00:09:54first. So what you were able to do was to simply turn up the volume of the cultural
00:10:03nationalism. England is the problem because ours was that pride in
00:10:09institutions, in the distinction of our law, of our administration, in the
00:10:16superiority of our industry. Now it was top-nation nationalism. The great
00:10:22problem is when you stop being top nation. The book that I think, I'm surrounded here,
00:10:28with historical tat, a very powerful piece of historical tat you should include, which
00:10:35I think is one of the sharpest analyses of where we are, is 1066 and all that. Sellers
00:10:43and Yateman. It's a parody, it's a historical satire of the 1930s. I think it's brilliant,
00:10:52I mean, it has immortal lines, like it has a series of observations, for example, that every time the Irish solve the Irish question, every time the English solve the Irish question, the Irish change the question.
00:11:07The wonderful phrase about the fact that the royalists0.88
00:11:15are wrong but romantic, whereas the Puritans1.00
00:16:50You have parliamentary legislation on identity and ethnicity0.99
00:16:54and defining who is a citizen and who isn't.
00:16:57And so what you're getting with Defoe is you're flinging, Defoe is defending the new order, the new, if you like, internationalist order or the multiple order under William III.
00:17:14And he's saying to all of you people pretending to be native English, we've got special rights, saying you're not.0.96
00:19:41So in other words, what clearly is trying to happen is to create a civic identity, that is to say, that being English is simply a function of being born there, for a country that isn't a separate notion, that doesn't have a separate passport, which for most people would be sort of semi-ethnically defined.
00:20:08But remember, it's worth, I'm sorry, you said move on, go to the detail.
00:20:13Once again, it's really worth asking this question.
00:20:16For example, there's a famous immigrant family I'd like to talk about
00:20:21where people will boldly say that it's perfectly clear that these people are not English,
00:21:22And it also usurps the name of a well-known English family.
00:21:26And the other thing you do is you introduce all the rules,
00:21:30you will marry English people and all the rest of it.
00:21:32And if you look at some of you like Prince Charles now, he clearly is the quintessence of a certain view of Englishman with the elegance of dress, the careful restraint of manner, the perfectly formed accent, the slight diffidence despite the grandeur of his position.
00:21:53So, in other words, English is something that you can grow into.
00:21:59I mean, the commander of the armed forces, or was certainly a very high-ranking general,
00:22:07called de la Billière, who, when you met him, was the most English of people,
00:22:12or the keeper of the Queen's pictures, de Belague.
00:22:16In other words, these were French Huguenots over the process of time
00:22:20and completely melded into Englishness.0.86
00:22:22Now, that's fine. You see, I suspect that most of the problem arises. In what context did Kemi talk about English?
00:22:32Well, the context was that the discussion online had been focused around drawing a boundary between being English and not being English as an ethnic identity.
00:22:47And Sweller Braverman had the temerity to say, well, I'm not English.
00:23:40That there was a wonderfully naughty joke, and as this is a programme, I think we can tell naughty jokes.
00:23:48You're not going to get yourself cancelled again, are you?
00:23:49About the French football team playing the football team of, I don't know what, let's say it was the Congo, or it might even have been Algeria.
00:24:02And the joke was, it was the legal immigrants versus the illegal immigrants.0.88
00:24:06So I think it is the English football team and the fact that black athleticism means they are, in terms of population, enormously overrepresented in it, that presents this in a peculiarly acute form.0.87
00:24:23And the people that figure as, surely this black, because it is black, is English, will be Lenny Henry.
00:24:33There will be a whole range of football players.0.82
00:26:19And you replace it with what's essentially riding gear.
00:26:22This is a modified version of the strong broadcloth that you can ride a horse in.
00:26:28And it's a symbol of the rise of England as a new kind of power with a new relationship of the aristocracy to business and to the rest of the population and so on.
00:26:49England appears not to have a culture because it invented everything that surrounds us.
00:26:55It invents sport. It invents the days of the week. Le weekend. It invents the idea of the public, of the non-religious public holiday, the bank holiday. All of these things. It invents the language we speak. In other words, everybody speaks English. So you lose, you see what I mean?
00:34:08And so the idea that we need to be pinning anything on Englishness when we talk about the English is, like you were saying to me earlier, I think it's a bit of a red herring.
00:34:21I think we've allowed a conversation to drag us to a place that we don't actually want to be.
00:34:26Because I don't think the conversation about who is English has actually anything to do with that.
00:34:31I think the conversation is actually about a feeling of demographic insecurity.
00:34:36You know, I said that. It's because the only reason this question arises is because it's not really clear who is English and so on.
00:34:45But I'm actually a bit worried, right? Because I think that when this is the question that is asked, there's, and especially given the answers that we're getting from the political class, right?
00:34:58Nigel Farage, the Conservatives, the Labour Party, and further to the left, they all hit on the
00:35:06fundamental, and I think what is perceived as a rather kind of disrespectful answer, which is
00:35:12anyone can be English. And when you're asking that question, you're asking that question for
00:35:20a pointed reason. Because what you're saying is, and like I said, I'm not endorsing anything,
00:35:26but I think what is at the bottom of this conversation
00:38:14And I mean, Suella, I think, is, I'm just picking up the case, is somebody who has thought very seriously on these questions, who is committed to those central ideals of the old Anglo-British state, not the new multicultural, cosmopolitan liberal state.
00:38:39And I think, again, you see, I've got a version of the Tebbit test, which isn't who you support at sport.
00:38:51It's what happens when you go into Westminster Abbey, a parish church.
00:39:00Do you, and remember, I'm of completely non-Anglican background.
00:39:06my religious origins are radical, leveling, Quaker, all of that sort of thing.
00:39:14I've assimilated powerfully, deliberately, through what I do, how I behave, how I dress,
00:39:22to that other world. And there's a thing that I call historical transcendence.
00:39:30One of the reasons that I am, in my better moods, less despairing than we've been now,
00:39:36is much of England still has this immensely powerful romantic quality.
00:39:45Remember, we are a culture which is naturally profoundly nostalgic in every way.
00:39:53There is always the awareness, anybody with any education,
00:40:00that we are two cultures overlaid on each other.
00:40:03the old Anglo-Saxon, and the new Norman, and the new French, that we have an amalgamated language.
00:40:11There is again the awareness of the whole of that Catholic world, like the ruined monasteries and
00:40:18whatever, Shakespeare's, many of Shakespeare's greatest poems, Colbert choirs and whatever,0.94
00:40:23and the sonnets, the awareness of that other world lying there, the world of pre-industrialization,
00:40:31the world, you know, the world of Jerusalem, of Blake and whatever, the invocation of that green
00:40:39and present land before it's smothered with industry. So there's this constant, as well as
00:40:44the bigger harking back, the understanding of the parallels between the greatness of England
00:40:50and the greatness of Rome, those two empires. You know, we are the only other, we are the only
00:40:55other society that's given law, culture, language on a world scale, and shaping particularly
00:42:21And whilst it was a beautiful iceberg, the demographic reality of the country as it is now is rendering the romantic view of England a wistful fantasy that for me, and I'm only 47, I remember the England of my childhood.
00:42:45and okay it was still in the 1980s and 1990s so it's still modern but it was so much better
00:42:54integrated to the continuity that we're talking about now and I really can see in especially the
00:43:03the men in their sort of 20s and early 30s now but also in my own children there's something else
00:43:09coming, right? There is a resentment that they don't live in that England. And they understand
00:43:15fundamentally that it's being taken away because of a series of policy decisions that were made
00:43:21that are damaging the sense of possession that the English have over their own land.
00:43:27And I, like I said, I'm not advocating anything, but I can see the direction of travel. And I think
00:43:35that our genteel arguments about integration and togetherness with immigrants and various other
00:43:46people, I think these will fall on deaf ears when the problem is so overwhelmingly manifested in
00:43:56their daily lives that I don't think they'll listen. And I think that, I think we're on a
00:44:03course for something quite dark. And when we first set up Lotus Eaters, right, Bo and I were having
00:44:08a discussion about what have we got to do. And Bo had a great turn of phrase. He said, well, we can't
00:44:16disgrace England. And I'm worried that we are on a trajectory where something disgraceful will seem
00:44:25like a perfectly logical thing. Like after you and me are gone and the problems haven't been solved
00:44:32and the problems I think fundamentally come down to demography
00:49:54And the lanyard class are signed up to a man and especially to a woman,1.00
00:50:00women being, you could argue that most of the new left is essentially female.0.98
00:50:06And that if you woke is a version of the Magnificat, it's a Christian heresy.0.69
00:50:11You know, if you remember the Virgin Mary after conceiving, there is he shall cast down the mighty from their seat and exalt them of low degree.0.95
00:50:21Well, if that's not woke, I don't know what is.
00:50:24But this group is bound together by what I call, and what Disraeli, back in the 1860s, called cosmopolitan liberalism.
00:50:36The fundamental belief that all human beings are the same.
00:50:42And that's the origin of the English debate.
00:50:45There's no point in debating Englishness because we're really all the same.
00:52:26This is the fundamental reason we're in the mess that we are,
00:52:30that we are dealing with a country in the same way when I talk about our government.1.00
00:52:35Our government is a mess because it's dealing with an unassimilated foreign body.1.00
00:52:41Yes. That our old, inductive, common law-based, traditionally rooted constitution has been partly overlaid with a new internationalist, deductive, liberal constitution.1.00
00:55:10But insofar as the cultural system that we dislike has power,
00:55:16it's because it's grounded in legal change.
00:55:20Therefore, the way you deal with it isn't,
00:55:24Well, I think you do have to shout about it and you do have to persuade people that the kind of things that it's brought in, however nice and cuddly, like human rights or equality, so-called equality, are in fact, in the way they've been done, profoundly dangerous and profoundly damaging.
00:55:41And we've got a great deal of evidence for that.
00:55:43But essentially what we on the right have got to do is to recapture law, which means
00:55:50we have to recapture political power, which means, once again, one of the disasters that's
00:55:57happened is the general degree of contempt into which the political class has fallen.
00:56:03So the kind of despairing noises you were making are a product of the loss of confidence
00:56:10in the political system to deliver what the majority of the population want.
00:56:17And it seems to me our great task, your task, my task,
00:56:21the task of all those of us on what I would call
01:05:32This is why this island, really with very few resources, becomes the workshop of the world, transforms the way the economies work, the way in fact the world becomes one, which is essentially brought about by that extraordinary thing called the British Navy.
01:06:26And again, what's happened is the fact that we have group divided in the way you're talking about is the result.
01:06:37Some people would argue, and I don't know enough about it to say whether I think it's true,
01:06:43but there's a great deal of plausibility on its side.
01:06:47That what happened with immigration into this country is that the traditional way in which we managed England, which, as I said, was by strict equality before the law, changed into how, for example, we managed British India, where you deliberately played groups off against each other.
01:07:11In other words, we imported imperial politics along with the populations of parts of the empire into the mainland.0.89
01:09:01And empires are transitory. Empires are never permanent, but nations are persistent.
01:09:08And I can feel the national principle in England gaining a lot of power at the moment.
01:09:14And I think that things happen that are not fair when the imperium has failed to understand the nation.
01:09:23Yeah, but sorry, you're now introducing in some ways a willfully awkward concept because what we have is indeed two separate systems, as I was trying to point out before.
01:09:39But, as it were, to revert back to the world of the ancient Middle East or whatever, I think confuses it.
01:09:47That what we have, as I said, we have an elite that is committed to a degenerate and confused form of international liberalism, of cosmopolitan liberalism.
01:09:58And a population that remains rooted in place in its sense of history, its sense of belonging, and so on.
01:10:06But all the time, the solutions are not, talk about Nebuchadnezzar, fascinating though Nebuchadnezzar may be, the solution is to look at the law.
01:10:21It's to win a political victory, but to win a political victory with a purpose, with an agenda, with an agenda which is to undo this stuff.
01:20:01And I think it would be, on the basis of the conversation we've had, I think we should have a second conversation which looks at what we would have to do with our politics to enable that benign solution as opposed to the Cassandra catastrophe.
01:20:22yeah so just to so i i mean i completely agree with you on all of this right i'm actually a
01:20:31very practical man and i in fact it's it often makes me quite unpopular uh in certain areas of
01:20:38the internet where i say well actually getting some of what we want would be better than getting
01:20:42none of what we want but having an ideological purity about ourselves so that that's no no
01:20:47question for me and i completely agree with you that um this was all done by policy and it can
01:20:52all be undone by policy and the re i mean i i particularly enjoyed your characterization i
01:20:58think it was with stephen edgington um that uh the the blairite revolution is essentially i mean
01:21:03i've characterized it as a slow motion french revolution is what they thought they were doing
01:21:07and and it i completely agree with you completely agree with you um the the issue that i think that
01:21:16we have is one that we've never had before. And it's not one that has a convenient parallel in
01:21:24history. And so we haven't got a ready example to draw upon in order to, I mean, you always get
01:21:30generals fighting the last battle, right? Every general fights the last war. And this is one of
01:21:36those things that I would, I'm a big fan of military history. I would love to just say,
01:21:41well, it's like this, it's like this. But I can see underpinning this one something that didn't
01:21:47exist previously. And I hate to bring it back to demographics, but I think that's the thing
01:21:51that's changed. And it has introduced a different problem into the discussion. I think Francis
01:22:00Fukuyama, as you mentioned in one of your recent videos, I think he gets a lot of stick for The
01:22:05End of History and The Last Man. But I think actually his Hegelian reading of liberalism
01:22:10actually has some merit to it, as much as I oppose liberalism, in that recognition and
01:22:16a sense of collective ownership, the thematic side of a person, is the thing that liberalism
01:22:49Well, that, that, that, it feels like subconsciously in the kind of collective unconscious of the country that a line is being drawn.
01:22:57And that, that's actually quite a worrying thing because all of the, all of the positions that I, that you've mentioned, and I, and I agree with you on all of them.
01:23:05they have real trouble when that line's been drawn.
01:23:09That is a very unyielding line that I think a surprising number of people
01:25:52And you come up with a good, sensible, level-headed, very British kind of thing with our first great conservative statesman, William the Marshal Earl of Pembroke, who was, of course, fighting Frenchmen.
01:26:08But I think that sense has not yet fully gone.
01:26:16I also think that all the things you describe, the tendency to northernization, the clanism, the sectarianism and whatever, all of these things are dealable with traditional English methods.
01:26:41Everybody goes on about the problems of Islam.0.89
01:26:44Now, Islam, in terms of its claims to a complete religion, to a complete mode of life, to, as it were, a rationale that sits above the state, to the priority of religious law over secular law, to being an international body with the right, if you like, to use both assassination and terrorism.0.96
01:27:09All of that was true of a particular form of Roman Catholicism in the later 16th, 17th, and early 18th centuries.0.64
01:27:19And we had a legal system that coped with it without large-scale persecution and imposed certain straightforward rules.
01:27:29I would revive something like those rules.
01:27:33Because our great problem has been that the reason things have got out of control is1.00
01:27:39we have welcomed groups into the country, like entire villages from Bangladesh or whatever.1.00
01:28:16The mistakes are those we have made as a notion, as governments and whatever.
01:28:23We have misunderstood. We've handled this process wrongly. On the other hand, in our earlier states of our political life, we confronted, this is where I disagree with you, we confronted very, very similar problems and we handled them well. And as always, there's one way you learn about them and it's called history. Thank you.