need to be a christian and you need to come legally and the bible speaks
02:07:27 to all that and you need to work hard and all those kinds of things and not get a handout not 0.84
02:07:31 get welfare the bible does speak to all those things and it's true that by getting rid of the
02:07:35 welfare state and requiring a christian profession that that would mitigate the numbers but if
02:07:39 america on on the other hand i think it would also bolster the numbers of people who want to come
02:07:43 because it would be safe there's less crime and there's it would flourish economically we would
02:07:49 be rich and safe rich and safe are always those are going to be two powerful incentives always
02:07:55 throughout all the time for other people to want in it's like you don't get free money but you can
02:08:00 work hard and get a job and make 10 times what you're making there and uh nobody's going to steal
02:08:05 it from you and there's not violence and mobs and um that is going to be incentivizing to the whole
02:08:12 world so you're never going to get rid those things i think the theonomist sometimes is over
02:08:17 overly idealistic and wants to say, if we had these things, then that would solve all of our
02:08:22 immigration problems. I don't think it would. I actually think that welfare, initially, on the 0.95
02:08:28 front end, less people would want to come here. On the back end, over time, America, by doing
02:08:33 righteous things, would flourish, and you'd actually even have more people want to come to
02:08:37 America. And you can't have four billion people come. You just can't. You have to be able to say
02:08:42 no. And theonomists have yet to give me a chapter and verse for how I can say no. But I know from
02:08:51 nature and reason you have to be able to say no. So that to me is not, so now I'm a natural law
02:08:58 guy, not a general equity guy. No, general equity doesn't speak to it one way or the other. So I'm
02:09:03 a guy who's always going to side with special revelation when special revelation speaks to
02:09:06 something. And when it doesn't, I'm going to appeal to nature and reason. And to be fair to the natural
02:09:11 law guys that we're talking about we're not talking 1700s enlightenment natural law i mean
02:09:16 stephen wolfe himself has a whole section on sabbath laws and blasphemy laws that in they're
02:09:21 not like the bible has no the the founders of america and the the common law of england was
02:09:27 quoting the old testament as its case law like like even those who at that time would would not
02:09:33 have known the term theonomy they would have said we look at nature and we look at god's book
02:09:36 they would have been some fusion of the two like like these are christian natural law
02:09:42 um practitioners or believers and and there's really a lot of overlap um that's why i think
02:09:49 joel you've been able to to fit comfortably as a generally equity general equity equity
02:09:55 theonomist who looks to the clarity of the word and also says we're not going to be dumb yeah
02:10:02 So I don't find attention yet.
02:10:04 I've had plenty of theonomists tell me that there must be attention
02:10:07 and that I should feel the tension.
02:10:09 Somewhere.
02:10:09 But I don't feel the tension,
02:10:12 and I feel perfectly comfortable in this space
02:10:15 that providentially God has carved out for me.
02:10:17 And so for the foreseeable future, I plan to remain in this space.
02:10:22 And again, back to names and ministries,
02:10:25 In this space, I have been permitted to minister alongside Ogden and Stephen Wolf and Isker and CJ and a whole host of individuals on one side of the aisle.
02:10:39 And yet I have been increasingly less warmly invited on the theonomist side of the aisle.
02:10:47 David Reese would be an exception, but there are others on the theonomist side of the aisle.
02:10:52 As I've kind of become more comfortable in this position and more clear in my views,
02:10:58 there's one side of the aisle that says, one of us, one of you, and is willing to welcome me
02:11:07 warmly in. And then there's another side of the aisle that has felt by the day increasingly
02:11:14 further away and so i wish that wasn't the case i wish we could all just get along and be friends
02:11:20 and maybe one day by god's grace there'll be you know some robust reconciliation and and maybe that
02:11:26 we can't um but in the meantime right now uh the muscular wing of the reformed world
02:11:32 um christian nationalist and theonomist are fractured um it's it's fractured and i i don't
02:11:40 think it's really i could be wrong but i don't think it's ultimately on the merits of the actual
02:11:44 substantive theological distinctions.
02:11:46 I think it's more of a generational divide
02:11:49 and it's some of the intangibles.
02:11:51 And I think the post-war consensus
02:11:52 actually is a good descriptor for explaining why,
02:11:56 as much as people think they don't like it.
02:12:00 So, all right.
02:12:01 Great.
02:12:03 Thanks, everyone, for tuning in.
02:12:04 Yeah, thanks for tuning in.
02:12:05 We'll catch you before Thanksgiving next week
02:12:07 with, Lord willing, Dietrich Bonhoeffer.
02:12:10 Oh, yeah, so we're going to get free tickets.
02:12:12 uh so online we i saw like uh they said that um uh if you're anti-semitic you get a free ticket
02:12:20 to bonhoeffer bonhoeffer so me and wes were joking we're like hey dude let's go get let's
02:12:25 go get our free ticket a free movie we earned them yeah we earned them um but no we're not
02:12:30 going to do that because one we're not really anti-semitic probably not going to do that we're
02:12:33 not going to do it tickets are 15 on a monday no we're not doing it we're going to pay because
02:12:37 this is why because uh anybody who gets that free ticket i guarantee that list somehow is
02:12:42 They're going to wind up with the ADL and all sorts of crazy.
02:12:46 It's directly the Southern Poverty Law Center.
02:12:47 It's just name, address, phone number, social.
02:12:51 They'll be like, oh, we've already got this Facebook number.
02:12:52 They're going to come after our response and shut it down.
02:12:55 Yep, shut it down.
02:12:56 But you think they're not on that list?
02:12:57 I know.
02:12:57 I know I'm on that list.
02:12:58 But anyways, no, we're not anti-Semitic in the sense of actually hating Jews and wishing them harm.
02:13:05 um uh sadly if if it's the adl's definition of anti-semitism then everybody yeah sure is
02:13:11 anti-semitic so anyways um but yeah we we plan on watching bonhoeffer and paying for our tickets
02:13:17 because we don't want to be added to a list and uh and then and then yeah it'll be it'll be uh
02:13:24 we're going to do a full movie review and um and sadly just crush a lot of boomers hopes and dreams
02:13:32 i've been reading cost of discipleship just to be like informed like honestly engage with him
02:13:36 he's a little bit smarter than martin luther king jr he uh doesn't fall into some of the
02:13:40 mistakes to say it quite as explicitly but his pietism is poisonous yeah it really is he denied
02:13:46 i mean he didn't believe in a literal virgin birth he didn't believe in a literal um resurrection
02:13:50 bodily resurrection he was very much influenced by carl bart in terms of his hermeneutic and his
02:13:56 view of inerrancy, that the scripture became scripture in your heart and in your mind in a
02:14:02 mystical, emotional kind of way as you're upon reading, but not actually in its written form.
02:14:08 So Bonhoeffer was terrible. Bonhoeffer was truly terrible. And so we're going to talk about
02:14:14 Bonhoeffer next week and just absolutely just burst every boomer bubble that you could possibly
02:14:23 fine all right thank you guys uh bonhoeffer is boomer fuel that's what you said wes hey he he
02:14:29 really is like he's profoundly influential in american evangelicalism of course because of his
02:14:33 historical role but he just writes these books that yeah it's pure boomer fuel it sounds so nice
02:14:39 it sounds so humble it sounds so rigorous uh but it's not saying anything at all yeah all right
02:14:44 so tune in next week uh for us to pour uh cold water on bonhoeffer thanks
02:14:53 We'll be right back.