The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - May 24, 2026


PREVIEW: Epochs #264 | The Life of Henry VIII - Part 2

Hosted by
Mentioned
PREVIEW: Chronicles #48 | The Rime of the Ancient Mariner FREEMIUM: Realpolitik #48 & The Forge | The ‘Special Relationship’ Cope w⧸ Harrison Pitt

Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

165.8

Word count

3,397

Sentence count

54

Harmful content

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

20

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Cardinal Wolsey was one of the most powerful men in England at the turn of the 16th century, but was he also the most tyrannical? And was he responsible for the break with the Church of Rome and Martin Luther?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hello and welcome back to Epochs, where I shall be continuing my story all about the monarchy,
00:00:26 the english monarchy we're up to henry the eighth now aren't we last time you remember uh we did
00:00:31 this early reign because he became king quite young didn't he was only like 17 or 18 uh we got
00:00:37 through some of the early details we did the battle of flodden flodden field where the english beat
00:00:42 the scots even killed the king of scotland on the battlefield and so that sort of makes it a bit
00:00:48 quieter well a lot more quiet on the scottish border for most of henry the eighth's reign we
00:00:53 talked about the Battle of the Spurs, where England won a victory in France. It wasn't
00:00:58 sort of any sort of crushing, decisive victory, was it? Like Cressy or Agincourt, a victory.
00:01:03 And we started talking about Wolsey, the Bishop, the Dean Wolsey, goes on to be famously Cardinal
00:01:08 Wolsey. So we started on that, didn't we? So this time I shall continue telling the story.
00:01:14 And we'll talk all about Wolsey and really the break with the Church of Rome, the Catholic
00:01:19 church in Rome and all that sort of thing, the age of Martin Luther we're in. As always I shall be 0.96
00:01:24 reading from Professor Sir Charles Oman, a late 19th century, early 20th century Oxford professor
00:01:30 of history, one of the best to ever do it, as well as Sir Winston Churchill and his history of the
00:01:34 English-speaking peoples, which if you haven't noticed borrows heavily from Oman, but you do get
00:01:42 all sorts of different details and slightly different takes. So okay let's jump straight
00:01:45 into it let me start reading to you then from omar who tells us following on from the the field of
00:01:53 the cloth of gold if you remember where the king of france and the king of england our henry met
00:01:59 and made out that they were best friends but in fact soon after both sort of betrayed that
00:02:05 friendship and there's that three-way power struggle remember between france spain and england
00:02:09 France and Spain are much more powerful militarily
00:02:12 But actually England is richer, incredibly
00:02:16 At this moment in time
00:02:17 Mainly because of the prudence of Henry VII
00:02:20 Henry Tudor, Henry VIII's dad
00:02:23 But that power struggle is
00:02:25 That balance of power is constantly shifting and changing
00:02:28 Okay, Oman says this
00:02:30 Quote
00:02:30 From all the negotiations and fighting
00:02:33 Which accompanied the changes of English policy
00:02:35 I keep switching sides between France and Spain
00:02:38 And they keep doing the same 0.99
00:02:38 One definite result was reached
00:02:41 England was beginning to grow poorer and more discontented
00:02:45 The hoarded treasure of Henry VII had long been exhausted
00:02:49 And the taxation which his son was compelled to levy was growing more and more heavy
00:02:54 Henry had fallen into the evil habit of dispensing with parliamentary grants
00:02:59 You know, a parliament giving the king money
00:03:03 from 1515 to 1523 and again in 1527 and 1528 he never summoned the two houses to assemble
00:03:12 the money which he ought to have asked for from them he raised by the illegal devices of
00:03:18 quote benevolences quote and forced loans that's a nice way of saying theft stealing it from rich
00:03:26 people saying don't you think it's in your best interest to just give me loads of money or a big
00:03:32 chunk of your money perhaps all your money do you want to still be alive perhaps you should give me
00:03:39 loads of your money right okay we've known we've seen how kings in the past have done that
00:03:44 and how that works out for them often Henry VIII happens to be living in a period of
00:03:51 very very strong monarchy where there aren't you know we've had the wars of the roses and there
00:03:57 isn't a really really strong nobility at this point in history it can rise up and sort of
00:04:04 overthrow him throw him in a castle and starve him to death or anything like that
00:04:08 most of the great lions of the age died in the walls of the roses the country doesn't want a
00:04:14 return to civil war like that so okay henry can basically sort of get away with it he's lucky in
00:04:21 his time and place. Wolsey got the credit of advising this tyrannous extortion and gained no
00:04:28 small hatred thereby but his master was in truth far more responsible for it than he. The cardinal
00:04:34 however bore the blame and it was said that all the chaotic changes in England's policy were
00:04:40 inspired by Wolsey's desire to attain the position of Pope. There's only ever been one English Pope
00:04:46 and that was centuries before this he desired the position of pope by the aid of whichever of the
00:04:51 two powers of france and austria had the advantage for the moment again the house the house of austria
00:04:58 and and sort of the spanish kingdoms and even the holy roman empire all rests in one person
00:05:05 the spanish king the spanish emperor habsburg emperor there is no doubt that there was some
00:05:11 truth in the charge the cardinal's ambition was overweening and he would gladly have become pope
00:05:16 because he had conceived great schemes of church reform which the possession of the papacy alone
00:05:22 would have enabled him to carry out it is certain that charles v the habsburg holy roman emperor
00:05:28 and king of spain twice deluded wolsey into aiding him by the tempting bait of the papal tiara
00:05:36 the tiara crown being pope but on each occasion the emperor used his influence at rome to get
00:05:43 some surer partisan elected wolsey's scheme of reforming the church was no doubt suggested to
00:05:49 him by the discontent against the clergy which was at this moment beginning to break out all over
00:05:55 europe again right we're in the age of martin luther and the reformation since the days of
00:06:00 Wycliffe, hundreds of years before, John Wycliffe, religious matters had not been taking any very
00:06:06 prominent place in English politics, but a storm was now at hand far more terrible than that which
00:06:11 had swept over the land in the days of the Lollards. The Lollards were the followers of Wycliffe.
00:06:17 I've talked about him before, but just to remind you, was a proto-Protestant, a Protestant hundreds
00:06:21 of years before actual Protestantism, saying there's all sorts of things wrong with the Catholic
00:06:26 church. We need to reform all sorts of things. The popes in Rome are doing Christianity wrong.
00:06:33 They're conducting themselves in an evil way, in a non-Christian way. So he was saying that
00:06:39 centuries before this. Martin Luther wasn't the first person to notice, let's put it that way.
00:06:45 The condition of the church of Western Christendom had become more and more deplorable of late.
00:06:50 The worst example was set at headquarters. Bad as the popes of the 14th century had been,
00:06:55 those who were contemporary with the Tudors were far worse. Rome had seen almost in succession
00:07:01 three scandalous popes, the first of whom, Alexander VI, the celebrated Rodrigo Borgia,
00:07:07 was a monster of depravity, a murderer giving up to the practice of the foulest vices.
00:07:13 The second, Julius II, was a mere secular statesman with no piety, but a decided talent 0.54
00:07:20 Both for intrigue and for hard fighting
00:07:23 The third, Leo X
00:07:25 Was a lover of art
00:07:27 And more than half a pagan
00:07:28 Who was reported to have said that
00:07:31 Christianity was a profitable superstition
00:07:33 For popes 1.00
00:07:34 So perhaps you can see why people like
00:07:37 Martin Luther or Calvin
00:07:38 Or any of these 1.00
00:07:40 Catholic heretics, Protestants 1.00
00:07:43 Why their message
00:07:45 What they were saying might have
00:07:47 Landed now in the
00:07:49 Early 16th century
00:07:50 there might be more people in fact millions of people that are genuinely prepared to hear that
00:07:56 message at this point under such pontiffs all the abuses of the medieval church came to a head
00:08:02 ill living corruption open impiety reckless interference in secular politics non-resistance
00:08:09 neglect of all spiritual duties greed for money were more openly practiced by the clergy than in
00:08:15 any previous age. Even the better sort of ecclesiastics could see no harm in obvious
00:08:20 abuses. Fox, Bishop of Winchester, a man of great virtue, absented himself for 20 years from his C.
00:08:28 He should have been in Winchester doing the business of being a Bishop of Winchester,
00:08:31 but just didn't go there. He was more interested in playing power politics and making money.
00:08:37 Wolsey held three C's at once and never went near any of them. The lamentable state of the church
00:08:44 would have provoked murmuring in any age but in the 16th century it led to open rebellion in all
00:08:49 those countries of Europe which still retained some regard for religion and morals. The revival
00:08:55 of arts and letters which men called the Renaissance was now at its height and Europe was for the first
00:09:01 time full of educated laymen who could criticize the church from outside and compare its teachings
00:09:07 with its practice. The multiplication of books owing to the discovery of printing, the Gutenberg
00:09:13 printing press had placed the means of knowledge in every man's hands and the revived study of
00:09:19 Hebrew and Greek, ancient Greek, was setting the learned to read the scriptures in their original
00:09:24 tongues. All the elements of a violent outbreak against the papacy, its superstitions and its
00:09:30 enormities were ready to combine. That's an absolute key thing that people like Martin Luther 1.00
00:09:36 Or Calvin or whoever would say
00:09:38 Is that the Latin mass 0.72
00:09:40 Well it is that
00:09:41 It's in Latin
00:09:42 And most normal people 1.00
00:09:44 Or nearly all normal people 1.00
00:09:46 Wouldn't know Latin 0.99
00:09:47 Wouldn't be able to read Latin for themselves 0.99
00:09:49 So they just have to rely on what their priest
00:09:52 Or bishop says it says
00:09:54 In the Bible
00:09:54 Well if you were unscrupulous
00:09:57 You could make up all sorts of things couldn't you
00:09:59 You could just tell the average
00:10:02 Unlettered person
00:10:04 Who can't read Latin
00:10:05 You can say, it says in the Bible, X, Y, Z
00:10:07 It doesn't necessarily say that
00:10:09 It's in your interest to tell them
00:10:11 And it doesn't
00:10:11 Well, now they can read it
00:10:13 Someone else can translate it for them into their native tongue
00:10:17 Whether it's German or French or Spanish or Italian or English
00:10:20 And now you can read it for yourself
00:10:22 And you realise, oh, the clergy have been lying to me and us for centuries
00:10:28 In fact, Jesus doesn't talk about tithes
00:10:32 And how we have to give loads of money to the church all the time
00:10:34 In fact, Jesus doesn't talk about the church at all
00:10:36 In fact, the Gospels don't say anything about popes
00:10:39 That sort of thing
00:10:41 And one goes on
00:10:42 In 1517, a German friar, Martin Luther
00:10:45 Had first given voice to the universal discontent
00:10:48 By opposing the immoral practice of selling
00:10:51 Quote, indulgences, quote
00:10:52 Of papal letters remitting penances for sins
00:10:56 In return for money
00:10:57 He had followed this up by preaching against any other papal abuses
00:11:01 And when Leo X replied by excommunicating him, Martin Luther
00:11:06 He began to attack the whole system of the medieval church
00:11:09 In vying against the Pope's spiritual supremacy
00:11:12 The invocation of saints, the celibacy of the clergy
00:11:16 The adoption of the monastic life and many other matters
00:11:20 Yeah, so, you know, a number of things
00:11:22 Again, Martin Luther and people like him are asking
00:11:25 Sorry, where does it say in the Bible
00:11:27 that that we're supposed to revere saints that we're supposed to give our money so that some
00:11:34 sort of big golden icon of a saint can be made where does it say that again aren't the clergy
00:11:40 supposed to be married to the church and be celibate how is it then that my my local bishop 0.97
00:11:45 has got many many lovers and wives and mistresses and is in fact some sort of sex pest show me the 0.75
00:11:52 lines where jesus says that there should be monasteries and that the monastery should own 0.56
00:11:57 Loads and loads of land
00:11:58 And be really really rich
00:11:59 And ring normal people for money
00:12:01 Where's the lines in the gospel
00:12:03 That say that?
00:12:05 Oh there aren't any
00:12:06 Okay
00:12:06 He was supported by his prince
00:12:08 Martin Luther
00:12:09 Was supported by his prince
00:12:10 Frederick
00:12:11 Elector of Saxony
00:12:12 And a great part of Germany
00:12:13 At once declared in his favour
00:12:15 And that was between
00:12:17 1517 and 1521
00:12:19 So usually
00:12:20 In centuries past
00:12:21 Somebody like Martin Luther
00:12:23 The church in Rome
00:12:24 Would hear of such a man
00:12:26 Spreading heresy
00:12:28 And demand that he's turned over
00:12:30 Or go and get him themselves
00:12:32 And well ultimately 1.00
00:12:34 Almost certainly burn him alive 1.00
00:12:36 For that 0.99
00:12:37 But Martin Luther
00:12:39 His prince Frederick of Saxony
00:12:42 Says to the Pope and to the Catholic Church
00:12:44 When they ask for Martin Luther
00:12:46 To be turned over to them
00:12:47 Says no actually no
00:12:49 I don't think so
00:12:51 Well that's a game changer
00:12:53 Real big game changer 0.99
00:12:54 Well, it sparks the Reformation
00:12:57 It says, England was not at first very much affected by the revolt of Germany against the papacy
00:13:03 The English church was far less corrupt than those of France or Italy
00:13:07 And though full of abuses, was not really unpopular with the nation
00:13:11 It still retained much of the old national spirit and was not the mere slave of the pope
00:13:15 Neither king nor people showed any signs of following the lead of the Germans
00:13:20 Henry wrote a book to prove Luther's views heretical
00:13:23 And received in return from Pope Leo X
00:13:26 The title of Defender of the Faith
00:13:28 So at 1st, Henry VIII is a good, loyal, good boy
00:13:31 Loyal to Rome and the Pope
00:13:33 We're told that the title of Defender of the Faith
00:13:35 Is an English sovereign still display on their coinage
00:13:38 In fact, King Charles III, our current king
00:13:41 Decided to change that to Defender of Faiths
00:13:45 In our own age
00:13:46 Bit of overreach 0.99
00:13:47 From Charles Saxe-Cobo-Gotha, Sausage Fingers, if you ask me
00:13:51 Suddenly he's a defender of all faiths
00:13:53 Really? A bit presumptuous
00:13:55 Okay, Oman goes on saying
00:13:57 Wolsey devoted himself
00:13:59 To practical reforms
00:14:01 Leaving doctrine alone
00:14:02 Because Wolsey is a cardinal
00:14:04 So he's got to or will always
00:14:07 Remain faithful to Rome
00:14:09 In Catholicism
00:14:10 He left doctrine alone
00:14:11 His first measure was to suppress 0.98
00:14:14 Many small and decayed monasteries 0.95
00:14:17 And to build with their plunder
00:14:19 His great foundation
00:14:20 of Cardinals College, afterwards known as Christchurch, in the University of Oxford.
00:14:26 So another thing to say, which will come up loads here, is the question of the monasteries.
00:14:29 So just to try and paint a picture of that. All over England, and there were hundreds,
00:14:34 maybe even thousands, there were certainly hundreds and hundreds of monastic houses.
00:14:39 Quite often they're just described as houses. What that means is a monastery, right? And
00:14:43 in centuries past, they would be filled with monks, and they would be great centres of
00:14:49 of learning of communities and served a really important sort of social purpose and all that
00:14:55 sort of thing and they became rich and they bought up land they became a whole giant power
00:15:00 structure in their own right and did some good things as I say learning like proto-hospitals
00:15:05 often all sorts of things but by the early 16th century a lot of them retained the land and the
00:15:13 money and the right to levy taxes on the local people but they'd fallen into disrepair disrepute
00:15:20 well Oman describes many of them as decayed that sometimes actual monastery itself is sort of
00:15:25 half in ruin falling down because the people that ran them the remaining monks often they were half
00:15:30 empty almost entirely empty of monks no one particularly wanted to be a monk not no one
00:15:34 very very fewer people wanted to become a monk by the 16th century and so where these houses
00:15:40 Were giant
00:15:41 And now they've only got
00:15:42 A handful of monks in them
00:15:43 But they're still
00:15:44 Raking in all the money
00:15:46 And owning all the land
00:15:47 Or a lot of money
00:15:48 And a lot of land
00:15:49 And people could see
00:15:50 That's not right
00:15:51 That's not fair
00:15:51 This is not
00:15:52 There's something
00:15:53 Gone terribly wrong here
00:15:54 There's a bishop
00:15:55 Who nominally
00:15:56 Or is
00:15:57 The head of this monastery
00:15:58 But there's only
00:15:59 A few monks there
00:16:00 He doesn't spend
00:16:01 Any of the money
00:16:02 On the monastery itself
00:16:03 Or in helping the people
00:16:04 In that area 0.86
00:16:05 He just rakes in
00:16:06 All the money
00:16:07 And he's also
00:16:09 Like a profligate
00:16:10 and he's also corrupt and in fact he's not even there very often nearly all the time he's not
00:16:15 even there he just rakes in the money for nothing he just goes there's no benefit to the normal
00:16:20 people it just goes straight into his pocket so a lot of people start to hate the monasteries
00:16:25 and so even before the reformation really really hits england already cardinal wolsey is beginning
00:16:31 to shut down and do away with some of the worst monasteries and just taking them all their money
00:16:37 and land it was not till about 1527 that england began to be drawn into the struggle which was
00:16:44 convulsing all continental europe and then the cause of quarrel came from the king's private
00:16:50 affairs and not from any doctrinal dispute and that is famously the fact that his wife catherine
00:16:59 of aragon who'd been married to for 20 plus years hadn't given him a son she'd had what was it four
00:17:05 or five different miscarriages or the child had died very very soon into infancy and she'd had
00:17:12 one they'd had one daughter together mary goes on to be mary the first queen mary the first bloody
00:17:17 mary so but henry wanted needed in his mind a son he absolutely needed a son because remember
00:17:24 the wars of the roses are in living memory or very nearly in living memory if you don't have
00:17:28 a son this is his thinking anyway if you don't have a son to pass the crown to then there may 0.82
00:17:35 may well be civil war and things other families will claim to be like the Della Poles will claim
00:17:40 to be on the Mortimers the the legitimate royal family so Henry feels he absolutely needs a son
00:17:47 at any price at any cost of course it turns out that a later daughter he has an Elizabeth
00:17:54 named after his mother Elizabeth of York goes on to be Elizabeth the first good queen best
00:18:01 and is one of the most successful, greatest monarchs we ever had.
00:18:05 A golden age, the golden age.
00:18:07 But all that's in the future.
00:18:09 And at this time, in Henry's mind, he just feels like he has to get a son.
00:18:14 And, OK, Catherine of Aragon is now probably too old to give him a son.
00:18:19 Somebody, was it Woolsey, described her as barren as a brick.
00:18:22 Pretty harsh.
00:18:23 But, OK, she can't give him a son and he needs a son. 0.96
00:18:28 So, ideally, he needs a new wife.
00:18:30 Well, he needs a new wife, doesn't he, for the child to be legitimate
00:18:33 But you don't really get divorced in these days
00:18:36 I mean, it is possible, but very difficult
00:18:40 You have to quite literally get the Pope himself to divorce you
00:18:44 Know your marriage, it's as difficult as that
00:18:46 But perhaps a king can get such a thing
00:18:49 Well, only if the Pope actually wants to
00:18:52 Only if the Pope isn't being bullied and coerced to not do that
00:18:57 Which sort of is the case
00:18:59 So Catherine of Aragon is, you know, an Aragonese princess
00:19:03 Spanish, she's Spanish
00:19:05 And the King of Spain doesn't want Henry to divorce her
00:19:09 Or get their marriage annulled
00:19:11 That would mean the King of Spain's position is heavily undermined
00:19:15 And the King of Spain, we'll get to all this in a moment
00:19:18 Is more powerful than Henry
00:19:22 Has got much more influence and power over the Pope
00:19:25 So this is what Henry wants
00:19:27 He wants a divorce or an annulment
00:19:29 from the Pope, but the Pope won't give it to him, can't really give it to him because the King of
00:19:36 Spain has got his thumb on the Pope's forehead and won't let him do such a thing. So a bit of an
00:19:42 impasse. We hope you enjoyed that video and if you did please head over to lotusseaters.com
00:19:48 for the full unabridged video.
00:19:59 Thank you.