The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - June 03, 2026


PREVIEW LIVE： Realpolitik #49 ｜ The Middle East's WWI Moment


Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

130.21806

Word count

2,743

Sentence count

123

Harmful content

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

47

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 Hello and welcome to another episode of RealPolitik. I am your host, Firas Maadad.
00:00:05.960 Today we're going to be talking a little bit about the Iran war, the war in Lebanon,
00:00:11.180 and the build-up to a conflict with Turkey on the back of what is going on in Lebanon.
00:00:17.720 So it's going to be a bit of a long episode, I think, maybe.
00:00:22.820 And some of the things that we're going to cover, latest developments on the ground in Lebanon,
00:00:27.880 where the negotiations are between Israel and Iran, they're going nowhere, the trouble that
00:00:35.060 Hezbollah is facing, and why the Turks are probably going to end up backing Hezbollah for a while,
00:00:42.140 at least, against Israel, but why that doesn't really solve very much for them, because they
00:00:49.120 have become already the next Iran, and how this could end up becoming a general widespread war
00:00:56.780 in the eastern Mediterranean. So it's a bunch of things that we should be covering and let's start. 0.89
00:01:04.820 The first thing is the U.S.-Iran negotiations and where these are. And briefly, where they are right
00:01:13.160 now is that they're going nowhere. There has been a bunch of exchanges of texts between the Iranians
00:01:19.640 and the americans they've added their own proposals they've gone back and forth and
00:01:26.680 all of the sticking issues that matter are still there trump simply is in no position to make an
00:01:34.720 agreement because any agreement would essentially confirm iran as a regional hegemon and the
00:01:44.160 reality is that if he lets the war end and the Iranians can still collect some fees for passage
00:01:52.540 through Hormuz and get back to exporting their oil, then they've won the war. And the current 0.92
00:01:59.980 proposals would do exactly that while negotiations continue over the future status of the enriched
00:02:07.840 Iranian uranium. And for the Iranians, they also can't give up the enriched uranium because the
00:02:17.360 worst-case scenario for them is to end up in a position where every few months, every few years,
00:02:25.100 the Americans and the Israelis go back and attack Iran. They need to create real deterrence,
00:02:30.760 and the only actual form of deterrence is nuclear, especially if you're facing the United States.
00:02:36.880 And so the two sides are fundamentally stuck. Plus, the dynamics within Iran have shifted.
00:02:47.720 What these guys are describing here in the Telegraph, in a pretty good piece in the Telegraph, is how the IRGC has consolidated control over Iran to sideline everybody who is on the political side.
00:03:02.300 And that includes the president of Iran, Pezashqian, and the speaker of parliament, Galibaf, who are in part responsible for the negotiations, but they're not the actual decision makers.
00:03:16.660 The actual decision makers, essentially, are the current head of the IRGC and the former head of the IRGC.
00:03:25.020 and so this change means that the iranians are in the middle of a transition that keeps on happening
00:03:33.400 in all islamic governments islamic governments begin with theocratic underpinnings
00:03:40.940 and then they end with total military rule that's always how it works and this is exactly what's
00:03:49.120 been happening in iran according to the telegraph and while i don't necessarily trust everything
00:03:55.700 that the telegraph says i think that this is actually spot on because the nature of these
00:04:01.860 regimes dictates that they end up under military rule um essentially in islam you are mandated to
00:04:11.060 wage permanent war and the ruler has the right to kill anybody in opposition and these two things 0.78
00:04:18.900 together lend themselves to military dictatorship with a religious fig leaf. That's how it was under
00:04:27.460 the Abbasid Caliphate. That's how it was under Mamluk rule. That's how it's been for most of 0.98
00:04:34.480 Islamic history. This is what's happening again in Iran. And so for these guys, maintaining a 0.98
00:04:42.660 permanent state of confrontation with the Americans serves to legitimize them having 0.66
00:04:49.440 totalitarian rule over Iran. And keeping a supreme leader, or the supreme leader, 0.81
00:04:57.200 Mustafa Khamenei, the son of the late leader Ali Khamenei, means that they end up having that
00:05:04.400 religious legitimacy that keeps the masses in line. And so this is the dynamic that is happening
00:05:11.860 right now. Plus, the Iranians, as Mr. Vali Nasser points out, he's very pro-Iran, but he's good on 0.82
00:05:20.460 Iranian thinking and understanding Iranian thinking. So take what he says with a grain of
00:05:26.380 salt. This is a biased source, of course. All sources are biased, including this one.
00:05:34.720 You have to look at people's biases, how honest they are about them, and then form your own view.
00:05:40.200 But the points that he makes here are very important. Namely, it's not that the Iranian 1.00
00:05:47.600 leadership is divided that's causing them to delay reaching an agreement. It's that the Iranians 0.99
00:05:56.580 can't trust that an agreement with the United States will actually be enforced. And this is
00:06:02.880 based on a bunch of historic precedents. In previous episodes, I'd mentioned, I think,
00:06:07.160 how under Rafsan Zhani, who was a pillar of the Iranian regime and who was president of Iran from
00:06:14.740 1989 to 1997, the Iranians made a bunch of openings to the United States, including
00:06:22.000 giving oil contracts to, I believe it was Conoco. They gave them a billion dollar oil contract to
00:06:29.800 try to get the Americans involved in the Iranian economy and try to reduce the tensions between the
00:06:34.900 two sides. Bill Clinton responds by imposing sanctions on Iran. The next president, he was
00:06:41.860 very much on the reformist camp. Muhammad Khatami, he governed from 97 to 2005. He was talking about
00:06:50.700 dialogue of civilizations, civilizations of rapprochement. They helped, the Iranians at the
00:06:56.680 time, help the Americans massively in the Afghanistan war. And their reaction from the U.S.
00:07:02.140 was, now you're part of the axis of evil, under George W. Bush. And so they got Ahmadinejad,
00:07:09.780 who was a hardliner's hardliner, and he governed from 2005 to 2013, I think, and they escalated
00:07:21.200 the nuclear program massively. That brought the Americans to the negotiating table. That in turn
00:07:27.340 led to the JCPOA under a different president, a centrist president, Hassan Rouhani. That didn't
00:07:35.660 go anywhere. Trump withdrew from the agreement. So basically, the point that Nasser is making here
00:07:41.800 is that the Iranians don't trust the Americans to actually implement any agreement that they make.
00:07:47.880 What they're worried about is that they will reopen Hormuz, relieve the pressure on the West
00:07:54.060 and on the United States. And that means that the Americans get another opportunity 0.81
00:07:59.480 to wage another war down the line. Whereas now, maintaining pressure on the West,
00:08:07.160 triggering a broad economic crisis would force the Americans to look inwards and would reduce 0.63
00:08:13.760 the risk of another war with Iran. More or less, this is the thinking here. And add to it the fact 0.81
00:08:21.680 that, you know, the Americans twice attacked Iran during negotiations, etc., etc., and so why should
00:08:28.980 they believe in diplomacy? And what this has led to is the Iranians suspending all talks with the
00:08:36.760 United States, and they are claiming that this is over Lebanon, which is something that we're going
00:08:43.860 to get to as we build up towards the narrative of, you know, where the region is going in general,
00:08:49.080 especially if the Lebanon war is not contained.
00:08:53.340 And what they're saying is that unless the Israelis stop attacking Lebanon
00:08:56.660 and withdraw from Lebanese territories
00:08:59.680 the Iranians are not going to make a deal with the United States
00:09:03.640 over anything to do with the nuclear program or over anything else.
00:09:08.420 So they've taken the most hardline position possible
00:09:11.080 and this was just a few days after the Supreme Leader
00:09:15.060 issued a statement about Israel
00:09:17.840 which was genuinely remarkable because of how extreme it was in terms of the need to just 0.86
00:09:25.160 eliminate Israel to dismantle the Jewish state not to kill all the Jewish people just to make 0.96
00:09:32.120 that distinction because the Iranians are willing to kill anyone that gets in their way of course 0.95
00:09:37.400 including all Jews if necessary but what they mean here is the dismantling of the Jewish state 0.94
00:09:43.720 not the destruction of the jewish people and so we've ended up in a situation now
00:09:51.440 where really the possibility of a new agreement is pretty slim
00:09:55.200 and there is no reason to believe that there is going to be one
00:10:00.360 and so trump faces this very difficult choice does he rein in the israelis or does he allow
00:10:09.880 them to continue attacking Lebanon and scuttle the possibility of any agreement with Iran,
00:10:18.200 meaning that he is stuck having to go back to war with Iran. But as we've discussed in previous
00:10:23.900 episodes, going back to war with Iran won't necessarily achieve what the Americans are after 0.71
00:10:31.200 unless they try very extreme things like using nuclear weapons against the underground missile
00:10:37.880 cities and against the nuclear program itself, when you cross that Rubicon, you are never going
00:10:46.020 back and you are legitimizing everybody else's use of nuclear weapons. And so that is quite extreme.
00:10:54.120 But in conventional terms, it really isn't obvious how the Americans can actually beat the Iranians, 1.00
00:11:00.760 but now they're stuck. And as time goes on, the Iranians are going to recover bits and pieces of 0.99
00:11:08.580 their nuclear program and they're going to try to militarize the program given that they believe 0.59
00:11:15.480 that they face an existential threat from the United States. So that's where things currently
00:11:21.260 stand in the negotiations process. Now, the reason that the Iranians are insisting on saving 0.91
00:11:33.840 Hezbollah and on forcing the Americans to reign in Israel is because things aren't going that
00:11:45.820 well for Hezbollah at all in Lebanon. And let's sort of dive into that a little bit and explain
00:11:53.320 what is going on and then get to why Turkey is going to back Hezbollah and what all of this
00:11:59.540 ends up meaning. Just a couple of days ago, the Israelis said that they captured this location,
00:12:08.080 the Beaufort Castle in South Lebanon.
00:12:13.260 And they filmed themselves having taken it
00:12:16.820 and put up the Israeli flag
00:12:20.360 and the flag of the, I think, the Gavati Brigade.
00:12:25.220 Why does this matter?
00:12:26.960 Why does this ancient crusader castle
00:12:29.480 in South Lebanon actually matter?
00:12:32.320 Well, let's look at the map and see what it tells us.
00:12:36.460 By the way, Hezbollah just issued a statement before we started filming this, before we went live, saying that the Israelis took it and withdrew from it, and there's a lot of contention over who controls which territory, and I'll explain in a second why, you know, it's really bad for all sides.
00:12:56.360 Now, the location that Israel captured is roundabout here, just across the river, just across the Litani River, and near the point where the area between the Litani River in South Lebanon and the Israeli border is shortest.
00:13:23.100 So this is a distance of around four or five kilometers.
00:13:26.740 There is 87,000 Israeli soldiers or thereabouts committed to the Lebanon campaign.
00:13:33.740 And they managed to advance this distance and to cross the river.
00:13:39.060 But much of the rest of the area south of the Litani is still not really under Israeli control.
00:13:46.860 And what the Israelis are doing in Lebanon, let me explain it.
00:13:49.780 they've declared this entire yellow line to be a security zone and they're slowly trying to expand 0.51
00:13:58.240 it they don't control all of it but they've destroyed all of it essentially and they are 0.96
00:14:06.080 trying to just clean up the entire hezbollah presence and build a buffer and in addition
00:14:13.600 they are displacing pretty much everybody in South Lebanon. So they're trying to force everybody 0.99
00:14:20.940 south of this river that marked in at the top of the red here, which is the Zahrani River,
00:14:28.560 to just pull up, pull back to the northern part of Lebanon. And they're displacing a million plus
00:14:37.180 people as a result, as well as probably another million people who live in this area in the
00:14:44.380 southern suburb of Beirut. And the idea for the Israelis is twofold. One part is to create a clear
00:14:54.140 zone in South Lebanon along this yellow line where there is zero civilian presence and zero Hezbollah 0.83
00:15:04.140 presence, and that would be then used as a buffer between Israel and Lebanon, and the Israeli 0.75
00:15:12.540 military would deploy there, and that then becomes a way of securing the settlements and the
00:15:20.460 communities in the north of Israel. That's one part. They're failing to do that,
00:15:26.780 and they're still struggling even though they're advancing. 0.53
00:15:29.500 And the second thing that they're doing is to just bombard civilian areas and force people to leave these areas completely to trigger a massive humanitarian crisis in Lebanon that then places pressure on Hezbollah and displaces the entire Shia community of South Lebanon. 0.58
00:15:55.020 The idea being that pressuring the Shia civilians who back Hezbollah 0.69
00:16:00.900 becomes a way of forcing Hezbollah to give up the fight 0.67
00:16:06.740 and of forcing Iran to accept that Israel has freedom of action in all of Lebanon regardless. 0.68
00:16:18.060 And so what the Israelis are doing, they're trying to separate Lebanon from Iran 0.61
00:16:22.500 so that they can eliminate Hezbollah even if they don't get a great deal on Iran itself. 0.90
00:16:29.820 They still get this additional living space. 0.82
00:16:32.900 They still get this insulation between them and the rest of Lebanon. 0.81
00:16:39.760 They still create a massive crisis for Hezbollah and eventually try to force it to disarm. 0.76
00:16:46.340 That's the thinking. 0.50
00:16:47.300 And if it doesn't work, the plus side is that it breaks the ceasefire between the United States
00:16:55.000 and Iran, and it forces the United States back into the war. So this is the Israeli thinking.
00:17:03.380 If they win militarily, great. If they don't win militarily and force an escalation of the 0.69
00:17:09.580 conflict, great. That's what they're trying to achieve here. And for Hezbollah, this is a huge
00:17:15.320 problem. Because having most of their base, their popular support from which their fighters come,
00:17:22.500 who are at the end of the day, the families of their fighters, having all of these people
00:17:28.380 displaced means that there isn't a human terrain in which Hezbollah can operate as an insurgency 0.65
00:17:35.720 and hide among civilians, which is something that it does do. And it means that basically 0.61
00:17:43.580 the entire community that backs Hezbollah is being displaced, bankrupted, broken, slowly destroyed
00:17:52.660 and forced into areas of Lebanon that are not traditionally Shia and that therefore hate the
00:18:00.660 Shia and want to fight against them. So they're using the civilians of Hezbollah as a weapon 0.92
00:18:08.260 against the group by forcing them into parts of Lebanon that absolutely hate their guts
00:18:14.420 to try to instigate civil conflict. And that civil conflict then becomes useful for the Israelis 0.82
00:18:22.860 because it saps Hezbollah's strength, because it forces Sunni powers to back Sunni actors against 0.57
00:18:31.120 Hezbollah. It forces the West to back the Christians against Hezbollah. It triggers a
00:18:36.740 broader conflict, essentially. That's what it does. And that works for the Israelis. And so this is a
00:18:43.620 real problem for Hezbollah, particularly also because of military considerations. So what we've
00:18:49.740 seen now is that with the Israeli campaign, Hezbollah's ability to fire missiles at Israel
00:18:55.840 has declined dramatically. And so when they do fire missiles and they score hits,
00:19:02.440 It's happening in this area, maximum in this area around Safad and around the Lake Tiberias.
00:19:09.200 It's not going as far south as Haifa, which is a major economic and population center,
00:19:15.180 let alone going as far south as Tel Aviv. 0.94
00:19:19.020 And if you're Hezbollah, what you want to do is to try to put pressure on Israeli civilians 0.75
00:19:24.280 in a comparable way to what the Israelis are doing in order to recreate deterrence. 0.87
00:19:31.860 And so deterrence is not being recreated by Hezbollah. 0.88
00:19:35.740 They're taking quite a beating.
00:19:40.180 And this is a real issue for them.
00:19:45.100 And so we saw Netanyahu celebrating that they reached Beaufort Castle
00:19:50.500 and that they are placing this pressure on Hezbollah
00:19:53.360 and claiming that they've killed more in the last month fighting Hezbollah
00:19:58.660 than they did in the entire 2006 war.
00:20:03.320 Just as a sort of side note,
00:20:05.960 in the 2006 war,
00:20:07.840 the Israelis claimed to have killed
00:20:09.300 a couple of thousand of members of Hezbollah.
00:20:12.200 Now they're saying that it was under 700.
00:20:15.200 And that gives you an idea
00:20:16.620 of how Israeli propaganda works.
00:20:18.740 It's just not very honest.
00:20:21.560 But why is the prime minister of Israel
00:20:23.460 commenting about this crusader castle
00:20:26.080 in South Lebanon?
00:20:27.060 because basically when you reach this location in South Lebanon, in Beaufort,
00:20:40.660 it becomes a lot easier to go further north towards the Christian town of Jezin.
00:20:57.060 Thank you.