The Peter Attia Drive - October 11, 2021


#179 - Jeremy Loenneke, Ph.D.: The science of blood flow restriction—benefits, uses, and what it teaches us about the relationship between muscle size and strength

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
#178 - Lance Armstrong: The rise, fall, and growth of a cycling legend #180 - AMA #28: All things testosterone and testosterone replacement therapy

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 59 minutes

Words per minute

168.0

Word count

20,157

Sentence count

1,249

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Jeremy Lonecky is an Associate Professor of Exercise Science at the University of Mississippi, better known as Ole Miss. He has a PhD in Exercise Physiology and a Master's in Nutrition and Exercise from Southeast Missouri State University, and is a fellow of the American College of Sports Medicine and a member of the AMA. He is the Director of the Applied Physiological Laboratory at the university's Applied Physiology laboratory, and he conducts research on skeletal muscle adaptations to exercise in combination with blood flow restriction.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey, everyone. Welcome to the drive podcast. I'm your host, Peter Atiyah. This podcast,
00:00:15 my website, and my weekly newsletter all focus on the goal of translating the science of longevity
00:00:19 into something accessible for everyone. Our goal is to provide the best content in health
00:00:24 and wellness, full stop. And we've assembled a great team of analysts to make this happen.
00:00:28 If you enjoy this podcast, we've created a membership program that brings you far more
00:00:33 in-depth content. If you want to take your knowledge of the space to the next level at
00:00:37 the end of this episode, I'll explain what those benefits are. Or if you want to learn more now,
00:00:41 head over to peteratiyahmd.com forward slash subscribe. Now, without further delay,
00:00:47 here's today's episode. I guess this week is professor Jeremy Lonecky. Jeremy is an associate
00:00:54 professor of exercise science at the University of Mississippi, better known as Ole Miss. He has a
00:01:00 PhD in exercise physiology from the University of Oklahoma and a master's in nutrition and exercise
00:01:06 from Southeast Missouri State University. He's also a fellow of the American College of Sports Medicine
00:01:13 and a member of the American Physiological Society. He's the director of an applied physiology laboratory,
00:01:19 and his research focuses on skeletal muscle adaptations to exercise in combination with
00:01:25 blood flow restriction. Now, some of you may have seen me recently posting things on Instagram about
00:01:31 blood flow restriction. I've been experimenting with it for some time recently. And in this podcast,
00:01:36 I even explained the first time I was exposed to it, which was a little over 10 years ago,
00:01:40 was actually in a swimming pool. Blood flow restriction is a general term that applies to
00:01:45 occluding some portion of the arterial inflow to a muscle. We get into the very nitty-gritty of this
00:01:52 during the podcast. And under these conditions, it becomes harder for the muscle to contract. And
00:02:00 what it allows an individual to do is exercise with a lower weight than they would normally do
00:02:07 unoccluded. Now, as we cover in this episode, there are lots of benefits associated with that.
00:02:11 There's also other terms that you may have heard associated with that. The most common
00:02:16 term associated with this from a brand perspective is katsu, K-A-A-T-S-U, which is Japanese for
00:02:24 basically training with restriction. Anyway, we get into all of that stuff in this episode and more,
00:02:30 but perhaps one of the most interesting things that comes out of this discussion, well, at least
00:02:34 from an egghead perspective like me, is that blood flow restriction offers a very cool,
00:02:41 way to study the relationship between muscle size and muscle strength. And that's a topic we explore
00:02:47 very deeply in this episode. We also start this episode off assuming that you know very little
00:02:53 about muscles. So we explain the physiology of the sarcomere, the micro anatomy of muscle fibers,
00:03:00 the difference between type two and type one fibers. So even if you come into this and you don't know
00:03:05 what an actin filament is and a myosin filament is, don't worry about it. We're going to spend quite a
00:03:09 bit of time getting you up to speed on that. And of course, if you already have a PhD in exercise
00:03:13 physiology and know everything about that stuff and just want to get to the BFR,
00:03:16 no problem. Get to that too. So anyway, without further delay, please enjoy my conversation with
00:03:21 Jeremy. Hey Jeremy, thanks so much for making time. I've been looking forward to this one for quite a
00:03:31 while, both personally and professionally. This is a topic I've wanted to learn a lot more about,
00:03:35 something I've been playing with a lot myself, including this morning, particularly painful
00:03:40 session this morning of blood flow restriction, which I might be doing wrong. So I'm looking
00:03:44 forward to maybe the end of our discussion when we can get into the practical aspects of it. But
00:03:49 I want to take a kind of a step back and get a sense about how you became interested in exercise
00:03:53 in general. Obviously you've devoted your career to it. So when did that become a passion great
00:03:59 enough that you decided it was worth all of your study?
00:04:01 Yeah. Thanks for having me on, Peter. I wrestled early on in my life. So I wrestled from probably
00:04:09 the age of five through high school, but I wasn't really into training that much. I was into wrestling,
00:04:15 but not really lifting weights or any of the conditioning. And my coaches would always tell
00:04:20 me that you need to try to get in the gym. You need to stay in the gym, get stronger, get stronger,
00:04:24 get stronger. And I didn't really listen up until towards the end of high school. And then I started
00:04:30 one of my friends was really into bodybuilding and powerlifting. So I started training with him.
00:04:37 I do feel like it probably helped me a little bit in wrestling. And then I kind of got interested in
00:04:43 just trying to see how to make a muscle get as big as possible. I started reading, you know,
00:04:48 muscle magazines, which is kind of the common story, training in a little bit. Then I focused on
00:04:55 exercise science early on in my undergrad. I was just trying to learn how to make a muscle bigger,
00:05:02 how to make a muscle stronger. That's all I was trying to get out of every lecture.
00:05:06 Towards the middle of, I guess, my undergrad, you have to make a decision about, you know,
00:05:14 obviously, what do you want to try and do with your career? And I was dead set on working with
00:05:18 athletes. But then I did that and quickly realized that's not what I wanted to do. So they suggested
00:05:24 that I instead, maybe you're really interested in research. Why don't you try and do an internship
00:05:29 related to that? So I landed at the University of Illinois. And that's where I met Lane and a couple
00:05:36 of other people. And that's where I really came across blood flow restriction. And that's where I
00:05:40 started to really read a lot about it and then came back and started to really focus all of my time.
00:05:48 So that was around 2007, 2008. So just about, you know, reading blood flow restriction and how I
00:05:52 might be able to do that. So I started off with wrestling and then kind of got interested in
00:05:57 bodybuilding, powerlifting, and then came across blood flow restriction when I was up at Illinois.
00:06:04 You mentioned briefly that you did a little bit of work with athletes, which was obviously kind of
00:06:08 a logical, at least place to look. But it sounds like you didn't find that to be what you wanted.
00:06:13 Why is that?
00:06:13 I'm a pretty mediocre athlete, but I always trained extremely hard. And I think I had this mindset that
00:06:21 everybody was going to train what I thought training was and how everybody was going to
00:06:26 train as hard as I thought they should train. And when I was doing a little practicum work
00:06:31 with some of these athletes, I mean, they weren't world-class elite athletes, but they were fairly
00:06:35 good collegiate athletes. I didn't get the same vibe that everybody was into training like I was in the
00:06:40 training at the time. It doesn't mean they weren't great athletes. They obviously were. It doesn't
00:06:44 mean they didn't train hard, but my perception of how they should have been training was not what
00:06:49 I thought it was going to be. So I knew I wanted to be in the exercise world, but I quickly learned
00:06:56 that I want to do research, but definitely not with animals. So I came back and that's when I got
00:07:01 into human research.
00:07:02 So where did you do your PhD?
00:07:04 University of Oklahoma.
00:07:06 And what was the focus of your dissertation?
00:07:10 Looking at different methods of applying blood flow restriction. So looking at different exercise
00:07:16 loads of 20%, 30%, different pressures. In other words, we were trying to get at this idea of,
00:07:23 do you actually need higher pressures? So in my dissertation, we were doing a lot of acute work,
00:07:29 which has obviously a lot of limitations with applying it to adaptation, but we were trying
00:07:35 to really see kind of a short-term characteristic of what that response would give. Acutely, what does
00:07:41 this response give? What does this response give? And then try and kind of pick out two of the more
00:07:47 promising ones and then study them head-to-head a little bit later on, which is kind of what we
00:07:51 did once I took a job at Ole Miss.
00:07:54 I can't wait to talk more about that. And there's no shortage of questions I have for you,
00:07:59 but I was thinking about this last night that before we jump into a lot of the questions I
00:08:04 have, I think it will be important for people to really understand the ins and outs of muscle.
00:08:11 What's the muscle, the structure of a muscle, not the gross anatomy of a muscle, but obviously
00:08:16 the microstructure, the physiology of a muscle. So without worrying about going too deep, I think
00:08:22 it's okay to do that. Let's talk about a muscle because I don't think we can get into what we're
00:08:29 about to talk about if people don't know what a sarcomere is and what actin and myosin are and what
00:08:34 the different types of fibers are. So if I were to sort of take a knife and cut down on my bicep and
00:08:41 yank it off the tendon and throw it out there as a, you know, a muscle, how would you explain to
00:08:48 somebody what's actually going on inside that thing? Yeah, that's a, it's a good question.
00:08:54 When we talk about a muscle, so like just your, the whole thing. So it's like a box within a box
00:09:01 within a box. The smallest unit of that is, as you said, a sarcomere, which is actin and myosin.
00:09:09 And that's the kind of the proteins that we're ultimately synthesizing when we exercise. So we're
00:09:14 making more of those. And if you make more of those than you break down, then obviously the
00:09:19 muscle will get bigger. So when we actually exercise those actin and myosin interact, and
00:09:26 that's how we make a muscle contract. And that's important because when actin and myosin interact
00:09:33 and you have muscle contraction, that's where you get a lot of this signaling for ultimate muscle
00:09:39 adaptation. So the characteristics of muscle, we have kind of two broad types is how we typically
00:09:47 teach it. We have type one, which is more endurance based type two, which is more force based. But in
00:09:54 reality, those are probably on a continuum. So when we exercise, we can shift them. We can shift the
00:10:03 continuum one way or another, depending upon the type of exercise that you're doing. But in general,
00:10:09 when we become more physically active, the overall fiber types shift slower. So they become more
00:10:16 oxidative, they become more efficient. That's the general response. So those are the different types
00:10:25 of fibers. The actin and myosin, that's the functional unit. They interact to make the muscle
00:10:30 contract. Let's explain to people how that works, Jeremy. So you pull out this sort of sarcomere and
00:10:36 inside you have these fibers and you've got these Z lines. Explain to people how the actin and myosin
00:10:42 actually interact with each other relative to the Z line, what the contraction looks like.
00:10:47 And frankly, even one of the more interesting things that I think is a bit counterintuitive the
00:10:52 first time people learn it is which part of the interaction between actin and myosin requires ATP.
00:10:57 It's a bit counterintuitive when you're first presented with it.
00:11:00 Right. So when we decide to exercise, we have a signal that goes from the nerve to the muscle.
00:11:08 Basically, we have a release of calcium. And that calcium is going to expose the binding site.
00:11:15 So basically, we have these filaments, they slide past each other. That's the general dogma,
00:11:21 at least with concentric actions. Eccentric is a little bit more complex. I think they're still
00:11:26 trying to figure that out with titan. But just in general, when a muscle contracts, so the myosin is
00:11:33 interacting with the actin and it's causing it to pull in. Now, ATP is required to break that bond.
00:11:41 So the ATP comes in, it breaks it off, it gets hydrolyzed, which re-cocks it and allows it to be
00:11:48 able to reattach, assuming there's more calcium on board. So that's the general basic physiology of
00:11:55 muscle contraction. So as long as calcium is there, or as long as the signal is being sent,
00:12:00 those sarcomeres, those actin and myosin will keep interacting. So they don't all interact at the
00:12:05 same time. Otherwise, you couldn't really sustain exercise. But you have them, you know, in a
00:12:10 textbook, we talk about, we have kind of like an image and we have myosin head. But those myosin
00:12:15 heads are all the way around that myosin and they're all interacting at different times. So that's
00:12:21 how we're able to actually move through kind of a fluid motion. And what's interesting, as you said,
00:12:26 is that the ATP is required to actually release the actin myosin complex, which is, we learned in
00:12:34 medical school, explains why a corpse is experiencing rigor mortis, right? When a person is dead and they're
00:12:40 no longer able to produce ATP, they don't have the ability to release the actin myosin filaments.
00:12:46 That's why a body gets stiff, sort of a morbid thought, but it explains physiologically what's
00:12:52 happening. So let's now talk a little bit about this difference in fibers, because again, I think
00:12:57 most people have probably heard of the idea of a type one and a type two fiber. But as you said,
00:13:03 it's probably more complex than that. And there's more of a continuum. I think even by the time I was
00:13:10 in med school, the teaching was really, it's a type one and then a two A and a two B, and then it became
00:13:16 a two A, a two AB, a two B. You could argue it's even more complex now. Let's start with the term
00:13:24 fast versus slow twitch. I've read conflicting things. So I'm hoping you can clarify this for me.
00:13:30 I've read that there's no difference in the twitch speed. They all twitch at the same speed. It's the force
00:13:36 of contraction and the speed to fatigue that's being referred to. So the faster twitch muscle
00:13:42 has a higher contractile force, but it also fatigues quickly, hence fast twitch. Is there
00:13:48 actually a difference in the neurologic signal that's happening there or the speed of contraction
00:13:53 for that matter? Yeah, that's a good question. This is not work that I actually do. I have a lot
00:14:00 of confusion surrounding this myself and a lot of it reading some of the work by Andy Galpin and some
00:14:06 others. A lot of it comes from the old methods are still being used. And the limitations of those
00:14:13 is that we don't have, we can't do hybrids. And some people say we should be using these new methods.
00:14:18 And I think it all depends on how you're actually identifying the fibers. What are you doing to
00:14:25 call it a fast or a slow? How are you ultimately deciding that with your methodology? So I don't
00:14:30 honestly know the ins and outs of all those. The general idea, I think, as you said, the type two 0.87
00:14:37 fibers. So for example, type two X, those typically are bigger. They're typically stronger, but they
00:14:44 fatigue much faster. The type two A, it's a little bit more oxidative. They're pretty forceful and you
00:14:51 can, they can sustain it for quite some time. So in general, when we exercise, it's thought that type
00:14:57 two X usually transitions to type two A. You don't have a whole lot of type two X left over. That's
00:15:03 my general understanding. Type one fibers generally a little bit slower and they're not as forceful,
00:15:11 but they don't fatigue. It takes a lot to fatigue those fibers. So I think that that's the general
00:15:16 characteristics. I think how you go about identifying that, you might get a little bit of different
00:15:21 things, but that was the general idea as I understand it, at least.
00:15:25 And what accounts for the difference in contractile strength between a type one fiber and say a type
00:15:31 two X, take two opposite ends of the spectrum. I mean, sometimes using the extremes is helpful,
00:15:36 right? So the type one fiber has lots of mitochondria surrounding the fibrils within the sarcomere.
00:15:43 As you said, it is readily able to access glucose and fatty acid oxidatively. Conversely,
00:15:50 the type two X fiber, I don't even think it has mitochondria surrounding it. It's purely a
00:15:55 glycolytic tool, meaning it's going to basically have to go glucose to lactate. What accounts
00:16:03 mechanically for the difference? That's a good question. I think most people would say that
00:16:09 perhaps the overall just size difference, whether or not there are other things, how it may interact
00:16:17 and the speed of it, that might be different as well. But the big characteristic difference,
00:16:22 at least in young people, is that the size of the fiber is just distinctly different.
00:16:27 And I think when you look at fiber mechanics outside of the body and you test a type one or test a type
00:16:34 two, they will be different. How those interact within the body as a whole, I think is quite a bit
00:16:42 different. And that's always been an interest of mine with respect to dynamic strength, moving the
00:16:48 whole person, not necessarily saying, well, their fiber is still nice and strong, but what about when
00:16:55 the fiber is in the person? What's going on then? So I think there are, I think both of those are very
00:17:00 important. I'm not, I don't want to come across like I'm talking down to that type of work. I think
00:17:05 it's very important work, but I think they're just different.
00:17:07 How genetically set is this? It seems that there's clearly a difference in individual's
00:17:15 capacity for work, meaning aerobic work versus explosive strength anaerobic work. But do you
00:17:22 have a sense of how genetically diverse the fiber distribution is?
00:17:28 That's a question I always put forth to my class as well. I think you can look at papers and get some
00:17:33 percentages, but I, I don't feel super confident doing that mostly because we have a lot, not that
00:17:41 those scientists don't know that, but those are mass extrapolations from small bits of fibers. And one
00:17:48 of the things that I'm always interested in is the athlete that's thought to have like some of the
00:17:54 greatest endurance capacities or cross-country skiers. And if you were to look at their fiber types, many of
00:18:01 them may have a predominance of type one fibers. So the question is, were they mostly born like that
00:18:07 and then they gravitated towards sports that they're good at, or was there some sort of shift with
00:18:13 training? If I had to pick one, it's probably both, but if I had to pick one, I think there's a big genetic
00:18:21 component there, probably at baseline and then your response to exercise as well. But it seems to me that
00:18:29 most people gravitate towards events that they're pretty good at and they don't do the things that
00:18:35 they're not good at. So I think that makes it difficult to study this anyway, but I do think that there's a big
00:18:42 genetic component to it. It doesn't mean again, that they don't train hard or that's always the thing that I get
00:18:50 when I have a lot of athletes in my class. It's like, well, we train. It's like, there's no, there's no question
00:18:55 that you guys train extremely hard, but it's also possible that there's something different about
00:19:03 you already. So that, that would be my, my guess. And you sort of already touched on it a bit, but
00:19:09 do we have data to suggest how malleable that is? You know, we all know the extremes, right? Like we
00:19:16 know these sort of mesomorphic specimens that kind of look at weights and get bigger and stronger.
00:19:24 And then conversely, we know that sort of wiry person who can't put on muscle no matter what
00:19:30 they seemingly do, but boy, like you get them out there on a, on a bike and you, you, you can never
00:19:37 catch them. But when you take someone maybe who's not quite at the extremes, how much can training
00:19:44 and over what time period impact fiber type? I think certainly some, I don't think we're going
00:19:52 to take someone like myself who's athletically quite average. I don't think any amount of training was
00:19:59 going to make me elite in anything, but I do think that I could improve certain aspects of that for
00:20:06 sure. But I, I don't think it's going to myself move me to, you know, up a couple notches. Now there
00:20:15 could be some people who certainly can. I think that this is where there's quite a bit of confusion
00:20:21 with individual response data and things like that. We've published a little bit on this topic about
00:20:27 the measurements that we have aren't typically good enough to say, not only did this group increase
00:20:34 muscle size more than this group, but this individual increase more than this person, but
00:20:39 not quite as much as this person and not quite as much as this person that would require a very,
00:20:45 very good instrument. So I think people often take that to mean, so you're saying that there aren't
00:20:52 individual responders. I I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying that we, we may not have the ability
00:20:57 to appropriately determine who's who we can say overall on average doing this will increase this
00:21:04 or that. But I think that just looking around, it seems at least pretty clear to me that there are
00:21:12 some people who you give them a certain response and man, do they look like world beaters a couple
00:21:18 months later. So that does tell me something is, is different about them, but I don't know that we
00:21:24 could detect that with a lot of the measurements that we have. Okay. I think the other thing that
00:21:29 would be helpful for us to understand before we get into the science of blood flow restriction
00:21:35 is to understand what strength is and to understand what hypertrophy is. Do you have a preference with
00:21:42 which one we start with? Either one. Okay. So if we measure the size of my bicep today,
00:21:50 we could do it crudely with a tape measure. We could do it more accurately with an MRI or an
00:21:56 ultrasound. And you were to prescribe exercises that we'll talk about whether, whether without
00:22:02 blood flow restriction, we can get into load, we can get into reps, et cetera. We come back and
00:22:07 measure. And again, let's just use the gold standard. We'll use an MRI. We'll come back and measure me in
00:22:12 six months and demonstrably my muscle has gotten bigger. What does that mean? Did I grow more muscle
00:22:21 fibers? Did each fiber get bigger? How would you explain to somebody what happened in that cycle
00:22:26 of hypertrophy? So there's a couple of different ways that it could happen. You could have an increase
00:22:33 in fiber size, which is hypertrophy. So all the muscle cells that you have, maybe not all, but the muscle
00:22:40 cell itself has gotten bigger. So that's hypertrophy. The other component would be you have an increase
00:22:46 in the number of cells. That's hyperplasia. In general, we don't think that hyperplasia is playing
00:22:54 a big role, at least in adults. And I wouldn't necessarily rule it out, but it doesn't seem like
00:23:01 we have a lot of evidence for that. So we always just look at gross changes and assume that it's
00:23:06 probably hypertrophy. So when your muscle was to get bigger following exercise, what that would mean
00:23:12 is that the individual cells inside that bicep have increased in size. And we typically assume that
00:23:20 that's due to increases in overall protein, actin and myosin and things of that sort. You're obviously
00:23:26 going to also have an increase in other components to help support the cell. But that's generally what we
00:23:34 mean, an increase in cell size. When you think about like an epithelial cell or something like that,
00:23:41 we don't really pay much attention to the size of those cells, right? Like I don't know that anybody,
00:23:47 I don't know the dermatologist is looking at somebody's moles when they biopsy them and looking
00:23:53 at the individual cells and talking about the size of them. There we would concern ourselves much more
00:23:59 with hyperplasia and certainly metaplasia or dysplasia. Those are the things that really
00:24:04 get people concerned. But in this sense, muscles are kind of unique in that they can have not just
00:24:11 a non-pathologic, but a healthy change in size. So is it, as you said, do you think it's primarily due
00:24:19 to an increase in the amount of actin and myosin within the cell or some other characteristic?
00:24:26 Does the actin and myosin complex actually change in size or do you just have more of it?
00:24:33 I think that most people would say that, because they usually connect it to short-term
00:24:38 measures of protein synthesis. So myofibrillar, which is actin and myosin. So synthesizing more
00:24:44 and more of those, I think it's the general thought that you have more overall actin and myosin along
00:24:49 with other things, of course. And let's talk about strength now. So we can kind of break it down,
00:24:55 into kind of mechanical strength and neurologic strength. How do you think about that? So again,
00:25:03 let's use the same example of you measure my ability to do a bicep curl. And let's just assume
00:25:08 there'll be two measurements. You'll measure my single rep max, so the most that I can do.
00:25:14 And then you'll also do a separate test for the most that I can do 10 times or 15 times or something.
00:25:19 So you'll measure kind of two different components of strength, maybe absolute extreme and sort of
00:25:25 more of a muscular endurance test. And then you'll have me do a set of prescribed exercises for six
00:25:31 months and we'll come back and we'll do that whole thing again. And my one rep max went up by 20%
00:25:37 and the amount of weight that I could move 10 times went up 15%. What happened to me mechanically,
00:25:46 structurally, neurologically? What explains that change in strength?
00:25:51 That's a question that I'm extremely interested in. And I don't know why people get stronger. I think
00:25:59 the general thought or how we teach people is the initial change in strength is due to neurological
00:26:09 changes. So what does neurologic mean? I think is also up to some debate, but we could think about
00:26:17 a signal being sent from the brain through the spinal cord to the alpha motor neuron. So the alpha motor
00:26:23 neuron is the nerve that communicates with the muscle. So there could be changes anywhere,
00:26:29 in between that. So you have more excitatory input, you have less inhibition, you have lowering of
00:26:36 thresholds that makes it easier to fire the type two fibers. There's a lot of different things that
00:26:41 could be playing a role there for why someone might get stronger with neural adaptations. So most people
00:26:49 are okay with that part. Then the next part is people will say after about three to four weeks, when the
00:26:58 muscle is also getting bigger, that that change in fiber size will also be contributing to a change in
00:27:05 strength. And that's something that we have recently taken some exception to. And there's been a lot of really
00:27:14 good discussions about that part of it.
00:27:16 And we'll come back to that, Jeremy, because I've read the studies that you're referring to. They're super
00:27:21 fascinating. And I was actually surprised at how little evidence there was in favor of the dogmatic
00:27:30 view. So I look forward to diving into that a little bit more. And you can see why intuitively one would
00:27:36 say, well, size must produce strength if size comes from more actin and myosin, which basically means more
00:27:44 contractile units. But as we'll see, I think when we talk about some of your more recent work, that's not
00:27:50 necessarily settled, is it? Not in my opinion, no. And to be fair, it's not settled one way or the
00:27:56 other. But I do think that there's probably a neural component. But I think that there can also
00:28:01 be some changes at the local level that might explain some of those changes in strength. And I
00:28:08 think we can discuss that a little bit later as well. But there could be some changes at the myosin head
00:28:13 or changes in calcium release and things of that sort. So I don't have any good evidence that that
00:28:18 is actually happening, but just some ideas behind why someone might get stronger following exercise.
00:28:27 All right. I think that's a pretty solid primer for where we're about to go. So I'll start with
00:28:33 the story. I used to swim a lot. And oh, God, this might be circa 2010. So call it 10, 11 years ago.
00:28:42 I have a friend, Steve Munitonis, who's himself a remarkable swimmer, truly a world-class marathon
00:28:50 swimmer. And he was visiting San Diego from where he lived in LA. And he came to join me for a workout
00:28:58 at the master's club I swam at. And after the workout, he brought out these bands. They were
00:29:06 called katsu bands, which we're going to talk about. And he said, okay, Peter, I'm going to put these
00:29:11 bands on your thighs, upper thighs, and I'm going to put them on your arms, the upper arm. 0.94
00:29:17 And I'm going to compress to a certain level. And he had what looked like a blood pressure cuff there
00:29:23 that he could sort of calibrate the occlusive pressure. And I want you to swim a 50-yard
00:29:29 butterfly all out. Now, keep in mind, swimming a 50-yard butterfly all out under any circumstance
00:29:36 is quite challenging, but totally doable, right? I mean, you would do a set of 10 50s of butterfly
00:29:43 at 90% with 45 seconds in between and be totally fine. And I remember pushing off the wall.
00:29:53 And before I got to the other wall, which is 25 yards away to begin turning around to come back,
00:29:59 I was like, this is the hardest thing I've ever done. This feels harder than swimming 200 yards of
00:30:06 butterfly, which is really hard. So butterfly is one of those strokes where the longest distance
00:30:12 it's ever swum is 200 yards. And even people who train to swim the race at 200 yards almost never
00:30:18 swim that distance in practice. You're swimming shorter distances perfectly because your form tends
00:30:24 to fall apart so badly at 200. And here I was at 25 yards thinking, I'm going to die. And by the end of
00:30:34 that 50, my body felt like it would normally feel at the end of a 200-yard individual medley or 200
00:30:43 breaststroke, which would be kind of two of the most miserable things you could ever do to yourself.
00:30:47 And, you know, that began my kind of curiosity with this technique. I read a couple of books about
00:30:56 it. And, you know, unfortunately, I kind of just forgot about it. I, you know, once Steve went back
00:31:01 up to LA and I didn't have access to the fancy devices, I kind of sort of forgot about it. But
00:31:07 recently it's now become sort of curious to me. So what's the story of Yoshiaka Soda? What was the name
00:31:14 of the gentleman who came up with this system? Sato? Sato, yeah. So tell me about this guy and then
00:31:20 how he came up with this idea. Yeah. So some of this is, I'll say, is of legend. But I think the
00:31:29 story that he's told is that he was at a Buddhist ceremony, was kind of kneeling. And Sato was also,
00:31:37 from what I understand, interested in bodybuilding, especially in his younger days. So he felt kind of
00:31:43 a little bit of numbness or a little bit of sensation that he felt when he was doing heavy
00:31:48 squats. So he kind of thought that there could be some connection there. Because he was kneeling and
00:31:54 he was restricting blood flow. Okay. Right. That led him to start kind of experimenting with different
00:32:00 ways to try and restrict blood flow in his lower body, upper body, et cetera. I think that
00:32:06 there's been some stories that his initial kind of ideas, he actually harmed himself a little bit
00:32:13 because he was maybe applying it too tightly. But I think then he actually had a skiing accident and
00:32:18 then applied it to himself and actually rehabbed himself with blood flow restriction and saw some,
00:32:23 what he thought was some pretty good kind of gains. And I think that he really did probably develop a lot
00:32:31 of the methods for at least the initial way we were doing blood flow restriction and kind of made it,
00:32:36 you know, very popular with studying and research and things of that nature. But yeah, I think
00:32:43 he's probably the one who made it more popular, at least initially, because they started doing research
00:32:52 on that in the late nineties, early two thousands, at least in the published literature. So the idea
00:32:59 is, is that it mimics something that he had felt before in the gym and he wanted to see how he could
00:33:04 try and do that. And ultimately he found that you can use very light weights, low loads, but make it
00:33:10 feel like you're lifting very, very heavy weights, which is obviously useful. You know, if you have a
00:33:14 skiing accident or you don't want to lift heavy weights or you'd have some sort of injury.
00:33:18 Yeah. I had a patient last year who was playing with his kids and tore his bicep, had a complete
00:33:26 tear. So he underwent a surgical repair of that, but we decided to have him use blood flow restriction
00:33:33 during the rehab phase so that he could get back to training sooner, obviously under a far less load.
00:33:40 And although it's anecdotal, I mean, it was a remarkable recovery that he made,
00:33:44 which further kind of piqued my curiosity around this. So this term katsu is kind of synonymous
00:33:51 with blood flow restriction. Is it, and I think it's Japanese for like training with pressure or
00:33:57 training with added pressure or something to that effect, correct? Yeah. It means increasing
00:34:01 pressure. So it's just a brand. It's the one that's, it's fair to say is one of the first,
00:34:08 but it's just a brand. So we started using, I think a lot of people will use katsu as
00:34:15 just kind of a generic name, but it probably shouldn't be done unless you're using the katsu
00:34:20 apparatus. But yeah, it's just, it's a form of blood flow restriction.
00:34:25 So I want to come back to the different types of apparatus, but let's kind of talk through it now,
00:34:30 maybe chronologically in terms of the most insights. Like if I, if I was to go back in time
00:34:35 to the 1970s and I'm Sato and I'm trying to think about how to test this hypothesis,
00:34:41 it seems like hands down, the easiest way to do this would be to use individuals as their own
00:34:48 controls and isolate and compress one side and not do for the other and have them do the same things
00:34:58 or do different things and try to isolate the variable. So was that the first experiment that was
00:35:03 done? Yeah. The, the first experiment done on blood flow restriction, at least to my knowledge
00:35:10 on how we think of blood flow restriction. So I always add a lot of caveats because some people
00:35:17 will say, well, if you look in the thirties, there were studies done where they applied a cuff,
00:35:22 but it wasn't done for the purposes of increasing muscle function. So to my knowledge with blood flow
00:35:30 restriction, how we use it, Shinohara published the first paper in 1998, where they had individuals
00:35:37 that all they were looking at was strength, but they had one leg do a certain exercise with blood
00:35:44 flow restriction. The opposite leg did the same exercise without blood flow restriction. And they 0.71
00:35:51 saw a treatment effect, meaning the limb that underwent blood flow restriction saw a greater change. So
00:35:57 that's the, the first study was looking at a change in actual function with blood flow restriction.
00:36:03 It's kind of amazing that that didn't happen until 1998, which is 30 years after Sato began
00:36:10 writing about this stuff, or at least experimenting with it, right? Yes. The other question for me,
00:36:16 that's been very difficult to wrap my head around is what is the definition of blood flow restriction?
00:36:22 If I were to wrap a cuff around my arm and apply no pressure, clearly that's no restriction.
00:36:29 If I were to create an occlusive pressure that was twice my systolic blood pressure,
00:36:38 almost certainly it would imply not a drop of blood is making its way past. So there's no arterial flow
00:36:45 and no venous return. That would obviously blood flow restriction. That would be blood flow restriction.
00:36:52 But like everything else, you have a continuum. So how do you think about this? And maybe that's
00:36:59 the wrong question. Maybe the better question is in the, in the genesis of kind of the study of this,
00:37:05 how was restriction defined? What methods were used and how much variability existed in the studies?
00:37:13 So the idea of blood flow restriction is to reduce blood flow going into the limb, but not completely
00:37:21 occlude blood flow. So in other words, we always want blood flow to be going in. So there is a
00:37:27 tremendous amount of variability in how the pressure was applied early on. That's improved substantially
00:37:35 at improvement in my opinion, at least the early studies would take a cuff and apply the same pressure
00:37:41 to every single person. Independent of their blood pressure, independent of blood pressure,
00:37:47 independent of limb size, independent of the cuff size that you're using. So all of these things
00:37:53 are important factors that you can account for by doing this one measurement. That's how we do it now.
00:37:59 But obviously it's easy to look in the past and throw stones, but there were certainly a lot of
00:38:05 variability. So given that the idea is to restrict blood flow, but not occlude it completely during
00:38:14 exercise, what we started to do and others have started to do as well is before we do exercise, let's just
00:38:23 take the cuff up to the lowest pressure of which there is no flow at all. So if that's 100 millimeters of
00:38:29 mercury means that you no longer have flow going into your limb at all, let's take a percentage of
00:38:35 that. So we know that you always have flow during the exercise. Now, do you determine that with Doppler
00:38:42 at some distal point to the occlusion? Yes, you can use ultrasound. We use just a handheld Doppler probe
00:38:50 that's essentially detecting the pulse. So we can look at it here. We look at it at the ankle.
00:38:56 So before we have anybody do any exercise, we just lie them down. We slowly inflate whatever cuff we're going
00:39:04 to use because the cuff size matters. It's going to totally change the pressure applied. So we slowly inflate
00:39:13 it until we don't hear any more flow. And then we take a percentage of that. So if the arterial occlusion
00:39:20 pressure, which is the lowest pressure of which there is no flow, if that's 100 millimeters or
00:39:25 mercury, then we'll typically apply anywhere between 40 and 80 millimeters of mercury in our lab at
00:39:32 least. Yeah. So two points I want to make, or one point, one question. The point I want to make that
00:39:38 is a very important one that you just made is that this idea of cuff size matters, right? Because
00:39:43 the pressure and the force are related by the area that that cuff takes up. So is it safe to say
00:39:50 that the wider the cuff, the lower pressure you need to reach occlusion?
00:39:57 Yes, that's definitely true. And I think some people interpret that to mean that, does that mean
00:40:04 that a wider cuff is better because the pressure is lower? I would say no, because it's pretty much
00:40:09 relative. Some would argue that the wider the cuff is, you might actually attenuate some of the growth
00:40:15 beneath the cuff, but certainly the size of the cuff will change the pressure. So as you said,
00:40:21 the wider it is, the lower the pressure that you need. But again, as long as you apply whatever cuff
00:40:29 that you're going to use to whatever limb you're looking to exercise, taking one measurement can account
00:40:34 for everything. So then my question is, when you say 40 to 80%, that is a very wide range. That's like
00:40:44 the difference between 40 millimeters of mercury and 80 millimeters of mercury when 100 millimeters
00:40:49 of mercury is the occlusive pressure could be the difference between comfort and discomfort as an
00:40:55 example, right? Yes. So typically we use 40%. 40, 4-0. Yeah. Okay. That's the pressure that we use
00:41:05 when all we care about is muscle adaptations. In other words, increasing muscle size and strength.
00:41:11 Now you can see the same adaptation at 80% with a little bit less work because you're going to fail
00:41:19 sooner, but the discomfort is going to be much higher. Now, I think the other component of that
00:41:27 is that's muscle adaptation. Now we have some data, it's very preliminary, but some data that suggests that
00:41:36 some of the vascular changes might actually require a higher pressure. So vascular changes meaning
00:41:43 kind of a change in form limb blood flow or form conductance. So that's a gross measurement of
00:41:51 basically the vascular network. So there's some indication that maybe you do need higher pressure
00:41:57 for that. But that's one study. We did observe it in both the upper and lower body, which gives me a
00:42:03 little bit of confidence, but it's one study. But with muscle, I feel pretty confident saying
00:42:09 you can use a moderate pressure, 40%, or a high pressure, 80 to 90%. And the adaptation is going
00:42:18 to be pretty much the same with respect to muscle size and strength. The discomfort might be, or will
00:42:25 be quite different. We'll be much higher with a higher pressure. How much variability is there between
00:42:31 an individual's tolerance for discomfort at a fixed occlusive pressure? So I love the idea of using
00:42:38 80% of occlusive pressure because now it's not a given number. It's 80% for that individual. So in theory,
00:42:45 everybody is experiencing the same amount of relative occlusion. But if you took a hundred people
00:42:52 and let's even make it more homogeneous. If you took a hundred fit people and you simultaneously
00:43:00 applied 80% of occlusive pressure to bilateral upper extremities and just had them sit there,
00:43:09 so we'll do the first experiment where nobody does anything, what would the bell curve look like? How
00:43:13 tight would it be for the time at which a person cries uncle? And the pressure is 50%?
00:43:20 You pick a number. I said 80, but- Okay, 80. I don't know the minute. We have done some discomfort
00:43:26 studies applying 40% and just having people sit. Yeah. So at 40%, what's the answer?
00:43:31 It's pretty low. We stopped it at four minutes. We didn't have anybody who couldn't do it.
00:43:38 But you are going to have some people who do experience that as more discomfort than other
00:43:43 people. But it becomes much greater when you obviously combine it with muscle contraction.
00:43:48 But yeah, you're right. So when we say a 40% AOP, that doesn't necessarily mean a 40% reduction in
00:43:57 blood flow either. Those are two separate things. So when we apply 40% of AOP, the reduction in blood
00:44:03 flow might be different depending on how big the muscle is, a variety of other things. And the 0.91
00:44:08 discomfort associated with that will also vary depending on the person. There's some people
00:44:14 who we have who, they perceive almost everything as extreme discomfort. Whereas we have people on
00:44:20 the opposite side as well. But in general, we see, I can't think of the actual numerical value, but
00:44:27 we have 40% is right here. And then with 80%, it shifts, meaning that the average is certainly higher.
00:44:34 But there are certain people who, the discomfort they feel at 40 is not different than it is at 80
00:44:40 because they already rated it so high. So I mean, that's the limitation of the scale. But yeah,
00:44:46 you're right. What is the approximate blood flow restriction that occurs at 40% AOP? How much of
00:44:53 the blood flow, arterial flow is being limited and how much venous pooling is occurring?
00:44:57 I don't know the actual percent drop off the top of my head. It isn't 40%. It's on average is a little
00:45:04 bit less than that, depending upon the position, depending on what you're doing. But yeah, in
00:45:10 general, I think during the rest period, you probably do have venous occlusion because it
00:45:14 doesn't take, it's not thought to take a lot of pressure to collapse a vein. So during the exercise,
00:45:21 you're obviously pumping it back out with the muscle pump. But I would say at most of the pressures
00:45:27 that we apply, at least at rest, there is venous pulling occurring. Yeah. Today I finished my workout
00:45:33 with a set of leg press. So did 30 reps, rest 30 seconds, 15 reps, rest 30 seconds, 15. And I'm not
00:45:45 sure what hurt worse, just the 30 seconds in between or the actual last two sets, the 15 reps on the last
00:45:55 two sets. I mean, the whole thing was just so wildly uncomfortable. Again, I'm flying by the seat of my
00:46:00 pants, not doing this based on occlusive pressure. So I don't know how far off I am. It's something I'm
00:46:08 looking forward to diving deeper into. I think you've already convinced me I should be more scientific
00:46:12 in my approach because I'm sort of white knuckling it and putting these things on and screaming for dear
00:46:19 life. So I'm in pain kind of before the, I'm sort of very uncomfortable before I start. And even after
00:46:26 that first set of 30, I'm questioning my sanity. So who knows, maybe I'm applying too much. It would
00:46:32 seem that the directionally, would you have a nomogram of occlusive pressure versus expected
00:46:39 number of reps at a percentage of one rep max? Yeah. That's also tough. I think most of the loading
00:46:48 that we use is 30%. And to be honest, if we have somebody who's stronger, they're not getting
00:46:55 30, 15, 15, 15. There's no, there's no question they're going to be at failure. Most of the time
00:47:01 when we actually do experiments, we just have people exercise four sets to as many as repetitions as you
00:47:07 can. That way we can at least hold that constant so we can control for effort. But I do think that you
00:47:14 can use the number of repetitions as a weak surrogate of blood flow restriction. So I would
00:47:20 say that if you're using 20 or 30%, you should be getting close to 30 repetitions. No, no, for the
00:47:30 first set. So, and then close to 15, you may get 12, but if you can't get 30 on the first one or get
00:47:36 close to that, the load is probably too high or the wraps are too tight. I would say that if you're in
00:47:42 pain before you're starting, it's too tight. And we've done a lot of work on practical restriction
00:47:49 as well. I would say that practical meaning where we don't really know how much pressure is being
00:47:54 applied. We're applying a knee wrap. That's what I refer to as, as practical blood flow restriction.
00:48:00 I think if you are rehabbing or you're in a clinical setting, are you working in that? I think
00:48:05 you really need to know the pressure that you're applying. I think if you're a healthy person in the
00:48:11 gym who wants to use blood flow restriction, I don't think it's all that important to know the
00:48:16 pressure. Assuming you have the discussion that we're having now where I know the load is low.
00:48:22 I apply the wraps. I'm in pain. Well, then the wraps are too tight. So I loosen them up.
00:48:28 Then I can get close to 30 reps and then close to 15 on the last three sets. Now on the last one,
00:48:35 depending on how strong you are, you might fail pretty quick in that fourth set. That's okay.
00:48:42 But I do agree with you that I think that you can use goal repetitions as a way to
00:48:47 have some idea as at the level of restriction that's being applied.
00:48:52 So when you're at 40% occlusive pressure, what would be the kind of maximum period of time you
00:48:58 would let a subject stay under that pressure, both in terms of the combined lift recovery period?
00:49:03 Yeah. I think if they're just starting out, I think one, it depends on are they resistance training
00:49:10 or are they doing kind of low intensity aerobic exercise? If it's low intensity aerobic exercise,
00:49:15 you can probably keep it on for 30 or 40 minutes because it doesn't feel that discomforting because
00:49:22 you're exercising at a low intensity. The cuffs are not all that tight. You're not building up a
00:49:28 tremendous amount of metabolites, probably why you're not also getting a tremendous amount of adaptation.
00:49:32 But with resistance exercise, I think if you're just starting out, it's hard to have a minute.
00:49:39 I think maybe seven, eight, nine minutes, 10 minutes or so. I would say one exercise is a good place to start.
00:49:47 We've done it early on. We did multiple exercises for people who are untrained and that's pretty tough.
00:49:53 But I would say, you know, start off with four sets of an exercise and then take the cuffs off or take
00:49:59 the wrap off. And then you might be able to eventually work up to a couple. But I wouldn't
00:50:05 with resistance training, I don't think that you should leave it on continuously for probably more
00:50:10 than a few exercises. But if you've never done it, I wouldn't go beyond one just so you can start to
00:50:15 kind of see what it feels like. And so if 40 to 80 percent of occlusive pressure is the technical way
00:50:21 to do it, what other metric do you, would people use if they don't have access to a Doppler? For example,
00:50:29 if somebody knew their blood pressure, I can see why that would not necessarily be, I can see why
00:50:35 systolic blood pressure would not be the same as occlusive pressure. Is it a reasonable proxy?
00:50:40 Not always. It really depends upon if the size of the cuff that you're using is very similar in size,
00:50:47 then you could you could do that and base the pressure as a percentage of your systolic pressure.
00:50:54 I think the average gym goer, I think one of the things that you could do is apply the wrap as a
00:51:01 percentage of your resting limb size. So there's some data that's done that's used that. One of the ways
00:51:08 that we've tried to work with is condition people to feel what 40 percent supposed to feel like.
00:51:16 So you would have to have the device one day. So we're doing this because there are some places that
00:51:22 are applying this to clinical populations, where they have only a small amount of time with the
00:51:29 patient, and then they send them home to do exercises. The idea being is that you could be with
00:51:36 the patient, have them feel what 40 percent supposed to feel like, and then say, when you get home,
00:51:42 try to mimic this pressure. So we've had some success with that. We are able to get people to,
00:51:51 on average, rate around 40 percent, but the individual level is anywhere between 20 and 60 percent
00:51:58 of AOP. So it's not terrible, but it's not very good yet. One of the things that led us to that
00:52:07 is that initially, I was on a paper a long time ago that said you should rate the pressure based on
00:52:14 7 out of 10, because that can make sure that the pressure will be sub-occlusive. And that's overall
00:52:21 pretty much true. The issue is that you have a tremendously wide range, and it's not reliable,
00:52:29 meaning that on day one, you might say 7 out of 10 is 90 percent AOP. The next day, it might be 10 percent.
00:52:38 So we don't really recommend that scale anymore. We're interested in this idea of conditioning and or
00:52:43 using a percentage of a resting circumference, and or what we talked about earlier, we use repetitions
00:52:51 is kind of a goal. The cups I have are super cheapo cups. I feel like I want to invest in
00:52:56 sort of nice ones, but the one thing they have on them is numbers. So I've got a sense of like
00:53:02 on arms, I need to be between 7 and 8, and on legs between 11 and 12. And sometimes I just overcook it.
00:53:13 And after the first set, I have to loosen them if I want to have any hope of completing the exercises.
00:53:19 And then going back to weight, 20 to 40 percent of one rep max is about the place you like people to
00:53:26 be. Yeah, I generally prefer lower, meaning around 20 or 30 percent. There are some people who creep
00:53:33 up to 40. And so I just think that the real utility of using blood flow restriction is the fact that
00:53:40 you can use it with very low loads. So that's the benefit. We've tried to combine it with high loads.
00:53:48 In different aspects, and other people have run training studies with it, but it's not additive.
00:53:54 So it doesn't add anything more to high load training. And it's probably because high load
00:53:59 normal exercise is a maximal stimulus. So it's hard to maximize something that's probably already
00:54:05 pretty much maximal in a given training session. So that's why I'm like, if you want to lift with
00:54:11 heavy weights, didn't just do that. I think the utility of using blood flow restriction is with
00:54:17 that you can use lower loads. Any playing with the speed, either concentrically or eccentrically?
00:54:24 And does that matter?
00:54:25 The slower you go, the less repetitions you're obviously going to be able to do.
00:54:30 I don't think that it probably matters overall too much, especially for growth. The pace that we
00:54:37 typically use is about one second up, one second down. So a relatively quick pace. Some people use
00:54:43 a second and a half. So if you use a second to a second and a half, it's usually a nice controlled
00:54:49 movement. We haven't messed with too much in the lab, but I don't think it would matter too much.
00:54:56 I think it would alter how much work you were able to do and the load that you'd be able to use
00:55:00 more than anything.
00:55:02 Do you think that ultimately time under tension is all that's going to matter? So if you do it slower,
00:55:07 but you get fewer reps, it's still okay if you have the same time under tension?
00:55:12 Yeah, for the most part. Because when we think about a muscle growing, at least when I think about
00:55:16 a muscle growing, where it requires a muscle to be activated for a sufficient duration of time for
00:55:23 all those signaling pathways to be turned on. So from my perspective, there's a lot of different
00:55:28 ways for that to occur. You can use really, really heavy weights repeatedly, and that will do it. Or
00:55:35 you can use low loads, or you can use very slow pace as well. I think all of those are kind of doing
00:55:42 similar things. You're recruiting these more and more and more fibers, activating them, and signaling
00:55:49 them to grow. So yeah, I think it would be very similar.
00:55:53 And how much rest are you prescribing? I did 30 seconds today. Sometimes I do like a superset where
00:55:59 I'll do one muscle, another muscle, another muscle, and just go back and forth with two different muscles
00:56:04 and not take a passive rest. What do you think about those approaches?
00:56:09 In general, we use about 30 seconds. That's the standard one that we use in our lab.
00:56:15 When I've experimented in the gym, I think that supersetting works really well, especially if you
00:56:22 are working out of muscle that's not necessarily directly under blood flow restriction.
00:56:29 So for example, the chest, there is some idea that just doing a standard bench press exercise
00:56:36 with blood flow restriction around the arms would augment the size of the chest. There's some data
00:56:42 that indicates that. To me, I think a lot of that is driven by the fact that the muscles distal to the
00:56:49 cuff, the triceps are fatiguing, and the chest is picking up the load. So in the gym, I like to
00:56:55 experiment with that. So do some chest and then superset with some tricep extension or something like
00:57:01 that. But we haven't studied that in the lab, but those are things that I've messed around with in
00:57:05 the past.
00:57:06 Well, it's interesting. I've never thought to do something like a bench press with it,
00:57:11 frankly, mostly out of fear. But I guess if you adjust the weight low enough, it shouldn't really
00:57:17 be that much of an issue. I mean, once I did deadlifts restricted, I wasn't sure if it was a
00:57:23 great idea. I mean, it was very lightweight. It was probably like 135 pounds. So it was not the type of
00:57:28 weight I felt like I could ever hurt myself with. But I was like, okay, well, let's do 30 reps here
00:57:33 of 135-pound deadlift under restriction. Truthfully, I thought it was pretty freaking cool. I think in the
00:57:40 end, I didn't keep doing it because I was like, well, look, I don't want to develop bad habits
00:57:44 deadlifting under such fatigue. What's your thought on doing complex multi-joint movements?
00:57:52 Yeah, there is data looking at bench press, squat, and they have seen some benefits. I generally
00:58:02 agree with you. I think that you can do those, assuming that you're using lightweight. I tend
00:58:09 to prefer kind of isolation movements, especially if the goal is growth. But you could do them. I think
00:58:16 that you'd have varying success depending on the movement. The deadlift, I mean, if it's a Romanian 1.00
00:58:22 type deadlift, maybe I could see that having maybe some sort of benefit. But I think I'd have a similar
00:58:29 thought as you. It's like, am I going to change my mechanics somehow and then put myself at risk and
00:58:35 then really require blood flow restriction in order to train because I'm hurt? So yeah, you can do
00:58:42 compounds that there's certainly evidence that suggests that it can help with the squat, help
00:58:47 with the barbell bench press. We tend to use isolation movements and for research purposes,
00:58:53 obviously. But I tend to feel that a little bit better and I feel a little bit safer doing those
00:58:59 types of exercises. Let's talk about risks because I know that when people think about blood flow
00:59:05 restriction, I've had people ask me, are you worried about rhabdo? Are you worried about nerve damage?
00:59:11 Basically, what are the risks of this and what's the safety profile?
00:59:17 Sure. So I think that's a completely reasonable kind of response when you're telling people that,
00:59:26 hey, I'm restricting blood flow and I think you might consider it. I think the first response that
00:59:32 I would hope a person would say is, what's the safety of that? I think a couple things. One,
00:59:39 it helps to understand that this is a very acute response. In other words, we're restricting blood
00:59:46 flow for minutes, not for hours. So I think that that's important. I think the safety profile overall
00:59:54 is comparable to that of high load exercise or traditional exercise. There are two concerns that
01:00:00 people generally bring up. First is blood clotting. Second is muscle damage. In other words, does it
01:00:09 increase the risk of blood clots? Does it increase the risk of muscle damage? And I think those are
01:00:15 the way I stated that is how it should probably be stated. So anytime we exercise or anytime we wake up
01:00:22 and live, as you know, there's a risk. There's always a risk for something to occur. In my mind,
01:00:28 the question, the important question is not, is there a risk? But when we add blood flow restriction,
01:00:35 does it increase the risk? And it doesn't appear to, at least at the group level and mostly healthy
01:00:43 individuals. So it doesn't increase the risk of blood clots. And that has been looked at in some
01:00:49 clinical populations as well, which is good. It doesn't increase the risk of muscle damage. You will
01:00:55 get sore, but when we look at the fiber, it appears to be intact. So it doesn't appear to be some
01:01:02 structural damages at all. Have there been studies where they've measured CK levels and contrasted them
01:01:09 with and without restriction? And does there appear to be more breakdown, at least measured by CK?
01:01:14 No. Generally, when they look at most of those, there's not a whole lot of difference between
01:01:18 the same exercise without blood flow restriction. There's certainly soreness that I feel confident
01:01:24 about, but not necessarily structural damage. Another one that's been kind of brought up is
01:01:31 the blood pressure response to this exercise. So proximal to the cuff is blood pressure going
01:01:38 up centrally in the heart, the aorta, the brain. Yeah. And compared to the same exercise without it,
01:01:44 it usually is higher, but it's usually comparable to that. It's not a little bit lower than high
01:01:50 load exercise. So I think the key component of that is, of course, it's probably going to be higher.
01:01:57 You're restricting blood flow, but how high does it get and how quickly does it return back to baseline?
01:02:03 So I think that those are kind of two important components. Now, when we've compared it to high
01:02:08 load exercise, it's usually pretty similar and it usually comes back down to baseline within five minutes.
01:02:14 Those are healthy individuals. Now, there was a paper written on it suggesting that
01:02:19 that's great, but there are certain populations where they may hyper-respond to that. And I think
01:02:26 that's a good point. So I do think that it might be something to consider. If you have some sort of
01:02:33 clinical ailment, you might want to, if you might be hypersensitive to that reflex, that might be
01:02:40 something to really think about. In myself, when I think about doing unrestricted heavy movements,
01:02:47 so five to eight reps of deadlifts or something where I'm really going for it, that feels like I
01:02:56 have a much higher blood pressure than the blood pressure I feel like I'm under doing blood flow
01:03:02 restriction. Even though there's a much greater discomfort with the blood flow restriction,
01:03:07 I never really get the feeling like my head's going to pop off my shoulders, which I commonly
01:03:12 feel when I'm doing a heavy deadlift. Yeah, I agree. And I think that's a lot of the intramuscular
01:03:18 pressure all over, you know, a systemic kind of restriction. Well, yeah, because I think when
01:03:24 you're really lifting heavily, the intra-abdominal pressure is what allows you to do it. And, you know,
01:03:30 that's actually compressing the aorta. So it'd be interesting if you really think about where the
01:03:35 pressure matters the most. But I would say that overall, it does appear to be very safe.
01:03:41 You know, that's something that we're we've been interested in for a long time. I do think that
01:03:46 as with anything, when you give a drug in a large clinical trial, you start to see
01:03:51 some side effects that you've never seen before. So my guess is, is that when it becomes more and more
01:03:58 popular, we will find there will be certain rare events that we've never seen before. But I think
01:04:05 in the actual studies that have been done, we see it to be overall, relatively safe. It doesn't
01:04:11 increase the risk, at least, assuming it's done appropriately.
01:04:15 Has the following experiment ever been done where you take, well, in an ideal world, I guess you'd take
01:04:21 the same subject, right? So you have them do the exact same exercises for the same number of reps.
01:04:29 So you take, let's say, 30% of one rep max and do the 30, 15, 15, 15. But one of the arms is occluded,
01:04:37 the other is not. So the one that's not is not hurting at all. That should be pretty easy to do
01:04:44 that in the unoccluded side, correct? Correct. So you're exercising one arm under blood flow
01:04:50 restriction, the other arm is not? Correct. But you're using the same weight, the same reps, the
01:04:54 same rest, everything. Yes. Shinohara, for example, same workload. One had blood flow restriction,
01:05:01 the other one didn't. That was within subject. Those studies have been done. I think the criticism
01:05:07 on within subject studies is with respect to strength, not necessarily muscle growth.
01:05:13 Because some people think that, not some people, I mean, it is an observable fact that when you train
01:05:19 one side, but not the other, the other arm oftentimes can increase in strength. But I'm
01:05:25 not sure that that happens when both limbs train. I think the limb actually responds to the local,
01:05:32 what it's been trained to do. So I don't know that it's that big of a limitation with strength,
01:05:38 but yeah, those studies have been done. And what are they finding typically when they're under the same
01:05:43 load? One side is restricted, one side is not. Is the restricted side still making gains in strength
01:05:48 and or size? Yeah. Generally, the blood flow restriction will be better than a work matched
01:05:54 control, even if it's the same person. With the caveat that it's not to failure. And that's the
01:06:01 difficult thing if you're using 30%. Because 30%, for some people, you'll be reaching failure almost on
01:06:08 four sets in the non-included arm. So I think that should be stated. I think when we have
01:06:15 one limb trained to failure, the other limb trained with blood flow restriction to failure,
01:06:21 we've done those studies lots. The adaptation is usually pretty similar, but the volume,
01:06:26 the exercise volume needed is much lower with the blood flow restriction limb.
01:06:31 That's what I was sort of going to get at, which is, is blood flow restriction mostly just a tool to
01:06:39 increase or decrease the time to failure and therefore act as a more efficient means to fatigue the various
01:06:50 fibers. Yes. I think that's fair to say with a couple of potential things to consider. Blood flow restriction
01:07:00 by itself. So just the application of restriction and deflation and some ACL reconstruction, post-surgery
01:07:09 environment has shown to have some sort of benefit. So that suggests to me that there could be something
01:07:16 to the restriction of blood flow. Same thing when we have people walk very slowly. In other words,
01:07:22 they're not really walking to failure or even close to failure, but there does appear to be
01:07:28 some adaptation. It's not close to what you see with resistance exercise, but there's something
01:07:34 that's a little bit more there. So I think with resistance exercise, that might be a very fair
01:07:40 statement to say that you're just causing the muscle to have to activate more of the muscle sooner and
01:07:47 fatigue sooner than a non-occluded condition. I think that's fair, but to say that that's the only thing,
01:07:55 the only benefit of blood flow restriction, I don't know that we can say, especially considering
01:08:01 the vascular response I talked about earlier, that the vascular network, the blood flow,
01:08:08 the resting blood flow to the forearm or calf, it does appear to respond with a higher pressure,
01:08:15 but not a lower pressure, despite that both of them are doing a tremendous amount of work.
01:08:18 So I think it might be fair to say with muscle with respect to resistance exercise, but
01:08:23 I have some remaining questions before I would go all in.
01:08:28 So let's get back to something that we touched on earlier. We'll get to it in more depth,
01:08:34 which is the relationship between strength and hypertrophy. It's very clear that they're
01:08:39 correlated. It's not clear which way the arrow of causation runs, if there is a causal relationship
01:08:48 between them. What's the conventional thinking on this? The conventional wisdom or the conventional
01:08:55 thinking is that once muscle growth is there, that it's probably contributing to changes in strength.
01:09:02 That's the textbook definition. Neural first, followed by large contributions from muscle hypertrophy.
01:09:11 And doing a lot of research in the low load realm, as we've done, I started to really see that
01:09:18 maybe that's actually not the case because we almost always see muscle growth, which is similar to or
01:09:28 equivalent to that of high load exercise. But the strength, assuming that we're not practicing the
01:09:33 test repeatedly, is almost always less. And in my mind, I had a hard time coming up with a lot of
01:09:42 excuses. I did for several years. But at some point, in talking with my students, we just started to ask the
01:09:51 question about, well, where did this story come from, about muscle growth playing a role? And why do we even
01:09:59 think it in the first place? Because I'm trying really, really hard to make excuses for why we aren't seeing it.
01:10:04 But maybe we should go back to the beginning and see why did we ever think it in the first place? And that's where I think it
01:10:11 really becomes difficult for people to have this conversation because everybody has learned the
01:10:18 same thing that I learned. It's neural, then hypertrophy, neural, then hypertrophy. And they have a hard time
01:10:24 taking a step back and going, okay, but were those studies ever able to actually make that claim?
01:10:32 Yeah. So where did that hypothesis come from? What is the evidence in support of the null hypothesis?
01:10:37 I think if you were to get a bunch of people together, and we measured muscle size, and we
01:10:43 measured strength, on average, people who are bigger will be stronger. People who are smaller
01:10:51 will be weaker. That's true. And we've seen that. We've documented that ourselves. But that's not an
01:10:58 effect of exercise because we see the same relationships in people who have never exercised
01:11:05 in their life. You're saying that the correlation or association between strength and size is equally
01:11:11 strong in the untrained as it is the trained? Correct. The question that we're discussing is
01:11:17 when a person begins to exercise and then they get stronger, is that due to changes in muscle size?
01:11:26 And that's where I have the question. I don't question whether or not they're related. I completely agree
01:11:32 that they are. But when we exercise, does a change in one result in a change in the other? So it
01:11:40 obviously makes a lot of sense that it could. For all the reasons that we said earlier, we're increasing
01:11:46 actinamized, we're increasing this protein. Why would they not then produce greater strength? But there's
01:11:53 numerous times in the literature where we have shown greater changes in muscle size, but strength doesn't
01:12:01 even change. So that leads me to believe that there could be quite a bit of disconnect with respect to
01:12:09 muscle growth and the change in strength. Now, you wrote a paper basically trying to
01:12:15 go back to the root of this dogma. I think you basically found that there were sort of three papers
01:12:23 that formulated this viewpoint. Two of them, I think, were from the 70s. And then one was kind of a review
01:12:29 paper of one of those papers. Am I remembering this correctly?
01:12:33 Yeah. So the one that's commonly cited is Mauritania DeVries or DeVry. And they had five
01:12:41 individuals. One arm lifted weights. The other arm did not lift weights. And they were basically
01:12:51 inferring muscle growth off changes in service EMG. So they did measure arm circumference, but that wasn't
01:12:58 the variable they were using to quantify growth. They were looking at changes in the slope of this
01:13:04 integrated EMG. So if they saw a change in the slope, they inferred that to mean muscle growth.
01:13:11 If they didn't see a change in that slope, then they said that was neural.
01:13:15 Can you explain to me how that works? I don't know enough about EMG to understand that inference.
01:13:21 At least in my opinion, you cannot infer growth off a change in EMG.
01:13:24 But what they were doing is, is that let's say, let's pick a variety of weights. So let's say 10
01:13:31 pounds, 20 pounds, 30 pounds and up. So what is the EMG amplitude? So, but EMG amplitude is
01:13:39 essentially an estimate of muscle action potential. So how much signal do you get when you lift 10
01:13:45 pounds at baseline versus 20, 30, 40? Then they would do that every couple of weeks.
01:13:51 So if they lifted 10 pounds and the, basically the amplitude was a little bit less,
01:13:57 they would infer that that was being picked up by muscle growth.
01:14:01 So the amplitude they're using to assess the neurologic signal. And over time, they're saying
01:14:09 if the neurologic signal is going down and the effort is the same, hypertrophy makes up the
01:14:16 difference. Or for example, yeah, I got it.
01:14:19 One of the points that we're always trying to make is that guarantees that at some point hypertrophy
01:14:28 is going to be a mechanism. You're not actually testing a mechanism. You're just assuming that
01:14:33 at some point it will be a mechanism. So that was the same thing with Ikai and Fukunaga, which is the
01:14:38 other study. So they actually did measure muscle size. And to my knowledge, that's actually the first
01:14:44 study to actually document changes in muscle size in response to resistance exercise. So what I would
01:14:51 call a landmark paper. I really enjoy the paper. But what they infer is, is that if muscle growth
01:14:57 changes, then it must be playing a role. And if it doesn't change and they got stronger, then it must
01:15:05 be neural. And that's kind of the, where we've been at ever since. In other words, that when we run a
01:15:11 training study, if you get stronger, but we don't document a change in muscle size, it's neural.
01:15:18 If you get stronger and we measure changes in muscle size, well, then it was neural and hypertrophy.
01:15:26 So to me, I don't think we can make that claim because you're just assuming that the ability to
01:15:32 document it means it's actually doing something with respect to strength. I would like to see a little
01:15:38 bit more rigor in that. I understand why people would think it. I get all of that. And that makes
01:15:44 sense to me as well. But my question is, is that does it actually, and we've approached this through
01:15:51 a variety of different ways, but I think it does help to think about this historically. Where did this
01:15:57 come from? And it really does seemingly come from those two studies. And then Digby Sale had a very,
01:16:04 really great paper reviewing kind of all the work that had been done where he suggested that most
01:16:12 training studies are only documenting a certain aspect of an actual person's training age. So they're
01:16:19 never going to be able to actually answer this question because the studies are too short. But I don't
01:16:25 know that that's fair to say because more time to breeze is eight weeks, which is the same duration as a lot
01:16:31 of other studies that have basically contradicted it. So yeah, you're right. Those are the three
01:16:36 papers that are commonly cited for this neural first followed by hypertrophy.
01:16:43 Even outside of BFR, which seems to provide a very elegant tool to test the hypothesis,
01:16:47 as you've explained, and we'll get into in a little bit more detail, it seems that you could do other
01:16:52 experiments to test this even without blood flow restriction. For example, couldn't you have somebody do
01:17:00 workouts where they only do one to five reps of exercises and they're basically always functioning
01:17:08 and each of those is to failure, right? So if you're doing one rep, it's a one rep max. If you're doing
01:17:13 two reps, it's 95% of one rep max. If it's three reps, it's probably 90%. If it's five reps, it's probably
01:17:19 85% of one rep max. So you cycle through those workouts where you increase strength. In fact, I'll put a
01:17:27 very practical example to this. I know specifically athletes who train this way and they train with
01:17:34 a trap bar and they do not do the eccentric motion. So they lift the weight up and drop it,
01:17:42 lift the weight up and drop it. And they're never going above five reps. So they're really trying to
01:17:47 maximize strength, which comes more from the concentric movement. And they're trying to minimize
01:17:53 any hypertrophy because they're athletes for whom strength to weight is the most important ratio. So
01:17:59 it's very typical workout for runners. So they'll dramatically increase their strength without adding
01:18:06 size. And then you could compare that to the opposite type of workout where you do more of a bodybuilding
01:18:13 workout. You're probably never going below eight reps and you'll get bigger. And I could imagine a
01:18:20 scenario where you don't even get as strong as that other person. I mean, wouldn't that demonstrate
01:18:24 how uncoupled these two metrics can be? Yes, I agree with you. And we've done this several times now.
01:18:33 We've tried to address this question via study design, doing something very similar to what you said,
01:18:39 where we have one group that's training, just doing the one RM test. That's it. They come in,
01:18:45 they work up to about five total reps and then they go home because we're trying to maximize the
01:18:51 strength signal, but not get growth. Because essentially to answer this question, we have to
01:18:56 know if the muscle did get bigger and stronger, what would strength look like if muscle growth had not
01:19:04 occurred? So when we look at the traditional training group, we have them doing about eight to 12 reps.
01:19:10 And this is a very simple movement, the bicep curl. In that group, we see muscle growth and we see a
01:19:18 change in strength. Now, what a majority of articles would do is say, given that muscle growth is there,
01:19:25 that muscle growth must be contributing to strength. In our mind, we have to say, well, what would strength
01:19:32 look like if growth hadn't been there? And when we look at the other group that was just doing one RMs,
01:19:38 the strength is the same. Now it's not greater, but it is the same. I do think that the more
01:19:46 complex the movement becomes, the greater that separation starts to happen. So we were doing
01:19:51 a barbell bench press. My guess is, is that the group doing one RM or close to a one RM would be far
01:19:58 better than an eight to 12. But it's just the fact that the movement is very, very simple.
01:20:03 So similar to what you said, in our mind, this does provide some method of trying to address this
01:20:12 because we see a group with no growth compared to a group with growth, but the strength is the same,
01:20:19 suggesting that that change in muscle size is not necessary for a change in strength,
01:20:26 nor does it appear to be contributing, given that the strength is the same. Now, there are limitations
01:20:33 with that. One of the big ones is that in order to get that differential in growth, we had to apply
01:20:42 slightly different exercise patterns. So one group was doing eight to 12, still a high load, but not
01:20:50 a hundred percent, where we had another group training at a hundred percent. So some suggested
01:20:56 that, well, that's not really that fair of a comparison. There's more things that are different
01:21:02 than just the muscle growth. And that's, that's true. And they suggested that instead that we should
01:21:10 follow that up with some mediation analysis, where we look at how much of this change relative to a
01:21:17 control is driven by muscle size within each group individually. And when we did that,
01:21:23 we did not see any mediation, meaning that none of the change in strength could be explained
01:21:29 by that change in muscle size in either one of the groups.
01:21:33 Explain that more for me. I'm not sure I follow how you would determine that.
01:21:38 So there are some statistical kind of approaches where you can do some causal mediation. In other words,
01:21:46 you can look at the relationship between, let's say we have these two exercise groups.
01:21:51 So instead of looking at them head to head, let's look at them individually compared to a group
01:21:56 that's not doing any exercise at all. That way we can kind of really control for the random error
01:22:01 across time. So measurement noise, random biological variability, et cetera.
01:22:07 Essentially what mediation is doing is saying, okay, we have this group here.
01:22:11 How much strength did they gain?
01:22:15 So they got stronger. So that's a direct relationship.
01:22:19 So when this group exercises, they got stronger.
01:22:23 Now mediation says, okay, let's add in a variable here to see if we can remove this relationship either 0.98
01:22:29 partially or completely.
01:22:31 So if we add in muscle growth to the model, and then this group no longer correlates with strength,
01:22:39 then we'll know that that relationship is completely driven by this other variable.
01:22:44 Now we wouldn't expect for it to be completely, but we would expect for it partially.
01:22:49 But we didn't see that in either one of the groups.
01:22:52 Is the contrapositive then that it's not at all coupled?
01:22:57 Because if you were to ask me what my intuition is, which is worth maybe a warm bucket of hamster
01:23:03 vomit, my intuition would be there is an association, but it's not 100% causal.
01:23:11 So the R squared might be 0.5, not 0.99.
01:23:16 So in other words, I would not guess that there is no association.
01:23:20 I certainly wouldn't guess a negative association,
01:23:23 but I wouldn't guess that it's one-to-one causal.
01:23:26 Can the mediation tease that out?
01:23:29 Yes, because it would be a partial mediation in that sense.
01:23:32 And you did not see a partial mediation?
01:23:35 No, we didn't see any effect at all.
01:23:37 Now, there are other potential reasons.
01:23:39 I mean, we have to think about random error across time with our measurement and things of that.
01:23:44 I don't think that any of the work that we have done so far can conclusively say that it plays no role.
01:23:51 But I do think that we're having an accumulating amount of evidence that's suggesting that
01:23:58 if it does play a role, it is so small that we aren't able to ever detect it.
01:24:05 So I am not sure that muscle growth in response to exercise is a mechanism.
01:24:11 I've seen no experimental evidence that suggests that that's the case.
01:24:16 Now, for a practical, pragmatic person, what would that mean for them?
01:24:22 Well, I think what it could mean is, is that if you are interested in maximal strength,
01:24:28 in getting as strong as possible, you probably don't care whether it's a mechanism or not.
01:24:33 You just want to know, how do I get strong?
01:24:35 I think we can learn a couple of things from some of these experiments.
01:24:40 One, that there's a huge specificity component, meaning that if you want to be a very good squatter,
01:24:47 a very good deadlifter, and being very good squatter or being a very good deadlifter means
01:24:52 you're able to lift as heavy as possible one time, then that means you should be training
01:24:57 at least a good portion of the time at or close to that one RM.
01:25:01 Now, if you really believe that growth might be playing some role, what that might mean
01:25:10 for you is to say, well, if it is playing a role, it might be pretty small.
01:25:15 So maybe I can allocate less overall time to it, which would be good for most strength
01:25:20 athletes because that's typically what requires a lot of recovery because you're doing a lot
01:25:25 of volume to make a muscle grow.
01:25:27 So I become more skeptical of muscle growth as a mechanism every year that goes by.
01:25:34 We're still doing more experiments to try and address this, but there certainly is no
01:25:39 evidence right now that suggests that it is a mechanism.
01:25:42 We have a lot of evidence that suggests that it isn't, but I do think it would be premature
01:25:47 to say, well, we've completely ruled it out.
01:25:50 I don't think that's fair to say at all.
01:25:52 So what are some other explanations?
01:25:53 I mean, I guess nobody's disputing the neurologic component to this.
01:25:57 Is one hypothesis that that is the entirety of it?
01:26:01 Or do you think that there is another mechanism that isn't fully clear?
01:26:05 Yes.
01:26:05 I think some people would say that some people are of the opinion that the exercise induced
01:26:11 changes are probably predominantly neural.
01:26:14 I'm not there yet.
01:26:15 I think that there could be some local changes at the muscle and that might be able to explain
01:26:23 why some groups get stronger.
01:26:26 That's not just neural.
01:26:27 In other words, maybe the muscle at the local level is actually getting better at responding
01:26:35 to forceful contractions.
01:26:36 So maybe it's, you know, how it deals with calcium or how the myosin head binds.
01:26:40 Maybe there's some alterations there qualitatively that aren't due to muscle size, but I don't
01:26:47 know what those would be necessarily.
01:26:49 I can only offer potential reasons.
01:26:52 And I think that's usually the argument that's brought up mostly against our point is, well,
01:26:58 if muscle growth is not a mechanism, then what exactly is it?
01:27:01 And I don't think that that's a fair argument, honestly, because I don't know that you have
01:27:08 to know for sure what something is to say, we don't have a lot of evidence for this.
01:27:12 And there's a lot of evidence against this, but that's just my kind of thinking.
01:27:17 But I do think that there probably is a huge neural component, but I don't know that there
01:27:23 isn't something going on at the local level that is independent of a change in muscle size,
01:27:29 but it is still muscular, perhaps.
01:27:32 So how common is BFR with athletes today?
01:27:38 I think it's becoming more and more common.
01:27:42 I know at Ole Miss, for example, as well as a lot of other Division I schools in the athletic
01:27:47 department, I would say a large portion of them do have blood flow restriction devices.
01:27:52 So they are using it for rehab.
01:27:54 And I know that I've seen players on ESPN and the NBA, NFL using blood flow restriction
01:28:02 as well.
01:28:03 For rehab exclusively, or do you see them using it when they're not injured as well?
01:28:07 I think there's a couple of NBA players just looking at some of the stories where they were
01:28:11 using it, not for rehab, but just as an everyday kind of way to train where they were able to
01:28:18 recover just a little bit faster.
01:28:19 And they don't have to have a, as they've aged, you know, they want to make sure that
01:28:23 they're ready to play on the actual court instead of just spending all their time recovering
01:28:28 from their workout.
01:28:29 So I think that they perceive this as one option to use where they're able to get some kind
01:28:36 of workout in, but maybe recover quite a bit faster than they might doing normal exercise.
01:28:42 Is the speed of the recovery a function of less trauma to the muscle during the workout?
01:28:47 Or why, why is their recovery quicker?
01:28:50 I don't know that we know that, but I, it does appear that when they are injured and
01:28:58 they're working out with blood flow restriction, they're able to usually to get a little bit
01:29:03 more out of that compared to high load exercise, or at least very similar to that, but they have
01:29:07 less pain during the movement.
01:29:10 So maybe they're able to get a little bit more out of the rehabilitation than they normally
01:29:13 are because maybe they're, before they're inhibited to a greater degree with, by pain,
01:29:20 that's reduced a little bit through the application of blood flow restriction.
01:29:23 But I don't really know, to be honest.
01:29:28 If let's take an extreme, a bodybuilder, right?
01:29:32 Where they're not being judged at all on strength.
01:29:34 I mean, I have yet to see a bodybuilder who's not very strong, but presumably due to the, just
01:29:39 the overwhelming amount of volume in their training.
01:29:42 But, you know, I even talked about this with Lane on the podcast when he was explaining
01:29:47 how, look, at the end of the day, the volume is what's going to matter.
01:29:49 And, you know, you can do that with isolated movements.
01:29:52 You can do that with compound movements, but you just need to get lots and lots and lots
01:29:58 of volume across these kind of ranges.
01:30:01 So if the goal is purely hypertrophy, which at least during part of the bodybuilder, but the
01:30:06 bodybuilder cycle is the case, how would they utilize BFR?
01:30:10 First of all, would it be a valuable tool above traditional training?
01:30:14 And if so, what would be the optimal way to use it?
01:30:17 Yeah, I think it could be.
01:30:18 It could be a tool if that's how they choose to use it.
01:30:22 I think for muscle growth, I think I agree with Lane that it really comes down to personal
01:30:27 preference because even without blood flow restriction, we've seen from 30% up to, you
01:30:34 know, 80% or even higher can produce the same amount of muscle growth.
01:30:38 So I think that allows you to have some level of preference on based on how you feel that
01:30:43 day or what you enjoy.
01:30:46 There are days where if you have a heavy day, for example, and you're going into the gym,
01:30:52 but you don't feel good or you're not psychologically have it.
01:30:55 And it could be potentially dangerous for you to use a heavy weight because you're not focused.
01:31:02 Then maybe that's a time where you might be able to implement some blood flow restriction
01:31:05 because you can use light weights.
01:31:07 It doesn't require as much focus.
01:31:10 And you could probably see a lot of the same response, at least with growth.
01:31:15 Another component could be is that it just helps with some variety.
01:31:19 I don't think that variety is necessary per se for muscle growth to be optimal.
01:31:25 But I think if you're training for an extended period of time across your life,
01:31:29 things can get pretty boring if you're just doing the same thing all the time.
01:31:33 So it could be a way to try and spice it up a little bit.
01:31:38 And then obviously, if you're hurt, I mean, it could be a great tool to use because there
01:31:42 is a lot of or becoming to be more and more evidence that it's helpful in the rehabilitation
01:31:48 world.
01:31:49 So I think there's a variety of ways that it can be used.
01:31:51 But I do think that it's probably important to note that if a person's not comfortable
01:31:56 with it, they don't have to do blood flow restriction in order to optimize how much muscle 0.74
01:32:02 that they can grow.
01:32:04 But it is a tool that could be potentially quite effective for them.
01:32:09 Yeah.
01:32:09 Actually, the example you gave is exactly what happened today, which was today's main set
01:32:14 for me was five by five deadlift.
01:32:17 So obviously, that's, you know, a heavy-ish day.
01:32:21 And I took five sets to warm up to get to the starting weight.
01:32:26 That first set of five, I was like, yeah, this, I just, I'm struggling.
01:32:30 Second set, still struggling.
01:32:33 Third set, struggled more.
01:32:34 Fourth set, I was like, boy.
01:32:37 And I'm supposed to be escalating the weight.
01:32:38 And on the fifth set, two reps in, I thought, this is the day you hurt yourself because I'm
01:32:45 going to break my form to get number three, four, and five.
01:32:48 So I actually just stopped.
01:32:49 And that's why I went and did the leg press with blood flow restriction, which was a very
01:32:55 lightweight.
01:32:56 I mean, I don't even remember how many pounds it was, but it was the type of weight that
01:33:00 if I wasn't restricted would have, you know, I could have done a hundred reps, I'm sure.
01:33:03 So, but it was a great way to mix up the training and that's the kind of stuff I'm interested
01:33:08 in exploring.
01:33:09 I also kind of think of this as a tool for people who maybe don't have some of the technique
01:33:17 to do heavier lifts, much in the same way I've sort of thought of the super slow lifting
01:33:24 protocols as reasonable protocols for people who just don't have the desire to train at
01:33:31 higher volume and frequency and, or don't have the technical chops.
01:33:36 Now that said, I've always felt that the problem with super slow training is unless it's done
01:33:43 to failure, which is upsettingly painful.
01:33:46 If you've tried those workouts, it's probably not nearly as beneficial as traditional training.
01:33:53 You know, the, the, the sort of super slow advocates will say it's on par with traditional
01:33:59 training, right?
01:34:02 You could do 20 minutes once or twice a week and have the benefits of six hours per week.
01:34:05 I'm not sure that that's true, even from a hypertrophy standpoint, but if it is true,
01:34:10 it's probably limited to the few people who truly can fail.
01:34:15 And I don't know if you've ever tried these super slow workouts, but it's very difficult to
01:34:21 truly fail.
01:34:22 I think it's, it's very hard for, I think most people.
01:34:26 Yeah.
01:34:26 A long time ago, but I, I never did much with it.
01:34:30 There was somebody in my, that I worked with in my PhD who was very interested in it for
01:34:35 a while, but yeah, I was never really a fan for sure.
01:34:39 How come for the same reason or.
01:34:41 I never felt like I was going to get very strong from doing something like that.
01:34:44 I'm just moving so slow and the weight is usually so light that I don't know how much that would
01:34:51 be transferring over to something that I was interested in at the time, which was to get
01:34:55 as strong as possible.
01:34:57 It's definitely hard.
01:34:58 There's no question, but I didn't enjoy that form of training.
01:35:03 So it's safe to say that the one place, I think you really talked about this already,
01:35:07 but I just want to make sure we put a dot on it.
01:35:09 The one place where it's unambiguous that you need to be doing a traditional lift without
01:35:14 restriction is if you're training for maximum strength of that lift, which again, I don't
01:35:21 think most people are doing maximum strength bicep curls.
01:35:24 I don't think that's, but, but when you start to talk about a bench press, a squat, a deadlift,
01:35:28 a leg press for that matter, if you're, if you care so much, there's probably no substitute
01:35:34 for being in that 80% to a hundred percent one RM.
01:35:39 Is that kind of a safe takeaway?
01:35:42 Yeah.
01:35:42 And if you do blood flow restricted exercise with low loads, assuming it's not extremely low,
01:35:49 like if you're around 20 or 30%, you will get stronger, but it will be to a much smaller degree
01:35:55 than you would with traditional exercise.
01:35:57 I completely agree.
01:35:58 And I'll just add to, we get this a lot where it's like, well, you're doing bicep curls in your
01:36:03 study is like, because we're using bicep curl.
01:36:06 It's a research model to answer a particular question.
01:36:10 We're not personally training people.
01:36:11 So I think sometimes people lose the reason why certain things are done.
01:36:18 Sometimes people will look at low load literature with blood flow restriction or even low load
01:36:23 literature without blood flow restriction and say, yeah, but look at this study.
01:36:27 They found very similar changes in strength as high load exercise.
01:36:30 And some of those studies do exist, but the majority of those that do find that effect.
01:36:36 If you look at the methods, what they're doing is the low load BFR group is doing the one
01:36:42 RM every two weeks or every three weeks.
01:36:45 And they're doing it in effect to try and reset the load so they can assume that they're progressing.
01:36:54 But what they end up doing is practicing lifting a heavy weight.
01:36:58 So you're not actually studying low loads of BFR.
01:37:01 You're studying low loads with BFR plus one RM training.
01:37:05 And I think that that's a very important point.
01:37:09 And we actually reviewed this.
01:37:12 We published a paper on this topic where we show that when you only look at the studies
01:37:17 with low loads that don't practice doing the one RM test repeatedly, almost all of them
01:37:24 lose the high load exercise.
01:37:27 Just again, illustrating the point that it's about lifting heavy weight is the best way to
01:37:33 get better at lifting heavy weight.
01:37:35 It doesn't mean that you won't get stronger lifting lighter weight, but you won't be as
01:37:40 strong as you were.
01:37:41 Let me summarize what you just said, because I think in terms of big picture, there are
01:37:46 really two areas where BFR shines.
01:37:50 One of them is in an individual who for some reason can't lift heavy weight, but still needs
01:37:57 to get stronger and potentially bigger.
01:37:59 And the obvious example is the person who's recovering from an injury.
01:38:04 And then potentially the person who just has a concern about lifting heavy weight, either
01:38:09 from a technical standpoint or injury avoidance or things like that.
01:38:13 The second place where BFR seems to really stand out is in hypertrophy.
01:38:18 Most of these studies are demonstrating slightly superior hypertrophy response despite less total
01:38:29 volume and certainly lower load.
01:38:31 It's at least as good in hypertrophy and in some cases better as my reading of the literature.
01:38:36 If you have a low load with BFR compared to a work-matched low load group without BFR,
01:38:42 hypertrophy is better almost always.
01:38:44 And to make them equal, you will just have to go more on the, you'll have to go to a
01:38:50 greater degree of reps on the unrestricted side to failure, basically.
01:38:56 Yep.
01:38:56 And therefore it takes more time.
01:38:58 Correct.
01:38:58 To get the same effect.
01:38:59 So it's a more efficient way potentially to generate hypertrophy.
01:39:03 It's probably more accurate than what I said earlier.
01:39:05 Now, the vascular adaptations, again, I keep putting that caveat in because it's always
01:39:11 in my mind because I really expected that to be the same across the board as well.
01:39:16 Meaning that as long as you're doing a lot of repetitions, it shouldn't matter whether
01:39:20 there's BFR or not.
01:39:21 That's not what we found.
01:39:23 Now, whether or not that can be repeated, I'm not sure.
01:39:27 Hopefully we can do that in the future.
01:39:28 But because my thinking for a long time was similar to what you were saying earlier.
01:39:34 It doesn't really matter whether there's BFR or not.
01:39:37 If you do enough, it'll be very similar.
01:39:39 The workload will just be less.
01:39:41 And I think that, again, it's true for muscle, but I don't know if that's true for every single
01:39:44 variable.
01:39:46 Let's talk about the mechanism by which this is happening.
01:39:48 My assumption, which I don't know if it's right or wrong, is that at least one of the
01:39:56 reasons that BFR can produce so much hypertrophy at such low load is in response to the metabolic
01:40:05 challenge that's posed.
01:40:07 And so one of the things I was doing quite a bit was testing lactate levels with and without
01:40:12 BFR.
01:40:13 It's very easy to demonstrate that when you occlude your arm, for example, well, distal
01:40:20 to that occlusion, lactate is going through the roof because you're exercising that arm
01:40:24 and you're not letting the lactate clear out of circulation.
01:40:27 So I'm pinpricking my finger and getting very, very high lactate levels.
01:40:33 And so that's obviously a metabolic byproduct of any time you're exercising and then especially
01:40:39 when you're doing this type of exercise.
01:40:41 And so, yeah, I could demonstrate that I had a higher level of lactate doing blood flow
01:40:48 restriction than not, even when I was lifting slightly more weight and doing something traditional.
01:40:54 Do we think that that matters in this equation?
01:40:57 Do we think that that's partially driving this?
01:40:59 And that's just one of the metabolites that we can measure easily.
01:41:02 There's plenty that we can't.
01:41:04 Yes, I would agree.
01:41:06 I think that there's kind of two schools of thought.
01:41:08 One is that the pooling of these metabolites in and of themselves is turning on some of
01:41:15 these anabolic signaling pathways, meaning just the fact that you're pooling lactate around
01:41:20 the fibers, that that's able to activate growth.
01:41:24 I used to be interested in that idea.
01:41:27 We tried to test this using a couple of different ways.
01:41:30 We didn't find an advantage to doing that.
01:41:34 So we kind of started to say, well, maybe there's nothing to metabolize in and of themselves,
01:41:40 but maybe it's what they're causing the muscle to do.
01:41:45 So in other words, maybe the way we think about it now is, is that as you said, you're exercising
01:41:50 with blood flow restriction.
01:41:52 The metabolites are being trapped.
01:41:53 What we think is, is that they're augmenting muscle activation.
01:41:57 So they're causing the muscle to have to work a lot harder than it normally would because
01:42:04 you're pulling this lactate around it and you might fatigue some of these cross bridges.
01:42:09 So we have to recruit more and more and more and more fibers.
01:42:14 So that's where we think the benefit of metabolites is, is that they're basically inducing fatigue,
01:42:20 which then leads to further muscle activation.
01:42:23 And muscle activation for a sufficient duration of time is, is the name of the game, at least
01:42:30 in my opinion, for making a muscle grow.
01:42:33 So one of the, the big kind of questions always is, are the mechanisms themselves different
01:42:41 from traditional exercise?
01:42:43 If I do high load exercise, is that going to be a different mechanism than when I do low
01:42:50 load exercise with blood flow restriction?
01:42:51 And I don't think so.
01:42:54 And I'll tell you why.
01:42:56 I think that the mechanism involved in activation is different.
01:43:03 But once the fiber is activated, all the signaling pathways, from what I understand, are going
01:43:09 to be very similar.
01:43:10 So when we lift a heavy weight, it requires a tremendous muscle activation to even lift
01:43:18 one rep.
01:43:19 If you are trying to do a bicep curl and you're only activating a small portion of your fibers
01:43:24 and you're trying to lift 70 pounds, if your one RM is a hundred pounds, that's an enormous
01:43:30 bicep curl. 0.90
01:43:31 So I was about to say, I really feel pretty pathetic here. 0.55
01:43:34 Yep. 0.96
01:43:34 But go ahead.
01:43:35 So choose any lift.
01:43:38 In order to lift that heavy weight, you need to activate a large portion of your musculature.
01:43:44 Otherwise the weight isn't going to move.
01:43:46 Compared to low loads, where you don't need to activate the same amount of muscle fibers
01:43:51 initially because the weight is extremely low.
01:43:54 So when we exercise with low loads and BFR, we're activating only a small amount initially.
01:44:01 But those metabolites, as you discussed, start to become trapped and we activate more fibers,
01:44:07 more fibers, more fibers, and more fibers.
01:44:09 And then by the end, we've activated a similar amount of fibers as we did with high load exercise.
01:44:15 By the way, is there an order in that?
01:44:17 So if your one RM bicep curl is a hundred pounds.
01:44:21 So with no blood flow restriction, you pick up 80 pounds and bang out, I don't know, 10 reps,
01:44:31 eight reps.
01:44:31 Compare that with if you picked up 40 pounds and banged out 40 reps, what is happening from
01:44:43 a fiber fatigue standpoint under those two scenarios?
01:44:47 In general, we have what we call the Henneman size principle, where you recruit type one motor
01:44:53 units first.
01:44:55 And then as you require, based on the exercise, you recruit type two in addition to type one.
01:45:02 So when you lift a heavy weight, you're getting to the type twos very quickly because you need
01:45:07 them.
01:45:08 Whereas with lower weight, you probably are taking a little bit of time, but then you are
01:45:13 eventually getting to those type two motor units.
01:45:16 So if the person in my example fails at eight reps with 80 pounds and 40 reps with 40 pounds,
01:45:24 it's just that the 40 reps took a lot longer to burn through the type one fibers.
01:45:30 And then the type two A's and the two A B's.
01:45:34 And then finally at the very end, the two X failed.
01:45:37 Whereas when he did the same exercise, you know, 20 minutes later at 80 pounds and failed
01:45:44 at eight reps, he did the same sequence, but he just got to the two X much sooner.
01:45:49 Is that what you're saying?
01:45:51 Yeah.
01:45:51 Yeah.
01:45:52 And the reason why I say that is if you look at, if you pull out fibers following training,
01:45:57 type one and type two fibers have both been shown to grow in both high load exercise as
01:46:03 well as low load exercise with and without blood flow restriction.
01:46:07 So they both respond.
01:46:09 Some people have suggested that type one might grow a little bit more with low load training,
01:46:15 but I, I'm not convinced on that yet.
01:46:18 I think that it's probably very similar to high load exercise, although I see the thinking,
01:46:22 but both of them will grow in response to both types of exercise.
01:46:27 In general, at the extreme level, is a bodybuilder's hypertrophy more explained by type one or type
01:46:34 two fibers, or are they both massive relative to anybody else?
01:46:39 I would say probably the increase in both, although I don't, I'm not, there's not one thing I can
01:46:45 point to that would suggest that for me, but I, I think that in response to training, my guess
01:46:53 is that both of them would increase.
01:46:55 I think you might be able to make an argument that people who might, again, go back to our
01:47:00 argument earlier, who start lifting weights and realize, man, I'm actually able to grow quite a
01:47:06 bit. Maybe they already had more type two fibers to begin with, which is something is more responsive
01:47:13 to loading. So maybe you can make that argument, but I think in response to exercise, when a bodybuilder
01:47:19 exercises, I would probably guess that both of them are going to grow both types of fibers.
01:47:24 You mentioned very briefly, passive BFR. What's the application for that? Is that in a highly
01:47:30 injured person?
01:47:32 Yeah. And again, there's only a small number of studies that have shown this. That could be for
01:47:37 a variety of reasons. One, it could be because those are hard to do, where you have somebody who
01:47:43 had ACL surgery, and then we apply blood flow restriction to their limb. We inflate and then we
01:47:50 deflate for a period of time, a couple of times a day. And that's been shown to slow muscle loss.
01:47:54 But there's only a few studies that have shown that. Now, again, you don't see growth. You only
01:48:00 see a slowing of loss.
01:48:02 Attenuation of loss, which is a big, big deal when people undergo surgery.
01:48:06 I'm very interested in whether or not that's true. One of the things that gives me a little bit of pause
01:48:12 is that there's not more of those studies. So in my mind, I always wonder, is that because
01:48:19 those are, again, hard to do? Or is it because those studies do exist, but they didn't see anything
01:48:25 and they didn't publish it? So I'm cautiously optimistic that that could be useful. But I do
01:48:33 think that as soon as a person can exercise, you know, and we kind of published a paper on this idea
01:48:39 a long time ago, kind of what we view as a progression of blood flow restriction. In other
01:48:45 words, someone who wants to, who can't do anything, how do we get them back to doing something?
01:48:50 So we start off with, if they can't even walk, we apply this restriction to slow down muscle loss.
01:48:57 Once they can maybe walk on a treadmill or walk very slowly, but they can't lift weights,
01:49:02 we start to transition them to that phase where they're able to increase muscle size
01:49:05 and strength just a little bit. And if nothing else, maintain what they have. But then once they
01:49:11 can transition to resistance exercise, I think that's where they're going to see the biggest
01:49:17 bang for their buck. And then they can go to highlight exercise if they choose. But I do feel
01:49:23 like that's a very potential useful progression to this technique. This is such an important question.
01:49:29 It's a real shame. This isn't being studied. Like if I were czar for a day and I was in charge of
01:49:35 where research dollars would be spent, I would be putting, because I don't think it would take that
01:49:40 much money by the way, but I would absolutely prioritize this question. When you consider
01:49:45 the extent of muscle loss that occurs in sedentary individuals following elective surgery,
01:49:53 emergent surgery and injuries. So those are three very big buckets of people disproportionately,
01:49:59 by the way, affected in the elderly where the effects are devastating. I'm sure you're familiar
01:50:04 with the literature of, you know, you take somebody in their seventh decade of life and you train them
01:50:10 very hard for a year. They'll put on X pounds of muscle and then put them in a hospital bed for 10
01:50:17 days. They will lose all of it. They will lose every ounce that they spent a year diligently gaining.
01:50:23 To think that there could be a tool that could slow that and we don't know the answer definitively
01:50:30 strikes me as just unbelievable, unwise decision that's been made. So I would hope somebody who has
01:50:38 the authority over where those dollars go is listening to this and realizing that the morbidity
01:50:43 and mortality associated with muscle loss, especially in the elderly, is so significant. And one of the
01:50:50 things we talk about a lot with our patients is once you get to be 70 and certainly 80 years old,
01:50:55 you're kind of one fall away from the end of your life, even if you don't die directly, right? So
01:51:01 there's the catastrophic fall where you hit your head, you have a cerebral hemorrhage and you die.
01:51:06 That's not the majority of them. The real fall you are away from your, the end of your life
01:51:12 is the injury that basically never permits you to get back on your feet. Because even when you recover
01:51:20 from the direct injury, maybe a broken hip, which is common, you never get back the strength and
01:51:26 stamina you once had. I just think BFR should be explored much more in this population. That should
01:51:32 be standard of care if indeed it is effective in both the passive and then the, as you described,
01:51:39 the progression, right? So passive, low end aerobic, low load resistance, and ultimately if you can get
01:51:45 back to high load resistance, great. Right. So if you had unlimited resources right now, what,
01:51:51 what experiment would you want to do? What's the, what are the burning questions that if
01:51:55 Francis Collins called you tomorrow and said, Jeremy, I've got this extra a hundred million bucks,
01:52:00 we just, we've got to get rid of it. What can you do? Huh? That's a good question. I would do
01:52:06 something with blood flow restriction, of course, but my interest right now is related to trying to
01:52:11 figure out why people get stronger. And I think I can always tie that back into blood flow restriction
01:52:16 and be able to do things of that sort. But I'm interested in what that means and what a change
01:52:24 in strength from resistance training, what that means for overall function of a person. So when I get
01:52:31 stronger with resistance training, does that actually carry over to improvements in my walking
01:52:37 ability and things of that sort? So those are some things that I'm interested in with blood flow
01:52:42 restriction. I'd obviously do kind of what you just stated. I'd have to probably connect with our med
01:52:48 school in order to do a study like that, but I, I would be interested in the application of blood
01:52:54 flow restriction by itself. I think that that is something that I've been interested in for a long time.
01:53:00 Again, I think it'd have to be not something we could do right out of my lab. We'd have to work
01:53:05 with a hospital, of course, but I'd be interested in that. And I'd be interested in doing it on a large
01:53:11 scale because all of those studies that currently exist are extremely small sample size. So for,
01:53:18 of course, for a variety of reasons, but I'd want to start answering a lot of these questions with
01:53:24 large sample sizes. That would be kind of my, my dream studies, whatever it would be,
01:53:29 whether it's strength, whether it's this bigger studies, longer studies. I think that a hundred
01:53:35 million dollars, I could do a lot for sure. Well, amazingly, that's a fraction of a penny
01:53:42 compared to the amount of research that goes into the fraction of dollars that goes into biomedical
01:53:46 research, but that's not necessarily always allocated wisely. Nevertheless, this has been a
01:53:51 super interesting discussion. Again, you can tell personally, I just want to understand this
01:53:54 for myself, for my patients. And ultimately I think this is a very important topic for,
01:54:00 for anybody who's interested in any aspect of that continuum we discussed. So Jeremy,
01:54:04 thank you very much. And I'm really so glad that Lane connected us. I'm sorry. I didn't have
01:54:08 a little extra alcohol. I know Lane mentioned you always like to have a drink when we start to talk.
01:54:13 And I should have thought to have sent out a nice bottle of tequila for you. Or is it scotch? What did
01:54:18 Lane say is your favorite? It's, it's scotch 100%. So, you know, I'll forgive you, you know, maybe we
01:54:24 can do it again and we can maybe have scotch next time. Perfect. A single malt, I assume. Of course.
01:54:30 Yes. Yeah. Do you drink it neat or do you add like the one spoon of water to it? I drink it neat
01:54:36 generally. Okay. I have a friend from residency. So I don't, I'm personally not a huge scotch guy. I love
01:54:42 tequila and Japanese whiskey, but I love talking to people who love scotch and can walk me through
01:54:50 the ins and outs of it. But this friend of mine, obviously a single malt guy would import water
01:54:55 from Scotland from a very specific lake. And he explained to me why you could, the scotch would
01:55:01 get a little better and it would open up a little bit more and be a little less anesthetizing to the
01:55:05 tongue. If you would add just this one spoon of lukewarm water to it. I don't remember the
01:55:12 exact reason, but it somehow had to do with diluting it just a little bit to prevent some
01:55:18 of the anesthetic effect. But you're a neat guy, which I like tequila neat and Japanese whiskey neat
01:55:24 as well. So. Yeah. I'm not quite on that level of drinking where I'm importing specific water,
01:55:30 but I do appreciate a good drink for sure. I find it interesting, by the way, you know,
01:55:35 on the topic of sort of genetics, I really do think people just genetically can like the taste of
01:55:40 scotch or not. And I don't possess the gene, I think, because I've, I've sampled very fancy
01:55:47 scotches and I've never found it palatable, but I don't doubt for a moment that you or someone who
01:55:53 does finds just as much enjoyment in the, in the actual taste of it that I would, for example,
01:55:58 in some of these other things I like. It's interesting because my students make fun of me for
01:56:02 this, but I can't drink beer unless it's like a fruity type of beer. So they, they obviously mock me for
01:56:10 that, but I can't drink beer, but I can drink hard liquor for sure all day. But the, the beer stuff I
01:56:17 can't do unless it tastes like apple pie or something else, then I'm all about, I'm on board, but just
01:56:24 standard beer can't do it. I'm with you. I think standard beer is about on par with urine in terms
01:56:31 of palatability. So, uh, I've never understood how Budweiser stays in business, but, uh, yeah,
01:56:36 I can't do really any of that. All right, Jeremy. Well, thanks so much. This was,
01:56:41 this was a super interesting discussion. I really appreciate it. Thanks for having me on Peter.
01:56:46 Thank you for listening to this week's episode of the drive. If you're interested in diving deeper
01:56:50 into any topics we discuss, we've created a membership program that allows us to bring you
01:56:54 more in-depth exclusive content without relying on paid ads. It's our goal to ensure members get back
01:57:00 much more than the price of the subscription to that end. Membership benefits include a bunch of
01:57:05 things. One totally kick-ass, comprehensive podcast show notes that detail every topic, paper, person
01:57:11 thing we discuss on each episode. The word on the street is nobody's show notes rival these
01:57:16 monthly AMA episodes or ask me anything episodes, hearing these episodes completely access to our
01:57:23 private podcast feed that allows you to hear everything without having to listen to spiels like 1.00
01:57:28 this. The qualities, which are a super short podcast that we release every Tuesday through
01:57:33 Friday, highlighting the best questions, topics, and tactics discussed on previous episodes of the
01:57:38 drive. This is a great way to catch up on previous episodes without having to go back and necessarily
01:57:43 listen to everyone steep discounts on products that I believe in, but for which I'm not getting paid
01:57:49 to endorse and a whole bunch of other benefits that we continue to trickle in as time goes on.
01:57:54 If you want to learn more and access these member only benefits, you can head over to
01:57:57 peteratiamd.com forward slash subscribe. You can find me on Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook all
01:58:05 with the ID peteratiamd. You can also leave us a review on Apple podcasts or whatever podcast player
01:58:11 you listen on. This podcast is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute
01:58:17 the practice of medicine, nursing, or other professional healthcare services, including the giving of
01:58:22 medical advice. No doctor patient relationship is formed. The use of this information and the
01:58:28 materials linked to this podcast is at the user's own risk. The content on this podcast is not intended
01:58:34 to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Users should not disregard
01:58:40 or delay in obtaining medical advice from any medical condition they have, and they should seek the
01:58:47 assistance of their healthcare professionals for any such conditions. Finally, I take conflicts of
01:58:52 interest very seriously. For all of my disclosures and the companies I invest in or advise, please visit
01:58:59 peteratiamd.com forward slash about where I keep an up-to-date and active list of such companies.
01:59:29 Thank you.