Podcast 998 FULL Audio
Episode Stats
Length
1 hour and 32 minutes
Words per Minute
190.81667
Summary
In this episode of The Echoes, Connor and Harry discuss the ABC-Trump-Harris debate, the death of the Internet Archive, and the impending dystopia of post-modernism. Also, a new issue of Islander is out, and it's available to order now.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
It seems we have reached a liminal moment in our politics. We have recently crossed
00:00:13.680
a threshold from which there is no going back. With the current Starmer regime and a prospective
00:00:19.960
Harris administration on the horizon, it's clear that night is finally closing in. The
00:00:26.480
mask, the grime that covered our eyes, has fallen away, and it's becoming evident now
00:00:32.560
that our countries are being governed for the benefit of someone else. Daily are imposed
00:00:38.860
upon us the indignities of a subject people. Our money is looted by a state that has betrayed
00:00:46.180
us to pay the wages of foreign mercenaries and, for now, we have no recourse. The distance
00:00:54.680
between our current reality and future dystopia is rapidly closing, and it seems inevitable
00:01:00.780
to arrive, which renders our unfortunate present a disturbing fact, and an uncertain future
00:01:07.900
a desirable outcome. We are plunged against our will into a strange journey through a shadowy
00:01:14.800
forest along a darkling trail as the sun goes down, and we have a long night ahead of us.
00:01:21.680
It is clear that we wayfarers must wend these moonlit paths and traverse strange territories
00:01:28.900
before dawn breaks. Wisdom must be our guide and lodestone. Insight into the metapolitical
00:01:37.180
circumstances which have forced our fellowship upon this shared course will be key to setting
00:01:43.680
the world in its proper hest. We must understand what is happening to us, and what is at stake.
00:01:51.640
This is the will of the second issue of Islander magazine. The magnificent success of the first
00:01:58.100
issue has only emboldened us to pierce deeper past the veil and uncover the mysteries beyond.
00:02:03.900
It is in this gradual process of becoming in which we will find within ourselves the determination
00:02:11.120
and grit to endure. Luckily, we have many great thinkers to help us. We feature outstanding
00:02:17.800
exclusive articles from famous lawsmiths such as Dave Green, Marcus Fallin, Morgoth's
00:02:24.580
Review, Stefan Molyneux, Dr. Charles Cornish Dale, Dr. Nima Parvini, and myself, along with
00:02:31.340
many more. These are couched in the beautiful aesthetic experience that you have come to expect
00:02:36.640
from Islander. And as with the first issue, each issue of Islander is unique and distinct.
00:02:43.380
It will only be printed once, and for a limited time. So order your copy now.
00:02:53.260
Oh, hi, sorry, you just caught me reading Islander. I guess we should probably start
00:02:57.080
the podcast with a load of seizures, shouldn't we? I'm your host, Connor, joined by Harry.
00:03:02.000
Hello, welcome to the podcast of the Echoes, Samson.
00:03:07.500
That's all right, no worries. It is the 11th of September 2024, and before we jump into
00:03:12.640
these stories, which are, of course, the ABC-Trump-Harris presidential debate, which
00:03:16.680
underwhelmed how the law is not on our side in the UK and the Death of Internet Archive,
00:03:21.680
we would like to remind you that, as you've just seen in Carl's exhaustive advert, Islander
00:03:27.460
issue two that Rory has been working on very diligently is now out. It is available to order
00:03:32.400
from shop.lotuseses.com, uk.shop.lotuseses.com, along with a new round of merch that Rory has
00:03:40.200
designed. If you do order Islander, first of all, thank you to all those that did the first time
00:03:45.680
around. It was an overwhelming success. This time, you're getting more essays for the same price from
00:03:50.900
people like Rory Nationalist and Stefan Molyneux. I was really glad I convinced him to join this.
00:03:56.080
And also, we heard your feedback, because last time, some of you did have problems with shipping,
00:04:00.180
so this time, rather than doing a pre-order system, when you order it, it's going to be
00:04:04.480
printed in batches, so you should, hopefully, as long as the authorities don't cause problems,
00:04:09.460
bearing on where you are, you should get your copy within two to three weeks this time. And
00:04:14.080
I've got a copy in my hands, and it does look rather nice. So, definitely go out and get one
00:04:19.580
of those. Yeah, we do the prettiest magazines. Yes, many people are saying. All the links are in
00:04:24.640
the description, as you can see it up on your screen. And without further ado, let's jump into
00:04:28.820
the news. Yeah, so I'm sad to say I watched the full Trump-Kamala Harris debate this morning on my
00:04:35.360
way into work, and it was boring. I have to be completely honest, guys. I know that people want
00:04:44.040
to hear about how it was this huge triumph for Trump, how there were so many incredible takedown
00:04:48.560
moments, how the energy was back. And I think there's a lot of truth to parts of that, because
00:04:53.040
Trump certainly was a lot more tenacious. He was much more on attack than he was at the Joe Biden
00:04:59.160
debate. But I think perhaps it's just a part of me and my preferences that I find these kinds of
00:05:04.500
big American moderated debates quite dull and boring. Maybe it's because, as much as I dismiss it and
00:05:12.340
say it's so terrible, I'm so used to the schoolyard bullying style of debate that goes on in UK
00:05:19.780
Parliament, where it's flinging thinly-veiled insults at one another while all of the rest
00:05:25.140
of your group goes, whoa, behind you, that this... underwhelmed.
00:05:31.640
You think that we've just reached the stage of civilizational grief where we've hit acceptance,
00:05:35.900
and lots of other people that still care about this are in the bargaining stage, and so they think
00:05:39.440
that recycling constant WWE-style smackdowns is actually going to move politics forwards,
00:05:45.840
and they think that if Trump just squeaks out another really convincing policy proposal,
00:05:50.180
or another brutal insult levelled at Harris, then it'll change all the minds of the single
00:05:55.440
women voting purely on the basis that they've been convinced the other side is weird. Because
00:05:59.140
at this point, I think the sides are so entrenched, these debates basically do nothing.
00:06:02.880
Well, that's one of my concerns with the whole thing, which is that the debate was essentially
00:06:07.260
a reaffirmation of all of the policies that we already know that Trump is going to do,
00:06:11.420
and maybe a hint at the policies that Kamala Harris has been not very forthcoming in explaining
00:06:18.500
to people. She was going on about how there was going to be some kind of, what was it,
00:06:23.620
accommodation economy, some kind of striving economy. Basically an economy that works for
00:06:29.420
the middle class, and Donald Trump was talking about how his economy wasn't just going to work
00:06:32.880
for the middle class. It was going to work for everybody with his tax cuts and his tariffs
00:06:36.820
that were going to be put on to different products coming from overseas, especially in places like
00:06:40.540
China. But we'll get into all of that as we get into the rest of the segment. First, for those on
00:06:46.380
the website that you'll already have heard of this, but for those watching on YouTube, we actually
00:06:51.380
have, after the immense and fantastic success of the first issue of Islander, a second issue
00:06:57.280
available on the website right now. It features articles from very many great, fantastic,
00:07:04.220
bigly authors like Roareg Nationalist, Returning for Issue 2, Morgoth's Comeback, Dr. Nimi Parvini,
00:07:11.560
but we also have some new authors who've contributed, including the fantastic Stefan Molyneux and
00:07:17.960
the Golden One, amongst others. You even have many more, and that's me. I'm included in many more.
00:07:24.200
I got an article in there, although don't let that put you off. That is available on the website
00:07:29.320
for $14.99. You can find the link in the description below. And unlike last time, we don't have a
00:07:34.960
pre-order system in place. We are printing them to order. So once you print it, the aim is that it
00:07:41.380
should be with you within two to three weeks. So please get on that. It's a fantastic product,
00:07:47.420
and it will only be available for a limited time and a limited run. Along that, we also have more
00:07:53.100
merch for the Islander, and you can get stuff like these t-shirts. My personal favourite one
00:07:59.180
is this. I'm gonna have to show it off. Look at this. Look at that bad boy. Rory really knocked
00:08:06.640
it out of the park for that one. As an authentic dyed-in-the-wool metal head myself, this...
00:08:11.700
Oh, it tingles me. It tingles me in all the right places. That's fantastic. And I will be getting one
00:08:16.940
of these myself. That's gonna go right next to my, um, uh, my In the Path of the Forest shirt from the
00:08:23.040
last run. So yeah, get a hold of all of that whilst you still can, because it is all limited runs.
00:08:28.560
Anyway, back onto the news. So yeah, I watched the debate. Um, Kamala Harris, uh, if I'm going purely
00:08:35.980
by vibes... Which is the most important thing in public. As most people do. Donald Trump, despite
00:08:41.440
obviously being, uh, getting along in his age right now, seemed energetic, he seemed a bit tenacious,
00:08:47.760
he was on the attack. Again, unlike when he was against Biden, because he knew that all he needed
00:08:51.620
to do with Biden was stand there and watch as Biden sank himself. Um, so he was energetic, interrupting,
00:09:00.120
a bit more combative, which was all very good. Um, Kamala Harris has the voice, mannerisms,
00:09:07.660
an heir of a naggy HR woman. And I think that Americans should purely vote against her and vote
00:09:16.220
for Donald Trump, just on the basis that, do you want the nagging HR woman to run your country and
00:09:22.420
be delivering speeches for the next four years? So, I think that Trump's tactic of being concise,
00:09:29.960
direct, and measured during the Biden debate served him well, not just because Biden actively has
00:09:35.780
dementia and was falling apart like the guy that drinks from the wrong cup at the end of Indiana
00:09:39.620
Jones 3, but also because it pushed back against the perception that he's too pugnacious, that he
00:09:46.420
is in this for his own ego, and that he just wants to be there to insult people that have personally
00:09:51.700
slighted him. And so I do think if there is another debate, which I think is unlikely given it's
00:09:57.260
approaching the election... I think I've seen that Elon Musk wants to host one, but, uh, he would not
00:10:02.400
expect Kamala Harris to show up. No, I think that two things should happen. One, in any future
00:10:08.800
debates, if they happen, it's unlikely that Kamala will agree to them, he should go back to his more
00:10:13.460
reserved, statesmanly, I am the king-in-waiting, you're mental, you've had four years to screw up
00:10:18.500
the country, here's how I'm going to fix it like an adult persona. And, as Baron Trump, our future
00:10:24.240
Caesar, of course, has been advising his dad, go on other podcasts and allow the at-length
00:10:30.540
platform where you can't be frustrated by a partisan moderator to show off your agenda and
00:10:35.860
show off how personal ball you are. The podcast with Theo Von was very good. I wouldn't be shocked
00:10:39.560
now that Trump has been... I think he also appeared on Logan Paul for places. I'm not sure. He may well
00:10:45.360
have done. He had a photo of Jake Paul, didn't he? I remember that. I believe so, yeah. Um, I think I
00:10:50.760
wouldn't be shocked. Joe Rogan refused to have Trump on his podcast last time around. This time around?
00:10:54.600
Maybe this time? Well, he's been endorsed by RFK and Tulsi Gabbard, which were Joe's preferred candidates,
00:10:58.940
so I wouldn't be shocked if you see Trump on Rogan, and that'll do better than any sort of debate with
00:11:02.800
Harris. Yes, and you mentioned the moderators. There was definitely a case to be made for this
00:11:07.640
that Donald Trump was debating three people at the same time. The moderators seemed a lot more
00:11:11.860
combative of the claims that Trump was making versus the ones that Kamala Harris was making. For
00:11:16.860
instance, one of the particular ones that I noticed was when Kamala Harris was mentioning that,
00:11:22.020
oh, Donald Trump's government left us with record unemployment, all of these different economic
00:11:27.960
problems, and we managed to bounce back from that and get everything back in order.
00:11:31.900
If Donald Trump had said such a thing, the moderators would have jumped in to correct him.
00:11:36.060
Donald Trump, in fact, had to correct her himself, when the moderators, in fact, seemed to be trying
00:11:40.220
to scoot the conversation along and get away from that subject, because Donald Trump pointed out,
00:11:44.700
hey, we were in the middle of a pandemic right then, we handled the pandemic great. Obviously,
00:11:50.140
on the Republican side, there's a debatable question as to whether Donald Trump did handle
00:11:54.400
the pandemic correct or not, but still, those were the circumstances of the economic downturn
00:11:59.860
that happened at the end of Donald Trump's administration, whereas all of the years leading
00:12:04.660
up to it were, for all intents and purposes, great for Americans economically.
00:12:09.080
Well, they were in a much better position during COVID lockdowns at the end of Trump's term
00:12:15.140
than after the COVID lockdowns because of Biden's Inflation Reduction Act, because of the mass
00:12:21.200
money printing here conducted, you just look at the job records, every single year when
00:12:24.600
they're revised, hundreds of thousands of them get shaved off. Lots of the jobs were
00:12:28.500
bounce-back jobs coming out of predominantly Democrat lockdown states and rehiring. Lots
00:12:33.480
of them were also federal employment jobs, like hiring thousands of IRS agents. And so, Trump
00:12:38.720
having to correct that on the fly. Another example was when he said that Governor Virginia
00:12:43.260
Ralph Northam had proposed post-birth abortion as a possibility, and the moderator stepped in
00:12:47.620
and said, that's not legal in any state. Actually, something to know, I think it was 2018 or 2019,
00:12:54.320
Kamala Harris, when a senator, voted against the Born Alive Protection Act, which means that if any
00:12:58.500
baby survives an abortion attempt, the doctor can now just leave it to die of exposure on an
00:13:04.140
operating table. Kamala Harris endorsed that. So, I would say that's a kind of post-birth abortion
00:13:08.160
right there. So, the moderator's not holding her to task on that and actually actively
00:13:13.180
frustrating Trump. Again, the fact-checking was very partisan in the way that it was being used,
00:13:19.000
especially against Trump, which is especially disappointing because those were outright lies,
00:13:23.680
as you've clarified there, being peddled not only by Kamala but by the moderators as well,
00:13:29.140
which is annoying when abortion seems to, for a lot of female voters in America, to be the one
00:13:38.300
hot topic issue that they actually care about and could win their vote. So, if you're trying to
00:13:43.320
appeal to them the very fact that Donald Trump is having lies said to him and about him on air that
00:13:49.340
aren't being contested by the moderators and supported by the moderators, that's disappointing
00:13:53.840
to see, but at the same time not surprising in the slightest. So, that's one of the big hot-button
00:14:00.500
topics that was discussed. The way it was formatted was, you know, a typical no audience like the Joe
00:14:06.480
Biden one, where you've got the moderators proposing the questions, each candidate has two minutes to
00:14:11.560
give their answer, and then there's a bit of back and forth in between all of that. So, it's done in
00:14:16.100
a very orderly way, but again, it made it very dull, going by policy by policy, which is very important,
00:14:22.980
I understand, but does not make for the most engaging listening. But I think what was the best
00:14:27.720
thing that Donald Trump did was that almost every single policy that they were discussing was that he
00:14:33.380
wrapped it back around into the immigration issue, which I think even more so than abortion for many
00:14:38.480
people is going to be a deciding factor for most voters, especially in the wake, as we'll get onto,
00:14:45.000
of the Springfield, Ohio case where the 20,000 Haitians have been, I think it's fair to say,
00:14:50.400
unleashed, is the appropriate term, on the local citizens.
00:14:54.540
They're acting as they would do in Haiti, surprise, surprise.
00:14:57.980
That magic soil, it takes the time to work, doesn't it? You need to wait for it to really kick in
00:15:02.460
before you start to get results. So, yeah, I think Trump was right. He made some very strong
00:15:07.260
statements regarding immigration, and he actually made some great points that engaging in the debate
00:15:13.460
in the first place is basically a waste of time. There was a slight criticism of the entire American
00:15:20.140
electioneering system at this debate, because Trump was pointing out, why are we doing this when
00:15:26.580
instead, you, being vice president of the current administration, could be at the White House right
00:15:31.520
now, coming up with solutions, proposing solutions, enacting solutions, making decisions to fix the
00:15:38.360
problems that are happening in this country. And again, one of the things that I noticed from
00:15:42.440
Kamala Harris when I was able to get past the irritating nasal whine of her voice was that she
00:15:49.420
didn't actually talk about any of the achievements of the Biden administration.
00:15:55.360
Yeah. Makes it kind of difficult, doesn't it? She was making lots of promises for what's going to
00:16:01.060
happen in the future. She was going to be giving a $50,000 tax rebate or tax cut to small business
00:16:09.020
owners who are going to be making, then starting up new small businesses. There's going to be some
00:16:13.500
kind of tax cut for the middle class. And then trying to say that Donald Trump was only going to
00:16:17.900
give tax cuts to the rich and the billionaires, etc, etc. All of the same rhetorical talking points that we
00:16:23.720
would expect these days. Donald Trump just turned around and said, you're a liar, you're a Marxist,
00:16:28.220
your father is a Marxist professor, we all know what you're actually like, you're one of the most
00:16:31.820
far-left liberals who's ever been in the government of the United States. So he was quite effective
00:16:37.640
in doing that. But I think some of the most important points can be basically summed up in a
00:16:42.400
few clips that I was able to find. One, which is when Donald Trump went very, very hard talking about,
00:16:49.260
you know, why are we wasting time? Why are you doing this? Yes, I've noticed. Ignore him. This
00:16:55.480
is just the clip that this particular man was able to get. Average Kamala Harris fan on the bottom
00:16:59.980
right. Yeah. She's so brat, don't you know? So here's Donald Trump excoriating her on why are we
00:17:05.900
doing this debate when you could be actually solving the problems? Why are we allowing these millions of
00:17:12.120
people to come through on the southern border? How come she's not doing anything? And I'll tell you what
00:17:16.480
I would do. And I would be very proud to do it. I would say we would both leave this debate right
00:17:21.680
now. I'd like to see her go down to Washington, D.C. during this debate because we're wasting a lot
00:17:27.980
of time. Go down to because she's been so bad. It's so ridiculous. Go down to Washington, D.C. and
00:17:34.020
let her sign a bill to close up the border because they have the right to do it. They don't need bills.
00:17:39.300
They have the right to do the president of the United States. You'll get them out of bed.
00:17:43.020
You'll wake them up at four o'clock in the afternoon. You'll say, come on, come on down
00:17:46.700
to the office. Let's sign a bill. If he signs a bill that the border is closed, all he has to do
00:17:52.440
is say it to the border patrol who are phenomenal. If they do that, the border is closed. Those people
00:17:58.160
are killing many people, unlike J6. We talked to him a really, really strong statement. That was 2016
00:18:05.040
Trump. Yeah, that was 2016 Trump. And when you get 2016 Trump coming out, which did happen a lot more
00:18:10.960
often in this debate, he has the same effect. He has that same charisma. He can grab your attention.
00:18:16.220
He can get you to laugh. But as well, he's advertising himself as that man of action.
00:18:20.420
He's saying, this administration, all that they've done has been a complete failure.
00:18:24.380
Everything that they've done is something that this country is ashamed of and has embarrassed
00:18:27.820
us on the national stage. I am the man of action who will make the difficult decisions
00:18:32.920
that we need to see in this country to fix those problems. So I think in moments like that,
00:18:37.900
he was very, very strong. And I think Rorak Nationalists actually took out a clip from his
00:18:43.020
closing statements, which sum it up very nicely here.
00:18:48.780
So she just started by saying she's going to do this. She's going to do that. She's going to do all
00:18:53.260
these wonderful things. Why hasn't she done it? She's been there for three and a half years.
00:18:59.200
They've had three and a half years to fix the border. They've had three and a half years to create jobs
00:19:05.800
and all the things we talked about. Why hasn't she done it? She should leave right now, go down to
00:19:12.140
that beautiful White House, go to the Capitol, get everyone together and do the things you want to
00:19:17.180
do. But you haven't done it and you won't do it because you believe in things that the American
00:19:21.820
people don't believe in. You believe in things like we're not going to frack. We're not going to
00:19:27.000
take fossil fuel. We're not going to do things that are going to make this country strong,
00:19:31.440
whether you like it or not. Germany tried that. And within one year, they were back to building
00:19:36.740
normal energy plants. We're not ready for it. We can't sacrifice our country for the sake of bad
00:19:44.920
vision. But I just ask one simple question. Why didn't she do it? We're a failing nation.
00:19:51.860
We're a nation that's in serious decline. We're being laughed at all over the world,
00:19:57.240
all over the world. They're left. I know the leaders very well. They're coming to see me.
00:20:01.040
They call me. We're laughed at all over the world. They don't understand what happened to us as a
00:20:06.400
nation. We're not a leader. We don't have any idea what's going on. We have wars going on in the
00:20:12.680
Middle East. We have wars going on with Russia and Ukraine. We're going to end up in a third world war
00:20:19.380
and it'll be a war like no other because of nuclear weapons, the power of weaponry. I rebuilt our entire
00:20:25.940
military. She gave a lot of it away to the Taliban. She gave it to Afghanistan. What these people have
00:20:34.280
done to our country and maybe toughest of all is allowing millions of people to come into our
00:20:40.300
country. Many of them are criminals and they're destroying our country. The worst president,
00:20:45.300
the worst vice president in the history of our country.
00:20:51.380
So a lot of Trumpism's thrown in there. Quite a bit of fire. You know, some have accused him of being
00:20:57.060
rambly, but I think he gets the point across that he's going for quite well. And again, that is the
00:21:02.860
important question that I think he kept harping on throughout. Why haven't you done it then?
00:21:09.100
The best way that I have found to frame any political issue is to put it on the people who
00:21:15.160
are in charge. They are to blame because all of these consequences are downstream of political
00:21:21.760
choices. Every single immigrant, illegal immigrant, legal immigrant, who kills a member of the
00:21:29.400
indigenous population, that is a political choice made by the government to keep making
00:21:35.520
Yes, certainly effective. He certainly thought it was effective because he went on Truth Social
00:21:39.960
straight after and said, I thought that was my best debate ever, especially since it was
00:21:52.440
This is the question. He did put a big post on Twitter a few weeks ago, didn't he? But I
00:21:56.440
think that's the only activity that's been on there since then. So, I mean, his posts on Truth
00:22:02.020
Social inevitably get onto Twitter one way or another. So, I suppose he thinks to himself,
00:22:07.320
ah, I don't need to do it directly anyway. And also, he has confidence within his own
00:22:13.100
platform. So, you know, I can't blame him for that. But I think one of, again, I mentioned
00:22:19.120
the Ohio situation. That might end up actually being a turning point because if we're going
00:22:24.580
to talk about how, you know, ghetto for Trump might have flipped a few voters within the
00:22:31.740
typically Democrat strong black American vote, then we've got to talk about how the kind
00:22:38.780
of bad publicity that's coming to the Biden administration through potentially cats and
00:22:44.320
dogs being eaten by rabid Haitians on the streets of Springfield, Ohio, is a bad PR move
00:22:51.940
for the Biden administration and might win Trump some votes as well, especially with the slop AI
00:22:58.380
meme campaign that immediately launched after... I love this. Yeah, I kind of love it. And also,
00:23:03.500
right, the great thing about this is it positions the wholesome love of the Anglo, of all of their furry
00:23:14.320
friends and feathered friends against the third world barbarism of if it crawls, walks or squawks,
00:23:22.500
I'll eat it. Like, that's... And so it just shows a big civilizational difference. And again,
00:23:28.260
it shows it's a political choice as to what attitude we have towards animals and who is brought
00:23:33.760
in to change that attitude. Yeah, certainly. And Trump was one to actually actively jump on it during
00:23:38.680
the debate. Here's a little clip. In Springfield, they're eating the dogs, the people that came in.
00:23:44.740
They're eating the cats. They're eating... They're eating the pets of the people that live there.
00:23:51.940
And this is what's happening in our country. And it's a shame. It's a shame. I love the... I love
00:23:59.160
the passion. It's like, they're eating the dogs. It's so good. It sounds like Frank Reynolds.
00:24:04.340
It really does. It's so good. But also, you know, we've seen this footage, these photos come out.
00:24:11.800
How can it be debunked? There are photos of it. The man has a whole goose.
00:24:16.460
Yeah. I've avoided the videos of people eating cats, but I have seen that they're going about.
00:24:22.120
It's happened in other European countries as well. We've seen it. Libs of TikTok has procured a police
00:24:27.040
report, police officers, where it's been called in that the Haitian migrants have been abducting the
00:24:32.420
police. I've got friends like Nate Hockman, who's going down there to interview the locals next week.
00:24:36.960
So all of this, oh, it's been debunked by local officials. Yeah, because it looks bad,
00:24:40.520
but it is actually happening. Yeah, well, local officials actually have a decision and choice
00:24:44.820
that they can make themselves, which is, are you going to report on it? Are you going to log it?
00:24:49.320
Are you going to admit it? Are you saying that local government can't also be corrupt or have its
00:24:54.860
own agenda that it wants to push and will spin or hide things because of that? I think that's very
00:25:00.840
naive and foolish or more likely just politically motivated in the first place. But as I mentioned,
00:25:06.160
there is the meme AI campaign going on right now to position Donald Trump as king of the kittens,
00:25:13.180
which is pretty great. This is great. This is great. If you're not watching and just listening
00:25:19.260
right now, I'd suggest you just look at your phone unless you're on your car or something. So just look
00:25:24.700
at the screen and see some of these. They're fantastic. Normally AI can be a bit hit and miss and a bit
00:25:29.200
try hard, but this is great. Look at this. It's wholesome and also reclaims the discourse of Trump
00:25:34.720
and Vance putting off quote unquote childless cat ladies. It's actually, no, no, we're family
00:25:38.640
friendly. We're also felon friendly. Well, yeah, that's the thing. Also, I don't know personally,
00:25:43.300
I don't know specifically, but I can't imagine that Donald Trump hates cats. Here he is in
00:25:48.520
Springfield, Ohio, actively saving cats from rabid Haitians. What a hero. Scroll down. Look,
00:25:57.640
they're eating the dogs is trending. In all caps. They're eating the dogs. And this, I assume this
00:26:04.840
is what he did immediately after the assassination attempt. He got off the podium and saw some Haitians
00:26:10.080
attacking cats and just knew what he had to do. He said, fight. Fist in the air. I joked with you
00:26:15.220
warfare. Maybe these Haitians just took the, um, the ducks are free meme from Alex Jones a little
00:26:19.780
too seriously. Yeah, perhaps. But even then you're not supposed to eat them. You weirdos. Take care of
00:26:25.120
this is what your cat is doing when you're away from the house. You've always wondered. We have
00:26:28.700
footage. Why do you keep calling this the Chinese visors? Why do you keep calling this the Chinese
00:26:35.040
visors? Why do you keep calling this the Chinese? There you go. Your cat loves him. You're going to
00:26:41.220
say no to your cat. If you are a childless cat lady right now, wouldn't you want to make your cat
00:26:45.260
proud? Here's Kamala Harris in the meantime. What she's planning on doing, this is a look. I've
00:26:50.760
looked into my crystal ball. This is a vision of Kamala Harris's America. This is what she's going
00:26:55.380
to be doing in the White House kitchen. Paired with a nice box of wine, I'm sure. Oh, sure. Only one?
00:27:01.260
My goodness. Here's, uh, what happened to Garfield after Biden and Kamala got their hands on him.
00:27:08.480
Yeah. Tragedy. I wonder why they couldn't rebuild after the earthquake. Is it maybe because their
00:27:12.880
civilization is really backwards? We also have live footage from what happened when the Haitians
00:27:24.140
Looks like kittens back on the menu, boys! Biden's fighting Uruk-hai at the ready.
00:27:30.860
Well, I have taken to referring to the sort of graffiti you see in diverse metropoles as the
00:27:36.520
white hand of Saruman. Yeah, actually. That works. That works quite well. And we've got
00:27:41.120
footage of... This is not the link that I put in there. Uh, here's the... Here's the, uh, footage
00:27:47.000
of Donald Trump. This is real, by the way. Don't fact check me on that. Kissing ducks.
00:27:52.780
He needs to retweet this. He does. He needs to... He needs to actively go out and do this as a
00:27:58.180
photo op, is what he needs to do. Trump feeding ducks would be a good... Especially with the grandkids.
00:28:02.700
That'd be a really nice photo. Exactly. But he's already done enough, I would say, in just
00:28:06.560
highlighting the issue as part of the debate to signal to everybody who cares about the
00:28:11.160
issue that he cares about the issue. Did Kamala say anything about it? No, she didn't.
00:28:15.540
Did you see the Gollum post, by the way? Uh, no, I missed that one. It's the man with
00:28:19.740
the geese, and it's contrasted to Gollum when he's singing in the Forbidden Pool, and it's
00:28:26.860
Oh, no. And, uh, I think one of the best things about this is that it's triggering the
00:28:32.760
libs. Here is Eric Salwell going berserk over it. This is the guy that farted in, live
00:28:38.860
on TV. Remember that? Apparently he also slept with the Chinese. Yeah, her name was Fong
00:28:43.760
Fong. You want some fun fun? Works every single time. What in the hell is this? The chairman
00:28:54.380
tweets, protect our ducks and kittens in Ohio because he goes some down, goes down some
00:29:01.240
crazy rabbit hole, completely debunked that aliens are eating pets? It's not aliens, it's
00:29:08.740
Haitians. My God. Are you okay, Mr. Chairman? Wait, is this real? Because last year, for a
00:29:15.480
very long time, you tweeted and promoted Kanye West as he was calling for genocide against
00:29:23.040
the Jews, the Jews, and you kept it up. And now, when we have victims coming here, you're
00:29:27.620
tweeting this nonsense. I don't know why you would do this. I hope you're okay. I don't
00:29:35.380
know if the aliens who are eating your ducks are in the room with us right now. But, Mr.
00:29:43.040
Chairman, this is a serious issue. These people have loved ones who have been lost. And you
00:29:49.660
tweeted this. This is a profoundly unserious person. A man actually losing his mind over
00:29:58.540
a fun meme of Donald Trump protecting ducks and cats. Not even a meme, actual photo confirmed,
00:30:05.040
fact-checked. It is actually happening. You liar. Well, yeah, exactly. Again, I shouldn't
00:30:10.180
be shocked by a man who cheats on his wife with a Chinese spy to have any integrity. All they
00:30:14.660
know how to do is lie, Connor. We know this. And then, of course, there are the incredibly
00:30:19.720
dishonest framings, as highlighted by Pagliacci, the hated, from leftists, saying that, oh, but
00:30:26.620
white rednecks go duck hunting. So what's the problem with this guy going into the local
00:30:36.280
Yeah, sure, you've got your duck hunting license and you've got all these regulations that you
00:30:40.380
need to stick to. But this guy went and randomly broke the neck of a potentially endangered goose.
00:30:48.800
Okay. I know recreational duck hunters from the States. I don't get it, personally. I don't
00:30:53.660
actually eat duck just because I feel too guilty, right? But they are playing-
00:30:57.280
I wouldn't go hunting if I went to America, but I wouldn't want to shoot-
00:31:04.380
Oh, Canada geese are a protected species, apparently, as well.
00:31:07.600
But they are playing into entire conservation ecosystem. So the money that the hunters pay
00:31:14.420
with their licenses, with the rental of equipment, that goes into conserving the natural area and
00:31:19.400
making sure the actual duck population flourishes. This is just a random third-worlder abducting
00:31:26.120
the feathered friends that kids feed in a park. There's a pretty big distinction there. If you
00:31:31.120
don't see that distinction, you're fundamentally dishonest or stupid.
00:31:33.600
Well, there's a few examples of the dishonest distinctions that could be made, but I like
00:31:38.220
the one that Pagliaggi put at the bottom, which is the equivalent would be someone getting
00:31:41.600
raped and you saying to them, well, you have sex, don't you? With the smug look on your
00:31:45.700
face. But that is essentially what's happening to America, isn't it? It's being raped. And
00:31:51.420
it's being raped by the Biden administration, and if things go the wrong way, by the potential
00:31:56.960
Kamala administration as well. So whilst the debate itself left a bit to be desired for me in
00:32:03.060
terms of pure entertainment value, these are very, very important decisions that are going to have
00:32:08.520
to be made in the coming months. So if you're going to go out and vote in America, vote wisely.
00:32:13.660
Right, before we move on, we've got some rumble rants, all pretty much pertaining to
00:32:17.140
Islander. So the Shadowbam at $10, congratulations on your second issue of Islander. Thank you very
00:32:21.300
much. Keith Kaiser, at Harry petitioned to change the Low Seasers intro song from...
00:32:27.060
Into a song from the Clayman album, even if as a one-off. You have no reference for that.
00:32:33.740
All I think is it's probably copyrighted, so we're really allowed to.
00:32:36.740
Well, no, no, no. But it would need to maybe do it in the style of the album Clayman by
00:32:40.920
Inflames, which I was actually listening to this morning on the way to work. That would
00:32:44.920
be awesome. If somebody wanted to mock that up, that would be fantastic. I don't have time
00:32:49.660
I personally think we should have made our own intro music long ago rather than just, you
00:32:53.860
know, using someone else's. But, because we've got an abundance of talent in the office.
00:32:57.220
I've done a version of it. Chris Gard sent me a version that he did for it.
00:33:07.580
And it's just been left in a drawer somewhere, hasn't it?
00:33:11.900
I'm not saying it's your fault it's been left in a drawer somewhere.
00:33:13.380
It's a version of the theme that already exists. It's the doot-doot-doots, but Chris did
00:33:19.240
his own version of it, which was a bit more impactful.
00:33:21.660
Okay, I'm sure we'll get right round to that in the next five years or so. Lady Dragon
00:33:26.260
Chris, $5. I bought Islander 2 within 10 minutes of the announcement video going up. Can't
00:33:32.920
$2 from the last Russian Islander metal shirt. Looks awesome. I'm sure we'll be modelling some
00:33:39.340
I need a sort of Jordan Peterson style emblazoned blazer to wear something like that. So maybe
00:33:44.200
for issue three, we can get one of those going.
00:33:46.100
Are you going to get your Riddler Two-Face blazers going?
00:33:49.480
Just coming dressed like a Batman villain would be good. Oh, I went to an exhibition
00:33:53.800
where they had all their suits on display. Jim Carrey's Riddler costume is as gay as
00:34:01.240
Fair point. And one more from the last Russian. Don't snack on me. Kitten, no snip on snack.
00:34:05.980
Gadsden parody of a parody. That's a very dense, but I think he's saying have a kitten.
00:34:15.440
Someone, we should do that as a t-shirt. That'd be good, actually. That's not a bad
00:34:21.040
Yep. Samson, feed it back to Rory. Good man. Jamie, pull it up. And Bald Eagle for $2. I
00:34:26.060
love the moderator said there was no official stories on the Haitians eating animals and
00:34:29.120
pets. The local government are going to ignore all complaints because it's embarrassing for
00:34:32.360
them. They're also police reports, so they are official. So, okay, but whatever. Anyway.
00:34:37.280
Well, everyone, we often hear how the law is supposedly on our side. I think we sort of
00:34:43.500
comfort ourselves with that any time that you get arrested for a meme. Eventually, there are
00:34:48.860
champions of our rights and liberties, like ADF International, the Free Speech Union, who say,
00:34:55.520
don't worry, we will win out in the end. And they have some important legal cases. But even if
00:35:00.740
you do appeal to the tools of the enemy, like the Human Rights Act, the ECHR, or the Equality Act,
00:35:05.540
even if they do net us some wins, like realising biological sex or trying to reduce the number
00:35:11.020
of thought crimes recorded by the police, what matters less than the letter of the law, it turns
00:35:15.800
out, is who is applying the law. And so we'll be going through some new examples today just to show
00:35:19.980
you how much the state hates you. That's basically our job over here at LowersEats.com. The other job
00:35:25.100
we have is producing amazing things like Islander Magazine. If you read the first issue, well done,
00:35:29.680
you're a man of culture, I see. If you missed out on that, we have now issue two that are...
00:35:35.540
Our intrepid editor, Rory, has been working on diligently, sweating away, doing all the art,
00:35:40.160
getting all of the articles together. He has been sweating. He stinks.
00:35:42.600
Yeah, he honks. He reeks. That mullet is just dripping. Anyway, we have essays. We have more
00:35:47.760
essays this time around. We have essays from Carl. We have essays from Rory Nationalists and Niva
00:35:51.820
Parvini. We also have new writers like Dave Green and Stefan Molyneux. So if you are curious about what
00:35:57.540
they've written for this Apocalypse Edition, you can go and pick it up for £14.99. Same price as last
00:36:01.960
time, but more for your money. And because we listened to your feedback, this time we are
00:36:05.700
printing in batches rather than pre-ordering. So it should mean that as soon as you order,
00:36:09.480
links are down in the description, you should get it within two to three weeks. So long as
00:36:12.680
whatever country you live in doesn't try and stop you from getting the gloriousness of
00:36:16.620
Islander at the border. We also have lots of new merch. This is back there and I pressed
00:36:21.600
the wrong button, didn't I? There it is. The new merch, which is all of these wonderful
00:36:25.520
design t-shirts. They're also limited edition. So as soon as Islander 2 goes out of print,
00:36:38.900
Okay, four or five weeks. So in about a month or so, this is no longer going to be available.
00:36:43.920
So quickly, rush down to the shop. By the way, I wasn't listening to the voices in my
00:36:46.960
head. It was my producer. I'm sane. I promise. Anyway, let's quickly move on. First example
00:36:50.880
of this. Some bloke sent Jess Phillips a death threat. I think this is a good example to contrast
00:36:56.900
the two tiers of justice in the UK. So we're glad that this man, Nabil Arif, I'm sure she'll
00:37:03.080
say he's just a man, a man of nondescript identity from no particular location whatsoever, moving
00:37:09.440
swiftly on. And we're glad Nabil Arif has been jailed. He's only been sentenced to 12 weeks.
00:37:15.500
He sent Phillips some abusive messages, beginning from the Israel-Gaza war in October 2023. In one
00:37:21.580
message, he told Jess Phillips, hell is real and you will burn. And in the last email, he said that
00:37:26.760
he will burn her till her skin is no more. I mean, that's disgusting. It's a death threat. He should
00:37:31.480
get far longer than that. I think we all agree. The Crown Prosecution Service said he was sentenced
00:37:36.460
to only 12 weeks after a court, after a trial at the same court on the 29th of July. And he's made
00:37:42.560
the subject of a restraining order. So he shouldn't ever contact Phillips again. Curiously though,
00:37:46.860
and I want to note this, at the bottom of this article, they include some details about the
00:37:50.200
Israel-Hamas war. They say 1,200 people were killed in Hamas's October the 7th assault,
00:37:54.620
close to 41,000 people were killed, according to the health-run ministry in the Hamas-run
00:37:59.000
territory. So Guardian just dropped that in at the end of the article there, almost as like
00:38:03.440
an excuse for why he was making those claims. To contextualise it. So see how this is treated,
00:38:09.060
both by the Crown Prosecution Service and the Labour-friendly press, because... The Guardian
00:38:13.580
basically hinting, well, she was kind of asking for it. Yeah, quite. Because, contrast this with
00:38:18.760
the Guardian's reporting on this woman. This is Julie Sweeney, for those who don't remember,
00:38:23.380
of Church Lawton, Cheshire. She pled guilty at Chester Crown Court to sending a communication
00:38:27.660
to convey a threat of death or serious harm. She was jailed for about two years, and she said
00:38:33.300
something that is far less a direct threat, still very inadvisable, don't do it, it's silly,
00:38:37.700
but far less a direct threat than what the prior gentleman decided to say. So she was part of a
00:38:42.860
Facebook community group with 5,100 members, responding to a photograph that showed a number
00:38:47.040
of white and Asian people involved in cleaning up after Southport. She posted,
00:38:51.140
it's absolutely ridiculous, don't protect the mosques, and she said this, not me,
00:38:55.040
blow the mosque up with the adults in it. Again, that's a bit extreme. Stupid. Disavow.
00:38:59.940
Was she with the imminent ability of doing that? No. Was the other fella more likely to be able to do
00:39:06.380
that to Jess Phillips? Certainly. We know this because in Jess Phillips' own constituency,
00:39:10.860
there were masked Muslims that were armed, attacking pubs and publicans, occupying a roundabout and
00:39:17.740
threatening people in cars, which Jess Phillips herself tried to obfuscate for, by the way.
00:39:21.820
And so the sentencing judge, Stephen Everett, jailed her for 15 months, so a bit over a year
00:39:26.660
and a half. No, sorry, just under a year and a half. Telling her, you should have been looking
00:39:30.660
at the news and media with horror like every right-minded person. Instead, you chose to take
00:39:34.340
part in stirring up hatred. You had a big audience. You threatened a mosque. It was a truly terrible
00:39:38.040
threat. So it's not enough to tell this woman that what she posted was incitements of violence.
00:39:43.740
He had to give her a little moral beating as well. Tell her that here's how you're supposed to think.
00:39:50.920
I know that this will be reported in the newspapers, so I'm going to signal to everybody reading
00:39:55.560
how they should feel about things. Well, he says here, so-called keyboard warriors have to learn
00:40:00.820
to take responsibility for their language, particularly in the context of the disorder
00:40:04.540
that was going on around the country. Remember that phrase. The context of what's going on
00:40:08.660
broadly, more politically, influences the justice system. That is the point they're making.
00:40:13.080
Well, and it's also important to remember that when judges make statements like this,
00:40:17.360
they're not making them for the person that they're sentencing. They're making them
00:40:20.720
for the newspapers to report on so everybody can read what you're supposed to do.
00:40:24.940
And to set precedent in law for future cases. That's an important thing.
00:40:28.680
Also, important to note for the Guardian, notice something missing at the bottom of this article.
00:40:35.020
Ah, it's context about the Southport Massacre that would have otherwise explained why Sweeney
00:40:40.660
was so angry, unlike the prior article that ends with details about Gaza, from the Hamas-run
00:40:47.020
health agency as well, very reputable, that tries to contextualise why Arif sent Jess Phillips'
00:40:51.580
reprehensible death threat. So, again, two-tier reporting, two-tier justice system.
00:40:56.100
So, speaking of the right to protest, Policy Exchange. Have a report out on the pro-Palestine
00:41:00.700
protests. You can go and download the publication in your own time, give it a read if you have the
00:41:04.640
time to read a 150-page report. I wanted to pull out some findings from this because we can see here
00:41:09.800
that the attempt to ameliorate the justice system and the police and the Crown Prosecution
00:41:16.000
Service by principles and legislation and a mandate to duly, impartially carry out the law
00:41:23.800
is just going to end up giving them over more powers to prosecute people like us. So, it's
00:41:28.720
not encouraging. So, there's some things in here and it says, first of all, it goes into the costs
00:41:33.260
associated with importing this kind of ethno-religious tension that we saw on the pro-Palestine
00:41:37.780
protests. The Met Police state the costs of policing the Palestine protests in London between
00:41:41.880
October 2023 and June 2024 were £42.9 million, with 51,799 Metropolitan Police officers shifts
00:41:50.800
and 9,639 Police officer shifts from officers usually based outside the Metropolitan Police
00:41:56.220
area. The 6,339 police officers had rest days cancelled between October and April 2024, all
00:42:03.560
of which were to be repaid in due course. Bear in mind, as we've covered repeatedly on this
00:42:07.560
podcast, the exact kind of population to go on these pro-Palestine protests are not net tax
00:42:12.420
contributors. So, they are frustrating our capital city every weekend and Wednesday. So, this is even
00:42:15.620
more of a drain. Exactly. So, these people are costing us money anyway, and now they're costing us
00:42:20.140
extra money to agitate for a foreign war on behalf of the prescribed terror group. Bear in mind, this
00:42:25.880
happened in the aftermath of October the 7th, not in the aftermath of Israel's response to the
00:42:29.820
October the 7th. So, it was a celebration of what Hamas has done, not a complaint about how Israel
00:42:34.140
responded. The same population as well, same host population paying for it, don't want to visit
00:42:39.880
their own capital city during these protests. As a Londoner, I can agree. Polling was conducted by
00:42:43.820
Policy Exchange, and it showed members of the public choosing not to engage in a wide range of
00:42:47.620
activities because of these protests. They dropped their plans to travel with small children, 71%,
00:42:52.620
travel with an elderly or mobility-impaired friend or relative, 69%, visit a tourist attraction,
00:42:57.280
62%, go shopping, 58%, and eat at a specific restaurant, 58%. So, more costs, economic, but also
00:43:03.440
cultural, spiritual, if the host population are being demoralized and chased out of their own
00:43:07.600
capital city. Oh yeah, I can speak from my own personal experience. I've not been to London in
00:43:12.400
at the very least over a year, and I have no intention to go back if I can avoid it.
00:43:17.600
Why would I go there? It feels like navigating the rubble of the Tower of Babel at this point.
00:43:22.060
It's really unpleasant. It's smelly, it's busy, it's expensive. I want to get out as quickly as
00:43:26.720
possible. The main headline that came out of this report that everyone was reporting on,
00:43:29.560
they did an interview with Assistant Commissioner to the Metropolitan Police, Matt Twist, and he said
00:43:35.680
the following. When we look back at the policing of protests over the last eight months, we know we
00:43:40.100
didn't get everything right, particularly in the early stages of October. We've developed our tactics
00:43:44.160
since then, becoming faster and more decisive. On an occasion, we did not move quickly to make
00:43:48.860
arrests. For example, the man chanting for jihad, which was a decision made following fast time advice
00:43:54.500
from lawyers and the CPS. So guidance provided by the 700-strong Muslim activist network in the
00:44:00.620
Home Office and pro-immigration lawyers, which usually have an ethnic and religious bias, are
00:44:06.080
advising the Met not to crack down on people chanting for intifad and jihad. I wonder why.
00:44:12.200
We are now much more focused on identifying reasonable grounds for arrest, acting where
00:44:16.200
needed, and then investigating, so in these circumstances, it's very likely arrests would
00:44:20.060
be made more quickly now. Oh, it's very likely arrests would be made more quickly now in the
00:44:24.380
aftermath of another set of protests, which were the indigenous population protesting, and
00:44:29.760
so now you're going to get much harder on it. Isn't that fascinating? I wonder if anyone
00:44:35.480
from the post-Southport protests, or one of Mr. Robinson's rallies, not you, other one,
00:44:41.400
would have chanted, from the channel to the Irish Sea, Britain will be free. They'd be locked up in
00:44:46.320
handcuffs, but not the other way around. Got it. Also, an important detail that they find here.
00:44:51.600
So, in order to stage a protest in Britain, you have to give the authorities six days warning,
00:44:55.740
if you want to do a large-scale march. The Palestine Solidarity Campaign contacted the
00:44:59.960
Metropolitan Police to inform them of their intention to conduct their first mass Palestine protest,
00:45:04.680
ten hours after the terrorist attack on October 7th. Right. So, not protesting the gross injustices
00:45:13.960
by the Israeli regime, just open ethno-religious solidarity and celebrating murders? Why were any
00:45:21.640
of these allowed? Letter of the law could have stopped at any time, but it doesn't. That's most
00:45:27.240
important. So, the recommended response was that the government should legislate to establish a
00:45:32.000
protest commission for London. A protest commission for London. Involving independent
00:45:37.840
commissioners. Independent, as we always know, there is no such thing. There's no such thing as
00:45:42.440
a neutral process. It's always political. Appointed by the Home Secretary, following consultation with
00:45:47.300
the Mayor of London. Independent, appointed by the Labour Home Secretary and the Labour Mayor of London,
00:45:53.400
both of whom endorsed and oversaw the protests. Great suggestion. The government should amend
00:45:58.880
Section 11 of the Public Order Act 1986 to increase the notification period for all protest marches
00:46:03.420
to 28 days. But they'll just step over that if they want to. They'll let the ones they like go
00:46:09.360
ahead and they'll ban the ones they don't like, which they do anyway. The government should legislate
00:46:13.220
to require the police forces must take action to prevent the interference by protesters with the
00:46:17.580
operation of those installations of facilities classified as key national infrastructure and expand the
00:46:23.040
definition of national infrastructure under the Public Order Act 2023 to include Parliament,
00:46:27.500
government departments, and the courts. So they're anticipating some sort of physical attack on
00:46:35.580
government, parliaments, and the courts? Because the only thing I can think of in recent memory was
00:46:39.320
the protest outside the ceasefire debate where they projected from the river to the sea on Big Ben,
00:46:43.820
but they knew where the projector was, Martin Daubley pointed out, and the Met Police just shrugged
00:46:47.180
their shoulders and didn't arrest anyone, didn't even turn it off. So again, choices were made here.
00:46:51.600
They could have done it at any time. They also should make it unlawful for individuals at
00:46:55.960
protest to wear face coverings. So a couple of years after mandating them, they're now going to
00:47:00.680
make them illegal. Again, I would feel, I don't like face coverings, but I would feel comfortable
00:47:06.180
with people wearing face coverings if they weren't a demographic more likely to commit violence
00:47:11.700
against me for ideological or impulse control reasons. Sadiq Khan should also apparently conduct
00:47:16.300
an equality impact of the protests on businesses, tourism, and threats to women, the disabled,
00:47:20.700
and the elderly, which I'm sure he'll do completely impartially, just as he did with you, Les.
00:47:24.080
The Commissioner of the Met Police must take all possible steps to ensure all those that
00:47:28.740
are suspected of committing criminal offences at protests are arrested at the time of the
00:47:32.680
offence. So the police should do their jobs. That's an actual recommendation in a policy
00:47:39.680
As well, we saw with the Southport riots and protests that went on that the Metropolitan Police
00:47:45.640
will just hoover up anybody if they feel like it, depending on the cause of the protest in
00:47:50.720
the first place. Yes, but if it inflames community tensions at Notting Hill Carnival or the Palestine
00:47:55.380
riots, they'll let people go and sort of lazily try and track them down comfortably from their
00:48:00.740
desk with a cup of tea and a packet of biscuits afterwards. And maybe they might perform some
00:48:04.660
arrests. And even then they'll say, oh, a small minority were ruining it for the rest of us.
00:48:09.060
How could they? There's also this reminder, right? Providing the executive summary.
00:48:13.400
Central to these events is the claim of a right to protest, despite there being no such explicit
00:48:19.480
and unfettered right within the ECHR or the Human Rights Act 1998. Instead of a right to protest,
00:48:26.120
the following articles are allowing people to protest. Article 11, right to freedom of peaceful
00:48:32.140
assembly and association. And Article 10, the right to freedom of expression. Both rights are
00:48:36.460
explicitly qualified by restrictions as prescribed by law and unnecessary in a democratic society,
00:48:41.840
among other things, in the interest of national security or public safety, for the prevention of
00:48:46.460
disorder and crime, protection of health and morals, protection of the rights of others, etc., etc.
00:48:50.660
So all of these are nebulous definitions, and they just allow the state to pretend that they're
00:48:56.360
ratifying and making impartial decisions on human rights, and instead punish their political enemies
00:49:01.100
and favour their political friends. And the perfect example of this is the recommendation in here that
00:49:05.320
the Crown Prosecution Service must amend its legal guidance on offences during protests,
00:49:09.220
demonstrations or campaigns, to reduce the likelihood of suspects not being prosecuted for
00:49:13.780
public interest reasons. That's literally what the judge said in Sweeney's case, that we're going
00:49:18.540
to teach you keyboard warriors a lesson. None of that was said about Arif, even though we had the
00:49:23.740
Palestine marches and we had those armed Muslims in Jess Phillips' own constituency. There wasn't a need
00:49:29.360
to talk about democratic principles or a chilling effect there. Just give him a few weeks, a few months
00:49:35.580
in prison and keep him shut up about it. Again, this is what I found, I remembered this, you
00:49:41.480
tweet this out a while ago, this is your law, Harry's law in effect. You tweet it out, no matter
00:49:46.160
its intended foreign target, anti-terrorist technology and intelligence departments will
00:49:50.120
be inevitably used to spy on and imprison white European populations. This is exactly that.
00:49:55.260
Well, if the purpose of a system is what it does, then the purpose of the UK government is to
00:50:00.940
Quite, yes. Perfect example of this is the Equality Act.
00:50:03.360
The Equality Act that people keep saying we need to appeal to, to get gender critical
00:50:07.240
wins, for example. This chap, Mr. S. Thomas. Bear in mind, he does use social media like
00:50:13.320
a boomer in here, so I will point that out. He went to an employment tribunal about the
00:50:17.860
NHS, claiming that he, as a contractor, had been discriminated against for his English
00:50:24.020
nationalist views. So the point of the Equality Act is it's meant to protect certain
00:50:29.840
characteristics, as in the government's favoured ones, and certain beliefs from discrimination
00:50:35.240
in employment. So, for example, it's intersectionality codified in law. You can obviously actively,
00:50:42.160
positively discriminate against white, straight Christian men, but you can't discriminate against
00:50:47.140
black women, for example. The recent win that we supposedly got was the Meyer-Folstater
00:50:51.300
case, where gender critical, aka believing in biological sex, beliefs are now protected characteristic
00:50:56.860
under the Equality Act. But this just shows that even if you try and appeal to the Equality
00:51:00.300
Act to get wins, they will just selectively apply it, if and where. Because this chap,
00:51:07.060
By the end of the hearing, Employment Judge Hyde considered the third question from the list
00:51:14.900
Were his anti-Islamic views worthy of respect and democratic society, incompatible with human
00:51:21.360
dignity, and did they conflict with the fundamental rights of others, such that they would prevent
00:51:25.120
the claimant's belief in English nationalism from being a protected characteristic, aka, did they
00:51:29.420
offend Muslims, therefore, can we fire him from his job? And they say, to the claimant,
00:51:35.160
And he identifies his views. So the claimant, English nationalism is the nationalism that
00:51:39.140
asserts the English are a nation and promotes, bless you, the cultural unity of English people,
00:51:44.080
the claimant's focus is on national identity which does not depend on ancestry or race rather
00:51:48.000
than common descent or race. So he's very boomer, civic nationalism, England is a set of values,
00:51:54.960
ideals, and even that is too far gone for the Equality Act. So he's not even arguing for
00:52:01.200
protection on the basis of ethnicity or racial identity, he's arguing for the protection on the
00:52:04.740
basis of values, and even then, they're making the discrimination against which values are
00:52:08.320
preferred by the state, versus which values are prescribed by the state.
00:52:11.660
Yeah, they're saying, sorry mate, Britain is gay race communism values.
00:52:17.360
Judge Hyde observed in cross-examination before the Leeds Employment Tribunal,
00:52:20.580
the claimant has said that Islam in its current form should be banned from England unless it were
00:52:24.120
anglicised and toned down to fit within society in England. So even then he's being quite generous.
00:52:29.400
Employment Judge Hyde commented at the hearing before her,
00:52:32.020
the claimant did not dispute these comments were consistent with his English nationalism.
00:52:35.560
The claimant alleged his assignment within the NHS trust had been terminated because of his
00:52:39.680
belief in English nationalism. He claimed this was belief discriminatory contrary to the Equality
00:52:44.120
Act 2010. At a hearing, the Employment Tribunal held the claimant's belief was not protected by
00:52:49.580
the Equality Act. The claimant appealed this decision. The appeal is dismissed. The claimant's
00:52:54.360
views are of an English nationalism which believes there is no place in British society for Muslims or
00:52:58.260
Islam itself. Among the claimant's views are that the Muslims should be forcibly deported from the
00:53:02.300
United Kingdom. These views are not capable of protection under the European Convention on
00:53:06.280
Human Rights as they would offend Article 17 which provides that nothing in this convention may be
00:53:11.040
interpreted as implying for any state group or person to engage in any activity or perform any act
00:53:18.440
aimed at the destruction of any rights and freedoms set forth herein at the limitation to a greater
00:53:23.300
extent that's provided in the convention. The claimant has not prevented from holding his views,
00:53:27.660
but he is outside of the right to complain that he has been discriminated against in relation to
00:53:31.620
those beliefs in the circumstances covered by the EQA. It's obvious that he's been discriminated
00:53:36.380
against on the grounds of his belief because this is happening in the judgment. And so what the
00:53:41.440
Equality Act exists to do is designate certain beliefs and certain characteristics above certain
00:53:46.900
others and afford them certain legal protections over the indigenous host population. And I don't
00:53:53.640
necessarily want to use the Equality Act for any of this. I would rather the entire thing were
00:53:56.460
scrapped, but the point matters that who applies the law matters less than the consistent letter of
00:54:01.860
the law. And here's a great example. Um, Mel B and some Labour politician for Birmingham Erdington,
00:54:09.300
Paulette Hamilton MP, are trying to bring forth an amendment to protect Afro hair under the Equality Act.
00:54:15.140
No. If it was up to me, no. I mean, again, we'd scrap the whole thing if it was up to me,
00:54:24.540
Yeah, well, you're in a joke of a country, so actually, um, our favourite independent journalist,
00:54:27.880
Kandi Drucker, has given us a vision of the future. Uh, you're under arrest for describing a mixed-race
00:54:32.000
woman's hair as frizzy without an Afro hair ally licence, which is a serious crime. It's all in here,
00:54:36.800
mate. You're going away for a long time. Makes me sick there are people like you walking the streets.
00:54:40.340
Well, not for much longer. You think I'm joking? Yeah, I mean, this is, I've seen him post a few
00:54:46.440
of these with this particular gentleman, uh, this particular officer holding up a variety of books,
00:54:51.880
the, um, Second Treatise on Government. Second Sex was one of them. Uh, the, the Second Sex, um,
00:54:57.680
Vindication of the Rights of Women. It's all in here, mate. It's all in here. This is why we're
00:55:02.360
doing this. Set text by the College of Policing. Now, look, I'll wrap this up because, um, you think I'm
00:55:06.260
joking. I wish. I wish we weren't a joke of a country because this actually could be possible because
00:55:10.160
Yvette Cooper is bringing back non-crime hate incidents. And we say bringing back because
00:55:14.820
for end of the show, Harry Miller in 2021 took the College of Policing to court and it was ruled
00:55:19.460
that the way they were recording these non-crime hate incidents was unlawful. They were giving you
00:55:23.260
a black mark on your DBS check, not informing you of who had made the claim, what evidence the claim
00:55:27.860
was, and if you had a claim against you. And so you could be turned down for jobs without ever
00:55:31.060
knowing why. And because there's no evidentiary standard, the people that were making the claim
00:55:35.160
were treated automatically as the victims and you as perpetrators, even though they're not
00:55:39.380
crimes. He had found that between 2014, when these were adopted as a result of the McPherson
00:55:45.320
report and 2020, over 120,000 of these have been recorded. We now estimate 250,000 of these
00:55:53.140
have been recorded. And despite Suella Braveman in 2023 putting in the Police Crime Sentencing
00:55:59.340
and Courts Bill, new legislation and guidance being given to the College of Policing to stop
00:56:04.860
recording these for frivolous reasons, they went up last year. The law does not matter.
00:56:11.500
30 of the 43 police forces in England and Wales increased the number of non-crime hate incidents
00:56:16.320
they recorded. So, I just want to reiterate for everyone, and you can find out more about
00:56:21.500
these stats in a recent episode of my show that I did there, I broke it down for an hour
00:56:24.520
and a half, it's very laborious, but hopefully a useful resource. The point of this segment is
00:56:28.860
to reiterate, as Thomas Hobbes once said, autoritas non veritas facit legem. Authority,
00:56:35.180
not truth, makes law. And the people applying the law are the authority. That matters more
00:56:46.840
Apologies. I think sometimes we just have to sort of catalogue these events.
00:56:50.260
Well, no, that's absolutely fair. We can provide a sort of resource for anybody who's looking
00:56:55.340
to see what's going on in the country. We have one more rumble rant before we move on to the
00:57:00.140
next segment. Keith Kaiser, live news at the moment, Keir Starmer is under fire for not providing
00:57:05.280
any stats about how cutting winter fuel payments would help the economy. It seems to be an attack
00:57:08.900
on Tory voters' thoughts. I was speaking to a senior political source earlier in the week,
00:57:15.280
and they explained to me the reason he's actually doing this is because the OBR and the Bank of
00:57:19.200
England work together to say that there are certain things you cannot touch because we have
00:57:24.740
existing spending commitments that are Acts of Parliament. So for example, everyone's hitting
00:57:29.520
him for the foreign aid budget, quite rightly so. That's where all the climate spending is coming
00:57:32.780
from. That's where all of the first year of refugee, asylum seeker, illegal migrant payments are coming
00:57:38.780
from. They're all coming out of the foreign aid budget. The foreign aid budget is set by an Act of
00:57:42.300
Parliament, so it would take him two years to repeal that. If he needs to make savings now, the only
00:57:46.700
place the OBR have told him he can do it is in public spending, but he's just giving loads of money to the
00:57:51.340
unions or pensions. So he's making cuts with the winter fuel payment, and he thinks that he can
00:57:55.820
weather the bad PR storm in the short run. I think this is a bad call.
00:58:01.100
This whole bad PR storm in the short run, his entire Prime Ministerial career so far has been
00:58:09.700
a bad PR storm. So the fact that he still turns around and goes, I've made every wrong decision,
00:58:16.980
I've stepped on every landmine, what's one bad decision, what's one landmine more?
00:58:25.080
Yeah, this man is going to go down as the most unpopular Prime Minister of all time, and rightly
00:58:31.120
so, and somehow he's managed to achieve it within months of having taken over from the most unpopular
00:58:36.740
Tory regime of all time. I mean, it's ridiculous. They really should just start handing out big shoes
00:58:43.700
and red noses when they step into Parliament, shouldn't they, these days?
00:58:47.720
Well, I think you can tell Tony Blair is very displeased as well, because he keeps coming out
00:58:50.940
actively counter-signalling everything that Starmer's doing.
00:58:53.740
Tony Blair basically came out recently and said, why aren't we sending them home?
00:58:58.040
Well, I think that was a sort of Hobson's choice to reopen free movement with the EU.
00:59:03.500
But he was right. What benefit having large dependent Asian and African families imported into Britain
00:59:10.100
Well, the thing that he contrasted the idea of the free EU movement was, well, yeah, we
00:59:15.240
had single people from Eastern Europe coming over, which I don't think is true. Purely
00:59:21.120
true. But he contrasted it with the, why do we have all of these people basically saying,
00:59:25.720
switch it back to how I was doing it, they have to go home.
00:59:29.740
Tony Blair staring down from a balcony at a Notting Hill carnival, sneering, we need to
00:59:38.580
We've got a seven point plan here, says Tony Blair.
00:59:41.260
So $5 from Eiffenheimer, I hope I pronounced that right. I didn't, I'm sure. E-E-F-A in
00:59:50.800
We had a pro-Palestine peaceful protest in Melbourne, Australia yesterday. They threw chairs,
00:59:56.200
crates, and horse excrement at our mounted police. Our police arrested the lot of them.
01:00:00.540
Well, I'm glad at least the police are operating in some competent fashion. It's just a shame they
01:00:05.420
learn those tactics from lockdown when they weaponize that against the native population.
01:00:09.740
Oh, oh, it's, uh, it's, um, I think explaining how to pronounce the name.
01:00:17.640
I apologize. I, I'm stupid. Uh, Threadnought, $5. Damn you. And he calls me Colin, but it's
01:00:23.820
Connor. Um, I was going to point out- I don't know why they've started calling you Colin
01:00:28.820
No, it's a bit of a dead meme. I was going to point out Stammer as, he doesn't Stammer,
01:00:33.500
um, mimicry of Sideshow Bob. No, he's, he's so robotic. He doesn't actually trip over his
01:00:37.860
words. He just like recites whatever script has been fed to him.
01:00:40.540
I've seen him trip over his words a few times. But anyway, thank you very much for those
01:00:45.240
rumble rants. Let's get into this last segment, which is about the death of the Internet Archive
01:00:50.400
and its massive online library, at least certainly the destruction of a massive portion of that
01:00:56.280
library. And I've got to be honest, I might upset a few people, uh, with this segment because
01:01:01.160
I'm not going to be entirely on the Internet Archive side as a company, as an organization.
01:01:06.580
I think the resources that they had compiled as part of their online library, which allowed
01:01:11.820
you to check out books for free online as if you were going to a library and had a massive
01:01:17.160
wealth of out of print and difficult to find books that you could get for free, uh, was
01:01:23.760
really fantastic. I've used it a lot of times, but as a company, um, they're shit libs and
01:01:32.040
Wasn't one of them related to Taylor Lorenz and tried to retroactively edit the Archive
01:01:40.420
That might be the case. I don't recall exactly, but I remember it being reported at the time.
01:01:45.120
And so, um, I'm not going to confirm it, but nor will I, uh, deny it.
01:01:50.080
Yes. Uh, first though, uh, one thing that will be very limited run and out of print soon
01:01:56.000
will be issue two of Islander, which I know that we've only just announced, but it is a
01:02:00.100
limited run for a reason. When we say limited, we mean limited. This is going to be your only
01:02:05.520
opportunity for the next month or so to get a hold of a copy of this. If you order it now,
01:02:10.680
it'll be printed to order and you'll have it within about two to three weeks. Got excellent
01:02:15.000
articles all written by a wealth of authors, some returning from the first issue like Dr.
01:02:20.060
Nima Parvini, Carl Benjamin, and others with some newbies, including Dave Green, the distributist,
01:02:26.020
Stefan Molyneux, and more. And also along with that, we've got the merchandise that's come
01:02:31.420
along with it. So you can get a hold of that. You can get a mug, you can get a shirt, or you
01:02:36.300
can get the awesome shirt, the best shirt, but don't buy too many of those. Cause I'm going
01:02:41.440
I'm not replacing my mug with one of those, but they are wonderful mugs.
01:02:44.320
Yes, they are wonderful mugs. They're just not gay enough for Connor.
01:02:50.600
I got a little giggle out of Samson. Anyway, uh, so let's look at what's been happening
01:02:55.680
here. So what's happened is the internet archive was being sued by a large, uh, conglomeration
01:03:02.000
of different publishing companies, including companies like, uh, I think it was, um, Hatchet
01:03:08.280
House. I'll, I'll go through the articles in fact, and just confirm before I start to
01:03:11.720
make a fool of myself any more than I already do on this show. Uh, so it says in here that,
01:03:16.920
uh, libraries across the country temporarily closed in the early days of the pandemic.
01:03:20.860
The internet archive had the idea to make its library of scanned books free to read
01:03:25.540
in an online database. They already had this library, which is made up of books that have
01:03:29.820
been legally purchased and then scanned and submitted to the website. Um, they already
01:03:35.020
had that, but they had a very particular system involved in it, which is explained a bit better
01:03:39.700
in the next link over. So I'll save it till then. The question of the library's legality
01:03:43.580
became a long running saga that may have finally ended on last Wednesday when an appeals court
01:03:48.020
affirmed that the internet archive violated copyright laws by redistributing these books
01:03:52.620
without a licensing agreement. The decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second
01:03:56.860
Circuit in Manhattan is a victory for the major book publishers that brought the lawsuit in
01:04:01.140
2020 and could set a precedent over the lawfulness of broader digital archives. The defendant attempted
01:04:07.020
to do what no one had done before, said Maria A. Pallant, president of the Association of
01:04:11.400
American Publishers, which helped coordinate the industry response. They said, uh, she said,
01:04:16.060
they were trying to call unauthorized distribution of entire books, lending without permission.
01:04:21.100
Obviously, we're delighted with this new decision. So the federal court had ruled against them in
01:04:26.040
March 2023, and then they'd appealed. Uh, that, uh, court ruling against them meant that they had to
01:04:31.440
remove a lot of books from the library that were on there, half a million. In fact, in its appeal,
01:04:37.380
the non-profit argued that its free digital library was protected by so-called fair use laws,
01:04:43.580
and that scanning the books was a transformative use of the material done in the public interest,
01:04:50.280
and the court rejected that claim. And I know that this whole thing is a shame. I think the
01:04:54.780
Internet Archive is a really great resource for people, anybody online, not just for the library
01:05:00.100
that they use, but for the archiving of old digital web pages as well. Um, given that a lot of that gets
01:05:05.600
lost to history, sometimes it's really good to be able to archive this stuff so that you can keep
01:05:10.380
track of it, but that's an awful argument. It shows a clear lack of understanding of how copyright law
01:05:18.600
works if you say that scanning the book and then printing it online is somehow transformative.
01:05:25.120
The whole point of transformative is that it doesn't occupy the same use that the original did.
01:05:30.820
That's like, if I snuck a phone into a movie theater, recorded it on my phone, and then posted
01:05:34.980
the whole thing online, I could argue it's a transformative work because the quality is
01:05:44.020
You're welcome to try the argument, but it won't work.
01:05:47.320
It won't work just like it didn't here. Um, so I do think that the entire line of argument
01:05:51.720
that they were going down there was, at best, an arse pull. Very clearly.
01:05:56.200
They carry on to say that, uh, to construe the Internet Archive's use of the works as transformative
01:06:00.240
would significantly narrow, if not entirely eviscerate, copyright owners' exclusive right
01:06:04.420
to prepare derivative works. We were, if, uh, and then it goes on to say, uh, if we were
01:06:11.380
to approve the Internet Archive's use of the works, there would be little to no reason for
01:06:15.340
consumers or libraries to pay publishers for content they could access for free on the
01:06:19.520
website. So, basically just saying, you would eliminate the entire profit part of the publishing
01:06:26.140
market if we were to allow this decision to go through. Because all of a sudden, you could
01:06:31.040
just scan books online anytime and they would be legally available for free for everyone.
01:06:39.220
In a petition to publishers to reverse the lower court's decision, the Internet Archive said
01:06:42.680
it had removed over half a million books from its public archive. Unlike traditional libraries
01:06:47.000
which pay licensing fees to publishers to make their books available for lending, the Internet
01:06:50.920
Archive acquires copies through donated or purchased books to scan and put online. The non-profit
01:06:55.600
is also known for Wayback Machine, a popular database of past webpages. There's a bit more
01:06:59.540
of an explanation in here that I'll quickly go over. So, the open library lets patrons check
01:07:05.960
out books for a limited amount of time. The library only has as many digital versions as
01:07:11.140
it has physical copies. A system called controlled digital lending. Whether they're housed at the
01:07:15.860
Internet Archive's own facilities or in the shelves of its 130 plus partner libraries across
01:07:20.500
the US, each of these books was legitimately purchased from publishers. As the electronic
01:07:25.580
Frontier Foundation, part of IA's defense team, wrote in a statement,
01:07:29.440
libraries have paid publishers billions of dollars for the books in their print collections
01:07:32.600
and are investing enormous resources in digitizing in order to preserve those texts.
01:07:38.060
In March 2020, as COVID-19 spread, the Internet Archive moved to temporarily allow an unlimited
01:07:44.020
number of people to access the same copies. A project called the National Emergency Library
01:07:48.500
that aimed to provide lockdown-bound students and professionals unable to access physical libraries
01:07:52.880
at least some of the resources that they needed to do their work. So, they opened it up in a way that
01:07:57.140
meant it wasn't like a library and just as many people as wanted could get these books, which seemed
01:08:01.580
to be what attracted the attention of this big conglomeration of different publishers.
01:08:06.640
Then, in June 2020, publishers Hatchet, HarperCollins, Penguin Random House, and Wiley filed the lawsuit for the
01:08:12.380
infringement of their copyrights of 127 works. Publishers claimed that as long as readers could
01:08:18.340
be patrons of a free digital library, their physical and e-book sales could suffer. The Internet Archive
01:08:22.780
actually brought in experts who conducted studies that found that the closure of the National
01:08:26.960
Emergency Library did not affect publishers' sales of physical copies and e-books. In fact, it
01:08:31.220
apparently, according to this study, decreased them in some cases. I could see that potentially being the
01:08:37.500
way that it would work, if only because if somebody can read a book online, it might actually inspire
01:08:42.060
them to purchase a physical copy. Personally, I've done that a few times where I've looked at
01:08:46.020
excerpts or some copies that you can find online of particular books, even through the Internet Archive,
01:08:51.480
and then purchase them afterwards because I think it's nice to have the physical copy. Also, I find I
01:08:56.520
retain the information a little bit better if I'm not reading them off a computer screen.
01:09:00.060
I do the same with comic book omnibuses. Like, I'll go and look at an issue in the middle of a run before I go and
01:09:05.520
pick up an omnibus because I'd rather check out two very flimsy issues before I spend 80 to 90 quid on
01:09:12.340
a 50-issue run, but then having that preview expands your market. It reminds me of back when,
01:09:18.240
do you remember when Nintendo, in the sort of 2014-15 era, was hitting loads of content creators with
01:09:23.580
copyright strikes for their gameplay footage, and they were saying, this is not just transformative,
01:09:27.800
it's also free advertising for you guys and more people are going to buy your games. They eventually
01:09:31.080
cottoned on. I do wonder, though, if this is just trying to put the lid on a sputtering pot because
01:09:37.120
the nature of the Internet means that once your book has taken a digital form, the amount of work
01:09:42.960
that goes into creating the product, its means of distribution will diminish the amount of profit
01:09:49.760
you can get over time. Like, if you pay someone a modest fee to generate an article which is free to
01:09:55.580
access, and it does the rounds, it not only generates advertising for your outlet, and therefore
01:10:01.680
ad revenue and interest, but it also means that the production cost is relatively low to the amount
01:10:06.860
that you spend. Production costs are relatively high relative to the amount of time that's spent
01:10:11.020
on creating a book, and if there's a sort of patronage market for physical books, that's great,
01:10:16.560
that keeps it going. People are more inclined to spend more physical copies, but the moment you have
01:10:20.500
a digital book market, of course you're going to get piracy. I think eventually it's just going to go
01:10:23.740
sort of free by the nature of, you can't stop every website from hosting this stuff.
01:10:27.980
Well, there is also the point that I've seen the statistic, I think it's something ridiculous like
01:10:33.420
80-90% of books get less than 2,000 readers that are printed these days. Most books that do get
01:10:40.480
published, even by the larger publishing houses, don't actually sell all that well, especially if
01:10:46.600
you're working in non-fiction, and especially if you're working in non-fiction as specialist and niche
01:10:51.660
subjects. They will be, inherently, books that only appeal to a very small audience, and so there is
01:10:59.520
a utility in having them available for free to a larger audience, because as you said, it gets it
01:11:04.860
out there, makes it more easy to access, and especially if it's gone out of print, you're
01:11:09.280
likely not going to be getting any money from the resales that happen anyway, because it'll be old
01:11:13.240
pre-owned copies that are getting traded about, so why not have them available for free at an easier
01:11:18.980
to access platform? The other thing is, the publishers themselves are turning away otherwise
01:11:23.840
profitable authors. Nigel Bigger had his book ready to go out the door, and it was cancelled,
01:11:28.880
and they had to find a new publisher. They nearly walked out over Jordan Peterson's second book
01:11:32.900
at Penguin Random House, and I was working with an imprint of Hachette to get mine across the line,
01:11:38.220
and right at the end, there was a... Is that how it's pronounced, by the way? Is it Hachette?
01:11:41.720
Yes, I didn't want to correct. You can correct me as well. I didn't want to be a dick. There was a DEI
01:11:46.520
obsessed executive that stepped in at the last minute of the acquisitions meeting when I was
01:11:49.760
going to get my deadline and said, no, we're passing. So this was over a year of work just up
01:11:53.320
the spout, and now I've got to look around elsewhere for some imprint. They had already...
01:11:57.480
I'm sure you'll find somebody. It's difficult. Yeah. They had already said, we're going to make this
01:12:02.800
amount of money on it because we're going to at least reach this number of people because of the
01:12:06.400
number of views that this show and my other stuff gets, and they still passed up a very profitable
01:12:11.220
venture for purely ideological reasons. Yes, and speaking of the actions of the publishers,
01:12:17.260
the publishers themselves in this did not provide empirical data to support their observation
01:12:21.660
that it would decrease the sales. The court nevertheless decided it was self-evident that
01:12:26.040
publishers would suffer market harm in the future if the Internet Archive's practices were to become
01:12:30.220
widespread. Now, I will say there is a practical example of something like this happening in the past,
01:12:35.280
which is with music. There was Napster 20 plus years ago. At this point, Metallica very famously
01:12:41.180
filed a lawsuit against Napster for stealing their music, and a lot of the complaints that Lars Ulrich
01:12:47.020
was making at the time, which was that if the piracy, the free piracy of music online became
01:12:53.160
widespread, it probably wouldn't necessarily affect Metallica's bottom line because they were already a
01:12:57.460
huge multi-million dollar selling band who can, you know, sell out arenas and stadiums across the
01:13:03.320
world. It will affect the ability of younger bands who don't have those opportunities already at their
01:13:09.320
feet to actually make money. And especially since Spotify has become a thing, Spotify is very
01:13:14.380
controversial in just how little money it pays out to any of the people who host on that platform.
01:13:19.920
It pays out something, a ridiculously small number, like something like 0.00001 cent per stream.
01:13:27.700
So you have to be, you have to go viral to actually make any money off of it. And it does mean that it's
01:13:32.460
very, very difficult for musicians to make money. But at the same time, it seems that this might just
01:13:38.600
be a sad fact of distribution of any media on a digital online platform. As things progress,
01:13:46.060
I don't see that there's a way to turn the clock back. It's a sad state of affair for anybody who's
01:13:52.220
creative. The best that you can hope is that you're able to become popular enough that if you're a
01:13:56.600
musician, that you can play gigs and sell merchandise that will make you money. And if
01:14:01.200
you're an author, I couldn't say, I don't know. But as it carries on in this article, the ruling
01:14:07.320
triggered the immediate removal of over 500,000 books. Over 1,300 of these books are either banned
01:14:14.160
or challenged in the US. If they haven't been removed from school and public libraries, they
01:14:19.060
might soon be. The open library used to be the last shred of hope for the average person
01:14:23.780
had a free access to such books. Now that they've been removed, the book bans feel totalizing.
01:14:28.860
On Twitter, Internet Archive has mentioned the oh-so-ironic removal of George Orwell's 1984
01:14:34.540
and Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451. We'll get onto that in a moment.
01:14:39.920
Also, alongside this at the same time, a recent lawsuit from Universal's music group,
01:14:44.860
Sony Music Entertainment, could result in high enough damages to put an end to the Internet
01:14:49.200
Archive altogether, which could take out the Wayback Machine with it, which would be,
01:14:52.840
again, a great shame. And as much as I say that all of this is a great shame and something to feel
01:14:59.240
bad about because of the fact that, yeah, it's a fantastic resource, whatever the ideological
01:15:03.900
positions of the people running it, the ideological position of those people is something that I'm going
01:15:10.120
to criticize now because I have to. First, here's the statement that they made on it. They're just
01:15:14.640
saying they're disappointed they're going to continue trying to appeal for it. It could go to
01:15:18.480
the Supreme Court, but who knows if they'll be able to get that there. Let's examine this claim
01:15:24.140
of banned books. So on their blog itself, they say that we had over 1,300 banned and challenged books. Oh my goodness.
01:15:38.740
Happily, as you can see here, there is a link that you can click that takes you to a long list of this.
01:15:49.400
Here's what you find. Well, first of all, as you may notice, there's quite a few cheats.
01:15:54.280
Quite a few cheats in here because 1984 is listed 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 times,
01:16:00.780
all under different years published. So they just had a load of different versions of the book,
01:16:06.340
which they're all lumping in as different books to plump the numbers.
01:16:10.120
If you scroll down, abortion and politics of motherhood. If I go down to, where is it, to the G section,
01:16:19.720
you can see that you end up finding books like gay believers, gay issues and policies, gay and lesbian,
01:16:25.300
gay people of colour facing. So what they've done here, being that it is a leftist organisation,
01:16:31.540
and also they've got Harry Potter in here, for goodness sake. What they've done is go,
01:16:36.140
these are the books that schools and the parents of children don't want in their schools.
01:16:42.600
Therefore, they're banned, which is a claim that we've all criticised on this podcast many times.
01:16:48.220
Therefore, the Internet Archive Library is the only way that your child, your son or daughter,
01:16:54.280
might have access to a book that you don't want them to have access to in the first place,
01:16:59.220
even though if you wanted to, you could still buy it for them from a shop or from Amazon.
01:17:03.660
But a few things on that. Any school is entitled to not have 1984 in it, because of the sexual content in it.
01:17:12.160
So they don't say which schools banned it, they don't say for what reasons. I would presume it's not-
01:17:17.940
Same with Brave New World. I would assume Harry Potter was banned by some of the more orthodox religious schools,
01:17:23.700
both Muslim and Christian, for the glorification of magic and witchcraft.
01:17:27.640
So, it might even have been banned by some because book four accidentally glorifies slavery.
01:17:33.480
Or, yeah, or because now J.K. Rowling is an apostate for gender ideology.
01:17:41.160
I mean, Adventures of Huckleberry Film was probably banned because it uses the N-word explicitly.
01:17:46.380
And so, this is lumped in with what I can only describe as LGBT propaganda.
01:17:54.780
Yeah, so I do have to criticise them for the dishonesty, and the response to this ruling has been very, very leftist in general,
01:18:03.020
because some of the stuff that they've been posting on their Twitter page has been,
01:18:07.100
won't somebody think of Prakash in India saying that they grew up in a poor region,
01:18:13.420
and I had limited access to books without archive.org, I wouldn't have been able to learn it. Don't care.
01:18:19.960
I don't care. Um, no, most of them, because a lot of people haven't paid attention to this.
01:18:26.000
Um, from our side, a lot of people, oh, this is no different than the Nazis, can you believe this?
01:18:30.640
Oh, it's terrible, I can't believe Prakash can't get hold of her books.
01:18:34.300
Um, I don't care. Focus on the fact that this could impede people's ability to get access to very, very rare,
01:18:42.440
actually out-of-print, difficult-to-find books.
01:18:45.500
Not books that you can get from Barnes and Nobles or any other bookshop that just your local school doesn't want to stock in the library.
01:18:53.560
If we don't have the access to the internet archive, how are we going to preserve African folktales?
01:19:05.660
I care more about the wealth of recorded, um, memory-hold pages from governments, various disreputable media organisations,
01:19:15.500
that we have the original versions so they can't lie and retroactively rewrite history.
01:19:21.200
That we have the screenshot of, for example, the New York Times article that was retitled,
01:19:25.740
that was originally, Elections are Bad for Democracy.
01:19:28.400
It's like, yeah, thanks for the mascot moment there.
01:19:30.700
As soon as Wayback Machine goes, we're not going to have that.
01:19:32.720
I mean, there are a few other archival services.
01:19:37.000
Yeah, but Wayback Machine archive, internet archive in general, are probably the most well-known.
01:19:44.240
I think it's been going since about 1996, maybe even longer than that.
01:19:48.240
So, yeah, there's a, whatever I think of the ideological nature of the people running it,
01:19:56.040
And I do think it's a shame that it's being attacked right now.
01:19:58.420
And as Connor has mentioned, there are some reasons to suspect the reasons that it's being attacked in the first place.
01:20:05.080
Also, I want to touch on one last thing before we end this segment, which is that this is also being blamed on Chuck Wendig.
01:20:17.560
So he's an author who's written new Star Wars books.
01:20:24.980
Yeah, certainly not a person that I'm a fan of, who posted when this first happened, NPR did an article on it,
01:20:32.900
and he said, this is a pirate website, it's not legit, what are you doing?
01:20:36.860
And so people are kind of blaming it on him for pointing the lawsuit in the direction.
01:20:41.120
Uh, for a reminder for anybody, he did this god-awful tweet way back in the day.
01:20:47.880
Tuesday, the day that you realize that nothing can stop you because you're a magic skeleton packed with meat
01:21:09.140
I also didn't know that he actually followed this up.
01:21:11.880
This was a thing that he was doing where he was saying,
01:21:13.920
it's Wednesday, the day you flumpty foo, the day you boopty boopty...
01:21:33.360
He's part of that kind of cultural corner of the world
01:21:50.080
I like to think of myself as something of a pop culture examiner.
01:21:55.420
and see what shiny baubles or squirming beetles my fingers can find.
01:22:05.480
Do they make these guys like Seth Rogen at a factory or something?
01:22:08.700
Yeah, I think that there's a conveyor belt pumping them out,
01:22:11.760
ironically, given the subject he's talking about right there with pumping.
01:22:14.980
But I hate to do this because he's an insufferable person.
01:22:23.740
says that he should face capital punishment for this piece of writing alone.
01:22:26.720
And I would never, ever support anything like that.
01:22:31.120
because there has been a lot said over the past few...
01:22:41.740
Yeah, he posted one time saying about how he thought that it was a pirate website.
01:22:46.540
They shouldn't have access to the books that they have
01:22:51.460
But he does explicitly say that he's not involved in it,
01:22:55.780
So, at the very least, I've got to dispel that myth.
01:23:04.960
that the Internet Archive put forward was complete shit,
01:23:23.680
and achieving a GDP per capita higher than the UK.
01:23:33.120
It's a similar process to bringing in your spouse,
01:23:37.280
and you're instantly deported if you serve one of 12 months in prison.
01:23:40.540
Finally, refugee intake was only about £20,000.
01:23:43.600
It honestly feels like Britain is trying to copy the results
01:23:52.680
of all of its foreign colonies into its country.
01:24:05.000
So, again, the laws on the books may say one thing.
01:24:28.920
is called Poo Poo Pictures Productions Limited.
01:25:42.040
Whether you're going to get a duck or a human foot
01:26:09.280
We'd like to welcome Father Calvin Robinson to the Lotus Eaters
01:26:13.220
He's still going to be doing common sense crusade here
01:26:15.500
It's just that he's going to be from the safe state of Michigan
01:26:30.500
Have always been shunned by the mainstream media
01:26:33.440
And have a lot of bass and historical themes in their lyrics
01:26:36.200
You could possibly do a lad's hour on music at some point
01:27:09.460
I don't know, I've not been a big fan of Iron Maiden's
01:27:13.960
I'm not going to be subjected to a struggle session