The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - November 19, 2026


The State of the Online Right | Interview with Marcus Furius

Breakfast With Beau | Wednesday 18th November 2026 Breakfast With Beau | Friday 20th November 2026

Episode Stats


Length

53 minutes

Words per minute

185.81

Word count

9,898

Sentence count

440

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

18

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Folks, I have the pleasure of being joined by Marcus Furious-Pertinax, a friend of mine from
00:00:04 the online right. And we were going to have a discussion about, well, the state of the online
00:00:09 right. This is pretty niche. So, you know, if you're not an online right winger, probably not
00:00:16 for you. But it's interesting to see how the community has changed over the years. Because
00:00:22 if you go back only probably about a year ago, the online right had a lot of wind in its sails,
00:00:27 It was making a lot of good points and providing incisive critiques.
00:00:32 And this drew a lot of people in.
00:00:35 And when you have a mass movement, if anything, well, it becomes, shall we say, lowest common denominator.
00:00:42 And this has caused a fracture in your mind, right?
00:00:46 Because I think there's a section of those people who are attracted to it,
00:00:53 possibly because they felt it was something niche
00:00:58 and it's kind of a scene.
00:01:02 And now they don't like the tenor of the scene
00:01:04 because it became a lot more popular than it was
00:01:07 when they began entering into it.
00:01:10 And so they have withdrawn completely.
00:01:14 And the message that I think we get is,
00:01:16 I'm not like the other Ritoids, which, okay, that's very good. 1.00
00:01:21 And so I thought we'd talk about the nature of it
00:01:24 and how things are going generally for the right.
00:01:27 Because, I mean, from my perspective, I think the right's doing quite well.
00:01:31 It's a bit fractured at the moment, thanks to Nigel Farage.
00:01:33 But overall, I think the arguments we're making have a lot of purchase.
00:01:39 And I can see the pieces moving on the board.
00:01:43 So it seems that eventually we'll come to some kind of settlement that will be useful.
00:01:49 I'm inclined to agree.
00:01:51 There's a few things at play here.
00:01:53 I hate to do the Putin-Tucker Carlson, oh, well, way back in Kiev
00:01:57 in sort of the 8th century thing.
00:01:58 If we actually look at sort of the online right sort of, quote,
00:02:02 unquote, as we understand it, and you've got to think you've been
00:02:06 in the trenches a long time.
00:02:08 You know, I'm comparatively something of a relative newcomer
00:02:10 and, you know, started with history streams and sort of here we are.
00:02:13 um but sort of the genesis of a lot of this um in the way that we understand it
00:02:21 you know really comes from because we were just having a bit of a chat before you know the cameras
00:02:25 went live is you know 2016 and you know what was the what was the effectiveness of you know the
00:02:32 online right then and sort of how is it sort of you know how's it morphed and metamorphosized over
00:02:39 that time. And, you know, you're sort of saying, you mentioned it having winds in a
00:02:45 sail. And I think on one hand, there's been a few key moments in recent history, which
00:02:50 has probably given us this sort of, well, age as general impetus, but also some righteous
00:02:58 indignation. And I think the aftermath, for instance, of, you know, let's just say 2020
00:03:02 and the events of, which include, you know, what happened in the States and what happened
00:03:06 with that little sniffle that went around and other stuff.
00:03:10 And more recently, you've got to think,
00:03:12 we've only just sort of come out of that first anniversary
00:03:13 of the tragedy of what happened with Charlie in America,
00:03:16 Charlie Kirk.
00:03:18 A lot of us have felt a sense of righteous indignation
00:03:22 about the fact that in some ways, yes,
00:03:26 we have a general inertia in our direction,
00:03:28 but also we have suffered setbacks that we haven't deserved
00:03:34 or haven't merited necessarily,
00:03:35 but yet we have suffered them you know regardless and the other thing is um that i wanted to sort
00:03:40 of make mention was and sadly this isn't like the relative immediate aftermath of you know
00:03:46 the events in spain with ceuta um with the burning of the building in limonias and and let's face
00:03:53 it's not the first one a lot of these i mean how many churches get burnt every year in europe we
00:03:57 know what that what that whole thing is and each and sort of each year or each month and each year
00:04:02 year that passes by. It's almost as if the kind of things we have been trying to save over a decade
00:04:08 just become more true. And it's almost as if it's, you know, the ringing in the ears is so loud now
00:04:14 that it's irrefutable. And I think in that sense, we have a lot in our, in our favour. And not that
00:04:20 we want bad things to happen. We clearly don't, but it just, those kinds of things make what is
00:04:27 happening and what is, you know, the world around us becomes, you know, undeniable to those who
00:04:34 might be naysayers or to those who might not believe the gravity of the situation. I think
00:04:38 that's in our favour, certainly. Yeah, and so I think it's unsurprising that if the, should we
00:04:45 say, the intellectual cadre of the right ends up establishing a kind of right-wing framework in
00:04:51 which we can find the moral justification to finally take our own side, it's not surprising
00:04:57 then that you get this kind of nucleus that begins to build and project the message outwards
00:05:04 and then draws in a lot of people who otherwise felt quite homeless, right?
00:05:09 And yes, when you have something that starts turning into a mass movement, in many respects
00:05:16 it becomes a bit plebeian.
00:05:18 That's to be expected.
00:05:20 and i don't know why this is such a surprise to um i suppose what we just call the sort of online
00:05:30 elite theorists um the the plan should always have included understanding that a large number
00:05:38 of people who are not intellectuals would end up supporting your movement right and if your plan
00:05:43 didn't include that then i don't think you're properly looking at the situation and the nature
00:05:50 that we're in. I mean, Rory's been arguing the case on this on Twitter with a bunch of
00:05:57 these types, pointing out, well, this is all a bit of an affectation, right? Oh, I reject
00:06:05 democracy. It's like, okay, well, then don't pay your taxes. You know, go and live in the
00:06:10 woods. You know, literally, if you're rejecting liberal democracy, then you are actually only
00:06:14 rejecting really the voluntary participatory aspect of it. You're not rejecting the parts
00:06:24 that you are obliged to engage in. And so the actual decision making, even if it isn't
00:06:33 a fundamental restructuring of the state and everyone in the positions behind the scenes,
00:06:41 ultimately the power of decision is still in our hands right and at the end of the day unless
00:06:48 you're going to start the welsh taliban this is your only option right so a complete retreat from
00:06:53 the field seems like a terrible idea to me um i'm for example rupert lowe and restore britain
00:07:01 this is the first actual representation that we have had as the online right rupert lowe doesn't
00:07:07 punch right he's never expelled anyone because they've said oh that person's a racist he didn't
00:07:11 go after steve laws right um the we've never had parliamentary representation representation for
00:07:18 and you can feel the pressure on the right because of it nigel farage yes they came out and said yeah
00:07:25 well i would never kick someone out for liking a tommy robinson tweet uh yes you did lots of times
00:07:31 that's how howard cox ended up in restore britain because you kicked him out for liking tommy
00:07:36 robinson yeah and this is so anyway the point being the the general shift to the actual right
00:07:42 on from the center right wouldn't be possible if we didn't have representation if we didn't
00:07:47 have popular support i mean we've been hitting double digits in some polls and some elections
00:07:53 recently so it's like okay this this has clearly got some in regards to restore in regards to
00:07:57 restore in actual elections like you know 10 11 and it's like okay there is clearly an energy
00:08:03 and power here. And there is clearly an upward momentum. So yes, you kind of have to accept
00:08:10 the mass nature of any movement. But retreating from all of this is just to say, well, actually,
00:08:19 I kind of got cold feet. And I don't really, I'm not really that bothered if we do win.
00:08:24 And so I find all of this critique of democracy to just be a kind of rationalization as to why
00:08:30 engagement oh it can't it can never possibly work so well people were saying the same things to
00:08:35 lenin before he overthrew the provisional government and look what happened so i i don't
00:08:43 i don't believe this doomerism well it's one of those things of i think and obviously speaking
00:08:50 personally um well and also just as an aside to like you know for those of for those of our
00:08:54 friends who aren't say in australia or or britain who don't have a representative democracy i mean
00:08:58 for Restore being a party that's barely six months old
00:09:00 or between six months and a year old.
00:09:02 Between six months and a year, right?
00:09:04 To have an 11% popularity in a constituency is amazing.
00:09:08 So, I mean, very few parties, if any,
00:09:10 have achieved that kind of success in living memory, right?
00:09:14 I can't think of any.
00:09:15 Correct.
00:09:15 I mean, it took Restore reform about two years
00:09:19 to start polling about 5% or 6%.
00:09:21 There you go.
00:09:22 And, I mean, in terms of, I suppose,
00:09:26 just to sort of buttress what you've been saying,
00:09:27 and just the sort of steel man aspects of it is,
00:09:29 I mean, let's even rewind back when you might say
00:09:33 the initial cracks first started appearing in Westminster here.
00:09:36 And that's when, now pardon me for forgetting,
00:09:38 I remember Douglas Carswell was one.
00:09:40 I can't remember the second MP that defected to UKIP
00:09:42 back in the early 2010s.
00:09:44 I thought it was just us, Douglas Carswell.
00:09:46 I'm sure there was two.
00:09:47 Anyway, I could be mistaken.
00:09:48 I mean, maybe I'm mistaken.
00:09:50 There was one or two, right?
00:09:50 And that sort of goes back to, you know,
00:09:52 back when Nigel was involved with UKIP
00:09:54 before he went off and did other things.
00:09:56 uh you know obviously before you know what you know uh ukip took a double trend shall we say
00:10:02 um you know that there was the first sort of if you think about the first crack in the edifice
00:10:07 and then subsequently sort of what's happened since then conditions in in this country have
00:10:12 got worse and worse as they have been sadly america and australia and other places but
00:10:15 regarding britain they've got worse and worse and you know in the end i you probably saw it
00:10:21 as a genesis of the brexit party with how popular it was and i mean we both know and many people
00:10:26 know that had Nigel not yielded, Boris would not have become PM with that size majority.
00:10:33 No, weirdly, just to frame everything you're saying here, you're completely correct.
00:10:37 At one point, the Brexit party actually eclipsed the Conservative party in the same way that
00:10:42 reform has eclipsed the Conservatives. Again, but we're on the downswing now, so don't worry
00:10:46 about that for now. And yes, what would have happened is what happened in 2024 with Keir
00:10:52 starmer uh farage would have cut the legs out of the conservatives we would have got a labor
00:10:56 government for five years but the case for farage would have been much stronger because the online
00:11:02 right and the the doubts around farage were a lot weaker back in 2019 would you also agree that
00:11:08 brexit party at that point in time had a lot more organic energy than what reform has yeah because
00:11:13 I would say that.
00:11:16 It was like an ice core, right?
00:11:21 When you drill through and it's like all sections of society,
00:11:24 you know, lots of different...
00:11:25 Reform now, a very boomer-coded party. 0.77
00:11:29 It's like, okay, you've got 20% of the boomers on your side now, Nigel. 0.99
00:11:32 What are you doing with that?
00:11:34 And obviously that breadth of constituency is also narrowed.
00:11:37 Rather than having sort of aspects of the Red Wall North
00:11:40 and aspects of the working class
00:11:41 and these other social constituencies that would have been coalescing
00:11:46 around the Brexit party as was.
00:11:47 Yes.
00:11:47 Again, you know, people from rural areas, agriculture,
00:11:52 middle class, small business, that sort of stuff.
00:11:55 Whereas now you kind of feel that reform has really narrowed itself
00:11:58 down to the sort of lukewarm, milk-toasty, centre-riotist.
00:12:02 Yes.
00:12:03 You might say in some ways like a mature Lib Dem party
00:12:05 with Tory overtones.
00:12:07 Honestly, it's where Farage I think is most comfortable
00:12:09 and why he's so vulnerable to attacks on the right.
00:12:12 But that's an interesting counterfactual, isn't it?
00:12:14 What if Nigel Farage had turned the Brexit Party
00:12:16 and Brexit as a concept
00:12:18 into a kind of culture war,
00:12:20 Gamergate-style fight
00:12:22 against the entire establishment?
00:12:24 That would have gone great, I think.
00:12:26 He wouldn't have won in 2019,
00:12:28 but come 2024,
00:12:30 he could have been a really powerful force.
00:12:32 I was going to say,
00:12:33 irrespective of what the final result
00:12:35 hypothetically would have been with 2019,
00:12:38 Brexit Party would have had quite a sizable chunk of Westminster.
00:12:42 I think that gives me a doubt.
00:12:43 Absolutely.
00:12:43 And it would have had the cultural cachet of the Brexit voters.
00:12:47 It would have had natural constituency.
00:12:49 As a sort of a...
00:12:50 Yeah.
00:12:50 You voted for Brexit.
00:12:51 Well, you want to join the Brexit Party then, obviously.
00:12:54 But Farage instead decided to step back and let things go,
00:12:57 like he did with UKIP.
00:12:59 And so this is why I'm of the opinion that he's probably going to step down
00:13:02 when reform reached about 15% of the polls.
00:13:05 I think he'll just bounce.
00:13:05 But the point that I think you're driving at is the right has very fertile ground at the moment, and we've been making some serious inroads.
00:13:16 I think that the general tone of the conversation on the right, and this has been a real issue for the left as well,
00:13:24 has been dragged far, far to the right by the online right in the question of who is English, as in who belongs, right?
00:13:32 And yes, they all decided, no, we're going to stand on our globalist SIDNAF position of everyone's English, everyone belongs.
00:13:39 But nobody really believes that.
00:13:41 Not to interrupt, but just to say, not only who is English, but what is English.
00:13:46 And those two questions sitting concurrently.
00:13:48 Yes.
00:13:49 But notice how they've all had to come out and answer those questions.
00:13:52 Rishi Sunak, Keir Starmer, you know.
00:13:55 Suella Braveman.
00:13:56 Suella Braveman.
00:13:56 I mean, they've all, you know, these are the people who are the prime minister
00:14:01 and the former ministers in government, right?
00:14:03 This is some serious influence that the online right is exercising at the moment
00:14:07 because we are hitting points that are true and they resonate.
00:14:11 And so this desire to say, well, I mean, you can never change anything really.
00:14:16 Sorry, the elites seem to be responding to us.
00:14:19 And not just seem to be, but the sense is that they're compelled to.
00:14:24 Yes.
00:14:25 And also I would say that, again, for context,
00:14:28 I suppose even more so for younger viewers,
00:14:30 is that, you know, let's not forget that,
00:14:32 never mind 10 years ago, but, you know, 20, 25 years ago,
00:14:36 at a time when, say, you or I might have been to high school,
00:14:39 say, or even earlier, these kind of headlines and discussions
00:14:42 would have had no place in The Telegraph or The Guardian
00:14:45 or The Sun or, you know, an equivalent paper in Australia, right?
00:14:48 You would never have heard a Prime Minister
00:14:50 coming out and talking about them.
00:14:51 Whereas when Tommy did his big rally in London,
00:14:54 Keir Starmer came out and said, this put a shiver up my spine.
00:14:58 So, OK, so you've got a random activist terrifying the sitting prime minister at the time.
00:15:04 It's like, sorry, I think we, you know, we can, I think they are conceding that there's something powerful in the online right.
00:15:12 And they're afraid of it.
00:15:13 That's not nothing.
00:15:14 That's not nothing at all.
00:15:15 And this is why I get frustrated with this kind of elite theorist position where it's like, oh, all power flows from the top.
00:15:22 It's like, that's just not true.
00:15:24 Power is found in many different locations in society.
00:15:28 The question is, what can be productively done with it?
00:15:31 Because the view from Keir Starmer when the Tommy rally was going on
00:15:36 is there's a great deal of power in Tommy's movement,
00:15:38 but it's purely destructive.
00:15:40 He might be able to destroy everything they've been trying to build,
00:15:42 but he's not going to build something out of that himself.
00:15:45 And in this regard, the elite theorists are correct.
00:15:46 Yes, you need an organized minority to actually build a new edifice.
00:15:50 Yes, I agree.
00:15:51 but that doesn't mean there isn't power in other locations.
00:15:54 That doesn't mean all power sits in the elite
00:15:56 and there can be no resistance or there can be no failure
00:15:59 or anything like this, right?
00:16:02 Power percolates around society depending on different forces
00:16:05 and different zeitgeists and different ways things work.
00:16:08 And this really comes to the point that you were making before we started.
00:16:13 The power of ideas is actually a thing.
00:16:17 Now, this is something, of course, a vulgar Marxist would never consent to.
00:16:20 And there is something in Marx's analysis of ideology in that ideologies are the remnants of previous material conditions that persist and then impose themselves from heaven to earth.
00:16:36 There is genuinely something in this, but that doesn't mean there's no power in ideology.
00:16:42 That doesn't mean that ideas don't matter.
00:16:45 And therefore, that doesn't mean that social media doesn't matter
00:16:48 because all social media is is a mechanism for the dispersal
00:16:51 and transmission of ideas.
00:16:53 And you can see this in Lula in Brazil right now.
00:16:56 He's like, okay, I'm basically going to ban social media
00:16:58 from the right-wingers.
00:16:59 That's the plan.
00:17:00 It's like, why would that be the plan?
00:17:02 You've just won the election.
00:17:03 Why are you so desperate to ban social media?
00:17:08 It's because the idea is terrifying.
00:17:09 There must be power in them.
00:17:10 Not to be trite, but it's the old adage about fearing the man,
00:17:13 cutting out the tongue.
00:17:14 It's literally that.
00:17:15 Yeah, it literally is that.
00:17:17 So this, like, I hate to say it's simplistic,
00:17:22 and I'm sure that it's like genuine theorists don't think of it this way,
00:17:28 but the way it's getting translated into the discourse and social media now
00:17:31 is becoming compressed and, I think, unsatisfying
00:17:35 to be a proper explanation of what's actually happening.
00:17:39 It doesn't account for many of the phenomenon we actually see,
00:17:42 so I think we should talk about these things realistically
00:17:46 and realistically, I feel that the online right
00:17:50 is doing an amazing job.
00:17:52 Yeah, 100%.
00:17:53 It's so much more powerful than where we were five years ago.
00:17:57 Well, I was going to say certainly 10 years ago.
00:17:59 Well, even five years ago.
00:18:00 I remember setting up load-seaters
00:18:02 and we were a comparative backwater
00:18:05 compared to where we are now.
00:18:07 That much I certainly agree with.
00:18:09 And also, too, I think if you look at
00:18:12 the sort of dissemination of ideas.
00:18:13 And I mean, we have mutual friends
00:18:15 that have done a lot of work in this regard,
00:18:18 both elite theorists and not,
00:18:20 who have sort of maintained
00:18:24 a very sort of steady course in this regard,
00:18:27 whereby, I mean, for example,
00:18:29 take like one of our American friends,
00:18:31 take Orrin McIntyre, right?
00:18:32 You know, he's booked The Total State.
00:18:34 I mean, yes, there are people in past times
00:18:36 that have sort of written similar times,
00:18:38 you know, like James Byrne or whatever,
00:18:39 but I mean, that's decades ago.
00:18:41 And for someone like Oran to pop up in the online right
00:18:43 and then within a couple of years, they're working for The Blaze
00:18:45 and then writing a book called The Total State,
00:18:47 which is properly sold, God knows how many copies,
00:18:50 would have been unheard of, you know, five, nine, ten plus years ago.
00:18:54 That is happening.
00:18:55 And, I mean, you know, we're obviously both friends with AA, for example,
00:18:57 and we're touching on the elite theory thing here.
00:18:59 I mean, again, for his tomes to have done the rounds
00:19:01 and to have influenced discourses they have is,
00:19:04 never mind it's not nothing, it's actually not insignificant.
00:19:07 No, I agree. 0.85
00:19:08 And I think, see, for me, I suppose for myself, I absolutely understand, having seen, especially coming from, you know, the prison colony, I've seen my fair share of slopulism, to use the term, right, and especially in the Australian coding of, you know, g'day patriots. 0.72
00:19:25 And listen, I'm a proud Australian. I'm very fortunate to count myself as an Australian. 0.81
00:19:29 But I have seen that level of politics be sort of, you know, regurgitated over and over again and churned out and then sort of, you know, it's scattered to the winds and it's sort of reconstituted.
00:19:38 And it kind of does it in the same way. Whereas I think when you look at, I mean, listen, I'm sure probably the both of us are a bit disappointed with the current administration in America.
00:19:48 But Trump has taken things in a direction which we would never have seen under the Bushes or under like a Romney-type president, right?
00:19:55 You'd never have had net negative immigration.
00:19:57 Exactly. 0.71
00:19:58 And the same thing here.
00:19:59 The fact that you've had Restore pop up in the way that it has done under the guidance of someone like Rupert, in the end, no one is faultless.
00:20:08 But Restore have done a great job to carve out something which is authentically right, at least in the current sort of British or Anglo paradigm.
00:20:16 I think you're absolutely correct.
00:20:17 I mean, one of the things, like, Rupert Lowe is, of course, a man of his era, but his instincts, I mean, as Alistair Campbell described him, he's the most right-wing man he'd ever met.
00:20:27 And so he's, like, 20th century boomer-coded, because that's what he grew up in.
00:20:32 But instinctively, he's got a very paternalistic way of approaching politics.
00:20:41 And this means that the Zuma cadre around him,
00:20:45 who are our friends, who are working in this policy team,
00:20:47 who are a spokesman and things like that,
00:20:49 I mean, they understand the problem better than we do
00:20:51 because they're living through the ruins.
00:20:55 And he takes their advice on board.
00:20:58 He listens to what their problems are.
00:20:59 He doesn't ever counter-signal them.
00:21:01 And there's mixed messaging sometimes,
00:21:04 okay, fine, that's the way these things work
00:21:06 when you're literally constructing a right-wing party out of nothing.
00:21:09 But considering how much competition there is on the right
00:21:14 between the Conservatives and reform,
00:21:16 again, whether you think they're right wing or not,
00:21:18 it's in the perception of the minds of the voters
00:21:20 as to whether they're right wing.
00:21:22 The fact that Restore can have 150,000 members
00:21:25 and double digits in the polls in eight months
00:21:27 shows there's a real hunger for this kind of politics.
00:21:31 And the fact that Rupert Lowe has held his ground on everything
00:21:35 when Nigel Farage never did,
00:21:37 even in the Tommy Robinson thing,
00:21:39 He got convicted yesterday and Nigel Farage from one side of the mouth was saying,
00:21:43 yeah, you can like his post, but yeah, he definitely did something wrong.
00:21:45 It's like, did he?
00:21:47 Anyway, the point being, Rupert Lowe has never backslid on any of the people who support him.
00:21:52 And that's what we're looking for, is a man who's prepared to hold the line.
00:21:56 No backsliding, no throwing under the bus, and no apology to people who are, let's face it,
00:22:00 are going to hate our guts regardless.
00:22:01 Yeah, who are just your enemies.
00:22:03 And I mean, listen, I've obviously never met Rupert and I wish him all the best with what he's doing.
00:22:07 because I know obviously you know you've had him on before oh yeah plenty of times yeah and he and
00:22:12 he comes across as very sort of you know I like I like how you use the term grandfatherly because
00:22:15 that's so true um but you know for someone of that time to have grown up in that sort of era
00:22:21 where politics was done a certain way it sort of it mustn't be easy uh to sort of go against what
00:22:28 is otherwise expedient in the media but chooses to do so on conviction and principle which I think
00:22:35 when you look at what has happened to the right writ large
00:22:38 and particularly, say, in the Anglosphere,
00:22:40 which is its own breed of right wing, you know,
00:22:42 as you have often said, continental things are different,
00:22:45 Germans, Italians, French, like it's all different kind of fish.
00:22:48 But say in the Commonwealth where we do have commonalities
00:22:52 and you would include America in this, you know,
00:22:55 where for the longest time being called bad words
00:22:59 by people who despise you was the greatest fear.
00:23:02 And in the end, it's actually refreshing that some,
00:23:04 that certainly someone of Rupert's era
00:23:07 has just realised actually
00:23:08 what's the point of worrying about this
00:23:10 and that is for people like us
00:23:12 and younger guys
00:23:14 that is a godsend
00:23:15 yeah that is the toehold
00:23:18 upon which everything
00:23:20 the rock upon which everything else can be built
00:23:21 Rupert saying to Emily Maitlis
00:23:23 I don't care
00:23:24 that's unprecedented
00:23:26 can't even imagine it
00:23:27 it's the Normandy beachhead of ideology
00:23:29 yeah it absolutely is
00:23:31 it's like great
00:23:31 okay we've got something we can build on here
00:23:32 And, again, you can complain about liberal democracy all you want,
00:23:37 but the only way we're going to dismantle the administrative state
00:23:40 is going to be via the parliament.
00:23:42 Now, in other countries that have got written constitutions,
00:23:45 this is a much more difficult job, right?
00:23:47 But in Britain, we don't have that.
00:23:48 And actually, if we got one parliament that was properly right-wing,
00:23:53 we could just spend that five years dismantling absolutely everything Tony Blair did.
00:23:56 There is actually a path to victory here, and it's actually visible.
00:24:01 You can actually see down the road and say, okay, if we just get there, we could actually do it.
00:24:07 Now, of course, there's going to be all sorts of resistance, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
00:24:09 Yeah, yeah, of course there will be obstacles that are thrown in our way.
00:24:13 But it's possible, and we could go that way.
00:24:16 And actually, things are heading in that direction.
00:24:19 So is bailing out now because of an impurity in the people replying to you on Twitter really the sensible thing to do?
00:24:27 I mean, don't get me wrong, you know,
00:24:29 my replies on Twitter are not all highbrow,
00:24:32 but that just comes with the territory, right?
00:24:34 It's just what do you think you're doing
00:24:36 when you're talking to the world via social media?
00:24:39 You're going to solicit all kinds of opinions.
00:24:41 And, I mean, those of us who know and understand this well
00:24:44 appreciate that in large part.
00:24:46 I mean, yes, there is a place and a time
00:24:47 for more high-minded discourse.
00:24:49 And, you know, it's actually refreshing that sometimes,
00:24:51 whether it's a follower or a friend,
00:24:53 you have you know discussions that are done in sort of good faith and with good grace and politely
00:24:58 and that's always lovely but in the end let's face it it is assessment yes i mean and most
00:25:02 politics is let's be real yeah but politics generally is but twitter especially is a
00:25:07 thornado everyone is exposed to everyone else's opinions yeah you can imagine how contentious
00:25:13 that gets yes um so i don't i think being precious about you know social media and again the plebeian
00:25:19 nature of it well it's it's a mass event what do you expect i mean not to make this conversation
00:25:25 too historical but i use this allegory because we are both you know history charts let's say
00:25:30 is that in any sort of i don't know if great movement's the right word but in the end you
00:25:36 know we are we're both well acquainted with the era of caesar so yeah and it's a case of that if
00:25:40 there wasn't that pressure and that kind of hazards use the word desperation but that sense
00:25:46 of concern and anxiety that existed because use the word plebeian in the plebeian class in Rome
00:25:51 right that gave Caesar a constituency and gave Caesar a power base where otherwise he would have
00:25:57 been locked out of you know sort of rather than so locked out of what was otherwise a very very
00:26:03 small cadre of aristocrats and senators which let's face it had been the end of the brothers
00:26:09 Gracchi for instance and had been the end of other so-called populares that had predated Caesar in
00:26:14 in the case of Gaius, Myris and others.
00:26:17 But, and I love the way,
00:26:19 I'm pretty sure it was Professor Hopkins
00:26:21 who's sort of now deceased,
00:26:23 but he used to be on BBC and I used to love his work.
00:26:25 But, you know, I can't remember if it was him
00:26:27 or it might've been Andrew Wallace Hadrill,
00:26:28 but one of those two said that the phenomenon of Caesar
00:26:31 is that a lot of people who write about him historically,
00:26:35 a bit, much in the same way they sort of write about Napoleon,
00:26:37 it's like it's all them and their ambition, their drive.
00:26:39 But as is always true with these kind of great men
00:26:42 is that it's as much the people behind them pushing
00:26:45 as they are pulling.
00:26:46 And if we sort of familiarise ourselves
00:26:49 or we sort of reference that, you know,
00:26:51 the whole like grug, midwit, brainiac chart,
00:26:55 is that a part of, in my opinion...
00:26:56 It is a high-low mechanism.
00:26:58 I was going to say, I think the important aspects
00:27:00 of let's call it elite theory,
00:27:01 and I do apologise if I'm mistaken
00:27:03 in sort of the ideologically pure sense,
00:27:07 but the role of people who either possess influence
00:27:12 or our thought leaders or people who are able to sort of very clearly
00:27:16 articulate what we are about, a part of their sort of quote-unquote
00:27:22 ideological noblesse oblige is to lead the charge.
00:27:26 It's to be the Lennon in a sense because in the end you can't,
00:27:29 it's a bit difficult to say, oh, this needs to happen
00:27:32 and then not be there.
00:27:34 This is where, for instance, I agree with you about being on the field.
00:27:37 Yes.
00:27:37 Because if you give up the field, you can never win.
00:27:40 You can't win a match, never mind the championship.
00:27:42 Yeah, every battle ends with the winner holding the field.
00:27:46 And if we're not the ones holding the field, then we didn't win.
00:27:48 And the great point with Caesar, by the way.
00:27:51 Caesar is a great example of why I'm frustrated with the, I guess, the online elite theorists,
00:28:00 because the narrowness of their view.
00:28:03 So, yes, decision making is made by elites, but the power base is created by popular sentiment.
00:28:10 And there's a great point about Caesar.
00:28:11 Right. And yes, Caesar gets to form the triumvirate because he has a constituency.
00:28:19 Right. Marius, because he has a constituency and also the rich guy.
00:28:26 Marcus Crassus. Crassus. I don't know why that was.
00:28:29 I wanted to say Salah, but I knew it wasn't Salah. And Crassus is insanely rich.
00:28:34 That's what brings me in. You know, Marius is a Marius.
00:28:38 Pompeii. Pompeii is a very famous general, very accomplished general.
00:28:41 And this is the elite that then has the purchase over the popular will.
00:28:49 It's the same with the French Revolution.
00:28:51 You have the Sans-Calotts running around.
00:28:53 You've got the sort of bourgeois revolutionaries being their voice against the aristocracy. 0.82
00:28:58 It's the same with Lenin.
00:28:59 Lenin waited for revolution.
00:29:01 He didn't create revolution.
00:29:03 Lenin waited and directed the revolution with his cadre of professional Bolsheviks.
00:29:08 But the elites need a kind of a tide to carry them forth. 0.61
00:29:14 And so rejecting the tide means you'll never end up in the position you want to be in.
00:29:18 Correct.
00:29:19 Lennon very much exemplifies, it's the, it was sort of an adage mentioned by Bismarck
00:29:25 that things don't just happen often, very often in history, you don't actually make things happen.
00:29:31 And to use sort of the words of his day, sort of when trying to counsel a very young and impetuous
00:29:36 Wilhelm, the younger
00:29:38 not the older, the younger
00:29:39 the third Kaiser
00:29:41 saying that all you can really do
00:29:44 is sort of hear for the footsteps of God
00:29:46 and then when he walks past the open door
00:29:48 you pull on the hem of his coat
00:29:49 and that's kind of in essence what Lenin did
00:29:52 Lenin had launched
00:29:54 that sort of revolution
00:29:56 much later
00:29:58 or much earlier
00:29:59 without the natural upswell
00:30:01 I mean he said explicitly
00:30:03 the revolution's happening, we have to be ready
00:30:05 He wouldn't have got that.
00:30:08 And the thing is, too, is that, I mean, there are a lot of people who do know this, but a great deal don't.
00:30:13 It wasn't even a case of that the October Revolution was itself launched against the Tsar.
00:30:17 Ultimately, the forces that coalesced against the Bolsheviks were the whites and the white generals.
00:30:23 It was Kolchak and Denekin and Miller and these sort of pro-Tsarish generals
00:30:31 that eventually coalesced a force against the Bolsheviks.
00:30:34 But in essence, Lenin and the Bolsheviks don't coup out the Tsar.
00:30:38 They actually basically coup out the Mensheviks led by...
00:30:41 Yeah, the provisional government.
00:30:42 ...by Kerensky.
00:30:43 I can't remember.
00:30:43 Kerensky.
00:30:44 Right.
00:30:44 By Kerensky.
00:30:45 And that's the moment.
00:30:46 That's the right moment.
00:30:48 Lenin waited for the right moment.
00:30:49 Yeah.
00:30:49 And the provisional government was weak.
00:30:52 Mm.
00:30:53 And that was the opportune time.
00:30:55 Yeah. 0.88
00:30:55 But it wasn't just the Bolsheviks burst in and then the revolution happened.
00:30:58 They waited for an upheaval, an uprising that was organic.
00:31:02 and then led that.
00:31:04 Yes.
00:31:05 And so...
00:31:05 Because they had the popular support in the cities,
00:31:07 as you know.
00:31:07 Yeah.
00:31:08 And so watching our elite theorists
00:31:10 see all of this unrest and uprising
00:31:13 and saying, well, I don't...
00:31:15 Or at least discontent, you know.
00:31:16 Well, I mean, look at the Danny Tomo stuff.
00:31:19 Look at the way the state's cracking down.
00:31:22 The point being,
00:31:24 then watching them saying,
00:31:25 okay, well, I don't need those people.
00:31:27 We're not interested in those people.
00:31:28 Well, yeah, it's understandable
00:31:30 that you get to the point where they're like,
00:31:31 okay, well, we can't do anything.
00:31:33 I'm actually going to withdraw from the arena completely.
00:31:36 I'm going to detach myself into an abstract world of theory
00:31:39 on Substack or wherever and write articles
00:31:42 and make YouTube videos about how nothing is possible.
00:31:46 It's like, well, yeah, but you've created the conditions
00:31:48 for nothing to be possible by explicitly rejecting
00:31:50 the mechanism that you would use to arrive at that point.
00:31:54 So I'm not going to do that.
00:31:57 I think there's something to be said that maybe
00:32:00 what is worth considering is that perhaps our ilk
00:32:06 ought to be perhaps a little bit more judicious 0.99
00:32:08 about indulging perhaps the worst of the slop
00:32:10 and about chasing rabbit holes that aren't worth chasing.
00:32:13 But in the end, unless we're active, nothing will happen.
00:32:18 And passivity is the, you know, nature might abhor a vacuum,
00:32:24 but sort of all change abhors passivity.
00:32:27 And this is where I think finding a middle ground
00:32:30 between the two things actually matters.
00:32:33 And I think if I, I obviously can't speak for you,
00:32:36 but if I sort of reflect on this myself
00:32:38 and looking at sort of the field of play before us,
00:32:40 where I think perhaps some of those critiques stand a bit more
00:32:43 or have a bit more relevance, say, is certainly in America.
00:32:46 I think if you look at the direction of the present administration,
00:32:51 you know, especially, I mean, for instance,
00:32:52 I spoke with Dan about Iran last week, right,
00:32:55 and you kind of, you feel quite disappointed
00:32:57 that there's all that energy and a lot of that sort of impetus behind that victory has been,
00:33:03 you know, a lot of that is being ebbed away by chasing other agendas that are not so
00:33:08 worthwhile and don't benefit really the American people. You know, in the end, being unable to
00:33:14 bring peace or not facilitating, say, peace in Eastern Europe and initiating a war in the Gulf,
00:33:21 you know, how much is this actually helping Americans who are struggling and in many cases
00:33:25 quite desperate for a changing course um whereas obviously you know maybe it's a temperament of
00:33:31 the british compared to americans things are a bit calmer here but there are still things going
00:33:34 wrong i mean you know for instance i've i've been here now like a few weeks and i've you know sort
00:33:38 of start to notice when people talk about oh i might not have enough money for my heating and
00:33:44 i have to pay back on things i actually went through i only four or five days ago i experienced
00:33:49 a brownout when i was having dinner with someone really yeah like the whole you know just went
00:33:54 down and uh and the irony is the person said like oh you know uh you know up north here you know up
00:34:00 in the hills here you know this place is full of you know coal and we used to have power stations
00:34:05 and generators and we actually could in theory be warm and have light and instead because of
00:34:10 intentional policy by politicians that adhere to a very specific ideology that's not the case
00:34:16 instead we have all this renewable stuff on farmland it's not from a lack of resources then
00:34:20 we import food it's nonsensical you know no no you're you're absolutely right um so and another
00:34:28 another complaint is and particularly about um our friends in america is their dedication to
00:34:35 a particular foreign country in the middle east now the americans have um millions tens of millions
00:34:42 of evangelicals who have a very special emotional connection to that particular country and an
00:34:49 They have adherence to their dispensationalism.
00:34:51 Yeah.
00:34:52 Britain doesn't have that.
00:34:53 The British public are not really... 0.98
00:34:55 I mean, 82% of the British public object to what Israel does.
00:34:59 There's no particular sentimental connection to Israel in this country.
00:35:05 And, I mean, you can say what you like,
00:35:08 but even the Labour government is not very kind to Israel. 1.00
00:35:11 And this is part of the reason why the Israelis are backing the Argentinians 0.50
00:35:14 and the Falkland Islands,
00:35:15 because of Andy Burnham and Keir Starmer's assessment
00:35:18 of what they're doing with Palestine. 0.96
00:35:21 Well, in fact, it's not the first time 0.76
00:35:22 that's happened either, right?
00:35:23 No, no, it's not.
00:35:23 It's absolutely not.
00:35:27 With friends like these.
00:35:29 And then, so that's, the left is very much
00:35:32 against this country.
00:35:34 But on the right, Rupert Lowe's made it clear 0.92
00:35:36 that, well, we are going to bow on halal and kosher slaughter.
00:35:40 And he came out and just flatly objected.
00:35:45 and rejected Israel's attitude to Britain's claim
00:35:48 over the Falkland violence.
00:35:49 And if I remember correctly,
00:35:51 he also made a stand against the Iran conflict too.
00:35:54 Yeah, he was the first one to say,
00:35:55 I have no interest in taking Britain into a war with Iran. 0.74
00:35:58 Which is refreshing for a right-winger.
00:36:00 It was shocking because the centre-right was like,
00:36:04 oh, Trump's taking us to war with Iran
00:36:05 and they would have happily gone with it.
00:36:08 But it was Rupert Lowe that staked out the,
00:36:10 no, this isn't good for us and we're not going to do it.
00:36:12 And suddenly their opinion on that completely collapsed.
00:36:15 If it wasn't for Rupert Lowe, they would have maintained that, I think.
00:36:18 And to his credit as well, I mean, not as much to compliment Starmer on,
00:36:21 but Starmer didn't take the bait either.
00:36:22 And actually, Starmer's position was, in fact, quite sort of decent, shall I say.
00:36:26 Yeah, Starmer did make some clever moves.
00:36:30 I mean, obviously, evil man wanted to destroy us all,
00:36:33 but, you know, you can't fault him on that one.
00:36:35 But the point being, it's like, okay, well, that seems to be the litmus test, right?
00:36:40 Is Restored Britain a Zionist party?
00:36:42 Well, not from any evidence I've seen.
00:36:45 In fact, if anything, it's being called an anti-Semitic party
00:36:47 just because of its lack of support for Israel.
00:36:50 I was going to say, if nothing else, like a lack of enthusiasm,
00:36:54 which is quite the accusation.
00:36:56 Absolutely.
00:36:57 And again, you didn't see this from Kemi Bainok.
00:36:59 You didn't see this from Nigel Farage.
00:37:01 You only saw it from Rupelo.
00:37:03 So I felt increasingly vindicated and confident that,
00:37:07 oh, no, it seems that Restore Britain is actually a nativist party.
00:37:10 It is actually a party that considers Britain first and foremost
00:37:14 rather than any foreign boondoggles or any liberal shaming or anything like this.
00:37:19 It seems that we're in exactly the right position with this party.
00:37:22 So it's like, okay, great.
00:37:25 Okay, you've got to tolerate the sloppilism online,
00:37:27 but that's just the nature of any mass movement.
00:37:30 But there's clearly a cadre of high IQ elite thinkers involved in Restore Britain.
00:37:37 So what's the fear?
00:37:40 You know, actually it seems that the right is positioned really well
00:37:44 to start making some serious gains.
00:37:48 I was going to, I've sort of, interesting,
00:37:50 I sort of unwittingly made the allegory towards, you know,
00:37:54 this Restore being sort of like an ideological Normandy beachhead.
00:37:57 And I sort of do fear, there's a part of me that does fear
00:37:59 that if Restore doesn't make, you know, a substantive dent
00:38:05 in the Westminster sort of, not the system,
00:38:09 But, you know, in Westminster writ large and in the system you guys have in Britain, it may sadly end up being a Dieppe parade instead.
00:38:16 And in the end, it's quite unfortunate that if you actually do succeed in achieving a hard fought bridgehead to not then, you know, substantiate it and build a bridgehead out and actually make an exploit and break through, you know, not to get all sort of walk or two on people.
00:38:31 But, you know, it is worth mentioning that inertia in any aspect,
00:38:38 but most especially in politics, matters.
00:38:41 And in the end, speaking, say, from events down under, you know,
00:38:46 I mean, we may or may not go there, maybe we can have this discussion
00:38:50 some other time, but it's kind of the sort of unfortunate existence
00:38:54 of we are very much more so than even here in Britain.
00:39:00 We have the political duopoly of, I mean, the Liberal Party are our Tories, basically.
00:39:05 We both have Labour.
00:39:07 And, you know, any break from that consensus is sort of unimaginable.
00:39:12 Yet in Australia, probably more so than even here, the centre-right has absolutely imploded on itself.
00:39:19 But what they've done is they've kind of just, when I say they, I'm not saying anyone in particular,
00:39:23 but what's occurred either organically or inorganically is basically resuscitation of one nation.
00:39:30 And in the end, personally speaking,
00:39:33 I've never met the woman, I don't know her,
00:39:35 but I personally think that Pauline Hanson
00:39:37 is comparatively more sincere and more genuinely patriotic
00:39:41 than what, say, Nigel Farage is.
00:39:45 But in the end, is One Nation going to be its own thing
00:39:51 in the way that the story is,
00:39:52 or is it going to be rather more beholden to other interests?
00:39:54 And I do fear, as has often been the case with One Nation,
00:39:57 that it will be a bit more beholden
00:39:59 And sadly, I mean, again, I don't want to discredit where her heart is,
00:40:03 but, I mean, Pauline isn't exactly a broad scholar, let me just say that.
00:40:08 Whereas I think sort of Rupert has a bit more sort of wisdom
00:40:11 and knowledge to him as a person.
00:40:13 And I think when a person doesn't have knowledge in certain areas
00:40:17 of the world, it is hard for them to lead political movements.
00:40:20 And I think, for instance, you know, in Australia,
00:40:22 I kind of feel that that captive energy will sort of be absorbed
00:40:25 into One Nation or whether they replace the Liberal Party or not,
00:40:28 I don't know.
00:40:29 but the Labour Party is at historic levels of unpopularity
00:40:33 and I think really will struggle to find a way forward in the future.
00:40:37 You know, if you look at interviews of even state leaders
00:40:42 of the party in Australia, if you change the blue outline
00:40:47 to a red outline, which is the ALP, the Labour Party,
00:40:50 the words are the same.
00:40:51 Like you could not tell the difference.
00:40:52 And I think one should not express too much ingratitude for the fact that something has arisen, as it has in the UK and Britain, and it's worth trying because in the end, you mentioned about the liberal democratic framework and it's true, this is the system we have.
00:41:16 this is the aftermath of the the resolution of the 20th century you know whether one likes it or not
00:41:21 whether one sits on the left or the right it is what it is and it's worth saying that unless
00:41:27 unless a figure of you know a Patton-esque or MacArthur-esque figure and in the end those
00:41:34 not only are those men more uncommon now than ever they don't have the the unyielding support
00:41:40 of men like those men did yeah and even in that case macarthur didn't succeed in the 50s eisenhower
00:41:47 became president and macarthur was shut out and went into retirement so you know are we going to
00:41:52 get a caesar moment in the way that we might fantasize and i think the answer is most likely
00:41:56 not no not to be killjoy but no no no but i think it's about being realistic and i mean
00:42:02 for a lot of the people who are kind of naysayers it seems less about an accurate description of
00:42:08 what's happening are more about temperament or disposition they they are deliberately removing
00:42:15 themselves from any will to power and have completely abnegated and said okay well we're
00:42:22 nothing and we're just abstract scholars online it's like okay well i want to engage on the field
00:42:28 everyone else wants to engage on the field and that's where victory is actually found like
00:42:33 honestly this kind of retreat into theory
00:42:35 it just tends to be a cope
00:42:37 it just looks like a cope to me
00:42:39 and I think it's also just unnecessary
00:42:41 because if we actually look at the gains that we're making
00:42:43 I don't see any
00:42:45 reason not to be optimistic
00:42:46 like okay yeah it's not a perfect system
00:42:49 it's liberal democracy we'll have to do what we can
00:42:51 within the system but we're making
00:42:53 some serious gains and we're dragging
00:42:55 everyone with us
00:42:57 so I don't understand the need for this kind of
00:43:00 negativity
00:43:01 and pessimism.
00:43:05 I'm not a pessimistic person,
00:43:07 but if the situation was not as it was
00:43:10 and if it was that, oh, God, there's nowhere to go,
00:43:13 nothing's happening.
00:43:14 Like five years ago, even reform weren't a thing
00:43:18 and it was just the Conservatives.
00:43:21 It's like, oh, God, yeah.
00:43:21 I mean, I was pessimistic then,
00:43:23 but events have conspired to make it so that, no,
00:43:25 we've got something solidly representative
00:43:27 that is actually putting pressure on everyone
00:43:29 and is growing.
00:43:30 why would I try and why wouldn't I just pour my energy into making that grow I mean you tell me
00:43:36 you weren't enthusiastic for Theresa May I mean come on not terribly but you're right though
00:43:43 and I agree and if I may if I may just offer some like a kind of um uh defense might not be the right
00:43:54 word but if if for those who want to pull away and do their own thing if they have a point that
00:44:00 i do find admirable it's their emphasis on localism but i don't think the localism should
00:44:04 be mutually exclusive from wider efforts to push things but we've been at a top of it and that's
00:44:09 what the basket we've as well that's true we already have this it's like okay no what you we
00:44:14 have and and obviously you know you've got those of us who are engaged in the political party on
00:44:19 the local level right so it's like what you want to do is translate that organization to politics
00:44:23 now because that's how the lib dems do it that's how the labor party have done it that's how the
00:44:27 conservatives have done it it's not that these people are genius elites that have the system
00:44:32 wrapped up it's just they went and got involved that was all it was all you have to do is be
00:44:36 present and show up and be the person at the time and then things arrive in the position that they
00:44:42 are now so okay we can do the same and i mean you're absolutely right it is absolutely admirable
00:44:47 to be involved in your community at any kind of local level and you should be translating that
00:44:53 to politics not not withdrawing from politics politics is not going to withdraw from you
00:44:58 which is surely the the fundamental lesson that we have all learned in the last 20 years
00:45:03 is that politics will not leave you alone so you've got to grab the ball by the horns
00:45:06 and we just need to get going inversely what we've discovered in the last well you could say 20 years
00:45:12 but especially in the last decade or even half decade is that politics has become ever more
00:45:19 emboldened in being intrusive yes i mean as you have found to your great disclosure becoming you
00:45:24 know the operator of this organization there's there's never a part of your life the government
00:45:28 will not molest i i wouldn't have done any of this if they'd left me alone it literally comes
00:45:34 down to that well well you and i have a similar ilk and i mean in the end they wouldn't let it
00:45:37 leave our video games alone no they wouldn't but that's but that's fine yeah but that's fine because
00:45:41 what what we found is that politics actually a lot more malleable than it first appeared
00:45:45 right when before any of this started to me it looked remote and impersonable and untouchable
00:45:52 but actually look at i mean it's just guys with twitter accounts and youtube accounts
00:45:58 that have pushed the prime minister into debating who who is and who is not english right yeah i was
00:46:04 going to say and this obviously occurred with me being back home when this happened but i was
00:46:09 shocked quite shocked when i heard uh starmer and you you might be able to elucidate or bring this
00:46:16 more to my to my awareness but his island of strangers speech i mean that was incredibly
00:46:22 dare i use the word paul-esque for someone that sits left of sense i mean he got criticized
00:46:26 heavily for it being we know that but i mean in the end would that have happened under a
00:46:33 alternative reality where that pressure wasn't exerted no of course not and i suppose that's
00:46:37 that point. Exactly. It was entirely in response to the Southport riots and the pressure that
00:46:44 the popular right-wing movement in this country has generated. And Nigel Farage tacking to the
00:46:51 right, you can see everything being dragged in our direction. And it's like, okay, well,
00:46:54 why would we stop now? Why would we stop? Politics is more malleable than people are giving it
00:47:00 credit for. We can have an impact. We are having an impact. So I'm actually profoundly optimistic
00:47:05 at this point i think yeah we can do some serious good well not not saying this to counter signal
00:47:10 you at all just as a matter of curiosity is that optimism more specific to the situation here in
00:47:16 the united kingdom or do you think that's like that can be applied to the right writ large in
00:47:20 the west i mean america trump has already won everything in america you know unfortunately
00:47:24 he's slightly squandering the victory but he did win the house senate the supreme court the
00:47:29 presidency the popular vote well that's where i was going how do you think things might look there
00:47:34 in like a post-Trump era?
00:47:36 Because I dare say that the vengeance of the Dems
00:47:40 always seems like it's sitting on the shoulder.
00:47:42 Yeah, but the Dems haven't really changed or learned anything.
00:47:46 That's true. 0.95
00:47:46 They're still insufferable.
00:47:48 They're still all of the things that drove the Trump victory.
00:47:51 And until they can manifestly
00:47:54 and sort of almost genetically change their attitude
00:47:58 towards the native population of America,
00:48:00 I don't think, I mean, they might, you know, like,
00:48:03 Oh, they're going to win the midterms.
00:48:04 Yeah, but that happens every single time.
00:48:06 Like that's, you know, there's a kind of wisdom of crowds effect.
00:48:10 It's like, well, we don't want the one party to have everything.
00:48:13 So we'll give them, you know, there's always that swing back and forth.
00:48:16 It's almost essentially the modus operandi of how the American system works.
00:48:19 Yeah, yeah.
00:48:20 Yeah, yeah.
00:48:20 And it's the same as in this country when it's like, oh, well, like there are actually
00:48:25 very rare labor governments in British 20th century history.
00:48:29 It's very rare.
00:48:30 Keir Starmer was only like the fourth Labour Prime Minister
00:48:32 in 100 years to win.
00:48:33 I was going to say, Starmer, Blair, Wilson and Attlee, right?
00:48:38 Yeah, I think so, yeah.
00:48:41 And so most of the time it's just lackadaisical conservative governments
00:48:45 that just essentially are a vote from the British public,
00:48:48 just please don't mess anything up.
00:48:50 You know, please just don't.
00:48:52 Just keep the ship sailing.
00:48:53 Yeah, exactly.
00:48:54 Everything seems fine, don't mess it up.
00:48:56 So anyway, it's not just.
00:48:59 also true of us by the way yeah really back home yeah i mean it's changing now but largely two of
00:49:04 us historically right right okay interesting um i don't know much about australian politics
00:49:08 there's too many things i've got to cover but um but the point being politics actually seems to be
00:49:15 a lot more malleable than it ever has been um the potential for change the the ease of reaching new
00:49:21 constituencies from the internet has also made it just it's opened up doors that would never have
00:49:26 been open before. So I just look at the fertility of the field and I go, why aren't we fighting
00:49:32 for this? We should be out there contesting everything, anywhere that we can, in every
00:49:36 spectrum. And we've got a huge number of people. And we have, as I said, the sort of cadre
00:49:42 of very intelligent young men who very much understand the problem, who are leading the
00:49:48 charge. So, okay, well, what's there to be pessimistic about? We've never had it so good.
00:49:53 Let's get out there and fight for it.
00:49:55 The other thing, because you mentioned this intelligent
00:49:57 cadre of young men, I think it's also worth saying,
00:49:59 because we have, I suppose, spent a bit
00:50:01 of time critiquing the elite theory
00:50:03 mob, is that we also have very intelligent
00:50:05 people who do work in the field of theory
00:50:07 and combining those forces would
00:50:09 make it even more potent. Yes.
00:50:11 And this is why I said it was more of a dispositional
00:50:13 issue. It's like, okay, well,
00:50:15 it's your disposition to
00:50:17 want to be aloof,
00:50:20 isolated,
00:50:20 and look down your nose at people.
00:50:24 But at the end of the day, you know, you're a part of this as well.
00:50:28 So you're going to have to learn to understand your place
00:50:32 in the grand scheme of things.
00:50:33 I mean, I obviously can't speak for you,
00:50:35 but if I may speak for myself briefly,
00:50:37 one of the things I actually have, I found very sort of illuminating
00:50:41 and, you know, encouraging from this sort of body work
00:50:44 that's been written, you know, amongst our friends, you know,
00:50:47 whether it's sort of more of the or on wing of things
00:50:49 or more the AA end of things is that, and particularly for someone like me,
00:50:53 I know, for example, you and I might differ is that I've obviously spent
00:50:55 like a lot of my life being inherently sort of traditionalistic, you know,
00:50:59 and I mean, as you know, like I'm a cradle Catholic and all that sort of stuff.
00:51:02 You've sort of come to the right through classical liberalism.
00:51:04 We've sort of actually ended up, you know, relatively proximal in many ways.
00:51:08 But in so far that perhaps conclusions you came to, you know,
00:51:14 waking up to and rejecting sort of aspects of modernity and liberalism,
00:51:18 And in my case, sort of like, why do these things that are age old truths, why are they important? Why do they make sense? And actually having a framework by which to make that all make sense, and then apply to our current time and place and our circumstances and being able to sort of, you know, not just have it make sense to us within, but then to articulate that to, you know, friends or family or colleagues or people around us and actually say, listen, this is actually in some reason why the world is the way it is.
00:51:46 and in the end there are things that occurred in life before that you know made sense and perhaps
00:51:51 it would be better for us to sort of do it this way rather than this way and in the end if we're
00:51:56 honest if we look at our system we look at our circumstances if we care about not only our own
00:52:00 prospects but the prospects for our future posterity and for our you know our descendants
00:52:05 yet to come we have to have some very serious thoughts amongst ourselves and discussions within
00:52:10 our own circles about where our various societies or or countries are headed and i think um some of
00:52:17 the the most admirable aspects of that working theory is being able to sort of make that you
00:52:24 know intelligible for us completely you know in the end it's just we have combining those energies
00:52:28 i feel is the best way forward yes i i just yeah i think you're exactly correct and all of the um
00:52:37 division as it is, I'm not going to say it's confected, but it doesn't feel very deep, right?
00:52:47 The division feels kind of aesthetic and superficial rather than a core actual issue between any
00:52:55 parts of the right.
00:52:56 And there are so many enemies around us.
00:52:59 So do we need enemies inside the gates as well?
00:53:01 Well, didn't Cicero have a thing about enemies within?
00:53:05 Well, yeah, they're worse than the enemies without, obviously.
00:53:07 but anyway I guess we'll leave it there
00:53:10 because we've covered a lot of ground
00:53:11 but thank you Marcus for joining me
00:53:14 and we'll see you next time folks