00:00:54.880uh where you can check out nate and beau talking all the time and um uh we all the time constantly
00:01:02.240about about any nonsense um we're also going to be talking about stelios is going to be discussing
00:01:07.600the louis through manosphere documentary which i have not watched you have obviously have you
00:01:12.480watched it yeah i'm interested to find what your take was on it and i'm going to be talking
00:01:17.080generally more about film the oscars and why films look terrible right now they just look
00:01:22.660rubbish for the most part and why no one can agree why that is one last thing before we start is that
00:01:28.260we do have the live show so make sure to get tickets for that whilst they're still available
00:01:32.800that'll be on the 11th of april if nothing else come because nate has promised to be there and
00:01:38.640we'll be planning on getting as sloshed as possible true story ignore everything that's
00:01:44.520going to be happening on stage and instead watch nate get so drunk that his trousers will fall
00:01:50.100down it'll be hilarious i assume that's what's going to happen at least maybe we'll see uh and
00:01:54.520also there is a live brokonomics after this at three o'clock where dan is going to be talking
00:01:59.540about the iran war and the chain of decisions that has led to it so all very exciting stuff
00:02:05.300with that let's get into the news all right let me just uh
00:02:09.300cheers hamster mate um so british is just a feeling once again we're back we're back at
00:02:20.820this conversation where british is just a feeling uh so a little bit of a self plug here uh i posted
00:02:27.900this on twitter because a bit of a crazy statement from one kelly j keen or posy parker um i'll kind
00:02:35.300of read this out in a minute but we'll just watch this and set the stage i guess is there any parts
00:02:40.860of right-wing politics that you don't agree with yes there is there's this new kind of if you're
00:02:46.580not white and christian you're not british i find that quite objectionable as though any of my kids
00:02:52.540could marry someone who isn't white like my husband's white so my kids are white and all
00:02:57.660our ancestors are white but i can't think for a moment that i would go on when my grandchild's
00:03:03.380mixed race therefore not really british um i just can't get on board the color of that
00:03:08.640and people have talked about it a lot like i'm english i'm ethnically english but i'm nationally
00:03:14.520i'm british national and i think it's a culture it's a frame of mind it's um you know that it's
00:03:23.140it's just the way you behave whether or not you're british and where you're born maybe but i think you
00:03:29.020can i think you can become british it's just an attitude yeah and i hope the audience realized
00:03:34.520that i'm so opposite i just want to pause it there are you picking up on anything maybe some
00:03:39.820parallel arguments that have been used maybe in in what and how she civic nationalism well i'm
00:03:45.860speaking more about how she grows to notoriety any other argument there about you can just feel
00:03:51.300something maybe so i i'm just gonna a certain way i'm gonna preface this by saying that we've had
00:03:56.820Posey on a number of times we consider her a friend of the show and like personally I think
00:04:02.660Posey is great but this is a very very confused statement that she's giving that even outside of
00:04:08.640all of her anti-trans activism and the fact that this is directly contradictory to that she's
00:04:15.560literally just saying using the trans argument for how you can be British as long as you feel
00:04:19.840British which is just not really true similarly the statement in and of itself is just contradictory
00:04:25.980in all manner of wild ways let me just uh do this i'll try occasionally to to be kelly's advocate
00:04:34.060on this just for conversation's sake right so i do agree with harry because there there are
00:04:40.200several contradictions there or lots of stuff that she said that seems to me to be more of
00:04:46.600you know speed of the tongue in that respect because this reminds me of the ethnic and the
00:04:52.680civic nationalism debate yeah i guess so yeah yeah and she mentioned culture and culture isn't
00:04:59.040i mean it does have a scent the aspect of a sentiment inside sometimes but not only that
00:05:04.940it is way of behaving but yeah just throwing just words isn't the most helpful but yeah i'm sure you
00:05:11.140have more to show oh got loads more got loads more so those initial comments well just perfectly
00:05:15.480reasonable but then she's gonna she's gonna make you uh disregard a lot of what you just said well
00:05:20.260i'm i'm also gonna i'm also gonna add a few other things as well here and this is to reflect my own
00:05:26.360mentality and for mixed race people watching the show she's completely true in saying her grandkids
00:05:32.680would be english they would be part they would absolutely you know we have that's just a true
00:05:38.460statement we have calvin on the show and i wish nothing but the best for him but this is in terms
00:05:41.860of decisions that you are that are yet to be made and values and such that you want to pass down
00:05:48.080onto your own children she says that you know all of her ancestors are white british all of
00:05:53.700her husband's ancestors are white british as a as a global section of the population
00:06:00.560white people and in particular as well white british people actually to be fair white british
00:06:04.740people anglos are probably the largest single ethnic group across the entire world of european
00:06:10.960descended people yeah probably followed up by germans in america as well but as a global
00:06:16.700population we are white people the absolute minority that's 17 i think last uh lower than
00:06:22.820that i believe it's lower than 10 yeah there's conflicting yeah this is why they've started
00:06:26.520using phrases like the global majority to men when they refer to non-white people now and the
00:06:32.180question is is it not a shame to break that continuity is it not a shame to essentially
00:06:38.040advocate or excuse or hand wave away the uh the the like destruction of your own ethnic group the
00:06:45.420i'm not going to go as far as to say it's genocidal rhetoric it's ethnocide for sure
00:06:50.560but it's ethno it's ethnocidal just just just just two other things right uh one would you not
00:06:57.880want your descendants to look like you and to be able to recognize those features in yourself
00:07:04.200in them you know one of my great prides and my mrs great pride is when we look upon our daughter
00:07:09.600and we can see our different features and similarly we can see the personality traits
00:07:13.520that she's inherited from both of us it's a great joy to be able to pass that down from generation
00:07:17.760to generation and similarly as well there is the very thorny genetic subject here as well and again
00:07:25.060this is not to insult anybody of mixed ancestry you know nobody chooses who their parents are
00:07:32.000going to be your parents choose to have you um but there is the ed dutton argument as well which is
00:07:38.020if you have a mixed race child genetically speaking you're more closely related to any
00:07:43.860random european person you pass on the street than you are to your own descendant which is a very
00:07:50.480tricky place to find yourself in all right well let's continue because some of the things that
00:07:56.760you guys have said ah chef's kiss a very very intelligent woman so that answer should be taken
00:08:06.040notice of because there's a lot of these fnats beating that you're going home drum if you're
00:08:10.360black brown or yellow and for me i think the whole you can become british culturally and mentally
00:08:16.760because your attitude controls your attitude and i know a lot of foreign people that contribute so
00:08:21.720much they've assimilated they pay their tax they support that you know they they protect my friends
00:08:27.160my family i've worked the door with them they've saved my ass and i guarantee some of these fnats
00:08:32.520not only are they missing teeth you want to you want to respond to shill mitchell no i'm just i'm
00:08:38.660just thinking back to his interview with steve yeah my nigerian mate footlong is my is my guy
00:08:45.700is my mate from was a guy is my guy and mate not british well you just said he's guy on and mate
00:08:52.220yeah so come on i get it gets worse it gets worse they probably never worked a day in their life
00:08:56.420it's like well which one would you rather be in the country the spongy nefnat or the or the or the
00:09:01.880the contributing african yeah that's right shill mitchell just toss your your your your your ethnic
00:09:08.920brothers to one side because maybe they've been displaced in their homeland and uh they're unable
00:09:14.000to get a job because of unfettered legal and illegal immigration and and maybe an african was
00:09:20.420given everything on a plate that's right shill mitchell just toss them all under a bus don't
00:09:24.300worry about it because they're unable to get a job how about everyone up north where you really
00:09:28.020really really struggle because the economic zone is completely falling apart how about that shill
00:09:31.600mitchell how about that what are you going to do what uh an ethnic brit is worth less to you
00:09:36.800than some random african migrant just because they got handed everything on a plate they came
00:09:41.140here they're put up in a hotel really it's absolutely absurd it's so disgusting also
00:09:46.660that's just not statistical reality no it's just like you're you're picking two imaginary people
00:09:53.160and in terms of the statistics if you were to if you were the god hand from black and white or
00:09:58.520something and you had a group of 100 white english people and 100 black african people who got here
00:10:03.440yesterday and you were to like just randomly pick one you're so much more likely to pick an
00:10:09.440economically contributing white english person than black african person in this country that's
00:10:14.680that's just a ridiculous nonsense but in his eyes he would much prefer to to toss the ethnic that
00:10:24.140maybe can't get a job out of the country that's what he's just exposed there it's disgusting
00:10:29.080it's absolutely disgusting gets worse i agree someone said to me the other day oh you're you're
00:10:33.920a traitor you should be defending white people and i'm just like i just can't i just don't see
00:10:39.280it's productive it's ridiculous never trust someone who can um bite into a curly whirly
00:10:44.440and not hit any chocolate what does that even mean it's classist snobbery i i've never heard
00:10:53.620that before what does it mean it's about people that can't get good dental health care oh and i
00:10:58.320wonder why you can't do that uh posy posy i wonder why people can't seemingly access the nhs dental
00:11:04.580service at the moment uh ah yes that would be over subscription yeah do we understand supply
00:11:11.680and demand yes basic supply and demand we understand but the moment it involves random
00:11:16.920foreigners we uh we toss supply and demand equation completely out of the window um so
00:11:22.400there's that so that that's the that's the statement this is what we're talking about today
00:11:26.180what do you reckon guys do you like it i hate it i want to see what you have next because i see this
00:11:32.280smile oh yeah well this is not working is this working mental do the boxes oh it is oh it's
00:11:37.300working my god and and now we start to look into the contradiction like a radio genoa video or
00:11:43.100something yeah well now now we start to look at the contradiction so kelly j kean
00:11:46.500the british caliphate but apparently british is just a feeling it's just a vibe anyone can
00:11:52.580be british kelly what's going on here if the british is simply a feeling and an attitude
00:11:57.060the british caliphate can literally exist as per her logic and let alone getting into the argument
00:12:04.400that the staggering lack of self-awareness and i you know i know i know kelly is a friend of the
00:12:11.480show but how can you be so disconnected from what has created you as a figure combating people that
00:12:22.500claim anyone can become a woman by using the very same arguments you're using to claim anyone can
00:12:27.680be british it's absurd and like that anyone can dismantle your argument now kelly the moment you
00:12:35.640stand up and start doing your activism everyone will just go yeah but you said anyone can be
00:12:39.260british love because it's just a vibe it's just a feeling it's just absolute drivel and nonsense
00:12:44.540it's okay to say that the british are people it's okay to say that if i'm going to try to uh steel
00:12:51.840man uh posy i'm going to try i'm going to try to argue from her perspective because she's not here
00:12:57.640to defend let me do that i'm the villain i'm the villain of the show no no no sometimes you die a
00:13:03.920hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the she did defend herself i had an
00:13:08.120interaction well i was i was just going to say that from kelly's own perspective i would imagine
00:13:13.920that she would argue that the realities of gender and sex are much more distinct than within race
00:13:21.280where there is a definitive cutoff with sex that you don't see as as sharply as you do with genetics
00:13:29.740and race where there are some kind of like wiggle rooms and gray zones in between and she is still
00:13:35.700ultimately arguing on behalf of a cultural british nationalism and a cultural british identity
00:13:41.780and it isn't just throughout christianity for starters so the islamic british caliphate can
00:13:48.020exist as per her own logic she's already thrown out you have to be white and christian or at least
00:13:53.520christian values to be british she's already throwing that out so as per her own logic the
00:13:57.940british caliphate can exist it goes on my son's college has no idea how many undocumented migrants
00:14:03.960attend this or any campus and have taken no extra safeguarding steps but they might feel British
00:14:08.240Kelly they might feel British what's wrong with them oh sorry what was what was Stelios no no I
00:14:14.040just want to say because there are just lots of things being thrown here both by Kelly and I think
00:14:20.320from what he said it's just the the Christian bit I know for instance some people who are pig
00:14:25.420who identify as pagans some of them are also friends on the show yeah I wouldn't say Tom
00:14:31.540rousal isn't english or british neither neither would i okay but that's her position okay is to
00:14:37.300throw out what that was was a thinly veiled attack at restore britain right which doesn't even make
00:14:43.980any sense because that's not what charlie downs said okay right but that's what that was well
00:14:49.120charlie was talking about the christian heritage of england and britain more more generally if
00:14:55.860you're talking about britain more generally we have two thousand years of christian heritage going
00:15:00.880almost 2 000 years going back to roman britain when the brits were um uh were converted under
00:15:06.260the roman empire and then after the fall of the roman empire it only took what 100 200 years
00:15:13.720between the anglo-saxons arriving before they were all converted i mean you have bead writing in the
00:15:18.840early 7th century and he's already writing the ecclesiastical history of the english people that
00:15:25.160being a recognition of the english as a christian people so charlie really was just speaking to a
00:15:29.960historical reality you know i agree i i absolutely agree i i agree that but she doesn't but i also
00:15:36.840agree that yeah you could be pagan and still be british like i accept that she doesn't though
00:15:41.560that's the thing right and so if you're going to throw out any of these kind of uh defining
00:15:47.500factors of what is going to make someone british you can't sit there and now then claim that the
00:15:52.540british caliphate couldn't exist under her own logic right you've got where's your position
00:15:58.140same as this oh there's been a misgender right okay well i mean that's that's that's fine you
00:16:04.780can laugh about misgendering posy but it's all fine and dandy to laugh at people who claim that
00:16:09.920british identity exists yeah one of the things i want to hear from people who are defending
00:16:15.660the the civic line of argumentation is right you are talking about culture as being
00:16:22.780you know a way of life that involves pattern of sentimentality and values but what are these
00:16:29.280values occasionally they say but the question is are these values uh compatible with a kelly fate
00:16:36.180yeah yeah well but to build off of that yeah her position is it's just a feeling it's how you act
00:16:41.660it's like but who are you acting yeah who are you acting like kelly you're acting like a people a
00:16:47.040group of people and who are they kelly the british who are the british even using her own
00:16:52.540statements it completely gets dismantled into pieces well yeah too often when they talk about
00:16:57.460british values what we what we end up discussing are the kind of more post-war liberal values and
00:17:03.660even then liberal i would say is very different in the post-war period to what it was in the pre-war
00:17:09.000and victorian period where i would basically say that like liberal values now are just like
00:17:13.520free market edward bernays wants to sell women cigarettes forever that's that's what i see like
00:17:19.620a complete radical individualism so that you can be a mindless consumer and packaged along with
00:17:26.020that come these british values of tolerance and acceptance and inclusivity which aren't really
00:17:33.020british values i'd say if there is one prevailing british value that's been held for a good few
00:17:38.240centuries by british people it's been a general sense of fairness which is different from
00:17:43.880inclusivity and different from tolerance it's a very we're actually quite different we're quite
00:17:49.420an intolerant people actually that's why we conquered the majority of the world and imposed
00:17:53.560our own position on certain countries oh indians you're welcome the fact that women uh whose
00:17:59.160husbands have died you're welcome you're not burning on a funeral pyre you're welcome the
00:18:03.600british did that the british stopped that that was our intolerance to a barbaric act you're welcome
00:18:09.520indians anyway so it goes further if this thing works uh just another just again just ideological
00:18:16.360sort of hypocrisy from kelly j keen predatory men will shield themselves with whatever ideology or
00:18:21.340job or vocation that provides them with cover that enables their abuse i mean i agree i agree
00:18:27.460um but what about predatory subversives looking to accept being replaced kelly
00:18:31.840anyway we'll continue on um oh the rights of women and children will be erased
00:18:39.420but but i thought anyone could be british posy this is all about islam the foundation of that
00:18:48.280entire religion is paedophilia and i've heard many a conversation on this channel they will justify
00:18:53.600how that's fine and it was a different time and it was a different place and no it wasn't it was a
00:18:59.380right okay well that's just vacuous incoherent nonsense as well kelly unfortunately because
00:19:04.680if they just come here and they feel like they're british according to you
00:19:08.200they're british so again just brilliant love it um oh what's this oh there are some on the right
00:19:15.060who would not consider this man british i just like to slightly for those not watching just
00:19:20.980listening it's an african guy it's a black guy and he calls out british politicians who are anti-trump
00:19:26.940is your statement here kelly that you have to be british to make a coherent argument
00:19:34.320an intelligent argument what is it the thing that's always assumed what what are we doing here
00:19:39.560is that there is some kind of value judgment in stating factually whether somebody is or isn't
00:19:44.720it's again it's a it's a factual statement and what we take issue with is um our own existence
00:19:51.100being denied to us when we're not saying that there's anything inherently wrong with not being
00:19:57.100british we have a preference for our own but i'm in favor of people having pride in themselves and
00:20:03.120pride in their own histories and achievements and it's removing our ability to hold that pride in
00:20:09.020ourselves that we dislike. Stelios isn't British but he is a friend of the British. So I wanted to
00:20:15.640ask you um how exactly do you define British? I'm not trying to be from the British Isles. Okay so
00:20:22.280is it just English being part of the fourth ethnicities? I would put it down to the yeah
00:20:28.100The ancestry, the kind of expansion of British to be a broader civic identity is a holdover from the empire, really, when you became a British subject, if you were under the empire.
00:20:39.420But prior to that, really, British is Scottish, Welsh, English.
00:20:44.680So it's descended from the fourth ethnicities of these isles.
01:27:15.100After talking about Star Wars again, I found myself thinking about the old series with the Yuzavong who come in from outside the galaxy and are a barbarian race that basically worships pain and torment.
01:27:27.520There's even this collaborationist fifth column called the Peace Brigade who are always going that it's our fault the Vong want to kill us and we just have to, you know, give more concessions and then they'll coexist with us.
01:27:38.340this is despite the fact the new republic keeps making ceasefires and you know concessions to
01:27:43.240them anyway and then they're immediately broken because the vong see no reason to honor such
01:27:47.440agreements no parallels in real life that doesn't sound like anything i'd recognize at all i'll read
01:27:54.340through some of the uh rumble rants as well cmc revy says what i've read online is that a lot of
01:28:00.140filmmakers are making their films netflix compatible color and background so that's why
01:28:04.020movies look so similar would not be surprised if that's the truth at all especially given what
01:28:08.300showed at the end with matt damon sigil stone they use orange and teal so much because digital
01:28:12.740cameras wash out all the color orange and teal are as opposite as you can get on the color wheel
01:28:17.060so it makes re-added colors pop that is true they they can wash out color but that's a choice because
01:28:23.960like they also have the ability to capture all the colors yeah they have the choice as we've seen
01:28:27.780with some of the older digital stuff they have the they have the ability to look gorgeous i mean
01:28:31.620david finch's early digital work was fantastic fictagious i've written a horror script called
01:28:37.240cane wood that i would class as original set in the wood just looking for investors to get it
01:28:41.340produced to support indie movies well get in touch with fictages if you're interested in that
01:28:44.960marked ashamed happy saint patrick's day happy saint patrick's day to you too that's a random
01:28:50.560name do you love black girls me lol lamow uh lotus seat is a far more diverse than hollywood
01:28:58.940they have their disabled working in front of the cameras why would you say that about poor nate
01:29:03.660uh and object door a lot of rap drama from the 90s was the former gangbangers picking
01:29:10.760on the former drama kids oh and also imagine being will smith and getting unironically
01:29:16.260mogged by effing twink tupac being married to jada should be a human rights violation let's go
01:29:22.780through a few of the website comments quickly as well do you want to go through some of yours nate
01:29:27.160i'll uh scroll down for you yeah uh what's this michael joe bear was uh contributing african
01:29:33.120what's that lol uh dirty belter says would you guys be interested in inviting miss parker on to
01:29:39.540discuss the growing ethnic debate i think that may be productive and it would be good to illustrate
01:29:43.680the growing rift between center right and right uh brackets logical tribe and physiological tribe
01:29:48.680thought um i'd be interested in having her on to discuss it well same all that i guess i mean i
01:29:55.640think i think it would only be fair to yeah sure to say it's a logical tribe and then the
01:30:00.100physiological tribe well one is just reality and the other is feelings it's not logical
01:30:04.800one's been determined by abstract rationality whereas the other one has been um determined
01:30:10.480more by biological reality yeah yeah i mean yeah sure um i don't i don't disagree uh fuzzy toaster
01:30:17.600says eastern european viking a yeah i could see that uh wandering around a blasted oblast
01:30:24.840a blast with a dozen disheveled raiders on your way to do some pillaging not that i can speak i'm
01:30:30.560so irish peasant i look like horde potatoes and have two dozen children take pride in that my
01:30:37.320legend do you want to read through some yeah john v says good morning lads yeah tate waller and
01:30:42.980fresh and fit are probably the worst of the manosphere and an anomaly in that is pearl
01:30:48.100a woman in the manosphere who claims to care about men but is really just exploiting them
01:30:53.580she's awful yeah she's i will see it's horrendous did you see those clips from her debate with
01:31:00.180anna kasparian where she just like kept no ching out no no i don't watch i don't i don't watch her
01:31:05.380the only thing out and just like not saying anything the only thing from her i've seen is
01:31:10.320when she was um ranting against sarah stock when uh you know she was pulling the trad thing and