The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - August 16, 2026


FREEMIUM: Epochs #276 | History of Sicily - Featuring Metatron

Hosted by
Mentioned
PREVIEW: Chronicles #59 | Childe Harold's Pilgrimage with Rory: Part III Breakfast With Beau | Monday 17th August 2026

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 17 minutes

Words per minute

184.42

Word count

14,206

Sentence count

221

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

47

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to this very special interview where I'm going to be talking to someone who's
00:00:25 got a far greater depth of historical knowledge of myself and I love doing that I absolutely love
00:00:30 it today we're in the presence of the one and only Metatron how are you sir the Muppet I'm very well
00:00:37 thank you how you doing me yeah I'm good thanks yeah I'm all good thanks for asking so whilst I've
00:00:43 got you and without too much sick of fancy you know more than I do and I love speaking to people
00:00:50 that know about the ancient world particularly and i know you're sicilian of of extraction and
00:00:56 so i thought what better thing to do than talk about sicily now there's so many things from
00:01:02 pyrrhus of epirus through to pattern in 1943 um i thought to begin with hopefully it's first of
00:01:10 many conversations uh maybe we could just go through a whole bunch of things about sicilian
00:01:15 history and you we can just chat about it and you can let me know some of your sort of real niche
00:01:20 knowledge on it is that all right with you that's actually perfect and uh what's interesting is that
00:01:25 i think i think but i mean i'm a little biased if you will but i do think sicilian history is
00:01:29 absolutely fascinating i mean at the end of the day so many powers developed in the mediterranean
00:01:35 basin and sicily is right there in the very middle we are touched by three seas you know
00:01:40 mediterranean turanian and aegean uh it's uh in the ionic so it's it's like a special place and
00:01:47 And I love to start with prehistory, for instance.
00:01:52 We can jump into the prehistory if you want, but usually people think of, unfortunately
00:01:56 when people think of Sicily, I think of Mafia, which I mean is a reality, and we can talk
00:02:01 about it if you want, it's a cultural reality, something that happens still, but I am more
00:02:06 fascinated by the ancient period in Sicily, and yeah, there is a lot of niche stuff that
00:02:12 we can say.
00:02:13 I mean yeah there's so as an Englishman you like to think being condescending to an American or
00:02:19 something as an Englishman you like think oh we've got so much history we're steeped in so much
00:02:24 history it's not a patch on Sicily right I mean Sicily really I mean the layer upon layer upon
00:02:32 layer upon layer there's so many things you could say just to start to begin to outline it like that
00:02:36 it's both blessed and cursed by history by its geography where it is right I would call it I
00:02:43 would call it the the jewel of the mediterranean lots of empires throughout history have obviously
00:02:47 thought of it that way uh that it's a crossroads of civilizations uh i'll describe it as an axis
00:02:54 on which the mediterranean has turned still does turn through the millennia um that it's been the
00:02:59 heart of trade and conquest and empires on and on so okay let's start should we go through
00:03:05 chronologically sort of basically um let's start with prehistory then so i'm sorry go ahead
00:03:09 absolutely yeah before we jump into the prehistory which is one of my favorite things there's some
00:03:14 mystery i'm going to tell you some stuff that's going to blow your mind but not not because of
00:03:18 me but because of some of the reason you know i have a team which is kind of funny because usually
00:03:21 my haters and redditors deny the existence of my team which is a way to it's flattering because
00:03:26 if they really think i do all the research like literally you're giving me all the credit i've
00:03:31 got a full team here but anyway some of the stuff we found particularly about the ancient period is
00:03:36 mind-blowing it's mind-blowing stuff very talented team and I want to give him
00:03:40 credit but I do want to start if it's okay but debunking just a couple of
00:03:44 myths so you know I live in in the United States right because I immigrated
00:03:48 here legally years ago married my wife and all that she's from here you know
00:03:53 what happened when I entered the US and I was going through customs there's the
00:03:57 immigration officer and he asks me the passport so I give him the passport he
00:04:02 asks me where are you from and I say was it on Ellis Island he wasn't on Ellis
00:04:06 island was it no no no no it's in New York so he he asks me where are you from I say Italy because
00:04:15 that's his normal quick answer he looks at the passport it of course the passport says Palermo
00:04:20 which is where I'm from my city in Sicily so he looks at me and he says oh you're Sicilian you're
00:04:26 not Italian do you mind if I debunk a myth very quickly please don't go ahead yeah get it off
00:04:31 your chest mate. Here's how it works, here's how it works. Every Sicilian is an Italian, but not
00:04:37 every Italian is a Sicilian. In other words, Sicily is a region, in fact, it's interesting
00:04:43 because it's the largest region in the entirety of Italy by land mass, we're talking at 10,000
00:04:49 square miles, I think it's in miles, and it's the fourth most populous. First foreign province
00:04:55 for the Romans, so there is a lot of history when it comes to Sicily. But what's interesting
00:05:00 is that so yeah no it italian sicilian they're not mutually exclusive it's like saying it would
00:05:06 be like telling you oh you're from london you're not english but you can be both you know what i
00:05:12 mean maybe you can look at it a bit like what british like the way you say british someone
00:05:17 can be british but you can be english you can be scott you can be welsh i get it's confusing
00:05:22 because it's an island so of course you can't be an irish man from england obviously not but it's
00:05:28 Sicilians and Italians, not mutually exclusive. You can be both. So it's just what they wanted to
00:05:32 clarify. And Italia, the word, is ancient. Because sometimes I get people in the comments getting
00:05:39 mad at me, being like, you shouldn't say Italy when you're talking about the Roman period. But
00:05:42 they did. There are literally thousands of entries of the word Italia in Latin. They used it. It's
00:05:49 just that they didn't use it in the modern sense after Giuseppe Garibaldi, the modern country of
00:05:55 Italy. They mean it geographically, usually, but like already by Dioclesian the islands were
00:06:02 considered Italy. So we're talking, we've been Italians from that point of view, at least
00:06:07 geographically, since the third century. That was just really quickly to kind of underline a thing
00:06:15 that kind of annoys me a little bit. Prehistory, yes. So I must, I imagine you heard about the
00:06:22 the three populations, the Elimoi, Sicanoi, Sikeloi.
00:06:26 Yeah.
00:06:26 The three populations, usually Sicily is divided in a map.
00:06:29 When you look at prehistory, probably has been inhabited
00:06:32 since the upper Paleolithic, early Mesolithic.
00:06:35 Have you ever heard, and I can see a lot about the populations
00:06:38 because I love them.
00:06:39 I freaking love the population. 0.99
00:06:40 The Elimoi or Elimians, I think they're called in English, 0.99
00:06:43 are my favorite, the ones in the West, because I am from the West.
00:06:46 So I'll tell you a little bit about those.
00:06:49 But I was going to say, oh, yeah, have you ever heard
00:06:51 of the cave system of Abdaura.
00:06:55 No? No?
00:06:56 Okay.
00:06:56 It's something you might want to Google.
00:06:58 So in 1997, they found,
00:07:00 so it's very recent,
00:07:01 they found this cave system,
00:07:03 which is literally like 20 minutes
00:07:04 from where I used to live
00:07:06 with my family in Sicily.
00:07:08 So right next to where I live.
00:07:10 And it was accidentally found.
00:07:12 I think there was some kind of
00:07:13 like allied ammunition explosion,
00:07:15 whatever.
00:07:16 I don't remember the exact details,
00:07:17 but they found this cave
00:07:18 and the cave is prehistoric.
00:07:19 and the cave has wall paintings and wall drawings and sketches now usually it's been dated to 11,000
00:07:26 BC so again mesolithic possibly upper paleolithic inhabitation of that area population and it's
00:07:35 fascinating stuff because usually graffiti or wall art of that type like that ancient it's usually
00:07:42 animals maybe a little bit of hunting for hunter-gatherer societies but generally speaking
00:07:46 animals not this one the caves of la daura show complex rituals uh ceremonial maybe ceremonial
00:07:54 burial but just definitely ceremonial practices and dancing 12 000 bc 11 000 bc these people are
00:08:01 dancing they're having ritual they're having society and they are writing it in the caves
00:08:06 so like who were these people right that's the first thing you ask i saw it now i think they
00:08:12 closed the site because of lack of structural integrity but when i was a child it used to be
00:08:17 one of the places where your school you take you right for school trips so i remember it
00:08:23 and uh yeah so the three people are fascinated feel free to interrupt me anytime because i talk
00:08:28 a lot the the three the my favorite than the ones in the west the um ellie moya get confused with
00:08:34 the uh with the do you consider yourself a direct descendant of those people who it's difficult to
00:08:40 I mean, I would have to do the genealogy of the century.
00:08:44 Plus, we don't exactly know who these people were.
00:08:47 There are speculations either that these are originally from the Mediterranean area.
00:08:51 Maybe they crossed during a favorable climate shift from mainland Italy.
00:08:56 But some people speculate they might be refugees from Troy.
00:09:00 So the ones from the West, it is possible.
00:09:03 I heard the ones from the East might be from like the Iberian Peninsula,
00:09:07 might be from modern day Spain. 0.55
00:09:08 That's the one in the middle. 0.85
00:09:10 That's the ones in the middle, the Sicanians. 1.00
00:09:11 Those are the ones in the middle. 0.98
00:09:12 And they are the most ancient, as far as we know.
00:09:15 The ones in the east, the Sicans, the Sicans, in English.
00:09:19 Again, I get confused with the English term.
00:09:22 The ones in the east are fascinating.
00:09:24 It's going to blow your mind.
00:09:25 They are most likely originally from Rome.
00:09:29 Rome.
00:09:30 Before the Romans were a thing.
00:09:32 So when we read the classics, long before, long before.
00:09:36 So here's the thing.
00:09:37 the original latins already as a people we imagine there is the idea that again eneas right so the
00:09:43 trojans troys destroyed the trojans eneas go to relocate the runaway this is the story we don't
00:09:49 know how much of it is myth but they relocate where do they go they go into the seven hills
00:09:54 and so they found rome but they find it inhabited that's what the myth tells us and generally
00:09:59 speaking myths are grounded in reality so i wouldn't just brush it off as a myth so the idea
00:10:04 is eneas and the trojans they find some people already in latium and we can talk about the
00:10:09 etymology of that word because it's mind-blowing but anyways they find some people and then who
00:10:15 are these people they call them the at least three authors that give us the same name ab
00:10:20 origines that's what they call them the initial people that were there and if you think about it
00:10:25 it sounds a bit like aborigines because it's exactly where that word comes from which means
00:10:30 at the origin and there is another author that calls them cascade which means the ancient ones
00:10:37 and ideally their king the name was latinus so when anas arrives with the trojans and they find
00:10:44 these people they're like let's unite and in honor of your king we'll call ourselves the latin now
00:10:49 maybe the king didn't exist but the idea that there were some people there before these trojan
00:10:54 refugees arrived and then they mix and become the romans is possible but then there are other
00:11:01 historical sources that tell us even before the aborigines arrived there were people there so who
00:11:08 were these people even before it's okay prehistoric ancestry and they tell us they are the same people 0.99
00:11:15 they will then move away because the trojans and the aborigines they are there they don't want to 0.83
00:11:20 mess with the the very ancient ones and they settle in eastern sicily and becomes the sickles 1.00
00:11:27 okay so i mean the story about um aeneas and stuff most famously um virgil's aeneid and um
00:11:35 i reread that not too long well a couple years ago uh i had to do it years and years ago when i was
00:11:39 young but reread it not so long ago and when uh aeneas goes there this is only obviously according
00:11:43 to virgil in like the first century of course bc in the age of augustus um the king he finds
00:11:49 there is turnus or that's the English translation in the book I had the king
00:11:53 that's already there is turnus and maybe that comes from latinus or something I
00:11:58 don't know I'm no linguist you're the linguist here but I personally don't
00:12:03 think that the it yeah the so the king latinos is probably it's probably a
00:12:08 made-up thing but the term latium for the area the region right the modern-day
00:12:13 Latio the region where Rome is we don't know exactly what that term means but
00:12:18 there is the possibility one of the etymological translations that it means the hidden place
00:12:22 or the hiding place so you'll be like hiding from what the romans liked that idea and they tell us
00:12:29 oh it's because there was the god saturnus and he was running away from jupiter so the king of the
00:12:36 god and he hides in this valley and that's why we call it like that now that's the mythological part
00:12:42 It's possible, however, that they called it the hidden place because the very original people lived in caves, so they were hiding because they were cave dwellers.
00:12:51 That could be a possibility.
00:12:53 It's not the only possible translation.
00:12:55 Sometimes the other possibility is that Latium comes from Latus with a long phonemic vowel, because Latus with a short phonemic vowel in Latin means side, but Latus means the expanse.
00:13:07 So it's possible that it was a valley among the hills.
00:13:10 Maybe that's where the name comes from.
00:13:12 or it comes from proto-latin latium but trying to figure out what that means is
00:13:19 well to be honest we're getting far ahead of ourselves talking about the
00:13:24 Roman period I'd like to start with well first thing before we get on to the
00:13:27 Greeks and the Phoenicians yes is there tell me about is there a megalithic
00:13:33 prehistoric megalithic structures on Sicily so you're talking about like
00:13:39 stonehenge type of stuff yeah just dry like large scale sort of um yeah stone not that i'm aware of
00:13:47 the most ancient sites that i have lived because i mean from there is usually the greek coastal
00:13:55 battlements of selinus which is selinunte modern selinunte it's in the south west uh that one is
00:14:02 probably like what three thousand years ago but that's already the bronze age so because you know
00:14:06 the south was colonized by dorian greeks so originally from northwest greece and then
00:14:10 peloponnes and then the east is colonized by ionic greeks so from attica not far away from athens
00:14:19 we're talking about magna grecia here so-called yes there was a large migration from the greek
00:14:24 world the classical greek world while talking like the eighth largely what the eighth century
00:14:29 i think famously they say corinth was the first one but of many we talk about the eighth century bc
00:14:34 the Greek people, classical Greek people, from the Aegean, moving and settling Sicily.
00:14:41 Yes. 0.99
00:14:42 Yeah, they settled the south and the east, but the northwest instead is either with these
00:14:48 original Elimians, which, again, we don't exactly know where they're from, but we know
00:14:52 that they were building cities, and one city that they found is the city of Eriks.
00:14:58 It's very ancient, it's modern-day Eriks, and it's my wife's favorite.
00:15:02 I take her there every time we go to Sicily.
00:15:04 because it's an absolutely stunning town at the top of a mountain today it looks medieval but i
00:15:11 mean it it looks like you're going back in time like it looks like you're walking around the
00:15:14 elder scrolls i did by the way put on my full plate armor and walked around the streets of erics
00:15:20 because it just it was amazing i filmed it i've got footage of it but this is ancient
00:15:25 and then right next to it the elimeans they built a port town which is modern day trapani but the
00:15:32 ancient name is a lot better and it's a drepanon which kind of it means sickle because it looked
00:15:38 like a sickle and they built it as a maritime sort of conduit for for that area so the north was was
00:15:46 from these original people then the phoenicians arrived and they built my six enormous in the
00:15:51 south you've got the greeks this is why sicily is so uh polysemic multi-ethnic but also culturally
00:15:59 linguistically you know did you know that for instance sicilian is not a dialect of italian
00:16:04 it's a dialect of latin it's not a dialect of italian so um sometimes people think because i
00:16:10 do speak it i speak both i was i was raised with both in my household so i'm native of both
00:16:14 and they're very difficult different they can be mutually unintelligible at times
00:16:18 and you know in a way sicilian is a sister language to standard italian which is based
00:16:23 on the florentine tuscan language but it's not a daughter of italian and even sicilian itself
00:16:29 it's a i don't even call it a dialect i call it a regional language because it has its own dialects
00:16:35 so sicily is split into three just like the ancient populations even linguistically
00:16:39 and then you have sub dialects that are like nine or ten depending on who you ask
00:16:43 and these are metaphonetically differently i can go into what that means if you're interested or
00:16:47 not i don't have to go into the linguistic stuff but basically even between sicilians or different
00:16:51 areas it might end up being mutually unintelligible because of all these different civilizations that
00:16:57 brought in vocabulary and language so one of the big things one of the big things then say then is
00:17:02 this mixture of both greek classical greek and phoenician peoples that's where a lot of documentaries
00:17:09 or even books really begin with sicily is starting around the 8th 7th century bc is the greeks and
00:17:15 the phoenicians who of course most people should know probably would know that they are very very
00:17:19 different and carthage is you know the the most uh the biggest most famous most important
00:17:26 phoenician settlement in the western side of the mediterranean so already long before the romans
00:17:32 before pyrrhus of epirus before even um what the athenian expedition you've got phoenicians
00:17:39 and greeks and they're fighting over in various ways they're fighting over the island
00:17:46 yeah and fighting with the original people in there as well at the same time trying to subdue 0.97
00:17:51 them the phoenicians of course we know they are semitic there are semitic people um when it comes 0.97
00:17:56 to the carthaginians so from tyre to make sure originally from tyre which is in modern day
00:18:00 lebanon isn't it modern day lebanon that's exactly yeah and then it's interesting when the connection
00:18:05 with modern day lebanon is is removed is severed and then you only have carthage on this side of
00:18:10 the world then carthage is like okay then we are taking control of the phoenician colonies including
00:18:14 palermo in the north of sicily and then there is the whole situation with rome trying to see 0.99
00:18:18 who is going to control sicily while there are still greeks but yeah they are originally they
00:18:24 are semitic definitions but actually i looked into this very recent new dna analysis and it seems
00:18:31 like that the carthagenians by the time they're carthagenians the semitic component in the dna
00:18:38 it's only a core for the nobility so the carthagenians aren't semitic anymore only a small
00:18:43 percentage of them and their dna by the time of the punic wars with the romans has changed so much
00:18:49 that now they are closely related to uh aegeans greeks and anatolian and anatolian people and
00:18:57 sardini they have the same dna as them it's interesting that it's not much sort of north
00:19:02 african it's still yeah i know it's still classical mediterranean that's very interesting 100 yeah
00:19:10 so i mean so i suppose because there's so much to say we'll have to whip through it a bit
00:19:14 let's talk a little bit about um alcibiades uh uh expedition the sicilian expedition uh if anyone's
00:19:21 right you see cities and in uh in that age what we're talking is the 400s isn't it the
00:19:28 the fifth century bc of 400s bc and the athenians decide crazy strategy as far as i've said well
00:19:36 Well, the leader of their polity at that point, Alcibiades, convinces them that they should go on a massive expedition to Sicily,
00:19:44 which in the scheme of things isn't really that close to Athens.
00:19:47 They're in the middle of a very, very decades-long war with Sparta, and they decide they're going to go to Sicily and conquer Sicily.
00:19:54 And ultimately, it's a disaster.
00:19:57 As you as a Sicilian, what do normal Sicilians in the 20th, 21st century think about Alcibiades and the Athenian expedition? 0.73
00:20:05 Is it a joke to them? Is it deadly serious stuff?
00:20:08 Well, I think most Sicilians don't even think about it much.
00:20:12 I mean, particularly the kids.
00:20:14 When we review the history, though, here's the thing.
00:20:16 I perfectly understand where they're coming from because they wanted Syracuse.
00:20:20 That's what they wanted.
00:20:22 I mean, everyone wanted Syracuse.
00:20:24 It was a powerhouse.
00:20:25 It was extremely culturally significant.
00:20:30 It was rivaling with the city-states in Greece.
00:20:33 So had they been successful, because, you know, we've got hindsight and hindsight is 2020. 0.79
00:20:38 But had they been successful, the amount of wealth that they would have got, which the Romans will get. 0.70
00:20:43 I mean, Sicily will become the granary of Rome eventually.
00:20:46 And there is a lot to say about wheat production in Sicily.
00:20:50 And that's something that it's still significant today.
00:20:54 So we can talk about that as well.
00:20:56 But first, yeah, they I think it was worth it.
00:21:00 They rolled their dice and they lost also because the Spartans interfered with the fleet.
00:21:07 So they did do that.
00:21:08 But I got to say, it was worth the try because, yes, if they had gained control over Syracuse
00:21:15 and in general, all of the grain production and the maritime trade, it would have definitely
00:21:19 repaid for the entire war 10 times over.
00:21:23 So I understand it.
00:21:24 And even as a modern Sicilian, I mean, to me, Greeks are brothers.
00:21:27 You know, we are the most Greek of all the regions in Italy.
00:21:29 so you know no no hard feelings i guess yeah i mean i definitely want to get into that a bit
00:21:35 later how how how greek sicily is in some ways i mean sort of in the byzantine period
00:21:43 i've heard it described as a greek island in a latin sea uh but we'll get on to all of that
00:21:48 we'll get into that in a moment uh before we get uh i want to ask you a little bit about
00:21:51 oh pyrrhus of epirus i'm a massive fan of the story of pyrrhus of epirus and he famously had
00:21:58 a big expedition even fighting with elephants and things wasn't he right on sicily and so
00:22:04 what are your thoughts and feelings on pyrrhus well i love that we get the expression of pyrrhic
00:22:09 victory right because the idea is he wins well except for the end when he gets murdered in the
00:22:15 final battle of his life or whatever but apart from the catastrophic ending it is interesting
00:22:19 that he was he's the one who created the expression which means you win but at extremely
00:22:25 heavy losses i mean the guy sometimes was given impossible odds and uh what do you like about
00:22:32 about i don't know the expeditions in general or the wars pyrrhus of epirus seems to me he's like
00:22:38 he's he's not quite as brilliant as alexander the great but for me it's close it's someone
00:22:44 up there it's someone like for me it's one of the all-time greats of the ancient world
00:22:48 it's a shame as you mentioned just there his final sort of quite ignominious death
00:22:52 where an old lady threw a roof tile on his head and killed him.
00:22:56 But other than that, he seems to have been an absolute badass,
00:22:59 like deliberately getting involved in single combat and stuff,
00:23:02 for real, though, not lost in the midst of time, for real,
00:23:05 if you believe the accounts.
00:23:07 And even though the Pyrrhic victories and losing loads,
00:23:11 he very, very seldom lost.
00:23:12 He just seems to be a great general, a really affable person.
00:23:17 Sorry, go ahead.
00:23:18 No, no, no, sorry, an exceptional strategist.
00:23:20 i like the fact that you're bringing up the fact of how sometimes generals fought and alexander
00:23:26 the great is another example of that he led the charges and sometimes get speared and then he
00:23:31 would literally there be that could you imagine modern day politicians leading a combat charge
00:23:36 with with a swat team or with like the commandos yeah because that's what we're talking about right
00:23:44 i mean medieval kings would stay in the rear i think classical antiquity is more heroic when
00:23:48 it comes to that although then again it kind of depends the romans they usually let the centurions
00:23:53 deal with it like the romans but they are ready to fight i mean they've got their uh bodyguards
00:23:58 right the um praetorian the predators they are like initially bodyguards of generals but the
00:24:05 generals are ready to fight they're in armor if something happens the general is gonna fight it's
00:24:09 like they know that that's gonna happen well there's definitely some examples from medieval
00:24:14 history the first thing obviously always springs to my mind is henry the fifth king henry the fifth
00:24:18 of England got involved in actual
00:24:20 combat on the field of Agincourt but there's
00:24:22 quite a lot of examples but in the ancient world it's even more
00:24:24 something, Alexander's supposed to have something like
00:24:26 30 odd wounds on his body
00:24:28 by the time he died, battle scars
00:24:29 being over the wall first, being the point
00:24:32 of a cavalry charge more than once
00:24:34 in a big battle and Pyrrhus just seems
00:24:36 to have been one of those guys, he would throw
00:24:38 himself into the middle
00:24:40 of a maelstrom
00:24:41 it's just great ancient stuff
00:24:44 it almost is like
00:24:46 legend although the history the literary accounts are to be believed i think i think i think it's
00:24:52 possible because these are a different they are cut from a different cloth ancient commanders
00:24:57 like that and in fact perus to me is even more impressive and let me tell you why because in
00:25:01 alexander and i love alexander the great that's my son's middle name is alexander so i gave him
00:25:06 that name but here's the thing uh he there was a psychological aspect to it alexander believed
00:25:12 truly to be a god he believed to be divine so i think that that influenced his decision as well
00:25:18 still brave and whatnot but i think he actually really did believe that there was divinity in him
00:25:23 he wasn't just a mere mortal um with someone like pyrrhus i don't think he believed that but he still
00:25:28 did it still did it yeah right still did it okay so we're talking there about like the late 300s
00:25:37 So it's not long after that, let's get to the Punic War, the first Punic War, and that's really where the Romans and the Carthaginians first really start vying for full control as sort of the sole superpower of the Mediterranean, at least Western Mediterranean world, and it's fought over Sicily.
00:25:57 it's very long war isn't it it's like 20 odd years long a very grinding sort of a war of attrition
00:26:03 almost in sicily and the whole time the thing that i thought remarkable that a lot of people
00:26:08 is often lost when we talk about the first punic war is there's already sicilians there it's not
00:26:12 just like a mostly empty island and the carthaginians and the romans are fighting over it it's like
00:26:16 there's loads of other factions in there as well lots and it's just one giant mess it seems to me
00:26:22 but um again i would love to know what a real sicilian thinks about that those that know about 0.75
00:26:29 it anyway i mean is that taught in your schools is it something to be embarrassed about is it
00:26:33 something you're very proud of i don't know you tell me no yeah no it's just history we love our
00:26:38 history it's uh yeah of course we go through the entirety of the thing and besides we read the
00:26:42 odyssey and in the odyssey the sicilian populations are mentioned um homer does mention the both the
00:26:49 the Eastern ones, the Sickles, and he mentioned the Sicanians.
00:26:51 It's just that he treats them as one people,
00:26:54 so it's possible that there was some assimilation by then
00:26:56 through Magna Gracchia and all that.
00:27:00 But what's interesting is, so we're in 264 BC
00:27:03 with the First Punic War.
00:27:04 But here is something interesting.
00:27:05 Have you ever heard of this idea that the Romans
00:27:09 didn't have a navy before the First Punic War,
00:27:12 but then because of the conflict with Carthage,
00:27:16 that's when they make a navy.
00:27:18 And that's wrong, it's a myth.
00:27:21 So if you want, we can address it because,
00:27:23 but it's an educated myth because it comes from Polybius.
00:27:28 So it's not something that people, Polybius does say,
00:27:31 oh yeah, the Romans didn't have a fleet,
00:27:33 but then the Carthaginians,
00:27:34 the situation with Sicily happened.
00:27:35 So they build 100 quinque remes and 23 remes.
00:27:40 He tells us the type of ships.
00:27:42 The thing is though, that he's been hyperbolic
00:27:44 and we know that.
00:27:45 Well, what he means is not that literally
00:27:47 the Romans didn't have a fleet because I can give you a date from when the Romans
00:27:51 began their fleet and it's a long time before that and I can get that date from
00:27:56 him so I can use Polybius to the bank Polybius in Chile. So what happened and
00:28:00 it's not the only ones Deodorus Siculus, Dionysus of Alicarnassus speak about it,
00:28:05 Titus Livius speak about the Roman fleet. So what happened is that in 509 BC, so
00:28:11 we're almost 300 years before the war, the Carthaginians write a treaty with the
00:28:17 Romans. Polybius tells us about it. And in this treaty, the Carthaginians tell the Romans,
00:28:22 you shall not traverse with your fleet. They're mentioning a fleet, a Roman fleet. They say,
00:28:28 you will not have your vessels cross this line. And they give us the name of a settlement,
00:28:33 which is in modern day Tunisia. I think, I don't remember the ancient name, the modern name. I
00:28:37 think the French protectorate in the 1800s called it Cape Lafarina, but I don't remember the ancient
00:28:43 name. Anyways, it's in Tunisia. And they tell us, you shall not cross this line because otherwise
00:28:47 it's war that's what the Carthaginian Republic tells the Romans but then they
00:28:51 add two caveats and this is when it gets fascinating caveat number one if it's a
00:28:55 tempest or a storm and you end up crossing it not a big deal just leave
00:28:59 second if you are engaging in naval combat and you need to retreat from your
00:29:04 enemies you can cross it but then you need to go back so what naval combat
00:29:09 if the Romans said name why are the Carthaginians even bothered I mean if 0.98
00:29:13 it was a bunch of fishermen why would they even care so they do consider 0.76
00:29:17 them a possible threat and they tell us you know you're not going to cross this and that's one
00:29:21 thing this the second thing is that the romans take a city called uh antium and it's a pirate
00:29:28 city and they take it and then what do they do they confiscate the the vessels and that's when
00:29:35 roman piracy begins and you know who mentions roman piracy alexander the great he says they're
00:29:41 pestering him he's annoyed by them because of course they you know there was no roman empire
00:29:46 but there was already a republic when alexander great was doing his thing it's not like yeah of
00:29:51 course yeah and uh so the romans did have a fleet they had a navy what changed is that in the first
00:29:57 punic war they are they humped up they went for a rearming and they built a significant fleet that
00:30:04 now could compete with the uh naval supremacy that the carthaginian had had up to that point
00:30:10 maybe you can remind me whether it's in polybius or maybe it's in livy the story i guess it's just
00:30:17 low resolution or maybe even apocryphal but that the romans somehow got seized uh a carthaginian
00:30:24 ship and they sort of um and they uh what was the word they they back engineered it that yeah
00:30:30 back engineered it took it apart and even found yes that the carthaginians uh made so many ships
00:30:37 that on each individual segment it was almost like lego or something you could it was shown how to
00:30:43 put it together by and so the romans were able to back engineer it and copy it effectively um
00:30:49 and aren't we told that that's during the first period or just before the first period course
00:30:53 something like that um and i can't remember if i think it might be livy that's in but um
00:30:58 so but that and they say that's the first time the romans ever had a navy but you're quite right
00:31:03 that can't be the case i can tell you the first time i can tell you the first time they ever
00:31:08 built the first ship it's in 620 bc when they founded ostia well now it's called ostia it's
00:31:14 ostia tiberina whatever uh they it's the first colony that rome ever built on the coastline
00:31:21 that's when they started making the very first vessels not as advanced as this because this is
00:31:26 completely different but uh it's no the romans have been dealing with the mediterranean well
00:31:31 Why wouldn't they?
00:31:32 They are a Mediterranean power.
00:31:34 Yeah.
00:31:34 Right?
00:31:34 Yeah.
00:31:35 I've been to Austria once,
00:31:37 and the beach had loads of cigarettes all over it,
00:31:40 littered with cigarettes.
00:31:41 I know, and I hate it. 0.94
00:31:43 But, okay, so the first Punic War,
00:31:46 the Romans win in the end, basically. 0.97
00:31:48 The idea is that all the Carthaginians
00:31:50 were pushed off of Sicily, if they really were.
00:31:53 And had to pay a lot of silver, yeah.
00:31:55 Yeah.
00:31:56 But, oh, God, there's already, there's so much to say.
00:31:58 So, I mean, Archimedes, quickly mention Archimedes.
00:32:01 Oh, yeah.
00:32:01 Surely every Sicilian child is brought up with the story of Archimedes?
00:32:06 100%.
00:32:06 Yeah, 100%.
00:32:07 We study him, the engines, the machines, the battlements,
00:32:11 the defense mechanisms, all the inventions.
00:32:13 It's insane.
00:32:14 Could you imagine what you could build in terms of machines?
00:32:17 Because these are machines.
00:32:18 It's just that it's Bronze Age, Iron Age, and classical antiquity.
00:32:22 It's their technology, right?
00:32:24 So the stuff that they can build with ropes and metal,
00:32:27 although, if you want, at one point, 0.94
00:32:29 maybe let's go through the Punic War,
00:32:31 because there are a couple of things i want to tell you about the second but then we can talk
00:32:34 about there is one type of screw that the it is attributed possibly to archimedes but in general
00:32:41 it's called the greek screw it's a bronze type of um construction that the romans used for mining
00:32:48 and they possibly took it from the egyptians and it's a fascinating story because it's going to
00:32:53 blow your mind how the romans did mining operation under under the soil and they had to consider
00:32:58 the oxygen and water displacement.
00:33:01 It's insane how advanced they were with this stuff.
00:33:05 So we can go into it if you want.
00:33:07 But, yeah, no, Archimedes is, I mean,
00:33:11 one at a time, genius of the era, 100%.
00:33:15 I guess it's one of those, I imagine,
00:33:17 it's one of those people that's in your history
00:33:19 that you're just very, very proud of the way
00:33:22 we might, Englishmen might be proud of,
00:33:24 I don't know, Isaac Newton or something,
00:33:26 Or, you know, something like that
00:33:28 It's just one of your all-time greats
00:33:30 But yeah, because there's a lot of Roman mining in Cornwall
00:33:35 Obviously in a later period, much later period
00:33:37 But there's actually, I actually studied Roman Britain a lot
00:33:40 And after a while you read enough, read around Roman Britain
00:33:44 Eventually they'll talk about the tin mines in Cornwall
00:33:47 Right, of course
00:33:48 Yeah, remarkable, yeah, not until really the 18th century was it surpassed
00:33:54 um yeah yeah absolutely incredible absolutely incredible yeah they had two were two ways to
00:33:59 mine they had vertical sorry horizontal mining operations and vertical mining operations the
00:34:05 vertical ones could go relatively deep not as deep as modern mining but then again that the heat
00:34:10 conditions and the lack of oxygen would have off them but they knew that so what they do is that
00:34:16 they use this uh this this greek or egyptian screw as they call it and what they do is that
00:34:22 they create a machine a wooden machine that can redirect underwater river flow so that it doesn't
00:34:28 flood and it can pump out the water it tells us of what rate and it can pump out the water and then
00:34:34 they use these like candles to see if there is oxygen they keep going down but then they have
00:34:39 to check if there is oxygen it's insane like a stuff that they can come up with it's remarkable
00:34:45 to think that both the greek world or ancient sicily even or the romans came very close perhaps
00:34:51 you could argue came very close to an industrial revolution because the first steam engines the
00:34:57 first pistons ever which is like the main component of of an engine was britain in the 18th century
00:35:05 or or late 17th yeah no 18th century um in order to pump water out of mayans right yeah there we
00:35:11 go right so so if the romans or the greeks had made a couple of little with the the genius of
00:35:16 archimedes and the and the elbow grease of the romans they were right there they're right there
00:35:22 a couple of little things and we might be two thousand years further ahead in human development
00:35:27 at this point but ah if you think about it i mean roman cement they figured out a way for it to
00:35:33 self-heal underwater so they compounded the chemicals in it in a way that the constituents
00:35:41 in a way this is of course the trial and error that's how ancient people do it but experiential
00:35:45 knowledge is not to be underestimated when you've got hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of years
00:35:49 of continuous trial and error and so they figured out this way whereby when the cement goes underwater
00:35:54 it whenever it cracks the water enters and it re sort of resurrects it and repairs it
00:36:01 automatically can you imagine that like roman cement in fact still stays strong today yes
00:36:09 it's remarkable in fact i watched something a little while ago probably a year ago now but
00:36:12 it was a little documentary just talking about the cement used in the coliseum specifically yes
00:36:18 and how remarkable like the chemical they they you know they analyzed it in a modern modern
00:36:24 scientific way the chemical makeup of it where they sort of couldn't believe how how perfect it
00:36:29 was really um yeah and even even pompey um just the other day i was hearing an interview with
00:36:35 christopher nolan and he was talking about like oh ancient people you know they didn't have a
00:36:40 modern scientific understanding so to them everything was gods and the fire is gone and 0.65
00:36:44 i'm like you clown you never opened a source have you because here's the thing when you actually
00:36:49 read how the romans reacted to the explosion of vesuvius and how you know pompeii right if you 0.90
00:36:56 read because you would imagine oh probably the romans thought the god vulcanus is punishing us
00:37:01 maybe some people thought that i'm not denying it but if you look at the historians the the emperors
00:37:06 no the first thing the emperors say we need to send aid so they organize very well put together
00:37:12 aid to go and help the victims then they try to figure out the physical causes like they are very
00:37:18 pragmatic it's insane when you read it and in fact they even try to figure out why the soil after the
00:37:22 lava and the explosion it becomes more fertile and they don't say well the gods blessed us no they
00:37:27 say probably it creates a layer of fat around there now they were wrong but they tried to explain it
00:37:33 through physical reality and observation which is very modern if you think about it and have you
00:37:40 ever thought the question why did they even try to build a settlement near a volcano like
00:37:45 wasuvius like wouldn't that be dangerous the i i asked myself that question and i found the answer
00:37:51 together with the team and it's actually mind-blowing the reason is they didn't know
00:37:57 because the previous now it's not documented but now we know because of geometric analysis
00:38:03 the previous explosion or eruption of the volcano was prehistoric so nobody knew they didn't know
00:38:10 it was a volcano now it looks obvious because you see it's got it looks like this because it
00:38:15 exploded if you look at drawings from the period before the explosion it looks like a it has a peak
00:38:21 it looks like a whole top of it blew off was it plenty the elder is it plenty the elder that gave
00:38:27 the account at the time yeah and uh yeah now it looks like a two double peak thing with yeah but
00:38:32 But at the time, they thought it was just a hill or at least a dormant volcano.
00:38:37 Because there's Herculaneum, which is even closer, isn't there?
00:38:40 I've been there.
00:38:41 Herculaneum is right on the side of the mountain, basically.
00:38:47 It's crazy how close that is.
00:38:50 But, okay, because there's so much to get through.
00:38:51 So, I guess, montage through the next few centuries,
00:38:57 because this is then the height of the Roman period,
00:39:00 from after the first punic war all the way up to the fall of rome in the west and now we're talking
00:39:07 like the fifth century a.d right for that whole time as you've said sicily exists as uh not just
00:39:14 a part of the roman republic and empire but a key part of it sort of their first overseas territory
00:39:21 and acts as something like a bread basket for rome and yes um so so that whole period is when
00:39:29 would you say this is the question um sicily becomes less greek and more roman is that fair
00:39:38 to say or is that just silly low resolution and i've got it all wrong no no for sure i mean you
00:39:44 can be a little bit of both because at the end of the day even in our language we use terms that are
00:39:47 clearly greek related um so you can tell there is and besides we do remember that even though
00:39:53 the romans conquered the greek temples are still there so there is still a lot of greek
00:39:59 architecture there and in fact we've got i think we have the most well-preserved temples in the
00:40:05 world when it comes to ancient greece they're in sicily so our temples are better there was an
00:40:08 earthquake in the selenus area uh but you know suggests that there are still temples that are
00:40:14 standing and you can go and experience them it's like the value of temples in agrigento for instance
00:40:19 that's the most famous ones but there are other areas that are less famous and to me more beautiful
00:40:24 where you still see the paved koto and the altars
00:40:28 where the population, the Greeks,
00:40:31 were doing sacrifices for the gods
00:40:33 in terms of grapes and food and stuff like that.
00:40:37 They're still there. You can see them.
00:40:39 You can still walk the battlements.
00:40:40 3,000 years old, they're still almost,
00:40:42 not intact, but like that.
00:40:45 There is one thing I wanted to tell you
00:40:46 about the Second Punic War.
00:40:48 So there is a lot to say,
00:40:50 but Scipio Africanus, one of the things he did
00:40:52 when he was dealing with Hannibal,
00:40:54 which by the way Hannibal was in Italy for like 13 years it's insane how long like we often when
00:41:00 we brush through it we don't realize how long freaking Hannibal was in Italy and they couldn't
00:41:05 get him out but it's very famous how Scipio Africanus decides I'm gonna take the Iberian
00:41:10 Peninsula and then he does the counter-attack in in Carthage, Zama and whatnot but I would like to
00:41:15 very quickly focus on what happened when he took the Iberian Peninsula because this is something
00:41:20 they always get wrong in every documentary i swear every documentary of video game so the
00:41:26 iberian peninsula belongs to carthage until roman troops go there and take it when the romans take
00:41:33 it one of the settlements that they take which is a celtiberian the celtic people is full of
00:41:38 blacksmiths these are the blacksmiths that invent the gladius in fact the first iteration is the
00:41:44 gladius hispaniensis from hispania the iberian peninsula so for any battle that you represent
00:41:53 graphically that happens before the romans in the second punic war take the iberian peninsula
00:41:58 the romans should not have a gladius the carthaginians should have a gladius because
00:42:02 the romans take the gladius when they take the iberian peninsula and then it becomes the roman
00:42:08 sword so a lot of situations you see the carthaginians with these like kind of falcata
00:42:14 looking swords. And the Romans have the gladius. I'm like, no, it's the other way around.
00:42:18 The Romans don't have the gladius at this time. They have three types of swords, in fact,
00:42:22 one of which looks a bit like a falcata. The rest look like a mixture between Celtic designs
00:42:26 because of Northern Italy and Greek designs. And it's the Carthaginians that have the gladius. 0.64
00:42:31 The Romans just take it from them once they take the entire opida with the blacksmiths. There were 0.73
00:42:36 like at least, I think, a hundred blacksmiths. The Romans confiscate them and say, okay,
00:42:39 mass producer we want this and in fact before this they weren't even using metal umbo they were using 0.74
00:42:45 wooden protection for the for the shield and then they because they take these so like it's it's
00:42:51 every time i see video games and i see why are the romans using a gladius before they take
00:42:55 like in the first punic war absolutely not yeah like the first punic wars romans fighting against
00:43:01 brennus or like any depiction of the early kings all the romans are using gladius no no that would
00:43:08 know it's like we know when it happened we even know i actually have the name of this settlement
00:43:14 somewhere let me see if i can find it numantia that's the name of the that's where they engineered
00:43:19 the gladius and i'm not sure what the modern name i mean at the end of the day the romans always
00:43:24 change names even paris paris today is the it kind of because the original name was parisi
00:43:31 but the romans called it lutetia so the romans conquer it change the name because that's what
00:43:36 they do and then they start digging and they create the stone underground quarries that they
00:43:44 used to then build the city which is now the labyrinth of Paris it's it's part of it it was
00:43:50 expanded in the Middle Ages the underground of Paris is insane if you go in there you'll never
00:43:54 come out some of which are ancient Roman mines because they were literally mining downstairs
00:43:59 downstairs taking the stones build the rest of the town but then eventually they want to go back to
00:44:04 you know afterwards they're like no we want to call it paris because the romans didn't call it
00:44:07 that they called the lutetia wasn't the parisi more like the tribe yeah but also the settlement
00:44:15 both yeah because you have adnonyms endonyms and depending on how people call themselves
00:44:20 and that kind of stuff okay so when the roman empire in the west finally falls
00:44:26 Sicily isn't necessarily immediately conquered by anyone else but we get well we would get into
00:44:35 the period of what like the vandals and the and the Ostrogoths people like Theodoric and stuff
00:44:42 how do Sicilians how do you view that period is that something that is well because as an
00:44:49 Englishman when I talk when I think about and when I talk about time particular times when
00:44:54 britain might have been invaded sometimes the feeling is like the romans you're like oh well
00:45:00 good on you you as a good opponent and you won fair and square and other times it's like like
00:45:05 viking invasion you think oh they're mean they're the baddies i'm not okay with that i'm not cool 0.54
00:45:09 with that do you feel sicilians feel like that about like the vandals and the ostrogoths or is
00:45:14 it or is it are you indifferent about it yeah i think we're a little indifferent about it only
00:45:19 because it wasn't long enough to define us as a culture whereas if you look at
00:45:24 the crown of Aragon in Spain if you look at the Norman conquest those right have
00:45:28 left or even the Saracens those have left buildings architecture and the
00:45:33 Byzantine that is visible today so you have Islamic structures you have a
00:45:39 Spanish or Baroque for instance as well so all of that is insisting in its
00:45:43 visual and the other thing is for me like I would say I kind of look
00:45:48 stereotypical for an italian but like in my class in my classrooms and this is a little anecdotal i
00:45:54 get it but just to give an idea in every classroom that i've ever been to as a child growing up
00:46:00 out of like 20 22 students three were blondes with blue eyes so the the norman the norman
00:46:06 influence is there ethnically you can see it it's not weird to us some people have a darker
00:46:13 complexion than me some people look exactly like me and at the end of the day it is because of the
00:46:18 ethnic makeup of all of these different civilizations that stayed stayed for a few
00:46:21 hundred years and then you know they were replaced by someone else because everybody wanted sicily at
00:46:26 the end of the day okay so to go through a little bit um chronologically okay so after the fall of
00:46:31 the roman empire in the west uh we've got vandals ostrogoths theodoric something like that but then
00:46:37 the campaigns of justinian the first and belisarius and the reconquest of italy and sicily at least
00:46:43 for a little bit by the eastern roman empire the by the byzantine yeah yeah so i guess that is as
00:46:51 you just said basically that is a much bigger part and then there's still lots and lots of
00:46:55 there's lots of byzantine architecture still there to this day yeah yeah and the art the christian
00:47:03 art particularly uh in fact when i went to the metropolitan museum of art which contains a lot
00:47:09 of european stuff like a lot i don't even know why we we sold them everything so anyways there
00:47:14 is a lot of like crucifixes and art that comes from that period specifically that area uh it's
00:47:20 mind-blowing the to me i think if you visit for instance palermo right um it's the norman
00:47:29 architecture that is the one that gets to me uh there is the palazzo dei normanni so norman palace
00:47:35 or like the cathedrals that were built as well
00:47:38 during the Middle Ages,
00:47:40 those are really the architecture
00:47:42 that every Sicilian will know.
00:47:45 The Byzantines, absolutely,
00:47:48 but I think that's like for history buffs.
00:47:51 But if you want to know
00:47:52 what the general population recognizes,
00:47:55 it's the Norman medieval period
00:47:57 and the kind of architecture
00:47:59 and structures and cathedrals,
00:48:00 those any Sicilian,
00:48:02 even if you ask a fishmonger,
00:48:04 they will know about it.
00:48:05 Right, okay
00:48:06 Well one question I wanted to ask
00:48:07 I don't want to spend too much time on it
00:48:09 Or get in too deep
00:48:10 Or any sort of controversy
00:48:11 But the tension
00:48:15 If that's even the right word
00:48:17 Between Orthodox Roman Catholicism 0.88
00:48:21 And Eastern Roman
00:48:25 Eastern Orthodox
00:48:26 Yeah, Eastern Orthodox
00:48:30 Eastern Orthodox, yeah
00:48:31 And so in Sicily
00:48:33 um there's you there's both of course but for you in your mind
00:48:38 try to try to explain for me a little bit what what that's like are most people
00:48:44 christians anyway are most of them catholic or like most of them eastern orthodox or
00:48:49 everyone everyone is everyone is roman catholic okay literally everyone is roman catholic right
00:48:54 so uh the reality besides so that that's it i think it's it we are too disconnected from that
00:49:01 period to have any remnant of eastern orthodoxy i've never met an eastern orthodox in my life
00:49:08 maybe they exist i'm not saying but i've never met one in my life okay so everyone yeah everyone
00:49:13 is a romano catholico apostolico romano so roman catholic right and uh okay yeah that's pretty much
00:49:20 it honestly it's really that's okay fair enough yeah yeah so so just before we get to the normans
00:49:26 then got to talk a little bit about the uh the abbassids ultimately the fatimids the islamic
00:49:34 invasions before and that was before the normans right right right and so there's a period there
00:49:39 is anyone getting the the trend the pattern that lots and lots of different empires and peoples 0.92
00:49:44 have uh anyone you realize it so next next up next up to bat is the uh the muslims from north
00:49:52 africa yes yes right and so tell me a little bit about modern day sicilian people's thoughts and
00:49:58 feelings about all of that there's lots of mosques aren't there yeah um active mosques i don't think
00:50:04 there are that many there are some repurposed buildings that occasionally used to be mosques
00:50:08 like you can see the it's called a cupola i'm not sure what the term is in english but basically
00:50:12 like the spherical uh roof that you see on top of that we see them in palermo all over the place
00:50:17 some have been turned into Christian churches by the way a function Christian
00:50:22 churches so that has happened I'm not sure yeah there are very again I've only
00:50:28 met one would you say active Muslim really but then again that's maybe that
00:50:38 just has to I guess this just has to do with and then again now it's different
00:50:42 with the immigration situation that it's happening in Europe it's a different
00:50:45 context but i think yeah i mean what they i think what they wanted to do was what they did in spain
00:50:50 it's just that it didn't last that long okay pretty much okay well so then yeah on to the
00:50:57 normans then so now we're talking the 11th century right it's actually about the time of
00:51:01 the norman invasion of britain the 1060s right it's the exact same time and so the normans come
00:51:08 in there and i mean it takes a it takes a few generations it's not like one battle or anything
00:51:12 but um and so this is like this is western europe now this is this is the frankish people
00:51:18 coming in and it's their turn next up to bat is them and i just want to reiterate there's still
00:51:25 the ancient sicilian people there and all the other layers of of conquest and migration and
00:51:32 all that sort of thing all one on top of the other still like a palimpset like and so on top of that
00:51:37 now normans but they stay there for a long time and as you're telling me uh you know they've you
00:51:43 can tell a big imprint of it physically architecturally to this day is still there and still
00:51:51 important yes and uh it's uh and linguistically there are some words that kind of sound
00:51:59 like you could tell they they have a connection to norman french uh that we have in our language
00:52:05 the sicilian language but you don't find in standard italian because of that and personally
00:52:11 the the norman palace and the cathedrals are what to me are some of the most impressive in fact
00:52:17 the cathedral of palermo is phenomenal and of course with that one then we'll have to go into
00:52:22 the kingdom of the two sicilies at one point but the the it you could tell how rich it was
00:52:28 because now you know after the unification of italy the rich part of the country is the north
00:52:33 but the south used to be the rich part of the country it's just that it got the relocated a
00:52:38 lot the resources were relocated for us it wasn't a great deal i want to be honest not that i'm a
00:52:42 secessionist what i want to separate that no i'm more than happy to be italian but i'm saying like
00:52:48 it used to be like if you look at the architecture there's no way you're going to think okay this is
00:52:52 place is like opulent it's insane in fact the cathedral of palermo is huge but lots of statues
00:52:58 but the cathedral of monreale which is a smaller town on the top of the mountain right next to
00:53:02 to palermo the inside is all gold leaf everything is gold inside the the entirety of the structural
00:53:11 and it's fun because even the cathedral sometimes the type of architecture borrows from muslim or
00:53:18 islamic arches but to build a christian it's a mixture you can see benzentine decorations as
00:53:25 well so when you look at one structure sometimes it's mixed so yeah yeah okay we learned this from
00:53:31 from those guys we learned this one these other guys let's put it all together and build an
00:53:34 incredible structure and um as i say there's this huge imagine of of cristo panto creatore so you
00:53:41 have like the christ as a creator and then it's all gold it's all gold it's like mind-blowing
00:53:48 like the expense of something like that is insane uh one could even argue but i mean
00:53:55 jesus was poor so i mean one could argue that yeah whatever yeah yeah tell a medieval king that
00:54:02 go tell a medieval king that i was gonna say as a as a sort of a an anglican church of england
00:54:09 northern european protestant that's all in terribly bad taste as far as we could say
00:54:17 a church must be a whitewashed empty hall with no glass with no stained glass certainly no gold
00:54:24 i'm okay no gold but i'm keeping the stained glasses because those are incredible
00:54:29 of course yeah now one thing i would say at this point i just want to reiterate something we said
00:54:33 right at the beginning that um sicily its geographical position uh means that it really
00:54:38 has been a crossroads a key to the mediterranean so by this point already we've had people from
00:54:44 as far away as uh the the holy land from tyre from lebanon and from scandinavia the normans
00:54:52 are really from scandinavia they're norsemen first and foremost yes so you've got people
00:54:57 from scandinavia and from lebanon and and they end up in sicily one way or another just an
00:55:05 absolutely remarkable fact really but so there's a couple of the key sort of norman kings would be
00:55:10 roger roger the first and roger the second roger the second are they known are they household names
00:55:14 in sicily oh yeah if you say ruggiero secondo that's how we say roger the second everyone
00:55:20 i would say everyone who has had an education i mean i guess it depends who you talk to but in
00:55:24 general yes these are well-known names uh because again they are history and i guess even if you go
00:55:29 into a minute school trip because they take you it is cool and i think that's great like middle
00:55:34 school you take the kids and then you show them all of these structures and architectures and
00:55:39 buildings which are still the medieval ones are in fantastic condition and i want to be honest
00:55:44 with you even the ancient sites are still in good conditions um i just wish that the italian
00:55:51 government and specifically sicilian authorities they used it better they cared they because as
00:55:57 you say sometimes the some areas are let down a little bit or they are not they don't have like
00:56:02 the ingenuity that both english and americans have where you guys are great are using your
00:56:08 own sites and your own things too like you know how to make money and business we are great we
00:56:14 get a lot of tourism but then sometimes they will block areas you gotta pay like at one point i even
00:56:20 asked a formal permission to film i tell you this i asked a formal permission to film in this ancient
00:56:27 greek area in sicily and they rejected it and i'm like but why and they said well you need to pay
00:56:32 us five thousand dollars a day and i told them i can't do that this is at the beginning of my
00:56:36 channel i'm like you're joking i'm not i'm not nolan i'm not a hollywood but i i said and at
00:56:42 the time i was a full-time teacher i was teaching in high school so i said but this is great because
00:56:48 the students we can make a mini documentary and the students gonna love it like our own people
00:56:53 are gonna know about the history we're gonna dress we're gonna be dressed up in historically
00:56:58 accurate gear and we're gonna do this they still said no so i did it anyways without their permission
00:57:04 ha ha ha brilliant classic classic yeah screw them yeah because because the rule was you can't
00:57:11 use a tripod that was the rule they said you can't put the tripod down like okay so i removed the
00:57:15 tripod and we filmed it freehand it wasn't breaking the law that way yeah brilliant brilliant well so
00:57:21 going through i mean after after norman's what you've got like at the house of hauenstaufen
00:57:28 right right so so now we're talking sort of more or germanic peoples i mean frederick ii
00:57:35 literally the holy roman emperor oh yeah this is this is a german this is now these are now germans
00:57:41 they're next up to bat to have a pop in sicily the germans i mean is frederick the second sort
00:57:48 of uh and i think or would you have to be like a real history nerd to to ever know really no
00:57:53 would have to be a history yeah you would have to be like either a student a young student who
00:57:57 paid attention in class so you would have to be like a history buff it's actually funny because
00:58:01 the the holy roman empire wasn't holy wasn't wasn't roman and definitely wasn't an empire
00:58:05 but hey it's it's pr it's pr it's it's like it's like subway here white bread they call it italian
00:58:12 which is just white bread with better pr that's what it is it's funny i've heard someone argue
00:58:17 that the holy roman empire because that's almost a cliche it's not holy it's not roman yeah it's
00:58:21 not an empire it's a cliche people argue no it is holy it definitely is roman and 100% it's an
00:58:26 empire what are you talking about i've heard people argue both ways but no i'm of the opinion
00:58:31 that yeah it's not holy it's not roman it's not an empire but okay so then we got like charles of
00:58:37 anjou right the angevins the angevin empire so i mean they're french essentially what today we
00:58:44 call france anyway so it's like so the germans just had a pop now now the french and then you
00:58:49 mentioned um arrogant peter the third right spanish effectively so the germans the french the
00:58:55 spanish it just keeps going on and on it never stops does it i want to tell you one thing that
00:59:01 is interesting you can tell the french and spanish conquered that area the italian word to say work
00:59:08 work or to work let's say the verb is lavorare that's how we say to work lavorare the sicilian
00:59:16 word is travagliare interestingly enough trabajar in spanish and travailler in french and we say
00:59:23 travagliare so clearly the sicilians got these plans to buy those all right there is that like
00:59:29 you could tell even in like everyday when this is everyday language people speak it it's still
00:59:34 a language that is spoken uh in sicily we speak both we just alternate is there any particular
00:59:40 a particular bit out of all these various uh invasions and conquests that you guys aren't
00:59:47 particularly happy with or particularly proud with for example i'll give you one example
00:59:52 in english history there's one point um during i think it's true i can't remember i think it's
00:59:58 during the age of king john something like that i think it's just after where the french king
01:00:03 one of the louis came over to london invaded england came over to london got into london
01:00:10 installed himself as king of england but then within months a few months was for political
01:00:15 reasons was deposed and sent back to france and english history largely really really quite largely
01:00:22 tries to paper over that and no one really ever talks about it and you'd have to be a real history
01:00:26 nerd who even ever heard of it and it's one of those things where it's like well we don't we
01:00:29 don't talk about that we don't that like barely happened it's not a thing is there any is there 0.99
01:00:34 any bit in sicilian anywhere out of all of these where you know sicilians are like we don't like
01:00:39 even the islamic invasions you're like oh yeah we okay we're not gonna really dwell on that yeah
01:00:45 i mean i don't i think it's it's large enough that you can't really consider it a footnote in
01:00:50 history but i think today due to the current geopolitical situation probably if you ask a
01:00:56 of sicilians they're gonna be mad about muslims coming in the country and then of course if you
01:01:01 bring up the idea of uh but the muslims already did invade then you could be like yeah and they're 0.65
01:01:08 invading again so i guess but that's a modern thing so when i was a kid it was just history
01:01:14 you know just like the normans just like this just like that but of course we're christians so
01:01:19 obviously we we consider it a happy ending that we kicked them out and because otherwise i would 1.00
01:01:24 be speaking arabic to you right now uh but the reality is that no one really saw it in at least 0.77
01:01:30 as i was growing up as anything but history in fact i don't think we have any i've got friends
01:01:35 who are from tunisia and uh grew up together never was a problem i think it's the current
01:01:41 political situation with the way some not not that i want to go into immigration politics and
01:01:46 stuff like that but it's a changing now because of the current political scenario but in general
01:01:52 all of these invasions are just looked at as well it's just a tuesday all right i guess i
01:01:58 say i mean is there any one of them i guess i guess you've sort of already answered it with
01:02:02 that question with that answer but are there any ones that are like you're particularly happy or
01:02:07 probably like are you proud to have been such a core part of the roman world or or like you're
01:02:12 particularly proud of like i don't know uh roger ii or something i think at least that could be me
01:02:20 but i was brought up like my mom when i was eight she was reading me the iliad the odyssey the n8
01:02:26 and all that stuff so i am proud of the sicilian component sorry of the greek component in this
01:02:31 greek right okay and uh so that is the one thing that i would say i'm mostly proud that and rome
01:02:38 probably are the two things uh the most also because again depends where you go there is this
01:02:44 incredible villa called villa romana del casale in sicily where it's like roman and all the
01:02:50 frescoes you see all the oftentimes if you google roman gladiators you're seeing frescoes from this
01:02:55 villa or mosaic from this villa in sicily because it was the villa of the posh romans that would go
01:03:01 and relocate to spend the holiday in sicily because of the beautiful mediterranean weather
01:03:05 nothing has changed so you still see the villa and all the frescoes and that's where you see
01:03:10 have you ever seen those images that look like there are women using dumbbells wearing bikini
01:03:15 yeah that's where it's from that's the villa that's the place all right okay I
01:03:20 didn't know that yeah so they look like that's a place and it's in Sicily and
01:03:24 it's a gorgeous very well-preserved villa where you can see all the different
01:03:28 sections where people would go and do the sauna then cool down then exercise
01:03:33 and that kind of stuff but then if you move a little bit further east then not
01:03:38 not Naxos built by the ancient Greeks with all of the ancient structures still
01:03:43 that so literally depending on turn left or turn right greek or roman that's how it's going to end
01:03:47 up a great put a great way of putting it a great way of putting it now there's there's so much
01:03:51 and i'm conscious of time um and there's loads of things i'd want to talk to you about the 20th
01:03:58 century um i know it's a bit of a jump perhaps from that's fine the crown of aragon and someone
01:04:05 like peter iii straight to sort of the the 20th century but talk to me a little bit about mussolini
01:04:11 What do you and what do Sicilians feel about Italian fascism and Mussolini
01:04:19 Is he a complete embarrassment or not at all
01:04:22 I know lots of Italian people who aren't even particularly right wing 0.88
01:04:25 Certainly not what you'd call fascist
01:04:27 But they're not embarrassed by Mussolini, far from it
01:04:29 They think he did very great things
01:04:31 What's your thought of this
01:04:33 And what's the average Sicilian person's feeling about that
01:04:39 Yeah, so Benito Mussolini, it is, in my opinion, a dark chapter in Italian history,
01:04:44 as it is for any 20th century totalitarian regime,
01:04:48 whether it be the Austrian painter fan club in Germany.
01:04:51 I don't want to get you to monetize, so I'm not saying the word.
01:04:54 Or whether it be the USSR with Stalin.
01:04:57 I mean, they're all, the totalitarian regimes remove freedom,
01:04:59 and so when you remove freedom, it's a catastrophe.
01:05:01 But with Giovanni Gentile, so the writer of the theory of fascism,
01:05:05 and benito mussolini um they the the one thing they did right was architecture so if you go to
01:05:13 the central post office in my city in palermo it's a fascist building and it's gorgeous like
01:05:19 the huge columns the imposing almost square like structures art deco stuff yeah i think that's the
01:05:28 term i'm not sure but they so the structure is great i guess they've made advancements in sports
01:05:33 but in general he was a warmonger and generally speaking again I don't know how many people
01:05:39 consider fascism a good thing in Sicily or in Italy in general most people see it as a dark
01:05:45 chapter in our history the also because I mean at the end of the day we did lose anyway and 0.86
01:05:49 interestingly enough the Sicilians specifically when the Americans the allied forces entered
01:05:54 through Sicily Sicilians didn't fight they didn't want to they didn't want to have anything to do
01:05:59 accept it. He's like, yeah, come in.
01:06:01 That was the next thing, before we get on to the actual
01:06:03 invasion in 1943, or
01:06:05 liberation of it. One thing
01:06:07 I want to say just before we move on from Mussolini
01:06:09 is something
01:06:11 I've heard some Italian people say,
01:06:14 and I've even heard it
01:06:15 written about, I've read it about,
01:06:17 one of the things he
01:06:19 did do was
01:06:21 fight against
01:06:24 the Mafia.
01:06:26 yeah now is that really true is that is there a lot of myth going on there what's your thoughts
01:06:33 and feelings on that did he really do much there and if so was it good was it ultimately good
01:06:38 you tell me i i think it was a pr campaign because the idea is uh the mafia is is a reality even
01:06:46 today it's real if you open any business in sicily you have to give a percentage to them
01:06:51 or they'll burn it to the ground. 0.95
01:06:53 So it's just how it is.
01:06:54 And the reality is that he did say that he was going to do that.
01:07:00 And he did, as far as I understand, again,
01:07:02 I'm not a specialist of modern history,
01:07:04 so you might need to double check.
01:07:05 But as far as I know, he definitely tried.
01:07:08 The problem with the mafia is that it's not easy to stomp out.
01:07:12 I mean, even when I was a child,
01:07:14 I remember I was 10 in elementary school,
01:07:16 and they suspended the class because there was a judge
01:07:20 called Falcone he was an anti-mafia judge and mafia exploded him they blew up they basically
01:07:27 placed TNT and explosives underneath the the bridge and the asphalt so that when the cars
01:07:33 would go through would explode and the student we remember that because we wore the shirts
01:07:38 because the mafia killed two judges Falcone and Borsellino and Borsellino was exploding they made
01:07:46 his car explode in front of his mother's house when he turned on the ignition and as 10 year
01:07:52 olds i remember wearing the anti-mafia shirts at school because they had taken out the anti-mafia
01:07:58 judges that's insane but the anti-mafia judges should be the most well-guarded of all the judges
01:08:04 because they are the ones to try to prosecute no i know the story all about falcone absolutely
01:08:08 yeah um so one thing i'll say before we go on again before we just get on to um 1943
01:08:15 um there's the book you know um mario puzzo's um the the godfather the original book then the
01:08:25 second book his second book is just called the sicilian and in that that's not the events that
01:08:32 you see in the film godfather part two the the the filmmakers that made the godfather decided to
01:08:38 just not really do that book because that book michael corleone is in it a little bit as a bit
01:08:43 part but it's all about sicily and people the sicilian people um militias fighting in the hills
01:08:52 and fighting the local mafia and the the corleone family michael corleone is very very tiny mentioned
01:09:00 a few times in it the whole book is about it's set on sicily about sicily about the culture and
01:09:07 about yeah it's very very deep i don't know if you've ever read it but i read it about two years
01:09:12 ago uh roughly and uh it's it's brilliant it's absolutely brilliant i i i'm sure you would i'm
01:09:18 sure you would like it in fact i'd love for you to read it and tell me what was nonsense in it and
01:09:22 what rings true for you uh but if you haven't read it yeah i'm sure he did his research so in
01:09:29 19... Sorry, go ahead.
01:09:32 Just one thing I want to tell you.
01:09:33 Of course, Corleone, famous.
01:09:36 Have you ever heard of
01:09:37 the mafia boss Totorina? 0.99
01:09:40 The Rina family? 0.99
01:09:42 Is he the one that 1.00
01:09:43 was only caught a few years ago
01:09:45 and he was very, very, very old?
01:09:47 He was like in his 90s, but they finally caught him
01:09:49 a few years ago. Yeah, I remember that.
01:09:51 I remember that his
01:09:53 name...
01:09:55 I remember my mum, she wouldn't
01:09:57 even say it out loud inside our house so like literally there's no one there's no one and my
01:10:04 mom would say she would whisper it and i said oh totorina she's like shh this is what i'm talking
01:10:10 about like in our house like no one on the third floor for second floor of an apartment building
01:10:15 because sicily has a lot of tall apartment buildings unless you go to the rural areas 0.93
01:10:19 and she was this is how this is how frightened people were of the reina family she wouldn't
01:10:25 even say like voldemort basically yeah right yeah he who cannot be named fascinating so in in 1943
01:10:33 the allies the united states great britain as a fair amount of canadians actually after we've won
01:10:43 the north african campaign against rommel and the italians in north africa uh that before there's the
01:10:49 actual invasion of mainland italy there's the uh liberation of sicily and you've got pattern there
01:10:56 and you've got monti you've got montgomery and um and and so i suppose well again you tell me
01:11:02 your grandparents lived through that did they and is that is that a thing you were told loads about
01:11:07 when you were growing up is it again is it something to be proud of is it something you
01:11:12 guys are ashamed of i really don't know well how do you how is it dealt with yeah in general
01:11:18 Sicilians is like proud of the fact that we are accepted the allies that we
01:11:22 were fed up with the fascists but one thing I'll tell you is this because I
01:11:26 do have a family history with that so my my so half of my family is all
01:11:32 Sicilian and I was brought up and bread goodness gracious what's the word I can't
01:11:38 remember the expression bone and bread there you go in Sicily but the other
01:11:41 half is northern my dad is from the Northeast and the the Friuli region and
01:11:45 And interestingly enough, his father was a colonel, I think, colonel major in the army, Alpine Deployment Unit for Artillery, I think it was.
01:11:56 And he refused to join the fascist party.
01:12:02 So the fascists arrested him and they gave him to the Nazi officers who took him to Dachau concentration camp.
01:12:10 so my grandfather ended up in the cow and stayed there for a few years so my grandmother imagine
01:12:18 went through hell and then the american soldiers liberated the cow right before they were going
01:12:23 to execute him so he survived and that's when he had my dad so i kind of owe my existence to allied
01:12:29 forces i have to say that so um having this kind of so he so this grandfather of mine on the north
01:12:37 He eventually joined the partisans.
01:12:42 And one thing about partisans is that
01:12:43 they weren't all communists, by the way,
01:12:45 because sometimes people think the partisans
01:12:47 were socialists and communists,
01:12:48 but by the end of the war, everyone was fed up with it.
01:12:52 The centrist, right-leaning people, right-wing,
01:12:54 everybody, they didn't even care at that point.
01:12:56 They just didn't want to deal with the fascists anymore.
01:12:58 And he was one of those, no socialist, no communist,
01:13:01 but he joined the partisans
01:13:03 for the anti-fascist opposition resistance.
01:13:07 Whereas down south, my grandfather down south,
01:13:11 I'm not sure, I know he moved around a lot.
01:13:14 At that time, I think he was in Sicily,
01:13:16 but he was a banker.
01:13:19 So, and his wife a pianist,
01:13:21 it was kind of a special situation.
01:13:23 I'm not sure if he had to deal too much with that,
01:13:25 but in general, yeah, Sicilians welcome the allied forces.
01:13:29 We're like, yeah, please come in.
01:13:31 One of the things that is sort of usually gets talked about if you watch a documentary or read a book about the about the Sicilian campaign in 43 is that they like to point out that a lot of a lot of American intelligence, military intelligence was bound up with, again, American US Sicilian mafia, where they had family deep, deep, deep connections still to Sicily.
01:13:56 And there was all sorts of intelligence and espionage and counter espionage going on on behalf of the Allies and the Americans behind enemy lines, essentially.
01:14:07 And that really, really helped defeat the fascists.
01:14:11 Again, from what you know, is that more myth than reality or was that a really big element of it?
01:14:19 Yeah, I mean, I think at that point you'd have to ask a specialist.
01:14:22 It wouldn't surprise me, though.
01:14:23 and the reason why it wouldn't surprise me is because i think mafia is an awful thing and the
01:14:28 stuff they do like if you if you tell on them they'll melt you in acid that's one thing they
01:14:33 used to do even up to the 90s or like they will wall you alive inside a building and let you there
01:14:39 to die as you're walled behind bricks stuff like that so mafia is awful but mafia does in its awful
01:14:45 aspects it also brings in order in a way that unfortunately has some positive ramifications
01:14:52 and let me tell you one if even today but this happened 10 years ago it doesn't matter if you 1.00
01:14:59 walk around milan there will be like foreigners or like we call them extra comunitari but like i 1.00
01:15:06 don't know people who are like come there and they just want to grape women mess with women 1.00
01:15:12 and whether it be i don't know where they're from but you know what i'm talking about 1.00
01:15:16 whatever ethnic group it is they start causing trouble and they're foreigners and it happens 0.95
01:15:20 in milan it happens a lot women are afraid of going out at night never in sicily you don't touch 0.87
01:15:26 a sicilian woman why because the mafia is going to melt you in acid so like it's an awful thing 0.92
01:15:31 but in this case at least they're doing what the government is supposed to do which is protect the 1.00
01:15:37 local population so this is one positive aspect i've never heard of a foreigner causing trouble
01:15:42 in sicily when it comes to like oh they're messing with their women never heard it in my life 0.99
01:15:48 interesting
01:15:50 very very interesting
01:15:52 I didn't want to spend a massive
01:15:55 amount of digging like really really
01:15:57 digging into the
01:15:59 Matthew with you because one it's a bit of a cliche
01:16:01 isn't it two there's so many
01:16:03 more interesting things to say
01:16:05 about Sicily I mean
01:16:07 if you're ever good enough to give
01:16:09 me a bit more of your time one day I'd love
01:16:11 to take any one of those things we've talked about
01:16:13 today and just do an hour an hour and a half
01:16:15 just on that
01:16:16 sounds good um but okay i mean i'm gonna have to draw it to a close there
01:16:21 uh i would just say once again without being too sick and fancy about it thank you very much for
01:16:26 your time i really really appreciate it and if you ever want to come on again just say the word
01:16:31 anything you want to talk about at all i would be i would be more than happy to sit here and chat to
01:16:37 you so um if you can let people know where they can see if anyone doesn't know who you are i can't
01:16:41 believe that's the case but let them know where they can let them know where they can get get you
01:16:45 absolutely but thank you so much for your time i really appreciated it fantastic time
01:16:50 thank you all right well there you go that's metatron ladies and gentlemen
01:16:56 i hope you've enjoyed that and uh and well until next time then take care take care