#340 - AMA #69ļ¼ Scrutinizing supplementsļ¼ creatine, fish oil, vitamin D, and moreāa framework for understanding effectiveness, quality, and individual need
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
177.1697
Summary
In today's episode, we cover supplements. As this is a very complex topic, we wanted to approach it first by proposing a framework that you can use to evaluate supplements that we can't make blanket recommendations on since everyone has their own individual health circumstances. To me, the framework is very important here because if I were to just dive into this podcast and give you my point of view on a random collection of supplements, it would be akin to giving you a bunch of fish when in reality, what I want to do is make sure you know how to fish.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hey everyone, welcome to a sneak peek, ask me anything or AMA episode of the drive podcast.
00:00:16.320
I'm your host, Peter Atiyah. At the end of this short episode, I'll explain how you can access
00:00:20.780
the AMA episodes in full, along with a ton of other membership benefits we've created,
00:00:25.400
or you can learn more now by going to peteratiyahmd.com forward slash subscribe.
00:00:31.100
So without further delay, here's today's sneak peek of the ask me anything episode.
00:00:39.340
Welcome to ask me anything AMA episode number 69. In today's episode, we cover supplements. As this
00:00:47.420
is a very complex topic, we wanted to approach it first by proposing a framework that you can use
00:00:53.440
to evaluate supplements that we can't make blanket recommendations on since everyone has their own
00:00:59.260
individual health circumstances. To me, the framework is very important here because if
00:01:04.260
I were to just dive into this podcast and give you my point of view on a random collection of
00:01:09.360
supplements, it would be akin to giving you a bunch of fish when in reality, what I want to do is make
00:01:14.420
sure you, of course, know how to fish. But not just giving you the framework, we also want to give you
00:01:19.820
a few fish. And so we want to use the framework to cover a handful of studies for some popular
00:01:25.420
supplements. We covered creatine, fish oil, vitamin D, vitamin B, or many of the vitamin Bs,
00:01:32.840
and ashwagandha. We also talk about how to look at supplement quality, and we hope that this episode
00:01:38.320
gives you an ability to take said framework and apply it to any supplement you encounter in the
00:01:44.680
future. If you're a subscriber and you want to watch the full video of this podcast, you can find it on
00:01:48.860
the show notes page. If you're not a subscriber, you can watch the sneak peek on our YouTube page.
00:01:54.200
So without further delay, I hope you'll enjoy AMA 69.
00:02:03.500
Peter, welcome to another AMA. How are you doing?
00:02:07.980
Always, always welcome. I know sometimes it's tough to get you to clear your schedule, but we're always
00:02:12.440
happy you show up. Haven't missed one yet, so that's always a good thing. So today we're hitting a
00:02:17.800
topic, which is one we get asked about a lot, which is supplements. And this can vary greatly
00:02:23.820
depending on the person, depending on the supplements. And the hard part with supplements
00:02:27.240
is that while everyone is interested in it, it's so variable person to person, and not even all your
00:02:34.140
patients are taking the same supplements or the same amount and all of that. And so it's really
00:02:39.360
hard to talk about it in a way that makes it applicable to everyone without being like, take this,
00:02:44.500
don't take this, which is something that you've never really done because of how you look at this
00:02:49.400
topic. What we decided to do today was instead look at a framework for how you think about supplements
00:02:54.920
and then go through case studies of a variety of supplements to talk through it, to hopefully allow
00:03:00.660
the person listening or watching to then be able to apply it in their own life so they can just get a
00:03:06.120
better understanding, be smarter when it comes to this topic. So we tried to pick ones that we get
00:03:11.480
asked about a lot for the case studies, which is creatine, fish oil, vitamin D, B vitamins, and
00:03:17.140
ashwagandha. So the hope is after this, not only will people understand those specific supplements
00:03:22.220
better that we're going to do the case studies on, but also how they can apply this framework to their
00:03:27.600
own life. With all that said, when patients come into the practice, what percent of the supplements
00:03:34.020
are they taking that you recommend they continue to take? Obviously any patient that's coming into the
00:03:38.880
practice, we're trying to gather as much information about them as we can through their medical history.
00:03:43.620
And an important component of that is understanding all medications, supplements, hormones, anything
00:03:48.420
they take. I call this the bucket of exogenous molecules. So generally we know this on the way in
00:03:54.560
and there's a ton of variety. There's people who come in who are taking nothing. They don't take any
00:03:59.080
medicine by prescription. They don't take any supplements. Conversely, there are patients who come in
00:04:03.360
on no medications, but a list of supplements that might be two pages long and everything in
00:04:09.220
between. Our view is generally to approach this the way the kidney approaches the filtration of
00:04:16.860
glucose, sodium, and potassium, which is you dump everything out and then ask the question,
00:04:22.380
what should be added back in? And I don't mean we literally stop everything, but I'm saying that's
00:04:27.060
kind of the mental model for how we go about thinking about it. Because a lot of times when we ask
00:04:32.100
patients, why are you taking this or why are you taking that? They don't know. They just say, oh,
00:04:36.400
you know, I started this a couple of years ago because I saw somebody on Instagram talking about
00:04:41.080
it. Or, you know, I saw this doctor a few years ago who told me to take this, but I have no idea why.
00:04:46.740
So there's just a couple of things worth acknowledging before we jump into this. And it
00:04:51.480
comes from discussions that I've had many times, which goes something like this. Hey, I don't believe
00:04:58.300
in taking any medicine, just so you know, only natural supplements. Now, my response to that is,
00:05:05.640
tell me the difference. There is a difference, but I just want to make sure you as the consumer of
00:05:10.640
this understand the difference. And it's really a question of regulation. So supplements are not
00:05:17.260
regulated. By definition, the FDA has tacitly referred to them as generally regarded as safe.
00:05:25.560
But the process by which that's determined is not entirely that rigorous. And pharmaceutical
00:05:31.640
products, while far from perfect, do have more in the way of regulation and oversight.
00:05:37.720
There are places where these overlap. I'll encounter a patient who says, listen, I will never
00:05:43.300
take a statin to lower my ApoB, but I will definitely happily take red rice yeast, at which point you have
00:05:50.960
to sort of explain to them, that a very high dose of red rice yeast is effectively a modest dose of
00:05:56.940
pravastatin. So I think it's just helpful for patients not to get ideologically wrapped up in the idea of
00:06:03.980
over-the-counter supplement versus pharmaceutical agent, and instead to just analyze any molecule you put in
00:06:11.700
your body through the framework we're going to talk about today. Today, we're going to limit it to over-the-counter
00:06:17.080
supplements because these are the things we get asked the most questions about. And frankly, it's
00:06:21.780
the area in which it's harder to do the type of analysis we're doing today. So the type of analysis
00:06:26.540
we're doing today is so much easier to do in the pharma space because of the regulatory hurdles that
00:06:33.100
must be cleared by a drug to be approved. So it's almost like shooting fish in a barrel. It's still a
00:06:38.420
great exercise to do, but doing it the way we're going to do it today is really how you develop the
00:06:43.340
muscle for doing this type of work. I think with that said, do you just want to run over
00:06:48.240
real quick the questions you asked to determine whether or not a supplement is worthwhile?
00:06:54.000
And I think just giving this overview will be helpful because as we said in the beginning,
00:06:57.700
when we go through the case studies, we'll stick to these questions and answer them
00:07:02.100
along the way. And so to kick it off, do you just want to run through what those questions are?
00:07:07.140
I think this is the single most important thing I'm hopefully transmitting throughout this episode.
00:07:11.120
I mean, the heavy lifting is actually showing you how we go through this, but this is the punchline.
00:07:16.500
Anytime you're considering taking a supplement or someone is suggesting a supplement, you should ask
00:07:21.320
the following questions or something that approximates them. So the first question I'm asking is,
00:07:25.300
are you taking this to correct a deficiency or are you trying to achieve supranormal levels of
00:07:32.860
fill in the blank? Second question, are you taking this molecule because you believe that it's going
00:07:40.260
to improve your lifespan or your health span or potentially both? The third question is,
00:07:46.640
if it is lifespan, is it because this molecule is targeting a specific disease and presumably
00:07:53.820
reducing your risk of that disease? Or do we believe it's more broadly geroprotective?
00:07:58.180
In the supplement landscape, that's pretty rare to find, but obviously you can see examples in the
00:08:03.320
pharma space where we might see certain drugs that we think have geroprotective benefits versus
00:08:08.260
those that have lifespan benefits, but only on one disease. Of course, the other question that is
00:08:14.700
the corollary of that is if you're taking it for health span, can you speak to which apparatus of
00:08:20.920
health span? Do you think this is something that is improving physical performance, cognitive
00:08:24.160
performance, or emotional health? The fourth question is, is there a biomarker that you can track
00:08:29.760
to suggest that you are getting the appropriate amount of the supplement or that you might be
00:08:35.720
in the therapeutic window? The fifth question is, do you understand the mechanism of action?
00:08:42.160
Now, again, I want to be clear. You don't have to answer every one of these questions in the
00:08:46.800
affirmative for it to make sense. For example, there are countless things that we use for which we might
00:08:52.760
not fully understand the mechanism of action, but we might feel confident enough on some of these
00:08:57.280
other dimensions to move forward. The final question is, what is the balance of risk to reward,
00:09:02.560
including potential side effects, the magnitude of the effect, the confidence we have in the data
00:09:10.280
that speak to its safety, and the quality of the supplement itself? And this last point
00:09:15.460
is especially important here. We know from previous podcasts that I've done, including the one with
00:09:21.240
Catherine Eban, that even in the pharma world, the quality of the drug is not to be taken as a given.
00:09:27.880
That episode, which is several years old and we'll link to it, really called into question the quality
00:09:33.560
of some of the pharmacologic agents out there, especially generic brands. But whatever amount
00:09:39.240
of nefarious behavior exists over there, I think you're safe multiplying that by 10 or 100 to
00:09:46.740
understand the magnitude by which that's happening in the supplement space. So I guess before we jump
00:09:51.320
into this, Nick, I just want to make sure we've pulled together a lot of information on the six
00:09:55.180
supplements you mentioned. For the sake of time, flow, making this conversational, I'm not going
00:10:03.040
to go deep into each study that we talk about. Rather, I'm going to try to cover the important
00:10:08.220
details, but we will heavily cite, link to, and explain the details of the studies in the show notes.
00:10:14.980
So if you're listening to this because you just want to see how the framework works, great. But if
00:10:19.440
you're like, actually, for those supplements, I want to go deeper, the show notes is where to go.
00:10:23.360
Perfect. So I think let's get started with the first one, creatine. Going through the questions
00:10:29.740
in the framework, are you using creatine to correct for deficiency or trying to achieve
00:10:36.960
super maximal levels? With creatine, it's clearly the latter. I'm sure there's somebody walking around
00:10:43.200
out there with a creatine deficiency, but that's not really the use case. So when people like myself,
00:10:47.780
and I do take creatine, it's because we believe that supraphysiologic levels are preferential.
00:10:56.160
We take this primarily to improve athletic performance, potentially increasing lean mass
00:11:02.140
slightly. There are some emerging studies that suggest that it may also ameliorate cognitive decline.
00:11:09.260
And basically, research shows that once muscle stores are fully maximized,
00:11:14.340
which can be achieved with three to five grams per day, you've flattened out that curve. In other
00:11:20.980
words, you don't need to go much beyond that. Although, as we've talked about on this podcast,
00:11:25.320
there was a day for those of us that are old enough to remember when the zeitgeist was to do
00:11:31.000
a period of loading at much, much higher doses in the neighborhood of 20 grams per day before
00:11:35.640
falling to a maintenance dose of five. But today, people that are taking it are usually just taking
00:11:40.560
three to five grams per day. As far as taking it for lifespan, healthspan,
00:11:46.520
which one are people usually taking it for? Well, we certainly see no direct evidence on
00:11:51.560
lifespan. I think most people who would take this, if being confronted with the granularity of this
00:11:56.380
question in this way, would say, look, I'm taking this for healthspan. I'm maximizing the benefits of
00:12:00.080
my exercise, especially with respect to resistance training, and maybe potentially warding off
00:12:06.260
cognitive impairment. Now, of course, indirectly, I would say that those are also benefits on
00:12:10.740
lifespan. But I would say that that's probably the way to think about this.
00:12:16.180
And you kind of talked about this earlier on, but is there a specific biomarker that people can use
00:12:22.020
to track to see if the supplement's quote unquote working or not?
00:12:26.400
No, there's not a biomarker for this. And again, what do I mean by a biomarker? Well,
00:12:30.960
if you're taking a medication to lower your blood pressure, measuring your blood pressure
00:12:35.220
actually becomes a biomarker for the thing you're taking. Am I taking enough or too much?
00:12:41.260
If you're taking a drug that lowers your ApoB, the ApoB itself serves as the biomarker.
00:12:48.640
We don't have a way outside of a lab commercially to measure tissue creatine levels. So we do not have
00:12:55.060
a biomarker for this. And that's why people who take it are just sort of adhering to a protocol.
00:12:59.620
On the mechanism of action, do we have any understanding of the mechanism of action for
00:13:06.260
creatine, whether it relates to the physical or the cognitive side?
00:13:11.260
On the physical side, meaning on the muscle performance side, it's certainly pretty clear.
00:13:15.840
People will recall how energy currency is delivered. So ATP, adenosine triphosphate,
00:13:25.120
is the richest form of energy currency, and it liberates energy. So it's spent by liberating
00:13:32.660
a phosphate. So ATP becomes adenosine diphosphate, ADP. Of course, that process works in reverse. So as
00:13:40.760
we want to build up and replenish our ATP stores, we need a phosphate donor. And this is where
00:13:47.120
phosphocreatine comes in. So we do naturally have phosphocreatine. In fact, when you start to think
00:13:52.840
about the various energy systems, if I asked you, Nick, to do something that was an all-out effort
00:13:58.380
for 10 seconds, that would not require oxygen. You're not tapping into your VO2 max or your
00:14:05.520
oxygen delivery system. It's frankly not even an anaerobic activity, meaning you're not actually
00:14:11.560
turning glucose into pyruvate, into lactate, etc. If you're doing something that is such a short burst
00:14:17.820
of activity, you are really relying on the phosphocreatine system to generate the ATP for that
00:14:23.360
activity. So if you're doing a 40-yard dash, you're relying on phosphocreatine. But of course,
00:14:27.900
phosphocreatine itself is a phosphate donor, and therefore, anything that boosts the supply of
00:14:33.740
phosphocreatine boosts the supply of ATP. And it's our belief that that's effectively what it is doing,
00:14:40.620
and therefore that it's helpful with anything that requires bursts of activity. But even beyond just
00:14:46.740
the super short, extending into the anaerobic, I don't know that there are really any proven benefits
00:14:52.320
that this augments aerobic performance. So once you get into the purely oxidative phosphorylation
00:14:59.780
pathway, I mean, maybe someone will correct us, but I'm not really aware that there are benefits of
00:15:03.860
creatine in that regard. I think it's more in the first two energy systems, the phosphocreatine system
00:15:08.220
and the anaerobic system. On the cognitive side, we know that a small amount of creatine is synthesized
00:15:13.260
in the brain, and that creatine can cross the blood-brain barrier. But the brain certainly
00:15:18.460
does not take up creatine to the same extent as the muscles do. So while we have, again,
00:15:24.720
some evidence to suggest that creatine is efficacious for cognitive function, it might turn
00:15:30.040
out to be the case that you need higher doses of it. I think that's still an open question as far
00:15:34.720
as I'm concerned. You mentioned earlier that we'll put a lot of more detailed information on the data
00:15:40.140
in the show notes, but looking at a high level, what does the data around creatine say about efficacy
00:15:46.220
of it? This is a supplement that has been quite readily studied. There's reasonable evidence to
00:15:51.560
suggest, and again, we'll link to lots of it, that creatine does help improve various parameters of
00:15:57.280
muscle performance. And it's not that subtle. I mean, it's typically in the range of 5, 10, maybe even
00:16:02.500
15%. So these include things like power and hypertrophy. Again, the power shouldn't be that surprising
00:16:08.260
when you understand the mechanism of action. The hypertrophy seems to be due to the, not just the
00:16:12.840
increase in the myofibril thickness, but also in the retention of water within the muscle. And of
00:16:17.820
course, that's still considered lean mass. As I alluded to, kind of physical performance in short,
00:16:22.880
intense burst activities, and potentially some benefits in slowing down the aging phenotype of muscle
00:16:29.820
mass. Again, like I said, it's really probably best suited for high intensity and anaerobic
00:16:36.080
activities. But the one meta-analysis we'll cite to found that creatine did not really improve
00:16:42.320
endurance events in trained athletes. Again, you always could argue, well, maybe it's because they
00:16:49.480
were really well-trained and their mitochondria were well-honed. But it's possible that there's
00:16:54.280
a study where you took completely untrained athletes, had them do an aerobic task with and without
00:16:59.620
creatine, and you might indeed see a benefit there. So again, I think we're still kind of in early
00:17:03.560
days on some of this stuff. There was a 2017 review that got quite a bit of attention that
00:17:08.700
we'll link to that concluded that creatine may help with the prevention and recovery from injury.
00:17:14.160
And there have been a number of meta-analyses looking at cognition. The most recent one, which
00:17:18.440
was this year, looked at 16 RCTs and found that creatine had a positive effect on memory.
00:17:25.500
I would say long and short of it is a lot of this stuff looks very promising. There's also some
00:17:30.840
evidence that women in particular might benefit more than even men. Women have lower stores because
00:17:38.080
muscle mass is the predominant store. Women have less muscle, therefore less stores. But there might
00:17:43.360
also be less consumption through diet. So it, again, at least leads to the hypothesis that women may
00:17:49.700
benefit even disproportionately to men. There's some, I think, rather weak data that suggests that
00:17:56.320
it may help reduce depression in women. And there's some evidence to suggest that it may be helpful
00:18:01.800
during periods of rapid hormonal change. And that could be within the monthly period of a menstrual
00:18:08.780
cycle, pregnancy, perimenopause, and menopause. So you might ask, why is that the case? Well,
00:18:15.000
the creatine and phosphocreatine pathways are impacted by hormonal changes. And of course, during all of those
00:18:21.280
periods that I just mentioned, you're seeing rapid hormonal changes. So it's not
00:18:24.680
really that surprising that supplementing to supernormal levels of creatine could offset some
00:18:32.380
of those impacts. Pregnancy is a question I get asked about a lot, Nick. I would say I remain a
00:18:38.040
little bit unclear and would probably suggest that it's probably safe during pregnancy, but we just don't
00:18:44.380
have enough human data to form a strong point of view. So in my mind, the wise thing to do is to avoid
00:18:50.260
anything that is not absolutely necessary during pregnancy. So just to give an example,
00:18:54.780
when we have women in our practice that are preparing for pregnancy or pregnant themselves,
00:18:59.120
I mean, no matter what they're taking, if they're taking medication for something that they can live
00:19:03.620
without for nine months, we would absolutely stop it. So yeah, I would say women should probably dose
00:19:08.980
it at about the same doses as men, but of course they'll get more bang for that buck because they're
00:19:13.760
on average smaller. Rounding out everything we talked about with creatine, what is the balance
00:19:18.780
of risk-reward to how you see it? Seems like a lot of stuff we talked about was a lot of reward,
00:19:24.020
but how do you think about this to summarize it? I would put this in the low-risk, modest-reward
00:19:30.360
category. We do have, I think, really robust safety data here, and it looks good. If the muscle stores
00:19:36.860
are already full, the liver is probably going to metabolize the delta. The kidneys will clear the
00:19:42.280
excess. There is one thing to keep in mind. If you're a person who doesn't have perfect kidney
00:19:48.060
function, you do probably want to talk with your doctor before you take it. And this is very
00:19:53.420
important. You want to make sure that they know you're taking it before they do any blood tests to
00:19:59.740
measure your creatinine because high doses of creatine can impact serum doses of creatinine, which
00:20:07.900
we would use as one of the metrics to determine kidney function. So in our patients that have
00:20:13.680
anything but perfect kidney function, if they're taking creatine, we typically have them stop
00:20:19.380
for a couple of weeks before we do a blood test. Creatine monohydrate really is the version to take.
00:20:26.560
I don't even know if they sell anything else. They used to sell a creatine phosphate a long time ago. I
00:20:31.340
don't think that there's anybody selling that anymore. I don't think it matters, but there's just no
00:20:36.000
evidence that you need to be taking anything other than creatine monohydrate. It's wildly inexpensive
00:20:42.200
and you should be looking for the purest product only that has nothing in it. The only ingredient
00:20:47.500
should be creatine monohydrate. No fillers, no extra ingredients, unless there's some flavoring agent
00:20:52.860
that you want. But I just mix this in with an electrolyte drink. So I want nothing other than
00:20:58.220
the creatine monohydrate in the sample. Anything else you want to say on creatine before we move to the
00:21:03.980
next one, which is fish oil. Nope. Perfect. Fish oil. Another supplement that we get asked about a ton.
00:21:11.420
We've done some podcasts on it. A lot of questions on it. Seems like a lot of people take it.
00:21:16.200
And so going through the questions with fish oil. First one is, are you correcting for deficiency or are
00:21:22.140
you trying to achieve super maximal levels when it comes to fish oil? Thank you for listening to today's
00:21:28.740
sneak peek AMA episode of the drive. If you're interested in hearing the complete version of this AMA,
00:21:34.820
you'll want to become a premium member. It's extremely important to me to provide all of this content
00:21:40.060
without relying on paid ads. To do this, our work is made entirely possible by our members. And in return,
00:21:46.120
we offer exclusive member only content and benefits above and beyond what is available for free.
00:21:52.060
So if you want to take your knowledge of this space to the next level, it's our goal to ensure members
00:21:56.680
get back much more than the price of the subscription. Premium membership includes
00:22:01.120
several benefits. First, comprehensive podcast show notes that detail every topic, paper, person,
00:22:08.320
and thing that we discuss in each episode. And the word on the street is nobody's show notes rival ours.
00:22:14.460
Second, monthly ask me anything or AMA episodes. These episodes are comprised of detailed responses to
00:22:21.540
subscriber questions typically focused on a single topic and are designed to offer a great deal of
00:22:27.040
clarity and detail on topics of special interest to our members. You'll also get access to the show
00:22:31.920
notes for these episodes, of course. Third, delivery of our premium newsletter, which is put together
00:22:37.880
by our dedicated team of research analysts. This newsletter covers a wide range of topics related
00:22:43.460
to longevity and provides much more detail than our free weekly newsletter. Fourth, access to our
00:22:50.520
private podcast feed that provides you with access to every episode, including AMA's sans the spiel
00:22:56.460
you're listening to now and in your regular podcast feed. Fifth, the qualies, an additional member
00:23:03.240
only podcast we put together that serves as a highlight reel featuring the best excerpts from previous
00:23:09.460
episodes of the drive. This is a great way to catch up on previous episodes without having to go back and
00:23:14.560
listen to each one of them. And finally, other benefits that are added along the way. If you want to learn
00:23:20.100
more and access these member only benefits, you can head over to peteratiamd.com forward slash
00:23:26.280
subscribe. You can also find me on YouTube, Instagram, and Twitter, all with the handle
00:23:31.340
peteratiamd. You can also leave us review on Apple podcasts or whatever podcast player you use.
00:23:38.040
This podcast is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine,
00:23:43.760
nursing, or other professional healthcare services, including the giving of medical advice,
00:23:48.300
no doctor patient relationship is formed. The use of this information and the materials linked to this
00:23:54.600
podcast is at the user's own risk. The content on this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for
00:24:00.540
professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Users should not disregard or delay in obtaining
00:24:06.160
medical advice from any medical condition they have, and they should seek the assistance of their
00:24:11.120
healthcare professionals for any such conditions. Finally, I take all conflicts of interest very
00:24:16.480
seriously. For all of my disclosures and the companies I invest in or advise, please visit
00:24:22.080
peteratiamd.com forward slash about where I keep an up-to-date and active list of all disclosures.