The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad - May 20, 2026


My Chat with Harvard Political Philosopher Dr. Harvey Mansfield (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_995)

Hosted by
Mentioned
Discussing Suicidal Empathy on One Nation with Brian Kilmeade (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_994) My Address at the World Symposium Against Antizionism (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_996)

Episode Stats


Length

26 minutes

Words per minute

121.94

Word count

3,192

Sentence count

131

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Willam R. Keenan Jr. has been a professor at Harvard since 1962. He is the author of two books, The Rise and Fall of Rational Control and Where Harvard Went Wrong: 50 Years of Commentary That Fell on Deaf ears. He was the recipient of the National Humanities Medal from President George W. Bush in 2004.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I'm delighted to report that I have joined as a scholar the Declaration of Independence Center
00:00:06 for the Study of American Freedom at the University of Mississippi. The center offers
00:00:12 educational opportunities, speakers, internship, and reading groups for the University of Mississippi
00:00:18 community. It is named in honor of the United States founding document which constitutes the
00:00:25 nation as a political community and expresses fundamental principles of American freedom,
00:00:31 including in the recognition of the importance of Judeo-Christian values in shaping American
00:00:37 exceptionalism. Dedicated to the academic and open-minded exploration of these principles,
00:00:43 the Center exists to encourage exploration into the many facets of freedom. It will sponsor a
00:00:50 speaker series, and an interdisciplinary faculty research team. If you'd like to learn more about
00:00:56 the center, please visit Ole Miss, that's O-L-E-M-I-S-S dot E-D-U slash independence slash.
00:01:05 Hi everybody, this is Scott Saad. Today I have a esteemed professor from Harvard who has been a
00:01:11 professor since 1962, before I was born. Professor Harvey Mansfield, how are you doing, sir?
00:01:20 pretty well thank you for considering my age yes uh well okay so i want to just briefly
00:01:28 introduce your bio it's a it's a shortened bio you're the william r keenan jr professor of
00:01:35 government at harvard as i said you've been at harvard since 1962 you were the head of the
00:01:41 department from 1973 to 1977 you held guggenheim and neh fellowships you were the recipient of
00:01:49 in 2004 of the National Humanities Medal from President George W. Bush. You've been the author
00:01:56 of many books, but today we're going to focus on two books, one that came out in 2026, this beauty
00:02:02 right here, The Rise and Fall of Rational Control. But you have another one that came out a week ago,
00:02:07 the same time as my book came out, and it's called Where Harvard Went Wrong, 50 Years of
00:02:14 commentary that fell on deaf ears so harvey where did harvard go wrong
00:02:23 harvard harvard went wrong by uh failing to take account of the monolithic character of itself and
00:02:33 And thinking that they could go along sitting and believing and speaking on the left and only on the left and nothing would ever happen to them.
00:02:50 And I think that was shown to be a mistaken view when the president that our woke corporation set before us, Claudine Gay, was forced to resign after a six-month tenure for being unable to explain why it was that Harvard,
00:03:20 was unable to refuse support
00:03:25 or to respond in any reasonable way
00:03:35 to the October 7th atrocity in Israel.
00:03:41 Now, how's this?
00:03:42 That was a good kid.
00:03:44 So it was actually,
00:03:45 it wasn't so much a lack of free speech
00:03:48 as the failure to use it properly
00:03:53 in that one searing occasion
00:03:56 that caused the trouble
00:03:58 and really forced her to resign.
00:04:02 And with her resigning,
00:04:05 suddenly everything else came apart.
00:04:10 And all the things that they had stood for,
00:04:15 they began to have to qualify and go back on.
00:04:21 And this was especially true of affirmative action and great inflation.
00:04:25 These were the two causes that I sort of held forth on for the time I was,
00:04:32 the 50 years that I was talking in the Harvard faculty.
00:04:38 The Supreme Court took care of affirmative action.
00:04:41 and well great inflation that was another liberal fantasy that was nobody defends it now nobody 0.53
00:04:51 defends either of those two things although i'm sure a lot of people still believe in them
00:04:58 do you did you see a radical shift in many of these issues over the past 10-15 years has there
00:05:07 been an acceleration of a lot of these woke parasitic ideas or were you able to sort of read
00:05:13 the writing on the wall from the 1960s? The writing on the wall in the 1960s would have been pretty
00:05:24 dim to read now and I mean it's the same sort of people and doing the same sort of things
00:05:33 But in the late 60s, the student rebels were more anti-American, more anti-war, and they didn't, well, they really tried to force the university to do what they wanted.
00:05:56 And there was resistance.
00:05:58 This time, they are the ones who inherited the tenured radicals they were, and so they were in charge, but they failed to take account of, you could say, the American people, or one half of the American people,
00:06:25 those who are not on the left.
00:06:29 And so even though they were this time
00:06:37 more calmer than in the late 60s,
00:06:43 they were the same people in charge
00:06:49 and they didn't have to be quite as rough
00:06:52 as their counterparts were earlier on.
00:06:57 So that's, I think, the comparison one could make.
00:07:01 In the late 60s, there wasn't the nastiness of anti-Semitism
00:07:10 that we saw here in Harvard starting October 8th.
00:07:18 Right.
00:07:18 And it had been planned that woke Harvard would come to its culmination in the appointment of Claudine Gay. 0.99
00:07:34 It was a black woman. 0.99
00:07:36 I know her.
00:07:37 I feel somewhat sorry for her. 0.99
00:07:41 But a black woman of woke belief was everything that the Harvard Corporation hoped to install.
00:07:53 And it fell apart very quickly. 0.77
00:07:57 Thanks to Elise Stefanik.
00:08:01 Yes.
00:08:01 Yes.
00:08:02 She's done great work.
00:08:04 It's from upstate New York. 0.99
00:08:06 Not a Jew, but a very effective accuser. 0.99
00:08:12 How was it for you over all the years? 0.51
00:08:15 She was the one.
00:08:17 Oh, sorry, if I can get a question.
00:08:19 How was it for you in all these years to be, I suspect,
00:08:23 one of the only outright and open conservative professors?
00:08:27 And it reminds me here of E.O. Wilson, who was a Harvard biologist.
00:08:32 I don't know if you know him, who went through a very difficult time himself.
00:08:36 Oh, yeah, I knew him, yeah.
00:08:37 Through the culture wars.
00:08:38 So would we say that your reception within Harvard was not unlike his at Harvard?
00:08:49 I didn't get quite the hostility that he did.
00:08:53 He was more of a threat to the ruling circles than I was.
00:08:59 So they listened to me most of the time, politely.
00:09:05 They heard me out, but they didn't listen.
00:09:08 They didn't really listen.
00:09:09 They didn't.
00:09:10 Nothing that I said went home to them.
00:09:14 And so I didn't have a terrible time having friends,
00:09:21 and my colleagues were congenial and helpful,
00:09:27 But they are the ones that hurt Harvard and brought it to the past that it came to.
00:09:43 So they are mostly the faculty that's responsible for what happened to Harvard.
00:09:49 they took it so far and were so provocative that at some point they were bound to encounter
00:09:59 opposition and that happened with donald trump uh surprisingly the first republican to take any
00:10:07 notice really of what was going on in the years in the universities so that so that was uh that
00:10:14 There's, of course, Trump, and he overdoes, I like to say,
00:10:20 he overdoes everything he does.
00:10:22 But he went after them with a bludgeon.
00:10:29 And, of course, that's still not over.
00:10:33 Do you hold out hope that the universities in their current form could be saved?
00:10:41 i do hold out hope partly because i'm optimistic and it's often irresponsible to be pessimistic
00:10:50 making excuses for yourself uh so i yes i i have hope i have some confidence that their
00:10:59 current harvard president and others like him uh spotted around the country uh see the necessity of
00:11:07 doing something different.
00:11:11 And so Alan Garber is our president,
00:11:16 and he's got some credit with the faculty for standing up to Trump.
00:11:20 And the question now is whether he can use that credit
00:11:23 to bring on reforms which the same faculty doesn't really care for.
00:11:28 Right. All right. Let's jump into this beauty right here.
00:11:32 So that's the...
00:11:35 Yeah, so there's a bit of a lag in our audio and apologies to all the listeners and viewers. There's a bit of a patchy connection, but we'll try to do the best that we can.
00:11:45 So here, Harvey, you list a bunch of guys, Machiavelli, Hobbes, Locke, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Emmanuel Kant, Hegel, Karl Marx, and Nietzsche. Why these specific guys versus some other ones give us the psychology of decision-making that included them and excluded others?
00:12:07 right well i was working under constraints this was a course i was giving so i had only a certain
00:12:18 number of lectures some 32 or something like that and i didn't want to give a course that
00:12:26 consisted merely of names and brief statements about each but i wanted to to read whole books
00:12:35 and to try to understand the arguments in those whole books.
00:12:40 And I came to the view that Machiavelli was really the source
00:12:45 of this trend of thinking called rational control,
00:12:52 trying to show how that was the case,
00:12:56 and then also how the principal variations or versions of rational control
00:13:04 or you could say of modernity,
00:13:06 that's my understanding of what is modern,
00:13:10 took place.
00:13:11 And there are people that I left out
00:13:13 like Montesquieu, Descartes, Spinoza.
00:13:20 So I often thought that there could be
00:13:25 a sort of alternative, of course,
00:13:29 that would take up all the people
00:13:30 that I had to leave out in this one.
00:13:34 But I think these are the principal voices which make, if not clear to us, at least present to our understanding what the most thoughtful, thought-out alternatives are in philosophy today or political philosophy.
00:13:57 I recently had on my show, I think, two historians that you undoubtedly know, one of whom was it was your colleague at Harvard, James Hankins and Alan Gueso.
00:14:10 You know, they wrote the two volume series, The Golden Thread. And in their case, I asked them.
00:14:16 Yeah, right. And I asked them a very similar question to what I asked you, which is, you know, how do you decide whom to include?
00:14:23 for example in their case just like you
00:14:25 they didn't include Spinoza
00:14:27 so that must be a very sort of
00:14:29 stressful decision making process
00:14:31 because on the one hand you obviously
00:14:33 can't include all of the great thinkers
00:14:35 but on the other hand you don't want to
00:14:37 leave an incomplete story
00:14:38 it's true
00:14:41 it's true
00:14:42 Spinoza especially you're right about that
00:14:44 he's
00:14:45 so the consummate modern
00:14:50 Jew 0.91
00:14:51 And it created modern Judaism and also presented alternatives to both Hobbes and Locke, as well as support for them.
00:15:11 And he was a great student of Machiavelli. 0.85
00:15:14 So, yes, Spinoza especially would be one I regret.
00:15:19 So not including. But nonetheless, I think this was enough for a single semester course.
00:15:32 So when I look at some of the names on that list, so for example, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in my view, he is actually responsible for some of the parasitic ideas that are at the root of wokeism. So the idea of the noble savage, the idea of the blank slate, I mean, which also John Locke talks about.
00:15:52 So as you go through these guys, are you able to exhibit the same reverence for them, notwithstanding that you know that some of their ideas led to some negative consequences down the line?
00:16:09 yes i i do try to do that i try to when i'm talking about rousseau i try to become a rousselian
00:16:18 and show people what what uh because he was not a stupid person right and even even more true of
00:16:27 marx said i i think uh i i gave a better view of marx than than a marxist would give or most of 0.95
00:16:35 So, yes, I try to step in and become a defender of the faith
00:16:44 of each one of my eight people with a few sort of concluding remarks
00:16:54 that show I haven't lost my notion of my beliefs.
00:17:02 right if i so i've often played this game with various uh people on my show when i asked them
00:17:08 if you could invite 10 historical people to your ultimate dinner party who would they be and before
00:17:16 i ask you to answer it i'll tell you who would be my number one it would be leonardo da vinci
00:17:22 because i'm a staunch interdisciplinarian i greatly admire people who are polymaths and of course by
00:17:29 definition he represents the ultimate renaissance man so if i were to ask you harvey who are the
00:17:36 10 men and people that you'd invite would the eight in your book be part of those 10 and you
00:17:41 just add another two or would you come up with a different list yes i think so those are all
00:17:48 moderns i also gave a course the semester ahead of this on the ancients so plato and aristotle
00:17:54 i'd certainly invite socrates number one and they don't aristotle and xenophon so and um and
00:18:06 somebody from the middle ages maybe uh um thomas aguinas or
00:18:17 maimonides let's have yes so i'm getting to more getting to more than 10.
00:18:23 right well i i was hoping that you would say maybe marcus aurelius because i love the fact
00:18:30 that here you had an emperor who would get annoyed when people would ask him to do emperor things
00:18:36 because he wanted to sit in his study and think and philosophize and that really resonated with
00:18:42 me again from a polymath perspective but fair enough uh what are some things that today you
00:18:48 You know, you've done it all. You've been a professor since the early 60s.
00:18:51 Are there things today that you wake up, you know, rub your hands in gleeful anticipation about the looming day?
00:19:00 What what keeps Harvey animated about the exciting future?
00:19:03 partisanship i think has been the theme of my writing starting from my first book
00:19:17 which was on edmund burke um thoughts on the cost of the present discontents
00:19:22 a really a pamphlet that he wrote in 1770 and this was the first argument
00:19:27 to argue that, to say that parties, political parties, in a decent regime, a republic maybe,
00:19:37 but not necessarily, was a good thing rather than a bad thing.
00:19:44 And Machiavelli had said that too.
00:19:46 But Machiavelli, well, he had two parties, the nobles and the plebs.
00:19:51 And those were sort of the nobility, the high-flown people, and the low plebeian types with whom they contested.
00:20:07 And so the latter were not respectable.
00:20:10 And what Burke did was to make it possible for gentlemen to disagree on partisan politics and still live together, or even govern together, or to govern in alternation.
00:20:29 Do you get invited to the cool kids party where everybody is progressive, or are you shunned and ostracized?
00:20:36 i'm certainly shunned and ostracized from anything progressive all of the you mentioned a couple of
00:20:46 honors that i've had every single honor i've had there's not a lot but every single one of them
00:20:51 came from a conservative source right so that tells you something and in fact that
00:20:59 That tells you something, too, about the state of academia today, because people reveal
00:21:07 themselves when they show you what they honor, and the type of person, and the type of reason
00:21:14 that they give.
00:21:16 And so, America's universities have honored only those on the left.
00:21:23 And that continues.
00:21:24 I'm waiting to see whether it'll be the case next week with Harvard.
00:21:29 They almost had a Republican last time, but not quite, not quite.
00:21:34 Maybe one will turn up.
00:21:38 Can I ask you for a favor, because I'm sure you have some pull within the relevant places.
00:21:45 Can we get Thomas Sowell a presidential freedom medal from the current president?
00:21:51 because he is, I think, roughly your age,
00:21:54 and he is certainly deserving of all possible accolades.
00:21:58 Can we make that happen, Harvey?
00:22:02 I don't have any particular good reception with Trump,
00:22:08 but I totally agree that he would be a number one choice for that.
00:22:16 Yes, a Medal of Freedom is what he should get.
00:22:19 One of my colleagues once did get that, James Q. Wilson, but Tom Sowell, I think, is the equal of him, and he's written so many books, and so intelligently and tirelessly, and he keeps himself away from universities and also from the lecture circuit by, well,
00:22:49 he's got a wife who takes care of him, like me,
00:22:53 but he saves himself for his writing,
00:23:00 and it's wonderful.
00:23:02 Right.
00:23:02 And, yeah.
00:23:04 What is it that made you, I mean, you know,
00:23:06 you've been at this, as I said, for many, many decades.
00:23:09 Most professors, even today, remain reticent
00:23:13 to adopt all of these new modes of communication that we have,
00:23:17 as we are doing right here yet here you are someone who's been around in academia longer
00:23:23 than them and yet you were perfectly happy to come on this show and chat how can we get the
00:23:28 rest of our colleagues to recognize that it's not only peer-reviewed journals that matter i'm
00:23:35 perfectly happy say again all right i wish i were perfectly comfortable i wish i were perfectly
00:23:43 be comfortable but i but uh yes i'm happy to be here and i i yeah i have the same feeling that we
00:23:50 need to catch up with uh technology and um which is uh rushing ahead almost out of control right
00:24:00 but i won't comment on that to ask you one other question i'm gonna cut our chat short if only
00:24:07 because we're having such technical difficulties with our, you know, link up. But otherwise,
00:24:14 I could stay with you here for hours. I want to ask you one final question, which I often
00:24:19 ask of my guests. It's a question on the psychology of regret. So Harvey, there are two types of
00:24:25 regret in life. There are regrets due to actions and regrets due to inaction. So regret due to
00:24:32 action would be I regret that I cheated on my wife and that led to my divorce regret due to
00:24:38 inaction would be I regret that I became a political philosopher because my dad was one
00:24:43 I've always wanted to be an architect and it turns out Harvey that for most people regrets
00:24:50 due to inaction are the ones that loom largest in their consciousness so if I were to ask you after
00:24:57 a life lived well
00:24:59 what is Harvey
00:25:01 Mansfield's most looming
00:25:03 regret would you care to share it with us
00:25:05 huh
00:25:07 well
00:25:10 I wish I was
00:25:12 smarter
00:25:14 oh you're being modest
00:25:16 you're being modest
00:25:17 no and deeper
00:25:20 and more profound
00:25:22 and I wish I could
00:25:24 write as well and as quickly as
00:25:26 tom saw well uh it is a very high bar to try to match the great thomas saw you know i i always say
00:25:37 that you know i've been fighting all these wokesters for you know some 30 years well he
00:25:42 was fighting them when i was in diapers so he's really the the old school guy who was swatting 1.00
00:25:49 them down so he's incredible yes a wonderful man all right well let me bring back again this book
00:25:57 people go out the rise and fall of rational control please check it out stay on the line
00:26:03 so we could say goodbye offline harvey thank you so much for coming on and come back anytime
00:26:08 my pleasure be well