The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad - April 29, 2024


My Chat with Mosab Hassan Yousef, Son of Hamas Founder - On Islam & Palestine (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_664)


Episode Stats

Length

59 minutes

Words per Minute

127.86296

Word Count

7,544

Sentence Count

408

Misogynist Sentences

7

Hate Speech Sentences

75


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Hassan Youssef is a Palestinian-American academic, author, journalist, and political activist. He is the author of the book, Son of Hamas: My Life as a Palestinian in the Middle East, and a regular contributor to the New York Times bestseller. In this episode, we talk about his life and how he became a rebel.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.920 Okay, guys, today I've got, I've had a lot of courageous people on the show, a lot, but
00:00:05.600 I don't know if there are too many that are more courageous than the guy that I'm speaking
00:00:08.980 to today.
00:00:10.200 Musab, Hassan, Youssef, how are you doing, sir?
00:00:13.100 Hey, brother.
00:00:13.980 Thank you for having me.
00:00:15.760 Well, of course, my pleasure.
00:00:17.120 You know, I've, I watched you, I think when your original book came out, Son of Hamas,
00:00:22.960 I think it was 2010, a New York Times bestseller.
00:00:25.400 I started seeing little clips of you, and then you kind of disappeared for a while,
00:00:30.100 and then you resurfaced now with a vengeance, and so it's such a thrill to be talking to
00:00:34.280 you.
00:00:34.900 Maybe we could start, Musab, by saying to each other hello in Arabic so that people know
00:00:39.960 that we are the real deal.
00:00:41.700 How are you doing?
00:00:43.440 Well, we've been doing it.
00:00:45.060 I've been doing it a lot, a lot, a lot, a lot, a lot, and I'm going to talk to you with
00:00:48.540 some of your language, the Palestinian language, you don't have to look at me, and I'm Lebanese.
00:00:55.400 Can you tell me?
00:01:01.820 Okay.
00:01:02.280 So I just, I tried to be a beggar for you, and I had to walkkat on Muslim.
00:01:14.200 Okay.
00:01:22.260 Okay.
00:01:24.260 Okay. So I just asked him, I just asked Basab, first, we just did niceties. Hi, how are you? And then I said, is your accent a Palestinian accent? Because, for example, we're Lebanese Jews, and there are a lot of similar accents between the Lebanese Jews and the Syrians and some Palestinians. And he said that his accent is one from Ramallah.
00:01:45.280 Okay, maybe we could start, Basab. You have an incredible story, your life story. Can you give a quick five, ten minute summary for people who don't know your work, what your trajectory in life has been?
00:01:58.020 It has been a challenge since day one. And whatever truth we have, how do we convey such a paradox or even metrics in some situations?
00:02:16.020 It's a complicated situation. I made very difficult choices. You can say I'm a rebel in nature, but I'm not always in a fight, even though since October 7, you say that I came with vengeance.
00:02:35.400 I did not want this. I did not want this. I did not want to talk about the Middle East, period, because it doesn't make sense for anyone who is outsider. But I think this is my dharma. It's my moral responsibility.
00:02:48.740 It was not just enough. It was not just enough to deflect from Hamas and draw the line that even though I was brought up in a conservative Muslim family, they believe that they are Palestinians, Arabs, nationalists, whatever it is.
00:03:08.740 I made very different choices. Because I don't think violence can bring peace to anybody in that region.
00:03:22.420 I did not believe in suicide bombing attacks, especially suicide bombing attacks, which was widely considered as a form of resistance.
00:03:30.780 Even today, after October 7, people have the audacity to actually say what happened on October 7 was justified or a form of resistance.
00:03:39.260 And I think this is the moral dilemma of the children of this conflict and now a new generation, a global generation that is joining the conflict.
00:03:52.000 And we want to justify our position.
00:03:58.160 Many people say, you know, I was born Palestinian means that I don't have moral responsibility towards the rest of humanity.
00:04:06.140 I'm a victim. I'm a victim. And here is my victim narrative. And they go on and on, magnifying their suffering.
00:04:13.040 We understand that they are suffering. The human experience is based on suffering.
00:04:19.220 Now, the fact that I was born for a Hamas leader, which, you know, I loved my father.
00:04:28.300 And many people think that I had issues with my father. But it's untrue.
00:04:33.320 My relationship with my father was excellent. With my family was excellent. I loved them. They loved me.
00:04:39.120 But my father's business has been a very, very bad business.
00:04:46.040 And this is where I had to choose.
00:04:50.480 You know, do I stick my head in the sand and just say I'm part of this culture, of this society, and resistance is justified?
00:04:59.940 Let's just go on for eternity, trying to annihilate the Jewish people, or let's say to annihilate the Israelis.
00:05:07.460 What's the difference?
00:05:10.300 It was nonsense and suicidal mission, especially for someone who was familiar with Hamas leadership, not only Hamas leadership, its military wing.
00:05:24.460 In fact, I was in Yasser Arafat's meetings.
00:05:29.920 In fact, I brought the information that condemned Yasser Arafat after winning the Nobel Peace Prize.
00:05:42.740 I, the one who brought the information of his direct connection to suicide bombing attacks.
00:05:49.160 And that was very serious, you know, to see just the double face of what's so called the revolutionary guards or the masters of the Palestinian cause, and how they have been deceiving everybody.
00:06:08.580 They did not care for the children.
00:06:10.760 In fact, they wanted the children to die.
00:06:14.380 This has been their game.
00:06:15.380 And this is a very sensitive issue because I witnessed so much bloodshed during the first Palestinian Intifada, and I always ask myself why.
00:06:26.900 And the widespread narrative on the Palestinian streets was, you know, because of occupation, colonialism, apartheid, the same broken record that so many people around the globe actually have been repeating.
00:06:45.380 So, but how long you can lie to somebody that all our suffering, our problems, our corruption, our abuse of women, of children, of power, stealing from public money, and using children as human shields.
00:07:04.060 Or during the first Intifada, Yasser Arafat was sitting in luxury, and other Palestinian leaders, and they wanted the children to confront tanks and the modern army, so they can show the world a wrong image of what's going on.
00:07:22.580 So, this nonsense of irresponsible, and not only irresponsible, they are criminals.
00:07:32.820 This entire revolution is the most corrupt revolution led by the most dangerous can artists of all time who have been actually trying to globalize the chaos and the violence.
00:07:50.380 And so, basically, this background did not mean that I would submit to the religion, to the belief system, to the political system.
00:08:02.780 And I followed my moral compass, but I had to disconnect from that world.
00:08:11.540 I mean, you cannot be just one leg in and one leg out to say, you know, the Palestinian cause, but reject violence.
00:08:24.780 Somehow, it depends on violence, it's a violent cause, it has been like this, even those who tried to make peace, it was a tactical thing for the Palestinian Authority, after the first Intifada, that they weren't sincere, actually, in their peace approach.
00:08:47.280 To them, it was tactical to just return, then continue from there.
00:08:52.860 So, I don't like hypocrisy, and I don't like when people lie, especially if it is going to lead to enslaving generation after generation after generation for how long, and for the sake of what.
00:09:10.480 So, I lost my faith in what's so-called revolution, because what I came to realize from early age, that the revolution was only for the sake of revolution.
00:09:21.580 It was not a revolution with a moral, ethical, fundamental compass that the revolution knew where they are heading.
00:09:35.000 So, basically, I can go on and on for hours, what actually made me make the change and reject the environment of my early life conditioning.
00:09:51.500 But was it, I mean, was there a catalyst, you know, you witnessed, you know, episode XYZ that really flipped you and, you know, made you realize things?
00:10:03.700 Or was it a gradual thing where at five or six years old, you were, you know, I tell, for example, the story of how when we grew up in Lebanon, and, you know, we'd go to the synagogue on Saturday morning, and I would ask my father, you know, why are we now standing?
00:10:18.160 Why are we chanting this? Why are we doing this? And then he would answer, you know, just shut up and do, don't ask questions.
00:10:24.860 And that, to me, even as a five, six-year-old, intellectually inquisitive boy, didn't sit well with me.
00:10:32.000 What do you mean I just get up and sit? I don't just follow, explain to me.
00:10:36.320 And so, already there, I started having doubts about, you know, the organized rigidity of religion.
00:10:42.260 So, in your case, is it something that you could say, you know, I was seven, eight, nine, ten years old, already having doubts?
00:10:48.220 Or it's only when you became heavily involved at a later age, as the son of the co-founder of Hamas, that these things came to, you know, to be clear to you?
00:10:59.220 Look, of course, I did not have the realizations that I have today.
00:11:04.080 Somehow, I knew them deep in my consciousness.
00:11:06.980 But it's an evolution.
00:11:12.640 And people want to reduce my life experience with all the adventures in it, in the public world and in the secret world of terrorist organization and the most powerful intelligence service out there.
00:11:27.880 They want to just reduce me to a victim, somebody who's got, like, issues with his father or someone who's got issues with Hamas.
00:11:40.060 They don't understand that this is a sole purpose.
00:11:44.660 And their lies, their false narrative, their false accusations, all attempts to discredit my life journey will go in vain.
00:11:59.500 And hence, I stand firm in my truth, because what I witnessed since childhood led me to this point.
00:12:08.460 When we talk about society that justify honor killing, how can we blame this on Israel or on the United States, on the colonizers?
00:12:27.040 This is a failing attempt to export all our problems, including social problems and cultural problems, on some hypothetical entity that we did not know about.
00:12:40.740 So, in principle, this I did not like.
00:12:45.040 I did not like to see a father hitting his daughter in the city square with a metal pipe on her head again and again and again until she died, while the public were watching and nobody did something about it.
00:13:08.800 No one tried to stop him.
00:13:10.740 Why? Because he's the father.
00:13:12.560 He has the authority to kill the woman, because the woman is a property in that society.
00:13:19.600 Now, this is not only one event in childhood.
00:13:23.740 It's happening all the time.
00:13:25.840 And in fact, there is no punishment for the honor killing.
00:13:30.060 So, a father can kill his daughter or a brother can kill his sister.
00:13:34.900 Then after that, there is no punishment.
00:13:36.960 They just give the gun to the Palestinian Authority police station and they don't spend even one night in prison.
00:13:43.560 So, now, when we are dealing with such brutality, you know, where the rape victims being punished equally as a rapist, and that's protected by the belief system.
00:14:00.700 This is protected by the culture.
00:14:05.280 It's the agreeable.
00:14:07.220 Then the cousin violence.
00:14:10.980 Then the factional violence.
00:14:13.780 Rival parties, each one of them belong to a foreign entity.
00:14:20.080 They have different masters, and they have extreme political views.
00:14:27.580 Irreconcilable in some cases, like in Fatah and Hamas.
00:14:32.220 And they are all claiming that they are fighting for Palestine.
00:14:37.380 I said, no.
00:14:38.400 What I see, what my first-hand observation, you are burning our people to death.
00:14:44.600 You don't care for the children.
00:14:46.000 You want people to die, and all you care about, money and power.
00:14:51.420 This has been their game.
00:14:54.020 So, the things went really south when I was in Megiddo prison.
00:15:00.340 I spent there about 16 months.
00:15:02.940 And this is where I witnessed Hamas brutality firsthand.
00:15:08.800 My father told me, we have to emancipate, or let's say, end the occupation.
00:15:17.700 And his version of end the occupation meant the ethnic cleansing of the Jewish people.
00:15:23.080 Then establishing an Islamic state.
00:15:25.820 Not a Palestinian state.
00:15:27.320 This is a very important point that people need to understand.
00:15:31.940 that most of the Palestinian factions, they are not even national organizations.
00:15:38.680 They are foreigners, or at least, they are serving foreign entities.
00:15:43.500 So now, when you want to go on such a suicidal mission,
00:15:47.700 you want to uproot a superpower.
00:15:52.140 A superpower.
00:15:52.740 And then you want to establish an Islamic state on the rubble of that power.
00:16:01.700 What does this really mean?
00:16:04.500 It means annihilation of everybody.
00:16:07.800 And could be a global war.
00:16:09.320 So how could this be?
00:16:10.580 How could any rational mind accept such an absurd agenda?
00:16:16.620 I don't want to say it's criminal only.
00:16:21.200 But if there is a definition of madness, this is what madness is all about.
00:16:28.260 And what animates this, and I mean, I think you'll agree with me,
00:16:31.960 but I'd really like to hear your perspective.
00:16:33.700 So growing up in Lebanon as a Jewish person,
00:16:36.900 even in tolerant, progressive, modern Lebanon,
00:16:41.060 Jew hatred was a banal part of the DNA of society, right?
00:16:45.960 People throw it at you like it's nothing.
00:16:48.020 It rained today, goddamn Jew.
00:16:50.000 I got diabetes, goddamn Jew.
00:16:52.100 My wife cheated on me.
00:16:53.500 It's the Jew who put the...
00:16:54.880 So I presume that you, growing up within the Palestinian territories,
00:16:59.780 you were exposed very early to Jew hatred.
00:17:02.860 And let's make it clear.
00:17:05.320 It's Jew hatred, not Zionist hatred, correct?
00:17:09.780 Yeah, absolutely.
00:17:11.400 It's all the attempts today to come and say,
00:17:14.320 oh, yeah, we are not anti-Jewish people,
00:17:18.080 but we are anti-Israel,
00:17:20.500 which, in my opinion, is even worse to say that.
00:17:26.160 Because this manipulation
00:17:29.140 and using, juggling with words
00:17:34.180 to hide the ill motive that we know
00:17:38.720 that the Arabs and the Muslims
00:17:41.520 have fundamental issue with the Jewish people.
00:17:45.540 And this conflict in the Middle East
00:17:49.280 is not a political conflict,
00:17:51.200 and it's not a conflict about the territory.
00:17:54.440 About land, yeah, exactly.
00:17:56.060 Or about land.
00:17:56.800 This is why many people want the artificial reasons.
00:18:02.940 They don't have the courage to dig deeper
00:18:04.840 that we have hundreds of millions of Muslims
00:18:07.480 around the world
00:18:08.440 that have been weaponizing their religious identity
00:18:12.600 against a religious minority in that region,
00:18:16.160 and they want it to cease to exist.
00:18:19.660 It's not only Israel.
00:18:21.160 What about me?
00:18:22.900 What we did in the Second Intifada,
00:18:25.900 risking my life on a regular basis,
00:18:29.140 trying to stop Hamas from blowing up
00:18:31.300 and buses, markets, universities,
00:18:36.960 killing people indiscriminately
00:18:38.440 in an era where Arabs, Jews, Christians,
00:18:42.980 or even Muslims were killed
00:18:45.580 during Hamas suicide bombing attacks.
00:18:49.880 So to take a stand against this brutality,
00:18:53.940 and I was never against the revolution
00:18:55.580 or against the resistance
00:18:57.340 or against my people.
00:18:58.700 We said Arab life and Jewish life.
00:19:02.620 There was no difference.
00:19:05.680 So why to be sentenced to death
00:19:10.100 for taking a moral stand,
00:19:13.140 to say no to shit in blood,
00:19:15.340 no to killing people indiscriminately?
00:19:17.840 Where do we draw the line
00:19:19.600 of what's so-called resistance?
00:19:22.520 To become barbaric by the name of resistance,
00:19:26.080 then discriminate against peaceful people.
00:19:31.160 My major at university was history,
00:19:34.460 and I allowed myself to study forbidden books
00:19:38.360 about the Holocaust, for example,
00:19:41.660 which the vast majority of the Arab world
00:19:46.100 are not educated when it comes to the Holocaust
00:19:49.400 because they deny it.
00:19:50.980 Even in the most respectful educational institutions
00:19:54.320 in the Arab world,
00:19:55.280 they reject the Holocaust.
00:19:58.620 And now we see actually,
00:20:00.920 October 7 was just almost a moment ago,
00:20:03.540 and we see the amount of denial
00:20:05.540 that it did not even happen.
00:20:07.300 So the denial of the Holocaust
00:20:11.700 and on the contrast,
00:20:13.780 me studying and reading about the Holocaust,
00:20:18.080 it was a heartbreaking experience.
00:20:22.300 The rise of Nazism also was fascinating.
00:20:27.200 I don't want to say fascinating,
00:20:28.080 but a dangerous phenomenon.
00:20:32.640 How fast?
00:20:33.480 Within five years,
00:20:35.300 how the Nazis were able to convert
00:20:37.820 and misguide the herd
00:20:40.940 towards unjustified Jewish hatred,
00:20:45.520 which eventually led to the death
00:20:48.100 of millions of people.
00:20:49.260 So there has to be a line,
00:20:56.480 like where do we draw the line?
00:20:58.020 I understand the frustration of people
00:21:01.880 when we are going through war,
00:21:04.460 the chaos of war.
00:21:06.140 This is understandable,
00:21:07.560 but we cannot hate others
00:21:11.200 because they are non-Muslims.
00:21:12.940 We cannot hate others
00:21:14.080 because they are different.
00:21:15.000 We cannot go on inciting
00:21:20.340 and reshaping generations
00:21:25.560 and feed them on hatred
00:21:28.020 towards other religions.
00:21:30.920 And this is what eventually led me
00:21:32.800 to study other religions,
00:21:34.300 and I start my criticism of Islam and Allah.
00:21:39.440 So there are so many things.
00:21:41.440 There is what actually,
00:21:43.220 the foundations of my truth,
00:21:44.600 where I stand today.
00:21:46.020 Some of it is political.
00:21:47.660 Some of it is personal.
00:21:49.340 Some of it is ideological.
00:21:51.380 And some of it is moral
00:21:52.920 and fundamental principles.
00:21:57.040 Do you think,
00:21:58.240 so some of the people
00:21:59.500 that I've talked to through the years
00:22:00.920 put on an optimistic lens
00:22:03.300 when it comes to Islam,
00:22:04.440 and they say,
00:22:05.400 if they're honest enough to admit,
00:22:07.100 yes, Islam contains a lot of content
00:22:10.080 that is completely incongruent
00:22:12.220 with our values here,
00:22:13.820 or let's say,
00:22:14.300 in Western secular societies.
00:22:16.440 But they will then add,
00:22:18.540 just like other religions
00:22:19.820 were able to reform,
00:22:22.680 certainly Islam can be reformable.
00:22:25.480 Now, I've often argued
00:22:26.660 that actually that is an impossibility
00:22:28.780 because if Islam is the final
00:22:31.400 inerrant word of God,
00:22:32.840 by definition,
00:22:33.680 it could not be changed.
00:22:34.660 Right?
00:22:34.840 There's not a single letter,
00:22:39.220 a single syllable
00:22:40.080 that should be changed.
00:22:41.440 So you really are at an impasse
00:22:43.140 where from a doctrinal perspective,
00:22:44.980 you cannot reform Islam.
00:22:47.280 So having said that,
00:22:48.080 my first question will be,
00:22:49.520 can you reform Islam?
00:22:50.840 And then my second question is,
00:22:52.780 can Islam coexist peacefully
00:22:55.460 within a Western context?
00:22:56.940 Look,
00:23:00.820 in order to reform Islam,
00:23:03.560 we need someone
00:23:04.160 with a higher authority
00:23:05.700 than Allah itself.
00:23:08.160 As long as this individual,
00:23:12.500 under the umbrella of Islam
00:23:14.500 or the constitution of Islam,
00:23:16.620 they don't have authority
00:23:17.580 to change the Quran.
00:23:18.540 they may have the authority
00:23:21.560 to have their own interpretation
00:23:23.660 and put some nice twist to it,
00:23:27.680 sugarcoat it,
00:23:29.160 and try to make it,
00:23:30.660 you know,
00:23:31.460 fit in the 21st century.
00:23:34.600 But can we do this
00:23:36.240 with every Islamic law?
00:23:38.620 Can we do this
00:23:39.840 with every verse in the Quran?
00:23:45.260 I don't think,
00:23:46.480 I cannot think of anybody
00:23:47.760 who has that authority.
00:23:50.540 And all the Islamic religious centers
00:23:55.220 or educational institutions,
00:23:57.520 they don't have that authority.
00:23:59.720 They are all under the burden
00:24:01.680 of a book
00:24:03.480 that was not even written
00:24:05.520 during the days of Muhammad.
00:24:07.600 It was written way after his death.
00:24:10.420 Muhammad himself claimed
00:24:12.060 that he was illiterate,
00:24:14.120 meaning he did not write it,
00:24:16.100 or when it was scripted.
00:24:19.880 He did not have the tool
00:24:23.560 to verify what others wrote
00:24:26.300 on his behalf.
00:24:27.980 Then it was collected
00:24:29.020 some 150 years later.
00:24:33.720 Some accounts say 400 years.
00:24:37.860 So how can I consider
00:24:41.120 this book legitimate?
00:24:43.980 Then the Islamic
00:24:45.680 sharia,
00:24:48.120 the Islamic law itself,
00:24:50.980 it cannot meet
00:24:54.420 with the demand
00:24:57.320 and the modern-day problems
00:24:59.860 for humanity.
00:25:02.940 If I want to go around
00:25:04.740 and start butchering people,
00:25:07.000 cutting their hands,
00:25:08.060 cutting their arms,
00:25:09.060 cutting their legs
00:25:09.980 because of felonies
00:25:12.580 or because of crimes
00:25:13.520 they are committed,
00:25:15.160 stoning people
00:25:16.060 in the city centers,
00:25:20.020 killing rapists
00:25:23.440 and rape victims
00:25:24.480 in the same place,
00:25:27.060 then what about jihad?
00:25:32.280 This is one of the biggest problems.
00:25:34.840 Most religions are delusional
00:25:36.680 and they need to be
00:25:37.940 actually integrated.
00:25:39.300 They have the essence
00:25:40.160 and the intelligent people
00:25:42.080 see the essence of the way.
00:25:44.660 And they can integrate it
00:25:46.440 into a higher consciousness.
00:25:48.260 That's possible.
00:25:49.840 The Sufis were able actually
00:25:52.060 to see Islam beyond politics
00:25:55.260 and beyond man-made laws
00:25:59.340 because if you are spiritual
00:26:01.360 in your essence,
00:26:02.860 if you are sincere
00:26:03.740 and devotional,
00:26:05.900 you will arrive at the truth eventually
00:26:07.600 because with humility
00:26:09.040 and devotion,
00:26:10.740 truthfulness,
00:26:12.040 discipline,
00:26:13.560 fasting,
00:26:14.600 praying,
00:26:15.840 this is not a political thing.
00:26:19.840 But who those actually
00:26:21.740 need the politics
00:26:25.340 or they need the religious mask?
00:26:28.380 Those are the ones
00:26:29.140 who are insecure.
00:26:30.980 Those are the ones
00:26:31.700 who are just cheap.
00:26:34.700 They don't have authority
00:26:36.360 over their own lives.
00:26:38.080 and they cannot escape
00:26:41.800 the cave of religion.
00:26:45.300 It's their security.
00:26:46.860 It's their identity.
00:26:47.860 It's everything they know.
00:26:49.760 So hence,
00:26:52.780 they want now
00:26:54.560 to convert everybody,
00:26:56.140 the rest of the universe,
00:26:57.180 to be like them
00:26:58.160 rather than trying to integrate
00:27:00.180 to a higher consciousness.
00:27:02.680 So there are so many
00:27:03.700 fundamental problems
00:27:05.040 about Islam.
00:27:05.940 jihad is the most dangerous
00:27:09.280 aspect of Islam
00:27:11.380 that is not available
00:27:12.580 in other religions.
00:27:14.600 Not only to be delusional
00:27:16.440 in your belief
00:27:17.840 because Muslims say
00:27:20.480 that they are believers.
00:27:23.260 And I say,
00:27:24.040 well,
00:27:24.200 believing is not enough.
00:27:26.580 It's either you know
00:27:28.140 or you don't know.
00:27:29.220 don't tell me
00:27:30.820 you believe
00:27:31.280 or you disbelieve.
00:27:32.940 So the fact
00:27:34.440 that they say
00:27:35.300 that they are believers
00:27:36.440 of Allah as entity
00:27:39.100 that sits on a throne
00:27:40.620 at the corner
00:27:41.320 of the universe
00:27:42.160 that who has been
00:27:43.520 preparing a hellfire
00:27:44.920 for all the infidels
00:27:46.400 and the majority
00:27:47.660 of humanity
00:27:48.460 who are non-Muslims
00:27:50.740 sounds
00:27:52.120 absurd.
00:27:56.420 So how do you,
00:27:57.820 someone who had
00:27:59.280 your personal trajectory
00:28:00.880 in life,
00:28:01.860 who's coming
00:28:02.380 with all the,
00:28:04.140 you know,
00:28:04.500 you have all
00:28:05.300 of the credentials
00:28:06.300 and right imprimatur
00:28:07.720 to say,
00:28:08.340 I know what I'm talking about.
00:28:09.580 I don't need some,
00:28:11.340 you know,
00:28:12.040 undergraduate
00:28:12.860 at Columbia University
00:28:14.400 who can't tell
00:28:15.360 where,
00:28:16.180 what Islam is
00:28:17.080 or what Palestine
00:28:17.900 is to be lecturing me.
00:28:19.460 And yet we're seeing
00:28:20.520 millions of Westerners
00:28:22.780 fall completely
00:28:24.240 under the sway
00:28:25.320 of this romantic idea
00:28:27.220 of,
00:28:27.620 you know,
00:28:27.880 Islam is the language,
00:28:29.420 is the religion
00:28:30.380 of the noble brown person.
00:28:33.660 Palestine is the,
00:28:34.980 is the land
00:28:35.940 of the oppressed.
00:28:37.020 So there's kind of
00:28:37.660 a romantic view
00:28:39.060 that is in part
00:28:40.160 shaped by this
00:28:41.140 astronomical ignorance
00:28:43.120 about the realities
00:28:44.200 that you can certainly
00:28:45.120 speak to.
00:28:45.880 How do we get
00:28:46.700 to the Westerners
00:28:47.920 to appreciate
00:28:48.980 some of the things
00:28:49.900 that you're talking about?
00:28:50.820 Is there a way
00:28:51.620 or is it completely hopeless,
00:28:53.520 Mossad?
00:28:55.960 Well,
00:28:56.540 it takes
00:28:57.040 manifestation
00:28:59.740 to understand
00:29:01.400 a certain theory.
00:29:04.660 For those who
00:29:05.840 studied history,
00:29:07.640 especially
00:29:08.980 the Islamic history,
00:29:11.100 it is not,
00:29:12.600 it's not a secret
00:29:16.020 what was the outcome
00:29:17.520 of an Islamic
00:29:18.360 Khilafah
00:29:18.940 and how many
00:29:19.840 Khilafahs
00:29:20.560 the Muslims
00:29:22.740 tried to actually
00:29:23.960 establish.
00:29:24.960 Can you explain
00:29:25.720 what it is
00:29:26.940 for those who
00:29:27.460 don't know
00:29:27.740 what that is?
00:29:28.540 Well,
00:29:29.000 Khilafah means
00:29:29.840 literally
00:29:30.500 an Islamic state,
00:29:31.720 but this Islamic state
00:29:33.480 is not
00:29:33.980 limited to
00:29:35.220 political border.
00:29:36.740 It's not limited
00:29:37.440 to
00:29:37.980 geography.
00:29:41.500 It's a global state
00:29:43.280 that it's the duty
00:29:44.620 of all jihadists,
00:29:46.100 of all Muslims
00:29:46.900 to fight,
00:29:49.060 to fight,
00:29:50.460 to practice jihad.
00:29:52.660 And I say
00:29:53.560 this is an
00:29:54.100 Islamic obligation
00:29:55.700 according
00:29:56.800 all Islamic
00:29:58.480 resources
00:29:59.000 that jihad
00:30:00.960 is the most
00:30:02.840 fundamental
00:30:03.480 principle
00:30:04.920 of Islam
00:30:05.660 and all Muslims
00:30:06.900 are committed
00:30:07.840 to jihad.
00:30:09.120 Now,
00:30:09.940 those who
00:30:10.720 cannot fight
00:30:11.820 by the means
00:30:13.440 of the sword,
00:30:14.580 like they are not
00:30:15.540 capable physically
00:30:16.620 or mentally,
00:30:17.960 they have to
00:30:20.180 donate
00:30:20.500 and they have
00:30:21.740 to fund
00:30:22.460 those
00:30:23.440 who are able
00:30:24.600 to fight.
00:30:26.180 And this shows
00:30:26.940 you why
00:30:27.560 the majority,
00:30:29.080 the vast majority
00:30:29.820 of the Muslim world
00:30:30.900 are complicit
00:30:31.940 in jihad
00:30:33.560 and jihadism
00:30:34.840 to the degree
00:30:36.980 they have failed
00:30:38.160 to condemn
00:30:38.980 Hamas
00:30:39.820 up to now.
00:30:40.840 Why?
00:30:41.240 Because
00:30:41.620 they know
00:30:42.820 deep
00:30:43.780 in their belief
00:30:44.840 that Hamas
00:30:45.780 is practicing
00:30:46.720 Islam.
00:30:50.860 Now,
00:30:51.720 the fancy
00:30:52.380 idea
00:30:53.020 of
00:30:53.720 let's
00:30:54.840 try
00:30:55.700 to destroy
00:30:56.620 or annihilate
00:30:58.120 civilizations
00:31:00.220 in the West
00:31:01.920 and in the East,
00:31:03.560 Islam is not
00:31:04.780 only against
00:31:05.900 Christians
00:31:07.260 or Jews.
00:31:08.740 Islam is against
00:31:09.720 all non-Muslims.
00:31:12.340 And
00:31:12.700 that includes
00:31:13.520 Hindus,
00:31:14.740 that includes
00:31:15.340 Buddhists,
00:31:16.720 and we have
00:31:17.600 a long history
00:31:18.540 of Islamic
00:31:19.700 violence
00:31:20.260 against
00:31:20.900 all other
00:31:22.040 religious
00:31:23.520 religions
00:31:26.340 around the world.
00:31:29.180 Now,
00:31:29.760 for people,
00:31:30.780 it's fancy
00:31:31.340 because they
00:31:31.960 haven't experienced
00:31:33.240 the manifestation
00:31:35.100 of an Islamic
00:31:35.940 state
00:31:36.440 and
00:31:38.500 or they lack
00:31:39.800 knowledge.
00:31:41.700 They are not
00:31:42.260 familiar with
00:31:42.880 the Islamic
00:31:43.260 history
00:31:43.760 that
00:31:44.600 I don't
00:31:45.660 want to
00:31:45.960 say
00:31:46.260 millions,
00:31:47.180 but at
00:31:47.440 least
00:31:47.600 hundreds
00:31:48.040 of thousands
00:31:48.820 of Muslims
00:31:49.720 actually
00:31:50.380 killed each
00:31:52.080 other
00:31:52.340 in the
00:31:54.380 internal
00:31:55.020 Islamic
00:31:55.680 conflict
00:31:56.160 between
00:31:56.660 Islamic
00:31:57.120 Khilafahs.
00:31:57.920 So,
00:31:59.120 I don't
00:31:59.680 want to
00:32:00.080 go too
00:32:01.160 far
00:32:01.540 with this.
00:32:03.320 The Islamic
00:32:03.840 state
00:32:04.300 throughout the
00:32:04.980 centuries,
00:32:05.740 1400 years
00:32:07.340 of experience,
00:32:08.380 proved to be
00:32:09.220 a dead
00:32:09.620 end,
00:32:11.000 proved to be
00:32:11.820 a failing
00:32:12.420 model that
00:32:13.520 did not
00:32:13.940 work.
00:32:15.300 So,
00:32:15.940 today,
00:32:17.800 as a
00:32:18.740 historian,
00:32:21.700 as a
00:32:22.480 person
00:32:22.960 who
00:32:24.140 is not
00:32:26.180 willing to
00:32:26.540 compromise
00:32:26.920 my
00:32:27.300 intelligence,
00:32:29.080 I know
00:32:29.600 that the
00:32:30.100 Islamic
00:32:30.640 Khilafah
00:32:33.840 will not
00:32:34.760 lead to
00:32:35.600 prosperity,
00:32:36.600 to peace,
00:32:37.180 to stability,
00:32:38.060 to justice,
00:32:38.920 and it is
00:32:39.840 going only
00:32:40.540 to ignite
00:32:41.720 the blood
00:32:42.700 lust
00:32:43.180 for more
00:32:44.780 dominion,
00:32:45.880 for more
00:32:46.220 aggression,
00:32:47.400 where
00:32:47.940 the Muslim
00:32:49.700 jihadists
00:32:50.540 can
00:32:51.360 take
00:32:53.920 women,
00:32:54.800 children,
00:32:55.320 as booty,
00:32:56.160 they can
00:32:56.540 enslave
00:32:57.240 humanity,
00:32:59.100 in case
00:33:00.000 they don't
00:33:00.440 convert to
00:33:01.000 Islam.
00:33:02.200 So,
00:33:03.340 my
00:33:05.240 intelligence
00:33:05.820 does not
00:33:06.380 allow me
00:33:07.220 to accept
00:33:08.800 such a
00:33:09.600 belief system,
00:33:10.740 and many
00:33:11.340 people tried
00:33:12.340 so hard
00:33:13.640 to differentiate,
00:33:14.700 say,
00:33:14.980 no,
00:33:15.200 there are
00:33:15.660 good Muslims
00:33:17.080 and there
00:33:17.580 are bad
00:33:18.080 Muslims.
00:33:19.220 You know,
00:33:19.500 this game
00:33:20.100 of
00:33:20.620 good cup
00:33:23.200 versus
00:33:23.920 bad cup,
00:33:25.880 but they
00:33:26.280 are both,
00:33:27.500 or both
00:33:28.000 parties are
00:33:28.720 serving the
00:33:29.300 same God,
00:33:30.400 they are
00:33:30.780 serving the
00:33:31.340 same
00:33:32.280 constitution.
00:33:35.720 Hence,
00:33:36.780 we have to
00:33:37.760 address Islam
00:33:38.620 the way it
00:33:39.200 is,
00:33:40.520 and
00:33:40.980 the more
00:33:43.040 we tolerate
00:33:43.880 such an
00:33:45.140 aggressive
00:33:45.540 and
00:33:47.000 violent
00:33:49.280 mindset,
00:33:51.440 more
00:33:52.620 violence
00:33:53.080 will happen.
00:33:54.040 And we
00:33:54.280 don't want,
00:33:55.040 we don't,
00:33:55.620 I don't want
00:33:56.160 this young
00:33:57.960 enthusiasts
00:33:59.160 who think
00:34:00.700 that
00:34:01.760 establishing an
00:34:03.280 Islamic state
00:34:04.240 or a
00:34:04.720 Palestinian state
00:34:05.700 on the
00:34:06.020 rubble of
00:34:06.400 Israel
00:34:06.740 or an
00:34:07.340 Islamic state
00:34:08.120 on the
00:34:08.440 rubble of
00:34:08.760 civilization,
00:34:10.540 what's,
00:34:11.620 what's in
00:34:12.660 common between
00:34:13.120 these two
00:34:14.080 entities,
00:34:14.860 Palestine and
00:34:15.700 the Islamic
00:34:16.140 state,
00:34:16.560 that both
00:34:17.260 of them
00:34:17.620 depend on
00:34:18.460 the destruction
00:34:19.100 of that
00:34:20.540 which exists.
00:34:22.720 So then
00:34:23.480 how do you,
00:34:24.400 so if you
00:34:25.200 were,
00:34:25.520 let's say,
00:34:26.440 Masab,
00:34:26.860 you were
00:34:27.400 the leader
00:34:28.240 of the
00:34:28.540 free world,
00:34:29.180 you were
00:34:29.460 the emperor
00:34:30.100 of reason,
00:34:31.580 would you
00:34:32.160 halt
00:34:32.680 immigration
00:34:33.400 from Islamic
00:34:34.400 countries
00:34:35.060 knowing that
00:34:36.440 notwithstanding
00:34:37.460 the fact
00:34:37.960 that there
00:34:38.260 are millions
00:34:38.820 of peaceful,
00:34:39.940 loving Muslims
00:34:40.540 that don't
00:34:41.020 want to hurt
00:34:41.440 anybody,
00:34:42.340 Islam itself
00:34:43.280 is problematic
00:34:44.300 in terms of
00:34:45.020 it being able
00:34:45.700 to assimilate
00:34:46.400 within a
00:34:46.880 Western context
00:34:47.840 and therefore
00:34:49.240 how could you
00:34:50.140 allow millions
00:34:50.820 of people
00:34:51.280 to come
00:34:51.640 into your
00:34:52.020 country
00:34:52.420 that have
00:34:53.400 95,
00:34:54.360 99%
00:34:55.440 of them
00:34:55.840 Jew hatred,
00:34:56.820 you're going
00:34:57.240 to get an
00:34:57.780 increase in
00:34:58.360 Jew hatred,
00:34:58.900 I live in
00:34:59.320 Montreal,
00:35:00.300 20 years
00:35:00.960 ago,
00:35:01.420 I never
00:35:01.900 had to
00:35:02.340 worry about
00:35:03.020 Islam,
00:35:03.780 today I
00:35:04.640 have to be
00:35:05.080 very careful
00:35:05.740 not to wear
00:35:06.480 a star of
00:35:07.080 David that's
00:35:07.640 too big
00:35:08.080 in Montreal,
00:35:09.000 Canada,
00:35:09.720 so is the
00:35:10.760 ultimate goal
00:35:11.800 going to be
00:35:12.660 Islam cannot
00:35:14.220 coexist,
00:35:15.700 within the
00:35:16.320 West or
00:35:16.800 is there
00:35:17.200 a way
00:35:17.540 to my
00:35:18.080 earlier
00:35:18.440 question
00:35:18.940 of making
00:35:20.480 it somehow
00:35:21.040 more gentle
00:35:21.860 or are we
00:35:22.740 doomed,
00:35:23.480 give us
00:35:24.300 some optimism.
00:35:26.920 Okay,
00:35:27.680 take for
00:35:31.140 example
00:35:31.580 Americans
00:35:33.420 from Muslim
00:35:34.200 background,
00:35:35.720 when they
00:35:36.120 vow loyalty
00:35:37.220 to the
00:35:37.700 American
00:35:37.980 constitution,
00:35:39.400 before they
00:35:40.440 get their
00:35:40.880 citizenship
00:35:41.380 as immigrants,
00:35:43.700 they make a
00:35:44.200 vow to the
00:35:44.800 American
00:35:45.060 constitution
00:35:45.700 and loyalty,
00:35:47.080 national loyalty
00:35:48.320 to the United
00:35:48.940 States,
00:35:49.460 this is the
00:35:50.260 supreme authority
00:35:51.340 of all
00:35:51.860 Americans,
00:35:53.540 but are
00:35:55.340 Muslims
00:35:55.840 sincere when
00:35:57.380 they pledge
00:35:58.520 loyalty to the
00:36:02.420 American
00:36:02.760 constitution,
00:36:03.980 are they sincere?
00:36:04.700 Because this
00:36:05.500 contradicts with
00:36:06.240 Islamic law,
00:36:07.400 the Sharia law
00:36:08.180 does not see
00:36:09.700 any higher
00:36:10.620 authority
00:36:11.260 than Allah,
00:36:13.460 whether if
00:36:13.980 it's earthly
00:36:14.760 or heavenly,
00:36:17.100 Allah is,
00:36:19.060 don't they say
00:36:20.140 Allahu Akbar
00:36:20.800 means Allah
00:36:22.440 is greater,
00:36:22.960 the greatest,
00:36:23.700 yeah,
00:36:24.300 it's not the
00:36:25.000 greatest,
00:36:25.480 it's greater,
00:36:26.180 but greater
00:36:26.560 than who?
00:36:27.080 Than what?
00:36:27.600 Yeah.
00:36:28.300 Than everything
00:36:28.840 else,
00:36:29.440 than the other
00:36:30.760 gods,
00:36:31.400 and then man,
00:36:32.440 then creation,
00:36:33.740 they totally
00:36:34.300 separate divinity
00:36:35.840 from creation
00:36:37.020 and I think
00:36:37.700 this is a
00:36:38.140 fundamental
00:36:38.600 problem in
00:36:42.320 Islam
00:36:42.720 that does
00:36:43.800 not see
00:36:44.260 actually
00:36:44.880 the creator
00:36:47.520 and creation
00:36:48.680 as one thing.
00:36:51.220 So anyway,
00:36:52.920 we need the
00:36:54.720 Muslims who
00:36:55.560 immigrate
00:36:56.480 to the West
00:36:57.460 to make
00:37:00.300 their loyalty
00:37:01.000 to the country
00:37:02.180 that welcomes
00:37:03.040 them and give
00:37:03.780 them citizenship,
00:37:04.900 not loyalty
00:37:07.580 to a hypothetical
00:37:08.640 entity called
00:37:09.960 whatever you
00:37:10.660 want to call
00:37:11.200 it.
00:37:12.420 Now,
00:37:13.440 people have
00:37:15.000 the freedom
00:37:15.340 to practice
00:37:15.920 Islam if they
00:37:16.600 want.
00:37:17.740 At some point,
00:37:18.820 I was practicing
00:37:19.800 Islam more
00:37:21.280 than anyone
00:37:21.800 else.
00:37:23.260 My mother
00:37:24.060 used to say,
00:37:24.660 you were born
00:37:25.240 in a mosque,
00:37:26.560 you know,
00:37:26.840 when she wanted
00:37:27.520 to give me a
00:37:28.120 hard time,
00:37:28.940 when I asked
00:37:29.700 questions.
00:37:30.860 And it's
00:37:31.240 true.
00:37:32.640 Islam was
00:37:33.540 our project,
00:37:34.900 my family
00:37:35.820 brought
00:37:37.820 Islam back
00:37:38.400 to life.
00:37:39.820 So this
00:37:41.500 is where I
00:37:41.960 get my
00:37:42.360 authority to
00:37:43.020 criticize
00:37:43.400 Islam.
00:37:44.800 Also as
00:37:45.620 someone who
00:37:46.500 went to a
00:37:47.020 Sharia
00:37:47.240 school,
00:37:48.540 someone who
00:37:49.580 studied the
00:37:50.120 Quran,
00:37:51.820 someone who's
00:37:52.800 familiar with
00:37:53.820 the Islamic
00:37:54.420 intellect and
00:37:55.260 the different
00:37:55.780 Islamic schools,
00:37:57.480 their dialogue
00:37:58.500 and their
00:37:59.080 argument.
00:37:59.920 government.
00:38:01.060 So you
00:38:03.380 cannot be
00:38:03.780 American and
00:38:04.320 Muslim at
00:38:04.720 the same
00:38:04.980 time.
00:38:06.220 You have
00:38:06.740 to choose.
00:38:07.940 If you
00:38:08.520 want to be,
00:38:09.140 if you make
00:38:09.860 your pledge
00:38:10.620 and your
00:38:11.020 loyalty to
00:38:11.620 the American
00:38:12.000 constitution,
00:38:12.560 you are
00:38:12.940 contradicting
00:38:13.400 with Allah.
00:38:14.120 Then you
00:38:14.460 have a
00:38:14.740 moral crisis.
00:38:16.600 So, but
00:38:17.900 there is a
00:38:18.420 concept in
00:38:18.960 Islam called
00:38:19.800 taqiyya.
00:38:21.600 And in
00:38:21.920 taqiyya, you
00:38:23.200 can announce
00:38:24.200 something, like
00:38:25.020 if you were
00:38:25.720 in Dar
00:38:26.260 Al-Kafr, which
00:38:27.020 is, let's
00:38:27.620 say, the
00:38:28.040 country of
00:38:29.060 infidels.
00:38:30.400 In the
00:38:30.920 country of
00:38:31.420 infidels, if
00:38:32.340 you were
00:38:32.740 forced to
00:38:34.220 choose, let's
00:38:35.520 say, a
00:38:36.180 fake identity,
00:38:37.920 let's say
00:38:38.160 American, this
00:38:38.760 is a fake
00:38:39.160 identity, but
00:38:40.400 your true
00:38:40.900 identity is
00:38:41.680 Islam.
00:38:42.140 So you can
00:38:42.640 hide your
00:38:43.220 true identity
00:38:44.040 to avoid
00:38:45.060 persecution and
00:38:46.440 pretend to be
00:38:47.200 American in
00:38:47.840 the meantime.
00:38:48.980 But when we
00:38:49.640 have chaos, like
00:38:50.780 the chaos we
00:38:51.440 experience in
00:38:52.160 right now
00:38:52.640 regarding
00:38:53.120 Palestine, all
00:38:55.000 of the
00:38:55.240 sudden,
00:38:55.720 the loyalty
00:38:57.560 is not to
00:38:58.220 the American
00:38:58.600 constitution, it
00:38:59.920 becomes the
00:39:00.600 loyalty to
00:39:01.420 Islam and
00:39:02.020 to Allah.
00:39:04.460 Are you
00:39:05.620 able to,
00:39:07.540 I mean,
00:39:08.800 when you
00:39:09.420 make your
00:39:11.040 public
00:39:11.440 pronouncements,
00:39:12.920 is there a
00:39:14.140 greater success
00:39:15.200 rate in
00:39:15.980 trying to
00:39:16.920 convince the
00:39:18.200 Westerners who
00:39:19.060 have romanticized
00:39:20.020 these ideas,
00:39:20.940 or are you
00:39:21.780 able to take
00:39:23.000 some of the
00:39:23.560 doubting Muslims
00:39:24.500 and get them
00:39:25.600 to finally
00:39:26.060 see the
00:39:26.440 light?
00:39:26.680 Is there a
00:39:27.140 difference in
00:39:27.700 your ability
00:39:28.360 to actually
00:39:29.060 persuade either
00:39:30.020 of these two
00:39:30.560 groups?
00:39:32.840 Look, I
00:39:34.140 have been in
00:39:34.640 this, I
00:39:39.020 don't know,
00:39:39.320 say a mission
00:39:39.860 because I don't
00:39:40.380 have a mission,
00:39:40.980 but journey
00:39:41.640 trying to
00:39:43.220 explain to
00:39:43.900 people, the
00:39:45.700 danger of
00:39:46.360 Islam, and
00:39:47.700 it looks like
00:39:48.920 many people
00:39:49.440 are in
00:39:49.780 denial because
00:39:51.640 they don't
00:39:52.020 want to
00:39:52.320 accept that
00:39:53.360 there are
00:39:54.040 200 or
00:39:56.700 there are 2
00:39:57.640 billion, close
00:39:58.880 to 2 billion
00:39:59.740 Muslims.
00:40:00.860 About one
00:40:01.380 fourth of
00:40:01.860 humanity.
00:40:02.360 A quarter
00:40:03.980 population of
00:40:04.840 earth believe
00:40:06.620 in a, in
00:40:08.660 a Sikh
00:40:09.160 religion.
00:40:12.320 And I am
00:40:13.840 not going to
00:40:14.600 sugarcoat it.
00:40:17.200 My, my
00:40:18.980 personal, it's
00:40:19.880 not an opinion,
00:40:20.960 but my personal
00:40:21.660 experience with
00:40:22.740 Islam and its
00:40:23.680 evolution.
00:40:24.200 Islam is a
00:40:27.520 mental illness
00:40:28.580 and the
00:40:30.860 Muslims, Muslims
00:40:32.620 are mentally
00:40:33.920 ill.
00:40:35.780 I cannot trust
00:40:36.980 them with
00:40:37.620 anything because
00:40:38.420 they are
00:40:38.820 double-faced,
00:40:40.220 because they are
00:40:41.520 conflicted about
00:40:42.500 their religious
00:40:43.040 identity, and
00:40:44.580 all they know
00:40:45.340 how to demonstrate
00:40:46.280 is violence and
00:40:47.280 aggression whenever
00:40:48.720 they are threatened
00:40:49.560 in their comfort,
00:40:51.680 in the cave of
00:40:52.640 their delusion.
00:40:54.180 So, it's my
00:40:55.740 moral stand.
00:40:56.920 It's very
00:40:57.220 different than
00:40:57.700 yours.
00:40:58.120 You don't have
00:40:58.680 to go there
00:40:59.280 and confront
00:40:59.940 you, you
00:41:00.220 can't help
00:41:00.720 the dialogue.
00:41:01.440 But I
00:41:01.880 personally, don't
00:41:04.000 sit with people
00:41:04.800 who want me to
00:41:05.940 cease to exist.
00:41:08.320 When they push
00:41:09.380 me to the
00:41:09.860 corner where I'm
00:41:10.720 fighting for my
00:41:11.560 life, for a
00:41:12.800 crime that I
00:41:13.620 haven't committed,
00:41:15.460 then they have
00:41:16.240 crossed all the
00:41:17.040 lines and there
00:41:17.740 is no dialogue
00:41:18.480 between me and
00:41:19.380 such people.
00:41:20.760 And I will
00:41:21.420 fight.
00:41:22.160 First, I will
00:41:22.840 fight the good
00:41:23.300 fight.
00:41:24.260 And I will
00:41:25.080 do whatever
00:41:25.660 it takes to
00:41:26.980 defend myself.
00:41:28.320 It doesn't
00:41:28.860 matter if they
00:41:29.420 are 2 billion
00:41:31.100 or 8 billion.
00:41:32.380 It doesn't
00:41:32.820 matter.
00:41:34.140 So, to see
00:41:37.500 it in a
00:41:38.580 positive way,
00:41:39.980 I think the
00:41:40.780 upper hand
00:41:41.640 should be to
00:41:43.740 a civil
00:41:44.320 constitution.
00:41:46.020 And first, we
00:41:46.720 need to
00:41:47.100 demonstrate this
00:41:48.120 here in the
00:41:48.700 United States,
00:41:49.640 like the
00:41:50.040 Muslims.
00:41:50.380 Muslims, what
00:41:50.900 is your
00:41:51.360 loyalty?
00:41:52.380 Is it to
00:41:52.840 Allah or to
00:41:53.640 the American
00:41:54.000 constitution?
00:41:54.900 Because Christians,
00:41:56.040 Buddhists, Hindus,
00:41:57.540 all other
00:41:58.100 religions, including
00:41:59.180 Jews in the
00:41:59.900 United States, all
00:42:01.140 American citizens
00:42:02.040 are under the
00:42:04.020 authority of the
00:42:06.480 American constitution.
00:42:07.740 nation, no one is
00:42:08.780 above the
00:42:09.460 law.
00:42:10.260 Isn't this the
00:42:12.040 rule of the
00:42:12.680 law, that no
00:42:13.600 one is above
00:42:14.160 the law?
00:42:15.060 But for some
00:42:15.760 reason, Muslims
00:42:18.000 think that they
00:42:18.980 are above the
00:42:19.600 American constitution.
00:42:20.800 So, I ask
00:42:22.600 myself, why are
00:42:23.420 you in this
00:42:23.860 country to
00:42:24.420 begin with?
00:42:25.760 What motivated
00:42:26.980 you to come to
00:42:27.640 this country?
00:42:29.100 Is it
00:42:29.760 capitalism?
00:42:31.200 Then, suddenly,
00:42:32.580 now you are
00:42:33.160 changing colors,
00:42:34.960 and you want to
00:42:36.900 turn your back on
00:42:37.680 the country that
00:42:38.240 took you in,
00:42:39.140 especially in a
00:42:40.000 war time,
00:42:41.800 demonstrating,
00:42:42.480 and I would
00:42:48.020 say, persecuting
00:42:49.420 religious minorities
00:42:50.920 like the Jewish
00:42:52.360 people.
00:42:53.980 So, what I would
00:42:56.020 like to see,
00:42:56.620 whether if it's
00:42:57.020 Arab country,
00:42:58.640 Asian country,
00:43:00.240 all Muslim
00:43:01.080 countries, that
00:43:02.820 they can begin
00:43:04.180 with a civil
00:43:05.120 constitution,
00:43:06.840 and not allow
00:43:08.300 religious authorities
00:43:09.820 have an absolute
00:43:11.200 control,
00:43:12.480 of people's
00:43:13.460 choices.
00:43:15.120 So, if we can
00:43:15.900 do the first
00:43:16.480 step of
00:43:17.480 bringing a civil
00:43:20.500 constitution,
00:43:21.400 then I think
00:43:22.000 people themselves
00:43:24.460 will drop
00:43:25.420 many of the
00:43:28.880 religious beliefs.
00:43:31.280 Inshallah.
00:43:32.300 Do you still
00:43:33.060 have eyes
00:43:34.880 with any of
00:43:35.880 your family
00:43:36.760 members, or
00:43:37.560 are you
00:43:38.040 utterly estranged
00:43:39.440 from anybody
00:43:40.420 from your past?
00:43:42.480 the relationship
00:43:44.360 is over a long
00:43:45.160 time ago.
00:43:46.400 With everyone?
00:43:47.180 There is no
00:43:47.860 sibling, no
00:43:49.100 cousin, no
00:43:50.280 one has written
00:43:51.000 to you?
00:43:52.040 With everyone.
00:43:53.660 It's, from
00:43:55.720 the beginning,
00:43:56.340 you know, a
00:43:56.780 couple of my
00:43:57.200 siblings wanted
00:43:57.860 to stay in
00:43:58.400 touch, but I
00:43:59.000 refused.
00:44:01.120 And they
00:44:01.700 said, you
00:44:02.000 know, we love
00:44:02.460 you regardless,
00:44:03.560 but I refused
00:44:04.240 because their
00:44:05.240 life could be in
00:44:06.020 danger if they
00:44:06.720 stay in touch
00:44:07.200 with me.
00:44:07.920 And also, I
00:44:08.800 did not want to
00:44:09.400 complicate it to
00:44:10.060 the family.
00:44:10.680 My family got
00:44:11.320 really hurt
00:44:12.020 because of the
00:44:13.160 choices that I
00:44:13.800 made.
00:44:14.480 They are still
00:44:15.020 hurting.
00:44:16.280 And this is
00:44:16.940 actually the
00:44:17.360 highest price
00:44:18.020 that was paid.
00:44:19.060 I did not pay
00:44:19.840 the highest price.
00:44:21.100 It's my mother
00:44:22.060 who paid the
00:44:23.280 highest price
00:44:23.980 because she
00:44:24.720 cannot understand
00:44:25.660 the choices
00:44:27.740 that I made.
00:44:29.180 But this is
00:44:29.600 where I really
00:44:32.800 had to choose
00:44:33.340 between my
00:44:33.880 comfort, between
00:44:34.680 my security, and
00:44:36.740 bring the
00:44:38.900 truth of the
00:44:39.560 inner work of
00:44:41.160 what's so-called
00:44:42.380 Palestinian
00:44:42.820 revolution and
00:44:44.500 the origins of
00:44:45.900 this complicated
00:44:47.500 issue.
00:44:48.100 It's not
00:44:48.400 coincidental that
00:44:49.260 I'm here.
00:44:50.020 And as you
00:44:50.440 said, you
00:44:50.760 know, I
00:44:51.000 disappeared.
00:44:51.600 I thought I
00:44:52.160 just did my
00:44:52.880 part.
00:44:54.020 And I thought
00:44:55.180 I moved on.
00:44:56.480 And the fact
00:44:57.240 that I did not
00:44:57.940 come back with
00:44:58.560 vengeance, you
00:44:59.320 know, the
00:44:59.660 reason for my
00:45:00.760 outrage that I
00:45:01.960 went into silence
00:45:02.780 for a very long
00:45:03.560 time, I did not
00:45:05.440 even talk to
00:45:06.660 anybody, Palestine,
00:45:08.280 to nobody.
00:45:09.080 Like, I did not
00:45:09.760 need, that's it.
00:45:10.640 I got shunned by
00:45:11.400 my family.
00:45:12.120 I moved on.
00:45:13.720 And I took
00:45:14.640 responsibility for
00:45:15.560 the decisions that
00:45:16.380 I made in my
00:45:16.900 life.
00:45:19.020 But then, when
00:45:22.140 October 7th
00:45:22.820 happened, I, like,
00:45:26.220 I just could not
00:45:27.220 help, I could not
00:45:28.740 help.
00:45:29.140 It brought me
00:45:29.740 back in the
00:45:30.260 worst possible
00:45:30.920 way, because
00:45:31.820 this has been my
00:45:33.640 warning from day
00:45:34.580 one, not only to
00:45:37.560 my father, not only
00:45:38.780 to other Hamas
00:45:39.540 leaders, also to
00:45:40.800 Israel and to the
00:45:43.320 Israeli Intelligence
00:45:44.060 Service, to the
00:45:44.880 Americans, that
00:45:46.700 Hamas was
00:45:47.980 danger.
00:45:48.460 But in 17
00:45:50.220 years, we did not
00:45:53.580 do what it was
00:45:54.600 necessary to
00:45:55.880 prevent Hamas
00:45:57.760 from reaching
00:45:58.480 this far, because
00:46:00.480 we had to
00:46:01.840 compromise.
00:46:03.740 Wow.
00:46:04.360 I mean, I'm
00:46:06.140 often asked by
00:46:07.300 people, how can
00:46:09.480 I have the
00:46:10.380 courage to speak
00:46:11.520 out?
00:46:11.980 I mean, never
00:46:12.340 mind about
00:46:12.840 Palestine or
00:46:13.640 Islam.
00:46:14.140 It could be
00:46:14.600 about, you
00:46:16.020 know, can
00:46:16.480 biological males
00:46:19.600 compete in
00:46:20.580 female sports?
00:46:21.560 And they're too
00:46:22.080 afraid to say
00:46:23.020 that, no, that's
00:46:23.920 crazy.
00:46:24.300 How could you
00:46:24.700 allow the sexes
00:46:25.520 to mix?
00:46:26.380 And the excuse I
00:46:27.920 always get is, you
00:46:29.200 don't understand,
00:46:30.140 Professor Saad, I
00:46:31.440 will lose my job.
00:46:32.760 I won't get my
00:46:33.660 promotion.
00:46:34.380 I won't get a
00:46:35.100 good grade on the
00:46:35.860 exam.
00:46:36.300 So there's always
00:46:37.100 an excuse while
00:46:38.760 it's not for you to
00:46:40.420 be courageous and
00:46:41.320 speak out.
00:46:42.540 And here I have
00:46:43.960 in front of me,
00:46:45.400 you, who, I
00:46:47.160 mean, never mind
00:46:47.860 today, you're still
00:46:48.720 taking risks,
00:46:49.480 right?
00:46:49.720 There are people who
00:46:50.360 might want to hurt
00:46:51.000 you today.
00:46:51.560 But you are
00:46:52.800 working within
00:46:53.940 that world, the
00:46:54.880 most dangerous
00:46:55.660 possible world,
00:46:57.220 helping the other
00:46:58.420 camp, the
00:46:59.380 Yahud, the bad
00:47:00.440 guys, the evil
00:47:01.280 ones, the
00:47:01.860 shaitan.
00:47:02.920 And so it
00:47:03.740 contextualizes the
00:47:05.280 kinds of risks
00:47:06.180 that people think
00:47:07.320 that they're
00:47:07.740 taking when they
00:47:09.340 compare it to the
00:47:10.280 risks you had to
00:47:11.120 take.
00:47:11.280 So that's point
00:47:11.780 one.
00:47:12.500 I'll cede the
00:47:13.420 floor to you in a
00:47:13.960 sec.
00:47:14.420 Number two, one
00:47:16.560 of the things that
00:47:17.040 I talk about in my
00:47:17.980 most recent book,
00:47:18.820 the book on
00:47:19.220 happiness, by the
00:47:20.000 way, is that for
00:47:21.340 you to be
00:47:21.900 happy, you
00:47:22.520 have to live
00:47:23.280 an authentic
00:47:24.060 life.
00:47:25.200 And what you've
00:47:25.920 done basically is
00:47:27.020 exactly that,
00:47:27.900 because you've
00:47:28.400 said, I'm
00:47:29.260 willing to give
00:47:30.240 up all of the
00:47:31.700 love and support
00:47:32.660 of my entire
00:47:33.960 family, because
00:47:35.400 to not do so
00:47:36.520 would be
00:47:37.260 inauthentic
00:47:38.200 according to my
00:47:38.980 moral compass.
00:47:40.080 So that's
00:47:40.640 remarkable.
00:47:41.720 If you want to
00:47:42.080 add anything to
00:47:42.720 that, go ahead.
00:47:43.260 listen, most
00:47:49.680 of us live in
00:47:51.060 darkness, and
00:47:52.140 we create
00:47:54.740 convenience out
00:47:56.660 of our narrative,
00:47:57.820 our belief
00:47:58.400 system, because
00:48:00.040 we're afraid to
00:48:00.760 die.
00:48:01.100 We're afraid of
00:48:01.760 death.
00:48:02.620 We're afraid of
00:48:03.380 others.
00:48:04.580 We're afraid to
00:48:05.040 be judged.
00:48:06.020 We're afraid
00:48:06.360 somebody is going
00:48:07.060 to come and
00:48:07.780 harm us.
00:48:09.380 hence we don't
00:48:13.240 take risk.
00:48:14.260 We don't
00:48:14.580 challenge our
00:48:15.220 own beliefs.
00:48:16.340 And when
00:48:16.580 someone come to
00:48:17.560 get us out of
00:48:18.760 challenge anything
00:48:21.060 that can get us
00:48:23.120 out of our
00:48:23.660 comfort, the
00:48:25.580 pattern that we
00:48:27.000 repeat on
00:48:28.100 regular basis,
00:48:29.260 then we think
00:48:31.440 we have mastered
00:48:32.300 life, just
00:48:33.340 because we know
00:48:34.040 how to repeat
00:48:34.800 a pattern.
00:48:36.480 Well, I also
00:48:37.420 can train my
00:48:38.180 dog to repeat
00:48:39.220 a pattern on
00:48:40.080 a regular
00:48:40.440 basis, and
00:48:41.020 they would be
00:48:41.500 doing an
00:48:42.000 excellent job.
00:48:43.620 You know,
00:48:44.160 individuals of
00:48:45.340 higher intelligence,
00:48:47.040 we don't accept
00:48:47.780 beliefs.
00:48:49.180 As I told you,
00:48:50.360 it's either we
00:48:50.860 know or we
00:48:51.480 don't know.
00:48:52.660 Now, to be
00:48:55.700 intimidated and
00:48:57.020 swayed by the
00:48:58.420 opinion of the
00:49:00.300 majority, and
00:49:01.080 this is especially
00:49:01.760 what's happening
00:49:02.360 right now, this
00:49:03.800 is not the first
00:49:04.540 time I'm in the
00:49:05.560 face of a
00:49:06.860 majority of
00:49:07.840 people who live
00:49:08.780 in denial, and
00:49:10.520 I am not the
00:49:11.220 first individual
00:49:12.340 to say no to
00:49:13.440 the system, no
00:49:14.340 to the
00:49:14.680 establishment, and
00:49:16.400 no to a sick
00:49:17.400 belief system.
00:49:19.660 Many others
00:49:20.400 tried this
00:49:21.120 before, and
00:49:22.840 swimming against
00:49:23.520 the current
00:49:24.120 could be
00:49:25.560 destructive.
00:49:27.340 But we,
00:49:29.400 those, when I
00:49:30.600 say we, the
00:49:31.760 handful of people
00:49:32.600 who chose to go
00:49:33.620 against the
00:49:34.260 flow or the
00:49:35.840 current of a
00:49:36.460 society, we
00:49:37.780 take the risk,
00:49:39.020 and death is
00:49:40.480 part of it.
00:49:42.640 I personally
00:49:43.660 make my peace
00:49:45.380 with death on
00:49:46.240 a regular basis.
00:49:47.560 In fact, death
00:49:48.340 is not a threat
00:49:49.540 at all.
00:49:50.720 Death is a
00:49:51.320 friend.
00:49:52.840 And as long
00:49:54.120 as we are afraid
00:49:54.800 of death, then
00:49:55.500 we are trying to
00:49:56.100 get along.
00:49:56.740 We are trying to
00:49:57.260 please everybody.
00:49:58.400 We are trying to
00:49:58.980 please the parents,
00:49:59.880 and we are trying
00:50:00.440 to please the
00:50:01.080 teacher, the
00:50:02.120 guru, the
00:50:03.000 politician, the
00:50:04.540 neighbor, our
00:50:06.360 children, and
00:50:07.960 all the irrelevant
00:50:08.820 people to our
00:50:09.560 lives.
00:50:10.180 We try just so
00:50:11.160 hard maintaining a
00:50:12.220 certain public
00:50:12.860 image.
00:50:14.220 What happens in
00:50:14.880 the process is that
00:50:15.640 we lose our
00:50:16.480 freedom and we
00:50:17.200 lose our
00:50:17.680 individuality, and
00:50:18.940 we just become
00:50:19.980 what others want
00:50:22.260 us to be.
00:50:23.060 I don't accept
00:50:23.660 this for myself.
00:50:25.980 And yes, it's
00:50:26.980 part of the
00:50:27.420 confusion.
00:50:28.380 You know, people
00:50:28.780 are confused about
00:50:29.780 their sexuality,
00:50:31.380 about their
00:50:31.840 sexual identity,
00:50:33.600 and we come
00:50:35.800 with all type
00:50:36.640 of cunning
00:50:39.400 methods to
00:50:41.560 justify the
00:50:43.340 imprisonment of
00:50:44.260 the mind.
00:50:46.220 I don't believe
00:50:47.420 mind is a real
00:50:48.460 thing.
00:50:48.920 I don't believe
00:50:49.540 consciousness is a
00:50:50.700 real thing, and
00:50:51.600 we're just passing
00:50:52.300 through, passing
00:50:54.140 through life.
00:50:55.800 Hence, it's not
00:50:58.080 our right to take
00:50:59.520 our generation,
00:51:00.580 then steal the
00:51:01.720 dream of next
00:51:04.380 generations,
00:51:05.220 especially steal the
00:51:07.520 dream of
00:51:10.280 children by deciding
00:51:12.120 for them what to
00:51:13.300 be, that children
00:51:14.560 were born innocent.
00:51:17.680 They were not born
00:51:18.740 Palestinians.
00:51:20.360 They were not born
00:51:21.560 anything.
00:51:22.540 and it's our
00:51:24.680 responsibility to
00:51:26.080 protect them in
00:51:27.860 every possible way,
00:51:29.620 not instead of
00:51:31.500 gambling with their
00:51:32.380 blood, instead of
00:51:33.720 gambling with their
00:51:34.460 future, using them as
00:51:35.640 human shields, and
00:51:37.260 call that resistance.
00:51:39.080 This is where it gets
00:51:39.960 tricky, and this
00:51:41.440 requires not only the
00:51:43.460 wrath of man or the
00:51:44.700 anger of me or a
00:51:47.240 handful of people out
00:51:48.160 there, that we are
00:51:49.100 outraged for the use
00:51:51.520 of children as human
00:51:52.860 shields by Hamas, for
00:51:54.720 sacrificing Jewish and
00:51:56.660 Arab children for the
00:51:59.180 sake of Allah and for
00:52:00.300 the sake of Islamic
00:52:01.000 state.
00:52:02.460 Hence, we have to
00:52:03.400 fight this evil, and
00:52:05.520 we have to fight
00:52:07.040 united.
00:52:08.380 Now, if we get hurt in
00:52:09.800 the process, if we get
00:52:10.780 killed in the process,
00:52:11.760 this is not the final
00:52:14.040 destination.
00:52:15.280 Everybody is going to
00:52:16.520 die, and you think
00:52:18.000 those who are playing
00:52:19.000 it safe, the
00:52:19.920 mediocrers trying to
00:52:21.240 please everybody,
00:52:22.500 living the life of
00:52:24.800 slavery, do you
00:52:27.620 think any of them is
00:52:29.140 safe, or any of them
00:52:30.420 can hide from death?
00:52:32.940 Wow, you are an
00:52:34.460 extraordinary man.
00:52:36.240 I mean, you know,
00:52:36.700 there are two guys, I
00:52:37.780 think, on this show
00:52:38.620 that stand out with
00:52:40.300 their courage.
00:52:41.080 The first one, you
00:52:41.900 may know, is the guy
00:52:43.860 who was known as
00:52:45.400 Ayn al-Mosul.
00:52:46.860 Do you know him,
00:52:47.960 Mosab?
00:52:49.540 Ayn al-Mosul is a
00:52:51.500 guy who was
00:52:52.580 documenting the
00:52:55.360 horrors that
00:52:56.760 Daesh, ISIS, was
00:52:59.280 doing in Mosul,
00:53:00.780 while ISIS was
00:53:02.520 trying to find
00:53:03.600 where he was, and
00:53:05.060 he was doing it
00:53:05.820 from within Mosul.
00:53:06.800 He then left, he
00:53:07.640 immigrated to
00:53:08.400 France, and we
00:53:09.480 had a chat, and I
00:53:10.860 think you certainly
00:53:11.720 fit within that
00:53:12.800 level of
00:53:13.540 unimaginable
00:53:15.280 courage.
00:53:15.800 Thank you so
00:53:16.300 much.
00:53:16.700 But before I let
00:53:17.380 you go,
00:53:18.340 are there any
00:53:23.020 projects you're
00:53:23.860 working on now,
00:53:24.980 any books that
00:53:26.040 you're writing that
00:53:26.860 you'd like to use
00:53:27.640 this opportunity to
00:53:28.540 promote?
00:53:30.640 In principle, I
00:53:32.200 try not to
00:53:33.000 promote any
00:53:33.920 books.
00:53:34.740 Maybe you can
00:53:35.600 see this clearly
00:53:36.660 on my social
00:53:37.360 media.
00:53:37.780 I try not to
00:53:39.560 mix my personal
00:53:41.180 interests with
00:53:42.800 this bloody
00:53:44.420 situation.
00:53:46.260 Yes, I have a
00:53:48.260 book out there,
00:53:49.040 and there is a
00:53:50.520 book coming out,
00:53:52.060 but I do this
00:53:52.940 project for fun.
00:53:55.220 I wrote a book
00:53:56.320 about the life
00:53:59.360 of Muhammad,
00:53:59.820 Muhammad, and
00:54:01.380 this is one of
00:54:02.180 my biggest
00:54:02.740 projects I
00:54:03.840 spent the last
00:54:04.920 10 years
00:54:05.740 actually writing
00:54:06.380 it.
00:54:07.200 It's a very
00:54:07.640 positive narrative
00:54:08.540 of the life of
00:54:09.980 Muhammad.
00:54:10.420 I don't know how
00:54:11.240 this is going to
00:54:12.060 fit in this
00:54:12.660 global chaos.
00:54:13.560 It was supposed
00:54:14.760 to be published
00:54:15.540 within weeks,
00:54:16.780 but I put it on
00:54:18.680 hold just for the
00:54:19.980 sake of the
00:54:21.320 situation.
00:54:22.740 The creative
00:54:23.340 process continues,
00:54:24.560 but whether if I
00:54:25.680 am here today or
00:54:27.100 tomorrow or all
00:54:28.440 of a sudden I
00:54:29.360 vanish, and
00:54:30.680 that's possible
00:54:31.220 because I'm not
00:54:32.880 dependent on this
00:54:34.560 conflict for
00:54:35.400 survival.
00:54:36.960 I have a
00:54:37.740 magnificent life
00:54:38.540 somewhere,
00:54:39.320 surrounded by
00:54:40.940 people I love
00:54:41.540 very much, and
00:54:44.080 they have nothing
00:54:45.280 to do with this
00:54:46.380 conflict.
00:54:46.980 It's very strange
00:54:47.780 for them, you
00:54:48.260 know, when I tell
00:54:48.720 them stories about
00:54:49.920 human madness in
00:54:50.760 the Middle East.
00:54:51.900 So for me, this
00:54:52.600 is just a temporary
00:54:53.280 situation.
00:54:54.060 I had to come
00:54:54.560 back for this
00:54:55.340 human tragedy, and
00:54:59.680 what I am hoping
00:55:00.960 that we will
00:55:05.180 remove Hamas
00:55:05.740 from power, and
00:55:07.700 I will not rest,
00:55:08.720 in fact, I will
00:55:09.500 not rest until
00:55:10.320 this goal is
00:55:11.780 accomplished.
00:55:13.420 Whether we go
00:55:14.500 into Rafah or we
00:55:15.920 don't go into
00:55:16.640 Rafah, Hamas is
00:55:18.520 over.
00:55:19.220 This has been
00:55:20.280 written in a
00:55:22.540 different plane.
00:55:23.620 It's not up to
00:55:24.540 any earthly
00:55:25.340 authority, I
00:55:26.180 promise you
00:55:26.680 that.
00:55:27.000 Sounds absurd,
00:55:27.880 but I promise
00:55:28.460 you that there
00:55:29.300 is going to be
00:55:29.880 a time.
00:55:30.620 You will look
00:55:31.040 back at this
00:55:31.520 conversation, and
00:55:32.260 you know that I
00:55:32.800 promise you that
00:55:33.440 Hamas is over,
00:55:34.560 Hamas is finished.
00:55:36.400 Once Hamas is
00:55:37.200 removed from power,
00:55:38.760 people need to
00:55:39.400 drop their
00:55:40.620 false identities.
00:55:42.560 You know, I
00:55:43.480 don't mind if they
00:55:44.300 want to call
00:55:44.800 themselves Palestinians,
00:55:46.840 Arabs, Egyptians,
00:55:48.460 whatever they are,
00:55:49.800 Muslims.
00:55:50.360 Muslims, it's
00:55:52.000 their right to
00:55:52.640 identify with
00:55:53.620 the devil of
00:55:54.820 choice.
00:55:56.000 That's not my
00:55:56.640 problem.
00:55:57.620 But if they
00:55:58.880 try to weaponize
00:56:00.740 their religion
00:56:02.160 against religious
00:56:03.660 minorities, risking
00:56:05.600 the lives of
00:56:06.380 children, this is
00:56:07.680 something that I am
00:56:08.600 not going to
00:56:09.280 tolerate.
00:56:10.160 All the freedom
00:56:11.200 fighters around the
00:56:12.240 world will not
00:56:13.440 tolerate, regardless
00:56:15.160 of a majority of
00:56:17.280 sheep being led to
00:56:19.300 the slaughterhouse.
00:56:20.800 Now, Palestine is
00:56:21.880 a trendy thing, and
00:56:24.420 many people want to
00:56:25.340 be part of the
00:56:26.200 revolution.
00:56:27.520 And I said this
00:56:28.600 earlier, that a
00:56:32.220 revolution for the
00:56:33.400 sake of revolution
00:56:34.560 only is not
00:56:35.660 welcomed in the
00:56:37.520 United States.
00:56:39.660 Parents who send
00:56:41.380 their children to
00:56:42.380 campuses, they have
00:56:44.080 the right to know
00:56:44.820 who is behind the
00:56:46.220 mask, because it
00:56:48.560 could be an
00:56:49.360 activist, it
00:56:51.580 could be a
00:56:52.140 sympathizer with
00:56:53.380 Gaza and the
00:56:54.480 tragedy there, but
00:56:55.620 also can be
00:56:56.320 Satan.
00:56:57.720 And I don't like to
00:56:59.120 see masked people
00:57:00.500 on campuses
00:57:01.460 interrupting the
00:57:05.360 educational process,
00:57:06.680 because this is
00:57:08.140 exactly what Hamas
00:57:09.340 and the Muslim
00:57:09.920 Brotherhood did
00:57:10.740 during the first
00:57:11.460 Parisian Antifada.
00:57:12.860 They targeted
00:57:13.560 schools, campuses,
00:57:15.020 places, then
00:57:15.820 immediately after
00:57:16.740 they targeted
00:57:17.660 economy and
00:57:19.220 public transportation.
00:57:20.840 So I don't want
00:57:21.880 to see actually an
00:57:22.940 intifada in the
00:57:23.720 United States.
00:57:24.540 In the United
00:57:25.020 States, it's the
00:57:25.620 way of dialogue.
00:57:26.840 We have
00:57:27.120 elections, we have
00:57:27.920 democracy, we
00:57:28.940 debate, some of us
00:57:30.520 win, some of us
00:57:31.400 lose.
00:57:32.040 Those who lose
00:57:33.500 accept defeat.
00:57:35.440 This is a very
00:57:36.020 different mentality
00:57:36.820 than the Middle
00:57:37.400 East, who turn
00:57:38.520 their defeat into
00:57:39.640 massacres and
00:57:40.880 genocides and
00:57:41.620 ethnic cleansing.
00:57:42.320 So this victim
00:57:44.220 narrative that
00:57:45.520 is now widespread
00:57:47.560 in the United
00:57:48.400 States and in
00:57:49.340 the West could
00:57:51.400 be a bestseller
00:57:52.300 narrative, but
00:57:54.220 in reality is
00:57:55.540 not a true
00:57:56.220 story.
00:57:57.580 So with that
00:57:58.320 said, Palestinians
00:58:00.540 can be whatever
00:58:01.300 they want to be
00:58:02.160 as long as they
00:58:03.840 drop their mad
00:58:05.580 idea to
00:58:06.880 annihilate Israel,
00:58:08.280 as long as
00:58:09.580 they drop
00:58:11.560 violence,
00:58:12.320 as a
00:58:14.480 means of
00:58:15.700 achieving
00:58:16.280 political
00:58:17.620 agendas.
00:58:19.160 So if they
00:58:20.300 want to
00:58:20.580 practice Islam,
00:58:21.440 I see them
00:58:21.880 praying on the
00:58:22.600 sidewalk.
00:58:23.840 I see also
00:58:24.580 dog walking
00:58:25.360 around the
00:58:25.900 street and
00:58:26.720 it's about the
00:58:27.780 same for me.
00:58:29.960 Oh boy,
00:58:31.000 here comes the
00:58:31.960 death threat,
00:58:32.600 here come the
00:58:33.180 death threats.
00:58:33.840 battle in Arabic
00:58:41.920 means like a
00:58:42.660 champion, a
00:58:43.260 strong guy.
00:58:44.460 It's an honor
00:58:45.320 to meet you.
00:58:45.960 Please stay on
00:58:46.480 the line so we
00:58:47.020 could say goodbye
00:58:47.720 offline.
00:58:48.800 Come back
00:58:49.260 anytime you
00:58:49.940 want, stay
00:58:50.660 safe, and I
00:58:52.080 look forward to
00:58:53.500 hopefully meeting
00:58:54.440 you soon in
00:58:55.180 person.
00:58:55.640 It'll be a
00:58:56.060 pleasure to share
00:58:56.880 a meal with
00:58:57.340 you.
00:58:57.520 Thank you,
00:58:57.840 Habibi.
00:58:59.140 You're welcome.
00:58:59.700 Thank you.