The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad - July 02, 2026


Discussing Suicidal Empathy at the Salem Center at UT-Austin (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_1013)

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Chat with Piers Morgan - On Gabor Mate, Elon Musk, Migration & Grooming Gangs (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_1012) American Exceptionalism, The Scorpion and the Frog Fable, and Zohran Mamdani (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_1014)

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 38 minutes

Words per minute

144.16

Word count

14,172

Sentence count

725

Harmful content

Misogyny

13

sentences flagged

Toxicity

76

sentences flagged

Hate speech

63

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Dr. Gad Saad discusses the neuroparasitological framework for understanding the parasitic mind and suicidal empathy, and how they work together to form a kinder, gentler world. He also discusses his new book, The Sad Truth about Happiness, and his new podcast, "The Sad Truth About Happiness."

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Well, good evening. I'm honored to be able to introduce to you Gad Saad, Professor of Marketing
00:00:05 at Concordia University in Montreal, Advisory Fellow at the University's Center for Inquiry.
00:00:11 He's taught at Cornell University, Dartmouth College, Northwood University, and the University
00:00:16 of California at Irvine. He's also a visiting scholar at the Declaration of Independence Center
00:00:21 for the Study of American Freedom at the University of Mississippi. He's not your
00:00:26 average business school professor. He's an accomplished, energetic, and creative evolutionary
00:00:31 psychologist who pioneered the application of evolutionary psychology to marketing and
00:00:36 consumer behavior. His works have garnered more than 5,400 citations. Gad's research breaks new
00:00:44 theoretical ground. It's also remarkably useful. I recommend his paper, Gender Differences in
00:00:50 Information Search Strategies, for a Christmas gift for anyone who's wrestled with the question
00:00:55 of what to get that special someone.
00:00:57 He's also a passionate public intellectual,
00:01:00 someone who defends science, reason, and common sense
00:01:03 against the many forces,
00:01:05 academic, political, and psychological, that assail them.
00:01:09 His books include The Evolutionary Bases of Consumption,
00:01:12 The Consuming Instinct,
00:01:14 What Juicy Burgers, Ferraris, Pornography, and Gift-Giving
00:01:17 Reveal About Human Nature, 0.70
00:01:19 The Parasitic Mind,
00:01:21 How Infectious Ideas Are Killing Common Sense,
00:01:23 the sad truth about happiness eight secrets for leading the good life and finally now suicidal
00:01:31 empathy dying to be kind he's also a prolific blogger his podcast the sad truth has more than
00:01:39 363 000 subscribers and over 43 million views its motto the truth can hurt the truth can set you free
00:01:49 but you can't hide from the sad truth.
00:01:52 Can you handle the truth?
00:01:54 If so, please welcome Gad Saad.
00:02:01 Thank you all for coming.
00:02:07 We were in a bit of a pickle
00:02:09 because we didn't want to promote it too much
00:02:11 because there's often security concerns.
00:02:14 So notwithstanding,
00:02:16 Notwithstanding not much of a promotional campaign, it's lovely to see many of you taking
00:02:21 the time to be here.
00:02:22 So I wanted to maybe spend 10, 15 minutes giving you a broad overview of both the parasitic
00:02:30 mind and suicidal empathy, how they sort of cover a full narrative, and then we'll have
00:02:36 a fireside chat, and then hopefully we'll have a bit of time to open it up for a moderated
00:02:41 Q&A.
00:02:42 So my background is in psychology of decision-making.
00:02:47 You know, how do people make choices?
00:02:49 How much information do people look at before they commit to a choice?
00:02:53 And while training within that paradigm, I studied things like axiomatic rationality.
00:03:00 So many of you who know, for example, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, they talk about axiomatic rationality.
00:03:07 rationality. If I prefer car A to car B, and I prefer car B to car C, I should prefer car A to
00:03:14 car C. If I don't do that, I'm being axiomatically irrational. So there are very tight definitions
00:03:22 of rationality. But in my recent books, I'm talking about another form of irrationality.
00:03:29 This is the irrationality that causes us to now engage into a debate as to what constitutes
00:03:36 male or female, right? Until 15 minutes ago, the 117 billion people that had existed on Earth
00:03:44 seemed to have been able to adjudicate through this very difficult conundrum of what constitutes
00:03:49 male or female very easily. But 15 minutes ago, we were no longer able to do that. Well,
00:03:54 this is a type of irrationality that really begs to be explained. When people tell you that there
00:04:01 are no objective truths everything is shackled by our personal biases therefore the scientific
00:04:08 method is inherently suspect that's a form of epistemological irrationality and so in the
00:04:15 parasitic mind I was trying to understand how is it that people can hold such parasitic thoughts
00:04:23 because if I really want to hijack your ability to think I have to hijack two elements your 0.90
00:04:30 cognitive system your thinking processes and your affective system your emotional system
00:04:35 parasitic mind deals with your cognitive system suicidal empathy deals with your affective system
00:04:42 if i can hijack both of these systems then i own your ability to to think or or not think
00:04:49 to depart from thinking but let me explain very briefly what why i use the neuroparasitological
00:04:55 framework. And then I will get into a bit of what suicidal empathy is about, which, by the way, is
00:05:01 literally out tomorrow. So suicidal empathy is now a term and concept that has really seeped its way
00:05:09 into the, you know, the daily parlance, the daily lexicon in many languages. And some people are
00:05:17 surprised that it hasn't been out, which I guess speaks to the fact that it has really resonated
00:05:21 with people. So I'm incredibly excited that finally tomorrow it'll be out. So anyway, so
00:05:27 in the animal kingdom, we study parasite-host interactions, right? And so there are many,
00:05:35 many examples of these. So a tapeworm can parasitize your intestinal tract, okay? That
00:05:43 would be an example of a parasite. But a neuroparasite is a parasite that ultimately
00:05:49 needs to get to the host's brain, altering its neuronal circuitry, typically to suit its
00:05:57 reproductive interest. So for example, a wood cricket, many of you maybe have heard me mention
00:06:03 this example, a wood cricket abhors water. It wants nothing to do with water. But when it is
00:06:09 parasitized by a hair worm, the hair worm needs the wood cricket to merrily commit suicide,
00:06:16 and suicidal empathy jump into water commit suicide because the hair worm needs to complete
00:06:22 its reproductive cycle in water so once that hapless wood cricket has been zombified it
00:06:30 loses its ability to pursue its survival instinct right and so what i argue in in suicidal empathy
00:06:39 is very different from what already the hit pieces
00:06:45 that are coming out on the book,
00:06:46 even though people haven't read it,
00:06:47 because by definition, my publisher wouldn't have sent it
00:06:51 to some of the people who would hold animus against me.
00:06:55 And so they're writing these articles
00:06:57 without even having granted me the courtesy
00:06:59 of having read the book,
00:07:00 but that's the way it is in the public sphere.
00:07:04 And so the general timber of their attacks
00:07:07 is the following one.
00:07:08 so let me sort of address it off the bat.
00:07:12 They usually argue that I am, you know, a neocon.
00:07:17 You know, I'm connected with Elon Musk and Donald Trump.
00:07:20 I'm trying to usher a dark world where empathy is no longer, you know, a valued trait.
00:07:30 I'm doing no such thing.
00:07:32 Empathy is a perfectly laudable virtue.
00:07:36 As a social species, we are expected to have evolved empathy as a trait.
00:07:43 Why?
00:07:44 Because as a social species, for you and I to have a meaningful conversation, I need
00:07:50 to put myself in your mind and vice versa.
00:07:53 This is called theory of mind, which is a feature of cognitive empathy, right?
00:07:58 Autistic children typically fail a theory of mind test, and that's how you diagnose
00:08:03 them as being autistic.
00:08:05 So there's nothing wrong with empathy per se.
00:08:08 It's wonderful.
00:08:09 We try to choose our closest friends if they are, hopefully they are empathetic.
00:08:14 We, both men and women, would love to be with spouses who are empathetic.
00:08:18 If we're choosing our physicians and therapists and vets, we want them to be empathetic.
00:08:24 So this is not an attack on empathy.
00:08:27 It's an attack on dysregulated empathy.
00:08:31 Now, what does that mean?
00:08:32 Before I explain what I mean by suicidal empathy, let me draw you an analogy from another psychiatric condition.
00:08:41 If I were to notice that one of you was sneezing frequently into their hands while you're listening to me lecture,
00:08:51 and then later you came up to shake my hand,
00:08:54 I would have probably coded the fact that you might be suffering from a cold or a flu that I prefer not to catch.
00:09:04 And so after I shake your hand, I will hopefully discreetly go off to the bathroom, wash my hands so that I have avoided this germ contamination.
00:09:14 So I did scan the environment for potential threats, and I acted accordingly.
00:09:20 So to scan the environment for potential threats is a perfectly rational evolutionary mechanism.
00:09:27 What isn't rational, hence it becomes dysregulated, is if I say suffered from germ contamination fears, as would be the case with OCD,
00:09:38 I would be stuck in the bathroom for eight hours, and it's stuck in an infinite loop,
00:09:44 washing my hands until my skin was falling off due to the scaldingly hot water.
00:09:51 So what was adaptive in the case of me tending to you sneezing in your hands
00:09:56 becomes maladaptive once it hyperfires, right?
00:10:01 Healthy cells multiply, cancer cells multiply, but cancer cells don't have a stopping policy
00:10:13 whereby they stop multiplying at a particular point, right?
00:10:18 So there are many, many maladies that are really the maladaptive instantiation of an
00:10:27 otherwise adaptive process.
00:10:28 That's what suicidal empathy is.
00:10:31 And now let me link it back to an ancient philosopher.
00:10:38 Many of you undoubtedly are familiar with Aristotle.
00:10:42 In his Nicomachean ethics, Aristotle spoke about the golden mean,
00:10:48 or I would call it the inverted U.
00:10:51 Too little of something is not good, too much of something is not good,
00:10:55 and much of life is about finding that middle sweet spot.
00:10:59 In the case of Aristotle, he was talking about, for example, a soldier.
00:11:04 If the soldier doesn't exhibit enough courage, he's cowardly.
00:11:09 That's probably not a good trait for a soldier to have.
00:11:12 If he exhibits an abundance of dysregulated courage, then he's probably going to die very
00:11:18 quickly and be a reckless martyr.
00:11:20 Somewhere in the middle is the optimal level of courage for the soldier to exhibit.
00:11:27 Same applies to empathy.
00:11:28 If I have little to no empathy, I'm called a psychopath.
00:11:34 And if I have too much empathy, as is the case in what I'm talking about in the book,
00:11:39 so it hyperactivates, it hyperfires, in the wrong situations towards the wrong targets,
00:11:47 then you get suicidal empathy.
00:11:49 And so let me give you an example of what would constitute targeting your empathy towards the wrong target.
00:11:56 let's suppose you have the trolley problem you all have maybe heard of the trolley problem a classic
00:12:03 you know experiment where you tell people there's a trolley that's barreling down and it's either
00:12:12 going to hit three of your biological children or you can pull a lever and then it could be
00:12:18 diverted and hit five random strangers well if the catalyst was simply how many people die in each 0.99
00:12:26 of the two options, you should always say, well, it'll be much better that it kills my 0.99
00:12:31 three children, because three is smaller than five. 0.94
00:12:34 But I bet that no one in this room would say, I would be willing to give up my three biological
00:12:40 children for five random people.
00:12:43 Now, I know it sounds like a sinister example, but it demonstrates that our emotional system
00:12:50 and our cognitive system has evolved to met out investments, resources, empathy, love in
00:13:00 strategically relevant ways as would be dictated by an evolutionary calculus. So for example, I've
00:13:06 done studies with some of my former doctoral students where we've looked at how do people
00:13:12 allocate their gift-giving budgets. And not surprisingly, people allocate their gift-giving
00:13:18 budgets in ways that are perfectly informed by an evolutionary calculus.
00:13:23 Few people give larger gifts to their second cousins than they do to their siblings.
00:13:31 Your siblings are on average, they share 50% of your genes with you.
00:13:36 Your second cousins share 6.25% of your genes.
00:13:41 And therefore, it makes sense that the way that I allocate my gift-giving budget would
00:13:46 would be consistent with some evolutionarily relevant metrics.
00:13:52 Suicidal empathy negates all that.
00:13:55 It basically says, when having to choose
00:13:59 between Guatemalan illegal migrants
00:14:04 or American vets who have fought for American liberties
00:14:08 and lost their limbs, 0.92
00:14:10 choose the Guatemalan illegal immigrants every time. 1.00
00:14:14 When deciding whether you should be empathetic towards rape victims or rapists of color, 1.00
00:14:23 well, then you've got to empathize with the rapist. 0.89
00:14:26 He's probably grown up in a white supremacist society, so we should probably be kind to him.
00:14:31 We should maybe give him a 187th chance at a second chance in life, right?
00:14:38 Suicidal empathy is saying that it is inherently evil
00:14:42 for there to be income that is not equal across all individuals.
00:14:49 Therefore, there should be some benevolent overlord
00:14:51 that redistributes your income
00:14:53 so that we live in a more equitable and empathetic society.
00:14:57 So communism, by the way, is very much justified
00:15:01 through an appeal to empathy, right?
00:15:04 Good people should not tolerate billionaires existing while other people are on food stamps.
00:15:11 Give up your money.
00:15:12 Be empathetic. 0.58
00:15:14 Empathy is what causes rape victims to empathize with their rapists.
00:15:22 I'm here to tell you as an evolutionary psychologist that our emotional system did not evolve to empathize with our rapists.
00:15:30 And I'll give you maybe one or two stories, but there are many, many of these that are documented in the book.
00:15:37 Early in the book, I talk about the example of a Norwegian man who was raped by a Somali migrant in Norway. 0.66
00:15:47 And after the Somali migrant was caught, because the Norwegians are on a higher plane of enlightenment,
00:15:54 and they don't believe in very severe, stiff punishments.
00:15:58 They're kind, they're empathetic, they're sweet, they're compassionate.
00:16:02 After he served a very short sentence,
00:16:05 then he was going to be deported back to Mogadishu.
00:16:08 Well, the rape victim felt great existential angst and great guilt
00:16:15 that this poor, hapless migrant was not going to be fully self-actualized
00:16:21 if he were to be sent back to Mogadishu.
00:16:23 That's probably not an optimal way for your emotional system to fire.
00:16:31 Suicidal empathy is when a woman is gang-raped in Germany
00:16:35 by some men who are speaking during the rape in Arabic and Farsi.
00:16:42 When the cops interview her,
00:16:45 she tells them that they were speaking in German.
00:16:48 She lies because if she were to say that they spoke in Arabic and Farsi, that might marginalize those communities. 0.75
00:16:58 And so best to lie to protect the identity of the rapists and their communities.
00:17:04 That's suicidal empathy.
00:17:05 There are many, many other examples which maybe we'll talk about during the fireside chat.
00:17:10 But what the book really shows is that many, most, all of the domestic and foreign policies that are really attacking the edifices of reason of the West stem from this dysregulated empathy.
00:17:28 So there you have it. Thank you very much.
00:17:30 And we'll now take it to the fireside chat.
00:17:33 should i sit here or where would you want here okay
00:17:42 hi yes before we start i want to direct your attention to this you'll have a chance or
00:17:50 a chance to submit your own questions um just look at the qr code or put that hideous thing
00:17:57 in your browser. Well, first of all, I want to start by having you say something about your
00:18:12 own background, partly to mobilize the empathy of the audience. I admit I'm being a little
00:18:17 manipulative. But, you know, in an oppression Olympics, you would have to be at least a
00:18:23 bronze medalist. So tell us about your own background. I think gold medal. That could
00:18:27 well be. So I'm, I was born in Lebanon. So Arabic is my mother tongue. We were part of the last
00:18:36 remaining group of Lebanese Jews that had remained in Lebanon. As you might imagine, the Jewish
00:18:43 communities throughout the Middle East became pretty much extinct, but there was still a very
00:18:49 small pocket, minuscule pocket of Jews that had stayed in Lebanon. Much of my extended family
00:18:55 had left Lebanon, you know, well before the start of the Civil War.
00:19:00 Unfortunately for us, we were caught up in the Civil War,
00:19:04 which started in 75.
00:19:06 It wasn't an easy existence.
00:19:12 Things that I saw during that first year of the Civil War
00:19:15 are things that you might see on TV in that region.
00:19:20 That was my childhood. 1.00
00:19:22 We ended up, luckily, thank God, being able to leave Lebanon. 1.00
00:19:27 And then on one of my parents' return trips to Lebanon, 0.99
00:19:31 because they still had business interests in Lebanon,
00:19:35 this was in 1980, they were kidnapped by Abu Nidal's group, Fatah.
00:19:42 And some really bad things happened to them in captivity,
00:19:45 but luckily they were able to be freed.
00:19:48 And so since 1980, no one from my family has gone back,
00:19:53 but that's sort of the background that I come from.
00:19:55 Oh, thank you.
00:19:57 I want to ask initially about something you say in the parasitic mind.
00:20:02 I highly recommend it, by the way.
00:20:05 On page 129, you're talking about these parasitic pathogens of the mind,
00:20:10 and you briefly there mention suicidal empathy.
00:20:13 It's the only mention, I think, in that book.
00:20:15 Very good.
00:20:16 And here's the quote.
00:20:17 reciprocal altruism is an evolved mechanism. Suicidal empathy is not. So could you start by
00:20:25 telling us why you decided to write an entire book on this particular pathogen of the mind?
00:20:31 Right. So because, as I mentioned briefly in my remarks, we are a thinking and a feeling animal.
00:20:40 So let me, one of the things that I, you know, lecture on is, for example, psychology of
00:20:45 advertising. And so if you are an advertiser and you're trying to sell a product or advertise a
00:20:53 product, there are really two routes of persuasion that you could take. You could try to invoke the
00:20:58 cognitive system of the consumer or their emotional system. So for example, if I'm trying to sell you
00:21:06 a mutual fund, then this is a cognitive product. It's a utilitarian product. So I'm going to say,
00:21:13 here are the seven reasons why you should buy my mutual fund. I am engaging your thought
00:21:18 processes, your cognitive system. On the other hand, if I were selling you perfume, usually you
00:21:24 don't have perfume ads that show a Harvard physiologist explaining to you the science of
00:21:32 olfaction. What do you usually have when you're selling a hedonic product like perfume? A beautiful
00:21:38 woman with luxuriant hair flowing on a horse and then there's the like a French sounding name for
00:21:46 the perfume, Mystère, right? So I'm trying to engage in one case your emotional system, in the
00:21:53 other case your cognitive system. So for me to be able to fully parasitize, hijack your capacity to
00:22:00 think, I need to do two things. I need to hijack your cognitive processes, hence the parasitic 0.84
00:22:07 mind, and then your affective processes, your emotional system, and suicidal empathy. So that's 0.97
00:22:13 the one-two punch. That's really helpful, and actually it makes me think of Aristotle, but in
00:22:19 a different way. In the rhetoric, he talks about these three sources of persuasion, and two of them
00:22:25 you've already talked about, logos and also pathos, but there's also ethos, and it's a question of,
00:22:31 as it were, the credibility of the source, having somebody recognized, even if it's somebody
00:22:37 irrelevant. So the pop star appears and recommends a political candidate or a particular product.
00:22:43 And in that case, what's happening is partly an emotional appeal, but partly just this appeal to
00:22:49 authority almost. And I'm wondering about the connection between that and things you talk
00:22:55 about in the book. The rather extensive attempt to silence dissenting voices, to put out frankly
00:23:03 obvious falsehoods as propaganda from a lot of people in positions of authority, that's been a
00:23:09 pervasive feature of our life for the past say 20 years. And is that the matter of this third
00:23:16 element being mobilized? And how does it interact with the other two? So I have a chapter in
00:23:22 suicidal empathy on what I call epistemological empathy. Epistemology, for those of you who
00:23:29 don't know, it's philosophy of knowledge, right? Now, if you're a scientist who adheres to the
00:23:34 scientific method, your epistemology is the epistemology of truth. You have to find the
00:23:40 means by which you could best approximate the truth out there. But then there's now a competing
00:23:46 type of epistemology that is called epistemology of care, meaning that the way that you should
00:23:53 adjudicate whether you study something or don't study something, whether you share certain
00:23:58 findings or you don't share them, is not whether they are veridical or not. It's what are the
00:24:03 consequences of that information getting out? Is it going to hurt someone's feelings? So therefore
00:24:10 you have what's called, for example, forbidden knowledge. Don't do research that shows that one
00:24:16 racial group is more likely to commit murder than another group. That doesn't adhere to the
00:24:22 epistemology of care. It might be perfectly true that that difference exists, but it's hurtful,
00:24:28 it's mean. Don't show that a group of immigrants might be less likely to assimilate than another
00:24:34 group of immigrants that don't share the same foundational values. That hurts someone's
00:24:39 feelings. So to your point about the third pillar on Aristotle's, you then get purveyors of what
00:24:46 is appropriate as truth. You get top-down approaches of what constitutes settled science,
00:24:54 something that we heard during the COVID, you know, debacle, right? This is what led 1,281,
00:25:04 I think if I remember my numbers, public health officials to say, you can't go to your dying
00:25:12 grandmother's old home place where she's dying because it's too dangerous because of COVID
00:25:21 transmission. But when 100,000 progressive people with hashtag BLM signs are banded together on top
00:25:29 of each other, the same virus that couldn't have you go see your grandmother and had all
00:25:36 of our children locked up for years during an important developmental stage of their
00:25:41 lives, it didn't transmit the virus as long as you carried hashtag BLM signs.
00:25:48 That literally epidemiologically protects you against, that's just settled science.
00:25:54 And so science is never settled.
00:25:58 I have a whole section in the book where I talk about some of the biggest scientists,
00:26:05 all of whom share one commonality, that they were going against the settled science of the day.
00:26:13 Let me just mention one or two.
00:26:15 A recent Nobel laureate, I think 2005, in physiology or medicine,
00:26:21 had argued that what causes ulcers is an actual bacterium.
00:26:27 Every single physician and researcher in the area said, this is insane heresy. 0.99
00:26:34 You're a quack. 0.97
00:26:36 It's caused by increased stress.
00:26:39 It's caused by the culinary choices you make, for example, spicy food.
00:26:44 And that's settled science.
00:26:45 The way that he was able to break through is he actually did a self-experimentation.
00:26:52 He ingested that bacterium and then demonstrated that he was right, and oops, I guess he was right.
00:26:59 Here is your Nobel Prize.
00:27:01 Sir Harold Ridley, Sir Harold Ridley, is the pioneer who developed the number one most successful surgery around the world.
00:27:12 Does anybody know what it is?
00:27:15 Sorry?
00:27:17 Can you speak up?
00:27:20 No?
00:27:22 No. Cataract surgeries. Okay. When he first proposed the mechanism for the cataract surgeries,
00:27:31 the entire ophthalmological community said this is some of the biggest quackery ever.
00:27:39 Let me just do one more. Semmelweis. Does anybody know who Semmelweis is?
00:27:44 Semmelweis was a physician practicing in Central Europe who noticed that there were many women who
00:27:55 had just given birth who would die of purpural fever and he noticed that some women in this ward
00:28:04 would not die and some women in this ward were dying at an alarming rate and the only thing
00:28:11 that could explain that it was sort of a natural experiment that had been set up you know
00:28:16 inadvertently it was because the physicians would be working on autopsies and then would go on to
00:28:25 deliver the babies without washing their hands so then he said hey if you and the other one
00:28:33 for for various reasons that wasn't happening so then he proposed the idea that there was
00:28:39 germ transfer from the autopsies to the obstetrics and all the physicians were terribly offended
00:28:49 you think us with our god complex are the ones who are killing the women how dare you now he
00:28:55 ended up dying a terrible death in a insane asylum and then later they now have statues of him
00:29:04 everywhere. And it's became known as the Semmelweis reflex. And that is when, irrespective of
00:29:12 how much evidence I show you that your position is incorrect, you go, la, la, la, I don't want
00:29:19 to hear it. We have a term for it from psychology named after this guy. So, suicidal empathy
00:29:25 manifests itself in endless ways. But what is always true to all of those cases is it's the
00:29:32 dysregulation of your empathy virtue. I was thinking about several vices. You were talking
00:29:38 about this, as a matter of fact. I want to talk about a couple of criticisms that I've seen
00:29:44 on X from people who, of course, haven't read the book since it's just come out. But nevertheless,
00:29:51 yes, some of them are just always saying that empathy is bad, which is clearly wrong. But
00:29:56 others say you're using the wrong word i mean it's really more compassion or sympathy that
00:30:03 you're talking about now in the book you say i'm going to use these interchangeably
00:30:07 but it does raise this issue of the the cognitive versus the affective aspects of things because i
00:30:14 think at least the way i hear those terms um sympathy and compassion seem more affective
00:30:20 than cognitive. Empathy seems sort of equally both. So could you say a little bit more about
00:30:26 the thinking-feeling issue and the difference between the books and whether it's primarily
00:30:31 a thinking problem here or a feeling problem? I mean, it's more of a feeling problem because
00:30:37 this book is about how your affective system is parasitized. And I'm glad that you pointed
00:30:43 the fact that I mentioned that I'm going to be using these terms. There are unbelievably
00:30:48 fine parsing definitions in the academic literature as to which elements of compassion,
00:30:57 empathy, and sympathy overlap, and which don't.
00:31:00 They're unbelievably arcane and really pedantic.
00:31:04 For most people, when I say the words empathy as is used colloquially, everybody understands
00:31:10 it, that one difference would be to sympathize would be, you know, what do you say when someone
00:31:17 passes away?
00:31:18 You have my deepest sympathies, right?
00:31:21 But empathize, if you'd like, is more active.
00:31:25 I could either, I understand your feelings,
00:31:29 or I feel your feelings, right?
00:31:31 And therefore, I will intervene in a way that is more active.
00:31:35 So there are very fine parsing definitions,
00:31:38 but for all intents and purposes,
00:31:40 everybody understands what I mean.
00:31:42 Right.
00:31:43 Here's another one that is, I think, maybe,
00:31:46 calls into the question larger issues.
00:31:50 So you put it this way.
00:31:53 You're assuming that people make
00:31:55 not only personal decisions,
00:31:56 but some key political and social decisions
00:31:59 based on suicidal empathy.
00:32:02 And this person might say,
00:32:04 look, I agree that lots of people in the public
00:32:06 are shaped by this,
00:32:08 but actually I don't think the political leaders are doing that.
00:32:10 I think they're cynical,
00:32:12 and they've either got a highly ideological worldview
00:32:16 or maybe they're even being paid off by foreign powers.
00:32:20 But in any case, they're really betraying their own citizens whom they hate.
00:32:25 So the right analysis of this is really Julian Benda,
00:32:29 Treason of the Intellectuals, 1927.
00:32:32 And yeah, a lot of their followers are deluded,
00:32:36 but that's not what's really driving events.
00:32:38 How would you respond?
00:32:40 There is a bit of that, it's true.
00:32:41 But I don't think that suicidal empathy was engineered and designed at a World Economic Forum meeting at Davos, right?
00:32:55 It's not top-down.
00:32:57 I think – now, that doesn't mean, though, that there might not be political leaders that are willfully diabolical in going along with those policies.
00:33:06 In general, I think what's happened is, so the parasitic mind goes through all of these parasitic ideas that have really wreaked havoc on our edifices of reason.
00:33:19 So what are examples of parasitic ideas?
00:33:22 Post-modernism, right?
00:33:25 There are no objective truths. 0.55
00:33:27 Up is down, left is right, men are women, freedom is slavery.
00:33:31 You can't tell what is true. 0.98
00:33:33 Cultural relativism would be another parasitic idea.
00:33:37 Who are you to judge the cultural practices
00:33:40 and beliefs of another culture? 1.00
00:33:42 If they have honor killings, shut up, racist. 1.00
00:33:45 If they have child rights, shut up, racist. 1.00
00:33:48 If they have female genital mutilation 1.00
00:33:50 of five-year-old girls, shut up, racist. 1.00
00:33:52 Don't impose your cultural belief system 1.00
00:33:55 on the noble others,
00:33:57 especially if the noble others have darker melanin,
00:34:00 then God forbid you should make a comment.
00:34:02 So, the way that suicidal empathy then finds fertile ground, it's a one-two punch.
00:34:10 You first have to have the proliferation of all of these dreadful ideas, and that then
00:34:15 creates the right environment for the dysregulation of empathy.
00:34:20 Let me give you an example.
00:34:22 If you internalize the parasitic idea of cultural relativism, which is you don't have the right
00:34:28 to judge the cultural practices of another society,
00:34:32 then that renders you impotent in making judgments
00:34:36 as to the differential value of prospective immigrants
00:34:41 into your nation, right?
00:34:43 So if you, for example, have an open border policy
00:34:46 that is perfectly consistent with suicidal empathy
00:34:49 because it says it's wrong, it's icky to argue
00:34:53 that one group of immigrants might be less likely
00:34:56 to internalize the foundational values
00:34:59 of, say, the United States.
00:35:01 And what led to you being
00:35:03 suicidally empathetic in that way
00:35:04 is that you've internalized
00:35:06 cultural relativism,
00:35:07 which says you have no right
00:35:09 to judge a society
00:35:10 if they think that gays
00:35:13 should go through a very effective
00:35:15 gravity-based conversion therapy program.
00:35:18 We find the biggest building,
00:35:20 we throw you off the building, 1.00
00:35:21 your brain splatters, 1.00
00:35:23 and you've been cleared 0.99
00:35:25 of your queerness.
00:35:26 You don't have a right to judge their values.
00:35:28 So if you let in millions of people that have internalized those values, so be it.
00:35:34 We're all going to get along beautifully and nicely and justly so.
00:35:39 So it really is a one-two punch.
00:35:41 I first have to soften you with all these parasitic ideas,
00:35:45 and then you could merrily swim in the infinity pool of suicidal empathy.
00:35:50 I want to ask you about the ecology of the pathogens in a way,
00:35:55 these parasites, because it does seem to me that suicidal empathy interacts with a lot of the
00:36:01 things you talked about in the parasitic mind in kind of interesting ways. So here is one of these 0.98
00:36:06 examples. Runaway selection, the peacock's tail. This very dangerous, in evolutionary terms,
00:36:15 signal, but nevertheless it works as a signal and confers evolutionary advantages precisely
00:36:21 because it is costly. And I was thinking about the fact that people who inhabit ideologically
00:36:28 uniform environments, like, oh, universities, or the media, or a variety of other things in culture,
00:36:37 tend to become more extreme, and partly as a way of distinguishing themselves from the rest.
00:36:44 And so how much, basically, what does that have to do with suicidal empathy, and how is it
00:36:50 leading to more and more of this.
00:36:53 So let me explain what you said about runaway selection and so on.
00:36:57 So there are two mechanisms in evolution that explains the selection of particular traits.
00:37:07 There is natural selection, which is the mechanism that results in the selection of traits that confer a survival advantage.
00:37:15 And then there is sexual selection, which is the mechanism that results in the selection of traits that confer a reproductive advantage.
00:37:25 So if we take the peacock's tail, the peacock's tail could not have evolved because of its increased survival advantage,
00:37:34 because if anything, it does the opposite.
00:37:36 Why?
00:37:36 Because having a very big tail that's conspicuous, that has iridescent coloring, makes you more visible to potential predators.
00:37:46 Having a big burdensome tail makes you less likely to avoid predators and take flight.
00:37:53 And so why would that tail have evolved?
00:37:57 Well, it has to be because it is conferring a reproductive advantage.
00:38:02 Now, what is the reproductive advantage?
00:38:04 there's a bunch of males that are going to be saying pick me pick me I'm the top male but in
00:38:11 order for the signal to be an honest signal it has to be costly meaning it has to be handicapping
00:38:21 so what the peacock's tail is effectively saying is despite the fact that I've got this very
00:38:27 burdensome tail that reduces my survivability here I stand before you isn't that an honest
00:38:34 signal of my phenotypic quality, so choose me as a mate. So then there is this runaway form of
00:38:40 selection that results in ever more outlandish traits. And so excessive purity tests, excessive
00:38:49 virtue signaling becomes a form of peacocking. Oh, you think that this particularly insane idea
00:38:57 from the university ecosystem is wild? Well, I'm going to outwild this one. And so you get
00:39:02 a never-ending cycle of complete departure from rationality, from logic, from common sense, from
00:39:10 your eyes, right, and by the way, I noticed this very early, and so I've been a professor now for
00:39:15 32 years, okay, since 1994, and my, as you briefly hinted at, my work is really to apply evolutionary
00:39:25 biology and evolutionary psychology to study human behavior in general and consumer behavior in
00:39:31 particular. Now, to me, it seemed quite obvious that humans in general and consumers in particular
00:39:38 don't exist outside of their biological reality. But to most of my social science colleagues,
00:39:45 that was complete heretical. To them, what made us human is that we transcended our biology.
00:39:54 Biology matters for the dog.
00:39:56 Biology matters for the zebra, to the mosquito.
00:40:00 But surely, Professor Saad, you don't think biology matters to human beings.
00:40:04 And surely, Professor Saad, if you're going to use evolution to study human beings, use it for things like why we've evolved opposable thumbs.
00:40:13 but God forbid you should use evolution to explain things above the neck, like the most
00:40:19 important organ that defines your personhood called your brain. So they're perfectly happy
00:40:26 to apply evolutionary theory to explain the evolution of every single species on earth
00:40:32 except one called Homo sapiens. So that was originally when I said, I think we have a problem
00:40:39 here. These professors who are supposed to be educated and smart, who have a lot of titles
00:40:44 before and after their names, are some of the biggest walking morons that I've ever interacted 1.00
00:40:49 with. How could that be? How could a trained social scientist not understand that humans are 1.00
00:40:59 not operating outside of their biology? And that's what led to the parasitic mind. So it really is 0.95
00:41:05 a broad narrative, these two books.
00:41:08 It really explains how we all
00:41:09 have the potential of becoming wood crickets.
00:41:13 There is a bizarre
00:41:14 thing you've noticed, not only about
00:41:16 wood crickets, but about
00:41:17 the same people
00:41:20 who mock creationists
00:41:22 for rejecting science
00:41:23 are social constructionists.
00:41:25 Yes. And reject biology
00:41:27 as soon as it involves anything mental or anything
00:41:30 social, which is an astounding
00:41:32 division. And if I may add to this, forgive me for
00:41:33 Yes. People have often asked me, well, why do you largely attack the left? And that's not because
00:41:41 I'm taking a political position. It's because all of these ideas that result in the parasitic mind 0.94
00:41:48 and in suicidal empathy stem from ideas that were spawned on university campuses. Now, university
00:41:55 campuses are almost exclusively populated by leftist professors. Now, we're not talking about
00:42:02 just a statistically significant odds ratio, let me, for those of you who may not know what that
00:42:08 means, let's suppose I'm trying to measure the efficacy of a drug. And I have a placebo group,
00:42:15 and I have the actual experimental manipulation. If the efficacy of the experimental manipulation
00:42:21 is 1.2 to 1, that means it's 20% more effective. Now, it's 1 to 1.2. Now, in academia, the ratios
00:42:32 are 1 to 140.
00:42:36 You get it?
00:42:37 So you would be very excited in publishing a paper
00:42:40 if you got an odds ratio of 1 to 1.2.
00:42:43 This is, if you go into communication studies
00:42:47 and ethnic studies and sociology and anthropology 0.99
00:42:50 and the rest of the bullshit stuff, 0.98
00:42:52 what you end up with, 0.99
00:42:54 you end up with literally more likelihood
00:42:57 of running into a unicorn
00:42:59 than having a conservative professor in those disciplines.
00:43:03 So this is why I attack those leftist ideas.
00:43:07 It's just because I'm a product of the ecosystem that I inhabit.
00:43:11 But that doesn't mean, to your point,
00:43:13 that people on the right can't also be parasitized.
00:43:17 It's just that it's different parasitic ideas that they are prone to.
00:43:21 So to your point, when it comes to believing in evolution,
00:43:27 people on the right are more likely to exhibit animus towards evolution but when it comes to
00:43:34 the application of evolution to the study of the human mind which is a sub-branch of evolution
00:43:41 it's people on the left that exhibit greater animus precisely because of social constructivism
00:43:48 social constructivism basically is another parasitic idea that argues we are all born
00:43:54 tabula rasa with zero biological imperatives that are endowed within our instincts. And then it's
00:44:02 only socialization that makes us who we are. This is, by the way, what leads to the suicidally 0.78
00:44:08 empathetic idea, what I call blank slate felons. Blank slate felons is a term that I use because
00:44:15 the blank slate is exactly what tabula rasa is. We're born with empty minds. So the criminal
00:44:21 doesn't have personal agency. The criminal became a criminal because he's a product of a really
00:44:28 unfair white supremacist American society. So what would be the point in you penalizing him
00:44:35 by putting him in prison? Don't you think he deserves 187th chance? And by the way,
00:44:40 now the book is already out, but the cases of suicidal empathy are never ending so that,
00:44:47 you know i could write volumes two three four and become very rich for many more years just adding
00:44:54 up the latest additions to suicide empathy two such examples that i'd love to share with you
00:44:58 that are not in the book you've all heard of the case in new york city that just happened
00:45:03 where there is a habitual offender who happened to be an offender of color so untouchable who
00:45:10 had been arrested just recently the woman didn't want to press charges against him because she 0.67
00:45:18 didn't want another black man in prison what did this lovely blank slate felon do a couple of days
00:45:24 ago he took a 77 year old former teacher retired teacher and for absolutely no reason other than 0.64
00:45:32 the fact that there's no there's no longer any coupling between actions and consequences
00:45:37 pushed him down killed him and now people are upset you know you're why are you punishing this
00:45:43 poor blank slate felon second example as you know Donald Trump there's been assassination attempts
00:45:51 on him not once not twice but three times the third time when they arrested the guy did anybody
00:45:57 see the incredible crying and sobbing of the judge recently I am so so sorry that we've put you 0.94
00:46:05 in this cell with no windows i mean holy crap what kind of unbelievably harsh society would put a
00:46:13 alleged assassination guy of the president of the united states not in the four seasons hotel 0.97
00:46:21 here in austin this is unusual and cruel punishment so the fact that this degenerate judge
00:46:27 actually had the reflex to apologize publicly to the guy who would assassinate the president
00:46:34 in the United States is probably an example of suicidal empathy.
00:46:38 I want to ask you about the relationship
00:46:41 between two of these pathogens
00:46:43 that I've noticed accompanying each other very frequently,
00:46:46 but I don't really grasp the connection between them.
00:46:49 In The Parasitic Mind,
00:46:51 you talk about the ostrich parasitic syndrome,
00:46:54 a kind of unwillingness to believe
00:46:56 even very clear data and obvious truths.
00:47:00 and it does seem as if there is an empathy problem in many of these cases but also just
00:47:07 an understanding the world problem so think about the things that all we've all been told like for
00:47:12 example if you get the covid vaccine you will not get sick period it would be the first completely
00:47:18 adequate vaccine in history or i mean you list a bunch of them i'll just mention a few all cultures
00:47:24 are equally valuable. The mind's a blank slate. Everything's a social construct. Immigrants
00:47:30 commit fewer crimes than natives. Diversity is our strength. All of these are absurd. And yet,
00:47:36 people insist on them and refuse to look at data. So how does that interact with the problem of
00:47:42 suicidal empathy? Well, reality has a way to autocorrect your otherwise reflex for suicidal
00:47:50 empathy but if you reject your lying eyes then that creates the fertile environment for you
00:47:56 holding on to the beliefs that lead to suicidal empathy i was asked recently well not too recent
00:48:02 now maybe two years ago by a i was invited on a show of a british psychiatrist and he's the only
00:48:11 one to have ever asked me this question which i think is surprising but also you know quite clever
00:48:17 on his part. The last question he asked me, he said, in all the years that you've been a professor
00:48:23 and a behavioral scientist, what is the singular phenomenon that has most surprised you about the
00:48:30 human condition? And so I had to sort of pause for a second because, you know, I've studied many
00:48:35 things. I said, the inability for people to change their minds once it is deeply anchored in a
00:48:42 position, which in a sense is quite a pessimistic view because there would be no point for me to
00:48:50 write these books if I thought that there was no chance to ever flip somebody from the anchored
00:48:57 positions that they hold. So what I've become very adept at, not perfectly so, but certainly much
00:49:03 better than earlier in my career, is if I'm interacting with you in good faith and I realize 1.00
00:49:09 that you're likely one of those ostriches, 1.00
00:49:12 I cut my losses and don't waste any more time on you 0.99
00:49:15 because I know that no matter what other information
00:49:18 I could ever show you,
00:49:19 I will never move you a single millimeter
00:49:22 from your position.
00:49:23 By the way, this is the exact reason
00:49:25 why I often refuse to have certain types of debates.
00:49:30 So I get invited, I'll mention his name,
00:49:32 I hope he doesn't mind,
00:49:34 Pierce Morgan, every 15 seconds his producers call me 1.00
00:49:38 to go on his show to debate this idiot and this degenerate and this imbecile the reason i don't 0.99
00:49:44 is not because i'm too haughty to speak because i actually will debate random eggs on x like 0.98
00:49:51 literally where i don't even know that so it's not that i modulate whether i speak to you if
00:49:56 you're important or not but it's whether it's in good faith that there is we're both coming into
00:50:01 the discussion there is a hope that if you say something that is convincing i might change my
00:50:07 opinion and vice versa. And if I think that there is no way that that could happen, then it looks
00:50:13 much better on your CV to have this conversation than it will look on mine. And so I refuse to then
00:50:17 do it. And so, for example, I won't debate a rabbi or a young earth creationist about the 0.84
00:50:26 validity of evolutionary theory versus whatever religious dogma that they adhere to, because no 0.79
00:50:33 amount of evolutionary evidence that I could ever show them or present to them would move them away
00:50:39 from their religious revealed truths. And so that's usually what makes me decide whether to
00:50:45 have a dialogue with someone or not. This brings me naturally to the next question I have, which is
00:50:51 about what you call epistemological dichotomization, this idea of seeing everything in terms of us
00:50:57 versus them, drawing a sharp binary distinction. And we see that in a lot of cases, it's an
00:51:03 oppressor versus oppressed, or bourgeoisie versus proletariat, or what have you. And it concerns me
00:51:11 that that, A, leads to a kind of dehumanization, something that you talk about a little bit in
00:51:18 the book. But it's also, as far as I can see, largely arbitrary. And so if I look for cognitive
00:51:25 types of explanations, for example, of how Jews end up being oppressors while Muslims are oppressed,
00:51:32 I start thinking, I don't understand this. I don't understand how you get to be part of one group 0.95
00:51:37 as opposed to another group. I'm luckily from the Balkans, where I think Americans don't have 0.98
00:51:44 any clear sense of who's the good guy and bad guy. We're just all crazy. But still, it seems to me 0.98
00:51:50 there is something odd and a lot of people end up as a result of this dichotomization
00:51:55 being in your words zombified by ideological rapture so um here's the thing you mentioned
00:52:04 wood crickets being zombified and so is that what's going on people adopt an ideology that
00:52:12 doesn't just keep them from seeing certain obvious truths but really does in a sense
00:52:16 zombify them in such a way that they become
00:52:19 self-destructive? Right, great
00:52:21 question. So there are
00:52:23 these two French psychologists
00:52:25 Hugo Mercier
00:52:27 and Dan Sperber
00:52:29 they wrote a book called
00:52:31 The Enigma of Reason
00:52:33 and they're
00:52:35 evolutionary minded psychologists
00:52:37 and they said that our
00:52:39 faculty of reasoning
00:52:40 did not evolve to seek
00:52:43 some objective truth
00:52:44 but it evolved to win arguments in other words most people don't say i want to be a honest
00:52:54 purveyor of information and based on where the information takes me i will then decide
00:52:59 accordingly where i fall but rather it's blue team red team la la la i don't want to hear what
00:53:06 the blue team has to say this leads by the way oftentimes when people ask me we we don't quite
00:53:11 know, I mean, are you a classical liberal or are you a conservative? And they think I'm being coy
00:53:17 and not giving them a definitive label, but that's because I truly am either one or the other,
00:53:25 depending on the specific issue. I have no allegiance to one group. When it comes to death
00:53:30 penalty, I would be extremely conservative. If we find your DNA on the bodies of four dead children,
00:53:36 I don't think that you're likely to be innocent. Let's execute you quickly. That would make me a 1.00
00:53:43 very harsh conservative. I'm not crying for the rights of the pedophile, right? On the other hand,
00:53:48 when it comes to whether you wish to live your life transgender this or that, I don't care. I'm 0.99
00:53:55 very socially liberal. But that doesn't mean that in my support of your right to have whatever
00:54:01 gender identity you want, that I should go along the ride with you, celebrate your personhood, 0.81
00:54:07 and murder truth in the service of your personhood. I could walk and chew gum at the same time. I 0.94
00:54:14 could support your right to be transgender, whatever you want, and I agree that you shouldn't
00:54:19 be discriminated against. That doesn't mean that I should now go back to my classes and change what
00:54:25 i teach about the effects of the ovulatory cycle on women's behaviors and to now change it to men 0.96
00:54:32 too can menstruate f off with this bullshit right so i can be fully socially liberal but yet adhere 0.94
00:54:40 to the truth i think in most cases the people who suffer from epistemological dichotomania 0.98
00:54:44 is that once i'm in this camp everything of this camp has to be false and the world is not
00:54:52 structured that way? This is a question that occurred to me as I was reading the book.
00:55:00 And so I can't blame this on random people on X. It's my worry. And that is, if you look at this
00:55:06 from one point of view, you can say, yes, these people seem to have too much empathy, or really,
00:55:11 I think, better as you put it, misdirected empathy. And that seems to me quite plausible.
00:55:18 But when I look at certain phenomena, I end up thinking, it's the lack of empathy that worries me.
00:55:25 Here's what I have in mind.
00:55:27 You mentioned briefly October 7th.
00:55:30 People in New York and other cities here in the United States put up posters of hostages to remind people it wasn't just the atrocities that occurred that day.
00:55:40 There were still many, many people being held hostage.
00:55:44 And leftists, mostly women, went through and defaced those. 0.54
00:55:47 Jewish women. Yes, and tore them down. Now, in that case, it's not really an excess or misdirected 0.95
00:55:53 empathy toward Gazans or something. It was really a lack of empathy for the people who were being
00:55:59 held hostage and for those who had been victimized. Or think of the murals that were put up for
00:56:04 Raina Zorutska, the woman who was murdered in Charlotte. People are insisting on repainting
00:56:11 them taking them down and so on that's a lack of empathy for a ukrainian immigrant um rather than
00:56:17 maybe too much empathy for someone else or i think about the celebrations of the murderer of
00:56:22 brian thompson or charlie kirk yeah um and in all of these cases i think how can you
00:56:29 lack empathy for the victims i get it if you want to say but think about i mean i don't really get
00:56:35 it but i sort of get it intellectually i have but see it from the other person's point of view
00:56:40 okay, I can try to do that and try to be aware of that.
00:56:43 But really, it's the utter lack of empathy for the victim that shocks me.
00:56:47 And I look at that and I think, I don't really,
00:56:50 even given what you've said, fully understand that.
00:56:53 And the result of it all seems to me monstrous.
00:56:57 So how do you think about that sort of phenomenon?
00:56:59 Well, what's basically happening is the evolutionary-based calculus of empathy
00:57:05 has been rewired by the hairworm
00:57:08 so that the rapist is more deserving of empathy
00:57:13 than the victim of the rape.
00:57:16 So to you, it seems so incomprehensible
00:57:18 because you're a Darwinian being
00:57:20 that is bound to these evolutionary-based rules. 0.94
00:57:23 Well, that's what makes it parasitic mind and suicidal empathy.
00:57:27 You are literally rewiring this evolved calculus, right?
00:57:32 I mean, I'll give you...
00:57:34 I could give you many other examples from the book,
00:57:36 but let me give you another one. 0.78
00:57:37 A woman goes to Haiti, a white woman who's incredibly liberal, incredibly progressive.
00:57:43 She's a much kinder woman than all of you people here.
00:57:47 And so she goes to Haiti to demonstrate that this idea that black men could ever commit violence
00:57:55 is simply a narrative that has been promulgated by the white supremacist society of the United States.
00:58:02 I mean, there really is absolutely no evidence that any black man has ever engaged in any violence anywhere.
00:58:10 So because she was incredibly empathetic, she decided to go to Haiti to be able to promulgate an alternative and correct narrative
00:58:20 that black men in their natural state are just lovely, all of them. 0.98
00:58:27 Well, there's this thing called reality that gave her a big slap as one of those Haitian black men 1.00
00:58:35 took her to a rooftop and violently raped her all night. 1.00
00:58:39 If you read her testimony, you're not going to be able to understand it 0.82
00:58:45 because it defies the human experience.
00:58:48 I don't have the exact quote, so I'm going to sort of paraphrase it.
00:58:51 She looked at her rapist and said, do you not realize that I, too, am an admirer of Malcolm X?
00:59:00 I mean, shouldn't that have stopped that Haitian man from raping her once she shared with him that she, too, is a Malcolm X scholar?
00:59:09 So a person that navigates the world with that kind of distorted thinking is probably someone who is a walking wood cricket. 0.85
00:59:18 At the end of her statement, she said, I now realize that it was, you ready, white supremacy that forced you to commit this act on me.
00:59:36 So let's go back and analyze that. 0.90
00:59:39 But when a Haitian man rapes a white woman on a rooftop in Port-au-Prince, that is a manifestation of white supremacy.
00:59:54 And she said at the end, and so finally, I am thankful for that experience.
01:00:02 You can go read it in the book.
01:00:04 So when you read that, it takes your breath away because that woman is literally, I mean, in a metaphorical side, that's an analogy, but she is the wood cricket that's jumping into the water to commit suicide. 0.58
01:00:18 Her emotional system has been so distorted that she feels zero animus to the one who violently raped her, but feels great animus to this amorphous thing called white supremacy in Haiti.
01:00:34 wow yeah i don't understand i would if before you go on i would suggest that as you read this book
01:00:44 maybe you take one or two volumes because uh i suspect that your blood pressures and cortisol
01:00:51 level is gonna go up because you're gonna read this and say this is not possible there is the
01:00:57 example of the woman who not long ago in germany was raped by a migrant and the migrant was allowed
01:01:03 to even though he was found guilty was given a sentence that involved no jail time whatever
01:01:08 but she posted something nasty about the experience and about him on social media
01:01:13 and she was sentenced to jail if i can correct that slightly oh yes please i if if if it's the
01:01:19 same story that i'm thinking you're talking about it's not the woman that was raped that posted it
01:01:25 it's another woman that ran across those guys and recognized their faces and called them 0.97
01:01:33 you pig rapist and that was considered hate speech in germany so the rapist served no jail time 0.99
01:01:43 the independent woman who had not been raped but who was defending a fellow woman from the pig rapist 1.00
01:01:51 was was punished for using these inflammatory words yeah i'm agape okay that yeah i think that's 0.96
01:02:02 even worse than what I had thought the story was.
01:02:05 Okay, there is something I've noticed for a while,
01:02:09 and it seems to me suicidal empathy plays right into this,
01:02:13 and you note this near the end of the book.
01:02:16 It seems to me that certain people have a pervasive inability
01:02:20 to think about risk, to think about higher-order consequences,
01:02:25 to think about incentives.
01:02:27 And so you see people, for example,
01:02:29 interested in imposing a wealth tax.
01:02:33 In some cases, not understanding
01:02:35 that the wealthy people will simply leave.
01:02:37 And if somebody points it out, they'll say,
01:02:39 well, good riddance.
01:02:41 As Katie Wilson said, bye.
01:02:43 Bye, exactly.
01:02:45 And so this is one manifestation of this
01:02:47 not thinking through the consequences of consequences
01:02:51 or the potential for risk.
01:02:53 And as you pointed out,
01:02:55 that seems to be an intimate part
01:02:58 of at least the cognitive side of suicidal empathy.
01:03:01 So how do you get people to be aware of this?
01:03:05 You give a number of good bits of advice
01:03:07 that I want to get to near the end,
01:03:09 and one of them is don't just fall into the trap
01:03:12 of the myopia of first-order effects,
01:03:15 but how do you get somebody who seems just incapable
01:03:18 of thinking about risk or higher-order effects
01:03:22 in reasonable ways to start doing that?
01:03:25 I mean, there's no other way other than to first point to the fact that they're committing that cognitive error
01:03:31 and then walk them through the consequences of that error.
01:03:35 So, for example, I had some knee issues recently, and I went to see a physical therapist.
01:03:44 Incredibly kind, suicidally empathetic, Montreal woman. 0.92
01:03:49 She cries when she puts the gas into her car because she's raping Mother Earth, the whole thing.
01:03:54 She's very kind.
01:03:55 And so at one point she had asked me,
01:03:57 what's your next book about?
01:03:58 So I said, well, it's called Suicide Empathy.
01:04:01 So give me an example of what would be Suicide Empathy. 1.00
01:04:04 Well, presuming that every single immigrant 0.99
01:04:07 anywhere in the world is allowed to enter 0.72
01:04:09 illegally to the United States
01:04:11 because they have a right to share in the American dream.
01:04:16 She was completely aghast by how mean-spirited
01:04:19 and callous I was.
01:04:21 She said, but while you're an immigrant, 1.00
01:04:24 You got the chance.
01:04:26 Why can't they get the chance?
01:04:28 So she's, I mean, she really speaks
01:04:30 at the level of a three-day-old squirrel, right?
01:04:33 So then I said, okay,
01:04:35 so let's play the boundary condition game.
01:04:39 Could you see that we live in a generous welfare state?
01:04:44 So the way that the Canadian government
01:04:46 is able to have all of this largesse
01:04:50 is through astoundingly high parasitic taxation.
01:04:54 I don't know if you have a sense of what the Canadian reality of taxes is, but anywhere in
01:05:00 the United States is child's play compared to Canada. So I said to her, let's say right now
01:05:05 you pay whatever taxes. Would you be willing to pay that much more so that more people could
01:05:13 come in illegally? She couldn't answer those questions because the only calculus was there
01:05:19 are people in need that want to come in, and the first order effect is by letting them in, I get
01:05:26 the dopamine-based hit of empathy. That's it. Reality doesn't unfold through multiple order
01:05:35 effects. It ends at order one. So did I get through her? I don't know, but there is no other
01:05:41 way than to administer the vaccine. That's why you should all go buy five or six copies of
01:05:46 suicidal empathy. Excellent. I suppose soon I should go to audience questions, but I do want
01:05:53 to ask you about existential guilt. You say suicidal empathy is driven by misplaced existential
01:06:00 guilt. And when I read that, I was reminded of these TV commercials I used to see as a child in
01:06:07 the 1960s, where someone would appear on the screen saying, I am black and I am beautiful.
01:06:13 and contrast that with the fact
01:06:16 that some posters appeared in 2020
01:06:19 saying it's okay to be white.
01:06:21 And this was considered outrageous white supremacy.
01:06:24 So why is it that people feel plagued
01:06:29 by this existential guilt?
01:06:30 It does seem to be behind a lot of this.
01:06:34 And I find it perplexing.
01:06:37 Hierocles in the ancient world had this idea,
01:06:40 almost a Kohlbergian idea of moral development.
01:06:43 we start being concerned for ourselves and then our immediate family and then a larger family
01:06:50 and then neighbors and so on and eventually the whole world and we recognize all of humanity
01:06:55 as akin to us and hierocles thought the idea was that we should care for all of them equally
01:07:01 but if you actually ask people and especially by political persuasion how they how much concern
01:07:08 they have for various people people on the right tend to have the most concern for those who are
01:07:13 closest to them and it gradually falls away nobody becomes utterly insignificant morally but
01:07:19 nevertheless it's a declining thing as you go further people on the left it's exactly the
01:07:23 opposite they care the least about the people closest to them and the most about the most
01:07:27 distant and i take that as a manifestation of this existential guilt as well i don't have
01:07:33 another explanation but help help me relate that to suicidal empathy right well so peter singer
01:07:40 the ethicist and animal activist used the argument of increasing the moral circle so that we can
01:07:49 exhibit kindness and empathy towards our animal cousins that we shouldn't only be caring about
01:07:56 the mistreatment of our fellow human beings but that these sentient beings called our animal
01:08:02 cousins and therefore increase it and of course there's there's value in say that i'm a huge
01:08:06 animal lover i the thing that i'm most afraid is when that spca commercial comes on uh you know
01:08:14 the one with the cruelty to dogs and so on you see me bolt out of that room as fast as i can
01:08:19 because i really can't bear to see those poor poor souls so there's nothing wrong in making people
01:08:25 aware that you may want to exhibit kindness and empathy towards beyond those in your nuclear
01:08:32 family but the inversion of the calculus has to be a form of suicidal empathy right so it it makes
01:08:39 none of us in this room have evolved the calculus that says if having to choose between protecting 0.54
01:08:49 to death my biological children or a random child in Rwanda sign me up for Rwanda that's not part 0.82
01:08:58 of your evolutionary calculus. Now, in a dream world, if all of us can save every child on Earth, 0.60
01:09:04 we would do it. But in a world of fixed resources, where there are trade-offs, right? Thomas Sowell
01:09:10 explained to us that life is about trade-offs. There is no optimal solution. There is just
01:09:17 the best of possible solution, right? That's what optimization theory is, right? That's what
01:09:22 operations research is. So what the suicidally empathetic do is they presume that the well
01:09:29 of empathy is infinite. So therefore, you never have to engage with what Philip Tetlock called
01:09:36 taboo trade-offs, right? So for example, if I were to tell you, in choosing between the rights
01:09:44 of a trans woman who has a penis and testicles but she's fully a woman or biological women 0.99
01:09:53 whose rights should supersede who well when it comes to the suicidally empathetic 1.00
01:09:59 that one trans woman supersedes all of the biological women so you can destroy the dreams
01:10:08 of all the women that have been fighting hard to get at the podium so that leah thomas thomas 1.00
01:10:13 who yesterday used to be joe blow but today has found out that she's a girl she is deserving of
01:10:21 all our empathy i mean imagine that we are having now discussions with the olympic committee where
01:10:28 the olympic committee is deciding yeah you know in retrospect biological males should not compete
01:10:35 with women i went in front of the canadian senate in 2017 and not to sound prophetic i warned the
01:10:43 canadian senate of exactly what would happen if we were to go down that path it wasn't because i was
01:10:50 a prophet it's because i can take from the lunacy where we were and extrapolate to the boundary
01:10:57 condition of where this would lead us and so yes this inversion results from suicide all right
01:11:05 one last thing that i wanted to say um in the last chapter here you talk about let me call them
01:11:12 inoculation imperatives, bits of advice for making yourself safe from suicidal empathy,
01:11:18 and some of them are just to resist immediate payoffs from empathy, avoid myopia, first-order
01:11:26 effects, statistical regularities matter, data is not defeated by anecdotes, don't assume equality
01:11:35 when it's not really there, don't be a fence-sitter, demand reciprocity, choose targets of empathy
01:11:41 wisely, and suicidal empathy is fatal. But there's one thing from the parasitic mind I would
01:11:49 add to that. In that book, you say, your voice matters, use it. And it reminded me of the words
01:11:58 of Rabbi Hillel, which are translated variously, but in one translation, it's when someone is
01:12:03 needed, endeavor to be that someone, which seems to be very, very important advice. There's another
01:12:10 translation that takes the gender or the pronouns more seriously where there are no men strive to
01:12:15 be a man and it seemed to me that exhortation to courage to stand up for what we believe and state
01:12:22 plain truths is vital right thank you for that so in in the parasitic mind in the last chapter
01:12:29 probably the call to arms that is now most that i'm most known for is when i implore people to
01:12:37 activate their inner honey badger. That speaks to that, right? And the reason why I use that
01:12:42 terminology is because the honey badger, for those of you who may not know, has been classified and
01:12:48 ranked as the fiercest and most ferocious animal of all animals in the animal kingdom. Now, that's
01:12:55 a big title because there are a lot of many fierce animals. It's the size of a small to medium-sized
01:13:02 dog, yet when lions in the African savanna see the strutting honey badger come along,
01:13:12 they go, oh, sorry, sir, we didn't mean to disturb you, and they cross the street.
01:13:16 Now, why is that?
01:13:18 Because while it may be physically small, it stands incredibly tall.
01:13:24 It stands its ground.
01:13:25 So when I ask people and I implore them to activate their inner honey badger, I'm not
01:13:30 asking them to be physically violent or you know physically domineering but i'm asking them
01:13:35 stand tall and defend print you know principles that you believe in if your professor is arguing
01:13:42 that of course men too can bear children say are you insane professor right i mean or maybe if you
01:13:50 don't want to say it in such a jocular manner take the opportunity to challenge whether it's
01:13:55 your professor or your rabbi or your imam or your mother, never let an opportunity where somebody is
01:14:03 murdering truth so callously to go unchallenged. Now, the reason why many people don't do it
01:14:10 is multifaceted. One, I've always argued that the seven deadly sins should add an eighth one,
01:14:16 cowardice, although arguably you can put cowardice as part of apathy, but okay, fine, whatever, or
01:14:22 sloth-like behavior. But also people are very keen to diffuse the responsibility onto others,
01:14:31 right? Gadsad has broad shoulders. He's got this. He'll handle it on my behalf. I'm too busy with
01:14:38 my daily life to really worry about these issues. Well, if all of us diffuse our responsibility
01:14:44 onto a few people, you're not diversifying the risk, right? It's only a few of us that are then
01:14:50 serving as the voice for everybody else.
01:14:52 I've said this before, but it's worth repeating.
01:14:55 Probably the most typical template of an email
01:14:59 that I received from a fan is the following one.
01:15:02 You ready?
01:15:03 Dear Professor Saad, many nice compliments.
01:15:08 Here is the last line.
01:15:09 If you choose to read this letter on your show,
01:15:13 finish the sentence for me.
01:15:15 please do not mention my name i write back dear so-and-so thank you for your kind words don't
01:15:24 you think the last sentence in your email is precisely why we are where we are and usually
01:15:30 you can i can almost hear them squirming uncomfortably right and these many of these
01:15:35 guys are tenured professors they're protected they can't be fired yet they're cowardice
01:15:43 their tepidness is astounding.
01:15:46 So all I would ask people to do,
01:15:48 as best as you can,
01:15:49 politely, have conversations,
01:15:52 and may the best ideas win.
01:15:54 Thank you.
01:15:57 Applause
01:15:57 It is now your turn, audience,
01:16:03 to submit questions.
01:16:05 So if you haven't already done so,
01:16:07 you have an opportunity through the QR code to do that.
01:16:10 And I, in theory,
01:16:13 should be able to receive them.
01:16:18 So let me reload this so that some of them appear.
01:16:28 Ah, good.
01:16:29 What's an example of a society that successfully
01:16:32 balanced compassion with self-preservation?
01:16:37 The West until five to ten years ago.
01:16:43 Right. Yeah, that seems right. What's the new point of diminishing returns of empathy as we transition back from globalism to nationalism? Is it the nation, the West, communities? I don't understand what I mean.
01:16:58 I think the idea is that it's certainly screwy
01:17:04 to have empathy increase as the distance goes,
01:17:08 but you might think there are certain, as it were,
01:17:11 thresholds where it changes.
01:17:14 And where are those thresholds?
01:17:16 Is it a matter of your nation, your neighborhood,
01:17:19 your civilization, your family, your tribe?
01:17:21 Yeah, I mean, it's going to sound as though
01:17:23 I'm giving a flippant cop-out answer.
01:17:26 your empathy has to be meted out in ways that do not violate evolutionary rules, right?
01:17:34 So, for example, kin selection, for those of you who may not know what that is,
01:17:40 kin selection is the mechanism that explains why you would jump into a river
01:17:45 to save three of your children, even though that results in your death, right?
01:17:50 If evolution did not operate at the gene level, that kin-based altruism could never arise
01:17:58 because I would never want to kill myself, the organism that is endowed with the desire
01:18:04 to survive, in the service of saving three of my children.
01:18:07 But if you recognize that your three children, each of them, share on average 50% of their
01:18:13 genes with you, then it would make perfect evolutionary sense for you to have evolved
01:18:18 this altruistic impulse to be willing to sacrifice yourself in the service of saving your three
01:18:24 children. So that would be an example of an evolutionary condition that would predict
01:18:29 under which conditions you should risk your life or not. So empathy follows the exact same set of
01:18:36 dictums, right? It has to be wedded to an evolutionary rational calculus. That's the best
01:18:42 that I can say. Ah, good. Um, next question. Why do large companies promote suicidal empathy?
01:18:50 What's in it for them? Uh, so in, in one of the passages in suicidal empathy, I talk about the,
01:19:00 uh, evolving role of the social contract between companies and consumers. This is about a hundred
01:19:09 year story but i'll explain it very quickly a hundred years ago it was the the contract was a
01:19:16 production-centric contract meaning that as long as i can produce something to meet demands that's
01:19:24 what was expected of me as a company so does anybody remember henry ford's famous quote that
01:19:31 speaks to that somebody's shaking their head what is it exactly you can have the
01:19:39 customer can have the car in any color he wants as long as it's black. So what is he effectively
01:19:44 saying? I don't care about the consumer heterogeneity preferences. My job is to simply
01:19:52 produce cars that meet consumer demands and that ends. Next stage was a marketing or consumer
01:20:03 centric contract, which is I need to produce products that meet demands and that cater to
01:20:11 consumer preferences. So therefore, I will create the car in multiple colors. The next evolution of
01:20:19 the social contract between the firm and the customer was I need to do those two first things
01:20:24 without harming any third parties. So for example, don't harm the environment. So that would be then
01:20:32 green companies. The fourth stage that then speaks to that question, which will be woke capitalism,
01:20:39 is that I should do those first three things, but fourthly, I should be proactive in seeking
01:20:47 social justice as an inherent feature of the fiduciary responsibility of my company. No.
01:20:56 Companies operate on maximizing shareholder profits
01:21:01 as your fiduciary responsibility.
01:21:03 It's not to render queer people more visible in ads.
01:21:08 That's not part of your responsibility. 0.73
01:21:12 But it is if you were the last disastrous campaign of Jaguar.
01:21:18 Did we all see that one?
01:21:20 Jaguar produces, what is it that Jaguar produces?
01:21:23 Oh yeah, cars. 1.00
01:21:24 And then what you saw was all of these transgender people of color sashaying an incredibly exaggerated sort of voguing. 1.00
01:21:34 There was no car shown. 1.00
01:21:36 And if you remember, Elon Musk then wrote in his inimitable style, he said, hey, Jaguar, do you still produce cars?
01:21:47 Because what is he speaking to there?
01:21:49 How is it that your ad campaign has no mention of the product that you're in the business of producing?
01:21:58 Well, because they have now higher values, and that is to render the marginalized communities that were invisible, render them visible.
01:22:10 That's their real mission.
01:22:11 That makes no sense.
01:22:12 That's not what we should be teaching in a business school. 1.00
01:22:15 I see many jaguars around, but they're all Waymos. 1.00
01:22:19 This, I think, is an interesting question. 0.94
01:22:23 What do you feel is the strongest criticism of your thesis that you take seriously?
01:22:28 Of suicidal empathy?
01:22:29 Of suicidal empathy, yes.
01:22:32 Well, it's actually, I'm sorry to say, it's not a valid criticism.
01:22:36 It's the one that we alluded to earlier.
01:22:38 It's the misunderstanding of what I'm saying,
01:22:41 and they usually say, you really are a callous, dark person.
01:22:46 you're trying to eradicate one of our most beautiful virtues.
01:22:51 And that, again, speaks to a bafflingly incorrect view
01:22:56 of what I'm trying to say.
01:22:57 So if any of you eventually read the book
01:23:00 and have some valid criticisms, send me an email.
01:23:03 I'm all ears.
01:23:04 Should we have empathy toward people
01:23:07 who are suffering from suicidal empathy?
01:23:10 Call it higher order.
01:23:11 That's like meta, yeah, higher order.
01:23:16 If it ends up affecting negatively,
01:23:20 if their suicidal empathy is something
01:23:23 that has zero effect on anybody else,
01:23:26 then I'll be empathetic to their degeneracy.
01:23:28 But if their suicidal empathy has an effect
01:23:34 on the future trajectory of my children and yours,
01:23:38 then I'm not empathetic to their suicidal empathy.
01:23:41 Ah, okay, good.
01:23:42 Yeah, this next question is about
01:23:45 the connection between suicidal empathy and Christianity. 0.95
01:23:48 I realize you're not a Christian,
01:23:50 so maybe this is not the best question for you,
01:23:52 but St. Stephen prayed for those stoning him,
01:23:57 and Jesus said, you know, love your enemies and so forth. 0.58
01:24:03 Is suicidal empathy just being Christian? 0.58
01:24:07 No, so I briefly allude to it in suicidal empathy 0.69
01:24:11 where I say that a lot of those edicts in Christianity
01:24:15 don't speak within the earthly realm.
01:24:19 You know, right?
01:24:21 You know, be forgiving of your enemies and so on.
01:24:25 That is a gateway for me to ascend to the afterlife.
01:24:31 I'm not sure that in the earthly realm of...
01:24:36 Because if...
01:24:37 Then how did the crusaders do what they did?
01:24:39 I mean, they seem to not always be very kind to their enemies, so did they misread those Christian edicts?
01:24:45 So I'm hardly a Christian theologian, but my understanding is many of those empathetic things don't necessarily apply within an earthly realm.
01:24:54 That said, and I'm sure she'd be happy that I mentioned it, there was a book that came out a few years ago called Toxic Empathy that was very much rooted within a Christian framework.
01:25:07 And her book was about what happens when Christian ethical systems are taken advantage of by this plea to empathy.
01:25:20 Whereas, of course, my argument is much broader.
01:25:23 It is not restricted to the Christian ethos.
01:25:26 Yes, absolutely.
01:25:28 How much of the current hyper-feminization of Western culture do you believe comes from denying biological sex differences?
01:25:37 a lot, of course.
01:25:39 And by the way,
01:25:40 so on average,
01:25:41 women score higher on empathy than men.
01:25:44 I mean, well-regulated empathy.
01:25:47 And they also,
01:25:48 although I don't have the empirical evidence,
01:25:50 I haven't done the study,
01:25:51 but certainly, anecdotally,
01:25:54 you have a greater preponderance
01:25:56 of suicidally empathetic people amongst women.
01:25:59 So hashtag refugees welcome 1.00
01:26:02 as those refugees are gang raping you. 1.00
01:26:05 Those are always being held by very kind, empathetic women, usually that have aposomatic 0.99
01:26:11 coloring of their hair.
01:26:13 Aposomatic coloring is the fancy word for, aposomatic colors are warning colors in the
01:26:20 natural kingdom.
01:26:22 So, for example, an Amazonian frog has very vivid colors.
01:26:28 Now, you would think it should be the opposite that he has.
01:26:31 He should have camouflaging so that the predators can't see him.
01:26:36 But when an Amazonian frog has such vivid colors, what is it that he's communicating?
01:26:42 He's saying, if you can see me, it's probably because you don't want to have a go at me.
01:26:48 Stay away from me.
01:26:49 So I took this principle from evolutionary biology, and in the parasitic mind,
01:26:53 I argued that many of the super progressive folks, and this is actually totally true,
01:27:00 have aposomatic hair coloring.
01:27:03 I am so venomous in my wokeism.
01:27:06 Stay away from me, right? 1.00
01:27:08 And so they're just piggybacking on the Abizonian fraud. 1.00
01:27:11 So yes, women are much more likely than men
01:27:14 to succumb to suicidal empathy.
01:27:17 The other group that is likely to be
01:27:21 quite suicidally empathetic are what I call,
01:27:26 forgive me, I'm going to use a colorful word,
01:27:28 but it's a real word,
01:27:30 from science. Sneaky fuckers. Anybody, if you've read the parasitic mind, you might know what 1.00
01:27:39 sneaky fuckers are. Sneaky fuckers are actually, that is a real term from zoology. The fancier 1.00
01:27:46 term is called kleptogamy. It basically means a mating strategy where you steal mating
01:27:55 opportunities. Now many species have this strategy whereby, for example, the males will come in two
01:28:03 phenotypes. There is the standard very sexual dimorphic male, like who looks masculine. Then
01:28:11 there is another type of male that mimics females within that species. So when that sneaky fucker 1.00
01:28:19 shows up with the dominant male. 1.00
01:28:23 The dominant male is confused and lets him in,
01:28:27 and then he engages in surreptitious coupling
01:28:30 with the females. 0.97
01:28:32 I argued in parasitic mind 0.88
01:28:34 that extremely sensitive guys
01:28:38 who wear foulard, who hug the tree,
01:28:41 who go to Greta Thunberg rallies 1.00
01:28:44 are engaging in a form of sneaky fuckers. 0.98
01:28:47 I'm incredibly sensitive, I'm incredibly kind, you don't have to really worry about me, I'm not like those other Navy SEAL types that suffer from toxic masculinity, you could trust me, right? 0.99
01:29:01 And therefore, hopefully one day I can get in that surreptitious mating opportunity with you when your guards are down. 1.00
01:29:09 Sneaky fuckers suffer from suicidal empathy. 1.00
01:29:12 okay the next question is it's hard to follow that one up um is suicidal empathy a modern 1.00
01:29:21 phenomenon uh or can we look to history for examples of the effects on society and where
01:29:26 this all leads i would comment that a recent survey found that a majority of men think about
01:29:31 the roman empire several times a week uh i know i do and so so the question is yeah is the roman
01:29:38 Empire or other empires in the past? Have they fallen in a similar way? So I'm going to answer
01:29:44 in a slightly oblique way, but I think it'll get to your question. Early in the book, I tell the
01:29:50 story of the eminent British historian, Arnold Toynbee, who did a 12-volume study of why
01:30:00 civilizations eventually die. And the maxim of that 12-volume study is civilizations die not by
01:30:09 murder, but by suicide. So the difference between what he's already realized and what I'm saying
01:30:17 is that there are many pathways to committing civilizational suicide. What I'm arguing in
01:30:26 the current era is that we're committing civilizational suicide via the dysregulation
01:30:33 of empathy. That is unique to the current period. And by the way, another term that I introduced in
01:30:38 the book that probably will go viral just like civilizational, just like suicidal empathy,
01:30:44 I call it civilizational seppuku. Seppuku is the Japanese term exactly for in cultures where you
01:30:54 have honor and shame, where losing face is a really disastrous thing, a fatal thing, say the samurai
01:31:02 class, if you engage in an action that brings you shame, the only way that you can seek repentance
01:31:10 for that is to commit self-disembowelment, meaning seppuku. Well, I argue that the West is currently
01:31:19 committing civilizational seppuku again because of what you referred to earlier this existential 0.91
01:31:26 guilt we are the product of a racist misogynistic islamophobic transphobic society we live on stolen 0.97
01:31:36 land we killed the the indigenous people therefore there is nothing to celebrate about our society 0.98
01:31:42 we are here by original sin maybe not in the christian sense or maybe in the christian sense 0.99
01:31:49 And therefore, the only way to seek a redemption, a repentance, is by committing civilizational seppuku. 0.70
01:32:00 Good.
01:32:01 There are some people on the left who have somehow managed to avoid suicidal empathy.
01:32:07 So there is, I think, definitely a political correlation here.
01:32:10 But it's not perfect.
01:32:11 Bill Maher might be an example of someone who not only has not succumbed to this,
01:32:17 but points out this problem in others.
01:32:20 How is it possible for people who share a similar ideological perspective
01:32:25 to, in some cases, avoid the infection?
01:32:30 I mean, again, this may sound like an unsatisfactory answer to you,
01:32:33 but there are natural variations across people.
01:32:36 Why did this person get cancer and not that person?
01:32:39 So we could only talk about statistical regularities, as you mentioned earlier.
01:32:45 We know for a fact that people on the left are astoundingly more likely to succumb to
01:32:51 suicidal empathy.
01:32:52 I mean, they're literally called the party of empathy, right?
01:32:55 So, but that doesn't mean that from the cesspool of kind and compassion, you can't get someone
01:33:02 who has a unique personhood that makes them inoculated against this nonsense.
01:33:06 Bill Maher might happen to be one of them.
01:33:08 but I would say it's almost exclusively the case
01:33:11 that it is an affliction of the left.
01:33:14 Ah, right.
01:33:15 Let me ask a question that's closer to philosophy.
01:33:20 In the book, you talk about the contrast
01:33:22 between consequentialist views,
01:33:24 where the value of something depends on the consequences,
01:33:28 and deontological Kantian sorts of views
01:33:31 that are much more absolute.
01:33:33 And then, of course, behind it all
01:33:34 is this evolutionary framework that is your home base.
01:33:38 So how do those interact?
01:33:40 And how does that sort of perspective get involved with these questions of suicidal?
01:33:46 Right, great question.
01:33:47 So deontological ethics, for those of you who don't know, are absolute statements of right or wrong.
01:33:54 It is never okay to lie would be a deontological statement.
01:33:58 If you say it is okay to lie to spare someone's feelings, that's a consequentialist statement.
01:34:04 So, my wife is sitting here in the audience.
01:34:06 She's probably heard me mention this joke a million times.
01:34:09 I always say, if you wish to have a very happy and long-lasting marriage, if you hear the
01:34:15 following question, do I look fat in those jeans, put on your consequentialist hat and
01:34:22 answer, no, you've never looked more beautiful, even if you might be slightly fibbing.
01:34:27 Why?
01:34:28 Because you care about your spouse's feeling.
01:34:31 you might be slightly engaging in a white lie, but it's for a good consequence. But there are
01:34:37 certain principles that by definition have to be deontological. Freedom of speech has to be
01:34:44 deontological. If you say, I believe in freedom of speech, but, then you're sinking into
01:34:50 consequentialism. I believe in freedom of inquiry, but, I believe in presumption of innocence, but
01:34:58 that doesn't work and by the way we saw it often in the last five six years right when when people
01:35:05 were celebrating the fact that donald trump had been had his account canceled on twitter all of
01:35:13 them said of course we believe in freedom of speech but not for an existential threat like
01:35:17 donald trump well i'm jewish i support the right of holocaust deniers to deny the holocaust there's
01:35:25 almost nothing that you could think of that is more offensive and insulting than to deny the
01:35:30 Holocaust. But in a free society, I have to be able to tolerate the falsehood spreaders, the imbeciles, 0.99
01:35:37 the racists, the haters. That's the price you pay for freedom, right? So Brett Kavanaugh, remember 0.99
01:35:44 when he was being confirmed and someone said, well, I think maybe it could be, I'm not really
01:35:49 sure, but I think 36 years ago, he was part of a gang of 16-year-old rapists that was going up and 0.61
01:35:56 down the eastern seaboard, raping everybody inside. And I think he actually raped me, but I don't 0.97
01:36:01 really have any proof. All of my very, very highfalutin professorial colleagues said, 0.60
01:36:08 oh, there you go. He's a rapist. We can't have him be a... I said, oh, what about this little thing 1.00
01:36:13 called, you know, we should maybe grant him the courtesy of presuming that he's innocent. No,
01:36:18 no no that doesn't apply to brett kavanaugh right what about our good friend the malibu meditator
01:36:24 sam harris who is all about writing books on he wrote a book called lying i mean literally the
01:36:31 book's called lying where he was extolling the values of never lying but remember when he went
01:36:38 on a show and said oh when there was a collusion between all of the social media companies and all
01:36:46 of the journalistic outlets to suppress the Hunter Biden laptop, that was okay because had it come out
01:36:59 what was in that laptop, then Orange Himmler would have become president again, and that would have
01:37:04 been an existential threat. So he believes in always telling the truth, but not when it comes
01:37:10 to the unique case of Donald Trump.
01:37:12 So my point to kind of wrap up
01:37:14 is that if you truly believe
01:37:17 that there are foundational principles
01:37:19 that are worthy of being deontological
01:37:22 within the American ethos,
01:37:24 you can't suddenly start flip-flopping
01:37:26 and no longer be deontological-minded
01:37:30 when it comes to your political opponents.
01:37:33 Very good.
01:37:33 Yes, Immanuel Kant thought the essence of immorality
01:37:36 was making an exception for yourself.
01:37:38 It may be that it also involves making an exception for everybody you don't like.
01:37:44 Well, you've heard the sad truth, so I hope you've gotten something and appreciated this.
01:37:50 I do want to remind you of The Parasitic Mind, as well as the new book, Suicidal Empathy.
01:37:57 And in addition, the book that just came out, what, three years ago?
01:38:02 Sad Truth About Happiness.
01:38:04 The Sad Truth About Happiness.
01:38:05 So let's all thank Gad Saad.
01:38:08 thank you very much
01:38:15 thank you all for coming