PREVIEW： Realpolitik #34 ｜ The End of NATO
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
140.24771
Summary
In this episode, I talk about the recent Munich Security Conference, and why it is so important for the world's leaders to attend it. I also talk about some of the key take-aways from the conference, including the call to action by the EU's foreign minister, Catherine Ashton Ashton Ashton.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hello, and welcome to another episode of RealPolitik. I am your host, Firas Maudad.
00:00:08.120
As has become customary, this is a live episode, so please drop your comments or questions
00:00:13.540
in the chat or on the comments page on the website, and I will do my best to address them.
00:00:20.540
Today, we're going to be talking about the Munich Security Conference, which took place
00:00:25.820
over most of last week, with really the final days being Friday and Saturday, or Thursday,
00:00:32.360
Friday and Saturday, where the big hitters, the country leaders, Secretary Rubio, etc., came
00:00:39.360
and spoke. Now, first, I want to tell you what is the Munich Security Conference and why is
00:00:45.400
it important. The way that the global calendar works is that first you have Davos, sometime
00:00:52.340
usually in January, where the corporations meet with the governments, and it's really
00:00:59.180
corporate-focused for the most part, and they go around and they discuss their priorities
00:01:04.460
and what they expect and what they want and things of that nature. And then afterwards,
00:01:09.900
the governments themselves, particularly at the defense and security level, ship off to
00:01:16.720
Munich and have their own big conference that kind of sets the global security agenda. And this is an
00:01:25.580
old event. It's been happening for 60 years, but it's really been gaining prominence as the government's
00:01:31.500
version of Davos, where they set out, as I said, their security priorities. And now you have
00:01:38.520
participation of the Chinese and of the Indians and of a bunch of other countries. And it gives you a great
00:01:44.720
great deal of insights into the nature of foreign relations. If you will remember from previous
00:01:50.660
episodes, we discussed how in 2007, at the Munich Security Conference, Russian President Vladimir Putin
00:01:58.280
pretty much set out his opposition to further NATO expansion and warned that there were going to be
00:02:05.900
consequences. And then the result of that was the 2008 invasion of a big part of Georgia, which sort of
00:02:15.220
ended the possibility of Georgia joining NATO and pretty much put a halt on further NATO expansion.
00:02:24.760
In the 2022 conference, Kamala Harris, formerly the vice president of the United States,
00:02:31.320
went to the Munich Security Conference and more or less said that Ukraine would be joining NATO at some
00:02:38.700
point in the future. And that was really the straw that broke the camel's back and that drove the
00:02:46.480
Russians to decide that, OK, we're going to actually go ahead and reinvade Ukraine, following up on their
00:02:54.300
intervention in 2014. So it's actually a big deal. And the theme of this conference was really that
00:03:02.560
the global order was collapsing, that the United States cannot be trusted, and that essentially
00:03:09.600
American-European relations were breaking down. And I thought I'd sort of show you a little clip
00:03:17.440
of how things were going. This was from a session between the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations
00:03:27.440
and Kayakalas, the essentially foreign minister of the EU, was participating. And this was how she was
00:03:37.600
Escalation. So what I'm hearing outside of forums like this privately is thank you for America.
00:03:43.640
So she's rolling her eyes at the American ambassador for saying that the Americans should be thanked for
00:03:51.580
their role in ending a bunch of conflicts under President Trump. And she really wasn't having any
00:03:57.780
of it. And it was really like that all through. What you saw was essentially that Britain, Canada,
00:04:05.220
the EU, Australia, all were ganging up against the Americans and against evil Hitlerite dictator,
00:04:14.160
Donald Trump. Some of it was comical. Some of it was genuinely comical. Here you have Kayakalas.
00:04:21.380
I think it's worth listening to again. Let's do this.
00:04:25.160
We hear the call to action. Europeans assemble. And let me take more inspiration from the Marvel
00:04:31.860
universe. Heroes are made by paths, are made by the paths they choose, not the powers that they are
00:04:40.680
graced with. Europe's path is clear. Defend Europe, secure our neighborhood and build partnerships
00:04:49.600
I think what somebody who's the foreign minister of the EU is taking her cues and her ideas from
00:05:00.100
Marvel, we really have a big problem. Just saying, it seems like a pretty serious problem
00:05:07.760
that this is the level of intellectual discourse. And it was really like that throughout the conference.
00:05:15.880
Keir Starmer obviously spoke at the event. Macron spoke at the event. Mertz of Germany spoke.
00:05:26.280
And they were broadly in agreement that the world was back in the 1930s. And to the extent that there
00:05:33.600
was disagreement, it was over who was the new Hitler. Was it Putin or was it Donald Trump?
00:05:40.320
Trump. They were attacking the far left and the far right and insisting that the only solution
00:05:48.600
is really for the globalist governments in Canada, the EU, Britain, Australia to fully align with one
00:05:58.740
another and to coordinate their actions completely to cut off the threat from any kind of populism.
00:06:07.320
And you always see this language and this attack on populism, by which they mean popularity.
00:06:13.480
So they're defending our democracy. But what they mean by that is more or less their democracy,
00:06:21.640
them remaining in power, them remaining in charge. And so to enable them to do this,
00:06:27.640
the big focus was on attacking Trump and attacking any kind of nativist politics that would try
00:06:37.180
to put the peoples of the countries that these individuals govern ahead of the special interests
00:06:45.420
that actually control the people in charge. And so one of the big themes of the conference was the
00:06:52.320
importance of Europe being able to go it alone and being able to defend itself without backing from
00:07:00.520
the United States. This is clearly deeply unrealistic, and I'm going to explain why.
00:07:09.400
The first reason that this is highly unrealistic is that essentially the countries of the EU have
00:07:15.800
fundamentally diverging interests. It's the leaders of the EU who believe that their interests are fully
00:07:22.600
aligned. But if you think just in terms of a map, if you look at a map of Spain and Poland,
00:07:29.960
the threats that are facing Spain are fundamentally coming from North Africa. Obviously, that's what the
00:07:35.080
geography of Spain dictates. The threat facing Poland fundamentally comes from Russia.
00:07:41.080
And the idea that Russia and Spain should be working together to face this common threat
00:07:45.880
is just laughable at the face of it. It doesn't really make any kind of sense. Plus, even when you look at
00:07:57.160
internal EU relations, you pretty much see that the relationship between the Germans and the French,
00:08:05.480
for example, is really completely breaking down. And you saw that with the photoshoot that happened
00:08:15.560
between Macron, Starmer and Mertz, where essentially, Starmer and Mertz were on one side,
00:08:22.440
and Macron was the odd one out looking deeply embarrassed and very much out of place.
00:08:28.920
They childishly refused to shake hands with Macron and tried to put him on the side. And every time he
00:08:35.240
tried to say something, they'd sort of try to ignore him. Why is that? Because although the Munich
00:08:43.640
Security Conference was full of talk about how European countries should centralize their military
00:08:49.400
procurement, how they shouldn't have 10 different models of tanks and 20 different models of destroyers
00:08:56.840
and whatever models of armoured fighting vehicles and so on and so forth, the actual way that it works
00:09:06.840
is that when push comes to shove, none of these countries is willing to give up its own position.
00:09:11.880
So the problem with the French is that they insist on having full autonomy in their own military supply
00:09:20.040
chain. The French are the only European country that build their own aircraft, they build their own
00:09:25.400
destroyers, their own one aircraft carrier, their own fighting vehicles, their own missiles and missile
00:09:32.600
interceptors, and everything of that sort, because they believe that they should remain autonomous no matter
00:09:38.520
what. And so when they talk about centralizing military procurement, as they did repeatedly
00:09:47.320
in the Munich Security Conference, I mean, Starmer was repeating this, Mertz was repeating this,
00:09:52.760
and even Macron was repeating this. When they keep on repeating this message, it just completely rings hollow.
00:10:00.200
Because when push comes to shove, two things happen. First, the French insist that they will have full
00:10:06.200
autonomy over their own supply chains, and they won't concede anything to anyone. And the second thing
00:10:12.120
that happens is that at the military level, these countries refuse to place their militaries
00:10:20.360
under anybody else's command, which is what would be required. And then there's another reason here,
00:10:26.200
which is that when you're thinking about military technology, it has to be specific to where you're
00:10:35.480
fighting. So that's why Russians always built lighter tanks, where the Americans built heavy tanks.
00:10:43.400
The Russians built lighter tanks not because they couldn't amass enough steel. The Russians built lighter
00:10:49.000
tanks because they know that the tanks are going to have to go over snow, and that there has to be some
00:10:55.800
proportionality or some relationship between the weight of the tank and the terrain that is going over.
00:11:03.080
And so Russian tanks tend to be 10-12 tons lighter than American tanks, meaning that they are fit for the
00:11:11.480
climate that they're fighting in. And if you wanted to build tanks for Spain or tanks for Britain, they will have to
00:11:18.280
adapt to the local environment that they're in. So it just simply never actually works.
00:11:24.760
Looking at some of the other themes that they were talking about here, and I'm just having to glance a
00:11:31.960
little bit at the notes, it really seemed like the objective of all of this was to throw as many
00:11:39.240
spanners in the wheels when it comes to what Trump was trying to do in order to paralyze him and in order to
00:11:46.600
make sure that he doesn't succeed, especially when it comes to the Russia-Ukraine war.
00:11:52.360
So you heard a huge amount of discussion about a couple of themes.
00:11:57.880
One of the themes was the importance of Europe maintaining its digital autonomy.
00:12:03.880
And what they mean by that is a rebuttal to the pressure that has been coming from the Americans,
00:12:09.400
insisting that the EU stop regulating free speech to the suffocating extent that it has been doing over
00:12:17.000
the last few years. And I think we just saw Starmer a couple of hours ago, tweeting about how protecting
00:12:24.200
the kids is a red line, and he won't allow social media companies to do anything that threatens the
00:12:30.280
welfare of children. This is the same Starmer that's been happy to look the other way when it comes to the
00:12:37.400
grooming gangs in Britain. So you can see how seriously you can take him. Macron repeated the
00:12:43.400
same message on digital autonomy. He and Mertz had an event a few months ago, emphasizing the same idea.
00:12:51.560
And what they mean by that is that they want to maintain the ability to regulate AI and control it,
00:12:58.840
and to regulate social media and control it. Because one of the themes that they kept on repeating was
00:13:05.160
how important it is that they be able to police speech in the way that they find fitting.
00:13:11.720
And in parenthesis, that kind of reminds you of the Romanian elections last year, which they pretty much
00:13:17.800
stole by alleging that the Russians had instigated some kind of campaign on Instagram to influence the
00:13:25.320
election. And it turns out the campaign was instigated by the losing candidate in the
00:13:30.600
Romanian elections, just so he could accuse his rival of receiving Russian backing. And that's the same
00:13:39.720
playbook that they used against Donald Trump in his first term, with a Russia collusion hoax.
00:13:45.160
So you see this emphasis coming out constantly out of the Munich Security Conference, that the
00:13:50.760
Europeans need to control the digital space more effectively. Meaning that they need to be able to
00:13:56.520
define American companies whenever they want to, when they don't comply. Meaning that they need to be
00:14:01.960
able to go after X and 4chan, and what's that other thing called Kiwi Farms, and so on and so forth,
00:14:12.200
to make sure that they have full control over the discourse. So that really came out. And they just
00:14:22.600
don't have any other choice. And the way that these guys see it is that Trump is an existential threat to
00:14:31.880
the EU regime in total. Because as I've argued in previous episodes, what Trump really wants to do at this
00:14:38.120
stage is to break the EU, even though the EU initially was very much an American-sponsored project,
00:14:46.200
because the Americans thought that they could control Europe a lot more effectively if they had the EU.
00:14:51.960
It's just that now the EU has turned into a golem, essentially, which has way too much power,
00:14:59.800
way too much control over regulation, and therefore can't do very much.
00:15:04.440
Another theme that we saw coming out of the Munich Security Conference was that they need to be able
00:15:14.360
to have less protectionism. Now this is genuinely hilarious. The premise of the EU was that it would
00:15:23.160
be a protectionist block for certain industries. And if the EU was to try to be less protectionist over
00:15:30.360
things like farming, it would pretty much face a full-on revolt from people like the French farmers,
00:15:37.240
and as we're already seeing from the Dutch farmers. So they're talking about being less protectionist,
00:15:45.080
but this is by far the most regulated piece of real estate in the world. Nobody is more regulated than the
00:15:53.560
EU. Nobody is more protectionist than the EU. It's just that they're using that as a vector of attack
00:15:59.880
against Donald Trump, because he's trying to use tariffs in order to extract concessions from the
00:16:06.600
Europeans. And you constantly see this, where these guys pretty much say anything, regardless of whether or
00:16:15.080
not it's true, in order to defend their interests. That's all that they do. You saw Europe complaining
00:16:25.000
an enormous amount over Greenland, and over Trump wanting to take Greenland. I'd have to argue that this
00:16:33.560
is valid to some extent, because you can't just grab the territory of another Christian country.
00:16:41.080
You have to buy it, you have to acquire it in a legitimate way. So Trump kind of threatening to
00:16:47.480
use force on Greenland wasn't really a good idea, and he backtracked from that. But they will never
00:16:53.640
forgive him for it. And it's not that they will never forgive him for it because he wanted to take
00:16:58.120
Greenland. It's that they won't forgive him for it because he's a threat to the status quo.
00:17:01.880
And the Trump example is really a problem for them. So we also saw, as I said, a lot of focus on
00:17:15.080
developing defense industries. And they're looking to India and Brazil and the Gulf and maybe even China
00:17:22.600
to partner with them on building up their defense industrial base. The issue here is that China has
00:17:31.240
pretty much eaten Europe's lunch. I mean, what China has done with its industrial base was to grow it to
00:17:38.200
such an extent that it's become literally the world's manufacturing superpower, bigger than the next 10
00:17:44.440
countries combined. And that's why the Americans are pushing to consolidate over Europe and Japan,
00:17:50.040
and to some extent, South Korea, because they need that industrial base if they're going to compete with
00:17:55.240
the Chinese at any point in the short term. Europe, instead of reading this correctly and realizing that
00:18:01.240
their interests are naturally aligned with their cultural allies, who are, at the end of the day,
00:18:08.680
the Americans. These are the natural civilizational ally of Europe and the natural civilizational leader of
00:18:17.160
Christendom as a whole, just because of the size of the United States. Instead of doing that, they're
00:18:23.880
looking to partner with India. And they're looking to partner with one of the most corrupt countries
00:18:30.360
in Latin America, Brazil. And they're looking to partner with the Gulf, which is, at the end of the
00:18:35.640
day, your civilizational rival, no matter how you spin it. Plus, China has pretty much eaten Europe's
00:18:42.760
lunch. What China has done was start from very low-level manufacturing, low-skill manufacturing,
00:18:49.240
to become the technology leader in a whole range of industries with enormous defense applications.
00:18:55.880
They now have their own lithography machines to build microchips. They have their own microchip
00:19:02.200
manufacturing. They're leading in all kinds of genetics-based medicine, in all kinds of
00:19:09.720
medical manufacturing, etc. They're leading in all kinds of optics and fibers and things that are
00:19:16.120
absolutely necessary for you to build modern weapon systems and modern communications.
00:19:22.520
So the Europeans are looking at this from the completely wrong angle. And you see that throughout
00:19:28.920
in the Munich conference, and you see zero relationship with reality. Like, the extent to
00:19:36.280
which these guys are dissociated from reality is insane. And the Canadians and the Australians are
00:19:42.360
fully in on the EU strategy. And they're trying to find a way to back each other in what is essentially
00:19:51.000
a rebellion of the provinces against the imperial center. That's the way to think about it. As I think
00:19:59.240
it was the Danish Prime Minister who said it, or the Danish Foreign Minister who said it, it's one thing to be
00:20:05.800
happy vassals. It's another thing to be miserable slaves. And with Trump changing the paradigm when it comes to
00:20:15.720
the way that the West should be operating, they are just in rebellion. You also saw a lot of talk about
00:20:25.560
technological autonomy in the EU and technological independence. So not just digital, but everything
00:20:31.320
to do with supply chains and manufacturing. And here a couple of thoughts come to mind. First, energy.
00:20:39.000
You can't want to build a manufacturing base and have green energy. A strong manufacturing base requires cheap,
00:20:47.800
reliable, reliable, predictable energy. Renewables are not in that picture. You can't operate an industrial
00:20:54.440
base based on wind and solar, because wind and solar are both incredibly unreliable and unpredictable.
00:21:01.880
So this is by definition impossible. But you saw them constantly harping on about climate.
00:21:08.120
And you see them consistently committed to this agenda, which fundamentally serves China.
00:21:12.760
China. No sense of reality. Second, if you want innovation and technology, you have to deregulate.
00:21:21.160
And you have to lower taxes. And you have to make entrepreneurship rewarding.
00:21:26.280
And this is impossible for them to do. Because it means that most of the jobs of the EU are unwanted,
00:21:34.440
because the only jobs that you get within the EU are regulatory jobs. So these guys aren't going to do
00:21:40.840
what's required to cut off the branch that they're sitting on, in order to achieve the objectives
00:21:48.520
that they're saying they want to achieve. If you enjoyed this piece of premium content from the Lotus Eaters,