The NXR Podcast - January 13, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - Why Young Men Are Flocking To Eastern Orthodoxy

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
THE FRIDAY SPECIAL - “Judeo-Christian” Was Always A Psyop - S04E01 w Andrew Isker @contramundumpodcast THE LIVESTREAM - Andrew Tate Clueless Christians

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 46 minutes

Words per minute

180.02

Word count

19,207

Sentence count

613

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

27

sentences flagged

Hate speech

66

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Pastor Jay Chase Davis joins Pastor Joel Webman to discuss what is driving Western men to Eastern Orthodoxy, and why our apologetics against it aren t working. This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reese Fund, as well as our patrons and faithful donors.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears. 0.98
00:00:30 Despite Protestants' many attempts, little has stemmed the tide of young Western men crossing
00:00:35 over to Eastern Orthodoxy. It would seem that there's a deeper underlying reason for Eastern 0.93
00:00:41 Orthodoxy's appeal than merely doctrine. This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors,
00:00:49 Armored Republic and Reese Fund, as well as our Patreon members and our faithful donors.
00:00:55 You can join our Patreon at patreon.com forward slash rightresponseministries, or you can
00:01:02 donate at rightresponseministries.com forward slash donate.
00:01:08 Today, we'll be joined by Pastor Jay Chase Davis to discuss what is driving men to the
00:01:15 East and why our apologetics against it aren't working.
00:01:19 Tune in now.
00:01:25 all right we are back ga we are good afternoon good afternoon i am joined by wesley todd and
00:01:35 michael belch and yours truly pastor joel webman here we are this is the live stream i want to
00:01:40 go ahead and um well just we're trying to train our listeners we have a new schedule a new lineup
00:01:46 that we're doing on a weekly basis so here it is you'll see if you're watching this in video format
00:01:51 everything that we are doing with this live stream it drops live on x and youtube so you can go and
00:01:59 you can watch it at our website right response ministries.com after the fact you can find it on
00:02:04 your favorite podcast platform whether it be spotify or apple whatever it is if you just want
00:02:09 to get the audio only you can also get it on our app we have a right response ministries app so the
00:02:15 website, the app, your podcast platforms, Apple, Spotify. But if you want to watch it live, it
00:02:22 drops at the same time. Simultaneously, we live stream both on YouTube and on X, YouTube and X.
00:02:30 And the schedule for the live stream is three times a week, Monday, Wednesday, and Friday,
00:02:36 Monday, Wednesday, Friday, all three days at 3 p.m. Central Time, 3 p.m. Central Time. And the goal
00:02:42 is three different segments interrupted each segment by a brief commercial break. In the
00:02:47 third segment, we really try to, as much as we can, engage with our listeners. And so we try to
00:02:54 have you guys in the live chat already. People are tuning in and saying things, but we try to
00:02:59 take your questions and actually interact with our live audience in that third segment. So make
00:03:05 sure that you subscribe to the channel. If you're watching on YouTube, make sure to also go over to
00:03:10 x and follow us on x the handle is at right response m ministries when it fit just too much
00:03:17 going on there so just at right response m on x go over there and follow us and on youtube go ahead
00:03:25 and subscribe to the channel as well as click the bell so that you'll be notified when we live stream
00:03:29 three times a week monday wednesday friday 3 p.m central time and then of course we also have the
00:03:35 last piece of content is also on friday at 8 p.m central time and that's the friday special right
00:03:41 now we are running a nine-part series uh we just launched the first episode this last friday it'll
00:03:46 be episode two this friday and uh our current series it's nine parts and it's with myself and
00:03:53 pastor andrew isker on all things israel i gotta talk about the jews it's spelled just for the
00:04:00 the record. It's spelled J-U-I-C-E. We would never talk about anything else. We're talking about
00:04:07 different kinds of juices. You got your cranberry, your grape, those kinds of things. I mean,
00:04:11 after all, we're Baptists, right? So Welch is juice. It's a sacrament. We use wine. But anyway,
00:04:17 so we're talking about Israel, how the church should think about Israel biblically, covenantally,
00:04:21 nationally, ethnically, all that kind of stuff. And then season two is going to be dropping,
00:04:27 starting in Q2 of this year, the year of our Lord, 2025. So that's going to start the first Friday
00:04:32 of April, and we've already got the whole thing recorded and edited and ready to go. And that is
00:04:37 with Dr. Stephen Wolfe. So that'll be myself and Dr. Stephen Wolfe. That's a 10-part series on all
00:04:42 things Christian nationalism. So make sure to tune in for that. But if you want to get both of these
00:04:47 series, not just an episode or two, but the whole nine-part series, ad-free, ready to go. You could
00:04:52 binge watch it today and the whole 10 part series ad free. You could binge watch that as well with
00:04:59 Andrew Isker on Israel and Stephen Wolf on Christian nationalism, all 19 episodes. Those
00:05:04 two seasons combined are actually available right now. They're going to go to the public on YouTube
00:05:09 and X and everything else, slow drip one per week, but they're all in their entirety available now
00:05:14 exclusively for our Patreon members. Again, that's going to be patreon.com forward slash
00:05:19 RightResponseMinistries, patreon.com forward slash RightResponseMinistries. So here we go,
00:05:25 ready for the episode, EO, Eastern Orthodoxy. We're going to talk about Eastern Orthodoxy,
00:05:32 which we've done before, but we want to try to do it from a little bit of a different angle.
00:05:36 And let me just say from the outset, if you are an EO bro, and you've got 14 different anonymous
00:05:44 accounts on X, and you're clocking in 14 hours and never touching grass, God bless you. You're
00:05:49 probably, you know, are single-handedly responsible for getting Donald Trump elected. We've got a lot
00:05:54 of things in common. We appreciate you. We're going to try not to beat you up. I know you think
00:05:59 we're stupid, and we don't think you're stupid. We just think you're, you know, a little mystic 1.00
00:06:03 and gay, you know, but we think intellectually, I would never try to insult you. I'd just insult 1.00
00:06:08 you in other ways. You know, you're not distinctly American. You know, I have problems with that. 1.00
00:06:12 But we're going to go for this episode a different angle, right? We've done the doctrinal thing,
00:06:17 and a lot of Protestants, not just us,
00:06:19 but a lot of Protestants have gone from that angle
00:06:22 and we'll be the first to admit
00:06:23 we want to exercise some humility.
00:06:25 I know that sounds kind of ironic
00:06:26 because I just said the whole mystic and gay thing. 0.99
00:06:29 That was tongue in cheek,
00:06:30 a little bit tongue in cheek, a little bit serious.
00:06:32 But we really do want to exercise some humility.
00:06:35 We don't want to just make this about how we think
00:06:38 Eastern Orthodoxy is off on the doctrinal merits,
00:06:42 but we want to talk about some of the cultural aspects.
00:06:45 We want to talk about even politically,
00:06:46 the voting patterns, these kinds of things. And then most importantly, we want to talk about
00:06:51 masculinity. That's just a constant theme over the last few years. Praise God, I think providentially
00:06:56 so, that the church and Christians, whether they be Protestant or Eastern Orthodox or Roman
00:07:02 Catholic, in all three of these major spheres of Christianity, there's been a rise, a massive
00:07:09 increase of people realizing the need for a biblical, robust masculinity. We realize that
00:07:16 the church across the board is lacking greatly in masculinity, which gives rise to guys like
00:07:23 Andrew Tate, who we'll probably talk about a little bit later this week. Michael's preparing
00:07:28 an episode for that, that we're going to do our best to address Andrew Tate and all those kinds
00:07:33 of things on Wednesday. So I'm going to hand it over to Wes to kick us off a little bit and outline
00:07:37 this particular episode. Yeah, absolutely. When the rubber meets the road, it's oftentimes a lot
00:07:44 different than you imagine it to be. So imagine that you're training for apologetics, and you go
00:07:48 out in the street, and you actually engage with people. And you've read Van Til's Defense of the
00:07:52 Faith. You've read Bonson. You've read Rush Dooney, By What Standard. And you have an idea of what
00:07:57 apologetics and everything looks like. And then you go out, and you actually interact with people,
00:08:01 and you realize once you get there that it never goes the way you intended to go. It never falls
00:08:06 along the lines that you thought it would. Every question, denomination, baptism, this, that, or
00:08:12 the other, they have their academic, intellectual questions, problems, debates, where pages,
00:08:19 thousands upon pages in books have been spilled trying to solve them. But then there's practically
00:08:23 just on the ground what actually happens and how people are convinced. It's very easy to think.
00:08:29 It's the arguments. It's the syllogisms. It's the logic and the reason that if you take someone and
00:08:34 you lay it out for them and you really just answer every objection, then they'll be convinced.
00:08:39 And I would say for many years that I thought that. That's how if you have a disagreement with
00:08:42 your spouse or like for, well, maybe not your children when they're young, but when they get
00:08:46 older, you reason with them and even other adults that you sit down and you hammer it out and you
00:08:50 go to the text, you go back and forth. And when you do that, the best argument will win. The
00:08:55 problem is that's not just the case. People don't typically arrive at the positions they hold,
00:08:59 not always, but the average person, even the average man does not typically arrive at the
00:09:04 positions he holds because of that intellectual rigor, but he arrives them because of emotional
00:09:10 reasons. He has friends and family that take a certain view. He goes to a church that teaches
00:09:15 something like this. He's surrounded by this influence at work. The reason we come to a lot
00:09:19 of our decisions, again, are not that hard, intellectually rigorous work of parsing throughout
00:09:24 all of it, studying all of that. We do it because, well, you go to a church that's Calvinist.
00:09:30 Like, when I first became a Calvinist, why was that?
00:09:33 Well, I had a pastor that taught Calvinism from the pulpit, and I was surrounded by Calvinists.
00:09:36 Now, on the back end, I have a fully orbed defense of Calvinism, and I fully believe that it's true.
00:09:41 But the reason it changed, and it happened to change within a couple years of starting to attend a Reformed church versus an evangelical kind of Arminian church,
00:09:49 well, what was it? Did I come into better arguments?
00:09:51 Some, sure, but I was also just surrounded by those kinds of people.
00:09:55 And so when it comes to the Eastern Church, so many Americans are so sick of modernity.
00:10:01 We don't even realize it.
00:10:02 It's like being homesick without being able to put your finger on it.
00:10:05 We're sick of cheap apartment complexes.
00:10:07 We're sick of shallow friends.
00:10:10 We're sick of consumeristic cultures and lifestyles.
00:10:13 And so man, especially the Western man, he's longing for something deeper.
00:10:17 It's been said that he's surrounded by all this beauty that the Western world made,
00:10:21 but he lacks the worldview.
00:10:22 He lacks everything that made it there in the first place.
00:10:25 And so he longs for beauty. He longs for tradition. He longs to be grounded and rooted,
00:10:30 but nothing is like that. And so you take a man like that, that has feminism that's infected his 1.00
00:10:35 church, modernity everywhere he goes, and he's trying all of this. And then one day he walks in,
00:10:40 is invited, brought in somehow to an Eastern church. And he encounters things in a different
00:10:46 language. He encounters masculine men. He sees icons and images that are Eastern and strange
00:10:53 and foreign to him, and as he's thinking about spirituality, and he's thinking about the church
00:10:57 and God and religion and eternal matters, when he steps into an Eastern Orthodox parish, temple,
00:11:03 whatever it would be, he steps into something a bit otherworldly. And again, because it's not just,
00:11:10 although a good man will parse through and arrive at his conclusions, it's not just the
00:11:13 intellectual arguments. It's not Nicaea II and the iconoclasm debate. It's not debates about
00:11:19 justification that are first and foremost on his mind. He steps in and there's families and there's
00:11:24 children and there's men and there's rigor and there's challenge. And it's a community of excited
00:11:29 people. And that has done a lot. The point is there are thousands and thousands of people
00:11:34 that their experience, what put the seed in their heart of considering it and even going over,
00:11:39 it was not so deep. It was not so complex as all of these arguments and all of the reading,
00:11:44 so much as they walked in somewhere. And it didn't look like a warehouse that you put pallets
00:11:49 and stage lights on they didn't see a woman on stage and they said i kind of like this right
00:11:54 that's so much of it yeah not all of it it wasn't hill song you know like taylor swift
00:11:59 you know with um instead of you know singing about travis kelsey you know he just replaced
00:12:05 his name with jesus jesus is my boyfriend songs and and then you know a ted talk you know and
00:12:10 smoke machines and all that kind of you know people you're right west like people are sick
00:12:14 of modernity and they want something that's rooted they want something that feels steady
00:12:20 stable everything else is shaking around them so they want security stability tradition something
00:12:27 that's old tried true tested and and anything that even has the veneer of that whether the
00:12:34 substance is there or not and we can make arguments about whether it is or whether it's not
00:12:38 but anything that even has the appearance of tradition old tested tried true is going to do 0.99
00:12:46 exceptionally well in our incredibly faking gay culture that we live in today and so i i don't 0.64
00:12:54 think that this was always a thing i tweeted out a couple days ago um i said you know i think that 0.89
00:13:00 eastern orthodoxy is a fad and you know the eo bros god bless them you know they immediately got
00:13:05 in the chat and uh we're like a 2 000 year old fad you know and like what do you mean a fad you
00:13:12 know it's uh it's uh eastern orthodoxy was was there you know uh before the foundations in the
00:13:18 world were laid you know and like you know make it making those kinds of arguments and i think
00:13:23 they misunderstood my point i i don't mean that it's a fad um everywhere i meant here right i
00:13:29 in america and and that is that's that's just undebatable that's inarguable um you can look at
00:13:37 the statistics and the graphs and the charts and uh eastern orthodoxy has certainly had a a rise
00:13:43 in america and it's a very recent uh rise mostly post-covid because a decent amount of them didn't
00:13:49 shut down exactly yeah they stayed open you have dudes with beards doing you know low register
00:13:56 bass gregorian chance um and they're open and meanwhile you know like uh it's like the meme
00:14:04 with you know the the dog that's like ripped with like an 18 pack you know and then like the little
00:14:08 quivering chihuahua you know and you've got like the quivering russell moore you know uh wearing
00:14:14 his his hobbit mask you know this iconic picture that i can't get out of my head which is terrible
00:14:19 you know it's stuck with me every you know for the rest of my life probably but he's like double 0.72
00:14:24 mass you know and bragging about getting the vax you know this hobbit got his vaccine you know and
00:14:28 teamed up with david french and you know and whatever francis collins you know and they're
00:14:34 all doing the bidding of fauci and um and and even the churches that they closed down were you know
00:14:40 uh feminist you know run churches to begin with with beth moore preaching on sunday for a 20-minute 0.72
00:14:46 ted talk and you know the jesus is my boyfriend worship and smoke machines you know and your 0.66
00:14:51 iced latte you know as you're in the the actual sanctuary you know and the lights are turned down
00:14:56 low and um and so that's that's church and then even that you know gets shut down for three months
00:15:04 six months 18 months in some cases and meanwhile the ortho bros are uh you know they're back at it
00:15:13 yeah they're doing church in a masculine way on on the lord's day and then on you know monday
00:15:20 morning they're over at you know father so-and-so's uh garage uh putting up iron lifting weights and
00:15:28 so you know and and then with a claim whether the claim is true or not is is you know for our
00:15:34 purposes today is largely irrelevant but at least still a claim nonetheless of this being very old
00:15:40 and so yeah on the on the backdrop of modernity feminism covid blm you know all these kinds of
00:15:50 things um eastern orthodoxy went to the moon as a fad not in the world as a whole that wasn't my
00:15:58 point in america that was my point in the world so if you have your three large i don't know if
00:16:03 you call them denominations but we could say traditions catholicism clocking in 1.5 billion
00:16:08 might be up to two at this point protestantism is around 800 to about a billion adherents eastern
00:16:15 Orthodoxy, the last I'm aware of the statistics, it's about 200 to 250 million. And that number
00:16:20 is declining. So it's kind of rising in the West. But as far as general religion numbers rising,
00:16:25 it's going to occupy a smaller share by 2050. And it's tough because I've met many, seen many
00:16:31 online who would say, my parish is exploding. We have so many catechumens. We have so many new
00:16:36 people, so many families, so many young men. The world is a big place, my friend. You definitely
00:16:41 may be experiencing a growth, as in your parish may have grown by 50%, 100%, doubled in size.
00:16:46 That absolutely could be true in the micro, in the small picture, COVID in these different
00:16:51 bumps.
00:16:52 But the integrity of a movie, of a movement, my exhortation would be is how long it lasts.
00:16:57 The final part of the story is not written at the beginning or written when the movement
00:17:00 is exploding and everybody's going to it.
00:17:02 It's what are the outcomes of it?
00:17:04 What are the fruit of it?
00:17:05 Does it have a meaningful impact that in generations to go, they'll talk about how
00:17:09 the orthodox church impacted politics and culture and everything in america and i can't jump to the
00:17:14 future and say the answer to that either but just because there's a lot of growth and a lot of
00:17:18 excitement and a lot of explosion those things aren't inherently bad it's like the search for
00:17:21 tradition and masculinity and family and uh and a spiritual transcendental view those things aren't
00:17:28 bad but they have to be judged by the fruit judged by what comes out of the tree right it's interesting
00:17:35 what marketing research has shown us
00:17:37 about why people make decisions.
00:17:40 And to some degree, that's what we're talking about today,
00:17:42 not so much the apologetic for
00:17:44 or against the doctrines of Eastern Orthodoxy,
00:17:46 but rather why it seems that so many
00:17:48 are moving in that direction.
00:17:50 And marketing research has shown us
00:17:51 that most people do much more work
00:17:54 after they make a purchase to justify it
00:17:58 than they do beforehand.
00:17:59 Most people, in their gut,
00:18:01 they have something they wanna buy,
00:18:04 And then they buy it.
00:18:05 And then the intellectual work comes in on their part to go through, oh, this was a great
00:18:10 purchase because dot, dot, dot, dot, dot, dot, dot.
00:18:12 And this is something that I think is really a fascinating thing to think about when it
00:18:17 comes to cultural Christianity.
00:18:18 Because in a sense, we want America to be a Christian nation, but a particular expression
00:18:25 of Christianity even.
00:18:27 And as we're thinking about Protestantism in the West, in America, there is a sense
00:18:32 where we want when people to think of Christianity, we want them to think, yeah, that's the sort
00:18:37 of lifestyle that I'm not saying I'm aware that no one seeks God, right?
00:18:43 But as far as what people think about when they think of Protestantism in America, we
00:18:48 want them to think of us as those are the fighters, those are the muscular, that's the
00:18:52 kind of rigorous tradition that I want to be part of.
00:18:55 And there is a sense where whoever wins that image debate or war doesn't necessarily win the doctrinal argument, but it does kind of win the cultural Christianity war.
00:19:11 What will be the expression of Christianity in a nation or in a tradition based on what that version of Christianity is doing with itself in the public eye?
00:19:23 right yeah and i think you know part of my argument and i understand it's not it's not a
00:19:28 doctrinal argument i never really claimed that it was um but that war for who's going to get the
00:19:35 visible who's going to win the day for being uh the visible sign of christianity in this nation
00:19:44 in these united states of america um it will never be eastern orthodoxy right it won't because it's
00:19:51 not america right and it never will be it simply won't uh we are not eastern mystics um america's
00:19:59 just that's just not what we are uh catholicism could win i hope it doesn't um i think that
00:20:05 america i don't think i know america its tradition its history its roots its origin
00:20:10 is protestant overwhelmingly protestant now in terms of which protestant denomination i don't
00:20:17 particularly care um i don't i think that you know you can have a pan that's what stephen wolf
00:20:22 is always talking about that america is a pan protestant nation and the christian nationalism
00:20:26 that he espouses would be a pan protestant project and so in these united states it would be
00:20:32 um it would be you know distinctly christian um a little less distinctly protestant but still you
00:20:40 would have that protestant feel um and then that's at the federal level and then at the state level
00:20:45 you could and you know in theory you could have state churches but you wouldn't have a federal
00:20:50 church because you know if at the federal level you had the national church was whatever anglican
00:20:56 and then mississippi is you know baptist well that would that would conflict um so you wouldn't
00:21:02 have a national church you could theoretically have state churches but they would be within
00:21:06 that pan-protestant movement you'd have a lot of presbyterian states you know and baptist churches
00:21:11 or Anglican churches or whatever
00:21:13 could still operate within those states,
00:21:15 but still overall for the state of Mississippi,
00:21:17 it would be Baptist, you know,
00:21:18 in the state of whatever, it would be Presbyterian,
00:21:21 state of whatever would be Anglican,
00:21:22 but this larger pan-Protestant, you know,
00:21:24 project at the national level.
00:21:26 And then even that, the only clear distinction
00:21:29 probably on paper, like a preamble to our constitution
00:21:32 would be something that even, you know,
00:21:34 the EO and the, you know, the RC, Roman Catholic guys
00:21:39 could still get behind something
00:21:40 that's even broader than protestant uh like adopting a preamble to the constitution that
00:21:46 would be like the nicene creed or the apostles creed or something like that that's uh distinctly
00:21:51 christian and so um but the point is that that that works um in american context and um and one
00:21:59 you know this is one of the things that we could get in maybe get into a little bit later on but
00:22:04 um the protestant faith that particular tradition within christianity um i think has the necessary
00:22:13 ingredients the working parts uh that makes it far more conducive to being a universal lowercase
00:22:21 c catholic faith um whereas uh eastern orthodoxy as like a geographic and physical locale even you
00:22:31 know roman catholicism certainly i mean it's roman um it has a locale yeah a specific locale
00:22:37 uh and there are certain things that don't translate like within roman catholicism you
00:22:42 know the latin right there's a language that's baked into the equation with it whereas within
00:22:47 protestantism um you don't have to be english speaking you don't have to be latin speaking
00:22:52 you don't like i mean there are certain things that would help when you're trying to read you
00:22:56 know older protestants and some of their writings but none of it is um a necessary ingredient and
00:23:03 so you could keep you know so protestants argue about you know the substance of worship versus
00:23:07 the elements of worship so the substance of worship that would be set and defined by scripture
00:23:12 all right so all over the world you would have churches that you know that publicly preach the
00:23:18 word pray the word sing the word in spiritual songs and hymns and psalms and publicly see
00:23:24 s-e-e-i-n-g seeing the word in the only two images prescribed to us by the lord jesus himself
00:23:31 being the lord's supper and baptism so you would have the substance of worship across the board
00:23:37 but the elements of worship would shift in terms of where church meets what building you know what
00:23:42 the building looks like the architecture the music whether or not there are candles or you
00:23:47 know whether or not there's some form of incense you know whether or not the music is loud or if
00:23:53 soft or you know instruments only yeah or instruments in addition to singing or singing
00:23:58 only acapella um all those different you know uh elements of worship um could be at some level you
00:24:05 know within theory an argument from permissibility they could be interchangeable but the substance
00:24:09 of worship would remain whereas eastern orthodoxy it's not just doctrine um but but it asserts as
00:24:16 substance of worship what we would categorize as elements of worship so that if it's wholly
00:24:22 incompatible with the nation with its traditions with its its entire world view its its way of
00:24:27 thinking its traditions um well tough luck right so you're western and you care about you know
00:24:34 cognitive substance right linear thinking linear thinking right so when you think about meditating
00:24:40 when you read you know david you know meditating on thy word day and night for you christian
00:24:46 meditation is meditating on god's word that is to fill the mind with god's thoughts with substance
00:24:53 namely the substance of scripture itself and beginning to think about the scripture what it
00:24:58 means and how it applies so christian meditation for somebody who's western is going to be thinking
00:25:06 in those terms i'm going to meditate on god's word day and night that means i'm going to be
00:25:10 thinking about thy law his law word filling my mind not emptying the mind but i'm filling the
00:25:16 mind feasting the mind on the word of god thinking about its meaning interpretation and how it works
00:25:24 its application um eastern orthodoxy that's something that is it's that's again it has a
00:25:31 physical locale it's it's limited it's not going to work across the board because when they think
00:25:38 of meditation even there are forms of prayer within eastern orthodoxy centered prayer these
00:25:43 kinds of things where um it very much is the goal is not to feast the mind on the substance of god's
00:25:48 word but rather to uh empty the mind and you might even take a phrase uh if you're learning
00:25:54 for the first time like a seven syllable phrase and you would repeat that phrase again and again
00:26:00 and again and again um and you could argue the counter would be well we're meditating on that
00:26:05 phrase no the point is to say the phrase ad nauseum to where uh the mind doesn't focus in
00:26:11 on the phrase but the phrase is used as as a as an anchor to help the mind not get focused on
00:26:17 anything so the mind doesn't get distracted by any substantive thought whatsoever the phrase
00:26:23 becomes an incantation to to blur the mind out and to just to veg out and from this state of
00:26:30 emptiness in Eastern concept, the goal is to experience oneness with God. Whereas in a Western
00:26:37 frame, it's not experiencing God so much as it is knowing God. I want to know God. And so those
00:26:46 are things that are culturally centered. They're bound in place. They're bound in time. They're
00:26:52 bound with particular nations, particular cultures. And it makes it very difficult. Whereas
00:26:57 the protestant faith i think is it's more translatable you can have a ugandan church
00:27:03 that still maintains some ugandan cultural aspects in the elements of worship while still being
00:27:10 uniquely christian and protestant with the substance of worship and you wouldn't expect
00:27:14 you know christian protestant churches in uganda to look exactly like a church in kentucky and and
00:27:22 and that would be okay um and still be biblically faithful and so in terms of winning out who's you
00:27:29 know who's going to win the day um well in terms of the world i don't know we'll we'll see what
00:27:35 happens but in terms of these united states protestants built this country and i think by
00:27:42 god's grace protestants will keep this country and i do think that um five years of being on the rise
00:27:51 because of covid and blm and effeminacy and all these kinds of things i get it i get it makes a
00:27:57 lot of sense protestants have been sitting on their hands protestants have um massively and
00:28:03 utterly failed and so i get it um but long run not just a five-year timeline but looking at a 50-year
00:28:09 timeline um i don't i don't think it's going to happen and if it did happen um if eastern orthodoxy
00:28:18 won the day uh then you you can't have both you would lose america yeah so you you eastern
00:28:25 orthodoxy can uh if eastern orthodoxy wins america loses uh you have you have no more america you
00:28:34 and different nation yeah and that would have to do like not only with the culture and um the
00:28:40 aesthetics and all these things but i i absolutely think it would play into immigration we've talked
00:28:45 about this before, we won't get into it today, but you look at voting patterns, evangelicals, 0.80
00:28:49 despite how fake and gay evangelicals are, I pick on evangelicals more than anybody else because I 0.96
00:28:55 am one. So I understand the problems. And yet still, despite how bad evangelicals have been 1.00
00:29:01 as of recent, it's not even close in terms of voting against abortion, voting for Republican
00:29:09 leaders voting against immigration vote you know all those evangelicals are far more conservative
00:29:18 politically conservative than eastern orthodoxy yep so all right let's go to our first commercial
00:29:23 break and then we're going to bring chase onto the show all right the clock is running out you
00:29:29 need to go and register now for our christ is king how to defeat trash world conference it's
00:29:35 happening, the year of our Lord, 2025, April 3rd, 4th, and 5th. That's a Thursday, Friday, and
00:29:42 Saturday. And by God's grace, we're able to provide for you an all-star lineup. We've got Steve Dace,
00:29:48 Calvin Robinson, Oren McIntyre, Dr. Stephen Wolf, Eric Kahn, David Reese, Andrew Isker, John Harris,
00:29:56 A.D. Robles, Dan Burkholder, Dusty Devers, Ben Garrett, C.J. Engel, and yours truly, Pastor Joel
00:30:03 webin come on out join us april 3rd 4th and 5th 2025 thursday through a saturday go to
00:30:11 right response conference.com to register today again that's right response conference.com
00:30:18 okay all right welcome pastor chase davis thanks for coming on the show can you hear me
00:30:24 i believe i believe we've got nathan working on the tech side of things there he is pastor
00:30:33 chase davis thanks for coming on the show can you hear me we have video he looks wonderful
00:30:40 it looks like he can hear us we don't hear him but we do not hear him not quite
00:30:45 can you hear me now we can we've got him perfect great awesome thanks for coming on
00:30:51 absolutely glad to be here uh tell our listeners just real quick where do you pastor i'm a pastor
00:30:58 of the well church in boulder colorado a church we planted back in 2011 and we are still here
00:31:03 great great all right so we're talking about eastern orthodoxy chase uh give you a little
00:31:09 bit of context we've talked about this before and we've dealt with it from the doctrinal side of
00:31:14 things um and and we're just we're trying to exercise a little bit of humility in this episode
00:31:21 and just admitting up front that a lot of protestant apologetics uh are falling flat it's just
00:31:29 it's not it's not working um and so we're trying to deal with some of the other things some of the
00:31:34 cultural aspects i i had a tweet you know part of why we're talking about is i had a tweet that got
00:31:38 you know a decent amount of attention uh last week where i said you know aside from the
00:31:44 scriptural arguments that would be first for me i'm a christian first um but second and it's a
00:31:50 fairly close second i would not go eastern orthodoxy uh into eastern orthodoxy simply
00:31:56 on the basis of the fact that i'm an american what do you think yeah i mean i've made that
00:32:03 argument i think it's a compelling argument uh the eastern orthodox tradition is foreign
00:32:09 to the american experience it's it's a foreign religion now one could argue that protestant
00:32:18 christianity was also foreign at one point to different contexts same thing with roman
00:32:23 catholicism was foreign the church was foreign to different contexts at different times but in terms
00:32:28 of the American experience, Protestantism is where it's at. And so the idea that, you know,
00:32:34 you could go to an Eastern Orthodox Church, and, you know, it's a new thing. I don't know what
00:32:42 God's plan for the future is for America, but I don't foresee it being Eastern Orthodoxy. I 1.00
00:32:48 foresee it being Protestant Christianity, because it has been, provided, you know, certain things
00:32:54 happen. But yeah, even we can go so far as to say the way of doing theology in the Eastern
00:33:02 Orthodox tradition cultivates a way of doing theology and intellectual discourse in a way
00:33:11 that's so incongruent with the Western tradition that it's almost hard to even have theological 0.94
00:33:16 discussions, because when they're talking about growing in Christlikeness, there's a whole other
00:33:22 way that they're approaching spirituality and our knowledge of God. Now, they may have some
00:33:28 insights to offer us there. We may be able to learn some things and exchange ideas in that way.
00:33:33 But I think if we just view it as like a denominational switch, like it's just another
00:33:37 option out there, I think that's a grave mistake. Chase, you've, well, earlier we rooted it into
00:33:46 masculinity. So young men, they're done with. They're done with being weak. They're done with
00:33:51 being talked down to. They're done with feminism. And so they look for masculine options for church, 0.99
00:33:56 for life, for all of these different things. And that's bringing them, in some cases, to the
00:34:00 Eastern Orthodox Church. You have, I would say, the priestly class in the Eastern Orthodox Church
00:34:05 on the whole, on average, beats out the evangelical. One of the reasons I wanted to have you on, 0.93
00:34:10 I think you're a pretty masculine guy. You do a lot of outdoorsy stuff. You probably could bench
00:34:15 more than me if I had to guess. How do you feel like being in your church there in Boulder,
00:34:20 having been there for a while, having interacted with a younger, kind of millennial crowd,
00:34:25 how is masculinity, as men are looking for different things, do you see that actually
00:34:29 attracting men in, that men come in and they say, man, there's families, the worship, the
00:34:34 atmosphere, it's reverent, it's somber, it's strong, it's composed. Do you see that playing
00:34:39 an impact, at least where you're ministering specifically? Yeah, I see a lot of young men
00:34:43 who are kind of fed up with the kind of lukewarm spirituality that they've been offered, the kind
00:34:49 of feminized spirituality they've been offered, where the expectation is you go into a dark room
00:34:53 and cry to Jesus and sing songs to your boyfriend in the sky. They're fairly disinterested in that.
00:34:59 Men, especially as they reach middle age, they start having kids with their wife,
00:35:06 that doesn't really do what it used to do for them when they were a young kid,
00:35:11 when they were confused. And so people are naturally attracted to that. And that's what
00:35:16 what I've tried to emphasize is what we can learn to this so-called, I mean, so far I haven't seen
00:35:23 numbers associated with this draw to Eastern Orthodoxy, this masculine draw. So apparently
00:35:31 there is a draw, but we don't know how many it is. But I have seen for my entire Christian life,
00:35:36 Christians drawn away from Protestantism into Roman Catholicism, now Eastern Orthodoxy as well.
00:35:42 And it comes down to an approach to their own faith, the way they carry the Christian faith, such that they're very disinterested in kind of like bending over backwards to please you, whereas most kind of non-denominational churches, their temperament towards either newcomers or whoever is still rooted in a very much like seeker-sensitive evangelistic mindset.
00:36:07 and of course we want more people to know Jesus and we want to share the gospel with them
00:36:12 but even the way we welcome people to the church or we try to explain our traditions to other
00:36:17 people we view most evangelicals view anything that would turn off a lost person as a problem
00:36:24 whereas in eastern orthodoxy and roman catholicism more high church protestant traditions
00:36:29 they're very unconcerned this is just the way it is this is how we do things you're welcome to come
00:36:35 you're welcome to go there's kind of like this well i view it as kind of a more masculine
00:36:39 presence about it where it's less anxious it's more settled and how it presents its tradition
00:36:45 it it really doesn't care if you understand what's being taught or why different things
00:36:50 are happening during the liturgy there's not like a worship pastor explaining everything
00:36:55 to newcomers every week it's like this is just how we do things here and we love you we're glad
00:37:00 you're here and um you're welcome to stay and learn more so i think that's the difference there 0.88
00:37:05 it's so funny with the seeker sensitive they think i'm going to bend over backwards i'm going
00:37:09 to have graders and welcome cards and connect cards i'm going to have a gift basket and i think
00:37:14 like that's what people want people want brian suveys talked about this a thick culture like
00:37:19 it actually belonged to it like it takes effort you've been there for six months you're still
00:37:23 struggling to sing parts in the psalms you know like you've got a workout group and they invited
00:37:27 you at 6 a.m. You couldn't walk for the next four days after. People want to belong to something.
00:37:32 They don't want to be just catered to. They don't want something that's surface level that they can
00:37:36 get the full experience of in two weeks. I watched, I think it's Father Josiah, and I want to say he's
00:37:41 out in California. He said, you come to an Orthodox church, you're going to be expected to fast.
00:37:45 Man, men love that. Men love to be challenged. That's not like a spiritual church thing.
00:37:49 That's just in general. Men want to be long. They want to be challenged. They want to have 1.00
00:37:53 something where it's not just, again, two, three weeks in, you've exhausted it. This is as far as
00:37:59 we're going to push you. The rest, you can take it from there. Yeah. Yeah. Men need to be challenged
00:38:04 with rigor. They need to be, you know, loaded up with certain expectations to grow because men want
00:38:11 to grow. All people want to grow, but men especially, they want to see a challenge in
00:38:15 front of them. And unfortunately, many evangelical churches today, they put a big emphasis on
00:38:21 belonging and inclusivity and all these kinds of things. When in fact, what people need is,
00:38:29 yes, the confrontation of their sin and the welcome good news of the gospel,
00:38:34 but even more so the spiritual disciplines that come with our faith, being encouraged to walk in
00:38:39 righteousness and put sin to death and practical application of how to do that. And you see some
00:38:44 churches try to do this with marriage classes and that kind of thing. But in general, the kind of
00:38:49 longstanding traditions, whether Roman Catholicism or Eastern Orthodoxy, they have a long, they have
00:38:54 a pattern of the man they are trying to shape, and they have practices that they will instantiate
00:39:00 and expect of you if you join. And I think most evangelicals, they hear that as either legalism
00:39:06 or scary or putting too much on people or all sorts of different words you'll hear.
00:39:11 Though one of the worst things that you could say in an evangelical church today
00:39:16 is that you have to behave.
00:39:19 You have certain duties you need to fulfill.
00:39:22 Instead, the big emphasis is on belonging.
00:39:24 And yet, our Lord and Savior says that if we love Him, we will obey Him.
00:39:29 There is behavior involved.
00:39:31 And we're so scared of that legalism boogeyman.
00:39:33 And that is out there.
00:39:34 The extra-biblical law is out there.
00:39:37 But in general, we're very weak on encouraging people to behave in all of life,
00:39:42 to follow Jesus Christ.
00:39:43 right i looked uh while you were talking there uh chase and there's not a lot of numbers actually
00:39:51 about the switch from um protestantism to orthodox churches however one of the deciding
00:39:58 things and this isn't that surprising but most of eastern orthodoxy's converts into eastern
00:40:05 orthodoxy in the u.s are from protestants so not necessarily not in christians or buddhists or
00:40:11 something like that. Like most of the people who are joining Eastern Orthodox churches, they do
00:40:15 have the data on that is from Protestant churches. So that's interesting. That makes sense to me
00:40:21 because I really think like, that's part of what we're getting at in this episode is I think that
00:40:25 the primary appeal is not doctrinal. So I don't think that it's, um, because if it was doctrinal
00:40:32 and it was all the claims of, you know, well, we have the church fathers and we have the true
00:40:36 tradition, you know, we have this and we have, you know, our councils were correct. And, um, you
00:40:41 know that were you know we we had this council but they ignored our council you know that you
00:40:45 know blah blah and it's if it was really an argument from history and tradition and authority
00:40:50 an argument from authority and it was a persuasive argument a powerful argument a true argument
00:40:55 then i think you would have you there'd be no um there would be no respecters of of converts from
00:41:03 protestants or from you know roman catholicism you'd have just as many catholics you know you
00:41:09 you know, I think in theory that are like, man, they have the superior argument. They have an 0.96
00:41:13 argument from tradition and from authority and from this and from that. But you don't have a
00:41:18 bunch of RC, you know, Roman Catholics in America, you know, transferring over to Eastern Orthodoxy. 0.73
00:41:25 And I think the reason why is, I think it's plain. The reason why is because the chief appeal,
00:41:32 the chief attraction i think is it's um it's the intangibles it's not the actual doctrinal
00:41:39 arguments or arguments from authority or tradition or history it's the intangible um aesthetics and
00:41:46 the feel and the it's it's my church is a ted talk with smoke machines jesus is my boyfriend
00:41:52 music and that's on a good day when they're open but they instead transformed our church for 18
00:41:59 months into a vaccine clinic you know and shut down for covet um and over here there's a bunch
00:42:08 of dudes with beards lifting weights monday through saturday and then singing gregorian
00:42:13 chants you know in the lowest register i could possibly imagine and yeah i'm gonna go there but
00:42:19 for the roman catholic guys yeah we kind of already got that aesthetically like we we've
00:42:24 got mass there yeah we've got the the latin mass we've got the the feel of old tried true tradition
00:42:31 rooted uh tested um and uh some of of also that that masculine uh aspect of the the you know even
00:42:41 in the aesthetics of the architecture of the vaulted ceilings that speak to the transcendence
00:42:46 of god and the natural light instead of just you know the the colored you know stage lights and
00:42:52 You know, as the main lights are turned down low and from the music, you know, it's from
00:42:57 tradition, it's old.
00:43:00 And so, yeah, you don't see a whole bunch of Roman Catholics here in America, across
00:43:05 the world.
00:43:06 I don't know, but I'm thinking about America.
00:43:08 I'm a pastor here in America, but in America, that's from what I've seen on the ground,
00:43:13 you don't have a bunch of Roman Catholic guys transferring over to Eastern Orthodoxy.
00:43:16 You got a bunch of Protestants.
00:43:18 And I think that's, to me, that says something.
00:43:21 And that makes a statement about what is the particular appeal.
00:43:25 I don't think it's just the superior arguments from tradition.
00:43:29 I think it's the superior, and I'm fine calling it the superior aesthetics and the superior feel and culture to the vast majority of evangelical Protestants, which is feminine, light in the loafers, a guy who has a plexiglass pulpit,
00:43:47 um you know and he's pacing back and forth between two ferns and he's not going to preach he's just
00:43:54 going to share you know like that's gay i think people leave protestant churches not because the 0.95
00:43:59 doctrine's bad but because protestant churches are gay i think that's it what do you think chase 0.93
00:44:04 yeah i think there's a lot there because it's interesting we live in such a sentimental age 0.88
00:44:10 people are drawn more to beauty and aesthetics more than they let on most people like to think
00:44:17 they're rational creatures that make decisions because they made a good argument. And most often
00:44:21 case, we will do things and then justify our behavior and find rational arguments that justify
00:44:27 what we've done. But in the same way, we're drawn to beauty, we're drawn to these aesthetics.
00:44:32 And so there's actually a really interesting parallel between why people are drawn to the,
00:44:38 if we want to call it the secret sensitive church, where it's heavy base, dark, and it gets the
00:44:44 feelings going. You know, there's a similar reason people are drawn then to Eastern Orthodoxy. It's
00:44:49 also if there's feelings there, there's something there. One thing I would emphasize, like you
00:44:54 talked about with the transcendence, is that most evangelical churches, they're very high on
00:44:58 eminence, the eminence of God. God is near to us. God is close to us. God condescended to us in the
00:45:04 God-man, Jesus Christ. And so Jesus is your friend. All these are very heavily emphasized.
00:45:10 And then when people start wanting to grow and they want to know more about God, they often come up short because they keep hearing the same thing.
00:45:19 Well, God's not that different than you.
00:45:21 Whereas when we emphasize the transcendence, we should have both.
00:45:23 But when we emphasize the transcendence, like the more high church tradition, like the Eastern Orthodox tradition, there's a sense that God is other, that we're encountering something that's different.
00:45:32 And I think in an age where people are, they're over a life where I come home, I order Grubhub, I turn on a screen, and that's supposed to be a good life.
00:45:44 That's not a meaningful life.
00:45:47 They're looking for something more.
00:45:49 And if Protestant churches, if that's all they essentially offer is kind of a buffet of spirituality where there's not a lot of accountability, not a lot of seriousness about our traditions and our faith and our practices, they're going to look elsewhere.
00:46:03 And when they look elsewhere, they see a tradition that's very much where God is other, where sometimes you may not even speak the same language as the songs we're singing,
00:46:17 where these are these icons going around and there's this sense of transcendence there
00:46:22 uh that is oftentimes lacking now you could try to manufacture that in the mega church world where
00:46:28 you've got manufactured transcendence oh we've got fog machines we've you know i've heard of
00:46:34 this uh this crazy idea where at some one church they had like gold dust falling from the ceiling
00:46:39 uh because they put it but they put it like in the air vents yeah yeah right yeah but they're
00:46:46 They're trying to manufacture this transcendence, and people are looking in our age for that connection.
00:46:53 They're looking for something more.
00:46:54 They're tired of the materialistic worldview, which offers nothing.
00:46:58 It offers no connection to God.
00:47:01 It offers no connection for a future vision. 0.96
00:47:05 It is just eat, have sex, die, have pleasure, avoid pain.
00:47:11 People are like, no, there's got to be more to life than this.
00:47:13 And so they're looking for churches that are going to speak to that, that are going to take themselves seriously, that aren't just going to constantly condescend to whoever's most offended or anything like that, but they're going to stand up straight and have a sense of propriety about themselves on Sunday.
00:47:30 That's one emphasis I've tried to make in our church about dress, and I'm definitely not legalistic by any means on this matter, but I myself have tried to dress more appropriately, more befitting, as a minister should wear, as a Baptist minister could be on a Sunday, to where there is a sense of this isn't just a campus ministry where we're all best buds.
00:47:50 And hear me clearly, this is coming from a guy who, when we planted, I would preach in
00:47:54 chacos and wear a V-neck and all this kind of stuff.
00:47:57 So this took a long time for me.
00:47:59 But I think it's important to emphasize for people that, look, when we gather to worship
00:48:03 the living God, this is not just another community club.
00:48:07 This is not just another hangout.
00:48:08 This is something unique that is happening, that God is doing, and God has accomplished
00:48:12 for us. 0.98
00:48:13 And unless Protestants are willing to go there and really carry that authority that they've 0.83
00:48:18 been invested with by god then yeah we're going to continue to see people explore other traditions 0.88
00:48:24 which are very foreign to our experience yeah one of the things that i love about the protestant
00:48:29 faith is um and i believe you know i'm protestant so i believe it's the true faith uh but one one
00:48:35 of the things that i love is is simplicity and i think it's actually you know um a profound tragedy
00:48:41 and and a profound irony as well that um like the protestant faith allows for if you have bread
00:48:49 wine water and a bible you can do church you know and two or three people souls and you can do
00:48:59 church that'll do um and and yet we've we've added all these elements but we've added all all the
00:49:09 elements uh are derived all because i i don't think that it means you you only i don't think
00:49:15 my point is the protestant faith is there's there's a divine simplicity there um and and
00:49:21 you can do it anywhere okay to use an analogy um i think there's a reason why uh soccer
00:49:29 or a football is uh like a global sport uh because all you got to do is put you know like
00:49:39 two twigs in the ground you know and have a ball whereas like water polo you know like like
00:49:46 uganda is probably not gonna you know be winning any you know competitions in water polo anytime
00:49:51 soon you know like because it like it it just it mandates um means of you know you like you have to
00:49:59 be able to have access to some of these things like the protestant faith really can thrive
00:50:04 everywhere it can thrive in the first world it can thrive in the third world it can thrive in
00:50:08 developing worlds it can thrive in in sub-sahara africa or in the west or in the east and you know
00:50:14 in all these different places because of its simplicity and it doesn't mean i'm not saying
00:50:18 is i i'm a regular principle guy but i i don't i don't take it i try not to be um a nazi about it
00:50:25 right you never catch me being a nazi and so um you try not to be a nazi about the regular principle
00:50:30 of worship so what i'm saying is i think there are aesthetics that you can add in elements of
00:50:34 worship that don't contradict any way or even detract from the substance of worship bread wine
00:50:39 water bible scripture um and and so you can have in other words you can have a protestant church
00:50:45 that might have you know god forbid put a little bit of thought into to the architecture you know
00:50:51 a nice building a steeple is a nice look i think it's i think it says something in the way that it
00:50:57 points up towards god but it also draws the focus of the town the town sees the church and in the
00:51:03 center of of the public square and that's that's and it has a beacon and that's where i go for help
00:51:08 and in times of trouble and need and all these different things so you can do that but you don't
00:51:13 have to do that there is a a lowest common denominator that makes it universal but then
00:51:18 there's room for aesthetics and to add in a way that doesn't detract from the substance
00:51:22 the problem is that we as protestants we have added and we've added in all the absolute most
00:51:31 modern feministic uh cheap um um materialistic consumeristic like the we've taken the worst 0.69
00:51:44 most we're talking about you know i i tweeted the eo is a fad like so i you know to exercise a little 0.51
00:51:49 humility here um protestants in in everything that they've added it has been the most fad like
00:51:56 substances you could possibly imagine what has been popular for 15 minutes and they've added
00:52:01 that so whether it be laser lights or smoke machine or plexiglass pulpits or you know or 0.76
00:52:08 having a woman on stage doing everything she possibly can except for preaching the sermon 1.00
00:52:13 unless beth moore's in town you know and then we'll let her do that too you know and all those 0.83
00:52:17 so like we've we have added the aesthetics we have um we just added all the wrong ones
00:52:23 any any further thought doesn't have to be on that you don't have to have thoughts about what
00:52:28 i said but i've actually thought about that too there there is something i would say about eastern
00:52:33 when when a young person would be drawn to eastern orthodoxy there's a different kind of simplicity
00:52:38 thereafter and the simplicity is that all they have to do is show up and obey the tradition
00:52:45 like there's not a lot of like i have to come to an understanding of it myself or i like you could
00:52:52 become Eastern, in my mind, again, if you're Eastern Orthodox and listening, this is how I
00:52:56 perceive it. If you could join the church, and it's literally, you're just inheriting the tradition,
00:53:02 so you don't have to be creative, anything like that. The Protestants, what you highlighted,
00:53:09 was good and accurate, and there's a reason where the West and Protestantism has flourished
00:53:15 is because it's so simple in terms of its faith and practice and what we believe in our tradition
00:53:20 that there's actually an onus put on the individual to live out the Christian life
00:53:27 and to live out their tradition in a different way.
00:53:30 So it's almost like there's this kind of old adage where the accusation against evangelicals
00:53:35 is you have to check your brain at the door when you go to an evangelical church,
00:53:39 which is just not true.
00:53:40 There's many brilliant evangelicals.
00:53:42 I would say the same could be said of someone who wants to join the Eastern Orthodox tradition.
00:53:47 You really don't have to understand everything.
00:53:50 You just have to like submit to tradition. And in that way, I think it's meeting a certain felt need that people have today, where they're having to make decisions left and right. And they're experiencing what some call decision fatigue, where they're, you know, you look at, you move to a new city, and you have to pick an evangelical church, and you've got non-denominus, non-denominat, all this kind of stuff.
00:54:12 And not only that, not only for your spiritual life, but food and everything is so easily accessible.
00:54:18 And I think with the simplicity offered in embracing a tradition in which you really don't have, there's not a lot of decisions to make.
00:54:26 There's not a lot of initiative to take.
00:54:28 It's just kind of like, well, this is what we do.
00:54:31 There's something freeing, and that's not necessarily good, but there can be something freeing to somebody who's looking for that transcendent experience with God because they're exhausted by modern life. 0.99
00:54:42 they're exhausted by kind of this global homo uh kind of like materialistic worldview of 0.99
00:54:49 commodification of everything commercialization of everything and you'll see the same thing 0.99
00:54:53 happen in protestant churches where spirituality becomes not this is how we do things here this is
00:54:58 our tradition it's we have a buffet of 50 ministry options depending on whatever your felt need is
00:55:03 we just want you to belong here which one do you want oh we don't have one for you well let's start
00:55:08 of mountain biking ministry just for you. You know, you can feel special here. Whereas in Eastern
00:55:13 Orthodox Church, you don't get a lot of that. And so it is kind of a, it's a different kind of
00:55:17 simplicity. While it's very complicated, like we've already highlighted, if you go to an Eastern
00:55:21 Orthodox worship service, incredibly complicated stuff. At the same time, it can be freeing for
00:55:26 somebody who is looking for that kind of like, man, I'm just tired. I'm tired of trying to make
00:55:31 a bunch of decisions right yeah if we go ahead west you go first and then i'll i have a couple
00:55:38 questions mine is the sum up question of what should protestant churches practically do to kind
00:55:43 of capture back some of that so why don't you go ahead and then we'll maybe wrap up for that
00:55:46 yeah let's do that in the third segment chase do you have time we're going to go to a commercial
00:55:51 break here in about five minutes and then come back and we'd love to keep you for another 20 or
00:55:56 so to maybe take some questions from our audience okay um so my question is just briefly because
00:56:01 we've done this in the past this is not the point of this episode but i'd love to hear from you um
00:56:07 just for a moment on doctrine are there any um what would be the doctrinal red flags
00:56:12 what would be the things that you're like oh that's doctrinally i don't like that one
00:56:18 yeah i i kind of looked into it a little bit in seminary i took some classes that dealt with
00:56:24 Eastern Orthodoxy, but since I spoke about it on my own podcast and we're speaking about it today,
00:56:28 I've looked into it a little bit more deeply on the stuff I already knew. And I think doctrinally,
00:56:32 my big thing is like the way it shapes you as a human, the way it shapes you and treats you as
00:56:37 a person is very different than Protestantism. And even the apprehension of God, how we understand
00:56:44 who God to be. For example, in salvation, you know, in the Protestant tradition, we have faith
00:56:49 alone. You put your faith in Jesus Christ, you repent of your sins, you become a new creation.
00:56:54 and you become a Christian. In the Eastern Orthodox tradition, it's going to be in the
00:56:58 church. That's where you find salvation. We can find this in the Protestant tradition,
00:57:04 but not in the same way. And that's the danger doctrinally with a lot of this,
00:57:07 is we're using similar words, but we're saying very different things. So you'll hear John Calvin
00:57:13 and others in the Protestant tradition talking about the church being the mother. There's no
00:57:17 salvation outside the church, but they mean it in a different way than the Eastern Orthodox,
00:57:21 where truly, like, they don't, it's not that they don't care about justification by faith,
00:57:27 they don't even, like, that's not even on their radar as far as a doctrinal concern,
00:57:32 if that makes sense, like, just because of the way their doctrine and theology has developed
00:57:36 over time. So for a Protestant who's clear on Christ's penal substitutionary death and
00:57:44 justification in Christ, to then switch to Eastern Orthodoxy, that's like, it's a different
00:57:51 rule book. It's a different language completely theologically. We have more in common with Roman
00:57:57 Catholics, you might have already highlighted this, than Eastern Orthodox in terms of our
00:58:01 Western tradition. Of course, one of the great theological controversies was about the filioque
00:58:09 or filioque um and and and you'll see in their own tradition there there is some kind of back
00:58:14 and forth on what it meant was it just semantics you know was it a big issue um but i think one of
00:58:20 the things that that really strikes me in eastern orthodoxy is the iconography the kind of veneration
00:58:29 of they don't as far as they say they don't worship these icons even though to protestants
00:58:34 we would say, that's what it seems like to me, they venerate these icons. But even like how
00:58:40 they understand hell, for example, whereas Protestants have a tradition of thinking of
00:58:45 heaven and hell as realms and even places, hell in the Eastern Orthodox tradition and heaven in
00:58:51 the Eastern Orthodox tradition isn't necessarily a realm or a place. Hell is an absence of God's
00:58:56 grace, and it's a state of being almost. And it gets into kind of the experiential aspect
00:59:02 of Eastern Orthodox and kind of the mystical components. And that cultivates humans that
00:59:09 are trained to perceive the world in a way that's just utterly different. And so there are just
00:59:15 really, on all sorts of doctrinal matters, such severe differences. Not that they, I'm not
00:59:22 necessarily claiming that those who are Eastern Orthodox are outside the faith, but they're just
00:59:27 very different, and I think it's very, you know, we should be very cautious about assuming
00:59:33 too charitably that we're saying the same thing when we're not actually saying the same thing.
00:59:38 You know, they have an experience of God where theosis is a big deal, and becoming like God is
00:59:43 a big deal, but even when we say that, we're meaning becoming more Christ-like, more human,
00:59:48 in a sense. We should live into our full humanity, and they mean something very different than that.
00:59:53 And so those are some of the doctrinal things that I've noticed, that there's just a totally different language that they're using.
00:59:59 Right. Penal substitutionary atonement is also a big one.
01:00:02 So I do think that Protestants, we would do well to add as a supplement, not as a substitute, so not to replace, but to add to penal substitution. 0.93
01:00:13 I believe penal substitutionary atonement, the idea that Christ, our sin, was imputed to him.
01:00:21 He who knew no sin became sin on our account so that we might be reconciled to God.
01:00:25 So he literally died.
01:00:27 And it's not only that, he also lived.
01:00:28 I believe like John Owen, the purity, you know, it's the act of obedience of Christ
01:00:32 in addition to the passive obedience of Christ.
01:00:35 So he lived in our place as our substitute, fulfilling all righteousness.
01:00:40 And most importantly, he died in our place.
01:00:43 Our sin imputed to him so that his righteousness might be imputed to us by faith.
01:00:50 and so um that i i would go so far as to say that penal substitutionary atonement is um it is the
01:00:59 gospel it is the gospel and justification by faith is a linchpin or the heart of the gospel
01:01:05 that said though i think you can hold to that as protestant and you would do well i think that as
01:01:11 protestants we can learn this so not as a replacement not as a substitute but a supplement
01:01:17 In addition, I think we can look at some other atonement models as well.
01:01:23 So penal substitutionary atonement, yes and amen a thousand times.
01:01:26 In addition to that, Christus Victor, ransom atonement.
01:01:30 There are other modes of the atonements that I think are all true.
01:01:34 I don't think it's a, you can only pick one and therefore the others are false.
01:01:39 I think there's a triage there of saying, you know, one is perhaps more important than
01:01:45 the others or more integral to the gospel and justification than the others but um but that
01:01:51 doesn't mean that um that only one can be true and the others are contradictory christus victor
01:01:57 does not on its face it depends on you know what exact you know espousing of christus christus
01:02:04 victor you might particularly get into but on its face christus victor does not contradict with
01:02:08 penal substitutionary atonement you can hold both of them that in the cross and the life death and
01:02:13 burial and resurrection particularly of jesus christ uh that he actually uh he emerged victorious
01:02:19 that he conquered uh spiritual powers that were living in a whole new world that he held uh
01:02:25 spirits to public shame that that there's uh that something changed in in this victorious
01:02:31 christ you can hold to those elements and still hold to penal substitutionary atonement because
01:02:36 it's addressing two different doctrinal issues um but in my reading um from eastern orthodoxy
01:02:44 their perspective penal substitutionary atonement is kind of like what you were saying with
01:02:48 justification by faith chase but uh penal substitutionary atonement is no it's just
01:02:53 not talked about it's just silent um it's it's only christus victor um and so that and i the
01:03:00 idea even of jesus died on the cross for sin he and and how he did that particularly he took my
01:03:09 sin and on the cross took the wrath of god that was merited by my sin that i deserved and he took
01:03:16 it for me and so that the the wrath of god this cup of the white hot wrath of god was poured out
01:03:23 on christ to the point of every drop to where it was empty so there is no wrath that remains
01:03:29 towards god's elect because jesus drank that cup in full um that's that doctrine not just
01:03:37 justification by faith but penal substitutionary atonement that that model of the atonement
01:03:42 seems to be virtually absent from eastern orthodoxy yeah so i yeah all right we should
01:03:50 stop with a doctrine we can come back let's take some questions from the chat you guys do me a
01:03:54 favor if you're listening live go ahead and type in questions now you guys got lots of you're
01:03:58 interacting with each other. That's awesome. But if you write something in and add a question mark,
01:04:04 put it in question form so we know it's for us, then we will come back and we'll address it right
01:04:08 after this break. Our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants to help you with one money move
01:04:14 that'll implicate itself in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day. They
01:04:20 help you to avoid taxation and to draw compound interest to your money. Now, if you're a high
01:04:26 net worth individual, someone who has maybe even 10 million dollars in net worth, then they can
01:04:32 help you even more. W-2 workers, contract workers, business owners, it's all about cash flow and
01:04:39 making tax deferred gains on all your money for the rest of your life. Don't avoid this. It's a
01:04:46 big move, but it's a great time to make it. Click the link below and you can get on Chuck de
01:04:51 Adorante's calendar, and he'll go over your background and what you want to accomplish.
01:04:56 And he's going to help model a program that exactly fits your needs. So go ahead and send
01:05:01 an email to chuck at privatefamilybanking.com. Again, that's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com,
01:05:09 or you can click the link below. Make a free discovery call now.
01:05:14 America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to do their duty
01:05:17 before God and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments of men.
01:05:22 Rees Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied, not just as a
01:05:26 plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business as though they're commandments from God
01:05:31 that we're supposed to obey. Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
01:05:37 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain our
01:05:42 capacity to do things here. Rees Fund, Christian Capital, boldly deployed.
01:05:47 all right we are back okay do we still have pastor chase with us we go great ladies here okay uh let's
01:05:57 get some questions from the chat what do we got let's start with a super chat first i saw that
01:06:01 the other paul is a good dude we know him um super chat 20 what a baller here we go
01:06:08 here in the sydney anglican diocese a reform movement over the past uh 40 years has gutted
01:06:17 our tradition to be gospel-centered and bridge with the culture. The 2024 Synod revealed that
01:06:26 attendance is at record lows. That's not a question. He just wants it to get out there.
01:06:30 There you go. We did a whole episode on different churches, be it in the Anglican tradition or
01:06:34 others, as they compromised on women pastors, for instance. They almost always marked the start of
01:06:40 the decline. The second you embrace them, you could count on it. You're going to see your
01:06:44 attendance drop. You're going to see buildings lost. That is the pattern. Right. Okay, another
01:06:49 question. There's a question. Chase, we talked a little bit about America. We are a Protestant
01:06:54 nation. By God's grace, we will always be so. But Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox, you say we
01:07:00 achieve Christian nationalism, and in our conception of ourselves, we are pan-Protestant.
01:07:05 Catholicism and Eastern Orthodox. What happens to those churches? They wouldn't enjoy, they wouldn't
01:07:09 be state churches, they wouldn't certainly be federal churches, but they would still be what
01:07:14 we would call christian churches here in the united states underneath a protestant milieu
01:07:20 what do you make of that yeah so if we have uh you know emperor uh baron come to power and call
01:07:27 a council and uh you know we have many different protestants come to this council and we argue for
01:07:34 what are we going to do with different uh things like this i think there's a way to have carve
01:07:39 vouts for whether eastern orthodox or roman catholicism uh there's no doubt that roman
01:07:45 catholicism in the country is a very powerful movement has been especially politically for a
01:07:50 long time and i think living in kind of a utopic uh lacking prudence vision of you know making
01:07:58 nations christian and understanding how they're how they're going to become christian and not
01:08:02 really appreciating like hey like there's prudence involved with what people are able to bear and
01:08:08 what people are currently citizens and have been citizens for a long time um there's certain
01:08:13 prudential measures that should be put in place and so there there can be opportunities for carve
01:08:17 outs there can be opportunities for that there can be opportunities for how we involve them
01:08:21 i think you know like for example at the inauguration coming up uh it was released
01:08:27 that like an imam is going to be speaking um at the inauguration which is very disappointing to
01:08:32 Uh, we don't want that. Um, and yet that is, that is reflective of kind of the general, uh, kind of conservative movement today that such a thing would happen. And so there would be ways that there would be exclusion from like public celebration of, of certain, uh, you know, faith, all that kind of stuff.
01:08:52 But there could be opportunities for partnership, have conciliatory relationships, all that kind of thing.
01:08:59 So we need not think of it too rigidly, but we can think of it creatively and with a bunch of prudence as well.
01:09:07 Yeah, that's good.
01:09:09 This is a super chat from Bruce Wilkie.
01:09:11 Is that okay?
01:09:13 Yep.
01:09:13 Close to Bruce Willis, not quite.
01:09:15 Bruce said, is EO gay because of Greece?
01:09:18 Greece the country. 0.96
01:09:19 Keep it up, dudes.
01:09:20 which greece just an orthodox country by and large like in its composition on paper and they 0.99
01:09:26 approved homosexual marriage at least the representatives of the people did by a good 0.93
01:09:30 margin about a year and a half ago at this point so you know it's gay and it's coming from greece
01:09:35 i regret i regret to inform you yeah it's uh sad but not shocking all right the man in charge asks
01:09:41 um how do you help someone thinking of going eastern orthodox so maybe he's been watching
01:09:49 in the YouTube videos, maybe has attended an Eastern Orthodox service, really inclined
01:09:54 in that direction, how do you help someone who's thinking of going in that direction?
01:09:58 What would you say, Chase?
01:10:01 Yeah, I would want to meet with them, especially if they're a member of my church, particularly.
01:10:06 But just generally, if they were a Protestant Christian, Evangelical Christian, was thinking
01:10:10 of doing that, I would want to have a lot of discussions around why, you know, what
01:10:15 What is the draw? You know, a question I always ask when I'm pastoring is, what do you want? What are you after? Jesus asks this question frequently to people, and you can hear them out, you know, you know, and then you can talk about, right, so how do you perceive Eastern Orthodoxy to be meeting that for you?
01:10:35 And why have you prioritized, like, getting that need met as the most important thing for you and your current, either current family or future family? Why do you view that as the most important thing? And then, of course, eventually, I would want to get into the doctrinal distinctions and divisions and help that person go like, hey, like, these are clear differences.
01:10:58 and so for me when I approach situations like this I want to meet with them hopefully in person
01:11:05 and then just talk through the issues it's not complicated but I would be emphasizing look part
01:11:11 of the reason I am Protestant is because of my parents and my grandparents that came before me
01:11:16 who were also Protestant and so in keeping the Protestant tradition going it's not just because
01:11:22 I believe it's true which I do the more I study it the more I love it the more I love God
01:11:25 And it's also because it's a way of honoring my forefathers who came before me.
01:11:30 And so what would that be saying to others?
01:11:32 And so one of the things you encounter in Eastern Orthodoxy, at least from what I understand,
01:11:38 the tradition, and the tradition is big in Eastern Orthodoxy.
01:11:41 The tradition says that people outside of Eastern Orthodoxy are not Christian.
01:11:45 And so what would you be saying by switching to Eastern Orthodoxy of other brothers of me?
01:11:49 What would you be saying of other people?
01:11:51 these are things you would want to take into account
01:11:53 especially as someone
01:11:55 might be drawn into that tradition
01:11:56 Good point
01:11:58 Do we have that quote from Calvin?
01:12:02 Michael has it
01:12:02 I can answer this quick one, it's just on Gavin Ortlund
01:12:05 while he pulls it up, someone asked the question
01:12:07 what are your thoughts about Gavin Ortlund
01:12:09 consistently pushing against the EO
01:12:11 trend by exposing their doctrine
01:12:12 and credit where credit is due, Gavin Ortlund
01:12:15 does a really good job, he's read a lot
01:12:17 of the early church fathers
01:12:18 and his apologetic videos
01:12:20 that's the best thing that gavin does that's the thing is he needs to stay out of climate change
01:12:24 and do eo apologize or young earth or global floods or anything else don't touch any of that
01:12:29 but um his stuff on the eo is good yeah yeah you'll probably hear some of his influences
01:12:34 visible invisible church to be talking about him because he's talked a lot about a lot about it
01:12:39 there's one more he knocked loose here i'll do this one michael pull up the calvin quote because
01:12:44 what chase said is important we need to get back to that and wes actually has a graph
01:12:47 his uh his chart game is getting stronger and stronger by the day um and so we we got a chart
01:12:54 that west made um and so we'll get to that here in just a moment but one more knocked loose he
01:12:58 says can we say that those and because it's on the same topic those in rc roman catholicism and
01:13:03 eastern orthodoxy are off or at least often uh true christians since their churches are in line
01:13:10 with the ancient creeds even if their gospels are whacked i'm going to say yes that is my answer
01:13:16 um i you know i've said this for years even even back you know after watching you know american
01:13:23 gospel and those kinds of things that's that's really what popularized uh it became uh kind of
01:13:28 like um well it just became across the board that the um the answer is you know roman catholicism
01:13:34 is um is you know you're going to hell basically uh i think american you know that obviously that
01:13:41 had been thought before american gospel but that's where it got into like the layman's
01:13:44 vocabulary in my assessment, at least within the Reformed camp. But even back then, I was fond of
01:13:52 saying, I think that bad Catholics make for good Christians. And by God's grace, most Catholics 1.00
01:14:00 are bad Catholics, like the vast majority, like 90%. I think most Catholics are not like, 0.96
01:14:06 yeah, I just got done reading Trent, the Council of Trent, anathematizing the free gospel of grace 0.75
01:14:14 and i love it i love that base that's that's what that's what keeps me roman catholic is i love
01:14:20 anathematizing the gospel of free grace that's just you know or vatican you know vatican two
01:14:25 you know that's that for me that was that's what won me over to uh catholicism um that's just not
01:14:31 the case most most roman catholics at least here in america um are yeah i think that most of them
01:14:39 are christian and i would be willing to to bet the farm that uh that well over half of them are
01:14:45 regenerate um catholicism i think you know if we're talking about with well with a lot of things
01:14:50 it's kind of like america like if we talk at a political level a national level um i think a lot
01:14:55 of america's civil leaders are traitors and should hang with a fair trial first of course but then 0.97
01:15:03 should hang the american people i think there's a lot of wonderful american people uh same with 1.00
01:15:08 roman catholicism uh if we're talking about uh catholics and we're talking about the pope and 0.99
01:15:13 cardinals and bishops and and priests i'm i'm a little bit i'm going to be i'm going to be bearish
01:15:20 on roman catholicism um the priest i'd be a little bit more sympathetic i bet you there's some good
01:15:25 priests um but the higher up you get you know the more in the the leadership class i think there's
01:15:31 more corruption guys who they actually have done the the reading they they know trent and they like
01:15:36 it um but with the parishioners you know like the sweet old lady who's been catholic and going to
01:15:44 catholic mass her whole life you know and loves jesus and she loves some mary too maybe a little
01:15:50 bit more than i'm comfortable with you know but but but she knows at the end of the day if you
01:15:54 said grandma how will we say jesus died for my sin amen and and how how do you you know did jesus
01:16:02 died for everyone? Is everybody going to go to heaven? No, you have to trust him. You have to
01:16:07 believe it. I've talked to Catholics. That's what the average Catholic says. So bad Catholics make
01:16:14 for good Christians. And by God's grace, most Catholics are bad Catholics. Amen. Love it. 1.00
01:16:20 And so all that being said, I have the same kind of perspective for Eastern Orthodoxy. I think most
01:16:25 of the EO bros, especially the more recent, you know, converts, they're like, it's not because
01:16:31 they they love um you know the uh centered prayer and emptying the mind and and because they uh
01:16:37 they hate penal substitutionary atonement or this or that no it's because they wanted because 0.83
01:16:43 protestants and evangelicals followed russell moore got super gay and the eo you know priest
01:16:50 down the road um had a beard and worked out and and and there were some masculine and old
01:16:59 tried and true traditional aesthetics and that that was it and so they they they went you know
01:17:05 and exactly what chase said and michael i think you said it before chase came on is you you you
01:17:10 make a purchase and then it's afterwards not before but afterwards then you do the homework
01:17:16 to try to justify the purchase you've already made but but the the original decision is is it
01:17:21 most of the time is a gut instinct i want something i want something i'm feeling something
01:17:26 is lacking. I perceive some kind of lack, some kind of need, some kind of desire. And so, boom,
01:17:32 I'm pulling the trigger. And then afterwards, when I'm asked about it again and again and again,
01:17:36 why'd you do that? Why'd you make that decision? Then I'm scrambling to do the reading and to have
01:17:42 some kind of justifiable explanation for what I did. But it really wasn't on the front. The front
01:17:48 end was my church closed because of COVID. And even when it was open, my pastor, every time I
01:17:54 shook his hand, I felt like I might, his arm might be ripped off. I mean, it was the limpest hand I've
01:17:59 ever shaken in my life. And this dude kept his church open and he can bench 300 pounds. That's
01:18:05 why. That is the reason. They're not going to tell you that, but that was the initial reason.
01:18:10 And then the last six months after making the decision for that reason, they tried to come up
01:18:14 with other reasons that sound a little bit more fleshed out. But here's the funny thing is,
01:18:19 I actually think that first reason is the best one. I don't think you need to justify it any
01:18:22 more than that. That is a great reason. And so likewise, I'm going to give you my gut instinct
01:18:27 reason that I think eventually, this is my prediction, will bring Americans back to
01:18:32 Protestantism. And here's my reason. Because this is America, gosh darn it. We are not Eastern 0.78
01:18:37 mystics. We are not monks. We don't do centered prayer and Eastern meditation. We are Americans.
01:18:45 we are western we think and jesus paid for sin that's it that'll bring them all back mark mark
01:18:54 it out mark my words give it 20 years tops eastern orthodoxy hath no power in these united states
01:19:01 so chase any thoughts yeah that was great uh i would add to kind of what you said i you know i
01:19:09 i've been curious because i i do have catholic friends uh good relationship with them and i i'm
01:19:15 I'm kind of split, like you're kind of handing out, with the actual papal bulls and all this
01:19:21 kind of stuff, the magisterium, and yet the average Catholic. There is in our American
01:19:27 tradition, and I'm just curious about it, a deep-seated suspicion of Catholics. I don't
01:19:35 necessarily want to cultivate that. I don't know if that would be healthy for our body politic or
01:19:40 even us relationally. At the same time, I think there's legitimate reasons people were a little
01:19:46 bit more, you know, I don't know that they were always wrong to be concerned about Catholic
01:19:52 influence in America. I think there's something to that. We've seen the Catholics have incredible,
01:20:00 wield incredible influence politically, especially in conservatism. And so I do think that we need
01:20:05 to be charitable, like I think you're rightly highlighting in terms of how we understand how
01:20:10 people are saved. At the same time, I think we also need to be cautious about how we understand
01:20:18 the universal authority of the Pope and how that works out. And I mean, the proof is in Joe Biden
01:20:25 being a Catholic. And so there needs to be, like you highlighted, a bit of both interpersonally
01:20:32 and working together on issues like ending abortion,
01:20:35 all that kind of stuff, as much as we can.
01:20:37 At the same time, there needs to be a lack of willingness
01:20:41 to go some places because we are so different.
01:20:45 We are, like you highlighted, we're a Protestant nation historically,
01:20:48 and by God's grace, we will be again.
01:20:50 And so that's an important thing that I think I would add to that.
01:20:54 Yeah.
01:20:55 On this question, Calvin in the Institutes in Book 4, Chapter 2,
01:21:01 really an interesting, actually, if you read 1 and 2, chapters 1 and 2 of Book 4, he is just
01:21:07 really going back and forth to try and resolve this question of what do we do about the fact
01:21:12 that we have split off from the Catholic Church, they have labeled us the schismatics and the
01:21:17 heretics and the people who have driven the wedge, and then he's wondering, well, is there anything
01:21:23 to the Roman Church, the papists, as he called them? And he, I don't know, his writing is
01:21:29 conflicted. But one of the things he lands on is the fact that in the Old Testament, when Israel
01:21:34 was apostatizing over and over again—I mean, you open a chapter of the Bible and Israel's
01:21:38 apostatizing—he says, well, nevertheless, at that time, they remained truly Israel, right?
01:21:45 Like when the prophets of all were sacrificing, that was still actually Israel, though very
01:21:51 corrupted and engaged in heinous false worship. And so he says in the same way, it is possible 0.59
01:21:58 for the people of God now to have been terribly corrupted.
01:22:05 And I mean, they wrote of the Pope as the Antichrist. 0.93
01:22:09 To them, the Pope was the most evil human 0.94
01:22:13 that you could imagine. 0.92
01:22:13 These are the reformers.
01:22:15 Yeah, yeah.
01:22:15 Nevertheless, he had this line where he said,
01:22:20 even the Antichrist is not strong enough
01:22:22 to wrestle the church out of Christ's grasp.
01:22:26 And then he said, he kind of concludes,
01:22:28 section 12 by saying this. He says, hence then, it is obvious that we do not all deny that churches,
01:22:35 that those churches, remain under his tyranny. Churches, however, which by sacrilegious impiety
01:22:41 he has profaned, by cruel domination he has oppressed, by evil and deadly doctrines like
01:22:46 poisoned potions, has corrupted and has almost slain. Churches where Christ lies half-buried,
01:22:52 the gospel is suppressed, piety is put to flight, and the worship of God almost abolished.
01:22:57 where, in short, all things are in such disorder as to present the appearance of Babylon rather
01:23:03 than the holy city of God.
01:23:05 In one word, I call them churches, inasmuch as the Lord there wondrously preserves some
01:23:11 remains of his people, though miserably torn and scattered, and inasmuch as some symbols
01:23:16 of the church still remain, symbols especially whose efficacy neither the craft of the devil
01:23:22 nor human depravity can destroy.
01:23:25 But, on the other hand, those marks to which we ought especially to have respect for this
01:23:31 distinction are effaced.
01:23:33 In other words, where the marks of a true church are gone, I say that the whole body,
01:23:38 as well as every single assembly, want or lack the form of a legitimate church.
01:23:43 And he really actually draws a fascinating distinction that maybe shows that he was
01:23:49 congregational uh he because he says it's possible that the overarching system and the papacy and and
01:23:56 the antichrist is utterly like there is no church there and yet still there are individual churches
01:24:03 which as he says are are torn are polluted are infected by the false doctrines remain yet still
01:24:11 true churches and that to me is remarkable um coming from coming from calvin yes it's really
01:24:16 surprising, actually. Yeah, it is. We've got one super chat. Chase, if you've got time for it,
01:24:21 this was a good question. It sounds like from someone who's considering Eastern Orthodoxy and
01:24:25 Roman Catholicism. Andrew 2727 says this, did Christ pass down a tradition not written in
01:24:33 Scripture? Did Christ pass down a tradition not written in Scripture? If so, it would seem to be
01:24:38 important to hold to Christ's oral traditions, even if not explicitly stated. That's one reason
01:24:44 that I'm considering going EO or Roman Catholic.
01:24:48 Chase, thoughts?
01:24:50 That's an issue to phrase the question.
01:24:54 Did Christ pass down traditions
01:24:56 that are not recorded in Scripture?
01:24:59 I think this is the argument
01:25:00 that Eastern Orthodox use a lot of times
01:25:03 in terms of their liturgy and their worship
01:25:06 and even their aesthetics,
01:25:07 their building construction,
01:25:10 all this kind of stuff.
01:25:11 That's what's so fascinating about Eastern Orthodoxy
01:25:13 when you go into an Eastern Orthodox Church, it does look so foreign, because it's so ancient
01:25:18 in terms of even the way they do art. And so they're trying to preserve something that they
01:25:24 believe to be the true kind of liturgical pattern of the early church. The question does get into
01:25:31 even in Protestant forms of worship, because like Joel's highlighted, a lot of Protestant churches,
01:25:37 not only is there no, well, there's liturgy, but it's not a stated liturgy, and it's a made-up
01:25:42 liturgy in terms of their their weekly rhythm of worship uh whether it's they kick off the
01:25:48 service with a secular worship or not worship but secular song that they play during worship
01:25:53 in order to make people feel more comfortable they have different things they do during the
01:25:57 service i remember growing up in churches where they were they would have skits i don't know if
01:26:01 you guys ever experienced this skits during the service so a lot of evangelical churches are very
01:26:06 uh creative we might say and how they do their liturgy but what he's getting at is the pattern
01:26:11 of worship, even drawing from the Old Testament. And what Protestants have traditionally been good
01:26:16 at, which many are not today, are drawing the pattern of worship from the Old Testament,
01:26:21 whether it's in terms of covenant renewal or other things, and how we conduct our worship together.
01:26:26 And so I think speculating on if Christ taught certain things that are not recorded in Scripture,
01:26:33 that are traditions that were given to the apostles, that then they were supposed to practice,
01:26:38 I don't view that as authoritative, naturally, because I'm a Protestant, whereas in Eastern Orthodox, maybe that would carry some weight.
01:26:45 But we actually have, in the Protestant tradition, a way to handle tradition.
01:26:50 And I think that's the accusation EO's come up with is, y'all have no traditions, solo scripture means there's no traditions.
01:26:58 No, this has been a question we've been wrestling with, we've actually provided answers to for hundreds of years.
01:27:04 We are not anti-traditionalist.
01:27:06 traditionalist. We have traditions we know how to think of. The Anglican communion has a way of
01:27:11 handling tradition. The Methodists have a way of handling tradition. Baptists haven't been as well
01:27:15 educated on how they handle their own tradition, but we all have a way of handling how we do
01:27:20 tradition and where it fits in relationship to Scripture. As Protestants, of course,
01:27:25 Scripture is primary. They submit to Scripture. If something doesn't accord a Scripture,
01:27:29 we're not going to practice it. But I think framing it in terms of what Jesus might have
01:27:35 commanded outside of recorded scripture i think that is very speculative and i wouldn't put a lot
01:27:42 of stock in that yep yep well said all right um we let's let's do the graph and then we'll
01:27:50 we'll call it a day all right throw throw it up this is the last big point chase i think you'll
01:27:54 agree with uh i'll let west flesh it out but there's one major distinction we'd be remiss if
01:27:59 we didn't cover between both roman catholicism as well as these are in orthodoxy versus protestants
01:28:04 Yep. So the claim of the Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church is they are the
01:28:09 visible instantiations of the church that Christ established on earth. Think of Peter and his
01:28:15 confession, and Christ responds to Peter. He says, you are Peter, on this rock I'm going to build
01:28:19 my church. And you'll listen to Matt Fradd, for example, Pints with Aquinas, and he'll have
01:28:23 Protestants that came over to Roman Catholicism, and they would go to the Vatican, and they would
01:28:27 see it, and they would say, oh, Jesus instituted a visible church, a church that was measurable,
01:28:34 a church with real living people.
01:28:36 And so the claim is that, for both of them, and they make really competing claims that
01:28:40 can't really be reconciled, that they are that visible church, that the succession of
01:28:44 bishops and the adherence to councils mean that they have the true church, and there's
01:28:48 a continuity all the way back to Christ. 0.96
01:28:51 Now, one of the difficulties with this is, what do you do with, you would have the unbaptized,
01:28:56 the catechumens, and the apostate. So you have these individuals, and I'm talking about like 0.50
01:29:01 apostates or reprobates that are in the church, but it's not known, it's not understood.
01:29:05 Francis Tartan, I was reading him on this, and he pushes back on Roman Catholic scholar Bellarmine
01:29:11 because what they have to assert for the Roman Catholic and the Eastern Orthodox is that the
01:29:16 church is visible. But if the church is primarily a visible institution, then that means that
01:29:21 everyone in the church would be saved. So we would say there's no salvation outside of the
01:29:26 church. When we mean that, we mean the body of believers across all time that are invisible,
01:29:31 that Jesus has joined together. The Roman Catholic says that there is no salvation outside of the
01:29:35 church, and he means the visible church. But then if there's no salvation outside of it,
01:29:39 then you have to be joined to the visible church. But then how do you distinguish within the visible
01:29:42 church those that are wicked and reprobate and those that are not? Because if you're a Roman 1.00
01:29:46 Catholic and you say there's no salvation outside of submission to the Roman pontiff,
01:29:51 then you are in communion fellowship sharing the visible church with joe biden and nancy pelosi
01:29:57 every sunday yep and same thing for eastern orthodox brother and sister in christ amen if
01:30:03 you're roman catholic not not not for us protestants right and they would have good conservative
01:30:09 catholics they would have pushback and say well no for these reasons or that here's where the
01:30:13 protestant has the advantage though you can show this graph of the visible invisible church
01:30:17 The Protestant asserts that the church is primarily a universal, invisible church.
01:30:24 So all believers, I think of Hebrews, the great cloud of witnesses, all believers past,
01:30:29 that would be the church triumphant, those who have attained their crown, they've run
01:30:33 the race, those present, the church militant, and all those future are being perfected here
01:30:39 in this life, have been translated by death into heaven, and will be the bride that Jesus
01:30:44 perfects.
01:30:44 Now, the visible church on earth is not a perfect overlap with the invisible church.
01:30:51 But the invisible church here on earth, those that are living, they're regenerate, they
01:30:56 live in, they inhabit the invisible universal church because they've been joined to Christ
01:31:01 by faith, and the visible church.
01:31:03 But there's one additional category in this visible church.
01:31:06 They're in the visible church, but they're reprobate and not part of the invisible church.
01:31:11 And so in this way, every given local church, a visible real church, will contain within
01:31:15 it the regenerate believers that belong to the invisible universal church.
01:31:20 And then they will have some that are reprobates.
01:31:22 Hebrews talked about those who were not joined by faith.
01:31:25 And we can say, yes, absolutely, they are part of the visible church.
01:31:28 They have made, Stephen Wolf, he said, the visible Catholic church is recognized by profession,
01:31:33 not an institution.
01:31:34 Well, anyone can profess, can't they?
01:31:36 Yeah, absolutely.
01:31:36 but they cannot profess and be part of the invisible universal church, which is on the
01:31:41 basis of faith in Jesus. But they can for a time join the visible church, and at the end of the
01:31:46 age, Christ will root out all those who through their professional faith claimed to be, I'm part
01:31:52 of the invisible universal church. No, you were wicked. You had an attachment for a time by 0.90
01:31:56 profession to a visible local institution, but you never were of the substance of the invisible
01:32:01 church. And I think for Protestants, getting this helps you see, you talked about Catholics,
01:32:06 that means that a catholic in a visible local parish there will be bad catholics good catholics
01:32:12 those that are regenerate and belong to it and there will be some that are they merely attend
01:32:16 mass twice a year they're in the visible church a visible true church but not belonging to the
01:32:21 substance of it amen i yeah i think this graph is super helpful anybody who's just listening to the
01:32:27 audio it this one would be worth going to the website right response ministries.com and pulling
01:32:32 up the video and then skipping forward to the end of it or going on youtube or whatever but just to
01:32:36 be able to visually um look at that you did a good job it made a lot of for me it helped like i you
01:32:41 know i already had that paradigm of visible and invisible church but it really helped to see um
01:32:46 to see it to be able to visualize it and yeah as as far as i understand both eastern orthodoxy and
01:32:53 roman catholicism um don't have that scheme that that framework that protestants do and i think at
01:33:00 some level what it what it allows for um a certain luxury or privilege that allows for
01:33:06 protestants that roman catholics and eastern orthodox guys don't have is um more of an
01:33:12 ecumenical spirit in a good way in the good sense and not the negative that um i'm able to look
01:33:18 like my desire for rome um is you know and this is something that i had to come to over time i
01:33:24 didn't always think this but um but for the last few years like my desire for rome is i want to
01:33:30 see rome repent um i i and and not just my desire if i could be uh just even a little bit more bold
01:33:37 my prediction for roman catholicism is um i don't think i'm post-millennial in my eschatology i don't
01:33:44 think if i had to guess if i had to bet i don't think that um roman catholicism will be um
01:33:51 completely uprooted and destroyed and removed i think it'll be restored um i think that roman
01:33:58 Catholicism is an offshoot, right? It's a pretty profound irony, much to their chagrin, despite all 1.00
01:34:06 the claims. They're the offshoot that's gone off the rails, and I think that they will be, by God's
01:34:12 grace, brought back in to the fold. And as they're currently off the rails as an offshoot, I still
01:34:18 think, my previous statement still stands, I think that many congregants, parishioners within Roman
01:34:24 Catholicism are a part of the invisible church, that they really are regenerate, that they really
01:34:30 do love the Lord Jesus Christ and have faith in him for salvation. But as an institution, 0.92
01:34:35 that sector of the visible church, as an institution, the Roman Catholic, you know,
01:34:40 institutional church, I think it's off the rails. But I think the plan of God is not to utterly
01:34:45 remove it, but to restore it. I think that Rome eventually will repent. I really do. I think that
01:34:50 they will go back and say, yeah, we should have, we should have held a council. We should have
01:34:54 heard you out. We should have, uh, we should have recanted here. We should have done that.
01:34:58 We should have done this. And, um, I, yeah, I'm, I'm very hopeful that that'll happen. I don't know
01:35:04 if it happens in our lifetime, but I think that it will eventually happen. And, um, and in the
01:35:09 meantime, uh, because if you're not careful, like some of the reformed bros, like I love them, 1.00
01:35:14 god bless them but um they talk about roman catholics like this like more harshly than 0.80
01:35:21 they talk about muslims and i'm like what in the world are you like they believe in the triune god
01:35:27 they believe in in jesus christ that he that he that he died and was buried and rose again like
01:35:33 um that you know this is these are completely separate categories like you know yeah but we've
01:35:40 had, historically, we've had a war with the Catholics more recently than with the Muslims. 0.98
01:35:44 True. True. But we have had centuries and centuries of wars with Muslims. 1.00
01:35:51 I agree. 1.00
01:35:51 You know, and so, yeah. So anyway, so I would like to see Protestants be a little bit more 1.00
01:35:58 charitable towards Catholics, but while still understanding the distinctives, the irreplaceable
01:36:03 distinctives of Protestant doctrine, and knowing that, yes, it absolutely matters, and we're not
01:36:08 going to compromise on that. But recognizing that those particulars, doctrinal particulars,
01:36:14 I think most of them exist, are more etched in stone at the higher echelons of leadership within
01:36:20 Catholicism and not necessarily parishioners. And then God's larger plan, I really do think
01:36:26 redemption and restoration and repentance is far more likely, if I had to bet, than utter removal.
01:36:33 And then I think, you know, I'd have a similar position towards Eastern Orthodoxy, and yet at the same time, and this would be something that would probably get clipped out of context, I'm not going either direction, but if I had two options and only two options afforded to me, I would become a Roman Catholic every day of the week and twice on Sunday before becoming Eastern Orthodox.
01:36:56 Same. 0.75
01:36:57 Same.
01:36:57 same i don't i don't know how any any western protestant could argue otherwise like i mean
01:37:04 to me that is just so abundantly clear um just simply the culture and the practices like i would
01:37:10 have to um i would have there would be no more joel left in the equation like i would have to lose
01:37:17 utterly lose every component about me i don't know i don't even know how to do that it like it makes
01:37:24 it feels so foreign to like i'm going to uh i'm going to just empty my mind and i'm going to
01:37:31 you know i i just i'm not um i'm an american gosh darn it so anyways and roman catholicism
01:37:41 particularly here in america is even yeah you know even closer because it has been you know
01:37:46 and same for eo they've had a prostan influence you go to ukraine or romania look a lot different
01:37:52 a lot different. Right. Chase, so what do you think about that? In terms of Roman Catholicism,
01:37:59 invisible, visible church being a uniquely Protestant scheme that Rome doesn't have,
01:38:04 that Eastern Orthodoxy doesn't have. And then what do you think as a pastor, a Protestant pastor,
01:38:09 do you think Rome will eventually come back into the fold? Or do you think it's just,
01:38:13 we're just waiting for it to all be burnt up? What do you think?
01:38:17 Yeah, I think the graphic is really helpful. Actually, I wish I could have that graphic. I
01:38:20 I teach that at our church, that distinction that we have as Protestants.
01:38:25 And I think it's an important distinction to make, you know, like you said.
01:38:28 And I think a lot of even Christians, Protestant Christians are confused on this in terms of how we talk about, you know, belonging to a local church and what it means to be saved by Jesus. 0.94
01:38:39 I'm less positive on the Roman Catholics coming back.
01:38:43 I did want to, it's an interesting thing, Joel, that I thought I'd ask since we're on the air.
01:38:52 You know, I sympathize with treating Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox, and I think it's part of our tradition and also part of my temperament and yours, to be somewhat charitable, I might say, with these people.
01:39:07 Like you highlighted this Roman Catholic grandmother who loves Jesus, and there's still hope for them.
01:39:14 Part of the tension I feel in my mind, maybe you don't feel this tension, but part of the tension I feel in my mind is we look at evangelicals that have compromised with women pastors, with all this kind of stuff, just giving themselves over to celebrating gay marriage, whatever it might be.
01:39:30 And we do judge them very harshly, right? 0.59
01:39:33 We do almost, I wouldn't say anathematize, but to use a word, there's a sense of like, they're outside the fold. 0.99
01:39:40 And yet there does seem to be a proclivity, at least in my mind, to give deference a little bit more so to the Catholics.
01:39:47 And that's why I'm less like when I hear guys not dumping on, but, you know, like attacking the Roman Catholic Church and all that kind of stuff.
01:39:57 That is more part of our heritage to do that, like was highlighted, where it's like we had wars with Catholics. 0.66
01:40:05 And there's a reason all the Reformers spoke of the Pope being the Antichrist.
01:40:09 And so there is a legitimacy to that critique, whereas these people that are evangelical ministers in America, Protestant ministers, who are deeply compromised, should we not extend a similar charity in their direction that we are also extending to kind of Roman Catholics and the hope there?
01:40:28 Does that question make sense?
01:40:30 That's the tension I'm feeling.
01:40:31 yeah yeah i think so i think the the reason why i don't is the charity that i'm extending to the
01:40:36 roman catholic guys is um i'm i'm thinking i i said it in a macro big picture sense but more
01:40:43 particularly i'm thinking of guys like uh what's his name charles taylor i think is his name um
01:40:50 my point is i'm thinking of the guys who are culturally and politically conservative
01:40:54 i think part of the reason that i wouldn't extend uh the same type of charity because all the
01:40:59 the arguments that i made uh doctrinally um certainly um you know you can make that about
01:41:03 russell moore you can make that about david french you know or you know anybody of of that of that
01:41:08 particular stripe you can say well these guys also believe in the triune god and they believe you
01:41:13 know in in this case they even believe in justification by faith and these kinds of things
01:41:16 um but the reason why uh the guys that you and i you know have big problems with uh in within the
01:41:23 protestant world um it's less doctrinal and it's more political and cultural and i think part of
01:41:29 the reason we have the problem with them is um because what they're tampering with isn't so much
01:41:34 the doctrine although they they are tampering with some things that are doctrinal um but they're
01:41:38 tampering with uh the physical um the physical future and life and and viability of my kids
01:41:46 so um so the conservative catholic i think he's wrong um on on a host of things but i think a lot
01:41:54 of them are ignorantly wrong again speaking of the parishioners um and in that case many of them if
01:42:00 you really kind of dig beneath the surface and you ask the questions you have the conversations
01:42:05 they actually you know they actually believe a lot of things that you do and they're not
01:42:09 really aware of vatican one and vatican two and trent and these kinds of things
01:42:13 um but then culturally that's doctrinally but then culturally and politically they're like yeah we 0.85
01:42:19 we got to stop murdering babies we got to stop transing kids we got to stop uh importing you 0.90
01:42:25 know in mass the third world um and rape gains and you know all these kind of stuff whereas um 0.99
01:42:31 like if russell moore wins my kids die and i mean that in a literal physical sense 0.95
01:42:37 russell moore wants to kill my children so i just have less charity for guys who want to kill my
01:42:42 kids yeah so we're distinguishing that's helpful so we're distinguishing between what's a more 0.84
01:42:48 imminent threat and i think that what you're saying is that the most imminent threat right
01:42:53 now are guys that we are within our own what we would say protestant tradition who are deeply
01:42:58 compromised politically and so we have to give the most force against that the threat of maybe
01:43:06 catholicism overtaking america uh is is doesn't feel like a great as great a threat as the
01:43:13 compromised churches left and right that have kind of been over back backwards to government
01:43:18 regulation and are are not standing firm on god's word today and i think that's a helpful
01:43:23 distinguishing uh to make there so thanks for uh going with yeah no thanks for asking the question
01:43:28 yeah and and the way that you are just articulated i think is super helpful it's it's a sense of
01:43:32 urgency is the sense of what's most imminent like i think you know if if we were predicting you know
01:43:37 the next 10 years um i think political left leftism um overtaking america seems to be far more imminent
01:43:47 than um then all of a sudden you know that we have um a catholic christian nationalism
01:43:53 that's drowning baptists you know that's drowning baptist yeah exactly so like catholics drowning
01:43:57 my baptist children i think they'd burn us at the stake or burning yeah or burning our my you know 0.61
01:44:03 so my yeah exactly but seriously like i and i think it helps it's like oh you're being hyperbolic
01:44:07 but but really it does help like i i live in a border state state of texas um what seems more
01:44:14 likely to me as a husband and father um in the next 10 years uh that texas becomes so overwhelmed 0.96
01:44:21 at the southern border by um by illegal immigrants many of them criminals murderers and rapists
01:44:29 that my four daughters and wife their physical lives are endangered does that seem more likely 0.75
01:44:37 or uh catholics um enacting catholic like taking over the united states enacting catholic laws
01:44:45 to where protestants are hung or burnt right like you know what i mean and when you when you
01:44:50 pose it like that then we can all laugh at the absurdity because it really is absurd like one
01:44:57 of those threats is like right around the corner like right on the doorstep the fact that donald
01:45:02 trump won this election is is sheerly the grace of god um if he hadn't won this election then i
01:45:07 would say yeah eight eight more if we had eight years of kamala we're done we're done um whereas 0.54
01:45:14 i think it would take a hundred years of catholics on their a-game you know and maybe 0.90
01:45:21 maybe they they might be able to arrest some protestants and i think still highly unlikely 0.54
01:45:27 so chase any final thoughts for you before we um in this episode no i'm good man thanks for having
01:45:34 me today yeah thanks for coming on we really appreciate it all right well we're gonna go
01:45:39 ahead and land the plane west any final thought the final thought is say you're eastern orthodox 0.57
01:45:43 you're hate watching, you're like, that was an hour and 45 minutes, a straw man, didn't like it,
01:45:48 and you go to that church and you never leave. There's going to be you. Here's the exhortation.
01:45:54 We love you. We want to see you on the final day, name written in the Lamb's Book of Life.
01:46:00 In the meantime, wherever you go, be it Roman Catholicism, be it Eastern Orthodox. We think
01:46:05 there's great reasons you shouldn't. But if you go there, love Jesus, love your family,
01:46:09 touch some grass and be a force for god's kingdom uh that's that's culturally that's politically
01:46:15 push back against wickedness push back against darkness love the people around you exercise the
01:46:22 fruit of the spirit charity patience kindness goodness to those you disagree with and um i
01:46:27 guess we'll see you on the other side yep lord sounds good lord willing all right we appreciate
01:46:32 you guys tuning in subscribe to the youtube channel go ahead and follow us on x at right
01:46:37 response M at right response M. And we will see you guys again on Wednesday.