The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - April 04, 2026


PREVIEW: Chronicles #41 | Out Of The Silent Planet with Nick Dixon


Episode Stats

Length

27 minutes

Words per Minute

190.83978

Word Count

5,307

Sentence Count

233

Misogynist Sentences

2

Hate Speech Sentences

6


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Chronicles, Carl and Nick talk all about C.S. Lewis's Out of the Silent Planet, the third book in the Out of Time Trilogy. They discuss the themes and ideas explored in the novel, the influence of H.G. Wells, and the legacy of Lewis's work.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 Hello, and welcome to this episode of Chronicles, where today we're going to be talking all about
00:00:18.640 Out of the Silent Planet by C.S. Lewis. This is actually the first time that we've spoken about
00:00:24.820 C.S. Lewis, dedicated an episode to one of his stories on Chronicles. And so I wanted to bring
00:00:30.900 in a heavyweight C.S. Lewis enthusiast, Nick. Thank you. Yeah. And not my actual weight. He
00:00:37.460 means, of course, my C.S. Lewis. Intellectual heavyweights. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, well,
00:00:43.020 great to be here. And in a way, I wouldn't say I'm a heavyweight, but I do have some expertise
00:00:46.660 on literature because I do have an MA in modern literature, although Lewis would hate modern
00:00:50.220 literature. But I know Carl's quite big on having degrees and stuff. So I do actually have a little
00:00:54.080 bit of expertise and then i'm the world's biggest c.s lewis fan right so that helps as well and i
00:00:58.920 think it's really great to talk about this trilogy because lotus eaters fans will love
00:01:02.540 at least the third one that hideous strength which is an incredibly prophetic book about our modern
00:01:08.380 political situation and i've even seen tweets recently saying you're not living in 1984 you're
00:01:14.440 not living in a brave new world you're living in that hideous strength so when we get to that one
00:01:18.700 people will resonate with it but we want to be thorough so we have to start we do we like to do
00:01:22.840 things properly here. So we've got to do the whole trilogy. And they are also all great in their own
00:01:26.980 right. They are. They are. I really enjoyed Out of the Silent Planet. It was a slow burn. You know,
00:01:34.220 it was a really slow build. And I suppose as well, because of the nature of the main character,
00:01:42.180 Elwyn Ransom, and, you know, you get into his mind, you share his anxieties about his situation
00:01:48.260 and where all of this is going, you know, you also fall into having those anxieties as well.
00:01:54.880 And so you're as surprised as he is when things don't really turn out to be as he thinks they're
00:02:00.800 going to. But before we get ahead of ourselves on all of that, let's start by talking a little bit
00:02:06.160 about Lewis himself, because obviously he was a lot like many of his writing heroes and the people
00:02:13.960 that had impressed him, you know, who were a generation or two before him.
00:02:18.760 For example, he name-checks H.G. Wells a few times in this novel.
00:02:24.860 Now, obviously, H.G. Wells' philosophy is very, very different to C.S. Lewis's,
00:02:31.120 but it speaks to the fact that they both obviously have a deep fascination
00:02:36.080 with space and the cosmos.
00:02:37.980 Wells was more of the arch-rationalist and materious, the Faustian.
00:02:42.220 Of course, Lewis is coming at it all
00:02:44.000 from a much more theological perspective.
00:02:46.820 Yeah, that's right.
00:02:47.280 I mean, he's very influenced by Wells
00:02:48.780 in terms of the sci-fi, the aesthetics of that
00:02:51.720 and the precedent there.
00:02:53.160 And he acknowledges that at the start
00:02:54.340 and a sort of preface.
00:02:55.180 But he would be very against Wells
00:02:57.240 in terms of the ideology.
00:02:58.100 As you say, Wells believed in a world state.
00:03:01.240 Basically, it was a technocratic globalist.
00:03:03.380 You thought, you know, this will solve everything
00:03:05.700 when we have a rationalist global state.
00:03:08.280 And Lewis, of course, completely against that,
00:03:10.120 which is clear in this book.
00:03:11.380 and in all of his writings yeah yeah c.s lewis has definitely been been acquitted um on this yeah he
00:03:17.660 seems to have been right oh yeah completely right and well's got it wrong yeah yeah and if you read
00:03:22.800 that hideous strand it's even more clear and even in this book out of the silent planet and in the
00:03:26.940 abolition of man uh which is written around this time and these books are the sort of fictionalized
00:03:31.680 version of the some of the themes in that he's completely against the utilitarian materialist
00:03:37.200 technocratic completely against all of that and that comes anytime you hear progressive in a lewis
00:03:43.060 book you know you're about to deal with some evil people the progressive tendency they're called in
00:03:47.880 that hideous trend these people at the university they're called the progressive tendencies you're
00:03:52.300 like right these are going to be the baddies yeah lewis hated anything progressive right and um
00:03:56.880 it's quite an interesting origin of course for this trilogy in particular uh because if i have
00:04:01.880 it right it began uh out of a conversation between lewis and tolkien where they were basically um
00:04:08.880 challenging one another to write some sci-fi stories and so this ended up being the first
00:04:14.000 of lewis's out of the silent planet and i believe tolkien had been working on a time travel story
00:04:19.440 but he didn't actually end up finishing it which is a shame because i'd love to have seen tolkien
00:04:24.240 try his hand at something yeah more in that vein they have a sort of a bet they say lewis says look
00:04:29.620 there's not enough of the stuff we want to read we're gonna have to write it ourselves yeah and
00:04:33.620 Tolkien does a chapter of the time travel uh novel it ends up so he puts it out somewhere in the end
00:04:39.340 and you can read that in one of his I'm not as big on Tolkien as some people I'm better on Lewis but
00:04:44.740 he emerges eventually and it's not in the Silmarillion I think it's another one but he
00:04:49.000 you can find that chapter but that's as far as he got whereas Lewis bangs out three novels yeah
00:04:54.100 and this is just typical of the difference between them because Tolkien famously took 14 years or
00:04:57.740 something to write Lord of the Rings. Very meticulous, extraordinary, far too meticulous
00:05:01.900 for his own good at times. He's writing an elvish alphabet when he's got deadlines,
00:05:06.360 whereas Lewis was bashing out, don't worry too much about little mistakes, things like that. He
00:05:11.640 chucks away all his manuscripts after he's finished, known for throwing out swathes of
00:05:16.060 things. Just a very different type, prodigious, prolific, but a very different type. Both
00:05:21.400 incredible geniuses, basically, but very different. Yeah, and obviously one coming at things from a
00:05:26.900 more Anglican perspective and the other coming at things from a more Catholic perspective as well.
00:05:32.100 Yeah. And that is always there. I mean, people will tell you now, people who like Lewis will
00:05:36.900 say, well, Lewis was reading Chesterton. Lewis was reading Aquinas. Lewis semi-believed in purgatory.
00:05:43.100 He's basically a Catholic. And I've even heard people claim like Peter Craved, who's great,
00:05:46.660 but he sort of claimed, oh, Lewis would have become a Catholic. This is nonsense because
00:05:50.780 he was a fierce anti-catholic, anti-catholic is perhaps too strong, but he was an ulcer man by
00:05:57.200 birth. He said to Tolkien, you don't understand, I was born in Belfast, I can never be Catholic.
00:06:02.860 But also he just, he and Warnie, his brother, would make jokes about Catholics when Tolkien
00:06:08.660 at one point said that he'd taken the name from a guy called Philip Neary. So Tolkien sort of took
00:06:14.220 that as his confirmation name from this Catholic figure. And he mentioned it to Lewis one night,
00:06:20.580 as a sort of bonding thing, like a revealing part of himself.
00:06:23.600 And Lewis apparently stood stiffly and said,
00:06:25.420 I can't think of two persons more dissimilar.
00:06:27.820 So completely shut him down.
00:06:29.860 Tolkien realises from then on,
00:06:30.980 I'm not going to talk about Catholic stuff with Lewis.
00:06:33.760 Another quick anecdote is there at the Inklings, which was there.
00:06:36.620 Sorry, may I just say that?
00:06:37.940 But that is quite strange, right?
00:06:39.700 Because it was Tolkien, of course, who changed Lewis from,
00:06:44.340 converted him from atheism to just a general faith,
00:06:47.940 faith, like actually believing in a higher divinity.
00:06:51.300 You're right.
00:06:51.620 I'm sort of getting ahead of myself.
00:06:52.600 So there's a famous talk between Tolkien and Lewis.
00:06:57.540 I think, is it?
00:06:58.520 It's not Barfield that's there.
00:07:00.200 It's, I think it's Hugo Dyson.
00:07:01.940 Anyway, they're at, they're in the, they're chatting late at night in Oxford and Tolkien
00:07:06.800 conveys to Lewis that Christianity is the one true myth.
00:07:11.220 So it is a myth, but it's true.
00:07:13.280 And Lewis thought of myths as lies before then.
00:07:15.580 and Tolkien explains to him this theory of the true myth.
00:07:19.000 And he ends up, that's a key part in his conversion.
00:07:22.300 There's several stages to it.
00:07:24.380 Barfield helps him, pointing out things like,
00:07:27.260 if you are getting all your ideas,
00:07:29.300 if your mind is just a collection of atoms,
00:07:31.380 but that's where you're getting all your reasoning from,
00:07:33.240 why should you trust the reasoning of a collection of atoms?
00:07:35.260 Things like that.
00:07:36.640 That pushes him on the way.
00:07:38.220 He goes from being this staunch atheist to a theist,
00:07:41.440 but not a Christian yet,
00:07:42.720 and Tolkien with that conversation amongst other things
00:07:44.780 moves him along to being an actual Christian
00:07:46.980 and then of course it was Tolkien's
00:07:49.360 hoped that he would become a Catholic
00:07:50.480 and he was gutted that he remained an Anglican
00:07:53.640 mere Christianity, a basic Anglican
00:07:55.500 he was very like I'm just going to stick with the basics
00:07:57.380 here, I'm not going to go into anything
00:07:58.980 for those reasons that I said before
00:08:01.640 his background was too dissimilar
00:08:03.240 and so he was never
00:08:05.620 going to really convert and the other story
00:08:07.080 I was going to just share was
00:08:08.900 they're speaking to a visitor
00:08:11.000 to the Inklings which was the literary group
00:08:13.500 they had at Oxford with Charles Williams, Owen Barfield, Tolkien, Lewis, Hugo Dyson, later Tolkien's
00:08:19.020 son, and others. They have a visitor, and they're talking about the Spanish Civil War. And it's quite
00:08:24.800 controversial, of course, that Tolkien sided with Franco. We know that Orwell took the other side.
00:08:29.240 And he sided with Franco because of Catholicism, mainly. But Lewis is dressing down this visitor
00:08:35.600 who's siding with Franco. And Lewis is saying to him, oh, you know, we shouldn't be backing Franco,
00:08:40.720 blah blah but Tolkien's sitting there thinking it's not the fascism that Lewis hates it's actually
00:08:45.100 the Catholicism may or may not have been true but this was apparently Tolkien's feeling that's based
00:08:49.500 on the Inklings book by Carpenter whether that's definitely true or not that was certainly something
00:08:55.980 that is in that book so the point is it's a bit of a digression but there was always this tension
00:09:01.280 between the Anglicanism and the Catholicism yeah so don't believe anyone that tells you Lewis was
00:09:04.820 going to become a Catholic he wasn't going to become a Catholic and this remained a slight
00:09:08.100 point of tension. It wasn't catastrophic. The fallout between Lewis and Tolkien is, from what
00:09:13.560 I can gather, overstated. But this was one point of tension. Yeah. Oh, yeah, definitely. Because
00:09:19.500 obviously C.S. Lewis passed away a good decade before Tolkien. And of course, Tolkien was very
00:09:25.220 upset at Lewis's passing, of course. No, they remained basically lifelong friends. Well, they
00:09:30.480 were lifelong friends, except for the last sort of 10 years, they didn't really talk as much.
00:09:34.380 and after Lewis's marriage
00:09:36.920 it was a problem. Tolkien didn't approve of Lewis's
00:09:38.960 marriage to Joy Davidman
00:09:41.300 because it wasn't
00:09:42.780 she was a divorcee
00:09:44.860 and so for that
00:09:46.880 and many other reasons it cooled
00:09:48.800 and there was famously Tolkien didn't rate
00:09:50.860 Narnia because he felt it was a mixing
00:09:52.920 of mythologies or mythologies
00:09:54.720 as he pronounced it and so there
00:09:56.800 were many reasons where their friendship cooled towards
00:09:58.860 the end but as you say when he died
00:10:00.400 Tolkien was distraught and
00:10:02.640 felt the weight of their earlier friendship and how much it had meant to them.
00:10:06.840 There are other reasons they're sort of slightly cool.
00:10:08.940 One was Lewis formed a close friendship with Charles Williams,
00:10:12.620 who Tolkien liked as a person, but couldn't get along with his work.
00:10:16.960 So for various reasons, the relationship cooled towards the end.
00:10:20.540 But these books, yeah, they come from that original challenge,
00:10:24.400 which is so interesting, that challenge to write the kind of things they want,
00:10:28.320 which they would have called romances, which means an adventure story.
00:10:31.300 Yeah, like in the Arthurian sense of a romance, though they do often be literal romances as well.
00:10:38.840 And I think as well, it's wonderful that from that wellspring of that conversation, that challenge that was laid down by both the men,
00:10:47.220 that we see in the beginning of Out of the Silent Planet with Elwyn Ransom, Professor Elwyn Ransom.
00:10:56.180 And if that sounds like quite a strange name for a protagonist, spoiler alert, it's revealed at the end to be a cover name.
00:11:03.440 It's not his actual name, but it's because of the events of the story.
00:11:08.300 That's the cover name that an alias that he's given.
00:11:11.540 But nonetheless, he is a he just so happens to be a professor of philology.
00:11:17.340 I know from reading ahead a little bit
00:11:19.960 that in Perilandra, in the next novel,
00:11:22.920 that he's also revealed to have been a survivor of the Somme.
00:11:26.820 So he's very much, it's kind of like C.S. Lewis
00:11:30.220 just putting Tolkien in space.
00:11:32.800 Yeah, that's debated.
00:11:33.920 I mean, Tolkien in his own letters says
00:11:35.680 he's not that much based on me,
00:11:38.000 but you're right, of course, there's certain ways that he can...
00:11:40.780 Homages.
00:11:41.480 Yeah, yeah, clearly.
00:11:42.980 And of course, strong elements of Lewis, of course,
00:11:45.260 get into Ransom as well.
00:11:46.160 some of his beliefs. For example, he doesn't believe in vivisection. Lewis wrote an essay
00:11:49.840 against vivisection. Some wartime experiences that are alluded to in Perilandra, I get the
00:11:55.060 strong impression that Lewis's experiences. So yeah, it's a mixture. I mean, and in terms of the
00:12:00.940 name, Tolkien writes to Stanley Unwin, his publisher, that actually Ransom was going to
00:12:06.940 be called Unwin, but he just, Lewis changed it. And the song said, I don't think the name is
00:12:10.620 particularly that important. The name becomes important later in the trilogy and Lewis finds
00:12:15.640 meaning for it, but originally I think he just needed a name. And yeah, he made him a philologist,
00:12:19.640 which is the philology part is key. It's basically an old name for being a linguist, pretty much.
00:12:24.600 That's key because he has to communicate with the aliens. But again, I don't want to get ahead
00:12:28.280 of ourselves, but that's a key thing. Absolutely. No, it reminds me,
00:12:32.440 it reminded me a lot of how in M.R. James' ghost stories, all of the protagonists in those
00:12:39.720 antiquarians it's like you just you you you put in the protagonist who has like a particular
00:12:45.240 penchant skill skill set that's going to allow them to to flourish yeah in the environment that
00:12:52.220 you're going to set them in like this wouldn't have worked quite as well if uh you know a brick
00:12:57.920 layer had been taken to space for example not that there's anything wrong with brick layers you know
00:13:03.420 but like you get my point yeah it's um it just allows for that and one thing that's immediately
00:13:08.400 interesting as well i mean i love the um one thing as well just to say i i really love there's such
00:13:15.680 an understated beauty to lewis's writing style it's not overtly flowery it's probably closer to
00:13:24.080 to george orwell's in that respect but it is really really beautiful and he has such a
00:13:30.220 a wonderful just as an example so um uh ransom is out in england uh on a short walking holiday
00:13:39.200 and he talks about the fact that um there's like uh natalie and sterk and all these little places
00:13:45.360 that he's just uh walking through um far off the grid uh which is perfect because the faculty
00:13:51.080 you know won't notice him being gone when he's abducted and taken to space um but we get this
00:13:57.460 wonderful little sentence where he talks about the fact that he's supposed to be getting a room
00:14:01.120 for tonight and he says about being refused a bed it says the place had changed hands since he last
00:14:06.680 went for a walking tour in these parts the kindly old landlord on whom he had reckoned had been
00:14:12.100 replaced by someone whom the barmaid referred to as the lady and the lady was apparently a
00:14:19.000 british innkeeper of that orthodox school who regard guests as a nuisance you know and so
00:14:25.040 immediately in with all these little quirks of the English character and even though they are
00:14:30.260 um you know he's saying that this is a particular type of character you can tell there is an
00:14:34.760 endearingness behind it it's it's a homely character I love that because of course I grew
00:14:39.600 up in a essentially a bed and breakfast little hotel and restaurant in the in the lakes I imagine
00:14:44.140 there's a lot of those yeah yeah yeah there's a lot of that actually we don't really love off
00:14:48.020 comers but yeah perfect observation a lot of people have said to me a lot a lot's going too
00:14:52.220 far many people but some have said to me they love this intro and i find it brilliant as well
00:14:57.320 it's quite hard to say why he's out there on a walking tour he's like oh i've got to walk too
00:15:00.940 far and and he ends up meeting uh we don't give the whole i don't know how many spoilers you give
00:15:04.600 on this show but but basically ends up uh he ends up offering to do a favor for a local woman yeah
00:15:09.760 of helping her son who's a bit sort of a challenged get home and so that ends up gets him into all
00:15:16.240 sorts of trouble yeah but but um the opening for some reason just out there walking is so
00:15:21.940 it's so striking and i found that as well i don't know why but it's just a great writer as you say
00:15:26.640 and i think he's i felt it was unobtrusive writing he's a great storyteller but not
00:15:31.420 not a sort of foregrounded style you know how you might read a comic novelist someone like
00:15:35.140 joseph heller or or whoever i mean you may read um i'm thinking of thomas bernard but no one knows
00:15:40.420 who that is but there are certain writers who have a very uh clear and foregrounded style
00:15:45.360 where you sort of the style is a big part of it particularly comic novelists because of course
00:15:49.040 it has to be funny of course so the prose itself and the sentences are important lewis i didn't
00:15:52.660 feel that i felt it was more unobtrusive storytelling but reading it a second time
00:15:55.820 i am struck by how good the writing is and i've also just read all of narnia and the writing is
00:16:00.760 so good and there's wry humor and i don't think you should underestimate lewis he famously
00:16:04.960 not famously, he said to a child who was asking him how to write,
00:16:10.660 one of the things he said was, listen back to it, read it out loud,
00:16:13.860 and if it doesn't sound right, don't use that sentence.
00:16:16.140 Oh, yes, I remember seeing this guidance that he wrote, yes.
00:16:18.440 So he's very big on how the sentence sounds,
00:16:21.060 so the care that has gone into his writing.
00:16:22.760 Although he was a prolific writer, the sentences are just great.
00:16:26.240 Yes, he had a very good sense of quality control on all of his work.
00:16:31.540 That said, Tolkien does accuse him in this book.
00:16:33.340 he says some passages are a bit sort of lead
00:16:36.240 and I think he says that he spoke to Lewis about that
00:16:38.560 and that he kind of revised them
00:16:39.860 because Tolkien was an absolute stickler of course for everything
00:16:43.240 Yeah, he was a man of very particular tastes
00:16:47.040 of very particular tastes
00:16:49.120 But I think this is compelling
00:16:50.100 I mean, speaking of Tolkien
00:16:51.000 he said he couldn't put this down when he read it in manuscript
00:16:53.480 Yes
00:16:54.020 Because he was writing to Stanley Unwin, Tolkien's publisher
00:16:56.800 saying, you know, Unwin sent out of the Silent Planet manuscript to a reader
00:17:01.320 the reader said it was not that good he said lewis may write a good novel one day but this
00:17:05.820 isn't it he described the characters as bunk and tolkien said well if you're capable of using the
00:17:10.200 word bunk you're probably not the kind of person that will like this book so he didn't think much
00:17:15.020 of the reader right and that is mad and it actually got rejected by unwin so think about that a world
00:17:19.680 where a c.s lewis book gets rejected it's absurd but it later got published but that did delay the
00:17:25.760 publishing but yeah i i found it the first time i read it i read it in like almost all in an evening
00:17:30.700 a little bit the next day, I find it extremely compelling, as did Tolkien.
00:17:34.120 Yeah, and I think as well that it's actually the perfect place
00:17:37.580 to start off the novel just in the rural English countryside
00:17:41.160 because it immediately positions, particularly for a British audience,
00:17:45.060 it immediately just catches you in something absolutely familiar.
00:17:49.580 Everyone, unless you're some weird Londoner who never leaves,
00:17:54.040 basically everyone has a point of reference to the English countryside.
00:17:57.500 Everyone's been there at some point on a holiday themselves
00:18:00.320 or the parents took them when they were kids.
00:18:02.640 You've seen it.
00:18:03.620 You know it's out there.
00:18:04.840 And so you immediately bring in the most familiar
00:18:08.280 kind of consensus setting, ready to take the protagonist
00:18:12.120 out to the absolute unknown and the deeply unfamiliar.
00:18:16.740 That is a great point.
00:18:18.060 And just on the biographical side,
00:18:20.200 Lewis used to love these walking tours with his brother, Warnie,
00:18:23.320 and they would walk at pace, huge distances,
00:18:26.300 because men were men back then.
00:18:27.520 They were.
00:18:27.860 Whereas if they walked with Tolkien,
00:18:29.540 he would always stop and name every tree an insect
00:18:32.000 and he became a pain because they wanted to
00:18:33.880 bomb on and he wanted to start and say like
00:18:35.420 don't bring Tolkien again because this is a
00:18:37.860 funny detail but on the familiarity
00:18:39.960 of the setting he even
00:18:41.880 goes as far in that hideous strength of
00:18:43.840 pointing out in the preface
00:18:45.380 that I've set this in a recognisable
00:18:47.940 world, a world I know which is the
00:18:49.820 university, he says the reason I've set it in university
00:18:51.800 that's the only world I know but he says
00:18:53.640 because it's a modern fairy tale
00:18:55.280 and he says that in those fairy tales of the
00:18:57.900 past when you came across uh petty kings and woodcuts and so on that was is fantastical to
00:19:04.020 them that was normal and then you went beyond into the strange world but that was normal to them so
00:19:08.620 he sets it in normality now but it's very much like this here he started off as you say in the
00:19:12.940 most normal and recognizable setting before getting to a very alien in all senses of the word yeah
00:19:17.480 right exactly so um as exactly as you said this uh this local woman um asks him to basically get
00:19:26.180 Her son's not home on time, and so he asks if Ransom will go and help get her son back for her.
00:19:33.220 And in doing this, he basically just forces himself through a hedge of this house called The Rise.
00:19:40.600 And in there, he finds, well, he's caught by the people who are about at the house,
00:19:47.000 and these prove to be a chap called Devine and another chap called Weston.
00:19:52.200 um and that i actually what you're saying i thought they were great great characters i
00:19:58.800 thought they were actually perfectly serviceable for um i mean i don't know where they go in
00:20:03.500 obviously the next two novels but like for the purposes of this one alone i felt like they were
00:20:08.440 really good characters in just carrying up conveying the themes and the the sense of
00:20:13.460 self-interest that on all of the the aspects of human nature that c.s lewis is basically trying to
00:20:19.780 to guard against and you immediately know that they're bad people because um ransom talks about
00:20:26.720 the fact that uh one of them devine uh that he knew him from his school days and he immediately
00:20:31.400 says yes now i distinctly remember him being the worst person at school like just the worst and so
00:20:37.540 you immediately know it's like and again we all know the worst person at school and that they
00:20:42.620 always remain the worst and so yeah there's a lot of clues yeah they're two great characters as you
00:20:49.380 say devine a sort of loose opportunistic just scumbag basically yeah he's greedy he's only
00:20:56.500 interested in power and money just complete scum all the way down superficial charm you know and
00:21:02.040 it's sort of that posh superficial charm but he's a total wrong and western a fascinating character
00:21:06.720 because he's not wholly a wrong and he's someone who has a very strong belief in what he's doing
00:21:12.860 he's a great scientist there's a moral crusade yes and he believes very much in the hg wells
00:21:17.420 I think he believes in the progress, science, and he has disdain for anyone who stands in his way.
00:21:23.300 Any means is worth it to get to his end. And he justifies this by saying, I'm a great scientist,
00:21:28.100 you don't understand. But because ultimately he believes that he's doing good, that's what
00:21:33.480 separates him from Devine, even though it's, we clearly learn in the narrative, it's wrongheaded
00:21:38.240 according to Lewis, certainly. He's not a hero like Ransom, who is a moral hero, but he's not
00:21:44.480 as bad as Devine, essentially. Yes. Just a great little passage here. It says,
00:21:50.480 Oh, I'm Devine. Don't you remember me? Of course, I should think I do, said Ransom as the two men
00:21:56.080 shook hands with the rather laborious cordiality which is traditional in such meetings. In actual
00:22:02.000 fact, Ransom had disliked Devine at school as much as anyone he could remember. Touching, isn't it?
00:22:07.740 Said Devine. The far-flung line, even in the wilds of Stirk and Nadabee. This is where we get a lump
00:22:13.700 in our throats and remembers Sunday Evening Chapel and the DOP. You don't know Weston, perhaps?
00:22:19.540 Devine indicated his massive and loud-voiced companion. The Weston, he added. You know,
00:22:25.660 the great physicist. Has Einstein on toast and drinks a pint of Schrodinger's blood for breakfast.
00:22:31.920 Weston, allow me to introduce my old schoolfellow, Ransom. Dr. Elwyn Ransom. The Ransom, you know,
00:22:38.800 the great philologist, has Jesperson on toast and drinks a pint of, and then Weston's just like,
00:22:44.600 I know nothing about it, and if you expect me to say that I'm pleased to see this person who
00:22:49.780 was just broken into my garden, you will be disappointed. I don't care a tuppence what
00:22:54.440 school he was at or what unscientific foolery. He is at present wasting money that ought to go
00:23:00.520 to research. I want to know what he's doing here, and after that, I want to see the last of him.
00:23:06.580 So that's the other thing as well.
00:23:07.820 It's the fact that Weston has absolutely no respect
00:23:10.960 for Ransom's field, of his professional field as well.
00:23:16.380 Yes. Was that page nine, by the way?
00:23:17.780 Are we on the same page?
00:23:18.300 It was, yeah. We are literally on the same page.
00:23:21.660 Good. Yeah.
00:23:23.680 What's fascinating about Weston, you touched on it there.
00:23:26.780 He doesn't have any time at all for what Ransom's up to.
00:23:30.360 He doesn't care.
00:23:31.940 And this comes across, there's a great part,
00:23:33.380 this is page 28 and 29,
00:23:34.520 where you get the differences in their philosophy.
00:23:37.860 So Ransom says that he disagrees with vivisection even,
00:23:43.080 which is something Lewis wrote a whole essay on,
00:23:44.860 as I said before.
00:23:45.880 So let me just find this quote.
00:23:46.920 He said, so Weston says,
00:23:48.780 you cannot be so small-minded as to think that the rights
00:23:50.920 or the life of an individual or of a million individuals
00:23:53.300 are of the slightest importance in comparison with this,
00:23:55.940 meaning this mission.
00:23:57.360 Ransom says, I happen to disagree, said Ransom.
00:23:59.600 I always have disagreed even about vivisection.
00:24:01.900 and so we see the difference there but even more in this passage here when uh western's saying to
00:24:09.120 him have i got ahead of the pot here should i back up so not so this is an overall note about about
00:24:13.740 western's talking about the mission and why they need to go to space and so on and why his
00:24:18.360 scientific mission should trump all ransom replies well you hold all the cards and i must make the
00:24:23.780 best of it i consider your philosophy of life raving lunacy i suppose all that stuff about
00:24:27.800 infinity and eternity means you think you're justified in doing anything absolutely anything
00:24:32.380 here and now on the off chance that some creatures or other descended from man as we know him may
00:24:37.160 crawl about a few centuries longer in some part of the universe and western just replies yes
00:24:41.740 anything whatever return the scientist sternly an all-educated opinion for i do not call classics
00:24:47.620 and history and such trash education is entirely on my side i'm glad you raised the point and i
00:24:52.980 advise you to remember my answer. It's very, very clear, the difference between them. And for
00:24:59.240 Weston, any means are justified to get to his end. And Ransom is completely different. So it's
00:25:05.880 really the difference between principalism and utilitarianism. And I'll just give you another
00:25:11.440 passage. This shows a difference between Devine and Weston, but also between Ransom. And these
00:25:16.040 are just overall thematic differences before we go too much into the plot. But there's a part where
00:25:20.600 Devine is speaking to Weston and we can't
00:25:22.720 hear Weston, so we only hear Devine's
00:25:24.540 answers. And he says, Devine
00:25:26.480 says, quiet, quiet. He said, it is
00:25:28.540 understood that you are doing it all from the highest
00:25:30.480 motives. As long as they lead to the same actions
00:25:32.500 as my motives, you're quite welcome to them.
00:25:34.940 So, this is brilliant
00:25:36.600 because Lewis is wryly pointing out
00:25:38.700 that evil is
00:25:40.540 evil, however you dress it up, whatever rhetoric
00:25:42.640 you use, and you're ending up in the same
00:25:44.580 place. So it doesn't matter about Weston's
00:25:46.480 big ideas about it. Whereas Ransom would not
00:25:48.580 do things in principle
00:25:50.580 i'll give you an example there's this classic um 10 men in a lifeboat uh scenario where it's
00:25:57.600 you can eat one man and kill him and eat him and nine will survive do you do it and if you believe
00:26:04.760 in principalism you go of course not we want we'll have 10 dead heroes rather than nine live
00:26:10.000 cannibals survive but if you believe in a sort of consequentialist utilitarian philosophy you say
00:26:15.420 well of course and i thought about that in light of these characters yeah ransom would never do it
00:26:19.820 Devine would say, what's for dessert?
00:26:22.060 Like, doesn't care at all.
00:26:23.580 Weston would say, yes, unfortunately,
00:26:26.060 we need to make the sacrifice for my great mission.
00:26:28.620 And it's unfortunate it has to be this person.
00:26:30.140 Weston would say, God, I'm full.
00:26:31.900 You know, it'd be like...
00:26:33.020 He'd say, I'm sure you'll understand, old chap,
00:26:34.460 but this has to be done for my research.
00:26:36.300 And so that's his philosophy.
00:26:38.140 It's all worth it for his great scientific mission.
00:26:40.460 And that's what Manson pushes back against
00:26:42.540 throughout the book.
00:26:43.580 He says, I don't even believe in vivisection.
00:26:45.180 So no, I don't believe in your world at all,
00:26:47.580 in your worldview.
00:26:48.540 And everything you're saying about Weston is even more just put on display for the reader,
00:26:53.260 because of course from this tiny little house in rural England, Ransom is very quickly drugged
00:27:00.700 by the two men and wakes up on board the spaceship.
00:27:04.060 If you enjoyed this piece of premium content from the Lotus Eaters,
00:27:07.420 head to our website where you can find more.
00:27:18.540 Thank you.