Tucker Carlson on the Israel First Meltdown and the Future of the America First Movement
Episode Stats
Length
1 hour and 50 minutes
Words per Minute
175.35678
Hate Speech Sentences
125
Summary
Golden Nugget Online Casino is live, bringing Vegas-style excitement and a world-class gaming experience right to your fingertips . The question from the American perspective is, is it good for America to get involved in yet another Israel-inspired regime change war in the Middle East?
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Ontario. The wait is over. The gold standard of online casinos has arrived. Golden Nugget
00:00:06.000
Online Casino is live, bringing Vegas-style excitement and a world-class gaming experience
00:00:11.040
right to your fingertips. Whether you're a seasoned player or just starting, signing up is fast and
00:00:16.680
simple. And in just a few clicks, you can have access to our exclusive library of the best slots
00:00:21.740
and top-tier table games. Make the most of your downtime with unbeatable promotions and jackpots
00:00:27.220
that can turn any mundane moment into a golden opportunity at Golden Nugget Online Casino.
00:00:32.820
Take a spin on the slots, challenge yourself at the tables, or join a live dealer game to feel the
00:00:37.920
thrill of real-time action, all from the comfort of your own devices. Why settle for less when you
00:00:43.140
can go for the gold at Golden Nugget Online Casino? Gambling problem? Call ConnexOntario
00:00:49.080
1-866-531-2600. 19 and over. Physically present in Ontario. Eligibility restrictions apply. See
00:00:56.340
goldennuggetcasino.com for details. Please play responsibly.
00:01:00.180
Pretty much every morning you wake up and open your phone and think to yourself,
00:01:03.980
I wonder if this roiling fight on the right is still ongoing. The fight over who's a Nazi and
00:01:10.180
who's Nazi adjacent and who should be platformed and who should be deplatformed. That fight,
00:01:15.140
the one that has mesmerized X users across the world. What is that fight actually about and how
00:01:20.760
long will it continue? Well, the first thing to know about it is that it didn't start three weeks
00:01:26.220
ago with Nick Fuentes' appearance on a podcast. No, this has been a fight taking place mostly
00:01:32.120
behind the scenes since January, and that tells you a lot about what it's actually about. So here's
00:01:37.960
how it began. Donald Trump inaugurated January 22nd of this year. Almost immediately after, he is
00:01:45.080
visited at the White House by the first head of state to come to Washington, the Prime Minister of
00:01:49.420
Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu. And the visit is not simply a congratulatory visit. They're not actually
00:01:55.520
allies in any sense. Remember that Benjamin Netanyahu is one of the very first to congratulate
00:02:00.100
Joe Biden after the 2020 election. So there's probably not a lot of warmth there, just guessing.
00:02:05.100
No, there was a purpose to the visit and the subsequent visits by the Prime Minister of Israel to
00:02:09.740
Washington. And that was to get American support for regime change war in Iran to overthrow and
00:02:16.160
replace the government of Iran, which the nation of Israel sees as its primary regional threat.
00:02:22.060
Iran has all kinds of very dangerous conventional weapons. The United States spends a lot protecting
00:02:27.120
Israel from those missiles. And Israel is also concerned that at some point, Iran will either
00:02:33.140
make or buy a nuclear weapon, leaving Israel no longer the only nuclear arm nation in the region.
00:02:40.160
So that's what it's actually about. And to be honest, you can see from Israel's point of view,
00:02:43.920
if you're trying to identify long-term serious threats to you, Iran would be at or near the top
00:02:49.740
of the list, especially since Israel has taken out almost all the other threats. So really,
00:02:54.140
it's just Iran. The question is, is it in America's interest to participate in that war? And make no
00:03:01.360
mistake, Israel wouldn't last three days in a war by itself against Iran. In fact, probably not even 24
00:03:06.460
hours. Israel's population centers would be taken out by Iran's conventional weapons. And at that point,
00:03:11.420
the Israeli government could either nuke Iran, starting a chain reaction that you can't really
00:03:17.540
predict once it begins, or allow hundreds of thousands of its own citizens, certainly tens of
00:03:24.120
thousands, to be killed. So Israel could not do it alone, and no honest person suggests or would
00:03:30.480
suggest that it could. It needs the United States. So the question from the American perspective is,
00:03:34.420
is it good for America to get involved in yet another Israel-inspired regime change war in the
00:03:41.180
Middle East? There have been quite a few, most notably Iraq. Is that a good idea? And so that
00:03:47.920
debate began, and it mostly began behind the scenes. It didn't sort of peek out into public
00:03:53.840
view very often, but when it did, the people who wanted the regime change war against Iran,
00:03:59.780
almost, with almost zero exceptions, almost never admitted what they actually wanted, and they
00:04:04.080
certainly never acknowledged what the debate was actually about. It was about one nation's interest
00:04:08.500
versus another nation's interest. Do those interests convene? Are they the same thing, or are they at
00:04:14.060
odds with each other? I can see what would be a good idea for Israel to want this. Is it a good idea
00:04:18.040
for us? That's the debate that never took place. And it didn't take place because almost from the
00:04:23.840
beginning, the people who wanted regime change war with Iran made the debate instead about,
00:04:30.160
why do you hate the Jews? You're a Nazi. And of course, that was never what the debate was about,
00:04:36.900
because Israel, the nation of Israel, the one with the parliament, the Knesset, and the military,
00:04:43.280
the IDF, and lots of people and tech firms, and it's not, by the way, exclusively Jewish,
00:04:49.760
and it isn't actually the same as all Jews in the world at all. And in fact, there are a lot of Jews
00:04:55.960
around the world who have mixed feelings about Israel or certainly don't want a regime change
00:05:00.240
war in Iran. But the people who do want that in the United States, Israel's proxies in the United
00:05:05.360
States, its defenders, its professional defenders in the U.S., immediately made the debate about
00:05:09.620
the Jews. It wasn't the anti-Semites who did that, actually. It was the defenders of Israel in the
00:05:16.780
United States, not all of whom are Jewish, to be clear. They're the ones who made the debate
00:05:21.260
from the first day, why do you hate the Jews? And so for those who were hesitant to get into
00:05:29.340
another regime change war, it's intimidating, because you're happy to have a debate any time
00:05:34.400
of day about what's in the interest of the United States, when should we project military force,
00:05:38.440
what can we learn for the last 25 years, et cetera, et cetera. And you'd probably win that debate,
00:05:42.400
because there's no evidence that any regime change war we've engaged in, in the past couple
00:05:46.940
of generations has helped us. Zero evidence. And everyone kind of knows that, including the President
00:05:50.800
of the United States. But if you make it a debate about why do you hate the Jews, then most people
00:05:55.240
are going to opt out because they don't want to deal with it. Most of them don't hate the Jews,
00:05:59.020
you hope, no evidence that they do. But nobody wants to be tarred as a bigot. And so very few people
00:06:07.380
pushed back, very few. In fact, as far as I know, only two people, me and Charlie Kirk, actually went
00:06:12.900
and spoke directly to the President to make the case that, no, you shouldn't get involved in this war,
00:06:19.000
because its aim is not actually to deny Iran a nuclear weapon. That may be a virtuous goal.
00:06:24.740
But that's not really what this is about. What this is about is luring the United States into yet
00:06:28.980
another regime change war. And if you do that, it's bad for everybody, including you. That's the case
00:06:32.500
that we made. Charlie went to the White House to make that case, and God bless him for doing that.
00:06:37.440
And he was hated for doing that. Hated for doing that. But he did it. Very few other people did.
00:06:43.180
In fact, as far as I know, none. So, of course, in June, the debate ended, and the United States
00:06:50.340
did commit military force to Iran. It bombed Iran and spent billions to protect Israel once again
00:06:56.720
from the inevitable, the predictable conventional response from Iran, et cetera, et cetera. And in
00:07:00.860
the end, thank God, we did not get lured into a regime change war. But the bitterness lingered,
00:07:06.860
and the total unwillingness of the people pushing for that war to state their aims, to be honest
00:07:12.880
about what they wanted, and to defend what they wanted, remained. They understood from the very
00:07:19.020
first day that they could not win that debate. They didn't want that debate. They wanted another
00:07:23.540
debate where they felt they could win or at least cow their opponents into total silence. And that
00:07:28.080
debate was about, quote, the Jews. Anti-Semitism. And again, this is a country that hasn't had a lot of
00:07:34.980
anti-Semitism. Decent people are not anti-Semitic. Christians understand that anti-Semitic behavior
00:07:41.860
or thoughts, attitudes, are unchristian, because Christians are universalist in their thinking.
00:07:49.080
Every person has the capacity to come to God through Jesus, every person, no matter how they
00:07:53.800
were born. And so, of course, no sincere Christian could be an anti-Semite, and no sincere Christian
00:07:59.480
would ever defend anti-Semitism. In fact, he would call it out, as he would, racism or any form
00:08:03.440
of discrimination on the basis of blood. He would call it out immediately. So this was never about
00:08:08.540
anti-Semitism, despite the fact there, of course, are anti-Semites and all kinds of other people in
00:08:12.060
this country. There are 350 million of them. But this debate was not about the Jews or anti-Semitism.
00:08:16.600
It was about when to use military force, and to what extent should you follow the lead of a much
00:08:20.800
smaller nation as you think about your own nation. And for a lot of people, this was enormously
00:08:27.460
frustrating since Donald Trump was elected for the second time last November on a platform that
00:08:32.480
explicitly promised, and this is why he was elected, to help the United States, which is in tough shape
00:08:37.040
and getting worse. And everybody knows that. And all of a sudden, this foreign prime minister shows up
00:08:43.280
and starts hijacking the attention and the money of our country to his ends. And that could be any
00:08:50.460
prime minister, by the way. It happens to have been Benjamin Netanyahu. But conceptually, that's
00:08:57.160
outrageous. And people were justly upset about it. Absolutely, they were upset about it.
00:09:03.200
So where will this go? Well, of course, the people who think the U.S. government should act
00:09:08.200
always and everywhere on behalf of its own citizens, the America First people, those people are going to
00:09:13.380
win the debate. In fact, there's never actually been a real debate. But when people's mind fog clears,
00:09:20.340
and they can think about what just happened, they'll understand that this was never about
00:09:24.500
the Jews or anti-Semitism, much less Hitler, who's been dead for 80 years as of April.
00:09:30.460
No, it was about should the United States act in its own interests or should it subvert its own
00:09:35.840
interests on behalf of a foreign power with a very effective lobby in Washington? That's exactly
00:09:40.100
what the debate is. And the answer is, of course, no. So the America First people are the people who
00:09:46.000
just think the government should serve its own citizens, which, let me remind you, is the only
00:09:50.260
legitimate rationale for representative government. In other words, if the government is not representing
00:09:55.400
its own citizens, if it doesn't care about its own citizens, it's not only off track, it's
00:09:59.580
illegitimate. It has no basis to govern because it's a representative democracy. So you are morally
00:10:07.720
bound, you're legally bound to represent your own people. That's the only purpose of having a
00:10:12.320
government in our country is to represent our people. And if you're not doing that, you're not
00:10:16.860
legitimate. So they will win. And in a year or two, we're going to look back on what we've
00:10:23.780
been watching for the last month or last eight months, and we're going to realize this is
00:10:28.480
exactly like BLM or Me Too. You know, at the core, there may have been a point, but basically
00:10:35.320
it's buffoonery. It is an effort to divert your attention from the real crisis. And we're going
00:10:46.820
to wonder, wait a second, since when did the institutional right conservatives, people who
00:10:52.980
run the think tanks and the dumb little magazines nobody reads, the people who blow Vienna and
00:10:56.780
Fox News, since when did those people become completely committed to identity politics and
00:11:01.980
censorship? Because they are committed to identity politics. That's what this is. It's identity
00:11:06.880
politics. Of course. It's group over nation. Of course. It's another country above our country,
00:11:13.180
a tiny country, an irrelevant country over our country. And people are going to look at that and
00:11:20.780
say, wait a second. We thought, in fact, we voted for you because we thought, that the two things we
00:11:26.920
could be assured you believed were you were against identity politics. You lectured us about woke for
00:11:31.720
like 10 years. You're against woke because you're against identity politics. You're against tribalism.
00:11:36.700
And here you are not only embracing it, but using it as a cudgel to hit people in the face.
00:11:42.060
And maybe even more shocking, we knew for a fact you were against censorship.
00:11:47.400
I mean, isn't that the whole point of the Trump election? We're against censorship. You can't
00:11:51.500
censor people in a free society. You can't have censorship in a democracy. How will you
00:11:55.660
have the information required to vote? Censorship is totally incompatible with Democratic government,
00:12:03.360
period. And it's also, by the way, illegal under the First Amendment to the Bill of Rights. And
00:12:08.140
Republicans just won an election on that platform. And all of a sudden, we learn there's really
00:12:15.280
nobody in the world more excited about censorship than a neocon podcaster or a national review staffer.
00:12:22.060
They just love it. People aren't going to forget that. And in a year or two or five years or
00:12:27.500
whatever, we're going to look back as we do on COVID and the BLM riots and the Me Too movement.
00:12:32.460
And we're going to ask ourselves, how do we fall for another moral panic, another social media driven
00:12:36.900
moral panic? How did everyone go insane all at once denouncing each other and denouncing old friends
00:12:43.580
and but clowning themselves because they're caught up in this moment and they can't see
00:12:47.760
that they're betraying the very principles they claimed like six months ago they would give their
00:12:52.980
lives for? And those people are going to feel shame and many of us will feel contempt for them
00:12:59.020
more than we already do. So that's going to happen. They can't win this debate. It's not actually a
00:13:05.200
debate. It's them name-calling. So that's going to happen, rest assured. But in the meantime,
00:13:12.400
the rest of us have to listen to an awful lot of a man who a year ago was unknown to most Americans,
00:13:18.340
kind of a third tier podcaster, TV host or radio host or whatever, a guy who was a weekend show
00:13:24.940
on a cable channel, a guy called Mark Levin. And for the last month, we've been watching Mark Levin
00:13:29.480
say things that no one in my lifetime has ever said from the right like this. Watch.
00:13:36.220
I don't know where there's Jew hatred from the Marxists, the Islamists, the neo-Nazis,
00:13:43.160
the grifters. I don't know where they're pulling us and pushing us.
00:13:56.580
What do they want to do? Where are they taking this country?
00:14:08.000
Carlson, Owens, Kelly, Bannon, it is a time for choosing. You pick the good guys or the
00:14:15.100
bad guys. You pick America or you pick the third right. They're not MAGA. They're not
00:14:23.680
conservative. In fact, they're more Marxist, Islamist, America-hating, Jew-hating, thugs
00:14:30.180
than anything else. And let me educate them briefly.
00:14:53.680
Hitler couldn't kill the Jews. And by this, I mean,
00:15:10.780
Your first thought is, wait a second, how do we get to that?
00:15:15.120
Just don't want a regime change war against Toronto.
00:15:17.540
By the way, a war in which Jews would die, presumably,
00:15:22.120
Like, no, don't want to kill anybody. Actually, that's kind of the point.
00:15:27.060
So the first thing you notice is like the total inversion
00:15:42.220
And all of a sudden, it becomes the Babylonians,
00:15:59.940
Everybody needs good rest for most of their days,
00:16:09.460
that automatically regulates your body temperature
00:16:39.960
They run their biggest sale of the year this month
00:17:04.420
You may recall a time when crushing a bag of chips
00:17:15.020
There's all kinds of crap they're putting in this food
00:17:20.560
Now, even one serving of your standard American chip brand
00:17:51.240
Snacking on masa chips is not like eating the garbage
00:17:56.080
You feel satisfied, light, energetic, not sluggish.
00:18:00.480
Tens of thousands of happy people eat masa chips.
00:18:11.140
Use the code Tucker for 25% off your first order.
00:18:24.320
it's easy to find your next favorite game with Bodog.
00:18:37.900
The second thing you notice is how totally personal this is.
00:18:55.540
There's no even attempt to address the argument
00:18:59.000
that anyone Mark Levin doesn't agree with is making.
00:19:04.940
And the third thing you notice is what animates this,
00:19:11.100
And hate is one of those words that is thrown around a lot as a weapon.
00:19:18.780
But that doesn't mean, just because the word itself is used cynically,
00:19:22.840
that the term doesn't describe anything or that hate isn't real.
00:19:35.380
Reacting against it can turn you into what he claims you are.
00:19:47.660
All of us, even people who are committed to not being the way.
00:19:53.080
I'm sitting on stage with Megyn Kelly at an event she was doing in New York.
00:20:03.700
but I'm not going to criticize a man on the day he dies.
00:20:05.480
I'm just not going to do that because I have reverence for death.
00:20:10.160
And so I said a few nice words about Dick Cheney.
00:20:13.560
And then I started thinking about his daughter, Liz Cheney,
00:20:15.600
whom I also know and have disliked intensely for quite some time
00:20:20.680
because she slandered me and because I think she is a violence espouser.
00:20:28.660
But rather than say that, I just attacked in a vicious way Liz Cheney.
00:20:34.720
And I said something awful about Liz Cheney, actually.
00:20:43.000
And I said that her father would be ashamed of her.
00:20:44.640
And if I had a daughter like that, I'd probably kill myself,
00:20:50.480
But in my mind, I was thinking of all the people I dislike,
00:20:53.520
Liz Cheney would probably be at the top of the list.
00:20:55.400
And so therefore, because I dislike her personally,
00:20:58.620
and because I so disagree with everything about her political views,
00:21:06.440
If you were to graph it out, I'd be on one side, Liz Cheney would be on the other.
00:21:12.820
I told myself, clearly I must have told myself,
00:21:15.380
that you can say anything you want about Liz Cheney.
00:21:18.360
You can say anything you want, including something really awful and nasty,
00:21:27.560
And so I just want to say I'm sorry to Liz Cheney,
00:21:34.580
I will not stop disagreeing with Liz Cheney until she changes her views.
00:21:39.200
But there is never an excuse to talk about people like that.
00:21:48.200
You know, I mean, no one's going to eat the dog food here, okay?
00:21:53.680
So the fear is not that Mark Levin will take over American politics.
00:22:03.340
By staring at Mark Levin too much, we become him.
00:22:07.660
Another way of putting it is the fight is not against Mark Levin
00:22:11.080
and the many Mark Levins out there, the screamers, the slanderers,
00:22:21.940
The real fight is against our own nature, our own natural inclination to,
00:22:39.240
And the only way to prevent yourself from becoming that person
00:22:44.580
is by admitting that you've acted like that person
00:22:47.960
and apologizing for it sincerely, not in a fake way.
00:22:55.100
And it's exactly what I don't like about someone else.
00:23:01.660
Probably by the end of the show, I'll do it again.
00:23:06.420
But we need to say, every single time we do that, no.
00:23:14.040
So really, just to keep in mind, as things heat up,
00:23:24.460
We wind up, I mean, the Second World War is that story.
00:23:26.780
We're fighting for freedom, but we're arming Joseph Stalin to do it.
00:23:29.940
Really, we sent more money and airplanes and tanks and jeeps and boots and food
00:23:34.980
to Joseph Stalin, the greatest mass murderer in history,
00:23:50.680
It's like, don't become the thing that you hate.
00:23:53.220
And if you don't do that, if you allow yourself to get carried away,
00:23:59.200
so mad that you start mimicking the hate that's coming at you,
00:24:13.900
We're still talking about a political assassination,
00:24:16.180
a friend's political assassination, on September 10th.
00:24:40.840
That's the other thing, is you don't want to espouse violence
00:24:45.140
It always begets more violence, 100% of the time.
00:24:48.020
September 11th led to millions of deaths in the Middle East.
00:25:03.480
but you can be fairly certain it will accelerate.
00:25:05.680
And when that happens, all calculations change,
00:25:11.500
And the feud becomes irresolvable, and more people die.
00:25:28.680
And we know that because Mark Levin has repeatedly,
00:25:33.660
and he's not the only one, but he's the most blunt,
00:25:36.800
has repeatedly called for just murdering civilians,
00:25:40.400
children in Gaza because they're amalek or whatever.
00:25:47.580
Prime Minister of Israel said exactly the same thing.
00:25:50.160
They are guilty by virtue of how they were born.
00:25:54.680
So that, by definition, includes women and children.
00:25:59.380
to keep the implications of these views to himself,
00:26:03.220
just to give you a sense about how Mark Levin feels
00:26:08.580
And I'm supposed to, what, shed crocodile tears
00:26:16.940
Maybe I'm the only one who will voice it, but I'm not.
00:27:04.220
I mean, you've got to fight to win and survive.
00:27:06.980
You can't sit there and figure all that stuff out.
00:27:52.560
which, of course, leads to collective punishment
00:28:03.640
And if someone said something like that on television,
00:28:05.660
I mean, he'd be probably pulled off the air for that.
00:28:29.820
They came in and killed people at a music festival.
00:28:41.740
and we're no better than the people we're fighting.
00:29:08.460
Should have been the lesson of the Soviet regime,
00:29:10.500
which, of course, practiced collective punishment
00:29:22.280
And a lot of us thought that was the main lesson
00:29:24.600
that we were supposed to take away from the war.
00:29:28.460
We should take that lesson from the Second World War.
00:29:51.320
unless you think you're morally superior to them.
00:30:04.220
should be killed because of how they were born?
00:30:06.440
But that is absolutely Mark Levin's assumption.
00:30:27.120
but what you're saying is actually creating antisemitism.
00:31:03.500
Landman is pretty exciting for a TV show, honestly.
01:22:32.640
these people win and turn me into an anti-Semite
01:23:00.280
trying to destroy their lives their livelihoods
01:23:23.760
you know it's algorithms how could they do this
01:23:33.480
and this issue that you're you know fired up about
01:23:41.180
that Israel is entitled to doing what it's doing
01:23:44.740
yeah and I don't think that I should be required
01:23:51.020
but it's interesting and very distressing to me
01:24:24.060
and of course it's the most American of all values
01:24:26.840
so I thought that that was a sacrosanct principle
01:24:34.700
but like you could never try to prevent me from saying it
01:24:53.680
thinking about how to prevent other people from talking
01:24:56.580
and working to prevent other people from talking
01:26:05.460
who are like hell-bent on engaging in censorship
01:26:10.360
do you know how this is going to work out for you