#214 - AMA #37： Bone health—everything you need to know
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
182.17564
Summary
In this episode, Dr. Nick Stenson and Dr. Peter Atiyah discuss why everyone should care about bone health, why menopause has a disproportionate effect on the bone mineral density of women, and why we should all care about it.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hey everyone, welcome to a sneak peek, ask me anything or AMA episode of the drive podcast.
00:00:16.500
I'm your host, Peter Atiyah. At the end of this short episode, I'll explain how you can
00:00:20.460
access the AMA episodes in full, along with a ton of other membership benefits we've created,
00:00:25.440
or you can learn more now by going to peteratiyahmd.com forward slash subscribe.
00:00:31.140
So without further delay, here's today's sneak peek of the ask me anything episode.
00:00:39.180
Welcome to ask me anything AMA episode 37. I'm once again joined by Nick Stenson. In today's
00:00:47.040
episode, we dive really deep into one subject, bone health. This is a topic we get a lot of
00:00:53.520
questions about, but we decided to save our AMA for a time when we had accumulated enough
00:01:00.080
questions that we could cover this comprehensively, which as you've gathered by now is sort of how we
00:01:04.000
like to do things because it allows us to go much deeper. So in this AMA, we're going to cover the
00:01:08.300
following. We look at why everyone should care about bone health. In other words, why is this
00:01:12.340
such a priority, not just for yourselves, but also for your children? We break down what bone mineral
00:01:17.780
density is, how it's measured, and how much variability exists between people, between sexes,
00:01:23.280
and how it changes over the course of your life. We also talk about what influences it both early
00:01:28.560
in life and later in life. We look at differences between men and women when it comes to this health
00:01:32.920
and why menopause has such a disproportionate effect on the bone mineral density of women.
00:01:37.460
We then get into ways that you can improve bone health from exercise to nutrition, supplements,
00:01:42.740
and of course, drugs. We end the discussion around what happens when we're forced to be sedentary
00:01:47.760
and how you can work to minimize the damage during these periods. As a reminder, if you are a subscriber
00:01:52.260
and you want to watch the full video of this podcast, you can find it on the show notes page.
00:01:56.320
If you're not a subscriber, you can watch a sneak peek of this video on the YouTube page. So without
00:02:00.740
further delay, I hope you enjoy AMA number 37. All right, Peter, welcome to another AMA. How are you
00:02:11.940
doing? Doing well, man. The final seven episodes of Ozark dropped tonight. We're recording this April 29th.
00:02:20.540
Interesting date for two reasons, by the way. The other thing that occurred to me this morning
00:02:24.180
is that the days and dates in this year, 2022, were the same as they were in 1994. So I was like,
00:02:31.900
oh my God, today is Friday, April 29th, which is the same as it was in 94. So on Friday, April 29th in
00:02:40.260
1994 was the practice day at Imola. And that's when Rubens Barricella had that horrible, horrible
00:02:46.980
accident. We can link to the accident where he basically hit the chicane and launched into a
00:02:53.060
barrier and amazingly only escaped with a concussion and a broken nose. The following day, which is the
00:02:59.400
same day as tomorrow will be, which was Saturday, April 30th, was when Roland Ratzenberger was killed,
00:03:06.860
which made it the first fatality in Formula One in 12 years. The last one being Gilles Villeneuve
00:03:12.940
in 1982. And then of course, Sunday, May 1st, which will be the same this year, was when Senna died.
00:03:20.900
Yeah, it was at the same race. You had these three horrible accidents resulting in two fatalities in
00:03:26.080
one weekend. But again, to think it's the exact same days this year as it was 28 years ago. I
00:03:34.080
This is really off topic, but do you still have the skill that you had back in the day where you can
00:03:39.600
remember what day, like day of the week, a date was?
00:03:44.060
Only if I can peg it to something, but not as profound as it used to be.
00:03:47.980
I remember in meetings, we used to just throw out random dates and then we would fact check it.
00:03:52.000
I feel like we wasted a lot of time doing that.
00:03:54.360
Someone would tell me their birthday and I would tell them what day of the week they were born on.
00:03:57.980
On the complete opposite end of that, what we're going to talk about today
00:04:01.200
is the topic that we get asked about a lot. And we've gotten a lot of questions that have come in,
00:04:06.060
but we've never really dove really deep into it, which is what we're going to do today.
00:04:10.520
And it's kind of all things, bone health, bone mineral density, osteopenia, osteoporosis,
00:04:16.800
things of that nature. And I know this is something that you work a lot with in your
00:04:21.300
patients. And I know it's something that's of really big interest for people. And so
00:04:24.980
our hope is that we can go through this episode and focus on why is this important? So why should
00:04:32.140
people care about this? People listening right now, there'll be a subsection of them that are
00:04:36.860
going to be super interested. And there'll be probably another subsection who are maybe younger.
00:04:41.480
They've never really thought about their bone health and they might not think it really applies
00:04:45.040
to them. But our hope is in the beginning, at least, we'll walk through why they should care
00:04:48.560
about this and why they should focus on it early on in life. And then from there, we'll talk about
00:04:53.960
how bone health changes as people age, the differences between sexes with men and women.
00:04:58.540
And then we'll also focus on things on how people can improve or help their bone health become
00:05:04.780
better from physical activity to nutrition, supplements, drugs, and more. And then if all
00:05:10.480
that goes well, and we still have time, which is always 50-50 on how these AMAs go, we'll also
00:05:15.180
focus a little bit on people dealing with acute injuries and how they need to think about this,
00:05:21.100
which I know is something that you're interested in given your recent shoulder surgery. And now
00:05:25.940
you're not as active in one side of your upper body as you used to be. All that said, I think
00:05:31.760
before we start going through those questions, it's going to be helpful to set the stage a little
00:05:36.060
bit just so everyone is on the same page and the definitions and what we're talking about. So
00:05:40.600
why don't we start with what are some of the types of bones we'll be referring to? Because
00:05:45.700
at least for myself coming into this, I just kind of think a bone is a bone and I don't really think
00:05:51.320
much more beyond that. So why don't you dive into that a little bit?
00:05:55.280
Bone is, it's a living tissue. Okay, that's obvious, but I think it's also easy for a person
00:06:00.780
to forget that and think of bone as somewhat inert. But in fact, bone is heavily vascularized.
00:06:07.260
Bone is an organ that plays a very important role in a lot of things. I'm actually not going to go
00:06:12.060
super deep into the anatomy and physiology of bones. I'll point out just a couple of things,
00:06:16.680
right? So first of all, think of a couple types of sections of bones. So we think about the cortical
00:06:21.560
or compact bone, and that's what forms like the shaft and the exterior of long bones. So if you
00:06:25.840
think of your femur, your humerus, things like that, they have the long shaft and then the nubbins at
00:06:31.340
the end. So the shaft of that is the cortical or compact bone. And then at the end, you have the
00:06:37.200
trabecular bone, sometimes called the spongy bone. Those are kind of at the end of the bone. And there are
00:06:42.040
some differences amongst those in terms of their vascularization and things like that. But again,
00:06:47.380
I think for the purpose of this discussion, whenever I talk about compact or cortical bone,
00:06:51.600
I'm talking about the shaft. And whenever I speak about the spongy or trabecular part,
00:06:55.200
I'm talking about the end. Again, I think marrow, people probably intuitively understand that marrow
00:07:00.800
is important, but again, it's very important, right? Marrow is what's producing our white cells and
00:07:05.980
our red blood cells. So in this era where we were thinking about a post-COVID world,
00:07:11.180
it's important to understand that the memory B cells and memory T cells that are going to provide
00:07:17.300
lasting immunity against this virus and other viruses reside in the bone marrow. The whole
00:07:22.460
purpose of being infected and then having a subsequent infection that's less devastating,
00:07:27.860
purpose of being vaccinated for the same reason, is to have memory B cells and T cells that are sitting
00:07:33.460
there in the bone marrow that can respond immediately and quickly upon reintroduction of the same antigen.
00:07:38.580
When you mentioned nubbins, it made me think about your banana nubbins. And you recently posted on
00:07:44.640
Twitter, you might be looking for a new profession. Do you want to let people know what your new
00:07:49.340
interest is in the world of longevity? I've been very interested in human longevity for a little
00:07:55.760
over 10 years, and I'm sure I will remain so. But I've at least considered moving into banana longevity
00:08:01.760
because I think the opportunity for impact is huge. It's one thing if you can figure out how to take
00:08:07.340
the average person from being 80 to 90, that'll have a huge impact on the world. But if you could
00:08:12.400
take the average banana and go from like two days before it turns mushy and brown to 10 days,
00:08:19.320
I think it's revolutionary. I just noticed I was on the USDA's most wanted list because of how many
00:08:24.220
bananas I waste. So I got to do something about this.
00:08:27.140
If you solve the banana crisis and you move to avocados, they'll probably give you a Nobel Peace
00:08:31.860
Prize as well. The upside is very high in this new world. Avocados last so much longer. I could buy
00:08:38.820
like seven avocados and eat them in a week. I can't buy seven bananas and eat them in a week at one a
00:08:44.060
day. It just doesn't work. I think that entire fruit space is just a racket. I think bananas are a
00:08:49.260
pyramid scheme. The whole thing is just total scam. Maybe one of our upcoming AMAs will just do a
00:08:55.300
conspiracies with Peter Atiyah and we'll just go into the world of bananas. So Peter, you mentioned
00:09:00.920
earlier ago, B cells and T cells. Can you walk people through what cells make bones?
00:09:06.980
This can be made as complicated or as simple as you want. Just think about osteoblasts and
00:09:12.460
osteoclasts. And I kind of remember from medical school, the way I used to remember this. So
00:09:16.520
osteoblasts B are responsible for building bone by producing collagen bone matrix and mineralizing it.
00:09:24.980
Osteoclasts remove bone by reabsorbing calcified bone and the matrix. So osteoblasts contribute to
00:09:34.540
increasing bone mineral density. Osteoclasts, the opposite. It's also important to understand
00:09:39.840
this exists in an equilibrium. So we're constantly remodeling bone, adding to and subtracting
00:09:47.180
from this and basically turning over calcium. So bone is like 50 to 70% mineral. And obviously
00:09:56.480
what's the predominant mineral? It's calcium. We'll talk about that in a second. It's about 20 to 40%
00:10:01.560
organic matrix. So again, what is organic mean? Organic is carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, sulfur,
00:10:06.820
etc. And then the rest of it is a bit of water and lipid. And again, you'll see that primarily in
00:10:11.360
marrow. In an adult, like the entire human skeletal system can be remodeled in a really long cycle.
00:10:18.220
It might take 10 years to turn over all of the mineral and organic content within the bone over
00:10:25.140
and over again. But at the micro level, calcium balance is happening quite frequently. I don't
00:10:30.980
remember the exact number. I want to say it's like 99%, but virtually all of the body's calcium
00:10:36.560
is contained within bone. And therefore bone plays a very important role in calcium homeostasis.
00:10:43.620
And if anybody's taking a physiology class, they probably remember how important calcium signaling
00:10:48.640
is to everything within a cell. Again, we think of these bones as structural entities, which of course,
00:10:55.740
first and foremost, they are. But remember, they're also a very important reservoir for calcium,
00:11:00.180
which is another very important ion in the activity of every cell.
00:11:04.220
You talked a lot about calcium. What about vitamin D? What role does vitamin D play in the bones?
00:11:11.420
They're both very important. And again, there's two forms of vitamin D, vitamin D2 and D3. But really,
00:11:18.120
when I talk about vitamin D, I'm going to mostly talk about D3, which is the active form. So what's
00:11:23.880
the problem with being deficient in vitamin D? Well, again, people might recall a disease called
00:11:28.760
rickets. And you see this often in developing parts of the world where people are really
00:11:32.980
malnourished and they have really, really soft sort of spongy bones. Actually, just yesterday,
00:11:38.560
I had a friend over who does a bunch of mission work in Rwanda. And she was showing me a child at
00:11:46.180
their camp whose legs, the child was like probably five years old. He was sitting down and they were
00:11:51.340
doing something with his legs that you would think would be impossible to do with a human being.
00:11:56.340
Basically, while he was sitting on the ground, they were able to move his foot back and forth,
00:12:01.380
back and forth. And he was in no pain, but it's because he didn't have bones that were anything
00:12:05.680
other than basically rubber bands. So he couldn't stand. And within, I want to say six months of
00:12:12.260
correcting his nutrition, totally normal. Amazing opportunity when you think about what happens in
00:12:16.940
that part of the world and how you can fix that. But what is it about vitamin D? Well, vitamin D
00:12:21.160
increases the gut's absorption of calcium. So if you're woefully deficient in vitamin D,
00:12:27.000
you're going to have trouble absorbing calcium through the gut. And we're going to talk in this
00:12:31.120
podcast later about the importance of dietary calcium and or supplementary calcium. And so you
00:12:36.900
can see why that becomes part of the issue. The other thing to kind of keep in mind here is the role
00:12:41.420
of another hormone. And again, I'm trying to only introduce concepts now that are going to become
00:12:45.840
relevant later, either through treatments or nutrition or supplementation. So I'm being
00:12:50.700
a little bit simplistic. But the other thing that you can't avoid here is understanding the role of
00:12:55.860
calcium and parathyroid hormone. I think most people are probably familiar with their thyroid
00:12:59.460
gland sits here in the neck. It's kind of got this shape to it where it's got like two main lobes
00:13:06.580
and then each lobe has two poles. Well, at each of those poles is a little tiny gland called the
00:13:11.680
parathyroid gland. So you have four of those. And the parathyroid gland is really the master gland
00:13:18.040
for regulating calcium levels. So low levels of calcium in the blood stimulate parathyroid hormone
00:13:24.540
secretion. As parathyroid hormone level goes up, it simulates the release of calcium from the bone
00:13:31.920
into the blood. Now, it also induces enzymes in the kidney, which then convert vitamin D into its
00:13:37.600
active form to then aid and speed up in the process of reabsorbing more calcium from the diet.
00:13:44.040
So all of this stuff, parathyroid hormone, calcium, vitamin D, very important to maintaining bone
00:13:50.780
health. And anytime you have things that disrupt that system, you're going to see disruptions
00:13:55.660
potentially in the bones. I think that was a good quick overview of what will be important for what
00:14:00.660
we cover next. And I think the natural follow-up to it is what is the consequence of poor bone health?
00:14:07.140
What is the consequence of low bone density? Some people who will be listening to this will have
00:14:12.480
already known issues of bone density. And some people have never thought about this before in
00:14:18.340
their life. What would you say to those people on why they should care about this and why they should
00:14:22.500
think about it? Thank you for listening to today's sneak peek AMA episode of The Drive. If you're
00:14:27.900
interested in hearing the complete version of this AMA, you'll want to become a member. We created a
00:14:32.880
membership program to bring you more in-depth exclusive content without relying on paid ads.
00:14:38.280
Membership benefits are many and beyond the complete episodes of the AMA each month. They include the
00:14:44.320
following ridiculously comprehensive podcast show notes that detail every topic, paper, person,
00:14:50.440
and thing we discuss on each episode of The Drive. Access to our private podcast feed,
00:14:56.320
the Qualies, which were a super short podcast, typically less than five minutes, released every
00:15:01.360
Tuesday through Friday, which highlight the best questions, topics, and tactics discussed on previous
00:15:06.340
episodes of The Drive. This is particularly important for those of you who haven't heard all of the back
00:15:12.020
episodes. It becomes a great way to go back and filter and decide which ones you want to listen to
00:15:16.760
in detail. Really steep discount codes for products I use and believe in, but for which I don't get paid to
00:15:22.700
endorse. And benefits that we continue to add over time. If you want to learn more and access these
00:15:28.380
member-only benefits, head over to peteratiamd.com forward slash subscribe. Lastly, if you're already
00:15:35.640
a member, but you're hearing this, it means you haven't downloaded our member-only podcast feed where
00:15:40.200
you can get the full access to the AMA and you don't have to listen to this. You can download that
00:15:45.400
at peteratiamd.com forward slash members. You can find me on Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook all with
00:15:53.400
the ID peteratiamd. You can also leave us a review on Apple podcasts or whatever podcast player you
00:16:00.040
listen on. This podcast is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute the practice
00:16:05.540
of medicine, nursing, or other professional healthcare services, including the giving of
00:16:10.540
medical advice. No doctor patient relationship is formed. The use of this information and the
00:16:16.240
materials linked to this podcast is at the user's own risk. The content on this podcast is not intended
00:16:22.420
to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Users should not disregard
00:16:28.920
or delay in obtaining medical advice from any medical condition they have, and they should seek the
00:16:35.060
assistance of their healthcare professionals for any such conditions. Finally, I take conflict
00:16:40.520
of interest very seriously. For all of my disclosures and the companies I invest in or advise,
00:16:46.260
please visit peteratiamd.com forward slash about where I keep an up-to-date and active list of such companies.