The Peter Attia Drive - August 08, 2022


#217 ‒ Exercise, VO2 max, and longevity | Mike Joyner, M.D.

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
#216 - Metabolomics, NAD+, and cancer metabolism | Josh Rabinowitz, M.D., Ph.D. #218 - AMA #38: Can you exercise too much?

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 53 minutes

Words per minute

196.41

Word count

22,197

Sentence count

1,413

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Dr. Mike Joyner joins me to talk about his research, his background in medicine, and the benefits of exercise as we age. Dr. Joyner is a Professor and Vice Chair for Research in the Department of Anesthesiology and Perioperative Care at the Mayo Clinic, and he has coauthored over 250 articles. He also has his own website titled Human Limits, which speaks to his interest in the limits of human physiology.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey, everyone. Welcome to the drive podcast. I'm your host, Peter Atiyah. This podcast,
00:00:15 my website, and my weekly newsletter all focus on the goal of translating the science of longevity
00:00:19 into something accessible for everyone. Our goal is to provide the best content in health
00:00:24 and wellness, full stop. And we've assembled a great team of analysts to make this happen.
00:00:28 If you enjoy this podcast, we've created a membership program that brings you far more
00:00:33 in-depth content. If you want to take your knowledge of the space to the next level at
00:00:37 the end of this episode, I'll explain what those benefits are. Or if you want to learn more now,
00:00:41 head over to peteratiyahmd.com forward slash subscribe. Now, without further delay,
00:00:47 here's today's episode. I guess this week is Mike Joyner. Now Mike, someone I've wanted to have on
00:00:54 this podcast for quite some time. And I even, I think I mentioned it in the podcast, you know,
00:00:58 Mike's someone whose research I've been reading personally for probably over 20 years. He's a
00:01:03 physician researcher. He is a professor and vice chair for research in the department of anesthesia
00:01:08 and perioperative care at the Mayo Clinic. He's coauthored over 250 journal articles, and he's
00:01:13 written numerous pieces all over the place, including in magazines that maybe some of you have read in
00:01:17 Outside and Sports Illustrated. He also has his own website titled Human Limits, which as the name
00:01:21 suggests, speaks to Mike's interest, which is really around the limits of human physiology. Now his
00:01:26 research background is in studying how the nervous system regulates vascular systems and blood flow,
00:01:30 how age and sex disease states affect physiology, and understanding basically the limits of human
00:01:35 physiology by studying elite athletes. In this episode, we talk mostly about exercise. And within
00:01:41 that, we talk about how exercise helps us live longer, the importance of exercise as we age,
00:01:45 and how exercise compares to nutrition in terms of the impact it can have in health. We talk about the
00:01:49 impact of the autonomic nervous system, blood pressure, heart rate, heart rate variability,
00:01:53 heart rate recovery, and maximum heart rate. From there, we talk about VO2 max, we discuss how
00:01:57 it's measured, we talk about what leads to the decline in VO2 max as we age. We spend some time
00:02:02 talking about the J curve as it pertains to overexercising. Is it possible? What are the
00:02:07 dangers of too much exercise? We speak about how one should partition their time between training at
00:02:12 high intensity and low intensity. And we talk about a few other things like performance enhancing drugs
00:02:17 in sports, and if there's ever going to be a drug that mimics the benefits of exercise. So without further
00:02:22 delay, please enjoy my conversation with Mike Joyner. It is such a pleasure to be at least virtually
00:02:33 sitting here with you today. As I was kind of alluding to a moment ago, if I were to sort of
00:02:37 look at all the people I've had on this podcast so far and kind of ask the question, when was the
00:02:42 first time I became familiar with their body of work? You would be pretty far up there in terms of
00:02:49 duration. So growing up, endurance sports were always something that meant the world to me. And
00:02:55 once I even made that decision to go to medical school, a big part of it at least was understanding
00:03:00 physiology better. And so it's been 25 or 30 years that I've been reading your studies. In some ways,
00:03:07 it's a long time coming to finally be sitting down with you and hope to meet you in person one day.
00:03:11 Peter, thanks much. And it's great to be able to chance to visit with you today.
00:03:14 Thank you for inviting me. And I'm glad somebody has been paying attention to what I've been doing
00:03:18 for the last 25 or 30 years. So it's a very validating. Thank you.
00:03:22 Let's talk a little bit about your background. You're a physician by training. I believe you're
00:03:26 an anesthesiologist, correct? Correct.
00:03:28 You decided in medical school, you wanted to do anesthesia. You've always had a lifelong
00:03:32 interest in exercise and exercise physiology. Did you just view anesthesia as the most logical
00:03:38 conduit to better understand human physiology?
00:03:40 Peter, before I went to medical school, I actually volunteered to be a subject in a study on the
00:03:46 lactate threshold or anaerobic threshold when I was 19 at the University of Arizona. And luckily,
00:03:52 there were excellent physiologists there. But a couple of younger physicians came over from the
00:03:57 med school. And it became clear to me when I was 19 or 20 that if I wanted to have a career as a
00:04:02 research physiologist doing invasive studies, in other words, putting catheters in people and humans,
00:04:08 it might be wise to go to medical school. So this was always sort of my vision starting by age 20 or
00:04:13 21. And then what happened is I was thinking of going to cardiology or pulmonary medicine.
00:04:18 And I was working at the Tucson VA at one time doing a surgery rotation. And I saw what they did in
00:04:23 anesthesia, which is a lot like an exercise test. You're measuring people's breathing. You're
00:04:28 measuring their blood pressure, their heart rate. And you're giving them drugs that affect their
00:04:32 autonomic nervous system. And I've certainly done a lot of that. So I saw it as the flip side
00:04:36 of the same coin. It is strange though, to have pursued this vision for over 40 years now.
00:04:42 I remember having the same thoughts when I did my anesthesia rotation. I can't even remember if
00:04:45 anesthesia was a required rotation in med school. I don't think it was, but it was positioned as sort
00:04:51 of a very good thing to do. And I agree with that. And I had a feel that even though I think by that
00:04:56 point, I knew I was going to go into surgery, but I absolutely loved it as a sort of physiology geek.
00:05:03 I think anesthesia and critical care for that matter are both two remarkable specialties that
00:05:08 are the tip of the spear of what physiology is. When you think about exercise or people climbing
00:05:13 mountains or adapting to some unusual environment, the brainstem back there has to do all sorts of
00:05:19 incredible things to maintain what we call homeostasis or the internal environment in a way
00:05:24 that allows you to survive and thrive. In anesthesia and critical care, you turn those mechanisms off
00:05:30 and the physicians and the nurses really become the patient's brainstem as they regulate the
00:05:35 breathing of the patient, the blood pressure of the patient, the heart rate, and so forth.
00:05:39 So again, it's the flip side of the same coin. As soon as I saw what the anesthesiologist did
00:05:45 at the Tucson VA, it just sort of clicked.
00:05:48 So where did you go on to do your residency in anesthesia?
00:05:51 So at the Mayo Clinic. And so what happened is I got out of medical school in spring or early summer of
00:05:56 87 that I moved here. I've been here ever since. So 35 years and a couple of weeks.
00:06:03 Where did you grow up? Did you grow up in a warm climate?
00:06:05 Grew up in Tucson.
00:06:06 Obviously the Mayo Clinic is a great program, but presumably there were other great anesthesia
00:06:10 programs that weren't in the middle of a place like Rochester. No offense to those from Rochester.
00:06:14 So what drew you to Mayo?
00:06:16 I'd read this paper, a review article about skeletal muscle blood flow, the regulation of skeletal muscle
00:06:22 blood flow. And there were a lot of new ideas in the middle 80s about the regulation of skeletal muscle
00:06:27 blood flow. And the world's leading expert was a man named John Shepard, who is a very senior member
00:06:32 of the faculty here. And I wrote him a letter, you know, it was before email and stuff. So he was
00:06:37 friends with the head of the department, a man named Alan Sessler, and John took it over to him.
00:06:41 I wanted to be able to both do my residency and spend time in the lab. And I was able to work with
00:06:45 Dr. Shepard. And our department and our residency program were very research friendly.
00:06:50 So that's really why I decided to come to Rochester, but I thought I'd stay, you know,
00:06:54 three or four years and go back to Doosan. So that obviously didn't happen.
00:06:58 Let's talk about exercise. People who listen to this podcast know that I'm really passionate about
00:07:03 this idea of longevity. We think about longevity through the lens of five sort of modifiable
00:07:09 behaviors, exercise, sleep, nutrition, emotional health, and all the tools around distress tolerance,
00:07:15 and then exogenous molecules. Those are the five things that, as far as I can tell,
00:07:20 mostly you can manipulate and they can both impact your lifespan and your healthspan.
00:07:25 Four of those are kind of behavioral. The medications aren't really behavioral in the
00:07:28 sense that compliance is relatively straightforward. The other ones really require a shift in
00:07:32 behavior and in mindset. Maybe we all have our biases in our blind spots, but I just think
00:07:37 exercise is in a league of its own in terms of its potential, both on the lifespan axis, you know,
00:07:42 its ability to extend life and reduce all-cause mortality is well-documented. We'll talk about that.
00:07:47 But also on the healthspan side, it really has no rival. So it's for that reason, I think,
00:07:52 that we spend a lot of time inside our practice focusing on exercise. It is really the biggest
00:07:58 pillar within what we do because it has the most impact. And unfortunately, or fortunately,
00:08:03 it's also the most challenging one, I think, to get people to change their existing behaviors around
00:08:09 because the time commitment is significant. So let's start with some of the basics just for folks who
00:08:14 maybe aren't completely up to speed. What would you say if you're at a party and somebody came up to
00:08:19 you and said, Mike, I understand you're really into this exercise thing. Can you explain to me
00:08:23 why it is that exercise helps you live longer?
00:08:27 I think there's a couple of things, Peter, and it's multifactorial. But the first thing is that
00:08:31 the risk factors that contribute to cardiovascular disease, all-cause mortality,
00:08:36 are all influenced by exercise and physical activity. These would be blood pressure,
00:08:41 diabetes, to some extent, lipids and cholesterol, and also how you deal with stress. So I think you
00:08:47 get the big three there. There are some other new age or second wave risk factors like endothelial
00:08:52 function, the lining of the blood vessels in your body that improve with exercise, the way what's
00:08:58 called your autonomic nervous system. And people may have heard of vagal tone or heart rate variability.
00:09:03 That's also influenced positively by exercise. So I think there's five or six things. But what's
00:09:09 interesting is when you add up each one, a modest increase in cholesterol, a modest reduction in
00:09:15 blood pressure, those sorts of things, when you add them up, you get X percent improvement in health,
00:09:20 span, life expectancy, any metric you want to use. But when you look at the epidemiology,
00:09:25 people who do the sorts of things you just mentioned have a much bigger benefit than just
00:09:30 the simple sum of the other risk factors. So there does seem to be some sort of synergy here
00:09:34 or some sort of X factor that we don't really understand yet. But again, this collection of
00:09:40 lifestyle related factors, and again, the autonomic nervous system, blood pressure, lipids,
00:09:47 the lining of the blood vessels, and diabetes would be the big five.
00:09:51 I want to dive into a couple of these in depth. You know, you've thought a lot and you've looked a lot
00:09:55 at this literature. And one can say, look, the epidemiology is so overwhelming. The hazard ratios
00:10:00 are sort of absurd. When we're used to looking at a field like nutrition and looking at the hazard
00:10:05 ratios in nutrition, they're very small. In fact, they're so small and also so inconsistent that it
00:10:13 becomes almost impossible to assign a mortality benefit or addition to almost anything you can eat.
00:10:21 I mean, literally, jelly beans to bacon to kale. The hazard ratios are trivial and they flip-flop
00:10:29 from month to month. Yeah, let me tell you something that's really interesting. It's good
00:10:32 you brought this up. So I'm working on a review article on related topics. And one of the things
00:10:37 I'm looking at is all of what you might describe as natural experiments, where you have two groups
00:10:43 of people that are otherwise similar exposed to different things. And that's a long-use tool in
00:10:48 epidemiology. And people are now using it in economics and behavioral sciences. And in fact,
00:10:53 these natural experiments, the economists just got a Nobel Prize for them a couple of years ago.
00:10:58 But the classic one is the London bus driver bus conductor story led by Jeremy Morris after World
00:11:05 War II, where they showed the physically active conductors who are walking up and down the buses
00:11:10 all day had much lower rates of cardiovascular disease than the sedentary bus drivers. And it was
00:11:16 about 50%. And they had similar things with telephone operators versus people who were out walking around
00:11:21 doing things. And you look at that 50%. It's incredibly consistent. Studies of longshoremen, studies of
00:11:30 Harvard alumni. There's one in the last 10 or 15 years of 50,000 male and 25,000 female finishers of the
00:11:39 Vasa Lopet 90-kilometer cross-country ski race in Sweden. And they compared them to match controls from the
00:11:46 Swedish record system. And they showed, again, about a 50% reduction in cardiovascular and all-cause
00:11:51 mortality. There's data from the National Cancer Institute showing the same sorts of things and
00:11:57 showing, you know, four or five or six-year increase in life expectancy, you know, among the people who
00:12:03 got a substantial amount of physical activity or structured exercise, either one.
00:12:08 The sort of take-home point for the listener is unlike nutritional epidemiology where the risk
00:12:16 increases and risk reductions are very, very small and they're never consistent. I mean, there's some
00:12:22 things that are consistent and consistently small. For example, vegetarians consistently have a small
00:12:29 reduction in mortality, which of course then gets to the next point, which is what are the confounders?
00:12:34 And this is where I want to kind of talk about it with exercise. And this is where the
00:12:37 natural experiments are much better on the exercise front than they are on the nutrition front.
00:12:42 You see, going back to the example you gave, which is a very famous one, guys running up and down the
00:12:46 buses, the sort of conductor guys versus the drivers, that's a great natural experiment because
00:12:52 it's really not amenable to a choice. You would be less likely to believe that the bus driver who sits
00:12:59 there is also making poor choices relative to the other guy when he's not at work. In other words, we
00:13:06 wouldn't really have a reason to believe that he's more likely to be a smoker. He's more likely to,
00:13:11 you know, make poor food choices, et cetera. Whereas when you look at sort of the vegetarian
00:13:15 to non-vegetarian dietary pattern in nutrition, it's pretty clear that a vegetarian diet is very
00:13:21 restrictive diet. And therefore the person who's making that choice is likely very health conscious
00:13:26 in a number of other ways, some of which are easy to- Yeah, they have a suite of behaviors.
00:13:30 Yeah, exactly. Some of which are easy to measure and correct for like smoking, but many of which are not.
00:13:35 That's what sort of makes the nutritional thing harder. The exercise thing is pretty profound.
00:13:39 So let's explain to people what it means when you have a hazard ratio of 0.5, which means a 50%
00:13:48 reduction in all-cause mortality. What's the timeframe that that's usually looking at and how
00:13:52 does that translate to a five-year increase in life expectancy? The way you would say it is
00:13:58 the relative risk of dying of heart disease in any given period of time, whether it's a year,
00:14:03 five years, 10 years, whatever the study is doing is 50% lower. But now obviously not everybody dies
00:14:09 of cardiovascular disease. People die of other things. And so then you have to translate that
00:14:14 into sort of years of life gained. And typically the years of life gained are somewhere on the order
00:14:20 if you account for smoking of three to five years, something like that. And then if you look at the
00:14:26 concept of health span, you may get six or eight years of improved health span.
00:14:31 So health span is, you know, Peter, how disability-free you are. And so you have, you know,
00:14:37 four or five-year increase in life expectancy and a four or five-year additional increase in health
00:14:41 span. And the idea, you know, is to live a long time and then die quickly with minimal disability.
00:14:47 That's right. And I've always found that the current medical definition of health span,
00:14:52 I understand why it exists because you have to be able to quantify things, but I've also found it
00:14:56 to be not entirely helpful. You know, freedom from disease and disability, which is the current
00:15:00 definition, I think that's a pretty low bar. One of the ways we try to get around this idea of the
00:15:06 vagueness of freedom from disease and disability is to make it very, very granular. And we do this by
00:15:12 creating this model we have called the centenarian decathlon, which says, if you go out to your
00:15:18 marginal decade, and we define the marginal decade as the last decade of your life. So again,
00:15:22 we don't know when that is, but let's just make the math easy and say, oh, that's going to be 79 to
00:15:26 89 or 81 to 91. You're in your marginal decade. What are the athletic events and the activities of
00:15:34 daily living that you want to be able to do? But we do it by making people cross off things they do
00:15:41 not want to do. So we make this a, you have to opt out of things. And they're very specific. So it's
00:15:48 like walking three miles in one hour, being able to climb X number of stairs, you know, 60 stairs
00:15:56 that are eight inches in one minute, being able to carry 20 pounds of groceries, a certain distance,
00:16:03 being able to get up off the floor with at most one hand of support. So it's very specific stuff.
00:16:11 And I think for most people, the initial reaction is, well, that's really easy. Like I can do most of
00:16:17 these things today. But when you're a 45 year old reading that, I hope that's easy. I don't think
00:16:22 they appreciate the precipitous decline that will occur without deliberate training. And it's for
00:16:28 that reason that I think exercise has more potential to offset all of those things than anything else,
00:16:34 sleep, nutrition, certainly any medication. To me, that's really what healthspan comes down to.
00:16:40 It's not just, I'm not disabled, but it's, I'm really thriving.
00:16:44 Yeah, I'm engaged. I can engage in what I want to engage in. I think, Peter, you've hit the nail
00:16:49 on the head. What we see in those decades, what's really instructive is if you look at
00:16:55 the decline in performance in age group, swimming, running, cycling, rowing, any sport where there's
00:17:02 pretty good record keeping, is people can start to decline at age 30 without training. You can push
00:17:08 that back to age 40 with training. In other words, if you work out every day and relatively hard.
00:17:13 But then something happens to people in their middle 70s where there seems to be a steeper
00:17:18 rise. And what's interesting about that steeper rise is it seems to shift from sort of a cardiopulmonary
00:17:25 limitation to sort of a skeletal muscle strength slash frailty situation. And what you described in
00:17:31 terms of getting up off the floor, 70% of 70-year-olds can't get off the floor. Not one hand, two hands,
00:17:37 just can't get off the floor. And we both know from being doctors, if you look at what happens when a
00:17:42 person in that age group falls, it's just no fun. So if you look at what really takes people out,
00:17:48 it's things like falls, it's inability to do things. And so what happens is walking three miles
00:17:53 in an hour takes some cardiopulmonary capability, but not a ton, just some. Whereas being able to go
00:18:00 up the stairs takes more, being able to get off the floor takes more. One of the things that people
00:18:05 have to think about, especially as they get into their forties and fifties is adding strength or
00:18:10 some sort of circuit training and agility training to their program. And one of the things I do is
00:18:15 I'm 63, almost 64, is I have the jump rope my mother gave to me when I was 14. She gave me a
00:18:22 beautiful boxer's jump rope, leather with ball bearings in the works. I carry it with me when I
00:18:28 travel because you can always jump rope, even if it's out in the parking lot of a hotel. People think
00:18:32 they're nuts, but it's a terrific exercise. It actually is for a number of reasons, including
00:18:38 foot reactivity. You know, the lack of foot reactivity is something that can contribute to
00:18:42 the fall. So you're getting the cardio benefit, the coordination benefit, and also this gentle foot
00:18:48 reactivity without, and it depends if you know how to skip like a boxer, you don't have to really
00:18:51 pound your knees as well. And the other thing is you do that with some body weight, things as simple
00:18:56 as pushups or planks, and there's a place to do some pull-ups, you're good to go. There's so many
00:19:01 things you said there, Mike, that I want to go back on and just make sure people really capture,
00:19:05 because it's so important. We'll probably find this study and I'll link to it, but there's an
00:19:08 amazing study that demonstrates like muscle mass changes, strength changes, and activity changes in
00:19:14 men and women as they age. And it's one of those things where you don't actually need to understand
00:19:19 the statistics to be able to see the figure. And it's exactly as you describe it. At the age of 75,
00:19:25 there is a cliff that is so violent, you can't believe what you're watching. It's at that cliff
00:19:34 where physical activity level declines like this. It just goes boom. Muscle mass goes boom. Strength
00:19:43 boom. Same thing. Of course, it begs the age-old question, is the patient losing strength because
00:19:49 they are no longer active or are they no longer active because they have lost strength? My view is it's
00:19:55 both. I think these things feed off each other. Which one's the first insult? I suspect it's
00:20:00 probably the loss of strength that contributes to the loss of activity. But then I think those
00:20:04 feed back and accelerates this thing. You really get into a death spiral. That's why it becomes
00:20:11 important to keep exercising relatively hard as you get over at least a few days a week to slow this
00:20:17 decline. And there are remarkable examples. There are some Swedish cross-country skiers, men who were
00:20:23 world and Olympic champions in the 40s and 50s. Many of them were woodsmen and lived in the countryside,
00:20:30 remained very active skiing and so forth. They were studied in their 80s. Now, you could argue that
00:20:35 there was something special about these guys to begin with or they would not have become champion
00:20:39 athletes. But their rates of decline were quite modest. And more importantly, their fitness levels
00:20:45 were similar to what you would see in people in very early middle age. The other interesting thing
00:20:50 about that is the classic studies from the 1960s. These fighter pilots, Navy and Marine and Air Force
00:20:56 fighter pilots were sent into outer space. These were incredibly fit guys. They'd go for a week and come
00:21:02 back completely atrophied, couldn't stand up, and really in bad shape. And in 66, NASA commissioned folks
00:21:09 at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas to put five college-age males, two athletes,
00:21:14 at bed rest. And they had tremendous reductions in their fitness over just three weeks of bed rest.
00:21:21 And interestingly, Ben Levine and his group in Dallas alone with the late Jerry Mitchell brought
00:21:25 these same men back 30 years later. So now they were early 50s. And it's incredible, but three weeks of
00:21:32 bed rest caused losses of physiological function associated with 30 years of aging.
00:21:38 Wow. So it's an incredible study. And that's one of the things that is instructive. Those sorts of
00:21:44 small studies. And that's why it's so important to just avoid inactivity of any type. And whether
00:21:50 it's low-grade physical activity, whether it's walking the dog, whether it's gardening, whether it's
00:21:54 taking a flight of stairs once in a while, or intentional working out, it's really the way to go.
00:21:59 And as you point out, really, in those lifestyle factors you mentioned, really sort of overwhelms
00:22:04 things. Overwhelms almost everything else. You mentioned and alluded to the danger of a fall
00:22:10 in later life. And this is something we've been doing a lot of research on internally,
00:22:15 given our concern around bone mineral density in the aging population. The mortality, when you look
00:22:22 at 65-year-olds and up who suffer a fall that results in the fracture of any part of the hip or
00:22:29 femur at one year, depending on the study, it can be as low as 25%, as high as 60%.
00:22:37 Yeah. The magic number is usually around 40, 50.
00:22:40 Yeah. I want people to understand what we just said. You take all the 65-year-olds and you look 0.73
00:22:47 at those who fall and the fall results in a broken hip or femur. And you ask the question,
00:22:53 how many of those people will be alive in 12 months? The answer is half of them.
00:22:56 And the other half, it's not like the other half are-
00:22:59 They're not back to themselves necessarily.
00:23:00 No, exactly. You want to avoid a major health like that for sure. And the other thing, Peter,
00:23:05 there's a couple other things that have really hit me as we've talked. One is this man named
00:23:10 Lester Breslow, who was this very famous epidemiologist who died in his late 90s,
00:23:16 was at UCLA for many years. And he studied people in Oakland in the late 50s and early 60s who made it
00:23:22 to 90. And the sorts of four or five things you talked about, he identified the people in Oakland
00:23:28 who made it to 90. And they were non-smokers. They weren't obese. They remained physically active.
00:23:33 They ate modestly. They stayed engaged in life. And there was just five or six things that they did.
00:23:38 And the same is true in the Honolulu Heart Project, when they've looked at a huge number
00:23:42 of Japanese-American males, same exact stuff that you mentioned. They weren't as focused on the small
00:23:47 molecules, but exactly what you've described. And then I think about natural experiments.
00:23:53 At the Cooper Clinic, they've looked at people's fitness levels. Now, that's not exactly the same
00:23:57 as physical activity. But in general, the fittest people are also the most active.
00:24:02 And they divided people into three or four groups of fitness and then had them look at a so-called
00:24:07 healthy eating index. Were you a junk food junkie? Did you eat okay? Or were you really conscious of
00:24:13 your diet? The healthy eating index in people that weren't particularly fit did have something to do
00:24:19 with all-cause mortality. But among the fittest people, there was very little impact of diet
00:24:24 on the outcomes, which is sort of interesting. It always brings me back to the famous quote in a
00:24:29 book about distance running called Once a Runner, where somebody said, if the furnace is hot enough,
00:24:34 you can burn anything, even Big Macs. Now, you have to take that with a grain of salt,
00:24:38 but it does kind of give you the take-home message. But just about what a powerful thing
00:24:43 exercise is. There's a very common mantra that says, oh, you can't outrun a bad diet. And I would
00:24:49 argue that's probably not true. I think you can outrun a bad diet, but it's pretty hard to do. And
00:24:54 most people don't understand the amount of running that's needed to do it. There's this incredible
00:24:58 study from the 50s, people who worked at a jute plant in India, and they categorized people on
00:25:04 incredibly physically active, doing manual labor, hacking away on jute to make, I think, linen or
00:25:10 rope. They were going to make rope with this stuff, all the way to office workers. As you got more and
00:25:15 more physically active, people got lighter. As you got more inactive, they got heavier. But what was
00:25:20 interesting is people that were in the middle rung of occupational physical activity also had
00:25:27 slightly lower caloric consumption, remained very trim. If people are physically active enough,
00:25:32 if you read the old papers about what lumberjacks were eating when they were chopping wood all day
00:25:38 long, I mean, it's 5,000, 6,000 calories a day. The old order Amish who walk around and do manual 1.00
00:25:44 labor all day long and don't have tractors and stuff like that, they eat an awfully lot and very
00:25:48 few of them are obese. You can't outrun a bad diet or can't out exercise a bad diet in a modern high
00:25:56 calorie, low physical activity world, I think is the caveat that has to go to that one.
00:26:01 And yet, when you look at athletes that are doing insane amounts of exercise,
00:26:05 most of them have a hard time keeping on weight.
00:26:08 Yeah, there's a terrific study about the Tour de France where they get done every day and they're
00:26:12 just handing them food. And these people are eating ad lib, except when they're on the bike and even
00:26:17 when they are on the bike. And they have a hard time and they're eating 6,000 calories a day,
00:26:21 they weigh about 150 pounds. And they have a hard time keeping their weight.
00:26:24 They are catabolic throughout the tour. I mean, they finish in pretty bad shape.
00:26:28 Correct. They look like not death camp survivors, but people who certainly haven't had a lot to eat
00:26:32 for a few weeks.
00:26:34 So let's go back to something you said at the outset, which was the impact of exercise on the
00:26:39 autonomic nervous system. Explain to folks what the autonomic nervous system is, how it differs from
00:26:44 the sympathetic nervous system, and why it plays such an important role in our health. And of course,
00:26:50 how exercise impacts it.
00:26:51 When we think about the nervous system, normally we think about our brain, our eyes, our ears,
00:26:56 and our senses, and also our ability to grab things, move our muscles, that sort of thing,
00:27:00 feel pain or feel heat or cold or sense the environment. But your autonomic nervous system
00:27:05 is what controls your internal environment. And it's called homeostasis. So, you know,
00:27:11 we can increase our metabolism 10 or 20-fold with exercise. Our body temperature only rises a degree
00:27:16 or two. And so this happens due to the actions of the autonomic nervous system. Now, there are two
00:27:22 branches of the autonomic nervous system. There's the sympathetic nerves and the parasympathetic
00:27:27 nerves. And these used to be kind of categorized as fight or flight. You would either activate,
00:27:34 especially the sympathetic nerves, if you needed to fight or fly, run away. And whereas the
00:27:40 parasympathetic nerves were seen as what happened when you were asleep, when you're digesting your food,
00:27:46 so on and so forth. But it turns out there's kind of more of a balance and a yin and a yang between
00:27:50 the two that happen all the time. But the parasympathetic nerves, and the most notable
00:27:55 one is the vagus. They control part of your heart rate, make your heart rate slower. They also tend to
00:28:01 lower blood pressure, and they're critical to digest your food. That's one side. The other side is the
00:28:06 autonomic nervous system. Nerves that increase your heart rate, stimulate your blood vessels to constrict,
00:28:12 help your muscles contract harder, and also do things like make you sweat. And the key thing
00:28:19 to remember is that they help you regulate the internal environment, and that exercise really
00:28:24 keeps these things tuned up. And by having your autonomic nervous system a bit better tuned up,
00:28:30 it can do a better job regulating your internal environment. The classic example being your blood
00:28:35 pressure. Now, of course, what everybody knows, and we're going to talk in a moment about VO2 max
00:28:40 testing and how that's done, because I want to get into the weeds on that. But when we have our
00:28:44 patients tested, we have a protocol. We look at their blood pressure before, and then we look at
00:28:49 their blood pressure throughout. And then we want to look where they are percentile-wise at the max
00:28:54 exertion, what's their blood pressure. And without exception, a person's blood pressure goes up when we
00:28:59 do a VO2 max test. So you take somebody whose blood pressure is 115 over 75 at the outset, they'll easily be
00:29:04 160 over 95 or 100. And that's completely normal and healthy at a max.
00:29:11 Even higher if you measured it while they're weightlifting.
00:29:13 So explain to folks why it is that during exercise, nothing looks good, right? Blood pressure is high,
00:29:21 heart rate's high, heart rate variability is low. What is it about the recovery phase from exercise
00:29:28 that produces a net positive effect, even though in the moment exercise presumably is doing things
00:29:35 that are not necessarily in our body's best interest in that moment?
00:29:38 I would say they are in their best interest because what happens is the system shifts a little bit to
00:29:44 kind of meet the demands of the skeletal muscle. You got to be able to contract the muscles to exercise.
00:29:50 And again, that's sort of consistent with the fight or flight thing. If you're going to run away or be in a
00:29:54 fight, you want to be able to contract your muscles. And so to do that, you need to send more blood flow
00:30:00 to those muscles. And one of the ways you do that is by increasing your blood pressure. More blood
00:30:04 pressure equals more flow. And the other thing you got to do is increase the pumping function of your
00:30:09 heart. At rest, people's heart is beating about five liters or a little over a gallon a minute.
00:30:15 During moderate exercise, it can be 10 liters a minute. During heavy exercise, 15 or 20. And elite
00:30:22 athletes who are very trained and have very large hearts, it can be 30 or 40 liters a minute.
00:30:26 So what happens is you're pumping all that blood out against these blood vessels and so your blood
00:30:31 pressure rises. So it's a completely normal thing to generate that large cardiac output. Cardiac output
00:30:38 is heart rate times stroke volume. That's the amount with each squeeze of the heart. And so naturally,
00:30:43 you're going to want to increase your heart rate. So that's what happens. But then when you stop,
00:30:47 as you mentioned, heart rate falls, blood pressure falls, and things look probably better than they
00:30:52 did it in somebody who is untrained and hasn't exercised. What do we know about the rate of
00:30:58 recovery? There's something called heart rate recovery, HRR, that is a pretty interesting metric.
00:31:04 Tell us what we know about HRR. So people do a maximum exercise test and their heart rate's,
00:31:09 you know, 150, 160, 180, whatever their age is. And 220 minus your age is an interesting number,
00:31:15 but there's a lot of patient to patient or person to person variability. So what happens is how fast
00:31:21 does your heart rate go back down to some number? How fast does it get until it's under 100? How fast
00:31:26 until it goes back to baseline? Whatever. So the faster it goes down, the faster it goes down,
00:31:33 the better the action of your vagal nerve, the nerve that slows your heart rate. The vagus nerve is also
00:31:39 responsible mostly for your heart rate variability. And this nerve also suppresses funny heartbeats and
00:31:46 is protective when it's in good shape against arrhythmias and ventricular tachycardia, ventricular
00:31:51 fibrillation, sudden death, all of those things. And so heart rate recovery, heart rate variability,
00:31:58 all of those things are indirect markers of what we call vagal tone or vagal activity. And that's a good
00:32:05 thing. Now heart rate variability can be quite genetic, right, Mike? The absolute number in
00:32:10 milliseconds between any two individuals can be quite distinct. And it seems to be not nearly as
00:32:16 modifiable as some other factors. Have you found that to be the case? Again, it depends on what sorts
00:32:22 of training people have been doing, what they've been exposed to. But in general, you know, most people
00:32:27 can get a nice training bradycardia, which again is vagal tone. And most people, if they're trained,
00:32:32 can go from, you know, slow heart recovery to faster heart rate recovery and also have more
00:32:38 heart rate variability. So I think worrying about the differences in the initial baseline, Peter,
00:32:42 while interesting and what they might be attributable to is probably less important than the fact that
00:32:47 they're modifiable, as you mentioned, you know, as they say at the top of the show.
00:32:52 So let's talk about this VO2 max test because we're going to talk about what it means and how
00:32:56 predictive it might be of an individual's mortality. So let's just start by explaining to people what
00:33:03 you do when a person comes into the lab. So what you do is you get them on a bike or a treadmill,
00:33:10 you put some EKG electrodes on them, and they either run on the treadmill or ride a bike and they have a
00:33:16 nose clip on if you're going to measure it directly and either a face mask or a mouthpiece that they
00:33:21 breathe. And that allows us to measure how much air they breathe in, how much air they breathe out.
00:33:27 We know that the air has 21% oxygen coming in. If we measure the amount of oxygen in the expired air,
00:33:33 we can make an estimate of how much oxygen has been consumed. And so what happens is when people start
00:33:40 to exercise, they go from using about three and a half mLs per kg per minute, or maybe 250 mLs or 300 mLs,
00:33:50 like 10 or 12 oz of oxygen per minute. And an unfit person in their 30s or 40s can typically increase
00:33:57 that about 8 or 10 fold to say 30 or 35 or about 3 liters a minute. And with training, most people
00:34:06 can increase things at least 10 or 20%. And if you have some ability and or you train very hard,
00:34:12 some people can almost double it. So what happens is once your VO2 max goes up, again, just like
00:34:19 physical activity. It's a measure of physical fitness, and it's also linked to all-cause mortality.
00:34:26 So the fitter you are, the lower your chance of dying in the next year, two years, five years,
00:34:31 10 years. For many years, they thought that things sort of plateaued at what they call about 10 or 12
00:34:37 METs. A MET mean your resting metabolic rate. So you had to be able to get 10 METs. And 10 METs is
00:34:43 being able to run one mile in about 10 minutes, roughly, for the average person. Henry Ford and
00:34:49 Detroit have shown that that continues to rise even up to 15, 16 METs. So people that are quite fit
00:34:54 continue to gain benefit in terms of all-cause mortality. I mentioned the cross-country skiers
00:35:00 earlier. And while they didn't do VO2 max tests in those people, the people who had completed the most
00:35:06 races and done the races the fastest, so people who had both been active for the longest period of time
00:35:12 and probably were the fittest, also had lower all-cause mortality. Not compared to sedentary
00:35:17 periods, but compared to people who'd done a few races a little bit slower. So yeah, peak fitness
00:35:22 matters. There's a paper in JAMA that I think is by far the most compelling description of this
00:35:27 phenomenon. A couple things are noteworthy about it. I've talked about this on a previous AMA.
00:35:32 I would consider it one of the 10 most influential papers that I have read in terms of changing how I
00:35:38 think about healthspan and lifespan. As you said, the relationship is monotonic and it does not
00:35:45 plateau. That's an important thing to appreciate, which is this is a more is better phenomenon. And
00:35:52 very few things in physiology are more is better. Usually physiology behaves in U's and upside-down U's 0.65
00:36:00 or maybe J's and things like that or plateaus, sigmoid curves. But this is not the case here.
00:36:06 This study that we're talking about put people into the bottom 25th percentile, 25th to 50th percentile,
00:36:12 50th to 75th. And then the last group, it basically divided into 75th to 97 and a half. And then they had
00:36:19 that little sliver of people that they called elite that were at the top two and a half percentile.
00:36:24 And all-cause mortality just went lower and lower and lower and lower. And if you looked at the
00:36:29 hazard ratio the other way, because we often think about hazard ratios and risk reduction,
00:36:33 but if you look about it in risk increase, when you compared the people in the top two and a half
00:36:38 percent, the VO2 max to the bottom 25 percent, the hazard ratio moving in that direction was 5.04,
00:36:46 if my memory serves me correctly. That means there's a five-fold increase in all-cause mortality
00:36:52 between the fittest two and a half percent and the least fit 25 percent. And even when you took
00:36:59 something less extreme, I believe if you looked at the least fit 25 percent to the third quartile,
00:37:06 so the 50th to the 75th percentile, the hazard ratio was still about just below three. I think
00:37:11 it was 2.75-ish, which was kind of right on par with the increase in mortality that you would see
00:37:18 from having end-stage renal disease, which is, by the way, greater than the hazard ratio associated
00:37:23 with smoking. Being unfit is an incredible risk factor. And people like Frank Booth have argued
00:37:30 that it should be, for lack of a better word, the risk factor. And Jill Barnes, one of my fellows at
00:37:36 the time, she's now at the University of Wisconsin, a faculty member. She and I wrote an editorial for
00:37:40 Mayo Clinic Proceedings maybe 5, 10 years ago where we said, look, if people had 12, 13, 14 met peak
00:37:48 exercise capacity, other than doing cancer screening, you could probably just ignore everything else.
00:37:55 I don't think anybody's ready to go there, the sorts of people who do health screening and that
00:37:59 sort of thing. But if you screen people for physical fitness and, again, just did the routine kind of
00:38:04 cancer screening, and you can even argue that you could probably cut back on the routine cancer
00:38:08 screening for most things, except skin cancers, because fit people tend to be outside of it more.
00:38:14 You can make that argument. And you can make it with a straight face, and the data's there to support it.
00:38:18 And I would belt and suspenders it and say, but look, I'd still do the cancer screening. I'd still
00:38:22 consider aggressive lipid management and things like that. But you're absolutely right. I mean,
00:38:26 there's really no intervention that we have that's going to rival it.
00:38:29 I think you mentioned lipids. I think there's a couple of things you got to remember. One,
00:38:34 especially for people who pick it up late in life, exercise is not a vaccine. And one of the most
00:38:40 incredible studies ever done, again, we're talking about in a one experiment of nature sorts of things.
00:38:44 There was a man named Clarence DeMar. He won the Boston Marathon seven times.
00:38:49 Born, I think, in 1888 or 1890. Also won a medal in the 24 Olympics, got a bronze medal in the marathon.
00:38:56 And he really is almost like master athlete number one. So he kept training his whole life.
00:39:01 Ended up dying, I think, of stomach cancer at about age 70. So he didn't live to be a gazillion.
00:39:07 But remember, he was born in 1888 or 1890. Paul Dudley White, a famous cardiologist,
00:39:12 we know him from something called the Wolf-Parkinson-White syndrome, a weird kind of
00:39:16 funny heart people get. He did an autopsy on DeMar. And he'd run really until very late in life.
00:39:21 And he had some plaque or fatty builds up and calcium buildup in his coronary arteries.
00:39:28 But his coronary arteries were huge, were just massive. And subsequent to that,
00:39:34 a man named Bill Haskell out at Stanford in the middle 90s, studied a bunch of people who've
00:39:39 done ultramarathons. And they did the same thing, except this time they put catheters in and
00:39:43 injected drugs to make the blood vessels expand. And they showed the blood vessels were bigger and
00:39:48 they expanded more. So again, while you could still have some blockages, even if you exercise,
00:39:54 and there are people with horrible lipids who do, in fact, get heart disease in spite of exercise.
00:39:58 So it's not a complete vaccine. Its overall protective effect is quite large, both in terms of
00:40:05 what it does to people's lipids, but the fact that the blood vessels get so much bigger
00:40:09 and the linings of the blood vessels are healthier.
00:40:12 Mike, one of the things that we've looked at a lot internally is the literature that argues a
00:40:17 different point. The literature that argues that, in fact, there's a J curve here. And we all agree
00:40:23 that a person who doesn't do anything is at the highest risk. The literature is so unambiguous there,
00:40:30 it doesn't warrant any further discussion. But let's now look at the addition of work. Now,
00:40:35 I just want to make sure the listener understands the way we're going to talk about this. Let's
00:40:38 talk about these in met hours per week.
00:40:40 A weird metric for sure.
00:40:42 I've actually had to convert my own training into a met hour per week spreadsheet so that I can
00:40:47 interpret what I do in the context of all the literature. Totally weird. But let's explain to
00:40:52 people what it is. So you told us what a met is. One met is the metabolic expenditure of sitting
00:40:56 at rest, which corresponds to about 3.5 milliliters per minute per kilogram of minute ventilation,
00:41:03 or actually VO2. So oxygen ventilation, not full minute ventilation. Then let's talk about how that
00:41:08 ramps up. How many met is it, Mike, to walk three miles in an hour?
00:41:12 Probably four, five, six, something like that. I don't know.
00:41:14 Oh, is it that high? Okay. I would have guessed lower.
00:41:16 It may be because remember a 10 minute mile is 10 met.
00:41:21 10 minute mile is six miles in an hour. And that's pretty nonlinear. Yeah, you're right. It's
00:41:25 probably about three to four met, I would guess. And then of course, as you noted, to run six
00:41:30 miles in an hour would be 10 met. So let's say you did that. You ran six miles in an hour for an
00:41:36 energy expenditure of 10 met. So that would be 10 met hours. You did 10 met times one hour. And if
00:41:42 you did that four times a week, and that was the only thing you did, you'd be at 40 met hours per
00:41:47 week of activity. So I do this for my training. I spend how much time am I on the bike at this
00:41:52 many watts, at this many watts, and in the weight room and carrying my rucksack. And I'm sort of in
00:41:57 the 100 met hours per week category. So if you look at the literature, the epidemiology on this,
00:42:03 it would say my mortality risk might be higher. That would be the headline than someone who's
00:42:10 doing 40 met hours per week. In other words, it's a J curve. So it sort of starts up here, 0.52
00:42:15 highest mortality at nothing. Mortality comes down, sort of naders, depending on the study,
00:42:20 between 50 and 75 met hours per week. And then the mortality tends to climb. Now,
00:42:25 I won't go into this in great detail other than we've looked at every one of these papers and we
00:42:30 find significant fault in each of them. What do you see? Not all of them say that in the sense that
00:42:35 some... That's right. Some of them don't. The big NCI study with 650,000 patients or subjects didn't say
00:42:42 that. And again, what I really like is that cross-country ski paper that I mentioned from Scandinavia.
00:42:47 If somebody's going to ski 90 kilometers and if they're going to do it year after year and they're
00:42:52 going to do it fast... They have to be training a lot.
00:42:55 You're going to have to be training a lot. You're going to have to be training year-round. You almost
00:42:58 are certainly getting all sorts of met hours and training pretty hard. Now, the one caveat in all
00:43:03 this, and I agree with you completely, I don't think the evidence for a J curve is particularly good.
00:43:09 The other thing is in many of these studies, the number of people that are way out there is very
00:43:14 small. So, even one death, somebody gets hit by a car or something, it can make a difference. That's
00:43:18 certainly one of the problems with a study from Copenhagen, as I recall, or Norway, but one of
00:43:23 the Scandinavian capitals. So, I really think that the dispositive study here is the real-world data
00:43:29 from the Vassalopet story. Now, the one thing that does happen is people do have an apparent increase
00:43:34 in risk of atrial fibrillation. A couple of caveats to that. The first thing is they do not have
00:43:40 any increased risk of fatal arrhythmias. Atrial fib is no fun, but it certainly can lead to medical
00:43:47 problems, but not typically to kill you. The sorts of things that kill you, ventricular arrhythmias,
00:43:52 these are not seen to any greater extent in these people that are really heavy exercises for their
00:43:57 entire life. So, then the question becomes, do these people actually have more atrial fibrillation,
00:44:02 or is it just that they're exercising and notice it? And that's the controversy. I think you would
00:44:07 probably have to say that people who train what you're talking about for their entire life have
00:44:13 some increased risk of atrial fib compared to people that are just super healthy otherwise,
00:44:18 physically active at that 50 to 70 met hour per week thing you're talking about or level you're
00:44:23 talking about. But your risk of atrial fibrillation is still probably lower than people who are sedentary,
00:44:28 hypertensive, obese, diabetic, and so forth. And there are good treatments for atrial fibrillation,
00:44:33 and you're continuing to be protected against fatal arrhythmias.
00:44:37 And what do you think about sort of myocardial fibrosis? There's been some talk about that.
00:44:41 Do we see compelling evidence to suggest?
00:44:43 Again, the data from Ben Levine's group down in Dallas, where they've done a bunch of echoes and
00:44:47 loaded the heart and done all kinds of things. And they show that fit young people have very flexible,
00:44:54 compliant heart muscles. And they show that that declines with age, but doesn't decline nearly so fast
00:45:00 in people that are either habitual exercises or people who remain master athletes or remain
00:45:04 highly competitive. So again, I think that you can talk yourself into these sorts of things
00:45:09 through a case report here, a case report there. But when you look at the sort of data that came from
00:45:14 Ben's lab and other things, you see that this sort of training keeps the ventricles compliant,
00:45:20 flexible, and able to handle the increased demands and pumping demands of exercise. So I think the
00:45:27 fibrosis argument's a little spurious. I think we've talked a little bit earlier about large
00:45:32 coronary arteries in people that are habitually physically active. We've talked that those
00:45:37 arteries vasodilate better. They probably are less likely to generate a clot. And then we've just
00:45:44 simply said, and you're protected against fatal arrhythmias, we've just simply said there may be a
00:45:47 subtle increased risk in atrial fibrillation. But again, good treatments for atrial fib. So I think
00:45:53 they're in good shape. I think in that regard, doing as much as you do, Peter. And the other
00:45:57 thing to remember is that it's not an absolute vaccine or an absolute, you work out an hour a day,
00:46:03 you're never going to get, have heart disease, but I think your risks are going to be dramatically
00:46:06 reduced. The other thing I think that argues against a J curve is the VO2 max data that we just
00:46:12 discussed, which is an enormous cohort, probably the largest cohort after the Copenhagen cohort and far
00:46:18 more balanced in terms of the number of people in each group. And has been repeated in other
00:46:23 populations. So there you have to ask the question, how is it that people in the top 2.3%
00:46:29 of the population for VO2 max have the lowest mortality by a long shot if they're not training
00:46:36 significantly? I know those numbers very well. I mean, we put all of our patients up against that
00:46:41 template and we show them where they are and where we want them to be. And we actually hold them to an
00:46:45 even higher standard, Mike. We kind of want our patients to be at the elite level for a decade
00:46:50 below where they are actually are age-wise. And I'll tell you in a moment why we do that. I want
00:46:54 to see if you agree with my logic. I don't see how you're going to get there doing 40 mat hours per
00:46:59 week. You can't achieve a VO2 max of that level just doing a little bit of maintenance stuff here
00:47:05 and there. You have to be training. Yeah, you have to be training. You have to be doing some high
00:47:08 intensity training. So I agree with you. The other thing is if you look at some classic studies by
00:47:13 people like Bob Hickson and more recently Wissloff's group up in Norway, people who do some
00:47:18 longer intervals three or four times a week can get a lot of bang for their buck in terms of VO2 max.
00:47:24 I want to come back to that, Mike, because I want to talk very specifically about the different
00:47:28 modalities for training. Before I do, I want to see if you can check my logic on this. A big part of
00:47:33 where we come up with the reason you want to have a high VO2 max when you're young is we want to be
00:47:40 able to prepare for the inevitability of decline. So I want to start by just asking you, what is the
00:47:45 most up-to-date understanding of how much peak VO2 declines? And let's do it in a non-training
00:47:52 individual and a training individual. So in general, people think VO2 max declines about 10%
00:47:58 per decade starting in the fourth decade, so sometime in your 30s. You know, some people say 9,
00:48:03 some people say 12, some people say 8, but roughly 10%. A lot of that is driven by age-related decline
00:48:09 in heart rate. But in people that are not training, it's driven because their heart can't pump as much
00:48:14 blood and their muscles can't use it. So among people who are training, you start at a higher
00:48:20 level. And then if people continue to train, you probably don't see a big decline until your late
00:48:26 30s or early 40s. And we see that among athletes because there are world-class endurance athletes in
00:48:31 the early 40s. And then you can reduce the rate of decline by about half, certainly up to your 70s
00:48:40 probably. Now, not everybody keeps training hard. If people stop training, their VO2 max falls
00:48:48 precipitously. Dr. Dave Costell, really one of the founders of exercise physiology in the United States,
00:48:54 studied a lot of elite athletes in the 60s and 70s. He brought them back to his lab when these guys
00:48:59 in the 90s, 1990s, when they were in their late 40s and 50s. And about a third of them had continued
00:49:05 to train very hard and had minimal reductions in their VO2 max. A third had become sort of joggers,
00:49:10 had some reduction. And there was a third that had just stopped doing anything and they looked like
00:49:14 regular sedentary people. So you do have to stay at it. A group of master athletes out in the LA area
00:49:19 were studied. Same sorts of things. People declined and their VO2 max declined. But among the people who
00:49:26 continued to train intensely, in the case of the men do some strength training, their VO2 max declined
00:49:33 at a much lower rate. So you have a situation where it's 10% if you do nothing. And if you really work
00:49:39 at it and stay with it at a really high level, it's maybe 5% or 6% per decade. But most people
00:49:46 who've been super competitive can't quite keep doing that their entire life. So they drop off a little
00:49:50 bit. But even if they drop off 10% per decade, they start at a much higher baseline. If your baseline
00:49:56 is 60 versus 35 and you lose 10% per decade, you're still going to be way, way, way ahead.
00:50:02 And at age 60 or 70, you're going to have a VO2 max value higher than a 30-year-old.
00:50:09 The reason we push so hard, Mike, for our patients to have as high a VO2 max as possible when they're in
00:50:15 their 40s and 50s, is based on this inevitability of decline and with the hopes that we're extending
00:50:22 life by a decade so that, hey, even though actuarially you might only be expected to live
00:50:27 to 81, we're kind of hoping you're going to get to 91. And if you say you want to be active,
00:50:33 then we have to reverse engineer what that means. So what do you think is the VO2 max above which
00:50:41 you have absolutely no limitation on any normal person's activities? In other words,
00:50:48 if you said to me, hey, look, when I'm in my 80s, I want to be able to do pretty much anything
00:50:54 reasonable. I don't have to run a five-minute mile, but what I do want to be able to do is I
00:50:58 want to go on a hard hike. And if that means I got to climb 100 feet in half a mile, so be it.
00:51:06 That's a great question. It goes back to one of your earlier comments about
00:51:09 your scale versus the traditional kind of anti-frailty scale. And what do you want to
00:51:14 not be able to do when you're 85 or whatever the magic number is? A VO2 of 14, mLs per kg per minute
00:51:22 or four METs. Four METs is required from an oxygen consumption perspective for people to do their
00:51:28 activities of daily living, which means an occasional somewhat brisk walk for a few minutes and be able
00:51:34 to kind of get around the house, go to the supermarket and be, quote, independent, whatever that means.
00:51:38 If you want to be able to run a mile in 10 minutes, that would be-
00:51:43 35 VO2 max, yeah.
00:51:45 Yeah, 35 or 10 METs. So somewhere between those two are the magic number. So I would say that,
00:51:51 you know, if somebody in their 80s had a max in their 20s or lower 30s, that'd be terrific.
00:51:56 We have arrived at 30 to 31 as the magic number.
00:52:00 That would be a rough guess. And what's interesting that you mentioned that
00:52:03 is those Scandinavian elite skiers I mentioned had values in that very high 30s or low 40s.
00:52:11 In their 80s.
00:52:12 Any sort of biological gifts or genetic gifts that those men had and or fact that they started
00:52:19 to train, you know, probably be very physically active as youngsters and were maximally physically
00:52:24 active from age, you know, 13, 14 to probably 30 would account for that.
00:52:27 And I think 30 would be a terrific goal. But I think the other thing too is how many push-ups
00:52:33 do you want to be able to do and how many sorts of body weight type of things do you want to be
00:52:37 able to do? What sort of agility maneuvers do you want to be able to do? And I think, you know,
00:52:41 you have to factor in orthopedic problems and that sort of thing. But again, we have good treatment
00:52:46 for those now. And our orthopedic surgeons can fix a lot of things that otherwise would have made
00:52:51 people difficult for them to walk and move around.
00:52:53 Yeah, we think a lot about those things. And we think that strength and stability need to be
00:52:57 trained in parallel and as hard as we're training from a cardio standpoint. But I do think this idea
00:53:03 that if you're trying to reverse engineer ending your life with a VO2 max in the mid-20s to high-30s,
00:53:11 the good news is you are never going to not be able to do something that you want to do.
00:53:17 If you're in the airport and the escalator isn't working, you don't care.
00:53:23 Yeah, right. And I think the thing you have to ask people, and this really resonates, is do you want
00:53:28 to be able to play with your grandchildren? That's one question for people. The escalator question,
00:53:33 that's a terrific question.
00:53:34 I was just in the airport last week, escalator down, and it's a long one. It was one of those
00:53:38 really long ones. You got your carry-on bag plus your backpack and you got to get up the escalator.
00:53:42 Now, I'm sure somewhere out there there was an elevator, but the point is, do you want to be
00:53:46 able to do this stuff? And if you do, then you have to do the math.
00:53:50 You have to work that. Agreed. And what's interesting, you see a few people around here
00:53:56 in rural Minnesota who grew up on less than fully mechanized farms and remained active milking cows
00:54:04 and doing these sorts of things, doing a whole lot of chores. It's remarkable the muscle mass that
00:54:09 some of these men and women have. Well, and if you look at in Japan, for example, and
00:54:14 the hilliest parts of Japan and some of the hilliest parts of Italy and Greece are where
00:54:18 the longevity is the highest. And people have argued it's because people have to walk up and
00:54:22 down the hills. And also, they keep their balance. They keep their glute strength. They don't fall.
00:54:26 That sort of thing, Peter. And also, that they're living a more rustic lifestyle is probably getting
00:54:31 them some de facto strength training on a daily basis.
00:54:35 Let's talk a little bit about VO2 max again in terms of what is actually driving it. So let's
00:54:41 go through all the variables. You've got gas exchange in the lungs.
00:54:45 In the lung, correct.
00:54:46 Then you have pump efficiency.
00:54:47 Correct.
00:54:48 We went through the mechanics of that again, but just so people understand what we talk about.
00:54:51 You've got stroke volume, contractility, of course, afterload and preload and all these things
00:54:57 that determine basically the efficacy of the pump to move the medium to the capillary bed. And then you
00:55:03 have capillary exchange in the muscle bed. So broadly speaking, let's just say those are three
00:55:08 variables, right? You've got the gas exchange at the source, you've got the pump, and then you've
00:55:12 got the gas exchange at the destination. I know that's overly simplistic.
00:55:16 So let's just think you got air to lung, lung to blood, blood from the heart to the tissues,
00:55:23 and oxygen from the blood to the tissues. There's four or five steps like that,
00:55:27 and you enumerated the three big ones. And so in general, oxygen uptake is cardiac output,
00:55:35 how much blood you're pumping per minute times arteriovenous oxygen difference, how much blood
00:55:39 you're extracting or oxygen you're extracting out of the blood. And it turns out that if you look at
00:55:45 all the studies and all the people fit, unfit, trained, untrained, in general, the biggest issue is
00:55:51 how much blood can you pump? So what is that heart rate times stroke volume equation? Where does that
00:55:57 leave us? Now, when you train, you get so you can extract more. And if you're at high altitude or if
00:56:03 you've got problems in your lungs, maybe the lungs don't work as well. But in general, I like to tell
00:56:07 people you cannot extract what has not been delivered. So the key is delivery, and that's
00:56:13 heart rate times stroke volume. And interestingly, Peter, as you, I'm sure you've seen, is some of your
00:56:17 fittest people actually have slightly lower peak heart rates. And one of the reasons is, is because
00:56:22 their stroke volume is so high. One of the really interesting, again, experiment of nature patients
00:56:27 or subjects is a man called Eskild Eberson, who won gold medals in five Olympics and rowing for
00:56:34 Denmark. They have serial VO2 max date on him from the time he was 18 or 19 until his early 40s.
00:56:40 And his VO2 max date around, you know, 5.6 liters per minute, which is quite high. And he weighed about
00:56:46 70 kilos. I believe he's a lightweight rower. But his peak heart rate dropped from about 190 to 150
00:56:52 over that period of time, which all that means is that he was able to pump the same amount of blood,
00:56:57 but he had to do more with each beat. That's an insane example, actually. So in other words,
00:57:02 in the individual, as they age, we think that the majority of the reduction in VO2 max is coming from
00:57:08 cardiac output reduction. Right. And the majority is probably coming from a reduction in peak heart rate,
00:57:14 which can be buffered to some extent if you have a nice compliant ventricle, like we talked about.
00:57:19 I'll tell you, I'm not quite yet 50. And I am just saddened by the reduction in my peak heart rate.
00:57:26 It is really breaking my heart. I mean, I...
00:57:29 Mine was never very high anyway, and I don't worry about it, you know, but I'm 63. So I stopped
00:57:33 worrying about it. I just, I worry about where my workload is.
00:57:36 I remember thinking like, there will never be a day when I can't get my heart rate above X.
00:57:42 But actually, I'll tell you, for me, it fell quite precipitously in my 20s. So as a teenager,
00:57:48 when I was training obscenely hard, inappropriately hard, a heart rate of 200 was an everyday
00:57:54 occurrence. There was never a day in high school that my heart rate didn't hit 200 to 205 beats per
00:58:00 minute. By the time I was in medical school, so 24, 25 years old, all of a sudden it dropped
00:58:08 immediately to about 180. It became very difficult to get over 180, which by the way,
00:58:13 was far lower than the 220 minus your age prediction.
00:58:17 I was in two famous studies as a subject. One is this lactate threshold study when I was 19.
00:58:22 And then a few years later, I went and worked one summer at Washington University in St.
00:58:26 Louis, and I stopped training. I had just finished my last year of track and field at the University
00:58:30 of Arizona. I'd run 10,000 meters in 30, 48 and didn't done well on the Pac-10s, which was a fast
00:58:36 time. Well, I was good enough to get lapped by the world record holders, is what I like to tell people.
00:58:40 But anyways, what happened is my peak heart rate was like 185 or 188. I can't remember. And over the
00:58:46 period of 12 weeks of detraining, it went up to about 10 beats a minute, which would have been,
00:58:51 you know, in the high 190s, which would have been, quote, 220 minus my age at the time.
00:58:56 There are all sorts of examples. There's a bunch of data on elite athletes showing that
00:59:01 some of them have peak heart rates similar to 220 minus their age, but many are lower than that.
00:59:07 And they're like Eskild Eberson. There are some people that have been world record holders,
00:59:10 Olympic champions that had peak heart rates in the 150s.
00:59:13 If I hit 170 today, that's a good day, which is about 220 minus my age.
00:59:17 That doesn't surprise me. My guess is I'd be hard pressed to get to 140.
00:59:21 I was talking with Lance Armstrong on a, had him on the podcast, maybe about a,
00:59:25 less than a year ago actually. And we were talking about back in the heyday of his tours,
00:59:29 they weren't really looking at their power meters when they were competing. So they trained with a
00:59:34 power meter when it was race day for the time trial, you just went off heart rate. And I was
00:59:40 just blown away. I mean, you got to think Lance was winning the tours between 28 and 35. He was still
00:59:47 holding 200 beats per minute for the entire time trial. So imagine 45 minutes at 200 beats per
00:59:55 minute when you're 30 plus years old is kind of insane.
00:59:58 The other example, there'll be a man named Bob Shule, who is an American who won the 5,000 in
01:00:03 1964, who did interval training all day and all night. It was incredible how he trained. And
01:00:09 I have the data someplace was like 154, 156. Jim Ryan's, the great miler was not particularly high
01:00:16 in his twenties.
01:00:17 Yeah. So just incredible stroke volume.
01:00:19 Correct. Correct. Correct. Big heart, big pumps.
01:00:21 All right. So let's talk a little bit about the training. Let's start with something that we
01:00:26 haven't talked about, which, you know, when you look at the best high output endurance athletes
01:00:32 today, it's one thing to talk about their peak engine performance, but it's easy to overlook what
01:00:37 they're doing at the low end. You know, I've had Inigo San Milan on the podcast twice, and we've
01:00:41 talked at length about Tadi Pogacar. And it's amazing to talk about how high his FTP is, his functional
01:00:48 threshold power. We could talk about his VO2 max, but equally amazing to that is how much
01:00:55 power he can put out while keeping lactate below two millimole. He's over four Watts per
01:00:59 kilo while keeping lactate below two millimole. Why that's amazing for someone who doesn't
01:01:05 ride a bike is if you took an average fit person off the street and said, hold four Watts
01:01:10 per kilo, they could maybe do it for a minute. Most people couldn't do it for a minute. And this
01:01:14 guy can do it for four hours. That low end aerobic efficiency, I always try to explain to my patients,
01:01:23 if your VO2 max represents the height or peak of your pyramid, the wider your base, the higher
01:01:28 your peak. Do you agree with that sentiment? What I would simply say is we think about
01:01:33 performance and you think about these elites, we think obviously about their VO2 max. Then you start
01:01:37 thinking about, you know, well, their lactate threshold, which would be sort of the FTP and
01:01:41 they're all sort of related anaerobic threshold. There's a lot of terminology here. You can get
01:01:45 in arguments with people about the details, but what fraction of your VO2 max can you perform at
01:01:51 for, you know, minutes to hours? And typically it's about 60% in untrained, young to middle-aged
01:01:59 people, lower in people that are really untrained, just sort of sedentary. People that are very fit,
01:02:04 it can be 75, 80, 85, even 90% of VO2 max. And in some older athletes, close to 100. So that's
01:02:12 exactly what you described. Somebody like that probably has a peak work rate that they could
01:02:17 sustain for 10 or 20 minutes of six, seven watts per kilo. So the fact that they can do four watts
01:02:22 per kilo forever shouldn't surprise anybody. You look at somebody like Mr. Kipchoge, you know,
01:02:27 who's running 440 miles at a pace that doesn't really probably cause much of an increase in his
01:02:32 blood lactic acid levels at all. Did they ever reveal any of those metrics when he...
01:02:38 That data has been published now. Tell me, what was his lactate level at the completion of the just
01:02:42 under two hour marathon? Remember at the end of the race, you wouldn't have a lot of carbohydrate on
01:02:47 board, but I would just simply say he can run 440 miles or over 12 miles an hour at levels that
01:02:53 barely nudges lactic acid levels. When I first started thinking about this and making models of
01:02:58 performance, I thought that the highest number was 85% of max. And it's probably closer to 90 for
01:03:03 somebody like him. And when you were talking about FTP for one minute, the other interesting
01:03:08 thing about that, Peter, is, you know, the Kipchoge challenge. People have put treadmills at 12 and a
01:03:13 half miles an hour. Yep. I've seen it done. Yeah. And see how long somebody can last on the treadmill,
01:03:18 you know, and it's like... Yeah, they're getting spit off in 30 seconds. Yeah, less than that.
01:03:21 It's insane. So same sort of thing. That sort of training, you know, for... And these people are
01:03:26 training two, three, four hours a day. If you look in terms of the runners, running is limited to some
01:03:33 extent because of... Yeah, the impact just becomes a problem. You know, orthopedic issues, the impact,
01:03:38 right. And so it's really difficult for people to run more than about 120 or 130 miles a week and
01:03:44 ever run too hard training for long periods of time. Now, there are a few people who can do it.
01:03:49 And if you look at what Kipchoge does, it's almost identical, even day for day, what Bill Rogers and
01:03:54 Frank Shorter did. Does it at altitude, but there's a lot of medium eight and 10 and 12 miles
01:04:00 of runs, a couple of hard interval sessions per week and, you know, long run. And that gets them
01:04:07 to 120 miles a week, you know, week in and week out. Now the cyclists can do more.
01:04:11 They don't have the impact.
01:04:12 Because you don't have that issue. But remember that with cycling, you know, you're going up and
01:04:17 you're going down and you have always a chance to take a break here and there. The swimmers do a ton
01:04:23 as well, you know, and again, because swimming is very forgiving in terms of not beating people
01:04:28 up, provided your shoulders, you know, don't get a bunch of tendonitis. But what's amazing is,
01:04:32 is that if you look at what the elite of the elite are doing, it does not really change that much for
01:04:37 50 or 60 years. You have better equipment, you have better races, you got better this, better that. 0.92
01:04:42 But in terms of, if you look at the data on the elite of the elite from the late 60s and early
01:04:48 70s, it's not like Kipchoge's VO2 max was 90. It was high 70s, just as what you would anticipate
01:04:54 and so forth. I think a lot of what's happened in terms of, at the very edge of things has been
01:05:00 better races. People that have longer careers, they don't stop when they're 25 or 26.
01:05:06 Sports medicine is better. So if they get injured, they can recover. We saw this last night with Clay
01:05:11 Thompson. He had two injuries that 30, 40 years ago would have been basically career ending.
01:05:17 And he's come back from a combination of an ACL issue and Achilles especially used to just
01:05:22 destroy people and he's playing very well. So I think those sorts of things, the races are much 1.00
01:05:26 better, you know, and they used to run the Boston Marathon at noon when every so often you'd get a,
01:05:31 you know, a really hot day. So most of the improved performance can be equipment, these sort of social
01:05:37 factors. Unfortunately, in the case of Mr. Armstrong, people, you know, bending the rules and so forth and
01:05:42 so on. So let's talk about kind of the intensity levels that one needs to be training at. I mean,
01:05:47 we could pick the most extreme example and talk about Kipchoge. How many hours per week is Kipchoge
01:05:53 running? Because I know he also does a ton of other strength training and bodyweight training.
01:05:57 My guess is that the total amount of time he's running is somewhere between 14 and 18 or 20 hours
01:06:04 a week. Yeah, he's covering a much greater ground, of course. You know, if you looked at it in terms of
01:06:09 the lactate threshold or the equivalent of critical power on the bike, probably 60, 70% of that is
01:06:15 fast, but not that fast. They typically start off their group run sort of jogging and then they pick
01:06:21 it up over time. Also remember that he's doing this at, you know, 7,000, 8,000 feet. And then my
01:06:27 understanding in reading his training program is a couple of days a week, he goes to a track and they
01:06:32 run multiple 400 meters, let's say 200 meter jog or multiple kilometers with a 200 or 400 meter jog,
01:06:40 like 10 times a kilometer, very fast. So the total amount of time he's running faster than Ray's pace
01:06:46 might just be 10 miles per week. So he's probably running about 60 or 70% of his stuff. Some of it
01:06:52 quite slow, but most of it, you know, medium fast, but certainly not where he's can't talk to you where
01:06:58 he's short of breath. Then he's probably spending about 20% of his time. He can still talk to you,
01:07:03 but he's pushing it a little bit and probably 10% of his time where he's pushing it a lot.
01:07:07 I mean, that's exactly my impression. And it's the same impression I have of elite cyclists and
01:07:11 elite swimmers. Those sorts of breakdowns, kind of the 60, 70, 20, 30, 10 are pretty typical. Now,
01:07:18 what's interesting is that's really emerged the last say 20 years. If you look at people who've
01:07:25 looked at the history of training and they have gotten training logs from people. And I told you,
01:07:31 we have lab data on people that's quite good starting in the 19, some even in the 1930s,
01:07:35 but certainly by the fifties and sixties, we've got plenty of good data. And if you look at what
01:07:40 these individuals who have tremendous treadmill values, tremendous VO2 max values, ran very fast
01:07:46 times on like dirt tracks and muddy conditions, that sort of thing. What we'd describe as a kind of a
01:07:51 kludgy bike now, certainly no aero bars. Look at the swimsuits people were racing. So if you look
01:07:55 at what those people were doing, they were doing all kinds of things. Runners in the sixties,
01:08:00 there were people again, like Bob Shule, a fascinating man who's still alive. His morning
01:08:05 workout would be 40 times a hundred meters with a short jog in between. And his afternoon workout
01:08:11 might be 20 times 400 meters. And he rarely ran continuously at all, except in races.
01:08:16 And it would be a fast interval slow. And there are other people who ran up to 200 miles a week
01:08:23 and hardly ever ran fast, again, except in races and some strides. There were already people doing
01:08:27 the sort of mixed training I described a minute ago. So what is interesting is the extent to which
01:08:32 things have sort of converged on this 60, 70, 20, 30, 10 sort of model. It makes sense if you've ever
01:08:40 done it yourself. And I can understand why there is a benefit to just the mitochondrial efficiency that
01:08:45 comes from the continuous effort that you'd miss out on if you were just doing the short bursts.
01:08:50 And similarly- Yeah, right. You'd make more money. Sure.
01:08:52 Yeah. Well, it depends what short is. I mean, again, if you're moving to 400s and to 800s-
01:08:57 Unless you do a whole lot of them. And the recovery is a jog because these guys aren't walking.
01:09:02 Do you think there is a training benefit? I know there's a health benefit, but a training benefit in
01:09:07 the lowest. So we kind of think about zone two as where Kipchoge is probably spending 60 to 70% of his
01:09:14 time. He can still talk. And then obviously he's in zone three, four kind of race pace. And then
01:09:19 he's like four, five, 10% of his mileage, which is really stretching himself. Now, is Kipchoge or
01:09:26 other athletes deliberately putting time into zone one, which is truly a recovery pace or-
01:09:32 Yeah. They do that when they're recovering between intervals. And you would be amazed at how,
01:09:38 because I did it many, many years ago. So the first mile or two can be very slow. It can be just
01:09:43 almost a walk, jog, and then they kind of drift into it. But thinking about the listeners who are
01:09:48 just trying to improve their health, that's where you come back to physical activity, you know,
01:09:51 versus intentional training. You start looking at the health benefits of just less than brisk
01:09:56 walking. You know, purposeful, but not really brisk walking. They're substantial. You know,
01:10:02 parking your car farther out in the parking lot and strolling in. I think, you know, walking the dog.
01:10:07 And that can mean all sorts of things, depending on what kind of dog you have and who's in the
01:10:12 neighborhood. The data on gardening. You could be out there hacking away weeds with a machete,
01:10:18 but most of us think about gardening as relatively light exercise. The health benefits of light
01:10:23 physical activity, light exercise are substantial. And remember, you're correct in the sense that,
01:10:29 at least from our perspective, there is no J-curve and things go up. But it's not completely linear.
01:10:35 The biggest benefit people get health-wise is the first 10 or 15 minutes a day.
01:10:40 And why do you think that is?
01:10:41 If you look at what 10 or 15 minutes does, I mean, I think it begins to do things in your
01:10:46 scalable muscle that improve your insulin sensitivity and help you fight against diabetes. I think just a
01:10:51 tiny bit of additional physical activity is at least some buffer against weight gain. I think that
01:10:57 there's some improvement in your aligning in your blood vessels and probably some improvement in
01:11:03 your autonomic function. Is your heart going to get bigger? Are you going to get a more efficient
01:11:06 cardiac pump? Probably not. But are you going to begin to do some of the things? And the answer is yes.
01:11:14 So, Mike, should those of us who really kind of care about this and care about using as many
01:11:18 metrics as we can to understand this? Should we be looking at heart rate recovery and adding that
01:11:23 to our kind of repertoire of something we track in ourselves as we train?
01:11:27 I think that there are people that are really into tech and monitoring, and then there's sort of
01:11:31 tech nudies. I'm a tech nudie. And part of the reason is there wasn't as much around when I started.
01:11:37 I mean, we just were getting digital watches and they weren't even stopwatches. And the other reason
01:11:42 is at the time, one of the big innovations was rating of perceived exertion. You know,
01:11:46 the 6 to 20 scale or some people use a 1 to 10 scale about how hard you're working. And I think
01:11:51 that what's been shown is because, you know, you can have a good day and a bad day in terms of the
01:11:55 metrics, that they're all sort of parallel. And if you learn to read your own body via, you know,
01:12:01 the rating of perceived exertion and or metrics, you know, find one you like and then just focus on
01:12:07 sort of big picture things. So, I would not get too hung up on heart rate recovery and too hung up on
01:12:13 heart rate variability. I would just more say, how much are you doing? 30, 40, 60, 180 minutes a week.
01:12:19 Are you also doing other forms of, not a week, a day? Are you also doing other forms of activity,
01:12:25 you know, like taking the stairs, as you mentioned? And what sort of combination are you doing? How much
01:12:31 time are you spending where you're really short of breath? How much time are you spending where
01:12:35 you're a little bit short of breath? And how much time is it kind of a pleasant sort of pace?
01:12:41 I think that that sort of information can get you as much as you need. And I think the main thing
01:12:46 then, Peter, is to make sure that you have some accountability, whether it's a training partner,
01:12:52 maybe with a device or a diary, maybe, you know, with just how far did I run today?
01:12:59 That sort of thing. So, what is your current exercise regimen? I mean, you sort of downplayed
01:13:03 it a minute, but 30 minutes and 40 seconds for a 10K, I don't think people understand how fast that is.
01:13:08 I once ran a 225 marathon, but, you know, the older I get, the better I was, right?
01:13:12 I'm a big believer in what's called hard easy. Hard day, easy day. What I'll do, like tomorrow,
01:13:19 will be a hard day. So, I'll get on, you know, a stationary bike in my workout room,
01:13:24 on the bike and the rowing machine, do some sort of warm-up for 10 to 15 minutes.
01:13:28 Then I will do a circuit that starts with 25 squat thrusts, a minute of jumping rope,
01:13:34 static wall sit to failure, and then some drop sets where you go down the weight stack.
01:13:40 Then drop sets with incline flies, then drop sets with leg extensions, and drop sets with a
01:13:47 combination of pull-ups and lat pull-downs and military press. Then some additional stuff for my
01:13:53 legs, push-ups, bar dips in, upright rows, followed by something else for my legs. So,
01:13:59 I alternate arms and legs, and I work my way through this with no rest. Drop sets on each
01:14:04 thing for all large major muscle masses, and that takes about 22 minutes.
01:14:08 22 minutes for one circuit.
01:14:09 One circuit. Then I get on the bike, and I'll do like eight times three minutes of a ladder where
01:14:16 you start unloaded, go up a notch, go up a notch, go up a notch, and I get to maybe about 350 watts
01:14:22 for the last 30 seconds, come back down to about 100 watts, 350 watts, do that times eight.
01:14:27 And sorry, how long do you take the ladder? Three minutes?
01:14:30 Three minutes. Something like 100 watts for 30 seconds, 150 for 30, 200 for 30, 250 for 30,
01:14:37 300 for 30, 350 for 30, come back down times eight. And that takes about an hour.
01:14:42 And how long in between your three-minute sets?
01:14:45 No, you just go up and come right back down.
01:14:47 Your rest from the...
01:14:48 So, the recovery is... Exactly. That takes about an hour, and that'll fix your wagon for a while.
01:14:53 That'll be your hard day tomorrow, and then what...
01:14:55 That'll be my hard day, and I'll do that basically every other day or every third day.
01:14:59 My easy days will be something like, this morning, I want to go do 20 more minutes,
01:15:03 not because I need to do 20 minutes, because I wanted to watch the first bit of Obi-Wan Kenobi.
01:15:08 So, all my easy days are built around what documentary or, you know, how many times can
01:15:16 you watch The Mandalorian? How many Clint Eastwood movies can you watch? And this started during
01:15:19 lockdown, right? So, my easy days are 30 to 40 minutes of light cycling, transitioning to rowing
01:15:26 back and forth of around 30 to 40 minutes. Sometimes I do one. Sometimes if I come home
01:15:31 from work, I do another one. But the goal there is an old concept called active rest.
01:15:37 So, I'm not trying to get a real training effect. I'm trying to loosen up from the day before
01:15:41 this workout, because I'm sore. You do what I described. You warm up for 10 or 15 minutes,
01:15:46 do 20 minutes of drop set, and that type of intervals at the end, you will be sore, right?
01:15:52 So, you have to recover the next day. Now, I'll do this for about six months,
01:15:55 and then probably when it starts getting dark again, I'll do what I did like last year,
01:16:00 where I start just doing kind of maintenance circuits in terms of the strength,
01:16:04 and maybe only twice a week. And I'll start doing longer rides. We have a Peloton.
01:16:09 I don't do any of the classes, but I started doing this hour of truth to see how many watts I could
01:16:14 average for an hour. Okay. What are you at?
01:16:16 I think my best during lockdown last year was 316, average 316 watts for an hour.
01:16:21 Wow. That's obscenely.
01:16:22 Yeah, that's pretty good for it. And the things are calibrated pretty well. I got a lot of equipment.
01:16:27 I got a watt bike, and I think they're pretty close. If you look online, they claim they're close,
01:16:31 right? It's consistent with what I think. I haven't measured my VO2 max in a while.
01:16:35 So, I want to see if I can get like 320 watts next year.
01:16:38 What do you think your VO2 max is right now?
01:16:40 Well, I'll tell you, back when I was quite young, it was 5.4 liters a minute.
01:16:44 At what weight?
01:16:44 My weight then was probably between 75, but close to 80 kilos. So, I was right at under 70.
01:16:50 I think my weight now is probably about 95 kilos because I've actually made an effort to gain some
01:16:55 weight. And I think my max is probably 4.5 liters a minute, would be my guess.
01:17:01 That's still an amazing wattage under any circumstance.
01:17:04 Assuming the machine is okay, but I think it is because remember when I'm doing those ladders
01:17:09 that I was telling you about or those pyramids, that's after I've done a heavy leg workout.
01:17:13 You know, so my legs are pretty fatigued when I've done that. But remember, I have some ability
01:17:17 too because...
01:17:18 Well, clearly given what you ran, yeah.
01:17:20 I didn't really start running until my senior year in high school, so I started late. And I'm 6'4",
01:17:24 and I like to tell people if I come back at the next life, I'll be a swimmer or a rower because I
01:17:28 used to show up with these tidy people. I'm the world's largest relatively good distance runner.
01:17:33 Formerly relatively good.
01:17:35 On your easy recovery day, Mike, are you just paying attention to RPE or are you looking at a
01:17:40 split time on the rowing machine or as a low wattage bar on the bike?
01:17:44 No, no. It's just all RPE. It's really just active rest, which is a lost
01:17:49 concept.
01:17:51 Do you have a sense of what your heart rate is as a percentage of your max heart rate?
01:17:55 No, I don't even measure it. It's probably about 140 is my peak heart rate. That would be my guess.
01:18:01 Again, I go with RPE. I go till I suffer. It's unusual to be able to do intervals on your own
01:18:06 and really push it. Not everybody can do it. And that's why you need a class or you need a coach or
01:18:10 you need a group and so forth. But I'm lucky enough to be able to do it. So my training is really
01:18:16 polarized. I mean, like really polarized.
01:18:18 So let's talk about folks who are listening to this who want to boost their VO2 max. Let's talk
01:18:24 about the different protocols that exist. I'll tell you what we typically tell patients to do,
01:18:30 which is in my experience, one of the most efficient ways that you can do it. But I'm
01:18:34 curious as to what other ways. So we typically talk about a four by four, four on four off protocol.
01:18:39 So we'll tell people. And again, the easiest way that I personally can do this is on a bike
01:18:44 on an incline. And it can't be a very steep incline. It's got to be like 6% grade. I want to stay in the
01:18:49 saddle, but I never want the resistance to go away. And I basically want to be in the saddle climbing
01:18:56 against resistance for four minutes. And I use a power meter and a heart rate. So I just want to keep
01:19:02 the power as steady as I can. Invariably, it dips in about the third minute, and then I can recover
01:19:08 it in the fourth minute psychologically. And then the recovery is four minutes of literally doing
01:19:13 nothing but rolling back to the starting line. And then it's basically just repeat that.
01:19:18 No, no, I'm with you. What I tell people, for example, that have come and say, I want to run a
01:19:21 faster marathon. I want to do this. I want to do that. And they're running a lot of miles.
01:19:25 They need to get their VO2 max up. And I tell them exactly what you've described.
01:19:28 Sometimes I tell them five minutes and three minutes rest, sometimes whatever.
01:19:32 And people that are fitter, sometimes only take, like I would only take two minutes of rest.
01:19:36 But four times four is terrific. So you would do something, if you were thinking about running,
01:19:42 I would tell people to do something that would be right at their sort of 5k race pace,
01:19:47 maybe a little faster, or you would do the first one a little slower than your 5k race pace.
01:19:53 The next one, you know, a little faster than that. The next one a little faster. The next one
01:19:56 faster than your 5k race pace. And depending on how fast you're running, if you're going pretty
01:20:02 fast, then you would just jog in between. And if you were not going so fast, you'd walk in between.
01:20:07 So that would be the sort of thing that I would describe to people. The classic training,
01:20:11 you know, among elite runners is mile repeats, you know, four or five times one mile. And then they
01:20:19 jog a quarter mile or half mile in between. And I personally have seen really good runners
01:20:24 do, you know, 430, 425, 420, 415, 410, 405. But I mean, these were people getting ready for the
01:20:33 Olympics. But sort of for the average person, the hard part that I think requires a little bit of
01:20:38 coaching up front is, you know, you and I have done this our whole lives. So we sort of know what
01:20:43 four minutes all out feels like. At 30 seconds in, you shouldn't be hurting too much. If you are,
01:20:49 you've gone out too hard. It takes a little bit of work to coach somebody to understand
01:20:54 what you're going for is a constant four minutes. But the suffering is disproportionately in the last
01:20:59 90 seconds. When you get done with the last one, the fourth one, you do not want to be bending over.
01:21:05 If you'd have gone a little bit of faster, you'd want to be bending over. So I call it the no bend
01:21:09 over rule. And then what people have to recognize, both for the four times four minutes and within the
01:21:15 four minutes is a good interval workout. And this sounds completely masochistic is like putting
01:21:21 your hand in warm water and then slowly increasing the temperature in the water to where you can
01:21:27 barely stand it anymore and then leave it in for a while. And then you turn it down, let your hand
01:21:33 cool off and do it again. One of the things I think we've learned from the cyclist is a terrific
01:21:38 phrase called manage your suffering. You know, you need to learn to manage your suffering.
01:21:42 And I think that's the other interesting thing about this type of training is to the extent,
01:21:48 you know, people can have these sort of religious experiences exercising.
01:21:52 This sort of interval training is one way to get them.
01:21:55 No, I completely agree. I mean, obviously, we're cut from the same cloth in this way. But I think
01:21:58 that there really is something wonderful about experiencing your limits and understanding that
01:22:04 level of discomfort.
01:22:06 And if you're able to maintain your rhythm and tempo, Peter, while you do it, that's when you can
01:22:11 have these sorts of experiences. I mean, one of the most beautiful things ever, and it wasn't a
01:22:16 total endurance, you know, even it was a little bit short, a couple of minutes. But to watch Michael
01:22:20 Phelps swim the butterfly and watch his stroke, he was good at everything, but he was especially good
01:22:25 at the butterfly. Most people's stroke has fallen apart and they end up taking more strokes the last
01:22:30 50 of a 200 meter butterfly. You know, his stroke count, the second, third and fourth lap didn't change
01:22:36 because he had that rhythm, that tempo. And if you listen to the old school coaches
01:22:41 talk about interval training, they're constantly talking about tempo. What is your rhythm? What is
01:22:46 your tempo? And why you're doing it, why you're suffering, Peter, why you're pushing it while it's
01:22:51 hurting, while it's burning. The goal was to not lose your form and not lose your tempo.
01:22:56 I used to watch Michael Phelps train before he kind of broke out in the early 2000s. I lived in
01:23:02 Baltimore because I did my residency at Hopkins and he used to train at a place called North Baltimore
01:23:06 Aquatic. Now, Michael, of course, within the swimming world was already an unbelievable prodigy
01:23:11 because he had gone to the Olympics in Sydney, placed fifth. At age like 15 or something, which
01:23:16 is quite young for a man. That's right. He became the youngest male to ever set a world record in a
01:23:22 time sport in early 01. He was still 15. When he, yeah, set the record for the 200 fly. So watching this
01:23:29 16 year old swimming at North Baltimore Aquatic and BAC, which his signature event of course was
01:23:35 the 200 fly. Now it's 200 long course butterfly. I would put that up there with the 200 breast and
01:23:42 the 400 IM as the three worst races in all of swimming. To me, it's like doing an 800 meter
01:23:47 intermediate hurdles on the track that event doesn't exist. It's insane suffer. But here's the
01:23:53 thing, Mike, his training, you never once saw him do a 200 fly. It was lots of 75s, lots of 75s. And
01:24:03 his coach, Bob Bowman was really adamant about perfect form. Because if I recall, Michael had an
01:24:10 unusual rhythm, which is that he breathed on every stroke. And when most people swam butterfly,
01:24:14 it was every other, you were head underwater for one stroke, head up for one down for one. Michael,
01:24:20 I'm pretty sure he would breathe every stroke. But as you pointed out, no one's form could rival his.
01:24:26 And that's why he was usually the last guy to hit the wall at the 50, yet would come back and just
01:24:31 devour everybody. And you see that with Edwin Moses, 13 steps between hurdles in the 400 hurdles in the
01:24:37 late seventies with that innovation. You see these people, you start with Kipchoge doing it for two
01:24:43 hours, their ability to maintain this form and tempo. And as you watch it, as you watch it, Peter,
01:24:48 you are awed by this sense of great effort and simultaneous relaxation. It's a real paradox.
01:24:55 You see that in other sports too. You see it when golfers get hot, how far they hit the ball,
01:25:00 both violent and relaxed at the same time. You sit there and watch Steph Curry or Clay Thompson
01:25:05 start launching balls. And it's just incredible, the tempo, the rhythm, the form, and the effort. But
01:25:11 again, just how relaxed they are. It's just wild to think about even.
01:25:15 Now going back to our very, very recreational person who's never trained in their life,
01:25:21 we don't use lactate testing on people at that level. We basically do the whole thing off RPE
01:25:25 and we try to get 80% of their time, which might start out at two to three hours per week as we
01:25:32 want you to be able to talk, but not enjoy it. I don't want you to be any higher than that.
01:25:37 And then once we build up a bit of a reserve in that, after maybe six months of that kind of
01:25:42 training, we're sort of ready to move them to that next phase of, Hey, once a week, I want you
01:25:47 to do kind of four on four off for four rounds. Do you think that once a week doing four hard
01:25:55 intervals is sufficient to boost VO2 max? It will increase it for sure. In that vast majority of
01:26:01 people, especially if they're doing the other stuff you're talking about, what I really liked about what
01:26:05 you describe and what people don't realize, especially when you're going to advocate relatively hard
01:26:09 training for citizens, is that sometimes you have to train before you can really train.
01:26:14 That's right. You got to train to train.
01:26:15 You've certainly seen that in some studies with people that are really 60, 70 years old,
01:26:19 is that they almost have to do three or four or six months of sort of pre-training before they
01:26:24 are fit enough to train hard. So I think you're spot on there. My guess is after they've been able
01:26:29 to do it for once a week for a while, you build them up to two times per week. I think the one thing
01:26:34 that people need to recognize, and this comes from a man named Stan James, who I think is still
01:26:39 practicing medicine. He's in his 90s. One of the pioneers of sports medicine, orthopedic surgery.
01:26:44 He's not operating anymore. The last I checked, he was alive and well out in Eugene, Oregon.
01:26:49 He worked with coach Bill Bowerman, you know, the great Oregon coach, one of the founders at Nike,
01:26:53 the waffle shoe guy. You know, and they got into this hard, easy thing, which is sort of what I do.
01:26:58 And I, you know, Dr. James would tell you that once people start doing more than about five or six
01:27:03 hard sessions every two weeks, you're beginning to ask for some sort of load management issue,
01:27:08 whether it's orthopedics, whether it's just you're fatigued, whether it's this, whether it's that.
01:27:13 So I do think, I can't remember the last day I didn't do anything. You know, it's probably been
01:27:18 years, but my guess is the number of times I do something hard is, you know, 120, 130 times per year.
01:27:26 And my guess is I'd never go more than a week without doing something relatively intense.
01:27:30 When you think about these sort of exceptional elite athletes, the Kipchoge's of the world, 1.00
01:27:35 do you believe they have a finite number of exceptional performances in them?
01:27:40 You know, people used to drift into the world rankings and they'd last, you know, maybe two
01:27:44 Olympics, six, seven years. So they'd come in, kind of emerge right before one Olympiad,
01:27:49 do well, do well in the next one and kind of fade. But I think there's two things that have really
01:27:54 changed. The first is that again, sports medicine is better. So if people do get injured,
01:27:59 they can do things about it. And I think the second thing is just become so professionalized.
01:28:03 People can, that are really, really good can now make enough money to make it worth their while
01:28:08 to continue. You know, you see this in terms of the age of Olympians, you know, it used to be very
01:28:14 unusual to have women over age 20 and swimming. There was no college swimming. There was none of this. 0.98
01:28:19 There was none of that. So it was a lot of teenagers. Now you see that drifting up and you see
01:28:23 people like Katie Lodecky having extended careers. Phelps going 2000, 2004, 8, 12, and 16 going to
01:28:32 five Olympics. Yeah. That would have been inconceivable previously for swimmers. You know,
01:28:37 people hung around and maybe stayed for one additional Olympics when they got done after
01:28:40 college, sometimes two, but eventually they had to go get a job. But again, among the most elite who
01:28:46 can now monetize this, people can last longer. And you see it also in quote, the major unquote,
01:28:52 professional sports, you know, before orthopedic surgery was good and every knee surgery was an
01:28:57 adventure, you know, somebody like Tom Brady. Yeah. His career would have been over in 2009.
01:29:02 And the other thing, Peter, is if you're making a hundred thousand dollars a year, why keep playing?
01:29:06 If you're making, you know, 23 million or however, whatever the number is, you know, why not keep
01:29:11 playing? And you look at in sports like running, swimming, cycling, you know, that's less of a kind of a
01:29:16 journeyman group. But if you look at the NBA, the NFL, major league baseball, the salary scales are
01:29:22 pretty good. And if people can play another couple of years, you know, this can be millions of dollars,
01:29:26 millions of dollars for them. So they're very motivated to do this. If you can be the eighth
01:29:31 man on the NBA team and give people 15, 20 quality minutes of a game, you know, you're going to have
01:29:36 a job for a long time. And again, if you're LeBron, you know, who apparently spent some huge amount
01:29:41 of money on training and cook and all that other stuff. If you start thinking about spending X per
01:29:46 year for a 40 X paycheck, why not? Why stop?
01:29:51 So where do you think we are today, Mike, in performance enhancing drugs in sports? So cycling
01:29:58 is probably the sport I would follow the closest of the major endurance sports. I guess I follow
01:30:03 swimming as well, though not nearly as much as I did for 15 years prior. You know, I think when you
01:30:09 go back and look at the cycling data, I love the way Lance talks about this, right? You know,
01:30:13 I think he's very open, right? To say, look, as long as there has been a tour de France,
01:30:17 there has been a graying of the line, but there is a difference between the kind of high octane
01:30:22 cheating that was done in Lance's era and sort of the low octane cheating that was done in Eddie
01:30:28 Merckx's era when they were using a little bit of MFET. Here's what I would say about where we are
01:30:33 with doping. So the testing has gotten better, both in terms of the frequency of testing and-
01:30:39 The ability to detect, yeah.
01:30:40 You know, the actual chemistry of the testing of the machines, the analytics.
01:30:45 If you look at the way what's called an abnormal test is called, it's not like what we call
01:30:50 an abnormal test or an out-of-range test in clinical medicine. There are typically many
01:30:56 standard deviations above average for these things, and they're typically designed so there's
01:31:01 not a lot of false positives. They don't want to have any false positives. So that gives people a
01:31:05 room, some room to micro-dose. And that's why you have relatively few positive tests.
01:31:12 But occasionally there'll be people, you know, caught through investigations, judicial mechanisms,
01:31:17 the police. And historically, many of the biggest busts have been the police. What I would simply say
01:31:23 is that the era of industrial strength doping is over. You know, people doing like the East Germans did 1.00
01:31:29 and androgenizing females to the extent that they really look like men. So I think that that is done. 0.87
01:31:35 You say that even in light of what the Russians did as recently as less than a decade ago?
01:31:40 I think what the Russians did was, again, relatively low dose by comparison. So I think 0.94
01:31:45 there's plenty of room for micro-dosing, plenty of room for the kinds of manipulation, systemic
01:31:49 manipulation, if there's a motivated government to do it. And there's plenty of room, you know,
01:31:54 for other forms of corruption. But I do think that industrial strength doping has largely been
01:31:59 quote, stop, prevented. I think there are probably a bunch of novel compounds that are out there,
01:32:05 you know, small peptides that cause this to be released or that to be released, which would be
01:32:09 very, very difficult to detect. They'd have vanishingly short half-lives and so forth. And
01:32:15 they would just boost your endogenous production of hormone X, Y, or Z, you know, something like a
01:32:21 growth hormone releasing factor, you know, something that caused testosterone levels to
01:32:25 go up or so forth. It's a cat and mouse game. I think for the kind of the big three amphetamines,
01:32:30 EPO slash blood doping and anabolic steroids slash growth hormone, I think that testing has gotten
01:32:37 better and industrial strength doping is over. We don't know what we don't know about these novel
01:32:43 compounds. And I think what we learned from the Ballco situation is that there are all sorts of,
01:32:48 you know, clever bathtub chemists who can make all sorts of things at home in the garage,
01:32:54 wherever it is in a very unregulated environment. And the barrier to entry for that kind of a do-it-yourself
01:33:00 sort of stuff is quite low. You can buy, you know, all sorts of laboratory equipment and reagents
01:33:06 and all sorts of things. So, you don't have to be, you know, a big pharma house to make
01:33:09 interesting things. That's where I'd say we are with doping.
01:33:13 How familiar are you with Ballco and the agents that we're...
01:33:15 Ballco and Patrick Arnold.
01:33:17 You know Patrick?
01:33:17 I don't know Patrick, but I know who he is. The tragedy of Patrick Arnold, this tremendous
01:33:22 guy with a master's degree, I believe, in organic chemistry, that he wasn't working for
01:33:26 one of the big pharma companies making anti-aging, anti-sarcopenia compound.
01:33:32 I've met Patrick a number of times. I've spent a lot of time speaking with him in a very unemotional
01:33:36 way and just a very frank way. He can explain in great detail exactly how he modified these androgens.
01:33:43 The guy has encyclopedic knowledge, apparently, of everything that's ever been synthesized in the
01:33:48 androgen field and what it does in terms of half-life and that metabolism and that sort of
01:33:53 thing. If you think about Victor Conte Jr., you know, a refugee from the Tower of Power, 1.00
01:33:58 junior college-educated rock-slash-jazz musician who's one of the great autodidects ever out there.
01:34:04 So I think with both of these individuals, step back from the legal ethical ramifications and say,
01:34:11 what do they know? And try to be a little bit objective about that. With doping, you get into
01:34:16 all sorts of other sort of areas. In the cultures those people were operating in, what was considered
01:34:23 the cultural norm? Lance was not the only person doing industrial strength doping. Was he doing it
01:34:29 better than other people? If there were six ways to dope and person X was doing two and you were doing
01:34:34 three, was Lance doing all six? That sort of thing. The other thing people have to recognize about
01:34:40 doping in these incredibly competitive situations with these incredibly competitive people,
01:34:46 competitive organizations or people that have, you know, foreign policy, our country is better than
01:34:51 yours because we won more medals, is that there's always going to be some sort of arms race mentality.
01:34:57 And you see it with training. You know, if you're in there lifting an hour a day, I'm going to go
01:35:00 lift an hour and 10 minutes a day. And so where does it stop?
01:35:03 Do you still think that growth hormone, human growth hormone, which is of course not something
01:35:08 that can readily be tested for, is still one of the more utilized agents probably even today
01:35:13 for performance enhancement? There's probably some of it going on. My guess is people are
01:35:19 probably have drifted back to more short-acting androgens, low-dose short-acting androgens,
01:35:24 and hope for the best. That would be my guess. The same would be true with low-dose EPO
01:35:29 and or sort of related compounds or other factors. When you learn about growth hormone is typically
01:35:36 because person X says that they're sending FedEx packages to athlete Y, you know, that kind of
01:35:43 thing. So much of this has a judicial slash, you know, investigatory element to it when you get to
01:35:49 the big scandals. Why do you think some sports seem more affected than others? So for example,
01:35:54 swimming as a general rule seems less impacted than say cycling or even running, even though the
01:36:01 demands are still pretty high. Hard to know. And how cultures head one way or the next,
01:36:08 tribalistic behaviors, what's normal, what's not normal, and so forth. I think that that's 0.97
01:36:12 key to understanding that sort of thing. We started this discussion, Mike, by talking about
01:36:17 the miracles of exercise, right? We went through all of these things that exercise is doing
01:36:23 physiologically and how the net impact of these things is so profound on the length of your life
01:36:30 and the quality of your life. There's no shortage of pharma companies out there that are trying to
01:36:36 understand how can those benefits be put into a pill. Exercise pills, sure. Exactly. What is your
01:36:43 level of optimism around the idea that some of the benefits of exercise could be basically captured
01:36:52 by a pharmaceutical strategy? The efforts for exercise memetics so far have been primarily things
01:37:00 that increase mitochondrial biosynthesis. And that appears like it at least works in animal models. And
01:37:06 then you always, how do you translate it from one to the next? But as I pointed out, exercise, sure,
01:37:11 it makes your mitochondria better or makes more of them. But making your mitochondria better isn't
01:37:16 going to make your autonomic nervous system better, isn't going to make your blood pressure better,
01:37:20 isn't going to necessarily make the lining of your blood vessels better, so on and so forth. So it's
01:37:25 not going to make your heart bigger, so on and so forth. So I think at least so far, at least so far,
01:37:30 these have been sort of one-trick ponies. And while you might be able to get some benefits for people
01:37:36 that are wheelchair bound or whatever, quadriplegic, let's put it that way, not even wheelchair
01:37:40 bound, can exercise for some other reasons, that may be helpful. I think the jury is really still
01:37:45 out. I'm not particularly enthusiastic about it. I don't think you're ever going to get one that does
01:37:51 any more than a little bit. I think more interestingly, I like to tell people, you know,
01:37:56 at some level, there's already an exercise memetic out there. It's called the poly pill.
01:38:00 But if you look at the data on people who get a combination, one pill a day of low-dose statins,
01:38:07 low-dose blood pressure meds, and maybe one or two other components, it causes pretty nice
01:38:13 reductions in risk factors in most people. Because doses are low, the side effects tend to be low,
01:38:19 and so forth. But again, none of this is patentable. But if people don't want to exercise,
01:38:24 can't exercise, you know, a better choice than trying to find some mythical exercise memetic is
01:38:30 to use a poly pill, which would do the same thing. She'd give them a statin, their cholesterol goes 0.98
01:38:35 down, and maybe their endothelial function gets better. You do a tiny bit of metformin,
01:38:40 maybe their glucose tolerance gets better. You do a bit of beta blockers, their heart rate is lower,
01:38:45 that sort of thing. And again, I'm not advocating this, but there's all sorts of data out there that
01:38:50 a poly pill, data and speculation and modeling suggesting a poly pill is a, quote, legitimate,
01:38:57 unquote, whatever that means, potential public health strategy for lifestyle diseases. I would
01:39:02 encourage people to exercise and do the sorts of things you're talking about, but I think poly 0.99
01:39:07 pills have been understudied. Mike, what is it you're most excited about right now? What is the
01:39:11 question you're most interested in trying to answer? I'm excited about a lot of things. We've got
01:39:16 some interesting data with Sarah Baker on sex differences in blood pressure regulation. I'm
01:39:21 quite interested in human performance. As you know, Peter, the first thing they teach in medical
01:39:26 school is that a right shift in the oxygen hemoglobin dissociation curve is good for you
01:39:30 at altitude. Well, all animals that are genetically adapted over centuries, millennia, to high altitude
01:39:36 llamas, the birds that fly over Mount Everest and so forth are left shifted. We've been doing some
01:39:41 really cool hypoxia studies in people with rare left shifted hemoglobins. I'm super interested in that.
01:39:46 Just as sort of a physiological question. Can you explain to folks what the right and left shift
01:39:51 looks like on the hemoglobin dissociation curve? Think of a curvilinear situation or an S-shaped
01:39:55 curve, an italicized curve. And so the idea is that if you shift it to the right, the red stuff,
01:40:02 the hemoglobin in your blood doesn't hold onto the oxygen. So it releases it and can give the oxygen
01:40:07 to the tissue. And that's great if it's hypoxic. Now, the problem with that is it's harder for that
01:40:13 kind of hemoglobin to get the oxygen out of the lung. And animals like llamas and like these incredible
01:40:20 athletes called the barheaded goose that fly over Mount Everest without acclimation. They're living in 0.58
01:40:26 the plains of Mongolia. One day they just fly over Mount Everest and go to India. They're left shifted 0.94
01:40:31 because they prefer to make sure that they can pick up the oxygen out of the air in their lungs
01:40:36 at very high altitude. So we have a family of people and some other subjects that we study that
01:40:42 are left shifted. Sorry, meaning there is a family of people who genetically shift left instead of
01:40:48 shift right under hypoxic conditions. And there's all sorts of rare hemoglobin variants. They're not
01:40:54 like sickle cell or anything like that. Very interesting, Peter, to be sitting in the lab having
01:40:59 somebody breathe in 10% oxygen talking to you. These left shifted people do that. It's crazy. It's just
01:41:04 wild. What is the FIO2 at the top of Everest, by the way, just for comparison? Barometric pressure
01:41:09 is about 250. So it'd be 21% of 250. So roughly about 50. So once you get in into your lung, I think
01:41:16 arterial is about in the 30s. Wow. Yeah. At 15%, which is 3,000 meters, these people exercise like,
01:41:23 you know, they do fine. So I'm very interested in that. And then as I mentioned, you know, before we
01:41:27 went on is through a weird collection of events, when the pandemic struck in March and early
01:41:34 April of 2020, I somehow became the principal investigator of the U.S. Convalescent Plasma
01:41:39 Program, a program that was initially designed to facilitate in 5,000 patients compassionate use
01:41:46 of convalescent plasma, antibody-rich plasma from recovered COVID patients that we would give to
01:41:51 people who had disease and hopefully the antibodies would help them. Through all sorts of twists and
01:41:56 turns, we ended up doing over 100,000 people. We found evidence if we gave people a whole lot of
01:42:01 antibody early in the course of disease, we made them better. We also found some evidence that it
01:42:06 was probably very helpful in people that were immune suppressed. And that has been the gift that
01:42:10 keeps giving. So at age 60, you know, 162, 63, I got kind of a new career in immunology and infectious
01:42:18 disease. And so we're pursuing that. And we're especially interested in that, Peter, because
01:42:23 whenever COVID sort of finally winds down, about 2% to 3% of the population is what we call B cell
01:42:31 deficient. So B cells are the cells in your body that make antibodies, help you respond to fight the
01:42:36 virus or respond to the vaccine. About 2% or 3% of the people don't have any or don't have very many.
01:42:42 And those people will continue to get COVID and other forms of infectious disease. And antibody
01:42:47 therapy is essential to help those folks. You know, I'm very happy that we've published papers in high
01:42:52 profile journals, but we just learned yesterday from People Magazine of all places that the actor
01:42:58 Jeff Bridges. The dude himself. The dude from The Big Lebowski. The dude himself had gotten lymphoma,
01:43:04 gotten drugs that depleted his B cells, which is typical for lymphoma patients. Got COVID, he could
01:43:10 not clear the COVID and responded to convalescent plasma. What's the total volume of plasma you need
01:43:15 to give a patient in that setting? If you get really high titer stuff, 2 to 400 mLs.
01:43:20 That's it. One-time treatment? Yeah, typically. Sometimes we give people more. And what's been
01:43:24 helpful, Peter, is that we now have people that have been both vaccinated and they've had a
01:43:30 breakthrough infection or they've had an infection and been vaccinated, right? So they have hybrid
01:43:34 immunity. And those people make, their plasma has a whole, whole lot of antibodies in them
01:43:39 and they're broad spectrum. So they cover all the variants and they almost anticipate future
01:43:45 variants because of the way the immune system works is a sort of a sloppy replicator. And so
01:43:51 they cover a lot of the variants. They cover potential future variants and as monoclonal
01:43:55 antibodies, which have been super helpful during the pandemic, as those get less effective due to
01:44:00 escape variants, this very high titer plasma is still available. We're back doing exercise studies.
01:44:06 We're back writing papers about exercise and doing our regular physiology. I think this
01:44:11 antibody therapies really took a bite out of me. It's like what Jim Bowden said, the great pitcher,
01:44:16 you know, you spend your life gripping the ball and thinking about your grip on the ball. And in
01:44:20 reality, it was the other way around. The ball had a grip on you. So, you know, I've been thinking a
01:44:24 lot about antibodies and maybe antibodies have been thinking about me because it's really hard to
01:44:28 stop thinking about it because it's so interesting. And we get reports back to us from not famous
01:44:34 patients that are very similar to what we've heard of Mr. Bridges. So we're quite excited to pursue
01:44:38 these solutions for our immune suppressed patients. When I started medical school in 1982, those sorts
01:44:44 of patients, their life expectancy was quite low. Now our patients with heme malignancy, multiple
01:44:49 myeloma, lymphoma, leukemias, a lot of those people live a long, long time.
01:44:55 How long after a person is infected and recovers from infection, are they a suitable plasma donor?
01:45:00 Within about two to three weeks.
01:45:02 When does that window close?
01:45:03 It goes on for three or four months, you know, probably up to six months. And it would probably
01:45:07 reopen if they got boosted, that sort of thing.
01:45:10 You only get sufficient antibodies from people who have had the actual infection,
01:45:13 not from people who just go get a booster?
01:45:15 Initially, because there were no vaccines, we only had people that had the normal infection.
01:45:19 Since the vaccines have become widely available in the last almost 18 months now or 15, 16 months,
01:45:25 we've now been able to get people who've had both. The people that have had both are really
01:45:29 super donors. And we can work with those people to come back in and get multiple units.
01:45:34 We collect our own blood at Mayo. We have a terrific blood bank here locally, but
01:45:37 they're using it at Hopkins, they're using it at Harvard, using it at Einstein, a lot of other big
01:45:41 places. We're working with the societies, the Food and Drug Administration and others like the
01:45:46 Lymphoma or Leukemia and Lymphoma Society, the CLL Group, Infectious Disease or, excuse me,
01:45:52 Immune Deficiency Foundation to make sure that we have this available for those sorts of patients.
01:45:57 They're doing this at scale in France to about 50 patients a week, which would be about 300 a week
01:46:02 in the US if you account for population differences. So that's one of the things we're quite interested
01:46:08 in. This is something people can donate. It's a way for people to give back.
01:46:12 Are you able to find sufficient donors? Are there enough donors that are aware?
01:46:15 Again, because there's so many people who've been both infected and broken through. There's always
01:46:19 logistical issues in terms of getting a person to the blood collecting center, getting it here,
01:46:24 getting it there. But availability should be pretty high.
01:46:27 And with plasma, do you still have to do a type and cross?
01:46:30 Got to still be typed and crossed and people are, they have to be eligible to otherwise donate blood.
01:46:35 But during the peak of plasma use prior to the vaccines and prior to the monofunals,
01:46:40 20, 30, 40,000 units a week were being used in the country. And in the weeks when more plasma was
01:46:46 being used, the death rate two weeks later was lower. So there's a pretty nice correlation between it.
01:46:51 But again, I think we've talked about training. We've talked a little bit about coaching. We've
01:46:56 talked about participation in support and so forth. But I think one of the things that really
01:47:00 helped me work with the government and work with our team, instead of do a 5,000-person
01:47:05 demonstration project, do really a treatment registry and over 100,000 patients, was the organizational
01:47:11 skills I learned from my coaches. And I used to joke with higher-ups in the Food and Drug
01:47:15 Administration. They'd say, well, how did you do that? I'd say, I'm a recovering physical educator.
01:47:19 And that was always good for laughter in at least a few dark hours.
01:47:24 Last question, Mike. Given your longstanding history in athletics, both personally and
01:47:29 professionally, are you optimistic or pessimistic about the future of Americans based on the
01:47:35 level of physical activity that we see?
01:47:38 We need to do something. We need to do something. And I think it really reflects our society in
01:47:45 general. I think that you have, for lack of a better word, upper middle class kids who have
01:47:50 access to superb coaching, to superb facilities, and to programmatic things. I think we've got a
01:47:58 tremendous problem with play and unstructured play. Things that when I was growing up in the 60s and
01:48:04 70s that were done through the park district and the school district, I think a lot of those
01:48:08 opportunities have fallen by the wayside. The kids who were college athletes used to come back and have
01:48:13 open gym all over Tucson when I was a kid. There's no open gym at the high schools in Rochester,
01:48:18 Minnesota, a rich community in the summer. And the advantage of open gym was, hey, you got people
01:48:24 off the street and they were doing things. And the police knew where we were, which they're always
01:48:28 very pleased about. If they know that all the high energy boys are in one place, it makes their life a
01:48:34 little easier as well. Yeah, I think it's a real problem. So I think we'll have these incredible
01:48:37 performances by the kids who have access. But I think that what we're doing in the rest of the
01:48:44 world is problematic. I guess if I could do anything, I'd start a national open gym movement,
01:48:50 winter, summer, whatever, because we have a lot of nice facilities that are used just a limited
01:48:54 number of time per day. Could you imagine if you were a czar and you could sort of do anything and
01:48:58 you just said, no matter what your lot is in life, if you're a school child, if you're a person who
01:49:03 works in an office, if you're a person who works in, we somehow rearrange the day such that every
01:49:08 person has a mandatory one hour activity. You could make it exercise. You can go to the gym for an
01:49:14 hour, but it could also be, look, at a minimum, you got to go out and walk. Well, you know, it's
01:49:19 interesting you mentioned that because in our department with remote work and so forth, this
01:49:24 has broken down a little bit, but we had a number of secretaries. They were all women, middle-aged
01:49:29 women. And we have this huge, deep bunker system with the bowels of the hospital with these huge 1.00
01:49:35 hallways. And it's about a mile around the place. And these folks would go down and walk at lunch.
01:49:40 They'd bring their tennis shoes to work. They would meet up with their pals and go do 30, 40 minutes
01:49:45 a day of laps at lunchtime with the secretaries all over the hospital. And it was, I think, terrific
01:49:51 for them. I think it was a social event for them. And I think that they solved a lot of problems
01:49:56 too. And they actually made them way more productive. As I said, at the outset, I've
01:50:00 enjoyed reading your papers for more than two decades and I'll continue to do so. And it's
01:50:04 been great to chat and hopefully we can meet in person at some point and do a workout together.
01:50:09 Yeah. I look forward to it. Thank you for listening to this week's episode of The Drive.
01:50:13 If you're interested in diving deeper into any topics we discuss, we've created a membership
01:50:17 program that allows us to bring you more in-depth exclusive content without relying on paid ads.
01:50:23 It's our goal to ensure members get back much more than the price of the subscription.
01:50:27 Now to that end, membership benefits include a bunch of things. One, totally kick-ass comprehensive
01:50:33 podcast show notes that detail every topic, paper, person, thing we discuss on each episode.
01:50:38 The word on the street is nobody's show notes rival these. Monthly AMA episodes or Ask Me
01:50:44 Anything episodes, hearing these episodes completely. Access to our private podcast feed that allows
01:50:49 you to hear everything without having to listen to spiels like this. The Qualies, which are a super
01:50:55 short podcast that we release every Tuesday through Friday, highlighting the best questions,
01:51:00 topics, and tactics discussed on previous episodes of The Drive. This is a great way to catch up on
01:51:05 previous episodes without having to go back and necessarily listen to everyone. Steep discounts
01:51:10 on products that I believe in, but for which I'm not getting paid to endorse. And a whole bunch of
01:51:16 other benefits that we continue to trickle in as time goes on. If you want to learn more and access
01:51:20 these member-only benefits, you can head over to peteratiamd.com forward slash subscribe.
01:51:26 You can find me on Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook, all with the ID peteratiamd. You can also leave us a
01:51:33 review on Apple Podcasts or whatever podcast player you listen on. This podcast is for general
01:51:39 informational purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing, or other
01:51:43 professional healthcare services, including the giving of medical advice. No doctor-patient
01:51:49 relationship is formed. The use of this information and the materials linked to this podcast is at the
01:51:55 user's own risk. The content on this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional
01:52:00 medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Users should not disregard or delay in obtaining medical advice
01:52:08 from any medical condition they have, and they should seek the assistance of their healthcare
01:52:12 professionals for any such conditions. Finally, I take conflicts of interest very seriously. For all
01:52:19 of my disclosures and the companies I invest in or advise, please visit peteratiamd.com forward slash
01:52:26 about where I keep an up-to-date and active list of such companies.
01:52:31 I'll see you next time.