The NXR Podcast - August 08, 2023


THEOLOGY APPLIED - The Growing Divide Amongst Reformed Evangelicals | with William Wolfe

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
DAILY TRUTH - Watchers, Nephilim, Giants, & Disembodied Spirits DAILY TRUTH - The Way In Is The Way On

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 9 minutes

Words per minute

186.03

Word count

12,981

Sentence count

547

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Pastor Joel Webin is joined by William Wolfe to discuss why there is controversy within the Reformed Christian camp, and why it's important to understand who is a "fundamentalist" and how to deal with it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 In less than a year, our podcast has gone from an average of 10,000 downloads a month to 50,000
00:00:05 downloads. What made the difference? You leaving us a five-star review. The more positive reviews,
00:00:11 the more the algorithm picks us up, and more people are confronted by the law and gospel of
00:00:17 Jesus Christ. Help us press forward the crown rights of King Jesus by leaving us a five-star
00:00:24 review on your favorite podcast platform. Thanks.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 All right, welcome back to another episode of Theology Applied.
00:01:23 I'm your host, Pastor Joel Webin with Right Response Ministries, and in this episode,
00:01:27 I am very privileged to welcome back to the show, William Wolfe.
00:01:31 William, thanks for coming on.
00:01:32 Joel, glad to be back.
00:01:34 I think this is my third time, so three times a charm.
00:01:38 Well, let's go ahead and hop right into it.
00:01:39 We want to talk about controversy, handling controversy, why there is controversy among
00:01:43 the Reformed Christian camp.
00:01:45 But before we get to that, I think there's some intertwining between these two topics.
00:01:49 Let's start with Aaron Wren and the recent article that he wrote addressing fundamentalists.
00:01:55 You had some great thoughts on that, but go ahead first for our listeners, anybody who
00:02:00 may have not read the article, give us a synopsis.
00:02:03 Yeah, thanks.
00:02:04 Aaron Wren is, you know, he's a commentator on the evangelical world.
00:02:08 He's from a consulting background, which is interesting, sort of like how I bring a particular
00:02:13 political background to my assessment of evangelical issues.
00:02:17 Aaron Wren brings a consulting class background.
00:02:19 So he's analyzing systems, the way that they function.
00:02:23 And a lot of times without necessarily weighing in too much on like the pros and cons of those systems, but pretty much looking at who the actors are and what they're doing.
00:02:32 And he recently had a piece in his newsletter on his blog entitled, Who is a Fundamentalist?
00:02:38 And he touches briefly on the history of fundamentalism, doesn't get into it too much, and I could cover that more.
00:02:44 But just if people aren't paying attention, you know, who is a fundamentalist?
00:02:48 The term fundamentalist really arose in the early 1900s as you get past the J. Gresham Machen and Henry Fosdick battle over the inerrancy of Scripture.
00:03:00 And there's this sermon preached by the liberal Fosdick, you know, shall the fundamentalists win?
00:03:04 And at that point, the battle was over, you know, believing in things like the virgin birth, the inerrancy of scripture, the validity of Jesus's miracles, the total comprehensive authority of God's word for our lives.
00:03:17 And the liberals at that time, the modernists, really, it was fundamentalism versus modernism.
00:03:22 They were trying to update the Bible for the modern era.
00:03:26 We see in each era that the church is confronted with new theories from the world.
00:03:30 We have to choose how to respond to them.
00:03:32 Well, unfortunately, we've seen what we call liberals often respond by sort of changing the Bible to appeal to the modern era.
00:03:39 And the fundamentalist at that time said, no, we have to stick to the scriptures that continues to grow.
00:03:44 Then you get Carl F.H. Henry. He has the uneasy conscience of a modern fundamentalist in 1947.
00:03:51 So this is a conversation that's been going on for decades.
00:03:54 And really now in American evangelicalism, we have pretty much everybody's a fundamentalist,
00:04:00 quite frankly, according to the commitments of broad swath evangelicalism.
00:04:03 But what Aaron Wren has done, he's come in and he's given us a great insight that now
00:04:07 fundamentalism is much less about a commitment to core theological beliefs, and it's more
00:04:13 about an overall posture towards adjudicating how those in power in evangelical circles
00:04:20 should approach the world.
00:04:22 And he has sort of this really pithy, you know, one sentence summary, and I'll read it for you guys here because I have the article up where he says, in his perspective, a fundamentalist now, practically speaking, will be anybody who challenges the incumbent power structures from the right.
00:04:40 and so that's a really key insight so if we think about incumbent power structures and
00:04:45 evangelicalism over the last decade plus we can think of what the young restless reformed
00:04:50 resurgence has built the gospel coalition you know the the last dying ebbs of christianity today
00:04:56 other major conferences now there are many brothers yourself included myself included
00:05:01 acts 29 would be a good example of a power structure of sort of modern evangelicalism
00:05:06 that those of us on the right are now critiquing because we think that they're overly compromising
00:05:10 with the world. And so that gives us a new paradigm to understand how this label is going
00:05:16 to be used. They're going to label people as fundamentalists, not necessarily because of the
00:05:20 things they believe, and not necessarily because as the historic fundamentalists did, they retreated
00:05:25 from the culture, drew hard lines of separation and said, we won't work with anybody who disagrees
00:05:30 with us on anything. But really, it's going to be people like you and me. And then he uses
00:05:34 An individual, James Wood, as an example of somebody who's actually pretty, dare you say it, winsome and soft-spoken and gives a fair treatment to people like Keller and yet still critiques them, even someone like that is going to be labeled a fundamentalist.
00:05:49 And so here we are now, and thank you for giving me this long opening monologue here, but my political insight on this is as such. As we look at how the establishment operates in the evangelical Christian world, the overlap with how the establishment operates in the political world is essentially that Venn diagram is essentially a circle.
00:06:08 And in the same way in the political world, you get people labeled deplorables or far-right extremists. Now, fundamentalists in evangelicalism are going to be those same people.
00:06:19 They're going to be the people that the moderates, even though they say they believe everything we believe, will refuse to work with to codify the beliefs of evangelicalism.
00:06:29 And thereby, ultimately, they'll let the liberals win unless we are able to convince them or have enough turnout at things like the SBC to maintain control of conservative evangelical institutions.
00:06:41 Well said.
00:06:42 Man, that was a great synopsis.
00:06:45 I didn't want to say a heck of a synopsis because you might think that I was joking about the length, but I will never give anybody a hard time about length because that would be the pot calling the kettle black.
00:06:57 The whole time you were talking, though, I kept thinking, you know, you could just take the same premise and apply it to Christian nationalism, right?
00:07:04 Like part of the reason why you and I were willing to wear that badge and to wear it proudly to say, hey, you know what, maybe not my first choice.
00:07:11 But yeah, I am a Christian nationalist. I'm going to roll with it and I'm not going to be embarrassed about it. Part of the reason why we were willing to do this is because we realized that all the guys who, many of them are good brothers. We're not saying they're not Christians or anything like that. We're saying they're good brothers. A lot of them are not just good brothers, but they're biblically qualified men. They're qualified to be good brothers and good pastors.
00:07:31 And yet we just felt like at the end of the day, these guys, they're making all these efforts in their language and their blogs and their articles and podcasts and sermons to bifurcate themselves, distinguish themselves from Christian nationalism.
00:07:49 And yet, if the libs win, you and me and G3 are going to be sharing a cell together in the gulag.
00:07:59 Like they're not going to say, you know what, Josh Bice, he's not a Christian nationalist.
00:08:04 He's okay.
00:08:05 And here's the funny thing.
00:08:06 And Josh knows that, and I'm not picking on him.
00:08:08 But my point is, my point is that not only will you get called, will you get treated
00:08:14 as though you're the enemy, you're a Christian nationalist, but you'll get called a Christian
00:08:17 nationalist.
00:08:18 I found this interesting recently, and you may be able to cite the example more specifically
00:08:23 because I'm just, I don't have the specifics of it.
00:08:25 But I know that there was some organization that listed sovereign nations with Michael O'Fallon, who is a brother in Christ, but listed him and his organization as Christian nationalists, which I just, I looked at it and I couldn't help but laugh and not picking on anybody or anything like that.
00:08:43 But I couldn't help but laugh because I just thought, oh, man, I feel I feel bad for the guy because he's gone to such great lengths to insist and to distinguish and to caveat, you know, that he is not a Christian nationalist.
00:08:55 But in the view of the world, in the view of, you know, the moderns, they're not going to look at Michael O'Fallon and then look at me and say, you know what, one of these are these are good guys and the other one's not.
00:09:11 they're going to just say yep they're both christian nationalists and so i'm just saying
00:09:14 hey i'm a christian nationalist somebody else is saying i'm not a christian nationalist the world's
00:09:18 going to look and say they're both christian nationalists and so it just seems it seems silly
00:09:22 and i think part of it is still coming off the heels where we you know going back to aaron rin
00:09:26 again you know his his negative and and neutral world and and then um and positive negative and
00:09:33 positive neutral and negative world well in the in the neutral world that we're now leaving in
00:09:38 terms of the world's, is there hostility? Is the general disposition a hostile disposition towards
00:09:44 Christians, or is it a positive disposition, or is it more indifference and neutral position?
00:09:50 And these categories are not theological categories. If somebody's lost, then the
00:09:54 mind of the sinful man is hostile towards God. It does not submit to his law, nor can it.
00:09:58 But we're talking about Christian culture, which you and I both see as a net positive good.
00:10:02 But the point is, in a world that was leaving Christianity but hadn't quite left in the West, we were kind of on our way from being Christian culture to pagan culture, and on the way, there was this optic for a moment, a long moment, multiple decades, but a moment in the big scheme of things, of this neutral world effect.
00:10:22 And in a neutral world, a guy like Russell Moore could actually have some benefits by making 17 caveats and a million different disclaimers and saying, well, I'm not like them.
00:10:34 I actually, you know what I mean?
00:10:36 In a neutral world, they might actually see the distinction being made by someone like a Russell Moore and say, okay, well, he's not as bad as that guy or, you know, whatever. 0.82
00:10:46 But in the world we're entering now, in a hostile world where the remnants and the effects of Christian culture are waning and there's very little fumes left in the tank and we're moving from neutral to hostile world, people are going to look at G3 and they're going to look at Right Response Ministries and they're going to look at William Wolff and they're going to say, like Pam from The Office, that meme is the same picture. 0.87
00:11:13 You don't gain a whole lot. 0.82
00:11:15 Do you agree with that assessment?
00:11:16 Yeah, I mean, I think that's right. And, you know, let me let me propose a brand new paradigm. Here we go. I've been kind of noodling on this and just kind of popped into clarity when it comes to labels like these, whether it's Christian nationalism or whether it's fundamentalist, what I think the dividing line you could consider sort of three buckets in terms of the evangelical world.
00:11:35 Are people allergic to that label? Are they apologetic to that label? Are they accepting of that label? And I think this really ties in to the fundamentalist bent that Aaron's getting at here, because you'll notice that that many of these men who are, we'll say, allergic at best or allergic at worst or apologetic at best of the labels, fundamentalist Christian nationalists.
00:12:01 they're ones in institutional positions maybe professors at seminary maybe they're guys who
00:12:06 have sort of more respectable platforms in the world and you'll notice that these leaders
00:12:11 posture themselves the crowd over here the unwashed masses are accepting of the label
00:12:17 and then they are lumped in with those people by the world so then they either have to be entirely
00:12:22 allergic to it and deny it and denounce it and try to defeat it or they'll be very apologetic
00:12:27 about it. And what they do is they have their eye on the New York Times and secular sociologists
00:12:32 and try to defend the unwashed masses who accept the label, but try to tweak the term a little bit 0.69
00:12:37 with it. And so I think that posturing is very important in evangelicalism today. I think many
00:12:43 people are looking for leaders who are accepting of the labels, who are willing to stand with the
00:12:48 masses contra the world. And so instead of sort of trying to stand between the masses in the world,
00:12:55 apologizing for these labels that are getting applied to them. Fundamentalists, Christian 0.64
00:13:00 nationalists, etc. So you and I are definitely in the accepting camp of many of these. Some of our
00:13:06 brothers are in the apologetic camp. And then many others are completely allergic. They don't want
00:13:10 anything to do with them. That's good. Accepting, apologetic, allergic. I like it. AAA. Finally,
00:13:17 a coffee company that doesn't hate you and your beliefs. Today's sponsor, Squirrely Joe's Coffee
00:13:23 is a thoroughly Christian company
00:13:25 that ships seriously good coffee
00:13:27 straight to your front door,
00:13:29 owned and operated by Joe Morris
00:13:31 and his family out of Olney, Illinois.
00:13:35 Joe also serves as a pastor of a small reformed church.
00:13:38 They believe that Christians should be building
00:13:40 a thoroughly Christian economy
00:13:42 by doing business with other like-minded Christians.
00:13:45 They also donate a portion of their proceeds
00:13:49 to Operation Underground Railroad
00:13:51 to help end child trafficking.
00:13:53 Just go to squirrelyjoes.com and use promo code RRM for 20% off your purchase.
00:14:02 Squirrely Joe's Coffee.
00:14:04 Share coffee.
00:14:05 Serve humbly.
00:14:06 Live faithfully. 0.99
00:14:07 Our sponsors, Private Family Banking Partners, is on a mission to help Christians live out 1.00
00:14:12 the dominion mandate by making a stealth-like move away from the mainstream banks and into 0.99
00:14:19 their own privatized banking system.
00:14:22 This innovative system is designed to guarantee uninterrupted compound interest and tax-free growth without exposure to typical stock market risk.
00:14:33 To join this growing community that is already building wealth unto future generations and
00:14:40 converting post-mill talk into post-mill action, contact Private Family Banking partner Chuck
00:14:48 Deloderonte at his email chuck at privatefamilybanking.com. That's chuck at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:14:59 Set up an appointment and receive a free copy of Chuck's new book, Protect Your Money Now,
00:15:05 How to Build Multi-Generational Wealth Outside of Wall Street and Avoid the Coming Banking Meltdown.
00:15:13 Go to the links in the show notes below.
00:15:15 Are you looking for a Christian-owned and operated cattle company that delivers high-quality beef to your doorstep?
00:15:22 If so, you'll love Mercy Meadows Ranch.
00:15:25 Our friends at Mercy Meadows share our values and vision.
00:15:29 making the dominion mandate a reality they raise top quality beef without any vaccines hormones
00:15:35 or antibiotics to celebrate their fall bulk beef launch they're giving away a free 10 pound box
00:15:43 of ground beef to one of our listeners you could be the winner of this amazing grass-fed grain
00:15:49 finished beef are you looking for beef to fill the freezer then check out their delicious steaks
00:15:55 roast, fajitas, and ground beef shipped free directly to your door. Don't miss this chance
00:16:03 to enter this incredible giveaway. Just click the link in the description below to enter the
00:16:09 giveaway. Mercy Meadows Ranch is the best choice for Christian families who want to eat healthy
00:16:15 and support Christians serving Christians. All right, that's really helpful. Anything else you
00:16:21 want to talk about with Aaron Wren and that particular article on fundamentalism, or do you
00:16:25 want to go ahead and shift gears now and talk about controversy? Well, I think that another
00:16:29 important insight that Aaron draws out and that I myself have noticed too, which is that
00:16:34 it really comes down to, are you willing to critique the existing crop of leadership in
00:16:40 any way, shape, or form? And Keller, again, is a very good test case with his recent passing.
00:16:45 You see that essentially the leaders of the young, restless, and resurgent movement
00:16:51 are completely opposed to anybody who would question Keller's legacy,
00:16:56 provide any critiques of it, you know,
00:16:58 say that maybe he did some good things but not other things.
00:17:02 As soon as you do that, whether it's with Keller,
00:17:04 whether it's with Russell Moore, whether it's with David French,
00:17:06 as soon as you have critiques to provide for them
00:17:08 or even maybe more center-right figures, you know,
00:17:12 who maybe are strong on other issues, who drop the ball on others,
00:17:15 as soon as you critique from the right, you become a fundamentalist.
00:17:19 And so that's something that people need to be aware of
00:17:21 when they see this being thrown around, it's not because they believe in the inerrancy of
00:17:24 scripture. It's not because they believe in biblical gender roles. It's because they're
00:17:28 on the right side of things critiquing, you know, issues and postures of the day. Whereas on the
00:17:32 left side of things, if you critique from the left, you'll be welcome. You'll be given a seat
00:17:37 at the table. They'll try to win you over. And so heads up, the false dichotomy will exist as
00:17:45 people try to paint the two extremes as ex-evangelicals and fundamentalists or
00:17:51 ex-evangelicals and Christian nationalists. And really, it's just a posture game.
00:17:56 With that, I just had a thought, and I'm curious to get your take. But I think part of it might be
00:18:01 because of just where institutions, because of the fact of where institutions actually exist.
00:18:07 So what I'm trying to say is, if you critique from the left, you said like, you'll be, you know,
00:18:11 you'll be accepted. You critique from the right and you'll, you'll be deemed an extremist. You
00:18:16 know, the words that I'll often get, you know, is dangerous. And this is from Christians, you know, 1.00
00:18:22 and again, I'm not, I'm saying they're brothers. I'm not questioning. I'm not saying these are
00:18:26 professing Christians. No, I really believe they're genuine Christians. Many of them, I think,
00:18:31 not just good Christians, but qualified to be pastors. Some of them may be qualified to be
00:18:36 pastors, but maybe should, you know, maybe just get off of Twitter for a little while, just for
00:18:39 the good of their soul, you know, those kinds of things. But, um, so I, I'm not disparaging any of
00:18:43 these brothers. My point is, um, the pushback that I'll get is, uh, the, the, the key terms
00:18:50 will be, um, dangerous. They, they, so they won't say he's a heretic or he's a wolf. It'll be like
00:18:56 wolf-like or, um, or dangerous or, um, scary, uh, scary. Uh, oh, oh, here, here it is. Here it is.
00:19:05 i'm concerned right i'm concerned right exactly and so i call them the concerned bros you know
00:19:12 because you and i would get labeled as theo bros and i thought you know what okay theo bro fine i
00:19:16 could just like christian nationalism i can work with it um i don't appreciate it i know it's a
00:19:20 pejorative you're making fun of me you know but um but theo bro yeah there are theo bros out there
00:19:25 and um and i'm happy to be one of them and and there are some that you know that okay man reign
00:19:30 it in you know like let's you know and i'll and maybe try to talk to them offline or something
00:19:33 like that. Hey, I don't think we, I think that's too far or whatever. So I'm not saying that,
00:19:37 you know, everybody in that camp is, is, uh, perfect by any stretch of the imagination. But
00:19:41 again, I'm not going to disparage them. I'm, I'm, I'm, I, that doesn't mean I'm not going to
00:19:45 correct them. That doesn't mean I'm not going to, um, to hold them accountable, but I'm not going
00:19:49 to publicly embarrass and publicly disparage those kinds of things with the Theobos. That's it. If
00:19:54 there is such a thing as Theobos, um, there is very much such a thing as concerned bros. I'm
00:20:00 concerned, very serious, very somber, very concerned. They're very concerned about you,
00:20:07 William. They're very concerned about me. Uh, they're very concerned, you know? And so the
00:20:11 concern bros are a thing. And so my point is, uh, the concern bros, if I say something, you know,
00:20:16 that back to that fundamentalist kind of thing, like I'm critiquing from the right, like some of 0.93
00:20:21 the things that the main things that I get in trouble for is I will critique pietism, nihilism,
00:20:26 and Gnosticism. Now, I always say this. I'm always careful in the sense that I'm not saying
00:20:34 Gnosticism, capital G, to the T, Gnosticism proper, which would be a heresy, but Gnosticistic,
00:20:43 Gnosticism leaning, a bent, an element, a degree of Gnosticism. Same with not Pietism,
00:20:50 uh capital p but pietistic pietist leaning those kind of and then nihilism not nihilism to the t
00:20:57 not all the way not capital in nihilism proper but saying no i think but i think there is a little
00:21:03 bit of of fatalism nihilism here that this sense of of we you know we can't win we're we're um
00:21:11 we're destined to lose you know that kind of stuff so all my point is when i make those kind
00:21:15 of critiques and those are probably usually my three big critiques and it comes in the form of
00:21:19 my post-millennial eschatology or it'll come in the form of Christian nationalism or it'll come
00:21:23 in the form, whatever. But when I make those critiques to the right, and me being in this
00:21:27 instance, in a lot of instances, I'm right there with them. But in these instances, I'm about an
00:21:32 inch further to the right than they are. Not a mile, but a little bit further to the right than
00:21:36 they are. But it's still worth critiquing. It's still worth noting. When I do that, I get the
00:21:41 response of, oh, yeah, I'm concerned or dangerous or wolf-like or whatever it might be. All that
00:21:47 being said, the reason, back to the institutions, the reason why I think there's so much acceptance
00:21:53 when there's a critique to the left is because if you critique, for instance, just using somebody,
00:21:58 not just a Tim Keller or something like that, let's use John MacArthur. And the reason why I
00:22:03 want to use John MacArthur is because John MacArthur's great. So hear me. I'm starting with
00:22:07 that. He's great. I appreciate him. I respect him. John MacArthur has learned and forgotten
00:22:14 more things about the Lord than, than, than I've ever known. And so, you know, John MacArthur is
00:22:18 wonderful. Um, I do have some, some areas where I disagree, dispensationalism, premillennialism,
00:22:23 those kinds of things. But the headline of the story is John MacArthur is wonderful. That said,
00:22:28 if I, while acknowledging the headline that John McCarthy, Arthur on the holes is wonderful,
00:22:33 I come and say, but I'm a little bit worried about the, we lose down here clip that was
00:22:38 circulating around. And I did a response video to that. Boom. I'm going to, I'm going to get hit
00:22:42 hard. If I was on the left of John MacArthur and I critiqued him, I think the reason I would get 0.72
00:22:46 accepted by institutions is because there are thousands of institutions that actually exist
00:22:51 to the left of John MacArthur. One of the reasons you don't get institutional acceptance
00:22:57 when you critique from the right is because I think, William, part of the problem is there are
00:23:04 no institutions to the right of John MacArthur. That's as far as the institutions go. And I think
00:23:09 part of the difficulty that you and I and some other young guys as we're trying to move the ball
00:23:13 forward and we're trying to kind of get out of boomer theology and get, you know, the post-war
00:23:17 mentality and get back to, you know, John Gill and get back to like some old Baptist and some
00:23:22 old Presbyterians and some old theology and some old political, you know, political theology and
00:23:28 these kinds of things is there are no institutions like that currently in existence that I know of.
00:23:34 And so there is no institutional acceptance because there's no institution that exists.
00:23:38 So you critique somebody who, again, is the lion's share of the story, you know, for the most part, very faithful, like a John MacArthur, you critique him from the left, and you've got somewhere to go. You critique him from the right, and you can move to, you know, Moscow, Idaho, and other than that, that's it. That's the only institution I can even think of.
00:24:00 And the point is, that's what we're trying to rectify. We're trying to say John MacArthur is awesome, but I think there are some other things where we can improve, not to his left, but to his right. And it's kind of like, I think just a lot of guys have just determined that they are the bookend.
00:24:17 There's bookends to acceptable discourse and orthodox theology, and a lot of the concerned
00:24:24 bros, I think they've deemed themselves for a very long time, they viewed themselves as
00:24:28 the far bookend on the right, that anything past that is to fall off the edge of the earth.
00:24:34 There's nothing past that that could ever possibly be deemed as legitimate.
00:24:38 So no one's built past that, so there's no institutions past that.
00:24:42 So if you critique from that side of the equation, there's nowhere to be accepted because there's
00:24:47 nowhere to go.
00:24:47 what do you think? Yeah, I think that that's a pretty good analysis overall. You know, I'm not
00:24:53 one usually to ever say, you know, the right and left paradigm that shouldn't be applied. But I'd
00:24:59 say one way I'd sort of tweak that a little bit in this conversation is not so much necessarily
00:25:04 right as we think like political right and left, but further. What I was picturing in my mind was
00:25:10 just sort of, you know, like ground has been plowed, you know, advancement has gone forward.
00:25:14 We're so thankful for people like John MacArthur and Grace D.U. and Phil Johnson.
00:25:19 We're so thankful for G3 and the way that these men have held the line and pushed things forward for Apologia Ministries and James White.
00:25:28 And then, you know, now we're living in a day and age where there are some, I think, very important and thoughtful voices actually trying to actually draw from the past to equip Christians in the modern era to go forward even further still in the application, particularly of what we can call practical theology and political theology.
00:25:49 Again, on theology proper, our distinctions are going to be small. We could debate eschatology here or there. But particularly when it comes to practical theology applied to living in the United States in the 2020s, we've seen a chorus of voices trying to draw from the historical reform Protestant tradition, particularly on practical and political thought, that pushes things forward further than some of these organizations have historically done.
00:26:18 And that's not necessarily a critique of them either. And I think that gets into our potential subject of touching on controversy and dealing with brothers who are different from you.
00:26:28 Because I think you and I would would hope that these guys would cheer us on as far as they can.
00:26:34 And if they have any and if they have any any warnings for us, it's not it's not, hey, stop, don't go, don't build.
00:26:41 It's just that, like, hey, maybe maybe I wouldn't build there. But, you know, who knows? Maybe that ground is solid.
00:26:47 You know, let's go and see if we can build and take that area and take that solid ground. And so it's interesting, too, this crossed my mind on the fundamentalist fight, is that one of the key hallmarks of sort of your historic fundamentalist were these degrees of separation for people who disagreed on secondary and tertiary issues or even, you know, even beyond that.
00:27:06 So here you come along with a book, Fight by Flight, and that is a book that's open to debate. Fight by Flight is not Nicene orthodoxy. And so people can disagree on that. And yet we're seeing almost this crowd evoke the sort of old school fundamentalist response of saying, no, that's dangerous. No, that's this. No, don't do that.
00:27:30 Instead of maybe weighing it on its own merits, disagreeing if you want to, but continue to go shoulder to shoulder with the brother as we're all trying to push forward into the 21st century.
00:27:41 And I don't mean to speak in too broad of historical terms, but in the opening to R.R. Reno's book, Return of the Strong Gods, he had a really gripping point where he said he received a letter from a young guy, if I'm calling this correctly, that essentially said sort of he longs to live in the 21st century.
00:27:59 and yet we're still living in the 20th century in many ways in the the 20th century last grasp
00:28:06 of enlightenment liberalism and post-modernism continues to sort of like weigh as ankles around
00:28:12 our feet and then there's people like you and me and others who are saying well actually you know
00:28:16 what we can cut these cords we don't we don't need post-modernism we don't need enlightenment
00:28:21 liberalism we can recover sort of classical christian conservatism in a classical view
00:28:27 of the state that says there's no such thing as neutrality and drive forward towards a new and
00:28:32 better, more comprehensive biblical understanding that makes some people uneasy. It leads certainly
00:28:36 to some disagreements. I would hope that it can lead to less, you know, infighting and controversy.
00:28:41 Yeah, no, I think you're absolutely right. That was really well said. It's, um, yeah, I think it,
00:28:46 you know, it's fine to disagree, but, uh, what I've, what I've found surprising is again, it's,
00:28:53 it's the uh it's not i disagree you wrote this book fight by flight you know here it is you know
00:28:59 and uh and you're making a case for leaving you know progressive places right that's the subtitle
00:29:04 why leaving you know godless places is loving godless places and i expected you know that it
00:29:10 would be somewhat polarizing um because obviously you know there are christians that live in blue
00:29:17 places and not all of them are going to leave and so they're going to have some kind of argument for
00:29:20 why they're not going to leave. And that argument is going to be something to the tune of, you know,
00:29:25 I disagree with your book. Um, but again, it's, it's not disagreement, uh, that surprises me or
00:29:31 surprises you. It's, um, it's the claims of, of, uh, not, Hey, I disagree. I think, you know,
00:29:37 I think you, you're off there or, or did you, you know, you got a good point, but I think you maybe
00:29:42 didn't consider this element. Um, that's not what I hear. Uh, for the most part, what I hear is
00:29:49 this is dangerous right you're dangerous you're dangerous you're leading people astray wolf
00:29:57 like right and that i think that's that's what's so shocking is um it's fine to disagree i you know
00:30:06 there's plenty of people i disagree with um but the dangerous element i think is what's surprising
00:30:12 and that to me um that's what makes me think and maybe we can get into this a little bit but that's
00:30:17 what makes me think that it's not just that the underlining motive if we get into why is there
00:30:24 disagreement um if the why behind the disagreement was simply um it was purely 100 just a love for
00:30:33 the truth and wanting as much theological biblical accuracy as we could possibly muster
00:30:38 then praise god um but i have a sneaking suspicion that it's um also that it's not
00:30:48 none of that i think there really is genuine motives right the heart is often a mixed bag
00:30:52 mixed motives that there are genuine motives to defend the truth of god and people being
00:30:56 theologically convinced in a particular way but i think in addition to that there's covetousness
00:31:02 envy pride i i think there's some sin i really do i think there's some sin and i think that's why
00:31:11 instead of i disagree that immediately gets elevated to mark and avoid what do you think
00:31:18 yeah well i mean again we have to be we have to be so careful because we don't know people's
00:31:23 hearts right but the out of the overflow of the heart the mouth that's why i said i suspect
00:31:28 That's right.
00:31:29 No, and I, yeah, and I'm just, I'm doing my own disclaimers.
00:31:32 And so, but out of the overflow of the heart, the mouth speaks.
00:31:36 And, you know, I've noticed that along with critiques of you or myself, or just sort of,
00:31:43 you know, sub, sub tweet critiques of, of the younger group of us, you know, however
00:31:49 much younger we are, it's critiques of things like, oh, they're just trying to build platform.
00:31:53 They're just trying to make a name for themselves.
00:31:55 They're just trying to drive controversy.
00:31:57 and you know i've seen some of those and i certainly i certainly would recognize that
00:32:02 those could be valid critiques but that just raises the whole question of well then what
00:32:07 does it look like to build anything new you know are we supposed to just is there some you know
00:32:13 list of totally acceptable you know secondary and tertiary positions or or points of practical
00:32:19 and applied theology or even you know wisdom of living in this world that we all have to sign on
00:32:24 to. And if we don't, and if we have different perspectives, and we try to advocate for those,
00:32:29 we believe in them strongly, we try to bring others along, all of a sudden,
00:32:32 we're platform building. I mean, I just, I think that's such a pejorative term, it's not helpful.
00:32:38 And then also, you know, Josh Dawes is the king of the threads of the everyone does this X,
00:32:44 everyone does this Y, right? And so it's like, everyone who agrees with me and is using social
00:32:49 media to say the things I agree with, has the purest of motives, and is just speaking the truth.
00:32:54 And everyone who disagrees with me is trying to build a platform.
00:32:57 And we just we can't we can't operate like that.
00:32:59 We shouldn't we shouldn't approach those who have come before us and have significant platforms, conferences, blogs, events and look at them and retrospectively just accuse them of having built a platform.
00:33:09 And at the same time, they shouldn't look at us trying to now join the fight because we were inspired by them.
00:33:16 And then, you know, say, you know, look, look at these platform builders.
00:33:20 So I think you're right. I think there could certainly be a part of that in there.
00:33:24 That's an unhealthy dynamic, but certainly is a dynamic that will continue to exist in the social media age.
00:33:29 And so that's why I think ultimately that's just resolved on our knees before the Lord, in our conscience before him.
00:33:35 If it's in there, if that pride's in our hearts, we need to confess and repent of it.
00:33:39 If it's in theirs, we can trust that the Holy Spirit's living and active and we'll work on them and just keep on going forward.
00:33:45 Amen.
00:33:46 Yeah, I saw a tweet the other day.
00:33:49 I thought it was really funny.
00:33:50 All that was really well said, William.
00:33:51 Thank you.
00:33:52 um, the tweet, it said, uh, those who believe that we lose down here are fighting hard, uh,
00:33:58 to win down here to make sure that we lose down here. So those who believe that we lose down here
00:34:04 are fighting to win down here to ensure that we lose down here. And, and I, you know, I thought
00:34:09 it was funny. Um, but there, there, there does seem to be a little bit of truth in that, that
00:34:14 like, you know, it, it, it can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Um, and I think sometimes
00:34:21 like, like you have a certain mindset of, I, you know, I, I, I've called it in the past in my
00:34:26 preaching and stuff. I called the Elijah, uh, complex, you know, I'm, I'm the only one left.
00:34:31 Right. And then God, you know, it's like, well, dude, I've, you know, I've got, I've got 7,000
00:34:35 other guys on the bench. I could replace you real easy, you know? And so like, there's, you know,
00:34:39 seven other thousand men who have not, you know, bowed their nail, their knees to ball or kiss the
00:34:44 polls. And so the point is that that's a good thing, that we're supposed to celebrate. And we
00:34:52 all struggle with it because we're all sinners, but we're supposed to celebrate when someone else
00:34:58 is doing something well. Today as we're recording, there's a guy, and I'm going to say his name
00:35:03 because I want to practice what I preach here, but he deserves praise. And I want people to hear
00:35:09 his name publicly so that they can go and follow him because, um, because he's legit. Um, his name
00:35:16 is Jamie Bambrick, J A M I E Bambrick B A M B R I C K. He lives in a Northern Ireland and he just
00:35:31 posted this little video. I'm sure you probably saw it video where, uh, you saw it William, but
00:35:36 where he, uh, he, he just makes a really strong case for the, for the general positive good,
00:35:43 even towards individual, uh, salvations and evangelism of Christian culture. That Christian
00:35:49 culture is a net positive. Did you watch that little video, William? I saw, I saw some of it.
00:35:53 Yeah. I shot him a message right away just to encourage him. Me too. Me too. I immediately
00:35:58 sent him a message that dude, I want to have you on my show. I retweeted him twice, um, and reworded
00:36:04 each time just so that i could do it twice and said you got to follow this guy and now i'm saying
00:36:08 it on this podcast with you so that more people hear him um but he's got a youtube channel he's
00:36:13 a pastor in northern ireland you can follow him on twitter he's got like 200 something followers
00:36:17 on twitter and on youtube i think he's got like 4 000 followers um but his videos i like i'll just
00:36:23 say it straight up it's better than mine he's better it's not just it's one more guy doing
00:36:27 good work uh it's another guy doing better work it's you know and the lord is using this ministry
00:36:32 to do this and do that but i'm i'm looking at him and i'm like man that was it's it's highly
00:36:38 produced it's strategic it's create it's concise it's clear i'm not always concise i'm pretty clear
00:36:43 but not always concise so anyways the point is um yeah we we should be celebrating though is my
00:36:49 point there's room and i think part of it it gets into our just this is theological do we believe
00:36:55 that the pie can grow or do we believe it's a zero-sum game right like do we believe and and
00:37:01 and how does it work with glory, right? Does God share his glory? Do we get to reign with the son?
00:37:06 There's a sense in which God will share his glory with no man. That's true. That is his divine
00:37:11 glory that rightly and only belongs to him. But there is a sense in which we get to share also,
00:37:18 we die with him that we might reign with him. And so there's a sense in which we get to reign
00:37:24 and share in the glory of God with him as his sons, as a priest and kings, right? There's your
00:37:31 hashtag king thing, you know, but as priests and kings, and we believe that the glory of God
00:37:36 is not a fixed pie, that the pie grows. And so when it comes to exalting other ministries
00:37:45 and putting eyes on other guys who are doing good work, we believe that we can do this
00:37:52 without necessarily losing something ourself. It's not that I've got to give up this in order
00:37:59 for him to have that no we we believe that the pie can grow and for me especially with my eschatology
00:38:05 like i i believe that we're going to have more and more progressively slowly but more and more
00:38:10 christians over time and so uh so even with ministry we're going to need more teachers and
00:38:14 we're going to need more online teachers and all this kind of stuff um but yeah it it does get
00:38:19 tiresome uh the disparagement of yeah well i don't know uh he's platform building it's like
00:38:25 but you have a platform it did it did it drop out of the sky or did someone build that platform
00:38:31 right so right so it's not platform building it's it's it's said as though that's that's just this
00:38:36 inherent evil platform building bad but but that's being said from platforms that were built
00:38:43 so that's right really it's no you can't build a platform that's that and that's what we're
00:38:50 pushing back on and saying why yeah i got it i got a tagline for you joel post-millennialism
00:38:56 we've got more pie there we go we've got more pie we've got more pie yeah i got a bible verse
00:39:04 too though that i think is incredibly applicable to this entire conversation and it's uh luke 9
00:39:09 uh 49 and and 50 51 and let me read it and then i think it applies directly to what we're talking
00:39:15 about. Uh, John answered him and said, master, we saw someone casting out demons in your name
00:39:21 and we tried to prevent him because he does not follow along with us. Notice he doesn't say follow
00:39:28 along with you. He says he does not follow along with us, but Jesus said to him, do not hinder him
00:39:34 for he who is not against you is for you. And I just think that that really is a verse that,
00:39:41 that our whole coalition should take the heart that, you know, whether we see people, you know,
00:39:47 approaching things in the name of John MacArthur or in the name of Josh Bice or in the name of,
00:39:53 you know, James White or in the name of Doug Wilson or in the name of Joel Webin, right? Like
00:39:58 I fundamentally believe all those four names I just said are all with each other. You guys will
00:40:02 all stand face to face with Jesus Christ in glory. And that puts us with Jesus. And because that puts
00:40:09 us with Jesus, we are not against each other. And even there, Jesus was instructing his disciples to
00:40:17 be more welcome and open to the fact that the ministry of the gospel was going to go forth
00:40:23 under other people and through other people that weren't just the 12. I mean, obviously,
00:40:28 that's the story of Acts in so many ways. And we see the spread of the gospel and, you know,
00:40:33 first century, you know, Christianity going forward with new churches and new elders and
00:40:38 new names you know being commended as servants of the gospel and so i think that's a that's a good
00:40:43 biblical um admonition for us to recognize that those who are not against us and to be there and
00:40:49 to be clear there those who would be against us would have to fall into the camp of people who
00:40:54 we think are denying the truly fundamentals of the faith that which you will not have a full gospel
00:41:00 um eschatology doesn't fall into that christian nationalism doesn't fall into that that means
00:41:05 we're together. And so, you know, we should act like it down here. I agree. And I think that's
00:41:10 a good word for all of us, myself included there. You know, I, I want to, I want to be more careful
00:41:16 when providing the critiques of solid brothers that need to be provided. I'm going to be less
00:41:24 careful. I'm still going to be careful in terms of accuracy, but I'll be less careful in terms of
00:41:29 tone uh when i am dealing with someone like russell moore sure who i believe has gone apostate
00:41:36 and that's why i that's why i would be i would use reserve stronger language um for david french
00:41:42 for russell moore for those kinds of guys um and then i want to use more careful language
00:41:48 when i disagree with someone who is not um apostate but somebody who is faithful and uh
00:41:55 and has been tried and true and you know what i think that's part of it also i think part of
00:41:59 is just the testing i think it's just time and and that's you know what that one i think is fair
00:42:04 to say okay well but i i've listened to this guy's ministry for 50 years and i've listened to your
00:42:11 ministry for five um and i still want to you know i want to give it some more time i think i think
00:42:18 that's fine so long as you don't just completely write someone off or as long as you don't make
00:42:22 unfair charges um i think it's fine though to say i'm i'm um it's not fine to say you're dangerous
00:42:31 if they're not doing something dangerous it's not it's not fine to you know publicly attack
00:42:36 but it is fine to say um i like your ministry i'm listening but i'm listening with uh with a
00:42:42 holy suspicion because um your ministry is newer and uh and there's not the decades of tried and
00:42:52 true faithfulness uh behind you i i'm fine with that what do you think yeah i mean i think i think
00:42:57 we all need to have a healthy uh skepticism christ commands us to be shrewd and that's and
00:43:03 to test the spirits and i think that obviously the bible provides a paradigm as we see here in
00:43:09 luke 9 of unknown people who are preaching the true gospel but aren't part of the tight-knit
00:43:14 immediate community and then we also get a paradigm of people who who claim to be a part
00:43:19 of the community, but then use their words and use their influence to undermine key doctrines,
00:43:25 right? And that's where the harsher language for false teachers and that, you know, drawing that
00:43:29 line on who's a false teacher when they say that they do adhere to all the tenets of Christianity,
00:43:36 and yet they're doing subtle things, doing underhanded things. So that's a paradigm that's
00:43:39 important to keep in mind. But, you know, something that came to mind when you're talking
00:43:42 about people's ministries, and I think this is a good, I mean, it's a good warning to me,
00:43:46 So I'll preach to myself. It's a good warning to all of us. And that's, you know, we don't fundamentally just want to in any way, shape or form, mint or create a new class of celebrity pastors, right? Like we, the one again, the disasters of the YRR of Acts 29, where these ministries were built around celebrity pastors.
00:44:03 So we want to be encouraging men and women to trust their local pastor.
00:44:08 And then if for whatever reason, if you can't fully trust your local pastor, then you should strive to find a church under whose pastoral authority you can trust and grow.
00:44:20 So I do think that maybe some of the controversies that are surrounding you and others are probably due to the fact that some members of flocks, you know, are hearing things you're teaching and then they're maybe going to their pastors with them and there's disagreement.
00:44:36 So that's not your fault.
00:44:37 I mean, quite frankly, that would be, you know, an admonition we should all give to those who hear what we have to say through, you know, media venues that's not coming from the authority of a pulpit.
00:44:48 You know, you shouldn't look if you find a great teacher who you love to listen to alongside your local pastor, you know, it would be unhealthy for you then to try to reshape your pastor into the mold of that teacher.
00:45:00 You need to recognize that God has given you a certain local pastor that you need to trust you and submit to as far as possible and expected by scripture.
00:45:08 And, you know, you shouldn't be trying to recast them into the mold of your favorite YouTuber at all.
00:45:13 And so that, you know, those out there who are listening to this know that if you can't, if you can't, then then, you know, you maybe need to spend some time with the Lord, you know, and then maybe, though, if your convictions change, if your theological convictions change, then maybe it would be good for you to find yourself in a different church that adheres more closely to your convictions.
00:45:34 And this gets back to everything else we're talking about, Joel, which is in our day and age, so much of the division is going to come down to not so much convictions on paper, but disposition in real life.
00:45:44 How are we applying those convictions to the life we find ourselves in today?
00:45:49 Totally. And that's that's the show that we're doing right now.
00:45:51 It's called, you know, it's our flagship show with Right Response Ministries.
00:45:53 It's the show that I was most passionate about starting.
00:45:57 And Lord willing, I want to start other, you know, I eventually want to have multiple different shows, podcasts and multiple different contributors.
00:46:04 and have, you know, like right response be more of like a network, you know, with multiple shows
00:46:08 and multiple hosts. But theology applied is the flagship one, but that's just it. That's my point.
00:46:14 Theology applied. Such a simple concept, right? There's nothing, no novelty about it whatsoever.
00:46:22 But of the recent past, we've done theology in the abstract, but we have not had, like Wilson
00:46:31 would say theology coming out of our fingertips. And I think there's just a desperate hunger for
00:46:35 that. And that's why I think some people are, they are leaving their churches. And I would say to
00:46:41 those people, first, try to stay, do what you can to try to stay and talk to your pastor and let him
00:46:48 have that opportunity as your pastor to speak into your ear and listen to those things,
00:46:55 take it before the Lord, exercise humility. But at the end of the day, if you feel like you got
00:47:00 to leave because your convictions have actually grown that small, uh, that strong, but it's over
00:47:04 something that's, you know, it's not a primary theological issue. It's not denial of the Trinity
00:47:09 or this or that. Um, then you should leave, um, as much as you can, uh, peaceably, you should
00:47:15 leave respectfully. You should leave quietly, not meaning that you don't tell your close friends in
00:47:19 the church that you're leaving, but you're not making a ruckus. You're not making a fuss. Um,
00:47:23 but here's the deal. You are allowed to leave. And I think that's part of the reason why some
00:47:29 guys get upset is because people, some people are leaving. And I think some pastors think that they
00:47:35 have more authority than they actually do. They think that, you know, you're allowed to resign
00:47:40 your membership at the church, but the elders have to agree with you. No, no. Because here's
00:47:48 the thing about elders. Elders are very reluctant to agree with a member's reasoning for leaving
00:47:55 that elder's church? Come to find out. Turns out you're allowed to leave a church without it being
00:48:01 a primary issue. You're allowed to leave a church and say, I love this church and I love the pastor
00:48:06 and my first inclination was to stay and I tried to. And I feel like I've made an honest effort.
00:48:12 I plan to leave quietly. I plan to leave respectfully, but it's not so much a difference
00:48:17 in theology in the realm of theory, what we believe, but how we apply it. I think that
00:48:24 these things that both me and my pastor, we both believe. I think that faithfulness Monday through
00:48:31 Saturday in believing these things, what that looks like is X, Y, Z. I think it looks this way
00:48:37 politically. I think it looks this way culturally. I think it looks it, and this is where I really
00:48:42 feel like the Lord's leading me. Now, sometimes you can just do it without your pastor being on
00:48:47 board, but I've talked to several Christians where they just started doing it. The thing that they
00:48:52 felt convicted about a theology applied and they started to be disparaged by their pastor and even
00:48:58 publicly their pastor in his podcast started you know without naming them you know like but but
00:49:04 very clearly like talking up disparaging members of his own church for uh not because they were
00:49:10 being divisive not because they were but just because they were they were passionately they
00:49:14 were trying to build something they they were trying to start this ministry or they were trying
00:49:18 to start this business, or they were trying to start a school, you know, or they were trying to
00:49:22 do this, or they're trying to do that. And, uh, and the pastors, um, you know, started disparaging
00:49:28 them, you know, like, like making fun of, you know, Christian nationalism or making fun of
00:49:32 post-millennialism or making fun of patriarchy. That's a big one. Like the pat, your pastor starts,
00:49:36 you know, saying, well, the trad wives, you know, like take, take aside for a moment. This is,
00:49:42 it's not primary doctrine. It's not primary doctrine, but take aside for a moment, which
00:49:46 position is correct. If a woman starts going to your church and she's wearing a head covering, 0.94
00:49:52 or she's been in your church for years and she starts head covering, even if that's wrong, 0.67
00:49:56 there's no command. There might be, R.C. Sproul said this, there might be a command in the Bible
00:50:00 for a woman to cover her head in worship, but there is definitely not a command in the Bible
00:50:04 for her, forbidding her from covering her head in worship, which is why Vesta Sproul,
00:50:09 we're talking about R.C. Sproul's wife now, who's still living, who still wears a head covering
00:50:13 in worship following the lord and what she sees the scripture saying she could be wrong i could
00:50:19 be wrong and also following her late husband and the way that he led her in that particular area
00:50:23 so here's the question you you're a pastor and members in your church they start listening to
00:50:27 joel webin or they start reading this book or they start listening to that and and one day they show
00:50:31 up with a head covering and and you disparage them like like publicly not just you pull them
00:50:38 aside and their husband pull the husband aside and talk to him private but you disparage them
00:50:42 on a podcast and start saying well the trad wives and theo bro like then yeah like dude of course
00:50:49 they're gonna leave your church right and you think that's that's you think that's the youtubers
00:50:54 fault right brother that's your fault right right you know that's you know i was given a piece of
00:51:01 counsel to people in the pews but you know if i were to give a general sort of perspective on
00:51:08 how pastors operate along these lines. First of all, it would be that, you know, you know,
00:51:14 you can't have it both ways, right? You can't have it that the social media world is totally fake,
00:51:19 and nothing real comes through it, or, you know, all your buddies are totally killing it on social
00:51:24 media, and everyone needs to read their latest TGC blog post, right? The reality is, in a day
00:51:30 and age of digital media, people receive, you know, information through YouTube, through Twitter,
00:51:35 through Facebook, through other platforms that speaks to them, not just because they got it off
00:51:40 the internet, but because it speaks to them in their conscience and in their convictions. And
00:51:44 then they open the scriptures and then they go explore it. And then they look for other
00:51:47 faithful men who have taught these things before. And then over time that could grow into a real
00:51:53 conviction of theirs. And sure, maybe it began by listening to somebody on YouTube, but that in no
00:51:58 way, that's not an argument against the validity of that position, nor is that a justification
00:52:02 for a pastor or somebody in authority to treat that person in a dismissive way.
00:52:07 And, you know, another thing, too, is that, again, as I contend that so many of the divisions
00:52:12 in evangelicalism and even conservative evangelicalism are dispositionally oriented,
00:52:18 not so much the doctrine you hold to, but the disposition through which you adjudicate it
00:52:22 and you, you know, engage the world.
00:52:24 You know, we're not, you know, we are, I think, trying to push pastors and Christian leaders
00:52:28 to broaden the Overton window of what is acceptable, and then to give everybody the
00:52:33 chance to exercise freedom of conscience under the Lord. And that's what it's like, if you're
00:52:38 a pastor and all of a sudden you've got five guys in your church who are big on Christian 0.84
00:52:42 nationalism, you should just thank God for that, I think, essentially, as long as they're not being
00:52:47 divisive or stirring up controversy. And again, holding different opinions and even believing in
00:52:52 them is not necessarily divisive, right? You need to have space for the people to wear head
00:52:58 covering space for men to believe in Christian nationalism, space for people to believe in
00:53:02 patriarchy, et cetera. But then if you start using your position of authority to attack that or
00:53:06 disparage that, well, then yeah, those people aren't going to feel like they're welcome there.
00:53:10 Even if your teaching is incredible and your confession of faith is spot on, you don't want
00:53:15 to sit and be belittled every week because of a secondary position you hold. So I think that a lot
00:53:21 of pastors out there need to wrap their mind around the fact that they are certainly not the
00:53:25 only voice that gets to their flock anymore and how they deal with that is going to matter greatly.
00:53:30 That's so well said. And I, and that goes back to all full circle, but it goes back to, um,
00:53:36 making, you know, carving out space for, for anybody and everybody to our left,
00:53:41 but, but very little of that same charitable spirit towards the right. And now we're just
00:53:49 supplying it to the pastor surely surely if anyone um you know should should be sure that
00:53:55 surely the pastor should be able to if the pastor can have you know people in his church um you know
00:54:02 let's say it's a calvinist pastor if he can have people in his church who aren't calvinist but are
00:54:07 arminians you know um and and he's willing to to work with them and tolerate them and make a place
00:54:13 then surely he he can have someone in his church you know if he's got an egalitarian in his church
00:54:20 surely he can have somebody who's who would hold the biblical patriarchy sure you know like and so
00:54:26 i think that's that's what's that's what's going on right now is i i just i think that you know
00:54:31 the lord and his providence is is just dusting off some it's it's not even it's not even that
00:54:38 we're going forward. I think we are in the big scheme of things pushing forward, but a lot of
00:54:43 it is just going back. We're just going back to, I mean, the head covering thing. I mean, it's just,
00:54:48 it's, it's silly, you know, like when, when you go back and you just, I mean, it's everybody was 0.99
00:54:53 wearing every, you know, every woman was wearing a head covering, the lion's share. I'm talking 1.00
00:54:57 the lion's share and until the 1900s. And I mean, and you had churches in America in the 1950s and
00:55:05 60s when when second wave feminism was really starting to kick off and some of them it was 0.72
00:55:10 orchestrated events on the same sunday all the women they planned it and they did it in women's
00:55:15 bible studies um the sewing groups is what you know they were but it was in that context of a
00:55:20 women's only bible study outside of the lord's day or women's study uh a sewing group or something
00:55:26 like that they they made hatched the plan that on a particular sunday they would go to church
00:55:31 And during the sermon, they would all take their hat off together at the same time and throw it on the ground to smash the patriarchy.
00:55:38 And so I'm just saying, when that's church history, when that's church history from 1 Corinthians 11 to 1960, head cover.
00:55:48 And then somebody in 2023 thinks, well, maybe I'll just try it out.
00:55:55 Right.
00:55:55 You know, and you're saying, and your reaction is not just, I think that's wrong, or I don't think that's the best reading, or, I mean, just say it. 0.76
00:56:03 If that's your view, if your view is that every Christian read the Bible wrong until the last 60 years, great, if that's your view.
00:56:10 But you need to acknowledge that. 0.58
00:56:12 This is not novel.
00:56:13 This is not crazy, and it's certainly not dangerous.
00:56:16 And it's one thing to go after, you know, another pastor like me, some YouTube guy.
00:56:21 But you start making members of your church and female members, women, on top of it.
00:56:29 And I get, as a pastor, I get angry.
00:56:32 I would like to meet with that pastor and have some words with that brother.
00:56:36 So I think, yeah, pastors are just, it's like, okay, this is the world that we live in now.
00:56:42 There was, once upon a time, it's like, okay, you're the only Baptist church in town.
00:56:46 You're the only Presbyterian church in town.
00:56:48 And there was a time where people wouldn't go five miles outside of the place where they
00:56:53 were born.
00:56:54 They would live and die within a five, you know, like 10 mile radius their entire lives.
00:56:58 And that's just, that's not the world that we live in anymore.
00:57:02 I still think church membership matters.
00:57:03 I'm a church membership guy.
00:57:05 I think that a covenant that you make with your local church, that it's significant,
00:57:10 that it's not a trifle, shouldn't be treated lightheartedly.
00:57:14 But at the end of the day, I also think that Christians, their conscience is clear to leave their church and it doesn't have to be a primary theological issue in order to merit a reason for leaving their church.
00:57:26 And pastors, we need to come to terms with the reality that because of the success of the Great Commission, it's a good thing.
00:57:33 Because the gospel has been so successful, predominantly in the West, our church members, instead of hearing one sermon from us on the Lord's Day or three, Sunday morning, Sunday night, Wednesday night, historically, from us, they now get to hear from a host of people.
00:57:51 And we had that where you'd have the pastor, but then you'd have the traveling evangelist, right?
00:57:57 Maybe it's a Whitfield or something, and he's kind of going up the coast and preaching.
00:58:01 And I'm sure there was this same principle that we're discussing, that there were members in those churches, you know, who, and maybe some of them even voiced it, and maybe that wasn't respectful or the right thing to do, but they were, I wish Whitfield was our pastor, you know, like, gosh, his sermon was so much better, you know, and now it's just that same thing.
00:58:18 But now it's instead of Whitefield, you know, coming on horseback, you know, maybe once or twice a year, it's our people are hearing a ton of sermons.
00:58:27 And yes, we do need to guard.
00:58:29 We need to guard as shepherds because some of those things that they're hearing actually are dangerous because they are heretical.
00:58:35 They are bad.
00:58:36 But a lot of what they're hearing, if our people are faithful, if they have discernment, if we've discipled them as pastors as well, then really what they're getting is they're just getting more Bible.
00:58:45 They're just getting more doctrine.
00:58:46 They're getting more sermons, and I think we should rejoice.
00:58:50 So anyways, all that being said, any final thoughts?
00:58:54 Well, yeah, I mean, I think that, you know, I do, I think we should continue to, you know,
00:58:59 modernity forces a lot of changes on the church, and we have to wrestle with and respond to them.
00:59:05 And so, I mean, I could certainly imagine if I were a pastor in George Whitefield today,
00:59:11 and he came through town, then all of a sudden I had members who were going to leave the community
00:59:15 and travel along with Whitfield, I would say that's not a good idea.
00:59:19 You know, you need to stay here and stay committed to your own local church.
00:59:23 I mean, it's a wonderful aspiration to plug into a local church, to grow up there, to
00:59:27 raise your kids there, to be there for life.
00:59:30 If that's, you know, I think we should aim for those things as far, you know, live in
00:59:35 peace as far as it depends upon you.
00:59:37 So we should strive for the goals of being planted, of being rooted, you know, and that
00:59:42 ties back even into your book of finding communities that you can plant and root in
00:59:46 and be there for a long time and seek to grow and ask yourself, is this somewhere that I would feel
00:59:52 good that my great-grandchildren grow up? And I'll be honest right now, California is not somewhere
00:59:57 that I have any confidence would be good for my great-grandchildren to grow up in. So we should
01:00:01 strive for that, but we must use wisdom. You know, Joel, I saw again sort of some dust up over what
01:00:07 jesus did or didn't command his followers to do about politics and as i saw this engagement it
01:00:13 just really it made me reflect that too many conservative christians continue to have the
01:00:17 red letter ethic just in a different way from the social justice folks you know and they look at
01:00:22 only what jesus said about what people should do and all of scripture is jesus speaking you know
01:00:29 go back to the proverbs go back to the old testament you know dig up the wisdom of old
01:00:34 from God and bring a comprehensive perspective for what it looks like to live in God's good world
01:00:39 and bring that to bear today. Yes, we live in the new covenant, but there's no exploration
01:00:43 on the biblical wisdom found under the old covenant, right? And so we need to have, I think,
01:00:49 a more comprehensive application of faithful Christian living that is not just tethered to
01:00:54 the specific commands that we have recorded in the gospels that Jesus delivered. Those are
01:00:59 important, but all of scripture is equally important. That's right. Yep. Red letter ethic.
01:01:04 that's a really good way of putting it that's yeah and i think that's why the game has changed
01:01:08 you know together for the gospel i think of that you know some of these things you know have have
01:01:12 pittered out in part because um because of what i would call and others have called a theological
01:01:20 maximalism that's part of what fundamentalism was uh there were there was some great things
01:01:25 about the fundamentalist but part of it was um when the enemy's at the gate when the city is
01:01:31 under siege um you fall back behind the wall you know if they break that you fall back to the inner
01:01:37 wall you know and you and then eventually everybody you're just in a small circle your backs are to
01:01:42 each other and and it's this is the hill to that we're going to fight live or die you know we're
01:01:46 going to die on this hill um to defend the virgin birth inerrancy of scripture bodily resurrection
01:01:51 and and at that point when when you're under such attack um you you're you know it's like if the
01:01:58 house is on fire, you can't move all your stuff. So you're thinking, all right, I get my wife and
01:02:03 kids. Maybe I get the dog. Maybe I get this precious heirloom, whatever. In some sense,
01:02:11 that's part of what the fundamentalism came out of. But now I think one of the reasons why we're
01:02:17 divided and things like together for the gospel that dog don't hunt is not because we don't want
01:02:22 to be united on the gospel anymore. But I think this is actually a good thing. It's because we
01:02:28 want to never talk about anything less than the gospel but we want to talk about now we want to
01:02:33 talk about more that we're pushing our theology to the margins that we're that we're saying okay
01:02:39 but what does the bible say about voting what does it say about immigration what does it say about
01:02:44 economics what does the bible say about vaccines what does it say about civil authority what does
01:02:49 it say about patriarchy the husband's authority in the home what does it say about children what
01:02:53 does it say about obligation to parents what does it say about where you live what does it say and
01:02:57 And so a lot of guys are starting to have those kinds of conversations.
01:03:01 And I think part of the charge of it's dangerous, it's divisive, your platform building, it's
01:03:07 the theological maximal guys who are saying all of Christ for all of life.
01:03:11 The Bible applies to this.
01:03:12 It applies to this.
01:03:13 It applies to that.
01:03:13 And I'm not even confident that I'm applying it perfectly, but I'm over here trying to.
01:03:20 That's the difference.
01:03:21 I'm over here trying to have a serious conversation about the Bible and how it applies to this.
01:03:28 And so it's not that you've got guys who are right and guys who are wrong.
01:03:31 You've got guys who are trying and guys who won't.
01:03:35 I think that's the dividing line.
01:03:37 It's the, I just wouldn't miss the good old days of the Together for the Gospel conferences,
01:03:43 where we talked about one thing, only one thing, and we sang, and that's it.
01:03:50 and i i don't miss those days i don't want to be divided i don't like division i don't how
01:03:56 blessed it is when brothers dwell in unity with one another i want unity um but i don't want
01:04:02 unity if the cost for unity is truncated theology minimalism theological if theological minimalism
01:04:10 is the cost for achieving unity then then i don't want that unity i want unity with theological
01:04:17 maximalism. And here's the crazy thing. The church has done it before, and I think she'll do it
01:04:23 again. I really do. Our fathers, our forefathers, you look back, they were way more robust in their
01:04:30 theology. The average churchgoer knew way more about the Lord. And yet, and there were divisions
01:04:35 over baptism, but in general, you had way more robust theology for the average churchgoer in
01:04:42 the pew and more unity to then then you do today where there's way less a lower bar of theological
01:04:50 aptitude for the average church grower and also less unity so i don't think theological minimalism
01:04:57 is um is the only path to uh to christian unity i just refuse to believe that yeah well that
01:05:03 reminds me of you know that what was known as the ecumenical movement you know that was born out of
01:05:09 the birth of evangelicalism, particularly Billy Graham and the spread of, you know, revival style,
01:05:16 you know, rallies. And, you know, that ultimately led to, you know, compromise on some fundamental
01:05:23 issues as they were trying to kind of scale it down to a minimalism of, you know, accept Jesus
01:05:29 Christ as your personal savior, not even always getting the Lord part in there. And, you know,
01:05:35 they're trying to work with Catholics and, you know, drifting in the wrong direction with, 0.57
01:05:39 and you have Martin Lloyd-Jones who stands against Graham and against John Stott and says,
01:05:44 no, we can't, we can't compromise here. And he's doing that because he's trying to maintain a
01:05:49 maximalist position primarily on the gospel and issues of salvation. But I think it applies today.
01:05:55 And again, something I see in the conservative political world that applies to what's happening
01:05:59 in the church is that, you know, the the answers to former problems that perhaps worked well or
01:06:06 were allotted in their times are not necessarily the ones that are going to fly for us today.
01:06:10 And that is not us necessarily in any way sort of discounting, you know, the good that
01:06:16 forerunners did. You know, you can you can praise good done by Buckley and Reagan and realize that
01:06:23 the Reagan economics aren't going to fly for us today. And that's not the answer. Right. We can
01:06:28 And we can, you know, be thankful, I guess, for a certain degree of the peace that, you know, provided the illusion of pluralism and classical liberalism and some of the ideas we got out of that.
01:06:41 But we recognize today that's not going to confront in a robust theological way an increasingly pagan society.
01:06:47 And it doesn't have to. I mean, there are areas we should and we can push forward.
01:06:51 So finding faithful answers to today's problems is not necessarily a disparagement of the past, but it's, again, it's fighting the battle for the faith once we're all delivered for the saints in a new generation and recognizing that nothing's ever settled.
01:07:08 And so we have to come up with new ways to apply theology to our lives today with the new issues facing us.
01:07:15 And we should give each other freedom to come up with some different answers along those fronts.
01:07:20 Amen.
01:07:21 William, great stuff, man. I'm blessed by your ministry. I'm blessed by your spicy tweets.
01:07:29 They're not always spicy. Sometimes they're just really, really loving. And the spicy ones I think
01:07:33 are loving too. But I'm just watching you from a distance, reading some of your stuff. And yeah,
01:07:39 man, I'm just excited with what the Lord's doing with you. And I hope that we get to partner more
01:07:42 someday. I wish there was some way I could get you down here to Texas, but keep on keeping on.
01:07:47 Well, I'd love to come down and I'm thankful for you too, Joel. I appreciate that. And if
01:07:51 If you don't mind me just giving a note to your audience here on Twitter, I actually
01:07:55 now have a subscription option.
01:07:57 If anybody feels like they want to chip in and support me as I'm doing that work, you
01:08:01 know, I'm going to provide, you know, exclusive content for people who subscribe, but really
01:08:06 the best way to think about it is if you appreciate the work that I'm doing, this really is a
01:08:11 way for you to support me in that work.
01:08:13 And I welcome the partnership.
01:08:15 Yeah, that's great.
01:08:16 Same, same with us with right response.
01:08:18 We always say, all right, yeah, there's, there's a little bit of, you know, uh, cost and value,
01:08:22 like we're going to do this and you'll get, you know, you're going to get some extra content.
01:08:26 You'll get a book, you'll get the, you know, but a lot of it is, um, what you're doing is a ministry.
01:08:31 What we're doing is a ministry. So, um, the, the biggest incentive is just saying, uh, it's not
01:08:36 just tit for tat. It's also, um, we just need your support. And, uh, and I think, yeah, you're a guy
01:08:42 worth supporting. So, uh, if you're not already doing that guys, check out William Wolf, at least
01:08:46 follow them on twitter and prayerfully consider subscribing what's what's the minimum can they
01:08:50 subscribe for like three bucks or something like that five yeah it's three dollars a month so just
01:08:55 take that take that money you're going to give to starbucks yeah thanks joel i appreciate it man
01:08:59 yeah that with with starbucks man that would get you a third of a coffee three bucks that wouldn't
01:09:04 get you a coffee all right thanks william thanks for coming on thank you joel thanks for having me
01:09:16 Thank you.