The Peter Attia Drive - March 27, 2020


#101 - Ryan Holiday: Finding stillness amidst chaos

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
#100 - Sam Harris, Ph.D.: COVID-19—Comprehending the crisis and managing our emotions #102 - Michael Osterholm, Ph.D.: COVID-19—Lessons learned, challenges ahead, and reasons for optimism and concern

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 22 minutes

Words per minute

178.75

Word count

14,814

Sentence count

888

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

18

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In addition to the conversation we released on Tuesday with Sam Harris, I also wanted to bring back Ryan Holley to talk about Stoicism and how it can help us during these current times. We talk in this episode about some of the measures of Stoic philosophy, and how moments like this are sort of tailor-made for examining those principles and, more importantly, figuring out how to apply them to our lives.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey, everyone. Welcome to the drive podcast. I'm your host, Peter Atiyah. This podcast,
00:00:15 my website, and my weekly newsletter all focus on the goal of translating the science of longevity
00:00:19 into something accessible for everyone. Our goal is to provide the best content in health
00:00:24 and wellness, full stop. And we've assembled a great team of analysts to make this happen.
00:00:28 If you enjoy this podcast, we've created a membership program that brings you far more
00:00:33 in-depth content. If you want to take your knowledge of the space to the next level at
00:00:37 the end of this episode, I'll explain what those benefits are. Or if you want to learn more now,
00:00:41 head over to peteratiyahmd.com forward slash subscribe. Now, without further delay,
00:00:47 here's today's episode. Welcome back to another episode of the drive. My guest this week is Ryan
00:00:55 Holiday, a previous guest and a close friend. In addition to the conversation we released on
00:01:01 Tuesday with Sam Harris, I also wanted to bring back Ryan to talk about stoicism and how it can
00:01:06 help us during these current times. We talk in this episode in particular about some of the
00:01:12 measures of stoic philosophy and how moments like this are sort of tailor-made for examining those
00:01:17 principles and more importantly, figuring out how to apply them to our lives. But worry not,
00:01:22 this is not an episode that gets deep or philosophical in any way, shape or form. It
00:01:26 is mostly about us talking about balancing the challenges, trying to think through other things
00:01:33 that folks are experiencing that perhaps Ryan and I are not experienced. For example, Ryan and I
00:01:37 happen to live in largely rural areas and therefore, at least we're not space constraint during this
00:01:43 period of time, but we're aware that many people are. And the question then is, okay, well,
00:01:47 what would you do if you're stuck on the 17th floor of a 600 square foot apartment in New York?
00:01:53 How can you apply some of these principles? We revisit some of my absolute favorite stories
00:01:58 from some of his books, including the one that I think about the most, which is that of Winston
00:02:03 Churchill during the second world war. And basically we extract insights and lessons from a number of
00:02:09 Ryan's book. Again, his most recent, Stillness is the Key, Obstacle is the Way, Ego is the Enemy,
00:02:14 et cetera. Let's just get right to this one. It's about 90 minutes long. And I think most of you
00:02:19 will find at least something of value in here. So without further delay, please enjoy my discussion
00:02:23 today with Ryan Holley. Ryan, thank you so much for making time on pretty short notice.
00:02:34 Yeah, of course. Anytime. How are you doing? I'm doing okay. Overall, I think I'm doing pretty well.
00:02:40 Feel pretty fortunate to be with my family during all of this. I think sort of reflected on it the
00:02:47 other day and thought, man, this would be a lot worse if all this were going on and I wasn't with
00:02:52 my family. So despite the inconvenience of this, which I think is, it's obviously inconvenient in
00:02:59 different extent to different people. Yeah. I don't know. I'm doing better than I was a week ago of
00:03:05 seeing the potential upside of this. Now you, from the beginning, Ryan, I mean, I was in contact
00:03:11 with you right away and you seem to immediately find a way to be productive in this. And I think
00:03:17 part of that is you're one of the people that has the luxury of being able to work from home. But
00:03:21 aside from that, does this also kind of pose for you a new laboratory in which you can examine your own
00:03:29 reactions to this sort of thing and then that of others?
00:03:31 Yeah. I mean, to me, that's the only potential positive of any sort of dramatic setback or
00:03:40 adversity or obstacle or whatever it is, is that it is a chance to sort of see things differently or
00:03:46 look at things differently. Almost always the status quo is something we had some sort of part
00:03:53 in setting up. So we kind of like things the way that they are. So sort of given a choice, I'd probably
00:03:58 have left them exactly as they were. But then when you sort of experience these sudden shocks,
00:04:03 suddenly you're working from home or suddenly you're not doing this anymore. Or in my case,
00:04:08 like a whole bunch of stuff that I was planning to do later this month and then in all of April was
00:04:13 suddenly canceled. And so obviously the economic hit of that is very large and very unpleasant.
00:04:20 But at the same time, so I never would have canceled them sort of deliberately. But then when you find
00:04:27 yourself feeling relief that they got canceled, you're like, oh, maybe my feelings on this were
00:04:32 a little bit more mixed than I understood. I mean, for me, I am very lucky. I work from home. Not only
00:04:39 can I work from home, but I live on a fair amount of property outside of a major city. So,
00:04:45 and I had some mutual friends and you being one of them that sort of gave me some heads up on stuff
00:04:52 that was happening. So I was able to prepare. So I wasn't sort of caught off guard or as harmed by it
00:04:58 as some people. So I have a little bit on the hierarchy of needs because I'm not that worried
00:05:04 about food, let's say, or not that worried about where my parents are or how my kids are doing or
00:05:10 whatever. I do have some time to think about it, but I, I have been feeling this weird feeling of,
00:05:16 oh, maybe this pace and this setup is actually closer to what I want my life to be than what
00:05:24 the life I had that was supposedly disrupted was. Yeah. That's an interesting thought, right? Because
00:05:31 as you said, there are a lot of things that there's probably nobody listening to this who hasn't had to
00:05:35 make an enormous sacrifice in something with respect to their professional life and their
00:05:42 personal life. And for many of us, those changes, like the example you gave are not things we would
00:05:48 have done on their own. If someone came to me in January and said from March 1st until, I don't know,
00:05:54 I'll just make it up and say July, you cannot get on a plane. I would have said that's impossible.
00:06:00 I'd just say, look, that's incompatible with my job. That's incompatible with what's expected of me
00:06:07 by the people I help. I could have come up with a hundred reasons why that could never have been
00:06:12 done. And yet, guess what? That turned out to be untrue. Yes. A lot of the things we think are
00:06:18 non-negotiable, we're just actually not willing to negotiate, but of course aren't non-negotiable.
00:06:25 Weirdly, that is something that kids sort of teach you as well, I think, is suddenly all
00:06:30 these things that you thought you couldn't do, that you thought had to be a certain way, get blown up,
00:06:36 and then you're forced to sort of question them. But yeah, I'm in the same boat. Obviously,
00:06:41 this is the way that it had to be. Obviously, this is the system. It only works this way.
00:06:46 But so much of that is just sort of a status quo bias that we have or a sense of what's normal.
00:06:53 One of the really great things about being a writer, of course, although I think there's probably a
00:06:58 metaphor in it. I remember early on in my life, Robert Greene told me he was all material. He's
00:07:02 like, every shitty thing that happens to you is material. Everything you mess up is material.
00:07:08 Every person that breaks your heart, every dollar you lose, every sort of missed opportunity is
00:07:13 material. There's a Jorge Luis Borges quote that's similar where it's like, you got to use it all,
00:07:19 basically. And so the one thing that I think in situations like this is like, how can I channel what I
00:07:25 think and feel about this into the output or the work that I actually do? And I think there's
00:07:32 probably an analogy there. If you're an investor, if you're a psychologist, whatever it is that you
00:07:37 do, and this is not at all a full redemption for the tragedy and the enormous losses that are going
00:07:44 to come from what we're experiencing. But it's almost sacrilegious, I think, to decide not to study
00:07:51 this and understand it and sort of realize a deeper understanding of humans, of yourself,
00:08:00 of leadership, of clients, whatever it is. I think deciding that you're going to experience this in
00:08:05 a way that you emerge from it, at least sort of wiser and better at what you do, to me, is sort of the
00:08:12 way to think about it.
00:08:13 So you've been writing a lot of really great stuff, Ryan, in the past three weeks, building on
00:08:19 obviously the themes that you've written on in the past, namely around stoicism. What are some of the
00:08:25 most important things that stand out to you specifically with respect to this type of
00:08:31 uncertainty around pandemic? And as you point out, it's really now sort of reared two very ugly heads.
00:08:39 The first is the head of the pandemic itself and the risk it poses physically to people and all of
00:08:47 the uncertainty around that. I mean, we still don't actually know how bad this virus is,
00:08:51 unfortunately, because we don't know the denominator of testing. We don't really know if this virus
00:08:55 kills 1% of the people it infects or 0.1% of the people it infects. So that's a tenfold difference
00:09:03 that makes all the difference. But if that weren't enough, as you alluded to, there is now an
00:09:10 undeniable economic tragedy that's being imposed on many people that itself and by itself would be
00:09:19 problematic, just as it was in 2008, 2009. So if you could bring Epictetus, Marcus Aurelius, and Seneca
00:09:27 back from the dead, bring them here today, walk me through what you think they would say about this,
00:09:34 this specific example and situation we're in. My instinct is typically to do that, right? There's
00:09:40 this quote from Churchill. He's talking as sort of World War II is breaking over Europe. He's not
00:09:47 quite been brought back into power. There's this letter he writes to his friend and he says,
00:09:51 the last couple of days, he says, I've been trying to put a thousand years between me and the 20th
00:09:57 century. And he was just talking about reading and writing about history. And so he was trying to
00:10:03 sort of get perspective. And I think we can do that really easily. And in a way, it's more informative
00:10:10 than watching CNN. Like, obviously, you need to watch CNN to know what the local authorities are
00:10:15 telling you to do this day or that day. There is value in the news in that sense. Although the news
00:10:20 is also sort of compounds hysteria and it passes on propaganda and misinformation. But I think looking
00:10:27 backwards gives us in some ways more insight because as unprecedented and new as this is,
00:10:34 it's also like one of the oldest things ever. I mean, Marcus Aurelius, who I write,
00:10:40 probably the main character in most of my books, died of a pandemic in 180 AD. So it's not as if
00:10:46 humans have not experienced pandemics and plagues and sort of massively contagious viruses. And I think
00:10:52 Marcus Aurelius is a particularly interesting example. What they call the Antonine Plague hits
00:10:58 Rome and it lasts for 15 years. So you want to talk about sort of a humanitarian tragedy of epic
00:11:06 proportions and then massive economic and geopolitical ramifications. When Marcus Aurelius writes
00:11:13 meditations, he is writing in the exact scenario that a lot of us are in right now, trying to keep
00:11:19 ourselves from being exposed, but also trying to do our jobs at the same time. He was a leader in a time
00:11:25 where they had a lot less visibility into this thing that was horrifically deadly, very contagious,
00:11:32 and spreading fear almost as quickly as it was spreading disease. And what I found in Marcus's
00:11:39 example particularly was just sort of calmness, clearheadedness, sort of courage. My favorite story
00:11:47 for Marcus, which I've told in a lot of my different books, but at one point the sort of treasury of
00:11:52 Rome is starting to run dry. And Marcus walks through the imperial palace and he starts selecting
00:12:00 various treasures that belong to the emperor and their family. And he sells them on the palace lawn to
00:12:07 pay down Rome's debts. When I say that, it just makes me feel so sad at sort of how far we've gotten
00:12:13 from that from a leadership perspective. But Marcus Aurelius talks about, he's like, look,
00:12:17 plagues are very bad. No one would say that they're not. But he's like, a plague can only threaten your
00:12:22 life. The real problem, the thing we actually have to be worried about is sort of selfishness and greed
00:12:28 and panic. These things sort of ruin your character as well as your life. And I think what we're seeing
00:12:34 now is people kind of struggling with that tension when we're so sort of removed from mortality,
00:12:41 from danger, from anything that makes us not do what we want to do at the moment we want to do it,
00:12:48 that people are really struggling with how to sort of temper themselves and how to limit themselves and
00:12:53 have self-discipline and put other people's needs above their own. So I think from history,
00:12:59 we can see that these are sort of timeless struggles that we've always had.
00:13:04 I read something a few weeks ago. I think it was a column that David Brooks wrote in the New York
00:13:09 Times. And the gist of it was that there are certain externalities that are very difficult
00:13:18 that can be uniting. And certainly Sebastian Younger has written very eloquently about this
00:13:23 in his book, Tribe. So in a post 9-11 New York, the suicide rate went down. People were united in a
00:13:32 common sense of urgency and a common sense of having been wronged. And it also probably helped to
00:13:39 diminish some of the sort of useless pettiness that defines our existence and showed us what really
00:13:45 mattered and what didn't. But the point I think that Brooks made in this article was, hey, pandemics
00:13:50 are different. It still has all of those same things of telling you what matters, what doesn't,
00:13:56 what's a threat, et cetera. But it comes with this bit of isolation that actually tends to be quite
00:14:03 negative. Now, I'm not sure I actually agree with David in that setting, because I think that might
00:14:11 be true historically. But I wonder if connectivity today is making it a little less so. In other words,
00:14:19 it'd be one thing if it's 1918, Spanish flu is ripping through the world, and it's clear that you basically 0.92
00:14:26 have to hunker down and be fully isolated. But today, even if we had to resort to those levels,
00:14:34 you and I have the ability to speak right now, look at each other on a computer screen. There's much more
00:14:39 intimacy today than there was then. So what is your take on this specific nature of a pandemic that
00:14:46 causes physical distance between people and how that factors into the challenges that we face as
00:14:55 humans being quite social creatures? Yeah, I read that piece too. And I think the seed of the
00:15:01 point is right, but there's some, you could argue against it in a lot of ways. I was in high school
00:15:06 during 9-11, but I remember concerts got canceled and sporting events got canceled and travel got
00:15:12 canceled and people were scared and they stayed inside their house. So there is an element of social
00:15:17 isolation in those tragedies. It doesn't last as long, but I think we forget very quickly how
00:15:24 we were all hunkered down for a short period of time. What I think the difference between... I think
00:15:31 it's actually less a nature of, is a pandemic a particularly vicious kind of tragedy or sort of
00:15:38 crisis because you can't see it. And in a sense, it almost pits people against each other. It forces
00:15:44 you inside. I mean, I think that that's an element of it, but in a way, it also connects us in that it
00:15:51 affects everyone all at the same time. The world wasn't suffering from 9-11 at the same time. Even
00:15:56 World War II did not actually affect large swaths of the planet. So it evens out. I think to me,
00:16:04 the defining feature, and when I sort of look at these things historically, the defining feature
00:16:09 between whether it sort of makes us better or makes us worse or how it manifests itself culturally
00:16:15 is what the leadership does. And to me, when I look at this crisis, I think it's ahistorical in
00:16:22 the sense that very rarely has there been such a failure of leadership at essentially every level,
00:16:30 from the geopolitical level to the specific world leaders, to the governors, to the government agencies.
00:16:37 It's been sort of quite horrendous in every sense. And I was just reading Doris Kearns Goodwin's book,
00:16:45 Leadership in Turbulent Times, which is very good. And she had a story in there that I remember from
00:16:50 Robert Caro's book on LBJ. But he talks about when LBJ takes over for Kennedy, it's a crisis,
00:16:57 at least on the US level, that it's difficult to wrap your head around. I mean, like a beloved
00:17:02 president is assassinated, then the assassin is killed, and it was done on television and everyone
00:17:09 saw it. And nobody knew who was responsible. Nobody knew what would come next. We were just a few
00:17:15 months past the Cuban Missile Crisis. This was a traumatic event without precedent. And here you
00:17:22 have a vice president who is not particularly... LBJ was everything Kennedy was not. He was a smoke-filled
00:17:29 room guy. He was not photogenic. He did not have charisma. He was not a good speaker. And most
00:17:35 importantly, he was not elected. And LBJ tells this in his sort of folksy Texas way. He says, like,
00:17:42 look, when I was a kid, he was like, the cattle would get stuck in a crevasse or a ravine or mud. And he
00:17:49 was like, it's in these moments that the foreman has to charge in and sort of lead the cattle out of
00:17:57 the swamp with confidence and aggression and clearness and sort of all the things that you
00:18:04 associate with somebody coming in, taking charge morally, physically, in all senses of the word.
00:18:11 And I think what we're experiencing now is less to do with the pandemic and to me, more a result of
00:18:18 what happens when something really scary and bad and alarming happens. And you realize we've been
00:18:26 operating, we've been in a rudderless ship and remain in a rudderless ship. I think that's what
00:18:32 everyone is experiencing right now. And I think you can say that wherever you happen to sit politically.
00:18:38 I don't think it's a political question. I think it's a leadership question.
00:18:42 What is a person to do? It's funny. You and I spoke in... God,
00:18:47 we probably sat down in late October, early November. That was released in January. I mean,
00:18:53 basically at the time that you and I spoke, we didn't actually know what this was. Nobody,
00:18:58 there hadn't even been a single case. And yet so many of the things that we talked about
00:19:04 seem even more relevant than they did at the time. We spoke about kind of consequences of having an
00:19:11 overly secure life and how that gives you this false misconception of unlimited time. Well,
00:19:19 certainly we're realizing that's not true. We spoke a lot about stillness and I want to come back to
00:19:24 that because I tell you, if there's one character you've written about that I can't get my mind off
00:19:29 as I struggle, it's Churchill, but I want to come back to that. And then there's kind of this idea of
00:19:35 dying well and how it helps you live better. So let's just start with, let's assume someone
00:19:41 hasn't listened to us speaking before and they don't know anything about stoicism. Let's go back
00:19:47 and kind of encapsulate a little bit about what this philosophy or as Tim, our mutual friend likes
00:19:52 to call it, I think he calls it an operating system. How would you describe it in the context of that?
00:19:57 Well, I think the sort of central precept of stoicism is basically that we don't control what
00:20:04 has happened or what is happening, but we control how we respond to those things. And so in a way,
00:20:11 it's kind of this resignation where it's seeding a lot of the things that we would like to be in
00:20:18 control of in favor of focusing on the things like that we actually immediately are in control of.
00:20:26 And you might think like, oh, you're talking about the reaction. So does that mean be reactionary?
00:20:31 No, it's just saying like, okay, what is in my immediate purview? And I'm going to start on that.
00:20:37 I'm going to make sure my family's okay. I'm going to make sure financially that I'm making some good
00:20:42 decisions here. I'm going to focus on, hey, even if I did get caught off guard or I was naked when the
00:20:50 tide went out, how am I prepared for this to get worse? How am I prepared for what may
00:20:56 happen after this? So it's this kind of focus on the immediacy, but it's focusing on doing what you
00:21:02 can, where you are with what you have. And so you can see like for the Stoics, yeah, they are dealing
00:21:08 with pandemics like we're talking about. They're also dealing with exile and war and mob rule and
00:21:15 all sorts of plus just the normal stuff, whether it's a problem in a marriage or a business partner
00:21:21 that's a cheat, or it's that they fell and broke their leg and now they're stuck in bed for six
00:21:26 weeks. Life is capricious and random and Murphy's law is real. What can go wrong does. And so obviously,
00:21:35 ideally you want to be prepared for those things, the Stoics say, but it's more about what do you do
00:21:41 when stuff goes wrong? How do you respond and how do you focus not on who's to blame,
00:21:47 how unfortunate it is, or any of those things? How do you instead focus on, okay, here's how I'm
00:21:54 going to move the ball forward? I talk about that in the books and I've read about that,
00:21:59 but I'm also just a human being who's trying to figure that out day to day, just like everyone
00:22:05 else. What happens when 30% of your income disappears? Or what happens when you've got to now
00:22:10 pay for employees that can't work? Or what happens when you watch your years of retirement
00:22:18 gains disappear? What happens when you can't go visit your grandmother one more time? Shit happens
00:22:25 to people. Philosophy isn't supposed to be this kind of abstract theoretical thing that you do in a 1.00
00:22:32 college classroom. It's designed for this. It's designed for when you're holed up in your house and
00:22:38 you don't like how things are. Yeah. I think that last point, Ryan, is so essential.
00:22:43 People like me never found philosophy that interesting in college, probably because I
00:22:48 wasn't smart enough. And now my attraction to it is not academic. It's what can I extract
00:22:55 from this way of thinking that will help reduce my suffering? Yeah.
00:23:00 So going back to the point I brought about Churchill, I've read Stillness is the Key three or four times.
00:23:06 I absolutely love it, Ryan. It is actually, of the 57 books you've written, it's my favorite.
00:23:11 No, I'm just kidding. It's only 12. How many books have you written, Ryan?
00:23:15 I think it's 10. I think it's 10.
00:23:17 Okay. Well, I have probably gifted Stillness seven or eight times in the last three months.
00:23:24 As I said, I've read it three or four times. And the section on Churchill really speaks to me. And
00:23:31 rather than me try to explain for folks who haven't read it, the story of how Churchill
00:23:35 went about creating routine and ritual during what I can only imagine is the most stressful
00:23:43 experience any one person could have really contemplated for a sustained period of time
00:23:49 in the last hundred years. I mean, maybe that's not true, but boy, it would be tough to make a case
00:23:54 that there was somebody that for months and years on end felt the angst that Winston Churchill felt.
00:24:03 So I find myself thinking, and I want you to kind of explain what that was and how he managed it,
00:24:08 because I was floored by sort of the ability that he had to maintain Stillness through that.
00:24:15 And that's something I've thought about, which is Peter, as upset as you are about this,
00:24:20 as much as the uncertainty torments someone like you, who's a control freak, and as much as you feel
00:24:25 the obligation to your patients and you want to make sure every one of them is okay and blah, blah, blah,
00:24:29 like that's a pittance compared to what Churchill experienced. And oh, by the way, Peter, you're like
00:24:35 three weeks into this. You better buck up and get ready for it. So tell people a little bit, A,
00:24:40 if they're not familiar with exactly how the war unfolded and B, with Winston Churchill, the man,
00:24:46 prior to the war and then during the war, give us a bit of the story because it's just such a beautiful
00:24:50 story. Yeah. I mean, Churchill's life obviously is incredibly privileged in some senses, but then
00:24:57 is an unending stream of adversity in pretty much every other sense. I mean, he's born early enough
00:25:04 in the 19th century that as a young war correspondent, he witnesses the last cavalry charge
00:25:12 of the British Empire and he dies sort of well into the space age. You just see that the scope
00:25:19 of history that he experiences. I mean, Churchill's first talk in America, he was very well received
00:25:25 and it was highly anticipated. He's introduced on stage in New York City by Mark Twain. And then
00:25:30 basically... After having sailed across the Atlantic.
00:25:34 Yeah, in a boat, right? And the last time he visits America, he flies in like a 727 or something
00:25:40 like that. So you get this enormous scope and span of history that's punctuated with he's not a bright
00:25:47 kid. Nobody has high hopes for him. His mother is sort of promiscuous, has a terrible relationship
00:25:54 with his father. His father dies. They think of syphilis when Churchill's like 20, assuming that his 0.94
00:26:00 son will never amount to anything. Churchill's taken a prisoner of war at like 22 years old, nearly dies in
00:26:07 Africa in this prison camp, escapes. He writes a series of books. He stands for his first election 0.70
00:26:13 and then sort of climbs his way to the top of sort of British politics and ends up being sort of the
00:26:21 fall guy for the Gallipoli campaign in World War I, has a nervous breakdown, thinks his career is over,
00:26:30 sort of emerges a little bit back and then ends up sort of destroying his political career by advocating
00:26:38 very strongly against the rearmament and the rise of Germany and spends what they call sort of 10
00:26:44 years in the political wilderness. He spends basically 10 years sort of run out of town. He's
00:26:51 radioactive. Everyone thinks he's an idiot. They think he's lost his mind. And he is 100% right and no one 1.00
00:26:59 listened to him. And Hitler rises to power. Germany rearms. World War II is the inevitable result of 0.92
00:27:06 this. And it could have been prevented and nobody listened to Churchill. And Churchill is only brought
00:27:11 back in after he is ignored for 10 years. And then, yeah, he sees himself. He basically saves the free
00:27:19 world, puts Western civilization on his back, draws the United States into the war, famously wins the war,
00:27:26 and then is rewarded for this by promptly being thrown out of office days after the war comes to
00:27:32 an end. And that's not even the end of it, right? It goes on and on and ends up dying as a very old
00:27:37 man, having sort of another series of triumphs and setbacks in that. And then I would say, if you just
00:27:44 look at... So that's the span. This guy wrote 10 million words in his lifetime, was one of the highest
00:27:49 paid, most successful writers in the world during his lifetime, holds office for 60 years, Nobel Peace
00:27:55 Prize, invents the tank. It's just an incredible life. Probably one of the most ambitious, busy people
00:28:03 of the age. I think proof of the great man of history theory, like the world we live in today is a
00:28:10 result of Churchill saying, fuck Hitler, I will give my absolute last breath defying this person. There's a 0.99
00:28:18 famous story I love. His daughter-in-law says, like, as it looks like the Nazis will certainly 0.98
00:28:23 land and invade Britain, his daughter-in-law says, like, what could we possibly do, Winston? Like,
00:28:30 how could we possibly... What do you expect us to do if this happens? And he looks her in the eye and
00:28:36 he sort of growls and he says, I expect you to go in the kitchen and get a butcher knife and take one of
00:28:41 them with you when they come in the front door. His point was like, we are going to fight this thing
00:28:46 down to the absolute last man. And that stand, which was partly a bluff, but also sort of 100%
00:28:54 real courage and commitment, turns the tide of history. And so I'm fascinated by Churchill because
00:29:00 that is an epic life. I want to add one thing to that, Ryan, before you get into the next part.
00:29:05 So I don't want to distract the thought. But the other thing that is amazing to me is,
00:29:10 here's a guy who a decade out calls Hitler. He basically says, this guy's a fascist and he's
00:29:18 going to do really, really bad things. And your point, he is completely exiled. And by the time
00:29:25 Chamberlain is finally forced to resign and they very reluctantly bring Winston Churchill back as the
00:29:34 prime minister, I mean, the Germans are basically knocking on their door. And what I find, it's another 1.00
00:29:41 subtlety of this, which I have to remind myself of. I have a tendency in a situation like this to say,
00:29:48 this was inevitable. How did we not see this coming? How is it that we shut down the branches of government
00:29:56 that should have and would have had us prepared for this? How is it that we didn't put, you know,
00:30:02 I could rattle off all the things we did wrong? And so when Churchill inherits a huge mess,
00:30:09 it seems almost unfair. It's like, well, now I have to be the one to fix the mess that I told you
00:30:15 for the last eight years was going to be the big mess. But again, the great ones don't seem to dwell
00:30:20 on that because there really isn't a lot of benefit that comes out of that backwards looking thing. So
00:30:26 do you want to say any more on that in addition to sort of everything you've already said?
00:30:30 Yeah. Churchill had this sort of code that he lived by, and I'm forgetting the exact phrasing of it,
00:30:35 but it was basically, it was like savage in fighting, magnanimous in victory, sort of gracious
00:30:42 in defeat. And part of that, what I think is not only did nobody listen to him, but they like
00:30:47 viciously punished him. They like destroyed his life basically. And then said, hey, now that the battle
00:30:53 is already lost, we're willing to sort of put you in charge. What I find remarkable is, was Churchill's
00:30:59 sort of empathy and compassion, even for those leaders. He kept some of them in his cabinet. He
00:31:05 managed to work with them. There was no recriminations, no punishments. He was Lincoln-esque in his
00:31:10 ability to sort of go, okay, this is just the hand I've been dealt. And there's a famous expression,
00:31:16 a famous statement he makes about the French general who surrendered to the Nazis. Obviously,
00:31:22 he's like, this guy's got to go. We're not collaborating with this guy. But he says something
00:31:25 like, let us be sympathetic that we never faced the predicament under which he broke. And so there
00:31:32 was this, for all of his combativeness and determination, there was also an understanding,
00:31:37 I think, in him having experienced a long tumultuous life. Shit happens. What matters is, 1.00
00:31:44 how are we going to solve this? And I think when you look at what he did, was like he rolled up his
00:31:50 sleeves and got to work. And even those 10 years, it's not like he spent 10 years of idle time.
00:31:56 One of the reasons, ironically, that Churchill was so able to understand Hitler, 0.84
00:32:01 Churchill was like the only one of the leaders in Britain who took the time to read Mein Kampf
00:32:07 and actually study it and look at it. And so Churchill had, in a way, that 10 years of exile
00:32:13 was the best thing that could have happened because it put him in a position to not be tainted
00:32:20 by the incompetence of the people that sort of brought everyone into this mess. It gave him a much longer
00:32:26 and larger perspective. And it put him in a position to sort of figure out what to do next.
00:32:32 And what I'm fascinated by, even if you sort of take out the war stuff, how was Churchill,
00:32:38 just to write 10 million words in your lifetime, just to do that in an addition to a political
00:32:44 career, how does he pull this off? He was a sort of a creature of habit and routine. He had this sort
00:32:49 of ritual. He would write at the same time every day. He would nap at the same time every day. He
00:32:54 would eat and dress, dressed for dinner. He had this rule that I've been joking with my wife about.
00:33:00 He said, spouses should not see each other before noon. That was the secret to a happy marriage.
00:33:06 He took long walks during the day. I was actually just in, this is maybe two months ago. I was in,
00:33:12 three months ago, I was in London. I had a talk in London. I was in London for maybe like 18 hours.
00:33:17 And I went, landed at Heathrow, took a Uber to Chartwell, which is Churchill's estate,
00:33:23 and then went back, gave my talk and flew home. But to experience, when you look at where Churchill
00:33:29 lived, it starts to make sense. He had his goldfish pond that he would visit every day.
00:33:33 He had the swans that he would feed. He had a little studio that he attached to his house that
00:33:38 he did his painting in every single day. He had even his estate or his house is surrounded by this
00:33:43 brick wall. He laid the bricks for the brick wall himself. He would write every day. He would paint
00:33:50 every day. He would lay bricks every day. And he would work every day. And this sort of
00:33:55 rhythm or ritual, I think was what allowed him to get into the headspace, to tap into the flow state
00:34:03 required to do what he did. I find, and you wrote obviously about this in terms of JFK during the
00:34:10 Cuban Missile Crisis. But to me, it's something about the way Churchill handled this because it was
00:34:16 much longer. Maybe it's in terms of the normalized value of stress, the Cuban Missile Crisis was greater,
00:34:23 but it was over in 13 days. This was years. And I just find it amazing the discipline in making time
00:34:33 to be still and how that mattered. And obviously he wasn't writing. He wasn't as prolific from a
00:34:38 writing standpoint during those bombing campaigns and such, but he took his bath every day, for
00:34:44 example. And it's funny, I was sort of talking to my daughter about this the other day because
00:34:48 we see like every kid around now, she's going through, you sort of, she's homeschooling
00:34:53 effectively. Right. And, you know, she was lamenting how much work she had to do. And I was
00:34:57 like, I sort of introduced her to, I can never remember if it's Parkinson's or Peter's law. I think
00:35:03 it's Parkinson's law, which is work expands to fill available time. And I kept trying to say like,
00:35:07 you have to make room for moments of detachment every day, regardless. I mean, it's just non-negotiable
00:35:14 because otherwise you could spend the whole day buried in your history lesson or whatever
00:35:19 other thing you're doing. And as important as that is, it would be very easy to say,
00:35:24 whatever it is I'm doing right now, whether it's trying to stay in touch with my coworkers or trying
00:35:30 to figure out a way that we're going to pay that next bill. I mean, those things are vitally important,
00:35:36 but it's not necessarily clear to me that you're going to do a better job of those things. If you
00:35:41 neglect that sort of self-care that comes from being in nature, being still detaching from it,
00:35:48 right? It's like a bipartisan complaint we have about presidents that they, it's like,
00:35:52 why are they playing so much golf? They're spending so much money playing golf. It's so
00:35:56 much taxpayer money playing golf. And I don't think it's a coincidence that presidents choose
00:36:02 that game and that they pretty much all universally play it. Going back at least to Eisenhower and
00:36:07 before, it's because what other excuse, and I think CEOs similarly gravitate towards golf,
00:36:14 because if basketball is your game, you get maybe 30 minutes of basketball, right? Or if running is
00:36:21 your game, you get five or 10 miles. But golf is a game that takes three or four hours. And it's three
00:36:26 or four hours where you're not supposed to be on your phone, where you have to sort of mentally focus,
00:36:30 you have to be present. It forces you to control and master your mind in a non-work context. And
00:36:38 Churchill happened to be famously terrible at golf, so he painted instead. But he said, actually,
00:36:44 like the most important thing that powerful people can do is have one or two hobbies. I would argue
00:36:51 that's something that's a problem for Trump. If Trump had more interests, whether it was reading or
00:36:56 sports or even socializing, he'd be watching less cable news and be able to see the bigger picture.
00:37:03 As a nonpartisan example, I was the director of marketing in American Apparel for a number of
00:37:07 years. And that was a company that self-inflicted. And then also the financial crisis was sort of in a
00:37:12 perpetual state of crises and sort of chaos. And I remember talking to one of the girlfriends of the
00:37:19 CEO, his name was Dove, we're in his sort of huge mansion. It's like totally empty of furniture. He's
00:37:26 not married. He works 24-7, 365. He's sort of perpetually on the never taking a vacation. He's
00:37:34 perpetually on the edge of sort of descending into insanity. And I said something like, does he have
00:37:38 any hobbies? And they were like, just sex. Like sex was his only hobby. And I think that was directly 0.96
00:37:45 correlated with a lot of the self-inflicted unforced errors that he made as a leader because he was
00:37:52 never stepping out. He was never disconnecting. He had no structure. Everything was always urgent.
00:38:01 Very minor example. There's something I'm dealing with some supply chain issues with my company.
00:38:06 And it was like someone who works for me called me. They were asking me about it. I was sitting down
00:38:11 for dinner with my family to be able to go like, hey, I'll call you back in an hour. I'm having
00:38:15 dinner with my family right now. Obviously, that's what you should do from a family perspective. But
00:38:19 that forced one hour break made me handle that situation better. Because if you'd forced me to
00:38:26 deal with it at that moment, or if I was a bachelor eating Chinese food in my house when I got that call,
00:38:31 I would have lost my temper. I probably would have made a rash emotional decision. I would not have
00:38:36 forced myself to take an hour to sort of let it sit, right? And so one of these things these hobbies do
00:38:42 and relationships do and a little bit of sort of order and structure in our lives do is they kind
00:38:48 of just protect us from just reacting and reacting and reacting all the time.
00:38:54 You've written both in your book and in your newsletters about alive time versus dead time. And even
00:38:59 though you didn't use those terms, a moment ago, you basically gave a great example with respect to my
00:39:05 favorite Churchill, which is he's booted out. He's in exile. He's a political pariah. He's the scum of
00:39:12 the earth. And you'd think, I mean, he could have done the equivalent of watching Netflix every day 1.00
00:39:18 in the 1930s, but he didn't. What did he do? He's reading everything that he can read about this crazy
00:39:26 guy in Germany. He's writing, he's being as prolific as anyone can be. And it prepared him for when the
00:39:34 chance came that he was going to come in and basically help save the world. And so what advice
00:39:40 could we offer people, myself included, by the way, I'm just going to be completely transparent
00:39:45 about my own selfishness and having this podcast with you, Ryan. It's mostly just a therapy session
00:39:49 for me. It's really tempting sometimes to just turn on YouTube and Netflix and take a break from the
00:39:57 news. The news is pretty upsetting, but is there any harm in just watching Breaking Bad for the fourth
00:40:03 time? How would you help us guard against the temptation to seek pure distraction? And how
00:40:10 would you counter that and why? What's interesting about Churchill is it's not like he was only
00:40:15 preparing. Churchill also, by nature of his writing and the speeches that he gives and the radio broadcast
00:40:21 that he does, becomes almost more famous in America than he is in the UK. And I'm not sure he would
00:40:28 have been able... His credibility with Americans was so great, greater than it was with his own people
00:40:34 at that time, that when it comes time to sort of sell the transatlantic alliance, that work that he
00:40:41 did was sort of very... paid enormous dividends. And this idea of a lifetime dead time, it's like,
00:40:48 look, you didn't control the fact that you're stuck in your house. You don't control that most operations
00:40:52 are set down. You don't control any of this, but you do decide what you're going to use this time for.
00:40:57 I guess the question is, when else are you going to get... The good news is basically for a lot of
00:41:04 people, very little is expected. I mean, some people, nothing is expected because they are
00:41:09 unfortunately not employed at the moment. But what's unique about this period is we are being,
00:41:16 I think, pretty understanding about the fact that things have ground to a halt without anyone's consent.
00:41:21 And so nothing is expected of you. So how are you going to use... You've essentially been gifted
00:41:28 time. And how are you going to use that time? I think it's absolutely appropriate to use some of
00:41:33 that for self-care, for relaxation, for tuning out, because that's not a terrible use of this time
00:41:40 anyway. If Churchill had emerged from those 10 years in the wilderness, and the only advantage had
00:41:47 been he was well-rested, I think that would have been beneficial, right? How is he able to basically
00:41:54 be active in politics up until his death, when I think most people would have burned out? I think
00:41:59 that 10-year period was not a vacation, but it was, what do they call it in the NBA? Load management.
00:42:05 It forced him to recharge and rest and sort of figure out what was important. So I think,
00:42:10 at the very least, we can use this time for that. But now is also time to really question a lot of
00:42:17 things about our lives, about the decisions we make, about the businesses that we have, about the
00:42:22 goals that we've been striving towards. It's also a chance to experiment with new things,
00:42:29 to try new things. I mean, as a very small level, right? I don't know about you, but I've gotten a
00:42:34 million requests to be on people's Instagram lives. And I saw this meme where they were like,
00:42:39 it took a global pandemic to get anyone to try Instagram live. But that's sort of what I'm
00:42:45 talking about, if only in the sense it's like, oh, because people now have a minute, they are
00:42:50 experimenting with and trying things that under ordinary circumstances, they would have never
00:42:55 allowed themselves to try. And so I think that's a good use of this time for people. What I'm trying
00:43:01 to do is focus on writing, on reading, and just sort of spending time with my family. Those are sort of
00:43:07 my big priorities. I'm also using it as practice to like, the financial blow has been so significant,
00:43:13 it almost makes everything seem comical. And so I'm almost using it as practice to say no to stuff.
00:43:20 Do you know what I mean? It's like, oh, if I can take this, I can do a lot less generally. Do you
00:43:25 know what I mean?
00:43:25 Yes, it gets back to that point earlier, which is, if you had said to me in February,
00:43:32 Peter, you know, I think it would be a good idea if from late February until late June,
00:43:37 you did not travel. I would have said, oh, that's a beautiful idea, Ryan, impossibility.
00:43:44 Don't you know, fill in the blank, right? Don't you understand, blah, blah, blah, blah.
00:43:49 And of course, then it's imposed on you and you realize, well, actually,
00:43:52 these things are much more possible than we believed. And therefore, we've kind of imposed
00:43:59 our own barriers to sanity at times. And that means, yeah, we could probably live with less
00:44:05 and we can do less. So as awkward as this is, this feeling, this helplessness,
00:44:12 A, there's not a huge amount of value in just being upset about it. I mean, it feels good in the
00:44:19 moment, but it doesn't really produce much benefit in the long run. Stoicism says so much
00:44:25 about this. And one of the things that it talks about that we don't like to think about is having
00:44:30 a plan if things get worse. How do you think about that personally? And how can others kind of apply
00:44:37 that insight to themselves?
00:44:39 Yeah, it's certainly not pleasant to think about how it could get worse when it's already so bad.
00:44:44 But again, we want to focus on moving forward rather than sort of staying in the same place or
00:44:51 looking backwards. I think what this is teaching a lot of people, myself included, is that we thought
00:44:57 about everything but this. There's a great line, Seneca quotes Fabius, who's one of the great generals
00:45:03 in Roman history. He defeated Hannibal. And he says, the only inexcusable thing for a military
00:45:09 commander to say is that I didn't think it could happen. It's not that you can't lose. It's not
00:45:15 that you can't mess up. But what you can't do is confidently say, here's the realm of what's
00:45:21 possible and what's not possible. And so I think what this is reminding me of, what we're sort of
00:45:27 making plans at my house for is just like, hey, look, don't be prepared for a rainy day where you're out
00:45:34 of work for two months. In a sense, that's almost something that you're more able to quickly adapt
00:45:39 to and resolve. But are you prepared for shit to really, really hit the fan? And I think that's 0.99
00:45:46 where a lot of us were more caught off guard. Actually, here's a great example of this. And I
00:45:51 think we're going to have to figure this out as a country. The American system of being sort of 50
00:45:57 strong states backed by a stronger central government, it was designed to be really
00:46:04 adaptive and resilient because, okay, a hurricane hits New Orleans. Now New Orleans can get the full
00:46:10 benefit of the American federal government. Florida gets hit by a hurricane. California gets hit by
00:46:16 wildfires. Wall Street is struggling. Our system was designed for isolated but serious short-term
00:46:26 black swans. What we are really clearly struggling with is massive interconnected problems that are
00:46:35 affecting everyone at the same time. And I think you could argue that on an individual level. Hey,
00:46:41 I've got life insurance in case I die, or I've got some savings in the bank in case my wife loses her
00:46:48 job, or we have a babysitter on call in case there's an emergency. We have a couple things here or
00:46:56 there. But what we're much less prepared for is everything to go wrong at the same time.
00:47:02 And I think that's something we're going to have to adapt and figure out how to do,
00:47:06 especially because it's that same weakness that sets us up to be very poorly equipped to respond to,
00:47:15 say, climate change or an invasion from a foreign threat. We are just not in a position
00:47:21 to deal with serious catastrophe. It's like we're set up only for minor catastrophes.
00:47:29 Yeah. The difference between centralized and decentralized organization,
00:47:33 again, I try not to spend much time thinking about all the reasons we're in this situation,
00:47:38 but I can't help but sometimes think, I hope we don't forget this. I hope we don't go back to
00:47:46 business as usual when this is over. I hope that a year from now, this lesson hasn't been forgotten.
00:47:53 Does stoicism tell us anything about the likelihood that we as a society will learn from this?
00:48:00 If you really look at history, the truth is like, yeah, we don't learn very much.
00:48:05 But I think stoicism is, there's a Hemingway quote I love, and it's in Farewell to Arms. He says,
00:48:11 the world breaks everyone. And afterwards, sometimes the broken people are stronger
00:48:18 in the broken places. But the people that don't break, the world kills. And so that's something
00:48:27 I've been thinking about because the myth of stoicism is that it makes you unbreakable.
00:48:32 It's the David Goggins thing. You can't hurt me. It's the James Stockdale superhero,
00:48:38 unbreakable, sort of sheer, almost inhuman strength and endurance under crisis. And in a way,
00:48:46 that's almost too aspirational because it doesn't feel real. I don't think stoicism is about making
00:48:53 you unbreakable. I think it's about making you stronger. But I think the reality is really bad
00:49:00 stuff happens, and we have no choice but to sort of assent to it. No amount of defiance,
00:49:06 as we are seeing from a leadership standpoint right now, no amount of defiance and denial
00:49:11 stops a pandemic. No amount of invective stops a pandemic. You roll over and you take it to a
00:49:18 certain degree. It's about sort of damage mitigation more than anything. But where I think philosophy
00:49:25 really comes in, what it's actually about is emerging from that better and stronger.
00:49:33 And so to me, the ultimate tragedy would be for the people that are unfortunately going to pass
00:49:41 from this. And that could be you or me or people we both love or just countless faceless strangers
00:49:48 we've never met. The worst thing we could do to those people would be to emerge from this
00:49:55 and essentially learn nothing, to go back to business as usual.
00:49:59 And I don't just mean that in, are we going to have better preparation for disasters?
00:50:06 The thing I keep coming back to, the thing that makes me saddest and that I'm sort of struggling
00:50:11 with trying not to be resentful about and trying not to be angry about, is that we, I don't just mean
00:50:17 in the United States, we put these leaders in charge, even though their flaws were very well
00:50:25 advertised, even though their lack of competence was almost something they bragged about, even
00:50:31 though the sort of obvious holes in their strategies and skill sets were there. We put those people in
00:50:38 charge because they agreed with certain policies we wanted, because we thought they would juice the
00:50:44 stock market, because we wanted to stick it to the other side. We made a deal with the devil,
00:50:51 and I'm talking about a lot of different countries. We put woefully unqualified leaders,
00:50:58 but more importantly, even if they were qualified, because some of them were, we put leaders with
00:51:03 enormous character flaws, people of genuine bad character in charge. And we knew it, and we knew it,
00:51:11 and we said to ourselves, I would never want to be this person. I don't want my kids to be like this
00:51:17 person. I don't like what they say. I don't like what they do in their personal life. And we said,
00:51:24 I know that they don't actually believe in the things that I believe in, but they're paying lip
00:51:28 service to them. We said, all of that is okay. It doesn't matter that they're a shitty human being.
00:51:34 What matters is they're going to get what I want accomplished, or they are going to make me more 0.98
00:51:42 money, or reduce my taxes. And as you're seeing now, because what leaders are actually supposed
00:51:49 to do is be there when shit hits the fan, we are seeing the ramifications of that. Look, it wiped 0.99
00:51:55 out all the gains of the market, and there's nowhere to go but down from here. And so I think that's
00:52:01 really what we have to learn. To me, I think it was a betrayal of my parents' generation to my 0.71
00:52:08 generation. But I also think I hold myself responsible too. I think we mortgaged our
00:52:14 children's future by not wanting to get involved, by not wanting to say anything. This doesn't just
00:52:21 affect us. It's going to have generational impact. And to me, that's what's got to change.
00:52:27 Bringing it back to right now, because at the time that we're recording this, which is
00:52:32 very late in March, my kids ask me every single day, how much longer, how much longer? And I think,
00:52:40 honestly, for them, it's mostly just they miss their routines and rituals. They miss going to
00:52:45 school. It's not like they're suffering. And I say, I don't know. I really don't know, guys.
00:52:50 You know, it could be this long, could be that long, but I really don't know. I'll have a better
00:52:53 idea in two weeks, blah, blah, blah. You're fortunate. You live on a farm, and you live outside of a city.
00:52:59 So you can always spend time outdoors. And I know for you personally, even before this came along,
00:53:06 that was the epicenter of your grounding. You and I sort of have that in common, which is I think
00:53:11 we sort of like solitude outdoors. What about the people who are listening to this who don't have
00:53:18 either of those options? You are living in a small apartment in New York City, or you're living in any
00:53:25 city, and you look out your window, and you can see people locked up in their house. I mean,
00:53:30 from a medical standpoint, my view is everybody should still be outside every day, regardless of
00:53:35 where they live. And one just has to take extreme care when those are areas that are high risk, like
00:53:41 New York, and in which you have to be careful what you touch and how close you get to people. But
00:53:46 what other sort of practical insights do you offer people that don't have the luxury of
00:53:51 being on a farm and being able to work from home? So we're back to the, you're thinking about applying
00:53:57 for unemployment. I just read today that over a million people in California have filed for
00:54:01 unemployment. At least that's according to a story that I read. Who knows at this point,
00:54:06 half the things I read, I don't even know if they're being taken out of context. But there's no doubt that
00:54:10 there is a staggering number of people that are in the process of filing for unemployment,
00:54:15 managing a life at home with kids that are out of a routine that means you now have another job,
00:54:23 which is trying to help educate your kids and basically homeschooling them. And just none of
00:54:29 this seems amenable to stillness, right? None of this seems amenable to letting your mind get out of
00:54:35 its own way. So how do we force it? Yeah, my sister is in a apartment in Park Slope, and I've been
00:54:41 trying for a month now. It's probably too late. I was trying to get her to leave. That's one of the
00:54:48 interesting things to me, I think a lesson that we have to learn. And again, putting aside sort of
00:54:54 following the health authorities, et cetera, but just the sort of amount of sort of passivity about,
00:55:00 it's like we saw the train coming and we froze, or we just went about our normal business as if we had
00:55:08 no agency. I would say one in 20 of the people I talked to had any sort of plan for how they were
00:55:16 going to weather what was so obviously coming, some form of quarantine, right? And if people had
00:55:22 been a little bit smarter about it, sure, there might've been some spreading of the virus, but
00:55:27 maybe New York wouldn't be so overloaded if the people who didn't have to be in New York right now
00:55:32 were not sort of going about their business, doing the de Blasio strategy of working out into the last
00:55:39 possible moment at the gym and then accepting the quarantine. Do you know what I mean? So I think a
00:55:45 lot of people are unfortunately stuck in less than ideal situations. What I'm trying to think about,
00:55:50 I'm trying to message friends of mine that I know, at least in Austin, just as some, it's like,
00:55:55 look, you can come to my house and walk around the farm or go in my pool. I will wave to you from
00:55:59 inside and then I'll wait for you to leave before I go back outside. I think that's something we're
00:56:04 going to have to figure out sort of culturally and relationship wise is like, how do people that
00:56:09 have resources or have sort of access to things, how can we get in a place where we share them
00:56:16 sort of effectively? So without endangering anyone, I've got a place in Florida that's sitting there
00:56:23 empty that would be better than a place in Park Slope, but that's sort of reality of the situation.
00:56:28 For me, a couple of things that one of the last purchases I bought on Amazon before,
00:56:35 as this was starting to sort of happen is you're stocking up and stuff. I bought like an old school
00:56:39 alarm clock and I have young kids, so I always get up early, but for a long, I don't keep my phone in
00:56:45 my room because I try not to use my phone in the mornings. But so it would be like, okay, yeah,
00:56:49 if I have to get up by 5am to catch a flight, I would set the alarm in the other room or whatever.
00:56:55 But I was like, you know, as part of this, part of sort of the routine, I was like, I'm going to set
00:57:00 an alarm and I'm just going to wake up really early every morning intentionally. I don't have
00:57:05 to. I could just wake up and drag myself through the morning and just be kind of like killing another 0.95
00:57:11 day. But one of the things I wanted to do was just decide to be like, just deliberate. It's like,
00:57:17 I can't be deliberate about where I'm spending the time. Like I have to spend the time here,
00:57:21 but I want to be deliberate about the order that I have in that. I don't know if you read
00:57:27 anything about Hurricane Carter. He was this- Yeah, Reuben Hurricane Carter. I know his story
00:57:32 very well. Yeah. My brother actually met him. Really? I think he's a fascinating person,
00:57:38 sort of wrongfully accused, spends decades in prison for this triple homicide that
00:57:41 almost certainly did not commit. And one of the things I remember reading about him doing,
00:57:47 just as a more extreme way of what we're talking about, he was like, okay, I'm physically in prison.
00:57:51 That's not my call. He's like, but I am going to rebel in every other way that I can. He's like,
00:57:57 I'm going to be awake at night and sleep during the day. I'm going to wear my uniform this way or
00:58:02 that way. I'm not going to ask for this favor or that favor. He decided that how he was going to
00:58:07 wrap his head around the lack of control that he had was he was going to assert control in other ways.
00:58:14 And I think that's an interesting approach that might be worth thinking about for people. So
00:58:17 how can you find some ways to assert agency in the midst of all of this powerlessness?
00:58:24 And I think you'll find that that's really reassuring.
00:58:28 I like that idea a lot. I mean, those of us with kids, I think are naturally in a point where we're
00:58:33 still getting up at the same time and things. But when you wake up making your bed first thing in the
00:58:39 morning, these things sound stupid and trivial, but I agree with that. I think having a schedule 0.98
00:58:44 allows you to maintain some control over something. Exercise to me is also a really big one.
00:58:50 I think obviously for most people, it's harder to exercise now because for most of us, it's going to
00:58:57 the gym that is exercise, which has now been taken away. But there are tons of great apps out there
00:59:03 that are basically saying, look, here's how we're going to modify this. And here's what you could do
00:59:08 with limited equipment, or here's what you could do with simply only your body weight. And to simply
00:59:14 take 20 minutes a day and do that, no matter what, and say, hey, look at 10 o'clock this morning,
00:59:19 I am absolutely doing my app-based workout. Even if worst case scenario, that's a day that I just
00:59:25 can't get out there and take a walk for whatever reason. It's hard to imagine not being able to make
00:59:30 20 minutes to do that. And yet it's much easier to spend that extra 20 minutes tooling around on Netflix
00:59:36 or YouTube. And yet the dividends of that 20 minutes are huge, not just sort of physiologically,
00:59:42 but I think psychologically. And I think, I mean, I hate the word spiritual because I'm not really,
00:59:47 but I think you know what I mean when I say spiritually as well.
00:59:50 No, no, I think that's right. My wife likes future, which is like a sort of remote. You have a personal
00:59:55 trainer that gives you a workout every day, but you don't actually see them and they design it based
01:00:00 on what you have in your house. I hope it drives people towards some of the more sort of
01:00:06 solo endurance sports too, because I think there's all sorts of psychological and philosophical
01:00:12 benefits to distance running or distance bike riding or swimming, if there's some way that
01:00:17 you could do it. Unfortunately, I haven't found a way to do swimming since this has all happened.
01:00:23 There's no real like rivers or lakes that are available at the moment or oceans. But I think
01:00:28 realizing like, oh, just sort of practicing that muscle of like, I'm going to tell my body what it's
01:00:34 going to do, I think is probably as important or relevant as ever in this moment. And I like,
01:00:40 yeah, in New York, the one or two exceptions to the quarantine is like going outside for your
01:00:46 physical or mental health. You've got to take advantage of that. And when we're talking about
01:00:51 sort of a lifetime dead time, like what good can come out of this, you were saying like a lot of
01:00:55 people are sort of already on a schedule with kids. We were always on a schedule with our kids,
01:00:59 like they had to go to school at a certain time, but we just sort of always had sleep training was
01:01:03 really tough for us. We made a lot of allowances. We sort of just leaned into the chaos of it a
01:01:08 little bit. There wasn't a ton of structure. What we use this for was a chance to really force that
01:01:14 and practice it. And I would say like, it's weird. We're just experiencing. So it's crazy and
01:01:20 disrupted as our lives are in some respects. In other respects, the machine is operating more smoothly
01:01:26 than ever. We're doing the same things every day, eating better. Bedtime is more on the dot.
01:01:33 And so again, no one would say like, hey, the global pandemic is now a positive because I've got
01:01:40 a better routine at home. That's cold comfort. But you can find redeeming qualities inside of the
01:01:48 shit sandwich, so to speak. You can say, hey, you write off the losses as a sunk cost, 0.99
01:01:53 but where you're able to find some good is that you made these marginal improvements across a
01:01:59 bunch of aspects of your life that will hopefully last longer than however long this goes on.
01:02:05 Ryan, how has your journaling changed in the past couple of weeks? You're a prolific journalist.
01:02:11 Well, journaler, I don't know what the word is there when you-
01:02:13 Yes. I guess journaler, yeah.
01:02:16 Yeah, yeah, journaler. Have you noticed anything in your journaling of late that maybe wasn't there
01:02:22 prior? Yeah, journaling is weird for me too, because my writing is also an outlet where I
01:02:28 get to work out a lot of thoughts. So I really have just felt on fire as a writer recently. I'm
01:02:33 currently researching some books, but I'm not writing for any book projects. So I found that
01:02:39 the Daily Stoic email that I do every day and Daily Dad, I've just been in the zone,
01:02:43 more productive than usual. It's better than usual. So I've really felt good about that.
01:02:48 For journaling, I've felt I'm really trying to think about, I'm really trying to use it as a
01:02:55 place to sort of remind myself and reiterate to myself how I want to be inside this. Sort of
01:03:02 reminders of, hey, you're worried about X, Y, and Z. One way not to think about that is to think about
01:03:08 other people instead. So I'm trying to just sort of buck myself up a little bit in the morning,
01:03:13 kind of remind myself of what's important to me. I'm trying to use it. Again, I think journaling is
01:03:19 not just this stream of conscious sort of thing you're doing. It's not performing for history.
01:03:25 To me, it should be, it's like playing scales on the guitar or on the piano. You're running yourself
01:03:32 through it over and over again so that it gets more imputed into your memory and kind of into your
01:03:38 being. Yeah, it sort of makes sense. Again, I think you get to write every day for those of us
01:03:47 who don't or when we're writing, like for me, I'm writing all the time, but it's usually kind of
01:03:51 technical stuff. This outlet has become something that I think is a, I don't know, I'll tell you what
01:03:58 brought it to my mind recently. So when maybe about three weeks ago when we sort of pulled our
01:04:05 kids out of school and just decided we were going to do something that at the time seemed outrageous,
01:04:10 but basically play the lesser of two risks, my daughter was like, this is crazy. There's no way
01:04:16 I'm not going to be able to go out and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And I was like, Olivia,
01:04:21 what do you think about Anne Frank? And of course she didn't know who Anne Frank was. So I was like,
01:04:25 all right, well, I want you to tell me by the end of today who Anne Frank is and let's talk about her.
01:04:29 So of course she goes about, read about her and stuff. But the interesting thing is my daughter
01:04:33 didn't know what an attic was. I said, Olivia, do you want to come see our attic? She goes,
01:04:39 we have one? I said, oh yes, we do, honey buns. So I got the ladder out, took her in the closet, 0.60
01:04:45 took her up to the attic. I mean, she just about had a cow. She couldn't believe how small and
01:04:51 miserable the attic was. And that this girl spent years up in an attic writing this journal.
01:04:56 With another family.
01:04:57 Yeah. Yeah. And like you read what she wrote in her journals and it's unbelievable. You cannot
01:05:03 believe a child could have written this. You can't believe how she could turn to that journal and say,
01:05:10 you are my best friend. You are the person to whom I can say all these things. I mean,
01:05:14 it's just, it's unbelievable. And again, it just, I don't say that to sort of begrudge the way we've
01:05:19 raised our daughter to not appreciate how good she has it relative to a girl growing up in the second 0.99
01:05:24 world war, but it is a little bit of a phase shift. And it just brought back to my mind a few
01:05:30 weeks ago, how powerful this tool can be. And it brought me back to our first discussion actually
01:05:36 about it. Yeah. It would be difficult to be a 13 year old girl at any time. And then to be a 13
01:05:42 year old girl in an attic in a country you're not from, right? Cause she'd already fled Germany to 0.93
01:05:48 the Netherlands. Then you're trapped in this attic with another family. It would have been horrendous. 0.99
01:05:54 And her journal is so good that it's actually something like Holocaust deniers use. They're
01:05:59 like, it's impossible that a 16 year old girl could have written it, but she was just a precocious,
01:06:05 brilliant girl. And what I think is interesting is that she wrote that journal partly inspired.
01:06:11 I think it was the queen of the Netherlands wrote, put out a call over the BBC saying like, Hey,
01:06:18 we're eventually going to get through this. We want your help. Please keep a record of what you're
01:06:24 experiencing and doing. And so that idea of finding purpose in something that you're doing,
01:06:31 even if she had no idea the impact that her journal would actually ultimately have, she had no idea that
01:06:36 it would be sort of final legacy, that it would be the sole sort of creative work that she'd be allowed
01:06:42 to do, which is all tragic and totally unfair. But I'm sure that because she not only wrote the
01:06:48 journal, but then she would go back and revisit the journal and she clearly edited it and she
01:06:53 responded to parts and she organized it. It was a project. And so I think that is something we're
01:07:00 thinking about with our kids is just what goals or things can we give them to throw themselves into
01:07:08 that allows them to sort of escape from this in a little bit. And I don't think that's terrible
01:07:14 advice for adults either. So what's a PR you're going to try to make in your deadlift if you have
01:07:19 weight rack at home? Are you and your wife going to try to lose five pounds? Are you going to try
01:07:24 intermittent fasting? Are you going to try to read the entire Harry Potter series as a family?
01:07:30 You can create things to throw yourself into that allow you to feel some momentum and
01:07:37 accomplishment and purpose. And if I knew how to do this, it'd be something I was doing.
01:07:42 But like, you know, just the people that are making masks right now. I mean, that's to me,
01:07:46 another great example of trying to find where you can contribute and where good can be done
01:07:53 rather than wallowing in your resentment or anger or boredom.
01:07:57 You're generally a pretty disciplined guy when it comes to social media. Have you created any new
01:08:03 rituals or routines around avoiding it or selectively utilizing it for some benefit but not getting
01:08:10 sucked into it?
01:08:12 Yeah. So I don't check Twitter because I've found that it sort of triggers me the most.
01:08:16 And I don't have Instagram on my phone and I don't check Facebook either. So I've been sort of
01:08:22 very actively not using those platforms. At the same time, I have been sort of stepping up
01:08:28 what I put out on those platforms. So I've been starting to do sort of lists of things or explaining
01:08:35 stoic topics on the different media. I've been enjoying the creative element of them, but trying
01:08:41 to distance myself or protect myself from the, let's call it the sort of manipulative and anxiety
01:08:51 inducing sort of characteristics of social media.
01:08:54 Yeah. What are you most optimistic about in the next couple of months? And what are you most
01:09:00 concerned about in the next couple of months? And that can be either about you personally and your
01:09:05 family or just broadly your fellow citizens.
01:09:09 I mean, upside, I hope this redefines the role of the president for a lot of people. Hopefully this
01:09:15 redefines the importance of a lot of the alliances and relationships internationally that we have with
01:09:21 a lot of different countries. And those things were, people were, Trump was not wrong in sort of
01:09:28 questioning some of them, but also sensing that the public wasn't that possessive of them. Hopefully
01:09:35 this redefines internationally how we operate in just our understanding of China, our relationship
01:09:42 to other countries. I'll say like, I'm very glad that for Daily Stoic, all of our products we
01:09:47 manufacture in the United States, because it has dramatically protected our supply lines and
01:09:54 allowed us to have inventory on hand. It's allowed us to keep the lights on in the business. It's
01:09:58 allowed us to connect with and sort of work more collaboratively with the people we work with.
01:10:04 I wish that maybe some of the stuff was even closer to home. Like I wish I had even more oversight
01:10:09 or control. I think positively, I think this is a wake-up call in a lot of ways. I think it sort of
01:10:15 knocked people out of the stupor or the slumber that we're in. I hope that's a positive. Tyler
01:10:21 Cowen wrote an article, and I think he's crushing it, by the way. Anyone who's looking for smart stuff,
01:10:26 I think Marginal Revolution and Tyler Cowen is putting out awesome stuff, as always. But he was
01:10:32 saying he thinks the pandemic has killed the sort of progressive woke left, that it sort of woke us up,
01:10:39 like why are we arguing about transgender bathrooms and neglecting this or that? Why are we fighting
01:10:45 about cultural appropriation and not sort of coming together on things that matter? Why are we talking
01:10:51 about healthcare for illegal immigrants and not, do we have enough ventilators in emergency rooms?
01:10:58 At the same time, I think one worry would be actually it doesn't kill the sort of revolutionary
01:11:04 extremes on either end of the party, but they seize upon the wreckage that emerges from this and are
01:11:12 actually empowered. That's something I'm worried about. And I think a little bit selfishly, but I
01:11:16 also think it's going to have big ramifications. I'm a millennial sort of smack in the middle of the
01:11:22 millennial generation. My generation, 9-11, catastrophic wars in the Middle East, which wasted trillions of
01:11:31 dollars, the financial crisis, the financial crisis, and now whatever we're going to call this financial
01:11:36 crisis. I mean, it is a betrayal of one generation to the next generation that I'm not... We talk about
01:11:44 the lost generation in the 1920s. I mean, people I know were just getting their shit together. They just 0.98
01:11:53 bought their first house in already expensive markets. They just started putting money away for their
01:11:59 retirement. They were just recovering from the last time the world was melted down by irresponsible
01:12:07 adults. And boom, it just fucking happened again. I'm going to be okay, at least right now, but I'm 1.00
01:12:14 certainly not so okay that I'm not thinking about, yeah, what does it look like? What does it do to
01:12:19 Medicare and Medicaid and Social Security that even the people that survive this are going to have
01:12:25 long-term health damages? What does it do that people who are about to retire just watched years
01:12:31 of their gains evaporating? If there's anything I'm worried about, it's actually more the economic
01:12:35 than the medical. Yeah, I don't disagree with that. What are you worried about? I think in the short
01:12:42 term, I'm certainly worried about a handful of geographies that I don't think under non-optimistic
01:12:50 scenarios will have this supply to meet the ICU demand. So I think New York is very likely going
01:12:59 to be overrun. And I think that that's obviously disconcerting because it puts doctors in a position
01:13:05 that I don't think anybody ever signed up for when they went to medical school, which is, and again,
01:13:10 it's something that's so foreign to us in the United States, but it's not foreign to doctors outside of
01:13:15 the United States, which is the truest form of triage. How do you look at two people that if you
01:13:20 had endless resources, you could probably save both, but in a situation where you don't have
01:13:25 endless resources, you have to prioritize one over the other. There's no, you didn't take a class in
01:13:31 that. And even if you did, it wouldn't have helped much. I'm just, I guess I'm glad I'll never have to
01:13:36 make that decision, I suppose. But a bunch of people might have to make those decisions. And that's,
01:13:40 I find that very, I find that frustrating through the lens that we've discussed, which is a little
01:13:47 bit more preparation, not a lot, believe it or not, but a little bit more preparation could have
01:13:52 thwarted that. I think the economic consequences of this are, as you said, at least as staggering,
01:13:59 if not more staggering than what comes of it, though, again, it's still so unclear what is coming of
01:14:05 this. And unfortunately you can make a model say anything. And that's a little frustrating because
01:14:11 there's models out, you can basically find a model that will say whatever you want it to say. So
01:14:16 that's not entirely helpful, but, but there are scenarios under which this thing is a problem that
01:14:22 could on the one end result in a million deaths in the United States, which would be enormous,
01:14:28 right? That would be a third of the total. That's like basically adding a third or 30% more deaths
01:14:35 to the all cause mortality we experienced. That's hard to fathom through this lens at the other end
01:14:41 of the spectrum. This could end up being a small fraction of that. It could be, it could end up
01:14:46 being the same number of deaths that you would get from influenza. Again, I don't think either of those
01:14:51 extremes, by the way, are what's going to happen, but they could. And in the latter case, it would be,
01:14:58 boy, that was, we paid an enormous economic price for that. You bring up an example of
01:15:04 comparing this to the 2008 recession. Well, it's going to look and feel a bit different.
01:15:09 And that scares me a little because I don't think we have a playbook for this one. Maybe it's not as
01:15:16 necessary. I mean, the, you know, as of when we're recording this, the federal government has
01:15:21 announced basically a $6 trillion stimulus package of which 2 trillion is in hard assets and 4 trillion of
01:15:29 that probably less so. But that's so much money. And it gets to the point you raised earlier, which is
01:15:35 unless you can keep interest rates at zero, the debt service on debt we've accumulated over the past
01:15:42 18 years is unbelievable. And I've asked people that I think are some of the smartest people on
01:15:50 earth when it comes to fiscal policy. I just asked them point blank, tell me what we do when we can't
01:15:57 pay our debt. Tell me what it means for the United States to default on its debt. Those things are
01:16:02 troubling. So all of that said, I still come back to something which Sam Harris and I talked about a few
01:16:09 days ago on the podcast, which was, it's okay that those things are upsetting and it's okay that I can
01:16:16 worry about them a little bit. I'm trying to check myself to make sure I'm not worrying about them at
01:16:21 the point where it ceases to be productive. Worry is only productive when it motivates me to do
01:16:26 something. And at this point, I'm pretty freaking motivated to do something. I'm doing everything
01:16:33 I can with my little narrow band of skillset to do everything I can. And therefore I realized that
01:16:40 there is little to be found in worry. And so what I've been doing is making a point to spend time
01:16:47 with my wife and kids every day and reiterate to them how happy I am to be home with them.
01:16:52 And in part, that's just telling myself that as well. It's sort of trying to combat that anxiety that
01:16:59 still slips into me, especially when I'm sleeping, frankly, and my dreams are pretty,
01:17:05 pretty distressing, but I'm just trying to basically curb the worry and focus on what's
01:17:12 here and what's here at the moment. And believe it or not, I've actually had weird thoughts, which is
01:17:16 when this thing's over and I have to get on a plane and go back to New York, I don't think I'm
01:17:20 going to look forward to it that much, not because of New York, but because it's like,
01:17:23 yeah, back to traveling again. Yeah, no, this could be a new normal that we appreciate more.
01:17:28 Maybe we all were flying more than we needed to be and working more than we needed to be.
01:17:33 And yeah, saying yes to things we didn't need to know about because we'd never sort of been fully
01:17:40 forced to appreciate what home and life was. And to me, yeah, that is a positive that emerges from
01:17:47 it. Again, not worth trading a million lives, but certainly a positive we can sort of pull from the
01:17:54 wreckage of this. Yeah. Well, Ryan, I made a plug for it in the past that I'm going to do so again if I
01:18:00 was very bullish on people becoming daily subscribers to the Daily Stoic. I'm even more
01:18:09 so today. What's the best way that people can sign up for that if they haven't done so?
01:18:13 Yeah, you can sign up at dailystoic.com or dailystoic.com slash email. And then the other
01:18:19 one I do every day that I've actually been liking just as much as Daily Dad, which is dailydad.com.
01:18:24 And people can follow you how on Twitter?
01:18:29 Yeah, I'm at Ryan Holiday and then also at Daily Stoic if you want a piece of stoic wisdom every day
01:18:35 as well.
01:18:36 Okay. Any of your books at this moment you think people should go back and reread or read for the
01:18:43 first time?
01:18:44 Yeah, I mean, I think Obstacle is the Way is probably particularly well suited if you're, 0.96
01:18:48 especially if you've sort of been knocked on your ass here and you're trying to figure out 0.95
01:18:52 what next. That's what that book is sort of designed to try to tackle. And then if you're 0.97
01:18:58 maybe more like you and I are and some of the things you and I were talking about are just the
01:19:02 stress and anxiety and worry and calming that kind of racing part of your mind,
01:19:08 Stillness is the Key is the most recent book. And that one sort of talks about a lot of things we
01:19:13 were talking about today.
01:19:14 Well, Ryan, thank you for making time today to talk and thank you for sharing your insights.
01:19:19 They mean a lot to me personally and I think they're going to mean a lot to folks listening.
01:19:23 Oh, I appreciate that. No, this was fun. And again, by the way, this is a, I don't know about
01:19:27 you, but I didn't think my mind was not racing. I wasn't distracted. I wasn't catastrophizing
01:19:32 because we spent an hour and a half actually engaged with each other. And I think not everyone
01:19:38 has a podcast, but one way to calm that racing mind is to go have a real long conversation
01:19:43 with a human being. And I think you'll be surprised at both what you find and then how much you get
01:19:49 out of that experience. Yeah. I think that's a great point. Connectivity matters.
01:19:54 Yes. All right, Ryan, best of luck rested today.
01:19:58 Thanks. Appreciate it.
01:20:00 Thank you for listening to this week's episode of The Drive. If you're interested in diving deeper
01:20:04 into any topics we discuss, we've created a membership program that allows us to bring you more
01:20:09 in-depth exclusive content without relying on paid ads. It's our goal to ensure members get back
01:20:15 much more than the price of the subscription. Now to that end, membership benefits include a bunch of
01:20:20 things. One, totally kick-ass comprehensive podcast show notes that detail every topic, paper, person,
01:20:26 thing we discuss on each episode. The word on the street is nobody's show notes rival these.
01:20:32 Monthly AMA episodes or ask me anything episodes, hearing these episodes completely.
01:20:36 Access to our private podcast feed that allows you to hear everything without having to listen
01:20:42 to spiels like this. The Qualies, which are a super short podcast, typically less than five minutes
01:20:48 that we release every Tuesday through Friday, highlighting the best questions, topics, and
01:20:52 tactics discussed on previous episodes of The Drive. This is a great way to catch up on previous
01:20:57 episodes without having to go back and necessarily listen to everyone. Steep discounts on products that I
01:21:03 believe in, but for which I'm not getting paid to endorse, and a whole bunch of other benefits that
01:21:08 we continue to trickle in as time goes on. If you want to learn more and access these member-only
01:21:12 benefits, you can head over to peteratiamd.com forward slash subscribe. You can find me on Twitter,
01:21:19 Instagram, and Facebook, all with the ID, peteratiamd. You can also leave us a review on Apple
01:21:25 Podcasts or whatever podcast player you listen on. This podcast is for general informational purposes
01:21:31 only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing, or other professional healthcare
01:21:36 services, including the giving of medical advice. No doctor-patient relationship is formed. The use
01:21:42 of this information and the materials linked to this podcast is at the user's own risk. The content on
01:21:48 this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
01:21:55 Users should not disregard or delay in obtaining medical advice from any medical condition
01:22:01 they have, and they should seek the assistance of their healthcare professionals for any such
01:22:06 conditions. Finally, I take conflicts of interest very seriously. For all of my disclosures and the
01:22:11 companies I invest in or advise, please visit peteratiamd.com forward slash about where I keep an up-to-date
01:22:20 an active list of such companies.
01:22:50 Thank you.