The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - November 16, 2026


Why Are They Claiming to Be English? | Interview with Dr David Starkey CBE

PREVIEW: Epochs #289 | James I

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 29 minutes

Words per minute

140.26

Word count

12,538

Sentence count

821

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

18

sentences flagged

Hate speech

140

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hi, folks. I have the pleasure to welcome Dr. David Starkey to Lotosita's headquarters,
00:00:04 where we are going to be discussing the state of things. Dr. Starkey.
00:00:10 Hello.
00:00:12 So I wanted to begin with the difficult questions, because you can go anywhere to get
00:00:20 a reasonably centrist and tepid discussion on the current state of affairs, looking at the polls,
00:00:26 looking at what the policies are in the manifestos.
00:00:29 That's what everyone does.
00:00:31 And I know you enjoy having these kind of difficult discussions.
00:00:36 So I would like to ask you,
00:00:40 why is everyone claiming to be English all of a sudden?
00:00:46 Or not?
00:00:48 Well.
00:00:49 Or why has it become a point of definition?
00:00:52 Yes.
00:00:52 I think there's the very obvious answer to the question, that we are less English
00:01:01 than we have been. That's putting it in a nutshell. It's a point of peculiar contention
00:01:09 in Britain, because on the one hand, we are a pioneer nation state. England is one of
00:01:19 the first, along with France, recognising the nation states. We were chatting before
00:01:24 we went on air briefly about Henry V. It seems to me manifestly at that point England sees
00:01:32 itself and is seen as what we would call a nation state. When Henry V has won his great
00:01:39 victories against the French, there is a general council of the church held at Constance and
00:01:46 England proclaims itself a great power.
00:01:50 It tells the world that it is to be held
00:01:54 as at least the equal of France, 0.78
00:01:56 which was just conquering and claiming,
00:01:59 that its language stands out as a great language.
00:02:03 It claimed Henry V is the first king consciously
00:02:08 to construct his correspondence in English,
00:02:11 as opposed to French.
00:02:13 Again, it uses language like territory, blood, soil, history, you know, in 1415.
00:02:25 So I think that there is this extraordinary long tradition, but at the same time,
00:02:32 something very peculiar happened.
00:02:33 It's the creation of Britain, which is a fusion of two old established monarchies,
00:02:41 England and Scotland.
00:02:43 There was never a very serious attempt at creating a British identity, a common identity.
00:02:52 There were some.
00:02:54 There are wonderful remnants of the idea of we're all British or all Britons.
00:03:02 So why, of course, was Rue Britannia?
00:03:04 Britons never, never shall be slaves.
00:03:06 So the most obvious attempt was for a period, sort of, to eliminate the name Scotland.
00:03:15 So Scotland becomes North Britain.
00:03:18 And I remember, until very recently, one of the two major hotels in Edinburgh is the North British Hotel.
00:03:27 I think it's now renamed the Caledonian or something.
00:03:29 So you swap that for Latin.
00:03:32 And at the same time, my favourite memory of it,
00:03:36 because I was a boy actor at school,
00:03:38 I played John Worthington in The Importance.
00:03:41 And you remember, he is the one who has to confront Lady Bracknell
00:03:44 about his three addresses.
00:03:46 Three addresses inspires confidence, Mr Worthington, even in Tradesmen.
00:03:50 Unfortunately, the one on Belgrave Square was the wrong side of the square.
00:03:55 The one in the home counties was okay.
00:03:58 But she was especially impressed with his Scottish address,
00:04:01 which was the sporn Fyfshire, North Britain,
00:04:05 late as the Edwardian period.
00:04:07 But that's not accompanied by any attempt
00:04:11 at using mass education to create a single consciousness
00:04:17 that on the contrary, the monarchy from a very early,
00:04:23 in fact, right from the beginning of union,
00:04:26 consciously cultivates a separateness
00:04:29 that you will get a royal prince will be given titles which are both English and Scottish,
00:04:36 later on Irish and Welsh, that you have separate orders of chivalry.
00:04:43 You have the Thistle for Scotland, you have the Garter for England, you then have the Patrick for Ireland.
00:04:49 Wales never acquires, because it's never a monarchy, it doesn't acquire that kind of separate existence.
00:04:56 Though by the time you've got to the beginning of the 20th century, you consciously construct a separate capital for Wales.
00:05:05 This is what Lloyd George does. I mean, I don't know whether you've been to Cardiff.
00:05:09 I have, not recently, but I have been there.
00:05:11 Cardiff has a magnificent imperial capital, built in full flamboyant Edwardian Baroque,
00:05:19 very similar to the buildings around Piccadilly Circus and exactly contemporary to them
00:05:24 because you're envisaging a semi-imperial structure of Britain
00:05:33 in which there are separate forms of nationhood.
00:05:38 Scots, Welsh, Irish, a pretty broad pattern of what I would call cultural nationalism.
00:05:45 You emphasize music, national music, bagpipes, whatever they have in Ireland.
00:05:51 by Steadfonts, Rabbie Burns, National Dress, Wailing Bagpipes,
00:06:02 all of that sort of stuff, the Romantic novel,
00:06:05 all of that's invented in Scotland.
00:06:07 There were elements of it before, but remember,
00:06:10 nearly all of that belonged to the Highlands, 0.76
00:06:13 which were Catholic and completely outside
00:06:16 the Presbyterian establishment of southern Scotland
00:06:19 and regarded as essentially barbaric.
00:06:23 The idea that the good burghers of Edinburgh would have worn a kilt
00:06:27 would have struck them as mad.
00:06:30 But what you get is Walter Scott,
00:06:33 in particular for that first royal visit,
00:06:37 the visit of George IV to Scotland,
00:06:39 the one when the king actually wears the kilt,
00:06:43 despite his proportions,
00:06:45 famously over corsets and flesh-coloured tights,
00:06:48 presides as the chief of chiefs at grand dinner in the old parliament house, where in fact the
00:06:57 modern kilt and its modern relationship with the clans is effectively invented for that.
00:07:07 So what you have, you've got that type of nationalism. And then English nationalism is
00:07:13 completely different. It's great nation nationalism. We are the biggest, we are the best, we have the
00:07:20 world, we are the mother of the British parliament, the English parliament, we call it the British,
00:07:25 but it's a mildly expanded version, is the mother of parliaments. In those days, of course,
00:07:33 we are the world's largest manufacturing country, and, and, and, and freeborn Englishman. So,
00:07:41 attachment to institutions. Now that doubleness has on the one hand enormously facilitated
00:07:52 the process of handling immigration because we've had this very recently invented category.
00:08:02 Save as an adjective for nationalized industry. British really, this is one of the reasons it's
00:08:08 got crappy associations. It's the original UK. It was British Leyland, crap cars. It was British 1.00
00:08:15 telecom, terrible phones. It was British Rail, trains that don't run and dried bent sandwiches
00:08:21 and all that kind of thing. But what you do is you consciously develop that idea as, by definition,
00:08:29 civic nationalism. A nationalism that anybody can hold, providing they have the requisite documents.
00:08:37 And at the same time, it's able to invoke a certain sense of history,
00:08:44 the British Navy, the British Empire, and all of that sort of stuff.
00:08:48 And all of that, meantime, leaves England, Englishness, extraordinarily stranded.
00:08:55 I mean, I think what is very strikingly the case is that Scotland, Wales, Ireland,
00:09:02 in terms of the modern expression of consciousness
00:09:06 were either welcomed the loss of empire or ignored it.
00:09:12 I mean, Scotland, of course, the left in Scotland,
00:09:15 the new Scottish nationalism of the SNP and whatever,
00:09:19 is a sustained lie.
00:09:21 It pretends that Scotland was, in fact, a wee oppressed power.
00:09:27 An unwilling partner.
00:09:28 And whereas in fact, of course, they were the principal and the most brutal imperialists
00:09:33 and very effective ones.
00:09:35 The role of Scots in the entire administration of India,
00:09:40 the role of Scots particularly in Hong Kong and the honkers and shankers, the great banks.
00:09:46 Canada, Canada is really greater Scotland.
00:09:50 It begins with Nova Scotia under James I.
00:09:54 first. So what you were able to do was to simply turn up the volume of the cultural
00:10:03 nationalism. England is the problem because ours was that pride in
00:10:09 institutions, in the distinction of our law, of our administration, in the
00:10:16 superiority of our industry. Now it was top-nation nationalism. The great
00:10:22 problem is when you stop being top nation. The book that I think, I'm surrounded here,
00:10:28 with historical tat, a very powerful piece of historical tat you should include, which
00:10:35 I think is one of the sharpest analyses of where we are, is 1066 and all that. Sellers
00:10:43 and Yateman. It's a parody, it's a historical satire of the 1930s. I think it's brilliant,
00:10:52 I mean, it has immortal lines, like it has a series of observations, for example, that every time the Irish solve the Irish question, every time the English solve the Irish question, the Irish change the question.
00:11:07 The wonderful phrase about the fact that the royalists 0.88
00:11:15 are wrong but romantic, whereas the Puritans 1.00
00:11:21 are right but repellent. 1.00
00:11:24 But my great favourite is the end of the book.
00:11:29 The book ends with the First World War,
00:11:32 and the last line is this.
00:11:33 Britain ceased to be top nation
00:11:38 I think it may even be England ceased to be top nation
00:11:42 and history came to a full stop
00:11:46 That is a fascinating view
00:11:50 One version of the end of history
00:11:52 I think it's spectacularly perceptive
00:11:54 Yes
00:11:55 So that's the background
00:11:59 That's the background to where we are now
00:12:01 and to where we stand with Englishness.
00:12:07 I think that being English, of course, is...
00:12:13 And I assert the fact that I am English very consciously.
00:12:16 Yes.
00:12:19 And I've done so more and more.
00:12:21 Not that I am about immigration,
00:12:27 though there are aspects of it that I found, again,
00:12:30 to use my cellars in the eight-man categories,
00:12:34 repulsive and repugnant and whatever.
00:12:39 But it is, I suppose, that assertion of belonging,
00:12:49 of, if you like, indigenousness,
00:12:53 of this is my place, this is my culture,
00:12:58 this is my language. I mean I believe passionately as you know that these
00:13:03 things are not issues of sort of little checklists of British values. Yes. That
00:13:10 they are in fact products of very very long rootedness and historical
00:13:16 experience and that one says that and by using the word England in English you
00:13:23 say that. And that therefore has a very strong element of ethnicity. How can it be anything else?
00:13:33 I also want, and I think I used when I was last discussing this publicly with Stephen Edgington,
00:13:40 I think I actually used the phrase, I wanted to be able to talk about myself without a qualifying
00:13:47 You did say that.
00:13:49 To say merely I am English.
00:13:51 I don't need to add anything to that.
00:13:53 And this seems to me to be a really not very complicated demand.
00:14:00 Well, I mean, anyone else is allowed to do it anywhere else in the world.
00:14:05 Ah.
00:14:05 It's a completely uncontroversial thing to say everywhere.
00:14:09 But you see, you're forgetting.
00:14:11 You are forgetting.
00:14:12 Even our wonderful friend, Jacob Rees-Mogg,
00:14:16 tells us that the English are mongrel.
00:14:21 And you know what? 1.00
00:14:22 He is right.
00:14:23 I agree with him that we are an Anglo-Celtic nation.
00:14:26 But I think that he...
00:14:27 Sorry, hang on.
00:14:28 The English aren't Anglo-Celtic.
00:14:30 Are we not? 0.87
00:14:31 Britain is Anglo-Celtic. 0.79
00:14:33 Sorry, Britain is Anglo-Celtic.
00:14:37 Oh, sure, the English are an English nation.
00:14:39 Right, but now you see, you're swimming around almost as badly as one of the politicians on the left.
00:14:49 I thought I was going to outflank you.
00:14:51 Do you know why this term, calling the English mongrel, why is it so frequently done?
00:14:59 I think fundamentally to delegitimize any core claim that we have to the country.
00:15:03 Yes, absolutely. But why is that particular word used?
00:15:06 Yeah, it's interesting, isn't it?
00:15:09 No, no, no, you're getting nowhere.
00:15:11 Oh, okay.
00:15:13 All of you unconsciously are quoting.
00:15:16 Right.
00:15:17 Oh, we're not Daniel Defoe-ing.
00:15:19 We are Daniel Defoe.
00:15:20 And you see, it's really important to understand that. 0.68
00:15:23 That particular charge of Mongolisation is made by Daniel Defoe
00:15:28 in the late 17th century.
00:15:31 And what's so interesting about the late 17th century,
00:15:34 This is really the moment at which Britain is just forming.
00:15:37 It's just before Union. 1.00
00:15:40 You've got a foreign king.
00:15:43 You've got William of Orange, who was the guarantor of their new liberal order, 1688, 1689. 0.60
00:15:51 You've got waves of refugees.
00:15:55 These are the extremely successful refugees from France, the Huguenots,
00:16:00 fleeing the revocation of the Edict of Nantes under Louis XIV.
00:16:04 You get other refugees from the Netherlands, from Germany, 0.51
00:16:08 Jews newly allowed into England by William the Conqueror. 1.00
00:16:11 So identity nationals... 0.96
00:16:13 Was it by Oliver Cromwell, sorry? 1.00
00:16:14 Pardon?
00:16:14 Oliver Cromwell?
00:16:15 It happened under Cromwell.
00:16:16 Well, Cromwell's only 40-odd years before. 1.00
00:16:19 So Jews continue to come in. 1.00
00:16:21 I mean, they're readmitted under Cromwell. 1.00
00:16:23 And you look at the first government of the Bank of England as a Huguenot and so on.
00:16:29 There are French churches in London.
00:16:31 There is a French, I mean, until I think the Second World War,
00:16:35 maybe even afterwards, there's a French hospital,
00:16:38 a French dispensary, there's a French lycée.
00:16:40 And all of this is as problematic then,
00:16:44 and what you get is a huge organized attack 1.00
00:16:47 on we have been taken over by foreigners.
00:16:50 You have parliamentary legislation on identity and ethnicity 0.99
00:16:54 and defining who is a citizen and who isn't.
00:16:57 And so what you're getting with Defoe is you're flinging, Defoe is defending the new order, the new, if you like, internationalist order or the multiple order under William III.
00:17:14 And he's saying to all of you people pretending to be native English, we've got special rights, saying you're not. 0.96
00:17:20 You're a load of mongrels. 0.96
00:17:22 You're a product of Romans. 1.00
00:17:23 You're a product of Danes. 1.00
00:17:25 You're a product of Anglo-Saxons, all heaped up. 0.98
00:17:28 Now, this is a particularly silly charge. 0.98
00:17:31 Think about it. 0.70
00:17:33 Is there any people in Europe that you couldn't actually say that about?
00:17:38 Is there any people in the world that you couldn't say that about?
00:17:41 Focus on Europe.
00:17:42 No, no, absolutely not.
00:17:43 For example, why is France called France? 0.92
00:17:46 Because the Franks took over the Roman people. 1.00
00:17:47 Oh, the Germanic people. 1.00
00:17:48 Yes. 0.73
00:17:49 as it were, that conquer the province of Gaul,
00:17:54 which we think, we're not really sure what Celtic means,
00:17:58 but anyway, the population of Gaul,
00:18:06 and they are German-speaking,
00:18:08 and you produce a fused culture.
00:18:12 Similarly, Italy, why do you have Lombardy?
00:18:14 Because the Lombards, another German tribe,
00:18:17 German tribes conquer the whole of the empire. 0.99
00:18:20 Same with Spain. 0.98
00:18:21 Same with Spain, exactly.
00:18:22 And there it's even more complicated,
00:18:23 and there it's even more complicated 0.94
00:18:26 because you get the Islamic conquest and so on.
00:18:29 So coming back to the original question then,
00:18:32 why is everyone calling themselves English all of a sudden?
00:18:35 Because you might remember just a few years ago
00:18:39 when you had David Lammy standing up in Parliament in 2018
00:18:43 saying, we are Caribbean people and we demand reparations.
00:18:45 Well, the English don't get any reparations.
00:18:47 Actually, it was the English from whom everyone was expecting money, whether you're in Scotland
00:18:51 or Wales or the Caribbean or wherever, and suddenly in the last month or two, everyone
00:18:56 said, oh no, I'm English, of course I'm English.
00:18:59 Kimmy Baden-Ock said, well, how dare you say my children aren't English.
00:19:02 I mean, that is a really very peculiar one.
00:19:07 Look at why her children should be English or why they shouldn't be English. 0.52
00:19:12 I mean, she proclaims herself to be not simply a Nigerian, but a Yoruba. 0.57
00:19:19 Her husband is very, very proudly Scottish.
00:19:25 So how, how in God's name, is a mixture of Yoruba and Scots to be proclaimed to be English? 0.93
00:19:33 Save on the grounds that apparently being born in England is itself enough. 1.00
00:19:39 Being born in a barn makes you a horse.
00:19:41 So in other words, what clearly is trying to happen is to create a civic identity, that is to say, that being English is simply a function of being born there, for a country that isn't a separate notion, that doesn't have a separate passport, which for most people would be sort of semi-ethnically defined.
00:20:08 But remember, it's worth, I'm sorry, you said move on, go to the detail.
00:20:13 Once again, it's really worth asking this question.
00:20:16 For example, there's a famous immigrant family I'd like to talk about
00:20:21 where people will boldly say that it's perfectly clear that these people are not English,
00:20:27 they are German.
00:20:28 That's to say the royal family who have been here for, God knows,
00:20:33 whatever number of generations since 1714.
00:20:36 Now, why is their perception of that German-ness?
00:20:40 For the simple reason people want to abuse them.
00:20:43 But also, they were a family that did exactly what a modern Bangladeshi or Pakistani family does. 0.82
00:20:50 They married back home each generation, which to an extent kept them foreign. 0.94
00:20:57 And then, in 1917, they took the decision, well, to keep our throne, we better become English.
00:21:05 We're not the Saxe-Cotha-Gotha.
00:21:07 Whatever they were, Saxe-Cotha-Gotha or whatever.
00:21:10 And you hastily rechristen yourself Windsor,
00:21:13 having done market testing, by the way, on the surname.
00:21:18 It's a good surname.
00:21:19 It's a good surname.
00:21:20 It's a very good surname.
00:21:22 And it also usurps the name of a well-known English family.
00:21:26 And the other thing you do is you introduce all the rules,
00:21:30 you will marry English people and all the rest of it.
00:21:32 And if you look at some of you like Prince Charles now, he clearly is the quintessence of a certain view of Englishman with the elegance of dress, the careful restraint of manner, the perfectly formed accent, the slight diffidence despite the grandeur of his position.
00:21:53 So, in other words, English is something that you can grow into.
00:21:59 I mean, the commander of the armed forces, or was certainly a very high-ranking general,
00:22:07 called de la Billière, who, when you met him, was the most English of people,
00:22:12 or the keeper of the Queen's pictures, de Belague.
00:22:16 In other words, these were French Huguenots over the process of time
00:22:20 and completely melded into Englishness. 0.86
00:22:22 Now, that's fine. You see, I suspect that most of the problem arises. In what context did Kemi talk about English?
00:22:32 Well, the context was that the discussion online had been focused around drawing a boundary between being English and not being English as an ethnic identity.
00:22:47 And Sweller Braverman had the temerity to say, well, I'm not English.
00:22:52 I'm Indian. I'm a British Indian woman.
00:22:54 And she was raked over the coals all over question time on this.
00:22:59 And as a kind of political jab at reform,
00:23:04 Kemi Badenoch said, well, I'm not doing a deal with a party
00:23:08 that debates whether my children are or are not English.
00:23:12 Yeah, but there's a more specific context.
00:23:15 You've forgotten the actual preface to that particular section of the speech.
00:23:22 What was it talking about?
00:23:23 You'll have to remind me.
00:23:24 It was talking about the English football team.
00:23:27 And you see, in a sense, this is where the whole thing has become profoundly problematic
00:23:33 because the English football team is largely black, as indeed is the French football team. 1.00
00:23:40 Many are. 1.00
00:23:40 That there was a wonderfully naughty joke, and as this is a programme, I think we can tell naughty jokes.
00:23:48 You're not going to get yourself cancelled again, are you?
00:23:49 About the French football team playing the football team of, I don't know what, let's say it was the Congo, or it might even have been Algeria.
00:24:02 And the joke was, it was the legal immigrants versus the illegal immigrants. 0.88
00:24:06 Yeah, I did see that. 0.93
00:24:06 So I think it is the English football team and the fact that black athleticism means they are, in terms of population, enormously overrepresented in it, that presents this in a peculiarly acute form. 0.87
00:24:23 And the people that figure as, surely this black, because it is black, is English, will be Lenny Henry.
00:24:33 There will be a whole range of football players. 0.82
00:24:36 Who himself has claimed reparations.
00:24:37 There will be boxes.
00:24:38 In other words, it's exactly what, if you may remember,
00:24:43 the awful chap Nathan Kofnass said, citing Harvard's own report,
00:24:51 that the figures, the areas where blacks will figure largely
00:24:55 in terms of natural talent in national life will be sport
00:25:00 and will be entertainment and music.
00:25:03 And so those are those areas.
00:25:05 And because, again, you see, I think there's a reason why we're especially vulnerable.
00:25:13 That increasingly, I talked about the fact that Scotland, Wales, Ireland have got away with these changes much more easily.
00:25:23 Nationalisms tend to be seen in so-called cultural terms.
00:25:27 That's funny music, funny clothes, whatever.
00:25:30 But, of course, being English has two aspects to it.
00:25:35 We never had a funny peasant dress.
00:25:40 For the simple reason, of course, we invent modern dress.
00:25:44 We're wearing a peasant dress.
00:25:45 No, it's not peasant.
00:25:47 Sorry, sorry.
00:25:48 Sorry, but it's really interesting to know what this is.
00:25:51 This is the new version of the English triumph.
00:25:56 The fact that a gentleman is supposed to be able to work,
00:25:59 that he can walk outside, that he can ride outside. 0.73
00:26:03 And what the English do is to replace the unbelievably elaborate French dress,
00:26:10 the abier, which is wonderful, beautiful, but you can step outside.
00:26:14 You'll be torn apart by the mob or you'll be stripped by the mob
00:26:17 because the clothes are so valuable.
00:26:19 And you replace it with what's essentially riding gear.
00:26:22 This is a modified version of the strong broadcloth that you can ride a horse in.
00:26:28 And it's a symbol of the rise of England as a new kind of power with a new relationship of the aristocracy to business and to the rest of the population and so on.
00:26:46 And this is true everywhere.
00:26:49 England appears not to have a culture because it invented everything that surrounds us.
00:26:55 It invents sport. It invents the days of the week. Le weekend. It invents the idea of the public, of the non-religious public holiday, the bank holiday. All of these things. It invents the language we speak. In other words, everybody speaks English. So you lose, you see what I mean?
00:27:16 you lose that sense of particularity.
00:27:20 And I think that this, again, is one of the reasons
00:27:23 why we never used to be a flag-wearing people
00:27:26 or flag-waving people.
00:27:28 No, it took me a long time to learn that.
00:27:30 Why it suddenly has become important,
00:27:33 because it's one of the few, as it were,
00:27:36 peculiarly English things, the flag of St. George,
00:27:39 or in extremis, the Union drag,
00:27:42 that you feel is very definitely yours.
00:27:46 And I think it is, again, I'm going to use class language,
00:27:50 I think it's particularly true if you belonged to what a Marxist would have called
00:28:00 the lumpenproletariat, the bottom of the pile, the unemployed, the badly educated.
00:28:08 And I think they're left feeling with nothing.
00:28:10 And I think that these council estates, because whenever you look at the great flag areas, that's what they are. 0.98
00:28:19 It's rather like Northern Ireland, where there's exactly the same phenomenon. 1.00
00:28:23 That this is the, and I feel a profound sense of, I think there's something in the proper sense of the word pathetic, there's pathos.
00:28:32 There's a sense of a very, very deep sadness,
00:28:39 a deep emptiness, a quest for some sort of meaning.
00:28:44 And I'm not sure what we can do to fill it.
00:28:48 Because, again, so much of the idea,
00:28:50 I mean, there always were very different ideas of Englishness.
00:28:54 There's the English gentleman, essentially refashioned
00:28:58 in the Victorian period with a particular form of dress,
00:29:01 a particular form of accent, a particular kind of deportment,
00:29:07 a whole series of language associations very, very strongly associated
00:29:12 with the tradition of the public school and so on.
00:29:16 There is, of course, the robust farmer.
00:29:19 There's the John Bull. 0.83
00:29:20 There was, of course, the archetypical trade unionist, the Bolshea trade unionist. 0.52
00:29:25 All of these characters, very few of them actually survive in the New England.
00:29:29 So can I pause this there a second?
00:29:32 Yeah, of course.
00:29:33 That's very interesting because the nature of trying to define Englishness to me is a very strange thing
00:29:40 because on one hand you can abstract out the forms of the people that you can see.
00:29:48 You can say, well, the English working class do this, the English middle class are incredibly pretty
00:29:53 and think of themselves better than they are, 0.99
00:29:55 and the English aristocracy have found their platonic form
00:30:00 in Jacob Rees-Marg, and you can form...
00:30:02 Who is half not English and certainly not an aristocrat.
00:30:08 I know, I know, I know.
00:30:11 His daddy was in trade.
00:30:12 He was the editor of the Times, yes.
00:30:14 Vulgar new money.
00:30:16 Anyway, so the point being...
00:30:17 But went to Eden.
00:30:19 But the point being, to abstract these things away
00:30:23 takes them out of the real world,
00:30:25 and they're no longer alive, what they are are essentially
00:30:28 ideological constructs that don't change over time.
00:30:31 No, they're memories.
00:30:33 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:30:34 No, no, that's...
00:30:35 But again, remember, archetypes have an enormous element
00:30:40 of living, they assume their own lives.
00:30:43 They do, and I'm not saying that the memory of them
00:30:47 doesn't change them over time or anything like that,
00:30:49 but essentially what we're saying is, oh, we've got a certain
00:30:53 set of categories of what it is to be an Englishman. And if you're not wearing your flat cap
00:30:58 in Yorkshire, then you're not a Yorkshireman, and things like this. And it becomes kind
00:31:01 of a photocopy of a photocopy, and a stereotype of a stereotype. And that's one way of looking,
00:31:09 and it's the weakest way. It's the way that's just waiting for a modern Diogenes to burst
00:31:17 into Plato's Academy and say, behold, an Englishman, to point at, say, Mothin Alley,
00:31:22 the deputy leader of the Green Party with his flat cap
00:31:25 and I'm from Sheffield. 0.97
00:31:26 And it's like, okay, but you're a Bangladeshi man, right?
00:31:30 So, you know, anyone, any child could say, 0.97
00:31:33 but the emperor has no clothes here.
00:31:35 And the alternative would be to say, 0.52
00:31:38 well, Englishness is what the English do,
00:31:41 which is why it's changed so much.
00:31:43 But that roots it firmly within the ethnicity of being English.
00:31:47 And it's not that other people...
00:31:49 You're assuming an extraordinary high degree of homogeneity.
00:31:54 Well, hang on, hang on.
00:31:55 What is this?
00:31:57 Let me carry on because I was going to say this is not homogenous
00:32:02 and it is not temporally bound either.
00:32:07 This changes over the centuries, right?
00:32:09 This changes a huge amount.
00:32:10 I mean, people don't realise just how phenomenally bizarre a conversation,
00:32:15 if you could even understand them, with like a 12th century Englishman 0.88
00:32:18 would be for your average Englishman now, right?
00:32:21 Genetically, there might be a completely concrete continuity,
00:32:25 but you would not understand what these people would do.
00:32:28 You would have no idea why he's angry
00:32:31 because you didn't go to the feast of St. Michaelmas
00:32:33 or something like that.
00:32:33 I don't know.
00:32:35 The point is, that is a more, how to say,
00:32:43 descriptive way of looking at it
00:32:46 that is actually more true to the fact of the thing,
00:32:50 because the stereotype of the thing,
00:32:54 you create a difference, a distance,
00:32:56 between what's the real thing that's happening
00:32:59 and what you expect to happen,
00:33:01 and that distance can grow and grow and grow
00:33:03 to the point now where, actually,
00:33:05 if you look around at the English,
00:33:08 they fit very few of the stereotypes
00:33:09 from the 20th century.
00:33:11 If anything, it's kind of sad to see
00:33:16 how distinct the English are from their own stereotypes.
00:33:20 The modern stereotypes are really unimpressive people,
00:33:25 and it's terrible to have witnessed.
00:33:29 You can go back and watch video footage
00:33:32 of just a random person on the street being stopped in the 1960s,
00:33:36 and you hear them speak, and they are fluent.
00:33:38 They can make their arguments.
00:33:40 They sound intelligent.
00:33:42 And this is just, you know,
00:33:43 and even if they've got a bit of a poorer accent,
00:33:46 They're still arguing their own case, but it's so different now as the average person is almost incoherent.
00:33:55 And I am just staggered at like the sort of goggle box watching public now compared to what you can see of just children talking in the 1960s.
00:34:07 The distinction is so different.
00:34:08 And so the idea that we need to be pinning anything on Englishness when we talk about the English is, like you were saying to me earlier, I think it's a bit of a red herring.
00:34:21 I think we've allowed a conversation to drag us to a place that we don't actually want to be.
00:34:26 Because I don't think the conversation about who is English has actually anything to do with that.
00:34:31 I think the conversation is actually about a feeling of demographic insecurity.
00:34:36 You know, I said that. It's because the only reason this question arises is because it's not really clear who is English and so on.
00:34:45 But I'm actually a bit worried, right? Because I think that when this is the question that is asked, there's, and especially given the answers that we're getting from the political class, right?
00:34:58 Nigel Farage, the Conservatives, the Labour Party, and further to the left, they all hit on the
00:35:06 fundamental, and I think what is perceived as a rather kind of disrespectful answer, which is
00:35:12 anyone can be English. And when you're asking that question, you're asking that question for
00:35:20 a pointed reason. Because what you're saying is, and like I said, I'm not endorsing anything,
00:35:26 but I think what is at the bottom of this conversation
00:35:30 is that a line is being drawn
00:35:32 and I think people are taking stock
00:35:34 of who is on what side of that line
00:35:36 and I think one day
00:35:37 they're thinking
00:35:39 we're going to expel people
00:35:41 on the other side of that line 1.00
00:35:42 I think that there's a sizable portion
00:35:46 of the country at this point
00:35:47 that would actually not object
00:35:50 if an Oliver Cromwell type figure
00:35:52 not that Cromwell did this
00:35:54 But if a figure just said, I have a new edict of the expulsion of the Egyptians that I'm going to pass, 0.57
00:36:03 and I'm going to stipulate a group, and that group can just go, 0.84
00:36:06 I think that that's what the question ends up leading to.
00:36:10 The Egyptian analogy is an unfortunate one. 0.99
00:36:13 They wanted to keep the Jews. 0.97
00:36:15 It was the Jews wanted to go themselves. 1.00
00:36:17 But yes, I do see your point. 0.97
00:36:22 but can we just remind ourselves of what's happened in America
00:36:25 where you had Trump doing a version of this?
00:36:29 You had ICE and it produced a profoundly hostile reaction, I think,
00:36:35 that we are where we are.
00:36:42 And again, can I just continue nibbling?
00:36:46 I know we're gnawing a bone, but can we continue gnawing the bone?
00:36:49 No, no, I'm happy to.
00:36:50 You see, I think, I'm casting my mind back to the discussion last night,
00:36:55 where it was quite a varied group in terms of the mainly male,
00:37:01 as you would expect from a group of conservatives.
00:37:04 You were talking about difference, spectacularly more formally dressed
00:37:09 than they would have been when I was a student.
00:37:10 Well, when I was a student, we were still wearing sports jackets
00:37:15 and cavalry twirls and whatever, but then the great shift of the end of the 60s.
00:37:19 The 60s really happened only at the very end of the 60s.
00:37:22 The 60s were really the 70s in terms of ordinary dress and behavior.
00:37:27 But most of them besuited, very respectable.
00:37:31 I mean, they actually stood up when I entered the room,
00:37:34 which, in other words, proper public school behavior, you know.
00:37:38 The great teacher enters and you all stand up.
00:37:42 Several of them, there were Koreans,
00:37:44 There were highly civilized, probably Hindu, I would imagine, in background.
00:37:52 And what was striking about many of those was that they had consciously assimilated 0.99
00:37:59 to those what we have been describing as half-dead visions of Englishness
00:38:05 and had done so in an astonishingly impressive way
00:38:10 and understood the substance of them.
00:38:14 And I mean, Suella, I think, is, I'm just picking up the case, is somebody who has thought very seriously on these questions, who is committed to those central ideals of the old Anglo-British state, not the new multicultural, cosmopolitan liberal state.
00:38:39 And I think, again, you see, I've got a version of the Tebbit test, which isn't who you support at sport.
00:38:51 It's what happens when you go into Westminster Abbey, a parish church.
00:39:00 Do you, and remember, I'm of completely non-Anglican background.
00:39:06 my religious origins are radical, leveling, Quaker, all of that sort of thing.
00:39:14 I've assimilated powerfully, deliberately, through what I do, how I behave, how I dress,
00:39:22 to that other world. And there's a thing that I call historical transcendence.
00:39:30 One of the reasons that I am, in my better moods, less despairing than we've been now,
00:39:36 is much of England still has this immensely powerful romantic quality.
00:39:45 Remember, we are a culture which is naturally profoundly nostalgic in every way.
00:39:53 There is always the awareness, anybody with any education,
00:40:00 that we are two cultures overlaid on each other.
00:40:03 the old Anglo-Saxon, and the new Norman, and the new French, that we have an amalgamated language.
00:40:11 There is again the awareness of the whole of that Catholic world, like the ruined monasteries and
00:40:18 whatever, Shakespeare's, many of Shakespeare's greatest poems, Colbert choirs and whatever, 0.94
00:40:23 and the sonnets, the awareness of that other world lying there, the world of pre-industrialization,
00:40:31 the world, you know, the world of Jerusalem, of Blake and whatever, the invocation of that green
00:40:39 and present land before it's smothered with industry. So there's this constant, as well as
00:40:44 the bigger harking back, the understanding of the parallels between the greatness of England
00:40:50 and the greatness of Rome, those two empires. You know, we are the only other, we are the only
00:40:55 other society that's given law, culture, language on a world scale, and shaping particularly
00:41:03 an alternative legal system.
00:41:05 So there's that awareness of these constant echoes.
00:41:08 And I think it's so powerful.
00:41:12 You see it with Chinese, you see it with Koreans, you see it with particularly Iranians, aware
00:41:22 of what's happened in their own country. 0.88
00:41:24 And that, so even if most of our own population are slouching around, growling inarticulately, there is this sort of meta-Englishment.
00:41:38 Yes, yes.
00:41:39 And because those values matter, and they're of huge importance, and they represent, I think, the core and essence of Western civilization.
00:41:52 there's nothing there I would disagree with
00:41:55 and obviously all of this
00:41:58 is music to my ears
00:41:59 this is and I
00:42:00 in my soul I find myself enchanted
00:42:03 by the romance
00:42:04 but I think
00:42:08 that this is
00:42:10 a carved iceberg
00:42:14 that is beginning to
00:42:15 melt and so
00:42:17 like if we are two polar bears on the iceberg
00:42:20 it's getting smaller and smaller
00:42:21 And whilst it was a beautiful iceberg, the demographic reality of the country as it is now is rendering the romantic view of England a wistful fantasy that for me, and I'm only 47, I remember the England of my childhood.
00:42:45 and okay it was still in the 1980s and 1990s so it's still modern but it was so much better
00:42:54 integrated to the continuity that we're talking about now and I really can see in especially the
00:43:03 the men in their sort of 20s and early 30s now but also in my own children there's something else
00:43:09 coming, right? There is a resentment that they don't live in that England. And they understand
00:43:15 fundamentally that it's being taken away because of a series of policy decisions that were made
00:43:21 that are damaging the sense of possession that the English have over their own land.
00:43:27 And I, like I said, I'm not advocating anything, but I can see the direction of travel. And I think
00:43:35 that our genteel arguments about integration and togetherness with immigrants and various other
00:43:46 people, I think these will fall on deaf ears when the problem is so overwhelmingly manifested in
00:43:56 their daily lives that I don't think they'll listen. And I think that, I think we're on a
00:44:03 course for something quite dark. And when we first set up Lotus Eaters, right, Bo and I were having
00:44:08 a discussion about what have we got to do. And Bo had a great turn of phrase. He said, well, we can't
00:44:16 disgrace England. And I'm worried that we are on a trajectory where something disgraceful will seem
00:44:25 like a perfectly logical thing. Like after you and me are gone and the problems haven't been solved
00:44:32 and the problems I think fundamentally come down to demography
00:44:35 that something disgraceful will happen
00:44:39 and we will have allowed this collectively to have come into being.
00:44:46 And that continuity that we're thinking of,
00:44:48 and I say this as someone, my father was in the RAF.
00:44:51 I spent in total eight years of my youth in Germany on a German camp
00:44:55 and part of that was up until about 17
00:44:58 and the drinking age in Germany was 16 for beer, 18 for spirits.
00:45:01 So what we would do is get on the local bus, and we'd go into Mönchengladbach, go drinking.
00:45:07 We had our passport, where we had our IDs from the camp.
00:45:11 So the Germans would say, oh, yeah, okay, you're 16, 17, here's some beers.
00:45:14 And they would give us giant flagons of beers.
00:45:16 And all the young Germans spoke English, because, of course, everyone did in the 1990s, and they do now. 0.86
00:45:21 The older Germans didn't, but that's fine. 0.90
00:45:24 We didn't learn any German, because they all spoke English. 0.88
00:45:26 And after five minutes of speaking to an Englishman, every German was talking about World War II. 0.52
00:45:31 Every German was talking about the Holocaust or Nazis.
00:45:34 And I don't want my grandchildren to have a burden like that on their shoulders.
00:45:38 I don't want us to have to go through terrible things. 0.93
00:45:41 And it just seems to me that this conversation of, oh, well, everyone is English. 1.00
00:45:46 No, that is not going to be sufficient for the young people now. 0.84
00:45:51 They do not believe it.
00:45:53 And, you know, all of those people claiming reparations from us don't believe it either.
00:45:57 and it is fundamentally disrespectful to the people who carry the heritage.
00:46:02 Yes, I mean, I think that clearly presenting it in straightforward demographic terms
00:46:11 leads to, well, the arguments of clashes of civilizations and whatever.
00:46:18 See, I wonder if there are, which I think we would both hope, forms of political solution.
00:46:26 And I think one of the things that's gone absolutely radically wrong, which again the
00:46:32 debate about Englishness illustrates, is we have two, as it were, cultural narratives,
00:46:41 or we have arguably two forms of legitimacy, or we have two groups of people. And I think the best
00:46:49 analysis of this is David Goodhart, the somewheres and the anywheres. And we have, particularly
00:46:57 in the machine, as you know, I've been saying for very long, but it seems a long time, it's
00:47:03 only two and a half years, I've been saying that what's gone, that you're focusing on
00:47:09 demography. I think there's also what's gone so wrong, very badly wrong with Britain, Anglo-Britain. 0.78
00:47:16 We all admit things have gone very, very badly wrong. 0.95
00:47:20 And I think the other thing that's gone very, very badly wrong is how we are governed.
00:47:25 Now how we are governed, as I constantly try to explain to people, changed more or less
00:47:31 at the same time you're talking about, the late 1990s, with the so-called Blairite, what
00:47:38 now is labelled actually the Starkey thesis.
00:47:40 The big changes that Blair brought about with the introduction of the Human Rights Act in
00:47:46 incorporating the European Convention on Human Rights and English Law,
00:47:51 the multiplication of huge numbers of expert bodies,
00:47:56 starting with the Bank of England Monetary Committee,
00:47:59 going through English Nature Climate Change Committee, whatever,
00:48:02 that flings about a third of state expenditure,
00:48:07 is dealt with by quasi-autonomous non-governmental organisations.
00:48:13 The one that ran, it's rather wonderful,
00:48:15 the headlines in the press today on the attempt that the abolition of the quango that ran the 1.00
00:48:21 NHS, it's so big that they can't abolish it. So they've had to set up a quango to abolish a quango. 1.00
00:48:31 And that is, there are 446 of these things. At the same time, things like the Human Rights Act 0.92
00:48:39 and the Equality Act and the creation of the Supreme Court mean that judges become ever more
00:48:44 political. And judges now decide, effectively, immigration policy, not politicians. Rishi Sunak
00:48:52 points this out over the whole Rwanda business. Judges now decide wages, because, incredibly, 0.97
00:48:59 the Equality Act has clauses, which, in fact, a series of equations, which introduce the Marxist
00:49:09 labour theory of value into English law. So saying, oh, I pay the market rate isn't a defence
00:49:16 anymore. Similarly, judges will now control rental because the Angela Rayner laws on this, 0.88
00:49:26 judges can control whether or not we can drill in the North Sea. There's a madness of it all.
00:49:36 But what that really means, Carl, and this is why this, I think, is directly relevant.
00:49:44 You now have a deliberate anti-political, anti-populist class running the show,
00:49:52 the so-called lanyard class. 0.63
00:49:54 And the lanyard class are signed up to a man and especially to a woman, 1.00
00:50:00 women being, you could argue that most of the new left is essentially female. 0.98
00:50:06 And that if you woke is a version of the Magnificat, it's a Christian heresy. 0.69
00:50:11 You know, if you remember the Virgin Mary after conceiving, there is he shall cast down the mighty from their seat and exalt them of low degree. 0.95
00:50:21 Well, if that's not woke, I don't know what is.
00:50:24 But this group is bound together by what I call, and what Disraeli, back in the 1860s, called cosmopolitan liberalism.
00:50:36 The fundamental belief that all human beings are the same.
00:50:42 And that's the origin of the English debate.
00:50:45 There's no point in debating Englishness because we're really all the same.
00:50:49 So these are just little local labels.
00:50:51 The other position, that's the liberal, the standard liberal position, and that's the standard liberal ideology.
00:50:59 But most people don't believe that.
00:51:02 As we know, conservatism is essentially a belief in locality and history.
00:51:12 This is why people like, with all their distinction, Roger Scruton made a terrible mistake at trying to produce a conservative philosophy.
00:51:20 There ain't no such thing.
00:51:23 There is no general conservatism.
00:51:26 Conservatism in America or in Germany or in France or Russia are all wildly different
00:51:30 because it's a localized, historically-based phenomenon.
00:51:36 It's about the constant pouring of new wine into old bottles.
00:51:43 And, of course, the old bottles, you know, a Russian bottle is jolly different
00:51:46 from a French bottle and even more different from an English bottle
00:51:49 and you couldn't possibly recognise it in Canada, could you?
00:51:53 But the bulk of the population operate in a quite different way
00:51:59 from our masters and rulers.
00:52:02 And they believe in the importance of place, of history, of belonging,
00:52:08 of the fact that it's not hatred, it's not xenophobia,
00:52:14 not the hatred of the foreigner, it's just that, well, we're different.
00:52:17 It's the recognition of the foreign.
00:52:18 It's a recognition of what is a fundamental human fact. 0.95
00:52:23 And I think this is where we've gone.
00:52:26 This is the fundamental reason we're in the mess that we are,
00:52:30 that we are dealing with a country in the same way when I talk about our government. 1.00
00:52:35 Our government is a mess because it's dealing with an unassimilated foreign body. 1.00
00:52:41 Yes. That our old, inductive, common law-based, traditionally rooted constitution has been partly overlaid with a new internationalist, deductive, liberal constitution. 1.00
00:53:00 and the two fight each other.
00:53:02 In the same way, a country which is a profoundly traditional country
00:53:08 like Britain, we are the paradox of being the country
00:53:11 that invents modernity and at the same time
00:53:14 has a profound conservatism.
00:53:16 And one of the things I'm so interested in is how you reconcile
00:53:20 those two things.
00:53:22 But we are a country that's fighting itself.
00:53:26 So it's not simply a question of demography,
00:53:29 that you are literally in a country where, consciously or unconsciously,
00:53:36 and increasingly it may become unconscious,
00:53:40 in which there are two contradictory value systems,
00:53:44 two very different views of right and wrong,
00:53:48 which is one of the reasons, of course, we're seeing so much suppression of freedom of speech.
00:53:54 There is a fundamental disagreement.
00:53:57 And, of course, on one side, the side of our masters, it's highly articulate.
00:54:02 On the side of those who are being sat upon and told either they mustn't express what they do believe
00:54:12 and they must believe what they don't believe.
00:54:15 There is both the suppression of speech and there is also compelled speech.
00:54:20 You are compelled to put your hand on your heart and say you believe in DEI, when, of course, you don't.
00:54:25 Now, I think this is where the conversation should be going.
00:54:30 But that also suggests to me, Karl, a degree of optimism.
00:54:35 These things, this new Blairite world, was brought in by law, by legislation.
00:54:44 It can be undone by legislation.
00:54:48 I completely agree on that.
00:54:50 Can I just conclude?
00:54:51 Because I think it's really important.
00:54:53 One of the problems on the right...
00:54:55 I mean, I was a friend of the late Peter Whittle.
00:54:58 I admire very much of what he did.
00:55:01 But this whole notion that this is a culture war
00:55:05 and a kind of clash of cultural systems,
00:55:08 well, it sort of is.
00:55:10 But insofar as the cultural system that we dislike has power,
00:55:16 it's because it's grounded in legal change.
00:55:20 Therefore, the way you deal with it isn't,
00:55:24 Well, I think you do have to shout about it and you do have to persuade people that the kind of things that it's brought in, however nice and cuddly, like human rights or equality, so-called equality, are in fact, in the way they've been done, profoundly dangerous and profoundly damaging.
00:55:41 And we've got a great deal of evidence for that.
00:55:43 But essentially what we on the right have got to do is to recapture law, which means
00:55:50 we have to recapture political power, which means, once again, one of the disasters that's
00:55:57 happened is the general degree of contempt into which the political class has fallen.
00:56:03 So the kind of despairing noises you were making are a product of the loss of confidence
00:56:10 in the political system to deliver what the majority of the population want.
00:56:17 And it seems to me our great task, your task, my task,
00:56:21 the task of all those of us on what I would call
00:56:24 with both a small R and a very large R,
00:56:27 the right side of politics, is to restore that faith.
00:56:32 Because that, again, is one of the things,
00:56:35 we were talking about violence, 0.99
00:56:36 one of the things that has distinguished Anglo-Britain
00:56:40 is that we learn to do without political violence, that we learned, I mean, look again at the
00:56:48 extraordinary contrast of how modernity in terms of something like democracy, vote for
00:56:57 everybody and whatever, the enormous contrast with how it happens here and how it happens
00:57:03 there. Here it happens, broadly, peaceably. There was obviously Peterloo, there were the
00:57:12 suffragettes and all the rest of it. But what… Compared to some places in the world,
00:57:16 that was very tame. It was tiny. Because what, of course, those outside the political system,
00:57:22 they weren't clamouring to bring parliament down. They were saying, we want to join.
00:57:28 We want to join. We want to join. And the complete contrast with the French
00:57:34 revolutionary tradition, we want to tear down. Again, and I think it's really
00:57:41 important we highlight these contrasts. I mean, everybody saw shots because it was
00:57:46 very terrible. Limoges is a little city I know a bit, and that fine town hall, and
00:57:53 You saw the Belfry collapse, and you felt, oh, this is awful.
00:57:58 But then we need to remind ourselves that in the French commune of 1871,
00:58:06 the heart of Paris goes up.
00:58:09 You burn down the great Hotel de Vienne in Paris.
00:58:12 You don't really do that.
00:58:13 We've forgotten, you know.
00:58:14 You actually burn down the equivalent of Buckingham Palace. 1.00
00:58:17 You burn down the Tuirie.
00:58:19 I mean, where you have the Louvre now, those two great wings going out,
00:58:23 There was a joining section in the middle, which was the main royal palace, and that
00:58:28 was Napoleon's palace, and that's burnt out and demolished.
00:58:33 Can you imagine?
00:58:36 That's part of that tradition.
00:58:38 Ours is radically different.
00:58:39 But the only way we can keep that difference, the only way we can keep that order, is not
00:58:45 by doing what Keir Starmer did after Southport.
00:58:49 It's not by, I am chief prosecutor.
00:58:53 not. That's a term which doesn't exist in English law. This is the kind of phrase
00:58:58 that you would use if you're in the Russian secret police or indeed in
00:59:03 France during the revolution where Fouquier-Tainville, the terrible state
00:59:08 prosecutor behind the terror, was such a feared figure. And we have to restore
00:59:16 this faith in the political process. In other words, the resolution of our
00:59:21 differences and and and and and disputes by debate by doing what we are doing now so I mean I
00:59:28 completely agree with you and I'm I'm personally I don't think of myself as a radical really uh
00:59:36 although I may say things that will seem radical um and I I certainly agree with you that anything
00:59:43 other than violence would be preferable anything um I'm I'm well learned enough in history to know
00:59:50 that civil wars are the worst kinds of wars.
00:59:52 The revolutions are appalling.
00:59:53 Yeah, they're awful.
00:59:54 And I'm very English in my disposition on this.
01:00:01 But there seems to have been a perverse inversion 0.95
01:00:07 of the natural order of the world to, I think, a lot of young people.
01:00:12 And I think they're growing very, very angry about it.
01:00:17 I like the point about they want to be brought
01:00:20 in. Now, if we look at what's happened in the last 30 years to our young people, it's
01:00:27 almost an inconceivable crime. They've brought in foreign peoples and given them higher regard 1.00
01:00:35 over their own on the basis of their race, on the basis of their religions, on the basis of
01:00:42 their differences. They get to be recognized at once as being foreign and unusual and a minority, 0.90
01:00:48 which gives you special privileges in this country. 0.99
01:00:51 I mean, look at Vikram Digwa stabbing Henry Novak.
01:00:55 I saw it literally described as the special privilege
01:00:57 that the Sikhs have to carry a weapon.
01:01:00 Well, okay, ask yourself 500 years ago, 1.00
01:01:04 should there be armed foreigners in England 0.72
01:01:05 while the English are disarmed? 0.98
01:01:07 No, absolutely not.
01:01:09 How can we tolerate such a thing? 1.00
01:01:11 Except don't we allow Scots to have a dagger. 1.00
01:01:14 Well, you know what I'm driving at. 0.95
01:01:17 No, but I'm so sorry, I'm semi-teasing.
01:01:20 I know, I know.
01:01:20 I'm semi-teasing.
01:01:21 I know, I know there are...
01:01:22 Look, Carl, I agree passionately, and I agree completely.
01:01:26 And I think that...
01:01:27 But just let me finish your point there.
01:01:29 Because it's the recognition and regard that the state is giving to the other,
01:01:36 and then in the same breath saying, but anyone is English.
01:01:40 You've already shown that you don't believe that,
01:01:43 which is why there's a suite of laws protecting them and not the English, 0.94
01:01:46 which is why they're getting DEI benefits and all this,
01:01:50 why they can still claim reparations right now.
01:01:53 And on the other side of their mouth, they can say,
01:01:55 but we're just as English as you.
01:01:57 The young people in this country are very much aware that this is a fiction
01:02:01 because our schools are starting to resemble prison yards.
01:02:04 All my kids are in school, and my kids have a much more heightened awareness
01:02:08 of the differences between groups than I ever had when I was a kid
01:02:11 because there was like one African kid, one Indian kid in the class, right?
01:02:15 Like, I hate to bring it back to demographics, but this is the world that they're living in.
01:02:20 They understand that there are real differences between people, and people are groupish.
01:02:25 People group with themselves.
01:02:27 And, okay, so that's that group, that's that group.
01:02:30 I mean, I had a conversation a few years ago with my son, because he said, Dad, are we Christians?
01:02:34 I was like, well, I mean, I'm a lifelong atheist, because my parents were atheist boomers.
01:02:39 And I was just like, well, in any other time and place, I would have said, no, we're just atheists.
01:02:45 But it became apparent that, OK, all the other kids in his class have an identity.
01:02:51 Which is primarily religious.
01:02:53 For him, it's primarily religious.
01:02:55 For my elder daughter, it's racial. 0.97
01:02:57 The black kids go over there.
01:02:58 The Indian kids go over there. 1.00
01:03:00 The Muslim kids, you know, the English kids stay over here.
01:03:04 They understand this is the world they're living in. 0.51
01:03:07 And now, so you've got this intrinsically collective groupish mentality.
01:03:11 and the government is saying you are the second tier of this.
01:03:17 And okay, if you were a worker in Dubai or something,
01:03:22 that might seem logical.
01:03:23 It's like, well, yeah, I moved from India to Dubai.
01:03:26 Obviously, I don't have political enfranchisement.
01:03:28 I'm here to work and then I'm going to go back.
01:03:31 We've done the opposite.
01:03:33 We've done the opposite. 1.00
01:03:33 We have imported a foreign ruling class as far as... 1.00
01:03:36 I think that's wrong. 1.00
01:03:38 They're not a ruling class,
01:03:39 a specially protected and privileged class.
01:03:42 Sure.
01:03:43 But sorry, it's really important.
01:03:45 Let me pick up on those points
01:03:47 because I think they're all very important.
01:03:49 I think there is absolutely no doubt,
01:03:52 and this is David Betts' big point,
01:03:54 that we are terrifyingly far advanced
01:03:57 into a form of sectarianism.
01:03:59 In other words, what you can call
01:04:01 the northern islandization of mainland Britain.
01:04:05 That is true, and it's very alarming.
01:04:07 And again, the thing that's so shocking about it, it flies against the entire policy of the English state. 1.00
01:04:16 The reason that England was England was from a very early point that you suppress clannishness. 1.00
01:04:23 You make sure that there is nobody that can say they're a community representative 1.00
01:04:28 because there's a specific cousinage or clientage or whatever it is behind them,
01:04:34 that we were all equal in the face of the king's law.
01:04:38 And this is the precondition, remember, for Anglo-Saxon universalism.
01:04:44 It is this idea that all citizens, even the noblemen in Britain,
01:04:48 had very, very few formal legal privileges.
01:04:52 He was vastly richer than other people, hugely richer than other people.
01:04:56 He had all the advantage of political access and all the rest of it.
01:04:59 But if he committed murder, he was hanged, but it was with a silken rope.
01:05:04 Yeah, that's it.
01:05:05 Have a silver rope if you like.
01:05:06 And of course, he could probably get off more easily
01:05:08 because better lawyers and connections or whatever.
01:05:11 But there was nothing like the principal difference
01:05:15 between the noble in France or the third estate or whatever.
01:05:21 There were not those legally separate categories.
01:05:25 And remember, this is the basis of the greatness of England.
01:05:30 This is why modernity happens here.
01:05:32 This is why this island, really with very few resources, becomes the workshop of the world, transforms the way the economies work, the way in fact the world becomes one, which is essentially brought about by that extraordinary thing called the British Navy.
01:05:49 So how do we deal with all of this?
01:05:55 And you, I think, were fusing two separate things again.
01:05:59 You began by talking about law.
01:06:01 You began by saying that the way the law works now actively privileges minorities. 0.58
01:06:10 In other words, two-tier justice and whatever. 0.97
01:06:13 The Nowak affair illustrating it with devastating, brutal clarity. 1.00
01:06:17 I believe so. 0.99
01:06:18 This is absolutely true.
01:06:20 But the solution is change the law.
01:06:26 And again, what's happened is the fact that we have group divided in the way you're talking about is the result.
01:06:37 Some people would argue, and I don't know enough about it to say whether I think it's true,
01:06:43 but there's a great deal of plausibility on its side.
01:06:47 That what happened with immigration into this country is that the traditional way in which we managed England, which, as I said, was by strict equality before the law, changed into how, for example, we managed British India, where you deliberately played groups off against each other.
01:07:11 In other words, we imported imperial politics along with the populations of parts of the empire into the mainland. 0.89
01:07:21 I'm glad you're saying this.
01:07:22 And I think, again, I don't know enough of my imperial history to know whether that's true, but it sounds very plausible.
01:07:31 And it is a terrible, terrible error.
01:07:35 So I think you're completely correct.
01:07:37 I've come to the same conclusion myself.
01:07:39 I've said the last country that's being occupied
01:07:41 by the British Empire is England, 0.99
01:07:43 and they seem to actually be intent
01:07:45 on reconstituting the empire in miniature in England.
01:07:49 In England.
01:07:50 Which is infirious.
01:07:51 And, of course, you get some people actually writing about it
01:07:55 as a kind of good thing, as an act of revenge.
01:07:58 Oh, absolutely.
01:07:58 As an act of revenge.
01:08:00 But once again, you see, I think that...
01:08:02 Well, sorry, can I pause on that?
01:08:03 Because that's what I mean, and this is why I'm worried.
01:08:07 Now, I'm not a natural warrior,
01:08:09 But I'm a big fan of ancient Middle Eastern history.
01:08:14 I don't know why, I just love it.
01:08:17 And ever since the time of the Assyrians, right through to the British Empire,
01:08:23 the imperial principle is to ignore national borders and use people as human capital.
01:08:28 So it doesn't matter where they're from, who they are,
01:08:30 the empire grabs them and makes them do something the empire needs done. 0.99
01:08:34 And that is the exact justification that we have for all immigration in this country. 0.99
01:08:39 It is, we need workers for the NHS, we need people to pay for pensions, we need people 0.99
01:08:43 for carers, we need bodies.
01:08:46 We all just grab them from wherever in the world and put them here.
01:08:50 And everywhere in all times, the imperial principle tramples on the national principle.
01:08:56 The national principle being, this is ours and belongs to us, how can you do this to
01:09:01 us?
01:09:01 And empires are transitory. Empires are never permanent, but nations are persistent.
01:09:08 And I can feel the national principle in England gaining a lot of power at the moment.
01:09:14 And I think that things happen that are not fair when the imperium has failed to understand the nation.
01:09:23 Yeah, but sorry, you're now introducing in some ways a willfully awkward concept because what we have is indeed two separate systems, as I was trying to point out before.
01:09:39 But, as it were, to revert back to the world of the ancient Middle East or whatever, I think confuses it.
01:09:47 That what we have, as I said, we have an elite that is committed to a degenerate and confused form of international liberalism, of cosmopolitan liberalism.
01:09:58 And a population that remains rooted in place in its sense of history, its sense of belonging, and so on.
01:10:06 But all the time, the solutions are not, talk about Nebuchadnezzar, fascinating though Nebuchadnezzar may be, the solution is to look at the law.
01:10:21 It's to win a political victory, but to win a political victory with a purpose, with an agenda, with an agenda which is to undo this stuff.
01:10:34 Yes, and we know it.
01:10:36 We know how to do it.
01:10:38 But again, can I come back?
01:10:43 You see, I understand completely, I think, why there is, for example,
01:10:50 today there is yet another report, yet another survey,
01:10:55 saying a large number of young people wouldn't fight for their country.
01:10:59 Now, we have to swallow a little bit hard on that one,
01:11:03 because remember famously the Oxford Union in the 1930s
01:11:07 similarly voted that it wouldn't fight the king.
01:11:11 Of course it did.
01:11:11 I didn't know that.
01:11:12 It's the most famous debate of the Oxford Union in the 1930s,
01:11:16 just before they all signed up and were heroes.
01:11:19 At least some of them were, and some of them,
01:11:21 it was from my university, they were all spies.
01:11:26 So we should be a little bit careful on that one.
01:11:29 The prospect of fighting when you're at peace
01:11:32 isn't necessarily a very happy one.
01:11:34 Wars have an energizing effect.
01:11:37 But the great problem is, I mean, let's look at the situation
01:11:41 we're in with the current war, the Ukraine.
01:11:45 The Ukrainian war and the notion we should be involved in it
01:11:48 is the most ludicrous of things for the very simple reason.
01:11:52 What is going on in the Ukraine? 0.82
01:11:54 Well, it's presented to us as the great offense 0.88
01:11:57 against the international liberal order, the rules-based order.
01:12:04 In other words, a sovereign state,
01:12:06 but Ukraine is challenged by another sovereign state, Russia.
01:12:09 But what's really going on is something very different.
01:12:13 It's a war of ethnogenesis.
01:12:16 It's a war rather like England and Scotland. 0.98
01:12:21 It is, are the people of the Ukraine a separate people 0.86
01:12:26 with a separate language, a separate history,
01:12:29 a separate territory, a separate tradition,
01:12:32 having been involved for forever
01:12:36 in either Poland-Lithuania as a completely separate quasi-state
01:12:44 or in the old Russian Empire.
01:12:47 And Putin's argument is explicitly they are not.
01:12:49 They are just a part of Russia.
01:12:50 Just let me conclude the parallel because it's so important. 0.91
01:12:54 In other words, what's going on in the Ukraine is a war about everything that you're not allowed to be here. 0.76
01:13:02 It's a war saying, are you Ukrainian? 0.91
01:13:05 It's the important thing that you are Ukrainian.
01:13:08 Is this territory yours?
01:13:10 Is this language mine?
01:13:12 Is that the others?
01:13:13 Is there to be a line of divide?
01:13:15 Now, all of that here, of course, you're not allowed to say.
01:13:18 You're not allowed to say, I'm in English.
01:13:20 This is my territory.
01:13:22 This is my language. 1.00
01:13:23 If you don't speak it, get the fuck out. 1.00
01:13:25 Otherwise, I will kill you, which is what is going on in the Ukraine. 1.00
01:13:29 So we have this absurd war, which is, in fact, 0.99
01:13:33 a deeply traditional sort of ethnogenesis, nationalist war,
01:13:38 being defended in terms of abstract international liberalism.
01:13:43 And the ludicrousness that our lads in the army,
01:13:46 who were really on the whole table...
01:13:49 I know you're in the British Army.
01:13:51 We really shouldn't talk about that.
01:13:53 Certainly you're not English, are you, really? 1.00
01:13:55 And by the way, an awful lot of them aren't. 0.65
01:13:58 You know many of our regiments now are filled with foreign mercenaries.
01:14:01 I didn't know that, actually.
01:14:02 That is indeed the case.
01:14:04 We are recruiting foreigners' troops.
01:14:07 I didn't know that.
01:14:09 Worth putting that in your memorandum book.
01:14:12 So we are in this absurd position
01:14:16 that all the things that you traditionally fight a war about, your flag, your frontier,
01:14:25 your faith, your home, we are told on the whole in really rather impolite terms.
01:14:31 And by the way, it's entirely legitimate for people to cross our frontier daily as we see
01:14:36 in the Channel. 0.60
01:14:37 What a silly idea we would defend it.
01:14:38 And by the way, isn't it laudable that the Royal National Lightboat Institution assists
01:14:44 the group?
01:14:45 All of this stuff.
01:14:46 The idea that the traditional patriotism, which, of course, was fundamentally embodied in the British army because your regiments were local.
01:14:56 They were the Norfolk Yeomanry or the Yorkshire, whatever it was.
01:15:00 They were based in places.
01:15:02 They drew directly on that sense of place.
01:15:06 Suddenly we were being told, well, no.
01:15:08 Oh, and the best descriptions of Britain draw on the general state of Neil Ferguson,
01:15:21 has written about this quite illuminatingly, although on other aspects of modern Britain.
01:15:26 I think he is much, much less well informed, but with a long parallel between us and the
01:15:32 Soviet Union in which you have an elite holding on to an extraordinary set of beliefs. The general
01:15:40 population knows is rubbish, but they have to pretend obey us. In the same way that you're 0.99
01:15:46 the worker proletariat or whatever, you all had to go through those motions in Soviet Russia by
01:15:52 the 1980s and 1990s. It was rubbish. But you get a few people insisting on, as I said, both the 0.97
01:16:01 suppressed speech and the compels speech to sustain it. We're in a very, very similar state
01:16:08 to that. Or, you know, it is Orwell. Orwell's 1984, the party represents exactly our lanyard
01:16:16 class. His descriptions of the people in it, the agitated school-mistressy women and all that sort
01:16:22 of thing, the etiolated homosexuals and whatever. The whole Orwell's portrait of the leftish 0.98
01:16:32 ruling class is one of magnificent, brutal cynicism. And then the proles below.
01:16:40 Yeah. So the point I'm trying to drive at, I think, is that there's a distinctly human
01:16:50 concern under all of this that is a collective concern that the lanyard-wearing liberal
01:16:57 individualists will never understand. The idea that you can say the English are not a distinct
01:17:06 ethnic group, everyone is English, and deny to the actual English kids that they don't have
01:17:14 a unique claim over England is something I think is going to have a lot of whiplash 0.94
01:17:19 when it becomes apparent
01:17:21 that they're just not going to tolerate it
01:17:23 because no matter...
01:17:24 I mean, they've been propagandists
01:17:25 their whole lives about this
01:17:26 and they don't believe it.
01:17:29 It's very much like your Soviet analogy.
01:17:32 The elite can say what they like,
01:17:33 but everyone can see that this is not the case.
01:17:37 And I'm...
01:17:38 Like I said, I'm not asking for anything,
01:17:41 but I can see some very non-liberal things
01:17:45 happening in the future.
01:17:46 Yeah, but sorry, I keep...
01:17:48 You're assuming this will continue to fester.
01:17:52 I am saying I see an alternative choice.
01:17:56 I see it, and I see it as our duty.
01:18:00 You're seeing it as your duty, it seems to me,
01:18:03 if I'm just listening to you, that you are going to be a Cassandra.
01:18:08 You will...
01:18:08 I don't want to be.
01:18:10 No, no, no, no, no, no, but you know that you will lament,
01:18:13 you will shed tears, you will wring your hands over the death of England
01:18:16 until there's a fate worse than Troy.
01:18:19 My position is completely different.
01:18:21 Well, I'm not in that position.
01:18:23 I do think we need to do things.
01:18:24 And I actually do.
01:18:25 I mean, I have agreed with literally all of your prescriptions
01:18:29 for fixing everything.
01:18:30 I mean, I completely agree.
01:18:31 But sorry, what I'm trying to say is that rather than forgive me,
01:18:38 and we're having a serious conversation amongst political friends,
01:18:42 right um you seem to me to be wallowing in what you've just described well um and i don't well i
01:18:50 do quite like wallowing rolling around especially with somebody else in it is jolly nice but but
01:18:55 but equally i'm afraid i'm married i i believe in as i said yeah politics as as as a solution
01:19:07 which is the non-violent solution.
01:19:10 And I think that our job is to recognize the problem,
01:19:13 as you've done, to highlight the problem,
01:19:17 but always when we highlight it,
01:19:19 to say this is the proper way to deal with it.
01:19:23 And the proper way to deal with it, forgive me, Carl,
01:19:26 is not, again, like Cassandra,
01:19:29 to see visions of ruin and rising smoke
01:19:33 and landslides and sort of Turner-esque horror.
01:19:39 It is to offer a sensible, proper politics that might work.
01:19:47 And this seems to me to be our task, and this is what we should be doing.
01:19:51 And I think we should pause this conversation here
01:19:53 because I am running out of time.
01:19:57 Just let me continue.
01:20:00 Running out of time.
01:20:01 And I think it would be, on the basis of the conversation we've had, I think we should have a second conversation which looks at what we would have to do with our politics to enable that benign solution as opposed to the Cassandra catastrophe.
01:20:22 yeah so just to so i i mean i completely agree with you on all of this right i'm actually a
01:20:31 very practical man and i in fact it's it often makes me quite unpopular uh in certain areas of
01:20:38 the internet where i say well actually getting some of what we want would be better than getting
01:20:42 none of what we want but having an ideological purity about ourselves so that that's no no
01:20:47 question for me and i completely agree with you that um this was all done by policy and it can
01:20:52 all be undone by policy and the re i mean i i particularly enjoyed your characterization i
01:20:58 think it was with stephen edgington um that uh the the blairite revolution is essentially i mean
01:21:03 i've characterized it as a slow motion french revolution is what they thought they were doing
01:21:07 and and it i completely agree with you completely agree with you um the the issue that i think that
01:21:16 we have is one that we've never had before. And it's not one that has a convenient parallel in
01:21:24 history. And so we haven't got a ready example to draw upon in order to, I mean, you always get
01:21:30 generals fighting the last battle, right? Every general fights the last war. And this is one of
01:21:36 those things that I would, I'm a big fan of military history. I would love to just say,
01:21:41 well, it's like this, it's like this. But I can see underpinning this one something that didn't
01:21:47 exist previously. And I hate to bring it back to demographics, but I think that's the thing
01:21:51 that's changed. And it has introduced a different problem into the discussion. I think Francis
01:22:00 Fukuyama, as you mentioned in one of your recent videos, I think he gets a lot of stick for The
01:22:05 End of History and The Last Man. But I think actually his Hegelian reading of liberalism
01:22:10 actually has some merit to it, as much as I oppose liberalism, in that recognition and
01:22:16 a sense of collective ownership, the thematic side of a person, is the thing that liberalism
01:22:22 has failed to actually account for.
01:22:23 And it is what we are witnessing springing up.
01:22:27 So the actions that we take have to understand that and be not tailored to it.
01:22:36 I don't want to, you know, draw, you know, prescriptions or anything like that.
01:22:41 But this is why, this is why, coming back to the question of why would the question be, well, everyone's English.
01:22:47 Who is English? What is English?
01:22:49 Well, that, that, that, it feels like subconsciously in the kind of collective unconscious of the country that a line is being drawn.
01:22:57 And that, that's actually quite a worrying thing because all of the, all of the positions that I, that you've mentioned, and I, and I agree with you on all of them.
01:23:05 they have real trouble when that line's been drawn.
01:23:09 That is a very unyielding line that I think a surprising number of people
01:23:14 are on the other side of.
01:23:15 And without respecting that collective sense of peoplehood
01:23:21 that the British state doesn't seem to want to respect at all,
01:23:27 none of the problems get solved, no matter what you do to the laws.
01:23:31 I think you're, forgive me, I think you are assuming that you have to confront that question of identity head on.
01:23:41 I don't think actually, there are some arguments, was Blair deliberately using immigration to rub the nose of the British people into it?
01:23:51 And there was probably an element of that.
01:23:55 But I think the basic endeavour was a very different one.
01:23:59 I think you're wrong when you say that we haven't had to do this before.
01:24:05 You see, you use that phrase, which actually is my phrase, the slow burn French revolution.
01:24:11 We had a real revolution.
01:24:13 I know.
01:24:14 And we took a decision to undo it.
01:24:16 And we did it in a way which no other country has ever done.
01:24:20 We did it without foreign intervention.
01:24:23 We took a decision that, on the whole, it had not turned out as we wanted.
01:24:27 And do you know what?
01:24:29 Wouldn't it be better to go back?
01:24:30 Now, I think, again, you may be right,
01:24:35 but the changes of modern Britain are so great
01:24:37 that our general former tendency to pull back.
01:24:44 You see, I would argue that going way, way, way back,
01:24:47 even to Magna Carta, the first Magna Carta is a disastrous document.
01:24:51 The 1215 Magna Carta would have turned us into an aristocratic republic
01:24:57 with a nominal monarch. 0.96
01:24:59 We would have finished up like Poland, dismembered.
01:25:02 And instead what happens is that collapses 0.78
01:25:06 and the following year you get a very conservative version of it
01:25:11 in which you cut out all the radical bits.
01:25:14 We commemorate the 1215 Magna Carta, we shouldn't. 0.73
01:25:18 We should commemorate the 1216,
01:25:20 which is a good conservative document
01:25:22 that keeps all the good bits about justice
01:25:25 and weights and measures and avoiding of river tolls and weirs
01:25:30 and all that stuff, and cuts out.
01:25:33 There was a committee of 25.
01:25:35 It was a genuine committee of public safety.
01:25:38 You were to swear, on the 2015 Magna Carta,
01:25:42 you were to swear an oath to the collectivity of the barons.
01:25:45 The barons authorised themselves to levy civil war against the king.
01:25:51 Disaster, all that goes.
01:25:52 And you come up with a good, sensible, level-headed, very British kind of thing with our first great conservative statesman, William the Marshal Earl of Pembroke, who was, of course, fighting Frenchmen.
01:26:04 But that's an entirely different matter.
01:26:08 But I think that sense has not yet fully gone.
01:26:16 I also think that all the things you describe, the tendency to northernization, the clanism, the sectarianism and whatever, all of these things are dealable with traditional English methods.
01:26:38 What we've done, we haven't applied them.
01:26:41 Everybody goes on about the problems of Islam. 0.89
01:26:44 Now, Islam, in terms of its claims to a complete religion, to a complete mode of life, to, as it were, a rationale that sits above the state, to the priority of religious law over secular law, to being an international body with the right, if you like, to use both assassination and terrorism. 0.96
01:27:09 All of that was true of a particular form of Roman Catholicism in the later 16th, 17th, and early 18th centuries. 0.64
01:27:19 And we had a legal system that coped with it without large-scale persecution and imposed certain straightforward rules.
01:27:29 I would revive something like those rules.
01:27:33 Because our great problem has been that the reason things have got out of control is 1.00
01:27:39 we have welcomed groups into the country, like entire villages from Bangladesh or whatever. 1.00
01:27:46 Mirpur.
01:27:48 Mirpur and whatever, without imposing our rules on them. 0.78
01:27:53 And that's the disaster. 1.00
01:27:55 In other words, what we've done is we've assumed that people who are intensely clannish 0.98
01:28:02 would suddenly become individualist when they come here. 0.94
01:28:06 And that's, of course, silly.
01:28:08 So the errors are ours.
01:28:10 And I want to stop on this point.
01:28:14 The errors are ours.
01:28:16 The mistakes are those we have made as a notion, as governments and whatever.
01:28:23 We have misunderstood. We've handled this process wrongly. On the other hand, in our earlier states of our political life, we confronted, this is where I disagree with you, we confronted very, very similar problems and we handled them well. And as always, there's one way you learn about them and it's called history. Thank you.
01:28:48 Thank you so much for joining me.
01:28:53 Thank you.