00:00:00Hello and welcome to another episode of RealPolitik. I am your host, Firas Maudad, and today we are going to talk about what might end up being the most important meeting in the world.
00:00:14President Trump and President Putin and President Xi are set to meet with each other sometime this week.
00:00:23Trump will arrive in China on Wednesday, and the meeting might be on Thursday or Friday, I suppose.
00:00:31They are going to be attending the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Summit in Shenzhen in China.
00:00:40Now, these kinds of summits, if you look at them historically, can be quite significant and very, very important.
00:00:47There are two sort of, shall we say, prime examples that we can think about.
00:00:53One is the Yalta Conference near the end of World War II involving Roosevelt, Stalin and Churchill.
00:01:01in that they decided on the new borders of Poland, on the partition of Germany into four occupation
00:01:09zones. It sort of set the stage for Russia taking over all of Eastern Europe because Russia was made0.89
00:01:16to promise that it will hold free and democratic elections in the countries that it takes over.0.54
00:01:23everybody knew that the soviet union was never going to do that um so you know it was always
00:01:31obvious that this was going to pave the way for a full takeover of uh eastern europe by the soviet
00:01:37union roosevelt was fully complicit in that and that summit set the stage for the next seven uh
00:01:47five or six decades, shall we say, of global politics in that it pretty much defined the
00:01:55security architecture of the world. It broke the world into two major empires, the Soviet Union0.80
00:02:02and the United States. It was a defining moment in the history of the 20th century. Another example0.65
00:02:10is the Concert of Europe in 1814. It was after the Napoleonic Wars. It included all of the major
00:02:18powers on the European continent. It didn't exactly keep the peace in Europe, but it set the rules of
00:02:25geopolitical competition, and it meant that the various parties in Europe had a respect for the
00:02:33balance of power in Europe and wanted to maintain a certain order. That didn't involve zero wars or
00:02:41no violence, very far from it. You had the subsequent revolutions in 1830 and 1848 that
00:02:48really upset that balance. But between the principal powers, Prussia, England, Austria-Hungary,
00:02:57Russia there was an understanding of the legitimacy of the other parties in
00:03:03these in these conflicts and there were limits that were drawn on the nature of
00:03:08the conflicts. A different kind of example of these kinds of summits would
00:03:13have been the Hague Convention and there were two Hague Conventions in 1899 and
00:03:17in 1907. These came with a Russian invitation basically and at the time
00:03:24what Russia was trying to do was to limit the arms race between itself and
00:03:29the two German powers. Well, a unified Germany at the time and Austria-Hungary.
00:03:38Russia was backwards in terms of artillery and in terms of its industrial0.52
00:03:42production. It wanted to see if there could be some kinds of limits on the
00:03:47level of armament that was being pursued because pursuing the buildup of its military prowess
00:03:57was really threatening to bankrupt the Russian state. And this was also paired with at least
00:04:04some idealism on the part of the Tsar wanting to be seen as a man of peace, wanting to be seen as
00:04:09someone who was willing to reconcile with his neighbors. These conferences failed to prevent
00:04:16a massive escalation, and even though they set some limits on the pursuit of war, including,
00:04:22for example, the ban of the use of poison gases, it didn't hold up, and World War I broke out
00:04:27anyway in 1914, and we still live in the shadow of the Great War. So these kinds of meetings,
00:04:37these kinds of events between world leaders can have an importance that continues across
00:04:44decades and decades afterwards. These meetings can be world-defining moments. And now we're in
00:04:51a situation where there's a war in the Middle East, there's a war in Ukraine, there is the
00:04:55threat of war over Taiwan, there is the issue of missile defense, there is the issue of cyber,
00:05:02etc. All of these issues could lead to a major conflagration between the great powers,
00:05:08and in the age of nuclear weapons nobody survives this. So at the very least in a meeting between
00:05:15Putin, Xi and Trump they've got to agree on some ground rules as to how to pursue
00:05:21conflicts and as we saw with the Hague Convention and the ban on the most advanced weapon at the
00:05:27time, chemical weapons, this may or may not survive the test if conflict actually breaks out
00:05:34but there's going to be a bunch of issues that are going to be discussed.
00:05:40And now maybe what we can do, because the White House was careful to sort of not say what the
00:05:47agenda of the meeting was going to be, and they're not going to discuss what the three leaders are
00:05:52going to talk about each other, but a meeting between Putin, Xi, and Trump in a moment like
00:05:57this is really important. So what I want to do now is talk about a couple of things. First,
00:06:03I want to talk about the kinds of issues that they're going to discuss and the importance of
00:06:07these issues and where the interests of the different sides are. Second, I want to talk
00:06:11about the parties that are excluded. Who should be at that table? Who isn't sitting at that table?
00:06:18If you're going to try to imagine this as another Concert of Europe meeting where the various
00:06:24European powers can sit together and maintain diplomacy and conflict at the same time,
00:06:31who else should be at the table, and what do they think about this meeting?
00:06:36Well, the first issue, obviously, is going to be the war in the Middle East,
00:06:41the U.S. war against Iran, and where that goes. For the Chinese, this is a major pressure point
00:06:47on their energy security. They've been able to adapt very well, to the extent that the cost of
00:06:55oil imported into China and the cost of oil imported into the United States is almost the same.
00:07:01But the Americans have an advantage because they have a massive domestic energy industry, which on the whole reduces their own energy cost.
00:07:09And what this war has become, other than a quagmire for the United States, other than a war for Israel, other than giving the option to the Israelis of further expanding their borders, what this war has become is a pressure point on China on the question of energy and a means of making the Chinese pay a little bit more than the Americans for their energy.
00:07:33and therefore this acts as an indirect tariff on Chinese industry and helps the Americans with
00:07:39their re-industrialization. But then the question is, what is the security architecture of the
00:07:44Middle East that emerges afterwards? Because what we're seeing also is Saudi Arabia is in a very
00:07:51vulnerable position because of the advances by the Houthis in Yemen who have taken both the
00:07:58north side and the east side of Bab el-Mandab. Let's see if this map has been actually updated.
00:08:06Samson, oh look, I can choose Yemen myself. But where things are right now is that the entrance
00:08:15and the exit from Bab el-Mandab are now under the control of the Houthi, which is disastrous for the
00:08:21Saudis, and they're getting hit left and right. And for the Chinese, this is important because they
00:08:27have extensive shared economic interests with the Saudis and with the Kuwaitis and with the UAE,
00:08:32but at the same time, their security interests align with Iran. And so what does the Middle
00:08:39East look like after this war? Or does this war continue to escalate? Or are there going to be
00:08:44some rules to the escalation? Things like China's support for Iran, this is going to be discussed.
00:08:51the presence of U.S. bases in the Middle East, this is going to be discussed. So the future of
00:08:59the Middle East is going to be one of the items on the agenda. And this is going to be a big deal
00:09:04for the energy security of China. It's also going to be a big deal for the stability of the global
00:09:10economy. So that's going to be one of the major issues. The other thing is going to be AI.
00:09:17If you're following the news, the improvements that have happened in AI in the last few months have been quite spectacular, with some experts saying that AI has advanced mathematics in the last couple of months more than mathematics has advanced in the last decade.
00:09:39And you're also seeing these incredibly sophisticated hacks that are sometimes being
00:09:46done by AI autonomously. And sometimes you're seeing AI just breaking the rules and ignoring
00:09:54what its creators or what its supervisors are saying to it, lying and cheating its way into
00:10:01all kinds of attacks, like the face-hugging thing, where AI just broke out of containment and went on
00:10:07rampage. Well, you can easily imagine that AI powers, including China and the United States
00:10:16and Russia, are sort of building their own AI hacking nukes, where in the event of total war
00:10:23between them or some kind of armed conflict between them, they would attack each other's0.84
00:11:40recursive self-improvement, where the AI improves itself, I mean, this is a fundamental change to
00:11:48the human condition. This is a very deep change to the human condition. And what do we do about this?
00:11:54Well, these superpowers are going to sit down and sort of discuss this between them. Do they agree
00:12:02on anything? Do they not agree on anything? Do they keep free trade in chips? This is becoming
00:12:09a major issue, especially with the NVIDIA story that Jensen Huang, the CEO of NVIDIA,
00:12:19the West's most important shipmaker, having been in an affair with a Chinese spy.
00:12:27That's a big deal. Does this trade continue? Do we end up with fully adversarial AI? Do we end up
00:12:33with some control on AI, this is going to be a question here.
00:12:38And the next thing is going to be global supply chains
00:12:41and, to a large extent, the dependence of the United States on China.
00:12:46China produces around a third of the world's industrial goods
00:12:50or a third of the world's manufactured goods, sorry, I meant to say.
00:12:57Industrial goods are slightly a different thing.
00:12:59But one-third of all global manufacturing happens in China.0.87
00:13:03And we've seen that for things like medication, for pretty much all kinds of consumer goods, and increasingly for a lot of high-tech stuff, the world is dependent on the Chinese.
00:13:15But these high-tech industries are downstream from more mundane industries like steel, refining, chemicals, plastics, etc., etc.0.90
00:13:30And that itself ties into the energy question. The Chinese are the world's refiners, and as oil
00:13:38goes to them, all of these chemicals and secondary goods that are derived from oil are produced by0.51
00:13:46them. And if the Americans succeed in disrupting the world's oil supply from the Middle East
00:13:54and re-establishing oil supplies in Latin America,0.77
00:13:58then it becomes conceivable for them to reconfigure global supply chains,
00:14:04starting with the basics, refining and chemicals,1.00
00:14:08and then continuing to try to catch up technologically with the Chinese
00:14:13and to try to do something about the industrial might of China.
00:14:19With the Chinese knowing that this is the American intention,