00:00:11.660She does podcasts and articles and is all over social media in Australia.
00:00:18.200And she recently, on her podcast with Cauldron Pool, interviewed Douglas Wilson in regards
00:00:24.160to his Meet the Press segment on Christian nationalism.
00:00:27.700And I see her from time to time, whether it be with Jeff Durbin or Doug Wilson.
00:00:31.680She's in our camp, that post-millennial reformed theology camp.
00:00:35.840And what I wanted to do in this episode was have her join me on the show and give us kind of a state of the union in regards to the church in Australia.
00:00:43.760Things have been hard in the United States these past two and a half years for those who love Christ.
00:00:49.360But in many ways, we've had it easy, especially in comparison to places like Canada, New Zealand and Australia.
00:16:38.400And then personally, I also want to see them step down because if they verbally repent, not just shifting in action like opportunist, you know, all of a sudden, because there's a conservative resurgence, they run out in front of the parade and pretend that they engineered it.
00:16:52.980I don't want to just see repentance in action.
00:16:56.940And so I want verbal acknowledgement that they were wrong, that they wrongfully bound the consciences of Christians, that they must get the vaccine in order to obey Christ's commandment to love their neighbor.
00:17:08.780And now in hindsight, we realize that there was no love for neighbor factor in that particular vaccine.
00:17:16.140So I want to hear verbal repentance, but I also think that many of these ministers should step down because repentance grants us grace and forgiveness.
00:17:25.840There's plentiful grace and forgiveness in the gospel of Jesus Christ for those who are
00:17:30.380willing to acknowledge their sin and repent.
00:17:32.780But when it comes to leadership, leadership is not a charity.
00:17:37.380And in my opinion, if somebody is 900 days late to the game, then what they have effectively
00:17:45.480proven is that they simply do not possess any level of discernment that would be required
00:17:54.980So it's not that you're a horrible person, it's not that you can't be a Christian, it's not that you can't be forgiven, but you're just not qualified to lead.
00:18:02.920If it takes you 900 days to figure something out, and it's not like everything was under wraps to where there was no way of discerning the truth.
00:18:10.600There were millions of people around the world blowing trumpets on the wall, sounding the alarm, begging and pleading.
00:18:21.320And not only were we ignored, but we were slandered.
00:26:19.400I think your decision to be a part of a church that, you know,
00:26:23.200if push comes to shove would, you know, lean a little bit more
00:26:27.160on the Arminian side than the Reformed side in terms of theirs.
00:26:31.240soteriology um i think that's right i think that that's a right instinct um is serious as i am
00:26:37.940about reform theology which is quite quite serious um i just i would rather be led by men
00:26:45.760who sincerely believe 60 of my doctrine than led by men who who insincerely believe 90 of my
00:26:56.480doctrine yeah i you know it's just you it's just it's just going through the motions at that point
00:27:03.220um it's it's hard to follow someone when when you don't when you don't have a sense of confidence
00:27:10.660that that person actually is leading from conviction um when when you feel like i don't
00:27:17.860believe you like you preach these things you say these things and i think that's how a lot of
00:27:22.440Christians have felt over the last two and a half years is, you know, um, even in very conservative
00:27:28.860and biblically faithful, uh, reformed churches with expositional preaching, where the preaching
00:27:35.320is an hour long and, and guys are taking, you know, their cues from, you know, preachers like
00:27:41.060Paul Washer and preaching on sin and all that, you know, um, but then it's like, we were all put to
00:27:47.920the test. And those who bowed the knee and, you know, and then slowly came out just like everyone
00:27:56.380else, right? It's like, well, you know, I'm not doing that anymore. You know, like our church is
00:28:01.440gathering, but what's different about you? Like, sure, you finally came to your senses,
00:28:07.780but you came to your senses in the same exact timeline as leftists and progressives and liberals
00:28:17.380came to their senses like what what what's different about like all of your doctrine
00:28:23.280and all of your convictions and all of your faith when tested by fire um how is this any pure how is
00:28:32.340this any of any more value than than we could just find in the the status quo like how are you
00:28:40.160I guess my question simply put is, how are you, sir, a leader? Like in what way do you lead? In what way are you ahead of others? In what way do you carry more courage than others? Which is not, you know, many have said courage isn't even a virtue, but it's the prerequisite for all virtue.
00:29:02.860um so for me it's it's like people get it wrong i've gotten it wrong as a minister and i've had
00:29:09.500to if i got it wrong privately i had to repent privately if i got it wrong publicly i had to
00:29:14.740repent publicly and there's a sliding scale of you know got it wrong in what category and then
00:29:20.500the question also is got it wrong to what degree and what frequency and there are objective
00:29:26.080benchmarks where if you get it too wrong even if you repent you have to step down because you're
00:29:30.420no longer meeting those qualifications of an elder.
00:29:33.540And again, salvation is free, but eldership is not free.
00:30:00.420in my assessment. And I don't think it's just because I was on the winning team, so to speak.
00:30:07.520I don't think it's just because by God's grace, I was one of the few guys who was able to wise up
00:30:13.820to what was going on at an early date. But I really feel like this was different than a minister just
00:30:20.920getting something wrong, right? Like maybe he taught something doctrinally wrong and then he
00:30:26.960you know, further reformed in his theology and was able to go back and say, so I've taught this
00:30:32.340in the past, but I don't think that this is biblically faithful. And it's a secondary,
00:30:37.340it's not like heresy, it's not like he maligned the gospel, but a secondary issue, you know,
00:30:42.660or something like that. That happens in ministry because nobody comes out of the womb with perfect
00:30:47.220theology. And sadly, nobody enters the pulpit with perfect theology. Nobody's ordained, you know,
00:30:53.940already having, because perfect theology is not one of the qualifications for an elder. He must
00:30:58.920be able to teach, but he doesn't have perfect theology. So, elders should be growing, right?
00:31:06.240They should have a certain benchmark, a bare minimum of sound doctrine, but hopefully an
00:31:13.380elder who has been in the pulpit and been in pastoral ministry for 40 years, I don't know
00:31:20.200if there's any guy who's been in ministry that long, that if you asked him, do you have better
00:31:25.400theology today than when you were first ordained? All of them are going to say yes, which implies
00:31:30.200what? It implies that from the moment they began pastoral ministry to the moment they now are at,
00:31:36.580there has been improvement. And so, I'm not saying that if anyone ever changes on anything,
00:31:42.040aka improves, assuming that changes for the better, then that proves that previously they
00:31:47.860weren't actually qualified and they should have stepped down. That's not my position. But this
00:31:52.280last two and a half years, I think is unique. I think, I just think it's different. I think that
00:31:57.700this was something that was so obvious, that was so clear. And that it wasn't, it wasn't,
00:32:05.080I guess what I'm saying, it wasn't a test of the intellect. It was a test of the will. It wasn't a
00:32:11.700test of someone, because the guys who, this, I guess what I'm getting at is, and I'm processing
00:32:18.280this, but one of the ways I know it wasn't a test of mere intellectual prowess or theological
00:32:25.460aptitude, one of the reasons I know that it wasn't merely that is because when you look at the guys
00:32:32.180who passed the test, they're all over the board theologically. Like you yourself said, you're
00:32:38.700going to a church that's less reformed than you are, but you're going there because your pastor,
00:32:43.780even though he has a different theological disposition from you, he had courage. And I
00:32:51.220really think that this was not a test of who is a master of the constitution, although that helps
00:32:56.980those who knew history, or this is a test of who's an epidemiologist, although it would help
00:33:03.540to know something about viruses. Or this is a test of who has a perfect understanding of
00:33:09.660Protestant resistance theory and theology, although that certainly would have helped.
00:33:14.160But really, I feel like this was a test of character. It was a test of the will. It was
00:33:18.780simply a test of who has a spine. And although it sounds a bit abrasive, I would say one of
00:33:27.420the qualifications for an elder is that he be male. Eldership is for men. And I feel like that's
00:33:35.240what was tested. And a lot of guys prove that they're not male. They don't have spines. They
00:33:42.940don't have masculinity. They don't have courage. And women can't be pastors. And I think a lot of
00:33:50.960guys in the pulpit prove that when push comes to shove, when they're actually tested, they are
00:33:56.380women. And I don't mean that to be demeaning because I know I'm talking to a woman right now
00:34:00.560who had courage and praise God for it. But men go into the fray. They don't cower and kowtow and
00:34:08.700say, please, sir, you know, yes, government. Yes, what can I? And so, yeah, I think it's a good sense
00:34:15.500that you're saying, you know what? Yeah, in an ideal world, I'd like to have my cake and eat it
00:34:20.960too. I would like to have a guy with character and reformed theology, but if I have to choose,
00:34:27.000I want to have a man leading me pastorally who not, you know, now there's a drop-off point,
00:34:35.840not a heretic who has courage, but a man who I think he's wrong on some theological issues,
00:34:41.340but they're secondary or tertiary, but he is orthodox, but he is also very masculine.
00:34:47.840And I'd rather have that than a guy who's spineless and effeminate, but, you know, went to Westminster, you know, whatever, and has some of the theological credentials.
00:35:00.520Do you have any pushback on that or thoughts on that or anything to flesh out further?
00:35:19.460And I think when we try to reject Genesis, you know, the ordained sort of order and the inherited nature and purposes that Christ created pre-sin, pre-curse, pre-fall, that's when chaos happens.
00:35:32.640And, you know, Genesis 2.15 is basically how I understand the definition of masculinity, which is men are to protect and to provide.
00:36:33.580Did you not see how powerful and did you not see his majesty?
00:36:37.300Did you not see he's the Alpha and the Omega, the beginning and the end?
00:36:40.060And then here you are in the desert building a calf.
00:36:42.800And it's spiritual blindness. And I think that's part of what we've witnessed the last few years. And, you know, whether God does it to benefit them by spiritually blinding them so that similar, I guess, you know, it was physical blindness with Saul, a.k.a. Paul.
00:36:59.620but like you know God uses things to help people to see is this a spiritual blindness is he doing
00:37:05.620this so that they can repent and regenerate their hearts and and you know reconcile with Christ as
00:37:12.860well as the congregation or is it spiritually blind because that's judgment and that's he's
00:37:18.660going to make us go through that and you know when God speaks like every time in the Bible God speaks
00:37:23.720you know, mountains shake, things move. And I think if people and ministers and Christians are
00:37:29.960holding on to things that aren't rooted eternally and rooted through scripture, through the word of
00:37:35.660Christ, it's going to fall off the shelf. And these ministers haven't been holding on to that.
00:37:40.400And so God's speaking to us and they're just sort of falling off the shelf as he speaks and his
00:37:45.440voice causes it to tremble. So I think that's what's happening. I do think we have emasculated
00:37:51.460men severe. And I think that when it comes to ministers in the pulpit, and this is just
00:37:57.280something I've seen, I've seen it throughout my life, not just with Christianity, but with all
00:38:02.360kinds of like jobs and careers and occupations. It's very academic now. Everything is about,
00:38:09.740you get that bachelor of theology, you get that, you do your time under a minister, and then you
00:38:15.300get that piece of paper and now you're a minister. Whereas historically speaking, and I think if you
00:38:19.880look at the Bible, God raises men up to those positions. It's a calling. It's not a, I want a
00:38:26.840career. I want to climb the ladder. I want to have a congregation of a hundred people, bums on seats
00:38:31.260every week, this and that. And I think the church is very academic. And I think that that's part of
00:38:36.980why there's so much spiritual blindness, because they came into that position, possibly spiritually
00:38:42.340blind and possibly already within themselves and their own soul, quite feminine in nature,
00:38:48.220rejecting God's patriarchal order and until we sort of shift maybe the recruitment or how it
00:38:55.280happens and we get men in those positions who are called into those positions uh we're going to be
00:39:02.400sort of having to sift the you know the wheat from the from the chaff for a bit longer um but I
00:39:08.640definitely think that this should uh be a good wake up to the church if anything else and it
00:39:16.320should hopefully stir in the hearts of good men to go,
00:39:27.920It says in the Bible he could barely speak properly.
00:39:30.860I don't even know what that means in literal terms
00:39:34.100or practical terms today, but they specifically made mention
00:39:37.680of that in the Old Testament and God used him.
00:39:41.860I mean, every time as well in the Bible that women are used,
00:39:46.320like Deborah and all of the other prophetesses and all these things that people like to
00:39:51.880misunderstand. It's because the men around them are failing. Right. That's why they've,
00:39:56.640it's a judgment. It's never a good thing that the women step up. It's a bad thing that the women
00:40:03.100do that. And I think that we got to stop saying, oh, but Deborah was a prophetess and all these
00:40:10.260women did this. It's like, no, that was judgment. That wasn't how it should be. That was against
00:40:15.920the correct order and you know it's about time men step up into those positions and put an end
00:40:22.840to this feminine pulpit ministry and be men be genesis 2 15 it's that simple yeah i agree and
00:40:31.120by god's grace you know in terms of you're saying you know this is going to continue to happen
00:40:34.620unless we get better stock in our pulpits and i think by god's grace and through his providence
00:40:39.680we are we're getting better pastoral candidates and better church planters and better ministers
00:40:46.620of the gospel because sometimes I think this is what it takes you know when things are so far
00:40:52.240gone when institutions are so so captured and so far corrupted that that it really takes some kind
00:41:00.780of profound providential earthquake in order to to reveal to people you know what's going you
00:41:09.620You need some kind of cataclysmic event that would dislodge the gatekeepers and create the opportunity for those who were not given permission to be able to come in and to step into roles.
00:41:28.420And so I'm really hopeful for the future.
00:41:30.560And I guess one of the last things that I thought as you were talking was just, I think people just, they were not familiar with the word of God, not nearly as familiar as they should have been.
00:41:43.960But I think we also are not nearly as familiar with wickedness that we should have been.
00:41:50.920The Bible says that we should be innocent babes in wickedness.
00:41:55.500So there's a sense of innocence, but there's also, there's a fine line between innocence and naivety.
00:42:02.920We should understand how evil works in the world.
00:42:07.760And I think one of the ways that we understand that is from scripture.
00:42:10.560And another is just simply by being good students of history.
00:42:14.500And I think, you know, it's, people always think like, you know, they look back and say, I would have been on the right side.
00:42:20.840I would have never done what the Israelites did.
00:42:22.820I would have never done what the Nazis did.
00:42:24.360I wouldn't have ever done what the Assyrians did or that, you know, when you go down the line, all these examples and you just assume that you would be on the right side.
00:42:33.340But you assume that because hindsight is clear, right?
00:42:39.560And so it's very easy to detect who the bad guys are and who the good guys are after the fact.
00:42:47.260And one of the reasons why it's easy is because the victors get to write the history books.
00:42:55.700And so actually, sometimes it's not easy.
00:42:57.700Sometimes we look back and we think that someone is clearly in the right, but that's simply because they won and they get to rewrite things from their perspective.
00:43:07.040But my point is, whether it's scripture or whether it's history, when we read the stories, when we read these historical accounts, we never have any sense of, I think, just godly humility to recognize, maybe I would have missed this.
00:43:26.480So like you brought up the Israelites and being led out of Egypt and then immediately, almost immediately, fashioning a golden calf and worshiping it.
00:43:34.940You know, but as even that example, as I've studied it more intently, I've realized that that was actually a breach of the second commandment, which by way of implication includes a breach of the first.
00:43:46.460But it wasn't directly, first and foremost, a breach of the first commandment, have no other gods before me.
00:43:51.580it was predominantly a breach of the second commandment,
00:43:54.480thou shall not make any graven images.
00:43:56.380The Hebrews were not saying Yahweh did not lead us
00:44:17.900faith comes by hearing and hearing the word of Christ, right? We do not walk by sight by what
00:44:23.680we see, but by faith. And because they were a people who were stubborn and steeped in unbelief,
00:44:31.780this absence of faith, the root sin of the Israelites, especially in the wilderness was
00:44:37.560a sin of unbelief because they lacked faith. They wanted sight. They wanted to see God. And because
00:44:44.400the man of God, the closest they could get to seeing God because he was absent. It's not that
00:44:50.280they wanted to worship another God. They simply wanted to make God visible, but in direct
00:44:56.260disobedience to what God had said. I am the invisible God. God is spirit. Those who worship
00:45:03.220him must worship him in spirit and in truth. We're not to worship through images. And so my point is,
00:45:08.060the only reason I bring that up is just that little perspective. I remember a few years back
00:45:12.680When I came into more understanding with that, it garnished within me a greater sympathy, not empathy, but a greater sympathy for the Israelites in that day thinking, oh, man, like, I like to read the story and imagine I'm Moses, you know, but maybe I would have been Aaron.
00:45:31.560Or maybe I just would have been Joe Blow Israelite, you know, telling Aaron what to, but at minimum, I easily could have been Aaron saying, I didn't really want to do this, but the people were pushing me to do, you know, like.
00:45:42.680Like, you know, and especially when you bring into account, like, we weren't trying to worship another God.
00:45:47.700We know it was Yahweh who led us out of Egypt with a mighty right arm.
00:45:51.480We know He's, like, we're giving Him credit.
00:54:21.040Says so many right things, but then has fever, passes, and all these things.
00:54:24.920But again, he didn't bow to Caesar during these lockdowns, and now there's been changes.
00:54:30.440So, I do think that the church is regenerating in some way, and individuals are more regenerate.
00:54:39.320and you know i think the whole process if anything has been very sanctifying for a lot of people and
00:54:45.640i'm encouraged by that and that's you know we can lead a horse to water but we can't force it to
00:54:51.880drink and that's sort of what i think i'm trying to to do my best at within my sort of realm of
00:54:59.320responsibilities but um i i do think that um it will get better i obviously adhere to a post-mill
00:55:07.880eschatology as well which has been apart from going from more arminian theology in my early
00:55:14.84020s to then reformed that was probably the best like most exciting change in my uh sort of journey
00:55:23.160uh this has been the next one um my change of eschatology and the way that i look at the future
00:55:30.520and so even though it sounds doom and gloom i'm i'm excited because i think that we're headed
00:55:36.120in the right direction and i i can see the fruits being you know produced from the trees that we're
00:55:44.280sort of planting now and the last few years um has been great for myself because i've been stuck at
00:55:51.560home i'm in the prison island here i have plenty of time i lost my job they i i worked in a private
00:55:58.280military company once i i left the place they said sorry you haven't had the job you're out
00:56:03.240So, I've had a lot of time and I've been able to read a lot and listen.
00:56:07.280I tell you what, I think I've read everything that Rush Dooney's ever put out in the history of his life.
00:56:12.660I'm going through his law and society book at the moment, which has been really good.
00:56:17.440But long story short, I think lots of people have had the time over the last few years because we've had no choice to really get into things and nut out theology and look into the future.
00:56:30.900and I think the whole dispensationalist view is sort of actually getting
00:56:35.940a lot smaller and a lot of people are at least going A-mil
00:56:39.080and now more post-mil, which I think changes the way Christians
00:56:43.000look at the world and how we tackle it and deal with it.
00:57:00.080Well, is there any practical place that if somebody is in Australia and they feel like the pickings are slim when it comes to faithful churches with good doctrine, but also pastors who have spines, is there any kind of like church search tool or something like that that you could direct us to?
00:57:47.220If you go to cauldronpool.com and contact any of the authors
00:57:51.780that are there, we can sort of direct you as well.
00:57:54.060A lot of us at Cauldron Pool all kind of know each other through church circles, and we know lots of people and friends.
00:58:01.520So, even if it's not on that website, I guarantee if you contact one of us, we'll be able to find something that's near you through word of mouth and through inquiry.