The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - The Age of Liberals Is Over

00:00:00.000 hi folks i thought we'd have a quick discussion about just the state of the country as it is at

00:00:05.880 the moment because it's very clear to everyone that things are going wrong but the people

00:00:11.000 who are in charge of the country and the various layers of political management the

00:00:18.100 local councils the media the academics that there's a general sense that this has all gotten

00:00:24.960 away from everyone and that they don't know what to do and so the answers that they present to us

00:00:31.580 are just more of the same this is morally the right thing to do and therefore we're going to continue

00:00:38.240 doing it and well we just got to hope we can keep the lid on the pressure cooker because otherwise

00:00:43.460 things go horribly horribly wrong the problem they have is the pressure is building quite high and it

00:00:51.540 looks like the lid isn't going to be kept on the pressure cooker and so we have to go back to the

00:00:55.580 original assumptions that built the society we currently have the values that we're told are

00:01:01.960 british values that made this society the the brilliant society that is and ask ourselves whether

00:01:07.940 there have been any mistaken assumptions perhaps at the bottom of them and so we live in what i'm going

00:01:14.560 to call a social contract society now we don't have a social contract you might be thinking of the united

00:01:21.920 states with their constitution that is a social contract society that has a social contract france

00:01:27.700 is a social contract society or at least a society masquerading as a social contract society that has a

00:01:33.500 social contract for good or for ill we don't have that you don't have a list of enumerated rights in a

00:01:40.480 document that you can use to make an appeal through the supreme court the supreme court in this country

00:01:45.880 is a bit of a strange beast because it has to use precedent that is built up through common law and

00:01:51.500 legislation which all can be changed at any time by any government so you are in a particularly strange

00:01:59.420 position because this is a bit alien to us is the way that things are in this country we are not a social

00:02:05.140 contract society we are a familial society we are a tribal society we are a historic uh sentimental

00:02:11.940 society and so having this imposed upon us is a strange thing and we don't handle it well because

00:02:18.520 the social contract society is premised on the blank slate view of humanity is premised on the idea that

00:02:25.300 everyone is fundamentally the same and only made different by their social surroundings by the

00:02:32.720 civilization in which they were born and raised and that means that everyone being rational animals

00:02:39.080 that's the the usual sort of aristotelian definition of what a human is if we're all just rational animals

00:02:44.540 then what we can do is set up a set of laws and rules and norms that are rationally justifiable

00:02:51.480 and everyone will therefore be compelled to follow them through the innate rationality of the system that

00:02:57.680 we have and that seems reasonable on paper that seems reasonable when you have a society that is

00:03:04.260 quite homogenous that has a overwhelmingly vast population the percentage of the population who

00:03:12.820 have been born and raised in a certain set of unspoken rules and assumptions and ways of doing

00:03:18.460 things or folk ways uh in which everyone finds that to be completely normal and so they for most of their

00:03:25.180 day they're actually not making rational decisions they're just following habits they're just going

00:03:30.080 through the motions as normal and as things always have been to them and so their interaction with the

00:03:36.540 state is predicated on this huge series of particulars these particular norms for this particular place for

00:03:44.780 these specific people following this individual history of the nation and this is not something

00:03:52.760 universalizable or interchangeable and people who come from other countries other civilizations they have

00:03:58.860 completely different experiences of the universe they have completely different expectations of what

00:04:03.780 people should be like and we've brought millions of them in and said right okay these are the rules

00:04:09.160 and you're rational human beings and therefore carry on everything should be fine well it turns out that

00:04:16.240 actually this whole system was predicated on a specific kind of rationality because actually there are

00:04:23.860 different kinds of rationality than the modern liberal materialistic view of the universe there are other

00:04:32.040 ways of seeing the universe and this has real consequences with what happens in society and whether

00:04:40.180 someone follows the rules and then you've got the question of mental health what if there are

00:04:44.240 populations that have dramatically higher rates of mental um mental illness than the native population that

00:04:54.220 everyone expects to just get on with life what happens when those people have like breakdowns or

00:05:00.100 episodes or whatever you want to call them um the rules of the social contract society only abide

00:05:07.580 whilst everyone is a rational actor within the system and agrees to them and the second that someone

00:05:14.160 doesn't agree to them well then they're worth nothing and they mean nothing and actually this is

00:05:21.300 it's these breaches that we're seeing that are creating the terrible environment in which we're

00:05:26.060 finding ourselves that are creating the sense of degradation and insecurity because a lot of the

00:05:32.400 people who are committing the atrocities that we're seeing on a near daily basis these days

00:05:38.260 probably wouldn't be the same in other societies because the point of a social contract society

00:05:45.820 is to make it so that everyone is essentially maximally free of one another and not dependent

00:05:51.820 on social groups not dependent on the people around them and we assume in the english and anglosphere

00:06:02.340 countries that this is normal because to us this is normal frankly to the protestant world this is

00:06:09.820 normal having atomic and nuclear families that don't have a huge and a deep web of deeply interconnected

00:06:21.100 familial relations around themselves is is an unusual thing that's only the northwest europeans that do that

00:06:29.620 every other place now this is to france the mediterranean uh obviously africa india south america

00:06:36.620 wherever everywhere else in the world has much tighter familial relations and much more extended

00:06:43.580 families living in much closer proximity i mean this is one of the things that happened during covid is

00:06:48.920 they found oh wait covid is by way more it's affecting to a much greater degree the ethnic minority

00:06:55.960 communities why is that well it's often because there are multiple generations packed into a house

00:07:00.360 like three or four generations are often packed into one household in these communities because that's

00:07:06.760 how they live that's that's the normal state of life for them and so this affects them more than it

00:07:13.480 affects us now it doesn't matter outside of these sort of things it seems but what that means and

00:07:21.580 you'll you'll doubtless have seen um indians in particular but like people from all over the world

00:07:27.100 uh when they're in public just constantly talking on their phones they need to be in constant

00:07:32.920 communication with the their friends and family their wider support the community network they need to be in

00:07:39.060 constant contact with these people and to an english person and to a westerner generally this is a bit

00:07:45.340 weird like we expect a bit of privacy actually even when we're in public we expect our privacy

00:07:50.320 and these people don't have that expectation at all they don't have privacy at home let alone in

00:07:55.500 public and so you can feel the difference and the distinction of having all of these people with

00:08:00.680 very different social systems being put among us with our particular social systems and so in their

00:08:09.460 society they would have people who would be closely around them closely linked around them socially

00:08:15.880 that would be dealing with the problems that they have uh but we don't provide that in the west and

00:08:21.840 often a lot of these people are not here with an extended familial or social network and so they're

00:08:27.460 just kind of left on their own they they've this is freedom this is what total freedom is in the

00:08:33.260 social contract society no one owes you anything you are to get along as best you can and that seems

00:08:39.780 normal for us but that is wild and weird and alien to them and we're just kind of dumping them in our

00:08:47.900 our society that from their perspective probably looks mad and saying look here are the rules just get on

00:08:54.300 with it that's not normal most societies are not like this most societies do not have this level of

00:09:01.560 freedom and they don't think in the same way we do and we don't understand them and they don't

00:09:08.400 understand us and it was assumed though because they're all rational animals they're all the same

00:09:13.720 rational people these rules are you any any rational person could universally assent to these

00:09:19.420 rules and therefore they would be able to get along with us just as well as anyone else and i think that

00:09:25.260 that is being proven to be false i actually think that the pre-rational habitual nature of man

00:09:31.920 that we are born and raised into without thinking about it without even having without even explaining

00:09:38.860 it to ourselves when we're in school all of these pre-rational assumptions actually really matter because

00:09:44.480 i think they they take up most of the person's day i think if you actually think about it how many times

00:09:49.680 did you sit down and derive a conclusion from premises rationally in your mind how many times did you

00:09:56.600 sat out a syllogism in your head and derived a conclusion that was logically coherent and the

00:10:01.960 answer is going to be zero practically very few times during the day do you actually have to perform

00:10:07.680 any kind of formal logic to get through your day most of what you do is just habitual and so this

00:10:14.460 actually is really important and we need to start thinking in terms that are much more particularist

00:10:21.340 when it comes to who actually makes sense to be here and what we are doing to them by bringing

00:10:28.040 them in like we have got essentially a kind of lure on a on a fishing line that is the apparent

00:10:37.540 material prosperity of the west and the the technological advancements and success that we've had

00:10:43.320 and this this this is a very irresistible lure but there are i think there are a lot of people who end up

00:10:48.580 coming here who realize that actually from their perspective what we're running is a bit of a mad

00:10:54.060 house actually this is not how civilization should be from their perspective even if we think that this

00:11:00.100 is how things should be to them this seems kind of mad and so like i said you have a situation where

00:11:08.000 we've brought in millions of people who don't understand us and we don't understand them and we've

00:11:14.200 told them look we've got a set of rules that you know in the abstract you can rationally agree to

00:11:18.760 presumably although there are definitely going to be examples where many of these new people are much

00:11:25.460 more say socially conservative than the average british person ask the average african what they

00:11:31.300 think about abortion or ask the average muslim immigrant what they think about you know abortion or

00:11:35.860 gay rights or pride praise all this sort of and i mean they they don't agree with the rationality

00:11:43.100 of how we got to the conclusions we got to with the rules that govern the social contract society

00:11:48.220 but putting that aside they can say well look if it doesn't affect me i'm just here to make money or

00:11:54.160 do whatever and maybe it's not a problem but this only obtains what while the system hasn't

00:12:01.760 effectively driven the mad this only obtains while the logic of liberalism is prevailing over the

00:12:09.300 logic of the belief systems that they have and were brought up in either in their home country or in

00:12:15.820 their local communities here because they are still replicating the logic of their home communities

00:12:20.940 in our countries and eventually i think that they find themselves in a position where they have to

00:12:29.420 essentially choose the logic of the home country or the logic of the liberal modern materialist

00:12:35.500 civilization and i think a lot of them to choose the opposite i think a lot of them you know i'm

00:12:40.240 actually against it and i actually want to take revenge on society more broadly and i think that

00:12:47.000 that is a large part of what jihadi terrorism is about so mi5 tell us that muslim terrorism is by far

00:12:55.260 the most prevalent kind of terrorism that they have to constantly foil and they are constantly foiling

00:13:00.620 terror attacks that never come to pass and we'll talk about some of them in a minute and most of

00:13:06.060 these are from people who i'm going to say are not ethnically british as in english scottish welsh or

00:13:12.400 northern irish or irish more broadly um but they are either themselves immigrants or the children of

00:13:19.700 immigrants from non-native ethnic groups and this is just overwhelmingly what mi5 spend their time 0.99

00:13:26.040 doing in fact the henry jackson society tells us that there are 43 000 people on the terror watch list

00:13:32.820 at the moment and 39 000 of them are muslims so that's an interesting statistic that makes you wonder

00:13:41.300 well how bad could it get if there was some kind of reason to provoke these people into action and we

00:13:50.760 saw an example of that with the manchester synagogue attack in october just a month ago where a man called

00:13:58.560 and i'm not making this up jihad al-shami which means holy warrior from syria that's his real name

00:14:06.120 was brought over here as a refugee given indefinitely to remain and decided that because

00:14:12.040 of the israel-palestine conflict what he needed to do is go to a synagogue in manchester and kill some 0.80

00:14:17.260 jews which is what he did and you'll notice that these areas are deeply ethnically segregated as well

00:14:22.980 we'd kind of created a microcosm of the israel-palestine conflict in manchester there was the area in

00:14:29.960 which the synagogue was about 59 jewish and then the area that the man was from was right next door

00:14:35.760 and about 60 muslim something like that and it's it's a question of okay well what happened to the

00:14:43.420 social contract society here what what are we talking about what happened here we said oh well

00:14:48.760 if you all just follow these rules rationally then we can all just live together in peace and harmony

00:14:52.280 and mr jihad al-shami decided that actually he didn't care about the rationality of the liberal

00:14:59.820 materialist order actually he believes in something transcendental he believes in a religion and this

00:15:05.820 religion and the god of the religion gives him moral instructions or imperatives that he has to follow

00:15:11.660 in order to be religiously proper and this is what all jihadi terrorism is about it's not just madness

00:15:20.520 it's not just killing for the sake of killing it is to be in in their interpretation of islam 0.60

00:15:26.520 religiously proper to do the right thing for the religion for the same reason that christians go 1.00

00:15:31.640 to church these jihadis commit these terror attacks and so this is an intrinsic part of what we are

00:15:39.480 dealing with in this community now it's not of course the the majority of the community and thank god

00:15:46.320 but there is always a small percentage of this community that interprets this religion in this way

00:15:53.300 and has decided to prioritize the violent and uh literal or excessive interpretation of the religion

00:16:02.180 over uh over the importance of following the rules set by the liberal order and so you get the

00:16:09.500 manchester synagogue attack and this is a perennial feature of this and this is just this is just the

00:16:16.240 latest jihadi terrorist attack of course we have had loads we've had loads of them going in the

00:16:21.340 manchester arena bombing the 77 attacks the london bridge attacks etc etc etc it goes on and on you

00:16:26.200 can find the wikipedia article with the list of them if you want but there have been plenty and this is

00:16:32.200 just a feature of life now as we said 39 000 of them being tracked by mi5 and i think it's worth

00:16:41.940 pointing out that william the conqueror only brought 10 000 people to conquer england when he conquered the

00:16:46.740 country i mean 39 000 is an army like that's bigger than isis was at its height so just saying that

00:16:54.040 that's a large number of people that mi5 are worried they'll become actual terrorists so and and it's not

00:17:00.840 like we don't keep seeing individuals radicalizing themselves presumably online but who knows god

00:17:06.620 however they're radicalizing and committing atrocities and this is just a normal feature of life

00:17:12.980 because we have introduced it to the country and this has just become what this country is about

00:17:17.960 following the social contract means putting up with occasional islamic jihadi terrorist atrocities

00:17:24.500 that's what it means we have to endure this to make sure that we have the rules-based liberal moral order

00:17:31.840 they that that comes out of the kantian principles of the categorical imperative that any rational person

00:17:38.600 could consent to in the kingdom events i i i didn't agree to this you didn't agree to this but this is

00:17:44.440 what we now have and this isn't just immigrants either right yeah and it's very tempting to say

00:17:51.480 well it's just an immigrant problem isn't it no it's actually not just an immigrant problem for example

00:17:56.220 there was a man called anglo jihadi a recent convert called jordan richardson who was arrested in

00:18:03.460 december last year uh for carrying around a recipe for mustard gas in his rucksack as well as plans

00:18:08.860 to shoot stab and throw grenades at a crowd according to deposition at least crown court he also had

00:18:15.580 linked to isis bomb making video that was used by the manchester arena bomber showing how to prepare

00:18:20.720 high explosives and he had suggested an attack on a shopping center with to another fellow social media

00:18:28.040 user and so he was arrested and while he was arrested he was told he told the prison guards

00:18:34.980 he was a supporter of the islamic state i mean okay that's that's great isn't it now we've got some

00:18:42.980 genuinely homegrown muslim terrorism because of a ginger convert islam but this is a a feature of 1.00

00:18:53.440 having a multicultural society because it's highly unlikely that kid would have ended up converting

00:18:57.920 to islam had there not been a substantive muslim community here and with the zeal of the convert

00:19:04.320 he's decided yeah okay what do i need to do i need to attack the immoral society around me in which i was

00:19:11.180 born and raised because actually the rules set by rationalist materialist liberalism are evil from this

00:19:19.480 perspective and i need to attack the society writ large like an attack on a shopping center or the

00:19:25.860 manchester arena or whatever these are not personal attacks these are not attacks drawn from a personal

00:19:32.260 motive as in that person over there has wronged me and i'm going to do something about it when you have

00:19:38.400 attacks and this is the same for school shootings in america by the way where they are uh not just

00:19:45.100 school shootings just mass attacks on crowded areas where they're randomly shooting into crowds or

00:19:49.940 randomly blowing up crowds or whatever it is these are attacks symbolically on the society itself

00:19:55.560 i have access to your soft underbelly where you feel safe but are actually most vulnerable and i'm going

00:20:02.360 to attack everyone indiscriminately in this area because they are all part of the society that has

00:20:10.140 either wronged me in some way or is in some way morally degenerate and needs to be corrected and the most

00:20:18.260 impactful way i as an individual suicide attacker or terrorist can do that is by just attacking you

00:20:25.300 at random just you don't know who i am i don't know who you are and i'm just going to attack you as 0.84

00:20:30.680 representatives of the society i hate and that's a bit of a problem isn't it if the social contract 0.98

00:20:38.140 society is actually producing people who are prepared on a fairly regular basis to commit terror attacks

00:20:44.160 or commit mass atrocities because the society itself is the problem well you're breeding the problem

00:20:51.800 within your own borders but your own rule set your own british values are the things creating these people

00:20:59.180 because you have assumed that the logic and values of liberal modernity the materialism and the rationalization

00:21:07.480 of all rules is universally acceptable even to those philosophies that disagree with it and it turns

00:21:15.800 up that's just not true and so you get suicide attacks you get terror attacks being committed all the time

00:21:23.040 like this is not just in england obviously this is i'm just using england as example this is happening

00:21:27.580 all over europe the people we the people that have been brought here and allowed to replicate their

00:21:33.800 culture from their home lands actually a sizable proportion of them hate our culture and will take 1.00

00:21:40.620 steps to commit atrocities against us out of this burning hatred of our culture as and and us more

00:21:47.620 specifically and so we have to ask ourselves how long can the social contract society be allowed to

00:21:53.980 produce those people who hate and murder because of what it is in relation to what they are

00:22:02.400 how long can that be permitted how long can it be that the assumption actually no everyone can live

00:22:08.680 under the giant umbrella of the social contract society be permitted while it keeps producing

00:22:14.520 insane murderers and i shouldn't use the word insane because that's not that's the thing they're not

00:22:20.240 insane they're using the particular logic of a transcendent religion that they feel that isn't that they have

00:22:28.480 an interpretation of that sanctions this how long can the social contract society continue to allow a

00:22:38.120 philosophy to propagate a worldview to propagate that sanctions this kind of action against itself

00:22:44.620 and most recently i'm going to assume that the uxbridge stabbing was the product of jihadi terrorism

00:22:51.840 although who knows it might have been the product of mental health or something else it's too early to know

00:22:56.340 yet because the official information hasn't been released but this was the horrific attack in

00:23:03.420 uxbridge in the middle of the day on not only a 14 year old boy who got attacked a landlord who was

00:23:10.760 there was an attempted murder by a chap called safi dawud but the most horrific part was just the murder in

00:23:18.400 broad daylight of wayne broadhurst who was just walking his dog and just completely innocently

00:23:25.020 obviously he was a bin man just local bin man just respected in the area just normal guy living his life

00:23:30.660 living a completely normal life and then some afghan afghan immigrant who was brought in a couple of years ago 1.00

00:23:37.100 given indefinite leave to remain just decided one day no i need to just murder a bunch of people here 0.89

00:23:42.520 i need to just kill them now is it because of islam or is it because he is insane we don't know yet 0.98

00:23:49.420 but it's entirely possible that it could be from islam it's entirely possible that he could have been

00:23:54.920 like yeah no i actually can't stand this insane degenerate culture and i need to go and murder a 0.74

00:23:59.960 few people to teach them a lesson or something like that who knows like like i said we don't know

00:24:04.640 but this is one of the more brutal things that's happened recently and it's because

00:24:10.600 the footage is just horrific absolutely horrific to watch obviously i can't play it because it's

00:24:16.980 literally that bad but it's the most it's genuinely awful because it really brings home that nowhere is

00:24:22.920 safe you can't just go and walk your dog and think that you are just safe to go and walk your dog around

00:24:28.800 the local area no there could be someone that boris's government or i think in fact um it was um

00:24:36.960 robert gemrick when he was uh in the government who snuck 25 000 of these afghans in under the 1.00

00:24:44.360 premise that well they helped us in afghanistan so i mean we've gotta we've gotta have tens of

00:24:48.780 thousands of them and then their families and various other people uh come and live here so

00:24:53.400 they snuck them in under the dead of night during the covid lockdowns and whatnot and it's like

00:24:58.040 okay great so you you just be aware that there are people on the streets now

00:25:04.780 who will do this kind of thing and this is actually not a terribly unusual thing to happen

00:25:12.400 these days is it shocking but not surprising is how i think we might characterize it but anyway like

00:25:18.800 i said we actually don't know what his motivation for doing this was yet i'm sure we'll find out and

00:25:23.500 i'm sure we'll talk about it on the podcast but we could assume that it's either islamic extremism

00:25:28.260 or it's mental health so let's talk about mental health because mental health is one of those kind

00:25:34.100 of get out of jail free cards for the establishment right oh he didn't agree with the logic of liberal

00:25:40.020 materialist individualism and therefore the guy's just mad he's just mad it's like well in some cases

00:25:46.280 no but in other cases yeah sure i agree but actually some people are genuinely just mad and so what do we

00:25:52.320 do about them well we have a system called care in the community in which essentially mad people are

00:25:58.520 just left to roam around in our community and they are given medication on the assumption that they

00:26:05.240 want to take the medication and so they are responsible for their own treatment regime and i mean

00:26:12.180 they have access to like carers and things like that who infrequently you know or regularly check up on

00:26:16.820 them but for a lot for large periods of time they're just on their own and they're just expected to just

00:26:22.960 get on with life as normal as in if he sufficiently takes a sufficient amount of medication he's no

00:26:30.220 longer insane or at least the the extremities of the exigencies of the insanity are kept to a minimum so

00:26:37.040 he can rationally operate in the social contract society it's like okay but it only takes a couple of

00:26:43.000 days of him skipping that for this all to come back and then i mean i'm just saying if he has mental

00:26:48.780 health problems maybe he won't take the medication and this is something we have actually seen but we'll

00:26:56.960 come to the specific examples in a minute because we let's talk about again the notion of the blank

00:27:03.280 slate society the social contract society where everyone is just the same kind of rational animal

00:27:08.080 well there are in fact cases in which this is demonstrably scientifically is not true and it's

00:27:14.620 quite difficult for us to politically talk about because actually it raises some serious questions it

00:27:21.540 turns out that the median distribution of schizophrenia across the world is 4.6 per thousand but as the

00:27:29.980 british journal of general practice have shown us in the study that they have but actually that is not

00:27:35.660 like i said evenly distributed and there are some races that have much higher incidences than others

00:27:42.160 i'm just going to read from the abstract of a study that they've produced because i don't want to be

00:27:47.300 accused of stoking up hatred or anything like that because of course that's not my intention but we have

00:27:52.080 to face the facts honestly we have to actually look at what is really happening to explain a lot of what

00:27:58.740 we're actually seeing and make policy informed by that because we can't just assume that everyone

00:28:06.140 everywhere all the time is just the same as they say the incidence of schizophrenia in the black caribbeans

00:28:13.760 living in the uk is substantially higher than the white british population when first reported these

00:28:20.440 findings were assumed to be a first generation migrant effect or merely the result of methodological

00:28:25.860 artifacts associated with inconsistencies in the diagnosis of schizophrenia in black caribbeans

00:28:32.220 and doubts about population denominators more recently it has become clear that the incidence of

00:28:37.420 schizophrenia based on standardized diagnoses and sophisticated census methods is higher still

00:28:43.020 in second generation black caribbeans the largest study to date has demonstrated a nine-fold

00:28:49.260 higher risk of schizophrenia in uk resident black caribbeans so black caribbeans in the united kingdom

00:28:59.120 have a nine-fold prevalence of schizophrenia in their community this is this is a really concerning

00:29:07.620 thing and they're not sure why it's happening it could be that it is just intrinsic to this community

00:29:15.200 but it's more likely that there i mean there may work obviously there's probably going to be some sort

00:29:20.360 of genetic difference and disposition because of course the different peoples of the earth are

00:29:24.760 genetically different but it's also quite likely to be a product of lifestyle because the black caribbean

00:29:32.260 community smokes a lot of cannabis and at the risk of invoking peter hitchens it seems there might be a

00:29:39.080 connection between cannabis usage and schizophrenia as they tell us evidence is accumulating that cannabis may

00:29:45.140 be a potent trigger for the development of schizophrenia but it's of course not entirely sure case managers

00:29:51.220 surveyed in south london reported that black born british patients with schizophrenia were significantly more

00:29:56.580 likely to be using cannabis than white british patients or black caribbeans or africans when they

00:30:02.940 were born abroad so it may be that the schizophrenics are smoking cannabis which i'm sure isn't helping but might 1.00

00:30:10.160 not be the cause of their schizophrenia or it might be that cannabis users are developing schizophrenia

00:30:14.360 as they say the evidence is accumulating that it might be a trigger although it might be a correlative

00:30:20.540 who knows the point being there is a community in this country that has a much higher incidence of

00:30:27.620 paranoid schizophrenia which often manifests in particularly violent ways and we're not doing

00:30:34.760 anything about this and so this becomes another normal thing a normal aspect of the social contract

00:30:42.440 society that assumes all people are just blank slates and therefore they are completely identical in not

00:30:48.340 just their genetics but in their behaviors their social structures their habits and the the way that

00:30:53.000 these things manifest in their lives and the consequences of this the social contract society can't

00:30:59.900 distinguish between these cultures between these communities and therefore can't do anything to resolve

00:31:05.540 this problem and there are some genuinely awful examples of where this has been the the cause of a terrifying and atrocious

00:31:15.780 mass killing event you'll remember the nottingham stabbings in 2023 where valdo

00:31:22.760 callow kane uh was not on his schizophrenia meds and decided to go on a mass stabbing killed three people 0.99

00:31:32.500 in cold blood it was absolutely atrocious i'll just read from the bbc barney barnaby webber grace

00:31:38.300 o'malley kumar and 65 year old in coats uh were killed by calcone who is psychotic and suffering from

00:31:44.440 paranoid delusions on the 13th of june 2023 the care quality commission on tuesday found a series of

00:31:50.200 errors and omissions and misjudgments by mental health services their review said key risk factors in

00:31:55.400 calcone's case had either been missed or omitted including his refusal to take medicine his persistent

00:32:00.940 symptoms of symptoms of psychosis and a level of violence towards other people without actions

00:32:06.740 that said the issues would continue to pose an inherent risk to public safety because he had

00:32:10.760 been he had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia three years before the killings and it was assumed

00:32:15.580 that he would just want to take his meds well what if he doesn't what if he doesn't want to take his

00:32:20.060 meds well three people died two 19 year olds and a 65 year old just murdered in in broad daylight

00:32:26.080 it's insane insane that we're allowing this to happen like paranoid schizophrenics probably shouldn't

00:32:34.040 just be given medication and then left to roam the country but then you've got axel rudikabana now i

00:32:40.420 don't have an official diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia from him but he had been in trouble repeatedly over

00:32:47.200 and over and over and clearly had some kind of problems and this was something that they had

00:32:52.960 specifically gone out of the way to try and minimize when he had had interactions with the authorities

00:32:58.140 i assume they were trying to be racially sensitive or something but that turned out pretty bloody

00:33:03.280 awfully didn't it they'd diagnosed rudikabana with autism and put together a care report an education

00:33:10.560 health and care plan designed to deal with it and they had spent their time watering it down because

00:33:16.820 i mean i've for god only knows what reasons it looks like sensitivity reasons but the report had

00:33:22.140 originally stated that there were concerns of occasions where axel would say and do things that

00:33:26.420 would have been described as sinister inappropriate and that sentence had been deleted along with the

00:33:32.180 line that said axel can also appear to be cold and calculating another line said that when axel when

00:33:37.860 rudikabana uh had difficulty managing when things go wrong he becomes very angry which was also deleted

00:33:44.000 so bit of a problem the sort of person who might not actually be that worried about the rational

00:33:50.320 rules of the social contract order and might just say you know what i'm just going to go on a mass

00:33:54.620 stabbing spree say at a taylor swift themed dance club class which it seems to be what happened

00:34:01.940 and of course then we learned that rudikabana was obsessed with genocides and had materials about white

00:34:10.100 genocide had said to someone that what this country needs is a white genocide and so we are dealing with

00:34:15.740 not only the looming prospect of serious mental health problems but also a kind of deep ethnic 1.00

00:34:23.240 resentment against the white british population and the fact that his dad had stopped him doing

00:34:29.220 this the week prior but didn't alert any of the authorities didn't do anything else and had

00:34:35.000 essentially allowed his son to continue roaming freely so he could go on his mass stabbing but we've got a

00:34:40.760 real problem here that isn't being addressed and this is something that i think we're still seeing

00:34:47.560 cropping up so for example in the huntingdon train stabbings the suspect is called anthony williams

00:34:54.020 and according to one passenger called dana arnold she told the telegraph that she saw the attacker

00:34:59.520 coming at her with a knife i said please please don't then something changed in his eyes and he said

00:35:05.760 the devil's not going to win

00:35:07.760 i mean i don't know why he's done this the information of this isn't out yet but if i

00:35:16.560 concluded paranoid schizophrenia from this

00:35:19.780 is it a fair assumption

00:35:22.680 and he had already stabbed earlier in the day a 14 year old boy

00:35:28.220 he'd burst into a barbershop elsewhere in the country with this giant knife threatening the people in there

00:35:33.800 somehow he wasn't arrested for these things and then he went on this train

00:35:38.700 the huntingdon train and stabbed 10 people i think one died

00:35:43.240 luckily many of the others didn't but this is just this is just mad right this is

00:35:48.980 indicative of a community that has serious problems

00:35:53.640 that the social contract order is actually not prepared to address

00:35:57.620 not capable of addressing because it can only deal with these things individually

00:36:02.400 when in fact it seems there might be a community problem

00:36:05.160 like for example the other day in swindon or last last month it was in swindon

00:36:08.960 a gang of youths just

00:36:10.760 stomped a kid unconscious 0.98

00:36:13.300 and hospitalized him outside of a school

00:36:15.700 for no reason at all

00:36:17.220 just because they wanted to attack someone

00:36:19.580 and they gleefully filmed it

00:36:21.840 and then sent it to him

00:36:23.620 they sent it to him on snapchat

00:36:26.700 and the police found no crime was committed

00:36:29.980 and it's like right am i am i going to assume that there's no

00:36:33.480 ethnic dimension to this am i going to assume

00:36:37.020 that this isn't also a consequence of

00:36:41.640 maybe mental health problems or something like that

00:36:44.160 or is this just a normal cultural habit for this community

00:36:47.440 either way we really have to be able to address these things

00:36:51.820 and the police have decided no crime was committed

00:36:54.280 and the worst thing that happened to any of these boys

00:36:56.400 is a suspension with one of them being expelled

00:36:58.460 like that that's not acceptable

00:37:00.980 right we have to be able to deal with these things

00:37:04.360 or else the social contract society is once again

00:37:07.340 allowing and creating communities

00:37:09.920 that simply don't abide by its rules

00:37:12.200 and don't care about what it thinks or says or does

00:37:15.620 like if they want to break the rules

00:37:17.480 then they'll just break the rules

00:37:18.540 they aren't actually being rational

00:37:20.800 in the things that they do

00:37:22.440 they're actually fulfilling awful base desires

00:37:25.760 or there is like with the case of anthony williams

00:37:28.880 and axel rudy cabana

00:37:29.860 they appear to be insane

00:37:31.880 and uh sorry and what was his name

00:37:34.660 al um valdo calcone

00:37:38.080 they appear to be genuinely insane

00:37:40.020 incapable of controlling their own actions

00:37:41.720 or just merciless

00:37:43.500 in the case of rudy cabana in particular

00:37:45.660 cold calculating and sinister

00:37:48.020 and angry against white people

00:37:51.220 and wants a white genocide 0.70

00:37:52.860 like it like we we have to be able to deal with these things

00:37:55.420 before they manifest

00:37:56.780 in mass killings

00:37:58.920 or public beatings for no reason

00:38:01.260 gang beatings

00:38:02.800 and various other things

00:38:04.060 like we have to be able to deal with these things

00:38:05.940 and if we can't

00:38:07.560 then the social contract society like said

00:38:10.500 is creating another constituency for itself

00:38:13.560 that doesn't abide by the rules

00:38:15.900 that are supposed to justify

00:38:18.100 creating that constituency in the first place

00:38:20.280 these people

00:38:22.680 are not native to this country

00:38:24.980 and that's an issue that we'll get to in a bit

00:38:27.620 but the last thing i want to say on this as well

00:38:30.440 when we talk about

00:38:32.660 foreign peoples being brought here 1.00

00:38:34.640 and then not actually following the rules based order

00:38:37.740 is that you don't understand just how different

00:38:40.400 a lot of these foreign peoples are

00:38:42.080 right you don't understand that they aren't just the sort of rules following northwestern europeans

00:38:48.660 that we are

00:38:49.720 and in fact their their entire cultures their entire world views are completely different to us

00:38:53.680 so there was a video recently going around about the african view of time

00:38:57.720 in which the future doesn't really exist

00:39:00.400 the present is the immediate moment

00:39:03.480 and then the past is this kind of dream time

00:39:06.820 that just goes on forever and everything just flows into

00:39:10.060 and so this african philosopher explained

00:39:13.840 that africans basically walk backwards through time 1.00

00:39:17.700 and they're always looking at what's happened in the past

00:39:20.040 what's directly in front of them

00:39:21.460 but they're not thinking long term into the future

00:39:24.140 whereas europeans definitely think long term into the future

00:39:27.320 most other peoples think long term into the future

00:39:29.600 and so that's just one of those ways

00:39:31.640 it's like right okay that's an entirely different way of looking at the universe

00:39:34.560 to us and we assume that they'll be like

00:39:37.740 yeah no i agree with the rational rules based order

00:39:39.820 that makes perfect sense to me

00:39:41.100 it's like well does it are we sure about that right

00:39:43.580 but not only that then you have

00:39:45.540 the weird problems that we have imported

00:39:50.300 from these places like obviously

00:39:52.460 child genital mutilation

00:39:55.000 is a feature of the islamic world 1.00

00:39:56.980 that we've brought into this country 0.99

00:39:58.220 and well it's something that happens quite often actually

00:40:01.960 tens of thousands every year

00:40:03.480 and what are we supposed to do about that

00:40:05.640 what's what's the government's response to that

00:40:08.820 because that would be specifically to target

00:40:10.980 a specific kind of community

00:40:12.600 and say you're not allowed to do this

00:40:14.900 but they don't do that

00:40:16.960 because they can only individualize each of each single problem

00:40:21.480 and so okay well we just have to wait for another one to happen

00:40:25.020 another one to happen another one to happen

00:40:26.240 and even if it's consistently through this community

00:40:28.700 they've got to be like well there's nothing we nothing further we can say

00:40:32.400 it's the same problem with the grooming gangs

00:40:34.020 it's like look if you can't talk about it as a community issue

00:40:36.900 then you can't really talk about it accurately

00:40:39.340 but the logic of liberal individualism

00:40:41.740 and the social contract society says no

00:40:43.240 things are only individual

00:40:45.140 and therefore we can only deal with these individual things

00:40:49.320 as and when they pop up

00:40:50.440 but that leaves a residual kind of stain on that community

00:40:54.700 people are aware that the community itself knew

00:40:59.220 that these things are happening

00:41:00.740 or that the community itself knows that child genital mutilation happens

00:41:04.420 that knows that grooming gangs happen 1.00

00:41:07.120 that knows that these things go on

00:41:09.640 and are a kind of permitted part of the community

00:41:12.660 because it's the culture from the old countries

00:41:15.140 and so we just have to accept that

00:41:18.240 the social contract society can do nothing about that

00:41:21.200 it just has to live with them

00:41:22.980 these are just things that when they come up

00:41:26.000 we'll criminalize, we'll punish

00:41:28.060 but they can't be prevented

00:41:29.940 they can't be anticipated

00:41:31.840 they can't be dealt with in advance

00:41:34.380 instead of allowing these things to happen

00:41:37.440 because that would be racist

00:41:39.260 and like I said there are a bunch of very strange practices

00:41:43.260 that are brought over here from the old world 1.00

00:41:45.580 from their old countries 0.98

00:41:46.960 that we have no particular experience of

00:41:50.220 like large amounts of Africans 1.00

00:41:52.600 believe in witchcraft

00:41:55.120 and I mean I just call it witchcraft I suppose 0.84

00:41:58.780 I don't have a better term for it

00:42:00.460 because obviously we don't believe in that kind of stuff

00:42:02.760 and so very few people abuse, mutilate or kill children

00:42:06.760 or other adults

00:42:08.140 based on witchcraft

00:42:10.460 we don't really have much experience of that

00:42:12.560 I mean the last person who really did that

00:42:14.260 was like Matthew Hopkins in the 17th century

00:42:16.200 and he was really doing it for the money

00:42:18.100 not for the true belief in the thing I suspect

00:42:21.120 but this is something that happens a lot

00:42:23.360 and there are loads of studies about African witchcraft

00:42:26.020 that has resulted in various forms of child abuse

00:42:29.560 various forms of mutilation

00:42:30.640 and is a problem that the British state

00:42:33.440 just doesn't know what to do about

00:42:34.980 what are they supposed to do

00:42:37.220 about Africans with beliefs in witchcraft?

00:42:40.240 they genuinely think this

00:42:42.680 they genuinely view the world

00:42:44.320 as being imbued with spirits

00:42:45.880 that can be manipulated by witches 0.78

00:42:47.540 that their enemies

00:42:50.540 people who they dislike

00:42:51.680 or demons or whoever

00:42:54.400 are doing this

00:42:55.980 and therefore they do terrible things

00:42:58.180 to say children or to whoever

00:43:00.880 based on this

00:43:02.140 and it's like okay

00:43:03.100 what's our plan for that?

00:43:06.140 what's the social contract society's plan

00:43:08.220 for witchcraft sacrifices 0.77

00:43:10.440 because that's something that's happened

00:43:12.520 in this country

00:43:13.440 that's something we genuinely have to think about

00:43:16.140 and yet we don't know what we're doing

00:43:17.820 and we can't address it on its own level

00:43:20.340 on a spiritual level

00:43:21.420 because our culture is irredeemably atheist 1.00

00:43:24.060 and materialist

00:43:24.940 and we can't deal with it on a community level

00:43:27.540 because that would be prejudicial

00:43:29.200 and so we're just sat here going

00:43:30.980 well I guess when it comes up

00:43:32.460 we'll just punish the guy who does it

00:43:33.660 it's like yeah okay

00:43:34.220 that's probably not a great comfort for the victims

00:43:37.200 right

00:43:37.800 the victims would probably

00:43:39.420 like to not have been victimized

00:43:42.000 assuming they're still alive afterwards

00:43:44.220 to have the opinion

00:43:47.140 same with the grooming gangs

00:43:48.780 same with the terror attacks

00:43:50.180 like prevention is always better than cure

00:43:53.400 and so the liberal establishment

00:43:55.220 on both the left and the right

00:43:56.520 is left in the unfortunate position

00:43:58.980 of having to conclude that actually

00:44:01.520 this is all fine

00:44:03.160 this is exactly the system

00:44:05.500 working as intended

00:44:06.860 and this is what you can expect

00:44:09.320 going forward into the future

00:44:10.780 more of the same is going to produce more of this

00:44:13.720 and this is going to be completely normal

00:44:16.460 so get used to it

00:44:18.220 both Fraser Nelson and Owen Jones

00:44:20.680 have published pieces saying

00:44:22.000 no crime isn't up in this country

00:44:23.760 crime is actually down across the board

00:44:26.140 everything is getting better

00:44:27.980 material prosperity is apparently increasing

00:44:30.740 even while you look outside of your house

00:44:33.460 and you realize everything is decaying

00:44:35.220 and the streets are filled with strangers

00:44:37.120 and everything is getting far less safe

00:44:40.220 they're convinced that the numbers

00:44:42.740 that they have on their charts

00:44:44.400 represent true reality

00:44:46.460 and your actual experience outside

00:44:48.640 is actually a false reality

00:44:51.360 a false consciousness

00:44:52.540 that you have of the world

00:44:54.240 and so they're convinced that this is all fine

00:44:56.640 and they draw this from the National Crime Survey

00:44:59.280 which is a survey that goes beyond

00:45:02.840 what the police actually record

00:45:04.360 because they're well aware

00:45:05.660 that the police are simply not recording

00:45:07.320 all of the crimes that are happening in this country

00:45:09.100 and the crime survey

00:45:10.800 they tell us

00:45:12.060 excludes crime against commercial or public sector bodies

00:45:14.800 tourists or those living in communal establishments

00:45:16.920 like care homes

00:45:18.020 student halls of residence

00:45:19.320 and prisons

00:45:20.000 the survey does not cover crimes

00:45:21.880 where there is not a specific victim

00:45:23.220 such as drug possession

00:45:24.220 or the crimes against the state

00:45:25.760 the headline crimes include

00:45:28.020 theft, robbery, criminal damage

00:45:29.660 fraud, computer misuse

00:45:30.900 and violence with or without injury

00:45:32.940 details of these crimes are collected

00:45:34.600 through interviewer administers

00:45:35.820 sectors of the survey

00:45:37.240 and the estimates are reported

00:45:38.860 as both incidents

00:45:40.680 the estimated number of crimes

00:45:41.820 and prevalence

00:45:42.380 the estimated proportion of the population

00:45:44.780 that were victims

00:45:45.480 and so what Fraser Nelson and Owen Jones do

00:45:49.680 is compress all of the crimes

00:45:52.360 into a single graph of total crimes

00:45:54.960 committed in the country

00:45:55.780 and say well look

00:45:56.340 this is down

00:45:57.520 and overall

00:45:59.020 that might be true

00:46:00.360 like if you look at the graphs

00:46:03.100 that they'll present

00:46:03.940 are just generally violent crimes

00:46:05.720 you'll notice that they peak

00:46:07.160 in like 2005

00:46:08.080 and then they tail off

00:46:10.220 and say well yeah

00:46:11.220 but that includes

00:46:12.200 for example

00:46:13.420 instances of guys

00:46:14.880 going to the pub

00:46:15.640 getting drunk

00:46:16.320 and having a punch up outside

00:46:17.600 or someone being assaulted

00:46:19.260 wherever

00:46:20.100 just in a fist fight

00:46:21.100 or something like that

00:46:21.860 that's all violent crimes

00:46:23.820 but actually

00:46:24.640 if you become more

00:46:25.300 slightly more granular

00:46:26.080 about this

00:46:26.700 and say pick

00:46:27.280 a certain kind of crime

00:46:28.680 you'll realize

00:46:29.680 that this has actually gone up

00:46:30.540 by orders of magnitude

00:46:32.680 we can take for example

00:46:34.280 crimes with knives

00:46:35.540 or sharp instruments

00:46:36.540 in 2005-2006

00:46:38.920 there were 32,820 offences

00:46:41.660 according to

00:46:42.800 crimeandjustice.org.uk

00:46:44.500 but according to

00:46:46.620 the National Crime Survey

00:46:48.020 last year

00:46:49.200 there were 51,527 offences

00:46:53.260 so that's nearly doubled

00:46:55.760 in the last 20 years

00:46:57.320 knife crime

00:46:58.140 and you can look

00:46:59.000 at the knife murders

00:47:00.380 the deaths

00:47:00.980 by knife crime

00:47:02.280 per year

00:47:03.920 in 2014-2015

00:47:06.260 it lulled

00:47:07.200 at 186

00:47:09.200 which is

00:47:10.220 mercifully fairly low

00:47:12.140 but last year

00:47:13.980 in 2023-2024

00:47:15.660 it was 262

00:47:17.380 so it's not like

00:47:18.660 that's gone down either

00:47:20.320 and okay

00:47:21.540 it's not great

00:47:22.980 that in 2005

00:47:24.380 you had a much higher chance

00:47:25.380 of being beaten up

00:47:26.120 outside the pub

00:47:26.820 or something

00:47:27.520 by some guy

00:47:28.180 who was drunk

00:47:28.680 or whatever it is

00:47:29.440 but I prefer that

00:47:31.540 over getting knifed

00:47:33.640 which is much more likely now

00:47:36.420 than it was

00:47:37.200 back in 2005

00:47:38.400 so just saying

00:47:40.600 the kinds of crimes

00:47:42.320 even just down to

00:47:43.680 violent crimes

00:47:44.440 are not consistent

00:47:46.100 they are not the same

00:47:47.040 they are not

00:47:48.020 in my opinion

00:47:48.720 equal

00:47:49.880 or equivocable

00:47:50.980 it would be better

00:47:52.440 to have more violent crimes

00:47:54.760 but less knife crimes

00:47:56.060 than less violent crimes overall

00:47:59.140 but way more knife crimes

00:48:00.860 and if you look at

00:48:02.060 different kinds of crimes

00:48:02.980 such as

00:48:03.360 I don't know

00:48:03.740 sexual assaults

00:48:04.600 for example

00:48:05.080 they're actually skyrocketing

00:48:07.180 back in 2006

00:48:08.580 sexual assaults

00:48:09.620 were reported to be

00:48:10.600 about 16,000 a year

00:48:12.080 for the entire country

00:48:12.880 which is terrible

00:48:14.020 obviously

00:48:14.640 but now

00:48:15.780 last year

00:48:16.740 there was 40,000

00:48:18.360 instances of rape

00:48:19.640 and sexual assault

00:48:20.440 so Fraser Nelson

00:48:21.980 can say

00:48:22.480 well I don't know

00:48:23.280 what you're talking about

00:48:23.720 violent crime is down overall

00:48:25.040 well maybe

00:48:26.380 but if you're a woman

00:48:27.960 walking around

00:48:28.840 and you're worried

00:48:29.400 about being sexually

00:48:30.300 assaulted or raped

00:48:31.180 you're in a lot more danger

00:48:33.100 if you're a young person

00:48:34.540 who's worrying

00:48:34.980 about being stabbed

00:48:35.960 you're in a lot more danger

00:48:37.520 and this is

00:48:38.740 this is the direct

00:48:39.880 violent attacks

00:48:40.940 against the person

00:48:41.640 as well

00:48:42.040 there are other kinds

00:48:43.280 of crimes

00:48:43.700 that are at record levels

00:48:44.740 the House of Lords

00:48:46.060 held a committee

00:48:46.600 last year

00:48:47.260 that investigated

00:48:48.880 smash and grab robberies

00:48:50.260 so people

00:48:50.720 just youths

00:48:51.640 going into shops

00:48:52.400 and just grabbing stuff

00:48:53.840 and then running out

00:48:54.460 this is an epidemic

00:48:56.540 that is at record levels

00:48:57.820 they helped this committee

00:48:59.120 into tackling shoplifting

00:49:00.440 which heard evidence

00:49:01.900 from police chiefs

00:49:02.640 retailers

00:49:02.980 and industry experts

00:49:03.880 and they found that

00:49:05.300 there were 44,000

00:49:07.200 incidents of shop theft

00:49:09.080 recorded by police

00:49:10.100 in the year

00:49:10.580 up to March 2024

00:49:11.580 the highest since records

00:49:13.560 began 20 years ago

00:49:15.380 so this is as bad

00:49:17.180 as it has ever been

00:49:18.800 and it just contributes

00:49:20.480 to the general sense

00:49:21.580 of degradation

00:49:22.140 and unsafety

00:49:23.500 in the country

00:49:24.640 and of course

00:49:26.760 these crimes

00:49:28.000 are basically not solved

00:49:29.160 in fact most crimes

00:49:30.380 are not solved

00:49:31.280 in this country

00:49:31.920 so not only

00:49:32.720 are in certain categories

00:49:34.620 these crimes

00:49:35.580 higher than they've ever been

00:49:36.840 but the people doing them

00:49:38.940 are also getting away

00:49:39.700 with them

00:49:40.080 and that's not

00:49:41.180 and that's not

00:49:41.740 including the times

00:49:42.520 where the government

00:49:43.820 is just like

00:49:44.220 yeah suspended sentence

00:49:45.280 the judiciary

00:49:46.060 is suspended sentence

00:49:47.100 he doesn't go to jail

00:49:48.120 we're not going to

00:49:48.600 press charges any further

00:49:49.480 when the police

00:49:49.900 don't bother taking action

00:49:51.100 like in the Swindon case

00:49:52.660 with the youth

00:49:53.320 beating up the boy

00:49:54.280 like where they're just like

00:49:55.340 yeah it's just not our problem

00:49:56.340 we're not going to

00:49:56.800 take action into it

00:49:57.720 that's not including

00:49:59.240 all of those times

00:50:00.600 so you can say

00:50:02.800 things are getting better

00:50:04.460 but sorry

00:50:04.980 I don't think they are

00:50:06.520 and we'll look at the numbers

00:50:07.520 in fact of crimes

00:50:08.400 that are just not solved

00:50:09.180 shall we right

00:50:09.700 so according to the government

00:50:10.940 this is their own statistics

00:50:12.460 for sexual offenses

00:50:14.540 it's 4.2% of them

00:50:16.940 that are solved

00:50:17.520 theft offenses

00:50:18.780 were 7.3%

00:50:21.000 one in nine offenses

00:50:22.680 involving a firearm

00:50:23.940 were actually came to a charge

00:50:26.300 and summons outcome

00:50:27.100 and for knife crimes

00:50:28.980 it was about 11.5%

00:50:31.060 for knife enabled robbery offenses

00:50:33.400 9%

00:50:34.380 knife enabled assaults

00:50:36.320 13.2%

00:50:37.980 so basically

00:50:39.540 about 90%

00:50:40.680 and that's

00:50:41.320 that's those crimes

00:50:42.340 where a weapon is involved

00:50:43.520 there are other

00:50:44.440 kinds of those crimes

00:50:45.960 that are about

00:50:46.740 6 or 7%

00:50:47.640 so overall

00:50:49.280 if you average it out

00:50:50.300 about 90%

00:50:51.600 of crime in this country

00:50:53.000 goes unsolved

00:50:54.240 there's no charge

00:50:55.660 or summons

00:50:56.180 nothing happens

00:50:57.540 to the people

00:50:58.520 committing these crimes

00:50:59.580 and that is

00:51:00.960 even assuming

00:51:01.840 these numbers

00:51:02.420 are vaguely accurate

00:51:04.400 which they might not be

00:51:06.020 as the BBC reported

00:51:07.400 in August

00:51:08.240 a report from

00:51:09.380 the Majesty's Inspector

00:51:10.640 of Constabulary

00:51:11.500 Constabulary

00:51:12.560 and Fire and Rescue Services

00:51:14.360 estimated

00:51:15.360 that about 5%

00:51:16.520 of crimes

00:51:17.120 went unrecorded

00:51:18.140 now that's

00:51:19.060 280,000 crimes

00:51:20.820 by their estimate

00:51:21.820 but who knows

00:51:23.180 it could be way more

00:51:24.480 this could be way worse

00:51:26.020 who knows

00:51:27.280 we don't have

00:51:28.300 the numbers

00:51:28.860 but we do know

00:51:29.940 that what is reported

00:51:31.300 is basically

00:51:32.220 going uninvestigated

00:51:33.320 I mean there are

00:51:34.040 areas in London

00:51:34.800 there are somewhere

00:51:35.540 like 16 different

00:51:36.500 boroughs in London

00:51:37.300 where a crime

00:51:38.440 hadn't been solved

00:51:39.780 in the last 3 years

00:51:41.260 the police have just

00:51:42.540 given up on it

00:51:43.300 and when

00:51:44.840 they

00:51:45.540 when something terrible

00:51:47.060 happens

00:51:47.400 when it's on video

00:51:48.400 and you know

00:51:49.320 the people involved

00:51:50.220 like for example

00:51:51.820 in the case

00:51:52.360 of the Swindon boy

00:51:53.060 got beaten up

00:51:53.620 by the gang of youths

00:51:54.680 the police are just like

00:51:55.700 yeah we just decided

00:51:56.420 there's not a criminal act

00:51:57.340 here and we're going

00:51:57.780 to take no further action

00:51:58.660 what do you do

00:51:59.940 how can you say

00:52:01.780 yeah no this is the society

00:52:03.400 as it's meant to be

00:52:04.400 Fraser Nelson

00:52:05.200 and Owen Jones

00:52:06.720 if this is what you think

00:52:09.080 your social

00:52:09.880 the ideal

00:52:11.040 the British values

00:52:12.000 are supposed to be building

00:52:12.980 the social contract society

00:52:14.780 that you have been

00:52:16.080 putting into place

00:52:16.820 and supporting

00:52:17.300 your entire careers

00:52:18.360 well I'm sorry

00:52:19.340 I'm against this

00:52:20.240 I think we should have

00:52:21.740 a much more

00:52:23.500 traditional approach

00:52:25.480 to not only

00:52:26.560 these communities

00:52:27.320 but the crimes

00:52:28.420 that are coming out

00:52:29.020 of them as well

00:52:29.680 and crime in general

00:52:31.040 obviously

00:52:31.760 I think we need

00:52:33.020 a much more draconian

00:52:34.000 approach towards crime

00:52:34.920 I think that we should

00:52:36.060 be sequestering people

00:52:37.180 with mental health conditions

00:52:38.480 such as schizophrenia

00:52:39.700 away from the general public

00:52:41.540 make asylums great again 1.00

00:52:43.400 they don't have to be

00:52:44.560 like Victorian asylums 0.92

00:52:45.920 they could be

00:52:46.620 essentially

00:52:47.080 mandatory daycare centres

00:52:49.360 where these people

00:52:50.200 get to play their

00:52:50.900 playstations all day

00:52:51.860 eat nice food

00:52:53.320 go for walks

00:52:54.340 on nice

00:52:54.760 you know

00:52:55.080 in the green

00:52:55.580 or in the grass

00:52:56.160 whatever

00:52:56.460 and are forced

00:52:57.460 to take their meds

00:52:58.500 I don't think

00:52:59.340 they should just be

00:52:59.980 care in the community

00:53:01.000 allowed to roam around

00:53:02.360 at will

00:53:03.460 and I mean

00:53:04.920 there are so many other

00:53:05.680 so many other points

00:53:06.860 but this all

00:53:09.360 becomes very clear

00:53:11.700 to the British public

00:53:12.520 that actually

00:53:13.680 if these people

00:53:15.260 weren't here

00:53:16.020 we wouldn't be

00:53:17.340 dealing with any

00:53:17.960 of these problems

00:53:18.640 what this has made

00:53:19.960 many people

00:53:21.140 in Britain realize

00:53:22.020 is that the

00:53:23.200 communities of

00:53:24.380 foreign extraction

00:53:25.200 that have been

00:53:25.940 planted in our

00:53:26.980 country

00:53:27.440 have brought with

00:53:28.960 them many problems

00:53:29.720 that the government

00:53:30.960 the state

00:53:31.920 and the governing

00:53:32.700 philosophy of this

00:53:33.740 country

00:53:34.100 is unprepared to deal

00:53:35.500 with

00:53:35.720 they have no answer

00:53:36.760 for any of these

00:53:37.260 problems

00:53:37.580 and in fact

00:53:38.300 the only thing

00:53:39.100 they can say

00:53:39.600 is no

00:53:39.860 you're going to

00:53:40.280 have to expect

00:53:40.760 more of the same

00:53:41.440 you're going to

00:53:42.000 have to take it

00:53:42.480 on the chin

00:53:42.860 you have to

00:53:43.280 tough it out

00:53:43.900 and that's the

00:53:45.080 only answer

00:53:45.700 that they have

00:53:46.400 and so people

00:53:47.500 are like

00:53:47.720 well actually

00:53:48.460 I think there

00:53:49.300 are other answers

00:53:50.120 even if

00:53:51.340 the liberal

00:53:52.280 materialist state

00:53:53.320 won't recognize

00:53:54.460 them

00:53:54.840 there are other

00:53:55.540 solutions to these

00:53:56.320 problems that would

00:53:56.980 act as preventatives

00:53:58.280 so fewer people

00:53:59.660 are raped and murdered

00:54:00.760 and I'm actually

00:54:01.680 in favor of those

00:54:02.500 and this has become

00:54:03.480 a problem

00:54:03.920 for the British

00:54:04.900 liberal class

00:54:06.000 because they're like

00:54:06.860 no no no

00:54:07.260 this is our dream

00:54:08.640 we are currently

00:54:09.620 living the dream

00:54:10.540 we are currently

00:54:11.200 instantiating human

00:54:12.900 rights

00:54:13.580 universally

00:54:14.720 across the country

00:54:15.600 so this is as good

00:54:17.380 as it can possibly

00:54:18.100 get

00:54:18.400 and if you think

00:54:19.120 things are getting

00:54:19.560 worse

00:54:19.820 your own crime

00:54:20.780 is at an all-time

00:54:21.500 low

00:54:21.800 we've never been

00:54:22.740 more prosperous

00:54:23.300 and if you think

00:54:24.640 these people are

00:54:25.520 not just as British

00:54:26.620 as you

00:54:27.540 then you're a bigot

00:54:29.960 and I hate you

00:54:31.660 basically a lot of

00:54:32.720 people are asking

00:54:33.220 themselves

00:54:33.580 why are they lying

00:54:34.700 about the nature

00:54:35.840 of what's happening

00:54:36.520 here

00:54:36.780 why is it that

00:54:37.800 the British

00:54:38.100 political class

00:54:38.840 is committed

00:54:39.900 to a series

00:54:40.600 of carefully

00:54:41.100 constructed lies

00:54:41.980 and outright

00:54:42.700 denials of reality

00:54:43.700 why are they

00:54:45.140 committed to them

00:54:46.240 being just as British

00:54:47.500 as you

00:54:48.040 and this is

00:54:49.420 something that

00:54:49.820 you'll see

00:54:50.300 the commentary

00:54:51.200 come out with

00:54:52.220 all the time

00:54:53.220 every time

00:54:54.200 there is a terrible

00:54:54.880 atrocity

00:54:55.440 they'll dig into it

00:54:57.000 and they'll be like

00:54:57.380 oh look at that

00:54:58.360 he was given

00:54:59.240 indefinite leave

00:54:59.920 to remain

00:55:00.340 or he was a

00:55:01.100 British national

00:55:01.760 he'd been given

00:55:02.360 citizenship

00:55:02.980 or and this is

00:55:04.400 their favorite one

00:55:05.020 he was born here

00:55:06.480 therefore he is

00:55:07.440 just as British

00:55:08.180 as you

00:55:08.680 you might well

00:55:09.800 be able to trace

00:55:10.420 your ancestry

00:55:10.980 back to Cheddar

00:55:11.680 Mann 9,000 years

00:55:12.920 ago

00:55:13.180 who was found

00:55:13.840 in Cheddar Gorge

00:55:14.560 and his descendant

00:55:15.220 was found just

00:55:15.820 around the corner

00:55:16.420 working as a

00:55:17.380 history teacher

00:55:18.020 but this chap

00:55:20.040 you know

00:55:20.560 Jihad al-Shammy 0.84

00:55:21.800 for example

00:55:22.420 well he was given

00:55:23.700 indefinite leave

00:55:24.280 to remain

00:55:24.600 a couple of years

00:55:25.120 ago and the

00:55:25.500 British passport

00:55:25.960 was issued to him

00:55:26.620 therefore he is

00:55:27.660 just as British

00:55:28.440 because the

00:55:29.640 social contract

00:55:30.400 society only

00:55:31.720 recognizes the

00:55:32.900 legal acts

00:55:33.940 of the state

00:55:34.780 as creating

00:55:35.940 the people

00:55:37.060 within the state

00:55:38.060 as being

00:55:38.900 British or 0.68

00:55:40.020 not British 0.99

00:55:40.700 and so if the

00:55:41.640 legal acts of the

00:55:42.320 state by

00:55:43.320 literally executive

00:55:44.460 fiat has issued

00:55:45.500 out passports

00:55:46.600 like they're

00:55:47.080 going out of

00:55:47.560 fashion

00:55:47.920 well then

00:55:48.760 what legal

00:55:49.980 avenue do you

00:55:50.780 have to say

00:55:51.260 these people

00:55:51.680 aren't British 1.00

00:55:52.080 and the answer

00:55:53.260 is you don't

00:55:54.460 if that guy's

00:55:55.320 got a British 0.88

00:55:55.680 passport well

00:55:56.340 then surely

00:55:57.240 he's a British

00:55:57.820 citizen

00:55:58.300 and if he's a

00:55:59.280 British citizen

00:56:00.000 that's all the

00:56:01.340 legalistic framework

00:56:02.360 needs for this

00:56:03.500 particular philosophy

00:56:04.480 to recognize him

00:56:05.780 as one of ours

00:56:06.740 and so Mr.

00:56:07.760 Jihad al-Shammy 0.84

00:56:08.680 or Axel

00:56:09.280 Rudakabana

00:56:09.960 or Anthony

00:56:10.800 Williams from

00:56:11.680 the Huntington

00:56:12.280 train attack

00:56:12.760 these are all

00:56:13.760 just as British

00:56:14.800 as you

00:56:15.320 and you are

00:56:16.440 a racist

00:56:16.940 for trying to

00:56:17.940 observe a

00:56:18.480 distinction

00:56:18.900 you are a racist

00:56:20.120 for saying

00:56:20.620 oh there is a

00:56:21.360 problem with a

00:56:21.920 minority community

00:56:22.860 in this country

00:56:23.540 that has brought

00:56:24.680 in to this

00:56:25.740 country problems

00:56:26.540 that we did not

00:56:27.300 previously have

00:56:28.240 and so they

00:56:29.320 have to lie

00:56:30.340 they have to

00:56:31.460 say these people

00:56:32.760 are just as

00:56:33.500 British as you

00:56:34.160 and they have to

00:56:35.360 then fall back

00:56:36.580 on the idea

00:56:37.100 of integration

00:56:37.880 well he was

00:56:38.940 born here

00:56:39.440 he's a Welsh

00:56:40.140 choir boy

00:56:40.720 he must be

00:56:41.640 British

00:56:41.940 because he

00:56:42.560 was born

00:56:42.940 here

00:56:43.200 even though

00:56:44.320 the question

00:56:45.460 of integration

00:56:46.060 is clearly

00:56:46.680 off the table

00:56:47.800 at this point

00:56:48.500 in many of

00:56:49.980 these communities

00:56:50.480 of course

00:56:50.880 immigration has

00:56:52.000 made it

00:56:52.300 so there are

00:56:52.620 just basically

00:56:53.440 zero British 0.89

00:56:54.220 people around

00:56:54.980 or British

00:56:55.740 people themselves

00:56:56.420 are the

00:56:56.680 overwhelming

00:56:57.080 minority

00:56:57.720 in these

00:56:58.260 communities

00:56:58.740 and therefore

00:56:59.920 how could

00:57:00.420 they integrate

00:57:00.960 into British

00:57:01.780 culture

00:57:02.320 it in fact

00:57:03.480 seems that

00:57:03.980 it's going

00:57:04.300 the other way

00:57:04.920 if the

00:57:05.960 Anglo-jihadi 0.95

00:57:06.920 is any

00:57:07.520 measure of

00:57:08.200 that statement

00:57:09.080 but you have

00:57:10.640 this problem

00:57:11.140 and this

00:57:12.220 is really

00:57:13.740 glaringly

00:57:14.340 demonstrated

00:57:14.880 in Tower

00:57:16.040 Hamlets

00:57:16.440 which is

00:57:16.940 essentially

00:57:17.300 a Bangladeshi

00:57:18.040 colony

00:57:18.400 which is

00:57:19.140 why

00:57:19.420 at the

00:57:20.260 Whitechapel

00:57:20.760 station

00:57:21.140 it's written

00:57:22.180 in English

00:57:22.780 and Bangladeshi

00:57:23.900 because there

00:57:24.600 are so many

00:57:25.540 people from

00:57:26.300 Bangladesh

00:57:26.700 who do not

00:57:27.680 speak English

00:57:28.320 in this

00:57:28.740 community

00:57:29.160 that they

00:57:30.380 need to

00:57:30.960 put up a

00:57:31.440 sign for

00:57:32.200 practical

00:57:32.900 reasons

00:57:33.620 so they

00:57:34.500 can use

00:57:35.100 the underground

00:57:35.760 and Tower

00:57:36.760 Hamlets is a

00:57:37.360 great example

00:57:37.820 of this

00:57:38.100 because there

00:57:39.240 are

00:57:39.480 councillors

00:57:40.400 of

00:57:40.800 Bangladeshi

00:57:41.500 extraction

00:57:42.040 in Tower

00:57:42.760 Hamlets

00:57:43.260 on the

00:57:44.180 council

00:57:44.580 who just

00:57:45.040 advocate for

00:57:45.600 Bangladeshi

00:57:46.200 interest

00:57:46.820 non-stop

00:57:47.440 but then

00:57:48.660 will go

00:57:49.440 back to

00:57:49.920 Bangladesh

00:57:50.340 and campaign

00:57:52.080 for the

00:57:53.320 Bangladeshi

00:57:54.000 National

00:57:54.560 Party

00:57:55.120 there is

00:57:55.960 currently a

00:57:56.720 councillor

00:57:57.340 in Tower

00:57:58.240 Hamlets

00:57:58.720 who is

00:57:59.460 campaigning

00:58:00.080 in Bangladesh

00:58:00.820 for their

00:58:01.760 national

00:58:02.240 party

00:58:02.740 whereas of

00:58:03.900 course in

00:58:04.440 Britain

00:58:04.740 they're

00:58:05.820 councillors

00:58:06.340 for the

00:58:06.580 very progressive

00:58:07.480 Spire

00:58:08.060 Party

00:58:08.500 they're

00:58:09.160 very

00:58:09.400 progressive

00:58:09.820 over here

00:58:10.500 but deeply

00:58:11.340 nationalistic

00:58:12.040 over there

00:58:12.940 and so

00:58:14.020 the question

00:58:14.780 is often

00:58:15.540 raised

00:58:15.880 and we'll

00:58:17.120 take the

00:58:17.420 example of

00:58:17.820 Mike Galsworthy

00:58:18.500 who raised

00:58:19.320 it on

00:58:19.660 Twitter

00:58:19.900 the other

00:58:20.220 day

00:58:20.540 when he

00:58:21.580 responded

00:58:21.920 to Matt

00:58:22.480 Goodwin

00:58:22.820 who's

00:58:23.060 saying

00:58:23.200 well look

00:58:23.420 these

00:58:23.580 people

00:58:23.840 aren't

00:58:24.040 British

00:58:24.320 he

00:58:25.720 replies

00:58:26.120 well

00:58:26.400 please

00:58:26.760 continue

00:58:27.100 Matt

00:58:27.300 what does

00:58:27.860 make

00:58:28.120 someone

00:58:28.340 British

00:58:28.640 if not

00:58:29.640 a piece

00:58:30.160 of paper

00:58:30.600 saying

00:58:30.980 that they

00:58:31.260 are

00:58:31.400 British

00:58:31.820 what an

00:58:34.100 incredible

00:58:34.360 take

00:58:34.760 again the

00:58:35.500 the take

00:58:36.600 the

00:58:37.080 opinion

00:58:37.740 precisely

00:58:38.800 of the

00:58:39.240 rationalistic

00:58:39.820 legalistic

00:58:40.400 social contract

00:58:41.080 society

00:58:41.500 it is a

00:58:42.540 piece of

00:58:42.960 paper that

00:58:43.440 determines

00:58:44.140 that denotes

00:58:45.160 whether you

00:58:45.800 belong here

00:58:46.360 or not

00:58:46.800 and therefore

00:58:47.660 it's done

00:58:48.160 by authority

00:58:48.800 it's done

00:58:49.380 by the

00:58:49.680 government

00:58:49.960 it's done

00:58:50.360 by the

00:58:50.600 legal system

00:58:51.200 and it's

00:58:51.860 done

00:58:52.120 by fiat

00:58:53.120 it is not

00:58:54.200 done by

00:58:54.660 something

00:58:54.960 outside of

00:58:55.700 the control

00:58:56.200 of the

00:58:56.780 establishment

00:58:57.240 it is not

00:58:58.520 that you

00:58:58.820 were born

00:58:59.320 here after

00:58:59.820 a thousand

00:59:00.780 generations

00:59:01.340 of people

00:59:01.840 stretching back

00:59:02.380 to Chederman

00:59:02.760 or anything

00:59:03.180 like that

00:59:03.500 that gives

00:59:04.260 you no

00:59:04.660 greater claim

00:59:05.500 to this

00:59:05.820 country

00:59:06.260 than does

00:59:07.460 jihad al-shami

00:59:08.800 being allowed

00:59:09.420 in by the

00:59:09.960 conservative

00:59:10.300 government

00:59:10.700 being given

00:59:11.420 indefinitely

00:59:11.840 to remain

00:59:12.400 by some

00:59:13.440 person in

00:59:15.220 the home

00:59:15.460 office or

00:59:15.940 whoever did

00:59:16.400 it it

00:59:17.540 doesn't matter

00:59:18.040 what they

00:59:18.420 think or

00:59:19.000 feel it

00:59:19.420 doesn't matter

00:59:19.920 if they're

00:59:20.240 a councillor

00:59:20.800 here and

00:59:21.480 then a

00:59:21.740 bmp party

00:59:22.740 supporter in

00:59:23.680 their own

00:59:23.980 country

00:59:24.300 none of

00:59:24.960 that matters

00:59:25.500 the the

00:59:26.500 rational

00:59:27.320 liberal state

00:59:27.940 cannot draw

00:59:28.600 a distinction

00:59:29.180 between these

00:59:30.140 two people

00:59:30.620 because it

00:59:31.440 can only

00:59:31.900 see them

00:59:32.480 as theoretical

00:59:34.840 individuals

00:59:35.940 on its

00:59:36.840 ledges

00:59:37.360 it doesn't

00:59:38.360 understand what

00:59:38.900 it truly is

00:59:39.780 to be British

00:59:40.420 and so if I

00:59:42.060 say pointed out

00:59:42.800 to Mike

00:59:43.120 say look it's

00:59:43.660 done by lineage

00:59:44.260 Mike it's

00:59:45.320 done by your

00:59:45.780 inheritance from

00:59:46.660 your parents

00:59:47.280 all you can come

00:59:48.560 back with and say

00:59:49.080 well look are you

00:59:50.120 saying that these

00:59:50.760 people aren't

00:59:51.460 actually British

00:59:52.260 the royal family

00:59:53.040 British Jews

00:59:53.780 or Zia Yusuf

00:59:54.560 it's like well I

00:59:55.760 mean Charles is

00:59:56.460 descended from

00:59:57.100 Elizabeth

00:59:57.700 descended from

00:59:59.060 Harold Godwinson

01:00:00.660 and William the

01:00:01.160 Conqueror so I

01:00:01.720 think he's

01:00:01.980 actually got a

01:00:02.400 claim but

01:00:03.340 yes people that

01:00:04.900 you determine as

01:00:06.220 being from

01:00:06.820 elsewhere are

01:00:08.320 actually not

01:00:08.980 native to

01:00:10.020 Britain that's 0.93

01:00:10.800 correct Jews 0.81

01:00:12.480 are from Judea

01:00:13.980 Zia Yusuf is 0.96

01:00:15.280 from Sri

01:00:16.660 Lanka and

01:00:18.180 these people

01:00:19.060 would surely

01:00:19.460 agree with

01:00:20.060 this they

01:00:21.220 would surely

01:00:21.620 say yeah no

01:00:22.200 of course we're

01:00:23.060 originally from

01:00:23.680 Judea we're not 0.98

01:00:24.380 from Britain

01:00:24.800 obviously which

01:00:26.020 is what the

01:00:26.780 claim to the

01:00:27.400 state of Israel

01:00:27.860 is predicated on

01:00:28.840 that this is the

01:00:29.440 native homeland

01:00:30.180 of the Jewish

01:00:31.360 people and

01:00:32.580 Zia Yusuf

01:00:33.120 has obviously

01:00:33.680 has said many

01:00:34.520 a time yeah I'm

01:00:35.220 not English or

01:00:36.920 Scottish or Welsh

01:00:37.980 or Northern Irish

01:00:38.760 but he's still a

01:00:40.140 patriot he still

01:00:41.140 seems to like this

01:00:41.960 country he's still

01:00:43.140 in the right-wing

01:00:44.640 party and the

01:00:45.820 thing is that's

01:00:46.200 fine I mean

01:00:46.620 Sweller Braveman

01:00:47.260 recently came out

01:00:48.200 and said the same

01:00:48.640 thing look I'm

01:00:49.680 not ethnically

01:00:50.420 British but I

01:00:51.980 am I have

01:00:53.060 British nationality

01:00:54.180 legally but there

01:00:55.940 is more to it

01:00:57.000 than that and

01:00:58.380 the British

01:00:59.080 liberal can't

01:01:00.500 accept this but

01:01:01.680 the thing is we

01:01:02.440 hear from them

01:01:02.980 all the time when

01:01:04.360 it's their own

01:01:04.780 minority interests

01:01:05.800 about how they're

01:01:06.400 not British when

01:01:07.660 they want say

01:01:08.200 reparations I

01:01:09.660 mean you remember

01:01:10.120 David Lammy saying

01:01:11.100 that he is

01:01:12.160 Caribbean he 0.60

01:01:13.020 represents the

01:01:13.700 Caribbean community

01:01:14.500 and by God they

01:01:15.700 want their

01:01:16.080 reparations same

01:01:17.440 with Lenny Henry

01:01:18.140 coming out and

01:01:18.920 saying look I

01:01:19.440 want reparations

01:01:20.160 too it's like

01:01:20.580 Lenny I thought

01:01:21.820 you were British

01:01:22.480 like Lenny Henry

01:01:24.400 is an old chap at

01:01:25.500 this point and

01:01:25.940 he's been a comedian

01:01:26.500 for many many

01:01:27.080 years and back

01:01:27.640 in like the

01:01:28.000 70s and 80s

01:01:28.780 and 90s he

01:01:29.940 was a famous

01:01:30.400 comedian in this

01:01:31.080 country and

01:01:31.540 nobody thought of

01:01:32.160 him as being

01:01:32.500 not British but

01:01:33.620 all of a sudden

01:01:34.320 now he's like

01:01:36.900 yeah no I'm

01:01:37.560 I'm Caribbean

01:01:38.760 I'm black

01:01:39.800 Caribbean I

01:01:40.360 want reparations

01:01:41.120 or reparations

01:01:42.080 from who Mr.

01:01:42.960 Lammy Mr.

01:01:43.540 Henry reparations

01:01:44.880 from who from

01:01:45.880 the British are

01:01:47.360 you paying

01:01:47.820 yourselves

01:01:48.320 reparations or

01:01:49.600 is this an

01:01:50.240 admission that you

01:01:50.980 know that you're

01:01:51.740 also not British

01:01:53.280 and if that's

01:01:54.960 the case why

01:01:56.440 can't the state

01:01:57.340 recognize that

01:01:58.260 is David Lammy

01:01:59.380 literally going to

01:02:00.000 be taxed to pay

01:02:01.000 himself reparations

01:02:02.000 because that's

01:02:03.080 what he's asking

01:02:03.740 for that's what

01:02:04.900 would have to be

01:02:05.620 the case under

01:02:06.820 the social contract

01:02:07.600 society that he

01:02:09.280 can't define it

01:02:10.080 any other way

01:02:10.560 and so we see the

01:02:11.720 contradiction being

01:02:12.580 revealed before us

01:02:13.900 we can see that

01:02:15.780 not only do the

01:02:16.540 Bangladeshi

01:02:17.480 nationalists in

01:02:18.340 Tower Hamlets not

01:02:19.120 think of themselves

01:02:19.700 as British I

01:02:20.720 doubt Shami

01:02:21.700 Jihad Al Shami 0.77

01:02:23.560 thinks of

01:02:23.980 themselves as

01:02:24.320 very British

01:02:24.800 but also David

01:02:26.240 Lammy and Lenny

01:02:26.840 Henry also

01:02:27.960 reveal that they

01:02:28.620 don't think of

01:02:29.020 themselves as

01:02:29.460 British either 0.99

01:02:30.060 because they are

01:02:31.460 expecting something

01:02:32.180 from the British

01:02:33.780 and yet those of

01:02:36.380 us who are

01:02:36.700 actually British

01:02:37.320 we've got to

01:02:39.040 pretend we've

01:02:40.640 got to sit there

01:02:41.320 with the lie

01:02:41.980 that the passport

01:02:43.280 makes someone as

01:02:44.320 British as Uri 0.95

01:02:45.280 or the fact that

01:02:46.160 he was born here

01:02:47.060 makes him as

01:02:48.000 British as Uri 0.95

01:02:48.960 or else we're

01:02:49.760 called names

01:02:50.480 it's like but you

01:02:51.580 guys admit

01:02:52.360 you guys admit

01:02:53.820 that you're not

01:02:54.320 British and you 0.92

01:02:56.260 still expect things

01:02:57.200 from us on those

01:02:57.940 terms and yet at

01:02:58.980 the same time if

01:03:00.840 we say well look

01:03:01.620 if all of these

01:03:02.960 non-British people 0.76

01:03:03.600 weren't here then

01:03:05.000 a lot of these

01:03:05.420 problems wouldn't

01:03:05.840 be happening

01:03:06.300 we have to instead

01:03:08.920 go for the

01:03:09.660 doublethink

01:03:10.200 accept the

01:03:11.120 doublethink

01:03:11.640 that actually they're

01:03:12.760 just as British as

01:03:13.500 us and as British

01:03:14.320 as us the whole

01:03:15.020 time there's no

01:03:16.040 distinction because

01:03:16.680 of this piece of

01:03:18.040 paper and these

01:03:19.240 arguments are

01:03:20.320 falling flat

01:03:21.320 these days the

01:03:22.440 British public is

01:03:23.040 well aware that

01:03:24.140 actually there is

01:03:24.860 something going on

01:03:25.760 here that is not

01:03:26.580 to our benefit and

01:03:27.940 we're in fact being

01:03:28.460 taken for a ride

01:03:29.480 these the British

01:03:30.960 values that we are

01:03:32.300 being constantly

01:03:32.900 propagandized with

01:03:33.940 are actually creating

01:03:35.420 more problems than

01:03:36.300 they're solving and

01:03:37.700 so the people who are

01:03:38.560 in defense of these

01:03:39.420 are starting to get

01:03:40.520 their back up about

01:03:41.260 it a good example of

01:03:42.620 this is Lewis Goodall

01:03:43.700 who is of course an 0.51

01:03:44.840 LBC commentator and

01:03:46.320 on the news agents

01:03:47.240 whatever and he is

01:03:48.160 kind of essentially

01:03:48.940 the the mouthpiece

01:03:50.200 of the liberal

01:03:51.140 establishment and he

01:03:53.320 on his LBC show

01:03:54.800 the other day

01:03:55.400 complained about the

01:03:56.720 quote reflexive

01:03:57.840 racism of the

01:03:58.880 British public when

01:04:00.160 a terrible atrocity

01:04:01.180 happens such as

01:04:02.460 an Islamic terror 1.00

01:04:03.200 attack or a

01:04:04.340 schizophrenic man

01:04:05.240 going on a

01:04:05.940 Caribbean man

01:04:06.700 going on a

01:04:07.060 mass stabbing or

01:04:07.660 something like that

01:04:08.280 he complains that

01:04:09.960 there is a

01:04:10.280 reflexive racism in

01:04:11.460 the British public

01:04:12.080 oh which which

01:04:13.860 foreigner did this 1.00

01:04:14.820 is the attitude

01:04:15.680 that people are

01:04:16.420 taking and he

01:04:17.740 finds it disgusting

01:04:18.660 he finds it

01:04:19.400 completely horrible

01:04:20.460 but the problem

01:04:22.700 that he has is

01:04:24.500 that it's very

01:04:24.920 rarely wrong

01:04:25.740 and in it being

01:04:28.400 rarely wrong

01:04:29.260 shows that there

01:04:30.580 has been an

01:04:31.220 increase in danger

01:04:32.460 from the rise of

01:04:34.460 mass immigration

01:04:35.100 from the immigration

01:04:35.760 that has been

01:04:36.180 forced upon us

01:04:37.240 of course a

01:04:37.720 population that

01:04:38.300 never wanted

01:04:38.800 immigration in the

01:04:39.480 first place

01:04:40.020 and so what this

01:04:41.720 means to him

01:04:42.700 the reason he

01:04:43.340 renders this as

01:04:44.000 disgusting and wrong

01:04:44.960 is not because it's

01:04:46.200 incorrect is not

01:04:47.980 because it doesn't

01:04:48.520 represent what's

01:04:49.220 happening it's

01:04:50.900 because it attacks

01:04:51.940 morally the

01:04:53.700 foundations of the

01:04:54.620 social contract

01:04:55.220 society it attacks

01:04:56.740 the assumptions that

01:04:57.840 it has made at the

01:04:59.220 root is that we're

01:05:00.460 just all the same

01:05:01.500 the blank slate is

01:05:03.340 the correct way of

01:05:04.400 approaching human

01:05:05.580 interactions and the

01:05:06.540 human assumptions

01:05:07.100 and so the rational

01:05:08.440 argument for

01:05:09.180 immigration is not 1.00

01:05:11.000 just attacking it on

01:05:11.780 its moral foundations

01:05:12.840 although it is

01:05:13.460 it's attacking it on

01:05:15.180 its own rational

01:05:16.220 foundations if the

01:05:18.100 blank slate is not

01:05:19.040 correct then the

01:05:20.740 social contract

01:05:21.400 society as a

01:05:22.760 rational endeavor is

01:05:24.400 also not correct

01:05:25.280 and so to impose

01:05:27.280 this on the country

01:05:28.140 is actually

01:05:29.940 irrational and

01:05:31.420 against what

01:05:32.120 actually reality is

01:05:34.240 as it is represented

01:05:35.260 in the real world

01:05:36.520 by the actual facts

01:05:37.900 of the cases

01:05:38.560 what this means

01:05:40.140 then is not

01:05:41.120 only have they

01:05:42.060 been irrational

01:05:42.840 not only have

01:05:44.400 they gone against

01:05:45.660 the true beliefs

01:05:46.500 that they genuinely

01:05:47.120 hold that everyone

01:05:48.260 is a rational

01:05:49.160 individual lone agent

01:05:50.480 that just goes around

01:05:51.540 doing rational things

01:05:53.200 all day every day

01:05:54.460 but they're also the

01:05:56.300 ones who are going to

01:05:56.780 be left with the

01:05:57.360 blood on their hands

01:05:58.280 because it was on

01:05:59.940 these irrational

01:06:00.760 assumptions that they

01:06:01.720 dressed up as

01:06:02.380 rational that they

01:06:03.620 brought all of these

01:06:04.280 people in that they

01:06:05.380 failed to address any

01:06:06.300 of the problems and

01:06:07.420 they bore witness to

01:06:09.440 and were basically in

01:06:11.140 defense of the

01:06:14.020 terrible atrocities

01:06:14.860 that are happening

01:06:15.460 because the atrocities

01:06:16.920 are a product of the

01:06:18.140 system and they are

01:06:19.460 the defenders of the

01:06:20.640 system and so no

01:06:22.280 wonder Lewis Goodall

01:06:23.040 is like yeah my god

01:06:23.700 that's it's disgusting

01:06:24.780 that you would admit

01:06:26.300 these things that

01:06:27.220 appear to be true

01:06:28.080 because then I look

01:06:30.400 like I'm culpable

01:06:31.460 because I was in

01:06:32.880 defense of the system

01:06:33.700 that produced them

01:06:34.420 and so you have

01:06:35.720 dinosaurs like Michael

01:06:37.800 Hesseltine the Tory

01:06:39.240 grandee coming out

01:06:41.080 of his retirement

01:06:41.860 I suppose is what

01:06:42.800 you'd call it at the

01:06:44.320 age of 92 and having

01:06:46.160 these lovely write-ups

01:06:47.100 in the Times where

01:06:48.280 they the first half of

01:06:49.620 this article describes

01:06:51.060 how he's just in his

01:06:52.760 gardens and he's

01:06:53.760 tending his trees and

01:06:54.920 his flowers and he's

01:06:56.320 living in this very

01:06:57.900 remote very gated

01:06:59.060 community in a 90 plus

01:07:01.240 percent white English

01:07:02.400 area complaining that

01:07:04.920 the politics of the

01:07:06.620 middle 20th and late

01:07:08.340 20th century no longer

01:07:10.260 obtain in the early

01:07:11.520 21st century back when

01:07:13.560 he was born Britain was

01:07:14.780 about 98 percent white

01:07:16.320 British back when he 1.00

01:07:17.880 was in government it

01:07:18.720 was about 97 percent

01:07:20.020 white British and when

01:07:21.400 he finally left politics

01:07:22.540 was about 95 percent

01:07:23.880 white British and now

01:07:25.860 in England it's about

01:07:27.860 75 percent English but

01:07:29.920 that's according to the

01:07:30.780 2021 census before the

01:07:32.920 Boris wave and even

01:07:35.200 then that wasn't taken

01:07:36.400 into account however

01:07:37.420 many millions of

01:07:38.320 illegals were here 1.00

01:07:38.980 anyway so we actually

01:07:40.660 don't know the

01:07:41.960 percentage of England

01:07:43.020 that is still English

01:07:44.020 hopefully it's about

01:07:45.540 70 percent it could be

01:07:47.800 as low as 65 percent

01:07:48.920 like I said we don't

01:07:50.360 know and he complains

01:07:52.420 that reform are a

01:07:55.020 right-wing party then

01:07:56.180 they're fascists

01:07:57.160 essentially is what he

01:07:58.560 says he says this I

01:08:00.680 want to expose reform

01:08:01.580 for what they actually

01:08:02.220 are he believes that in

01:08:03.800 some ways they are the

01:08:04.580 reincarnation of Oswald

01:08:05.960 Mosley and his fascists

01:08:07.040 in the 30s when it was

01:08:08.340 Jews who were the 0.97

01:08:08.940 target and of Enoch

01:08:09.780 Powell with immigrants 1.00

01:08:11.000 in the 60s Farage is

01:08:12.940 the reincarnation of

01:08:13.880 that human instinct to

01:08:15.080 distrust something

01:08:15.920 different from yourself

01:08:17.000 we've seen it all

01:08:18.640 throughout our history

01:08:19.480 the war of the roses

01:08:20.660 Catholics versus 1.00

01:08:21.580 Protestants we have

01:08:22.780 been there before and I

01:08:23.680 hate it I want to tell

01:08:25.200 the conservative party

01:08:26.140 with all the experience

01:08:26.840 I may have they must

01:08:28.140 never do a deal with

01:08:29.220 Farage

01:08:29.800 the world has

01:08:37.140 changed and he has

01:08:38.940 not updated his

01:08:40.860 understanding of the

01:08:41.640 world to accept it

01:08:43.400 now he's 92 so I'm not

01:08:46.140 surprised he's a bit

01:08:46.800 stuck in his ways I'm

01:08:47.700 not surprised that he

01:08:48.900 thinks the country is as

01:08:50.920 it was back in the

01:08:52.400 1970s and 1980s but that

01:08:54.880 world has moved on that

01:08:56.540 world has gone and

01:08:58.140 unfortunately for him

01:08:59.360 it is not merely about

01:09:01.260 now victimizing innocent

01:09:03.880 minorities who have done

01:09:04.980 nothing wrong actually we

01:09:07.200 can see what's happening

01:09:08.380 with these communities and

01:09:10.420 we can understand why it's

01:09:11.660 happening we have lots of

01:09:13.240 evidence to suggest these

01:09:14.360 are real problems and

01:09:16.060 unfortunately this kind of

01:09:18.140 universalist liberal social

01:09:19.740 contract morality can't deal

01:09:22.620 with the issues so all they

01:09:24.980 can do is promise more of

01:09:26.380 the same all they can do is

01:09:28.120 say well look we can't

01:09:28.960 address any of it or else

01:09:29.840 you'd be a racist you'd be

01:09:31.560 the reincarnation of

01:09:32.800 Oswald Mosley which is

01:09:34.600 just absurd to think that

01:09:36.940 Nigel Farage is the

01:09:38.340 reincarnation of Oswald

01:09:39.100 Mosley and it also is a way

01:09:41.500 of deflecting from admitting

01:09:43.260 that the politics that they

01:09:45.020 agreed with their whole

01:09:46.380 lives and even to this day

01:09:47.680 has created this state of

01:09:49.480 affairs it's a way of trying

01:09:51.180 to avoid taking any of the

01:09:53.280 blame shouldering it having

01:09:54.900 any culpability in the way

01:09:56.140 things are now but you are

01:09:57.860 the people who brought us to

01:09:59.400 this point it's all of you

01:10:01.460 guys the entire political

01:10:03.140 establishment that has brought

01:10:04.700 us to this place and has left

01:10:07.160 you essentially on the outside

01:10:09.220 of your own project because of

01:10:11.200 the manifest problems that you

01:10:12.980 in your arrogance assumed

01:10:14.500 wouldn't pop up because you

01:10:16.680 thought you knew what human

01:10:18.400 nature was you thought you knew

01:10:20.760 that actually people are all

01:10:22.300 rational universal individualistic

01:10:24.400 animals that will all agree on

01:10:26.900 the same set of principles and

01:10:28.460 premises and therefore can live

01:10:30.340 multiculturally side by side with

01:10:32.440 no problems at all and reality

01:10:35.200 has come back and slapped you in

01:10:37.400 the face that's not how it works

01:10:39.660 and actually your precious rules

01:10:41.560 your precious social contract that

01:10:44.520 only lasts as long as the people

01:10:46.760 involved care about it and as soon

01:10:49.740 as they don't terrible things

01:10:52.340 ensue so what can we conclude from

01:10:54.580 all of this well we can conclude i

01:10:56.620 think that the liberal paradigm of

01:10:58.640 the 20th century that was

01:10:59.940 accelerated under tony blair and

01:11:02.220 accelerated even further under

01:11:03.940 boris johnson is coming to an end

01:11:06.660 i think that the excesses of it have

01:11:09.540 been manifested throughout the

01:11:11.660 terrible amounts of crime and

01:11:13.680 terrible amounts of terror attacks and

01:11:15.160 various other mass casualty events

01:11:17.260 that we've had and it can't go on

01:11:20.120 forever what we're looking at is the

01:11:22.440 paradigm of the 20th century finally

01:11:24.820 breaking down in the 21st now that's

01:11:27.300 going to leave a lot of people on the

01:11:30.420 outside and left holding the bag on

01:11:33.540 this being the ones who are

01:11:35.120 responsible for this and they aren't

01:11:37.360 prepared to try and change their

01:11:39.220 positions on anything in order to

01:11:41.320 account for the new reality but things

01:11:43.480 are getting worse they're not getting

01:11:45.120 better things are genuinely part of

01:11:48.180 community problems things are

01:11:50.400 genuinely outside of the control of

01:11:52.560 the state and no and this and i'm i'm

01:11:55.860 adopting a very narrow view of the

01:11:59.160 problems but i think these are the

01:12:00.240 core problems that are the real issue

01:12:02.520 but the the problems are of course way

01:12:04.540 wider than this like i'm not talking

01:12:06.400 about the economy i'm not talking about

01:12:08.020 the amount of taxation the amount of

01:12:09.540 state spending i'm not talking about

01:12:11.020 the the second and third order

01:12:12.260 consequences of mass immigration such as 1.00

01:12:14.280 the difficulty of getting a job the

01:12:16.200 suppression of wages the increasing of

01:12:18.120 the price of housing and renting i'm not

01:12:21.080 talking about the fact that everything

01:12:22.340 is just getting more expensive and that

01:12:24.160 everything everything is just getting

01:12:26.120 outside of people's reaches i'm not

01:12:27.800 talking about any of those things i'm

01:12:29.300 talking about the the questions of the

01:12:31.800 nature and composition of the civic

01:12:33.580 polity itself of the national identity and

01:12:37.260 of the problems that are generated by

01:12:39.360 communities that are just invisible to

01:12:41.940 the liberal establishment like that's

01:12:45.120 i'm i'm only talking about one narrow

01:12:46.740 pillar of the perennial and repeated

01:12:49.160 failures of this liberal order and we are

01:12:52.380 watching it like i said in real time

01:12:54.560 break down in front of us and so what

01:12:58.440 does that mean well that means that the

01:13:00.520 people who decided that we're going to

01:13:01.800 rub diversity in our faces well the boris

01:13:04.380 wave is rub diversity right back in their

01:13:06.800 faces and now it seems that this project

01:13:09.800 is just unsalvageable i don't know how

01:13:12.260 they could from their own principles from

01:13:14.940 their own paradigm from their own

01:13:16.100 philosophy attempt to address any of

01:13:18.200 these problems because a lot of these

01:13:19.900 problems are collective they are communal

01:13:21.940 and they are non-rational they are not

01:13:24.360 problems that can be solved with a

01:13:26.500 further application of laws and you'll

01:13:28.760 notice when everything whenever anything

01:13:30.200 happens that's the first thing you do

01:13:31.780 well i mean we're just going to have to

01:13:33.340 ban knives or we'll have to ban zombie

01:13:35.080 knives we're gonna have to ban this ban 0.88

01:13:36.520 that ban the other as if this is the

01:13:39.660 problem it's oh we had a an insufficient

01:13:43.040 amount of laws which is why we didn't get

01:13:45.820 these kind of things happening back in

01:13:47.300 like the 1990s or 2000s or whatever like

01:13:49.860 it's it's as if the insufficient overbearing

01:13:54.100 nature of the state has not yet created

01:13:56.660 the utopia but again even if we had the

01:14:00.220 digital id and if we had uh train like

01:14:03.640 weapon scanners going into trains like

01:14:06.020 doing planes and things like this even if

01:14:07.960 we turn ourselves into a tyrannical

01:14:09.580 dystopian police state that only works

01:14:12.300 assuming the police are actually going to

01:14:14.920 enforce the laws and we've seen

01:14:18.220 repeatedly that the police only enforce

01:14:21.060 the laws against those who are compliant

01:14:23.440 you will get extra taxes you will get

01:14:27.260 digital id you will get the arrested for

01:14:31.440 things you post online but the people

01:14:34.740 who are not compliant with the state

01:14:37.180 do not consent to be policed by the state

01:14:39.980 well they won't they'll get away with

01:14:42.760 their crimes they will just continue to

01:14:44.640 steal from shops they will continue to

01:14:46.380 engage in violent behaviors they will

01:14:48.100 continue to take on you know like do all

01:14:50.840 sorts of things like 90% of gun crime

01:14:53.200 being unsolved all that sort of stuff

01:14:54.320 they will continue to do these things and

01:14:57.820 you just have to hope that it doesn't

01:14:59.540 happen to you because this is the world

01:15:02.660 getting markedly worse it's degrading in

01:15:04.920 front of us law and order breaking down

01:15:08.080 this is the society in decay and they

01:15:12.360 can't arrest it because it is the very

01:15:15.220 nature of the operating principles that

01:15:17.140 they have brought into play that has

01:15:19.240 created this they can only produce more

01:15:23.440 of the same and so the best they've been

01:15:26.640 able to do up until this point is keep a

01:15:29.140 lid on it to stigmatize you you concerned

01:15:32.500 about grooming gangs oh you're a racist

01:15:34.080 you're an islamophobe concerned about 0.83

01:15:36.040 this you're a homophobe you're this you're 0.92

01:15:37.660 that you're a xenophobe you're whatever

01:15:38.920 they had all sorts of social tools to

01:15:41.540 keep a lid on all of this for many many

01:15:43.700 years but the problems kept increasing

01:15:45.180 and they kept growing they kept getting

01:15:46.340 worse and now it's got to the point

01:15:48.000 where I don't think they can keep a lid on

01:15:49.380 it I don't think any amount of social

01:15:51.140 censure or censorship will actually be

01:15:53.780 able to keep people from properly

01:15:55.600 understanding what the problems are and

01:15:58.480 this is why I think that people

01:16:00.680 overwhelmingly are voting to the right

01:16:02.420 the right are the ones currently in the

01:16:05.800 driver's seat culturally and soon it

01:16:08.900 looks like it'll be Nigel Farage in the

01:16:10.520 driver's seat politically and if he had a

01:16:15.080 vision then he would be able to overthrow

01:16:17.880 and overturn this whole order of course I

01:16:20.040 don't think he's going to do that I

01:16:21.660 think what he's going to try and do is

01:16:22.920 essentially prop up a system that is in

01:16:25.280 decay and I don't think he'll arrest the

01:16:27.660 decay by doing more of the same and so

01:16:30.420 expect tomorrow or the day after the day

01:16:33.600 after that the terrible things you read

01:16:35.620 about in the news they could be you

01:16:47.880 you

01:16:49.940 you

01:16:50.940 you

01:16:52.940 you

01:16:54.940 you

01:16:56.940 you

The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - November 05, 2025

The Age of Liberals Is Over

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript