The NXR Podcast - June 27, 2023


THEOLOGY APPLIED - The Watchers, The Nephilim, & Creatures Living Deep Inside The Earth | with Ben Garrett

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
DAILY TRUTH - America’s Collapse | Judgment For The Wicked, Or Discipline For The Church? DAILY TRUTH - Irrational Fear Is A Sign Of God’s Judgment

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 22 minutes

Words per minute

182.72

Word count

14,992

Sentence count

552

Harmful content

Toxicity

16

sentences flagged

Hate speech

42

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Ben and Brian discuss the Watchers, their offspring, the Nephilim, and what is currently living under our feet, deep within the earth, in the deep caverns. In less than a year, our podcast has gone from an average of 10,000 downloads a month to 50,000. What made the difference? You leaving us a five-star review.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 In less than a year, our podcast has gone from an average of 10,000 downloads a month
00:00:04 to 50,000 downloads. What made the difference? You leaving us a five-star review. The more
00:00:10 positive reviews, the more the algorithm picks us up, and more people are confronted by the law
00:00:16 and gospel of Jesus Christ. Help us press forward the crown rights of King Jesus by leaving us a
00:00:23 five-star review on your favorite podcast platform. Thanks. Welcome back to another
00:00:29 episode of Theology Applied, I am your host, Pastor Joel Webbin with Right Response Ministries.
00:00:34 In this particular episode of Theology Applied, I am privileged to welcome to the show for
00:00:39 the first time, Ben Garrett.
00:00:41 Ben Garrett is the co-host, along with Brian Sauvé, of a popular new podcast called Haunted
00:00:47 Cosmos.
00:00:48 So in this episode of Theology Applied, Ben and I discuss the Watchers, their offspring,
00:00:53 the Nephilim, and what slash who is currently living under our feet deep within the earth
00:00:59 in the deep caverns.
00:01:02 Okay, now that being said, real quick, if you haven't checked out my book, Fight by Flight,
00:01:07 go ahead and check it out on Amazon.com or RightResponseMinistries.com.
00:01:12 The subtitle is Why Leaving Godless Places is Loving Godless Places.
00:01:17 The book is forwarded by Doug Wilson, and if you check it out, I promise you'll be in
00:01:21 for a treat.
00:01:22 Real quick, before we start though, here's a brief word from our sponsors.
00:01:26 There are very few things as important as fellowship.
00:01:30 Taking the time to spread the gospel is our duty as Christians,
00:01:34 but sharing the word over a warm cup of Squirrely Joe's coffee, now that is our passion.
00:01:39 Like the caffeine coursing through their veins, Squirrely Joe's is energized by their calling
00:01:45 and emboldened to model their relentless faith.
00:01:49 Based in Olney, Illinois, their association with the endangered white squirrel isn't just a novelty.
00:01:57 It's a reminder that His Majesty can appear in the most unexpected places, in a humble squirrel, through a chance conversation, and even in a simple cup of Joe.
00:02:10 Share coffee, serve humbly, live faithfully.
00:02:14 Squirrely Joes is owned and operated by Joe Morris, his wife Rachel, and their seven children.
00:02:21 They believe in being a truly Christian business where Christ is in the DNA of the business.
00:02:28 Joe also believes in living Coram Deo, that means before the face of God, in every aspect of life.
00:02:37 Joe is also a pastor of a small reformed church, and both Joe and Rachel are veterans of the U.S. Marine Corps and U.S. Army, respectively.
00:02:48 They believe that Christians should be building a thoroughly Christian economy by doing business with other like-minded Christians.
00:02:56 The coffee is also fantastic.
00:02:59 So, don't delay. Visit squirrelyjoes.com to order your coffee today. 0.91
00:03:05 Again, that's squirrelyjoes.com to order your coffee today.
00:03:11 With the banking industry in another tailspin and the Fed ready to raise interest rates once again, 0.81
00:03:17 many of you are probably asking, when does this madness stop?
00:03:20 If you're interested in learning how to establish a family banking system
00:03:24 outside of today's mainstream banking insanity,
00:03:27 then schedule a call with our sponsors at Private Family Banking.
00:03:32 There's a way for individuals, families, and businesses to put their hard-earned money to work continuously accruing compounding interest
00:03:40 and then have those resources available as collateral for cash or for financing investments, businesses, college, and other major life expenditures without having to go to the big banks for loans.
00:03:56 Income tax protected, safety from stock market losses, guaranteed rates of compounding interest,
00:04:03 and the ability to store up an inheritance for your children's children and avoid the death tax on your estate.
00:04:10 If this interests you, then email our friends at banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:04:17 Again, that's banking at privatefamilybanking.com.
00:04:21 Or you can give them a call at 830-339-9472.
00:04:29 Again, that's 830-339-9472.
00:04:35 Schedule your appointment today.
00:04:38 Applying God's word to every aspect of life.
00:04:42 This is Theology Applied.
00:04:44 All right, welcome back to another episode of Theology Applied.
00:04:52 I am your host, Pastor Joel Webin with Right Response Ministries.
00:04:55 And in this particular episode, I'm very privileged to have joining us for the first time, Ben Garrett.
00:05:01 Ben, welcome to the show.
00:05:03 Hey, thanks for having me, Joel. Happy to be here.
00:05:05 Take just one second, Ben, and tell our listeners a little bit about you.
00:05:08 Some of them will probably recognize your voice, but not necessarily your face, because you guys in Ogden, Utah, you don't really do video, but you do audio really, really well.
00:05:18 So who are you?
00:05:19 How would our listeners probably know you best?
00:05:22 They'd probably know me best from from Haunted Cosmos, this podcast that my my friend and pastor Brian Sovey do together.
00:05:30 But I'm a deacon at Refuge Church, which is our church in Ogden, Utah.
00:05:34 I'm also on staff, actually, with New Christendom Press, which is our publishing house.
00:05:38 So I kind of split time between those two things and spend a lot of time researching really weird stuff online to talk about with Brian on Haunted Cosmos.
00:05:48 I'm a mechanical engineer by trade.
00:05:51 Felt a call to ministry about three years ago and have since been pursuing that along with this podcast game.
00:05:59 I'm married to a lovely wife.
00:06:00 We have two boys and, Lord willing, many more to come someday.
00:06:05 Great.
00:06:06 Well, thanks for coming on the show.
00:06:07 I'm a big fan of Haunted Cosmos.
00:06:09 I think you guys have done a great job.
00:06:12 I think I've told you this already offline, but I'm not quite as interested in the Mothman
00:06:16 episodes, which I know a lot of people like them.
00:06:19 I mean, I find it intriguing.
00:06:20 I find it intriguing.
00:06:22 And I think it's possible and I'm totally down for, you know, demons shape-shifting
00:06:26 and taking on the forms.
00:06:27 Whatever.
00:06:28 but uh man give me sea serpents or give me death right yeah i mean the great white shark plummeting
00:06:34 2 000 feet underneath the sea you know and the temperature rising from 40 something to 90 something
00:06:38 like that yeah that was so good and then i really loved the episode that you guys did probably at
00:06:45 this point i guess about a month ago because you guys do it once every two weeks yep uh but the
00:06:49 one where you talked about the watchers and the nephilim and i was hoping that you know we could
00:06:53 start there in our conversation today and then there's some other things you've got some theories
00:06:57 I've got some theories, you know, that we can just kind of bounce off of each other and talk
00:07:01 about all sorts of things. But starting with the Nephilim and the Watchers, can you help our
00:07:06 listeners understand a little bit, biblically speaking, who are the Watchers? Who are the
00:07:10 Nephilim? Yeah, no, that's great. This is one of my favorite topics, so I'm happy to start here. 1.00
00:07:16 The Watchers are a category of angelic beings, and we hear about them in the book of Daniel,
00:07:22 specifically Daniel 7. We're told that it's this group of angels that look down on the affairs of
00:07:28 men, and essentially they act as God's deacons on the world, and they ensure that the decree
00:07:35 is carried out. And so one example that we get, and it's not necessarily fact that these are
00:07:42 watchers that are discussed here, but they very well could be. Regardless, their function is
00:07:47 similar. But it says in Daniel, one of the angels comes to visit Daniel and give him prophecy. And
00:07:53 it says that he was resisted by the prince of Persia for 21 days. And then Michael came and
00:07:58 helped him defeat the prince of Persia. And the prince of Persia is an angel. It's a throne or a
00:08:05 power and principality that was resisting this other good angelic force seeking to do God's will.
00:08:12 And so we know that there's spiritual battle going on all the time and, and the watchers play a crucial role in that. And so where they get really popular is in Genesis six, where we have this event, the sons of God go into the daughters of men because they find them very lovely and they produce this offspring.
00:08:31 and it says that the offspring is called the Nephilim. It says the Nephilim were on the
00:08:36 earth in those days and also after. And so if you take the supernatural view, which is actually
00:08:43 the common view held throughout almost all of church history until about the 20th or 19th
00:08:48 century. Right. That's when they started doing the line of Seth. Yeah, exactly. That's when
00:08:52 we're sophisticated now. We don't believe those fairy tales. Although I guess Calvin was a Seth
00:08:59 guy so it was a little bit yeah there were some guys but it really became mainstream it was
00:09:04 something um i forget his name but yeah there were some old guys because i remember teaching
00:09:09 on it a while back and and i took the seth view because i was cool and yeah and now now i'd rather
00:09:14 have fun and yeah we have more fun no i i i do think that it's right though uh also i mean i
00:09:22 love my sethite guys right but uh but i think that they're wrong about this but anyway if you
00:09:26 take the supernatural view of Genesis 6, 1 through 4, then the most likely candidate for the sons of
00:09:34 God who fell are the watchers, this category of angelic beings called the watchers. And we're
00:09:39 informed by the first book of Enoch a little bit there, because that work is cited in Jude and
00:09:45 2 Peter. So that kind of helps us see how they were thinking through this issue. But then the
00:09:50 offspring that they produce with human women are the Nephilim. We believe that they're giants, 1.00
00:09:54 The Septuagint just very casually calls them giants in its rendering of Genesis 6-4.
00:10:01 And so we believe that angels fell.
00:10:05 They lusted after women. 0.60
00:10:06 They had this Nephilim offspring, and they were basically like half-human, supergiant, hyper-people, so to speak.
00:10:14 And so that's part of why the flood occurred is so that the massive corruption that they 1.00
00:10:19 helped induce on the earth would be curbed and retarded a little bit. 1.00
00:10:26 And that's, I think, and that's another reason why I think the, you know, the view of the 0.99
00:10:30 Nephilim actually being a hybrid of, you know, demonic human hybrid is important for theological
00:10:37 reasons.
00:10:38 One, because I think it's a plain reading of the text and we always want to take scripture
00:10:41 seriously.
00:10:42 um but two because it also helps um it helps to make sense of a global flood um because people
00:10:50 are bad today right like you know and yes we have god's promise you know he has set his bow in the
00:10:55 sky and so we have his promise to never flood the earth again um you know so his covenant i mean
00:11:02 that certainly matters the noate covenant um but i mean you look at what's going on in the world
00:11:07 today and you think well i mean all right so god said he wouldn't flood the earth but you know
00:11:11 could he destroy every living person another way you know and technically keep his covenant
00:11:16 because people seem really really bad and so when you look at the world and you look at you know and
00:11:21 you hold to the doctrine of total depravity and look at what's going on today and all these kinds
00:11:24 of things um you think like why isn't god just wiping everybody out now you know or or if you
00:11:31 take the other approach and you're like people aren't really that bad and i can't believe this
00:11:35 was really uh cruel on god's part that he would flood the whole earth you know there were there
00:11:39 were women and there were children and babies. But it really helps to make sense of how much
00:11:47 evil there really was when you think, no, no, no, we're not just talking about totally depraved
00:11:51 people. We're not just talking about bad people. We're not just talking about violent people and
00:11:56 warring people and raping and pillaging people. We're talking about demonic hybrids. We're talking 1.00
00:12:03 about half demon half man who are you know and going around and teaching people uh dark arts and 1.00
00:12:12 sorcery and all these you know and and that's that's part of why god's wiping things out because
00:12:18 people you know will look at genesis what is it 6 14 or 15 what is it uh it's six four okay i'm
00:12:25 thinking of the verse i think it's 15 but the verse that says uh that god looked you know and
00:12:29 all that the every intention of man was only ever evil continually yeah right and and we'll preach
00:12:36 that right a good paul washer sermon you know and i appreciate me some paul i don't know why you're
00:12:40 clapping yeah i'm talking about you exactly and so guys have used that you know and said this is
00:12:46 the picture of uh of not just them but but you and i agree i agree um in terms of the heart um
00:12:54 Now, not you being you and I, not those who are born again in Christ.
00:12:59 We're still sinners, but we're not totally depraved.
00:13:01 We actually have the spirit of God.
00:13:02 We have new hearts. 1.00
00:13:04 And so, but total depravity as it pertains to the unbeliever today in 2023, that is still 1.00
00:13:09 a theologically true statement. 1.00
00:13:10 Genesis 6, 15, every intention, every thought, only evil continually.
00:13:14 The difference though, in Genesis 6 before the flood is it wasn't just at the level of
00:13:19 the heart.
00:13:19 It wasn't just intent.
00:13:21 it was um because of what was going on with the nephro you have a you have a physical superiority
00:13:27 that allows for the intentions of the heart the evil on the inside to have far greater
00:13:33 manifestations outside does that make sense would you agree with that no that i think that makes
00:13:40 total sense the so that's part of what's going on and that's part of the you know the justification
00:13:44 not that god needs any if it was just people god would still be justified in destroying the wicked
00:13:47 because he does that in hell but but it does help you know more to understand like why why
00:13:52 wasn't there an attempt to just reform the world why why destroy the world by water well because
00:13:59 part of what you have running around is not just bad people but but bad half demon half man yeah
00:14:05 people and so that's yeah that's crazy so anyway so watchers nephilim go on you were you were
00:14:11 describing the was there more that you were going to say no i no i mean that's basically it the
00:14:17 The trouble that you run into with taking this view, and it comes from the Sethite view as well, no view is immune to this problem, is that it seems because of clear statements in Scripture, especially in Numbers and Deuteronomy, that there exists in the land of Canaan after the flood, it says descendants of the Nephilim.
00:14:39 Presumably, that's direct descendants of the Nephilim.
00:14:42 So to paint the picture really clearly, you have antediluvian world. Watchers come down because they're lusting after women. They have sex with them. They procreate and the Nephilim appear on the earth. You then have the flood that we would all agree wipes that out. 0.84
00:15:02 So there's total destruction. The Nephilim are done away with. And then after the flood, you somehow, some generations later, have this group of people that the Bible calls descendants of the Nephilim. 1.00
00:15:15 And so that's really where the fun starts. You know, you can talk about how the spirits of the Nephilim, the disembodied spirits of the Nephilim are what the Second Temple Jews would just assume were demons. 0.84
00:15:30 So the people that Christ were, or the things that Christ was casting out of these people in the land of Capernaum and Galilee were disembodied Nephilim spirits, demons. 0.55
00:15:43 But I think that the really interesting question is how did they come back, so to speak, or did they come back?
00:15:50 Is it some kind of like lesser version of the Nephilim, but we can still call them that. 0.96
00:15:55 And so that was one of the things that we were talking about before we started recording is what kind of theories are there that allow for the flood to occur, totally obliterate everything that's not on the ark, which, of course, we would all agree with. 0.98
00:16:09 And yet, somehow we have descendants of the Nephilim in the land that Israel has to go in and drive out after the flood. 0.98
00:16:18 That's where the real fun starts. 0.99
00:16:20 So one of the theories.
00:16:22 Yeah, let's talk about that.
00:16:23 Yeah, you go ahead and give a theory.
00:16:24 I'll give a theory.
00:16:24 Yeah, yeah. Let's ping pong theory. So the one that I currently hold to, but it is one that I hold pretty loosely, is that the syntax of Genesis 6-4 allows for there to be multiple events of this type. Before and after the flood, Genesis 6-4 gives freedom for it to be interpreted as angels falling, creating Nephilim with human women, both before and after the flood, multiple times.
00:16:52 So you could have literally just the same event happening throughout history before and after the flood. And that kind of lessens the punch of the flood in that regard. And it kind of says like, well, why the flood then? Why the flood? If it had anything to do with that, then why then if it was just going to happen again after? But let's hear your theory too.
00:17:17 yeah so and when ben says for the listener when he says multiple events the event you're talking
00:17:22 about is angels falling from heaven yes yes right so he's saying specifically falling from heaven
00:17:27 to interbreed with human women right so you're saying that it's not just that a third of the
00:17:33 angels you know like a third of the stars swept out of heaven in a singular moment that that may
00:17:38 be as well but there were also other angels uh that that angels uh rebelled against god so we're
00:17:45 talking about falling in the sense of of sinning against god rebelling against god but then also
00:17:50 quite literally falling from heaven in the sense of moving physically geographically to earth for
00:17:56 the express purpose of creating a um posterity for yeah and so and you're saying uh that one
00:18:04 theory the syntax in genesis 6 4 allows for that to happen uh that event to happen more than once
00:18:09 that happened pre-flood and then happened again after the flood and the reason why we're insisting
00:18:13 or at least saying that it's plausible um that it would happen again after the flood is because we
00:18:20 have one or two texts in the book of numbers and i think you said there's another text in
00:18:24 deuteronomy that talk about the nephilim after the flood right we have the 10 wicked spies
00:18:29 israelite spies but they're wicked because they're filled with unbelief and not trusting the promises 0.88
00:18:34 of god right and cowards will will be in the lake of fire so wicked is an appropriate term for the 0.98
00:18:39 counter but these 10 wicked wicked spies um you know they go with joshua and caleb 12 and all 0.55
00:18:44 but 10 return and bring a bad report of of the land and say that we were like grasshoppers in
00:18:50 our eyes uh and that the nephilim were there with them and um and so then some guys like the seth
00:18:56 ike guys you know they would um they would say you know well um you know you know we were like
00:19:01 because this doesn't just say nephilim you know men of renown but then also says physically we're
00:19:05 like grasshoppers we were small you know so then that that gets real tough to say that the nephilim
00:19:10 weren't actual giants um but then you know some guys would say well that this just uh this just
00:19:16 is meant to further indict those 10 wicked spies and their unbelief um because they're actually
00:19:21 lying lying saying that there's there's giants because they're so cowardly that they don't want 0.92
00:19:26 to face them or or maybe even psychologically they believed that they were like grasshoppers
00:19:30 and these guys were five times their size uh because they just they couldn't even think straight
00:19:34 because they were so given into fear um or or the alternative is uh that they're actual giants yeah
00:19:41 and you know and that the the nephilim happened again so my point is the reason why ben for the
00:19:46 listener is saying there could have been um multiple events events referring to angels falling
00:19:51 from heaven to earth for the express purpose of creating nephilim half angel half half man
00:19:57 by breeding with the daughters of men is because you know uh the nephilim aren't just uh in existence
00:20:04 before the flood, but we see them again after the flood light numbers. So just real quick,
00:20:11 one important thing that I think will be important in contrasting your theory is that these are
00:20:17 different angels. It's not the same angels doing it over and over again. It's angels do it,
00:20:23 they're judged, more angels do it. And so that's just important. It's different angels each time.
00:20:29 yep that's helpful um so so my theory take a little bit of framework but so adam and eve were
00:20:36 created uh without us in nature they were created in a state of integrity um and so they were able
00:20:41 to fall um but they were not yet fallen um so a state of integrity um but not immutable integrity
00:20:47 able to fall and so you and i i think agree on this in terms of our our you know pre-lapsarian
00:20:53 view of uh you know that that adam so i i like to use the words eternal and forever life and
00:21:00 bifurcating that i'll explain the ways that i'm using the two terms of forever and eternal
00:21:04 but adam had forever life without eating of the tree of of life he did not need to eat of the tree
00:21:10 of life to uh to gain forever life he he actually only needed to not eat of the tree of the knowledge
00:21:15 of good and evil to maintain forever life god said the day that you eat of it the bad tree the
00:21:21 tree of the knowledge of good and evil. The day that you eat of it, you shall surely die. So in
00:21:24 order for Adam to not die, aka live forever, he didn't need to eat from the good tree, tree of
00:21:31 life. He needed to just not eat from the bad tree, the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.
00:21:35 I believe that the purpose of the tree of life was that Adam and Eve were in a probationary period
00:21:41 in a state of integrity in the garden and that there was a definite end to this. We don't know
00:21:47 exactly what that end was, but eventually Adam would have passed the test. If he had guarded
00:21:51 the garden, if he had protected his wife, provided for her, cared for her, obeyed the word of the
00:21:57 Lord, resisted temptation, watched over his wife, killed the serpent or sent it, you know, fought it
00:22:01 and got it out of the garden, the whole nine yards. If he had done that well, then God would
00:22:06 have held out to Adam the fruit of the tree of life. And upon eating of the fruit of the tree
00:22:13 of life adam who already had forever life by just not eating of the tree of the knowledge of good
00:22:18 and evil he then by eating of the tree of of life he would attain not just forever life but eternal
00:22:24 life eternal the way i'm using it is not just now in a state of integrity with death having not
00:22:30 entered the world but now a state of immutable integrity uh where he is not fallen and also now
00:22:37 not able to fall yeah and so that that's what i'm arguing there okay so now apply that to angels and
00:22:43 watches if there are multiple fallings um one of the things that's difficult you know we we watch
00:22:49 previous you know i mean we read history books we read the bible you know the best history book 0.91
00:22:53 there is um and we see prior generations of mankind doing really stupid things i mean just 0.99
00:22:59 just really stupid things the dumbest things and and paying the price i mean a hefty price you know 0.99
00:23:05 and just, and, and yet generation comes and generation goes and, and yet each one, we never 0.99
00:23:13 really learn, you know, that, that, you know, there'll be a fresh batch of people and they'll
00:23:17 think, but has socialism really ever been tried, you know? And, and, and it's like, how, how? Well,
00:23:23 one of the ways that we can explain that is because human beings, each generation, it may be a new
00:23:27 group of people. They may have the history books. They may be able to look and see these lessons
00:23:32 that people learn the hard way by doing terrible things and the consequences that, you know,
00:23:36 came about. And yet this fresh batch of people, this new generation have, they're totally depraved. 0.92
00:23:42 They have a sin nature because Adam and all his posterity are now born under the curse of sin.
00:23:48 And so that explains why, you know, we could look at Adam and Eve's fall and we could look at this
00:23:52 person's fall and that person's fall and that person's fall and still fall ourselves and still
00:23:56 make bad choices. Angels though, however, if it's multiple fallings, multiple events of angels
00:24:02 falling, the difficulty for me is that the angels that did not fall the first time. So if you have
00:24:08 the first batch of watchers pre-flood, antediluvian world, they fall and come into the daughters of 0.99
00:24:15 men, find them lovely and produce offspring. But then this is wiped out in the flood. And now we're
00:24:22 saying another batch of angels well those angels this next batch of angels is not like um like uh
00:24:28 another generation of angels they're they're angels that have watched the whole thing go down
00:24:33 yeah and they don't have a sin nature they don't they're not totally depraved like future generations
00:24:38 of man um they actually they're not just reading about it in a history book they watched these
00:24:43 angels fall they watched god's judgment of them uh they they watched the consequences and and they
00:24:50 watched it from a state of integrity without a sin nature um which to me seems very compelling
00:24:56 that that they would not say okay and but but maybe this time socialism will work you know
00:25:02 yeah yeah you know so that's that would be my position so then how do we have nephilim after
00:25:07 the flood one like i already said well maybe the 10 spies are just being super cowardly and saying
00:25:12 they're giants when really they were like six foot four instead of six foot one you know um that
00:25:18 but i don't think that i think actual nephilim um happened again in numbers these are actual
00:25:24 giants actual hybrid offspring of of fallen angels again another but not another batch i'm
00:25:30 sorry not another batch but the watchers this would be my view and i got this by thinking a
00:25:35 little bit about you and brian and and listening to your very first episode of the sea serpent
00:25:41 and and you guys talked about like how like there'd be more demonic activity for instance
00:25:46 in nations uh that aren't christianized in pagan nations right and then if a nation becomes
00:25:52 christianized like sure there's the c.s lewis aspect of like okay well technology and innovation
00:25:58 and development and so now demons are gonna you know they're gonna play a different strategy
00:26:02 right and that totally makes sense to me and so you know flying under the banner of depression
00:26:06 and some psychological disorder and schizophrenia you know or this or that um instead of just you
00:26:11 know full full-blown you know witch doctor uh demonic kind of stuff because it's a different
00:26:17 people and they're wanting to fly into the radar and and not be found out that makes sense to me
00:26:21 also i think the west has had a little bit just i think they're coming back but a little bit less
00:26:26 demonic activity because the west for the last you know 1500 years if you constantine but certainly
00:26:32 a thousand years with king alfred has been christianized yep and so the demons got their
00:26:36 butts kicked and so they you know they went to some place in africa in south america for a while
00:26:40 and and and so um but my point is with the watchers um the nephilim were wiped out because 0.77
00:26:46 these are the offspring of the fallen angels watchers and daughters of men so they're half
00:26:52 human they have they have lungs they're giants they're superhuman but still they have lungs
00:26:57 they have a beating heart they they need oxygen they're they're they're physical beings and so
00:27:02 the flood was enough and it needed to be catastrophic it needed to be global in order
00:27:05 to not just wipe out human beings wicked people but wicked super people yeah and it did i think 0.56
00:27:10 it was successful in wiping out the nephilim but the watchers themselves that are not half blood
00:27:16 fallen angels but full blood uh fallen angels they're they're you know they're the the real
00:27:22 deal the you know not a hybrid but the full full-blown angelic i'm wondering could they
00:27:28 have survived the flood could they have taken on you know the form of like a sea serpent for
00:27:34 instance and and survive the flood now some of them going to jude and and the book of enoch talks
00:27:41 about that but um we know that some of them were locked away in gloomy dungeons and so i i'm
00:27:46 thinking that god sent you know some some angels the flood to wipe out the nephilim and and man
00:27:51 and then some angels um to to go and bind up and lock away in gloomy dungeons some of these watchers
00:27:59 but maybe some of the watchers were missed by by the angels that they somehow escaped took on the
00:28:05 form of a sea serpent whatever escaped in the flood god of course being sovereign overall allowed
00:28:10 them to escape and then these are the ones who then again after the flood generations later came 0.74
00:28:16 into the daughters of man a second time created a new batch of nephilim blah blah so that's that's
00:28:21 kind of my theory and what i'm thinking there and then you and i think we also both agree that in
00:28:25 terms of these gloomy dungeons uh you and i both have some some theories on what's under the earth
00:28:31 yeah yeah these gloomy dungeons maybe being literal physical places yeah under our feet i do
00:28:37 think they are i'll say one thing too just for the listeners to kind of help them think through the
00:28:42 these two uh views so when we talk about man falling okay and then all of man now is totally
00:28:52 depraved. The reason that that is, is because Adam was our federal covenant head. He represented
00:28:59 man before God. And so if he fell, man falls. But the opposite's also true. If Adam prevails,
00:29:06 we also are born righteous in a state of immutable integrity before God. Immutable,
00:29:12 positive holiness. You'd agree that's just the basic reformed view. It's pointless because it
00:29:17 didn't happen. But if it did happen, that would be the case. The angels aren't like that, though.
00:29:21 The angels don't procreate like human beings in their normal state.
00:29:26 So when we hear in the confession that there are elect and non-elect angels, that election is not.
00:29:34 Well, I shouldn't put it that way.
00:29:37 God's God decrees that election and he brings it about as he providentially determines.
00:29:41 But what we can say is that the fall of one angelic group doesn't determine the fall of another angelic group.
00:29:49 Right. The same is also true. 0.96
00:29:51 the positive obedience of one angelic group doesn't determine the positive obedience of
00:29:56 another because they're different. So I could see the argument and I would probably make this
00:30:00 argument if I was really trying to like debate it, but I could see the argument that because
00:30:05 of how different humans are from the angelic category, you could, you could conceivably have
00:30:12 a group of angels that watch this event happen. And as they watch it, they are still in that
00:30:19 state of integrity. But since there's no federal headship in the angelic world, they're still able
00:30:26 to fall. So, you know, there's no, as far as we know, there's no singular moment where angels
00:30:32 suddenly just in mass stop becoming able to sin before the final day of judgment.
00:30:39 And I think that, I think that Berkhoff's view is pretty compelling that each angel eventually
00:30:44 reaches a stage where they're no longer able to disobey, but we have no way of speculating as to
00:30:49 win that whereas adam would have done it for all of us exactly because he's a federal head of all
00:30:53 his posterity yes because of reproduction because of fatherhood that because he's a patriarch father
00:30:59 rule but angels don't have they don't have fathers right they have they've gone the father yeah but
00:31:05 but but they don't have yeah exactly so it's it's one batch of angels um it's not one man and then
00:31:12 from him he begot so-and-so who begot so-and-so who begot so-and-so um that so you're totally
00:31:19 right so that's and so i like i like that the idea of burkhoff's view that each angel individually
00:31:25 um without federal federalism each angel individually having just like adam would
00:31:31 have had like some kind of probationary period whatever that looked like and probably you know
00:31:35 always attached to my my guess would be a task an assignment yeah so almost like it's kind of funny
00:31:40 but a wonderful life you know when an angel gets its wings you know when an angel goes in and so
00:31:45 probably for the watchers and i like you know all the way back to the beginning of our conversation
00:31:48 but like you know some the seraphim you you were mentioning that to me offline and that was really
00:31:53 helpful for me i actually hadn't thought about that but you said like that they're you know
00:31:57 they're standing before the presence of god they're facing god yeah right so there are some
00:32:01 angels that in quite literally in a literal sense are like they have a a god-facing ministry
00:32:07 assignment but there are other angels that are very interested in the affairs of men and not
00:32:12 in a sense that like they find men more interesting than god but but by design by god's order his
00:32:18 decree. He is like Hebrews. It says, are angels not ministering spirits that are called, I forget 0.99
00:32:25 the exact verbiage, but called to help the sons of men who are to inherit salvation, the elect
00:32:31 people. So there is a category of angels per Hebrews that exists, was created by God to give
00:32:40 him praise and worship, but to also honor him by fulfilling man-facing assignments, man-oriented
00:32:47 assignments particularly men who are elect called to salvation and so perhaps these angels for the
00:32:53 watchers for the seraphim god-facing angels perhaps it's it's different you know but for
00:32:59 the watchers it could totally make sense that each one individually apart from federal headship
00:33:03 each one individually task-based assignment-based as they go and help that that elect person called
00:33:11 to salvation like hebrews talks about and and succeed uh that they the angel gets its wings so
00:33:16 wings being the angel already in a state of integrity no no sin having never sinned but now
00:33:22 moving from a state of forever you know to eternal from a state of integrity to a state of immutable
00:33:28 integrity now not fallen but also not fallen and unable to ever fall um totally yeah i mean
00:33:36 if you think about the the typology of church officers uh you know you have the bishop elder
00:33:43 pastor, if you take two, three office view, whatever, you have this guy or a group of guys
00:33:49 who represent to the church Christ. They are the ones that God said, you are the shepherds of my
00:33:57 flock. You have the keys of the kingdom and you will represent me directly to the people. Well,
00:34:04 then you also have this office of deacon that is the minister, the assistant to the elders,
00:34:09 much like how we would think of just in really basic terms, the angels are the assistance of
00:34:14 God. They're carrying out God's providential decree on the earth. And he, because he just
00:34:19 seems to want it to be done that way. And so if you think about that, well, then you look at the
00:34:25 qualification for a deacon and you're like, oh, well, that's kind of a cool connection that he's
00:34:30 supposed to hold the mystery of the faith with a clear conscience. And he's supposed to be tested
00:34:34 first and proved right. And then he can take the office. And so if you think about how,
00:34:40 you know, Berkhoff's view of the angels is that each one would have this probationary period.
00:34:45 And I really like your idea that it's oriented towards a specific task. Well, that is like the
00:34:51 heavenly or the unseen diaconate in the world where each one is given this task and he's tested
00:34:58 or she, whatever you call an angel, pronouns, they, them, but each one is tested. And then
00:35:05 upon successful completion of the test, they would be out of their probationary period and in this
00:35:15 immutable state of integrity. That's a really interesting idea. Yeah. I think that totally
00:35:19 makes sense. With my theory, you're absolutely right. So no federal headship, not necessarily
00:35:26 an immutable state of integrity but what i'm arguing is that even apart from an immutable
00:35:32 state of integrity just by a state of integrity alone angels one group of angels watching another 0.97
00:35:38 group of angels rebel against god and then and then get their butts kicks kicked by god and
00:35:45 locked away in gloomy dungeons um you know that these guys over here even though they're still
00:35:52 able to fall that they would still look at that from from without a sin nature from a state of
00:35:56 integrity and say no no you know whereas whereas us as human beings we look at past other generations
00:36:06 of human beings who have done terrible things and and the reason why it's different than angels is
00:36:14 because we have a sin nature so we can say that was a really bad idea i don't know why he did that
00:36:19 and then yet we still make mistakes ourselves sometimes the very same mistakes um but it makes
00:36:25 more sense from a human standpoint because um because of the sin nature even for the christian
00:36:32 who who is now redeemed and has a new heart and has the spirit of god dwelling within them
00:36:37 even for the christian there's something to be said uh you know with roman 7 what i want to do
00:36:42 this i cannot do but the evil that i do not want to do this i keep on doing oh what a wretched man
00:36:46 i am who can save me from this body of death right that the soul has been saved but there's still
00:36:51 this sense of the body and glorification that's um that that is being awaited and that of course
00:36:57 that you know i just showed my hand i i think that paul that's a post-conversion i think paul's
00:37:01 writing as a christian romans 7 some would disagree with that position i understand but
00:37:05 anyways all that being said even for if if i'm right about that that this is paul romans 7
00:37:10 talking about how he keeps doing the the evil the sin that he doesn't want to do and it's the
00:37:15 apostle paul as a christian saying that then certainly um a non-christian person is going to
00:37:22 give in but the angel would be different to me because even though he's not immutable he's never
00:37:29 sinned before and so even if there's a curiosity it's like all right i'm watching how'd it go for
00:37:35 you not well okay let's uh take note of that but i don't i don't know so anyway so it could be
00:37:42 multiple fallings or it could be the the nephilim themselves the hybrid offspring of these watchers
00:37:49 fallen angels are wiped out in the flood but some of the watchers themselves locked in gloomy dungeons
00:37:55 under the earth in caverns that are there right now today yes that are literally caverns yep or
00:38:02 and i should say not or and some of them locked away but some of them taking on morphing into
00:38:09 sea serpents surviving the the torrents of water in the flood and then and then the same so the
00:38:15 same group a lesser number of them this time but the same group doing it again um and that's the
00:38:21 nephilim that we find in the book of numbers so that's so it's either as a second a different
00:38:26 batch of watchers angels falling in a second event a second falling after the flood or it's
00:38:33 some of the the nephilim are wiped out but some of those watchers some of that first batch survive
00:38:38 the flood aren't locked up in gloomy dungeons and they do it again one of those things and that's
00:38:42 how we get nephilim i wasn't going to say this because it spoils a little bit of a future episode
00:38:49 of haunted cosmos but say yeah i have to say it because i'm really liking what you're saying
00:38:56 that some of the watchers are still around still active um it's easy if you take my stance to get
00:39:05 into this position where there is no watcher activity whatsoever. It's just disembodied
00:39:10 Nephilim spirit activity. The reason that I don't like that is because if you look at the message
00:39:15 that alien abductees are receiving from these aliens, if you believe their stories at all,
00:39:21 if you just suspend disbelief and listen to what they say, what they'll tell you oftentimes is that
00:39:29 the aliens are abducting them. And part of the fundamental reason why is because they they're
00:39:35 trying to create a hybrid race of them and human beings. And so you can say, well, all the Nephilim 0.91
00:39:43 spirits, you know, they learned this from their dads and they're still trying to just do it. And 0.84
00:39:47 so they they fly around and flying saucers trying to deceive man or or if you're right, you can just
00:39:55 say like no it's just literally the same play by the same people it's not even it's not chips off
00:40:00 the old block it's the old block it's the old block it's it's the it's the simplest thing in
00:40:06 the world like literally are we just dumb they're doing the exact same thing so i do like that we
00:40:11 get into that in episode 10 of season one so so stay tuned for that but it's a good little easter
00:40:15 egg yeah that's a great one so yeah so i think i think that's totally possible so now let's talk
00:40:20 a little bit about um caverns under the earth yes uh angels fallen angels watchers being locked
00:40:29 away in in actual literal physical uh gloomy dungeons on this planet under under this ground
00:40:36 and i'd like to as we explore that as we explore these caverns i'd like to also uh explore the
00:40:43 idea of not just uh angels being locked away but uh what else might be down there yes under the
00:40:49 ground. Yes. So why don't you start? What do you think? Sure. Other, other things besides Bigfoot
00:40:54 that are clear. If you got something on Bigfoot, feel free. Yeah, I do. I do genuinely think that's
00:41:02 true, but I don't have, I don't have a defense for it. It just smells good. Yeah. So we're told
00:41:08 that the angels are locked in chains under the earth. And I think that that's literal. And the
00:41:12 reason that i think that is because you have the story in in it's in luke uh and christ is telling
00:41:19 a parable about the the rich man and lazarus right and lazarus dies he's taken to abraham's bosom
00:41:26 and from abraham's bosom he can see this rich man that used to oppress him in life and the rich man
00:41:33 can see lazarus and they're and they're not physical anymore they're in a spiritual state
00:41:39 and yet they're able to see one another. They're localized spirits and they're able to shout at
00:41:45 one another. And Abraham is able to shout back at this rich man as well. And even in a spiritual
00:41:49 state also recognize one. Yeah. Yeah. Also recognize one another. And so, yeah, exactly.
00:41:55 So now we have a category that's really, really weird of spiritual people, people that are
00:42:02 disembodied souls at this point, living in the earth, presumably because Sheol has spoken about
00:42:09 only in terms of it being in the belly of the earth, literally. Right. And yet there's an open 0.78
00:42:14 space. They can see one another, talk to one another and recognize one another. So I think
00:42:19 that within this, this massive category of Sheol, you have a bunch of different neighborhoods. 0.97
00:42:25 So you have the Sheol of the damned, which is where the normal human guy who dies a reprobate 0.87
00:42:31 will go to await final judgment and it's torment there. It's not good. It's not a place you want
00:42:37 to be. You also have Tartarus, which is this separate kind of neighborhood that I believe
00:42:42 that's where the fallen angels are bound. You know, whichever ones are bound, whether it's all
00:42:47 of them or some, that's where they are. And then you have this really paradisical neighborhood,
00:42:51 which is Abraham's bosom, but it's no longer there because now Abraham's bosom was carried
00:42:56 up into the presence of the Lord by Christ upon his ascension and resurrection and ascension. 0.67
00:43:01 And so, you know, you could say that Sheol got a little bit bigger for the reprobates, but I think that those are literal places. I think that there is a massive space in the earth or multiple spaces in the earth where disembodied souls go.
00:43:18 um i that's a very medieval idea but it also seems to be the plain reading of the text that
00:43:24 i don't think we're i don't think god is tricking us here and i also don't think he's just dumbing
00:43:29 things down to some sort of uh metaphor that we can understand i think that he's actually just
00:43:35 telling us this the actual state of things so i think that there's not only fallen angels chained
00:43:41 in the earth i think that there's also reprobate souls who are damned in the earth awaiting final
00:43:46 judgment. And I think that the souls of the saints also used to be living in the earth and bound to
00:43:52 the earth. And you can look at, you know, in a good paradise place, but yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Really
00:43:56 good place. Abraham's bosom. Yeah. Yeah. But first Samuel 28, you have the witch of Endor scene.
00:44:01 And I believe it's first Samuel 28. Called up. But yeah, you have Samuel called up. You know,
00:44:07 you'd think that a saint would come down. And some commentators will try to say, well, clearly that
00:44:12 means that this is a demon who's trying to deceive Saul but that's just not what the bible says it
00:44:17 says that it's Samuel multiple times it refers to him as Samuel both in the proper noun sense and
00:44:23 then in the pronoun sense as well and so you have to why would a demon rebuke Saul like a demon
00:44:27 encourage Saul for that action like hey you're doing this thing that God hates and I really
00:44:32 like it keep doing more of it you know but like but it sounds like Samuel um yeah material Saul
00:44:38 recognizes, yep, that's Samuel. What does he look like? So there's still like a physical,
00:44:42 I mean, it is spiritual, but with an appearance that can be recognized, manifesting some kind
00:44:48 of appearance that can be seen and recognized. But then it's not just the way that the spirit
00:44:53 looks, but when the spirit speaks, there's a rebuke of Saul. That is something that a righteous
00:45:01 Samuel would have said. Yeah, exactly. So I think that at the very minimum, before Christ came and
00:45:09 did his mediating work in time, you had three groups of beings in the earth, the reprobate,
00:45:16 the saint, and also the fallen angel. But however, I do genuinely think that Bigfoot is a disembodied
00:45:25 Nephilim spirit, and I think that those can certainly be in Sheol as well. 0.75
00:45:29 So I'm with you on all of it, except for Bigfoot. But the good news is that I could probably be one over. So you guys wait for a Bigfoot episode. Yeah, get to that episode. And, and, you know, I'll, I'll give it a hearing. I'm not one over by Mothman. But I don't know, Bigfoot, just give it time. You got to let it simmer in your mind.
00:45:49 okay um so all right so here's here's some of my theories of under the earth uh so everything you
00:45:56 said 100 um except for the bigfoot part well you and me both i mean i don't yeah who knows but we're
00:46:03 not sure but the other ones i i agree with you 100 i i feel fairly confident that that's that
00:46:09 that's the case a little bit of background theology for the listener um with uh with um
00:46:17 And Jesus, you know, so basically what I'm trying to get at is a descent to hell.
00:46:23 So we, you know, we do the Apostles' Creed and we say descent to Hades.
00:46:28 You know, he descended to Hades on the third day he rose again.
00:46:31 And so what we're trying to say is that he descended to the realm of the dead.
00:46:35 Jesus didn't go to hell.
00:46:37 So Jesus did not.
00:46:39 The wrath of God was poured out on Christ on the cross.
00:46:42 so so jesus suffered the shame um the humiliation the physical torture uh physical death but he
00:46:51 also on the cross was underneath the white hot wrath of god for sin and i think the wrath of god
00:46:57 was beginning to be poured out on on christ even in the garden of gethsemane as he's getting closer
00:47:04 to uh the crucifixion that he's sweating drops of blood and so um so my view and i think it's the
00:47:11 the historic Reformed view is that Jesus did not need, in order to atone for our sin,
00:47:17 the wages of sin is death, and particularly death under God's just judgment, not just physical
00:47:25 death, but a spiritual death. In order for Jesus to take our penalty, Jesus didn't have to go to
00:47:31 hell. So that sounds good. It sounds like that'll preach. Jesus went to hell, so you don't have to.
00:47:35 um no jesus uh drank the full cup of god's wrath towards sin so that you don't have to and i think
00:47:42 he did that on the cross so so when he died and gave up his spirit uh he did not go to hell um
00:47:50 the the bad of these three chambers the bad place in sheil uh the belly of the earth the realm of
00:47:56 the dead um but he actually went to the good place in sheil and proclaimed across that chasm so he's
00:48:03 over there with abraham and with lazarus says what's up guys i'm here and they're like no way
00:48:08 it's just you know and then and then he proclaims and preaches a sermon um in first peter chapter
00:48:14 three talks about this yep uh nope is it chapter three chapter four i think is it chapter three
00:48:21 the angels long to look into yes exactly and the one on baptism it's on about yeah four i always i
00:48:27 always say first Peter, uh, chapter three, because I'm usually, uh, going to say something about,
00:48:33 um, women having a gentle and quiet spirit. That's it. That's a, that's a, always a fan
00:48:40 favorite. Um, so, uh, but anyways, uh, so all that being said, so Jesus, he he's, you know,
00:48:45 in the belly of the earth, he's with Abraham. He's on the good side, Abraham's bosom. He's
00:48:50 shouting across this chasm, preaching, um, a sermon to the, you know, like the, the rich man,
00:48:56 you know who tormented lazarus during his lifetime and all everybody else all the reprobates all
00:49:01 all those and um and he's not giving them a second opportunity at salvation um he's he is
00:49:09 proclaiming his triumph over them and he's also preaching who else can hear this sermon
00:49:14 would be that that third room down there of those those watchers fallen angels locked in gloomy
00:49:20 dungeons, and he's mocking them, and he is proclaiming his triumph, his victory over sin,
00:49:29 over Satan, over death, and then he leads a host, everyone in Abraham's bosom, out and up now into
00:49:38 the presence of God, because he has now made a way, and so, yeah, and so, but everyone else is
00:49:45 now staying there, and they're going to stay there until the final day where they're cast into the
00:49:49 lake of fire yep she was cast into the into the lake of fire yeah right so we would say right now
00:49:54 those who have um who are saints old testament saints new testament saints anyone who dies in
00:49:59 the lord or has died in the lord um is in the presence of the lord um now in heaven um and
00:50:06 abraham's bosom is no more um but there are still um under the earth fallen angels and fallen men
00:50:15 who died apart from saving grace in Christ. And so that being said, one other thing I think might
00:50:22 be under there is, I think we should talk just a little bit. You said you have some, you know,
00:50:27 a little bit of thoughts on this. I've got some thoughts, but primary water.
00:50:31 Oh, yes.
00:50:32 What do you know about primary water?
00:50:33 Okay, so here's all I know. I know that it's something that I'm tempted to just say like,
00:50:40 yeah i'm i'm i'm in it it smells good i'm bought in but my understanding of it is that the of
00:50:49 course the elites are lying to us that water is not some finite resource on the earth but rather
00:50:56 water is all the time being created by the pressures and and all the different elements
00:51:02 in the earth and of course by god's sovereign hand over all those things and so we get new
00:51:07 springs popping up all the time, which is true. That's just true. The difference is that the
00:51:14 primary water people, and correct me if I'm wrong, are saying that that's actually new water that's
00:51:19 being made. It's not just the same water that's being recycled and put up in a new location
00:51:23 because of ventilation shafts from the center of the earth or something. And so what you have is
00:51:29 a government psyop that's trying to tell you everyone needs to be afraid all the time.
00:51:33 Well, this is like precious resource in the world. Yeah. And it's running out water. And yeah. Yeah. And so you have like a Mad Max situation where everyone's just killing each other over water when the reality is, no, that's not a fear that that we should have. That's not a that's not a feature of the curse. And instead, we actually have plenty of water. We just have lost the wherewithal of our surroundings to know where it is and how to find it. So is that is that kind of?
00:52:00 absolutely you nailed it and you're gonna love this because i'm gonna get to atlantis but uh
00:52:05 so with but so with that 100 agree um in terms of just the character and nature of god here's
00:52:13 what christians have to believe this is why some of these things they they met all these things
00:52:16 matter um but this is just one you know theology applied all right so let me apply it to the
00:52:21 character and nature of god god is not capricious god is not cruel um god did not command us in our
00:52:28 very origin as mankind to do the very thing that he knew secretly would bring about our own demise
00:52:34 right god doesn't say be fruitful multiply and then behind closed doors he's
00:52:39 just this is how the the whole you know human race will end by obeying my command because i'm
00:52:47 god and i give really bad commands that hurt people like i mean think about that first if
00:52:52 you're a christian you you have got you have got to completely mortify the overpopulation myth
00:53:00 yeah you like you are not allowed to be a christian and believe um in the goodness of god his
00:53:06 character and his law word that that what god commands is not only that which is morally right
00:53:12 but that also which is good um you you cannot be a christian and and have a biblical view of the
00:53:19 character of god and think that um that we shouldn't have a bunch of kids 100 agree so so
00:53:24 we'll start with that so that's step one um so now thinking of that um we cannot believe that
00:53:32 the context the habitat environment that god created for us to multiply in um that it would be
00:53:39 that it would be a zero-sum game that it would be uh something that yeah well you sure you can
00:53:45 multiply but you know if if you're the more obedient to god you are aka the more children
00:53:51 you have the more multiply the more obedient uh to god you have the less you'll actually be
00:53:56 rewarded you'll have to you'll have to split that pie more ways and each person gets a smaller slice
00:54:03 um that's just simply not the that's not the character of god so i believe that that resources
00:54:09 are finite um but but that they're not um that they're not they're finite but they're plentiful
00:54:16 yes um and and and there's far more than we've yet to discover so when you think of you know
00:54:23 60 million babies over the last 49 years you know um murdered in their mother's wombs and you think
00:54:30 well 60 million uh less males defeat well we've already talked about theology our view of god
00:54:35 that he's not capricious, he's not cruel. But working down from that and what the Bible says
00:54:40 about anthropology, our view of man, do you see man as a leech, as a parasite? Or do we see man
00:54:47 as a lowercase c creator, not able to create ex nihilo like God out of nothing, but a creator
00:54:54 nonetheless in the image of God, needing resources and materials to create with, but able to reproduce
00:55:01 and create and multiply the resources that god has given us in extraordinary ways so disney if
00:55:07 you think of what's the pagans anthropology it's exactly the opposite of the christians
00:55:12 the pagan is going to say that on the inside follow your heart because on the inside your
00:55:17 intentions your inward intent and motives and true person deep down is really really good 0.98
00:55:24 but on the outside people are like parasites every person that's born is just another mouth
00:55:30 to feed and so it'd be better to have less of them that is the liberals the progressives view of man 0.84
00:55:35 on the outside bat he's a liability on the inside good um a sweet little heart the christian's view
00:55:43 is exactly the opposite that apart from from saving grace in christ jesus upon initial physical
00:55:50 birth every human being that enters the world on the inside totally depraved on the outside
00:55:56 bearing the image of god and able to create suspension bridges eventually cure cancer and
00:56:01 you know the whole nine so we believe exactly the opposite we believe on the inside probably
00:56:05 shouldn't follow your heart you're not that sweet you're not that cute on the outside
00:56:09 good golly um that like the sky is the limit you know atomic bombs are are in the cards and and so
00:56:17 is you know the cure for all kinds of diseases and so so we literally believe the exact same 0.50
00:56:21 exact opposite thing that the pagan believes about mankind now all that being said i believe
00:56:27 that there's so many things that we've yet to discover and one of those i think is a plethora
00:56:33 of of water under the earth um new water that's being created but then also water that's already
00:56:39 there and i think part of this explains so not only the flood with a flood you have the canopy
00:56:45 of water being being broken and pouring out on the world um but you also have the the great springs
00:56:51 of the deep opening up. And I think in their opening up, as the world was beginning to flood,
00:56:56 I think that that's part of where the good angels, God commissioned them to come and take the
00:56:59 watchers, the fallen angels, and take them as these great springs and caverns are being opened
00:57:04 in the world. And as the flood is starting to commence, the good angels are going down
00:57:10 into those springs and locking up those watchers, those fallen angels under the earth, like what
00:57:17 we talked about earlier. But so we know water under the earth is springing forth during the
00:57:21 flood but then i'm also thinking of peter uh that says that uh that the earth was formed um from
00:57:27 water uh that you know that the spirit hovered you know and then genesis the spirit was hovering
00:57:31 above the water it was without uh void and without form um but but the water was uh the earth was
00:57:38 formed out of water and so my my thought is one i think there's plenty of resources we're going to
00:57:43 discover more and more things and i i think that the world could host a trillion people i think
00:57:48 We'd have a trillion people as a population and be just fine because we're going to discover more and more and more things and we're going to have more and more resources and all that.
00:57:59 But all that being said, in terms of my view of the final return of Christ, I was thinking, okay, so on one hand, Peter says that the earth is destroyed by water, but then it'll be destroyed by fire.
00:58:11 And that's where a lot of, you and I have been, you know, the Georgetown, Texas group and the Moscow group and the Ogden group, you know, we would differ from a lot of our reformed brothers in the sense that we don't believe that the world is going to be destroyed in the sense of being annihilated.
00:58:31 Yeah, no annihilation.
00:58:33 Disintegrated, exactly.
00:58:34 So, like, I was in San Diego for a while, so we were, you know, just south of Westminster, Escondido, right?
00:58:40 so you got van druden you've got michael horton you've got the whole radical two kingdom uh stuff
00:58:45 and and van druden i mean he you know they they believe like the world is going to disintegrate
00:58:50 it's going to be annihilated it's going to you know they they believe the only thing literal
00:58:55 physical thing that uh that will transcend from this world from this life this age to uh the
00:59:02 heavenly jerusalem is the physical body and van druden you know you can tell he he almost is
00:59:07 begrudgingly allowing for that but he knows that if he doesn't hold to a bodily resurrection he's
00:59:11 a heretic so i can find the physical body that can continue but everything else is disintegrated
00:59:18 and if i could find a way to say biblically that your body would never come back i would
00:59:22 and so that's kind of you know that's that's the view um whereas i would say okay well god
00:59:26 destroyed the world once already yeah but we're not on a different rock exactly it's the same rock
00:59:32 And so the Bible is perfectly truthful when it says God destroyed the world with water.
00:59:40 It was a decreation and recreation event.
00:59:43 Exactly.
00:59:44 So fire.
00:59:46 So my thought is under the earth, you have caverns.
00:59:51 You've got the whole thing that we've already discussed of people who are damned, demons that are locked up in gloomy dungeons.
01:00:00 Abraham's bosom now empty now with heaven because of Christ and his finished work
01:00:04 then primary water being one layer under that I'm thinking molten lava core fire and and so my
01:00:14 thought is like that God opens this first layer of water with the first flood that destroys and
01:00:21 recreates the earth destroys in a real sense life is is wiped out but but but also recreates
01:00:28 it doesn't annihilate or disintegrate. It's the same planet, the same rock. At the end,
01:00:33 he's going to do it with fire. And so now I'm going to cross-reference here with Thessalonians. 0.88
01:00:36 I'm almost done and I'll turn to you. But Thessalonians says that when he returns,
01:00:40 we'll be caught up in the air. Now, if you pair that with like the parable of the 10 virgins,
01:00:47 that five are wise and five are foolish, the five that are wise, they have enough oil in
01:00:51 their lamps to keep them lit so that when the bridegroom finally does come in the middle of 0.85
01:00:55 the night they can see him and they go out to meet him so that he can take them somewhere else
01:00:59 no they they've been waiting for him to come to that town the one that they're already in
01:01:04 not not they're not waiting for him to come to take them to another town they're waiting to
01:01:09 greet him but but it's like well then why are they going out to meet him well they're going
01:01:13 out to meet him as an act of honor not because they're going out to meet him so he can take them
01:01:18 somewhere else they're going to meet him and then now be turn around and be his accompanying party
01:01:23 to to usher him into the town where they already were and so i believe that you know that at the
01:01:29 end there's not a secret rapture i'm not a dispensation let's praise god but at the end
01:01:33 you know that we will be caught first those who are dead in christ then those of us who are alive
01:01:37 caught up into the air um and and not for for christ to take us somewhere else but for us to
01:01:45 go and meet him and each other in the air and then be his welcoming committee to usher
01:01:53 him back down to this earth.
01:01:55 Now, during that time that we're in the air, I think that one thing that will occur is
01:02:00 just like the flood, they were spared on the ark, that we would actually be up in the air
01:02:05 with Christ and with one another watching now, not the layer of water under the core
01:02:10 open but the deeper layer of of fire open and consume christ enemies and then being swallowed
01:02:17 up in the earth like we see uh in the days of moses in the wilderness um and and being swallowed
01:02:23 up in the earth and that we're up here and that the fire now is is also reforming so you you think
01:02:29 of like and all this in a time lapse perhaps you know like sped up but like there water brings life
01:02:35 But there are tropical islands that only exist because of volcanic activity, that fire actually reshapes.
01:02:43 It does, it destroys initially, but it could actually give birth to greater vegetation, greater life, greater, you know, all these things.
01:02:53 And so, I'm wondering if, what if we're in the air and now, instead of like in the days of Noah, opening up the first layer, the great springs of the deep, the water under the earth, now it's even deeper than the water.
01:03:03 We've already tapped into that in our post-millennial discovery of the world and sustaining our
01:03:08 population of a trillion people strong, you know, and, and now it's the deeper layer of,
01:03:12 of fire and that's opening up and consuming the adversaries of God, the earth, swallowing
01:03:17 them up, remaking the earth.
01:03:18 And now we're bringing, we're welcoming Jesus, not to go to the 17th dimension, uh, with
01:03:23 him, but to usher him down to the kingdom that's being delivered to him.
01:03:27 This planet remade that, I don't know.
01:03:29 That's my theory.
01:03:30 What do you think?
01:03:30 No, so here, so my, the first thing that I thought of was loyal to the foil.
01:03:39 The first thing that I thought of when you were saying that was Sodom and Gomorrah,
01:03:42 because Sodom and Gomorrah is sort of like a, in my mind, a typological precursor to the judgment
01:03:48 of fire that is to come. And you have a really clear typological parallels between the story
01:03:56 of Lot and Sodom and Gomorrah and the story of Noah and the flood. You have this one guy who's
01:03:59 chosen. He's saved via something else. He's not saved of himself. Just like Noah was saved by the
01:04:07 ark, Lot is saved because of the righteousness of Abraham that God remembered. That's Genesis 19.
01:04:14 And so you're kind of seeing on a small scale what God's plan is for everything else. And that is to
01:04:21 judge the clear and obvious wickedness and rejection of him that's happened in the land.
01:04:26 But what does the destruction of the Jordan Valley in that narrative bring about? Well,
01:04:33 eventually it brings about the people of God coming into that land and taking it over for 0.98
01:04:37 the good that it is. And so it actually does bring some degree of new and better life.
01:04:43 So I don't hate that. And then you also have Lot, and he did this imperfectly, of course,
01:04:49 but Lot being called out. But he's being called out to be with Abraham, the righteous covenant
01:04:57 person that he was saved because God remembered. He was called up into the mountains. That's where
01:05:03 Abraham was. He was supposed to go up to Abraham. He rejected that. He went over into the caves and
01:05:08 then very bad stuff happened. So I don't, I mean, I don't know. I don't know. But that's the first
01:05:17 connection that jumped out at me and i think that there's legs to it but there's i think that
01:05:22 there's a clear theme in scripture of a judgment of water and then a judgment of fire and you have
01:05:28 both um and so it wouldn't surprise me to find that rhyme scheme played out on the scale of the
01:05:38 entire world and its final reformation and recreation uh on the last day i mean that's
01:05:43 what happened in ab 70 on a on a on a uh on a city-wide scale in jerusalem right you had a
01:05:48 fire you agree with me though in terms of fire um that it's it's going whatever that destruction is
01:05:55 going to be that it's not just the the whole world disintegrating destroyed in that sense
01:06:01 no no i i don't think the world is annihilated i think that this is the i think that this is the
01:06:05 one we got yep um and i new heavens on this earth made new not another earth new earth but
01:06:12 uh this earth made new new earth much like how the new covenant is substantially the same as
01:06:18 the old covenant it's just renovated yeah well okay all right um we'll save that for another
01:06:25 time but but van druden one more thing with with the westminster escondido guys is they would say
01:06:30 in this vein of what we're talking about right now they would say you know that um you know the
01:06:36 scripture that says that all creation is groaning with eager um expectation for the sons of god to
01:06:42 be revealed uh van druden says that um that what creation because because we would read that and
01:06:48 say creation why does why is creation eager it's first why is it groaning because um because adam
01:06:54 was federal head over all his posterity his wife and all uh future generations of humankind but
01:07:00 but god doesn't uh just curse um man he he cursed you know or the woman he cursed the the ground
01:07:07 yes the ground is cursed because of you so adam was actually federal head of all earthly
01:07:12 creation um that animals are groaning because of adam and trees are groaning because of adam
01:07:17 mountains are groaning because of adam um and so so creation is groaning for the new sons of god
01:07:24 um to be revealed uh so that so the first son of god as as genesis i think it's chapter five when
01:07:31 it gives the the um the the lineage the um yep um what is the word that i'm looking for the
01:07:37 genealogy the genealogy it says you know so and so the son of so and so the son of so and then
01:07:41 goes all the way to adam it's either genesis it might be 11 or it might be uh five but uh it's
01:07:47 genesis five yeah and then it says adam the son of god you know and and so the first son of god
01:07:53 in a sense not not the true son of god jesus but adam put creation under a curse uh jesus
01:08:02 said it right and all of it you know he comes to make his blessings flow as far as the curse
01:08:07 you know is is found and so um the the curse is being reversed now um yes the deeper magic right
01:08:14 is uh turning back the clock you know the blessing is not an annihilator the blessing
01:08:20 is a revitalizer right exactly and so and so now the the curse is being reversed progressively
01:08:27 throughout uh real human history and time things are getting better um that we actually even in
01:08:34 america we actually uh we literally have more force today then but you know so everyone's like
01:08:39 oh you know stop chopping down trees we have more force today than when um when america was first
01:08:45 found it there are more trees that with more people it's it's better for creation because
01:08:50 we're gardeners that's what god has has made us to be sure you can be corrupt and some people do
01:08:54 bad things but in general it's a positive force and so all these things being made new but my
01:09:00 point is that van druden those guys would say that creation is groaning so under the curse of adam
01:09:06 with eager expectations for the sons of god to be revealed because at that time the earth will
01:09:12 be destroyed in the sense of disintegration annihilation and uh what creation is groaning
01:09:17 for is a mercy killing it's groaning for god to mercifully take it out behind the old woodshed
01:09:24 and put her down um and i just i just i think that's a horrendous reading yeah of i think that
01:09:31 has to be so eisegeted to assume that uh it's eager creation has eager expectations for the
01:09:38 sons of God to be revealed. And it's, it's really happy and excited that this is going to happen
01:09:42 because then it will get shot by God in the face and die. I just, you have to force that onto the 0.99
01:09:49 scripture. That's just stupid. That's unintelligent is what that is. So creation wants the sons of 1.00
01:09:54 God to be revealed and renewed because in our salvation is creation salvation as well. That
01:10:02 we're tethered together, that as we're redeemed, creation is being redeemed as well. This creation,
01:10:07 Not that it's going to be put down and replaced.
01:10:11 Not that, you know, this dog's old, so we're going to take it out back, you know, and we'll get you a new puppy.
01:10:15 No, we're going to make this dog new.
01:10:17 Same dog, but brought back to health.
01:10:21 Because we're part of creation.
01:10:23 We are part of it.
01:10:24 We were made during the days of creation.
01:10:27 We're the crowning achievement of creation, so to speak.
01:10:30 And so 1 Corinthians 15, when a person dies, they're buried in shame, but they're risen in glory.
01:10:35 The same is true of the rest of creation.
01:10:37 We don't look for an annihilated and completely brand spanking new ex nihilo earth because we don't look for a completely brand spanking new ex nihilo man. 0.56
01:10:49 We look for a glorified man and we're looking for a glorified creation too. 0.85
01:10:53 That's just basic reading of what the word says.
01:10:58 To think otherwise, you get into all these crazy problems and frankly, it gets really close to Gnosticism too.
01:11:04 It does.
01:11:05 far too close for my comfort. But even just beyond that, it's not a compelling thing.
01:11:12 No one wants that. No one actually wants that. When you look around yourself, you think,
01:11:18 I want this to be made perfect. I don't want something that I don't know. I want something
01:11:23 that I know. And God made us to live here on this earth, not somewhere else. Otherwise,
01:11:28 he would have made us somewhere else. Again, he's not capricious and he doesn't change his mind.
01:11:33 what he did he meant to do and so just like in leviticus 18 you have the the sins of the people
01:11:39 of canaan the child sacrifice the sexual depravity and the land it says the land spit them out well 0.85
01:11:46 in the same way now that christ has accomplished his mediatorial work on the earth you have
01:11:52 creation it's like uh it's like when you're really hungry but you don't realize it and then someone
01:11:57 gives you a bite of like a cookie, but just one bite. And you're like, oh man, now I'm starving.
01:12:04 Like now I realize how hungry I am. Well, creation drank the blood of Christ. The dirt that we walk
01:12:12 on drank the blood of its king and maker. And now it wants the rest of it done. It wants the rest of
01:12:19 the victory worked out completely. So of course you have it groaning for the revealing of the
01:12:23 sons of God, just like us as part of creation are groaning for the revealing of Christ himself
01:12:29 and his return. Amen. Well, I, I said earlier that I would get to Atlantis. So I'll just say
01:12:35 real quick, just to circle back to that primary water thing. I, I just, I, I think you and Brian
01:12:41 are 100% spot on Sahara desert Atlantis. I, so I don't think Atlantis is under the earth. That was
01:12:46 not my point. I think that in restoring the earth, that primary water will be part of that,
01:12:52 you know that it's progressively that uh just so so isaiah i believe it's 65 that talks about like
01:12:59 the youth shall die at 100 so this dispensationalism that dog won't hunt with with isaiah 65
01:13:05 um it's this is not christ has returned um and but people are still dying yeah people don't die
01:13:12 when christ that's right when christ returns he lays death in its grave the and and death is not
01:13:17 the first of his enemies to defeat but the last of his enemies to defeat and the kingdom is handed
01:13:21 to him. Um, and so, and so all that being said, um, this is a later stage, I believe Isaiah 65.
01:13:29 Um, it says, uh, that, that, um, that no longer, um, will, will, uh, the child die in infancy and
01:13:36 the youth shall die at a hundred. Um, and so, you know, right now, even like if somebody dies at,
01:13:40 at, uh, 50, we say, man, he was so young, right? But not that long ago, if somebody died at 50,
01:13:46 people, people weren't saying he was so young. They would say, yeah, he lived a full life.
01:13:49 so in the same way that we would say somebody who dies at 100 he was just a kid he was just a youth
01:13:54 that that's that's in this dispensation for lack of a better word in this gospel age before the
01:14:00 final physical return of christ um and so so lifespans diseases being conquered um certainly
01:14:07 some godless ideologies marxism and communism and you know all these different things um better
01:14:13 stewardship better this better and and in that also discoveries to sustain a greater population
01:14:19 because people are living longer and they're obeying Jesus and being fruitful and multiplying.
01:14:23 You know, there's more people, so more water.
01:14:25 That's where primary water comes in.
01:14:27 And my point is, I think that when it's all said and done, I don't think there'll be any deserts.
01:14:32 Well, I like that.
01:14:32 So when Jesus comes, I don't think it'll be Jesus comes back and gets rid of the deserts.
01:14:37 I think Jesus, when he comes back, it'll be glorified, so even greater.
01:14:42 But I think, um, before he returns, um, that, that us redeemed man living out, um, uh, the
01:14:52 cultural mandate and the great commission, both the great commission doesn't replace
01:14:56 the cultural mandate, but comes alongside it by doing both, um, and the great commission
01:15:00 succeeding, um, and, and the, uh, the cultural mandate as the great commission succeeds,
01:15:06 the cultural mandate isn't something that we spurn and despise, but something we embrace.
01:15:10 And I think, you know, and throw a little sprinkle, a little primary water into the equation, you know, and then, yeah, there's no more Sahara Desert.
01:15:18 And Atlantis is brought back to her former glory, but without without the demons, without the demons.
01:15:23 Man, that would be great.
01:15:24 I hope anyways, I hope that's true.
01:15:26 I like that.
01:15:27 And then so let me just let me make sure I understand.
01:15:30 So redeemed man does this amazing work of cultivating the earth and bringing about, you know, the fullest glory that we're capable of on the earth as redeemed, not glorified.
01:15:44 And then at Christ's final return, we're taken away and there is this final judgment of fire on the earth and it's fully renovated and renewed, glorified.
01:15:55 It's raised in glory.
01:15:56 So that's good. So, you know, you get the postmillennial hope, but you avoid, you know, an over realized like a hyper realized eschatology because you're you're not denying the final judgment at all.
01:16:08 I like that. Right. And thanks. I mean, primary water makes sense because primary water is.
01:16:13 I don't mean this in the scriptural sense. I mean this in the scientific way. It's living water.
01:16:18 It is, uh, it's structured water and a lot of the health problems that we have today
01:16:24 are because we're lacking structured living water and, uh, and primary water gives us
01:16:30 that fresh spring water gives us that.
01:16:32 So I like that a lot.
01:16:34 Yeah.
01:16:35 Well, one of these days I would love if haunted cosmos ever gets to the point where you and
01:16:39 Brian do an episode on primary water.
01:16:41 Maybe we will now.
01:16:42 Yeah, that would be, I'm going to be thinking about that for a while.
01:16:45 All right.
01:16:45 Well, Ben, I'll let you have the final word.
01:16:48 Do you have any other thoughts that you want to add to this?
01:16:51 If not, let us at least know how people can follow you.
01:16:55 Yeah, no, I have appreciated the heck out of this conversation.
01:16:59 This has been awesome.
01:17:00 I've been really blessed by it and have a lot to chew on.
01:17:02 Primary water is really going to be an area of study for me for now.
01:17:07 Yeah, I was kind of like, oh, that's cool.
01:17:08 But, you know, I have other stuff to think about.
01:17:11 No, not anymore.
01:17:12 I can only think about this.
01:17:13 You can. No, thanks for having me on, Joel. You can find me on Twitter at Tom Pombadil, just like Tom Bombadil, but replace bomb with pawn P-A-W-N. It's a really dumb handle. If you can't find it, I won't be offended. Or you can follow us at Haunted Cosmos underscore. That's mostly Brian and I tweeting from there. And it's pretty much half and half. So it's kind of fun to have people guess who they think tweeted what.
01:17:41 But you can find me at Haunted Cosmos on Twitter, at Tom Pommadil on Twitter.
01:17:45 You can also find us on Instagram.
01:17:48 Awesome.
01:17:49 How was the new Christendom conference that you guys just did?
01:17:53 Oh, man, it was amazing.
01:17:55 We had a really big time.
01:17:57 The Lord was really kind in allowing us to put on what I think was a great time for people.
01:18:03 I think people were blessed.
01:18:04 I certainly was.
01:18:05 And we pray the Lord was glorified and his people were helped.
01:18:07 But it was awesome.
01:18:08 We're looking forward to the next one.
01:18:10 Cool.
01:18:10 Are you going to try to make it annual once a year?
01:18:13 I don't know.
01:18:14 So I'm not going to say.
01:18:16 I don't want to speculate.
01:18:16 We're having a debriefing meeting tomorrow.
01:18:18 We'll probably decide something like that.
01:18:21 But we definitely want to do it again.
01:18:24 I think it's very safe to say we're going to do it again.
01:18:26 Cool.
01:18:27 All right.
01:18:27 Well, thanks so much for coming on the show.
01:18:29 Thanks for having me, Joel.
01:18:30 Y'all have a great night.
01:18:31 All right.
01:18:31 Hold up.
01:18:32 You're not going to want to miss this.
01:18:33 I'm going to tell you exactly how our spring 2024 conference is going to go down.
01:18:37 Here's the title of the conference.
01:18:38 Blueprints for Christendom 2.0. Subtitle, Seven Doctrines for Ruling the World. We're going to
01:18:45 have seven primary sessions covering each of these doctrines for ruling the world righteously. Number
01:18:52 one, Reformed Confessionalism. That's going to be Pastor Doug Wilson preaching on that topic.
01:18:58 Then we've got Covenant Theology with Pastor Brian Sauve. Then we've got Biblical Patriarchy
01:19:03 with pastor Michael Foster. Then we've got presuppositionalism with Dr. Joseph Boot.
01:19:09 Then we've got Kuyperianism, all of Christ for all of life, where we're going to welcome pastor
01:19:14 Doug Wilson back for a second session. Then we've got general equity theonomy. We're going to have
01:19:20 Dr. Joseph Boot come and do a second session on that topic. And then lastly, we'll have pastor
01:19:25 Dale Partridge on post-millennial eschatology. In addition to these seven sessions, we're also
01:19:31 going to have not one but two live podcasts on the first day of the conference that's friday
01:19:37 march 1st we're going to have a live theology applied podcast i'll be on the stage hosting
01:19:43 the discussion with douglas wilson michael foster and eric khan from it's good to be a man the topic
01:19:49 is going to be all about biblical patriarchy we're going to specifically be parsing out
01:19:54 distinguishing the biblical doctrinal differences between patriarchy and complementarianism again
01:20:01 And that's Friday, March 1st, the first day of the conference, a live Theology Applied
01:20:05 podcast on biblical patriarchy.
01:20:08 Then we're going to have the next day, that's Saturday, March 2nd, a live Haunted Cosmos
01:20:14 podcast.
01:20:15 I'll be hosting this discussion with Brian Sauve and Ben Garrett.
01:20:19 We're going to be talking about the Nephilim.
01:20:20 We're going to be talking about the Watchers.
01:20:22 We're going to be talking about what creatures currently are living underneath the surface
01:20:26 of the earth and chasms of the deep.
01:20:28 It's going to be wacky.
01:20:29 It's going to be weird, but it will also be thoroughly biblical and incredibly unhinged.
01:20:35 So you're not going to want to miss these two live podcasts, Theology Applied, on Friday,
01:20:39 March 1st, the first day of the conference on biblical patriarchy with Doug Wilson, Michael
01:20:45 Foster, Eric Kahn, and myself.
01:20:46 And then the next day of the conference, Saturday, March 2nd, a live Haunted Cosmos podcast with
01:20:52 Brian Sauve and Ben Garrett and myself on the Nephilim, the Watchers, and What Lies
01:20:58 under the surface of the earth. And then the conference will hold over for one final, the
01:21:03 third and final day. That's going to be the Lord's day Sunday, March 3rd, where one of our speakers
01:21:08 will be holding over to preach the Lord's day sermon. And I'll be leading us in worship through
01:21:14 the liturgy. So we've got three days, a Friday, Saturday, Sunday, March 1st, 2nd, and 3rd of 2024
01:21:20 blueprints for Christendom 2.0, seven doctrines for ruling the world. You're not going to want
01:21:27 to miss this conference. Our early bird rate is still available, but only for a very short period
01:21:33 of time. We are ending the early bird rate on August 31st at 11 59 PM. That will be the final
01:21:40 chance to get into this conference at an affordable, cheap rate. All right. So go and
01:21:46 take advantage of the early bird rate right now by going to right response conference.com. Again,
01:21:52 That's rightresponseconference.com to register for Blueprints for Christendom 2.0, March 1st,
01:22:00 2nd, and 3rd, 2024. Register today.