00:00:00.000Hello and welcome to the podcast of the Lotus Eaters episode 1381 for Tuesday the 24th of
00:00:07.520March 2026. I'm your host Captain Darling joined today by Josh. Hello. Stelios. Hello. And today
00:00:15.440we're going to be talking to you all about when woke ideas become lethal, when they actually
00:00:21.820start to kill. We're then going to be talking about the fall of the lords and the end of
00:00:26.840hereditary peerage in the House of Lords. And then we're going to end today's podcast by doing
00:00:32.860a touching tribute, we hope, to the great late Chuck Norris. So before we get into the meat of
00:00:39.960the segment, just want to alert you to the announcements, of course. We do have a live
00:00:43.940event coming up in a few weeks, ladies and gentlemen. It's going to be on the 11th of April,
00:00:48.560which is a Saturday, which should hopefully make it far more practical for you. And yeah,
00:00:54.100come down to join us at the local mecca in swindon uh not to be confused with that religious city in
00:01:00.500the middle east and we will have uh we'll have a live lads hour we'll have um a podcast we'll have
00:01:06.640some great discussion it'll be a wonderful chance to meet many of uh the fans of the show of course
00:01:11.260we'll have some drinks together and it should all be really really good fun also i just want to let
00:01:17.380you know that I, Harry and I, when I find it, now have three parts, first three-part Chronicles
00:01:26.300series all about Macbeth, because if you're going to go into anything in detail, Shakespeare's kind
00:01:32.840of a thing that you should focus in on, and Harry and I had a really great conversation about Macbeth,
00:01:37.840about a lot of its wonderful themes and characters, and I'm not normally one to like toot my own
00:01:43.720on but i think this is some of the best work on chronicles so far so if it's of interest to you
00:01:48.720check it out and that's a that's a good thing because chronicles is a wonderful series thank
00:01:54.360you so if you if you are saying that this is one of the best works in chronicles so far you
00:02:00.480definitely have to watch it i don't know i think this one was you know better obviously i haven't
00:02:04.620seen this one it was damn good well i mean if we're gonna have a chronicles we've got uh amadeus
00:02:10.320with josh firm uh whoever that may be that guy yeah uh stelios and i did one on the mandrake
00:02:15.460done many more but you have to say that i was one of the voices who said that in amadeo in the
00:02:22.480thumbnail yes on the thumbnail would need the f marie abraham's oh we were all for it we're all
00:02:27.380for it anyway all right then let's um without further ado should we go to get back here we go
00:02:33.620Okay. So I'm going to be talking about when woke ideas kill. And of course,
00:02:39.340ideas can't kill, it is people. But what can be done is these ideas can permeate institutions
00:02:46.060which facilitate people being able to kill others in ways in which they wouldn't otherwise be able
00:02:52.700to. And this is one of those stories that in all my years of journalism, really sort of shocked me.
00:02:59.440You know, I'm used to reading institutional failures. I'm used to reading about wokeness. But this combination of things was just such a stark realisation to me, just how deep the rot goes into Britain's institutions.
00:03:15.340But it also shows you in great detail how these things can happen in the first place and how many failures went on to allow it to happen.
00:03:24.700um one thing um before i get going is that we do have a live event um in swindon on the 11th of
00:03:32.820april which is a saturday um if you would like to meet us and have some fun it'll be a very jolly
00:03:38.100occasion and um please do come along it'd be nice to meet you all and uh it'll be nice to do
00:03:43.720something a little bit different in person um so get some tickets while they last i think you know
00:03:50.720got to get there they are selling so i wrote an article about this because um i was shocked when
00:03:58.820i was reading what is known as the nottingham inquiry which is an investigation basically
00:04:03.820into institutional wrongdoing dealing with the 13th of june 2023 attacks by valdo callocaine who
00:04:11.140is I believe he's from Guinea-Bissau in West Africa, a Portuguese-speaking country and he
00:04:20.480moved to Portugal and then from Portugal to Britain but when he was young and so it's worth
00:04:27.320mentioning as well another dynamic of migration is that people can move from one country to another
00:04:31.760European country and then on to Britain and so that it might still be the case that you're getting
00:04:36.780dangerous people from dangerous parts of the world from European countries which is something
00:04:41.600to bear in mind when you're talking about immigration as well but I'm going to read the
00:04:48.340actual series of events leading up to the attack because this will genuinely be shocking to most
00:04:55.620people I'm not saying that as like a you know a slop this will shock you as in this is something
00:05:02.360that you should be sending to people and saying look at how bad the situation is this is unbelievable
00:05:08.520so i do excuse me reading my own writing a little bit but um as as you can probably guess i think
00:05:14.520that my write-up is the best um otherwise i wouldn't have done it that way um so i'm going
00:05:22.100to read a lot but please do stop me if you want to interject so callow kane's first notable contact
00:05:27.860with authorities came in May of 2020. He attended A&E believing he was having a heart attack. After
00:05:33.140returning home from hospital he kicked down the door of a neighbour's flat resulting in police
00:05:37.740arresting him for criminal damage. A mental health assessment concluded that he was experiencing
00:05:42.280psychosis and he was released for community monitoring which is interesting because of
00:05:48.180course if he's going for a period of psychosis wouldn't you think that perhaps it'd be good to
00:05:53.360keep an eye on him maybe he's a danger to himself or other people which funnily enough um was what
00:06:00.340happened so mental health professionals were inclined to section him because of the nature
00:06:04.660of the incident in that he violently kicked down a neighbor's door um but ultimately decided against
00:06:10.480it when they considered the research that shows over-representation of young black males in
00:06:15.440detention this is something that came out in the inquiry so because there are lots of young black
00:06:21.100men in mental health detention uh they had to let him go apparently so this is exactly like in um
00:06:29.340the manchester arena bombing where uh there were people who were suspicious of the terrorists
00:06:34.600beforehand but in order to avoid the stereotyping and the the baggage that comes with these sorts
00:06:40.920of things in order to appeal to the progressive values they turned a blind eye and that resulted
00:06:46.120in um yeah all the things that would naturally result from it um it's also you know something
00:06:52.720that happens quite often in the united states where people go through both the criminal justice
00:06:58.400system and the mental health system repeatedly sometimes having like 40 different contacts with
00:07:03.100authorities only to be released and then eventually do a horrific crime um i carry on to say within
00:07:10.84040 minutes of being released he forced entry into another neighbor's flat and the resident was so
00:07:15.620frightened she jumped from a first floor window suffering severe spinal injuries that required
00:07:20.600surgery the woman insisted that had she not done so he could have killed her so you think at this
00:07:26.300point okay the authorities messed up they're not gonna let him go for another time right they let
00:07:31.580him go and within 40 minutes of him being released he did exactly the same thing again so you think
00:07:37.340in a sane society had this mistake happened they would have been like okay we really need to do
00:07:43.120something now uh well nothing was done we will see he was detained under the mental health act
00:07:49.840for the first time bit of foreshadowing and hospitalized for around a month it was documented
00:07:55.520that callocaine's behavior had been an episode of psychosis brought on by stress of coursework
00:08:00.600and an upcoming exam believe me i've been under a lot of stress from both of those things um you
00:08:06.400know including resulted in you like someone having to jump out of a window to escape you it's
00:08:12.840probably, you know, accelerated my graying hair. But other than that, you know, coupled with a
00:08:18.600lack of sleep, again, this isn't something that normally causes you to kick your neighbor's doors
00:08:22.860down. The previous week, however, he would later be diagnosed as a paranoid schizophrenic, which
00:08:27.860makes a little bit more sense. And then fast forwarding a little bit, in July 2020, he was
00:08:33.040admitted to hospital after forcibly entering another neighbor's flat, but was released after
00:08:38.580two weeks for some reason so at this point his neighbors must be absolutely terrified of him
00:08:43.880free neighbors in in the same building that he lives in following his discharge he received
00:08:49.580regular visits to monitor his condition but of course you can't have someone there all of the
00:08:54.580time so it's not in any way a perfect system here then fast forwarding to may of 2021 he turned up
00:09:02.100outside the mi5 headquarters dressed all in black and insisted over the intercom that he be arrested
00:09:07.640and when police arrived he was coherent and compliant was already in the process of leaving
00:09:12.340willingly the police officer had um into who he had interacted with sorry saw nothing unusual and
00:09:17.900described it as a routine stop which uh what is quite a condemnation of the state of policing in
00:09:24.520london i imagine i think that's where the mi half five headquarters is isn't it um that he thought
00:09:29.680that that was normal so when the police arrived he was coherent right okay yeah so he went over
00:09:39.260there basically asked them to arrest so even when the met police are as overstretched as they are
00:09:45.440crime is out of hand even when they literally have criminals turn up on their doorstep asking
00:09:50.360them to take them in and with the least possible resistance they won't even do that apparently not
00:09:55.720At this point, it would be obvious that someone was undergoing a mental health episode of some
00:10:01.280kind, right? That someone should have intervened. And then in August of 2021, it was established
00:10:07.040that he stopped taking his medication and was refusing treatment, claiming the medication could
00:10:11.340slow the mind, which, you know, there's a debate in psychology about this. As a result, he was
00:10:18.060placed on a waiting list for inpatient care. By September of 2021, after refusing medication and
00:10:23.620resisting detention during a mental health assessment the police were called when officers
00:10:28.440arrived he was reportedly calm but as soon as they entered the room he suddenly attacked one
00:10:33.240officer by punching and headbutting him and using handcuffs from the police officer as a weapon
00:10:38.340and police had to use a taser and pepper spray before they're able to detain him
00:10:42.140so at this point i think it's well established that this man is dangerous he's kicked down three
00:10:48.220neighbors doors he turned up to mi5 trying to get arrested he assaulted a police officer
00:10:53.480Sorry, because you've got the dates here.
00:10:55.040When was the first incident that they actually...
00:12:52.300And we also have to remember that many times when crimes are committed, the first excuse
00:12:56.680by the state is this person had mental illness issues.
00:13:03.480And yeah, I mean, in this instance, he obviously did have some sort of mental health issues.
00:13:08.780When he was kicking down one of the doors in his apartment building, he was hearing
00:13:14.580auditory hallucinations that his mother was being sexually assaulted um right and so i think the
00:13:22.200the medical records seem to indicate that this is a case where they were mentally ill but the
00:13:26.880problem of course is why is this west african mentally ill man in our country in the first
00:13:31.920place it would have been much better not to have him here um and three people would be alive had
00:13:37.060he not been so on the 13th of june 2023 he carried out a combined knife and vehicle attack in
00:13:42.780nottingham that left barnaby webber grace o'malley kumar both 19 and ian coates 65 dead whilst also
00:13:49.820attempting to kill three other people and he was sentenced to an indefinite hospital order in
00:13:54.660january of 2024 after admitting manslaughter by diminished responsibility and attempted murder a
00:14:00.260sentence that received significant pushback from the victims families because you you can't really
00:14:05.900carry out a combined knife and vehicle attack without it being premeditated in my opinion
00:14:09.880and it doesn't really matter if someone's mentally ill if anything that makes them more
00:14:14.780dangerous because they're not going to behave in ways that a normal person might well and it also
00:14:21.380obviously shouldn't shine huge investigations over all of the people that you're documenting
00:14:26.820that led to this permissiveness throughout the years yeah and i i wrote a little bit about this
00:14:33.020because um you know i know quite a bit about clinical psychology being you know a psychologist
00:14:38.600although my specialization was behavioral decision making but that doesn't mean i don't
00:14:42.500know how the system works and don't know the literature so i i wrote here there currently
00:14:48.180exists a convenient marriage of perspectives women britain's institutions that result in
00:14:51.900dangerous people being allowed on the streets the first of which is the belief that being
00:14:55.300in the community helps those with mental health conditions this may be true if you have a family
00:14:59.440living with you and caring for you but when living alone with neighbors who are rightfully
00:15:03.180terrified of you it is doubtful that he received any support at all which i feel like is
00:15:08.400near impossible to dispute really because i would be terrified if i lived in the same building as
00:15:13.380him similarly detaining and treating someone with mental health issues is rather expensive and so
00:15:18.060efforts have been made in britain to reduce the number of those detained in mental health
00:15:21.240facilities the consequence of this partnership of perspectives is that severely mentally ill people
00:15:26.060are mixed into the population without sufficient support and they are you know as we can see a
00:15:31.280danger to both people around them and often themselves as well and this is something that
00:15:36.780I think needs to be addressed. I think that we do need to bring back the asylums where people like
00:15:42.760him, paranoid schizophrenics that are dangerous, should be kept and never let out because they're
00:15:48.300not going to get better. And one thing that we need to understand in particular is the nature
00:15:53.060and reality of schizophrenia, because it's not a condition where, you know, there's any impact on
00:16:00.800racism. Racism doesn't change the manifestation of a deeply biologically rooted condition.
00:16:08.320I'm going to skip to the part about that because this is really, really important.
00:16:14.220So, okay. The reality is that rates of psychosis and schizophrenia are much higher for black
00:16:20.300individuals leading to more interactions with mental health services. It's not that the system
00:16:25.220is racist, as these mental health professionals initially posited, that led to his repeated
00:16:32.860release over and over again. Afro-Caribbeans are nine times more likely to be diagnosed with
00:16:38.240schizophrenia than white British people. Black Africans are six times more likely. Even in the
00:16:42.900United States, black Americans are four times more likely to be diagnosed with schizophrenia
00:16:47.620than white people. So the disparity in psychosis and schizophrenia is well known, and most
00:16:54.560clinicians are familiar with this and in fact large-scale studies have found that it's got
00:16:59.220heritability rate of around 79 percent or 80 percent which is very high that you that is very
00:17:06.640likely to be inherited from a parent and oh sorry so is this uh genetic and uh the narrative says
00:17:15.740that no it isn't it's systemic yes nature versus nurture culture yes exactly but the research very
00:17:22.960much says otherwise to this as in it's actually quite well established that schizophrenia is
00:17:27.980largely a genetic phenomenon because as I later say in this article which I suppose I'll see now
00:17:34.420you can look at neuroimaging outputs and diagnose someone with schizophrenia obviously it's not a
00:17:40.880bulletproof method but you could at an above chance rate look at their brain scan and see
00:17:46.120the difference between a normal brain because of the overactivity in certain areas and how their
00:17:51.140brain is working and so it's got a deeply physiological rooted cause and so i don't
00:17:58.220think that this is something that um even if you know he was the victim of racism um would be
00:18:04.480affected by this well and also even if he was the victim of racism basically what we're saying is
00:18:10.640because he was a victim of racism that is somehow equivalent to the distress that he's put other
00:18:18.920people through and the lives that he's taken yeah which obviously you can't
00:18:22.640quantify I'm of the opinion that the main priority of mental health
00:18:28.100clinicians is keeping ordinary people safe you know you shouldn't put ordinary
00:18:32.780people in danger for the well-being of a mentally ill person that's the wrong
00:18:36.980way round and I think that that's something that needs to change in many
00:18:40.860Western institutions that there's this really quite silly idea that oh he's you
00:18:47.360you know, just being in the world is magically going to make them better. But if you don't have
00:18:50.760the support like he did, what's going to happen other than you're going to degenerate and get
00:18:56.000worse? Because there's no one there to support him. And then I go on to say, today, the genetic
00:19:02.300basis of schizophrenia is well established within clinical psychology and psychiatry.
00:19:07.760And I go on to point out the brain, parts of the brain, increased activity in the striatum is
00:19:13.020associated with hallucinations in the hippocampus with memory deficits and the medial frontal and
00:19:18.300parietal areas with an impaired ability to distinguish between thoughts and external
00:19:22.560reality we know these things these are quite well established neurological areas that are
00:19:29.200implicated in schizophrenia and and so that the idea that you know he just needs community support
00:19:34.700well it can't change the structure of his brain and i go on to say that all this is to say that
00:19:40.540condition is deeply rooted in biological causes that are largely genetic. There is little room
00:19:45.780for racism to be a causal factor in the disorder itself unless racism somehow determines which
00:19:50.240genes are expressed in a person's DNA. And anyone working in the field of mental health should
00:19:54.940understand this very clearly. And I argue that it's because they placed ideology over the actual
00:20:00.460real world evidence that this was allowed to happen in the first place. And in a proper
00:20:04.540functioning country um his first interaction where he he showed signs of violence should be okay
00:20:10.440we need to figure out what's specifically wrong with this guy you can't just say oh you know it's
00:20:15.060an episode of psychosis let's let him out no no if someone just randomly kicks down a neighbor's
00:20:20.220door that's a really unusual behavior to have in a normal society and should be taken seriously
00:20:25.780they should be detained and monitored until you can with absolute certainty establish what is
00:20:32.120wrong with them and what their situation is there's no ifs or buts about that really and
00:20:39.040one thing that is quite frustrating as well is I'm not the only person to say this and in fact
00:20:44.840people within the police have said the same thing that I've been saying the former chief constable
00:20:50.300of Nottingham police has admitted that he should have been arrested before he carried out the
00:20:54.520deadly attacks well she's a constable at the time when it was going on when you say I would presume
00:20:59.200so yes um yes nottingham police so yeah i would imagine that that's the case this is all part
00:21:05.920this is all the stuff being dug up by the nottingham inquiry right okay and um it's even
00:21:11.900being talked about um i believe it should be somewhere here um the police are saying that
00:21:16.820yeah i i believe this is um i can't remember sanders i think they were a senior person in the
00:21:23.240police um that it was murder and that his um manslaughter charges were not necessarily just
00:21:31.940because of the premeditated premeditated nature of the crimes and they were saying that at the
00:21:37.980time they were preoccupied with actually dealing with the crime itself um and so there was perhaps
00:21:43.520some some political efforts here to uh give it a mental health diagnosis which we say often are
00:21:50.280Yeah, which is very interesting. And also another thing that I found very interesting as well was this ongoing narrative that's come out of the Nottingham inquiry that the police sped up charges upon him to shut down stories that, you know, the police had acted incompetently, that they've made mistakes, that the mental health services had made mistakes and the like.
00:22:15.340um which you know is quite compelling given how long it takes to charge some people and he was
00:22:21.180charged relatively quickly considering the complexity of the case and so there's so many
00:22:27.180different layers here of errors that it's almost incomprehensible to to know where to start in
00:22:33.360fixing them right and this is one of those things where um it's one thing to say yes
00:22:41.100wokeness allowed this person to come out but once you actually hear exactly how this happened in the
00:22:47.260institutions you realize wow we've got a really long way to go to restore some sort of sensible
00:22:52.440policing and mental health service treatment of these people and yeah it really shocked me i
00:22:59.720couldn't believe it um it's one of those things where you hear it going on more in the united
00:23:05.880States, but less so here. But it seems to be the case that this is happening in just the same way
00:23:12.520in the US as it is here. And so it seems to suggest that there's some sort of ideological
00:23:17.900commonality because no sensible country would operate in this way and endanger their own
00:23:24.020citizens in this way. Believe you are using the right word, it's ideology. And ideology makes
00:23:30.460people completely unrealistic and it often gives them excuses for crimes they hate other people
00:23:37.140when they're committing them and ideologues are very unrealistic and they don't understand
00:23:44.820practical context and what do i mean by this it's a fancy way of saying that they don't understand
00:23:50.620that our choices aren't always choices between absolute good and absolute evil it's a lot
00:23:57.600sometimes it's a mix of good and evil of pros and cons and ideologues hate this and they focus only
00:24:04.160on something they don't like and if they don't like something they instantly brand it as demonic
00:24:12.560and this is one of those issues because there is a very interesting debate when it comes to the
00:24:18.240nature and nurture aspect of discourse i think basically generally speaking it's a mix of both
00:24:26.080for when we are talking about how the sorry just ever so quickly um to sort of reinforce your point
00:24:33.120i did skip over a little bit uh just for the sake of brevity where i pointed out that the
00:24:38.060environmental factors in schizophrenia are living in urban areas cannabis use and parental separation
00:24:43.440which uh seems like a perfect storm for this fella um i don't know whether i'm not going
00:24:49.340for Peter Hitchens here and saying that it was necessarily, but people of his demographic
00:24:54.440are more likely to have these things in their life, you know, live in an urban area, have
00:25:01.620access to drugs and be separate from, say, their fathers. And so these are things that
00:25:07.920basically aggravate pre-existing genetic predispositions, as I think you were saying,
00:30:27.520Well, no, it's just to say that you're absolutely right.
00:30:29.680There was a compromise that was made which allowed for 92 hereditary peers to continue on, which was a deal made with the Tories at the time.
00:30:39.560And obviously one of the reasons for this was that Blair identified that the House of Lords, because of the hereditary peers,
00:30:47.680They were naturally more conservative, not only in party, but in their actual temperament and in their loyalties as well.
00:30:54.520And so naturally, like everything else to do with Blairism, that was simply something that had to be done away with.
00:31:00.580But because it was in the Labour Manifesto as well, it basically means that it's in alignment with the Salisbury Convention, where the House of Lords can't really block it.
00:31:12.100So, you know, the peers can't actually block this from happening.
00:31:15.200They just have to step back and allow the convention to take place.
00:31:19.140But one of the things that I also wanted to talk about with all of this, actually, just to go back to the framing of it here, to talk about service and merit.
00:31:27.940And obviously it's all being coached more in it being a gradual step to having an entirely elected and more democratic second chamber.
00:31:38.120And actually, I just wanted to draw a passage from George Orwell on this, where he says in politics and the English language, the words democracy, socialism, freedom, patriotic, realistic, justice have each of them several different meanings which cannot be reconciled with one another.
00:31:56.080In the case of a word like democracy, not only is there no agreed definition, but the attempt to make one is resisted from all sides.
00:32:05.360It is almost universally felt that when we call a country democratic, we are praising it.
00:32:12.640And I feel like this type of thinking of basically the way that the word democracy or democratic is kind of just used almost in international language at this point as a synonym of good.
00:32:23.520If something is democratic, it is naturally good, it is naturally better than if something is undemocratic or grounded in tradition.
00:32:33.320And this is really important because this is what we actually see, as Apostolic Majesty points out here,
00:32:40.260that was kind of the trajectory from the very end of the Edwardian period when Asquith was prime minister and David Lloyd George was chancellor.
00:32:49.940And when they were trying to put through the people's budget, the Lords decided that they were going to block it because obviously it was counter to their own conservative landed interests and their own economic interests.
00:33:03.940And so because of this, Asquith went forward and basically changed it so that at the time before this, the Lords could actually veto legislation that was put to an end by the Liberals.
00:33:19.940Sorry, just a question. So does this mean that the parliament has become a unicameral body from a bicameral one or not yet?
00:33:30.240I'm sorry, I don't actually know what that...
00:33:32.480It does, yes. So bicameral means that it has two different chambers in the legislature.
00:33:38.660So what Stelius is saying is actually what I was going to say, which is basically it makes the House of Lords redundant
00:33:45.960because it needs to be a distinct chamber from the House of Commons.
00:33:50.580And even though it might still have the name House of Lords,
00:33:54.140if both are elected, both are effectively operating the same way.
00:33:58.080So it's no longer operating in the bicameral way
00:34:02.220in which our Parliament has operated in for hundreds of years.
00:34:08.100And so the expertise that the Lords had in refining legislation,
00:34:15.180which is the main thing that they do in today's Britain, or at least they did, is probably going to be weakened.
00:34:23.240And it just means that you can have a greater tyranny by the Commons, as I see it.
00:34:27.900And there have been many criticisms from the Lords of the Commons and the way our democracy works in the first place,
00:34:33.640which I find interesting, that this seems to align to a greater empowerment of the Commons,
00:34:38.680because you have people like Lord Hallisham many years ago
00:34:41.920saying that our political system is basically an elective dictatorship
00:34:45.940that as long as you get a majority in the Commons
00:35:03.040and in fact I think it's one of the chambers
00:35:04.700that had previously been less polluted by the corrosive nature of party politics.
00:35:12.560It's basically an anti-constitutional move, in a sense.
00:35:16.060Not that it's necessary that it's against the constitution,
00:35:20.840but in the sense that you have less checks on power.
00:35:25.740You framed it wrongly, but that, in my mind, is a bad thing.
00:35:31.680Yeah. And the other thing as well that I would just say with all of this is that I'm not going to defend the House of Lords like it's always been a perfect institution, like it's been beyond corruption.
00:35:43.120I mean, there are so many examples, not only with the way that King George V threatened to stack it with peers if the Conservatives didn't buckle to what the Liberals wanted back in 1911.
00:35:55.580But, you know, going right back to times that we think of now as, you know, with more vitalism, when we were truly an incredible country, I think about the regency crisis with the madness of King George.
00:36:07.740And, you know, William Pitt the Younger was very clear about making sure that the regent couldn't just stack the House of Lords with all of his cronies and his appointees and peers.
00:36:18.100and okay fine so the king and all of these people can't stack the lords with their peers now but
00:36:25.760now all of a sudden just boris johnson can do it though that's fine that's okay starma can as well
00:36:32.140right and key is starma can and all the rest of them but the problem that we run into is the fact
00:36:37.160that uh according to you go polling so you know i'm not expecting them to be the most honest about
00:36:44.600anything. But most Britons would support making the House of Lords fully elected. And I would
00:36:50.400suggest that actually, though, as I just said, I don't trust YouGov, I don't see there anything
00:36:57.320really incongruent with public mood on this, especially when the public, like the Lords,
00:37:03.780like everyone in society, have been inculcated with these more liberal ideals and these feelings
00:37:09.920of democracy being the highest form of good, I can understand why the public have been
00:37:15.900turned in this direction, especially as the Lords continued throughout decades to drift
00:37:21.880more and more into this kind of halfway house where it's not really anything in a true form.
00:37:27.820Democracy without checks and balances or with fewer checks and balances is not particularly
00:37:38.520When they were drafting the US Constitution, where he was thinking that the states individually are too democratic, they do need extra checks and balances.
00:37:47.860I was just going to add that I think it's the complete opposite. I think that the House of Lords should be entirely unelected, because otherwise it's just a repetition of the House of Commons, and therefore it is redundant.
00:37:57.980It'd be better to have it in an ideal society as a chamber where you can have lots of expertise in various fields.
00:38:06.920You have, you know, doctors, industrialists, lawyers, people who can weedle out mistakes and errors and conflicts within legislation and just improve the quality and the intention of it.
00:38:21.560Of course, we run into difficulties in the modern day because we know that this would be abused.
00:38:27.100but at the same time were we to have a restoration of british institutions i think that a movement in
00:38:34.420that that direction would be much better because you want you you don't want people who've just
00:38:40.060been freshly elected into politics shaping legislation necessarily because you want people
00:38:45.400with years and years of experience and you can have the best of both you can have elected
00:38:49.400representatives in the commons representing your interests whilst people with considerable and long
00:38:55.060careers in their respective industries in the House of Lords. And these are good counterweights
00:38:59.460to one another. And that's how the system has worked for hundreds of years. And it's a shame
00:39:05.100to see it end. No, I quite agree with you. I mean, you know, I can only think back to the segment
00:39:10.420that I did last week on abortion, of course, and the House of Lords feature quite heavily in that
00:39:15.280as well. Because even though it went towards the most tragic possible result, the point was that
00:39:22.180that legislation was rushed through the Commons after merely 46 minutes of debate.
00:39:27.220Now, surely something as seismic as that requires much more discussion and, you know, much more
00:39:33.540scrutiny and, frankly, shouldn't have been entertained in the first place, but that's by the
00:39:38.540by. The point is that also as well, it's, as you say, it's good to have, it would be better to have
00:39:45.140an entirely unelected chamber because ultimately once you, and, you know, I mean, your idea of
00:39:51.560experts as well but even if you have it being uh amongst those ranks are the hereditary peers
00:39:58.600those who are you know tied to the land who have literally their families haven't moved from their
00:40:04.760ancestral homes in all of these generations and in the world of globalization and nomadism
00:40:11.140i think that that's actually quite a healthy antidote to it another thing as well of course
00:40:15.800is that if you are a member of parliament it's constantly making false promises it's constantly
00:40:21.160laying out red meat to voters it's constantly having to appeal to these sort this the short
00:40:26.960termism that comes with general elections and democracy and having a more educated body above
00:40:33.780it that doesn't have to take into consideration that it gives it um more chance for long-term
00:40:40.480planning for actual a more farsightedness i would suggest i mean just look at it at the face of it
00:40:46.660it's the House of Lords. It's sort of like a proxy for some of the strongest points of monarchy
00:40:52.720or, say, dictatorship, is that you have a stable group of people involved in the decision-making
00:40:58.840process. And of course, I'm not in favour of, you know, I want people to be able to choose their
00:41:03.600government. That's not what I'm saying. But that is what the Commons is for. And, you know, these
00:41:09.140should be complementary. And that's how it was understood for a long time. And I don't think
00:41:12.620anything has changed it's just that there's a political incentive for the left and the Labour
00:41:18.420Party to remove these people and it has been for you know since 1997 right so not before so now
00:41:24.880what we see just as an example is that one of those set to leave the chamber will be the Duke
00:41:30.900of Norfolk and Earl of Arendelle and he can trace his peerage all the way back to 1138 and that's
00:41:39.300just just gone it's just gone because the Labour Party willed it so and bear in mind as well that
00:41:46.920this is a party that really only won the election because its competitor collapsed after being one
00:41:53.720of the worst. It has no mandate to do these sweeping constitutional changes in sort of
00:41:59.180objective terms. Sure it's got an electoral majority but they should understand that these
00:42:04.640sorts of things, they haven't really been given the permission to do it. You know, being the least
00:42:10.720hated at the time of the election is not an achievement and it's not a mandate to enact all
00:42:15.940of the worst excesses of your manifesto. No, and it certainly doesn't endear you to
00:42:21.440the more progressive vision of what the Lords can be if it's more reliant on appointees from
00:42:29.500former prime ministers. And, you know, as Boris Johnson did when he was on his way out of office
00:42:34.480and he appointed Charlotte Owen, 30-year-old former advisor,
00:42:39.040joined the House's Lords as the youngest peer.
00:42:41.520According to a LinkedIn profile, Baroness Owen started a career as an intern
00:42:46.040in then-Chancellor George Osborne's constituency office,
00:42:50.440and then she went on to intern for Johnson
00:42:52.480and as a parliamentary assistant for Alok Sharma and Sir Jake Berry
00:42:57.760before joining Number 10 as a special advisor.
00:43:00.000So she spent, look, I'm not judging her as a person,
00:43:03.380But there is nothing remarkable about her. There is nothing extraordinary beyond where she's come from.
00:43:11.980In fact, she's served politicians who have only made England a worse place for them being here.
00:43:20.820So their judgment on who to appoint to this chamber is really not worth anything whatsoever.
00:43:27.500Also, the fact that when Keir Starmer's come in, sorry, we have Carmen Smith, a 28-year-old
00:43:35.260Plaid Cymru activist, sorry, so not Keir Starmer, appointed by Plaid Cymru to become
00:43:56.180She says, Baroness Smith defends the process by which she was nominated, arguing it helps to improve the representation of women in the chamber at 70% male.
00:44:06.840And it points out as well that Plaid Cymru is one of only two parties, along with the Greens, who can elect their nominees for the Lord.
00:44:15.620So again, just fine, this is what they're taking away, but are they replacing it with anything that actually seems to be an improvement?
00:44:23.420It's worth pointing out as well that all the hereditary peers that have been removed were men.
00:54:54.480And he also says, the entire point of getting rid of the hereditary peers was so that meritocracy could flourish and corruption is flushed out.
00:55:04.500the exact opposite happened and the entirety entirely predictable outcome yeah absolutely
00:55:10.960um i mean it's not going to get rid of corruption if all the appointees are appointed by the corrupt
00:55:16.660is it so cheer us up stelios yeah stelios right so i'm gonna cheer you up by talking to you about
00:55:23.780the 11th of april there's a low to see to the live event um i feel better already yeah yeah
01:01:25.120But when they met, at some point she wrote a letter to him, they met, and he told her that we don't even have to do a genetic test, you're my daughter.
01:18:14.980to publish The Truth About Chuck Norris,
01:18:17.400a book that became a New York Times bestseller
01:18:20.540Despite initial legal challenges from Chuck Norris's team regarding monetization, a settlement eventually was reached and there were subsequent additions being labeled as unauthorized parody.
01:26:56.900Yeah, I've only ever written to an MP once before, I think, in my entire life.
01:27:01.280And that was back during the lockdowns when they were trying to basically have, you know, a two-tier system for those who'd had the jab and hadn't had the jab.