00:06:56.160So then the question is, is it going to be pagan or Christian?
00:06:58.860Pagan tribalism or Christian tribalism?
00:07:01.100Pagan nationalism or Christian nationalism?
00:07:03.480pagan globalism, or Christian globalism. So we're saying nationalism seems to get0.95
00:07:08.600the lion's share of biblical support. So we're going with that one. And then it's a no-brainer0.63
00:07:13.140for the second question. Is it Christian or is it God-hating? It's Christian. It has to be
00:07:17.900Christian. Pluralism, it's anti-Christian, right? So in that sense, I just wanted to define my terms.1.00
00:07:25.360When I say I'm a Christian nationalist, what I believe is the goodness, the biblical goodness
00:07:28.800of sovereign nations and the right to police their borders and adhere to certain customs,
00:07:33.060but with Christ Jesus being king over all of it, and they must obey his will, which we find in
00:07:39.780the law word of God, every jot and tittle, none of it will pass away. Heaven and earth will pass
00:07:45.300away before any jot and tittle of the law. So we have the full law of God. Certain points have
00:07:50.380been fulfilled by Christ, like the ceremonial law. It's all been fulfilled, but fulfilled and
00:07:55.220abrogated the ceremonial law, but the rest remains intact. And those things need to continue to this
00:08:01.360day. And Caesar is God's deacon, God's servant, serving under Christ as the high king, and he
00:08:06.880needs to do his bidding. That's what I think of when I say I'm a Christian nationalist. That's
00:08:11.140what I mean. I think that that's not a theonomic position. It is, but I think that's just the
00:08:15.980Christian position. I think anything less than that is not Christian. What do you think?0.55
00:08:20.300Yeah, I try to keep it very simple. You know, I think that when you break it down, you know, our nation and all nations should be self-consciously Christian. That's what they should do. That's the good thing. And so everything about the nation should be Christian. So they should have Christian laws. They should have Christian traditions. They should have Christian customs, morality, education. Everything should be Christian.0.99
00:08:45.380And, and we should be self-conscious about that, trying to do the best we can to be as Christian as possible in every area. And what I mean, and that necessarily means that we're not making any accommodations for any other moral perspectives, any other religious perspectives. So in other words, you know, you could be a Muslim in a Christian nation, but you're not going to get Ramadan off. We're working. And if you don't want to work on Ramadan, that's up to you, but we're working, you know, and we're taking Christmas off.
00:09:11.620And if you don't want to take Christmas off, that's up to you, but we're taking it off.
00:35:15.200We don't want to cause, you know, fights just for the sake of it.
00:35:18.320But the thing is, like, our mission is going to cause problems because the thing is, like, you know, people who hate Christ don't like hearing that he's the king and we have to actually act like it and we have to order our lives according to it and all of this kind of stuff.
00:35:37.000And they really don't like hearing that. And so there is really no peace between us so long as we're on this mission. Right.
00:35:47.340You know, we can, we can be friendly with guys like James Lindsay, you know, honestly, he always seemed like the kind of guy that I could grab a beer with, you know, and, and hang out and, and, and chat with him. That's what he seems like. I mean, I don't know if he's like that, but, but that's what he seems like.
00:36:00.960Um, but at the end of the day, we're just coming at, at this from completely different planets, you know what I mean? Very different planets. And so, um, any, any agreement we have on, on anything, you know, is it's, it's really kind of just agreement on the surface more than anything.
00:36:21.500and so of course you know it's not surprising to see responses of like like that like where
00:36:30.220he's just kind of cursing and you know you know making jokes and stuff like that that's not
00:36:34.600surprising um i they're really it shouldn't look the same as jared versus doug wilson right because
00:36:42.460it's a total there's just coming at it from completely different perspective we have a
00:36:47.160different standard that's a completely different standard we have a different standard for
00:36:51.340everything that we do including how we disagree like there are christian standards for every
00:36:56.860everything in all of human life including uh disagreeing with somebody else and james lindsey
00:37:02.760doesn't have that standard in his position he wants to you know to defend with every bone in
00:37:07.160his body to his dying breath um yeah no standards that's his but that's that's what he wants to give
00:37:12.280his life for is that um that you know like that freedom of speech means absolute freedom of speech
00:37:18.620you can say anything yeah always when the reality is it's not you know rush dooney is so helpful
00:37:24.640just that whole you know catchphrase of it's not whether but which there's always going to be a
00:37:29.160reigning orthodoxy there's always there's always going to be a theocracy see that's the crazy thing
00:37:33.680is like oh well we don't want a theocracy um what do you think the branch covidians for the last
00:37:39.140three years have been all about you think that's not a deity that's not a religion of course it's
00:37:44.040a religion it's certainly not science right it's the science tm right which is which is a religion
00:37:49.900there's nothing scientific about it you know take the booster do this like and with without backing
00:37:55.060anything up and if you disagree what what happens to you well you get freedom of speech no you don't
00:38:00.560you get shadow banned you get blackmailed you lose your job you get kicked off of this you know all
00:38:07.440these different things. So the point is, there's never a perfect freedom of speech. And I think
00:38:13.600what we have to realize is, again, it's not whether but which, there's always a reigning
00:38:18.200orthodoxy. By way of consequence, whatever the orthodoxy is, things that are outside of that,
00:38:23.960especially things way outside of that, are going to be labeled as blasphemy. And there's always
00:38:28.580going to be some penalty, whether it's a cultural, like society penalizes you by just,
00:38:34.520we're not going to interact with you anymore. You don't get invited to our gatherings anymore.
00:38:39.120You're losing friends over it, or whether it's a civil penalty. So whether it's a social penalty,
00:38:43.220more organic or a formal civil penalty, there's always an orthodoxy. There's always blasphemy.
00:38:48.840There's always a standard. It's not whether, but which. And there's always a God. That standard
00:38:54.460flows from the God. There's always a theocracy, this idea that we don't need theocracy. Let's
00:38:59.560just do this classical you know liberalism let's just do this but no there's always a god there's
00:39:05.280always a god and and if if there is no god truly then government is the god government is the
00:39:12.540theocracy in and of itself it becomes the deity and so to me it's inescapable but guys guys still
00:39:20.620keep pushing back and not not so charitably this is the thing like like james lindsey just to stay
00:39:26.880on him for a second. Like you, you, you had to see this coming, right? So you, what you said
00:39:32.840was perfect. You know, he's really good at identifying problems, right? Yes. He might not
00:39:37.240know exactly why it's a problem, but, but at the end of the day, he does have some moral compass
00:39:42.660because God created him to have one, right? So, so he has it because God put it there and, um,
00:39:48.420he's inconsistent with it and he's not going to be, you know, he's not going to, he's not going
00:39:52.740to serve you know god he's going to do whatever he wants but but he does have some stuff so he can
00:39:57.400he can know the difference between right and wrong we all understand that so he's good at that
00:40:02.440but we all i thought to be honest joel i thought we all kind of knew that like there'd be a limit
00:40:09.000to being able to you know use joel's or i'm not not joel's uh james's stuff right exactly but but
00:40:16.160But but but the more time passed, the more I didn't see any limits.
00:40:21.320Like I saw him, you know, talking about what pastors ought to do.
00:40:25.020And I'm like, what are you talking about?
00:50:47.220It makes no sense to be a Muslim, but it makes more than atheism is is the bottom rung.0.66
00:50:51.700you if you if you have a creator who's made himself known in everything he's created everything0.99
00:50:58.900and you and you decide you know i'm not i'm gonna reject that that's this foolish as you
00:51:06.560could possibly be right right and just real quick for the record for the listeners ad is using the0.99
00:51:10.580word fool in the proper biblical sense again and again again the bible says the fool says in his0.97
00:51:14.600heart there is no god sure the fool says so the guy who says there is no god in biblical terms0.99
00:51:19.820fool is the exact word that has to be used. R.C. Sproul used to say, we celebrate fools once a0.99
00:51:25.440year on April 1st, right? And April Fool's Day. And so he said, April 1st, it should be called0.96
00:51:32.720National Atheist Day, right? And so April 1st, we can get James Lindsay a birthday card and send it
00:51:38.080to him in the mail or whatever, because that is the fool according to scripture. The fool says0.99
00:51:42.880in his heart, there is no God, and we don't need fools leading the way. And if fools led us and1.00
00:51:49.580helped us to destroy a bigger fool, right? That's what it was. It was a smaller fool destroying a1.00
00:51:54.880bigger fool. All that means is like, well, thank you. We can be thankful for that. But we don't1.00
00:52:01.160then go and make him king, right? So if Deborah goes with Barak, it's to the shame, it's not to
00:52:07.880glorify Deborah. It's an indictment to the shame of Barak. And when they come back and win the
00:52:14.220battle, what you don't do is you don't then make Deborah queen. You don't crown her and say,
00:52:19.840and now we're going to have a gynocracy. Now we're going to be led by having this woman win1.00
00:52:26.720one battle worked so well that now we're going to be underneath female leadership,1.00
00:52:32.040a female dictatorship for now on, for the rest of Israel's future. That's not what you do. What you1.00
00:52:37.820do is you say, thank you, Deborah. And then you say, shame on you, Barak, and may this never have
00:52:42.100to be needed again. That's what you do. And the thing is like, and we don't have to pretend like,0.60
00:52:48.720like, you know, listen, do I want James Lindsay to be, you know, at Tom Askell's church one day
00:52:57.400and hear the gospel and for God to change his heart and for him to accept the gospel? Absolutely.
00:53:02.780Right. I absolutely do. And if James was just going to go quietly into the night and, you know,
00:53:09.120you know i just take my hat off to him and i would i would never speak his name again
00:53:13.080i don't know him like that right but i'm sure people around him do and and they you know they're
00:53:17.560they're ministering to him and they're they're preaching the gospel to him and all that kind of
00:53:21.220stuff i'm sure they're doing the right stuff i'm sure michael fallon is doing the right stuff that
00:53:24.720he ought to be doing as a christian but the reality is he's not going quietly into the night
00:53:30.460the reality is that he's decided to take up arms he's decided to fight and when the fight comes to
00:53:37.180you as a christian i mean you meet him you meet him there that that's your mission you know what
00:53:42.320i mean and so um he needs to be put in his place he needs to be defeated um his arguments i've read
00:53:48.880through some of them and it's just like i remember this because i used to you know argue with atheists
00:53:54.260in in in public and online i used to i used to go to colleges and and argue with you know punk
00:53:59.320atheist kids you know they thought that were they were the smartest things ever i remember this this
00:54:04.720is the old village atheist stuff right i get it you know what i mean and it's like it was always
00:54:10.220there it was just kind of put off to the side when he was focused on this woke stuff but the
00:54:15.100reality is he's a village atheist and he's to be dealt with and i i i you know listen i know he's
00:54:22.240got people christian solid christian people around him and i and i pray that they're reaching out to
00:54:26.280him because um what he's doing now is just it's embarrassing is really what it is yeah yeah and
00:54:34.260And I think part of the problem, though, is that, I want to be careful with how I say this, but part of the problem is that if every Christian went to James Lindsay and said, friend, because you're not a brother, but friend, you're under the just condemnation of God.
00:55:19.000We want someone who can cure cancer.0.98
00:55:21.640But the problem is not every Christian is saying that.
00:55:25.320like christians we're divided because we don't want the same thing you and i ad see you and i
00:55:32.820we want christ as king over not just our nation but every nation in the world we want the nation
00:55:38.880the nations are his heritage we want the nations to flock to him to to to we we want we want the
00:55:47.000whole earth to be covered with the glory of god with the knowledge of god as the seas as the water
00:55:53.340to cover the seas. We want his rule. We want his reign, and we want to see his will done on earth
00:55:59.880as it is in heaven. But it's not just that we have a disagreement on that point with James.
00:56:05.860We have a disagreement on that point with the majority of evangelical Christians.
00:56:11.720Yeah. The truth is that there's a lot of Christians that are public atheists. In other
00:56:16.880words, in their public life, there's literally no difference between them and the classically
00:56:22.720liberal atheist and the classically liberal muslim and the classically liberal whatever
00:56:26.040mormon um there's literally no difference in their public life and that's a big problem
00:56:30.900that's a huge problem and um one of the many reasons why this thing has to be hashed out0.64
00:56:38.160you know aggressively yep yep absolutely all right well so doug wilson jared moore good good
00:56:46.000way to disagree that said i found myself on jared moore's side which was a bummer because i love
00:56:53.420doug i mean doug wilson has been so faithful done so many great things and this is this is the thing
00:56:58.660but i did disagree with him i find myself in a great spot because i um i i've i've disagreed
00:57:06.040with doug i think twice and this is one of them and the other one was something to do with covid
00:57:11.080lockdowns and i gotta say i've come out on top both times so oh wow look at you so the see that's
00:57:18.520the beauty is um if if you want to be when i pick all the battles exactly i win 100 of the time
00:57:24.240exactly if you want to be doug wilson superior what you do is like right because there's a
00:57:28.120trillion theological positions and implications so what you do is you haven't thought of half of
00:57:32.780those you just read what he thought about it and say yeah that's pretty good that's my position
00:57:36.880thanks for doing all the legwork and then on the two positions and then on the two positions that
00:57:41.460he actually is wrong on is probably only two on those you say look at me so i'm just as good as
00:57:46.860doug wilson plus two you know plus two yeah so maybe it's three i don't even remember but yeah
00:57:52.560that's that's how you do it that's how you do it that's how you write about everything that's
00:57:56.340exactly you just only just ride ride his coattails on every issue for the last 40 years except for
00:58:02.720too that's that's where you take the opportunity to distinguish yourself there's doug wilson's of
00:58:06.980the world we're grateful for those guys but then there's me anyway so but that that was a good that
00:58:12.260was a good way to disagree doug was wrong and we're not saying it's a good way to disagree
00:58:16.700because because in the end of that disagreement they came to the same conclusion that's not what
00:58:20.960we're saying we're saying what the whole point of this episode is to say it's not that jared
00:58:25.280moore and doug wilson disagreed well because they eventually came to the same conclusion
00:58:29.900No, the episode left off with, you know, when they got on there with John, they still disagreed.
00:58:35.280But it was good because number one, we got to substantive arguments to where someone like you or I, right, the third party watching could actually learn something.
00:58:44.440It was actually helpful and useful and helped me figure out what I thought about that particular issue.
01:07:50.120And I think Jared Moore and Douglas Wilson did that.
01:07:52.580I think that the skirmishes with James Lindsay and William Wolfe and guys like that have not done that, and it shouldn't be a surprise because in one debate you have two Christians, in another you have Christians versus someone who in their inmost being hates the Lord Jesus Christ, and we should remember that.
01:08:08.500Yeah, ultimately, you know, obviously we're not trying to destroy, you know, Doug Wilson or Jared Moore, obviously we know that, they're our brothers, we're trying to help them.
01:08:18.180And honestly, it's the same with James. We don't want to destroy him and we do want to destroy his arguments, but we don't want to destroy him. But James does need to be uncomfortable with his foolishness. He needs to be made to feel uncomfortable with his denial of Christ.
01:08:36.880And, um, and whatever that takes, we, we, we don't want to hurt him, but sometimes it
01:08:42.680does take your, your, your, your pride to be hurt a little bit, um, to, to recognize
01:08:47.860your need, you know, people need to sometimes be brought to the precipice before the, the
01:08:53.480solution, the antidote, the, the, the, the way is, is apparent to them.