The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - September 09, 2026


PREVIEW: Realpolitik #63 | Everyone Is Losing the Iran War


Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

137.32

Word count

2,826

Sentence count

130

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

42

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.240 Hello, and welcome to another episode of RealPolitik. I am your host, Firas Maudad.
00:00:06.360 And today, unfortunately for everybody, we are going to be talking about the Middle East again.
00:00:11.280 Because it seems that another kickoff, even bigger than the managed kickoff that we had last week,
00:00:18.660 is really starting to look inevitable.
00:00:22.800 And I will walk you through why that is.
00:00:26.840 We will talk a little bit about internal Iranian politics and their calculations.
00:00:31.000 We will talk a little bit about oil prices and where they are and storage levels.
00:00:35.280 And then we will see where that leaves us.
00:00:39.380 Now, oil prices are now at $97.
00:00:43.040 And Goldman Sachs is warning that they might end up hitting $120.
00:00:49.220 What's happening right now is that both the United States and Iran are absolutely stuck.
00:00:55.740 The Americans don't have a pathway to victory.
00:00:59.280 They can't invade Iran. 0.71
00:01:01.600 They can't prevent Iran from attacking them and attacking shipping and disrupting oil. 0.60
00:01:07.140 And as I've mentioned many times, higher oil prices means higher interest rates.
00:01:12.960 Higher interest rates are a big problem for everybody, especially given the level of indebtedness in the West.
00:01:18.960 Let's park that to one side. 1.00
00:01:20.680 But the Iranians also don't have a pathway to victory. 1.00
00:01:24.860 They can't defeat the United States. They can't destroy the American Navy. 0.94
00:01:29.720 This is now a bit of a waiting game, but as the two sides wait, they're in immense trouble.
00:01:36.440 For the Iranians, their trade is largely cut off because of the American blockade.
00:01:41.420 The American Navy has the power to impose a full blockade on Iran and stop any shipping into the country.
00:01:50.040 And with a country the size of Iran, they need to import food, they need to import some fuel, they need to import all kinds of inputs that go into their industries, their economy gets paralyzed when they don't have trade.
00:02:04.500 This is true of everybody. It's only a country like North Korea that is actually almost fully autarkic. Most countries rely on trade, and the best way to trade is still by sea.
00:02:19.440 So for the Iranians, their economy is slowly falling apart.
00:02:24.180 For the Americans, their economy is slowly falling apart, 1.00
00:02:29.180 but they are in a much better position than Iran 0.90
00:02:31.700 because nobody can impose a blockade on the United States.
00:02:35.780 This is the situation as it currently stands.
00:02:39.420 And this is beginning to cause some problems within Iran.
00:02:43.440 The former president of Iran, Hassan Rouhani, came out and said
00:02:47.760 that if there are people in this country who think that we should fight global powers for
00:02:54.620 20 years, they need to say that to the public and ask the public if they're willing to fight
00:03:01.120 for 20 years. Essentially, Rouhani is calling for a deal. For those of you who don't know,
00:03:07.220 Rouhani was the president when the agreement between Iran and the United States in 2015
00:03:13.940 was finalized, and he had run for election against a much more hard-lined figure, Ibrahim Raisi,
00:03:21.180 who later became president and then died in a mysterious helicopter crash.
00:03:26.320 He was the president when that deal was agreed. And this isn't some random guy. Rouhani, before
00:03:34.400 becoming president, was the representative of the late supreme leader, Ali Khamenei, on the Iranian
00:03:42.100 European Supreme National Security Council. This is the decision-making body on all things related
00:03:49.600 to foreign policy, military affairs, trade, etc. This is where the actual power in Iran lies.
00:03:56.740 And as representative of Khamenei there, he would not have been in that position were he not a
00:04:02.760 hardliner. So we have a cleric who was a former president and a hardliner trusted by Khamenei,
00:04:10.900 essentially saying, look guys, we need to make a deal because we can't just sit there without any
00:04:17.380 trade indefinitely. And the reason that he's saying that is obvious. The Iranian real is basically
00:04:29.780 let me find the chart that I'm looking for here. If you look at what the Iranian currency has been
00:04:39.420 doing since, say, July 2023, the currency is completely collapsing. And it is now at
00:04:49.360 200,000 riyals to the dollar, 220,000 riyals to the dollar. It's losing almost 10% of its value
00:04:58.580 in a matter of days. The Iranians are in very, very deep trouble. But they're not in so much
00:05:05.760 trouble that they have to stop fighting. This hasn't arrived yet. What we've seen with these
00:05:11.940 regimes, as we saw with Saddam in the 1990s, he was under a blockade. From 1990 till 2003,
00:05:20.380 the regime didn't fall without military action. Assad was under enormous sanctions. From 2016
00:05:28.500 2016 was when the Caesar Act kicked off, I think, to 2024. Enormous sanctions. The regime didn't fall without military action. So the Iranians can keep fighting. But there are voices in Iran that are saying, guys, is this really necessary? Are we not better off finding a deal?
00:05:47.420 and obviously the hardliners in Iran were immensely critical of him, accusing him of
00:05:54.420 wanting to surrender, accusing him of wanting to basically give up the fight. They're still
00:06:00.860 trying to mobilize the public and mobilize the opinion of people to take a much more severe
00:06:08.060 position, but you are beginning to see some cracks. And Danny Citronowitz, who's a former
00:06:16.760 who's an Israeli analyst and actually pretty good, like his analysis tends to be very, very good.
00:06:24.820 He points out that, look, this is a disaster for the Americans because they didn't have to go into
00:06:32.700 this war. If Trump had stayed in the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action and just forced
00:06:38.560 an extension of that deal that would have allowed more robust inspections on Iran and more restrictions
00:06:45.840 on the nuclear program, none of this would have been necessary. None of this would have been
00:06:51.580 necessary. But what the Americans did was that they weakened people like Rouhani who wanted an
00:06:57.260 agreement. And now they are stuck in this war. And they don't really have a way out of it.
00:07:04.660 It's not that the Americans are sitting idle. Over the last couple of weeks, since we last
00:07:10.460 discussed the Middle East, the U.S. has announced a total economic war against the Iranians. 0.77
00:07:17.820 People are suspicious of this, and so am I, but the issue here is how much are the Chinese willing
00:07:26.660 to help the Iranians, and can the Iranians get past the American blockade? And we will go over
00:07:32.680 that in a few minutes. It's not the new sanctions that matter. It's the physical blockade of Iranian
00:07:41.320 ports. That's what's actually hurting the Iranians the most. And they don't have a way out of that
00:07:47.020 blockade. But what they are obviously going to do is to try to tighten their grip over the strait
00:07:53.860 further. The Emiratis are saying that they are going to participate in this blockade against
00:08:01.040 Iran, and they've announced that they're going to sever all of their ties to Iran and stop trading 0.52
00:08:07.700 with it, the Iranians can make them change their mind by just bombing them again. So the key 0.95
00:08:14.860 question is, do Gulf states get punished enough by the Iranians in order to break the U.S. blockade? 1.00
00:08:22.340 And with the Iranians more squeezed economically, they have no choice but to hit the Gulf states 0.67
00:08:27.460 more so this is again pointing towards escalation now the iranians are um confirming the idea that 0.99
00:08:38.300 they're getting screwed you're seeing people protesting over you know in case you were
00:08:44.300 wondering about how the deliveroo economy is going in iran well obviously they don't have 0.94
00:08:47.920 the actual deliveroo but they have versions of it and what is happening there is that the iranians
00:08:53.820 being forced to raise their fuel prices and low-level workers are beginning to protest against
00:09:00.220 this and you are seeing the iranians being forced to raise the price of fuel in their country
00:09:08.620 quite significantly having to double it essentially you're also seeing massive
00:09:13.660 queues for fuel throughout iran because the iranians are short of a couple of hundred million
00:09:19.740 barrels of gasoline, or a couple of million barrels of gasoline every day. And this shortage
00:09:29.240 is hurting them. And the negotiations with Oman to try to find some way where they both charge 0.85
00:09:36.120 for fees to cross Hurmuz aren't going anywhere, the Omanis, having been threatened by Trump that
00:09:41.580 he's going to bomb them, basically decided not to work with the Iranians. The only way that the 0.94
00:09:48.180 Iranians can change this is to keep on attacking the Gulf. The issue is that they aren't doing it. 0.96
00:09:54.280 And the reason that they aren't doing it is because they are deterred. They are afraid
00:09:58.180 of the U.S. reaction. They are afraid of the Israeli reaction. As they get more and more
00:10:03.820 desperate, however, despair forces people into very difficult choices. And the purpose of what
00:10:12.720 is going on is to push this further, is to impose this kind of escalation further.
00:10:22.480 Now, Reza'i, who is a pretty senior military leader in Iran, has come out and said that in
00:10:32.240 response to the American blockade, the Iranians are going to shut down Hormuz completely.
00:10:37.520 And what this points to is a massive escalation in the risks to shipping.
00:10:45.000 Because right now, if we could get Google Maps on the screen, Samson,
00:10:49.220 right now the Iranians are focusing their military efforts on shutting down just the Strait of Hormuz.
00:10:59.100 That said, when you look at a map of the Iranian coast, it is pretty massive.
00:11:04.980 and the Iranians have the option of attacking shipping from anywhere along their coast. 0.54
00:11:14.480 So what we've seen over the last few days in this round of escalation
00:11:18.120 is basically the fighting focused just on the strait itself.
00:11:24.420 And slowly the Iranian capability to control the strait
00:11:27.680 is being weakened by the Americans.
00:11:33.360 What are the Iranians going to do? 0.99
00:11:34.980 they're going to start attacking shipping from elsewhere and they are 0.64
00:11:40.260 threatening to declare a total blockade on all the ports that are in the Gulf
00:11:47.100 which basically means that they're planning on turning the Persian Gulf and 0.95
00:11:51.600 the Gulf of Honan into a shooting gallery and trying to make the Gulf
00:11:56.760 States scream so that the Gulf States will whenever they receive cargo from
00:12:02.880 anywhere send some of that cargo in iran and break the american blockade this is the dynamic
00:12:09.680 that is now shaping up and this is what's changing meanwhile the iranian position in the region
00:12:17.520 is generally getting worse uh in yemen the houthi are taking a hammering the houthis as you will
00:12:27.760 remember, control the northern part of Yemen, which they use to attack shipping in the Red Sea.
00:12:38.220 All along the front lines, the Houthis are a little bit on the back foot. And this really
00:12:43.940 is terrible for the Iranians, because what they need is to maximize the cost for the Gulf states
00:12:51.000 and restrict oil flows, with the Houthi weakening, this doesn't really look good for them. 0.99
00:13:00.160 The Houthi, the issue is, are just as insane as the Iranians. And so when they are under pressure, 0.94
00:13:06.920 the only thing that they can do is hit Saudi energy again. And so they began doing that, 0.62
00:13:15.000 and well, they've been doing that for a while, but they did that again.
00:13:18.300 the issue is that what they're hitting is just this refinery here in jazan right on the border
00:13:27.600 with saudi arabia which hurts the saudis but not enough for the houthi to actually deter saudi
00:13:34.960 arabia and stop the the pro-saudi side in yemen from continuing to advance against them because
00:13:41.600 obviously the saudis are backing the enemies of the houthi they need to hit further north
00:13:46.800 and they need to hit the oil-loading facilities here in Yanboa,
00:13:52.640 which would be a massive escalation.
00:13:55.280 And the problem is that it is one of the last cards that the Houthi can play. 0.68
00:13:59.540 Will they do it?
00:14:01.280 I suspect that everybody is being driven into a more and more desperate position.
00:14:06.760 And they don't have many choices other than that.
00:14:10.820 At the same time, the Lebanese Hezbollah is taking another hammering.
00:14:19.040 This is one of the most important hills in South Lebanon, which contains a major Hezbollah command center. 1.00
00:14:25.920 If we pull up the live UA map, Samson, that would be good. 0.99
00:14:34.340 Hezbollah is losing one of its most important strongholds in South Lebanon. 0.94
00:14:40.820 pick the lebanon one and that is a real problem for them because slowly the israelis are forcing
00:14:54.980 the group to disarm all along their border and they're expanding their territory into lebanon
00:15:04.900 unbothered the hezbollah is just losing the ability to stand up to them basically 0.81
00:15:10.820 And this is a major win for the Israelis, and it's happening because Iran is on the back foot. 0.96
00:15:15.940 So having cleared this hill called Ali al-Tahir in Lebanon, it sort of sits around here, I suspect. 0.68
00:15:29.880 Having worked on clearing this, Hezbollah's strongest position that is the command post for South Lebanon is gone. 0.52
00:15:37.160 And as the Israelis expand further, Lebanon's position gets weaker and weaker, and Hezbollah gets weaker and weaker.
00:15:48.480 And at the same time, in Syria, the Druze faction in Sweda is saying that they are a part of Israel, and that they want to join Israel.
00:16:00.220 So the area that we're talking about here is this whole part of Syria.
00:16:04.940 that where the druz religious leadership are saying that they want to join the israelis
00:16:12.060 now to remind you the druz are the community that i originally come from before converting
00:16:18.360 to catholicism this is a very strange esoteric sect with a bunch of weird beliefs it's an
00:16:27.380 offshoot of shia islam they believe in a holy quantity that is sequential rather than co-equal
00:16:35.400 so the holy trinity in christianity the father the son and the holy spirit they are all god
00:16:42.880 they are the they are different persons of the same god equal in essence but different
00:16:51.540 the Druze went down the sequential way where there is the great soul that realized itself
00:16:59.520 and there was a great mind that thought about itself and then this led to matter and from
00:17:05.160 matter there was the past and the future so it's it's slightly it's a different take on the
00:17:11.880 perception of time and creation shall we say that's what it is but this region which is largely
00:17:20.720 Druze is saying that it wants to join Israel. Now Israel's borders stop here,
00:17:30.000 or you know, they stop here in the Golan Heights and the Israelis have expanded further 0.81
00:17:35.840 to be able to threaten Damascus more effectively. This area of Syria is trying to join
00:17:43.760 this area of the Golan, which used to be Syrian,
00:17:49.080 and then the Syrians lost it in the 1967 war.
00:17:52.440 To do that, the Israelis would have to basically 0.51
00:17:55.800 kick out half a million people in between these two regions 0.80
00:18:01.780 in order to expand and envelop Jordan. 0.98
00:18:05.600 This is what the Israelis would have to do. 0.89
00:18:08.080 So what the Israelis are doing essentially 0.73
00:18:09.640 is using the weakness of Iran and the fact that they've been able to push back against Turkey
00:18:18.340 and deter Turkey to expand their borders. This is what's happening on the ground.
00:18:27.580 And at the same time, the Israelis are really pushing in the West Bank to the extent that Mike
00:18:36.260 Huckabee, the U.S. ambassador to Israel, who famously said to Tucker Carlson that the Israelis 0.69
00:18:43.620 can have the entire Middle East if they want to, has been calling the Israeli actions, the settler
00:18:50.720 violence against Palestinians in the West Bank, an act of terror. This is how extreme the Israeli
00:18:59.540 behavior is being and what they're trying what the israelis are also trying to do is to basically
00:19:07.380 kick out if you could select israel for me from that from the list here uh from select region
00:19:14.660 what they're trying to do here essentially is to kick out the palestinians from the west bank 0.88
00:19:21.220 and follow that up or in conjunction with kicking out the palestinians from gaza 0.76
00:19:26.820 so what's materializing in front of you is this for the past several years since the early Obama
00:19:36.840 days for the past two decades now the United States has been saying that it wants to find a
00:19:43.840 way to pivot to Asia and that it wants to find a way to exit the Middle East and focus on the
00:19:49.820 actual threat to the United States which it believes is China correctly China is really
00:19:56.360 the only power that can contend with the United States. Every time this was attempted, the Americans 0.89
00:20:04.860 got dragged back into the Middle East. Now they're stuck in a war with Iran, where the Iranians are 0.89
00:20:11.680 losing because their economy is collapsing, and where the Americans are losing because if oil
00:20:17.640 prices keep heading upwards and pushing up interest rates, there is not only going to be a massive
00:20:23.740 debt crisis in the United States, but it is going to basically kill the Republican Party's chances
00:20:29.980 in the midterms in November and in the presidential elections in 2028.