The Peter Attia Drive - January 13, 2025


#331 ‒ Optimizing endurance performance: metrics, nutrition, lactate, and more insights from elite performers | Olav Aleksander Bu (Pt. 2)

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
#330 – Autism, ADHD, and Anxiety: Understanding the rise in autism and a multidisciplinary approach to diagnosis and treatment of each condition in children | Trenna Sutcliffe, M.D. #332 - AMA #67: Microplastics, PFAS, and phthalates: understanding health risks and a framework for minimizing exposure and mitigating risk

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 16 minutes

Words per minute

205.05

Word count

27,908

Sentence count

1,726

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, I speak with Olav Aleksandr Buu, Head of Performance for the Norwegian Triathlon team, about his approach to coaching and the use of data to measure performance. Olav is an endurance coach, exercise scientist, engineer, and physiologist, and is best known for coaching two of the world s top triathletes, Christian Blumenfeld and Gustav Iden.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey, everyone. Welcome to the Drive podcast. I'm your host, Peter Atiyah. This podcast,
00:00:16 my website, and my weekly newsletter all focus on the goal of translating the science of longevity
00:00:21 into something accessible for everyone. Our goal is to provide the best content in health and
00:00:26 wellness, and we've established a great team of analysts to make this happen. It is extremely
00:00:31 important to me to provide all of this content without relying on paid ads. To do this, our work
00:00:36 is made entirely possible by our members, and in return, we offer exclusive member-only content
00:00:42 and benefits above and beyond what is available for free. If you want to take your knowledge of
00:00:47 this space to the next level, it's our goal to ensure members get back much more than the price
00:00:53 of the subscription. If you want to learn more about the benefits of our premium membership,
00:00:58 head over to peteratiyahmd.com forward slash subscribe. My guest this week is Olav Alexander
00:01:06 Boo. Olav was a guest in March of 2024, and at the time of that conversation, I realized we hadn't got
00:01:12 through the majority of what I wanted to speak about, so it was inevitable that I would have him
00:01:17 back. Olav is an endurance coach, exercise scientist, engineer, and physiologist. He is the
00:01:22 head of performance for Norway Triathlon and is best known for coaching two of the world's top
00:01:28 triathletes, Christian Blumenfeld and Gustav Iden. In this episode, we review his work and his approach
00:01:37 to coaching and the way that he relies very heavily on data. We talk about and define various performance
00:01:44 metrics like FTP, functional threshold power, critical power, anaerobic threshold, lactate
00:01:49 threshold, VO2 max, and the importance of consistent protocols when testing these performance metrics
00:01:56 and how they can vary depending on an athlete's training. We discuss differences in training
00:02:02 methodologies across sports and how different sports and activities influence power, pace, and endurance.
00:02:08 We look at the significance of nutrition in endurance sports, how athletes train to
00:02:14 properly fuel themselves for races, and why this is so different from what has been done
00:02:18 historically. In fact, we really got into this difference in carbohydrate metabolism.
00:02:23 Just like the first time Olav and I spoke, this is a discussion that can be quite complex at some
00:02:28 points. We do get a little bit into the weeds, but the truth of it is because of the nature of what
00:02:33 we're talking about, it's very difficult to talk about these things meaningfully and superficially.
00:02:38 Patience is always appreciated and the rewards are always there if you're able to stick with it.
00:02:42 Without further delay, please enjoy my conversation with Olav Aleksandr Buu.
00:02:51 Olav, thank you very much for coming to Austin on your way. I guess you're on your way to Arizona?
00:02:57 Yes, on my way to Flagstaff. Also, thank you very much for having me again.
00:03:01 Yeah. Well, as I mentioned last time we spoke, I had a lot of notes. We got through,
00:03:06 I think, one-eighth of them. There's a lot to cover today. Of course, as we've been sitting here for
00:03:11 the last 15 minutes or so, we've already kind of started the podcast, unfortunately. And I want
00:03:15 to go right to where we just left off, but I'm going to resist the urge. Last time we spoke really
00:03:21 about sort of the most nuanced ins and outs of cardiorespiratory fitness. Maybe just for the
00:03:26 person who didn't catch that episode, can you give the one-minute version of what you do and why
00:03:33 you're certainly one of the few people that would be poised to talk about what we're going to talk
00:03:37 about today? I'm not very good at the pitches. My background is from engineering, and it means
00:03:42 also that this principle have guided me quite a lot through my journey in endurance sports or in
00:03:48 sports in general. We embarked on a journey 10 years ago, more than 10 years ago, I would say now 15
00:03:53 years ago, where we started to do what I would call extreme in-depth and longitudinal studies on
00:04:00 two of the arguably fittest athletes in the whole world. Yeah, I think that pretty much resembles it.
00:04:05 Obviously, a large part of that also involves technology development, simply because we are at
00:04:10 the edge of basically what we have available information on, research on. And that means
00:04:16 that even in some cases, we have to develop technology to allow us to even progress the
00:04:21 understanding of getting a more granular understanding of why things are the way they are.
00:04:27 Yeah. So in many ways, you're kind of an applied scientist.
00:04:29 Yes.
00:04:29 And your laboratory is both a CPET lab and then a racing environment where most of the athletes you
00:04:36 work with are triathletes, correct? Yes and no. I would say that it's actually quite spread. It's
00:04:41 a mixture between triathletes, cyclists, runners, track and field, to even sailors, which is, let's
00:04:48 say, on the explosive end of the domain, actually, and not endurance, but yeah.
00:04:52 Yeah. I feel like we're going to use a lot of terms today. We're going to probably throw out the
00:04:57 word anaerobic threshold, lactate threshold, VO2 max, FTP. So I just want to make sure everybody
00:05:02 kind of understands those things. So let's just take them one at a time. Can you define FTP or
00:05:07 functional threshold power for folks? There is a couple of definitions of this already,
00:05:11 which is, I have to say that it's bad when you have good terminologies, but they start to get diluted.
00:05:17 But the original definition of FTP by the authors, I think, was Andy Kogan. And that was that
00:05:24 basically, you first actually have to do a five-minute all-out effort. And then basically,
00:05:28 there's a short pause in between there. And then you go to a 20-minute all-out effort.
00:05:33 And then you subtract 5% from that to find your FTP. So typically, it would be your 20-minute all-out
00:05:38 minus 5%. And the reason for that is to try to get a ballpark-ish idea of what your, let's say,
00:05:45 sustainable output is possible to do over an hour. But as we have learned over the years,
00:05:51 is that one, we figure out that this is not as accurate always, because there are a couple of
00:05:55 other things in there. And also, unfortunately, there have become different ways to doing it.
00:06:00 Like some people, they just do a warm-up and then they do a 20-minute all-out and then they
00:06:03 subtract 5%. And that's already different. Yeah. We used to sometimes do 20 minutes and
00:06:08 subtract 10%. So we would do a gentle warm-up for an hour, then do 20 minutes and then subtract 10%.
00:06:15 So yes. But I guess the spirit of FTP, which is maybe what we want people to think about and not
00:06:20 get mired in the details, is it really approximates an energy zone that is more than just an all-out,
00:06:29 but clearly less than what you could hold indefinitely. And it's directionally about
00:06:33 the highest output you could have for an hour. And there's different ways to approximate it, of course.
00:06:38 Maybe more importantly to that point is that as long as you do something consistently,
00:06:43 you keep the same protocol, you could say, okay, this one thing is the original thinking and that
00:06:48 went into devising this kind of protocol. But I would say more importantly is rather to stay true
00:06:54 to the principle of how you do it. So as long as you do it the same way each time, this is more
00:06:59 important. And then how does that differ from another term that is used interchangeably, but I
00:07:05 believe erroneously, which is critical power? So critical power is something that you normally more
00:07:10 extract from that you do multiple all-out efforts. And then you apply reverse extrapolation to this
00:07:16 to basically figure out what is your critical power. So it's a more of a little bit more advanced
00:07:23 mathematical approach to it. Typically, you would say that there are different concepts to this.
00:07:27 I personally have to say that I like the critical power approach a little bit better.
00:07:32 And what is it trying to approximate?
00:07:33 So critical power is basically where you try to divide something into two zones. That's a
00:07:41 cross oversimplification, but you distinguish between, let's say, a non-severe and a severe state,
00:07:47 or basically where you are, again, also in the same way as FTP, trying to figure out what is the power
00:07:53 you are capable of staying at for a prolonged time, and basically where you go into a territory where
00:08:00 small changes has a huge consequence on the duration that you're capable of holding it.
00:08:06 And where does critical power typically lie in relation to FTP?
00:08:10 Again, this depends a little bit on how you test FTP, but I would say that how maybe FTP have been
00:08:16 used over the last, or let's say a little bit more deviated from how the authors originally devised it,
00:08:22 I would say that it actually is not too different. And normally you would say that critical or
00:08:27 functional threshold power would lie slightly lower in power output than critical power.
00:08:34 But again, it depends very much on, let's say, also in critical power there are today,
00:08:37 I don't know how many different definitions there are of critical power and how you should do the
00:08:41 protocol there. But it means that normally critical power, if you look at it from a metabolic perspective,
00:08:47 it sits somewhere between your maximum lactate steady state, or call it anaerobic threshold,
00:08:52 and VU2 max. So typically more close to VU2 steady state or so on, but that's introducing another term
00:08:59 that it just doesn't bring clarity. We'll define those in a second. So many of these metrics,
00:09:05 FTP, critical power, are easiest to think about in terms of cycling, because we use power meters.
00:09:11 Do the same concepts still apply in swimming and running?
00:09:14 Yes, I would say. I think for the sake of simplicity, it sometimes helps to refer to,
00:09:23 like say, one condensed number. So you use, for example, you can say critical pace,
00:09:27 for example, in running and swimming. And the way of testing it is not too different to what you
00:09:33 would do in cycling. But one thing that actually happens in the process is that you actually have
00:09:38 access to more granular information, and you are dumping down information a little bit when you
00:09:42 call it FTP or you call it critical power. Because more importantly, I would say, is that when you
00:09:48 present a critical power number only, or an FTP number only, you have taken two-dimensional
00:09:54 information and made it one-dimensional, meaning that you only look at the y-axis and you take away
00:09:59 the information that is quite critical, I would say, and that is how long are you able to sustain
00:10:03 something. So for example, for critical power testing, I would say, again, also when you first do
00:10:08 critical power testing, it's more interesting to know, let's say, how fast or how far you're able
00:10:14 to get over one minute, for example, five minute and 15 minutes, and then actually see what happens
00:10:19 in the next time you do it for the one minute, the five minute and 15 minutes, because this is
00:10:22 actually quite crucial to understand also the balance or what's happening with the different
00:10:27 balances in the body. Also FTP, most people think of this as a 20-minute power, so it's even a little
00:10:33 bit more condensed or even simpler information. But as we will probably come back to, is that when
00:10:40 you're training, there are two things that normally can happen. One is that you increase your general
00:10:43 capacity, meaning that both power and capacity, one or two, are increased. The other thing that
00:10:50 happens there is that at some point, we are all time limited, and this is where we need to pivot.
00:10:54 So we need to pivot or let's say, prioritize what is more important for us. Is it the more explosive
00:10:58 or speed or is it more endurance? And then it becomes more interesting for how you guide the
00:11:04 training to understand what's happening between this different power or pace and durations.
00:11:10 Okay. You mentioned two other terms there, anaerobic threshold. Let's start with that. How do we define
00:11:15 it? Probably in the same way today that we say something we just say and call, and now in the
00:11:19 world of chat GPT and everything, we just call something AI. Basically an extremely broad term that try
00:11:25 to encompass more or less the exact same thing that we already talked about. Basically, let's say the
00:11:31 difference between where something is steady and where it goes over to unsteady, or basically for
00:11:37 where you can hold something for a longer duration and where it goes to shorter duration. It's a
00:11:42 misconception to think that anaerobic threshold means basically when you become anaerobic, because
00:11:47 that's not the case. Yeah. It's a continuum, of course. It's not a switch. Yeah. Yeah.
00:11:51 Where does anaerobic threshold typically, if we're just limiting this to make the discussion easier
00:11:57 in talking about, say, cyclists with a power meter, where does anaerobic threshold tend to sit relative
00:12:02 to FTP? So again, obviously, because this is a more, but if we then, let's say, bring it over more
00:12:08 to lactate as a tool for trying to figure out where this is. And again, this opens up a whole new world of
00:12:16 definitions, but to try to answer it simply, I would say that typically anaerobic threshold,
00:12:20 when you use lactate, and let's say that you use, for example, gold standards or maximum lactate
00:12:25 steady state, this will normally sit below the critical power of FTP, so at the lower power.
00:12:30 So for keeping track, we've got critical power, FTP, AT.
00:12:35 Yeah. Also, what's important here is that when we say anaerobic threshold is that when we talk about
00:12:39 the differences here, the differences here depend a little bit on what kind of athlete you are,
00:12:43 whether you are a high-power athlete or endurance athlete. So if you're a high-power athlete,
00:12:48 typically you'll see that there are larger differences between this, so the percentage
00:12:52 difference between this will be larger. Our endurance athletes, it will be smaller,
00:12:55 but you could basically call these minute differences. We are talking percent differences.
00:12:59 It's not like these are going to be 10% apart in terms of power or anything like this. We talk about
00:13:04 percentages from a couple of percents to maybe five, worst case, maybe 10.
00:13:10 Okay. And then lactate threshold, just adding more definitions.
00:13:12 Yes. So lactate threshold, I would say the lactate threshold has probably more of a result of
00:13:18 limitations in the measurement method, because we know that lactate is something you produce
00:13:23 all the time, even when you are sleeping. So the difference here is more where you're looking at
00:13:28 where you find a first infliction point on a lactate curve when you do as an increase in intensity.
00:13:34 So one thing that is maybe easy to get wrong here is that it looks like when you do increasing,
00:13:41 so if you start low enough power or low enough pace, it looks like, oh, there is no increase in
00:13:45 lactate production. The problem is the way we measure. We don't measure lactate in the muscle,
00:13:50 we measure in the bloodstream. And for it to basically be reflected on the instrument,
00:13:54 there needs to be a large enough lactate production in the muscles where you're not able necessarily to
00:13:59 metabolize the lactate immediately. And it starts to get transported out into the bloodstream,
00:14:04 and it starts to reflect also as an increase in lactate there. So the difference is also is that
00:14:09 depending on protocol, this will change. So that's also a little bit of the challenges when you also
00:14:14 start to mix something external with something internal as well.
00:14:19 And so if we did a lactate protocol, a speed or power escalation, right? I think we talked about this
00:14:26 in the last podcast, which was kind of the way we used to do it in swimming is you'd think we would
00:14:30 do 200-yard swims. So you do a 200-yard swim at a very modest pace. Come back, check the lactate,
00:14:37 rest, do it again, five seconds faster per 200. Go and do it again. Lactate, da-da-da-da-da. And you
00:14:43 get a plot. So pace on the x-axis, lactate on the y-axis. And the curve is very distinct. It is very,
00:14:50 very flat, and then it is not. And we would draw these tangent lines between the two, and then that
00:14:55 point was the lactate threshold. Where would that typically lie? Assuming we did it on a bicycle,
00:15:02 so it was really easy to do the power checks. First of all, how long a duration would you have
00:15:07 an athlete do this if you were doing it on an ergometer? Would you say we're going to do
00:15:12 three-minute efforts or something like that? Is that appropriate to generate the lactate performance
00:15:16 curve? It depends, again, how you're going to utilize it. If you are going to use it for actively,
00:15:21 let's say, controlling the intensity outdoors, for example, using a lactate meter,
00:15:25 then I would say it really doesn't matter. Even taking into account that there's some lag
00:15:29 between what's happening in the muscle and what's happening in the blood?
00:15:32 Exactly. Because the thing here is that here you're looking for more, not necessarily,
00:15:36 here also it's important just for me to say initially that when you find, for example,
00:15:40 a lactate concentration of LT1 and LT2, for example, or basically AT and LT, for example,
00:15:46 or AT, LT2, but we basically say lactate turn point two and lactate turn point one,
00:15:51 so the first one and the second one. And then when you do this,
00:15:54 it's also a misconception to think that your LT2 is always a constant value because this will be
00:16:00 influenced by many factors. We measure a concentration in the blood and the blood
00:16:03 is influenced by hydration and all things like this. So for example, if you have a change in
00:16:07 hematocrit, we won't come into that, but you can easily from the beginning of the session
00:16:11 towards the end of the session, see changes in hematocrit of more than 10%.
00:16:15 As you get dehydrated.
00:16:16 Yes. So this will already influence the lactate concentration, but to use it as a guiding
00:16:21 principle, it really doesn't matter how long your steps are. Basically, what you're looking
00:16:25 for is to find a concentration value, and then you go out into the field and you're trying to
00:16:29 figure out where this is. You basically said, okay, if you figured this out to be for an endurance
00:16:33 assay, for sake of simplicity, we say one millimole and two and a half millimoles. So one millimole at
00:16:38 the lactate threshold or LT1, and then two and a half of LT2 or anaerobic threshold, AT.
00:16:44 We usually saw them a little bit higher than that. Actually, I didn't really differentiate
00:16:48 between LT1 and LT2. I kind of looked at the single inflection point just using a two line.
00:16:54 Usually people were kind of in the three to four range was where that inflection point.
00:16:59 You're saying that corresponds to LT2?
00:17:01 Yes. So, and this also comes back to a little bit what kind of athlete you are.
00:17:05 Yeah. This was mostly swimming that we were doing.
00:17:07 I found swimmers, by the way, had the highest lactate capacity.
00:17:11 Basically for how much lactate-
00:17:12 How much lactate they would produce and tolerate.
00:17:14 And tolerate, yeah.
00:17:15 Yeah. Any idea? I mean, it could be just a small sample size.
00:17:18 Very often, it depends on what kind of swim is. If you look at the 100 meter swimmer, for example.
00:17:22 So call it two to 400 breaststroke, butterfly, individual medley. I never saw higher numbers
00:17:28 of lactate in myself or other swimmers than in those. I always assumed it was two things. It was
00:17:33 individual medley, you're using every muscle in the body. It's not like
00:17:37 cycling or running. You're hemorrhaging lactate into the system. And then secondly, at that distance,
00:17:43 two to 400, I mean, you're really in the pain train of, you're clearly not able to do this
00:17:49 fully anaerobically. So you're sort of maximizing aerobic and then topping up anaerobic. But that was
00:17:54 sort of why I sort of assumed, I mean, literally I measured on several elite swimmers, lactate's over
00:17:59 20 millimole.
00:18:00 I think very often it helps to think that metabolism is basically the same. The body is
00:18:07 the same, no matter what kind of sport we do. And that's why sometimes it makes it more universally
00:18:11 easy to understand. If we think of what kind of sport we do as a function of intensity and duration.
00:18:17 So as long as you find a sport, so let's say that you compare a sport that has a certain
00:18:22 intensity and duration. So let's say, for example, if it's a 200 meter or 400 meter, you could say that
00:18:27 then you are typically in the range of, let's say for the fastest swimmers, typical, let's say two to
00:18:31 four minutes, for example. If you take a 1500 meter runner and you look also at the lactic concentration
00:18:37 of them, you will also find actually pretty much the same values, let's say among also tracking
00:18:41 field athletes that does 1500 meters or 800 meters as well. As the moment you start to go a little bit
00:18:47 longer, then you will actually start to see that this actually is not the case anymore.
00:18:51 And this is also where it helps to also distinguish between lactic concentration,
00:18:55 let's say the highest value you're looking for, and also lactic production. Because lactic
00:18:59 production, it's even more complicated. We can't really measure lactic production,
00:19:03 then we need to integrate for time. So you have to do, let's say a pre-measurement,
00:19:07 a post-measurement, and then also obviously here there are, again, many weaknesses to an approach
00:19:12 like this, but you have to derive it based, let's say more on calculations than really that you can
00:19:19 measure it directly. How high you can get in lactic concentration is also valuable because it obviously
00:19:24 tells you something about how much you are able to buffer in your body too. So again, what we see
00:19:29 coming back to the main question of how do you use lactate and then basically for the sake of where
00:19:34 you do a profile and testing, this is where I would say that for endurance athletes like,
00:19:39 for example, marathoners, triathletes, and others, which has a very, very long duration,
00:19:44 and they don't have very much top speed. Here it's actually not uncommon even to see where the
00:19:49 second infliction points even validated by maximum lactose steady state that actually can
00:19:52 even be below two millimoles. Let's just translate that into English for people. One of the challenges
00:19:59 of talking with you is I enjoy it so much, and I sometimes forget that there are other people
00:20:03 listening who might not care nearly as much as you and I do about some of this minutia, but
00:20:08 it's just, it's, I can't get enough of this stuff. So let's make sure people understand what you just
00:20:13 said. You just said that when you look at the most elite endurance athletes, these people have
00:20:19 either some combination of such low lactate production and or such high lactate clearance that
00:20:27 frankly, the need to buffer it becomes secondary. They're producing such a high degree of power.
00:20:33 They're generating so much work with so much aerobic efficiency that their steady state lactate
00:20:39 doesn't even need to hit two millimole, which of course you can sit at two millimole all day long
00:20:44 and not notice it from an acid base standpoint. Is that a fair assessment of what you said or
00:20:49 implication of what you said maybe? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Because I think for those that are a little bit
00:20:53 more into the details, I think also again here is important to come back to that it's a lactate
00:20:59 concentration. And one thing that we also do know in elite athletes is that elite athletes has a
00:21:04 higher blood volume, larger plasma volume and other things as well. So this means basically that the
00:21:08 absolute lactate could still be higher. Exactly. So lactate production can be higher,
00:21:11 but basically it shows up as a smaller concentration in the body. But what we distinguish between is
00:21:17 basically where comes the point where you are continuing at the same pace or power, but now lactate
00:21:22 doesn't stay steady anymore. So if you measure after same pace, same power, but after five minutes,
00:21:27 after 10 minutes and so on, basically then you'll start to see that lactate still continues to rise.
00:21:32 It doesn't stay stable anymore. This I think is probably one of the few concepts of where you
00:21:37 can say that, okay, if you test it this way, it becomes very easy to translate. Let's say the
00:21:42 communication between people, because at the moment you start to talk about anaerobic threshold,
00:21:46 this is more like, okay, how do you define it? Is this 20-minute power? Is this 60-minute power?
00:21:50 Or what kind of duration, what kind of protocol, and all these kinds of things.
00:21:54 But that's one. And the second point also is that what happens, because obviously when you are an
00:22:00 endurance athlete, like a triathlete or a marathoner, for example, is that you need to have
00:22:04 a sustainable energy supply for the duration of the event. And obviously the faster you can go of
00:22:10 your potential for that duration, the more beneficial it is. So that means also that your utilization,
00:22:16 maybe come back to this a little bit, because VO2max is one of the terms we're going to define.
00:22:19 So utilization normally, just to take that term then, or let's say partially, let's define
00:22:24 utilization. Utilization is basically, normally you can do it as whatever you want. You can do
00:22:29 it as a race-based, oxygen consumption at race-based versus your VO2max. But very often in scientific
00:22:34 literature, we define this as, for example, your oxygen consumption at maximum active steady state
00:22:40 versus VO2max. So for example, if it was, then it could be that your maximum active steady state,
00:22:46 you see the oxygen consumption there is, for example, 80% off your VO2max.
00:22:51 Is that what you would typically see in an elite athlete?
00:22:54 That's low.
00:22:55 That's low.
00:22:55 That's low. For a marathoner, you would go even higher. So for a marathoner,
00:22:59 like the elite marathoners, you're talking about 94, 95% of the VO2max. For Christian,
00:23:05 Gusto, when they do Ironmans, you're also pretty much around there.
00:23:07 Let me just make sure we get people to understand that, because that is, as you know, now that I
00:23:12 have a VO2 master, I'm testing my VO2max all the time. And I'm also testing my VO2 at submax
00:23:18 levels all the time as well, and looking at how that corresponds to lactate levels.
00:23:22 Yes.
00:23:23 So why don't you define VO2max, and then we're going to come back to this point,
00:23:26 because I want to make sure people can internalize and maybe even one day experience what you just
00:23:31 described.
00:23:32 So VO2max is normally defined as the maximum oxygen your body is able to consume over a
00:23:40 minute, a full minute. But this is also something that is debated. It's less of, let's say,
00:23:48 protocol influence. You can still go out and do, for example, efforts out in the field,
00:23:54 and you will be able to produce higher numbers than what you would be able to do on a standard
00:23:59 graded exercise protocol.
00:24:00 That's been the case for me. You know, I've shared my data with you. So I like to do it on
00:24:05 my bike on a hill. Take a hill that's going to be not too steep, 6% grade. You're in the saddle the
00:24:12 whole time, and you're in the big chain ring, and it is go for broke and make sure you're dead at the
00:24:18 top. Four minutes of climbing, and that produces a VO2max. There's going to be a level, usually near the
00:24:24 very top of the hill in the last minute where I reach the maximum volume of oxygen that I'm consuming.
00:24:32 Now, indoors, I, for some reason, hate doing it on a stationary bike. So instead, I do it on a
00:24:37 Stairmaster. So now I'm just sprinting upstairs doing the same thing. I get a comparable number,
00:24:43 but it's a little bit lower. Now, what I haven't done yet, and I was going to try to do it before we
00:24:47 met today, but I ran out of time. I was traveling last weekend. I have a prediction, which is, I think
00:24:54 I would have a higher VO2max running on a treadmill, even though I'm very inefficient running, because
00:24:59 my heart rate is always higher when I run than when I cycle. Do you think that would be the case?
00:25:05 Normally, I would say that should be the case, but it is also where there can also be other
00:25:13 factors also involved in it. One of the places where this is something that have quite passed me
00:25:20 is that, for example, Formula One drivers, they sit in for almost, let's say, one and a half hour
00:25:25 with extremely high heart rates. But having looked at that telemetry very closely, a lot of that is
00:25:32 driven by the G-forces. I mean, the first time I looked at an F1 driver's telemetry, I was like,
00:25:37 there's a mistake. These are just errors. These aren't real numbers, because I had never seen
00:25:42 such rapid changes from low to high to high to low. And then I realized they were all corresponding to
00:25:50 either very, very strong break points or very, very fast corners. Obviously, the only thing that's
00:25:56 common to that is something about 5G on the body is dramatically doing that. Now, it would be very
00:26:02 interesting if we could do it, I don't know how you would do it, would be to measure VO2 and see if it
00:26:08 has a commensurate change. What would you hypothesize?
00:26:11 So this is, I think also when you are doing these, so it could also be like jet fighters as well.
00:26:18 I would imagine that's even more pronounced for them. And we could actually measure that because
00:26:21 they're already in a mask.
00:26:22 Yes, exactly. So you could say that in dogfighting, for sure, then I think you will actually be pretty
00:26:27 much maybe same as Formula One. But I think that if you're just pushing really high G-forces
00:26:33 in one direction, then it would maybe not be as high, even if it's a prolonged one.
00:26:38 The reason for that is because I think that the G-forces, obviously, you're trying to counteract
00:26:42 that. So you're mobilizing every bit of muscles that are in your body in order to stay exactly
00:26:47 where you need to stay.
00:26:48 But there's a slight difference, which maybe you're about to get to, so I apologize if you are.
00:26:53 There's got to be also a part of that heart rate that is coming from the compromised Venus return
00:26:57 to the heart due to either the Valsalva or the actual impeding of the inferior vena cava.
00:27:05 I would think at a high enough G-force, part of that high heart rate is stroke volume has
00:27:10 gone way down because preload is way down. Again, sorry, I should make sure everyone understands
00:27:16 what we're saying. When you fill the heart less with blood, you don't stretch the muscles
00:27:21 out. That's called preload. So the heart needs to be preloaded with lots of blood volume
00:27:26 so it can get a good squeeze. And anything that prevents that, either dehydration or literally
00:27:31 forces that are preventing the blood returning to the heart, could make that high heart rate
00:27:36 really a product of tiny, tiny little ineffective beats.
00:27:39 Yes. That's also, we've done some studies on that.
00:27:43 In high G-force athletes?
00:27:44 No, actually in similar, because it's quite interesting to see that what happens also with
00:27:49 the muscles. So when you do work, you produce a certain amount of power. Obviously, there are forces
00:27:54 involved and there is velocity involved. These forces require a certain amount of recruitment
00:27:59 of muscle fibers. And these muscle fibers, at a certain point, will actually start to cause
00:28:03 vasoconstrictions. So they actually start squeezing off the blood supply. They normally act also as a
00:28:08 pump. They actually help pumping blood around in the body, promoting preloading. But the interesting
00:28:13 thing is that we do see that where you also get in the area of anaerobic threshold is actually
00:28:22 where you are starting to come to the point where you're squeezing off the blood flow as well in
00:28:25 the muscles. And this happens around ballpark-ish. Obviously, there is a fairly large ranger,
00:28:31 but ballpark-ish around 30% of your 1RM.
00:28:34 You should never experience that on a bike, right? Because in theory, it's hard to imagine you could
00:28:41 ever come close to 30% of a 1RM force on a pedal stroke. Could you?
00:28:47 That's true.
00:28:47 Maybe there's an extreme moment you're at a 16% grade or something like that, I guess. It's possible,
00:28:53 huh?
00:28:54 Yeah, for sustained efforts. For short efforts, you can get very, very close. But for sustained ones,
00:28:59 yes, I would agree. But coming back to running versus the bike, which was, let's say, the place
00:29:05 where it started. Normally, I would say that, yes, in running, you would at least a sub-maximal
00:29:10 efforts have a higher view to max. The only thing is that we see that in people that are, let's say,
00:29:16 somewhat balanced trained, so they spend some time on the bike, they spend some time on running,
00:29:20 then normally there are more muscles involved for a longer duration in cycling than it is in running.
00:29:25 So when you test Christian or Gustav, if you were to have them fresh on two separate days,
00:29:31 and on one day you put them on the bike, and on one day you put them on the treadmill,
00:29:37 and you have them do a VO2 max test, what would be the approximate difference you would see in them?
00:29:41 Actually, when I started working with them, then it was close to a significant difference between
00:29:46 cycling and running, and even more in swimming.
00:29:49 Higher in swimming?
00:29:50 No. Lowest in swimming, actually. And that comes also back to one other thing.
00:29:54 One thing is also when we talk about preloading and how this also affects it, 0.88
00:29:58 I actually were stupid enough to teach Christian and Gustav this a long time ago,
00:30:02 and that is if they wanted to have a very high view to max. Obviously, if you're trained, 0.99
00:30:06 you will see this immediately on the breathing patterns. But what you can do to create an
00:30:10 artificially high view to max is that you basically, when you come pretty close to your
00:30:14 all-out effort, if you try to restrict your breathing, let's say for a short, short time
00:30:19 there, you will create a depth, and this depth will actually boost the numbers even higher.
00:30:23 This is the VO2 max hack for everybody watching this. How do I boost my, because my hack for boosting
00:30:29 VO2 max is weight loss. Just figure out a way to lose five pounds in the week leading up to the test,
00:30:35 then you're, goes, I've been obviously knowing how to train for it. I mean, if you train in those
00:30:40 intervals. So you're saying if you restrict breathing, as you get close to that failure point,
00:30:45 each breath you take becomes that much more of an oxygen explosion.
00:30:49 And even there, you can even train yourself also to the point where you're not talking about
00:30:54 marginal differences in your VO2. You can spike the numbers up to extreme numbers,
00:30:59 if you practice this a little bit. That aside, I think it's important here to remember that
00:31:03 that's not equivalent to getting fitter. It's just a way of basically manipulating something
00:31:08 in the body, and you're cheating a protocol. And it's not your, let's say, VO2 max.
00:31:12 But for those listening to this who have a bet with their friends about who's going to have
00:31:16 the highest VO2 max, this becomes their little trick.
00:31:18 Yes, then definitely you can do this, and you will get some really nice numbers.
00:31:22 So that's true.
00:31:23 How much of a boost would you get? Like, let's say you're a person who just
00:31:26 doing the protocol normally is 60. With no other change other than this breathing trick,
00:31:30 what would you take that to? One thing I want to add here just before answering that,
00:31:34 VO2 max for me, in the same way as power, you can look at it in relative terms and absolute terms
00:31:39 as well. So obviously losing weight. Yeah. So let's say it's five liters based on the weight that comes
00:31:45 out to 60. Yeah. I would say that in this case here, it comes very much down to technique,
00:31:50 but if you practice this a little bit that you can boost it above 70.
00:31:53 What? Not a problem.
00:31:56 Wow. I thought you were going to say 64, 65.
00:32:00 No, no. I've seen some crazy numbers. I don't even have to go into the raw dollar. You just
00:32:04 see it on the screen and say, okay. But wait a minute though. Doesn't that sort of fly in the
00:32:08 face of our definition of VO2 max, which is it's the highest oxygen consumption you sustain for one
00:32:14 minute? Because I know when I do my test, I think I'm always checking for 60 second average,
00:32:21 and I'm not ever just looking at the peak. It's very noisy data. So in this breathing technique,
00:32:26 don't you just get a really big spike that is otherwise noise in the one minute best effort?
00:32:32 No. So it would be a little bit more prolonged than that if you create an oxygen depth in your
00:32:37 body. But one thing that I think also here is important too, because this is also one of the
00:32:42 things that is a little bit challenging when you read a lot of research too, is that very often we
00:32:46 take that research for granted. Well, it's good. There is a lot of things around it that we don't
00:32:51 have access to or we don't know. And also one thing that also is sometimes a challenge is for
00:32:57 people to understand also whether the technology they are using, one, is it good for what you really
00:33:02 are doing here? So you can get a lot of machines that can measure some kind of oxygen uptake or
00:33:07 ratios and other things, but it doesn't mean that it necessarily is a good instrument for what you
00:33:11 want to do. And the second part of it also is that we have to understand where are we measuring?
00:33:16 Obviously in this case, when we do oxygen measurement, we measure it on the exhaust and
00:33:21 not in the muscles. And that's also an important difference here, because if we go to the point,
00:33:27 and I think we're going to run out of time if we continue on this path here, but if basically
00:33:32 you look at cellular or basically cell respiration, the numbers you will see much higher. I remember
00:33:38 this from our last discussion. We're not limited at the cell.
00:33:42 No. Again, here, I think it comes down to just staying true to some principles that can guide us.
00:33:47 The good thing with VU2 max testing is that there, the generally accepted standard for doing this
00:33:53 is a graded exercise test. And you go through that and it will produce fairly comparable numbers
00:33:59 for most people to relate to. There will be some differences.
00:34:03 What are some of the mistakes you want people to look out for? Because again,
00:34:06 people listening to this podcast are no stranger to VU2 max. We talk about it as if you were going
00:34:10 to sort of say, I need to know 10 parameters of my body for optimal health. VU2 max is on that list
00:34:17 every day of the week. So even if you are listening to this and you don't care about triathlons or
00:34:23 cycling or swimming, but you just have the desire to live as long as you can. And as well as you can,
00:34:28 you have to know your VU2 max and you need to optimize it and make it frankly, as high as you can
00:34:32 with whatever time you're willing to devote to training. That said, most people aren't going
00:34:36 to go out and buy a VU2 master and they're not going to geek out and do this stuff on their own.
00:34:40 They're going to rely on going to a place where the VU2 max is measured in a stationary fashion,
00:34:44 either on a treadmill or on a bike. What are some things that those folks need to be aware of when
00:34:48 they go to a center to test this as far as mistakes that people make? So for example,
00:34:52 I've seen many people go and do a test and I talked to them after and I go,
00:34:55 how exhausted were you at the end of the test? And they say, oh, it was okay. I could have kept
00:35:00 going and I'm realizing, okay, you didn't do a maximal test. Other mistakes I've seen are people
00:35:04 who don't have a long enough warmup time. The total test took five minutes and I'm like, well,
00:35:09 you didn't come close to sufficiently warming up. So are there any other things that you would just
00:35:12 have people have in the back of their mind when they call a place up to say, hey, I want to come
00:35:16 and do a VU2 max test. But before I give you my hundred bucks, I want to understand the protocol.
00:35:21 Of course, the question becomes also to what extent you're able to influence this as well,
00:35:24 because there are some practices that they want to dominate in a very rigorous way. They even
00:35:28 almost prescribe what you should do the days leading before and another where you just come
00:35:32 in and they just put you through a test and then you get what you get.
00:35:36 So what should folks look for? If you were sending somebody to a public place where they could go and
00:35:41 do this, they're not coming into your lab where you're going to administer the test.
00:35:45 What would you want them to be looking for?
00:35:47 What I would normally do is the one I would try to create as a standardized protocol from time to time.
00:35:54 And that means not only the testing itself, but also what happens a little bit before
00:35:57 without it, it becomes too invasive into people's lives, like standardizing what you do the days
00:36:02 before and all these kinds of things. I think this is impractical for most people. If this is a very
00:36:07 important metric for you, like one of the key metrics you use in order to understand how have
00:36:12 the previous period influenced you and you are looking for marginal changes, then it becomes very
00:36:17 important also how you standardize the days before. But I would say for a normal person, I would say that
00:36:22 I would keep a standardized protocol. So I would come in there, let's say at least trying to eat
00:36:27 pretty much the same every time I go there. And that means making sure you are well fueled as if
00:36:32 you were going to do important training session. That means normally more carbohydrates, make sure
00:36:38 you're well hydrated. And obviously also that you are to the extent you can influence it or you can,
00:36:44 you should be able to influence it, but make sure that you also had a proper sleep so you don't come in
00:36:47 like completely tired and things like this. Reasonably well rested, not trained the day
00:36:53 before, would you say, or like training the day before? This is where I would say it's more
00:36:57 important to use your experience and to have enough understanding of what makes you set up for a
00:37:02 good test the day after. So for some people, exercise is irregular and there are more time in
00:37:07 between. Obviously, if you're going to do a little bit harder exercise the day before or anything like
00:37:11 this, you'll come into the session and you even feel sore in the muscles. This is not ideal
00:37:15 necessarily for the ability to mobilize. For the athletes that are well trained, then it's
00:37:20 completely different. Then it's more like, okay, what would I do the day before a competition or
00:37:25 anything like this? It doesn't have to be an elite level, but it's more like you think a little bit
00:37:28 like, what do I want to do in order to make sure that I've gone through the different stuff and I
00:37:32 feel ready for the day after. So on the day of the test itself, one is important, timing of the day.
00:37:37 This is important to try to keep somewhat consistent, I would say, because of the circadian rhythm.
00:37:42 We know that, for example, your temperature levels in your body, this fluctuates. This is maybe one of
00:37:47 the easiest observable differences in a human, basically, as an indirect measure of the circadian
00:37:52 rhythm, where we basically see that you have a minimum point that happens typically in the morning
00:37:56 just before you wake up, and then you have a maximum point typically in the afternoon.
00:38:01 And there is, of course, plenty of research suggesting that aerobic exercises are best done
00:38:07 normally a little bit in the afternoon when you are typically also around the highest
00:38:12 core temperature or natural core temperature. The minimum point is easy to measure. So for
00:38:16 people that has the core, like now it's become very popular, like in the Tour de France and all
00:38:20 the places, triathlons, you see these people, they run around with this little temperature device on
00:38:24 their body. And it's very easy to observe if you use it 24-7. This is very easy to observe,
00:38:29 basically, when your minimum point is. The maximum point is influence, let's say it can be masked
00:38:34 by noise and other activities and other things you do, so it's a little bit harder to see where it is.
00:38:38 But let's say you put them 12 hours apart as a guiding tool. But now I'm already getting to the
00:38:43 point where it gets a little bit, let's say, more detail, but I would just say, keep the timing of
00:38:47 the day the same. So it really doesn't matter if you do it in afternoon or you do it in the morning,
00:38:51 as long as you keep it consistent. Then from there, I would do a proper warmup. That's important.
00:38:57 How long do you think that should be for a person who's like modestly trained? Let's assume we're
00:39:00 not doing this on someone completely untrained, but someone who's recreationally trained versus
00:39:04 relatively elite. So again, here I would do a warmup much in the same way I would do a training
00:39:09 session. So I would normally stick to a standardized warmup protocol where you start out maybe, for
00:39:14 example, six minutes, very easy. This can even be walking. Then I would do, or basically pedaling,
00:39:18 soft pedaling. Then I would do six minutes with a little bit more effort, but it typically should
00:39:23 be more something that you would be comfortable doing as your longest sessions that you do. So if you
00:39:28 are out and you do, I say the longest sessions you do is an hour. Obviously, if they're all out,
00:39:33 then it would be a little bit too hard, but then you should more aim for something I could do for
00:39:36 like, this would be an easy session for me, but I could do it for some while. You could,
00:39:39 for some people say, this is your marathon, let's say pace or where you do more of a longer rides.
00:39:45 And then I would do a short effort around three minutes that sits somewhere where at this time,
00:39:50 I wouldn't look too much on my power meter or my heart rate or anything, but more by feeling
00:39:55 where you feel, okay, this is where my normally where my treasure would be. And then I would probably
00:40:00 also do, let's say a couple of short, short efforts that are, let's say progressively towards
00:40:06 view to max. So let's say one, two, three, maybe two to three efforts that are somewhere between
00:40:11 10, 15 seconds with equal rest in between. And the reason for this is that it's easy to think,
00:40:16 ah, but don't you exhaust yourself now before you do the view to max then? Well, no, you don't.
00:40:21 The little fatigue or let's say the little fatigue that you possibly would induce with this
00:40:25 is easily offset by other factors that will much more contribute to your view to max when you start
00:40:31 doing this. So that means also that after I've done this one, I would just again, go back to very
00:40:35 short, easy efforts. Let's say you get a total warmup of 20 minutes, something like this in
00:40:39 between there, take a toilet break or anything like this, but don't keep this rest too long,
00:40:43 because obviously now you're going to cool down again, if you don't go to your view to max test now.
00:40:47 So that means also like have a small sip of water, something like this, if you want to do that.
00:40:52 Also, before you start your warmup, it can be good things. If you have something
00:40:54 carbohydrate based, you consume a little bit of that. Some people would say, ah,
00:40:59 I don't like this because it could influence. Yeah. It can influence the RQ.
00:41:03 Yeah. But then again, this is something I would say that a sub maximal, yes, maximal,
00:41:07 it won't do that very much because the closer you get to your metabolic steady state or maximal
00:41:12 metabolic steady state and then above basically things start to homogenize. Yeah.
00:41:16 We tend to do these separately now. So we don't use the day of the VO2 max test to do the fuel
00:41:24 partitioning test. So we want to measure fat oxidation on a totally different day. We'll
00:41:28 usually separate by a day even. So you'll do your VO2 max test on Monday and we'll do it this kind
00:41:33 of way where we can agree completely like you should have all the carbs in the world. We actually
00:41:37 like to standardize the fat oxidation test to a fasting test. That way it's just always the same.
00:41:42 You're going to do it in the morning, you're fasted. It's a sub maximal effort. We're not
00:41:46 pushing you to maximum because we're just pushing to see what your maximum fat oxidation is.
00:41:49 This is a good way to open up, let's say a little bit the door to how we, because again,
00:41:54 we are at the edge cases where basically we have to do the research ourselves.
00:41:57 One thing we have to consider is that when we do gas exchange measurements, for example,
00:42:02 to understand a little bit substrate metabolism.
00:42:04 What's your preferred in-lab test? Do you use Parvo?
00:42:07 No, we use a device which is still on all device. There are two devices I like to use.
00:42:13 One is the Jager Oxycon Pro with a mixing chamber and this is important. The Parvo has a mixing
00:42:19 chamber as well, but we have the Oxycon Jager Pro. When I've been testing in the US, for example,
00:42:23 on elite athletes, Olympic athletes, then we have used the Parvo simply because that's the one that
00:42:28 has been here. Europe is more used to Jager. We don't use the, maybe I shouldn't say that,
00:42:33 we don't use the Vintu CPX, which is the successor of Jager Oxycon Pro. This is one of the devices.
00:42:38 We use also the AEI Moxes, but this is more of our, call it for specially interested people.
00:42:45 We use also the Vue to Master actually quite significantly and more and more of the testing
00:42:49 actually have gone over to the Vue to Master. We have been fortunate enough to work with them
00:42:54 for some while. So we have the CO2 version as well, but this is where it has been in alpha mode and it
00:42:59 requires also completely different skills than what you would normally require. But the reason also
00:43:05 why we do that is again, also for one of the reasons you experienced is that you see that
00:43:09 your Vue to Max is maybe a little bit different when you are out and cycling and do the efforts
00:43:12 and it's not inside the laboratory. Because also we have to remember that Vue to Max is on the one
00:43:18 side, we say it's the highest oxygen consumption normally as they normalize over one minute.
00:43:22 That is a wrestle how much muscles that are involved in the work there. So obviously modality
00:43:26 will influence this quite a bit as well.
00:43:29 Which is why I was surprised when you said the guys were lower in swimming than cycling and running,
00:43:33 even though I realized that their efficiency in swimming is relative to the world's best,
00:43:39 less than it is in cycling and running, where they would be closer to the world's elite.
00:43:43 But I would have just thought more muscles would have meant higher O2 consumption.
00:43:47 Let me shed some light on it because that was basically when I started working with Christian
00:43:50 and Gustav. Where they are today is that basically there are virtually no difference between
00:43:54 swimming, cycling, and running.
00:43:55 Same Vue to Max.
00:43:57 More or less on the three disciplines, but it has again to do exactly like you said,
00:44:01 you can manipulate your Vue to Max by that you are targeting, let's say, typically shorter
00:44:05 duration efforts. And so you start recruiting more, learn to recruit a little bit more,
00:44:10 and also train, let's say, fibers that you are not normally used to use so much.
00:44:14 And this is also something that is highly plastic, much more plastic than we ever have thought
00:44:19 it was before. To the point where we have leading researchers in Norway that have solely
00:44:24 focused on Vue to Max. And let's say they went into schools where they've done this for decades,
00:44:28 but where we even sat down and we looked at the data and thought something has to be wrong.
00:44:33 And that comes actually from the period when we switched from Tokyo Olympics and then on to
00:44:37 Ironman. And basically we saw a decline in Vue to Max. For me, not unexpected, but more,
00:44:44 there hasn't been data on this. So it was actually quite nice to measure.
00:44:46 What is the decline? How much?
00:44:48 So the decline in absolute, or let's say in relative Vue to Max, and so it makes more sense
00:44:52 for people, is that Christian and Gustav, typically the highest numbers we have had on them
00:44:57 are very, very high. Highest numbers ever measured in history.
00:45:00 I mean, 90?
00:45:02 Well, Christian, we've had measurements with him actually invalidated, but on him, we have
00:45:08 exceeded in absolute terms 7.7, 7.8 liters per minute in oxygen uptake.
00:45:15 At what, 75 kilos?
00:45:16 No. So at that time he was around 80 kilograms. So just let's say around 100 milliliter per minute
00:45:22 per kilogram in oxygen uptake. So Gustav is a little bit smaller, so he has a little bit
00:45:28 lower oxygen uptake than what Christian have, but he has the highest he clocked in around,
00:45:33 let's say 94 milliliter per minute per kilogram, something like this at the highest. But I would
00:45:37 say that this is not beneficial for what they are doing.
00:45:40 Of course. I think anybody who's done this type of testing and done this kind of work,
00:45:44 they'll have an appreciation for what those numbers mean, which is to say, I'm trying to come up with
00:45:48 an analogy for another sport to explain what that would be. That would sort of be like, I don't know
00:45:54 how to compare it to non-endurance sports. It's like saying in an NBA basketball game, occasionally
00:45:59 they score a hundred points. It doesn't compute. It doesn't really compute that they could utilize
00:46:06 that much oxygen.
00:46:07 Yeah. So the interesting thing there and the good thing about it is that this was something we
00:46:11 reproduced over three months.
00:46:14 But the training at that time was presumably geared specifically towards VO2 maximization.
00:46:19 It was short distance. It was interval based.
00:46:22 Well, actually, yes, it was. But this is also where one place where we resonate a lot. VO2 max
00:46:28 is the single best metric we probably have for anything that is related to human health and performance.
00:46:36 But it is also where we understand that there's a little bit more nuanced than that. I'm not
00:46:40 talking about it as pure as a predictor for your race performance, because that's a different domain.
00:46:44 But where you could also say that you could still be healthier with a little bit lower
00:46:48 VO2 max. And now I'm not talking because about that you put yourself through some stress and
00:46:52 other things like this, so this becomes negative longer term. VO2 max is a one-dimensional
00:46:56 also unit. Again, we talk about something on a y-axis. Yes, we normalize it as a milliliter per
00:47:02 minute. So you could say that it has a second access to it, an x-axis or time access to it as
00:47:06 well. But we don't say how long- Over what duration. We don't get into capacity.
00:47:11 Exactly. And this means also that you can trade off some of your VO2 max. And I would say that
00:47:16 the very, very best predictor is capacity. Capacity is maybe the single best one for everything. But
00:47:22 the problem is that testing for capacity is such a brute force endeavor that it's not practical.
00:47:27 It is really not practical. That's why VO2 max is, I would say, is the single best predictor of
00:47:33 everything measured in a practical way. But for Christian, what was really nice when we did this,
00:47:39 this is not only actually where we measured. And I can say that we are at the edge where there are
00:47:44 things that we don't understand. There are still things we are researching. And like you said,
00:47:49 introductory, I'm in the applied world. And in the applied world means basically much more
00:47:53 experimentation and understanding what happens here with some individuals. My sample size doesn't
00:47:59 come from the population. It comes from the sheer amount of data that I gather on these apps. So
00:48:05 it's not like a single view to max test. It is so many view to max tests that there's probably no
00:48:10 other human in history where there have been true this testing protocols over time, where we can
00:48:15 correlate it to also a range of other metrics as well, both internally, but also external metrics.
00:48:21 And that means that, for example, here, to put this into context, the good thing is that when we do
00:48:26 testing, I normally not only have Christian into the lab, I have also minimum of, let's say,
00:48:30 one or two athletes as well into the lab. And our protocols are quite extensive. So this is also
00:48:35 one thing that we already talked about, that protocols can have an influence on testing. And what you do
00:48:40 before the protocol will have an influence on your V2 max. That's exactly why we're discussing,
00:48:44 should you warm up or should you not warm up? Yes, you should, because it will normally give you,
00:48:48 let's say, a better result when you are warmed up. But that means also that the protocol will also
00:48:53 have, can also then have an influence on your V2 max measurements. And we normally do the V2 max
00:48:58 measurements at the end of our test, which is, you would say, ah, but that's normal. Yes, well,
00:49:03 we also do that simply because it also more normally simulates what they're also going to see
00:49:08 on racing. So normally what happens in racing is that you normally also will go closer to,
00:49:13 let's say, complete exhaustion when you get towards the end of the race. And this is why it's
00:49:17 interesting to test it there. But we don't only test it once, we even repeat it. So we do two
00:49:21 V2 max tests just 10 minutes apart. And even this year, we did even three tests, let's say,
00:49:27 with less or 10 minutes apart as well. Interesting thing here is that what we see is that you normally
00:49:31 don't get your highest V2 max on the first one, even though you're exhausted. We even see that even
00:49:35 on the second one. More interestingly to also to serve here is that then you would think that,
00:49:40 I say, intuitively you can say that, okay, you would maybe also then see a higher carbon
00:49:43 dioxide production as well. You don't. That's actually lowered. That has to, let's say,
00:49:48 call it some priming effects more in general terms. But also what we do see is that there
00:49:53 are some substrates as well that actually do influence on micronutrients also that actually
00:49:57 also can help boost your V2 max as well. Such as?
00:50:01 Long story short, beetroots obviously have been something that people have found quite interesting
00:50:06 over a long time.
00:50:07 Beetroots?
00:50:08 Beetroot, yeah. So they use beetroot concentrates. And the main thinking behind is that when you eat
00:50:13 nitrate, which beetroot is normally rich in, and the body converts this to nitric oxide,
00:50:19 this helps for vasodilation. So vasodilation, you can think of this almost like a plumbing
00:50:23 in our body. We already said that from our previous conversation that basically cellular respiration
00:50:28 is not the limitation to UVU to max. So there are other things that are limiting factor.
00:50:32 That means also that, for example, your cardiovascular system, meaning also actually your ability to
00:50:38 transport blood around in your body is going to be important. For example, one of the reasons
00:50:42 why when you then use some supplements that are highly enriched in nitrate, so you get
00:50:50 a nitric oxide boost, is that this was actually, it's almost like plumbing. You're opening up
00:50:55 the plumbing and it allows your blood to circulate faster throughout your body. This is hard to
00:50:59 reproduce in elite athletes. Like in amateur athletes, we normally see that this has a positive
00:51:03 effect.
00:51:03 How much of an effect? 5%? Something measurable?
00:51:07 Let's say something like that, and then take that with a grain of salt.
00:51:10 These are not people that are out there literally eating endless beetroots you could
00:51:13 buy as a supplement.
00:51:14 Yeah, concentrate.
00:51:15 Now, would it be anything that increases nitric oxide?
00:51:18 So that's the thing, because one thing that we don't see this, we don't see these effects in
00:51:22 elites, for example. And this is obviously one of the benefits when we do more longitudinal
00:51:27 studies with such, let's say, granularity and in-depth measurements we do.
00:51:31 And one of the things we see there is that when they use beetroot concentrate, nitrates
00:51:36 are considered an ergogenic aid. When you do all these measurements, you leave out the
00:51:41 guesswork and we see, well, over all the testing we do, we have not seen a real effect out of
00:51:47 this, at least not on VU2max, maybe other places, but it doesn't seem to have any effect
00:51:50 on VU2max.
00:51:51 Because they're already optimized in that regard.
00:51:53 Probably, or maybe there are other limiting factors instead. We were approached by a company
00:51:58 that is called Plasmaid, and they actually focus more on the other part of it. Let's
00:52:02 say the catalyst that actually help, because you have to convert nitrate into nitric oxide.
00:52:07 And there's a cost to this. So what they did instead is that they made from pine bark extracts
00:52:12 instead, they made adaptogen, or they extract an adaptogen that helps catalyze this process.
00:52:17 And the interesting thing with this adaptogen is that, again, now we are a place we can just
00:52:22 look at the observations and repeated observations over time, and we can't necessarily explain
00:52:27 100% yet, so it becomes more speculations. But from those, what we can only speculate
00:52:32 or hypothesize is that what happens here when they use this Plasmaid is that, I remember
00:52:38 when we got this first presented, I was thinking like, okay, we've tested nitric oxide or nitrate.
00:52:44 It really didn't give any help, so why should this really give a help, or basically make a
00:52:48 difference? The interesting thing is that Christian and Gustav were quite positive, so they said,
00:52:52 okay, fine, we're going to use this. We were just going to test it. We had a bunch of them
00:52:56 laying around there, and they said, okay, let's try it. I said, okay, fine. Gustav was the first
00:53:00 one to say immediately that he felt it did something with his respiration. Also, it's a little bit the
00:53:06 placebo as well, like, okay, how much of this is placebo? How much of this is real? You get something
00:53:10 new and say, oh, looking for something in your body. And Christian also, but he observed a little bit
00:53:15 like a different effect to him. He felt more like he normally felt quicker ready for the next effort
00:53:22 using this. But I would say that these record measurements that we did came in the tail of
00:53:27 when we started using this. And that was a little bit of shock because what we also saw at the same
00:53:32 time was that the efficiency, so the biochemical efficiency in the body also went down. The
00:53:36 interesting thing was the RQ was heavily, on the CO2 side, was slightly reduced. The VO2 were heavily
00:53:43 increased. Tell folks what RQ is and what the reduction would imply. At the end, normally you
00:53:48 would say that for a VO2 max test to be valid, one of the criteria is that you should meet 1.1
00:53:53 in RQ. Meaning you have 10% more production of CO2 than consumption of oxygen. Yes. In elite
00:54:00 athletes, this is sometimes hard. In the best trained elite athletes, bringing them to 1.1 during
00:54:06 the test can actually be quite challenging. So if you have a short warmup protocol, they are not well
00:54:10 warmed up and all these kind of things, then you would easily be able to exceed this. But if you
00:54:14 do it more in a simulation like we did, or you have longer protocols before, you normally see that
00:54:18 this is a little bit suppressed. So let's say that Christian normally on a VO2 max test, or let's say
00:54:22 at the end of the VO2 max effort, he would basically click in at, let's say, 1.05. Then after we started
00:54:28 using these supplements, we could see suddenly not 1.03 or 1.02. We basically dropped it by 10 points.
00:54:35 So basically to 0.95 instead. Preserving the VO2. No. CO2 was basically not as much changed.
00:54:42 So the VO2 was increasing. Yes. So VO2 went up quite a bit. The good thing here is that now I
00:54:48 have two other athletes obviously in the lab at the same time. So I have one athlete that comes
00:54:51 in before Christian. So I already do dynamic calibration of the machines before. We also
00:54:56 have a lung simulator just because we are working with edge cases. So we need to independently validate
00:55:00 the machines as well. So this means basically we have a large gas tank with a reference gas beyond
00:55:05 what is used for just the calibration. But we have a separate system where basically we have a lung
00:55:09 simulator where we feed in, for example, six liters of oxygen, six liters of CO2, and we know this is
00:55:14 the exact amount in the bottle, gravimetrically calibrated. And then if we don't get this out of
00:55:18 the machine, then there's something wrong with the machine independently of the calibration.
00:55:22 But the good thing here is that despite this, first athlete in, numbers are where you expect them to be
00:55:27 based on the training we did before. Christian comes in, you start to see some numbers that
00:55:31 are crazy and you start, did I do something wrong here in the calibration process or anything like
00:55:35 this? But then also when you validate it afterwards as well, you basically know this is, the numbers
00:55:40 are good. And then this we did then over, this was in December, January, and February over nine tests,
00:55:46 more or less. We saw a little bit over time that actually VU2Max started to come down a little bit
00:55:50 because what this indicated also was that his biochemical efficiency was not optimal either. What that
00:55:57 means again is that if you look at basically his oxygen consumption versus his power, so the power,
00:56:03 power was higher as well, but the ratio was not the same as it was before. VU2 had gone up much more
00:56:09 than the power, enough. Suggesting efficiency is going down. Yes, efficiency is going down. And this
00:56:15 was then efficiency going down, well, can we somehow get an understanding of this? And this is, of course,
00:56:21 on this test, they actually are using a temperature pill. So we put a pill up their ass. 1.00
00:56:24 And also at the same time, we have multiple of core sensors around in the body to also measure 0.99
00:56:29 the temperature of the body as well. And where we basically see the same thing. We basically see an
00:56:33 increased heat production for the same power output, basically indicating the same. You can
00:56:38 basically think of that. The reason why you have gas exchanges is because we call this indirect
00:56:41 calamity. It's not useful oxygen. It's actually the worst thing you could possibly have because
00:56:46 you're also utilizing more fuel. So now you've created a scenario where for the same amount of power,
00:56:51 not just you need more oxygen. Oxygen is free. You're going to need more glucose.
00:56:56 Well, actually not more glucose because since the RQ here is basically also now in favor,
00:57:01 you actually are able to oxidize more fats. Oh, that's interesting. Yeah. So you're saying
00:57:07 because the RQ came in the same, you're going to hold carbohydrate metabolism constant and you're
00:57:13 actually increasing fat oxidation. Yes.
00:57:16 And that works out perfectly in the stoichiometry?
00:57:18 Pretty close. It's counterintuitive.
00:57:22 This is a rabbit hole I would like to go down into, but-
00:57:24 We'll delve gently. We'll delve very gently for the four people that are still listening to this.
00:57:28 Yeah. Because also the difficulty with this is that if you just look up purely the RQ of where
00:57:33 basically the threshold sits as well for elite athletes or for any athlete that you have in the
00:57:37 laboratory. From some literature, you would just say, okay, if you have an RQ, let's say around
00:57:40 talking about thresholds, you'll find several places in research literature where they basically just
00:57:45 use an RQ of 0.96 as a proxy for your anaerobic threshold, for example. But this is something
00:57:51 that you also see is differing. If you basically take an athlete in a training for short course or
00:57:55 basically for sprinting, you will basically see that then basically you will have an RQ that is
00:57:58 higher than 0.96. If you go to extreme endurance athletes, this actually gets closer to 0.94,
00:58:04 93, 92 even. So the implication of this is that if you then measure the lactate threshold,
00:58:09 you will actually come into a zone already at 0.92, 0.93, where you actually are starting just
00:58:14 as a function of time now, you will get a higher lactate concentration in your body.
00:58:18 And if you take that lactate concentration now and you calculate the volume of lactate that is
00:58:23 available in your body, you'll actually see that the volume of lactate now becomes a significant
00:58:27 contributor to actually your energy production. But you have to know plasma volume pretty well to make
00:58:33 that calculation, right? Yes. So plasma volume, but this is a good thing. We have our own machine
00:58:37 for measuring carbon monoxide rebreather. So we do regularly also testing of basically their blood
00:58:43 volume, plasma volume, and hemoglobin mass as well when we do this testing as well. And of course,
00:58:48 you want to know also something about the water content in the body as well. There are different
00:58:52 ways. The gold standard is probably double label water, and we've done this as well. But the point is
00:58:57 that to give you an example, you can easily at 0.92, 0.93, go from, let's say, if you consider
00:59:04 normal lactate levels, or let's say, if we then take it into volumes, it would mean that the energy
00:59:09 contribution from lactate could be, for example, five. But if you just stay long enough there,
00:59:14 basically, you would say that, okay, if these were the levels, you're talking about now 13%, 14%
00:59:19 energy contribution from lactate. And the problem with this is that all the tables we have today,
00:59:23 which basically look as a ratio where you use RQ to say something about the ratio between
00:59:27 carbohydrates and fats, we normally say that, well, this is good up to an RER of one, but above one,
00:59:33 we don't do it anymore, because exactly lactate and other things becomes a too large contributor to
00:59:37 it. So this already tells us that we have to be also cautious when we look at RQ and just go
00:59:43 crudely into a table and just say, okay, this is your fat metabolism, this is your carbohydrate
00:59:47 metabolism, because it is... Do you feel we can do that safely up to one?
00:59:51 No. Not even? No, no, no, no. Not even. I would say that for elite athletes,
00:59:55 if you're an endurance athlete, I would already start to be skeptical around in the low 90s.
01:00:00 Hmm. Very interesting. Sorry, one other question there. What RQ are you typically seeing for maximum
01:00:07 fat oxidation? Not obviously percent of fat oxidation, which is low, but in absolute grams per
01:00:13 minute, max fat oxidation at an elite athlete who's on a high carb diet, you're typically seeing that at
01:00:20 what RQ? That's a longer time since I basically really paid a lot of attention to that.
01:00:26 Because I would have to imagine that that corresponds very closely to their race pace.
01:00:32 No, because here it also gets a little bit more complicated simply because one of the things we
01:00:36 do, because we also do isotope tracing also of substrates as well. We've used quite a lot of carbon
01:00:42 13 or 13 carbon over the last years. And we added that as a tracer to glucose and fructose,
01:00:47 for example, to look at how much of the exogenous carbohydrates, to use a more common term, how much
01:00:53 of the carbohydrates that you ingest that you're able to utilize. Because obviously you have-
01:00:57 You have your own glycogen and your own fatty acid.
01:00:59 Yeah. And then you want to understand how much- And this is also where exactly when you look at
01:01:04 even VO2 max, this starts also to become where you understand that in our context, this is a little
01:01:10 bit of less valuable, less valuable purely. Because if you took Christian, for example, or Gustav, and
01:01:17 you test it just before race. So you did exactly the protocol we just talked about. You did the
01:01:22 step-toe warm-up, a short effort just to make your body ready. Then you did a great exercise test to
01:01:27 VO2 max. Okay, fine. You went out, you did your racing. And then basically at the moment you come over
01:01:32 the finish line, you test this again, or even half an hour afterwards. It would matter a little bit,
01:01:37 but not that much. You will basically see the race pace is actually now coming to the point where it's
01:01:41 extremely close. You like your utilization from the beginning of the race to the end of the race
01:01:45 have completely changed, significantly changed. Sorry, you're saying fuel utilization?
01:01:50 Yes. Not only your fuel utilization, but also actually would also imply fuel utilization,
01:01:55 but also your threshold sits now so much closer to, yeah, yeah.
01:01:59 This is hilarious. It was about an hour ago that we got off onto this tangent in response to what you
01:02:05 said, which was at the most elite level, their race pace is above 90% of their VO2 max.
01:02:13 For elite marathoners, yes. And also for Christian and Gustav, when they do Ironman racing, this is
01:02:18 getting, let's say, in those domains. We can't push it all the way because it has some implications.
01:02:22 Again, this is just impossible for me to wrap my head around. This means that someone whose VO2 max is
01:02:28 five liters per minute, if they're elite, which means they're obviously pretty light,
01:02:33 they're going to spend an entire Ironman at 4.5 liters per minute. 0.98
01:02:39 No. The thing is that what will happen here is that this will actually come down. So your VO2 max
01:02:43 that they don't have-
01:02:44 Ah, the VO2 max is declining and therefore it's, okay, that's what I wanted to make sure of because
01:02:48 I was like, how in the hell can they hold 4.5 liters per minute? Or in their case, 7.2 liters per minute.
01:02:54 So this is the difference. This is the interesting thing because this is the difference. The
01:02:58 consequence of aiming for Ironman is that you want to have minimal decline in this.
01:03:02 Yes. And you need a lower VO2 max.
01:03:04 Because it has to do with priority and training. You can't prioritize having like a high one minute
01:03:09 power or five minute power simply because it's too far away from specificity of what you really need
01:03:14 there. So if you start building good sessions with where you basically are looking to increase your
01:03:18 one minute power, five minute power, that's obviously going to have a cost for the whole week that
01:03:22 you are doing of training. So let's talk about that now in the context of the Olympics. So you talk
01:03:27 about an athlete like Christian or Gustav where in theory, they want to be able to go between three
01:03:32 distances in theory, Olympic distance, half Ironman, Ironman. Yes. Let's remind people what the
01:03:39 distance is. Olympic is 1.5 kilometer swim, 40 kilometer bike, 10 kilometer run. Elites are doing
01:03:47 this in an hour 45 ish. Yeah. Okay. Half Ironman. Well, let's just do Ironman. 2.4 mile swim. So
01:03:55 4K swim. 3.8K. Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. 112 bike. So 180K bike marathon run 42K. The best in the world
01:04:05 are doing this in seven ish, seven and a half. What are they doing it in? Christian is the record holder
01:04:11 still. He actually did that on his debut and it still stands. What was the time? Seven? 7.21.
01:04:16 Seven and a half to eight hours. And then half Ironman is you take one of those last distances
01:04:20 and you cut it in half. So just under two kilometer swim, 90K bike and call it a 21K run.
01:04:27 So roughly twice the Olympic distance in some regards, less in others. And again, they're doing
01:04:32 this in three and a half hours. So these are three very different events. Is it possible to be elite
01:04:40 in all of them? This is also quite interesting because one of the main differences I would say
01:04:45 that differs them, call them as, or compared to the specialists in the sports is actually not
01:04:51 their metabolism. If you look at their view to max on running, cycling, and swimming, you will actually
01:04:58 see that there are equally or higher than their peers in those sports. But their efficiency is
01:05:03 not the same. This comes probably most down to the fact that they have to do three different sports.
01:05:09 You don't get the same time of just pure stimulus, mechanical stimulus from doing something and
01:05:14 optimizing it because you have to change. And it also has some priorities also as well. In running,
01:05:19 you could say you don't want to compromise on your leg stiffness at all. In cycling, this is a little
01:05:23 bit more beneficial to do this, for example. So here you have to strike a balance between the three.
01:05:27 Which makes it very complex. But in swimming, they are higher than the highest view to max that
01:05:33 are measured on elite swimmers in the world. But the difference is also I had the bronze medalist.
01:05:36 The efficiency is unbelievable.
01:05:37 It is so poor. It is so poor. It's actually funny. I think we talked about this last time. I had one of
01:05:44 the best swimmers in the world in the flume and tested him. And he's a big guy, 195, 100 kilograms,
01:05:50 close to 100 kilograms, muscles all over. And then Christian into the flume at the same, 0.99
01:05:55 basically same velocity. I don't remember exactly what this velocity is now, but basically this big
01:06:00 guy. And the flume is an endless pool?
01:06:03 Yes.
01:06:03 It's a stationary swimming pool?
01:06:05 The difference here is that endless pool, very often people think of it as a counter current,
01:06:09 where there's a lot of turbulence. Here we are talking about something which is virtually
01:06:13 laminar flow that goes through. So it's a big canal, which is circulating the water on the outside,
01:06:17 and it comes back in the front. And you have even honeycomb structures in the front and the back.
01:06:21 So it truly replicates swimming stationary. So it's the closest thing we have to an aerotunnel
01:06:26 for swimming.
01:06:26 Same. Yeah.
01:06:27 Yeah.
01:06:27 Does it allow you to use dye in the water or anything like that? Bubbles, I assume you use to-
01:06:32 You can, yeah. Yeah. The thing here is that when you look at these two guys now swimming-
01:06:37 So you put them at the same speed?
01:06:38 Same speed.
01:06:39 Okay.
01:06:39 The lead swimmer, he is even retired. First of all, Christian, eight kilograms, this guy,
01:06:44 close to 100 kilograms. And that's not because of fat. He is lean. He is well-trained still.
01:06:50 All things equal, he should be much higher in his VO2 at that moment in time. He's simply
01:06:54 supporting more muscle.
01:06:55 Much more muscles involved and bigger proportions. He's utilizing 25% less oxygen than Christian. 0.84
01:07:01 In an absolute term.
01:07:02 In absolute terms, yeah.
01:07:03 On a relative basis, a third less oxygen.
01:07:06 Yeah. Which is still crazy. Yeah.
01:07:09 Here's my thesis on swimming. Of all the three big endurance sports, I feel like swimming has the
01:07:15 most potential for radical change in performance based on drag avoidance. All of these sports,
01:07:23 but especially swimming and cycling, come down to propulsion versus drag. Running is less so because
01:07:29 these speeds aren't high enough relative to air. Obviously, swimming, just so people listening
01:07:33 understand why I would say that, swimming is much slower than running, but the density of water is,
01:07:37 what is it, 1,300 times that of air. So you don't need a high V squared to get a lot of drag just
01:07:43 based on the density of the medium you're in, which is water. So in that sense, cycling and
01:07:48 especially swimming really come down to this ability to avoid drag. And that's why in a time
01:07:52 trial, position matters so much on a bike and how can you generate power, even if you have to
01:07:56 compromise your power there. So I feel like in swimming, there could be like a massive breakthrough
01:08:02 if a technique emerged that reduced output or power or forward propulsion by 10%, but reduced drag by
01:08:10 20%. You know what I mean? Again, I'm so far from the sport, I don't know. But to me, I would really
01:08:17 be curious as to that. Because again, remember, this happened in cycling in the 80s, where prior to
01:08:23 that, nobody was paying attention to bike position. And then Francesco Moser comes along in 1984,
01:08:28 smashes the one-hour record with all this crazy aero equipment. And then of course, you got into
01:08:34 Boardman and all these guys getting into more and more crazy aero positions where their actual power
01:08:38 went down relative to what they could have been in a less kinked position. But of course, 0.72
01:08:43 their speed went up because the CDA goes down. And I just wonder, do you ever think about that in
01:08:47 swimming? Is there some major disruption where we just have this dramatic change in technique
01:08:53 to have a bigger positive impact on frontal surface area than the negative effect it might have on
01:09:00 propulsion? Yeah. So this then touches up on one of my favorite areas and that's biofeedback.
01:09:07 In cycling, we have extremely good tools for biofeedback today. You have a power meter
01:09:11 and you have a GPS. So just these two combined, for example- Speed and power perfectly.
01:09:15 Yes. Like we talked about last time when you were out riding 200 watts constant,
01:09:19 and basically you see you're getting faster. So you have this direct biofeedback because
01:09:23 as long as you ride enough, you will basically start to get a very good feeling for when you sit
01:09:28 at a certain power and you start doing different things. Suddenly you creep up like half a kilometer
01:09:32 power or what? Like for a person, when they start cycling or they're cycling a little bit like,
01:09:36 for them, it doesn't become interesting enough yet because there are other things that is basically
01:09:40 more challenging for them to master. But for people that do a lot of biking like yourself,
01:09:45 it's where you exactly start to pay attention to those, let's say even half a kilometer per hour,
01:09:50 maybe even you're getting below that as well, where you start to really pay attention to this.
01:09:54 And then over time, simply because wind and other factors makes a difference too.
01:09:58 Running, this is also a place where we have really good biofeedback tools. You have your watch,
01:10:02 you're running and you can have a look at it. And now we have also really good power meters in
01:10:06 running as well. How does that work?
01:10:07 So most of these, there are some of these power meters in running today that requires an insole.
01:10:12 So you put basically an insole inside and it measured the forces.
01:10:14 So it's a force plate inside your shoe.
01:10:16 Yes. And then you have other ones that are more motion capture devices. So they basically,
01:10:21 you rather input your body weight. And since when you're touching on the ground with one foot,
01:10:25 you're basically carrying your whole weight there. So as long as you have a good enough motion
01:10:29 capture device that are capable of capture the three-dimensional accelerations,
01:10:34 you can then basically also say some, well, you know, the force because you basically have to
01:10:37 carry your weight.
01:10:39 So you can directly measure this with a force plate insole, or you could indirectly do it
01:10:43 with motion capture. But I assume the motion capture only works on a treadmill.
01:10:46 No. So the motion captures today, they are, it becomes so small. They're basically a small
01:10:50 device that you attach to a shoe and they are, when we validate these.
01:10:53 Are these commercially available products?
01:10:54 Yes.
01:10:54 Yes. If you go to a laboratory and you basically test this, you will basically see that. So we
01:11:00 have been for a long time in working together with Stride. I started working with them when
01:11:04 they were in beta stage and we've gone through there, but they are so accurate today that when
01:11:08 you measure on an athlete.
01:11:11 First of all, do you have any idea how much you just ruined my wife's life? 0.96
01:11:14 Like, do you have any, so how many minutes do you think after this podcast, am I going to be
01:11:20 on my computer ordering these devices, jamming them on her shoes? You know, she's running the 0.99
01:11:25 Boston marathon next year and I'm convinced she's actually going to run it faster than she did her 0.56
01:11:30 first Boston marathon 20 years ago. Cause she actually now works with a running coach and her 0.92
01:11:35 qualifying time this year was only one minute slower than her qualifying time 19 years earlier.
01:11:41 And again, it's just because she's more structured in her training, not because she listens to a word
01:11:46 I say she doesn't, but she's like finally at least agreeing to use heart rate and velocity
01:11:52 for tempo training. She's not listening to this podcast. Obviously one of her friends will
01:11:55 probably hear this and tell her to listen, but we're going to implement power training for her 1.00
01:11:59 running and she's going to curse me all day long because she doesn't want data. But how is every
01:12:04 runner not doing this? I think this has to do with a lot with tradition. And also that even when
01:12:09 power meters were introduced, it's easy to look back and say like, why didn't we have this before?
01:12:13 Or even how power, there's so much information we can extract from a single power meter today,
01:12:18 which is, I say, beyond people's comprehension. Still, we only use the power number that is there
01:12:23 and we use it even in a one dimensional context, FTP, for example, or critical power.
01:12:28 The amount of information you can get out of this is crazy because we are not going to talk about
01:12:32 this today. We still kind of use normalized power and other... No.
01:12:37 We never use it? No. We only go by raw numbers.
01:12:39 I only work by raw numbers all the time. So I don't condense it down to a single metric. I use
01:12:44 only raw numbers. But the implication here is that even when you look at studies that are looking at
01:12:48 gross efficiency, for example, in the old days, or even today, one thing you consider is a net
01:12:53 mechanical power. So the interface between basically looking at your gross efficiency
01:12:56 is where you take VO2 and we're already there. Most people understand that, okay, you have a difference
01:13:01 between net oxygen consumption and gross oxygen consumption. You would ideally like to have the net
01:13:06 oxygen consumption. There are other things there. But in cycling, actually, also what we only consider
01:13:10 there is the net mechanical power. You don't consider the gross mechanical power. On your
01:13:15 biochemical efficiency, you should not look at the net mechanical power. You should look at the gross
01:13:19 mechanical power. But that's even before we start to get into vectors, power vectors, force vectors,
01:13:23 and other things, even in a three dimensional plane as you do cycling. Because this is something we
01:13:27 can extract from the power meters today.
01:13:29 So when running, you have more degrees of freedom. There's more inefficiency. There's
01:13:34 probably a lower relationship, a more strained relationship between gross and net power.
01:13:40 This is maybe one of the reasons for why it is not as widely adopted in running as it is in cycling,
01:13:46 because it is still debated what really is running power. How do you really quantify it? And this is
01:13:51 something that I even discussed with the team at Stride. So when we are having our regular calls and we
01:13:56 are diving into the topic, even we also sometime have our different opinions on how this really
01:14:02 should be looked at. Because if you want to translate this into running, then you have to
01:14:06 look at only at the propulsive power. Could you imagine seeing this? Have they put these in Olympic
01:14:11 sprinters? The power numbers there? No. Commercially available, this has its limitations. Because since
01:14:15 you do motion capture, you need to do a little bit of filtering. You can't take out because it's going
01:14:20 to be so much noise. Exactly because as you said, you have so many degrees of freedom. If you're going to
01:14:24 output all the vectors that basically you were able to measure with strain gauge-based power meters on
01:14:29 a bike today, people wouldn't be able to utilize. That's why you condense it down to a single number
01:14:33 that is there for most people. If you had that force plate chip in the insole, you could at least
01:14:38 capture force normalized to weight with each step, right? Yes. So what you can do, and this is
01:14:44 validated. So if you, for example, run on a track, a track which has force plates, or you run on
01:14:49 specialized treadmills that has force plates integrated in them, you will basically see that the curves are
01:14:53 the same. So this is the way, let's say, this is the external validation of the device is good, both in terms
01:14:58 of that it captures the force curves, but also here, when you have motion capture devices, you can also
01:15:02 capture the footpath as well. So this is something we can visualize in 3D today, after the event, when you
01:15:07 are doing running. We can see what happened there, fresh, fatigued, throughout the race, when it's technical
01:15:12 and other things. But I think the reason why this is not as widely adopted is because in science, this is still
01:15:18 debated on how do we really capture and quantify mechanical power for running. Stride have taken a
01:15:25 smart approach to this, to make it commercially viable, and that is that they output it as a
01:15:30 metabolic power. So if you actually went on a treadmill, and you went running, and you looked
01:15:34 at it versus your oxygen consumption, you will basically see that this matches perfectly with
01:15:38 cycling. That's without having a bicycle near you at all. So you can say that, well, this is what you
01:15:42 expect. So when you have a certain power, then this would have a certain metabolic cost.
01:15:45 I don't like it because I don't like modeled numbers. I want to have raw numbers. So in my case,
01:15:52 I'm extracting the net and the gross mechanical power, or the positive and the negative mechanical
01:15:56 power, because these are the components I want to have, because I have VO2 master, I have metabolic
01:16:00 devices. I don't need a metabolic equivalent. I want to have the raw because I'm using as an interface
01:16:06 to gauge the difference. Like for example, on a Formula One car, what really matters in the end there,
01:16:11 how fast can you go around the track for the full event with a certain amount of fuel? Because
01:16:15 there's a limitation to how much fuel you can have in your car. That's the true input and the true
01:16:19 output. Your engine output and this kind of thing is actually secondary. It's easy to think,
01:16:23 oh, we won't have the biggest engine, but big engine without efficiency is still bad. The engine,
01:16:28 it becomes more of a device to measure. Let's say you look at the power and you look at how efficiently
01:16:32 are you able to translate this fuel out into speed over, let's say, the event or velocity.
01:16:38 For me, having access to the net mechanical power and gross mechanical power, and then you have the
01:16:42 metabolic devices, this allow me to, on the one side, look at when we change something in running.
01:16:46 So let's say you change, for example, your shoes, or you change your training. You can now have a much
01:16:52 more granular understanding of, am I influencing the biomechanical part of the training, or is it
01:16:56 the biochemical part of the training? But in order to do so, you have to have that interface that
01:17:00 distinguishes between gross mechanical power and net mechanical power. And the interface between gross
01:17:05 mechanical power and net mechanical power is only the, let's say, work efficiency. How efficient are you
01:17:10 working, but not metabolizing or moving? Because in the end, you have to take this power and be able
01:17:15 to output into velocity. If you're looking at a cyclist, for example, can you make a statement
01:17:20 using something so simple? So if you had 10 different cyclists and you did a VO2 max test on all of them,
01:17:26 and each of them, you end up getting a number, which is going to be, let's normalize it to weight.
01:17:31 So you line them up in rank order from the lowest to the highest in milliliters per minute per kilogram.
01:17:37 And then you look at what power they were at when they achieved that VO2 max, and you normalize that
01:17:43 to weight to watts per kilogram. It's not going to be a one-to-one match.
01:17:48 The interesting thing is that when you are getting close to VO2 max, then it's getting close to a
01:17:52 one-to-one match actually. But a submaximal, it doesn't. A submaximal you will normally see in
01:17:56 running simply because it's a weight bearing sport. Just to make sure I understand that, are you saying
01:18:00 that the rank order will be identical for VO2 max and watts per kilo at VO2 max in cycling?
01:18:08 In running and cycling at maximal effort, so basically at VO2 max, pretty much the same, yeah.
01:18:13 But I feel like my personal power at VO2 max is lower than many other people's at a comparable VO2 max.
01:18:21 Like, I just feel like I'm very inefficient. I have a higher VO2 max than a PVO2 max,
01:18:26 if that makes sense. Yeah. And that's because probably there is a lot of anaerobic contribution
01:18:30 in there as well that basically supplies that gap that you're observing there too.
01:18:34 Oh, you're saying I'm anaerobically not trained enough and that's why my power, yeah, yeah. I'm
01:18:40 too aerobic, not anaerobic enough. Yeah.
01:18:42 Great point. That's a very interesting point.
01:18:44 So the thing here is for Christian Gustav obviously being, or we're trying to keep exactly the training
01:18:49 as balanced as possible between the three sports, there you will normally see at maximal efforts
01:18:53 that actually that the power also is pretty much the same. The mechanical power is pretty much
01:18:57 at VO2 max, but as you go at submaximal effort, then that's where you start to observe the big
01:19:01 differences. Because in cycling, you would see that as you go down in intensity, basically because
01:19:09 of the weight-bearing sport, going from 15 to 16 kilometers power, let's say 17, 18, 19, 20,
01:19:16 and so on, basically what you see, but this is also observable exactly from a metabolic heart as
01:19:20 well. And that is when you go at, let's say, a low intensity, you will see that your oxygen
01:19:23 consumption also is higher at the perceived lower intensity in running than it is in cycling.
01:19:28 Because cycling is not weight-bearing, so it's easy to go down to a very low intensity. Still
01:19:32 keep a normal cadence because you can keep a cadence of 80, 90, for example, and it feels
01:19:38 comfortable. Feels comfortable and easy in this kind of way. But going down to those cadences
01:19:41 in running is impractical because it means walking. You're not running anymore, so you're walking.
01:19:45 So the modality is changing more in running. What kind of muscles are involved are changing more
01:19:49 in running than it does in cycling. Coming back to the question, original question of
01:19:53 why isn't this more useless in running, it is gradually getting more and more attention there,
01:19:57 more and more people using it. I think what is still to be determined is to agree on, let's say,
01:20:04 a common standard for what numbers should be outputted. In cycling, one could ask the question,
01:20:10 so when the guys are on the bike, are they paying more attention? So let's just talk about them doing
01:20:15 a four-hour ride in an Ironman. Are they more concerned, because you're triangulating between
01:20:20 RPE, heart rate, and power. How are they prioritizing those things? How they feel,
01:20:26 what the heart rate is, and what the power meter says. How are they regulating effort based on those
01:20:31 things in a race? In training or racing?
01:20:33 Race.
01:20:34 In racing, I would say that training, we use also many more sensors, and then we limit it a little bit
01:20:39 more in racing simply because it's not practical to do it there. But I would say that this is also a
01:20:43 very interesting topic because then they touch a little bit more on psychology, but we'll come
01:20:47 back to that another time. But in racing, obviously, first and foremost, Ironman racing is so long.
01:20:52 It's so long. And with all this practice, you shouldn't be slave to the numbers, for sure,
01:20:57 because you can have suddenly your hero day where you just are able to go faster than what you
01:21:00 normally do. So you need to listen to your body. So I would maybe say that RPE is the most important
01:21:05 one in some senses. Or RPE is also a place where you can also talk about one dimension,
01:21:09 two dimensions, because RPE is normally, let's say if you take Kipchoge, when he did a two-hour
01:21:14 marathon, sub-two-hour marathon, if you put him on a treadmill and you did a normal step test on him
01:21:19 and you asked him when he was at 21 kilometers per hour and you asked him, how does this feel? He
01:21:23 would say, for the sake of the discussion, we say that seven is a round threshold or anaerobic
01:21:27 threshold. If you relate to FTP, something you would be able to hold around an hour for well-trained
01:21:32 athletes. Or what you would test for when you did a 20-millimeter protocol and then you
01:21:36 subtract the 5% to extrapolate it to that. If you asked him a 21-kilometer power, okay,
01:21:40 how do you feel here? And he gives you an RPE score. He would maybe say, ah, this feels like a
01:21:43 six when he has a 21-kilometer power or actually slightly above. If you ask him at the end of a
01:21:48 marathon, how do you feel? And he's still running the same pace. He would say probably 10. This is a
01:21:52 nine to a 10. Because we forget, again, there's a dimension and that is a duration. Let's say the
01:21:56 fatigue component that comes in there. And that's why it also helps sometimes to ask, I would say that
01:22:01 when I ask Christian Gustav or at least- But also his heart rate might be different there too.
01:22:04 When you throw him on for a minute at 21 kph and he says RPE 6, his heart rate's probably a lot lower
01:22:11 than it would be two hours later at that pace, right? But that brings us back a little bit also
01:22:16 to exactly utilization as well. Because one of the things that you would probably not be able to do,
01:22:21 you won't be able to get yourself up to a maximum heart rate at the end of a race even. So your max
01:22:25 heart rate, you could say in many ways are limited at this time. But this is also when you then say,
01:22:30 okay, but how on earth is it possible to ride at 4.5 liters when you have a five-liter view to max?
01:22:36 This is the key, obviously, in endurance sport. You want to increase this robustness.
01:22:40 So when you are finding this optimum of between of where should my view to max is,
01:22:44 this is what happens with specificity. If you're tuning this down, exactly where you start and
01:22:49 where you end becomes far less. And there's a whole range of implications to this because it comes down
01:22:56 to why is this important? Couldn't you just have a higher view to max coming into the race and just
01:23:00 have a higher view to max? Well, the problem with that is that the heart also is a muscle and it's
01:23:05 not very efficient muscle. So even the heart has energy. It's not insignificant. It's actually a
01:23:10 significant energy consumption as well. And if you have a heart that actually is trained for something
01:23:14 different than what you really need, it means basically also your heart is going to use energy
01:23:18 more inefficiently. How much lactate does the heart generate?
01:23:21 Probably you are better suited to answering this. I probably read it sometime, but I've never done any
01:23:25 research on that. I looked more at, let's say, when we broke down the body into components,
01:23:30 it's more like where I looked at it basically is energy consumption.
01:23:33 What's the mitochondrial density of cardiac muscle versus skeletal muscle? I mean,
01:23:37 they're both similar in some ways. They're striated muscles. I should know that. I mean,
01:23:41 your intuition would be it has to be very rich in mitochondria, right?
01:23:44 Yes. And then that's also why the heart obviously uses lactate also as a fuel source simply because
01:23:50 it is probably full of... I've never done a muscle biopsy of the heart itself. It would be
01:23:55 interesting just to see what's the ratio between type 1 and type 2 fibers there, but I would almost
01:24:00 imagine this is probably one of the muscles where you are as close as possible to...
01:24:04 Just to pure type 1.
01:24:05 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:24:05 Yeah, yeah. And I learned recently in the podcast with George Brooks that we can actually shuttle
01:24:10 lactate into the mitochondria for oxidative phosphorylation. I was completely unaware of that.
01:24:15 That would explain, of course, why the heart could richly use lactate.
01:24:19 Yes. And this also comes down to Mikael's constant, where you also look at the affinity for different
01:24:25 substrates, also for different muscles as well. And where lactate has the highest affinity for most
01:24:30 of these muscles as well, especially like the heart. But if you're going to bring this back up,
01:24:35 a lot of the research when you do apply research like we do, a lot of the times we can't actually
01:24:41 use a lot of the research that is there to base our decisions on. I don't know if we talked about
01:24:46 monocarboloxate transporters last time or not, but one of the things that is there is that this is
01:24:51 also a place where if you want to understand something, you can go in and you can do a
01:24:55 concentration measurement. The problem very often with research is that we get a partial view of
01:25:00 something, but it's only partial and it's not a complete view. And that means that, for example,
01:25:06 most of the time for us to understand what really works and doesn't work, we have to work with just
01:25:12 raw numbers. We talk about calorimetry, so we want to understand what kind of substrates are
01:25:17 being utilized here and how this is. One thing that we basically see when we're using isotope
01:25:21 traces and we start to dig into this, and we can also talk about actually maybe creating lactate as
01:25:25 an artificial fuel. So in the same way that you take glucose and you create supplements based on
01:25:30 fructose and glucose, and you use this as a fuel source or ketones or beta-hydroxybutyrate,
01:25:36 then basically lactate actually is very interesting in that context, simply because it is extremely
01:25:44 energy efficient. And that is in the end limitation for elite athletes.
01:25:49 How difficult to deliver orally? I assume it's delivered in a salt?
01:25:53 This is actually something we started discussing. The interesting thing of it is in a salt is that
01:25:58 it could also then in that sense has a little bit the same effect as bicarbonate. So you could use
01:26:03 it as a buffer. Yeah, let's make sure folks understand the chemistry there. So I was going
01:26:07 to actually ask you about this and then we got off onto another topic. I want to come back to that
01:26:10 exact question, but we'll preface it with this question. People ask me all the time, hey, I
01:26:16 understand, Peter, that as my workload increases, my production of lactate increases. And as my production
01:26:22 of lactate increases, my capacity starts to fall off because as lactate goes up, it's buffered by a
01:26:28 hydrogen ion or it's married to a hydrogen ion. And that's what creates the acid part of lactic acid. 0.99
01:26:35 And it's that hydrogen ion that's causing all the trouble. It's not the lactate. We can tolerate
01:26:39 endless amounts of lactate. And lactate is crucial in metabolism. Yeah.
01:26:42 Yeah. We just can't tolerate the hydrogen that comes with it. And it's that hydrogen
01:26:45 that actually paralyzes the actin myosin filaments, prevents them from disengaging. And that's what
01:26:51 leads to that seizing up that you feel, the rigidity you feel when you exceed your lactate
01:26:56 threshold. So the question then becomes, well, can I buffer this? And everybody and their brother
01:27:01 talks about, hey, what if we took lots of Tums, anything that we could get sodium bicarbonate
01:27:06 into our systems? Looking at that literature, which I haven't done in a while, this strategy
01:27:10 didn't really pan out. There wasn't really a great way to orally ingest enough bicarb to make a
01:27:16 difference. Obviously intravenously you could, but that's probably illegal anyway. I mean, I don't
01:27:21 think water would permit that. But even if you weren't concerned with that and just asking the
01:27:25 theoretical question, unless you're on a stationary bike, it's not practical to have an IV drip
01:27:30 of bicarbonate to buffer your hydrogen. So what is the state of buffering agents to reduce and lessen
01:27:40 the impact of lactic acidosis? This is a little bit of a complicated domain.
01:27:45 Unlike all the other simple domains we've been discussing today. Yes.
01:27:48 The reason for that, I've been very fortunate over the last decade to be involved in a lot of edge
01:27:54 case researchers. Plenty that we are years away before this will be published. Not necessarily
01:28:00 because we don't want to publish in it, but there just remains work to be done, to understand it.
01:28:05 And for example, again, this is also a place where we have some indications now, but where some of my
01:28:11 colleagues, they have actually also tested on larger population. But Gustav's highest view to max
01:28:17 actually is done under bicarbonate utilization. Not Christian, but Gustav. 0.56
01:28:22 How? How is it administered?
01:28:24 So the way it was administered is that there's a company in Sweden called Morton. What they did,
01:28:29 this is actually something that is going to be studied now also in actually in health,
01:28:33 in medical settings as well, because it actually has some quite interesting applications there too.
01:28:38 How this was administered is basically that it is packed in a hydrogel and this allows you...
01:28:43 Oh, so you get rid of the gastric, you would bypass the gastric pH and you get it into the intestine.
01:28:49 Medicine, using the same mechanism. You basically pack the agents into a vehicle
01:28:52 to deliver it where you need it more efficiently. So this means that we can go to concentrations that
01:28:58 are significant.
01:29:01 What have you seen is the difference in his lactate tolerance with and without this buffering?
01:29:07 So this is a place again, where obviously the sample size is still limited.
01:29:11 Sure. But in him, in a world-class elite athlete.
01:29:14 So the interesting thing there is that here we have two different cases. And that's, for example,
01:29:19 I have some athletes that have almost twice as high lactate concentration in the blood when they're
01:29:25 using. This is why I said we are opening a can of...
01:29:27 The proverbial can of lactate buffered worms.
01:29:30 Yes, exactly. We also have them to remember because then we have to come back to the technology,
01:29:34 where do we measure...
01:29:35 And what is this called again?
01:29:37 So this brand is called Morton.
01:29:39 Morton, as in Morton salt.
01:29:40 It's written M-O-R-T-E and Morton. People go crazy over the gels and everything during
01:29:47 races. They have a gel that is actually based on the same principle. So we open up that box
01:29:52 as well. But basically Christian Gustav sits comfortably and not eating 160 grams of carbohydrates
01:29:56 per hour. And basically this is then quantified using isotop traces as well. So they don't only
01:30:02 eat it and it starts packing up in the stomach, they utilize it. 0.99
01:30:06 Yeah. I'm going to save time to talk about nutrition because I want to ask you about that.
01:30:09 So this is a commercially available product. Athletes are using it. So do you have a sense
01:30:13 of why some people find... Like Gustav seems to find huge benefit from it. Sounds like Christian 1.00
01:30:17 does not.
01:30:18 Well, I wouldn't say that Christian doesn't, but it depends a little bit on, let's say,
01:30:21 the setting we are using it in as well. And triathlon is inherently complex in the sense that
01:30:26 you have three sports that you put together and with a very varying intensity, all the things that
01:30:30 are happening there, which makes it a little bit more complicated. And then there also is some
01:30:34 benefits, but can also potentially be disadvantages with it. But the benefits that also comes with it
01:30:38 is that it actually also increases your plasma volume fairly instantaneously as well.
01:30:43 You're pulling fluid into the plasma.
01:30:44 Yes. Yeah. But early studies that have done on this, which will be published on this,
01:30:48 basically shows that there's a positive effect of using bicarbonate now or using,
01:30:53 for example, the molten product. We have studies now on larger population done by some of my colleagues,
01:30:57 which indicates this. Then on top of that, what I would say is that we don't fully understand why
01:31:04 it is like this. It's a one interesting hypothesis I presented to the research group is that because
01:31:11 on the one side, what we think is that, okay, this increases the buffering capacity. So we think,
01:31:15 okay, if it increases the buffering capacity, then you can basically do more, then you can go
01:31:19 more anaerobic or more into anaerobic or glycolytic resources. Because one thing that we are fairly
01:31:25 sure about is that you're never going to run out of glycogen, really. You come to a certain level
01:31:29 and the body will rather start to sense that it's really, really low. And that's why you shut down.
01:31:33 You don't shut down because you basically depleted every gram of glycogen in your body.
01:31:38 That's one. And then there are other preserving mechanisms.
01:31:40 By the way, that's easy to verify with a muscle biopsy at failure, right?
01:31:44 No. The problem with that is that even in muscle biopsies, you will see that if you basically do
01:31:47 sampling just across one muscle, it's so heterogenic.
01:31:50 If you wanted to do it, you would need to biopsy multiple times, multiple sites simultaneously,
01:31:55 or even make somebody radioactive and start to do nuclear measurement measurements on people.
01:32:01 Yeah. It's so impractical to really study that you have to go more by, again, coming back to,
01:32:05 for example, first order principles. For example, looking at gross efficiency and then calculating
01:32:11 us basically how much subsidy you're using basically is already involving inaccuracies to it.
01:32:17 That's why you just have to sometimes just say, okay, we are going to look at oxygen consumption
01:32:20 versus, let's say, mechanical power output. And then you just say, we don't care about whether
01:32:24 that's RQ correlates to this value. You just have to have the raw values.
01:32:28 Back to the bicarbonate, what we can observe, for example, is that when we do blood gas analysis,
01:32:33 so when the athletes are exercising, basically a longer protocol, we are taking blood samples
01:32:37 to look at pH level in the body. And what is interesting to see there, even for Christian,
01:32:42 he does not have a doubling in his lactic concentration. So Christian have almost 0.99
01:32:46 unchanged lactic concentration in his blood.
01:32:48 At what level of exertion?
01:32:50 Whatever. Even all out.
01:32:52 Any given power?
01:32:52 Any given power.
01:32:53 Or any given VO2. Yeah. Okay.
01:32:55 Yeah. But the interesting thing here is that, the interesting thing here, this is easy to think now
01:33:00 that when an athlete has double the lactic concentration in the blood, then it has to be
01:33:04 double the contribution from the glycolysis. We have to remember, we measure in the blood,
01:33:08 this is a concentration metric, and the state can be completely different other places in the body.
01:33:12 Here's just a crazy idea. Have you ever done a muscle biopsy on the two of them to see
01:33:17 the relative differences in monocarboxylate transport density on their muscles?
01:33:23 No.
01:33:23 Think about this as, I mean, just for the listeners to understand what we're talking about,
01:33:26 the MCT transporter on the muscle cell must play a significant role in determining
01:33:32 the relationship between intracellular lactate and intraplasma lactate. It would be in an athlete's
01:33:39 best interest through training to increase the density of those, because the more you can get
01:33:44 lactate out of the cell, the more presumably you're going to get the hydrogen with it out
01:33:48 of the cell. We probably have a greater capacity to buffer acid in the plasma because we have the
01:33:54 respiratory drive to adjust bicarb than we do in the cell where that hydrogen is really poisonous.
01:33:59 So it just makes me wonder, as a hypothesis, maybe Christian has more MCT density, and that's why 0.96
01:34:08 he is less impacted by this buffering strategy. I don't know. It could be the other way around.
01:34:14 I wonder if all things equal, that would be... It's just so hard to believe that two world-class
01:34:18 athletes could be that different in their response.
01:34:22 One can be MCT transporters, for sure. One can be, but I doubt it to be significant.
01:34:27 Yeah. It's hard to imagine that's 2x difference.
01:34:29 And the reason why I doubt that to be significant is because if I look at purely the biochemical
01:34:34 efficiency, first order principle, looking at oxygen versus power output, cross mechanical
01:34:39 power output, this is so close that it can't explain it alone. One other difference that is
01:34:45 there, and which is maybe larger, but I don't know, maybe are closer related to this is, for example,
01:34:52 exactly plasma and blood volume. Because the blood volume and plasma volume in Christian and Gustav
01:34:57 is beyond significant in difference.
01:35:00 Why? They're not that different in weight, are they? 80 kilograms versus...
01:35:05 But still, it is borderline where the word significant doesn't do the difference. One of
01:35:11 the places where we don't have any definitive answers, it is just different. But then you can
01:35:15 say, well, it wouldn't have had implications on, for example, the VO2 max.
01:35:18 And stroke volume, cardiac output.
01:35:20 Yeah. Well, actually, that's the interesting thing, because if you talk about stroke volume,
01:35:23 I would agree, yes, there is a massive difference. Again, significant doesn't really do it justice.
01:35:28 We would talk about massive differences in stroke volume, but not in cardiac output.
01:35:32 What's the max heart rate of each?
01:35:34 Christian, ballpark-ish around 180, maybe 170, 180. I would say 178, something like this.
01:35:43 Gustav, around 200. So this is one, but also more interesting here as well, is that Christian 0.75
01:35:50 has a much larger also hemoglobin mass than what Gustav have. One thing we also have to remember is
01:35:56 that if we create a performance stream, more or less, and we put VO2 max on the top of this one,
01:36:00 where all these different factors are contributing, let's say, contributing factor to your VO2 max in
01:36:05 the end. That's why we say that VO2 max is the holy grail or such a good metric, because if there's
01:36:11 something broken somewhere in the system...
01:36:12 It trickles up.
01:36:13 It trickles up, yeah. But it doesn't mean that if something is broken here,
01:36:17 that that's a good metric, even though we could say that it has been used in research and other
01:36:21 things. So probably one of the most plausible explanations for why there are such big differences
01:36:27 in Christian and Gustav in terms of, let's say, where the biggest differences comes from more
01:36:33 is that Gustav has to circulate his blood much quicker than what Christian does, not relatively
01:36:40 speaking, but in absolute. So the absolute circulation of blood, cardiac output has to be
01:36:45 at least the same for Gustav, maybe actually a little bit higher than what it is for Christian.
01:36:50 But Christian compensates in other ways. And that's also an interesting thing then,
01:36:54 basically, when we talk about all these different things, whether it's MCT or other things that are
01:36:58 in the body, is that there are so many mechanisms in the body that we see that when you come
01:37:02 closer and closer to elite level, other systems have to start to compensate for you to take the
01:37:08 next step. In people that are not well-trained, then you can basically do whatever it is,
01:37:12 and the body will just prioritize to develop what is the easiest to develop. But at elite level,
01:37:16 it seems like more like now it starts to be like a really hard priority. And that's even before we
01:37:21 start discussing epigenetics. Let's go back and say one thing about temperature. There's some
01:37:26 reasonable data suggesting that a relatively high dose of acetaminophen can certainly improve heat
01:37:32 performance. So tolerance, race pace tolerance in warm temperatures, that it may even perform output.
01:37:38 And again, nobody knows why. Is it improving performance, i.e. absolute output, because it's
01:37:45 actually reducing and blunting body temperature, and that temperature itself becomes a bit of a
01:37:49 governing mechanism on output? Or if it's just blunting pain, and pain is part of the wall that
01:37:56 we face. But curious if you have any experience with high doses, 1 to 1.5 grams of acetaminophen
01:38:01 in any of these athletes?
01:38:04 No, we don't. We don't use it.
01:38:05 Have you experimented with it in training?
01:38:07 No. One of the reasons why we don't do it is because I believe at the moment you start
01:38:13 manipulating what is not manipulating. Already when you're using exogenous, for example-
01:38:18 Bicarb.
01:38:18 Bicarb hydrates for that sake, or anything like this, you can already say, okay, well,
01:38:22 this already also has an effect. But I would say that the problem when you try to go in and you try
01:38:27 to acutely, let's say, do something in the body, it means basically that you're trying to target one
01:38:33 part of one system of the body and you don't consider the other ones to be important. What
01:38:38 I more believe in is that, for example, if you talk about heat, for example, and heat tolerance,
01:38:42 if you have more of a natural approach to this and you build this into your protocols,
01:38:47 this means basically that, let's say, whatever is in the body that is there in order to help
01:38:51 increase your heat tolerance have to adapt to this. So for example, pain is something that is
01:38:57 trainable. And there are many mechanisms that are involved with this. Using, for example,
01:39:01 supplements to try to lower the pain, for example, or the perceived pain of something.
01:39:07 I think this is a place where, talking about, for example, performance-enhancing drugs,
01:39:12 it's interesting to see that despite post-big doping scandals that were in cycling, everybody
01:39:18 thought that, okay, now Tour de France will become slower. Did, short period, and suddenly it just
01:39:23 became faster, became faster, became faster. I don't think this is because people are doping more
01:39:30 now than what they did before. There are probably some cases where people still do doping or they
01:39:34 are really like venturing into the gray area. But obviously we have found techniques and other things
01:39:40 that are more powerful than using performance-enhancing drugs to get to this level.
01:39:45 I'll share two with you. I'm curious to your thoughts. We're going to talk about nutrition in a
01:39:49 minute. You already alluded to the fact that your athletes are routinely able to
01:39:53 consume 160 grams of carbohydrate per hour on the bike during competition. A hundred years ago,
01:40:01 when I was competing in anything, we were stuck at 60. It was really hard to get past 60 grams per
01:40:08 hour. For ultra-distance things like I did, it really became a bit of an energetics problem.
01:40:14 You had to start figuring out ways to get fat in the substance that you were consuming just to get
01:40:18 the additional calories, even though you didn't really need fat because you have enough of it.
01:40:21 It's glucose you're limited by. I very recently, literally the other day, asked Lance Armstrong,
01:40:27 we were talking about something unrelated. And I said, by the way, Lance, back in the tour,
01:40:31 how many grams of glucose were you consuming per hour? You know what he said? He said,
01:40:37 we didn't even pay attention to it. We just ate when we were hungry. So this is not saying that the only
01:40:46 reason those guys were exceptional is because they were using blood products. No, they were using
01:40:50 blood products and they were exceptional and they trained really hard, but their knowledge of
01:40:55 nutrition was very pedestrian to what it is today. As you know, if you wait till you're hungry to start
01:41:01 fueling, you're not fueling in an optimal strategy at all. So that to me is one enormous advantage in the
01:41:09 Peloton today. I think that nutrition science has evolved so much what these guys can do. I've
01:41:15 heard rumors that they can put down 200 grams per hour, that they've trained themselves up to that
01:41:19 level. I think a second interesting difference in the tour today, and I'd love your point of view on
01:41:24 this as well. I think people forget how big cyclists were 20 years ago relative to today. If you look at
01:41:31 the GC contenders in the era of Lance Armstrong, if you look at Jan Ulrich, Ivan Basso, Lance himself,
01:41:39 I mean, these were guys that weighed 70 kilos. Lance raced at, he'd start the tour at 74 and finish at 72
01:41:47 kilos. These are normal sized human beings. If you look at the GC contenders today, these guys are 58
01:41:56 kilos. I mean, they're very small. So in cycling, if we think about it as watts per kilo, it's not that
01:42:04 they've gone up that much on watts. Their absolute wattage is significantly lower than what it was 20
01:42:10 years ago. They've just gone down so much on weight. So I'm wondering what you think about those two
01:42:15 factors that are clearly stark differences between the world's best cyclist today and the world's best
01:42:22 cyclist 20 years ago as a way to bridge the gap between the use of drugs then versus not today.
01:42:29 There are also a couple of other interesting topics here as well, but I think, yeah, nutrition,
01:42:33 obviously, fuel in, speed out in the other end. It's crucial. And it doesn't help if you try to do
01:42:40 something with your VO2 max on the things if you're running out of fuel. It doesn't help to install a
01:42:44 larger engine in a car if your tank is. Yeah, exactly. I think one of the biggest differences is
01:42:50 exactly like you point out. Their attention to nutrition today in the World Tour, for example,
01:42:54 is in a completely different level than what it was a long time ago. I know also over the last
01:42:59 five years, these have also made a big, big change as well because it's large teams. So they're even
01:43:05 trying to devise tools and methods and other things that allows them to scale this a little
01:43:09 bit more. The benefit I have working with a couple of athletes is that we can go on a completely
01:43:14 different level and what they can do again. So we can even use metabolic measurements even out in
01:43:19 the field to do measurements basically just to see what is happening and become extremely detailed on
01:43:24 what we do. Even looking at basically post-exercise, even what's happening there, or pre-meals,
01:43:29 post-meals, what even happens with your resting metabolic rate because even this changes throughout
01:43:33 the day. And to keep up the consistency over time, you need to fuel accordingly.
01:43:37 Coming back to the question, and that is that I think one, nutrition, yes, this is probably one of the
01:43:41 main contributors. Of the two, this is the main contributor to why they are racing faster today
01:43:47 than what they did five, 10 years ago. Further, I would say that the watts per kilogram, this is a
01:43:51 place where I feel that we will see a change again. I think actually that the weight of athletes will
01:43:57 start to go up again. But the reason for why we start to see this going there is because if we look
01:44:02 at trying to understand why did we end up with the training programs we have done and so on, obviously
01:44:06 it's a very empirical approach to it, practical approach, which very often is extremely good
01:44:11 when it just gets enough time to evolve. But at the same time, also what haven't happened
01:44:16 is that we have adopted training strategies intact with the availability of information,
01:44:23 technologies, and all things that helps us do better fueling. Because one thing we also do know
01:44:28 is that in order for any growth to take place in the body, you need obviously oxygen. We already
01:44:32 talked about that, but we use oxygen as a proxy to understand metabolism. And metabolism, again,
01:44:36 is also a function of growth. When you do training over time, you're obviously trying to signal to
01:44:41 your body you need more muscles to be more efficient in one or the other way. And if you now start to
01:44:46 limit or you put a cap on fueling in order to drive down your weight, this will also start to impair
01:44:53 most likely ideal growth. Do we see this in triathletes? I mean, cycling is an interesting sport because
01:44:59 you don't really get a benefit from weight reduction if you're a time trialist, for example. In fact,
01:45:05 it's the opposite. It's watts more than watts per kilo that matters. But obviously, if you're in the
01:45:10 grand tours, all three of which are basically built around climbing, watts per kilo is ultimately the
01:45:17 metric. Now, we can debate whether you can get a more optimal watts per kilo at a slightly higher
01:45:21 weight than a slightly lower weight. But clearly, you're not going to see people winning a grand tour
01:45:27 at 80 kilos or 75 kilos. I think those days are probably gone. But in triathlon, how much of an effort
01:45:34 do these guys put into their weight? This is actually one of the interesting things because if you
01:45:39 talk about watts per kilogram, Christian actually is watts per kilogram have gone up with increasing
01:45:43 his weight. You said he's 80 kilos? 80 kilograms, yeah. And his FTP is? If I'm going to convert it to
01:45:49 FTP, it would be probably in the range of 400 and... If I did him on a 20-minute test, probably, let's say
01:45:56 for the sake of simplicity, 420 for something like this, probably if we tuned him. If that was how we did
01:46:02 testing and we started to standardize that, maybe even higher, I don't know. It's really hard to say
01:46:06 because we don't do FTP testing. Yep. What would be his average power in an Ironman for four hours?
01:46:13 So for four hours, typically there, they would be around... Let me see if I can guess. You said,
01:46:20 before we started the podcast, you mentioned they were holding 44 to 45 kph.
01:46:25 Or even slightly above, yeah, in the most extreme cases.
01:46:29 So he's got to be at 360 to 370 watts to do that?
01:46:35 Well, that's where aerodynamics come in and we are able to lower the numbers because obviously
01:46:39 staying at 360, 370 will have a quite big impact also on energy utilization and heat production as
01:46:44 well. And for example, coming also back to the question of basically using supplements to
01:46:48 try to mitigate pain or lower your temperature, we also know that this is not necessarily good.
01:46:52 But really also here's a question as I thought of that one, probably we're not going to continue
01:46:57 on that path now, but using, for example, supplements to try to lower your temperature.
01:47:01 I think this is where it's important to ask yourself first order principle,
01:47:04 where does that heat come from? The heat comes from basically mechanical power.
01:47:09 Is it lowering mechanical power? Because I think the argument of the acetaminophen literature
01:47:13 is that the body is bumping up against a couple of set points that are acting as governors
01:47:20 to output. One of them is pain. One of them is temperature. The body does not want to let you
01:47:25 get too hot and obviously doesn't want you to tolerate too much pain. Acetaminophen potentially
01:47:30 blunts both of those. You're arguing, yeah, but if part of the way it's blunting energy output
01:47:36 or temperature is by reducing mechanical work, gross mechanical work, then you're going to probably
01:47:43 pay a net mechanical work price. Yes. And also a capacity price, you could say in some regards.
01:47:50 I have no idea what the answer is. I would just want to test it in training. Literally alternate
01:47:55 weeks with, without as a placebo test with acetaminophen, without acetaminophen, with acetaminophen,
01:48:00 without. Because again, at your level, you get a 1% difference. It matters.
01:48:05 This is the wonder of the body. One thing that happens, obviously, if you start to use a lot of
01:48:09 carbide, so you go to 160 grams. We even cropped in at the highest numbers. We measured it's in
01:48:13 excess of 240 grams per hour of carbohydrate utilization. That is so... Can you tell people
01:48:20 what 240 grams of carbohydrates looks like if it were food? Do it in pasta or something like that.
01:48:26 How much pasta is 240 grams of carbohydrate? To make it simple, it would be probably as you took
01:48:33 pure gel and you fill this glass and you drank it. Take those pure little nasty, disgusting energy 0.91
01:48:40 gels and fill your 16 ounce glass there with it. And drink it. And what form are they consuming 0.92
01:48:47 the carbohydrate in? Normally they would do it in the form of drink mix. So how do they get that much
01:48:52 liquid in their body? That's a part of it. Normally they would consume around, I would say around minimum
01:48:58 of 1.4 liters, but say around two, a little bit more than two liters per hour. Good Lord.
01:49:03 What's the glucose concentration in that liquid? In that one, then I have to calculate.
01:49:08 So we could just do the math. If you said two liters, 200, that's 12%. That's a 12% mixture.
01:49:13 Yeah. Approximately. Probably, yeah. Yeah. 0.674.
01:49:16 Which again, that also completely flies in the face of traditional nutrition science, which says
01:49:21 five to 6% is the limit for gastric tolerability and is the sweet spot for absorption. At five to 6%,
01:49:31 your max. Now again, that's a different problem. That's optimizing for water absorption into the
01:49:36 cell, not your primary point. You're probably overdoing it on liquid and you're trying to
01:49:42 maximize glucose into the cell. But also absorption here, because this is also where it's interesting
01:49:47 or important and to go back to also a little bit like, what is this research? Like who is this
01:49:51 research done on as well? Yeah. And it's not done on these trained athletes.
01:49:53 Yeah. Okay. First question, how long did it take you to train the athletes to be able to tolerate
01:50:01 that? Because if someone's listening to us today and they're saying, oh, I heard these guys talking
01:50:05 about the 12% carbohydrate concentration, which again, just means for people listening, that means
01:50:11 120 grams of glucose per liter. That's twice the standard what you'd see in an energy drink.
01:50:18 And then I'm going to drink two liters of that every hour. I think within two hours,
01:50:22 a normal person is going to be puking their guts out. They simply can't get that volume of glucose
01:50:28 out of the upper gastrointestinal tract. So is this just like any other muscle where you can train
01:50:35 yourself to exceed capacity? Seems like it. Seems like most things in our body is actually extremely
01:50:40 trainable. That's also comes back to the nutrition part as well, where exactly also the training
01:50:45 programs we have today have not seen the same change as nutrition strategies have done over
01:50:50 the last years as well. So that means also that the power numbers that was output maybe
01:50:54 five, 10, 20 years ago, I'm not so sure if that's the limitation we're going to see.
01:50:59 Especially late in races. This is where it's going to make a bigger difference. It's not going to make
01:51:03 a big difference at the beginning of the race, but it could make a huge difference at the end.
01:51:07 Talk to me about formulations. Back when I was swimming great distances, one of the challenges I had
01:51:12 over a 12 hour event was literally fatigue of the same flavor. So part of the challenge was how do
01:51:18 you just mix things up? And after a while, sweet becomes horrible and you actually want something
01:51:23 salty, but then salty becomes horrible. Like how are you managing the actual practical implication of
01:51:29 this? So again, this is a place where more than they made actually their gels to be as neutral as
01:51:35 possible. And because it is formed as a hydrogel, it actually encapsulates the sugar inside the
01:51:40 hydrogel, meaning that the perception of sweetness is much lower than for any other gels. You will
01:51:46 still perceive it as slightly sweet, but it's much, much less.
01:51:49 Wait, sorry, this Morton gel is a significant driver of their calories as well as the bicarb?
01:51:54 No. So there are two different products because Morton has the bicarb product,
01:51:58 which actually also is encapsulated in hydrogel, but actually with carbohydrates.
01:52:01 But then they have the dedicated fueling products, which is basically consist of a drink mix,
01:52:06 which Christian and Gustav are mainly using, but they also have gels as well. So it's more
01:52:11 practical, obviously, to have a gel. Silly question. The bicarb capsule, 0.97
01:52:15 they're swallowing a capsule while they're on a bike drinking?
01:52:17 This is a two-component, or actually a three-component mixture. You have the hydrogel,
01:52:23 which is basically in a dry format in a sachet, and then you have the bicarb tablets, and then you
01:52:28 basically you take water. So you add water to this. First, you add water to the hydrogel mix,
01:52:32 and then basically you are forming the hydrogel. And then you take the bicarb and you mix it into
01:52:36 the hydrogel. And in this way, you wisp it around. And then basically this way, you're able to bring
01:52:41 it into the stomach and actually able to deliver it without it actually causes any problems.
01:52:46 I can't say actually too much in detail what kind of concentration we are on at the moment.
01:52:51 I will come back to this a little bit later because this is probably things that we will publish.
01:52:55 But to put it this way, 19 grams of bicarb, for example, that would be like a standard dosage.
01:53:01 You can go to 22 grams of bicarb as pure, and you can take this. And this doesn't require very much
01:53:06 training. What is the base of the carbohydrate in that brand that they seem to like? Is it straight
01:53:11 dextrose, multidextrin? No, mainly fructose and glucose.
01:53:16 What's the ratio? It's a little bit of a time since basically we went through
01:53:20 details of the law, let's say looking at the balances between this, but let's say it's a 40-60.
01:53:25 So it's basically high fructose corn syrup. Yeah. The genius part of it is actually not
01:53:29 the carbohydrates itself. It's the packaging mechanism.
01:53:32 Yes. Exactly. That's the difference. So if you were consuming 60 grams per hour,
01:53:36 spare the money and buy orange juice or even put honey inside and drink it. Where it differs itself
01:53:42 is when you are really starting to push the limit of the concentration. But you can even train yourself
01:53:46 today. This is something we know. You can even take honey today and you can mix it and you can train
01:53:50 yourself to go to higher values than what have previously been published, like pure normal products.
01:53:54 If you want to get to 160, you need the technology. Yes, exactly.
01:53:58 No fat and no protein, any amino acids throughout that whole race?
01:54:01 No. This is something that was also done research on, but we ended up in the end,
01:54:06 pure glucose and fructose. And it actually has to do with actually how oxygen is being prioritized in
01:54:11 the body. Because we have to consider two things here. It's easy to think that while you're only
01:54:15 racing at 80% of your VO2 max or 70 or 90, whatever percentage it is of your VO2 max. But that's a
01:54:21 bit of a short circuit. Because what we have to think of is that this oxygen, more oxygen is going
01:54:26 to contribute to more heat as well. So it's not like you can just go, whatever, I'm rising at a
01:54:30 solo percentage of a VO2 max, so I can go whatever and do in the beginning. Because it always will
01:54:35 accumulate towards the end of your race. That means already from the beginning, it's critical how you
01:54:40 pace and your efficiency as well. Because every inefficiency you have, either it's biochemical or anything
01:54:45 like this, it will basically end up towards the end of the race. So this means also that at the
01:54:51 moment you start putting any other substrates or nutrients into your mixture that the body have
01:54:57 to prioritize somehow in the system, that means also that there are going to be less oxygen available
01:55:03 for pure propulsion. And in the end, it's a pure propulsion that really sets the winner apart
01:55:08 from the rest of the people there. So you basically want to peel away absolutely everything that doesn't
01:55:13 contribute to forward propulsion. Use every milliliter, every mole of oxygen purely for that purpose and
01:55:19 nothing else. Because oxygen is one of the limitations. We talk about different kinds of
01:55:24 substrates and these kind of things, which is still also a place where we don't know. We are actually
01:55:28 doing quite some interesting research on different kinds of substrates from glucose, fructose.
01:55:33 Have you looked at BHP, beta-hydroxybutyrate?
01:55:35 Yes. So we looked at BHP as well. And one of the things, if you purely look at the stoichiometry,
01:55:41 there are interesting things here. But the problem is that we cannot only do stoichiometry.
01:55:45 We actually need to know the enthalpy, and we also need to know the Gibbs-free energy that is
01:55:49 available, and ideally even the entropy. Okay. So the Gibbs-free energy, if you're making the BHP
01:55:55 yourself, much more complicated. But if you take it purely exogenously and consider it an additional
01:56:01 substrate above and beyond glucose, do we have reason to believe that we're going to get more ATP
01:56:07 per mole of oxygen? No, because the practical limitation of this is that when you do racing,
01:56:12 if you think of this more first order principle again. So if you do racing, and this was actually
01:56:16 one of my first questions, because we have been working together with one of the leading brands,
01:56:21 or arguably the leading one, they are situated here in the US. But one of the limitations that
01:56:26 you have to look at is basically when you are racing, this has a certain fuel demand. So there's
01:56:30 a certain amount of fuel that needs to go through the system there. And that means that in the context
01:56:33 when we talk about glucose and fructose, we are looking at basically trying to replace as much
01:56:37 as possible. We said, okay, glucose, fructose, or basically a carbohydrate seems to be a very,
01:56:41 very oxygen-efficient fuel source when you do movement. But that means also that in order not
01:56:47 to run out of this, we are trying to replace as much as possible or this to be able to race faster.
01:56:52 Because if you said, this is the fuel source I have available in my body, I'm going to race this
01:56:56 fast. Obviously, I cannot go faster than this. So certain power number, certain duration will
01:57:00 deplete this energy source or basically bring me close to depletion of that source. So that means,
01:57:05 okay, instead of then switching to other sources, or you're basically always using other sources as well,
01:57:09 but trying to get more from that source means basically you have to replace more of the power.
01:57:13 So more of the power now, we have to create an environment where more power can come from the
01:57:18 same source. Let's say you were originally around at 80 grams or 90 grams, let's say 80 grams for
01:57:24 simplicity, say 80 grams of carbohydrates, and you have a biochemical efficiency of 20%, for example,
01:57:29 that means basically you're getting out, or if you say 4.2, let's say you can get basically,
01:57:33 so one gram would be then the equivalent of, let's say, one joule per second or one watt,
01:57:37 more or less like this. So you could get from that one. So if you double this from 80 to 160 now,
01:57:42 that means basically now you can get double the amount of what's coming from carbohydrates here.
01:57:46 The problem with ketones is that the strategy is not to basically fuel the amount you are using in
01:57:52 a race. You don't fuel with ketones in the same way. Like if you go to 70, 80, or even 100 milliliters
01:57:58 of ketone consumption in an hour, you're going to have so high levels of ketones in your body
01:58:04 that you will start to feel almost like you are getting diabetic. There's a feeling of bonking
01:58:08 almost. So the thing that is there is more like it's inducing a state in the body rather than you
01:58:13 actually fueling, using it. Because in order to fuel, so they said your idea was that you're going
01:58:18 to replace what you're losing from your body, because that's driving your body also out of
01:58:22 homeostasis as well. You are going to try to keep homeostasis as much as possible, or try to keep the
01:58:28 state of the body as unchanged as possible. That would mean that you would need to ingest so large
01:58:33 amount of ketones during a race. And then you have also the issue with the salt, if you're bringing
01:58:37 it in with a salt versus an ester. Okay, a couple of things I want to chat about. So one, we talked
01:58:41 a little bit about this before, but let's kind of go back to it. So remind me, did Christian and
01:58:45 Gustav both compete in Tokyo Olympics? Yeah, both did compete in Tokyo Olympics, yes.
01:58:50 And how did they do in Tokyo? Christian won. Gustav came seventh, eighth, seventh place, yeah.
01:58:57 After that Olympics, they went back to Ironman distance for the next three years.
01:59:01 And then Gustav did not compete in Paris. He had an injury. Christian did, and I think you said he
01:59:06 was 12th. Yes. How much of that was the mismatch in distance? Again, he's much more optimized for
01:59:13 Ironman, Olympic distances. That's like asking a marathon runner to go and run a 5K. Very unusual.
01:59:21 What was the process like to get ready for that? And what was the difference in his personal
01:59:26 performance between 2024 and 2021? We went there for two reasons. One, we thought it was possible
01:59:33 to get back on the podium. And I would say even after disappointing wrestles, I would say that we
01:59:38 are more convinced today that it's possible to go back than we were. But there are other reasons for
01:59:42 that, coming back to that. Sorry, meaning in Los Angeles, you're saying? In Paris, yeah, even there.
01:59:47 So if we then look also back to there, Christian already had in training put out far better
01:59:53 performances than what he was capable of getting out on race day. I would say that there are two
01:59:58 things that looking back at, let's say, the process leading into Paris that for me explains most of
02:00:04 this. And one part of it is one of the differences leading from Rio, leading into Tokyo, was that we took
02:00:11 a massive shift in how we did intensity control. And again, now we're talking about intensity control,
02:00:17 that doesn't mean necessarily about talking about just threshold or anything like that. This means
02:00:21 exactly like pinpointing different intensities and working on them in order to optimize the human
02:00:26 body. And then how we find this. One thing that we did, actually, we got maybe a little bit too
02:00:31 complacent the last year. And that is basically, we've done it so much that it's more like, okay,
02:00:35 we had more projects. So it's also one place you just think that, okay, you are getting really good at
02:00:39 controlling the intensity and these kind of things. So we stressed it a little bit. The key
02:00:44 that really made a difference between Rio to Tokyo, we became sloppy at.
02:00:50 Rio to Tokyo or Tokyo to Paris?
02:00:53 Yeah, from Rio to Tokyo, that was the massive shift going from unknown to basically Olympic champion
02:00:57 to basically where we, the last year, I would say in particular, let's say the two last year,
02:01:03 were much more sloppy on simply because you just think that, okay, after you've done intensity control
02:01:07 for so long time, you would think that you have such a good calibrated body for this.
02:01:11 We made the same error actually already in 2017 to 2018, where 2016 to 17, we saw massive
02:01:18 improvements in performance. From 17 to 18, we have done so much measurement. We lacked it and
02:01:22 other things like this. Just thinking, okay, they must have a good feeling for this, really good
02:01:25 calibrated. To a couple of months, we saw that, okay, this doesn't work. We have to go back to the
02:01:29 practice. The same error we did the last year going into Paris. Purely in terms of performance,
02:01:34 Christian basically put out performances that was far exceeding what he did on the run in Paris. In
02:01:41 Paris, he lacked around four minutes per kilometer over the 10K. That was the difference between the
02:01:46 first place and the 12th place. Sorry, say that again?
02:01:48 Sorry, four seconds. Okay.
02:01:50 Four seconds per kilometer. Four minutes would be between them and me.
02:01:53 Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, so four seconds per kilometer.
02:01:57 So 40 seconds he lost on the run.
02:01:58 Yeah, around there. But one of the differences that also were between Tokyo and Paris was that
02:02:04 Christian actually sat there. When he came out of the water, Christian's swimming have never been
02:02:08 his forte. That's been the worst discipline for him. And the same actually made, this was also,
02:02:14 we are an arena where we would see even bigger differences. So the poor swimmers in Paris,
02:02:19 some of them even didn't finish.
02:02:21 A lot of people heard about how disgusting the river was. How did that create more separation
02:02:26 between the excellent and the good swimmers? It's the current in the water. There was a
02:02:30 massive current in the water, basically to the extent that if you said it was still water,
02:02:34 most of the triathletes basically set 400 meter record, world records swimming the first 400
02:02:39 meters. Usually that closes the gap between people when the current is strong.
02:02:43 The only problem is that you have to turn back up. And then the problem also with this,
02:02:47 because this is in a river, you can normally say that if this were basically a place where you just
02:02:50 knew you had laminar flow. So you had laminar flow and it was homogenous all over the place.
02:02:55 Then you could say that really it would make that much of a difference or should not. A little bit
02:02:59 it would do, simply because the swim in distance is the same, but the duration becomes slightly
02:03:04 longer. And if it's a slightly longer duration, you open up a little bit more of a gap.
02:03:07 The challenging part with Paris and the Seine was also that flow is not, especially in the Seine,
02:03:13 not homogenous. It is highly heterogeneous. Meaning basically, if you look at the swimmers there and
02:03:19 you see that they basically come around the first buoy and they are aiming for the buoy next to them,
02:03:24 suddenly people go in a large parabola because they underestimate actually how much more
02:03:29 up current they have to basically point in order to get around. And then after that as well,
02:03:33 when they get closer, because there are two bridges that went across the river as well.
02:03:37 And around this one, you would normally think that the current is actually slower next to the
02:03:45 pillars that are into the water. The fastest swimmer that was suddenly in the front there,
02:03:48 suddenly became second or even down into the group simply because the people that went a couple
02:03:54 of meters, two meters further to the right there, swam suddenly past them. The fastest swimmer
02:03:59 suddenly, it looked almost like they were, came, had good speed and suddenly standing still almost,
02:04:04 where they had to deviate out from the pillar and basically, so it becomes a far more tactical race.
02:04:09 How far did he come out in the water after the leader in swimming?
02:04:13 I don't remember. That was quite significant. That was, to be honest, the only thing I remember
02:04:19 from that is that he came out, I think, let's say of that long, because also what happens here,
02:04:23 instead of that you get a pack that is swimming, it gets a long, long line instead. And that's also
02:04:28 challenging in this context as well, because you get a completely stretched out field instead of that
02:04:33 people come more like in patches out of the water. I think Christian came out from the last guy in 0.98
02:04:39 the first group. He was, I think, 17, 20 seconds behind him, but out on the bike, he became,
02:04:46 I think, 40 seconds down from the lead group. One of the differences that we already anticipated
02:04:53 from the first year to the second year also was that one thing that I think people got a little
02:04:58 bit shocked over the first year, so that was basically during the test event, was how quickly
02:05:02 in that course the groups behind basically catched up with the lead groups on the bike.
02:05:08 Like, this one thing we knew that basically the people that obviously were in the first group,
02:05:12 they would benefit everything from basically going a little bit harder,
02:05:15 and maybe even starting devising strategies where they even got domestics. Like, this is an
02:05:19 individual race, but people actually starting getting domestics and sacrifice people in the
02:05:24 races from a nation perspective to be able to keep up, let's say, a different racing strategy.
02:05:29 Because they're allowed to draft in triathlon now?
02:05:31 Yeah. So in short course triathlon, you can draft. There you can draft. This is the difference
02:05:34 between that and long course like Ironman racing. What did this mean for Christian? It meant for
02:05:38 Christian that basically in Paris versus Tokyo, he had to pedal 30% harder for three-fifths of the race
02:05:48 in order to just come back in the group, and you don't get 30% for free for basically 25 kilometers.
02:05:54 30% extra power for 25 kilometers, that has a massive cost. So even though we could say that his fitness
02:06:01 have increased beyond what it was before, which made it confident that if this had been a pure time trial,
02:06:07 in let's say where you had like a normal swimming conditions, this kind of thing,
02:06:10 he would be faster than what he was in Tokyo. But because this is a place where obviously the dynamics
02:06:15 is completely different, that's extra fitness. 30%. I mean, I'm surprised he could even do that.
02:06:20 Yeah. That has an implication when you get out on the run. Because obviously here,
02:06:24 this is not a time like you where you go all out on a bike.
02:06:26 What was his 10K time?
02:06:28 30 high something, I think. Let's say around 30 minutes. I have to go back and check.
02:06:33 Sometime I'll head a little bit different place.
02:06:35 Still so fast. Good Lord.
02:06:37 Yeah.
02:06:38 Last thing I want to just chat with you about is where you are using AI today,
02:06:43 or where you see AI going to make your insights better and your efficacy better.
02:06:50 So with all the data we collect, one of the things that I would be able to discover quicker
02:06:57 with AI is that his utilization went up too high in the month leading into the Olympics.
02:07:04 Utilization.
02:07:05 So meaning basically where you are trading away a little bit on your anaerobic capacity and power,
02:07:11 or let's say at least anaerobic power, maybe not capacity, you don't want to trade that away,
02:07:14 but let's say anaerobic power, in order to increase your aerobic power slightly more.
02:07:19 So let's say off your view to max, you're able to raise sustainably an even higher percentage
02:07:23 off your view to max. So that means also substitute utilization would normally then be improved as
02:07:28 well. Whether that would make a difference, to be honest, I don't know because of how the race
02:07:31 played out. That's one. Where AI really makes a difference is that for me, we have used AI for
02:07:38 some while. We started developing our own systems. I think this must have been back in 2020. And that
02:07:45 is that with all the data, because of all the in-depth research we have done, we obviously have a lot of
02:07:51 data and interesting findings where we can build AI systems that allows us to take new data that comes
02:07:58 into the systems in real time and help us highlight what is important and what is not important. Like
02:08:04 if there are things that we need to prioritize more, or I can even put attention to this.
02:08:09 So AI for me is also where I think research, just purely in terms of longevity, in terms of human
02:08:14 health, everything will really supercharge us to a completely different level. Researchers and other
02:08:21 people that I work with today, and one of the main limitations when they come in and they basically see
02:08:24 the work we do, is to say, okay, the research we do is insane. It has a depth to it that basically
02:08:29 is unmatched. But it's not because they don't have necessarily the competence in a group or anything
02:08:35 like this to do it, but it's just the sheer amount of work that is required in order to utilize it,
02:08:41 or even use it in a study in itself. And when you have AI, like a lot of work that actually is done
02:08:47 in research today is still manual work. There are plotting that is still done manual, there are
02:08:51 measurements that are still done manual, but where instrumentation AI really can change this to the
02:08:57 point where I'm not talking about one study can be done with maybe one more instrument or something
02:09:02 like this, but where you can use a multitude of extra of instruments and be able to dig into the data
02:09:08 on completely different levels than what you could do before. AI will not replace the decision-making,
02:09:14 but it will help us in terms of information.
02:09:16 Basically extract patterns you might not otherwise be able to direct your own statistical analysis
02:09:23 towards? Yes. You can also imagine here, AI, how we train today is that for a normal person,
02:09:29 I don't have a PhD in mathematics, I don't have a PhD in machine learning, but the good thing is that
02:09:34 we can basically take... You're using large language models to do this?
02:09:38 No, we have built an agentic system. So large language models is basically the interface for us.
02:09:43 So I would use that, for example, I would say that I want to look at data in a certain way,
02:09:48 so I'm using more the LLM or NLP to inform which agents that should be utilized in order to understand
02:09:56 or to dig into the data. So I still have to produce the question. I still have to produce the question.
02:10:01 AI for me is basically just an autonomous system. I know this is a big debate on how intelligent these
02:10:06 systems are, but one of the best cases is that because I work so much in edge cases, so there was
02:10:12 a study that just came out now and people say, oh, it seems like AI has the possibility. It came out of
02:10:17 Stanford, I think it was, and it was quite a lot of research involved in it. And I say that AI has the
02:10:21 possibility to seemingly to produce quite a lot of novel ideas on par with humanity. But where I would
02:10:27 say that, well, it depends on what kind of perspective you look at it. And also where I would say that
02:10:32 if it doesn't have data that it's been trained on for this, the best thing it can try to do is
02:10:37 interpolate between data it already have access to. That means edge cases or basically cases where
02:10:42 you are in the, let's say in the domain where you need to extrapolate, they greatly suffer. This you
02:10:46 can see again and again and again. But the good thing is that you empower a group of people or even
02:10:52 a single human with PhD level capabilities in mathematics, in biology, physics, all these kinds of
02:10:59 things. So you use the NLP, you ask a question, and basically it can target this kind of data.
02:11:04 Like even programming is a limitation for many people today. They are able maybe to formulate
02:11:09 great questions, but they don't have the capability or the resources available to really put or execute
02:11:15 and look into it. But when you have AI, suddenly now you can, without necessarily skills and programming
02:11:20 other things, you're able to formulate the question and you can ask the questions into the data.
02:11:25 And these different agents can now suddenly employ extreme level competence from multi-domains by the
02:11:33 hands of a single user into the data and give you insight back that otherwise would be impossible,
02:11:38 even for large research teams. As you think about 2028, if you think about the next four years,
02:11:44 if you had to just sort of speculate wildly, what percentage improvement do you think this will
02:11:50 bring, not to the insights, but to the actual performance?
02:11:55 I think that, okay, first to answer it a little bit more high level, I think that today Norway have
02:12:01 been a superpower in winter sports. A lot of the reasons has been because of the technology research
02:12:06 and other things that have gone into, for example, purely optimization of skis. You could come to the
02:12:11 Olympics, you can be a better trained athlete, but you want to win simply because the way the
02:12:15 technology makes a difference on the skis, for example. I think AI will be, or I'm convinced AI
02:12:21 and the systems we are building now will have the same implication on purely human performance and
02:12:26 training. Meaning that if you basically don't employ AI at some point, you will be at such a
02:12:31 deficiency. So you have great people. What is important for me to say here, coaches are very
02:12:36 often extremely advanced, almost super intelligent in the space of exactly making people fitter.
02:12:43 They are maybe not, or not even closely remote to the understanding of everything we have talked
02:12:49 about today in terms of even knowing exactly the definition of such a widely common expression
02:12:55 like, or terminology like FTP, but still they produce some excellent athletes because they have
02:13:00 observational skills and developed an intuition of what works and not works through a lot of
02:13:05 experience, empathy and so on, that they are brilliant. But AI is not conflict to them, rather again,
02:13:12 a superpower where they can employ their level of understanding into much better questions
02:13:19 into what is happening here with my athlete. So it shouldn't change the way you do coaching,
02:13:24 but it increases the precision of what you do in the coaching. And the biggest change thus in
02:13:30 performance will come through even better consistency in the training. Not that single workout that is so
02:13:36 much more brilliant, but purely in the consistency of the training and adaptations you do to the training
02:13:41 programs. Is there an area in particular that you see the biggest gap between where your insights are,
02:13:49 your coaching insights are today versus where you hope AI is going to close a gap?
02:13:54 Yeah, being able to be far more proactive than what I am today. I still, even though I would consider
02:14:00 myself as one of the leading persons on using technology and also in applied research when it comes to
02:14:06 elite performance, I can still say that I am only able to utilize in the daily life a fraction of
02:14:12 the data that we are collecting. Then you can say, well, why do you collect all of the data? Well,
02:14:16 very often it becomes insight. You come back, you learn something from it that you otherwise wouldn't
02:14:20 be able to do. Well, and you're going to have training data.
02:14:22 Yes.
02:14:22 Great training data.
02:14:23 Yeah. Yeah. But being able to be proactive and make adjustments, individual adjustments much more
02:14:28 proactively will be one of the biggest differences. And this doesn't go only apply to elites. This
02:14:33 applies even to amateurs or normal people. Well, it's been a fascinating discussion. Thank you again
02:14:40 for making the time to swing by on the way to Flagstaff. And as always, just enjoy talking about this
02:14:46 stuff. And hopefully folks enjoyed this as well, even though admittedly it was a little technical at
02:14:50 times. Thank you the same. Thank you for listening to this week's episode of The Drive. Head over to
02:14:57 peteratiamd.com forward slash show notes. If you want to dig deeper into this episode, you can also
02:15:05 find me on YouTube, Instagram, and Twitter, all with the handle peteratiamd. You can also leave us
02:15:11 review on Apple podcasts or whatever podcast player you use. This podcast is for general informational
02:15:17 purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing, or other professional healthcare
02:15:22 services, including the giving of medical advice. No doctor patient relationship is formed. The use of
02:15:29 this information and the materials linked to this podcast is at the user's own risk. The content on this
02:15:35 podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.
02:15:40 Users should not disregard or delay in obtaining medical advice from any medical condition they have,
02:15:45 and they should seek the assistance of their healthcare professionals for any such conditions.
02:15:50 Finally, I take all conflicts of interest very seriously. For all of my disclosures and the companies
02:15:56 I invest in or advise, please visit peteratiamd.com forward slash about where I keep an up-to-date
02:16:04 and active list of all disclosures.