The Peter Attia Drive - January 11, 2021


#144 - Phil Maffetone: Optimizing health and performance through maximal aerobic function

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
#143 - John Ioannidis, M.D., D.Sc.: Why most biomedical research is flawed, and how to improve it #145 - AMA #19: Deep dive on Zone 2 training, magnesium supplementation, and how to engage with your doctor

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 22 minutes

Words per minute

164.19

Word count

13,520

Sentence count

877

Harmful content

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Phil Maffetone is an author, a coach, and a health practitioner. He wears many hats, and many of you will probably recognize him as he has written a number of books, the eighties, the nineties, and today, covering a variety of aspects of exercise, sports medicine, biofeedback, nutrition, and more. In this episode, we talk about his journey, how he became interested in this, both as an athlete, and then ultimately as a coach. And we get into what is maximal aerobic function, and what it means for performance and health.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey, everyone. Welcome to the drive podcast. I'm your host, Peter Atiyah. This podcast,
00:00:15 my website, and my weekly newsletter all focus on the goal of translating the science of longevity
00:00:19 into something accessible for everyone. Our goal is to provide the best content in health
00:00:24 and wellness, full stop. And we've assembled a great team of analysts to make this happen.
00:00:28 If you enjoy this podcast, we've created a membership program that brings you far more
00:00:33 in-depth content. If you want to take your knowledge of the space to the next level at
00:00:37 the end of this episode, I'll explain what those benefits are. Or if you want to learn more now,
00:00:41 head over to peteratiyahmd.com forward slash subscribe. Now, without further delay,
00:00:47 here's today's episode. I guess this week is Phil Maffetone. Phil is an author, a coach,
00:00:55 health practitioner. He wears many hats and many of you will probably recognize him as he's written
00:01:00 a number of books, the eighties, nineties, and today, basically covering a number of aspects
00:01:06 of exercise, sports medicine, biofeedback, nutrition. I first probably came across Phil's
00:01:12 work when I was in college and I was interested in aerobic training, trying to improve my cycling
00:01:17 performance at the time and became pretty interested in the way he was advocating for a very low intensity
00:01:23 relative to what I was doing approach, which of course today in hindsight seems to be quite the
00:01:28 logical thing to do. Phil's background is in biology. He has a doctorate in chiropractic and
00:01:34 he also has trained in Chinese medicine and kinesiology. He was in private practice for about
00:01:40 two decades and he's now a consultant along with continuing to write, doing independent research
00:01:45 and lecturing. In this episode, we talk about his journey, you know, how he became interested in this,
00:01:49 both as an athlete himself and then ultimately as a coach, we get into what is maximal aerobic
00:01:54 function. And this overlaps very closely. In fact, you could argue this is a very similar way to
00:02:00 describe zone two, something we speak about in a previous podcast, but coming at it through a sort
00:02:05 of different lens and using heart rate as opposed to lactate to measure it. We get into the importance
00:02:13 of fuel partitioning. In addition to different levels of intensity, we talk a little bit about
00:02:18 marathon times and how they've changed over time and what that probably tells us about training. So
00:02:23 I hope you'll enjoy this episode and without further delay, please enjoy my conversation with Phil
00:02:28 Mavito.
00:02:34 All right, Phil, thanks so much for making time so late in your day. You're in, where are you? Are you
00:02:39 in Portugal right now?
00:02:40 I'm in Lisbon, Portugal. And you know, they don't have dinner here till nine or 10 at night,
00:02:45 which I usually skip. So it's just past lunch for me. It's great to be with you. So thanks, Peter,
00:02:52 for having me.
00:02:54 Well, I've been wanting to speak with you for quite some time. And we've got a lot of listeners who
00:02:58 have been excited about getting you on. A lot of questions have come about. We've talked a lot about
00:03:03 aerobic efficiency on this podcast because obviously it's such an important part of delaying the aging
00:03:10 process. So even if you take it out of the context of performance, I think today we'll sort of talk
00:03:16 about both of these things, sort of performance and health. But it's obviously something that you've
00:03:21 been working on for such a long time. It's been kind of central to the work you've done. But I kind
00:03:26 of want to go back and give folks a bit of a sense of how you cut your teeth on this stuff. So
00:03:31 you're obviously an avid runner yourself, correct?
00:03:34 I've been running since, yeah, since high school, I guess. And from track and field in high school
00:03:40 and college. And then when I got out and into practice, I thought, you know, this road running
00:03:47 stuff looks interesting. I'm starting to see patients. Let me see what's going on. And I, you know,
00:03:54 I jumped into a 5K and it was a complete disaster because I was a track runner. And what do we know
00:04:01 about distance? And gradually I progressed to the marathon. I trained for a six-day running race
00:04:08 on a track because I had been working with some ultra runners, Stu Middleman in particular.
00:04:14 And it looked like such an exciting event. I thought this, you know, I'm going to do this.
00:04:20 Then I can, you know, my bio could read, I've run everything from 200 meters to six days.
00:04:25 I thought that was cool. Of course, I was, by that time, I was so busy with, with treating other
00:04:31 athletes that I was just not able to get the time on the training. All the training was on a track
00:04:38 because the race was on a track. Yeah. Tell people what a six-day race is.
00:04:43 Yeah. A six-day race is a running race where you run on the track and the person who accumulates the
00:04:49 most miles or kilometers is the winner. You can run as you please. You can start and stop anytime.
00:04:57 You can sleep if you want. If you can stay awake, good luck. And I, I trained some people and it was
00:05:04 for me, a fascinating thing. Clinically, it was really akin to having a, a mouse in a lab where you,
00:05:13 you know, you do something to this mouse and then you put them back in the cage and have them run on the,
00:05:18 on the wheel for a while. And then you take them out and you do something else, measure something.
00:05:24 And, you know, it was such a great learning experience for me. And it was a great opportunity
00:05:30 to really hone my skills of observation in terms of gait and talking to an athlete, finding out when
00:05:39 they really were tired, unlike what they said. It was just so many really fascinating things. And then
00:05:45 the idea of doing the race seemed quite interesting. And I just ran out of training time.
00:05:51 And so what is the ideal strategy in my mind right now, I'm going through multiple ideas for how one
00:05:57 could approach a six day race. And, you know, one idea that comes to mind is you simply walk 18 hours
00:06:05 a day and sleep six hours a day, or, you know, you walk 20, sleep four and never put yourself under
00:06:11 incredible duress, but also never go too fast. The sort of slow and steady wins the race approach.
00:06:18 And then alternatively, you can see something crazy where you, you know, actually take out a
00:06:22 reasonable clip and run for, you know, an hour and take an hour off. But of course, in that scenario,
00:06:28 you don't really get a full recovery. So what did you discover was the optimal scenario for covering
00:06:33 the most amount of ground in six days? What I discovered was you, you start the race by walking.
00:06:41 And now you're the only runner who's walking. The gun goes off, everybody starts running,
00:06:48 you're left walking. And that was always a kind of a comical scene for me. And the runners I worked
00:06:54 with, Stu Middleman in particular, who has the, maybe still has the American record for that distance.
00:07:00 They were a little embarrassed in the beginning, but the strategy was to start slow, gradually run
00:07:07 faster, start jogging, gradually hit a certain plateau using the heart rate, that maximum aerobic
00:07:16 heart rate that we can talk about at some point. So very easy, relatively easy, relatively low heart
00:07:23 rate. And then now you're two hours into the first run, maybe three hours, and then you start cooling
00:07:30 down. And you take a half an hour to cool down, basically just the opposite of what you did in
00:07:35 the beginning. And now you can get off the track and take a very short break and then get back on
00:07:41 the track and do the same thing. And that segment would sometimes be elongated in the beginning in
00:07:48 particular, because people are kind of jittery and they want to do something. Taking a break is not
00:07:53 something they want to do. And so there's no hard running. Certainly there's no high heart rate,
00:07:59 high intensity training. You do see that in other athletes. And that's how the days go by. That's it.
00:08:08 So you spend a fair amount of time walking. And with Stu in particular, as an example, Stu really liked
00:08:16 the idea of going for 36 hours without sleep. And I said, okay, let's try it. And it worked out well.
00:08:25 So we did that. And then we took a longer break before getting back into a 24 hour cycle. I'll tell
00:08:31 you the interesting thing for me is that it was exhausting for me, because I really had to be awake
00:08:40 longer than, than he did because I couldn't sleep when he slept because we had a specific time frame
00:08:47 for him to sleep sometimes as short as seven minutes. And I needed to be awake when he was
00:08:53 waking up because sometimes he didn't know where he was. And so for me, it was quite a stress. It was
00:08:59 quite, I mean, the circuit, you know, you're interfering with your circadian rhythm so much that
00:09:03 you could literally hallucinate after day four by day five potentially. And I've, I've done that.
00:09:12 So it's a very different kind of event than most runners have ever experienced.
00:09:17 Yeah. It sounds a lot like Ram, the race across America in cycling, which I interviewed a guy named
00:09:23 Mike Trevino a while ago, who has done Ram a number of times and his stories are very similar to that.
00:09:29 And again, very different strategies that many cyclists will take, but there's nobody at the
00:09:34 end of that. That's not in a significant world of pain and the hallucinations can lead to crashes
00:09:40 and all sorts of crazy things. And it's pretty high stakes racing. It's a obvious indication of
00:09:46 significant brain stress, but I think the key is to like with everything else, individualize it with
00:09:53 your athlete. And like I said, Stu had this idea that he wanted to go for 36 hours, which we had
00:09:59 talked about a lot beforehand. And that became part of the strategy because that's something that he
00:10:04 wanted to do. And the way we did, it seemed like we weren't going to sacrifice his health much. And so
00:10:11 it was okay for me. And I think in, in whether you're on a bike or running or whatever you, you,
00:10:18 you need to, as a coach, as a clinician. And in that kind of race, I served as a clinician because
00:10:24 I did things like biofeedback, neuromuscular biofeedback. Obviously there's significant
00:10:31 stress in that area of the body. You still want to allow the athlete to voice, you know, how they
00:10:38 would like to do this race. And then you want to voice how you think it should be done. You come to some 0.98
00:10:42 meeting of the minds. But for me, it was always, I'm not willing to sacrifice the health of this
00:10:51 athlete because that's, that's against what I do as a clinician. As a coach, I want him to perform
00:10:58 his best. And he was running about a hundred miles a day for six days. That's, that's not a bad
00:11:03 performance. Wow. At what point did your thinking start to transition from the training of peak
00:11:11 athletes to sort of a broader set of metrics or parameters that could be applicable to health?
00:11:19 Or did that not occur in sort of the fashion I've sort of described it?
00:11:24 It occurred the opposite way. I always loved sports. I loved sports myself. I competed at a very high
00:11:31 level. I played other sports and in undergraduate school, my goal was, Hey, I want to study and get out
00:11:39 into the world. And my goal is to help people. It was, my goal was to help people with their health.
00:11:47 And I knew there was this fitness thing and I wasn't sure how it goes together, but I, I, I didn't
00:11:52 focus it. The athlete component was not really there. And in those early, early days, when I got into
00:12:01 practice and started seeing athletes who were injured, they were local athletes who were,
00:12:05 you know, they were, they were five, 10 K runners, half marathon runners. Some of them were marathoners.
00:12:11 You know, this was the, the boom in the seventies. And there were a lot of patients because there were
00:12:19 a lot of injuries. And so my focus was, why are they getting injured? And I would gradually see
00:12:26 better and better athletes locally. That led to two things. One, some of those athletes got really good
00:12:33 and attained a national class level. And, and then they referred people that they knew who were
00:12:39 professionals. And I started seeing pro athletes who were in running, of course, because that was the
00:12:46 big thing back then. But there was this thing on the West coast called the triathlon, which just
00:12:52 fascinated me to death because I was a swimmer and I was a cyclist and a runner. And to have three events
00:12:59 to work with was just, it was exciting. And I started seeing some local people who were,
00:13:07 you know, I was in the New York city area. So I was on the East coast where it took a while for the
00:13:12 word of triathlon to get there. And when it did, there were some athletes and that was a lot of fun as
00:13:18 well. So this is now sort of late seventies, right? When the triathlon movement starting in Hawaii,
00:13:26 kind of migrating over to California and the West coast.
00:13:29 Yep. And it was still new. It was crazy. And all we, all we really knew about it were these,
00:13:35 these three guys in a bar who were arguing about who's the better athlete, the swimmer,
00:13:41 the cyclist or the runner. And, you know, blah, and that, I don't know how accurate that story is,
00:13:45 but supposedly that's, that's how the event started. And interestingly enough, early on,
00:13:51 there was a double Ironman. I worked with somebody who did that, but yeah, that was late seventies and
00:13:58 then into the eighties. And by then I was seeing some professionals in most sports by then, certainly
00:14:04 by the, by the mid eighties, I had seen professionals in all sports. And by the mid eighties, what fraction
00:14:11 of your practice is professional athletes or athletes competing at a very high level versus normal
00:14:18 people who are coming to you saying I'm overweight or I have diabetes or something like that?
00:14:25 Gosh, I have to, you know, by then my clinic was so busy. I was taking on associates. So I had other
00:14:31 doctors in the clinic. You know, my goal was for them to treat the local patients I had because I was
00:14:39 now starting to travel with athletes, which I hadn't, hadn't done. Mark Allen was a patient of mine by that
00:14:45 point. And I think it was 83. I had been doing some sports clinics on the road in various cities. San
00:14:54 Diego was one. And that's where I first met Mark and Paul and Newby Frazier and some of those other
00:15:00 folks who were just getting going. And so by the mid eighties, I was on the road a lot. And certainly
00:15:08 by the mid eighties, I was in Boulder every summer because that's where a lot of athletes went.
00:15:15 And so I went there. So by that point, most of the patients I had were competitive athletes who I
00:15:22 was working one-on-one with. And I was doing a lot of lecturing, starting to do a lot of writing as
00:15:29 well. So at what point did you sort of, I would say, congeal the idea that said, Hey, we need to train
00:15:38 at a lower level of intensity for longer periods of time. You know, we're going to get into obviously
00:15:44 the methodology, but I want to talk even broader than that, which is, did you look at athletes and
00:15:51 say, wait a minute, something is a muck here. These people are training too much or either, either
00:15:57 volume is too high or intensity is too high, but something is off and we need to do something that's
00:16:02 sort of counterintuitive, which is dial this back in one or both of those metrics. Was there,
00:16:07 did you sort of see that in the eighties? Oh, I saw it before the eighties. I saw it quite early
00:16:13 because I was seeing these people who were, were able to run a marathon in whatever time. And that was
00:16:19 like, wow, this guy could run a marathon. What an example of optimal health. Well, it wasn't because
00:16:27 they were broken down. They were getting sick. You may remember, I mean, back then, you know,
00:16:33 it was a badge of courage to have a high white blood count because you are a runner. And I, I started
00:16:40 putting all these things together and it was pretty clear that something wasn't right. Cooper's aerobic
00:16:46 revolution was not, something wasn't working. You don't just go out and train and everything falls into
00:16:52 place. These people were falling apart. So that, that was in the seventies when I started seeing
00:16:58 that. And I was having a hard time understanding that relationship between being healthy and being
00:17:03 fit. And when I ran the, the New York city marathon in 1980, and I crossed the finish line,
00:17:09 it just hit me. These athletes are fit, but unhealthy. And that whole concept of fit, but unhealthy
00:17:15 and fitness and health are two separate definitions and they need to be balanced. Whether you're
00:17:22 a grandmother who goes out for a walk four or five times a week, or you're training for the race of 0.99
00:17:30 your life as a professional, it's all the same. And many of the things that I developed, like the,
00:17:36 the MAF tests, for example, were never meant for athletes. They were meant for the average person,
00:17:41 because I thought whatever we're doing to this person to help them get healthier,
00:17:46 we need an indication, not just a blood test. We don't want to know if they're
00:17:51 blood picture looks better. You want a functional test.
00:17:56 We want a functional test that at the time didn't really exist. And so the functional test for me was
00:18:02 that they were going to be able to walk faster at the same low heart rate than they could a month or
00:18:06 two earlier. And that was, that was the big thing. And then soon after that, I said, Hey, wait a minute,
00:18:12 these guys are running faster now at the same heart rate. And I thought, wow, this is,
00:18:17 this is interesting. Can you give folks an explanation? Let's assume that people aren't
00:18:24 entirely clear on the nomenclature between aerobic and anaerobic fitness. This will allow us to, I
00:18:30 think, more accurately talk about what submaximal means and maximal and all of these things. People
00:18:35 have heard the term VO2 max, but I think it's important to give a bit of a context for where
00:18:41 that'll fit on the spectrum. So can you explain to folks what we mean by aerobic and anaerobic
00:18:46 systems? Yeah. And, and, and I don't want to go into the, the microbe definition, which is where
00:18:53 a lot of us have learned those terms, you know, there are aerobic microbes and anaerobic microbes.
00:19:00 So the anaerobic microbes are without oxygen. And when patients would say, well, I, I want to do some
00:19:07 anaerobic training. I'd say, well, what is, what is that? Is it that, well, what's without oxygen? I said,
00:19:12 you mean you can hold your breath while you're doing the intervals. And so we need a better
00:19:17 definition. And my definition became fat burning was, was associated with aerobic and all of the
00:19:24 factors that are associated with fat burning. So the aerobic muscle fibers and the mitochondria and
00:19:31 the ability to convert fatty acids into energy, into ATP and anaerobic was the glucose side.
00:19:39 And that was simple enough. It wasn't scientific enough, but it was simple enough for what people
00:19:46 needed to understand. And especially when we can come up with a heart rate that says, well, if you
00:19:52 go over this heart rate, you're drifting into that anaerobic state. And if you stay under it,
00:19:57 you're in an aerobic state and therefore you're training your body to burn more fat as an energy
00:20:03 source. And therefore you're going to store less fat and, and you're going to get rid of any excess
00:20:08 fat and so on and so forth. Can you explain to folks what the VO2 max is? Because I want to
00:20:15 spend some time explaining why it's not a great predictor of much, despite the fact that it
00:20:20 certainly produces boasting rights. It produces for sure boasting rights. It's a number that people
00:20:27 talk about. Everybody talks about it and hardly anybody gets tested and almost nobody gets tested
00:20:33 with some regularity so they could do something with the numbers. We can define it academically,
00:20:39 which doesn't tell you much, but it's a test that is, was developed a long time ago. And so there's a
00:20:45 lot of tests around. And the real question is, what does it really mean? And I'm not sure it means a
00:20:53 whole, I didn't do many of those tests. So I, you know, I had an academic education and, and I knew about
00:21:01 VO2 max and I knew about all this traditional stuff, the 220 formula, which I used in the very
00:21:08 beginning, because I thought that was the science of, of exercise physiology and quickly learned it
00:21:16 wasn't. And VO2 max was right there. And, and VO2 max became the tradition. I think it was the
00:21:22 tradition back then. I don't remember when it was first developed. It was by Hill, wasn't it? Back in.
00:21:29 I actually don't know who developed it. The 1920s. But for listeners, I think it's,
00:21:34 it's a relatively straightforward test to administer, provided you have the machinery and
00:21:40 the machinery is complicated because you have to be able to isolate gases very well, specifically
00:21:47 oxygen and carbon dioxide. So the test is normally done on either a treadmill or a stationary bike
00:21:55 where you can control the resistance or the, the load that the athlete is under. The challenge is
00:22:02 creating an airtight seal around their nose and their mouth, because what you're really doing with
00:22:07 the test is you want to measure how much oxygen is coming out of their respiratory system and how much CO2
00:22:17 is coming out because you know, how much is going in. And therefore the difference is the amount of
00:22:24 oxygen consumed. Now, if you're sitting here at rest, you have a VO2, an amount of oxygen that's consumed.
00:22:33 And the purpose of the test is to ramp up the level of exertion until you reach the maximum level
00:22:40 of oxygen consumption. So VO2 max is simply the maximum amount of O2 consumed. And the difference
00:22:48 between a very fit person and a non fit person is the fitter you are, the more oxygen you're able to
00:22:55 consume. And that's basically a function of your muscles. It's what can the muscles do? So I think a
00:23:01 lot of people erroneously think this is a, a test of the heart and lungs, but it's not really a test of
00:23:07 the heart and lungs, right? The lungs is where the gas exchange is happening. The heart is the
00:23:11 circulatory pump. It's really a test of what your muscles can do in terms of utilizing that oxygen.
00:23:17 And to your point, it's how much fat oxidation can happen because that's where you're utilizing the
00:23:24 oxygen is in the mitochondria to oxidize fat. But all of that said, the research actually says that
00:23:32 you can't predict marathon finish time by VO2 max.
00:23:37 You're right. And people don't like hearing that because they have this idea that this set,
00:23:42 now this VO2 max is directly associated with performance. So they need to rev up their VO2 max
00:23:49 by doing hard training, which will get them performing better. And that, you know, that's where the whole
00:23:55 system breaks down. That's the problem we have. This VO2 max is a, it's something we,
00:24:01 we have been worshiping and we're worshiping the wrong thing.
00:24:07 So tell folks what MAF stands for.
00:24:11 MAF stands for maximum aerobic function. And in essence, the goal of being healthy,
00:24:18 the goal of being fit is to develop the aerobic system. This is what our ancestors did. This is how
00:24:25 we got here. We developed a really incredibly powerful aerobic system by doing the things in
00:24:34 our lifestyle that drive that aerobic system to develop, which includes eating more fat,
00:24:42 not eating much carbohydrate, eating moderate amounts of protein, maybe even relatively small
00:24:48 amounts of protein for the earlier humans, because we were, we were not the hunters in those early
00:24:54 stages, but we, we certainly ate a large amount of fat and we didn't sprint after animals. We jogged
00:25:01 after animals. And so all of that is how we, we developed, we developed bigger brains, bigger bodies.
00:25:12 We developed bodies that had great longevity and a higher level of health to match that longevity.
00:25:19 And it doesn't take long when you start reading about this. And, and, and it was really an anthropology
00:25:25 course, I think that I first started reading this kind of stuff. And it was really quite fascinating because
00:25:32 they said, well, if that's what they were doing, why are we doing all this other stuff now? And that sort of
00:25:39 got me thinking about this as an undergraduate student, because it seemed pretty clear what our ancestors were
00:25:46 doing and the fact that they were doing it for so long, you know, just what happened between some
00:25:54 time ago and now, how did we get into the mess we're in? And so the concept of maximum aerobic function
00:26:01 has been really with me for, for quite some time. When I was working with runners, which is almost
00:26:08 all the athletes I worked with, certainly in the seventies, I started talking about the pace that these
00:26:15 athletes could run at with this given heart rate that I had come up with this aerobic heart rate.
00:26:23 And I called it the maximum aerobic heart rate. And so the pace they were running was the maximum
00:26:28 aerobic pace. And how did you come up with that heart rate? That heart rate was derived in combination of
00:26:36 a physical exam in my office. I want to know how healthy they were. I want to know about their history.
00:26:42 What did their labs look like, their posture, their strength, and so forth. And then I would go out
00:26:49 to the track and I would monitor their heart rate. I'd monitor their gait while we use different
00:26:57 heart rates. And so I'd see them at a 120 heart rate. I'd look at their gait. I'd say, this is,
00:27:03 it's a pretty good gait. And then we'd go to 130. That's a pretty good gait, maybe even a little
00:27:09 better. And then they'd go to 140 and I'd start seeing irregularities. And then I'd bring them
00:27:15 back to 130 and I'd see a nice smooth gait again. And I'd put all that together and I'd assign them
00:27:23 a certain MAF heart rate and they would go train. And then I would test them again to see if it
00:27:29 correlated. And it was a long process. And it was, it would not be for two or three years when
00:27:35 I developed a formula, which I never used personally because I always wanted to do it
00:27:41 manually, but they correlated so well. And you may have heard me say, I was lecturing one day about
00:27:47 this and how I came up with this heart rate and what it meant and how people were benefiting from
00:27:53 it. And somebody said, well, how do we come up with that heart rate? And I, I didn't have an answer.
00:27:58 And I started realizing that, well, there's probably some simple mathematical process that
00:28:04 I can go through to use the athletes I had. I already know their heart rate. Let's plug in the
00:28:12 numbers. And the 180 formula was born. I tweaked that for a couple of years. And the formula you see
00:28:20 today is basically the same formula that existed in the early 80s. Let's go through it in a bit more
00:28:26 detail. Just to make sure folks understand what we're saying. You're saying that a person is going
00:28:33 to be at their maximum aerobic output. So meaning they're going to be maximally fat oxidizing at an
00:28:41 approximate heart rate of 180 minus their age, plus or minus a few modifications. So I believe there are
00:28:50 a handful of these. If you're recovering from an illness or you're kind of in an overtrained situation,
00:28:56 you might actually need to discount that by another 10, right? That might be 170 minus your
00:29:01 age. Correct. The key is that you want to individualize it. So you, you begin with 180 minus
00:29:07 the age, which has no meaning like the, the 220 formula that, you know, you subtract your age from
00:29:13 220 and they say it's your maximum heart rate or whatever. Yeah. Your max heart rate. And of course it's
00:29:18 not most of the time. So 180 minus the age has no meaning. It's just a means to the end,
00:29:24 but you now want to individualize it to your health and fitness needs. So if you're recovering from an
00:29:31 illness, if you're severely overtrained, if you're in rehab, you want to subtract another 10 from that.
00:29:38 But if you're not in that category and you only have the typical two or three colds a year, you might have
00:29:46 asthma or seasonal allergies, you might be over fat. You might be training for a while and then you kind of,
00:29:55 you lose time, you can't train and then you get back into it. And not in that category, you subtract another
00:30:01 five all the way to the competitive athlete who has no health problems, who has been progressing quite
00:30:10 well. They can add five to that number. So in the, you know, that formula, what's important for people
00:30:17 is to follow the formula and be honest. That's the hardest part is to be honest. So if you're on
00:30:24 medication, for example, you've got to subtract your age from 180 and you've got to subtract another 10.
00:30:29 And what kind of meditation? Does it matter?
00:30:33 Doesn't matter. That's the thing. People will say, well, I'm only on this and that's not really
00:30:38 affecting my heart rate or, or I don't have to be on it. Or I, I don't know what, you know,
00:30:44 if you're on medication, you subtract 10. And if you get healthy along the way by training this way,
00:30:51 and now you can get off your medication, well, now you could redo the formula because now you're no
00:30:56 longer on medication, you're healthier. Let's have a look at the 180 formula again and modify it as
00:31:02 needed. You know, it's like doing a history on a patient. The most important thing is that they be
00:31:09 honest because if you don't get the right information, you're, you're in trouble.
00:31:14 So it's kind of amazing to me, by the way, that you were able to do so much with heart rate back in
00:31:18 the seventies and eighties. What, what did you even use for heart rate monitors or were people just
00:31:23 manually checking their heart rate doing these tests?
00:31:27 Well, yeah, I began manually checking heart rates. Uh, there were some finger units that were
00:31:34 not very accurate. There's some clips you put on the ear. They were not accurate. Unlike the ear buds
00:31:40 that are used today, picking up the heart rate in the ear, in the ear canal is, is a good measure.
00:31:46 And I finally got a heart monitor that was used in cardiac rehab in hospitals. And it was a big
00:31:55 obnoxious, you know, double strap. One went over the shoulder, one went around the chest and it had
00:32:00 this box that was in the middle and it, you know, all you got was the heart rate. You could see it in
00:32:06 this tiny window and you can hear the thing beeping. And it would be several years before the wireless
00:32:14 monitors came out, which I think was late in 83 maybe. And when I first started using this heart
00:32:23 monitor, I had one in my office. It was like having, you know, I had a stethoscope. Okay. And I used it
00:32:29 when I needed to use it. And so I had this heart monitor and I would use it, go to the track, put it
00:32:34 on an athlete. We'd use it, take it off, put it on another athlete. And I, silly me, I thought, well,
00:32:41 okay, once they feel what 130 heart rate or 150 heart rate is like, they'll be able to train that
00:32:50 way. Well, that didn't work. So then I started lending out the heart monitor and then I had to
00:32:56 buy another one. And then I had like three of them, you know, it was like, you have three heart
00:33:02 monitors. Yeah. I have three in my office. It was like the old, you know, 1950s people had one
00:33:07 television. And if somebody had two television, it was like, you mean you have two TVs? Wow. That's,
00:33:13 you know, you know, then people started buying them. They said, I'm going to train with this.
00:33:18 Cause when I trained with it, I feel better. I'm not tired. I'm, you know, my back doesn't hurt
00:33:22 anymore and blah, blah, blah. It progressed that way. And then when the wireless heart monitors came out,
00:33:29 everybody wanted to buy one, which was interesting. So the formula, the math formula of 180 minus age,
00:33:39 and then adjusted based on all the factors is a way to basically gauge the intensity.
00:33:47 How did you then prescribe volume and how did you not only prescribe the volume there,
00:33:54 but determine how much volume to add in that was at a higher intensity?
00:34:00 That's an interesting question. It really began early on when I had no intention of coaching.
00:34:07 I didn't want to be a coach. I, you know, I wanted to be a clinician and fix people's knees and help
00:34:13 them, you know, get off blood pressure medications or whatever. And with athletes,
00:34:19 I thought if I could just keep them from getting injured, they'll just perform better because,
00:34:24 you know, that seemed to be the thing that slowed them down, getting some physical injury.
00:34:30 And I realized that I was treating symptoms. I was, I was really, you know, it was against
00:34:38 my nature to, to do that. I was, I was fixing some runner's knee and they'd go out and train.
00:34:46 And then I'd see them again in my clinic a month later with the same knee problem. I said, well,
00:34:50 what, what did you do? He said, well, I just did my normal training. And, you know, eventually I said,
00:34:56 well, let me look at your training and people would write down their schedules and I would start
00:35:01 looking at it. And I realized that I didn't, I needed to have some input on this schedule because
00:35:08 what they're doing was excessive. They were literally over-training. And so I became a coach
00:35:16 and I didn't want to be like a regular coach where I'd give out a schedule. I wanted them,
00:35:22 like I said earlier with, with, with Stu Middleman, I wanted the athlete to be part of the process.
00:35:30 You know, I wanted to say, well, what would you like to do with your training? And they'd bring
00:35:36 in their schedule and I'd look at it and I would just say, let me get this straight. You work 60
00:35:42 hours a week. You have three kids and a house and you do all these social things and you're trying to
00:35:49 run a hundred miles a week. That doesn't make sense. You either have to get rid of your kids,
00:35:55 get rid of your family, get rid of your job, or reduce the number of miles you're running.
00:36:00 And so, you know, I got a lot of laughs and we, we went on and I found that people could do a lot
00:36:09 less training at a lot less intensity and perform in a race a whole lot better. And it didn't take
00:36:20 long to see that, you know, it's like a taper. When you taper, you get stronger. Well, when you cut
00:36:27 somebody's schedule down, they can get more out of their training. And so it, it, it worked that way.
00:36:33 And so the, the big issue was really this aerobic system stuff. How do you build the best aerobic
00:36:42 system? Of course, I had been familiar with Arthur Lyddiard, who was a patient in my clinic actually at
00:36:49 one point. And so I knew about this concept of the aerobic base and, and it just seemed to make a lot
00:36:56 of sense. And what I found through working with a number of patients that if they, if they do their
00:37:02 traditional two days a week of interval training on the track, they never got faster at the same heart
00:37:11 rate. Like these other people did who seem to excel quite quickly from, from one month to the next,
00:37:19 they could be running starting at a nine minute, a mile pace at their MAF heart rate. They might be
00:37:25 running eight 30 a month later, same heart rate months later. Now they're running at an eight minute
00:37:30 pace. Okay. So I want, I want to pause there for a sec. So when the athlete makes progress, when they're
00:37:36 doing their MAF test, which again, I just want to remind everybody, cause we're, we're talking about
00:37:41 both an MAF heart rate, but then the MAF test, and these are very important concepts. So let's go back.
00:37:47 So I figure out either through a very bespoke manner or using the formula that my MAF heart rate is one
00:37:55 30. I go out and I'm going to do my training at one 30 and I'm running a nine minute mile. The question
00:38:03 becomes while keeping my heart rate at one 30, can I get faster? Can I go from a nine minute mile to an
00:38:11 eight 30 mile to an eight minute mile? And if I can do that while staying at one 30, by definition,
00:38:17 I have become aerobically fitter and more efficient. Correct? Correct. Now, is there a point at which you
00:38:26 begin to adjust up the heart rate and say, Peter, I want you to now train at one 32, or do you keep me
00:38:34 at one 30 and see how far we can drive that down until I plateau? How do you make that decision?
00:38:41 I keep you at one 30 because I've determined that one 30 is a good number for you because you're
00:38:48 progressing now. Can we cheat a little bit up to one 32 and one, one 33 and only to find out two months
00:38:55 later that you're back to where you were. I don't want to spend that time because at some point I've
00:39:00 had enough experience to know that's not a good use of our time. So we're going to stay at one 30
00:39:07 and we're going to allow your body to develop that aerobic system. The question people often have is,
00:39:15 well, how do I run faster at the same heart rate? It doesn't make sense. And the answer is that
00:39:19 you're, you're, you're able to generate a lot of energy from fat. You're, you're building the
00:39:25 aerobic system. So you're, you're increasing fat burning. Now you have more energy. You have,
00:39:31 you have the steam engine, the more wood or coal you throw in there, the more that engine can,
00:39:38 can go and the faster it can go. And you will progress and you'll month after month get faster and
00:39:44 faster. At some point you will hit a plateau. And, and early on, I realized it took three,
00:39:52 four, five, six months before people hit a plateau. So there are two issues. One is,
00:39:59 do we keep allowing the body to get faster and faster, which for an endurance athlete is the greatest
00:40:06 benefit they can obtain? Because if they can go faster at a sub max pace, they can go faster at a max
00:40:14 pace. Let's unpack that for a minute. That let's, let's unpack that. That's a very, very important
00:40:20 statement. Can you talk about some of the experiences you've had to establish that? And again,
00:40:27 actually, before we do that, Phil, let's talk about why that's relevant. You're running a 10 K let's
00:40:33 say at the very competitive level, a 10 K is, you know, depending on how competitive, obviously it can
00:40:38 be sub 30 minutes. But if you're kind of a recreational athlete who's running competitively,
00:40:43 you're going to be in the, you know, 32, 33, 34 minute range, by definition, you're running well
00:40:49 above your math target. Is it necessarily true that if you take the top 10 finishers of that race,
00:41:00 and then a week later have them run at their math heart rate, they'll cover greater distances
00:41:10 as a function of what they ran in the 10 K race. In other words, do you, we do have evidence that
00:41:16 that's true? Cause if it is, it's a remarkable statement, right? We do have evidence that that
00:41:21 is true. Hypothetically, you have the outlier who's this guy who can't run nine minutes without
00:41:28 hitting a one 80 heart rate. These are the people who are over-trained enough to be in that sympathetic
00:41:35 state. They get into a 10 K and they run a PR and amazing feet. How could, you know, I've run a minute
00:41:43 and a half faster. My, you know, these are the people that are ready to fall apart at any minute.
00:41:49 And I've seen them. These are also the people who are ready to drop dead of a heart attack.
00:41:56 And so if we take those outliers away, then yes, we have this hierarchy of, of athletes who have a
00:42:03 increasingly better sub max condition that corresponds to their race pace.
00:42:11 If that's true, then Phil, it would really lend credence to the idea that even if you're training
00:42:18 for a five K or a 10 K, you still want to push your math protocol. It's still matters how much you can,
00:42:27 how, how much distance you can cover at that lower heart rate and lower intensity where you
00:42:33 are running at your maximum fat oxidation and maximum aerobic capacity.
00:42:39 Yeah. And I think it's pretty clear now that sub max performance predicts maximum performance.
00:42:47 How far down can you go even for a miler? I think it comes down to how much fat burning do we need?
00:42:57 And even for a mile, there's a lot of fat burning taking place in a one mile race.
00:43:02 I want to ask you about fat. When I was in medical school, the conventional wisdom was that fat
00:43:09 oxidation could not exceed one gram per minute. Now I didn't think much of it, but many years later,
00:43:18 when I underwent a enormous dietary switch and I went from being a kind of ultra distance
00:43:26 athlete, basically mainlining carbohydrates. So probably consuming, I would say five bottles
00:43:37 of power aid a day. So let's say if I was training four hours a day, I would go through five liters of
00:43:43 power aid plus Cytomax plus hammer perpetuum, like basically all of these very high carbohydrate
00:43:49 formulas, you know, rotting my gut. And when I would do my VO2 max testing, which I did pretty
00:43:58 frequently, you get a lot of data on the way up to VO2 max. You're getting all of your fuel
00:44:03 partitioning data because you're getting VO2 and VCO2. So I know how much, I know how many calories I'm
00:44:10 expending at every level of intensity. And I know what the mixture is of carbohydrate versus fat.
00:44:16 So clearly in that state, I was nowhere near oxidizing one gram of fat per minute. In fact,
00:44:24 I was pretty much only oxidizing glucose the entire level. In other words, even at my low intensity,
00:44:32 I was still a glucose oxidizer. Fast forward years, several years, I've tried something totally radical.
00:44:39 I've gone on a ketogenic diet. I've done it for not just a while, but actually for three years.
00:44:44 And I've become very adapted to it such that I can function at high and low intensity.
00:44:50 And I'm now doing the same thing. I'm repeating VO2 max testing, but on this ketogenic diet.
00:44:57 And I hit a fat oxidation, which is still submaximal. So it's just below my VO2 max,
00:45:06 but my max fat ox was 1.73 grams per minute. Wow. And I remember thinking, how is that even
00:45:14 possible? Now, of course I would go on to learn that world-class athletes training on a very low
00:45:21 carbohydrate diet were able to hit two, 2.1, even 2.2 grams per minute, which I found interesting.
00:45:29 It basically said that this conventional wisdom we have about sports nutrition and sports science
00:45:37 is largely predicated on assumptions of what people are eating that aren't necessarily the optimal way
00:45:43 to go about doing it. It's a very good point. And I mean, you and I came to that same conclusion in
00:45:49 different ways. And we also had the same studies to look at the same lab tests to do. And unfortunately,
00:45:58 we had a lot of the same subjects or we read about studies that use the same subjects, which were big
00:46:04 carbohydrate eaters that distorted the research completely. But all along the way, I knew there
00:46:13 was something about fat. And the question is, well, how could we really measure it? And I knew we could do it
00:46:18 in the lab. My clinic was in the middle of, I mean, I was in the New York City suburbs at the time. So
00:46:25 I occasionally had access to a lab, occasionally could get somebody in there to test. And occasionally
00:46:33 they would say, wow, this is amazing. How could this person burn so much fat? We don't understand
00:46:39 this. It must be a problem. And then, you know, as the months and years went by, you know, it was
00:46:46 not a problem anymore. This was great. And so all along the way, for me, it was always,
00:46:52 I know what's going on. I know this athlete's getting healthy. I know they're burning more fat
00:46:56 because they're running faster at the same MAF heart rate. And now we're starting to see it be
00:47:02 measured. And it was a point where I said, I can't be the scientist. I'm not really a scientist.
00:47:10 I do wear that hat, but I'm too busy being a clinician and coming up with all these crazy
00:47:17 tests. And still my primary concern was helping people get healthy and fit. And if it was an
00:47:25 athlete, it meant they were going to perform better, but not by sacrificing their health.
00:47:30 And if they were not an athlete, we still had a lot of work to do. And it was only after a while
00:47:37 that I started thinking more scientifically, I always thought scientifically, depending on who
00:47:43 you ask. You know, if you ask a scientist, they would say, well, I'm not being very scientific when
00:47:49 I explain this MAF heart rate. And if I ask a clinician, they say, you know, you're too scientific
00:47:55 about this. So I gradually became more and more scientific only because A, it was fun, especially
00:48:03 reading the new research. And B, it was much better for me as a clinician to explain things
00:48:11 in scientific terms. I still had that scientific mentality of this is how we communicate to the
00:48:22 rest of the world from a scientific standpoint. So the fat burning component became that factor that
00:48:29 we can measure more and more. And like the story you told of the changes you made and how it
00:48:36 affected fat burning, you know, I started gathering that kind of data and started writing more.
00:48:44 As a clinician, you can't publish papers. You just can't, you know, your brain is unable to
00:48:50 spend time doing that because you're spending so much time doing other things. And it wasn't until
00:48:56 after I left my clinic because healthcare was getting so bad. I just couldn't do that anymore.
00:49:03 And I, I ended up only working with, with athletes. And so healthcare was really out of the picture
00:49:10 in, in many ways. And then I was able to spend more time thinking and writing scientifically and
00:49:18 start publishing more. I wrote a textbook. I started publishing more scientific papers and
00:49:25 talking about all this with a scientific hat on rather than merely a clinical hat. Although a lot
00:49:33 of the scientific things I've written are clinical oriented because that's still my goal is to help
00:49:40 people. And one of the ways of helping people is to help other clinicians who can then in turn
00:49:45 help their patients. There's something about this nutritional component that I think creates a lot
00:49:52 of confusion for people, which is that it tends to be in flux. So it's not constant. When I was young,
00:49:59 so call it the first athletic phase of my life, which I would say is about age 13 to 18. So between
00:50:06 the ages of 13 to 18, I was indestructible, just like most 13, you know, to 18 year olds are, you can do
00:50:12 anything. There is no such thing as overtraining, nor is there such a thing as overeating. I could consume
00:50:19 such comical amounts of food and they were really not of high quality at all, right? So, you know,
00:50:26 breakfast would be a box of cereal into a large Tupperware bowl, the entire box. I mean,
00:50:32 six or seven sandwiches for lunch every day. So a whole loaf of bread turned into sandwiches,
00:50:37 plus French fries, plus a one gallon thing of orange juice. I mean, just disgusting quantities of food,
00:50:46 food, but absolutely no impairment of performance or health, at least by any measurable amount.
00:50:54 But by the time I'm in the sort of second and third phase of my life into my late twenties and my
00:51:01 thirties, my tolerance for that amount of carbohydrate went down. And so even though I was
00:51:07 still exercising a lot, certainly by, by any normal standard, you know, I metabolically became quite sick
00:51:14 and I became the example of that guy who can't outrun his bad diet. Although in my case, I was out
00:51:23 swimming it. I was trying to out swim it or out ride it. And so how did you then either as a coach
00:51:31 or as a clinician trying to help just a normal person calibrate, not just the intensity of exercise,
00:51:41 not just the duration of exercise, but now this third layer, which is specifically, what is the
00:51:48 carbohydrate tolerance of the individual? Given that one, two people can be similar in very,
00:51:56 in a number of ways and yet be different in that regard. And secondly, any given individual is likely
00:52:01 going to see a deterioration of that over time. Sure. And we, we all become more insulin resistant
00:52:07 as the years go by. I like to call it carbohydrate intolerance because as soon as you say insulin
00:52:14 resistance to the average person, they either shut down or they panic or they totally ignore you
00:52:20 because that's a hard, it's a hard term to relate to because they can't relate to it. Carbohydrate
00:52:27 intolerance, at least when you say you're not tolerating the level of the amount of carbohydrates
00:52:34 you're reading. So you need to cut down. They can relate to that. They may not be happy,
00:52:39 but they can relate to that. But the more important factor was one that I already knew about, although
00:52:47 I didn't know how to apply it to patients, but I already knew going again, going back to undergraduate
00:52:53 school where this idea of wholism, you know, it came from philosophy really for me, this holistic idea
00:53:04 showed up one day. And I think out of that came this idea that we're all individuals and we all have
00:53:11 uniquenesses. And I carry that with me into my clinical world. And there wasn't much to do,
00:53:20 you know, to measure insulin resistance back then meant going into the hospital and having a
00:53:25 glucose clamp test. That was just unheard of. They laughed at me when I sent patients to the
00:53:32 cardiologist because I wanted to see, I want to measure heart rate variability in this patient
00:53:36 because I think there's an autonomic problem. Well, half of them didn't have any problem, but
00:53:41 the other half did. And they said, well, gee, how do you know that? You know, these things as a
00:53:46 clinician, because you do a good evaluation, you assess the patient and you spend a lot of time
00:53:53 talking to the patient, something that's not done anymore, wasn't done much back then either. But
00:53:59 by doing that, you learn about the patient. You learn about so many things, including insulin resistance.
00:54:09 How sensitive are they to insulin? How do they respond?
00:54:12 An obvious example is a New York City executive works in an office all day, training for a marathon,
00:54:21 goes out for lunch, comes back, and is so tired that he has to put his head on the desk and literally
00:54:27 fall asleep. Obviously, Bob, what did you have for lunch? Well, you start putting two and two together
00:54:35 and it's not that hard. And then just like the MAF test where you want to see what is this person
00:54:42 capable of doing at this given heart rate, I came up with another challenge, which was a food challenge
00:54:49 called the two-week test. Okay, Bob, I want you to not eat those things at lunch anymore. I don't even
00:54:57 want to have you eat those things for breakfast. In fact, let's take away all the junk food from your
00:55:05 diet and take and cut way down on the natural carbohydrates like lentils and beans and rice and
00:55:12 fruits and fruit juice, etc. And we'll do it just for two weeks. It's a challenge. We want to see how
00:55:19 you respond. So we gather all the signs and symptoms that are not normal. I fall asleep after meals. I fall
00:55:27 asleep easily at night because I'm so exhausted, but I wake up at 2 a.m., etc., etc. Okay, let's put these
00:55:35 things on the table. Let's do this two-week test after the two weeks of eating that way. Let's look
00:55:39 at all these signs and symptoms. Are any of them better or any of them worse? Well, yeah, three-quarters
00:55:46 of them are better. Of all the miracles I've seen in clinical practice, the two-week test is one of them
00:55:52 because you see these people become new people after a very short period of time. And it's really
00:55:58 amazing. I mean, it's because insulin is involved. Insulin has immediate effects. Carbohydrates have
00:56:04 immediate effects. The two-meal effect with, you know, it's just, it's almost an instant change. So
00:56:11 now you've gathered more information. You're still assessing the patient. But now we can start
00:56:18 individualizing things more and more. And that process was just ongoing. And again, I always wanted
00:56:26 to enlist the patient. So I wanted to say, okay, you've done this two-week test. You're feeling so much
00:56:32 better after two weeks. Now we want you to add some lentils to your midday meal or add a small piece of
00:56:41 fruit at breakfast or whatever. And let's see how you feel. Let's see if some of those signs and
00:56:46 symptoms come back with just one piece of fruit. Or let's see if you've lost 10 pounds, you're starting
00:56:54 to gain after a couple of weeks of only having a little bit of carbohydrate, whatever. But I want to
00:57:01 enlist them in the process. I want them to use their instincts and intuition, which we all have,
00:57:06 to understand what it feels like to eat too much carbohydrate before you've gotten there.
00:57:15 One more bite of this apple and I'm in trouble. I want you to know that. I think it's a very important
00:57:21 thing. It's a very human thing. And so that holistic component, that individualizing aspect of my work
00:57:31 has always been there. And in many ways, it makes it easier. People might say, well, if you just give
00:57:37 somebody a diet, it doesn't get any easier than that. Well, it doesn't get any rewarding when you do
00:57:42 that either. So it was a very important part, and it still is a very important part, even though I'm not
00:57:49 sitting with patients one-on-one anymore, usually. I may do some consulting, but I am writing. I am
00:57:56 still lecturing. And I could take that component of individualization, of holism, and get those points
00:58:05 across to people so they can take that and run with it, so to speak. Now, I, again, mentioned that I spent
00:58:14 all this time on a very low-carbohydrate diet and saw, you know, enormous improvements in my aerobic
00:58:20 fitness. When it was all said and done, my anaerobic fitness, my higher-level intensity fitness did not
00:58:27 deteriorate, but it took a very long time for that to come around. And the conclusion I drew from that
00:58:34 was athletes who were heavily involved in glycolytic activity really ought not restrict
00:58:43 carbohydrates as much as, say, athletes who are doing things that can be done at a much more
00:58:50 aerobic level. Now, a couple of years ago, you were part of a study that sort of flew in the face of my
00:58:56 assumptions because it was a very short study. It was a four-week study, and it put athletes on a very
00:59:03 low-carbohydrate diet. They averaged less than 10% and maybe 15% protein. So they were, you know,
00:59:09 if they weren't on a ketogenic diet, they were very close to it, and they were doing high-intensity
00:59:15 interval training. And you guys didn't find any difference between the groups suggesting that this
00:59:23 amount of carbohydrate restriction did not impair performance. What can you say about that study?
00:59:28 It was a good study. Part of it, actually, we published a separate paper on it showing that the
00:59:34 high-fat diet did not have any adverse effect on inflammation. But that study really came from this
00:59:41 idea that athletes can still burn high amounts of fat when they do interval training. Paul Larson did,
00:59:51 you know, that's how I met Paul. They did a study some time ago. They showed that high-intensity training
00:59:57 can still produce large amounts of, relatively speaking, fat burning, as opposed to, you know,
01:00:04 burning 100% carbohydrate, like you were mentioning earlier. I sent him an email, and I said, yeah, well,
01:00:10 I sent him an athlete I had worked on who we had done some lab studies on. And at, I don't remember
01:00:18 the numbers, but at about a 180 heart rate in this 36-year-old athlete, he was burning a lot of fat,
01:00:25 relatively speaking. And I said, yeah, here, you know, here's a, here's an example of what I found
01:00:31 clinically. And, you know, and so we've known this for a long time. It's good to see that you're doing
01:00:35 this. And, and he wrote me back and, you know, we've been colleagues ever since. And he was in that
01:00:42 study. So it was a study that showed what we are already knew clinically in, in a sense. And we wanted, we
01:00:50 wanted to demonstrate it from a lab standpoint. Do you remember how many participants were in that study?
01:00:55 I want to say 20, but I, I, that seems so long ago.
01:01:00 Okay. Yeah. So, I mean, it would be interesting to see if with a larger sample size, that is still
01:01:07 the case. And obviously at different levels of the athletes incoming, right? In other words,
01:01:14 is that true of recreational athletes only? Is it also true of high level athletes?
01:01:19 Yeah. These were students. I think Jeff has done, Jeff Volek has done some, some studies with the
01:01:25 higher level athletes, with some ultra athletes. Again, they're, they're not running as fast,
01:01:30 but they're running at a max level. These were students. And these were subjects who, the ones who,
01:01:38 who were on the very low carbohydrate diet were only there for a month. And my feeling is we really
01:01:47 should have gone longer. I think we could have seen different results, but, but they're only
01:01:52 there for a month. A month is long enough for some people, but not long enough for others. And
01:01:57 there's a good argument to make that, you know, it should be two months or even three months to really
01:02:02 stabilize that metabolic change, but whatever. It was a good study. And, you know, like other studies,
01:02:11 somebody will see it and say, Hey, this should be done with more people. Just like you said,
01:02:16 let's get more numbers. Let's get a wider age group. Let's get beginners, athletes, you know,
01:02:22 middle of the pack runners, professional athletes, professional athletes are really hard to get
01:02:27 because they don't want to do this. They don't want to go into a lab and do that.
01:02:31 But from a clinical standpoint, I love all these studies. I love being involved with them.
01:02:37 But for me, the bottom line is, can you, the athlete run faster at the same sub max heart rate?
01:02:48 In fact, I don't care what you do with your training or your diet. If you could run faster
01:02:54 at the same heart rate as the months go by, whatever you're doing is working, keep doing it.
01:03:01 So that MAF test is so powerful that that's really the only thing you have to sell people on.
01:03:10 And then when they start seeing that they're, they're not getting faster or when they see
01:03:16 they've gotten faster and now they're going to start doing some weight training, fatiguing type
01:03:21 weight training, or they're doing some intervals and then they get slower. You know, now you've got
01:03:27 their attention. Now you say, yeah, see, do you understand what's happening? And, you know,
01:03:32 they, they start feeling it because they say, well, you know, I, I felt it wasn't quite right.
01:03:38 Or I didn't feel comfortable doing that. Or I didn't, you know, so when I first started using
01:03:43 a heart monitor, I thought this is, this is interesting. This is biofeedback by definition.
01:03:49 We're, we're going to listen to, or we're going to look at our heart rate and we're going to respond
01:03:54 to what that heart rate does. And the goal is to be able to do that without this heart monitor.
01:04:01 So I thought really these heart monitors were just a one use, maybe for, maybe spend a whole week
01:04:07 doing it. Now you, you know how to run at one 30 heart rate. It never happened. Once in a while,
01:04:15 I see an athlete who knows exactly where they are. They know exactly when they could run at that max
01:04:21 fat burning level. And I've always been amazed by that. And there's some good ones and some mediocre
01:04:27 runners who, who were able to do that. But most people, we are in a no pain, no gain world. And
01:04:34 we're seeing injuries because someone watches the New York city marathon on TV. And the next day they go
01:04:42 out and they want to run like that lead pack runner. They want to stride out like, you know, come on,
01:04:50 man, you can't even break four hours in the marathon. No wonder you got injured.
01:04:55 Speaking of the marathon, I want to talk about this, this book you wrote in 2014, which was just
01:05:00 such a brilliant idea. The title of the book is one 59. The sub two hour marathon is within reach.
01:05:07 Here's how it will go down and what it can teach all runners about training and racing.
01:05:12 And of course, five years later in October of 2019, Kipchoge goes and runs one 59 40. Now we can
01:05:22 explain to people who care about the nuance that it was not technically a sub two in a world record
01:05:27 pace. It was sort of a contrived example of what could be done under the most optimal conditions. It
01:05:33 was not a race, but there's simply no denying that what Kipchoge did was unbelievable. He had tried a year
01:05:41 earlier and I believe came very close, was probably two double O I don't know, 40 seconds or something.
01:05:50 Yeah. Yeah. He was, he was pretty close. He was under 201. So let's put aside the, the technicality
01:05:57 of how this wasn't a, you know, a world record in the typical sense of how world records are run in
01:06:03 marathons, but instead just focus on what you thought needed to happen in 2014, why you thought
01:06:11 this was achievable and, and maybe what we learned from Kipchoge. Well, I had originally written an
01:06:18 article called the one 59 marathon back in the nineties. It was half, I wouldn't say that it was a kind of a
01:06:28 joke, but it was half goof, but half serious because the lead pack runners were running faster and
01:06:35 faster. World records were, were being broken all the time. There was no evidence that said,
01:06:43 this is going to stop. We're going to hit a plateau and we're not going to get any faster. There were
01:06:47 people who thought that I don't know where they got those ideas from, but we started seeing the fact
01:06:54 that age group runners were not getting faster. And I thought that was interesting. And, and when you
01:07:00 start putting numbers together, such as what if you wore a lighter shoe or what if you were three pounds
01:07:11 lighter, or what if you were shorter, or what if your body type was this? And of course, what if you were
01:07:19 a better fat burner, how much more energy would you have? And then again, the next obvious step is,
01:07:26 well, what is your MAF test need to be to run under two hours? And I was getting some runners who were,
01:07:36 who were starting to hit five minute pace for their MAF test. They're running five minutes a mile
01:07:46 at their MAF heart rate. And so I thought there's no indication that, that they're reaching a limit,
01:07:54 that they're hitting a plateau in, in performance. So why couldn't it keep going? And that's really
01:08:00 where the idea went and it turned into a book. And I'm not sure it was a book that sold very well. I think,
01:08:09 you know, in the nineties, when I wrote that article, a lot of people just asked me why I even wrote it,
01:08:15 you know, this is silly. What, you know, we're not going to see a 159 marathon in our lifetime.
01:08:23 And I said, well, how long do you plan on living?
01:08:28 So I think what this runner did was amazing. I don't like what he did. I don't like the whole
01:08:34 idea behind it. I still know that a runner is going to do it in Berlin or, or London on the right day.
01:08:42 And it's relatively soon it's going to happen. And I'll be much happier to see that.
01:08:49 And you're just saying, you're not happy with the way it was done because of the sort of contrived
01:08:53 nature of it.
01:08:54 Yeah. It was, it was an advertisement. I'm not opposed to advertising, but it was,
01:09:00 it was more like a circus. And I think it took away from professional running as a sport.
01:09:07 So that's what I didn't like about it. Yeah. It was, it was a Nike commercial for sure.
01:09:13 Do we know much about Kipchoge's nutrition or other factors that, that we could, you know,
01:09:22 extrapolate from, uh, for example, in a two hour race, you know, even at the level he's exerting
01:09:29 himself, he technically didn't, doesn't really need calories. Fluids should be enough. Do we know if
01:09:35 he actually consumed glucose during that race?
01:09:39 I'm not aware of what, what he consumed, if anything, you know, if properly trained,
01:09:45 obviously he was burning a lot of fat. If properly trained, he wouldn't have needed any added
01:09:49 nutrition, maybe not even water. You know, water is this interesting thing because it has a lot of
01:09:56 weight. And if you dehydrate a small amount, the time factor is significant enough where you're,
01:10:05 you're running faster. There's this window and I don't know if it's, if it's 2% dehydration from a
01:10:12 weight standpoint or, or what it might be. You have this game of dehydrating, but not impairing
01:10:20 performance. And as a result, you're getting lighter. And so you're going to, you're going to run,
01:10:25 be able to run faster. It's all about performance. If you can prevent impairment of performance,
01:10:32 that's where you want to be. But I don't have information. My, my impression with the, the
01:10:38 Kenyans, with the East Africans is that if you look back in history, we've got all these areas of the
01:10:45 world that have taken their place on the world stage of great runners. And now it's the Kenyans.
01:10:53 The question is number one, who's going to be next? Cause somebody else will be next.
01:11:00 But the real question is why have all these countries come and gone? And my feeling is that
01:11:06 in Kenya, you know, it's a very poor country. These young men and women have an opportunity to become
01:11:15 kings in their own country with the money they make on racing. And they go from race to race and they 0.98
01:11:22 race all the time and they burn out. And it's really sad, but I think that's what's happened.
01:11:31 And the ones I've met along the way at, you know, at the races and at different events,
01:11:37 a lot of them are, are burned out, but they're going to make as much as they can make as a job.
01:11:43 And, and that's it. Imagine being able to take one of those athletes and train them. I'd want to
01:11:50 say properly, but train them more effectively. I think you'd have a two hour marathon broken already
01:11:56 in a real race.
01:11:57 When you look at somebody like Kipchoge or guys at this top level, though, there is a longevity to
01:12:03 them, which is they're, you know, I've spoken with really world-class marathoners and many of them
01:12:09 will sort of acknowledge they might only have a dozen marathons in them, you know, in their entire
01:12:14 career where they're going to really be able to run at a certain level. And that's, you know,
01:12:20 that says, look, I might only have 12 marathons over 15 years in me that are truly world-class
01:12:26 performances. And that's, that's sort of a different philosophy than the churn and burn
01:12:31 philosophy. Like look at Meb when he won the Boston marathon. I mean, he was what? 39.
01:12:37 How old was Kipchoge when he went under two? I mean, he was in his mid thirties, wasn't he?
01:12:42 Yeah. And that's what, that's what I, you know, in the book, I wrote this, this is the makeup of a
01:12:47 one 59 marathon or someone who's in their thirties, not someone who's, who's in their twenties,
01:12:52 not somebody who could run a great 10 K. They had almost had to have run a
01:12:56 great 10 K when they were younger, but now that they're 35 and they've, they've built this great
01:13:02 endurance base. Now they've got the best of everything. And so, yeah, I, my feeling is that
01:13:08 you're, you're in your mid to late thirties and maybe even forties, man. I've just, I've worked
01:13:15 with some incredible 40 year olds who have won some races and, you know, history has shown these
01:13:22 people and people are, you know, often say, well, these are amazing people. They're outliers.
01:13:27 I don't think they're outliers. I think it's, I think it's the norm.
01:13:31 So I want to talk a little bit about a term that you were, you've used it a couple of times today.
01:13:37 And I, and I've heard you, you know, or seen you write about it before, which is you don't like the
01:13:41 term overweight. You like the term over fat. You, you, you're, you're very clear to talk about
01:13:48 it's adipose tissue. We should be concerned with not mass. How do you think about that in the
01:13:54 overall context of health? You know, we, we tend to focus on weight. You know, if we get one more
01:14:00 layer of sophisticated, we look at body mass index, which of course is a highly flawed metric,
01:14:04 but where do you see the trends in fatness and how does that factor into maybe what you said earlier,
01:14:12 which is at the level of recreational athletes, we're not really seeing much improvement in
01:14:19 performance. Are those related? I think they're related in terms of the diminishing performance
01:14:26 of age group athletes. The problem, clearly the over fat condition can typically add weight to the
01:14:35 body. So that's going to affect a running performance, but more significantly, those people
01:14:40 with excess body fat have some downstream problems that can be very serious. We're talking about
01:14:48 chronic disease. So along the way to chronic disease, you have blood fat abnormalities, blood
01:14:55 sugar abnormalities, blood pressure abnormalities, and these things then lead to chronic diseases. So
01:15:02 of course, in that situation, people are not going to be performing their best over fat, excess body fat,
01:15:10 also impairs the immune system. So people tend to get sick more often. And Paul Larson and I wrote a
01:15:17 paper on this regarding COVID early, early on in the spring, actually. And people with excess body fat
01:15:26 also have physical impairment problems more frequently. And so we're talking about the basic,
01:15:34 simple injury that plantar fasciitis and also pain patterns. So low back pain on the less serious all
01:15:42 the way to the arthritities that are affecting runners. But again, in an injured athlete, you're not going to
01:15:50 perform your best. So these things are going to, over the years, show diminishing performance in age
01:15:58 groupers. And it's number one, that's really sad to see. Number two, it's even more sad to not be
01:16:05 acknowledged. I just don't see people talking about this. I don't understand why.
01:16:11 I think people are starting to acknowledge that it always takes longer. I guess someone like you,
01:16:17 who's sort of been clinically at the forefront of a lot of these things, it seems like what's taking so
01:16:24 long because you're seeing these things many years before. But for example, sugar consumption is
01:16:31 actually declining. But it sometimes takes a while for this decline to necessarily translate into some
01:16:38 of the health benefits. And furthermore, these things are so multifaceted, right? I think that,
01:16:44 I don't actually know the data on this, so I'm kind of making this up, but I would guess that you can
01:16:48 sometimes see an improvement in one parameter and a deterioration in others. For example, activity levels
01:16:53 might be declining, even while certain elements of nutrition improve. And so the net effect of that
01:16:59 could be a reduction or something we didn't talk about, sleep. Quality of sleep could be declining,
01:17:04 and that can sort of offset any benefit that we see. But this idea that health and performance are not
01:17:13 necessarily the same thing is something I see a lot of people struggle with it, right? I see a lot of
01:17:19 people who are not very healthy believe that the key to getting healthier is to train for a marathon
01:17:28 or train for an Ironman or train for this bike race or train for this event. And it usually puts me
01:17:36 in a bit of an awkward position because on the one hand, I'm so grateful that they have found something
01:17:40 to do to be active and to train for. And I don't want to discourage that.
01:17:43 But I also want them to understand that there's nothing especially healthy about doing an Ironman
01:17:50 and that one doesn't need to do that to be healthy. So do you have a message for folks around that?
01:17:58 Well, I have a lot of messages for them around that, but the main one is that they don't have
01:18:02 to do it just like you said. And in fact, all they have to do is start walking around the block
01:18:07 and the benefits, the fat burning benefits that they'll get from that are huge, but also
01:18:16 that the food is more important. And so they need to look at the big picture. And of course,
01:18:23 they need to look at stress also, but the food is such a key factor in all of this. And going back to
01:18:31 the question you asked me, what is MAF, maximum aerobic function? How can we maximize our aerobic
01:18:37 system? Well, two of the components of lifestyle are food and exercise. And sure, stress is a very
01:18:46 important factor. And yeah, you can't smoke cigarettes and drink too much alcohol, but food
01:18:52 and exercise are keys. And it's really, really simple. Just don't eat junk food and take it easy out
01:18:59 there. Well, Phil, on that note, I think we've given folks a lot to think about today. And I want
01:19:04 to thank you for your time. You're going to be ready for dinner soon, which it sounds like you skip
01:19:09 anyway, right? Yeah, I'm here when they will be starting to eat dinner soon and I'll be watching,
01:19:17 which is okay because I'm not hungry. But thank you, Peter. I enjoy your work. I have for quite some
01:19:25 time and thanks for having me on. It's been great. Thank you, Phil.
01:19:30 Thank you for listening to this week's episode of The Drive. If you're interested in diving deeper
01:19:34 into any topics we discuss, we've created a membership program that allows us to bring you
01:19:38 more in-depth exclusive content without relying on paid ads. It's our goal to ensure members get back
01:19:44 much more than the price of the subscription. Now to that end, membership benefits include a bunch of
01:19:49 things. One, totally kick-ass comprehensive podcast show notes that detail every topic,
01:19:55 paper, person, thing we discuss on each episode. The word on the street is nobody's show notes rival
01:20:00 these. Monthly AMA episodes or ask me anything episodes, hearing these episodes completely.
01:20:06 Access to our private podcast feed that allows you to hear everything without having to listen to
01:20:12 spiels like this. The Qualies, which are a super short podcast that we release every Tuesday
01:20:17 through Friday, highlighting the best questions, topics, and tactics discussed on previous episodes
01:20:22 of The Drive. This is a great way to catch up on previous episodes without having to go back and
01:20:27 necessarily listen to everyone. Steep discounts on products that I believe in, but for which I'm not
01:20:32 getting paid to endorse, and a whole bunch of other benefits that we continue to trickle in
01:20:37 as time goes on. If you want to learn more and access these member-only benefits,
01:20:41 you can head over to peteratiamd.com forward slash subscribe. You can find me on Twitter,
01:20:47 Instagram, and Facebook, all with the ID peteratiamd. You can also leave us a review on
01:20:53 Apple Podcasts or whatever podcast player you listen on. This podcast is for general informational
01:20:59 purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing, or other professional
01:21:03 healthcare services, including the giving of medical advice. No doctor-patient relationship is formed.
01:21:10 The use of this information and the materials linked to this podcast is at the user's own risk.
01:21:16 The content on this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice,
01:21:21 diagnosis, or treatment. Users should not disregard or delay in obtaining medical advice
01:21:27 from any medical condition they have, and they should seek the assistance of their healthcare
01:21:32 professionals for any such conditions. Finally, I take conflicts of interest very seriously. For all of my
01:21:38 disclosures and the companies I invest in or advise, please visit peteratiamd.com forward slash about
01:21:46 where I keep an up-to-date and active list of such companies.
01:22:08 Thank you.
01:22:18 Thank you.