The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - May 20, 2026


Makerfield or Bust

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
PREVIEW: Brokenomics | Market Update May 2026 Breakfast With Beau | Thursday 21st May 2026

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 14 minutes

Words per minute

182.49

Word count

13,630

Sentence count

347

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

26

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Andy Burnham is standing against Keir Starmer in the upcoming by-election in Wigan's Makerfield, but what does that mean for the rest of the Labour Party? And why is this even a thing?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 folks welcome to another one of our political chats where today we're going to be talking about
00:00:04 the battle for makerfield so in wigan there is a constituency called makerfield and it has been
00:00:10 triggered for a by-election by the resignation of labor mp john simons now sorry josh simons
00:00:17 now this has been done in order to allow andy burnham the current mayor of manchester to have
00:00:24 a run at the um parliament so that he can trigger a leadership challenge against kia starmer and
00:00:31 save the labor party well i mean that's a theory isn't it that's the goal i mean it's the point
00:00:37 let's say you do get andy burnham everything is still going to be broken yes you're just
00:00:43 going to have a different person and it i i think that we'll talk about andy burnham's record
00:00:49 at some point as well because it's not as uh actually amazing as it might seem well there
00:00:55 is there is a reason that he didn't get on in westminster politics and he he went off to um
00:01:01 to manchester yes he he's not coming from manchester because he is a once-in-a-generation
00:01:07 politician who took westminster by storm that that is not what happened it's certainly not
00:01:14 so for anyone doesn't know Andy Burnham represents basically the last great hope of the sort of soft
00:01:20 left faction uh he's been endorsed by Angela Rayner and he's to the left of Wes Streeting
00:01:28 Wes Streeting represents the the kind of uh Blairite managerialists who really are lined up
00:01:35 behind Keir Starmer but have realized that Keir Starmer is the kiss of death is he though because
00:01:40 I mean, there's a joke that they tell inside the Labour Party,
00:01:45 which is a Blairite, a Corbynite and a soft left MP
00:01:48 walks into a bar and the barman says, hello, Andy.
00:01:52 They do.
00:01:53 And this is because Andy Burnham is not,
00:01:59 he's not someone who's excessively ideological.
00:02:03 No.
00:02:03 But he's in that milieu.
00:02:06 And I mean, you can say something similar about Starmer as well.
00:02:10 There's a lot of sort of factional positioning in Labour.
00:02:14 I mean, you think of Starmer's rise back in Corbyn
00:02:17 and then betraying Corbyn
00:02:18 and then essentially stomping on the entire Labour Party itself
00:02:23 and showing complete contempt for it.
00:02:27 Some people are quite hard to pin down,
00:02:29 but Burnham, he's got a bit of everything in him.
00:02:33 That is true, hence the joke.
00:02:35 I mean, people are finding these videos
00:02:37 of things that you said over the years,
00:02:38 but you can also find a video of him saying the opposite because he he he just he's out for his
00:02:44 career yes he does seem like something of a careerist uh but i i i always hate having to
00:02:51 hold that against someone it's like you you wanted to be successful and they feel you took moves to
00:02:55 be successful it always feels a bit cynical to use that as an angle of attack so i'm i'm yeah
00:03:01 not really in favor of saying oh it's careerism i mean there is something to be said for getting
00:03:05 in a class of politicians who don't particularly want to be politicians who'd rather be doing
00:03:09 something else there is yeah but also uh andy burnham has had some consistencies over the
00:03:15 years right so for example he's wanted to have um uh state-run institutions uh such as you know
00:03:22 water the buses take manchester for example uh and you know various other um what they feel as
00:03:28 vital public services uh they'd like to be owned by the government and to be honest with you there's
00:03:33 an argument there to be made yes so it's i don't view him through this particularly an exclusively
00:03:40 cynical lens of just being a careerist no i just sort of somewhat reject the suggestion of you
00:03:45 know labor's got its soft left and it's hard left and it's right we're starting from a position
00:03:50 where state spending in this country is 45 of gdp and indirectly controls another 25 and that's not
00:03:57 enough our government compared to china communist china as a proportion of gdp our government is
00:04:05 twice the size of china's well remember remember we've covered this before the soviet union was
00:04:10 50 of gdp when it fell so anyway let's get back to makerfield um so makefield is like i said a
00:04:17 constituency in wigan and these are the results for the 2024 election and see josh simons won it
00:04:23 by quite a healthy margin, to be honest.
00:04:27 Yes, he did.
00:04:28 But I don't know if you've got 2019,
00:04:30 because 2019 is perhaps even a stronger example
00:04:32 because the whole story of 2019
00:04:34 was the red wall has become a blue wall.
00:04:38 That was Boris Johnson's absolutely storming election
00:04:41 where he won a majority of 80.
00:04:44 Even in 2019, Labour won it with a solid majority of 5,000.
00:04:50 So this part of the red wall didn't even go blue.
00:04:53 This is a proper, proper Labour constituency.
00:04:57 Yes, this is one of those constituencies that has just always been Labour
00:05:01 since the invention of democracy in this country.
00:05:05 Labour are losing these, which is remarkable.
00:05:08 I mean, but that's a great point that you make.
00:05:11 It's a healthy margin, but it's not that healthy,
00:05:14 considering what the constituency is.
00:05:16 Yeah, but I mean, this election was not the worst setup for Labour, actually.
00:05:25 But yeah.
00:05:26 Yeah, no, it was fine, which is why they won it.
00:05:28 A 45% vote share, which is very respectable.
00:05:32 The interesting thing is, for us, I think, that the turnout was only 52%.
00:05:38 So 48% of the constituency just didn't bother.
00:05:43 Now, the question here, then, is, well,
00:05:46 why did reform fail to turn out the other half of the electorate?
00:05:50 Well, yeah, it's almost as if what this constituency really needs 0.67
00:05:53 is a party that's really good at getting non-voters back in the voting system.
00:05:56 Yeah.
00:05:57 And it's the same with Gorton and Denton,
00:05:59 where you had about 47%, I think it was, turn out.
00:06:02 Despite it being a by-election and national attention,
00:06:05 because the argument will be,
00:06:08 oh, but by-elections they get more, they get more attention.
00:06:10 Well, how come reform didn't do it there either?
00:06:12 Yeah. And yeah, exactly. How is it you didn't mobilize the white working class there? So anyway, as you can see, there's no other options from this particular election. The Conservatives, Liberal Democrats, Greens, and other, no chance in hell, frankly, of them winning.
00:06:33 I suspect Greens will do a lot better this time.
00:06:35 maybe but um we'll get on to the uh information about the seat actually let's talk about the seat
00:06:42 so this is a 65 leave voting area which is pretty um levy um there we go some details there um it's
00:06:52 got an average income of 32 000 pounds 150 000 pounds the average house price 58 percent of
00:06:58 people are employed 47 of them home homeowners weirdly uh only 32 of them are married in this
00:07:05 sort of area you'd have expected marriage rates to have been a lot higher it's not a student area
00:07:08 is it it's not a student area it doesn't have a university and it's 95 96 percent white english
00:07:14 that's worrying yeah you'd expect the marriage rates to be a bit bloody higher wouldn't you
00:07:20 yeah um especially with the house prices being 150k yeah but uh i mean i'm not sure what the
00:07:27 difference between locality and ward is on this one but it says in the seat 47 which is about on
00:07:32 average for the country so maybe i'm misreading that but um but anyway it's as you can still see
00:07:38 it's 68 christian so um this is indicative of uh the sort of working class areas that have been
00:07:47 left behind in the country and so actually 90 percent white 97 yeah wow okay so i don't see
00:07:56 that much anymore in in in the big cities no but it's quite proximal to uh manchester and other
00:08:03 areas of wigan right that are not 97 white quite so uh like like with clacton and great yarmouth
00:08:11 uh actually this is not so terribly dissimilar i mean this looks like the sort of seat that
00:08:18 reform would expect to do well in yes and they have done well in actually we'll get to that in
00:08:25 a minute um we've got some further information here uh oh yeah here's the by-election information
00:08:32 uh from 20 uh sorry the local uh oh no what am i looking at here uh oh yeah sorry there's just
00:08:40 further information so the other right these are these are salvation uh forecasts and as you can
00:08:46 see uh labor predicted with a candidate other than burnham to be absolutely swatted by reform
00:08:54 But if they have Burnham as the candidate,
00:08:56 it's expected that he will squeak in.
00:09:00 Now, whether...
00:09:01 So wait, Burnham's personal vote is 18-20%?
00:09:06 Yeah.
00:09:06 That's a hell of a personal vote.
00:09:08 He's the only Labour politician who has a positive approval rating.
00:09:14 That's because he's the only Labour politician
00:09:15 that anyone has heard of who isn't in Westminster.
00:09:18 That's why.
00:09:18 I suspect a lot of people haven't heard of him either.
00:09:21 i mean if you were to walk around just you know somerset moors or something and say what do you
00:09:27 think of andy burnham yeah i'm sure people in wigan have yeah well exactly yeah and so it's
00:09:31 i think it's very regional um but in this region which he happens to be running in yes sensibly
00:09:38 um standing in sorry uh he's he's got a lot of political cachet here and he's generally
00:09:44 viewed in a positive manner because he seems i mean and just on a personal he seems like a really
00:09:50 nice guy right he does seem like a nice chap he's not an inhuman automaton like he may have a soul
00:09:58 and he may dream unlike somebody yeah he he comes across a lot more like the kind of naive uh student
00:10:06 politician of a sort of Angela Rayner type right so it's she she she wants good things and not bad
00:10:13 things yes she likes people they she doesn't hate the country and whatnot best intention unfortunately
00:10:18 clueless yeah that's that's genuinely how he comes across and also he's one of the few in
00:10:24 labor who's receptive to the idea that actually the white working class being left behind by
00:10:29 labor's dance with the radical left under corbyn and extreme blair as a blairite managerialism
00:10:36 has not won any favors and what not won any affections from a seat like this right he's
00:10:43 actually quite uh switched on to this because of course this is like the ex-industrial heartland
00:10:48 of northern england so these are these are people who feel and rightly so i think yes betrayed by
00:10:56 labor and that's why the local election results they they got completely spanked by reform in
00:11:01 every seat in every ward in uh makerfield uh reform won them all so it's difficult to go on
00:11:10 the limited information i have but from from the limited reaching out to people who actually from
00:11:14 this area tell me they absolutely hate Labour yeah they feel utterly utterly betrayed and
00:11:23 actually the guy I was talking to is saying well don't don't think that just because Andy Burnham
00:11:28 is running that means they're all going to vote for him because because even if he does come in
00:11:33 and save Labour they don't want that yeah they want Labour Party destroyed much of the same way
00:11:38 as we felt about the Tories a few years ago and a massive problem that the Labour Party have is of
00:11:42 course keir starman now burnham's primary argument here is well i'm running to unseat keir starman
00:11:49 in fact we'll get into that in a little bit so uh burnham does have a kind of mimetic weapon to use
00:11:54 against that line of attack um but i don't know i mean i've fooled me once shame on you fool me
00:12:03 twice fool me a third fourth and fifth time okay andy burnham comes knocking saying well hey i'm
00:12:08 here to change the labor party you know do i want to change the labor party so i'm not a man of a
00:12:13 left so i it's i suppose maybe i i have no right to make this claim but i am a creature of the
00:12:19 right and when kemi came along and said well look i know we've betrayed you for every single past
00:12:26 tory government but trust me with me it's going to be different i'm like no no i i don't think i
00:12:33 find that persuasive maybe people on the left will find it persuasive if you just change the
00:12:38 leader you know i don't know so i think i think it's important that we actually um define left
00:12:45 and right because these are usually um ideological signifiers uh and so we are quite comfortable
00:12:51 saying zach polanski is on the left because zach polanski is ideologically essentially just a
00:12:57 communist right i i don't think zach polanski has any kind of uh thoroughgoing political or
00:13:03 ideological uh or philosophical understanding of the left um i just think he understands it well
00:13:09 enough to be able to parrot it in interviews and whenever he's dragged off script you can see he
00:13:14 kind of starts just spitting fascist at people but but there's no first order thinking going on
00:13:19 no no well no no no it's not even that it's it's all first order thinking it's all uh rationalistic
00:13:24 front of the brain without any kind of deep understanding of the theories that led up to
00:13:29 this point right um that's not what what wigan and makerfield are as far as i can tell just to
00:13:37 be clear i've never been there so i'm just judging from an outsider's perspective but that's not what
00:13:41 this looks like to me so to call them left is not to call them left in an ideological sense
00:13:45 but more in a practical sense and we've spoken about this before but i think it's worth reiterating
00:13:50 I think there are real differences between the North and the South in what they expect out of life.
00:13:57 And I think that the North, the industrial heartland of England, much like the Welsh Valleys, are not full of entrepreneurs.
00:14:05 They're not full of people who are ruthless capitalists, who expect essentially a kind of life of unlimited and unbounded freedom to pursue their own ends.
00:14:14 what these people are i think uh like with the people in the welsh valleys is the people who
00:14:21 for 250 years were the industrial backbone of an empire so philosophically their worldview
00:14:31 was completely contained within the idea of duty and obligation right northerners are definitely
00:14:38 much more somewheres than your average southerner very much so um and so but the
00:14:45 but the the perspective is a lot more sort of old british old english we we are providing
00:14:54 for the empire and therefore you know as duty and obligation yes and so duty and obligation not just
00:15:01 the local communities but to the country at large and so and also they expect the same from their
00:15:06 leaders they they expect we give you duty you give us obligation yes they we break our bodies
00:15:12 to spend our lives producing the steel the manufacturing the coal that the empire uses
00:15:19 to crush our enemies abroad you make sure we are well taken care of yes this so these are people
00:15:25 that fundamentally believe in national industries i mean the old trope is the british army is is
00:15:32 northern um soldiers southern officers yeah absolutely but and and this this is the i think
00:15:39 the north's view on the economy as well and this is why in the north um like if you look at the
00:15:45 politicians like you know burnham angela rayner and those sorts of types um they they do not
00:15:52 have the same kind of like thatcherite view essex man has yeah in in the south of england
00:16:00 we've got a much more skeptical view of state intervention in the economy
00:16:05 because we didn't grow up in generations upon generations and generations
00:16:09 of people who worked almost exclusively in state industries, right?
00:16:15 So these people would have worked in the steelworks or the shipyards
00:16:19 or in Wales, the coal mines and things like that.
00:16:21 These are not entrepreneurial industries.
00:16:24 these are industries that were of strategic importance for the british state and therefore
00:16:31 controlled by the british state and therefore these people lived in actually a very quite rigid
00:16:36 um yes market right you are going to grow up and if you're in wales you're going to become a coal
00:16:41 miner if you're in some way about wigan you're going to be a steel worker or something a factory
00:16:45 worker or something like this right so it's the furnace of britain not the shop front exactly
00:16:50 right and so one thing on the right that we have to understand is that that means that these people
00:16:54 will they're deeply patriotic people as you can see from the election results but they're not
00:17:02 rabid free market capitalists and but they're also not dogmatic marxists right so a lot of
00:17:10 people will say what they expect out of life is socialism and only in the most general sense
00:17:17 if you were to sort of narrow it down to any kind of ideological doctrine of socialism all of these
00:17:23 people would reject it as being anti-british right and so like the the the socialism of it
00:17:29 is actually the kind of uh paternalistic uh patrician social you've got to remember that
00:17:36 the the socialism of you know the the 80s and before um was very much against open borders
00:17:43 completely the the the left-wing position was european union borders all of it it was always
00:17:49 a right-wing idea, bringing in cheap labour,
00:17:52 and that was completely rejected by it.
00:17:53 It was only really when Tony Blair came in.
00:17:57 And what he did is he skewed the British left
00:18:01 from being a somewhere organisation
00:18:04 to being a globalist organisation.
00:18:06 Completely correct.
00:18:08 And you still see the sort of lingering remnants of it
00:18:13 in people like Bernie Sanders and Jeremy Corbyn,
00:18:15 that kind of old left, that were sceptical.
00:18:18 Yes. 0.52
00:18:19 Bernie Sanders calling it a Koch brothers plan is correct.
00:18:21 Exactly.
00:18:22 And even though Blair broke it
00:18:24 because they had been voting for the Labour Party for generations.
00:18:28 Where else are we going to go?
00:18:29 Yeah, their parents, their grandparents, their great-grandparents,
00:18:32 their great-great-grandparents had all voted Labour.
00:18:35 Probably going back to the very beginning of democracy.
00:18:38 Yeah, the beginning of the Labour Party, certainly.
00:18:41 Absolutely.
00:18:41 And so when Tony Blair broke that model,
00:18:45 it didn't turn off on a dime.
00:18:47 No.
00:18:47 but i think i think the penny has truly dropped in the north now that that this brand of left
00:18:54 wingism is is nothing like your values yes and this is what the wigan local election results show
00:18:59 where um literally reform won every ward uh and so this this is the kind of place that it is as
00:19:07 far as i can tell i think i have a bead on it there um and so this leads us into uh i guess
00:19:16 we'll just have a look at the current polling it's not changed dramatically reform have had
00:19:19 a very slight bump from the local elections uh but not much of one frankly and if i were reform
00:19:26 i would have hoped for a much bigger bump out of this so the landscape hasn't dramatically changed
00:19:32 it really hasn't has it um and so i guess we'll begin with okay well what's the state of play in
00:19:36 the labor party well starmer has said i'm not resigning now the rumors were that he was going
00:19:42 set out a timetable for his resignation yeah that he was just going to accept that everyone around
00:19:49 him they've been making all of these maneuvers that have been quite public and so kiss camera
00:19:53 seen them all and he's just impervious to it i i may have made a bet on the on the last
00:20:00 on the last podcast that he that he would be gone um at this point you're a tenner don't you i'd
00:20:09 I'd better pay up.
00:20:10 There we go.
00:20:11 Good point, yeah.
00:20:12 There we go.
00:20:13 I'll get that afterwards.
00:20:15 That's a good point.
00:20:16 I forgot all about that, but yeah.
00:20:17 Hopefully I can still feed my children tonight.
00:20:21 Yeah, I lost that one.
00:20:22 Fair and square.
00:20:23 Should have made it a grand, shouldn't I?
00:20:25 Anyway, so I told you he wasn't going to resign
00:20:27 because Starmer holds the rest of his party in utter contempt.
00:20:31 And I just thought he's U-turned on absolutely everything.
00:20:34 Why can't a U-turn on this?
00:20:36 I'm not going to U-turn on hating the people around me.
00:20:39 Well, that's an eternal...
00:20:40 He's not going to be able to do anything now. 0.99
00:20:45 No civil servant is going to bust their arse over the weekend 0.97
00:20:48 on some project of his. 0.98
00:20:50 No ministers are going to take it.
00:20:52 Nobody is going to be listening to this man.
00:20:54 Only if he truly crushes them all in some sort of leadership election
00:20:58 will he be able to gain any kind of political capital back, I think.
00:21:02 Wes Streeting has resigned from his government.
00:21:04 He's not actually declared because it's rumoured
00:21:08 and it was assumed that West Street only got 44 people to back him.
00:21:12 He needs AC1, so he couldn't actually trigger it.
00:21:15 And Keir Starmer just came out and said,
00:21:17 nothing's been triggered, I'm going to carry on.
00:21:18 44 would have been enough until one of the first things Starmer did
00:21:22 is he changed the rules when he came in and he changed it from 40 to 80
00:21:26 precisely because he could foresee a situation 0.99
00:21:29 where his soulless arse was going to get voted out of office. 0.99
00:21:32 Yep, Keir Starlin was properly on it. 0.98
00:21:35 so um anyway uh basically what's going to happen well you gov thinks that essentially
00:21:41 west street is going nowhere and if starmer is challenged by west streeting uh 59 uh sorry um
00:21:50 no 65 think that uh starmer would be preferable to streeting he only got 15 of the labor membership
00:21:57 backing him in that if you're west streeting he's got to really burn that you can't win
00:22:05 against Keir Starmer in a popularity contest.
00:22:12 The most unpopular prime minister since records began
00:22:15 and West Street can't beat him.
00:22:17 I mean, Starmer, the reason we're supporting Starmer
00:22:20 in all of this is because Starmer is leading the Labour Party
00:22:23 to absolute destruction.
00:22:24 I've got to say, it doesn't bother me.
00:22:26 I don't care.
00:22:27 I think it's great.
00:22:28 No, it doesn't bother me who gets in
00:22:30 because this idea that Andy Burnham will save Labour,
00:22:34 nothing will change absolutely nothing will change they're all going to have the same set
00:22:39 of constraints they're all going to have the same fact that we we've run out of money in
00:22:43 let me let me pin that because we will come back to exactly okay because you have correctly
00:22:49 presaged precisely what's going to be the case yes uh but anyway as you can see from the polling
00:22:54 uh burnham is on 47 compared to 37 31 for uh first preference of lady leadership over starmer so it
00:23:04 is likely that if burnham can get in and he will be able to get enough signatures to trigger trigger
00:23:09 a leadership election starmer has already said he's not standing down so he will automatically
00:23:13 be uh running in opposition to uh burnham and burnham will probably win uh like i agree with
00:23:20 you that i don't think it's going to change anything i don't think it's going to save the
00:23:23 labor party at the moment i think the brand has been pretty irredeemably tainted at this point
00:23:28 um so i don't think that's going anywhere and west streeting and this is the thing with the
00:23:34 sort of like the these two factions and the soft left they're not terribly brave because i mean
00:23:40 you've seen you've seen uh burnham hovering around this for a long time well he he didn't move you
00:23:47 you you don't get to participate in the uni party if you are brave yes that they they very much
00:23:55 select for yes men yeah so it's it's not surprised that there was a crashing lack of bravery at the
00:24:01 key moment or anything no and this is why catherine west uh someone no one had ever really heard of
00:24:06 had to kind of force their hand into it but even then catherine west came out and said yeah if it
00:24:12 happens i'll probably vote for starma nice oh okay amazing but uh you know what west street you might
00:24:17 not have well anyone else's support but he does have peter mandelson's support because remember
00:24:22 well that's worth something i guess he's a manderson protege so yeah how wonderful
00:24:28 now he resigned from starmer's cabinet which means that starmer needs a health secretary
00:24:35 well i mean there's a few people knocking around to a free aren't there like angela rayner why not
00:24:41 invite her he hasn't done that he's invited her but she's refused oh he offered it he offered it
00:24:48 Oh, I didn't see that.
00:24:49 He offered it, and she was like, no thanks.
00:24:51 Keep your friends close and your enemies closer, I assume.
00:24:55 No idea.
00:24:57 So that's why Angela Rayner was in the press a few weeks ago
00:25:01 as having given up vaping.
00:25:03 Maybe.
00:25:04 It was because she was keeping her options open.
00:25:05 I didn't see that.
00:25:06 Yeah, it was like the sort of thing that, oh, Beth Rigby
00:25:10 and all those sort of second-grade political commentators
00:25:13 were talking about.
00:25:14 And I was like, why is this a story?
00:25:16 It suddenly makes sense.
00:25:16 She was keeping her options open just in case she agreed to this,
00:25:20 but she decided not to in the end.
00:25:22 So it turns out that Burnham was chosen as the candidate, by the way.
00:25:25 Right.
00:25:25 And he gives this kind of false humility
00:25:31 that they're all projecting at the moment
00:25:34 that everyone from the Labour tries to project.
00:25:36 And he ends it with,
00:25:39 I would feel privileged to be given the opportunity
00:25:43 to represent Makesfield.
00:25:44 It's like, well, okay, everyone can tell
00:25:45 this is entirely um machiavellian right it's very obvious you're not doing this you didn't you didn't
00:25:52 give up mayor of manchester because you you suddenly felt actually screw the rest of manchester
00:25:57 it's this this is the bit i like no it's clearly not that is it it's because it's because starma 0.98
00:26:04 is absolutely dying on his ass out there that's why you're doing it yeah um just to be clear he 0.95
00:26:09 hasn't given up the mayorality of manchester right so according the way that the system works 0.99
00:26:14 is to be a candidate in the election.
00:26:17 He doesn't have to give up the mayorality.
00:26:19 If he wins, then he does.
00:26:21 So if he loses, he carries on as he is.
00:26:24 So actually, this is minimal risk for Andy Burnham
00:26:27 in order to save the Labour Party.
00:26:29 Now, weirdly enough, Keir Starmer has endorsed him.
00:26:32 Well, I suppose he has to.
00:26:33 Oh, you kind of do, don't you?
00:26:35 I mean, publicly.
00:26:36 Yeah, but you blocked him from being able to run previously.
00:26:39 If Keir Starmer wants to completely sabotage Andy Burnham,
00:26:44 He should go to Makerfield and campaign for him.
00:26:47 And stand next to him at every single photo opportunity
00:26:50 with his arm around him.
00:26:51 According to all of the sort of like insider podcasts,
00:26:58 like the Times podcast and things like that,
00:27:00 Burnham has begged him not to come.
00:27:02 Keir Starmer, in fact, during the local elections,
00:27:06 he made the fewest number of public appearances
00:27:09 with the candidates on campaign.
00:27:12 He only made it 11 compared to, like, Farage's 44
00:27:15 because everyone was well aware that actually turning up
00:27:18 with Keir Starmer in tow is bad for you.
00:27:21 But that's how Keir Starmer sabotages him.
00:27:23 It is.
00:27:25 Anyway, yes, Keir Starmer, in a show of magnificence,
00:27:29 has said, no, Angela Rayner, I'm not threatened by you.
00:27:31 Come on in, even though she was thinking about running as the candidate.
00:27:34 Oh, Andy Burnham's running specifically to unseat me.
00:27:36 I support him 100%.
00:27:38 I mean, the last time he tried to run for a seat,
00:27:40 he rigged the process so that andy burnham couldn't run for it i know so it's gone from
00:27:44 at least 49 to 100 bloody quickly isn't it but you can tell that the the feeling in the labor
00:27:52 party is oh this is really getting quite existential now so the nec is not the nec is not a unified
00:27:59 body i watched the times podcast from one woman who was a member of it who clearly was very anti
00:28:06 starmer and pro burnham explaining the process of how they're going to essentially strategize to
00:28:12 get burnham through he did get through he is the candidate so this obviously worked and basically
00:28:18 what this is what this must have meant is persuading the starmerites on there that look
00:28:23 starmer's going to get us all killed like what are you doing politically we are crushed what are
00:28:27 you doing you've got to let us at least have a chance is the argument i've been making these
00:28:30 shows for months it's just just just pick anyone angela rayner andy but just just just throw a
00:28:36 bloody dart in in the tea room and whoever it hits make them because you're heading towards
00:28:41 four seats no good so even if you get seven seats you've won yeah no let them have it this is what
00:28:48 kemi badenock's uh local election celebrations are about we only lost 500 seats 700 seats i'm a
00:28:54 winner anyway so um who who is who is andy burnham right so we'll go through a bit of a profile on
00:29:00 andy burnham why is he titled pretty straight um because does he have one or two experiences at
00:29:06 university that no no he's he's quite boring basically right so he's born in 1917 in aintree
00:29:13 studied english at fitzwilliam college cambridge uh before entering parliament he worked in
00:29:18 political and public policy roles including for tessa jowell the and the nhs confederation and
00:29:24 a football task force so he's never had a real job right he's got an english degree obviously 0.99
00:29:29 the man to lead the country then yeah never looked at a p&l in his life let's make him the leader 0.96
00:29:35 yeah never had a job that actually pays taxes outside of working for the state yeah became a
00:29:41 labor mp for lay in 2001 holding a seat until he left the commons in 2017 to become mayor of
00:29:46 manchester during the new labor brown government years he rose quickly through ministerial office
00:29:50 He served in the Home Office, Department of Health, Treasury, and then became Chief Secretary to the Treasury in 2007, Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport in 2008, and Health Secretary from 2009 to 2010, when Labour was kicked out by the Lib Dem Conservative Coalition.
00:30:06 Then he ran against Corbyn and got trounced.
00:30:09 Yeah, yeah, he did.
00:30:11 After Labour lost power in 2010, he remained prominent in opposition.
00:30:14 he was shadow education secretary shadow health secretary shadow home secretary and ran twice
00:30:19 unsuccessfully for the labor leadership um so what this tells us is a man who's just never been
00:30:27 outside of labor party politics yeah his entire life his entire career okay yeah well uh his
00:30:36 politics became associated with a soft left public service focused labor tradition around the nhs
00:30:40 social care transport housing and regional inequality in 2017 he left westminster and was
00:30:45 elected the first mayor of greater manchester re-elected in 2021 and again in 2024 he focused
00:30:53 on rough sleeping developing public services skills housing policy housing policy and transport
00:30:58 policy his flagship achievement is the b network including bringing greater manchester buses under
00:31:03 public control through franchising that only helps so much in makersfield because makersfield is very
00:31:09 much a commuting town it's not it's i mean it's it's i mean it's a bit weird i mean it is in
00:31:15 manchester but it's also sort of in liverpool you know they're in with they're in the greater
00:31:20 manchester area but a lot of them support everton in liverpool so yeah but it's it's
00:31:25 so does burnham burnham sports everton yeah but uh i mean of of the sort of key policies the one
00:31:30 that people always say is the bus stuff that won't make any difference to people in makersfield i
00:31:34 don't think yeah um he gained a lot of notoriety during the covid pandemic as he clashed with the
00:31:40 conservative government i will give him that i'll totally give him that he he was one of the very
00:31:45 few people who was pushing back in any way he wasn't straight out coming coming out and saying
00:31:51 the stuff that i would have said with this which this is complete nonsense he was arguing about
00:31:54 the tiers structure and stuff like that but he was at least one of the voices who was pushing
00:31:59 back on that madness i'll give him that and uh this uh helped him get his sort of northern
00:32:06 champion reputation king of the north as it were people keep saying king of the north that's nice
00:32:11 king in the north dummies anyway well and also nobody north the m25 actually says it's a very
00:32:18 westminster coded thing yes or i mean possibly andy burnham himself says that he's king of the
00:32:25 north but nobody else says it yeah so he's he's got quite a prominent uh profile especially in
00:32:33 the labor party but not really very far outside of the north uh if you are someone who's just
00:32:40 somewhere else in the country in the midlands in the south andy burnham's main doesn't really mean
00:32:46 all that i'm pretty sure if i knocked on my neighbor's door and asked they they won't have
00:32:48 heard of him yeah absolutely my normie friends won't have heard of him absolutely and there's
00:32:52 no particular reason they should have done um which is why he's got an approval rating of about
00:32:57 37 positive about 25 negative and then the rest is just no particular opinion i'm confident we
00:33:05 can get those numbers down if if he does end up becoming prime minister those numbers will be
00:33:08 gone in no time yeah and it's it's because he just doesn't really know what he's doing but we'll
00:33:14 talk about manchesterism in a bit uh so that's the candidate for uh the labor party the lib dems have
00:33:19 said they're going to be standing a candidate which seems like a waste of 500 pounds um i don't i
00:33:26 don't think makersfield is a particularly big garden place well no we we've already covered
00:33:32 it haven't we it's 32 000 pounds 150 000 pound house on average this is not lib dem territory
00:33:37 no no um the as uh you gov has have actually come out there's a little graph here where
00:33:44 that proved our point
00:33:46 because we were running on
00:33:49 vibes
00:33:51 but
00:33:51 there we go, voting the attention by
00:33:55 income level. The average
00:33:57 Lib Demer is somewhere between
00:33:59 $40,000 to $70,000 plus.
00:34:02 So yeah, just average wage
00:34:05 in Makerfield
00:34:07 is $32,000.
00:34:09 This is why Lib Dems never really have had
00:34:11 any particular standing
00:34:13 here and the greens are also standing a candidate even though caroline lucas is like this might be 1.00
00:34:17 a bad idea because what if we split the labor vote and allow some evil far writer in somebody 0.99
00:34:23 should point out to her she that she's in a political party and what political parties do
00:34:27 is they stand candidates for election yeah i mean you say that but jacob reese mog is like i don't
00:34:34 think the tories should stand candidates okay radical idea how about we let the voters decide
00:34:43 who they want to vote for that is a radical idea uh but anyway so yeah the greens are going to be
00:34:48 standing candidate uh i'm not very concerned about the greens in this constituency uh there's no
00:34:55 students for foreigners no i mean that simply is literally there must be one or two impressionable
00:35:01 young women left but so i'm sure they get something yeah yeah they'll get a few percentage
00:35:06 points doubtless um but i like i said i i just don't think this is one of those constituencies
00:35:12 we're not going to be seeing the greens campaigning entirely in bangladeshi those videos weirdly i
00:35:18 don't think they will i mean there's just there are very few people in maker field who just
00:35:22 genuinely hate their own constituency in the country at large right this is not one of those
00:35:26 It's not Bristol or Brighton or anywhere like that
00:35:29 or, you know, Bradford South or wherever.
00:35:31 You know, this is a place of normal English people
00:35:34 who are sick of the way the country's being run
00:35:36 and don't want that anymore.
00:35:38 So no more of Zach Polanski.
00:35:40 Like I said, the Tories,
00:35:41 Jake Friesmog said, look, the Tories shouldn't stand.
00:35:43 But Kemmy Baden-Ox said, no, I am going to stand a candidate.
00:35:48 She's the leader of a political party.
00:35:49 This is what they do.
00:35:50 Yeah, and honestly, like,
00:35:52 everyone's like, the Tories are going to split the vote.
00:35:53 It's like, well, there's no evidence for that.
00:35:55 yeah even in the best possible scenario makerfield was not a tory place in 2019 for example no i mean
00:36:03 to be fair they they did come second back in the days when you had two choices
00:36:08 like i said under optimal conditions they couldn't even win it uh so yeah they're gonna
00:36:17 stand a candidate but i'm sorry just the energy just isn't there and i mean i could maybe if it
00:36:23 was jeremy clarkson or something mashed a run then yeah whatever the i mean he's a bit oxford
00:36:29 isn't he but whoever whoever northerners like yeah yeah it's unlikely that maybe one of those
00:36:35 ant and deck things i've watched ant and decks as i was a kid uh anyway so uh yes so the tories
00:36:45 are going to be running the lib dems are going to be running the greens are going to be running but
00:36:47 i think these are all going to be um non-entities uh reform are the people who we're going to be
00:36:53 watching most closely i think because i actually think that the over i think that burnham star is
00:36:59 being overestimated i've heard uh reports from people in the area that the the burnham love
00:37:06 is over egged yeah i i find i find this difficult because i i see a lot of people saying that sort
00:37:13 of thing on vox pop stuff and but at the same time whenever i see pollsters who've done their
00:37:17 focus groups apparently and they've really dug into it they seem pretty convinced that Andy
00:37:22 Burnham is going to win but they are pollsters yeah and they get everything wrong I mean they
00:37:28 predicted that they predicted that the vote for leave at the Brexit referendum was going to be
00:37:32 like 15-20% so but but to be fair the people who do this full-time for a living are convinced that
00:37:38 Burnham is going to win but I think you're right it's it's not gonna I don't think it's going to
00:37:43 Yeah, that way.
00:37:44 But anyway, so Reforma, of course, throwing everything at it.
00:37:48 With a weird sort of Saruman-esque attitude,
00:37:52 we're going to be closely monitoring the attendance
00:37:56 of all of our campaigners and candidates.
00:38:00 We'll expect you to demonstrate that commitment in practice
00:38:04 and not just on paper.
00:38:05 It's like, all right, Jesus Christ, steady on.
00:38:09 There's a very strange attitude.
00:38:11 They're appealing to, not loyalty, not support.
00:38:16 They're not appealing to anything positive in this.
00:38:19 This is just, you have been told.
00:38:22 Yeah, very much so.
00:38:24 And this has been the attitude that the local branches in reform
00:38:26 have objected to in the past.
00:38:28 Why the local ground game for reform has not been very strong.
00:38:31 I mean, if every communication is written like this,
00:38:34 I'm surprised they have any branches left.
00:38:36 Yeah, I know.
00:38:37 I mean, I can see why a lot of them have defected before.
00:38:39 I mean, just look at the, as you will be aware,
00:38:41 the forthcoming Makerfield by-election represents a hugely important opportunity for the party.
00:38:46 As somebody who has applied to become a prospective parliamentary candidate,
00:38:49 there's an expectation that you play an active role in supporting major life campaigns such as this. 0.94
00:38:54 All right, bloody hell. 0.81
00:38:55 There's not a single sentence in that, which is, we would value, we need you, we want you. 0.97
00:39:03 I mean, if you ever find yourself talking to your spouse like this, your marriage is doomed.
00:39:07 Oh, yeah, my wife would be bloody angry.
00:39:10 We are therefore asking all parliamentary,
00:39:13 we're not inviting you, we're asking.
00:39:16 The parliamentary candidate applicants
00:39:18 to commit to attending Makefield
00:39:20 for a minimum of three full days campaigning
00:39:22 between now and polling day.
00:39:23 Attendance we've closely monitored and noted.
00:39:25 Like, oh, Jesus Christ, all right?
00:39:28 Like, what kind of attitude is this?
00:39:30 Anyway, so they did choose their candidate,
00:39:34 and it's a good one, to be honest.
00:39:36 Yeah, I don't mind this guy, actually.
00:39:37 yeah robert kenyon uh very you you've got a hand to them because so uh dr david bull yesterday
00:39:44 resigned as the chair of the party and everyone knew the announcement was coming today so i was
00:39:49 like please god so my take on that was i thought that they were going to run um dr david bull
00:39:58 because they were convinced that he would match gpt it that he would he would crash and burn
00:40:03 which would send burnham to westminster which would mean that they could have a run at the
00:40:08 mayor of manchester i thought they were going to throw it but no it looks like they they do
00:40:13 actually want to try and win yeah i mean reformer put into a very strange position at the moment
00:40:17 with messaging because you remember in the local elections the message was vote reform to get star
00:40:21 out yes well that didn't happen to now vote reform to keep starmer in yes it is and so it's it's a
00:40:28 very strange time for reform we've always been at war with eurasia kind of stuff yeah yeah no no
00:40:34 very much so um but we can we can watch this chap's video because it is is a very we'll watch
00:40:38 a pub it's a very strong video i was born in makerfield if i was elected i'd be the first
00:40:43 person born in the constituency to become the mp i don't think any mp that's ever stood in
00:40:48 makerfield was actually born in the area i'm a plumber gas engineer i've done that for a long
00:40:53 time i did my apprenticeship when i was 18 i love being a plumber i do enjoy it it's hard
00:40:58 But I do enjoy it because I do take pride in my work.
00:41:00 I think it gets me a bit emotional sometimes thinking there's a chance that I could be
00:41:04 representing people in Parliament because it's a massive honour and people will be thinking
00:41:08 oh in a minute, he serviced my boiler last week.
00:41:11 Labour and probably the majority of the other parties have got career politicians, you know
00:41:16 they go to private school, to university, they get a job at a think tank or they're an
00:41:21 assistant to an MP and then before you know it they parachute into somewhere they've never
00:41:26 even visited to stand as an mp now they might know the system they might know how politics works
00:41:31 they might know westminster but they don't know the area or the people you know you could read a
00:41:36 book about something but you'll never understand it until you actually do it for andy burnham
00:41:41 makerfield will be a stepping stone but for me it's the only place i've ever wanted to represent
00:41:48 and we'll stop it then so you've got a good impression of uh the kind of candidate he's
00:41:53 currently a counselor he did in the ashton and in makerfield award and he was the candidate that
00:42:01 they ran in 2024 who came second so he's got a local profile and he will be someone i mean he
00:42:07 like he actually comes across as an actual plumber yes like hannah from gordon and then
00:42:12 she was supposed to be a plumber yeah she was also meant to be a plumber and obviously she 0.73
00:42:17 wasn't really a plumber she she installed what was a the uh heating system the heating engine 1.00
00:42:24 there was some outside heating thing but she apparently she did administration anyway
00:42:28 so so this is the type of guy that 100 would have been your bread and butter labor voter in the 70s
00:42:36 even labor mp is really only after the blair river that sort of guy just got ejected from it
00:42:42 yeah absolutely but i mean but he runs his own business if if the labor party was full of guys
00:42:49 who'd run their own business we would be in a radically different situation and he's got he's
00:42:53 got a good track record he was a plumber served in the british army worked for the nhs for six
00:42:57 years and he's a counselor there already for reform uh so he's a strong strong candidate
00:43:04 very strong candidate no he's a good guy seems like a really nice chap um not sure about the
00:43:09 line of attack though no it's the well all of the candidates we get are private school boys who have
00:43:15 never been to the constituency well Andy Burnham isn't not from this place he's not just a drop
00:43:21 in from nowhere he is someone in the region and has roots there already so it's not I think he's
00:43:29 from that side of town I don't think he's he's exactly within the Makerfield board but I mean he
00:43:33 is he's he would have been mingling with people from Makerfield yeah he'll probably be able to
00:43:38 say yeah yeah when i was growing up you know i used to ride my bike over to here yeah it's my
00:43:43 friend's house or something like like it so it's it's not that he can be like oh he's the carpet
00:43:48 bagging matt goodwin who's just yeah that won't work that that's not going to work right so the
00:43:53 appeal to um the sort of the very right-wing appeal to play some parochialness is is just
00:44:00 not a strong fact here so really you've got to focus on um uh burnham himself uh anyway can i
00:44:07 Can I just quickly say how nice it is that we're back in an era
00:44:10 where candidates are from the place they're from.
00:44:14 Oh, thank God, yeah.
00:44:15 When I first got into politics in 97, I then had to watch.
00:44:17 I mean, one of the first elections I got involved in
00:44:20 was the Uxbridge by-election, long before Boris Johnson was there.
00:44:23 This was a time long before.
00:44:24 And the Labour candidate was like something slaughter.
00:44:28 He was a top London lawyer who got parachuted in
00:44:30 and the Conservative guy was again.
00:44:32 I can't remember who the Conservative guy now was, but that's nice.
00:44:36 getting back to actual people of the country representing the people of the country that is
00:44:40 good i mean i i for me rishi sunak i found the most annoying one yeah because he was plugged
00:44:47 out of southampton and dropped in richmond in york and it's just like sorry latterly of southampton
00:44:51 anyway well yeah yeah but he was grew up in southampton but we've got a super safe safe seat
00:44:57 in richmond in york so it's like sorry you don't you're not from this but you do not represent
00:45:01 this place at all no what are you doing here oh this is entirely cynical to get the goldman
00:45:06 sachs lawyer richmond is a long way from south ampton yeah uh so yeah like like you say i'm
00:45:12 actually excuse me i'm actually really glad to see at least there is this understanding now
00:45:19 that local people do not have to just vote red or blue and the abandon and it was this
00:45:25 pure commitment to where you've got the red or the blue rosette so and this place votes for red 0.88
00:45:31 or this place votes for blue so it doesn't matter which pig we pin the rosette on we can just dump 0.93
00:45:36 some alien pig in your thing and pin the rosette to it and you're going to vote for it well that's 0.76
00:45:42 good that that paradigm is broken yes no what that means is i need someone authentically from 0.98
00:45:47 this area because i can't just pin the blue rosette on the pig and expect you to vote for it
00:45:51 so it's like fantastic that's a great start as a great change so uh what are reform going to
00:45:59 campaign on well apparently brexit really what yeah what was that then i have no idea i assume
00:46:09 it's because andy burnham has made the foolish mistake of saying yeah i'd like to rejoin the eu
00:46:16 hang on let's watch this rejoin the eu or stay out long term i'm going to be honest i'm going
00:46:22 to say it i i want to rejoin it i hope in my lifetime i see this country rejoin the european
00:46:28 so i mean we've just spent the last 15 minutes bigging up reform oh yeah great candidate we
00:46:37 like that guy that's good everything yeah that's really good but okay if he wins he's not going to
00:46:44 be able to rejoin the eu and even even if he had that power which he would never get that across
00:46:50 the lining he's not going to be able to do it even if he did he now represents a seat which
00:46:55 is 70% leave 65 but close enough yeah he he's not going to touch it this is a politician who
00:47:02 has advocated almost every left-wing position on all sides Blair right soft left Corbyn it's all
00:47:08 of them he's not going to touch this at all in fact not not only that right but if he doesn't
00:47:15 win then we're going to get Miliband or Rainer right Miliband represents I think Starmer stays
00:47:21 in well or starmer stays in starmer is more likely to do it he knows that he's out um miller band
00:47:28 represents doncaster north which was a mildly leave constituency and he's actually more likely
00:47:35 to do it because he's got a solid majority and angela rayner is 100 going to lose her seat at
00:47:40 the next election and literally has nothing to lose she is more likely to do it whereas if he
00:47:45 wins this constituency he's going to go into the next election expecting to win it he's not going
00:47:52 to upset his 65 percent leave back so so this whole attack line for this is not the attack line
00:47:58 that you pick what you do is you say oh actually i can't think of any reform policies that are good
00:48:04 um we we will try and appeal to islam so that we can win in 2015 yeah we'll come to that in a second
00:48:11 So, what's interesting here is this is very clearly,
00:48:16 Andy Burnham has said, oh, I'm very much against the Westminster bubble,
00:48:19 but it's the Westminster bubble that's obsessed with Brexit.
00:48:23 They're the people who never got over Brexit.
00:48:26 If Andy Burnham's like, oh yeah, I represent the true north.
00:48:28 Well, the true north was Brexit, really quite heavily in some places, actually.
00:48:32 Really heavily.
00:48:33 Some of the most Brexit areas of the country,
00:48:36 like some of them are 65%, 70% in Oldham.
00:48:39 very very heavily brexit because it's that kind of old british socialism that's insular and
00:48:47 isolationist it's not islington lefty lawyer no and that's what he's appealing to yes applaud for
00:48:52 me applaud for me it's like no no no this was only in december 2025 as well right so it's not
00:48:58 like you go oh that was four years ago during the referendum six years ago during the referendum
00:49:01 no this was just last year because you never got over it being part of the london bubble
00:49:05 like you think you're not but you reveal yourself to be and of course that means that farage and
00:49:11 reform like ah yeah we're going to put brexit at the heart of it great i really don't want to have
00:49:16 to talk about brexit again i'm really tired do you not think we're exhausted of talking about brexit
00:49:21 but it it doesn't take a lot of political skill to square the circle all burnham needs to do is
00:49:28 come out and say well yes it's an ambition of mine um but i would only ever consider it if i
00:49:34 don't know these four tests are met um and and he'll make one of them that it that it benefits
00:49:41 the people like the people in makersfield that'd be one of and then he set the other three criteria
00:49:46 so that they're basically impossible and everybody will look at it and go oh yeah that's not going
00:49:51 to happen is it and then he squared the circle of yes i support it no it's not going to happen
00:49:56 so he he can neutral if he's got a modicum of political skill which he has he will neutralize
00:50:03 this attack line in two minutes he would but he hasn't managed to he's just like well i'm just not
00:50:07 i'm just not proposing this election okay i'll put everything i just said in a tweet and at him
00:50:13 i mean you are i think you're exactly right we just literally set a four criteria yes that we
00:50:18 can't meet and then you can just step past it yeah it doesn't meet the criteria moving on he
00:50:22 hasn't done that um but anyway he's he's sort of backtracked on this but that's not persuasive
00:50:26 either so now essentially andy burnham has is going to be dragged into discussing brexit in the
00:50:33 eu by reform with an electorate that doesn't really want to talk about brexit because we know
00:50:41 this because if you just look at what the most important issues facing oh is it going to be
00:50:45 economy and immigration boy shockingly shockingly economy and immigration like no nobody wants to
00:50:52 talk about brexit right now let's just check so let's see if we can get i mean these are just the
00:50:57 top issues but is that oh there we go leaving the eu is 14 oh look it was really high when we were
00:51:04 in the eu and now it's not because we're not in the eu yeah and so you've got a country who are
00:51:10 just flat out exhausted about this subject where like 13 14 of people want to talk about this
00:51:16 whereas 50 of people on both like 55 and 49 put that put immigration and the economy as the top
00:51:24 issue right so london bubble obsession is going to be projected onto makerfield obviously it's
00:51:30 immigration and the economy but but well i i know i know the answer to why reform doesn't want to
00:51:37 talk about those things because well they're they're they're weak on immigration because they
00:51:43 they don't want to they don't want to send anyone back i mean i think they've made some noises now
00:51:47 after after spending three years explicitly ruling it out yes they've now come out and said oh well
00:51:53 No, they sent Zaya Yusuf out to do it.
00:51:55 Yeah. 0.99
00:51:56 Well, he's dark enough skinned to be able to say it. 0.98
00:51:58 That he's allowed to. 0.93
00:51:59 He can say, we can't, but he can say it.
00:52:01 Literally, Beau and you weren't allowed to say exactly what Zaya Yusuf said.
00:52:04 No, we were thrown out of the party for saying that.
00:52:06 Yes.
00:52:06 Exactly.
00:52:07 So, not exactly reliable, but dragging up the ghost of Brexit,
00:52:11 I think, is actually a really poor manoeuvre.
00:52:13 Yeah, it doesn't work.
00:52:15 Like, if I were on the doorstep and I had a reform candidate
00:52:19 or a reform canvasser, I'd be like, hi there,
00:52:21 Did you know that Andy Burnham wants to take us back into the EU?
00:52:24 God, I'm not voting for him either.
00:52:26 You know, just Jesus Christ.
00:52:29 It's just not on my radar at the moment.
00:52:32 Thank you very much.
00:52:32 Somebody knocks, the Tory knocks on the door.
00:52:34 Andy Burnham is going to repeal the Corn Laws.
00:52:36 Is that what I'm saying? 1.00
00:52:41 Anyway, Andy Burnham wants to just build council houses for foreigners. 0.99
00:52:46 He wants to, like, shock and surprise, 0.97
00:52:49 he he wants to do all of this uh like what i guess what you would call manchesterism for the
00:52:55 rest of the country it's like okay but the rest of the country isn't the industrial heartland of
00:52:59 uh the north um we actually not do not necessarily want a massive council house building program on 0.98
00:53:07 the scale not since seen since world war ii because we know who's going in those goddamn 0.99
00:53:11 council houses mate and it's not going to be the um the white british children exactly and 0.95
00:53:17 what's worse for burnham and i think this is a real mistake is that he has said on the doorstep
00:53:24 that he's doing this to save the labour party listen to this i did do um yeah a protest vote
00:53:30 yeah now that you're back on board oh really right that means everything that's why i'm doing it i'm
00:53:35 trying to get this party back to where it solidly should have always been you know and that's what
00:53:40 i'm that's why i'm doing it there we go just out of the horse's mouth i'm doing this because i'm
00:53:46 trying to save the Labour Party.
00:53:48 But, I mean, this is it.
00:53:49 People don't remember that they have built him up in their minds
00:53:52 to be this titanic figure of mythos.
00:53:57 I remember when he was in the cabinet, he was considered C-list.
00:54:01 Oh, yeah, very much.
00:54:02 He was considered a second-rate politician, and that's why he buggered off.
00:54:05 Very much an Ed Miliband sort of level.
00:54:07 Yes, yes.
00:54:08 It was so funny when Ed Miliband became leader.
00:54:11 Yeah.
00:54:11 Yeah, and the fact that Ed Miliband is one of the leading lights of Labour now,
00:54:15 It's like, okay, the degradation of your party.
00:54:18 Now Andy Burnham is the thing that's coming forth to save it.
00:54:21 It's like, okay.
00:54:22 I mean, he genuinely is one of the best in the Labour Party.
00:54:25 Which is a damning indelible for the Labour Party.
00:54:27 But he's not going to revive the fortunes of Labour.
00:54:32 If he somehow wins this election, I simply don't care.
00:54:35 But look at what the woman said. 0.90
00:54:36 I use them as a protest vote,
00:54:39 which is a thing that I think reform have got to be wary of,
00:54:41 as we've talked about previously.
00:54:43 and i i said i don't think people are die hard reform commitment uh i mean evidently not because
00:54:49 they didn't vote for them at the last election when they were an option exactly yes and this
00:54:53 woman said well i use them as a protest vote but now you're here and you're going to fix the labor
00:54:57 party i can finally go back to my ancestral party is what she's saying now what this means is that
00:55:03 makerfield is being expressly used cynically here by burnham he's just saying it oh yeah no he
00:55:10 literally said elsewhere as well no no this is a vote to change labor right so i'm using i i may
00:55:16 have been a great mayor of manchester but i'm using makefield to save the labor party now the
00:55:22 people at makerfield have to ask us do i want to save the labor party is that what i actually want
00:55:27 at this point can i trust them to actually do what they should have done all along or is the
00:55:33 party too compromised well if the soundings that i've taken are anything to go on absolutely not
00:55:38 under no circumstances they want Labour to crash and burn.
00:55:41 Which is what I've heard too.
00:55:43 Yes.
00:55:44 Now, like very much how we in the South feel about the Conservatives.
00:55:48 Yeah, yes.
00:55:48 Because these genuinely were just the North-South party.
00:55:50 I assume it's the same.
00:55:53 I mean, people in the comments, if you're Northern, you can explain.
00:55:56 But I want the Tory party to be destroyed.
00:55:58 I will not vote for the Tories. 0.99
00:55:59 Under any circumstances whatsoever, they must be annihilated completely. 0.99
00:56:04 And this is coming from somebody who was a member 0.89
00:56:06 who worked in CCHQ for a while.
00:56:08 I'll dream of my work experience when I was 17, 18 or something.
00:56:11 I despise them.
00:56:13 Tell me in the comments if that's your impression as the North.
00:56:16 If you're in the North and you're in Manchester
00:56:17 and you feel the same way about Labour, let us know.
00:56:20 Anyway, so like I said, it's a cynical attempt 0.97
00:56:22 to save the party that deserves to die. 0.97
00:56:25 I mean, he literally says,
00:56:26 a vote for me is a vote to change Labour.
00:56:28 So I found this sub-stack,
00:56:29 because I don't know anything about Manchesterism.
00:56:31 I'm not an economist or anything.
00:56:33 But maybe you want to do brokonomics on this at some point
00:56:36 and explain uh burnham's philosophy better to us because burnham uh seems to just have made his
00:56:44 entire name on handouts right and that's literally what it seems to be uh so burnham as he they say
00:56:56 in here as uh this chap says in here which i like i said i've been watching a lot of podcasts
00:57:01 talking about this and this seems to be the most distilled way of uh actually framing it and
00:57:06 actually with some numbers right so um burnham thinks he can ignore the bond markets because as
00:57:12 he previously said he doesn't want to be in hock to the bond markets right yes uh and this article
00:57:18 does a great job of explaining well the bond markets are a market right if you want to borrow
00:57:22 money you want to sell bonds you know then you have to have uh essentially um the uh market
00:57:30 actually in your favour to do so?
00:57:33 Well, when you, on your monthly or weekly basis,
00:57:37 however often you're doing, how short you are on money,
00:57:40 when you offer up the bonds for sale,
00:57:42 somebody then has to come along and say,
00:57:44 yeah, I'll buy them.
00:57:45 Yeah, there has to be desire to buy them.
00:57:47 I mean, they can force it to a little bit
00:57:49 by making banks and insurance companies hold them,
00:57:51 but that doesn't get you very far.
00:57:53 You need people to want to buy them.
00:57:55 So if he doesn't want to be in hock to the bond markets,
00:57:58 don't borrow 132 billion from them every year and then you won't be in hock to them but but what
00:58:06 this is this this is a bit like you getting home tonight and your and your seven-year-old is stood
00:58:11 there with his arms crossed and then saying um i don't want to be in hock to daddy anymore
00:58:16 by the way can i have my pocket money yeah yeah it doesn't work no no that's exactly right if you
00:58:23 if you expect to sell the gilts to the market then you have to have more demand than supply
00:58:31 for it to be worth your time and if you don't the yields will blow out and that's what's happening
00:58:35 now and exactly and therefore the amount you have to spend on the um interest and debt payments
00:58:41 whatnot is is just way higher so okay great and so as uh marlow here says right uh he's
00:58:50 And Andy Burnham's outriders are claiming that he's going to bring the markets to heel,
00:58:54 which means one of three things.
00:58:56 Burnham is planning £340 billion of tax rises.
00:59:01 Burnham is planning £340 billion of government spending cuts,
00:59:04 or he is just delusional.
00:59:06 And honestly, I think we're at his just delusional part.
00:59:10 So tax rises won't work, because if you put taxes up from this point,
00:59:14 you'll actually collect less revenue.
00:59:16 Oh yeah, Rachel Reaves has discovered this. 0.96
00:59:17 In fact, we're already starting to see it on some taxes.
00:59:19 It's the tax rate has gone up and people just stopped doing stuff less
00:59:22 and so the tax rate collections will fall.
00:59:25 Laffer curve is undefeated.
00:59:27 It's clearly not going to be spending cuts
00:59:29 because Labour are psychologically incapable of this.
00:59:32 Not just Labour.
00:59:33 This is completely anathema to Andy Burnham's personal record as well.
00:59:36 Well, yes.
00:59:37 And therefore, by process of deduction, it has to be delusion.
00:59:42 Absolutely.
00:59:43 And he concludes in this, right?
00:59:46 Thinking that you can just ignore bond markets
00:59:47 when you are relying on them to lend you the money to pay for public services is insane
00:59:51 burnham has promised huge amounts of public spending such as nationalizing water companies
00:59:55 and the way he's going to pay for it and the way he's going about it implies he has no idea how the
01:00:00 government is going to get the money to pay for it he has spent in the last decade of mayor of
01:00:05 great manchester right 1.5 billion pound sorry 1.4 billion pounds of debt which is 825 percent
01:00:13 of his authority's annual revenue
01:00:14 that he has borrowed
01:00:16 all from the central government
01:00:17 via the Debt Management Office.
01:00:20 He has never had to consider markets
01:00:21 nor convince anyone
01:00:22 who's good for the cash.
01:00:24 The Treasury has just cut him a check
01:00:25 at preferential rates
01:00:26 any time he wanted the money.
01:00:29 That's what underpins Manchester.
01:00:31 Well, that's how local government works.
01:00:33 They can basically borrow
01:00:34 at the interest rate,
01:00:37 the Bank of England rate,
01:00:38 plus like a quarter of a percent
01:00:40 or even less.
01:00:42 Yes.
01:00:42 And so it's just an open piggy bank.
01:00:44 Yes.
01:00:44 And that's how Manchesterism has made Manchester a success.
01:00:48 It's been subsidies from central government, right?
01:00:50 Yeah.
01:00:51 They've just, yeah, he's like, we're going to give it to you.
01:00:53 We're going to give you an incredibly preferential interest rate.
01:00:56 So you get all of the benefits of essentially the country subsidizing Manchester, right?
01:01:03 That's why this is working.
01:01:04 The second that stops or can't be done, well, then what happens then?
01:01:09 The thing fails.
01:01:11 and it's not like Burnham is actually going to go outside of any of the established rules
01:01:16 he's already told us. Andy Burnham is fully ruled out changing Rachel Reeves's fiscal rules.
01:01:23 He's just going to stay within the system as it is, which another point is what's actually
01:01:28 substantively different between Burnham and Keir Starmer or Rachel Reeves or anything like that?
01:01:31 They want to do exactly the same things. This is what I've always been saying.
01:01:35 all of the constraints still apply all of the limitations still apply all of the
01:01:42 he won't the only way that you can get greater degrees of freedom is by rejecting the system
01:01:50 as it stands rejecting the liberal assumptions that it is based on it is to do things which
01:01:57 will be considered incredibly painful because they involve disruption yes and he's not going
01:02:03 do any of that no he's he's told us explicitly uh the and he wants to do all of the same things
01:02:09 as keir starmer more social housing more things like starmer declared the other day he was going
01:02:14 to bring steel into public ownership for example which okay fine i'm not even saying it's a bad
01:02:18 idea but just we're still on the same tracks and we're still heading in the same direction right
01:02:23 we're still fiddling the same broken dials that aren't connected to anything exactly so nothing
01:02:28 even if burnham wins nothing substantial is going to change he's going to get in and say well can i
01:02:33 just start spending money and the treasury and whoever else will just say uh no you're not the
01:02:39 mayor of manchester anymore like what the bond markets have said no and he's gonna be like oh
01:02:44 jesus christ what does that mean and so he's going to find himself like you've said just up against
01:02:48 the brick wall when he's in the same system he can't move anything he can't change anything he
01:02:52 will get set down by the permanent secretary who will explain it to you prime minister what you
01:02:57 have to be aware of is and then he just and he will just end up doing everything that keir starmer
01:03:03 did exactly and and keir starmer just did everything that boris johnson did and so that's
01:03:07 how how it works because nobody's rejecting the underlying structures here yeah anyway another
01:03:14 attack line that reform are going to have on him are the grooming gangs because uh he failed at
01:03:19 the sort of last hurdle on the grooming gangs um to really plunge into the issue properly because
01:03:26 of course this is an issue that he as a labor party grandee doesn't really want to have anything 0.88
01:03:32 to do with but who else failed on the grooming gangs nige oh that's right you i was just thinking 0.99
01:03:37 a reform sure that they want to expose that flank because what if what if there's somebody out there 1.00
01:03:43 who's got a far better credible line on this than he does yeah what if what if there is yeah nigel
01:03:50 didn't do the work uh burnham didn't do the work but rupert did do the work right and the things
01:03:56 that we saw coming out of the growing rupert called it the most harrowing two weeks of his
01:04:00 life yes going through this uh and so let's talk about the one percent prediction
01:04:06 now uh all of reform's talking heads and just to be clear web restore talking heads 0.89
01:04:14 uh have said no you're not going to win you're going to lose it's moronic and then we started
01:04:19 getting well okay well if we're going to get one percent then it's our deposit to lose right 0.68
01:04:24 you're not going to be that bothered about it you're not even going to notice one percent are
01:04:28 you so so i don't know why you're bothered exactly then then it started getting to well you're going
01:04:33 to split the vote it's like right so we're going to do better than one percent then so you're
01:04:38 expecting a significant percentage and therefore we should stand down to make sure that andy burnham
01:04:42 doesn't get into parliament and doesn't become the leader of the labor party yeah so everything
01:04:48 remains exactly the same so to be fair i am i am in winchester not not makersfield but for example
01:04:54 i didn't vote in in the council elections because there was no restore candidate and if the general
01:04:58 election comes around there's no restore candidate i won't vote again so if i vote for restore
01:05:03 candidate i'm somehow splitting the vote am i yeah that's another point that a lot of people have
01:05:06 made say well i wasn't going to vote for reform yeah but i will vote for us and we know that what
01:05:12 they do is they activate non-voters because we've literally just had 10 elections in great yarmouth
01:05:17 that demonstrate exactly that.
01:05:19 They activate the non-voters.
01:05:21 By a massive margin.
01:05:22 Yes.
01:05:23 By a massive margin.
01:05:25 And Ferraz had a good post that was going around
01:05:28 pointing out, look, this is actually existential for reform
01:05:31 because of the threat to the right.
01:05:33 If Restore do better than expected,
01:05:37 and in fact, if Restore win,
01:05:39 then what's the point of reform?
01:05:41 That'll be the second high-profile by-election
01:05:44 that reform will have lost.
01:05:47 Yep.
01:05:47 So the right and the left, showing that they are a centrist uniparty
01:05:51 and the public have gone against centrism.
01:05:54 And before we found out it was Burnham,
01:05:57 they were massively the favourites to win this.
01:05:59 By far.
01:06:00 Yes.
01:06:01 Like somewhere 85% likelihood of them winning.
01:06:04 And with Burnham, it's on a knife edge.
01:06:07 It's within a few percentage points.
01:06:09 So the point that Forrest is making, I think, very well,
01:06:13 is essentially nothing changes very much for restore if we don't win this right if we get
01:06:20 if i mean if we got one percent okay that'd be egg on the face it would be yeah but it doesn't
01:06:25 change anything in the grand scheme of things it's one by election if we get 10 or 15 that's
01:06:33 not a bad showing actually where we were predicted to get one percent and shows that the ground game
01:06:40 has teeth i mean any number higher than the polling average precisely any any number higher
01:06:45 than four percent basically yes is a win for restore and if reform were to lose this that's
01:06:52 bad for them yes very bad i i think if restore does the work it's not silly to say they can win
01:06:59 well that's a great point now who's restores candidate well the bbc have given us a rather
01:07:06 a mild article about her this is rebecca shepherd she's 53 she's a local business owner in the area
01:07:14 and she's very concerned about the way things are going in the country like everyone else
01:07:20 she's actually not terribly dissimilar to um the chap that reformer running okay then just local
01:07:27 person who is concerned about the way things are business owner local business parent business
01:07:31 owner yeah good yeah as the bbc tell us she's a local businesswoman 53 has described the party
01:07:36 is understanding firsthand the pressures facing local businesses
01:07:38 and working families across the area.
01:07:40 Very sensible.
01:07:42 Got some, again, coverage in The Spectator
01:07:45 and coverage in GB News,
01:07:47 which was all just surprisingly normal.
01:07:50 Wow, they were actually covering Restore?
01:07:52 Yeah.
01:07:53 Wasn't expecting that.
01:07:54 Yeah.
01:07:55 This video has been put out,
01:07:56 but honestly, it was a very small video
01:07:58 that didn't tell us that much.
01:08:00 But you can tell that she's a very normal local person.
01:08:03 I would say a common sense party
01:08:05 with a trustworthy leader who cares about his um people his constituents um doesn't try and
01:08:12 lie about anything and just really wants the best for the people so that's why she's joined
01:08:19 restore britain and why she's standing um okay it's not a slick reform production which honestly
01:08:24 i do think is a mistake we do need high quality production values um but she's normal yeah she's
01:08:31 not some radical like absurd candidate or anything like that she's very normal and apparently she's
01:08:37 doing very well on the doorstep we are okay good liably informed so let's have a look at the odds
01:08:42 trackers um if i can get rid of that so the odds oh this is a three horse race these odds have been
01:08:50 getting dramatically better since this morning when i prepared this podcast so you can see labor
01:08:56 4 to 7
01:08:56 reform
01:08:57 2 to 1
01:08:58 or 15 to 8
01:08:59 we're still
01:09:00 we're in 5 to 1
01:09:01 in many of the
01:09:04 leading
01:09:04 betting markets
01:09:06 so
01:09:07 for a few months
01:09:08 old party
01:09:09 that's not
01:09:09 bloody bad
01:09:10 and for a party
01:09:11 where like
01:09:11 reform and labour
01:09:12 should have this
01:09:13 completely sewn up
01:09:14 so to have some
01:09:15 outsider
01:09:16 who's on
01:09:17 I mean look at the
01:09:18 Greens and the
01:09:19 Conservatives
01:09:19 200 to 1
01:09:20 500 to 1
01:09:21 it's funny
01:09:22 how the Conservatives
01:09:23 just aren't
01:09:24 every so often I see a clip
01:09:27 and it's from a conservative
01:09:29 and I remember that they exist.
01:09:32 They're just, they're so done.
01:09:33 Yeah, it's only when they put
01:09:34 Kemi Badenock in my face. 0.97
01:09:35 They're 500 to 1. 0.96
01:09:38 There's just no,
01:09:39 they're done, they're tanked.
01:09:41 But, so as I said,
01:09:42 this is a three horse race.
01:09:43 Now, there are two horses in the lead,
01:09:45 but this was 7 to 1
01:09:47 when I started, 7.5 to 1
01:09:49 when I started this morning.
01:09:50 So the fact the odds are shortening
01:09:51 at the bookies is very interesting.
01:09:54 Now, that's not polling or anything,
01:09:57 but it's very interesting how literally the day after this has been announced
01:10:00 or two days after this has been announced,
01:10:02 this is what people are thinking and feeling in the arena.
01:10:10 We just don't have much information on Restore in elections at this point
01:10:16 because the only elections they've ever fought in,
01:10:19 they have triumphed so completely
01:10:22 but it kind of blew out the metrics yeah uh and so yeah like ben habib has said look we're not
01:10:27 going to be standing a candidate here uh and we urge people to get behind rebecca which is great
01:10:32 um and so everyone's out canvassing there's lee anderson canvassing in makefield as well
01:10:37 and of course there's our guys out canvassing in makefield uh so i mean it's all to play for
01:10:46 i mean for a small party it's a huge turnout it's it's impressive how passionate people are about
01:10:51 this i mean it used to be the case that the liberal democrats didn't do that well in elections but
01:10:55 they always had a strong ground game and it was always attributed to the fact they'd spent decades
01:11:00 building it up well quite obviously restore because it launched a few months ago has not
01:11:04 had decades to build it up this is because this well this is basically because there were five
01:11:09 parties running in this in this um by-election who are left-wing and one party that's right-wing
01:11:15 basically and and people are like i finally have something i want to vote for yes and this
01:11:21 there's a real feeling of insurrection about restore like no no farage and his tories they're
01:11:29 men of the system you know i'm sick of the system farage is clearly being accepted by the system as
01:11:35 well i mean one of the one of the frequently uh left-wing complaints about reform about the bbc
01:11:41 is how often reform are on like question time and things like this right they're like oh look
01:11:45 reform are constantly getting coverage and promotion from the mainstream media it's like
01:11:48 yeah they are actually in a way that's not wrong and that does act as a kind of campaigning arm for
01:11:55 them and show that they've been accepted by the status quo's consenters so bbc basically endorsed
01:12:00 them at this point basically yeah and so the the lefties are not wrong when they level this critique
01:12:05 about the mainstream media and their acceptance of farage and it's funny watching the lefties 0.59
01:12:10 spurg out about farage because he's just not what you think he is i mean christ's sake if if nigel
01:12:17 farad was what the left think he is i would vote for him and campaign for him myself that's why i
01:12:22 vote for rupert low anyway so russian has been up on the ground he's uh he's from manchester so he
01:12:31 uh he knows the area a lot better than we do uh he says been in make for 15 minutes and george's
01:12:36 flags everywhere union flags everywhere rupert low stickers we've got this so i don't know right
01:12:41 so all i'm saying is this this these are this is what i have seen that i think is worth presenting
01:12:46 It would be amazing, but it's not impossible.
01:12:49 It's not impossible.
01:12:51 Like, I think the betting markets probably have it right now.
01:12:55 But remember, we've got a month until these elections.
01:12:57 Yes.
01:12:58 So these are 18th of June.
01:12:59 We have got a full month, and it is going to be rampant.
01:13:03 And you know full well what's going to make the difference
01:13:06 between coming third, second, or first.
01:13:09 It is doing the work.
01:13:12 If you want to save your country, don't leave it up to Rupert
01:13:16 or the five guys around him or just click like on a video every now and again turn up and save
01:13:22 your country and it starts here yes so if if you are a restore britain member and supporter and
01:13:29 volunteer uh definitely would recommend you go to make field we're gonna we're gonna see if we can
01:13:34 get a crew to go up there make some content speak some people on the ground and uh see what we can
01:13:41 discover from me i mean if if everyone who backs a store and there's a lot of people who backs
01:13:47 a store if everybody can just do a day just go up for a pick a day that works for you and go up
01:13:52 we could do this because they exactly i mean if this is how it begins yes like on day two
01:13:59 it's like this on day 30 who knows it could be a great yarmouth so and it's very clear that the
01:14:08 people in reform are very worried about this oh i've i had noticed they're very salty online
01:14:15 that rupert lowe dare as you said you know do the thing that parties do and contest it yes
01:14:20 that's only because it looks like actually this could go somewhere and uh who knows maybe the
01:14:28 people of makefield aren't just going to be like yeah i'm voting for the protest vote maybe they
01:14:33 will vote for what they actually want and maybe that will be revealed to be restored
01:14:39 because it's going to actually be on the ballot.