The NXR Podcast - April 07, 2025


THE LIVESTREAM - Yes, The Gospel Changes Genetics - ICYMI

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
THE LIVESTREAM - Nations: Don’t Unite What God Divided THE LIVESTREAM - If This Fails, America LOSES BIGLY.

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 15 minutes

Words per minute

185.91

Word count

25,166

Sentence count

982

Harmful content

Misogyny

18

sentences flagged

Toxicity

33

sentences flagged

Hate speech

80

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we discuss genetics, faithfulness, and godly living, and how all of it matters. Join us for this special episode where we dig deep on genetics and Godly living. This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reese Fund, as well as our patrons and faithful donors.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Leave us a five-star review on your favorite podcast platform.
00:00:03 I get it. It's annoying. Everybody asks, but I'm going to tell you why.
00:00:07 When you give us a positive review, what that does is it triggers the algorithm
00:00:12 so that our podcast shows up on more people's newsfeeds.
00:00:16 You and I both know that this ministry is willing to talk about things that most ministries aren't.
00:00:21 We need this content for the glory of God to reach more people's ears.
00:00:26 War, disease, famine, worship, prosperity, technology, diet, and exercise.
00:00:37 All of these things fundamentally affect who we are as individuals and as groups.
00:00:44 But it affects more than psychology or experience.
00:00:48 It affects us at a genetic level, and the impact of these events and patterns is measurable
00:00:55 over the course of even generations.
00:00:59 Because of this, how we live matters.
00:01:03 Living well, including eating well, living in chastity, staying active, and avoiding
00:01:08 toxins and their impact is not just something that will affect you, not even just your children,
00:01:15 but it has the potential to affect untold thousands of your future descendants.
00:01:23 God visits iniquity on those that hate him to the third and fourth generation,
00:01:29 but he shows steadfast love to the thousandth generation of those who love him,
00:01:35 and catch this, and keep his commandments.
00:01:40 Yes, this literally means that the wicked reap their reward for their iniquity in their own bodies.
00:01:48 Not merely their souls in the life to come, but even in their flesh, here and now.
00:01:55 We see this per Romans chapter 1.
00:01:58 While the righteous, however, are renewed and protected for their faithfulness.
00:02:04 This episode is brought to you by our premier sponsors, Armored Republic and Reese Fund,
00:02:11 as well as our Patreon members and our faithful donors.
00:02:14 You can join our Patreon by going to patreon.com forward slash right response ministries,
00:02:22 or you can donate by going to right response ministries.com forward slash donate.
00:02:28 Join us for this special episode where we dig deep on genetics.
00:02:34 faithfulness, godly living, and how all of it matters.
00:02:48 Welcome back. Here we are. It is Wednesday afternoon. For those of you who are new to the
00:02:52 stream, we live stream three times a week on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday at 3 p.m. Central
00:02:58 time with myself, and we also have Michael Belch, and we also have Wesley Todd. Now,
00:03:04 today's episode, as you just saw in the cold open, is going to be dealing with some things
00:03:08 that are important, that we believe the Bible addresses, but that are highly controversial
00:03:13 for our culture today, especially within the church. We are going to address some things
00:03:19 that the evangelical church has said are not allowed. You're simply not allowed to go there,
00:03:25 kind of like Simba and Mufasa. What's that dark shadowy place over there? That's the subject of
00:03:32 race and you must never go there. But we are going to go there and by God's grace, we're going to do
00:03:37 it carefully, but we're going to do our best to do it courageously and truthfully. And we're going
00:03:43 to try to do it using as much of the scripture and also as much natural revelation of what we have
00:03:49 data as possible. This is an episode, just to be frank, that I would not feel comfortable doing by
00:03:56 myself. And so I'm glad, I'm very, very relieved and grateful that I have both Michael and Wes
00:04:04 with us today. Wes has outlined this episode. Real quick, you've said it in the past, but if
00:04:10 we have new listeners just for this particular episode, what are your bona fides? There was a
00:04:15 comment already from classic troll and he said i guarantee none no one in this lot has an education
00:04:21 biology behind high school so went to columbia university for neuroscience behavior for my
00:04:25 undergrad oh troll oh oh getting known the biology parts you the neuroscience behavior is the psych
00:04:31 part and then the neuroscience is the biology part the two classes there uh dr deborah mausiewicz
00:04:37 she teaches them both the regard as some of the hardest biology classes in the nation of which i
00:04:42 did both of them. So that was my undergraduate neuroscience and behavior. And now I have my
00:04:45 master's degree, master's in public health epidemiology and epidemiology for the record
00:04:50 is a study of diseases and traits among people groups as a whole. So the micro level biology,
00:04:56 and then the macro level, I hate credentialism, but if it comes down to it, I have the credentials
00:05:01 like Paul, I'll say like, no, I have a degree in my mind to speak like this, but allow little 0.95
00:05:06 fool's talk. I have a degree in these things. And so that's why I'm qualified to talk about it. 0.96
00:05:09 Joel, you didn't ask me.
00:05:10 I'm going to state mine.
00:05:11 Yeah, well, Michael, you are fantastic.
00:05:13 I think better than me.
00:05:15 I took high school biology.
00:05:16 There you go.
00:05:17 There you go.
00:05:18 So did I.
00:05:19 I think I even took the, what do they call them?
00:05:22 AP or like the advanced class?
00:05:24 Yep.
00:05:25 I think I was right in the middle of the pack.
00:05:27 I think you're qualified to lead this one off then.
00:05:29 No.
00:05:30 So Wes is going to be, he's outlined this episode.
00:05:34 He's going to be leading out.
00:05:35 We're all going to be pitching in.
00:05:36 We have thoughts about this.
00:05:37 I've been thinking about this for quite a while, but Wes has done a lot of the research and the
00:05:41 heavy lifting, and we're going to make sure that we're looking to God's book of nature that he's
00:05:48 written, that he's sovereign over, but making sure that ultimately, in this sense, I would still
00:05:54 define myself as presuppositional. In what sense? Because every time I disagree with someone, I just
00:06:00 recite Romans 1. No. Presuppositional in the sense that at the end of the day, I'm going to appeal to
00:06:07 logic and nature and these things, but I know that these things ultimately have authority and
00:06:11 that they are trustworthy, incredible because of the Word of God. To me, the heart of
00:06:17 presuppositionalism is when you peel back behind this and this and this and this and you get to
00:06:22 the very bottom. What is the bottom? Is it nature or is it the inspired Word of God? And I believe
00:06:28 it is the Word of God. So I can look to nature and learn things that God has said through nature.
00:06:33 but the reason I can trust my sense perceptions and I can trust things that I see in nature as
00:06:39 an orderly world and not just chaotic or random is because the Bible tells me so. The Bible tells
00:06:45 me so. So we are going to be looking at a lot of studies, and we're going to be relying on
00:06:50 Wes's expertise, and we're going to be doing our best at the very same time to root these things
00:06:57 also in the scripture. That being said, real quick, if you haven't registered yet for our
00:07:02 conference, Christ is King, How to Defeat Trash World, happening Thursday, Friday, Saturday,
00:07:08 April 3rd, 4th, and 5th this year, then we encourage you to go and do that. Go to Right
00:07:13 Response Conference, not ministries, but Right Response Conference. It has its own page,
00:07:19 rightresponseconference.com. And go ahead and also sign up for our business networking lunch.
00:07:25 If you are a business owner or an aspiring business owner, you're looking at starting
00:07:30 a business sometime this year, then we encourage you to sign up for that. It's $25. We're just
00:07:37 trying to cover, we're going to cater food for this. So we're just trying to cover the food and
00:07:41 the tip and the delivery and tax. And so sign up for that. It's on that same page. So you can sign
00:07:47 up for the conference. And if you scroll down, you'll be able to sign up for the business
00:07:50 networking lunch. And then also for our singles event. Unfortunately, we are full for the guys
00:07:56 and we still need a few gals. We're about halfway there with the gals. So, if you are a God-fearing 1.00
00:08:02 woman and you want to be a part of this conference, again, go to rightresponseconference.com
00:08:06 to register. If you've already registered, still go to that page, scroll down, and you'll see the
00:08:12 singles event and register for that. So, that's pretty much, that's all of our talking shop. I
00:08:19 think we're ready to dive in. All right. The best way I know to illustrate this, we've talked about
00:08:23 this before. This is the field of epigenetics. So genetics, epi meaning above, above genetics,
00:08:29 what's going on that affects them. The best way I know to do this is to literally illustrate it
00:08:33 and to talk about real life case examples. That's what we're going to spend most of the episode
00:08:36 doing. But before I do that, it's necessary to just, there is a notion going around. I don't
00:08:42 know who said it. Oh, wait, every evangelical, that race is not real. Race comes from this idea 0.90
00:08:47 of a fountainhead. And when we describe race, what we're just, we're really getting at is really
00:08:53 ancestor. Now, if you could show this chart when you get back into the office, this is
00:08:57 the best way I know to illustrate it because it can be hard to conceptualize of streams of people
00:09:02 and they break off and they form new populations, new groups or whatever, and they carry on
00:09:07 different traits. So this is what's called a phylogenic tree. And what a phylogenic tree
00:09:12 could do, if you imagine the first dogs that got off Noah's Ark, imagine there was one canine,
00:09:16 right? That class of mammal canine. Well, that dog went on to break into bigger and smaller breeds.
00:09:22 Now, you could speak of terrier, and then you could speak of some of the smaller ones.
00:09:25 Those would only be two groups.
00:09:26 But within those two groups, there's then groups of five, six, seven, eight, nine.
00:09:30 And then even within terrier, within lab, within all of these different ones, there
00:09:34 would be then sub-differences.
00:09:35 And all of those would be because maybe you take a bulldog from England, and you brought
00:09:38 it over to America, and that then became the American bulldog.
00:09:42 In human beings, we have the same thing.
00:09:44 All human beings come from Adam.
00:09:47 Adam and Eve were the first man and the first woman, and all men and women come from them.
00:09:50 and so everything about what makes us human ultimately originated in them and we experienced
00:09:55 what was called a bottleneck at noah so in the story of noah as we see god floods the earth and
00:10:00 he wipes out all but roughly three sons their wives maybe a couple other people knowing his wife
00:10:06 about eight people so you have tons of genetic data and everything when you say maybe you mean
00:10:11 definitely eight persons in all do they have kids at the time nope that's what i'm getting persons
00:10:15 in all yeah all right so first peter so you get all the way down to that amount and from then his
00:10:19 suns then spread out and they fill the earth and it would look kind of something like this
00:10:24 so all i've done is here illustrated this isn't necessarily this part from a study this is for
00:10:29 example the european phylogenic tree of the different races that would comprise europeans
00:10:33 a big one is the germanic peoples then you had the romance peoples the slavics this would be
00:10:38 more in eastern europe celtic all of that and there's more that i haven't mentioned there's
00:10:42 more that goes down of course europeans and africans and asians as big groups but the point
00:10:47 is you can get as small or as big as you want this is what is tough i get why people say like
00:10:53 they don't like race because like what's the difference between an anglian and a saxon so
00:10:57 these are both english individuals that came from a germanic peoples and they resided in different
00:11:02 areas historically like are they different races in the same way like germans and um like russians
00:11:08 are like well not as much then difference from europeans and africans is even bigger
00:11:12 there's not necessarily like strict hard and fast rules but if we get back to the idea of that word
00:11:19 race fountainhead is referring to different peoples that came from different origins that
00:11:24 settled in different areas and formed distinct peoples now you can pull up this chart the graph
00:11:29 two chart games out of control this week all these little dots on here i made for the record
00:11:34 wow wow wow so let's imagine right here on the left you have imagine each one of these dots it's
00:11:40 it's talking about 10,000 people. And this, the common ancestors occupied one space.
00:11:45 Each one of the arrows. 10,000 people. Dots, arrows. Each of these represents a large number
00:11:52 of people. And at one time, all of these people on the right, which is as time goes on,
00:11:57 they all originated from a smaller core group. And that smaller core group shared a lot of the
00:12:02 similar characteristics. Maybe it was characteristics like height and intelligence and skin color
00:12:06 and all of that but then you had one people as you can see there that maybe migrated north and
00:12:11 they went to a different climate and then the people down there that maybe experienced war and
00:12:16 then when that war ended there's two people split off but you can begin to see there in the colors
00:12:20 that differences arise that people that once had one set of traits on the whole on average no longer
00:12:27 share them with the people that they once did the environment events things that happen diet this
00:12:32 that or the other change somewhat of their composition. A great example of this, I want
00:12:37 to illustrate it on the ground, is the LCT gene, which allows adults to process lactose. So normally
00:12:45 the ability to process lactose goes away as a child gets older and weans. They simply don't
00:12:50 need that milk anymore. But in especially northern European peoples, it became a very advantageous 0.85
00:12:56 trait to have. So there was not a lot of food going around. But what they could do, even adults
00:13:00 who had this gene was drink cow's milk because they'd be able to process the lactose and so now
00:13:05 there are different groups of people in the world some of them can process lactose i destroy about a
00:13:10 half gallon of milk a day literally like it's it's a great source of calories protein protein shakes
00:13:14 all of that i can process it other people's can't and if you and if you it's mind-boggling that
00:13:21 people would go so far as to kind of deny these differences that common origin we're tracing back
00:13:26 to someone, tracing back to an event, tracing back to different lifestyles, different environments
00:13:30 would actually create differences. But it's just objectively true. People have different traits
00:13:36 from the environment, from their lifestyle, from the different things they do. And it does
00:13:40 meaningly affect their life. Being able to process lactose affects my life. It changes my diet,
00:13:46 the way I eat. It's a great source of calcium, which helps me, then children, all of those
00:13:50 different things. So just to lay the groundwork, common origin, common ancestor, the traits they
00:13:56 have passed down to pass down, people's breaking off, starting new groups, intermarrying, all of
00:14:01 those come to create differential sets of traits in different people. And none of that is extreme,
00:14:08 obscure, contested, anything like that. That is what has been believed. This is what has been
00:14:13 affirmed in the literature. This is how people have lived. And it's observable. And it's observable.
00:14:19 exactly like melanin like darkness of the skin that's a function of the equator and the sun
00:14:23 like people that lived there ended up needing a darker skin to combat the continual effects of
00:14:30 the sun versus people that lived farther north that often had fairer skin like that's just that's
00:14:35 how it works and so those people that live there develop that trait a culture did not give someone
00:14:40 black skin or white skin they were born with it because of the environment because of genetics
00:14:45 yep all right all right so far makes sense let's go to chart number three nathan um i realize some 0.95
00:14:53 of this especially as we get into dna it's a little bit technical but here's the deal for
00:14:57 those of you that want this you're going to get the info and if you can't follow it here's the 0.99
00:15:01 deal every minute i keep going atheists look stupider and stupider dumber and dumber the 0.99
00:15:07 human genome is incredible the complexity here like i'm just we're going to get pretty complex 1.00
00:15:13 just scratching the surface. It is incredible the way that God has made our cells and our genes to
00:15:20 be passed down. Every single one of your cells, besides red blood cells, contain 23 pairs of
00:15:28 chromosomes, 46 total in general, that contain all of your DNA. Every single one of your cells
00:15:33 in every single part of your body. And it's from that DNA, you see there the chromosome,
00:15:38 the DNA is contained within the chromosome, and the gene is then contained within the DNA.
00:15:43 every protein, everything that makes your eyes, everything that makes your liver, your fingernails,
00:15:47 your skin, all of these things come from your genes that are there. And so because you have,
00:15:53 for example, all 46 chromosomes in your eye, the eye unravels just certain portions of your
00:15:59 chromosome that has the proteins and the enzymes and everything needed just for the eye, unravels
00:16:04 it so the DNA is accessible. And then the gene there actually transcribes it. It's called the
00:16:09 central dogma of the cell. Transcription, where what's called an RNA polymerase, reads the DNA,
00:16:15 and then the DNA is taken into messenger RNA that is then translated and made into proteins.
00:16:21 I say all of this to say, these genes contained on the DNA, in the chromosome, in every single cell,
00:16:28 can be turned on and off. They can be done with two ways. In the chromosome, the way they stay
00:16:34 all wrapped around, because there's like a meter worth of DNA in every single cell, and you have
00:16:39 trillions of cells in your body, is wrapped tightly around these things called histones.
00:16:42 And histones can be turned on and off with the addition of what's called methyl groups. We're
00:16:46 going to talk a lot about methyl groups and methylation in this episode. Methyl groups,
00:16:50 methylation. Methylation blocks the enzyme that comes in and reads the gene. So you have a gene
00:16:57 here for some type of protein, like vitamin A or whatever it would be. If there's a methyl group,
00:17:02 either on the histone that contains that gene or just on the DNA in general, it blocks transcription
00:17:07 of it now it could be a truly total like this is not being transcribed at all or it could be much
00:17:12 sort of it's transcribed less to a lesser degree transcription that's really important right because
00:17:17 that's passing on to new cells so i think you need to exactly that's the that's like copying it down
00:17:22 for the next one and the next one and the next one exactly because originally we were only essentially
00:17:26 two cells the the zygotes so the sperm and the egg but then they came together and they divided
00:17:30 make two and then four and then eight so at one point your eye was like a single cell now it had
00:17:36 all the information to make all the pieces of the eye but eventually it took those different pieces
00:17:42 it made more cells those replicated those replicated retina and cornea exactly yeah but
00:17:47 genes turned off say at that very beginning cell that very first cell that went on to make your eye
00:17:52 or went on to make your liver or your heart or anything like that different parts of being turned
00:17:56 off and turned on really matter because then the cells that followed would also be turned on and
00:18:02 turned off. So all of these different traits, all of these different proteins, habits, ability to
00:18:07 process lactose come back down to your gene. Your gene's held across your DNA, wrapped in chromosomes
00:18:12 contained in every cell of your body. Praise God. Absolutely amazing. What happens? What could be
00:18:22 a way? What is a practical example of the way this worked? The Native American Indians, Rush
00:18:28 Juney speaks of this, they really were a hearty people. Obviously, it was variation in the tribe.
00:18:31 some of them were much more nomadic, some had settled more, but they were very nomadic people
00:18:36 that really, Rush Duny, he lectures about this, they spent every moment of their day working
00:18:41 because they had to find food. They were a hunting, gathering community. They didn't have
00:18:46 downtime. It seems like the least, the most that they would do was the children would gather around
00:18:51 the grandparents at night for a fire. They were a hunting, gathering community, and it's one of
00:18:55 the reasons alcohol has destroyed them, for example, on the reservation. There's not much
00:18:59 work. They're not doing what they did for thousands of years. So when the Europeans that
00:19:06 then went on settled America and became Americans, they took the Indians and they said, we've got to 0.90
00:19:11 put them somewhere. We have hundreds of thousands of people. What are we going to do with them?
00:19:14 They eventually put them on the reservations. They began to provide a stipend that gave them
00:19:18 a bad diet. So Nate, you can pull up this quote. This is quote number one from history.com.
00:19:24 And so you had European colonization, and it changed the diet of a people that had lived
00:19:29 a certain way for thousands of years and were very good at it.
00:19:32 Let me read this for anyone that's listening.
00:19:34 During these forced relocations, so relocation to Indian reservations, new foods were distributed
00:19:39 to tribes in the form of government-issued rations.
00:19:42 These rations, distributed twice a month, originally included lard, flour, coffee, and
00:19:46 sugar, and canned meat, generically known as spam, which has been linked to an increased
00:19:49 risk of diabetes among native people.
00:19:52 This food distribution program led to one of the most dramatic dietary changes in Native American history.
00:19:58 The original intention of the U.S. government was to supply rations as an interim solution until relocated Native people were raising enough food on their own.
00:20:05 Instead, many indigenous people became dependent on the rations.
00:20:10 Some tribes initially abandoned their traditional food procurement practices, but found that there were never enough of the government-issued food to feed all of their tribal members.
00:20:19 And so what you had happen, this is late 1800s, this is getting to the 1900s, and most certainly
00:20:24 now today is a government-supplied diet.
00:20:28 And when we talk about spheres and responsibilities, this is why the government does not provide
00:20:33 food.
00:20:34 The family does.
00:20:35 A father does.
00:20:36 Because when the government supplies food, it's going to supply it at the lowest possible
00:20:39 price.
00:20:39 And the government doesn't really care about diabetes and hyperactivity and all those things
00:20:43 because that's ultimately not their problem.
00:20:45 They're concerned with just, are these people fed?
00:20:48 are they happy? So what have been the results of this? The results of this diet that has been fed
00:20:54 to Native Americans on reservations, largely subsidized by the U.S. government since then.
00:21:00 In some American Indian communities, this is from a scientific research,
00:21:03 type 2 diabetes prevalence among adults is as high as 60%. So prevalence being how many people
00:21:11 in a population have it. 60%. Type 2 diabetes is destructive to the body. It is not something you
00:21:18 want to have. And for anyone listening, my heart goes out to you because that is a lifelong condition
00:21:22 that you're going to have to deal with. This process of insulin sensitivity, I think,
00:21:28 type 1, and then insulin resistance in type 2. 60%. Now you can say, okay, but if they quit it
00:21:36 tomorrow, imagine tomorrow you get out all the junky sugary drinks. You get out all the sugar,
00:21:40 all the fatty foods all of that well it all go back to normal right well scripture does speak
00:21:45 about i want to be careful because the iniquity in this case really is in some ways in the u.s
00:21:49 government the iniquity of the father is visited on the children to the third and the fourth
00:21:54 generation like the bible says that yeah and now god shows faithful love to the thousandth
00:22:01 generation of those that love him and keep his commandments but there are effects that just they
00:22:05 don't go away. Diabetes is up to 70% heritable. That means in a given group of people, if you
00:22:13 took 100 people, and how many of them got diabetes? The difference between, well, they all eat the
00:22:18 same diet and they all exercise the same, the difference, 70% of it, could be attributed to
00:22:23 genetics. Now, I'm going to get into the genetic exactly here, but you have to understand this.
00:22:29 There are thousands and thousands of children today, Native American Indian children that have
00:22:34 type 2 diabetes. And as I'm about to show, it comes from that high sugary diet, which led to 1.00
00:22:38 a genetic change, methylation, all of that, that are really suffering right now today because of
00:22:43 a government subsidy of a bad food program and a bad diet. Like real people with high medical bills,
00:22:50 lower quality of life, lower length of life, they're going to live less long. And the point 0.98
00:22:55 is, even if they had a perfect diet today, it wouldn't all go away. And it wouldn't all go
00:23:00 away tomorrow and 10 years and 20 years it would last i i don't want to make a scientific judgment
00:23:05 that every single one there's some arbitrary cut off at the 40 to 60 year mark well three to four
00:23:11 generations it would take for this people group in whole to be affected like kind of what the bible
00:23:16 says crazy kind of like what the bible says three or four generations yeah anything else to add
00:23:21 gentlemen before i get into how nope all right well what's real quick what's the name of russ
00:23:27 june's uh book where the whole thing is the case study of the reservation oh yeah the uh indian
00:23:33 reservations i'm trying to remember i was going off the lectures if you can find that i just want
00:23:37 to be able to recommend it to the listeners you can be looking as west goes on but there's a whole
00:23:41 book that uh rush june wrote because he worked his he worked on indian reservations for a lot of
00:23:46 his personal work um yeah so yeah that and uh man they were a people that were destroyed like
00:23:52 alcoholism he said it was uh there was a fourth grade boy that was pulled in front of the court
00:23:56 for disorderly drunkenness wow and he was like well i've just been drunk my whole life like that
00:24:01 is the destructive effect and my point is this is not surface level culture this is not well it's
00:24:06 habits and its values and this that or the other that can be very easily swapped out one for
00:24:11 another no there's a propensity right now at the genetic level in this people towards it's called
00:24:16 the american indian published by rj rush juni the american indian by rush to name rj rush
00:24:22 genetic propensity towards, but then also, so you could say like, well, there's tons of people that
00:24:27 have worshipped demons for thousands of years. I thought it was only a third and fourth generation.
00:24:30 Well, if that sin is repeated again and again through the centuries, then that iniquity has
00:24:34 continued to be visited. I'm going to show you how this actually works. Again, because I want
00:24:41 you to see it. I want you to see the complexity that God's made. So Nate, you can pull up. This
00:24:44 will be the next graph. It was already on the TV behind us. Transcription-like factor two. So I
00:24:51 talked about transcription. You go from the DNA to the RNA, from the RNA to the protein.
00:24:55 So transcription-like factor 2 is one of the biggest alleles for risk for type 2 diabetes.
00:25:00 So it encodes a transcription factor involved in signaling that's crucial for your pancreatic
00:25:05 beta cell proliferation. So your pancreas is where insulin is made, and it's necessary to
00:25:09 have these beta cells that then grow and multiply and secrete insulin. So your TF7L2,
00:25:16 transcription factor seven like two, makes insulin. DNA methylation, the addition of methyl groups to
00:25:23 DNA to turn these things off. DNA methylation, CPG, there's four different amino acids that DNA
00:25:31 is made of. A, T, C, and G are their abbreviations. So cysteine preceding guinine sites. And the TCF
00:25:37 7-2 promoter can alter its transcription impacting glucose homeostasis. So I've listed here,
00:25:43 you see on the right, what are some lifestyle factors that affect turning off this gene that
00:25:48 when it turns off leads to a propensity to diabetes? A high calorie diet, too much fat and
00:25:54 calories adds chemical tags to TCF7L2, turning it off in the pancreas. This reduces insulin
00:26:00 production, making blood sugar control worse. Fasting can remove them. So then if you have
00:26:06 calorie restriction and you fast and you just practice not being gluttonous, those tags can
00:26:12 be turned off. And this transcription factor turned back on. Then your insulin works better,
00:26:16 lowers your blood sugar. Pregnancy and baby's future health. If a mother eats too much sugar,
00:26:20 fat while pregnant can permanently alter her baby's genes. That some of these can truly be 0.97
00:26:25 turned off for life. And so you have this thing that helps make insulin, which helps regulate
00:26:30 your glucose. You can eat a diet that is high in sucrose, high or high in glucose that suppresses
00:26:36 transcription, and you have less insulin in the body. Go to the next graph, Nate.
00:26:41 And then this is the ultimate result. So you eat this diet high in sugar, you have less insulin,
00:26:47 and that increases your diabetes risk. You develop insulin sensitivity. And this TCF7L2
00:26:55 is a genetic risk factor that is one of the most predominant ones and is brought about by high
00:27:00 sugary diet. And in this group of people, it is very common. Many, many, many of them have it.
00:27:04 It gives them a predisposition, which is not a sentence.
00:27:08 So it's not as though you have this, you will develop diabetes, but you will have the risk
00:27:12 for it.
00:27:12 And you could eat a diet better than someone else who doesn't have this and still develop
00:27:16 it while they don't.
00:27:18 And all that to say, these are the practical means that God accomplishes it.
00:27:22 It's complicated.
00:27:23 We wouldn't know this without decades and decades of research and understanding, looking
00:27:27 at the body.
00:27:28 We now understand that you can turn off the thing that helps you regulate sugar by eating
00:27:32 a bad, high sugar diet.
00:27:34 Right.
00:27:34 It's like you almost like break it.
00:27:37 Like it's supposed to regulate sugar to a degree,
00:27:39 but if you overload it, it just collapses.
00:27:43 It's a relevant question
00:27:44 because it wouldn't make sense to answer it later.
00:27:46 James says all fats, Wes, or just trans fats?
00:27:51 Like grass-fed butter.
00:27:53 Like there's some things that are good for you, right?
00:27:54 Yes, your saturated fats
00:27:56 and your polyunsaturated fats.
00:27:58 I'm bullish on both of them.
00:27:59 I'm negative on the cholesterol theory
00:28:01 of high blood pressure and everything.
00:28:03 The biggest thing is what's surrounding those fats.
00:28:05 Stacey would agree with you.
00:28:07 He absolutely would.
00:28:09 What's surrounding those fats?
00:28:10 So you're eating a high-fat diet, but it's a high-fat of deep-fried things,
00:28:13 or is it a high-fat that's generally healthy?
00:28:15 So I wouldn't worry too much about the trans line on your – 0.99
00:28:18 you need to be worried about trans in general. 0.97
00:28:20 The trans line on your nutrition label,
00:28:24 I wouldn't worry about that so much as what is my sugar looking like,
00:28:27 what is my protein looking like.
00:28:28 If it's high in protein, low in sugar, high in trans fat, don't worry about it.
00:28:32 All right. I have one anecdote to add there, Wes. You said that we understand this now through
00:28:39 medicine and medical research. But what's amazing is people have, I think, either instinctively or
00:28:48 just through process of trial and error, understood this for a long time. I know, for instance, that
00:28:54 when we were missionaries in Taiwan, Taiwanese women have a very regimented 1.00
00:28:59 diet for the first three months after they give birth and they all have to have it and it's like 0.95
00:29:07 a lot of bone broths and soups and meat and things like that what's interesting is um this is
00:29:15 speculation here but i would imagine that if you took that same diet and gave it to a western woman
00:29:21 it would probably have some benefit to her post-delivery but i bet i bet it would not be 0.53
00:29:26 as precisely effective as what has been developed in taiwan with these asian women because just 1.00
00:29:33 process and trial and error and over time they've realized like these things for our people produce
00:29:39 the healthiest women coming out of pregnancy and then the healthiest babies um you know for the
00:29:43 first couple months or years of life i'm glad you brought that up because it's now being understood
00:29:49 we don't understand much of it now people adapt to a local diet so if you ate for example from
00:29:55 generally the same farm in the same area that experienced the same weather, same farm, the same
00:30:00 eggs, this side or the other, your diet works best to that. It adapts to best pull out nutrients,
00:30:07 to pull out the things that it needs. So you should be eating a consistent diet,
00:30:10 and that's from that same area. And if we're getting into ancestors and all of that,
00:30:14 it would probably be best if it's a land, for example, your grandparents and your parents and
00:30:17 everything that you live there, you generally ate from those individuals, that would be your body
00:30:22 best adapted to the nutrients that it's getting right we don't understand all the mechanisms of
00:30:27 how this works but all that being said like do we really need to like do you need to be told like
00:30:32 you should eat local beef from a farmer that you know and eggs from a guy instead of the giant
00:30:37 chicken farm 500 miles away like like do we really need like a clinical peer-reviewed study say which
00:30:44 one's better for you which one if you eat longer term is going to be more profitable for your
00:30:49 health like a lot of these things we actually do well i don't know i don't know if we do know that
00:30:53 to be honest i you're right like common sense kind of as we're getting back to like living on
00:30:58 the land and and we've talked about like the idea is not to go full homestead well the best thing
00:31:03 for me to eat local cow and so i'm gonna do 50 acres i'm gonna try to make it profitable
00:31:06 my brother in christ you'll spend 50 years and we'll be profitable like it's just farming isn't
00:31:10 something that we all can do but generally speaking where do i source my food where do i
00:31:14 get things. Local is better. To your point, Michael, people, they live, they pass down habits
00:31:21 for generations. This is best. And it really helped me with nausea during pregnancy. This is best and
00:31:27 helped me when I was postpartum. Like they've passed these down. This is what people groups
00:31:31 always did. They passed on diet, they passed on habit, they passed on different supplements to
00:31:35 help them. And they formed something very unique. You couldn't export it. So you couldn't take one
00:31:39 people group here. That's like, we eat this mushroom and we eat this and eat that. And
00:31:42 everyone across all time, everywhere should do it. People are different, and they have different
00:31:46 genes, and they're adapted to different things, and there is not a one-size-fits-all solution.
00:31:52 We're at 3.30. Let's hit our first commercial break, and we'll be right back with another
00:31:56 example. Our sponsor, Private Family Banking, wants to help you with one money move that'll
00:32:01 implicate itself in multi-generational wealth building starting the first day. They help you
00:32:07 to avoid taxation and to draw compound interest to your money. Now, if you're a high net worth
00:32:13 individual, someone who has maybe even $10 million in net worth, then they can help you even more.
00:32:20 W-2 workers, contract workers, business owners, it's all about cash flow and making tax deferred
00:32:27 gains on all your money for the rest of your life. Don't avoid this. It's a big move, but it's a great
00:32:33 time to make it. Click the link below and you can get on Chuck DeLaterrante's calendar and he'll go
00:32:39 over your background and what you want to accomplish. And he's going to help model a
00:32:44 program that exactly fits your needs. So go ahead and send an email to chuck at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:32:51 Again, that's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com. Or you can click the link below. Make a free
00:32:58 discovery call now. America is a country that was founded for the purpose of allowing Christians to 0.99
00:33:03 do their duty before God and not to have their consciences ruled by the doctrines and commandments
00:33:07 of men.
00:33:08 Reese Fund exists in order to see the Ten Commandments properly applied, not just as
00:33:12 a plaque on the wall, but to actually be used in business as though they're commandments
00:33:16 from God that we're supposed to obey.
00:33:19 Our goal is to find businesses and to buy them and to build them up.
00:33:23 We want to find manufacturing businesses and use them to make sure that we can maintain
00:33:27 our capacity to do things here.
00:33:30 Reese Fund, Christian Capital, Boldly Deployed.
00:33:33 all right all right we are back i i gotta i i plug this book this is every time we talk about
00:33:42 i've been on a podcast i know it's incredible because people are listening like is joel there
00:33:46 is he okay did he die does he have bad genes yeah this is the west michael show from here on out
00:33:50 yeah all right i plug this book a lot this is the book uh deep nutrition by kate shanahan yeah
00:33:56 this deals with all of this specifically more in the diet aspect and to be honest and uh we can
00:34:02 talk about a little she gets into beauty as well like uh like beauty is a property of symmetry 0.80
00:34:07 it's a property of fertility and she says like look if you want your kids not just to be healthy 0.72
00:34:12 they don't have diabetes they have strong bones all of that like uh healthy living is also a big
00:34:17 function of beauty and then because people are healthy they look better and then they also people
00:34:22 also marry and have children with people that also look better like it's not just an egalitarian
00:34:28 level free-for-all like these things actually matter in real i've been saying a lot but like
00:34:34 real tangible ways and one of those is beauty and the way people look she says this and this is
00:34:40 this is profound kate shanahan deep nutrition taken together nate you can show this quote on
00:34:45 the screen taken together all epigenetic evidence paints dna as a far more dynamic and intelligent
00:34:52 mechanism of adaptation that has been generally appreciated in effect dna seems capable of
00:34:58 collecting information through the language of food about the changing conditions in the outside
00:35:02 world, enacting alteration based on that information, and documenting, keeping record of, both the
00:35:09 collected data and its response for the benefit of subsequent generations. Junk DNA is full of
00:35:15 genetic treasure. It may function as a kind of ever-expanding library, complete with its own
00:35:20 insightful librarian capable of researching previously written volumes of successful and
00:35:25 unsuccessful genetic adaptation strategies. It follows that more complex organisms, like human
00:35:31 beings, with larger cells whose genomes represent a more complex evolutionary history would carry
00:35:38 relatively more substantial libraries filled with more junk DNA. And what he's saying is that junk 0.95
00:35:44 DNA is in many ways a reference library that's not currently in use. They'd be filled with more
00:35:48 of this DNA, and we do know that. That DNA, we don't understand how, but it would appear to have
00:35:54 some level of an understanding like, oh, we've seen this before, or we know what this does.
00:36:00 There's an incredible study in pigs. And so she talks about this in the book. They took pigs and
00:36:04 they deprived them of vitamin A. And vitamin A is a byproduct of photosynthesis, which gets down
00:36:09 into plants. And deprived of vitamin A in utero, pregnant pigs gave birth to pigs that had no eyes.
00:36:14 It's like, okay, so we knocked out vitamin A, they just don't develop eyes. Well, if there's no sun
00:36:19 to go to the plant to produce vitamin A,
00:36:22 why would the pigs need ice?
00:36:24 They still had lids. 0.95
00:36:24 They still had everything.
00:36:25 But it would appear at some level
00:36:27 there are mechanisms within the DNA itself
00:36:28 to say sunlight might not be hitting plants
00:36:31 and photosynthesis and creating these vitamins.
00:36:33 We don't actually need these anymore.
00:36:36 And so we do all this.
00:36:37 It's like, wow, we understand.
00:36:38 It's all cool.
00:36:39 Yeah, and there's an iceberg of things
00:36:41 we actually still don't understand.
00:36:44 I'm going to get into a more controversial one.
00:36:46 And this one is because it deals with morality.
00:36:48 The last one, diabetes and junk food,
00:36:50 like that one's more of an affliction, right?
00:36:52 You're afflicted with diabetes.
00:36:53 I have this.
00:36:54 It requires time, insulin, needles, all of that.
00:36:57 But it's not necessarily a propensity
00:36:59 to a certain moral action,
00:37:00 unless we get into kind of gluttony,
00:37:01 but there's different ways of parsing that out.
00:37:04 But I'm going to get into one that's moral.
00:37:05 And again, the verse is in the Bible.
00:37:08 Faithfulness to a thousand generations
00:37:10 of those that love me,
00:37:11 and they keep my commandments.
00:37:13 What are the commandments?
00:37:15 In the cold, I just wanted to real quick point that out.
00:37:17 Like that verse, you know, and that's why we included it in the cold open today, but it's not just, um, got to be faithful to a thousand generations of Christians, but included in that, just like the great commission, right? Like it, it's, you know, um, going and making disciples and baptizing them into the name of the father, the son, and the Holy spirit and teaching them to obey, teaching them being nations, peoples to obey all my commandments.
00:37:41 And so, too, in this promise that we have, that God would promise to be faithful to the righteous and to a thousand generations of those who love him and obey his commandments.
00:37:54 So, there is an obedience mechanism.
00:37:57 Yep, absolutely.
00:37:58 Nate, you can pull up this graph.
00:38:01 So, oxytocin is a molecule that modulates—it's called the love molecule—but it modulates pair bonding.
00:38:07 uh emotional connection affection regulation all these different things between is that primarily
00:38:13 between like mother and child or everything it's broader than that it's social but most
00:38:18 specifically in and i'll get to a study on this in a minute in a minute pair bonding like like
00:38:22 the bonding of a husband and a wife they come together in marital union like that's it's not
00:38:27 just like it's not just a machine that runs a command or a function or the equivalent of
00:38:33 adding a contact to your phone. They're joined together. And that's mediated by real things
00:38:39 that happen. It's not just abstract and spiritual, but it's bodily. It's in the body. And so oxytocin
00:38:44 is one of these things that mediates it. And so this is a graph from a 2022 study
00:38:49 in genes, brain, and behavior of oxytocin expression in major people groups. So just
00:38:57 like transcription like factor, transcription like factor seven, like two, just like that
00:39:03 one related to diabetes, the O-X-T-R gene modulates, regulates, promotes the expression
00:39:11 of the molecule, the gene O-X-T-R to the molecule oxytocin.
00:39:18 Oxytocin modulates all of these different things that are good.
00:39:21 Your body produces it.
00:39:22 Yep, your body produces it at a genetic level.
00:39:24 so this is between five different people groups the average estimated expression rate in this is
00:39:32 a brain brain region but the higher values indicating more expression so on the left you
00:39:37 have africans this is the average expression it's the lowest of the five groups and then in east
00:39:42 asians so this would be this would be china vietnam korea japan east asians have the highest
00:39:47 expression i'll go through these other ones and come back to east asians in a minute then you have
00:39:51 america and michael i want to hear from you on the length of time that people can stay and that
00:39:55 matters you have america which is second lowest europeans and then you have south asians so these
00:40:01 are some of the southern regions like india i don't know if australia would fit into that no
00:40:04 wouldn't so you don't have australia but you have southern asian regions and that's the second
00:40:08 highest these are the average levels of oxytocin expression and this is a molecule that helps
00:40:15 people pair bond, stay monogamous, helps mothers nurture their children, breastfeed them, helps
00:40:23 people control emotional regulation. That people can still sin, but it, it, it sets them up with
00:40:28 the highest chance, with the greatest propensity of staying faithful in marriage, of being nurturing
00:40:34 mothers. Is that what you're saying? Yes. Yeah. Like a, like a good mother is not, like it's just
00:40:40 not an abstract category. Like a mother that loves her children and cares for them and, and
00:40:45 breastfeeds, which is a great thing that should be done as much as possible. Sometimes it's not
00:40:48 possible, but if it's possible, demand without pain and difficulty and all these things that
00:40:53 should be done. And the point is those things are mediated by real physical things that exist.
00:40:58 And the graph of different people groups on the whole, on average, it's not a flat line. It's not
00:41:04 the same propensity. It's not all of these groups are the same thing. It's not egalitarian. Exactly.
00:41:10 And we're not talking about behavior. So this is not a graph of monogamous behavior. Well,
00:41:14 these cultures have less monogamy, less faithfulness, less husbands staying in the home, 0.68
00:41:19 and these have more. No, these are genetic levels. And the problem is, oh, well, that's just genes,
00:41:25 that's just numbers on a screen, that's just molecules deposited in a brain. Well, which of
00:41:29 those peoples, of those five different ones that were named, have the greatest level, the greatest
00:41:34 family values? Oh, it's East Asians. Compared to Europe and compared to America, East Asians have
00:41:41 the most structured long-standing grounded rooted sense of family values of anywhere in the world
00:41:48 and they're not perfect and also some of the longest lifespans they have some of the longest
00:41:52 lifespans they have honor cultures now all of these different things there's a thousand things
00:41:56 of course right that mediate monogamy so nothing in this graph i i just want to note for a second
00:42:02 because on x you know there's so many people that hate us and they love us but they hate us well
00:42:10 I'd say there's a hundred thousand people that love us and about 10 million that hate us,
00:42:14 but, uh, which I'm, I'm fine with that, that ratio, but here's the thing. People have hated
00:42:19 me for a while now, but, um, Wes really doesn't get enough credit. Uh, but you were quickly up
00:42:25 and coming. And, uh, and I've noticed, you know, on the, the Twitter streets, um, even just the
00:42:30 past few weeks, like people starting to realize, wait a second, Wes might be, uh, might be further
00:42:36 right than jolt and as they're starting to notice like they're kind of like now they're kind of
00:42:40 you're kind of starting to get some of your own credit you're getting your own you know special
00:42:44 attention and but i just want to say that like with that chart that you're showing you know so
00:42:48 with the haters you know one of the things that i've seen people say that's absolutely
00:42:52 false and slanderous um but they're uh they're just white supremacists right well but i i i love
00:43:00 white people and i happen i am one i love them right my wife happens to be white my kids are
00:43:06 white um so i i love my parents are white i love white people um and i love my country and i love
00:43:12 my kinsmen i love all those things um but if we were just white supremacists and that was our 0.99
00:43:18 agenda uh you probably wouldn't be showing charts where the asians are kicking our butt 0.99
00:43:24 kicking our butts is strong yeah okay right right right maybe not kicking our butt but just you 0.99
00:43:29 know of this specific gene that mediates in this family values and monogamy this does not help your 0.99
00:43:34 white supremacist case just want to throw that out there exactly all right go ahead and and this
00:43:37 culture for the record like japan is two percent christian right they are very their central bank
00:43:43 is screwing them over that's a topic for another time but um but as far as a culture as far as trust
00:43:48 uh success work ethic all of that like these aren't china is not majority christian so this
00:43:53 is not a chart of like least christian somewhat christian most christian these are just different
00:43:57 people groups that have lived a certain way and as a result look different. Nate, we can go to the
00:44:03 last quote here. But real quick, just let you show the chart, but let's just say it for those
00:44:07 who are listening, because we're just, we're just looking at something. There's no animus here.
00:44:10 There's not, there's nothing sinful. We don't need to apologize. We don't need to be cowardly. So
00:44:14 with the chart, you're seeing East Asians rated the highest. Yes. Americans were second lowest.
00:44:19 Yep. And in part, I'm going to argue that part of that is because, um, because of our greatest 0.69
00:44:25 strength diversity part of it and um there's also something to be said too for just being a
00:44:35 homogenous people that have high trust like europe is higher europe is more godless than us right now
00:44:41 in the moment but they're an ancient people i remember i was uh i was back when i worked in
00:44:45 consulting i was talking with a guy and he's like our old cities our old cities you're like oh dc's
00:44:50 an old city boston's an old city like our old cities amsterdam's like 1500 years old two thousand
00:44:55 3 000 4 000. you go to italy it's like this cathedral was built in like 280. exactly or 480.
00:45:01 america has existed for 250 years a little bit longer obviously if you go back to some of the
00:45:05 original arrivees and mayflower and stuff but um but i do think that's that's one of the things
00:45:10 america is second lowest we're even lower than obviously europe and asia and all those different
00:45:15 things uh and there's different factors that impact it but one of those is just it's been a
00:45:19 while it has not been long that we've been a people and even in being a people our greatest
00:45:24 strength we don't even have any type of cohesive sense of who we are right that's been the biggest
00:45:28 question right last year like what is a woman that's what is an american or what is you know
00:45:32 what is a woman and then matt walsh did am i racist but we yeah we really need like what is
00:45:36 an american yep what is a nation um is it people in place or is it just you know some prop set of
00:45:43 propositions so yeah so i think it's how young we are as a nation and that like the cement hasn't
00:45:48 hardened the dust hasn't settled that it's just been this now there have been various times where
00:45:53 things did kind of settle and america did really well you know but then there'd be
00:45:57 new waves of immigration you know so from you know like it's the irish it's the italians it's 0.95
00:46:04 you know and and we kick them off into the west because there's a lot of land so they'd arrive 1.00
00:46:08 people didn't want them there for them kick them out well that's the thing you kick them out and 1.00
00:46:12 then they actually get to become settlers right they have something to sell there's still irish 0.73
00:46:15 in the east coast yeah but some of these waves early waves of immigration there's still something
00:46:20 to settle it wasn't just immigrants um it was actually going somewhere and making something
00:46:25 on your own and building um but then you know so that so there's waves of upheaval seasons of
00:46:31 upheaval and upheaval and disrest uh unrest and then um and then you know things kind of calm
00:46:37 down and the dust starts to settle and then it happens again it happens and but then lately like
00:46:42 by design and this is not just us europe is now experiencing this they just have you know a thousand
00:46:47 years as a bedrock, you know, so a little bit more stabilization, but it's being destabilized.
00:46:53 But most recently, it's not like our past and different historic moments in America,
00:46:59 and there's nothing historic that you could go and point to being similar, you know, with England
00:47:04 or with France, but it's a somewhat novel phenomenon of your political elites and leaders
00:47:12 of these european nations and also here in america intentionally by design trying to
00:47:19 replace the native population with poorest borders and and legislation like anchor babies you know
00:47:26 which praise god trump's trying to get rid of that it's a horrible horrible policy um that just
00:47:31 incentivizes people who are nine months pregnant you know to just just barely make it over the line
00:47:37 hit that disneyland trip what hit that disneyland trip so you give birth in the united states right
00:47:42 and then drop literally like that's what happens that is what happens so anyways um so all that
00:47:46 being said like there's reasons for why america is rated more lowly on this scale and this isn't
00:47:52 an overall this was particularly in regards to what oxytocin which again that's not as though
00:47:59 you have high levels you'll be monogamous low levels you won't but of different factors of
00:48:04 the higher levels you're you're better able to pair bond better emotional regulation also some
00:48:08 research here in a minute on mothers and nurturing but right of oxytocin on average on the whole 0.80
00:48:14 and it's even tough with america because you have different races that are all here and all of that
00:48:17 but on the whole lower than east asia and europe and europe yep and then the lowest was africa
00:48:25 yes the lowest is africa uh and we'll have to do an episode probably on the fertility crisis but
00:48:30 diversity is something that presence of diversity diverse municipalities communities nations they
00:48:37 they don't have people having a lot of children like at the end of the day like that's another
00:48:41 reason you bring in that foreign populace and then the people that are there are like well there's not 1.00
00:48:44 a lot of future for these children that i could have but why would i have a bunch of them they 1.00
00:48:48 have no place to just be displaced and deracinated and all that different thing because they're dumb 0.92
00:48:52 and they watch boy meets world and instead of practicing violin for eight hours right exactly 0.98
00:48:57 wasn't that hypocritical to see vivek like he's going on his re-imaging rebranding tour like his
00:49:02 his crawl of penance and atonement but it's so hypocritical and ironic because it's like
00:49:09 you just said americans are too big on recreation and now you're going to the indy 500 or some kind
00:49:14 of you know sports car race you know it's like shouldn't you be at home you know teaching your
00:49:18 kids math right right yep and when i say home i mean india no it's like i i understand but
00:49:26 let's take the last quote so i want to show because the point is you you can modify this
00:49:32 this is not set in stone right diabetes 70 of it is genetic iq it's between 50 and 100 but it's
00:49:40 probably not it's not all genetic either there are things you can do to modify it so this is a study
00:49:45 from 2019 in psychoneuroendocrinology the journal and this was looking at voles are actually really
00:49:51 cool you do a lot of studies in these i did some studies on this in my undergrad because they're
00:49:54 they're one of the few mammals that pair for life. So we actually, we look at them and we do things
00:49:58 to them we couldn't do to humans and understand the effects of oxytocin for these moles, these
00:50:03 voles that literally like as animals have one spouse for life. We report, the author's report
00:50:08 in this study, I'm quoting now, that low levels of early care in voles lead to de novo DNA methylation.
00:50:15 So early care, this means nurturing, licking, petting, nursing, low levels. So less nurturing,
00:50:21 less care, less provision for these little youth in these prairie voles leads to, we've been talking
00:50:27 about this whole episode, DNA methylation at specific regulatory sites in the oxytocin receptor
00:50:33 gene, OXTR, impacting gene expression and protein distribution in the nucleus accumbens, that's a
00:50:40 brain region. These results identify a mechanism by which early care regulates later displays of
00:50:46 typical prairie vole social behavior and suggest the potential for nurture driven epigenetic tuning
00:50:53 of OXTR in humans. So the reason you can use voles and mice and all these different things
00:50:59 when they have the same regions and structures and all of this as humans, you can do something
00:51:03 in a mouse. You can observe an effect and say, we anticipate, obviously you're not going to kill a
00:51:07 human being, look at their brain and replicate it. You can say, we can, we anticipate this would be
00:51:11 replicated in humans. But don't miss what this study is saying. Little voles, they're little
00:51:16 babies, and those that received less care had these receptors and these genes that mediate
00:51:22 them later on as adults, as moms and dads, this bonding, this social behavior, this emotional
00:51:27 regulation, all of that. Those who didn't get that early care early on, their DNA itself,
00:51:32 methylation, methyl group, turned that off, turned that off, turned down that gene expression.
00:51:37 so then later on in life they experienced lower levels of that ability to do what voles do but
00:51:44 the behavior that it was tied to was not abstract and it wasn't chemical or molecular it was
00:51:49 nurturing behavior it was care it was obviously they're animals they're not human beings it was
00:51:54 love and the authors say in that study like this guys is not this is not 4chan literature this is
00:52:00 peer-reviewed academic study we think the same thing would happen in humans we think the same
00:52:06 gene, this same mechanism, this same care, love, and nurture, if deprived early on, would impact
00:52:13 an individual later in life through the same mechanism. So you're saying with people that it's
00:52:19 possible, maybe even likely, that if you had not just one generation, but I assume it would only
00:52:26 compound if you had like three generations or four generations of a loving mother, ideally if
00:52:33 she's able to, like my wife was not able to breastfeed. And we're on our fifth child now,
00:52:38 a little baby, Mabel, who's doing great. She's about three months old now. And she's our first
00:52:43 child that my wife, Megan, has been able to breastfeed. And with each child, she was able
00:52:48 to produce a little bit more milk, which is amazing. And I think that's happened naturally
00:52:53 with her body, but all of it is the work of God and the way that he's designed her. It's like
00:52:57 each child, it's like training her body to do that. But anyways, my point is,
00:53:03 If you had like three generations of a nurturing mother, stay-at-home mother, especially in the early years of life, and if she's able to, I'm not saying that it would just be intentionally by design.
00:53:16 I understand my own wife wasn't able to breastfeed, but for those who can, she chooses to breastfeed and all those things.
00:53:22 and um a father i would imagine the mother would be more integral but the father for those later
00:53:28 years as the child starts to develop if he's also in the home um and providing and and doesn't
00:53:33 abandon the marriage and abandon the child and that happens consecutively for three generations
00:53:38 um we would say on the spiritual side that's discipleship um and but then we would say that
00:53:47 like god created a world that's so incredible and so magical i mean he made a magical world
00:53:52 right it's like oh well that's just science yeah but but he made it the fact that water
00:53:56 i forget who said it gk chesterton or lewis that like water flows downhill like when it you know
00:54:03 god could have made it go up it but it's just as amazing we should we should be amazed um for us
00:54:08 it makes sense and so we're not we we lose the the the sense of all but all this is built into
00:54:13 the fabric of the world that god has made and so on the one hand the spiritual way that we would
00:54:16 describe it is discipleship. But that also has a chemical and biological side of it that works
00:54:25 not against, and it's not just completely severed, but they're working together. On the one hand,
00:54:30 it's discipling generation after generation after generation of good parenting,
00:54:35 loving mothers, loving fathers. But then also that's having a physical effect. So it's not
00:54:42 anything less than the Spirit. It's not anything less than discipleship. It's not anything less
00:54:46 than love, parental love, and Christian love for those Christian families, which we would say would
00:54:51 be all the greater. It's nothing less than that, but we're just saying that, you know, God moves
00:54:55 sovereignly. So, like, whenever someone's saved, well, how does that happen? Well, before the
00:54:59 foundations of the world, God and His sovereignty elects, like, all that's true. So, that's the
00:55:04 macro-ultimate spiritual side of the equation, and that is the ultimate, because God sovereignly
00:55:09 ordains, and the Spirit regenerates, and that's how God saves. But also, He works through human
00:55:15 means. Somebody shares the gospel, there's evangelism, there's a mind that's at work,
00:55:19 you know, and firing and making logical conclusions and all these different things.
00:55:24 And so, we're just saying the same thing, not so much with soteriology, salvation, but when it
00:55:29 comes to nurture and discipleship and these kinds of things that with three generations of good,
00:55:35 natural love and nurturing for a child with a mother and a father, I would imagine that would
00:55:40 be all the better, to do that consecutively, and then to do that even to a greater degree with
00:55:47 not just being natural love, but Christian love, which wouldn't be against natural love, but just
00:55:53 even heightened, you know, grace restores and elevates nature. And to do that with three
00:55:58 generations, we would say that spiritually speaking, by the time you get to that third
00:56:02 or fourth generation, they've been well-shaped and discipled. But you can also say that the human,
00:56:09 you know the the physical biological means at play within you know the larger macro picture
00:56:14 of what god has established is that it actually is even making even making them biologically
00:56:21 physically with a higher propensity with with a greater inclination towards doing the same now for
00:56:27 their own children for their own offspring to be loving and caring and present and nurturing
00:56:31 whereas if you have the reverse i'm just spitballing here doesn't sound that crazy but if
00:56:37 you have multiple consecutive generations where the father leaves or is in jail right you know
00:56:44 and and maybe the mother is there but but it's it's one parent home you know or maybe the mother
00:56:50 isn't as an attentive or these kinds of things that um that you're saying that that that's not
00:56:56 just a spiritual component but the spiritual component is is ultimate but that there's a
00:57:02 physical components and deficiencies that would, that would, they would, they would compound over
00:57:10 time that would set that person generations down the road at a greater disadvantage.
00:57:15 Yeah. I'm going to hit Alex's question because they're, they're questioning, but I think it's
00:57:20 from a good place. So Alex asked two questions that directly relate to this. I'm talking about
00:57:25 moles, voles and mice. So people are like animals, Alex asks, how can someone be nurturing if God
00:57:31 made them not to be nurturing. And that is some of the thorny question of this. The caution I do
00:57:36 want to say, and I'll go back to the animal's comment, is none of this should be taken as a
00:57:40 mechanical problem. My mom was absent. Therefore, I'm doomed. I'm fated. Mechanics, I won't be able
00:57:49 to commit to my woman, to show nurture, love, all these different things. That's not what's going on.
00:57:54 You don't know how her mom, what she maybe gave to your mom, which then passed down.
00:58:00 So the genetic level, nothing is for sure
00:58:01 because our human genome, our DNA, yours especially,
00:58:07 you don't know what sites are methylated.
00:58:09 We don't know that, and it's good that we don't know that.
00:58:12 God made it that we don't know that.
00:58:13 So none of us are able to say,
00:58:15 well, I'm sure X happened,
00:58:16 or I have this genetic this, that, or the other,
00:58:18 and that's why I disobey, or that's why I do what I do.
00:58:21 You just simply don't have that excuse,
00:58:22 and then even there are people that defy the odds.
00:58:25 So someone could come from a long line,
00:58:26 and it does happen of bad parenting and an abusive home that didn't show love and they say i'm not
00:58:32 going to be like that it stops with me it stops with me it ends with us and they turn it around
00:58:37 if they turn it around you know five generations from them their great great grandchildren would
00:58:42 would be better than them but but they would still merit um a a great degree of credit and respect
00:58:49 and honor because they're the ones that that changed the sequence that changed the time exactly
00:58:53 and that does happen that's the thing people are addicts people are violent people and someone
00:58:58 says be it the gospel whatever right it's done with me and then they build something new and
00:59:03 that faithfulness god blesses at the genetic level to where a couple generations down they're not
00:59:09 inheriting what was given to them right that does happen right in god's sovereignty my my personal
00:59:15 story is is somewhat in this line uh that um for those who don't know you know when eric khan got
00:59:21 in big trouble sometime last year uh for his uh infamous uh adoption tweet well eric the the reason
00:59:30 he did that was believe it or not he wasn't just trying to be an edgelord and get under everyone's
00:59:35 skin you can always wear something different so i wouldn't have said it like that i've never heard
00:59:42 anybody say anything that i didn't think i would have said it differently so okay you want to say
00:59:46 like that fine um but but was what was behind the scenes because i i talked to him about it
00:59:52 was you know multiple families that he's close to that had adopted and uh and in many of these
01:00:00 cases adopted older children through the foster foster um foster care system and then you know
01:00:06 god opened their wombs and they had um biological children uh later on and had um obviously not
01:00:13 going to be completely inappropriate to share names and i'm not going to go into details with
01:00:18 the situation but i'll i'll just say in a general sense um some pretty pretty alarming and terrible
01:00:25 tragic things um done to the biological children who ended up being younger by the foster adopted
01:00:33 child who was older and especially these children coming from broken homes that their parents came
01:00:40 from, broken homes that their parents came from. And yeah, I'll leave it there. I could be more
01:00:46 detailed. So that was kind of the behind the scenes was in a lot of these families, they're
01:00:51 all Christian families because it's, let's just be honest, it's Christians for the most part that
01:00:55 are willing to adopt and serve in the foster care system, all these kinds of things. And so
01:00:59 these were Christian parents who love both their biological and adoptive children. Both are their
01:01:05 children, and yet had talked to Eric as a pastor about some of those challenges. And Eric was
01:01:12 privy to just knowing about some of them, and then even pastorally dealt with some of them.
01:01:17 And then from myself, from my own story, so I defended Eric, one, because he's my friend,
01:01:23 and I thought he was right. I wouldn't just defend him because he's my friend,
01:01:26 but that helps when you have a relationship with someone. I also thought he was right,
01:01:29 um and i knew some of the behind the scenes experience um that was informing that tweet
01:01:35 and then i also know my own personal set of circumstances so i i was fine defending that
01:01:41 that tweet because i'm adopted you know maybe a lot of our listeners don't know that but i
01:01:46 i was adopted um my biological parents especially my father um was a deadbeat you know he was just 0.98
01:01:57 you know, he was a loser. And, you know, and he probably would have, I don't know. I don't know.
01:02:05 I don't know what he would have done. But I know he abandoned my birth mother. And so I wouldn't
01:02:12 be surprised if he would have been fine with her getting an abortion. Praise God, my biological 0.87
01:02:17 mother did not opt for having an abortion. And she actually, you know, she was charismatic,
01:02:24 like most Christians in America, you know, more Pentecostal,
01:02:28 but she was a Christian and she was older
01:02:32 and she had health problems.
01:02:33 I think she was almost 40 years old 0.99
01:02:35 when she gave birth to me and she was poor 1.00
01:02:38 and didn't have a husband.
01:02:41 And my biological father was, you know, hit and run.
01:02:44 He's out of the picture.
01:02:45 And so she was like, I can't do this.
01:02:47 And so she decided to put me up for adoption.
01:02:50 And for the few days that she had me,
01:02:53 She had me in the hospital for a few days because I had heart complications, which I still have.
01:02:58 And so I had to be lifelighted to Herman's Children's Hospital in Texas and all these
01:03:04 different things to find out if I was going to be okay and running tests and doing some different
01:03:10 things. And so she was with me in the hospital and nursing me during that time. And she wanted
01:03:15 to call me something. So she called me Samuel. And that's why I said like a little charismatic,
01:03:19 But like in her mind, she was thinking like Samuel, you know, Hannah says, you know, God, if you open my womb, give me a son, I'll give my first child to you, you know, to the house of the Lord, the temple with Eli, the priest.
01:03:33 And so she wanted to give me up to adoption, but to Christians and particularly a pastor.
01:03:37 My dad was a minister.
01:03:39 And so she said yes and let my dad and mom adopt me.
01:03:43 But my point is, my parents did such, my adoptive parents now, did such a great job of being,
01:03:54 they weren't overly spiritual.
01:03:56 Like, they were, you know, serious Christians, love the Lord, believe we live in a world
01:04:01 that's not just stuff.
01:04:02 Dad was a pastor.
01:04:03 Spiritual component.
01:04:04 Dad's a pastor, charismatic pastor, for that matter.
01:04:07 Both of my parents are members in our church now, and two of my favorite members.
01:04:12 besides me fantastic yeah besides you guys of course um but uh but you know but even being
01:04:18 charismatic and and and certainly believing that god created a world that's not just stuff and
01:04:22 there's a spiritual component they also were just my parents my adopted parents are um just the most
01:04:29 down-to-earth people you ever meet and and nothing but the very best ways and just it's awesome like
01:04:35 every every sunday night after our second service of church they come over we do a game night you
01:04:39 You know, they read to the grandkids, we put them down to bed.
01:04:41 And then me and my wife and my parents have game night together.
01:04:43 And they're just so practical and they're just normal people.
01:04:48 And so my point is from a very young age, though, they noticed because my mom, my adopted mom, God opened her womb.
01:04:57 And so then I had biological brothers and a sister younger than me.
01:05:02 And at a young age, they realized like, you know, one of these things is not like the other.
01:05:09 Joel, he's a weirdo. And I just had some challenges. Nathan, he's our tech director.
01:05:17 He's my cousin. He's like, yeah, Joel is a little strange. And by God's grace, he protected me from
01:05:23 doing something beyond just that silly, that strange. But yeah, it was different. It was
01:05:30 different. Because here's the thing about adoption, even as a child, the bright side is
01:05:36 um in adoption someone chooses you um the bad side though is uh someone chooses you because
01:05:43 someone rejected you someone didn't want you you know you can say well you but your birth mom was
01:05:48 just doing the best you okay well then my birth father like somebody didn't want me um and and
01:05:55 and so to you know so i wasn't breastfed for a few days and then it's bottle and it's you know
01:06:01 and and there's and there's just there's and then i came from i came physically biologically from
01:06:09 a line of as far as i know i don't know every detail about my birth father but a line of
01:06:14 not great people not great people with not great habits and and uh yeah and and so with there were
01:06:22 things but here's the point all that back to what wes was saying none none of the three of us are
01:06:28 saying. And therefore, I'm not morally culpable for any of the mistakes I've made. No one's
01:06:35 saying that. I'm a sinner. And I'm responsible for every single sin I've committed. And it's
01:06:44 only because of the blood of Jesus Christ that forgives and atones for sin that I have any
01:06:50 chance. And that's my justification. But in my sanctification, the same standard that God would
01:06:57 hold from for for children who come from a good home he holds for everyone like it's not like
01:07:04 there's 10 commandments for for this set of people over here and then i had you know five
01:07:08 commandments or you know some kind of lower bar like no and so but but all i'm trying to say is
01:07:14 that um the immutable law word of god remains constant for each and every one of us and and
01:07:19 every man romans chapter one is is without an apology or without an excuse like i i had the
01:07:25 law of God written on my heart, even before it was converted, like all men do, just by being
01:07:29 created in the image of God and having a conscience and these kinds of things. And yet,
01:07:35 I will admit, and I probably wouldn't even been aware of this because I was so young, my parents
01:07:41 would admit, my adopted parents would admit, yeah, it was harder for Joel than our other kids.
01:07:46 Like in school, that last thing I said, in school, all the way through elementary and part of middle
01:07:52 school, I had three, in every single one of my classes, I always had three desks. I had one in
01:07:59 the rows with the other students, one right next to the teacher's desk, outside of the rows at the
01:08:04 front of the classroom. Not quite the place of honor. And then one out in the hallway. And I
01:08:08 would basically, on a daily basis, hour by hour, depending on my behavior, rotate between one of
01:08:13 those desks. And a lot of times, I would just be getting distracted. If I was getting distracted,
01:08:18 then i'd have to sit by the teacher if i was being distracting i would you know because there
01:08:23 were those moments too i'd be in the hall but the point is um these things are real they're real and
01:08:29 none of them none of it makes and so and so there's a certain class of people who are that's
01:08:33 just wokeness right like that like they're you're absolved from your sin it's not your fault no
01:08:38 um because somebody has to turn the tide somebody has to say as for me in my house we will serve
01:08:42 the lord and if i come from a line of of you know i mean that it's like even when i think of like
01:08:49 europeans especially i love like people show like some pagan dance or something video on x will go
01:08:55 viral and they'll say you should do um you should follow the heritage of your ancestors and do what
01:09:00 um what they did and convert to christianity you know like the richest heritage um of of many
01:09:06 ancestral people especially among europeans is um giving up paganism and turning to the lord
01:09:12 jesus christ and my point is um in every single person's history and every people's peoples of
01:09:19 the earth history at some point they had to convert to jesus at some it's not like they
01:09:25 just came out of the ether as moral people you know loving jesus they had to convert from pagan
01:09:31 demon worship, from bad habits, from all these kinds of things. And so whether it's on a micro
01:09:37 scale with adopting a child from a family that's kind of a rough family, or whether it's on a
01:09:43 macro scale of a new peoples that comes to Christ and now has to be discipled and learn better
01:09:48 habits that ultimately all of it stems from the Word of God that affects every single realm of
01:09:53 life, including even their biology, not in 15 minutes, but over generations that would lend
01:09:58 towards more health and prosperity and blessing and better habits and morality and fidelity
01:10:07 and all these kinds of, like, the point is all these things are true, and these things
01:10:12 being true absolves no one.
01:10:14 We all ultimately still rely on the grace of God and are still responsible for obeying
01:10:22 Christ's commandments.
01:10:23 And God will not be mocked, a man reaps what he sows.
01:10:25 and there are, right, the prosperity gospel, and the last thing I'll say, I know I've said this,
01:10:31 the last thing I'll say, the last thing, the prosperity gospel is a heresy because what it
01:10:36 asserts is that you can have the blessing of God apart from obedience, that you can use faith
01:10:41 as a mechanism, as like an incantation, as like some pagan spell, and where Jesus isn't even the
01:10:49 true object of your faith, but you just have faith in your faith, and by just manifesting
01:10:54 positive thinking and just wishing it into existence you can have you know a 401k and a
01:11:00 big house and and ferrari um and and health you know and your cancer will go away like
01:11:06 that that's a heresy that's a prosperity gospel um but that but that's not what we're talking
01:11:12 but what we're talking about is the law of sowing and reaping the law of sowing and reaping and the
01:11:17 prosperity gospel are not the same and there's a lot of people i think in the reformed camp that
01:11:22 want to say they you know they think they're being cute you know like the pam beasley you know office
01:11:27 meme like corbett wants you to see that you know this is the same picture reaping and sowing
01:11:31 prosperity no it's not the same picture but one of them's a heresy and one of them's the word of
01:11:35 god the bible what i'm trying to say is that the bible is clear that it's not just the life to come
01:11:42 but there is there are temporal blessings in this earthly life for obedience not guaranteed you can
01:11:50 still get cancer and die, right? God's not entitled. You're not entitled to the blessing
01:11:55 of God. God's not beholden to anyone. There's nothing you can do by your obedience to work
01:11:59 the God of the universe into your debt. But ordinarily, I'll use that qualifier, ordinarily,
01:12:05 God's system and the way that he set things up is that obedience, right? Children, obey your
01:12:10 parents. This is the first commandment with a promise that it may go well with you. Not that
01:12:14 if you obey your parents, you'll have eternal salvation. No, you only get that by faith in
01:12:19 jesus no you'll get an earthly blessing if you obey your parents it'll go well with you and you'll
01:12:23 live a long life on the earth temporally in this life and and that's just you know that's the fifth
01:12:29 commandment and so if you have consecutive generations of nurturing parents and honoring
01:12:34 obedient children and like yeah that's society and if that becomes society wide you know not
01:12:41 not just one family but those families become more and more families and that becomes eventually a
01:12:45 civilization and the nation and you have that kind of heritage then yeah that that those peoples
01:12:52 that come from that lineage are probably going to be doing pretty well do you want to have a
01:12:59 predisposition to diabetes or not right literally like would you rather not i would rather be part
01:13:05 of the people that he who work does not work shall not eat but these people did work they
01:13:09 ate a good diet and are health because of it right which one would you rather personally be
01:13:13 part of, which is your kids. That's a great point, Wes. Like, it gets jarring and people get offended.
01:13:20 Piantist, hardest hit. I know. It gets offensive. And I know that sometimes we say things, I say
01:13:25 things in a bombastic manner. I get it. We're trying not to do that in this episode. I hope
01:13:30 the listener can sense that. But I'm glad you said it like that, because that's not being hyperbolic
01:13:35 or bombastic just for the fun of it. No, it really is. There was a group of people, and we're not
01:13:41 saying it was all their fault talking about um again going back to like indian reservations
01:13:46 so we're not like you can put a lot of blame on the united states government exactly so we're not
01:13:50 even putting it all all the responsibility on them but but here's here's the facts you have
01:13:55 a group of people that um that literally for life don't have to work and so many of them
01:14:01 the vast majority don't they don't you don't have to work um and and a bunch of them you said what
01:14:08 what was it? 60%? 70%? 60% in some communities. So not every single tribe reservation, but some
01:14:13 of them as high as a prevalence of 60% of type two diabetes. Diabetes. And then if you have,
01:14:19 which is 70% hereditary, right? This is not something that it's just like 60% of them eat
01:14:23 badly. No, almost entirely driven by genetic predisposition to it, which does come by eating
01:14:30 badly over generations. Exactly. Am I right that the predisposition is more likely to be unlocked
01:14:38 depending on then what you do with it exactly i want to get to that in the last second but okay
01:14:42 so you have multiple generations of of a particular people group that because of sin whether it be
01:14:48 their sin or other sin or a combination of the two and i would argue probably the latter combination
01:14:52 of the two um they're by and large not working and just living off of tax money for a guilty
01:15:03 white people, even this is not generosity, it's guilt. White people felt guilty. And so out of
01:15:09 guilt, we gave reparations, basically, in perpetuity, indefinitely, to these peoples.
01:15:18 And so our sin of guilt instead of gratitude caused us to give reparations instead of actual
01:15:25 generosity and teaching people like reparations in perpetuity, which allowed for another sin of
01:15:30 apathy um and not working and eating poorly because they weren't willing to work and now
01:15:37 there's there's actually a genetic in their own body romans 1 receive penalty in their own body
01:15:45 there's a physical consequence as well as all the spiritual and relational that's that will preach
01:15:52 now in america a lot of people don't want it to preach they don't want to hear that sermon
01:15:58 um because they think that sermon is racist or they think that um but these are biblical
01:16:04 principles and if we and if we just pretend that they're not and i'll be the first like once again
01:16:10 first to say this is not something that i've been aware of and and consistently teaching for 30 0.97
01:16:16 years no no i haven't been consistently teaching this for 30 years i've been consistently stupid
01:16:22 for 30 years like there's very few things well but this is also pretty like cutting edge like
01:16:28 as far as our understanding i don't know anyone else connecting the field of epigenetics which
01:16:32 is emerging to religious christian living yeah i don't know of anyone doing that yet except me
01:16:36 and you miss we a few a few months back i i said it publicly yeah um and i like heard you talking
01:16:44 about but then i made that connection of epigenetics i think it was like you're preaching
01:16:47 on faithfulness across generations i was like wait we know how that happens biologically well
01:16:51 we've been having the discussion behind the scenes a lot about like what is the nexus of like what
01:16:57 is the connection between like like jordan peterson was was talking about how psychologists
01:17:03 are trying to treat people who have depression strictly through diet right which has prompted
01:17:08 us to be talking behind the scenes like what is spiritual and what is physical right anxiety is a
01:17:13 sin and yet it could be cured with the physical means like it's very interesting like are you
01:17:20 sleeping are you exercising depression what's your diet so my point is like i'm all i'm trying
01:17:24 to say is that um i don't want to pick on anybody because if anything i should just pick on myself
01:17:29 these are um we are learning we're learning i'm learning michael is learning wes is teaching
01:17:38 teaching you know he's teaching but still like you said that like make connecting some of the
01:17:42 dots between what you learned at columbia and where was your grad school university of texas
01:17:47 university of texas and then you know from some of the my sermons on covenantal uh teaching and
01:17:53 taking the covenantal aspect and and then taking the biological aspect and seeing like how like
01:17:59 here's god's promise and then here's the agency and the ways that you know or at least one of the
01:18:04 agencies in the physical you know sense that you could objectively point to and say these people
01:18:08 did this right so now they look like feel like act like this right so my point is for all three
01:18:15 of us um we're perfectly willing to admit happy to admit that um it's new for us i say all that
01:18:22 that to build up to this, I, so it's not like I've been
01:18:27 saying this for 30 years, I, there are guys right now
01:18:30 who say there's only one race, the human race.
01:18:33 And I say that to say, I would have been one of those guys. 1.00
01:18:36 Well, in one sense, it's objectively true, right?
01:18:40 There's only one humanity, right?
01:18:42 It gets muddy because it's like, honestly,
01:18:45 it's kind of like talking, I'm not trying to, again,
01:18:47 I'm not trying to get a rise.
01:18:48 We're trying to be really careful in this episode, 1.00
01:18:50 but it's like talking about the Jews,
01:18:52 religion, ethnicity, nation.
01:18:54 You know what I mean?
01:18:55 We're talking about America.
01:18:57 There's so many of these topics that they're already touchy.
01:19:01 They're already controversial.
01:19:02 And what makes it even harder is like race,
01:19:05 but in what sense?
01:19:07 Jews as in the religion or the ethnicity?
01:19:09 I think we need a better word than race
01:19:11 because race has been through the 17 and 1800s,
01:19:15 especially the 1800s.
01:19:17 It was not what you're talking about now, Wes.
01:19:19 You know, it's not what Calvin was talking about
01:19:21 when he talked about the English race
01:19:23 and the Irish race and the Scottish race, right?
01:19:25 He saw three different roots of people.
01:19:28 He saw them as distinctly three races,
01:19:31 which now we would say rice is white.
01:19:33 Right, that's the problem is getting at the beginning
01:19:35 with the different tiers.
01:19:37 And so race for the listener, someone asked me like,
01:19:39 what do you mean by race?
01:19:40 Biology, biological differences.
01:19:43 Not just culture.
01:19:45 Not just culture, ethnicity, habit, location,
01:19:48 like all these different things.
01:19:49 Race is truly biology.
01:19:51 What was passed down, what is prevalent?
01:19:53 Hold up, so you're saying,
01:19:54 you weren't saying ethnicity is one of the components.
01:19:57 You were saying, you were giving two different categories.
01:19:59 So race is biology, and then you were saying,
01:20:02 ethnicity is distinction from race.
01:20:03 Is the layer on top of it that then,
01:20:06 how is that expressed?
01:20:07 How is that modified, that genetic milieu?
01:20:09 And then there's a lot of, so going back to what I was saying,
01:20:11 there's a lot of modern guys.
01:20:12 So Vodibachum is a great example.
01:20:15 I love Vodibachum.
01:20:17 So I have not a single negative thing to say.
01:20:19 But I think what he would say is he'd say there's only one race, but there are multiple ethnicities.
01:20:23 What you're saying is, no, there are multiple races and multiple ethnicities.
01:20:27 To Calvin's point, different branches, different groups.
01:20:31 But Vodibachum, by race there, he means species.
01:20:34 Yes.
01:20:35 Of which there is only one species, the human race.
01:20:38 And that's my point.
01:20:39 I think the term is difficult because it means so many things in so many contexts.
01:20:44 Because all of us are different races in a sense.
01:20:46 I don't think we need to invent a new term, but we just need to define our terms.
01:20:50 This is what we mean.
01:20:50 But the problem is the term has been defined in culture differently than what we're necessarily saying now.
01:20:55 And so it's like when you say, Wes, one of the first, you don't know this.
01:20:59 I've never told you.
01:21:00 It's one of the first conversations that you and I had.
01:21:02 You said, yeah, I'm leaning more old earth.
01:21:06 And I went away thinking like.
01:21:07 I didn't know that.
01:21:08 I don't like that at all.
01:21:09 And then I came back and I talked to you and you were like, yeah, I think it's more like maybe 8,000 and not 4,000 to 6,000.
01:21:15 i was speaking of an extended pre-noaa flood either way either way the point was like in
01:21:21 popularly defined old earth means billions and billions of years yes right so we have to
01:21:28 acknowledge that when we say race even if we define it that's not what everybody hears this
01:21:33 is my point yep exactly but um someone mentioned the jews and i'll add this in there as another
01:21:40 example uh there's a group of people called the ashkenazi jews that claim to be the origins of
01:21:44 the people that obviously got blessed there's some of the highest rates of schizophrenia because of a
01:21:49 genetic malfunction in a dst gene which leads towards schizophrenic symptoms which include
01:21:54 mental disorders difficulty understanding reality like it's kind of an ironic like a people claim
01:22:00 to be these who are objectively not that they have higher rates of mental illness like talking
01:22:06 about dna and everything's gonna get clipped by right wing watch but but objectively the clinical
01:22:11 literature shows there's a group of distinct people that have these higher rates and so it's
01:22:16 not just like like you guys found the two examples of diet in the side of the other no it's because
01:22:21 all different people we can give multiple examples exactly yeah that and i think that is a good
01:22:25 example because you're talking about a group of people who um now the argument that you made and
01:22:30 i understand that that is technically my position and for anybody who wants you know that has to be
01:22:34 fleshed out thoroughly and i could one i could be wrong two uh see my published work and when i say
01:22:40 published work, I don't mean peer-reviewed articles because I'm not that guy. But I do
01:22:45 have a nine-part podcast series with Andrew Isker on Israel and who are these people? How should we
01:22:52 think about them? What does the Bible say? And basically, our position is that Romans 11 was
01:22:58 ultimately fulfilled in AD 70, that it's not that God didn't keep his promises, but there was a great
01:23:02 spiritual revival. A bunch of people did come to faith in Jesus among that generation that Jesus
01:23:07 was actually speaking to in Matthew 24, 40 years later, many of them still living with the
01:23:12 destruction of the temple in Jerusalem and all these kinds of things from Titus coming in, who
01:23:16 later became emperor, that many people saw that. They saw Jesus coming on the clouds, clouds
01:23:21 signifying judgment like Joel 2, Isaiah. And so they saw that as judgment language, not heavenly
01:23:26 pretty clouds. And they realized, oh man, Jesus literally said not one stone in the temple would
01:23:30 stand on another. This is a fulfillment of the prophecies. We crucified the son of God. He was
01:23:35 right we were wrong and many actually did repent and so god's promise was not neglected it actually
01:23:40 was fulfilled um but it was fulfilled 1950 years ago and it's not a future promise today so no
01:23:45 future land promises and also not a future spiritual revival so then the question of course
01:23:49 becomes well then who are these people i don't think that we need to this is back to michael's
01:23:54 point like you can't just invent a new word when the whole culture already you know so i'm not
01:23:59 advocating for um that country over in the middle east we should call it something besides israel
01:24:03 right that's just not going to happen that's just that would like i would devote my life to a 0.83
01:24:07 an endless fruitless battle of trying to change the name like that's just it's just dumb so for 0.57
01:24:12 all intents and purposes they are the jews i would just like to maintain uh whenever i'm able to
01:24:17 clarify and define my terms um these are not the israelites of the bible of antiquity right um these
01:24:23 are a a new people called the jews and and not new in the sense that they just sprung up you know in
01:24:28 the last 50 years, like there's centuries. But here's the deal. All the way back to what you 0.76
01:24:33 said, Wes, if I'm right about that, and Richard Baxter even holds something. So if you're wondering
01:24:41 in anybody in antiquity, hold that position. It is not the lion's share. It's not the lion's share.
01:24:46 It's a minority position. And I'm willing to admit that. But guys today would be like Jim,
01:24:51 you know, James Jordan, Andrew Riskier, myself, and other guys on the new Christian right. But
01:24:57 then, you know, Richard Baxter would be one.
01:24:59 But with that, if we're right, then you're saying,
01:25:03 so a people who are trying to, trying to... 0.83
01:25:07 Especially like Ashkenazi Jews, 0.62
01:25:08 they just basically emerge about 600 or so AD 0.89
01:25:12 in Western Europe or so.
01:25:15 So then they'll kind of migrate North.
01:25:16 They were very isolated.
01:25:17 So they didn't intermingle with outside groups.
01:25:19 That's one of the things that could help mitigate
01:25:21 certain genetic diseases.
01:25:22 They're in group.
01:25:23 They emerge, nobody knows where,
01:25:24 about 600 years after the death of Christ,
01:25:27 after the end of the disbursement of the judean people they just emerge but this is a group then
01:25:32 claiming continuity which really would probably be those that have lived in the region since before
01:25:37 that time they claim that continuity but then on an objective level they have some of the highest
01:25:42 rates of schizophrenia right of any people my point is if you have a people that um are defined
01:25:46 by many things as many as all people's different peoples are defined by much more than just one
01:25:51 thing but there's at least two things not the only two things but at least two things one
01:25:54 claiming an identity that may not actually be theirs and number two the identity that they're
01:26:00 claiming they're also claiming um with their ideology and the religion of judaism um they're
01:26:05 claiming a a unique and um explicit hatred of the lord jesus christ right so if you so even if you
01:26:13 aren't don't have the lineage actually tracking back to abraham and first century you know jews 0.84
01:26:21 Even if that's not the case, if you're claiming to have that lineage and saying, you know, 0.86
01:26:25 and some of your religious literature literally talks about Jesus, you know, being in hell right
01:26:29 now, burning in human excrement, which is a teaching of the Talmud. So, if that's your,
01:26:35 if your people and your culture has been shaped by that religion and that ideology, we hate Jesus, 1.00
01:26:40 he's burning in hell in excrement, human excrement. And also, you may not, most Jews 1.00
01:26:48 wouldn't even be aware of this. 0.94
01:26:49 So it's not even conscience.
01:26:50 But your heritage is people who actually,
01:26:53 or at least possibly, according to our opinion,
01:26:55 which could be wrong,
01:26:56 but actually hijacked an identity
01:26:58 that wasn't actually theirs.
01:26:59 And then you find out statistically,
01:27:01 you also have a disproportionately high degree
01:27:06 of schizophrenia. 0.97
01:27:07 And for anyone who hates this,
01:27:09 this is just objectively in the literature.
01:27:12 Is your legitimate position, you shouldn't know that?
01:27:15 Some of these things come down to,
01:27:16 differences in IQ and this, that, or the other. It's not even like, yeah, this is true, but we
01:27:21 should do something different about it. It's, you shouldn't know that. I'm uncomfortable that you're
01:27:25 even aware of that fact. But like, this just, this is a well-known fact that has been clearly
01:27:29 replicated. It just is a reality of the world God made. I want to jump on there. One thing before we
01:27:34 go to our break. This really runs into a lot of problems in healthcare, because there are things
01:27:42 that certain peoples are genetically predisposed to. 0.99
01:27:48 And when healthcare systems treat blacks
01:27:51 as exactly the same as whites, 1.00
01:27:53 yeah, there's a lot of similarity. 1.00
01:27:55 But when they're unwilling to look
01:27:59 at some of the genetic predispositions
01:28:00 that generally categorize different blacks
01:28:05 or whites or Asians or whatever.
01:28:06 Or men and women.
01:28:07 Or men and women, 100%.
01:28:09 Like, it really runs into problems.
01:28:12 And we're talking tangible real-world problems
01:28:15 simply because people have to run around like this, you know?
01:28:20 That's a good point.
01:28:21 Yep.
01:28:23 Let's do this.
01:28:23 So we want to try to get to some of the questions.
01:28:26 Nathan, I just, in my peripheral,
01:28:28 I saw him, the cursor on the screen was just going wild.
01:28:32 The question about epigenetics.
01:28:33 Yeah, so we'll get into some of that,
01:28:35 but there's three things we need to do.
01:28:37 One, we need to go to our last commercial break.
01:28:39 Two, we need to make sure that Wes is able to leave it all in the field, so to speak.
01:28:45 And then three, get to some questions.
01:28:47 So let's go ahead and go to our last commercial break.
01:28:49 Listen, guys, you probably listen to Right Response Ministries because
01:28:52 you take the Dominion mandate offered to us in Scripture seriously.
01:28:58 Well, unsurprisingly, so does Dominion Wealth Strategist.
01:29:02 As the only distinctly reformed financial consulting firm,
01:29:06 they help Calvinistic, covenantal, and confessional Christians to steward their
01:29:12 resources faithfully in a way that actually aligns with God's Word. Dominion Wealth leverages
01:29:18 all corners of the financial service industry as independent brokerage agents, matching you
01:29:24 with suitable products and services from dozens of top industry providers. Their mission is to
01:29:31 equip believers to secure their family's future and build a legacy that glorifies God by building
01:29:38 holistic financial strategies that include budgeting, insurance, debt management, retirement
01:29:45 planning, estate planning, and more. In order to make wealth Christian again with a portfolio that
01:29:51 might even put King Solomon to shame, go and take dominion over your finances today by visiting
01:29:58 www.reformed.money and book an introductory overview right now. All of Christ for all of life
01:30:08 and all of finance for Christendom. All right, we're going to get right to questions. We've got
01:30:14 some great super chats. The final thing I want to say, people hate when we talk about this topic.
01:30:19 They say it's eugenics. They say it's racism, like even just knowing and laying it out and
01:30:24 being clear, like, hey, here are the differences. But here's the deal. Like these predispositions,
01:30:29 diabetes, schizophrenia, like Parabond, all these different, and there's many, many, many, many,
01:30:33 many, many more. If you don't talk about them whatsoever, you remove from people the option,
01:30:39 the hope of saying, and it doesn't have to be this way. There are probably, we have a number
01:30:44 of viewers today, some of them certainly probably have type 2 diabetes, and some of them could even
01:30:47 be Native American. At the end of the day, you're going to have to eat healthy, you're going to have
01:30:52 to care about physical exercise now knowing this knowing the predisposition that you could have
01:30:57 because some won't even say it like well you know everyone kind of has that risk for this
01:31:01 we said hey this could be a risk factor these are the things you need to do and you are at
01:31:06 high risk and you are at higher risk reason this is more likely to happen to you cardiac all the
01:31:11 time right you go in the doctors like you're at risk for cardiac disease you need to it's just
01:31:16 whenever we want to group them into certain peoples who are more likely to have a predisposition
01:31:21 and then we start freaking out.
01:31:23 And here's the awesome thing,
01:31:24 the way God has made the world.
01:31:25 DNA methylation,
01:31:27 it is not something that happens one time
01:31:28 and it's over.
01:31:30 You get a certain set of genes
01:31:31 and some are turned off.
01:31:33 They can be turned on by lifestyle.
01:31:35 You have hours and hours to go through
01:31:36 the different diet and everything like that.
01:31:38 Read books, go educate yourself.
01:31:40 You're here watching,
01:31:41 you have the internet,
01:31:42 you need to care about your health.
01:31:43 But they can be turned back on
01:31:45 if they're good ones
01:31:46 that have been turned off
01:31:47 by how your previous generations lived.
01:31:49 And if they're bad ones,
01:31:50 they can be turned off by the way that you live.
01:31:52 And you might not do all of it, go ahead.
01:31:55 And I love that, and not just for you,
01:31:58 but it can make a difference for you,
01:32:00 a real difference for you.
01:32:02 It can make a compounding significantly greater difference
01:32:07 for your children, and then even greater,
01:32:10 if they continue it for your grandchildren-
01:32:11 Assuming you're pre-childary.
01:32:13 Greater.
01:32:14 Right, but my point is, that just, that rocked my world.
01:32:18 It's only been about a year when I thought, you know,
01:32:21 I started talking, you know, the last five years about,
01:32:24 you know, with post-millennialism,
01:32:25 the great, you know, post-millennial hope
01:32:27 and saying, you know, like we want to leave
01:32:29 first and foremost, a spiritual inheritance
01:32:31 to our children's children.
01:32:33 A good man, a wise man leaves an inheritance
01:32:34 to his children's children.
01:32:36 And about, you know, last five years, I was like,
01:32:38 yeah, and also poverty gospel, prosperity gospel's bad.
01:32:41 So is the poverty gospel.
01:32:42 We want to leave in addition, not as a substitute,
01:32:45 never a substitute,
01:32:46 but in addition to a spiritual inheritance nothing less than that but more than that we want to leave
01:32:52 a monetary financial inheritance and i started talking about that over the last five years
01:32:57 and over the last one year i started realizing you know combining some of these things
01:33:03 west that we've been talking about today with scripture i realized what if you can actually
01:33:08 leave a spiritual inheritance a financial inheritance wealth and even a physical
01:33:14 inheritance health right not that not that your offspring are going to live forever anything like
01:33:19 that and not that god owes it to you he's still sovereign he allows for suffering and sickness in
01:33:23 the world your great-grandchildren you could love the lord your children love the lord your
01:33:27 grandchildren love the lord and your great-grandchildren love the lord and one of them
01:33:31 um is diagnosed with leukemia at two years old yeah like we're not we're not this is not the
01:33:36 prosperity gospel we're not it's not we're not negating those things yeah it's not a guarantee
01:33:41 but we're talking about statistics of likelihood, of likelihood. God's always sovereign and there
01:33:46 will always be tragedies and exceptions, but we're talking about going with the overall general grain.
01:33:53 And when I realized, oh my goodness, this didn't, my point that I'm trying to make is this did not
01:33:58 take away from my faith in the word of God. It only strengthened my resolve. It made God's word
01:34:04 all the sweeter, all the truer, all the more authoritative to realize, whoa, what God has
01:34:10 promised in his word is actually applicable at every level, not just in a spiritual plane in the
01:34:17 17th dimension, but it's applicable spiritually and eternally. That's first, and that's ultimate,
01:34:24 but also financially and also even physically in terms of not just wealth, but also health.
01:34:30 That Winston Churchill could smoke cigars all day, drink like a fish, take random naps,
01:34:39 wake up play with action figures methamphetamines during the war methamphetamines during the war
01:34:44 not sleep at night um call the war delicious and tell everyone i you know written testimonies of 0.96
01:34:51 how much he loved it refuse all the chances of peace i mean be an absolute be an absolute maniac 0.98
01:34:58 churchill was a maniac and he could be a maniac and not not just being a warmonger which he was 0.91
01:35:03 but but in addition to that i'm saying physically in terms of his diet and his health habits 0.96
01:35:07 and die at 90 how because he was standing on the bones of the english stock the english stock
01:35:15 of a like close to a thousand years or at least you know eight nine hundred years of of practices
01:35:22 both in diet and exercise and monogamy and sanitation and all these things that were far
01:35:28 superior at that time compared to multiple other peoples and cultures around the world and so he
01:35:35 took an inheritance right so a wise man leaves an inheritance to his children's children i'm saying
01:35:39 that's spiritual first also financial also health and he um took that inheritance and chose not to
01:35:47 give it and shut all those genes down you know by he didn't have many children did he i don't know
01:35:52 but i'm just saying based off of this research theoretically he would have had all the wrong
01:35:57 habits and he would have he would have taken that inheritance and like the prodigal son
01:36:01 he would have lavishly spent a lot of it on, well, but I just, I want to
01:36:08 live life to the fullest and play with action figures and take naps and smoke cigars.
01:36:13 This brings something that I thought about earlier, and now it's back, so I'm going to say it.
01:36:19 Sometimes we look at the nine-year-old grandma. I have a, my wife has a great aunt who, she drinks
01:36:26 like three or four Dr. Peppers a day. 1.00
01:36:28 She eats French fries all the time. 0.99
01:36:31 She's not, she's in her 90s and she's still spry.
01:36:36 And so you get these examples
01:36:37 where the guy that smokes three packs a day lives to 85,
01:36:41 you know, doesn't die of lung cancer.
01:36:43 Here's the point of all of this.
01:36:46 We need, like the life of the Christian is lived by faith. 0.77
01:36:52 And part of this even is in spite of the fact
01:36:54 that before I knew about epigenetics,
01:36:56 I saw some people that bucked the trend you have two choices you can say well I'm going to choose
01:37:02 to live in an unhealthy way myself and God made it work out for them he's going to make it work
01:37:07 out for me or you say no no by faith God has said that the discipline the bodily exertion
01:37:13 and the being healthy and the honoring your parents and all of these things they go into a
01:37:19 healthy lifestyle are still important regardless of what I might see the 90 year old or the 85 year
01:37:25 grandma or grandpa doing we live by faith and so like like what part of what i'm trying to get at
01:37:32 is a lot of people are going to listen to what you said west and i you know i hear some of this stuff
01:37:36 a little bit because my wife's medical um but if you're just coming into this topic it's like oh
01:37:41 this is totally overwhelming part of it is like you can educate yourself this is an emerging field
01:37:48 i just bought a book on epigenetics that i'm working through um but also if you are simply
01:37:55 faithful to obey the commands of god of being healthy providing uh desiring to leave a long
01:38:02 life so that you can be a better steward so you can see your great-grandchildren and invest in
01:38:06 them like like part of this is people before they knew about epigenetics were doing this already
01:38:11 simply because christianity or even just natural law informed how they lived right right this is
01:38:19 not even though it's verging on rocket science at the technical level it's not rocket science
01:38:24 in the practical level well to explain how it happens is rocket science yes but to know that 0.87
01:38:28 simply what you should do is not rocket science unfortunately breastfeeding is like of course
01:38:34 we do live in a system that's working to to provide counter narratives to all of this
01:38:41 that's right that is a reality right people are even people who think they're healthy
01:38:45 can be living in very unhealthy ways now because our our nation is is nuts right now but
01:38:50 all right okay we've got a super chat i'm gonna hit this one personally this is from philip
01:38:55 nathaniel one of my best friends from back home actually really good guy uh he says this first
01:39:01 of all, $50. Thank you so much, Phil. I really appreciate that. He said, thank you for doing
01:39:05 the Lord's work. My wife and I, wonderful wife, they got married. I was in their wedding. They
01:39:10 were married young. They said, we're going to get married. We're going to start a family.
01:39:13 He said, my wife and I are the fourth generation in our families of divorce, abuse, and fatherlessness.
01:39:18 And I was on the front lines when we were both friends, younger on, to all that that went on.
01:39:23 We both committed to ending the generational sin with us. God has been good. Hey, Wes,
01:39:27 thank you for this live stream thank you brother and god bless yeah that's a good one a couple other
01:39:32 super chats we'll start with some of these are from earlier and they were just uh they weren't
01:39:36 necessarily questions so we didn't tackle them right away but granddad farms thank you very much
01:39:39 again for your generosity said uh ga from emmet idaho see uh see if you can get on right room
01:39:45 watch with this episode we did our best i think well we actually did our best to be careful yeah
01:39:51 right but the subject matter is just so controversial that this this one might like
01:39:56 we might have like three or four clips on right wing watch or from probably christians yes you
01:40:01 think that's the same thing these days right wing watch is more charitable right like seriously when
01:40:06 when right wing watch clips me out they actually leave at least some of the context the most
01:40:13 uncharitable sinister i mean just really like just you can just tell it's just mean spirited
01:40:18 like where it's like spliced up up up up up like and it's not even like just cut out of the overall
01:40:23 context but it's like three seconds then seven seconds then four seconds and like like just
01:40:27 just deceitful just absolutely deceitful right wing watch uh the pagan kamala voters who
01:40:34 aren't christians and hate christians they wouldn't do that they have more integrity the only people
01:40:39 who do that are um well like unsupervised uh women tweeting sure is the name like it's seriously
01:40:46 it's um it's it's women um who profess to be followers of both genders of both genders that's
01:40:53 right. Some of those women have beards, but for the most part, it really actually is women
01:40:59 in the literal sense who claim to be Christian and actually are far more deceptive than a group
01:41:09 like Right Wing Watch that's not Christian at all. The Westminster Catechism on the commandment
01:41:13 to not bear false witness against your neighbor is very strong in its prohibitions of all types
01:41:17 of defaming. So any type of, and maybe like, well, it's not slander. That's literally what
01:41:22 he said. Deception, falsehood, obfuscation, all of those things are strictly prohibited
01:41:28 by the law of God. Ben Hofstadler, thank you so much. $50. Get that support going. Men,
01:41:35 it's in all caps. Keep it up, guys. Changing the world with your submission to the spirit.
01:41:39 Men and women, that's it. Only way there is something produced through a union. Amen. 0.96
01:41:43 and one more micah timmons yep uh super chat 20 thank you micah he says thank you brothers for
01:41:50 your ministry uh greatly looking forward to the conference p.s if you find any help uh or if you
01:41:56 need is what i think he's saying any help with uh tech at the conference then let me know um
01:42:02 and i guess that's his x handle it's at the 1689 wizard at the 1689 wizard nathan our tech whiz
01:42:12 make a note of that. If you do need any volunteers or help, Micah Timmons at the 1689 Wizard.
01:42:21 Thanks, Micah. Let me hit the, this is a biochem question. I'll hit it quick and then I can hand
01:42:27 it to Neville. Dolly0987, I'm a biochem student, biochemistry, so this topic really interests me.
01:42:33 I don't disagree with anything said, but I'm curious if you are specifically referring
01:42:37 to epigenetics only, referencing epigenetics only, or epigenetics and natural selection.
01:42:42 it is epigenetics and natural selection natural selection happens much higher at kind of a
01:42:47 population level so like lactose for example people that could tolerate lactose were able to
01:42:52 have better nutrition and have more children and then their children were able to so it's
01:42:56 kind of natural selection high level think of epigenetics that's there are patterns for sure
01:43:02 but also that's much more like individual like me specifically passing on diabetes predisposition
01:43:07 this together so it is natural selection and epigenetics for the record natural selection
01:43:12 the christian is not opposed to it that's not evolutionary biology that's just simply stating
01:43:17 that the strong god has made the world such that the strong survive and do better yep
01:43:25 okay um any other good questions nathan here's one from yeah that's a really interesting question
01:43:31 neville says do you think the renewing of the mind but the gospel does normally fulfill
01:43:35 still fully does fully overcome a genetic intelligence deficiency built up for generations
01:43:41 of unbelief i'll answer this one because i'm for for the three of us on this particular topic and
01:43:48 let's be let's be real on most topics i'm uh the moderate centrist between the three of us
01:43:53 so this would be my position and all three of us have talked about it a little bit on the podcast
01:43:58 uh here and there and we've talked about it you know just as friends offline uh multiple times
01:44:03 with other men in our church, because it's fascinating. And it's a question that you're
01:44:06 going to have to answer. I understand that some of the other pastors and Christian YouTubers 0.99
01:44:11 and influencers are going to say, you're racist and you're Hitler. None of us are Hitler fans.
01:44:19 We just also don't think that we need to define everything in the world for all of time based off
01:44:26 of Hitler. We think that that's part of why we're, that's what the post-war consensus in a nutshell 0.83
01:44:30 is is everything i don't like is hitler like why can we not have nice things well because 80 years 0.62
01:44:35 ago there was a german dude who did x y and z um no you're allowed to have nations they're allowed 0.58
01:44:40 to be independent and sovereign you don't have to have gay globalism you can have hierarchy uh where
01:44:45 there's still equality under the law and everybody's still made in the image of god in the eternal sense
01:44:49 you have equal worth and dignity but you still recognize disparities and differences because god
01:44:54 didn't create a homogenous world but he created a world uh with beauty and part of that beauty is
01:44:59 with distinctions, and distinctions naturally create disparities, and disparities don't always
01:45:03 necessitate injustice, but it could just be rooted in God's created order and all these kind of
01:45:07 things. You could do all that, believe it or not, and not even know how to speak German. 0.89
01:45:14 I would be a point in case. So, all that being said, there's that, but a lot of guys are just,
01:45:21 they're not going to be able to go there. And these guys are going to become obsolete. They
01:45:26 are and and i don't it just i want to be really clear i don't want that i'm not celebrating that
01:45:31 at all i mourn that um there are there are guys who i i would like to have a strong christian
01:45:37 voice for for decades to come i really would but um but here's the deal um we you think oh we're
01:45:44 american free speech no we have not had freedom for decades especially when it comes to information
01:45:50 and speech and things being suppressed and all around the world right now whether it's jd vance's
01:45:55 speech in europe you know um and and uh in germany you see like they're like did you share a meme
01:46:01 you're going to jail you know like i mean like yeah it's real and um and you've got pastors like
01:46:07 ministers like and i'm not trying to open the can of worms and redo this but but you know i won't
01:46:13 say the name so for those of you who aren't privy to this story it doesn't at least doesn't involve
01:46:17 new you know new people coming into some gossip thing but but with some of the controversy that
01:46:22 I recently went through, there was a guy, you know, who, you know, he explicitly said, I don't
01:46:30 think that we should have free speech in certain regards. And I do think that the state should
01:46:36 crack down with legal penalties on somebody who questions the number of the Holocaust or something
01:46:43 like that. And this is a Christian pastor, a reformed pastor. And he's saying it as though
01:46:47 it's like like just the gospel truth like of course and how could you joel be so racist to
01:46:53 think otherwise you know and and i got in big trouble for i got in big trouble for um having
01:46:59 a differing opinion from the opinion that um you know the gospel of of six million and not one less
01:47:06 and and if it is one less uh you're going to jail uh like i got in big trouble for that and uh and
01:47:13 it wasn't even something that I was espoused, but defending a man in my church. And so my point is
01:47:18 faithful ministers, including that minister, I think is largely faithful. So I'm not trying to
01:47:22 disparage anybody. The point is that a lot of guys, good guys, good guys, they can't go here.
01:47:30 But the world is going here. The world is. And we don't want to go with the world to appease the
01:47:35 world. But we do want to explore and say, but is there anything that all truth is God's truth? Is
01:47:41 there anything that is actually god's truth here because if there is then we want to be able to say
01:47:46 no the bible actually addresses this there's actually a christian answer to this there's a
01:47:51 christian alternative uh with this um and and not just put our heads in the sand and pretend that
01:47:59 it's not there and hope it goes away and so all that being said my point is that um
01:48:03 and and looking into these things i'm what i'm trying to do is with everything i'm trying to
01:48:09 like the Bereans, test everything with the Word of God. Test everything with the Word of God.
01:48:14 And that being my final arbiter. So looking at natural revelation and realizing that,
01:48:19 okay, this is God's world. He made the world. And there are true things that we can observe.
01:48:23 And those things, if they're really true, they won't contradict the Word of God. So looking at
01:48:27 those things and the position that I've landed on for about a year now, where I'm at, and I could
01:48:34 be wrong. I could be wrong. Put that on my epitaph. Here lies Joel Webbing. He could be wrong.
01:48:40 But the position that I've landed at as of now is I think that the gospel really can change
01:48:49 everything, but slowly is basically how I would say it. So back to the question, Neville says,
01:48:56 do you think the renewing of the mind by the gospel does normally?
01:49:00 fully is the key word there right fully overcome a genetic intelligence deficiency built up
01:49:07 uh for generations of unbelief it's a great question and i like the way you were yeah neville's
01:49:13 thinking he so he he's everything i'm saying he he already gets it's clear that he gets it from
01:49:17 the question um what i would say is um i think significantly i would say significantly i'm
01:49:25 inclined to think fully but i definitely would feel comfortable saying significantly but here's
01:49:29 caveat i would add over generations so no i don't think that you can come from a um a people
01:49:37 who for a thousand years um were uh sexually uh not monogamous um using substance abuse and
01:49:48 worshiping demons, um, violent, violent, um, promiscuous, um, uh, no, no, uh, system of
01:49:59 sanitation. Um, your, your diet is, uh, instead of eating cows and cooking them, you eat, you use 0.94
01:50:07 cow dung, you know, in your diet. Uh, I don't think you can come from, um, that being your
01:50:13 ancestry, and then in five years, you know, or even 20 years, in one generation, in your personal
01:50:20 life, fully, try and answer the question, fully overcome all of the genetic deficiencies and how
01:50:29 that might affect things like intelligence or whatever, all in the course of one generation.
01:50:34 I do think that you can say, the curses stop with me. As for me and my house, we're going to serve
01:50:41 the lord and then you just try to be the faithful servant if you have five talents or two talents or
01:50:46 one if the master is only in his providence has only given you and your house one talent then
01:50:50 don't be like the wicked servant what made him wicked wasn't being given one talent what made
01:50:54 him wicked was that the one talent he had he didn't put in service of the master so take your
01:50:59 one talent take whatever you got right if you have a lower lifespan it's like i'm only going to have
01:51:04 70 years of life instead of 85 or 60 years of life or whatever, or I have an 85 IQ instead of
01:51:12 100 or 120. You take your intelligence, you take your life, you take your gifts, you take whatever
01:51:18 the master gave you because he gave you something. You have breath in your lungs. He gave you
01:51:22 something. The master has been generous to everyone. There's not one person on this planet
01:51:27 that Jesus hasn't been generous to. And he's been generous even to the poorest of the poor.
01:51:31 we all because the only thing we deserve is help anything more than that is generosity from the
01:51:36 master so so he has been generous with you you take whatever generosity he has given you and
01:51:42 you don't get bitter you don't get angry by comparing it to his other servants and saying
01:51:46 well he gave me less you take your lot the lines have fallen for me in pleasant places what makes
01:51:51 it pleasant is not um the objective place where the lines have fallen what makes it pleasant is
01:51:57 is trusting that the lines have sovereignly fallen and that the lord is the one who laid
01:52:01 them there, that it's his doing, and that it's marvelous in our sight, that he's good, that he's
01:52:05 just, that he's kind, and that he's working all things according to the counsel of his will for
01:52:10 the good of those who love him and are called according to his purposes. You believe that.
01:52:16 You take that to the bank and you say, the generational curses end with me. As for me and
01:52:21 my house, we will serve the Lord with whatever we have, however much, however little. And will it
01:52:26 fully? Can the curse fully be undone even at a genetic level? I'm talking about even IQs
01:52:34 increasing. Yes, I think so, but probably not in your lifetime. Probably not just with you.
01:52:39 If you're sitting on a thousand years of demon worshipers and pagan ancestry and no sanitation 1.00
01:52:45 and substance abuse and promiscuity and cannibalism and all these things, then it can 0.96
01:52:53 It happened for you and your posterity.
01:52:55 But it happened for you and your posterity the same way it happened with other cultures, like European cultures.
01:53:01 They had to turn and convert and follow Jesus and do so faithfully and patiently over generations and generations and generations.
01:53:10 That's my position.
01:53:14 And if that's racist, well, then number one, then racist just, then we just all need to admit that the word just doesn't mean anything.
01:53:23 um it's then if that's how you define racism then racism really isn't a sin number two um if that
01:53:31 really is um you're gonna say well okay well i'll use a different word but that's you know whatever
01:53:36 that's ethnic you know animus or what um guys you are um you it's it's like a computer program
01:53:47 deleting itself you you you have just rendered yourself completely and utterly obsolete um
01:53:58 that world i understand that like for especially for those who are older you grew up in that world
01:54:03 the world where um the world of usaid where everything where nature is artificially suppressed
01:54:12 or inflated by billions and billions of dollars and programs and systems and three-letter agencies
01:54:19 by the dozens who hide these sources and give you this made-up sources and manipulate and the
01:54:26 propaganda of having just a few news stations that they all work in concert with that guys i'm
01:54:31 the boomer world is over it's over um you you will not be able to survive with the uh with
01:54:43 the principles that you once had that used to be you know they used to be workable effective 0.97
01:54:49 principles they are not going to work in this new world and i'm telling you this new world it's scary
01:54:54 in a sense it's it can be intimidating it can be daunting who knows like jesus please you know
01:54:59 Jesus, take the wheel. Please lead it in a Christian direction, because you can veer to 0.99
01:55:03 the right and towards nature, and it doesn't necessitate that it's Christian. It can be a
01:55:08 pagan nationalism. It can be a pagan new right, whatever. It can be Islamic. The verdict's still
01:55:15 out whether or not it will be Christian. And a lot of that is up to ultimately the sovereignty
01:55:20 of God, but in terms of agency, to Christians. Are we going to accept the providence of God
01:55:27 and celebrate even what he's doing and say it's good that we can have free speech it's it's good
01:55:33 that lies and manipulation and propaganda are being exposed every day a new story of these
01:55:39 things being exposed it's good that the billions of dollars that are going to fund programs in 0.98
01:55:45 pakistan that lie about nature and try to brainwash people and indoctrinate people that they're being 0.99
01:55:51 canceled it's good it's good it's good but here's the deal here's kind of the the consequences of 0.98
01:55:56 that, well, on one hand, then crazy progressive leftists aren't going to be able to do very well
01:56:03 in this new world. But also, even your neocon, boomer, post-liberal...
01:56:11 Egalitarianism, everything's flat and the same.
01:56:14 Neochristianity also won't do very well. Because this next generation, they have the whole world's
01:56:21 information in their pocket generation z is going to look at you pastor and they're going to say 0.96
01:56:28 i like him he's a nice guy you know i i don't have anything against him but he's either lying 0.93
01:56:35 or or he's dumb and in either case neither of those look i can't i can't follow him
01:56:42 you know like i can you know 15 years from now i can come and visit him and bring him cookies in 0.97
01:56:48 the nursing home you know and like but i can't but he can't be my leader he can't lead me because 0.54
01:56:53 he's either ignorant or deceitful and so all these things are going to come out the fact that people
01:57:00 are different is going to come out it's already coming out so then the question is can the 0.96
01:57:06 christian run into that space without fear without guilt but with a bible in his hand with courage
01:57:13 in his heart and with the blood of Jesus atoning for his sin and all the sins of his past and any
01:57:20 generational sins of ancestors and say, I'm forgiven. I'm innocent in the sense of my
01:57:25 positional justification, my positional righteousness. I'm forgiven. I'm blameless.
01:57:30 I have the Bible as my ultimate arbiter, my guide, and I'm courageous because the righteous
01:57:37 are as strong as lions. And I'm going to run into this space with all this new information that's
01:57:42 been hidden by nefarious people for a very long time and i'm going to trust that the spirit of
01:57:49 god is within me he'll give me the words and that in his word in his written word there are
01:57:56 explanations that none of this undoes christianity it might undo uh 20th century christianity
01:58:02 judeo-christianity judeo-christianity is certainly going to be undone but um none of this undoes
01:58:08 Christianity. And in fact, as I look at the Bible, and in conjunction with the Bible, as I read the
01:58:13 Bible alongside theologians and pastors who are older than just the last, you know, 50, 60, 70, 0.70
01:58:20 80 years, when I look at the Bible, and I look at Calvin, and I look at Turretin, and I look at
01:58:25 this guy, and this guy, and this guy, oh, they had answers for all of this. This is just historic
01:58:32 christianity and none of these guys were racist bigots they were just i'll tell you they were
01:58:40 who cares your fathers your fathers were better than you they were better than you um our fathers
01:58:49 are like and we have been breaking the fifth commandment and dishonoring our fathers
01:58:55 for decades in the west calling them all a bunch of bigots calling them all a bunch of racists
01:59:02 uh saying well they're good on soteriology but even when we reprint their books we'll do secret
01:59:07 revisions and take some of their words out of it and not even tell people talking about reform
01:59:12 publishing companies now um and you know and and we'll read them on soteriology but we'll tell 0.98
01:59:18 everyone they're stupid when it comes to political philosophy and they didn't know they they were
01:59:23 better than you not just on soteriology it's not just oh we can learn from their soteriology because 1.00
01:59:28 they were better here no they were better than you on everything and everything turns out it's
01:59:35 taken me years to figure that out but basically it's taken me about 38 years old it's taken me
01:59:40 about four decades to realize um one consistent truth one common thread that runs through 0.96
01:59:46 everything um our generation sucks and um we are the lesser sons of uh former better sires
01:59:57 and the best that we can do in a large sense what we're talking about is like if you're this guy 0.98
02:00:01 then you know the the best that you can do is say well the buck stops with me and i'm going to turn
02:00:05 the tide well at a macro level at a corporate pastoral level um that's that's kind of that's
02:00:12 that's really the story for our entire generation, for all of us, even the best and the brightest of
02:00:18 us. We all, the mighty have fallen. The apple has fallen and rolled far from the tree. Every
02:00:25 single one of us, even the best and the brightest, we all pale in comparison to these titans that
02:00:31 came before us because we have been walking in rebellion against the Lord. And so we should run
02:00:40 to this new space, not be intimidated by new information that's actually just old, observable
02:00:46 information that's now no longer being suppressed and is now coming to the forefront. And then we
02:00:54 should run to it with courage, run to it with a forgiven, clear conscience, and run to it with
02:01:00 the Word of God, and run to it with older, better fathers. Fathers in the faith before World War II
02:01:09 um before liberalism um and step into that space take our one talent our generation with the one
02:01:18 talent that we have we're not a five talent generation take our one talent don't bury it
02:01:23 in the sand because we don't want to be icky in cold you know marxist terms instead take the one
02:01:31 talent even if all we have is one put it to work and trust that the lord will be faithful and bless
02:01:36 it, and that our great-grandchildren, they'll be a five-talent generation again, and that one day
02:01:42 we will have Calvins again and Luthers again. That's kind of taken me a long time to figure
02:01:49 that out, but macro picture, that's where I'm at. So to answer your question, Neville,
02:01:55 yeah, I would go so far as to say even fully, definitely significantly, and I'd like to think
02:02:00 fully. The curse of sin and dozens of sinful, rebellious generations can be undone even as
02:02:11 that curse affects biology and the body, but over time. That's the one qualifier I would add to it,
02:02:18 but that shouldn't discourage us, even if it's planting trees whose shade will never sit under.
02:02:26 I think somebody said something about that once upon a time. Sounds like a good thing.
02:02:30 so so let's do it let's do it okay next there's three questions maybe we can hit them quickly
02:02:36 can we trust the literature who is behind the literature that's a fair question scientific
02:02:41 studies there's lies there's uh what is lies damned lies and statistics it is it is with
02:02:47 scientific literature totally possible uh but when you get to dozens and dozens of studies
02:02:52 observing something that doesn't contradict with common sense and how god made the world
02:02:56 i'm much more willing to trust that than you know some magical study that says formula is better for
02:03:03 babies than breastfeeding right well you know let me let me see the author list what are your
02:03:08 thoughts on generational sin curses i don't think they're nobody is generationally cursed to be poor
02:03:14 right so you're you're mailing money to the televangelist break the generational curse of
02:03:18 poverty no but what some of what we're talking about could be considered right generational
02:03:23 it passes on for generations and it's a result of sin right now it's there's certainly no curse
02:03:27 that it will always be this way that a given people group will always have a predensity
02:03:30 predisposition to diabetes so curse eternally it's always going to be there no generational
02:03:36 sin that has an effect see the whole rest of the episode yeah that does exist yeah michael you got
02:03:41 it in right at the end so i don't know real quick so this is a super chat for michael um i'm going
02:03:45 to do this one so michael i really appreciate this and just we have been in so much hot water
02:03:51 that I just, I'm not going to read it exactly the way that you wrote it, but I'm going to
02:03:55 answer the question for you. It is a good question. It's a fair question. I don't think
02:04:00 there's, you know, I don't think you're wrong in asking it because it makes sense. But just so
02:04:06 that I'm not publicly on record saying exactly what you said here, I'm just going to answer
02:04:12 the question for you and you'll know what I mean. So Michael writes, how much of the blame for this
02:04:17 Judeo-Christianity and some of the more kind of post-war
02:04:22 consensus, neo-Christianity thoughts and sentiments.
02:04:27 How much of this should be blamed on the legacy of,
02:04:31 and then he puts a particular name here,
02:04:33 but some of the older, well-known ministers and ministries
02:04:40 that many of our listeners would know if I named them.
02:04:44 um i would i would just i would say for the guys who are currently living today
02:04:51 i want to give them a ton of blame i really want it um because i think it it kind of i think it
02:04:58 started in some sense before them um i i think that in many ways uh they had a choice they had
02:05:06 an opportunity to stem the tide and in many ways instead they doubled down and perpetuated
02:05:11 um, many of the lies and the problems that we're now facing. Um, but I don't, I don't think it's,
02:05:19 um, I'm hard on the boomers. You guys know that. Um, I tried to, there have been episodes where, 0.97
02:05:29 where I have actually gone to some pretty intentional great lengths to honor boomers,
02:05:33 believe it or not. It's just those parts don't get clipped up and go viral. Um, but I'll say this.
02:05:39 I think the boomers made some catastrophic mistakes that have just absolutely destroyed 0.99
02:05:49 the welfare and the likelihood of viability of future generations in the West, and especially 0.99
02:05:57 here in America. I just think that's undeniable. However, everybody's a product of place and time.
02:06:05 Nobody lives life or does theology or any of these things in a vacuum.
02:06:12 We're all product of place and time.
02:06:14 The boomers were not the first generation.
02:06:16 They're not Adam and Eve. 0.86
02:06:18 They didn't come out of the garden.
02:06:19 They weren't created in a state of innocence or a state of integrity and then willfully fall and everything starts with them. 0.88
02:06:27 The boomers, there's generations before them.
02:06:30 And so, I mean, even like the greatest generation, I don't want to pick on them either, but a bunch of people went to fight wars and then came back and pretty much decided that they had seen so many atrocities in these wars.
02:06:50 They pretty much decided that the world was fundamentally broken and could never really be fixed.
02:06:57 And like a lot of your dispensationalism, like Schofield predates, you know, World War I, World War II.
02:07:03 And I understand that 150 years with dispensationalism and 80 years, you know, if you're thinking of like World War II.
02:07:08 But World War II and the aftermath and the disposition, the psychological frame that these men came back with their wives who were trying desperately to hold down the fort and, you know, while they were gone.
02:07:22 and when they came back um they they just the ones who did come back the ones who did come back
02:07:30 right and then think about all the children who grew up without father fathers like they they
02:07:34 just they they they're like yeah that like i post-millennialism was pretty hard to believe
02:07:41 in 1945 yeah you know that the world's getting better and the christ is raining now yeah yeah
02:07:47 like when when that's like that's your life and so a lot of people just came back defeated like
02:07:54 world war ii is like well thank god germany lost everybody lost that war in my opinion
02:08:00 everybody lost that war um and i'm not saying that we should have teamed up with the germans 0.80
02:08:07 and fought against the bolshevik the bolsheviks were terrible i think stalin was worse than 0.95
02:08:11 hitler that's my opinion you guys have heard me say it but they were i think they were both bad 0.91
02:08:14 guys. And personally, I think America should have stayed out of it. That's my political historic
02:08:21 opinion. But the point is everybody got involved. It was in some sense similar to like Putin and
02:08:28 Zelensky, you know, it's like with, you know, like Poland and what's going on here and Hitler
02:08:33 wanting to invade. And it should not in the same way that I've been like, this thing needs to end
02:08:39 with Ukraine and Russia. And this is not the world's problem. It's their problem.
02:08:44 um that's kind of how i feel about about world war ii but but that one churchill made it the
02:08:52 world's problem he did he forced that he's like everyone is going to deal with this because this
02:08:58 right it's the great britain you know the the empire for which the the sun never sets well
02:09:04 the sun kind of was setting on great britain and uh and they didn't really like it and um
02:09:11 And they needed to, they weren't just caring about virtue and, oh, the principles.
02:09:16 There was some of that.
02:09:17 But there was also a sense of, no, Germany, like, we're the superpower of Europe.
02:09:21 We're Great Britain.
02:09:23 Germany can't supersede us.
02:09:25 And so this thing became a global affair. 0.59
02:09:26 And here's the deal.
02:09:27 Everybody lost.
02:09:28 Every country lost.
02:09:30 Our country lost.
02:09:31 We lost probably the least, right?
02:09:33 Because just geographically, we were removed.
02:09:35 And so we had less to rebuild.
02:09:36 part of the reason why america became quickly a superpower just economically was all of europe was
02:09:41 was on fire all of europe was in shambles and we were we were hurting too but we had less to rebuild
02:09:49 than all these other european countries so anyways my point is um even the greatest generation which
02:09:55 again i don't want to disparage those guys at all but even like the greatest generation in some
02:10:00 sense. You can make an argument that the greatest generation is also the founding generation of
02:10:06 pessimism, eschological pessimism, that the world will only get worse and worse and worse. 0.59
02:10:12 And then they give to the boomers their eschatology, but then coupled with a ton of just 0.85
02:10:19 tangible, you know, temporal luxuries. And so the world's only going to get worse and worse and 0.95
02:10:24 worse, and there's not much that you can do about it. And the only thing that you can do,
02:10:27 You can't really fix things at a cultural level, civilizational level, but you just
02:10:32 do evangelism.
02:10:33 So then the boomers made a ton of money with all these tech, you know, booms and innovation
02:10:38 and, but then didn't put it into cathedrals and long works. 0.59
02:10:44 They thought Jesus was going to come back next week.
02:10:45 And so they put it into the only thing that seemed to them to matter with that kind of
02:10:49 eschatology, if Jesus is coming back relatively soon, evangelism and global missions.
02:10:54 and then their own kids all went to public school and then grew up and became new atheists and
02:11:03 yeah it's just it's all a wreck it's all a wreck so my point is just to say to answer the question
02:11:10 i know it's long long-winded but michael um it's a thoughtful question don't blame me for asking it
02:11:16 it's a good question um but i guess what i would say in terms of the the person that you named
02:11:21 specifically and his ministry. And then others like him because he is kind of a stand-in. He's
02:11:27 a good guy to name. He's representative of a lot of other ministries of that generation,
02:11:32 of the boomer generation, Christian ministries. Yeah, I think nobody's absolved, right? See what
02:11:39 I said earlier. So I'm not absolved. Okay, well, boomers are also therefore morally culpable and
02:11:44 responsible. But nobody, no individual and no generation of individuals just sprouted out of 0.94
02:11:52 the ether or was forged in a vacuum. Everyone's product and place were all in a stream. And this
02:11:58 generational stream, that's the whole point of today's episode, I think. I think this comes full
02:12:02 circle. But the whole point is there was a stream that was already moving. And it was a positive
02:12:07 a stream of Christendom, and it got off the rails, but it didn't just get off the rails
02:12:13 in 1970s and 80s with the boomers or the 60s, you know, as their young 20s, you know, in the
02:12:20 sexual revolution. It got more off the rails, and I would argue significantly so, but it was already
02:12:26 off the rails, and you could argue with the greatest generation and their pessimism and
02:12:29 feeling defeated and all these kinds of things, like the world was broke and it can never really
02:12:32 be fixed. And then you can argue all the way back to the enlightenment. There was a positive stream,
02:12:38 there was a negative stream. That negative stream, the fount head of that negative stream is not the
02:12:42 boomers. That wouldn't be fair. The boomers might be where that fount in the stream all of a sudden 1.00
02:12:47 goes into a surging waterfall and picks up speed. Multiple streams joined together and made a big
02:12:53 river. Yeah. The boomers might be representative of that, the currents of the stream picking up
02:13:00 force significantly, but it's not the head of the stream. That would not be fair.
02:13:10 That's all. All right. I think that's it for today. Do us a favor again. Go and register
02:13:15 for the conference, rightresponseconference.com. Not ministries, rightresponseconference.com.
02:13:21 Register for the conference. In the spirit of generosity, we made a promo code for you guys
02:13:27 today uh if you just type in christ is king all caps one word okay so no spaces no underscores
02:13:35 no lower case all caps one word christ is king if you type that into the promo code we're going
02:13:42 to give you guys uh 20 off okay we're not going to leave this promo uh 25 right or 25 you're right
02:13:48 yep 25 off yeah you thought you're getting 20 you're getting 20 pretty good yep 25 every penny
02:13:53 accounts. So 25% off, uh, this promo code will probably be up for about 24 to 48 hours. So not
02:13:59 very long, uh, go to right response conference.com, use the promo code. And also, um, the reason we're
02:14:05 doing the business networking lunch, we think it'll be actually helpful for you guys. I'm going
02:14:09 to go to this lunch and meet with all you guys and talk to you about how maybe you could even
02:14:13 partner if you're willing partner with right response, with advertising and things like that.
02:14:16 Um, but also part of the reason we're doing it is the guy who, who put it on my radar. Um,
02:14:20 one of our followers said hey i've got an idea it would help me as a local business owner to write
02:14:27 off this conference and the travel and everything as a business expense so if you're a private
02:14:31 business owner um then sign up for the business networking lunch same thing on right response
02:14:37 conference.com on that page scroll down sign up for the business networking lunch it's 25 bucks
02:14:42 just to cover food and um and you could write off our conference you know with your expenses 0.56
02:14:48 And then also, if you are a Christian woman, please sign up for the Singles Mixer. 1.00
02:14:55 Same thing, right? 0.97
02:14:56 ResponseConference.com.
02:14:57 Scroll down.
02:14:58 The Singles Mixer. 1.00
02:14:59 We're full on the guys, unfortunately, and about halfway there with the gals.
02:15:04 I think we're doing 20 guys.
02:15:06 We're limiting.
02:15:06 It's going to be 40 people total. 1.00
02:15:08 So 20 guys and 20 gals, and we've got about 10 women. 1.00
02:15:12 So we're looking for 10 more women who fear the Lord and want to find a husband. 1.00
02:15:16 Go ahead and sign up. 0.96
02:15:17 Thank you guys so much for tuning in and Lord willing, we will see you again on Friday.