Podcast 998 FULL Audio
Episode Stats
Harmful content
Misogyny
20
sentences flagged
Toxicity
43
sentences flagged
Hate speech
60
sentences flagged
Summary
In this episode of The Echoes, Connor and Harry discuss the ABC-Trump-Harris debate, the death of the Internet Archive, and the impending dystopia of post-modernism. Also, a new issue of Islander is out, and it's available to order now.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
It seems we have reached a liminal moment in our politics. We have recently crossed
00:00:13.680
a threshold from which there is no going back. With the current Starmer regime and a prospective
00:00:19.960
Harris administration on the horizon, it's clear that night is finally closing in. The
00:00:26.480
mask, the grime that covered our eyes, has fallen away, and it's becoming evident now
00:00:32.560
that our countries are being governed for the benefit of someone else. Daily are imposed
00:00:38.860
upon us the indignities of a subject people. Our money is looted by a state that has betrayed
0.67
00:00:46.180
us to pay the wages of foreign mercenaries and, for now, we have no recourse. The distance
00:00:54.680
between our current reality and future dystopia is rapidly closing, and it seems inevitable
00:01:00.780
to arrive, which renders our unfortunate present a disturbing fact, and an uncertain future
00:01:07.900
a desirable outcome. We are plunged against our will into a strange journey through a shadowy
00:01:14.800
forest along a darkling trail as the sun goes down, and we have a long night ahead of us.
00:01:21.680
It is clear that we wayfarers must wend these moonlit paths and traverse strange territories
00:01:28.900
before dawn breaks. Wisdom must be our guide and lodestone. Insight into the metapolitical
00:01:37.180
circumstances which have forced our fellowship upon this shared course will be key to setting
00:01:43.680
the world in its proper hest. We must understand what is happening to us, and what is at stake.
00:01:51.640
This is the will of the second issue of Islander magazine. The magnificent success of the first
00:01:58.100
issue has only emboldened us to pierce deeper past the veil and uncover the mysteries beyond.
00:02:03.900
It is in this gradual process of becoming in which we will find within ourselves the determination
00:02:11.120
and grit to endure. Luckily, we have many great thinkers to help us. We feature outstanding
00:02:17.800
exclusive articles from famous lawsmiths such as Dave Green, Marcus Fallin, Morgoth's
00:02:24.580
Review, Stefan Molyneux, Dr. Charles Cornish Dale, Dr. Nima Parvini, and myself, along with
00:02:31.340
many more. These are couched in the beautiful aesthetic experience that you have come to expect
00:02:36.640
from Islander. And as with the first issue, each issue of Islander is unique and distinct.
00:02:43.380
It will only be printed once, and for a limited time. So order your copy now.
00:02:53.260
Oh, hi, sorry, you just caught me reading Islander. I guess we should probably start
00:02:57.080
the podcast with a load of seizures, shouldn't we? I'm your host, Connor, joined by Harry.
00:03:02.000
Hello, welcome to the podcast of the Echoes, Samson.
00:03:07.500
That's all right, no worries. It is the 11th of September 2024, and before we jump into
00:03:12.640
these stories, which are, of course, the ABC-Trump-Harris presidential debate, which
00:03:16.680
underwhelmed how the law is not on our side in the UK and the Death of Internet Archive,
00:03:21.680
we would like to remind you that, as you've just seen in Carl's exhaustive advert, Islander
00:03:27.460
issue two that Rory has been working on very diligently is now out. It is available to order
00:03:32.400
from shop.lotuseses.com, uk.shop.lotuseses.com, along with a new round of merch that Rory has
00:03:40.200
designed. If you do order Islander, first of all, thank you to all those that did the first time
00:03:45.680
around. It was an overwhelming success. This time, you're getting more essays for the same price from
00:03:50.900
people like Rory Nationalist and Stefan Molyneux. I was really glad I convinced him to join this.
00:03:56.080
And also, we heard your feedback, because last time, some of you did have problems with shipping,
00:04:00.180
so this time, rather than doing a pre-order system, when you order it, it's going to be
00:04:04.480
printed in batches, so you should, hopefully, as long as the authorities don't cause problems,
00:04:09.460
bearing on where you are, you should get your copy within two to three weeks this time. And
00:04:14.080
I've got a copy in my hands, and it does look rather nice. So, definitely go out and get one
00:04:19.580
of those. Yeah, we do the prettiest magazines. Yes, many people are saying. All the links are in
00:04:24.640
the description, as you can see it up on your screen. And without further ado, let's jump into
00:04:28.820
the news. Yeah, so I'm sad to say I watched the full Trump-Kamala Harris debate this morning on my
00:04:35.360
way into work, and it was boring. I have to be completely honest, guys. I know that people want
00:04:44.040
to hear about how it was this huge triumph for Trump, how there were so many incredible takedown
00:04:48.560
moments, how the energy was back. And I think there's a lot of truth to parts of that, because
00:04:53.040
Trump certainly was a lot more tenacious. He was much more on attack than he was at the Joe Biden
00:04:59.160
debate. But I think perhaps it's just a part of me and my preferences that I find these kinds of
00:05:04.500
big American moderated debates quite dull and boring. Maybe it's because, as much as I dismiss it and
00:05:12.340
say it's so terrible, I'm so used to the schoolyard bullying style of debate that goes on in UK
00:05:19.780
Parliament, where it's flinging thinly-veiled insults at one another while all of the rest
00:05:25.140
of your group goes, whoa, behind you, that this... underwhelmed.
00:05:31.640
You think that we've just reached the stage of civilizational grief where we've hit acceptance,
00:05:35.900
and lots of other people that still care about this are in the bargaining stage, and so they think
00:05:39.440
that recycling constant WWE-style smackdowns is actually going to move politics forwards,
00:05:45.840
and they think that if Trump just squeaks out another really convincing policy proposal,
00:05:50.180
or another brutal insult levelled at Harris, then it'll change all the minds of the single
00:05:55.440
women voting purely on the basis that they've been convinced the other side is weird. Because
1.00
00:05:59.140
at this point, I think the sides are so entrenched, these debates basically do nothing.
00:06:02.880
Well, that's one of my concerns with the whole thing, which is that the debate was essentially
00:06:07.260
a reaffirmation of all of the policies that we already know that Trump is going to do,
00:06:11.420
and maybe a hint at the policies that Kamala Harris has been not very forthcoming in explaining
0.93
00:06:18.500
to people. She was going on about how there was going to be some kind of, what was it,
00:06:23.620
accommodation economy, some kind of striving economy. Basically an economy that works for
00:06:29.420
the middle class, and Donald Trump was talking about how his economy wasn't just going to work
00:06:32.880
for the middle class. It was going to work for everybody with his tax cuts and his tariffs
00:06:36.820
that were going to be put on to different products coming from overseas, especially in places like
00:06:40.540
China. But we'll get into all of that as we get into the rest of the segment. First, for those on
00:06:46.380
the website that you'll already have heard of this, but for those watching on YouTube, we actually
00:06:51.380
have, after the immense and fantastic success of the first issue of Islander, a second issue
00:06:57.280
available on the website right now. It features articles from very many great, fantastic,
00:07:04.220
bigly authors like Roareg Nationalist, Returning for Issue 2, Morgoth's Comeback, Dr. Nimi Parvini,
00:07:11.560
but we also have some new authors who've contributed, including the fantastic Stefan Molyneux and
00:07:17.960
the Golden One, amongst others. You even have many more, and that's me. I'm included in many more.
00:07:24.200
I got an article in there, although don't let that put you off. That is available on the website
00:07:29.320
for $14.99. You can find the link in the description below. And unlike last time, we don't have a
00:07:34.960
pre-order system in place. We are printing them to order. So once you print it, the aim is that it
00:07:41.380
should be with you within two to three weeks. So please get on that. It's a fantastic product,
00:07:47.420
and it will only be available for a limited time and a limited run. Along that, we also have more
00:07:53.100
merch for the Islander, and you can get stuff like these t-shirts. My personal favourite one
00:07:59.180
is this. I'm gonna have to show it off. Look at this. Look at that bad boy. Rory really knocked
00:08:06.640
it out of the park for that one. As an authentic dyed-in-the-wool metal head myself, this...
00:08:11.700
Oh, it tingles me. It tingles me in all the right places. That's fantastic. And I will be getting one
00:08:16.940
of these myself. That's gonna go right next to my, um, uh, my In the Path of the Forest shirt from the
00:08:23.040
last run. So yeah, get a hold of all of that whilst you still can, because it is all limited runs.
00:08:28.560
Anyway, back onto the news. So yeah, I watched the debate. Um, Kamala Harris, uh, if I'm going purely
00:08:35.980
by vibes... Which is the most important thing in public. As most people do. Donald Trump, despite
00:08:41.440
obviously being, uh, getting along in his age right now, seemed energetic, he seemed a bit tenacious,
00:08:47.760
he was on the attack. Again, unlike when he was against Biden, because he knew that all he needed
00:08:51.620
to do with Biden was stand there and watch as Biden sank himself. Um, so he was energetic, interrupting,
00:09:00.120
a bit more combative, which was all very good. Um, Kamala Harris has the voice, mannerisms,
0.86
00:09:07.660
an heir of a naggy HR woman. And I think that Americans should purely vote against her and vote
1.00
00:09:16.220
for Donald Trump, just on the basis that, do you want the nagging HR woman to run your country and
1.00
00:09:22.420
be delivering speeches for the next four years? So, I think that Trump's tactic of being concise,
00:09:29.960
direct, and measured during the Biden debate served him well, not just because Biden actively has
00:09:35.780
dementia and was falling apart like the guy that drinks from the wrong cup at the end of Indiana
00:09:39.620
Jones 3, but also because it pushed back against the perception that he's too pugnacious, that he
00:09:46.420
is in this for his own ego, and that he just wants to be there to insult people that have personally
00:09:51.700
slighted him. And so I do think if there is another debate, which I think is unlikely given it's
00:09:57.260
approaching the election... I think I've seen that Elon Musk wants to host one, but, uh, he would not
00:10:02.400
expect Kamala Harris to show up. No, I think that two things should happen. One, in any future
00:10:08.800
debates, if they happen, it's unlikely that Kamala will agree to them, he should go back to his more
0.89
00:10:13.460
reserved, statesmanly, I am the king-in-waiting, you're mental, you've had four years to screw up
00:10:18.500
the country, here's how I'm going to fix it like an adult persona. And, as Baron Trump, our future
0.79
00:10:24.240
Caesar, of course, has been advising his dad, go on other podcasts and allow the at-length
00:10:30.540
platform where you can't be frustrated by a partisan moderator to show off your agenda and
00:10:35.860
show off how personal ball you are. The podcast with Theo Von was very good. I wouldn't be shocked
00:10:39.560
now that Trump has been... I think he also appeared on Logan Paul for places. I'm not sure. He may well
00:10:45.360
have done. He had a photo of Jake Paul, didn't he? I remember that. I believe so, yeah. Um, I think I
00:10:50.760
wouldn't be shocked. Joe Rogan refused to have Trump on his podcast last time around. This time around?
00:10:54.600
Maybe this time? Well, he's been endorsed by RFK and Tulsi Gabbard, which were Joe's preferred candidates,
00:10:58.940
so I wouldn't be shocked if you see Trump on Rogan, and that'll do better than any sort of debate with
00:11:02.800
Harris. Yes, and you mentioned the moderators. There was definitely a case to be made for this
00:11:07.640
that Donald Trump was debating three people at the same time. The moderators seemed a lot more
00:11:11.860
combative of the claims that Trump was making versus the ones that Kamala Harris was making. For
00:11:16.860
instance, one of the particular ones that I noticed was when Kamala Harris was mentioning that,
00:11:22.020
oh, Donald Trump's government left us with record unemployment, all of these different economic
00:11:27.960
problems, and we managed to bounce back from that and get everything back in order.
00:11:31.900
If Donald Trump had said such a thing, the moderators would have jumped in to correct him.
00:11:36.060
Donald Trump, in fact, had to correct her himself, when the moderators, in fact, seemed to be trying
00:11:40.220
to scoot the conversation along and get away from that subject, because Donald Trump pointed out,
00:11:44.700
hey, we were in the middle of a pandemic right then, we handled the pandemic great. Obviously,
00:11:50.140
on the Republican side, there's a debatable question as to whether Donald Trump did handle
00:11:54.400
the pandemic correct or not, but still, those were the circumstances of the economic downturn
00:11:59.860
that happened at the end of Donald Trump's administration, whereas all of the years leading
00:12:04.660
up to it were, for all intents and purposes, great for Americans economically.
00:12:09.080
Well, they were in a much better position during COVID lockdowns at the end of Trump's term
00:12:15.140
than after the COVID lockdowns because of Biden's Inflation Reduction Act, because of the mass
00:12:21.200
money printing here conducted, you just look at the job records, every single year when
00:12:24.600
they're revised, hundreds of thousands of them get shaved off. Lots of the jobs were
00:12:28.500
bounce-back jobs coming out of predominantly Democrat lockdown states and rehiring. Lots
00:12:33.480
of them were also federal employment jobs, like hiring thousands of IRS agents. And so, Trump
00:12:38.720
having to correct that on the fly. Another example was when he said that Governor Virginia
00:12:43.260
Ralph Northam had proposed post-birth abortion as a possibility, and the moderator stepped in
00:12:47.620
and said, that's not legal in any state. Actually, something to know, I think it was 2018 or 2019,
00:12:54.320
Kamala Harris, when a senator, voted against the Born Alive Protection Act, which means that if any
00:12:58.500
baby survives an abortion attempt, the doctor can now just leave it to die of exposure on an
00:13:04.140
operating table. Kamala Harris endorsed that. So, I would say that's a kind of post-birth abortion
0.99
00:13:08.160
right there. So, the moderator's not holding her to task on that and actually actively
00:13:13.180
frustrating Trump. Again, the fact-checking was very partisan in the way that it was being used,
00:13:19.000
especially against Trump, which is especially disappointing because those were outright lies,
00:13:23.680
as you've clarified there, being peddled not only by Kamala but by the moderators as well,
00:13:29.140
which is annoying when abortion seems to, for a lot of female voters in America, to be the one
1.00
00:13:38.300
hot topic issue that they actually care about and could win their vote. So, if you're trying to
00:13:43.320
appeal to them the very fact that Donald Trump is having lies said to him and about him on air that
00:13:49.340
aren't being contested by the moderators and supported by the moderators, that's disappointing
00:13:53.840
to see, but at the same time not surprising in the slightest. So, that's one of the big hot-button
00:14:00.500
topics that was discussed. The way it was formatted was, you know, a typical no audience like the Joe
00:14:06.480
Biden one, where you've got the moderators proposing the questions, each candidate has two minutes to
00:14:11.560
give their answer, and then there's a bit of back and forth in between all of that. So, it's done in
00:14:16.100
a very orderly way, but again, it made it very dull, going by policy by policy, which is very important,
00:14:22.980
I understand, but does not make for the most engaging listening. But I think what was the best
00:14:27.720
thing that Donald Trump did was that almost every single policy that they were discussing was that he
00:14:33.380
wrapped it back around into the immigration issue, which I think even more so than abortion for many
00:14:38.480
people is going to be a deciding factor for most voters, especially in the wake, as we'll get onto,
00:14:45.000
of the Springfield, Ohio case where the 20,000 Haitians have been, I think it's fair to say,
00:14:50.400
unleashed, is the appropriate term, on the local citizens.
00:14:54.540
They're acting as they would do in Haiti, surprise, surprise.
00:14:57.980
That magic soil, it takes the time to work, doesn't it? You need to wait for it to really kick in
00:15:02.460
before you start to get results. So, yeah, I think Trump was right. He made some very strong
00:15:07.260
statements regarding immigration, and he actually made some great points that engaging in the debate
00:15:13.460
in the first place is basically a waste of time. There was a slight criticism of the entire American
00:15:20.140
electioneering system at this debate, because Trump was pointing out, why are we doing this when
00:15:26.580
instead, you, being vice president of the current administration, could be at the White House right
00:15:31.520
now, coming up with solutions, proposing solutions, enacting solutions, making decisions to fix the
00:15:38.360
problems that are happening in this country. And again, one of the things that I noticed from
00:15:42.440
Kamala Harris when I was able to get past the irritating nasal whine of her voice was that she
1.00
00:15:49.420
didn't actually talk about any of the achievements of the Biden administration.
00:15:55.360
Yeah. Makes it kind of difficult, doesn't it? She was making lots of promises for what's going to
0.82
00:16:01.060
happen in the future. She was going to be giving a $50,000 tax rebate or tax cut to small business
1.00
00:16:09.020
owners who are going to be making, then starting up new small businesses. There's going to be some
00:16:13.500
kind of tax cut for the middle class. And then trying to say that Donald Trump was only going to
00:16:17.900
give tax cuts to the rich and the billionaires, etc, etc. All of the same rhetorical talking points that we
00:16:23.720
would expect these days. Donald Trump just turned around and said, you're a liar, you're a Marxist,
1.00
00:16:28.220
your father is a Marxist professor, we all know what you're actually like, you're one of the most
1.00
00:16:31.820
far-left liberals who's ever been in the government of the United States. So he was quite effective
00:16:37.640
in doing that. But I think some of the most important points can be basically summed up in a
00:16:42.400
few clips that I was able to find. One, which is when Donald Trump went very, very hard talking about,
00:16:49.260
you know, why are we wasting time? Why are you doing this? Yes, I've noticed. Ignore him. This
00:16:55.480
is just the clip that this particular man was able to get. Average Kamala Harris fan on the bottom
00:16:59.980
right. Yeah. She's so brat, don't you know? So here's Donald Trump excoriating her on why are we
00:17:05.900
doing this debate when you could be actually solving the problems? Why are we allowing these millions of
00:17:12.120
people to come through on the southern border? How come she's not doing anything? And I'll tell you what
00:17:16.480
I would do. And I would be very proud to do it. I would say we would both leave this debate right
00:17:21.680
now. I'd like to see her go down to Washington, D.C. during this debate because we're wasting a lot
0.99
00:17:27.980
of time. Go down to because she's been so bad. It's so ridiculous. Go down to Washington, D.C. and
00:17:34.020
let her sign a bill to close up the border because they have the right to do it. They don't need bills.
1.00
00:17:39.300
They have the right to do the president of the United States. You'll get them out of bed.
00:17:43.020
You'll wake them up at four o'clock in the afternoon. You'll say, come on, come on down
00:17:46.700
to the office. Let's sign a bill. If he signs a bill that the border is closed, all he has to do
00:17:52.440
is say it to the border patrol who are phenomenal. If they do that, the border is closed. Those people
00:17:58.160
are killing many people, unlike J6. We talked to him a really, really strong statement. That was 2016
0.98
00:18:05.040
Trump. Yeah, that was 2016 Trump. And when you get 2016 Trump coming out, which did happen a lot more
00:18:10.960
often in this debate, he has the same effect. He has that same charisma. He can grab your attention.
00:18:16.220
He can get you to laugh. But as well, he's advertising himself as that man of action.
00:18:20.420
He's saying, this administration, all that they've done has been a complete failure.
00:18:24.380
Everything that they've done is something that this country is ashamed of and has embarrassed
00:18:27.820
us on the national stage. I am the man of action who will make the difficult decisions
00:18:32.920
that we need to see in this country to fix those problems. So I think in moments like that,
00:18:37.900
he was very, very strong. And I think Rorak Nationalists actually took out a clip from his
00:18:43.020
closing statements, which sum it up very nicely here.
00:18:48.780
So she just started by saying she's going to do this. She's going to do that. She's going to do all
00:18:53.260
these wonderful things. Why hasn't she done it? She's been there for three and a half years.
00:18:59.200
They've had three and a half years to fix the border. They've had three and a half years to create jobs
00:19:05.800
and all the things we talked about. Why hasn't she done it? She should leave right now, go down to
00:19:12.140
that beautiful White House, go to the Capitol, get everyone together and do the things you want to
00:19:17.180
do. But you haven't done it and you won't do it because you believe in things that the American
00:19:21.820
people don't believe in. You believe in things like we're not going to frack. We're not going to
00:19:27.000
take fossil fuel. We're not going to do things that are going to make this country strong,
00:19:31.440
whether you like it or not. Germany tried that. And within one year, they were back to building
0.83
00:19:36.740
normal energy plants. We're not ready for it. We can't sacrifice our country for the sake of bad
00:19:44.920
vision. But I just ask one simple question. Why didn't she do it? We're a failing nation.
0.95
00:19:51.860
We're a nation that's in serious decline. We're being laughed at all over the world,
00:19:57.240
all over the world. They're left. I know the leaders very well. They're coming to see me.
00:20:01.040
They call me. We're laughed at all over the world. They don't understand what happened to us as a
00:20:06.400
nation. We're not a leader. We don't have any idea what's going on. We have wars going on in the
00:20:12.680
Middle East. We have wars going on with Russia and Ukraine. We're going to end up in a third world war
0.86
00:20:19.380
and it'll be a war like no other because of nuclear weapons, the power of weaponry. I rebuilt our entire
00:20:25.940
military. She gave a lot of it away to the Taliban. She gave it to Afghanistan. What these people have
0.75
00:20:34.280
done to our country and maybe toughest of all is allowing millions of people to come into our
1.00
00:20:40.300
country. Many of them are criminals and they're destroying our country. The worst president,
0.89
00:20:45.300
the worst vice president in the history of our country.
0.94
00:20:51.380
So a lot of Trumpism's thrown in there. Quite a bit of fire. You know, some have accused him of being
00:20:57.060
rambly, but I think he gets the point across that he's going for quite well. And again, that is the
00:21:02.860
important question that I think he kept harping on throughout. Why haven't you done it then?
00:21:09.100
The best way that I have found to frame any political issue is to put it on the people who
00:21:15.160
are in charge. They are to blame because all of these consequences are downstream of political
00:21:21.760
choices. Every single immigrant, illegal immigrant, legal immigrant, who kills a member of the
0.54
00:21:29.400
indigenous population, that is a political choice made by the government to keep making
0.85
00:21:35.520
Yes, certainly effective. He certainly thought it was effective because he went on Truth Social
00:21:39.960
straight after and said, I thought that was my best debate ever, especially since it was
00:21:52.440
This is the question. He did put a big post on Twitter a few weeks ago, didn't he? But I
00:21:56.440
think that's the only activity that's been on there since then. So, I mean, his posts on Truth
00:22:02.020
Social inevitably get onto Twitter one way or another. So, I suppose he thinks to himself,
00:22:07.320
ah, I don't need to do it directly anyway. And also, he has confidence within his own
00:22:13.100
platform. So, you know, I can't blame him for that. But I think one of, again, I mentioned
00:22:19.120
the Ohio situation. That might end up actually being a turning point because if we're going
00:22:24.580
to talk about how, you know, ghetto for Trump might have flipped a few voters within the
00:22:31.740
typically Democrat strong black American vote, then we've got to talk about how the kind
00:22:38.780
of bad publicity that's coming to the Biden administration through potentially cats and
00:22:44.320
dogs being eaten by rabid Haitians on the streets of Springfield, Ohio, is a bad PR move
1.00
00:22:51.940
for the Biden administration and might win Trump some votes as well, especially with the slop AI
00:22:58.380
meme campaign that immediately launched after... I love this. Yeah, I kind of love it. And also,
00:23:03.500
right, the great thing about this is it positions the wholesome love of the Anglo, of all of their furry
00:23:14.320
friends and feathered friends against the third world barbarism of if it crawls, walks or squawks,
0.80
00:23:22.500
I'll eat it. Like, that's... And so it just shows a big civilizational difference. And again,
00:23:28.260
it shows it's a political choice as to what attitude we have towards animals and who is brought
00:23:33.760
in to change that attitude. Yeah, certainly. And Trump was one to actually actively jump on it during
00:23:38.680
the debate. Here's a little clip. In Springfield, they're eating the dogs, the people that came in.
00:23:44.740
They're eating the cats. They're eating... They're eating the pets of the people that live there.
00:23:51.940
And this is what's happening in our country. And it's a shame. It's a shame. I love the... I love
00:23:59.160
the passion. It's like, they're eating the dogs. It's so good. It sounds like Frank Reynolds.
00:24:04.340
It really does. It's so good. But also, you know, we've seen this footage, these photos come out.
00:24:11.800
How can it be debunked? There are photos of it. The man has a whole goose.
00:24:16.460
Yeah. I've avoided the videos of people eating cats, but I have seen that they're going about.
00:24:22.120
It's happened in other European countries as well. We've seen it. Libs of TikTok has procured a police
00:24:27.040
report, police officers, where it's been called in that the Haitian migrants have been abducting the
00:24:32.420
police. I've got friends like Nate Hockman, who's going down there to interview the locals next week.
00:24:36.960
So all of this, oh, it's been debunked by local officials. Yeah, because it looks bad,
00:24:40.520
but it is actually happening. Yeah, well, local officials actually have a decision and choice
00:24:44.820
that they can make themselves, which is, are you going to report on it? Are you going to log it?
00:24:49.320
Are you going to admit it? Are you saying that local government can't also be corrupt or have its
00:24:54.860
own agenda that it wants to push and will spin or hide things because of that? I think that's very
00:25:00.840
naive and foolish or more likely just politically motivated in the first place. But as I mentioned,
0.98
00:25:06.160
there is the meme AI campaign going on right now to position Donald Trump as king of the kittens,
00:25:13.180
which is pretty great. This is great. This is great. If you're not watching and just listening
00:25:19.260
right now, I'd suggest you just look at your phone unless you're on your car or something. So just look
00:25:24.700
at the screen and see some of these. They're fantastic. Normally AI can be a bit hit and miss and a bit
00:25:29.200
try hard, but this is great. Look at this. It's wholesome and also reclaims the discourse of Trump
00:25:34.720
and Vance putting off quote unquote childless cat ladies. It's actually, no, no, we're family
00:25:38.640
friendly. We're also felon friendly. Well, yeah, that's the thing. Also, I don't know personally,
00:25:43.300
I don't know specifically, but I can't imagine that Donald Trump hates cats. Here he is in
00:25:48.520
Springfield, Ohio, actively saving cats from rabid Haitians. What a hero. Scroll down. Look,
1.00
00:25:57.640
they're eating the dogs is trending. In all caps. They're eating the dogs. And this, I assume this
00:26:04.840
is what he did immediately after the assassination attempt. He got off the podium and saw some Haitians
0.99
00:26:10.080
attacking cats and just knew what he had to do. He said, fight. Fist in the air. I joked with you
00:26:15.220
warfare. Maybe these Haitians just took the, um, the ducks are free meme from Alex Jones a little
1.00
00:26:19.780
too seriously. Yeah, perhaps. But even then you're not supposed to eat them. You weirdos. Take care of
00:26:25.120
this is what your cat is doing when you're away from the house. You've always wondered. We have
00:26:28.700
footage. Why do you keep calling this the Chinese visors? Why do you keep calling this the Chinese
00:26:35.040
visors? Why do you keep calling this the Chinese? There you go. Your cat loves him. You're going to
00:26:41.220
say no to your cat. If you are a childless cat lady right now, wouldn't you want to make your cat
1.00
00:26:45.260
proud? Here's Kamala Harris in the meantime. What she's planning on doing, this is a look. I've
00:26:50.760
looked into my crystal ball. This is a vision of Kamala Harris's America. This is what she's going
00:26:55.380
to be doing in the White House kitchen. Paired with a nice box of wine, I'm sure. Oh, sure. Only one?
00:27:01.260
My goodness. Here's, uh, what happened to Garfield after Biden and Kamala got their hands on him.
00:27:08.480
Yeah. Tragedy. I wonder why they couldn't rebuild after the earthquake. Is it maybe because their
00:27:12.880
civilization is really backwards? We also have live footage from what happened when the Haitians
1.00
00:27:24.140
Looks like kittens back on the menu, boys! Biden's fighting Uruk-hai at the ready.
00:27:30.860
Well, I have taken to referring to the sort of graffiti you see in diverse metropoles as the
00:27:36.520
white hand of Saruman. Yeah, actually. That works. That works quite well. And we've got
00:27:41.120
footage of... This is not the link that I put in there. Uh, here's the... Here's the, uh, footage
00:27:47.000
of Donald Trump. This is real, by the way. Don't fact check me on that. Kissing ducks.
00:27:52.780
He needs to retweet this. He does. He needs to... He needs to actively go out and do this as a
00:27:58.180
photo op, is what he needs to do. Trump feeding ducks would be a good... Especially with the grandkids.
00:28:02.700
That'd be a really nice photo. Exactly. But he's already done enough, I would say, in just
00:28:06.560
highlighting the issue as part of the debate to signal to everybody who cares about the
00:28:11.160
issue that he cares about the issue. Did Kamala say anything about it? No, she didn't.
00:28:15.540
Did you see the Gollum post, by the way? Uh, no, I missed that one. It's the man with
00:28:19.740
the geese, and it's contrasted to Gollum when he's singing in the Forbidden Pool, and it's
00:28:26.860
Oh, no. And, uh, I think one of the best things about this is that it's triggering the
00:28:32.760
libs. Here is Eric Salwell going berserk over it. This is the guy that farted in, live
00:28:38.860
on TV. Remember that? Apparently he also slept with the Chinese. Yeah, her name was Fong
1.00
00:28:43.760
Fong. You want some fun fun? Works every single time. What in the hell is this? The chairman
00:28:54.380
tweets, protect our ducks and kittens in Ohio because he goes some down, goes down some
00:29:01.240
crazy rabbit hole, completely debunked that aliens are eating pets? It's not aliens, it's
00:29:08.740
Haitians. My God. Are you okay, Mr. Chairman? Wait, is this real? Because last year, for a
0.99
00:29:15.480
very long time, you tweeted and promoted Kanye West as he was calling for genocide against
00:29:23.040
the Jews, the Jews, and you kept it up. And now, when we have victims coming here, you're
0.98
00:29:27.620
tweeting this nonsense. I don't know why you would do this. I hope you're okay. I don't
00:29:35.380
know if the aliens who are eating your ducks are in the room with us right now. But, Mr.
00:29:43.040
Chairman, this is a serious issue. These people have loved ones who have been lost. And you
00:29:49.660
tweeted this. This is a profoundly unserious person. A man actually losing his mind over
00:29:58.540
a fun meme of Donald Trump protecting ducks and cats. Not even a meme, actual photo confirmed,
00:30:05.040
fact-checked. It is actually happening. You liar. Well, yeah, exactly. Again, I shouldn't
00:30:10.180
be shocked by a man who cheats on his wife with a Chinese spy to have any integrity. All they
00:30:14.660
know how to do is lie, Connor. We know this. And then, of course, there are the incredibly
00:30:19.720
dishonest framings, as highlighted by Pagliacci, the hated, from leftists, saying that, oh, but
0.98
00:30:26.620
white rednecks go duck hunting. So what's the problem with this guy going into the local
0.98
00:30:36.280
Yeah, sure, you've got your duck hunting license and you've got all these regulations that you
00:30:40.380
need to stick to. But this guy went and randomly broke the neck of a potentially endangered goose.
00:30:48.800
Okay. I know recreational duck hunters from the States. I don't get it, personally. I don't
00:30:53.660
actually eat duck just because I feel too guilty, right? But they are playing-
00:30:57.280
I wouldn't go hunting if I went to America, but I wouldn't want to shoot-
1.00
00:31:04.380
Oh, Canada geese are a protected species, apparently, as well.
00:31:07.600
But they are playing into entire conservation ecosystem. So the money that the hunters pay
00:31:14.420
with their licenses, with the rental of equipment, that goes into conserving the natural area and
00:31:19.400
making sure the actual duck population flourishes. This is just a random third-worlder abducting
1.00
00:31:26.120
the feathered friends that kids feed in a park. There's a pretty big distinction there. If you
00:31:31.120
don't see that distinction, you're fundamentally dishonest or stupid.
1.00
00:31:33.600
Well, there's a few examples of the dishonest distinctions that could be made, but I like
0.99
00:31:38.220
the one that Pagliaggi put at the bottom, which is the equivalent would be someone getting
0.99
00:31:41.600
raped and you saying to them, well, you have sex, don't you? With the smug look on your
0.99
00:31:45.700
face. But that is essentially what's happening to America, isn't it? It's being raped. And
1.00
00:31:51.420
it's being raped by the Biden administration, and if things go the wrong way, by the potential
0.70
00:31:56.960
Kamala administration as well. So whilst the debate itself left a bit to be desired for me in
00:32:03.060
terms of pure entertainment value, these are very, very important decisions that are going to have
00:32:08.520
to be made in the coming months. So if you're going to go out and vote in America, vote wisely.
00:32:13.660
Right, before we move on, we've got some rumble rants, all pretty much pertaining to
00:32:17.140
Islander. So the Shadowbam at $10, congratulations on your second issue of Islander. Thank you very
00:32:21.300
much. Keith Kaiser, at Harry petitioned to change the Low Seasers intro song from...
00:32:27.060
Into a song from the Clayman album, even if as a one-off. You have no reference for that.
00:32:33.740
All I think is it's probably copyrighted, so we're really allowed to.
00:32:36.740
Well, no, no, no. But it would need to maybe do it in the style of the album Clayman by
00:32:40.920
Inflames, which I was actually listening to this morning on the way to work. That would
00:32:44.920
be awesome. If somebody wanted to mock that up, that would be fantastic. I don't have time
00:32:49.660
I personally think we should have made our own intro music long ago rather than just, you
00:32:53.860
know, using someone else's. But, because we've got an abundance of talent in the office.
00:32:57.220
I've done a version of it. Chris Gard sent me a version that he did for it.
00:33:07.580
And it's just been left in a drawer somewhere, hasn't it?
00:33:11.900
I'm not saying it's your fault it's been left in a drawer somewhere.
00:33:13.380
It's a version of the theme that already exists. It's the doot-doot-doots, but Chris did
00:33:19.240
his own version of it, which was a bit more impactful.
00:33:21.660
Okay, I'm sure we'll get right round to that in the next five years or so. Lady Dragon
00:33:26.260
Chris, $5. I bought Islander 2 within 10 minutes of the announcement video going up. Can't
00:33:30.220
wait to read it. Very wise choice. Good gal.
0.99
00:33:32.920
$2 from the last Russian Islander metal shirt. Looks awesome. I'm sure we'll be modelling some
00:33:39.340
I need a sort of Jordan Peterson style emblazoned blazer to wear something like that. So maybe
00:33:44.200
for issue three, we can get one of those going.
00:33:46.100
Are you going to get your Riddler Two-Face blazers going?
00:33:49.480
Just coming dressed like a Batman villain would be good. Oh, I went to an exhibition
00:33:53.800
where they had all their suits on display. Jim Carrey's Riddler costume is as gay as
1.00
00:34:01.240
Fair point. And one more from the last Russian. Don't snack on me. Kitten, no snip on snack.
1.00
00:34:05.980
Gadsden parody of a parody. That's a very dense, but I think he's saying have a kitten.
00:34:15.440
Someone, we should do that as a t-shirt. That'd be good, actually. That's not a bad
00:34:21.040
Yep. Samson, feed it back to Rory. Good man. Jamie, pull it up. And Bald Eagle for $2. I
00:34:26.060
love the moderator said there was no official stories on the Haitians eating animals and
00:34:29.120
pets. The local government are going to ignore all complaints because it's embarrassing for
00:34:32.360
them. They're also police reports, so they are official. So, okay, but whatever. Anyway.
00:34:37.280
Well, everyone, we often hear how the law is supposedly on our side. I think we sort of
00:34:43.500
comfort ourselves with that any time that you get arrested for a meme. Eventually, there are
00:34:48.860
champions of our rights and liberties, like ADF International, the Free Speech Union, who say,
00:34:55.520
don't worry, we will win out in the end. And they have some important legal cases. But even if
00:35:00.740
you do appeal to the tools of the enemy, like the Human Rights Act, the ECHR, or the Equality Act,
00:35:05.540
even if they do net us some wins, like realising biological sex or trying to reduce the number
00:35:11.020
of thought crimes recorded by the police, what matters less than the letter of the law, it turns
00:35:15.800
out, is who is applying the law. And so we'll be going through some new examples today just to show
00:35:19.980
you how much the state hates you. That's basically our job over here at LowersEats.com. The other job
00:35:25.100
we have is producing amazing things like Islander Magazine. If you read the first issue, well done,
00:35:29.680
you're a man of culture, I see. If you missed out on that, we have now issue two that are...
00:35:35.540
Our intrepid editor, Rory, has been working on diligently, sweating away, doing all the art,
00:35:40.160
getting all of the articles together. He has been sweating. He stinks.
00:35:42.600
Yeah, he honks. He reeks. That mullet is just dripping. Anyway, we have essays. We have more
1.00
00:35:47.760
essays this time around. We have essays from Carl. We have essays from Rory Nationalists and Niva
00:35:51.820
Parvini. We also have new writers like Dave Green and Stefan Molyneux. So if you are curious about what
00:35:57.540
they've written for this Apocalypse Edition, you can go and pick it up for £14.99. Same price as last
00:36:01.960
time, but more for your money. And because we listened to your feedback, this time we are
00:36:05.700
printing in batches rather than pre-ordering. So it should mean that as soon as you order,
00:36:09.480
links are down in the description, you should get it within two to three weeks. So long as
00:36:12.680
whatever country you live in doesn't try and stop you from getting the gloriousness of
00:36:16.620
Islander at the border. We also have lots of new merch. This is back there and I pressed
00:36:21.600
the wrong button, didn't I? There it is. The new merch, which is all of these wonderful
00:36:25.520
design t-shirts. They're also limited edition. So as soon as Islander 2 goes out of print,
00:36:38.900
Okay, four or five weeks. So in about a month or so, this is no longer going to be available.
00:36:43.920
So quickly, rush down to the shop. By the way, I wasn't listening to the voices in my
00:36:46.960
head. It was my producer. I'm sane. I promise. Anyway, let's quickly move on. First example
00:36:50.880
of this. Some bloke sent Jess Phillips a death threat. I think this is a good example to contrast
00:36:56.900
the two tiers of justice in the UK. So we're glad that this man, Nabil Arif, I'm sure she'll
00:37:03.080
say he's just a man, a man of nondescript identity from no particular location whatsoever, moving
00:37:09.440
swiftly on. And we're glad Nabil Arif has been jailed. He's only been sentenced to 12 weeks.
00:37:15.500
He sent Phillips some abusive messages, beginning from the Israel-Gaza war in October 2023. In one
00:37:21.580
message, he told Jess Phillips, hell is real and you will burn. And in the last email, he said that
00:37:26.760
he will burn her till her skin is no more. I mean, that's disgusting. It's a death threat. He should
0.99
00:37:31.480
get far longer than that. I think we all agree. The Crown Prosecution Service said he was sentenced
00:37:36.460
to only 12 weeks after a court, after a trial at the same court on the 29th of July. And he's made
00:37:42.560
the subject of a restraining order. So he shouldn't ever contact Phillips again. Curiously though,
00:37:46.860
and I want to note this, at the bottom of this article, they include some details about the
00:37:50.200
Israel-Hamas war. They say 1,200 people were killed in Hamas's October the 7th assault,
00:37:54.620
close to 41,000 people were killed, according to the health-run ministry in the Hamas-run
00:37:59.000
territory. So Guardian just dropped that in at the end of the article there, almost as like
00:38:03.440
an excuse for why he was making those claims. To contextualise it. So see how this is treated,
00:38:09.060
both by the Crown Prosecution Service and the Labour-friendly press, because... The Guardian
00:38:13.580
basically hinting, well, she was kind of asking for it. Yeah, quite. Because, contrast this with
00:38:18.760
the Guardian's reporting on this woman. This is Julie Sweeney, for those who don't remember,
00:38:23.380
of Church Lawton, Cheshire. She pled guilty at Chester Crown Court to sending a communication
00:38:27.660
to convey a threat of death or serious harm. She was jailed for about two years, and she said
00:38:33.300
something that is far less a direct threat, still very inadvisable, don't do it, it's silly,
00:38:37.700
but far less a direct threat than what the prior gentleman decided to say. So she was part of a
00:38:42.860
Facebook community group with 5,100 members, responding to a photograph that showed a number
00:38:47.040
of white and Asian people involved in cleaning up after Southport. She posted,
00:38:51.140
it's absolutely ridiculous, don't protect the mosques, and she said this, not me,
0.98
00:38:55.040
blow the mosque up with the adults in it. Again, that's a bit extreme. Stupid. Disavow.
1.00
00:38:59.940
Was she with the imminent ability of doing that? No. Was the other fella more likely to be able to do
0.97
00:39:06.380
that to Jess Phillips? Certainly. We know this because in Jess Phillips' own constituency,
00:39:10.860
there were masked Muslims that were armed, attacking pubs and publicans, occupying a roundabout and
00:39:17.740
threatening people in cars, which Jess Phillips herself tried to obfuscate for, by the way.
00:39:21.820
And so the sentencing judge, Stephen Everett, jailed her for 15 months, so a bit over a year
00:39:26.660
and a half. No, sorry, just under a year and a half. Telling her, you should have been looking
00:39:30.660
at the news and media with horror like every right-minded person. Instead, you chose to take
00:39:34.340
part in stirring up hatred. You had a big audience. You threatened a mosque. It was a truly terrible
00:39:38.040
threat. So it's not enough to tell this woman that what she posted was incitements of violence.
00:39:43.740
He had to give her a little moral beating as well. Tell her that here's how you're supposed to think.
00:39:50.920
I know that this will be reported in the newspapers, so I'm going to signal to everybody reading
00:39:55.560
how they should feel about things. Well, he says here, so-called keyboard warriors have to learn
00:40:00.820
to take responsibility for their language, particularly in the context of the disorder
00:40:04.540
that was going on around the country. Remember that phrase. The context of what's going on
00:40:08.660
broadly, more politically, influences the justice system. That is the point they're making.
0.51
00:40:13.080
Well, and it's also important to remember that when judges make statements like this,
00:40:17.360
they're not making them for the person that they're sentencing. They're making them
00:40:20.720
for the newspapers to report on so everybody can read what you're supposed to do.
00:40:24.940
And to set precedent in law for future cases. That's an important thing.
00:40:28.680
Also, important to note for the Guardian, notice something missing at the bottom of this article.
00:40:35.020
Ah, it's context about the Southport Massacre that would have otherwise explained why Sweeney
00:40:40.660
was so angry, unlike the prior article that ends with details about Gaza, from the Hamas-run
00:40:47.020
health agency as well, very reputable, that tries to contextualise why Arif sent Jess Phillips'
00:40:51.580
reprehensible death threat. So, again, two-tier reporting, two-tier justice system.
00:40:56.100
So, speaking of the right to protest, Policy Exchange. Have a report out on the pro-Palestine
0.89
00:41:00.700
protests. You can go and download the publication in your own time, give it a read if you have the
00:41:04.640
time to read a 150-page report. I wanted to pull out some findings from this because we can see here
00:41:09.800
that the attempt to ameliorate the justice system and the police and the Crown Prosecution
00:41:16.000
Service by principles and legislation and a mandate to duly, impartially carry out the law
00:41:23.800
is just going to end up giving them over more powers to prosecute people like us. So, it's
00:41:28.720
not encouraging. So, there's some things in here and it says, first of all, it goes into the costs
00:41:33.260
associated with importing this kind of ethno-religious tension that we saw on the pro-Palestine
00:41:37.780
protests. The Met Police state the costs of policing the Palestine protests in London between
00:41:41.880
October 2023 and June 2024 were £42.9 million, with 51,799 Metropolitan Police officers shifts
00:41:50.800
and 9,639 Police officer shifts from officers usually based outside the Metropolitan Police
00:41:56.220
area. The 6,339 police officers had rest days cancelled between October and April 2024, all
00:42:03.560
of which were to be repaid in due course. Bear in mind, as we've covered repeatedly on this
00:42:07.560
podcast, the exact kind of population to go on these pro-Palestine protests are not net tax
00:42:12.420
contributors. So, they are frustrating our capital city every weekend and Wednesday. So, this is even
00:42:15.620
more of a drain. Exactly. So, these people are costing us money anyway, and now they're costing us
00:42:20.140
extra money to agitate for a foreign war on behalf of the prescribed terror group. Bear in mind, this
00:42:25.880
happened in the aftermath of October the 7th, not in the aftermath of Israel's response to the
00:42:29.820
October the 7th. So, it was a celebration of what Hamas has done, not a complaint about how Israel
00:42:34.140
responded. The same population as well, same host population paying for it, don't want to visit
00:42:39.880
their own capital city during these protests. As a Londoner, I can agree. Polling was conducted by
00:42:43.820
Policy Exchange, and it showed members of the public choosing not to engage in a wide range of
00:42:47.620
activities because of these protests. They dropped their plans to travel with small children, 71%,
00:42:52.620
travel with an elderly or mobility-impaired friend or relative, 69%, visit a tourist attraction,
00:42:57.280
62%, go shopping, 58%, and eat at a specific restaurant, 58%. So, more costs, economic, but also
00:43:03.440
cultural, spiritual, if the host population are being demoralized and chased out of their own
00:43:07.600
capital city. Oh yeah, I can speak from my own personal experience. I've not been to London in
00:43:12.400
at the very least over a year, and I have no intention to go back if I can avoid it.
00:43:17.600
Why would I go there? It feels like navigating the rubble of the Tower of Babel at this point.
00:43:22.060
It's really unpleasant. It's smelly, it's busy, it's expensive. I want to get out as quickly as
00:43:26.720
possible. The main headline that came out of this report that everyone was reporting on,
00:43:29.560
they did an interview with Assistant Commissioner to the Metropolitan Police, Matt Twist, and he said
00:43:35.680
the following. When we look back at the policing of protests over the last eight months, we know we
00:43:40.100
didn't get everything right, particularly in the early stages of October. We've developed our tactics
00:43:44.160
since then, becoming faster and more decisive. On an occasion, we did not move quickly to make
00:43:48.860
arrests. For example, the man chanting for jihad, which was a decision made following fast time advice
0.72
00:43:54.500
from lawyers and the CPS. So guidance provided by the 700-strong Muslim activist network in the
00:44:00.620
Home Office and pro-immigration lawyers, which usually have an ethnic and religious bias, are
00:44:06.080
advising the Met not to crack down on people chanting for intifad and jihad. I wonder why.
00:44:12.200
We are now much more focused on identifying reasonable grounds for arrest, acting where
00:44:16.200
needed, and then investigating, so in these circumstances, it's very likely arrests would
00:44:20.060
be made more quickly now. Oh, it's very likely arrests would be made more quickly now in the
00:44:24.380
aftermath of another set of protests, which were the indigenous population protesting, and
00:44:29.760
so now you're going to get much harder on it. Isn't that fascinating? I wonder if anyone
00:44:35.480
from the post-Southport protests, or one of Mr. Robinson's rallies, not you, other one,
00:44:41.400
would have chanted, from the channel to the Irish Sea, Britain will be free. They'd be locked up in
00:44:46.320
handcuffs, but not the other way around. Got it. Also, an important detail that they find here.
00:44:51.600
So, in order to stage a protest in Britain, you have to give the authorities six days warning,
00:44:55.740
if you want to do a large-scale march. The Palestine Solidarity Campaign contacted the
00:44:59.960
Metropolitan Police to inform them of their intention to conduct their first mass Palestine protest,
00:45:04.680
ten hours after the terrorist attack on October 7th. Right. So, not protesting the gross injustices
00:45:13.960
by the Israeli regime, just open ethno-religious solidarity and celebrating murders? Why were any
00:45:21.640
of these allowed? Letter of the law could have stopped at any time, but it doesn't. That's most
00:45:27.240
important. So, the recommended response was that the government should legislate to establish a
00:45:32.000
protest commission for London. A protest commission for London. Involving independent
00:45:37.840
commissioners. Independent, as we always know, there is no such thing. There's no such thing as
00:45:42.440
a neutral process. It's always political. Appointed by the Home Secretary, following consultation with
00:45:47.300
the Mayor of London. Independent, appointed by the Labour Home Secretary and the Labour Mayor of London,
00:45:53.400
both of whom endorsed and oversaw the protests. Great suggestion. The government should amend
00:45:58.880
Section 11 of the Public Order Act 1986 to increase the notification period for all protest marches
00:46:03.420
to 28 days. But they'll just step over that if they want to. They'll let the ones they like go
00:46:09.360
ahead and they'll ban the ones they don't like, which they do anyway. The government should legislate
00:46:13.220
to require the police forces must take action to prevent the interference by protesters with the
00:46:17.580
operation of those installations of facilities classified as key national infrastructure and expand the
00:46:23.040
definition of national infrastructure under the Public Order Act 2023 to include Parliament,
00:46:27.500
government departments, and the courts. So they're anticipating some sort of physical attack on
00:46:35.580
government, parliaments, and the courts? Because the only thing I can think of in recent memory was
00:46:39.320
the protest outside the ceasefire debate where they projected from the river to the sea on Big Ben,
00:46:43.820
but they knew where the projector was, Martin Daubley pointed out, and the Met Police just shrugged
00:46:47.180
their shoulders and didn't arrest anyone, didn't even turn it off. So again, choices were made here.
00:46:51.600
They could have done it at any time. They also should make it unlawful for individuals at
00:46:55.960
protest to wear face coverings. So a couple of years after mandating them, they're now going to
00:47:00.680
make them illegal. Again, I would feel, I don't like face coverings, but I would feel comfortable
00:47:06.180
with people wearing face coverings if they weren't a demographic more likely to commit violence
00:47:11.700
against me for ideological or impulse control reasons. Sadiq Khan should also apparently conduct
00:47:16.300
an equality impact of the protests on businesses, tourism, and threats to women, the disabled,
00:47:20.700
and the elderly, which I'm sure he'll do completely impartially, just as he did with you, Les.
00:47:24.080
The Commissioner of the Met Police must take all possible steps to ensure all those that
00:47:28.740
are suspected of committing criminal offences at protests are arrested at the time of the
00:47:32.680
offence. So the police should do their jobs. That's an actual recommendation in a policy
00:47:39.680
As well, we saw with the Southport riots and protests that went on that the Metropolitan Police
00:47:45.640
will just hoover up anybody if they feel like it, depending on the cause of the protest in
00:47:50.720
the first place. Yes, but if it inflames community tensions at Notting Hill Carnival or the Palestine
00:47:55.380
riots, they'll let people go and sort of lazily try and track them down comfortably from their
00:48:00.740
desk with a cup of tea and a packet of biscuits afterwards. And maybe they might perform some
00:48:04.660
arrests. And even then they'll say, oh, a small minority were ruining it for the rest of us.
00:48:09.060
How could they? There's also this reminder, right? Providing the executive summary.
00:48:13.400
Central to these events is the claim of a right to protest, despite there being no such explicit
00:48:19.480
and unfettered right within the ECHR or the Human Rights Act 1998. Instead of a right to protest,
00:48:26.120
the following articles are allowing people to protest. Article 11, right to freedom of peaceful
00:48:32.140
assembly and association. And Article 10, the right to freedom of expression. Both rights are
00:48:36.460
explicitly qualified by restrictions as prescribed by law and unnecessary in a democratic society,
00:48:41.840
among other things, in the interest of national security or public safety, for the prevention of
00:48:46.460
disorder and crime, protection of health and morals, protection of the rights of others, etc., etc.
00:48:50.660
So all of these are nebulous definitions, and they just allow the state to pretend that they're
00:48:56.360
ratifying and making impartial decisions on human rights, and instead punish their political enemies
00:49:01.100
and favour their political friends. And the perfect example of this is the recommendation in here that
00:49:05.320
the Crown Prosecution Service must amend its legal guidance on offences during protests,
00:49:09.220
demonstrations or campaigns, to reduce the likelihood of suspects not being prosecuted for
00:49:13.780
public interest reasons. That's literally what the judge said in Sweeney's case, that we're going
00:49:18.540
to teach you keyboard warriors a lesson. None of that was said about Arif, even though we had the
00:49:23.740
Palestine marches and we had those armed Muslims in Jess Phillips' own constituency. There wasn't a need
1.00
00:49:29.360
to talk about democratic principles or a chilling effect there. Just give him a few weeks, a few months
00:49:35.580
in prison and keep him shut up about it. Again, this is what I found, I remembered this, you
00:49:41.480
tweet this out a while ago, this is your law, Harry's law in effect. You tweet it out, no matter
00:49:46.160
its intended foreign target, anti-terrorist technology and intelligence departments will
00:49:50.120
be inevitably used to spy on and imprison white European populations. This is exactly that.
0.94
00:49:55.260
Well, if the purpose of a system is what it does, then the purpose of the UK government is to
00:50:00.940
Quite, yes. Perfect example of this is the Equality Act.
00:50:03.360
The Equality Act that people keep saying we need to appeal to, to get gender critical
00:50:07.240
wins, for example. This chap, Mr. S. Thomas. Bear in mind, he does use social media like
00:50:13.320
a boomer in here, so I will point that out. He went to an employment tribunal about the
00:50:17.860
NHS, claiming that he, as a contractor, had been discriminated against for his English
00:50:24.020
nationalist views. So the point of the Equality Act is it's meant to protect certain
00:50:29.840
characteristics, as in the government's favoured ones, and certain beliefs from discrimination
00:50:35.240
in employment. So, for example, it's intersectionality codified in law. You can obviously actively,
00:50:42.160
positively discriminate against white, straight Christian men, but you can't discriminate against
0.95
00:50:47.140
black women, for example. The recent win that we supposedly got was the Meyer-Folstater
00:50:51.300
case, where gender critical, aka believing in biological sex, beliefs are now protected characteristic
00:50:56.860
under the Equality Act. But this just shows that even if you try and appeal to the Equality
00:51:00.300
Act to get wins, they will just selectively apply it, if and where. Because this chap,
00:51:07.060
By the end of the hearing, Employment Judge Hyde considered the third question from the list
00:51:14.900
Were his anti-Islamic views worthy of respect and democratic society, incompatible with human
00:51:21.360
dignity, and did they conflict with the fundamental rights of others, such that they would prevent
00:51:25.120
the claimant's belief in English nationalism from being a protected characteristic, aka, did they
00:51:29.420
offend Muslims, therefore, can we fire him from his job? And they say, to the claimant,
00:51:35.160
And he identifies his views. So the claimant, English nationalism is the nationalism that
00:51:39.140
asserts the English are a nation and promotes, bless you, the cultural unity of English people,
00:51:44.080
the claimant's focus is on national identity which does not depend on ancestry or race rather
00:51:48.000
than common descent or race. So he's very boomer, civic nationalism, England is a set of values,
00:51:54.960
ideals, and even that is too far gone for the Equality Act. So he's not even arguing for
00:52:01.200
protection on the basis of ethnicity or racial identity, he's arguing for the protection on the
00:52:04.740
basis of values, and even then, they're making the discrimination against which values are
00:52:08.320
preferred by the state, versus which values are prescribed by the state.
0.82
00:52:11.660
Yeah, they're saying, sorry mate, Britain is gay race communism values.
00:52:17.360
Judge Hyde observed in cross-examination before the Leeds Employment Tribunal,
00:52:20.580
the claimant has said that Islam in its current form should be banned from England unless it were
00:52:24.120
anglicised and toned down to fit within society in England. So even then he's being quite generous.
00:52:29.400
Employment Judge Hyde commented at the hearing before her,
00:52:32.020
the claimant did not dispute these comments were consistent with his English nationalism.
00:52:35.560
The claimant alleged his assignment within the NHS trust had been terminated because of his
00:52:39.680
belief in English nationalism. He claimed this was belief discriminatory contrary to the Equality
00:52:44.120
Act 2010. At a hearing, the Employment Tribunal held the claimant's belief was not protected by
00:52:49.580
the Equality Act. The claimant appealed this decision. The appeal is dismissed. The claimant's
00:52:54.360
views are of an English nationalism which believes there is no place in British society for Muslims or
00:52:58.260
Islam itself. Among the claimant's views are that the Muslims should be forcibly deported from the
0.74
00:53:02.300
United Kingdom. These views are not capable of protection under the European Convention on
00:53:06.280
Human Rights as they would offend Article 17 which provides that nothing in this convention may be
00:53:11.040
interpreted as implying for any state group or person to engage in any activity or perform any act
00:53:18.440
aimed at the destruction of any rights and freedoms set forth herein at the limitation to a greater
00:53:23.300
extent that's provided in the convention. The claimant has not prevented from holding his views,
00:53:27.660
but he is outside of the right to complain that he has been discriminated against in relation to
00:53:31.620
those beliefs in the circumstances covered by the EQA. It's obvious that he's been discriminated
00:53:36.380
against on the grounds of his belief because this is happening in the judgment. And so what the
00:53:41.440
Equality Act exists to do is designate certain beliefs and certain characteristics above certain
00:53:46.900
others and afford them certain legal protections over the indigenous host population. And I don't
1.00
00:53:53.640
necessarily want to use the Equality Act for any of this. I would rather the entire thing were
00:53:56.460
scrapped, but the point matters that who applies the law matters less than the consistent letter of
00:54:01.860
the law. And here's a great example. Um, Mel B and some Labour politician for Birmingham Erdington,
00:54:09.300
Paulette Hamilton MP, are trying to bring forth an amendment to protect Afro hair under the Equality Act.
00:54:15.140
No. If it was up to me, no. I mean, again, we'd scrap the whole thing if it was up to me,
00:54:24.540
Yeah, well, you're in a joke of a country, so actually, um, our favourite independent journalist,
00:54:27.880
Kandi Drucker, has given us a vision of the future. Uh, you're under arrest for describing a mixed-race
1.00
00:54:32.000
woman's hair as frizzy without an Afro hair ally licence, which is a serious crime. It's all in here,
1.00
00:54:36.800
mate. You're going away for a long time. Makes me sick there are people like you walking the streets.
00:54:40.340
Well, not for much longer. You think I'm joking? Yeah, I mean, this is, I've seen him post a few
00:54:46.440
of these with this particular gentleman, uh, this particular officer holding up a variety of books,
00:54:51.880
the, um, Second Treatise on Government. Second Sex was one of them. Uh, the, the Second Sex, um,
0.97
00:54:57.680
Vindication of the Rights of Women. It's all in here, mate. It's all in here. This is why we're
0.98
00:55:02.360
doing this. Set text by the College of Policing. Now, look, I'll wrap this up because, um, you think I'm
00:55:06.260
joking. I wish. I wish we weren't a joke of a country because this actually could be possible because
00:55:10.160
Yvette Cooper is bringing back non-crime hate incidents. And we say bringing back because
00:55:14.820
for end of the show, Harry Miller in 2021 took the College of Policing to court and it was ruled
00:55:19.460
that the way they were recording these non-crime hate incidents was unlawful. They were giving you
00:55:23.260
a black mark on your DBS check, not informing you of who had made the claim, what evidence the claim
00:55:27.860
was, and if you had a claim against you. And so you could be turned down for jobs without ever
00:55:31.060
knowing why. And because there's no evidentiary standard, the people that were making the claim
00:55:35.160
were treated automatically as the victims and you as perpetrators, even though they're not
00:55:39.380
crimes. He had found that between 2014, when these were adopted as a result of the McPherson
00:55:45.320
report and 2020, over 120,000 of these have been recorded. We now estimate 250,000 of these
00:55:53.140
have been recorded. And despite Suella Braveman in 2023 putting in the Police Crime Sentencing
1.00
00:55:59.340
and Courts Bill, new legislation and guidance being given to the College of Policing to stop
00:56:04.860
recording these for frivolous reasons, they went up last year. The law does not matter.
00:56:11.500
30 of the 43 police forces in England and Wales increased the number of non-crime hate incidents
00:56:16.320
they recorded. So, I just want to reiterate for everyone, and you can find out more about
00:56:21.500
these stats in a recent episode of my show that I did there, I broke it down for an hour
00:56:24.520
and a half, it's very laborious, but hopefully a useful resource. The point of this segment is
00:56:28.860
to reiterate, as Thomas Hobbes once said, autoritas non veritas facit legem. Authority,
00:56:35.180
not truth, makes law. And the people applying the law are the authority. That matters more
00:56:46.840
Apologies. I think sometimes we just have to sort of catalogue these events.
00:56:50.260
Well, no, that's absolutely fair. We can provide a sort of resource for anybody who's looking
00:56:55.340
to see what's going on in the country. We have one more rumble rant before we move on to the
00:57:00.140
next segment. Keith Kaiser, live news at the moment, Keir Starmer is under fire for not providing
00:57:05.280
any stats about how cutting winter fuel payments would help the economy. It seems to be an attack
00:57:08.900
on Tory voters' thoughts. I was speaking to a senior political source earlier in the week,
00:57:15.280
and they explained to me the reason he's actually doing this is because the OBR and the Bank of
00:57:19.200
England work together to say that there are certain things you cannot touch because we have
00:57:24.740
existing spending commitments that are Acts of Parliament. So for example, everyone's hitting
00:57:29.520
him for the foreign aid budget, quite rightly so. That's where all the climate spending is coming
00:57:32.780
from. That's where all of the first year of refugee, asylum seeker, illegal migrant payments are coming
00:57:38.780
from. They're all coming out of the foreign aid budget. The foreign aid budget is set by an Act of
00:57:42.300
Parliament, so it would take him two years to repeal that. If he needs to make savings now, the only
00:57:46.700
place the OBR have told him he can do it is in public spending, but he's just giving loads of money to the
00:57:51.340
unions or pensions. So he's making cuts with the winter fuel payment, and he thinks that he can
00:57:55.820
weather the bad PR storm in the short run. I think this is a bad call.
00:58:01.100
This whole bad PR storm in the short run, his entire Prime Ministerial career so far has been
00:58:09.700
a bad PR storm. So the fact that he still turns around and goes, I've made every wrong decision,
00:58:16.980
I've stepped on every landmine, what's one bad decision, what's one landmine more?
00:58:25.080
Yeah, this man is going to go down as the most unpopular Prime Minister of all time, and rightly
00:58:31.120
so, and somehow he's managed to achieve it within months of having taken over from the most unpopular
00:58:36.740
Tory regime of all time. I mean, it's ridiculous. They really should just start handing out big shoes
0.97
00:58:43.700
and red noses when they step into Parliament, shouldn't they, these days?
00:58:47.720
Well, I think you can tell Tony Blair is very displeased as well, because he keeps coming out
00:58:50.940
actively counter-signalling everything that Starmer's doing.
00:58:53.740
Tony Blair basically came out recently and said, why aren't we sending them home?
00:58:58.040
Well, I think that was a sort of Hobson's choice to reopen free movement with the EU.
00:59:03.500
But he was right. What benefit having large dependent Asian and African families imported into Britain
1.00
00:59:10.100
Well, the thing that he contrasted the idea of the free EU movement was, well, yeah, we
00:59:15.240
had single people from Eastern Europe coming over, which I don't think is true. Purely
00:59:21.120
true. But he contrasted it with the, why do we have all of these people basically saying,
00:59:25.720
switch it back to how I was doing it, they have to go home.
00:59:29.740
Tony Blair staring down from a balcony at a Notting Hill carnival, sneering, we need to
00:59:38.580
We've got a seven point plan here, says Tony Blair.
00:59:41.260
So $5 from Eiffenheimer, I hope I pronounced that right. I didn't, I'm sure. E-E-F-A in
00:59:50.800
We had a pro-Palestine peaceful protest in Melbourne, Australia yesterday. They threw chairs,
00:59:56.200
crates, and horse excrement at our mounted police. Our police arrested the lot of them.
01:00:00.540
Well, I'm glad at least the police are operating in some competent fashion. It's just a shame they
01:00:05.420
learn those tactics from lockdown when they weaponize that against the native population.
01:00:09.740
Oh, oh, it's, uh, it's, um, I think explaining how to pronounce the name.
01:00:17.640
I apologize. I, I'm stupid. Uh, Threadnought, $5. Damn you. And he calls me Colin, but it's
0.95
01:00:23.820
Connor. Um, I was going to point out- I don't know why they've started calling you Colin
01:00:28.820
No, it's a bit of a dead meme. I was going to point out Stammer as, he doesn't Stammer,
01:00:33.500
um, mimicry of Sideshow Bob. No, he's, he's so robotic. He doesn't actually trip over his
01:00:37.860
words. He just like recites whatever script has been fed to him.
01:00:40.540
I've seen him trip over his words a few times. But anyway, thank you very much for those
01:00:45.240
rumble rants. Let's get into this last segment, which is about the death of the Internet Archive
01:00:50.400
and its massive online library, at least certainly the destruction of a massive portion of that
01:00:56.280
library. And I've got to be honest, I might upset a few people, uh, with this segment because
01:01:01.160
I'm not going to be entirely on the Internet Archive side as a company, as an organization.
01:01:06.580
I think the resources that they had compiled as part of their online library, which allowed
01:01:11.820
you to check out books for free online as if you were going to a library and had a massive
01:01:17.160
wealth of out of print and difficult to find books that you could get for free, uh, was
01:01:23.760
really fantastic. I've used it a lot of times, but as a company, um, they're shit libs and
1.00
01:01:32.040
Wasn't one of them related to Taylor Lorenz and tried to retroactively edit the Archive
01:01:40.420
That might be the case. I don't recall exactly, but I remember it being reported at the time.
01:01:45.120
And so, um, I'm not going to confirm it, but nor will I, uh, deny it.
01:01:50.080
Yes. Uh, first though, uh, one thing that will be very limited run and out of print soon
01:01:56.000
will be issue two of Islander, which I know that we've only just announced, but it is a
01:02:00.100
limited run for a reason. When we say limited, we mean limited. This is going to be your only
01:02:05.520
opportunity for the next month or so to get a hold of a copy of this. If you order it now,
01:02:10.680
it'll be printed to order and you'll have it within about two to three weeks. Got excellent
01:02:15.000
articles all written by a wealth of authors, some returning from the first issue like Dr.
01:02:20.060
Nima Parvini, Carl Benjamin, and others with some newbies, including Dave Green, the distributist,
01:02:26.020
Stefan Molyneux, and more. And also along with that, we've got the merchandise that's come
01:02:31.420
along with it. So you can get a hold of that. You can get a mug, you can get a shirt, or you
01:02:36.300
can get the awesome shirt, the best shirt, but don't buy too many of those. Cause I'm going
01:02:41.440
I'm not replacing my mug with one of those, but they are wonderful mugs.
01:02:44.320
Yes, they are wonderful mugs. They're just not gay enough for Connor.
1.00
01:02:50.600
I got a little giggle out of Samson. Anyway, uh, so let's look at what's been happening
0.97
01:02:55.680
here. So what's happened is the internet archive was being sued by a large, uh, conglomeration
01:03:02.000
of different publishing companies, including companies like, uh, I think it was, um, Hatchet
01:03:08.280
House. I'll, I'll go through the articles in fact, and just confirm before I start to
01:03:11.720
make a fool of myself any more than I already do on this show. Uh, so it says in here that,
01:03:16.920
uh, libraries across the country temporarily closed in the early days of the pandemic.
01:03:20.860
The internet archive had the idea to make its library of scanned books free to read
01:03:25.540
in an online database. They already had this library, which is made up of books that have
01:03:29.820
been legally purchased and then scanned and submitted to the website. Um, they already
01:03:35.020
had that, but they had a very particular system involved in it, which is explained a bit better
01:03:39.700
in the next link over. So I'll save it till then. The question of the library's legality
01:03:43.580
became a long running saga that may have finally ended on last Wednesday when an appeals court
01:03:48.020
affirmed that the internet archive violated copyright laws by redistributing these books
01:03:52.620
without a licensing agreement. The decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second
01:03:56.860
Circuit in Manhattan is a victory for the major book publishers that brought the lawsuit in
01:04:01.140
2020 and could set a precedent over the lawfulness of broader digital archives. The defendant attempted
01:04:07.020
to do what no one had done before, said Maria A. Pallant, president of the Association of
01:04:11.400
American Publishers, which helped coordinate the industry response. They said, uh, she said,
01:04:16.060
they were trying to call unauthorized distribution of entire books, lending without permission.
01:04:21.100
Obviously, we're delighted with this new decision. So the federal court had ruled against them in
01:04:26.040
March 2023, and then they'd appealed. Uh, that, uh, court ruling against them meant that they had to
01:04:31.440
remove a lot of books from the library that were on there, half a million. In fact, in its appeal,
01:04:37.380
the non-profit argued that its free digital library was protected by so-called fair use laws,
01:04:43.580
and that scanning the books was a transformative use of the material done in the public interest,
01:04:50.280
and the court rejected that claim. And I know that this whole thing is a shame. I think the
01:04:54.780
Internet Archive is a really great resource for people, anybody online, not just for the library
01:05:00.100
that they use, but for the archiving of old digital web pages as well. Um, given that a lot of that gets
01:05:05.600
lost to history, sometimes it's really good to be able to archive this stuff so that you can keep
01:05:10.380
track of it, but that's an awful argument. It shows a clear lack of understanding of how copyright law
01:05:18.600
works if you say that scanning the book and then printing it online is somehow transformative.
01:05:25.120
The whole point of transformative is that it doesn't occupy the same use that the original did.
01:05:30.820
That's like, if I snuck a phone into a movie theater, recorded it on my phone, and then posted
01:05:34.980
the whole thing online, I could argue it's a transformative work because the quality is
01:05:44.020
You're welcome to try the argument, but it won't work.
01:05:47.320
It won't work just like it didn't here. Um, so I do think that the entire line of argument
01:05:51.720
that they were going down there was, at best, an arse pull. Very clearly.
0.97
01:05:56.200
They carry on to say that, uh, to construe the Internet Archive's use of the works as transformative
01:06:00.240
would significantly narrow, if not entirely eviscerate, copyright owners' exclusive right
01:06:04.420
to prepare derivative works. We were, if, uh, and then it goes on to say, uh, if we were
01:06:11.380
to approve the Internet Archive's use of the works, there would be little to no reason for
01:06:15.340
consumers or libraries to pay publishers for content they could access for free on the
01:06:19.520
website. So, basically just saying, you would eliminate the entire profit part of the publishing
01:06:26.140
market if we were to allow this decision to go through. Because all of a sudden, you could
01:06:31.040
just scan books online anytime and they would be legally available for free for everyone.
01:06:39.220
In a petition to publishers to reverse the lower court's decision, the Internet Archive said
01:06:42.680
it had removed over half a million books from its public archive. Unlike traditional libraries
01:06:47.000
which pay licensing fees to publishers to make their books available for lending, the Internet
01:06:50.920
Archive acquires copies through donated or purchased books to scan and put online. The non-profit
01:06:55.600
is also known for Wayback Machine, a popular database of past webpages. There's a bit more
01:06:59.540
of an explanation in here that I'll quickly go over. So, the open library lets patrons check
01:07:05.960
out books for a limited amount of time. The library only has as many digital versions as
01:07:11.140
it has physical copies. A system called controlled digital lending. Whether they're housed at the
01:07:15.860
Internet Archive's own facilities or in the shelves of its 130 plus partner libraries across
01:07:20.500
the US, each of these books was legitimately purchased from publishers. As the electronic
01:07:25.580
Frontier Foundation, part of IA's defense team, wrote in a statement,
01:07:29.440
libraries have paid publishers billions of dollars for the books in their print collections
01:07:32.600
and are investing enormous resources in digitizing in order to preserve those texts.
01:07:38.060
In March 2020, as COVID-19 spread, the Internet Archive moved to temporarily allow an unlimited
01:07:44.020
number of people to access the same copies. A project called the National Emergency Library
01:07:48.500
that aimed to provide lockdown-bound students and professionals unable to access physical libraries
01:07:52.880
at least some of the resources that they needed to do their work. So, they opened it up in a way that
01:07:57.140
meant it wasn't like a library and just as many people as wanted could get these books, which seemed
01:08:01.580
to be what attracted the attention of this big conglomeration of different publishers.
01:08:06.640
Then, in June 2020, publishers Hatchet, HarperCollins, Penguin Random House, and Wiley filed the lawsuit for the
01:08:12.380
infringement of their copyrights of 127 works. Publishers claimed that as long as readers could
01:08:18.340
be patrons of a free digital library, their physical and e-book sales could suffer. The Internet Archive
01:08:22.780
actually brought in experts who conducted studies that found that the closure of the National
01:08:26.960
Emergency Library did not affect publishers' sales of physical copies and e-books. In fact, it
01:08:31.220
apparently, according to this study, decreased them in some cases. I could see that potentially being the
01:08:37.500
way that it would work, if only because if somebody can read a book online, it might actually inspire
01:08:42.060
them to purchase a physical copy. Personally, I've done that a few times where I've looked at
01:08:46.020
excerpts or some copies that you can find online of particular books, even through the Internet Archive,
01:08:51.480
and then purchase them afterwards because I think it's nice to have the physical copy. Also, I find I
01:08:56.520
retain the information a little bit better if I'm not reading them off a computer screen.
01:09:00.060
I do the same with comic book omnibuses. Like, I'll go and look at an issue in the middle of a run before I go and
01:09:05.520
pick up an omnibus because I'd rather check out two very flimsy issues before I spend 80 to 90 quid on
01:09:12.340
a 50-issue run, but then having that preview expands your market. It reminds me of back when,
01:09:18.240
do you remember when Nintendo, in the sort of 2014-15 era, was hitting loads of content creators with
01:09:23.580
copyright strikes for their gameplay footage, and they were saying, this is not just transformative,
01:09:27.800
it's also free advertising for you guys and more people are going to buy your games. They eventually
01:09:31.080
cottoned on. I do wonder, though, if this is just trying to put the lid on a sputtering pot because
01:09:37.120
the nature of the Internet means that once your book has taken a digital form, the amount of work
01:09:42.960
that goes into creating the product, its means of distribution will diminish the amount of profit
01:09:49.760
you can get over time. Like, if you pay someone a modest fee to generate an article which is free to
01:09:55.580
access, and it does the rounds, it not only generates advertising for your outlet, and therefore
01:10:01.680
ad revenue and interest, but it also means that the production cost is relatively low to the amount
01:10:06.860
that you spend. Production costs are relatively high relative to the amount of time that's spent
01:10:11.020
on creating a book, and if there's a sort of patronage market for physical books, that's great,
01:10:16.560
that keeps it going. People are more inclined to spend more physical copies, but the moment you have
01:10:20.500
a digital book market, of course you're going to get piracy. I think eventually it's just going to go
01:10:23.740
sort of free by the nature of, you can't stop every website from hosting this stuff.
01:10:27.980
Well, there is also the point that I've seen the statistic, I think it's something ridiculous like
01:10:33.420
80-90% of books get less than 2,000 readers that are printed these days. Most books that do get
01:10:40.480
published, even by the larger publishing houses, don't actually sell all that well, especially if
01:10:46.600
you're working in non-fiction, and especially if you're working in non-fiction as specialist and niche
01:10:51.660
subjects. They will be, inherently, books that only appeal to a very small audience, and so there is
01:10:59.520
a utility in having them available for free to a larger audience, because as you said, it gets it
01:11:04.860
out there, makes it more easy to access, and especially if it's gone out of print, you're
01:11:09.280
likely not going to be getting any money from the resales that happen anyway, because it'll be old
01:11:13.240
pre-owned copies that are getting traded about, so why not have them available for free at an easier
01:11:18.980
to access platform? The other thing is, the publishers themselves are turning away otherwise
01:11:23.840
profitable authors. Nigel Bigger had his book ready to go out the door, and it was cancelled,
01:11:28.880
and they had to find a new publisher. They nearly walked out over Jordan Peterson's second book
01:11:32.900
at Penguin Random House, and I was working with an imprint of Hachette to get mine across the line,
01:11:38.220
and right at the end, there was a... Is that how it's pronounced, by the way? Is it Hachette?
01:11:41.720
Yes, I didn't want to correct. You can correct me as well. I didn't want to be a dick. There was a DEI
01:11:46.520
obsessed executive that stepped in at the last minute of the acquisitions meeting when I was
01:11:49.760
going to get my deadline and said, no, we're passing. So this was over a year of work just up
01:11:53.320
the spout, and now I've got to look around elsewhere for some imprint. They had already...
01:11:57.480
I'm sure you'll find somebody. It's difficult. Yeah. They had already said, we're going to make this
01:12:02.800
amount of money on it because we're going to at least reach this number of people because of the
01:12:06.400
number of views that this show and my other stuff gets, and they still passed up a very profitable
01:12:11.220
venture for purely ideological reasons. Yes, and speaking of the actions of the publishers,
01:12:17.260
the publishers themselves in this did not provide empirical data to support their observation
01:12:21.660
that it would decrease the sales. The court nevertheless decided it was self-evident that
01:12:26.040
publishers would suffer market harm in the future if the Internet Archive's practices were to become
01:12:30.220
widespread. Now, I will say there is a practical example of something like this happening in the past,
01:12:35.280
which is with music. There was Napster 20 plus years ago. At this point, Metallica very famously
01:12:41.180
filed a lawsuit against Napster for stealing their music, and a lot of the complaints that Lars Ulrich
01:12:47.020
was making at the time, which was that if the piracy, the free piracy of music online became
01:12:53.160
widespread, it probably wouldn't necessarily affect Metallica's bottom line because they were already a
01:12:57.460
huge multi-million dollar selling band who can, you know, sell out arenas and stadiums across the
01:13:03.320
world. It will affect the ability of younger bands who don't have those opportunities already at their
01:13:09.320
feet to actually make money. And especially since Spotify has become a thing, Spotify is very
01:13:14.380
controversial in just how little money it pays out to any of the people who host on that platform.
01:13:19.920
It pays out something, a ridiculously small number, like something like 0.00001 cent per stream.
01:13:27.700
So you have to be, you have to go viral to actually make any money off of it. And it does mean that it's
01:13:32.460
very, very difficult for musicians to make money. But at the same time, it seems that this might just
01:13:38.600
be a sad fact of distribution of any media on a digital online platform. As things progress,
01:13:46.060
I don't see that there's a way to turn the clock back. It's a sad state of affair for anybody who's
01:13:52.220
creative. The best that you can hope is that you're able to become popular enough that if you're a
01:13:56.600
musician, that you can play gigs and sell merchandise that will make you money. And if
01:14:01.200
you're an author, I couldn't say, I don't know. But as it carries on in this article, the ruling
01:14:07.320
triggered the immediate removal of over 500,000 books. Over 1,300 of these books are either banned
01:14:14.160
or challenged in the US. If they haven't been removed from school and public libraries, they
01:14:19.060
might soon be. The open library used to be the last shred of hope for the average person
01:14:23.780
had a free access to such books. Now that they've been removed, the book bans feel totalizing.
01:14:28.860
On Twitter, Internet Archive has mentioned the oh-so-ironic removal of George Orwell's 1984
01:14:34.540
and Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451. We'll get onto that in a moment.
01:14:39.920
Also, alongside this at the same time, a recent lawsuit from Universal's music group,
01:14:44.860
Sony Music Entertainment, could result in high enough damages to put an end to the Internet
01:14:49.200
Archive altogether, which could take out the Wayback Machine with it, which would be,
01:14:52.840
again, a great shame. And as much as I say that all of this is a great shame and something to feel
01:14:59.240
bad about because of the fact that, yeah, it's a fantastic resource, whatever the ideological
01:15:03.900
positions of the people running it, the ideological position of those people is something that I'm going
01:15:10.120
to criticize now because I have to. First, here's the statement that they made on it. They're just
01:15:14.640
saying they're disappointed they're going to continue trying to appeal for it. It could go to
01:15:18.480
the Supreme Court, but who knows if they'll be able to get that there. Let's examine this claim
01:15:24.140
of banned books. So on their blog itself, they say that we had over 1,300 banned and challenged books. Oh my goodness.
01:15:38.740
Happily, as you can see here, there is a link that you can click that takes you to a long list of this.
01:15:49.400
Here's what you find. Well, first of all, as you may notice, there's quite a few cheats.
01:15:54.280
Quite a few cheats in here because 1984 is listed 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 times,
01:16:00.780
all under different years published. So they just had a load of different versions of the book,
01:16:06.340
which they're all lumping in as different books to plump the numbers.
01:16:10.120
If you scroll down, abortion and politics of motherhood. If I go down to, where is it, to the G section,
01:16:19.720
you can see that you end up finding books like gay believers, gay issues and policies, gay and lesbian,
01:16:25.300
gay people of colour facing. So what they've done here, being that it is a leftist organisation,
0.53
01:16:31.540
and also they've got Harry Potter in here, for goodness sake. What they've done is go,
01:16:36.140
these are the books that schools and the parents of children don't want in their schools.
01:16:42.600
Therefore, they're banned, which is a claim that we've all criticised on this podcast many times.
01:16:48.220
Therefore, the Internet Archive Library is the only way that your child, your son or daughter,
01:16:54.280
might have access to a book that you don't want them to have access to in the first place,
01:16:59.220
even though if you wanted to, you could still buy it for them from a shop or from Amazon.
01:17:03.660
But a few things on that. Any school is entitled to not have 1984 in it, because of the sexual content in it.
01:17:12.160
So they don't say which schools banned it, they don't say for what reasons. I would presume it's not-
01:17:17.940
Same with Brave New World. I would assume Harry Potter was banned by some of the more orthodox religious schools,
01:17:23.700
both Muslim and Christian, for the glorification of magic and witchcraft.
1.00
01:17:27.640
So, it might even have been banned by some because book four accidentally glorifies slavery.
01:17:33.480
Or, yeah, or because now J.K. Rowling is an apostate for gender ideology.
01:17:41.160
I mean, Adventures of Huckleberry Film was probably banned because it uses the N-word explicitly.
01:17:46.380
And so, this is lumped in with what I can only describe as LGBT propaganda.
01:17:54.780
Yeah, so I do have to criticise them for the dishonesty, and the response to this ruling has been very, very leftist in general,
01:18:03.020
because some of the stuff that they've been posting on their Twitter page has been,
01:18:07.100
won't somebody think of Prakash in India saying that they grew up in a poor region,
01:18:13.420
and I had limited access to books without archive.org, I wouldn't have been able to learn it. Don't care.
01:18:19.960
I don't care. Um, no, most of them, because a lot of people haven't paid attention to this.
01:18:26.000
Um, from our side, a lot of people, oh, this is no different than the Nazis, can you believe this?
01:18:30.640
Oh, it's terrible, I can't believe Prakash can't get hold of her books.
01:18:34.300
Um, I don't care. Focus on the fact that this could impede people's ability to get access to very, very rare,
01:18:42.440
actually out-of-print, difficult-to-find books.
01:18:45.500
Not books that you can get from Barnes and Nobles or any other bookshop that just your local school doesn't want to stock in the library.
01:18:53.560
If we don't have the access to the internet archive, how are we going to preserve African folktales?
01:19:05.660
I care more about the wealth of recorded, um, memory-hold pages from governments, various disreputable media organisations,
01:19:15.500
that we have the original versions so they can't lie and retroactively rewrite history.
01:19:21.200
That we have the screenshot of, for example, the New York Times article that was retitled,
01:19:25.740
that was originally, Elections are Bad for Democracy.
01:19:28.400
It's like, yeah, thanks for the mascot moment there.
01:19:30.700
As soon as Wayback Machine goes, we're not going to have that.
01:19:32.720
I mean, there are a few other archival services.
01:19:37.000
Yeah, but Wayback Machine archive, internet archive in general, are probably the most well-known.
01:19:44.240
I think it's been going since about 1996, maybe even longer than that.
01:19:48.240
So, yeah, there's a, whatever I think of the ideological nature of the people running it,
01:19:56.040
And I do think it's a shame that it's being attacked right now.
01:19:58.420
And as Connor has mentioned, there are some reasons to suspect the reasons that it's being attacked in the first place.
01:20:05.080
Also, I want to touch on one last thing before we end this segment, which is that this is also being blamed on Chuck Wendig.
01:20:17.560
So he's an author who's written new Star Wars books.
01:20:24.980
Yeah, certainly not a person that I'm a fan of, who posted when this first happened, NPR did an article on it,
01:20:32.900
and he said, this is a pirate website, it's not legit, what are you doing?
01:20:36.860
And so people are kind of blaming it on him for pointing the lawsuit in the direction.
01:20:41.120
Uh, for a reminder for anybody, he did this god-awful tweet way back in the day.
01:20:47.880
Tuesday, the day that you realize that nothing can stop you because you're a magic skeleton packed with meat
01:21:09.140
I also didn't know that he actually followed this up.
01:21:11.880
This was a thing that he was doing where he was saying,
01:21:13.920
it's Wednesday, the day you flumpty foo, the day you boopty boopty...
01:21:33.360
He's part of that kind of cultural corner of the world
01:21:50.080
I like to think of myself as something of a pop culture examiner.
01:21:55.420
and see what shiny baubles or squirming beetles my fingers can find.
01:22:05.480
Do they make these guys like Seth Rogen at a factory or something?
01:22:08.700
Yeah, I think that there's a conveyor belt pumping them out,
01:22:11.760
ironically, given the subject he's talking about right there with pumping.
01:22:14.980
But I hate to do this because he's an insufferable person.
0.93
01:22:21.440
Good tweetman, and I completely disavow this,
0.97
01:22:23.740
says that he should face capital punishment for this piece of writing alone.
01:22:26.720
And I would never, ever support anything like that.
01:22:31.120
because there has been a lot said over the past few...
01:22:41.740
Yeah, he posted one time saying about how he thought that it was a pirate website.
01:22:46.540
They shouldn't have access to the books that they have
01:22:51.460
But he does explicitly say that he's not involved in it,
01:22:55.780
So, at the very least, I've got to dispel that myth.
01:23:04.960
that the Internet Archive put forward was complete shit,
0.99
01:23:23.680
and achieving a GDP per capita higher than the UK.
01:23:33.120
It's a similar process to bringing in your spouse,
01:23:37.280
and you're instantly deported if you serve one of 12 months in prison.
01:23:40.540
Finally, refugee intake was only about £20,000.
01:23:43.600
It honestly feels like Britain is trying to copy the results
01:23:52.680
of all of its foreign colonies into its country.
01:24:05.000
So, again, the laws on the books may say one thing.
01:24:28.920
is called Poo Poo Pictures Productions Limited.
01:25:35.900
No, no, I'm not in the way that Haitians do
1.00
01:25:42.040
Whether you're going to get a duck or a human foot
01:26:09.280
We'd like to welcome Father Calvin Robinson to the Lotus Eaters
0.99
01:26:13.220
He's still going to be doing common sense crusade here
01:26:15.500
It's just that he's going to be from the safe state of Michigan
01:26:30.500
Have always been shunned by the mainstream media
01:26:33.440
And have a lot of bass and historical themes in their lyrics
01:26:36.200
You could possibly do a lad's hour on music at some point
01:27:09.460
I don't know, I've not been a big fan of Iron Maiden's
01:27:13.960
I'm not going to be subjected to a struggle session
01:27:33.200
Trump won the cat lady vote with that debate
0.99