And, This Is Gaming Culture & Gen-Z Nihilism With Content Creator Brandon "Atrioc" Ewing
Episode Stats
Length
1 hour and 20 minutes
Words per Minute
191.87805
Summary
In this episode of the Stuff You Should Know Podcast, host Jay Shetty is joined by Emma Watson to talk about why she's stepping down from acting and why she thinks it's a good idea to retire from the entertainment industry.
Transcript
00:00:08.300
Seems like the DNC as a whole is trying to run a very similar playbook
00:00:12.960
that didn't work and is wondering why they're not getting different results.
00:00:33.720
a new podcast about what it means to live through a time as uncertain as this one.
00:00:38.580
We sit down with politicians, artists, and activists
00:00:41.300
to bring you death and analysis from a unique Latino perspective.
00:00:45.320
The Moment is a space for the conversations we've been having as father and daughter for years.
00:00:50.400
Listen to The Moment with Jorge Ramos and Paola Ramos
00:00:53.880
on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:00:58.340
Hi there, this is Josh Clark from the Stuff You Should Know Podcast.
00:01:02.260
If you've been thinking, man alive, I could go for some good true crime podcast episodes,
00:01:08.400
Stuff You Should Know just released a playlist of 12 of our best true crime episodes of all time.
00:01:13.340
There's a shootout in broad daylight, people using axes in really terrible ways,
00:01:17.720
disappearances, legendary heists, the whole nine yards.
00:01:20.940
So check out the Stuff You Should Know True Crime playlist on the iHeartRadio app,
00:01:25.300
Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:31.320
The murder of an 18-year-old girl in Graves County, Kentucky, went unsolved for years.
00:01:38.320
Until a local housewife, a journalist, and a handful of girls came forward with a story.
00:01:46.800
Bad things happens to good people in small towns.
00:01:56.740
Listen to Graves County on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:02:03.160
And to binge the entire season ad-free, subscribe to Lava for Good Plus on Apple Podcasts.
00:02:08.660
Hey, I'm Jay Shetty, and I'm the host of the On Purpose Podcast.
00:02:20.720
Emma Watson has announced she's retiring from acting.
00:02:22.940
Has anyone else noticed that we haven't seen Emma Watson in anything in several years?
00:02:27.120
Emma Watson is opening up the truth behind her five-year break from acting.
00:02:33.100
Listen to On Purpose with Jay Shetty on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:02:41.120
In early 1988, federal agents raced to track down the gang they suspect of importing millions of dollars worth of heroin into New York from Asia.
00:02:50.540
Had 30 agents ready to go with shotguns and rifles and you name it.
00:03:00.120
Basically, your stay-at-home moms were picking up these large amounts of heroin.
00:03:09.320
Once I saw the gun, I tried to take his hand, and I saw the flash of light.
00:03:12.840
Listen to the Chinatown Sting on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or anywhere you get your podcasts.
00:03:27.660
Your online name, which we'll get to in a minute.
00:03:30.480
And for folks that don't know you, millions of people do because they watch you religiously.
00:03:34.940
You're a rock star on YouTube, content creator, a Twitch live streamer, speed runner.
00:03:44.820
But also really focused on building community around marketing, around business.
00:03:49.240
And that's what your background represented, working at Twitch, working at NVIDIA.
00:03:55.540
But I really wanted you on because with so much focus on what happened a few weeks ago with
00:04:03.120
Charlie Kirk and Tyler Robinson, the person who's been accused, some of the gaming questions and issues that came up,
00:04:09.640
some of the memes that were allegedly part of some components of the investigation.
00:04:15.780
And the broader conversations we're having in this country around the manosphere and what's happening with gaming culture generally, issues of boys and men, everything about this.
00:04:30.660
I all came back to you as a guy that can explain to unpack all of this stuff.
00:04:39.280
And I wanted to, first of all, I want to say, you mentioned millions of people might know my stuff.
00:04:45.740
But the people that know me, I think they'll like me.
00:04:47.760
People that don't know me, when they hear content creator or YouTuber or Twitch streamer,
00:04:51.460
I think they have an instant dislike, and I don't really blame them.
00:04:56.520
Like, I don't think that's, I think most people have an instant distrust of someone who has that as their job.
00:05:03.220
So I want to try and get across why people are turning to this, why this is becoming a new form of media.
00:05:09.520
And also understand that, like, if you don't, if this is not for you, I get it.
00:05:15.320
But people, I mean, it explains more things in more ways on more days, particularly to parents.
00:05:18.900
I mean, I've got four young kids, and it's pretty overwhelming, the gaming culture that's out there.
00:05:24.740
I mean, 70-plus percent of teenagers are active gamers?
00:05:33.720
You know, and I don't think this is your stance, but it's, like, really important for me to get across early.
00:05:37.820
It feels like in the wake of what happened with Charlie Kirk, there is a re-ignition of old, old, old debates
00:05:44.780
around how video games, violent video games are the problem.
00:05:47.440
And I just want to be so clear, from my POV and from the POV of my audience, who's, again, younger Gen Z men,
00:05:56.580
You know, South Korea, Japan, UK, Germany, France, they all have the same rate of video game playing,
00:06:02.380
and they have none of the violent crime, or a small fraction of the violent crime.
00:06:14.480
No, and by the way, full stipulate, could not agree with you more.
00:06:17.680
As someone that's deeply focused on the issue of gun violence, mass shootings, and all these things,
00:06:23.600
and sort of the lazy punditry that comes back to this gaming culture has been completely debunked, 100%.
00:06:29.800
So could not agree with that more, just stipulating an alignment of thinking on that.
00:06:34.800
And then, you know, now they're saying, I think they're about to haul the head of Reddit, and Discord, and Twitch,
00:06:47.920
I will say, some young men are spending a large percentage of their time on these platforms.
00:06:53.840
This is a symptom of them having almost nowhere else to go.
00:06:56.840
And especially when I talk about gaming, the idea that gaming is driving isolation,
00:07:01.700
and not isolation is leading to people trying to find an escape or connection through gaming,
00:07:08.840
So, I don't know if you have children, you have young boys?
00:07:14.920
Oldest just turned 16, and the two boys, 9 and 13.
00:07:27.040
Battling them on YouTube, watching someone else play Minecraft.
00:07:34.080
And so, what I would say is, you know, I assume you do the normal thing parents are doing,
00:07:38.660
especially in SF, they limit screen time, things like that.
00:07:40.500
But, to be honest, if you told them they can't play Roblox, or they can't play Fortnite,
00:07:46.560
Like, they are less able to connect to their friends nowadays.
00:07:51.080
I know it's a generation disconnect, but that is not the problem.
00:07:55.140
The young men that are turning to Discord servers and gaming are trying to find friends
00:08:00.660
They are logging on after work and hanging out in voice chats with their friend and having
00:08:05.000
This is, like, the one thing that's keeping them sane in a world that is going, I think,
00:08:08.780
increasingly insane and not offering them economic opportunities.
00:08:11.820
Let's unpack, because, you know, I think a lot of people, obviously, YouTube people are familiar
00:08:16.140
There's a sort of generation, though, that's heard of Twitch.
00:08:19.420
There's heard of Kik, that's heard of Discord, but they don't know what these things are.
00:08:24.260
Reddit, maybe people are a little bit more familiar with.
00:08:27.520
And when I started, I mean, Twitch is sort of a go-to for a lot of folks in the gaming
00:08:32.400
But explain what these are, what these platforms represent, how they started, and what they've
00:08:38.600
So I worked at Twitch right around the time it started.
00:08:41.180
It was a very lucky thing for me, because I was a ASU, Arizona State University, the
00:08:45.640
Harvard of the Southwest, they call it, graduate.
00:08:51.840
And it was very, very lucky that I found this route into Twitch, which was a website which
00:09:04.400
And people that also played the game found that to be entertaining, and they would start
00:09:07.940
to build communities and audiences, and it would grow.
00:09:09.660
And tell me, at what time were people starting to really, I mean, was it a particular individual
00:09:14.540
that said, hey, I'm going to put myself online?
00:09:17.180
Was there a moment that marked consciousness of this whole, I mean, because it's become
00:09:20.840
a gigantic business, and we'll get to that in a moment.
00:09:24.080
But was Twitch really the first to really popularize as a platform?
00:09:27.900
Twitch was the one that found this niche early.
00:09:39.360
Because everyone's stuck at home, and it just hits the right time in the right place.
00:09:44.460
You discovered Twitch as someone not just doing content, but someone that was marketing
00:09:52.180
I never had any interest in doing content myself.
00:09:54.420
I was at Twitch, and they needed someone to go on camera every now and then, and I was
00:09:59.820
And I got some training, and I was using the program.
00:10:02.240
And you got on camera, and you started doing what?
00:10:08.440
So what I'm saying might sound completely unwatchable to someone who doesn't play video
00:10:13.760
But over the past, since 2014 to now, the platform has changed dramatically.
00:10:18.220
The biggest thing on the website is not games at all.
00:10:20.300
It's just people talking to the camera about their lives, about the news, about what's going
00:10:25.220
People are just using it because it's a real direct connection.
00:10:30.740
The gaming is still a big part of Twitch, but it's into the culture.
00:10:33.880
You might play games a little bit during the day, then Switch talking about the news,
00:10:44.680
No, just at the time you were, what was the biggest content that was being provided at
00:10:49.600
Was it, was there a particular game that was mostly popularized or that was disproportionately
00:10:55.660
So I, again, first it was COVID and then I would say, you know, celebrities started to
00:11:02.120
And I think Drake played with Ninja, some Fortnite and that every, every, every, I know I was
00:11:07.200
I saw every little step would blow Twitch up a little bit more and then it started to
00:11:11.200
But what I would say is it's spread beyond Twitch now.
00:11:16.880
What I'm saying is people right now are just engaging through content creators because
00:11:19.980
they have this more direct one-to-one connection.
00:11:22.880
I actually, what I'll say, what it is, is, um, and you probably deal with this as a challenge
00:11:28.720
Like people are very, very tired of inauthenticity.
00:11:34.360
People feel like everyone's out to sell them something.
00:11:39.340
But they're trying to find somebody they can trust.
00:11:44.320
And so you're saying kids are going online and they, and they end up looking for that.
00:11:47.500
They see someone they can identify with through a medium that they're already identified
00:11:51.980
with, a game that they have in common or interests that they have in common.
00:11:56.400
And, and, and so Twitch figured this thing out.
00:12:01.580
Twitch is not, it's not just a platform exclusively for gaming.
00:12:05.100
The biggest thing on the platform is not gaming.
00:12:06.620
Just, I think that's a shock to some people, but it really is just people talking, people
00:12:10.960
And it's these sort of areas of interest where you get into these group chats and there's
00:12:17.200
People are engaged in a two-way conversation, not just one.
00:12:21.220
I mean, at a big enough chat, you're not really talking one-to-one, but the idea is
00:12:25.080
people feel like their voice is somewhat being heard.
00:12:27.560
And what's the difference between Twitch and Discord?
00:12:33.340
You know, uh, there's a lot of, um, among Gen Z, there's these memes going around about
00:12:43.840
It's nobody's, it's your own private little room with your friends.
00:12:48.080
It's like saying, I heard you're using an iPhone.
00:12:53.100
It's just a, you're not in the same, uh, group.
00:12:56.140
And you're referring to, cause there was, I mean, you, you, you hear about Discord often
00:13:00.900
in the context of some of these more high profile instances.
00:13:04.940
Obviously this Tyler Robinson is accused of, of, accused of shooting Charlie Kirk, uh, used
00:13:12.540
Yeah, but he used a Discord chat room with his friends.
00:13:15.140
Nobody else is, it's, you know, and it's any, any medium could have done this.
00:13:18.860
The, the idea that Discord is uniquely, uh, brewing people like this is, is, uh, unsubstantiated.
00:13:26.240
So the gaming area, the gaming, most of the gaming platforms, YouTube's sort of dominant
00:13:31.760
Along with Twitch, who else is sort of emerging in the gaming space as the platform, the sort
00:13:38.420
I would say YouTube and Twitch is the vast, vast majority of people doing this.
00:13:43.820
You could talk about Kick, you could talk about Rumble, you could talk about the more
00:13:46.680
fringe, wild ones, but, uh, Twitch and YouTube.
00:13:50.280
And YouTube is the 800 pound gorilla in the space.
00:13:54.200
That's where I'm putting out my content online.
00:13:57.460
And so you started just as you, you just were there in Arizona.
00:14:03.060
You just, you know, you just found just sort of a proclivity for it.
00:14:06.900
You remember the first game you were like deep into, like you're just obsessed with.
00:14:10.580
Well, no, here's what I want to say is like, this is me in Arizona.
00:14:16.780
I had okay grades and the, and the college is not some incredible degree.
00:14:23.100
And, and thanks to a lucky opportunity and thanks to the economy being in a better spot
00:14:27.320
at the time, I get this last chopper out of nom.
00:14:30.440
It feels like where I get a decent chance to, to go off and make enough money to now I can,
00:14:40.880
But so, uh, I have friends now who are younger than me that are like, I have a friend who's
00:14:46.240
graduating from Berkeley, uh, computer science, smart guy.
00:14:50.060
He's graduating in an environment that is a hundred times harder to get a job than it
00:14:58.180
So that is going to make him more likely to be nihilistic.
00:15:02.600
It's more likely to make him disengage from the system, more likely to make him angry at
00:15:08.220
It's just, it's not, it's tough to say that like, I just find it for, and you're not doing
00:15:13.860
this, but I'm saying I'm finding it frustrating.
00:15:15.840
The endless pointing to discord, Reddit, Twitch, it's, this has nothing to do with it.
00:15:22.620
It is, it is the situation where people are, are more and more desperate.
00:15:30.100
I mean, I played, I played, I wasted my college on a game like League of Legends.
00:15:33.600
I wasted, you know, but I, but you didn't waste your, because you created a career.
00:15:39.480
I mean, I don't, I don't think that's, uh, and what I do now has almost nothing to do
00:15:49.020
So people have an understanding who we're talking to here.
00:15:55.920
There's a game called Hitman where you, uh, you know, you're, you're flying around and
00:15:59.420
I, listen, I, I, uh, that is a time of my life where I was here.
00:16:03.780
I started doing this when I was working at NVIDIA.
00:16:05.540
I was working some insane hours and I wanted to come home and disengage.
00:16:08.680
I wanted to just play video games and I wanted some friends in the chat to do it.
00:16:14.160
Then after COVID, I started talking about, you know, I'm an avid reader.
00:16:17.740
I'm reading the news every day and I want to talk, I just give my thoughts.
00:16:21.560
And eventually that was enough that I could leave a job that was really stable and good
00:16:26.220
And you started to be able to monetize it at that level.
00:16:28.980
Working for one of the great chip companies on planet earth.
00:16:32.260
And now one of the biggest market cap companies, quite literally.
00:16:36.000
Uh, and, and, and you started making the kind of money that you said, man, I'm just full
00:16:54.460
Uh, you're sharing it, uh, in a very public way.
00:17:01.040
And it's nice of you to say, but there, as with all things, there's some aspect of hard work
00:17:06.100
And there's a, and the idea that this is the path that everyone could just, you know,
00:17:10.560
I, I, I can think of so many times things could have gone a different way.
00:17:15.940
And you'll acknowledge, I mean, and, and I think it's just important to illuminate.
00:17:18.740
I mean, but a lot of people are finding this path, right?
00:17:25.280
No, yeah, well, no, I mean, I'm not going to, we'll see what happens, but it's in terms
00:17:29.160
of my future, Jesus, but it's no, but it's, but it's interesting to me.
00:17:32.320
I mean, it's, I think it's people just to understand and absorb a sort of this digital
00:17:37.840
I mean, there's a whole generation that frankly, they, they're digital.
00:17:42.240
Obviously we talk about digital immigrants versus digital natives, uh, in sort of a lazy
00:17:46.100
vernacular, but this whole digital first experience is, is radically changing everything, including
00:17:52.160
So we're going to get to that in a moment, but, but the gaming culture is real.
00:17:57.520
You've got stadiums now quite literally filled physical stadiums with people watching these
00:18:03.600
e-sports, uh, and other people playing games, uh, to a degree that I don't think most people
00:18:12.660
I went to a study abroad in South Korea and they had these big tournaments and I was blown
00:18:17.300
away and I was like, let's get this in America.
00:18:19.580
It happened without me, but I came back and started to work in that space and that blew
00:18:24.400
But again, I can't tell you enough, uh, this, like the e-sports is, is really a small part
00:18:30.560
of what is becoming this online, um, influencer first culture.
00:18:35.520
If you were to spend some time browsing Twitch, you would not see as much gaming as you're thinking
00:18:40.520
It really is people just looking for human connection, humans to talk to.
00:18:46.920
I'm not saying everyone should be spending all their time on these platforms.
00:18:49.900
I am just saying that it's, it's a very natural response to, to things getting more expensive,
00:18:55.140
to looking for, to finding people who have shared some similar values or ideas as you
00:19:02.080
Cause I mean, there's those deep issues, generational issues that, uh, we've, we've been talking
00:19:07.400
about on the podcast with a number of people in the past and, and it's off the chart, particularly
00:19:11.840
And, and so I just want to unpack it a little bit more, just again, for people that are
00:19:15.280
not fully, uh, that just don't have the level of understanding the space, but you, you talk
00:19:20.600
about e-sports and I just think it's an interesting space in this context.
00:19:24.880
You say it's a relatively small space, but it's not a small amount of investment that
00:19:29.880
I was just reading about Michael Jordan, uh, Shaquille O'Neal, Beckham, uh, folks putting
00:19:34.760
tens of millions of dollars, uh, into e-sports teams.
00:19:41.360
But what I'll tell you is being dead honest, Gavin, a lot of them are going to lose their
00:19:45.380
It's not, you know, I've been around the e-sports space a while and a lot of people have gotten
00:19:50.600
The problem is it's really hard to monetize the user.
00:19:56.040
They don't, you know, there's not a, there's not a lot of in-person stadium buying merch
00:20:00.280
The business economics of e-sports are interesting, but it is growing in terms of viewership and
00:20:04.300
it'll get there, but they got way ahead of their skis.
00:20:07.040
I think a lot of people are, are coming down off the highs.
00:20:09.740
You know, it was like, it was one of those things, almost every business, there's some
00:20:14.340
And then it's, that's, that's happening with these.
00:20:18.860
It was like, you could do the salaries were insane.
00:20:21.120
They were getting paid absurd amounts for these players to sit in the room and play games.
00:20:24.520
It's less now, you know, it's, it's, and I, you know, Rick Fox of the Lakers put a bunch
00:20:29.160
of money into a team lost, you know, had to get out.
00:20:31.260
And I'm saying it'll happen, but I'm not going to be one of those guys.
00:20:39.300
And so you're, what's interesting about you is not only your history and, and, and, and,
00:20:44.620
and how you've evolved in terms of your own career path and, and going into these aspects
00:20:49.980
and disciplines, but the marketing background and the business background and the work you're
00:20:53.620
doing on a new podcast, uh, lemon, it was lemonade, lemonade stand.
00:20:57.120
And you're talking about business and branding, et cetera, but you mentioned just in, in reference
00:21:01.680
and passing something that I think is interesting and, and for folks, again, may not be familiar
00:21:05.820
with on Fortnite in particular, which I just remember my kids watching religiously to your
00:21:10.560
point during COVID, uh, excessively as a parent from my perspective.
00:21:16.020
Uh, but, uh, from their perspective, they were, I just got on it, dad.
00:21:20.320
I've only been on for 10 minutes, but I remember turning it on one day and they're listening to
00:21:28.800
And they, so that fascinated me to this integration for live concerts, uh, Travis Scott, that is,
00:21:34.920
I think Ariana Grande, uh, may have done one also brands, right?
00:21:38.760
I mean, you've got Nike now working on those and those platforms, Louis Vuitton.
00:21:45.120
Give us a sense of what that integration as well.
00:21:48.000
I mean, it is as crazy as it can sound from someone outside of it.
00:21:52.980
It's people all over the world in a digital world, watching these concerts together.
00:21:58.540
And it's just becoming where the culture, that is where I think there is such a line
00:22:05.040
And, uh, and I think that is what allows me to talk about other things with the lingo
00:22:10.320
and the references that they use, because it's just something they're native to a hundred
00:22:15.880
But I, you know, I think people will, will come around to it.
00:22:21.340
I, you know, here's an example, uh, for e-sports, all of the biggest ways to watch it are not,
00:22:28.100
you know how you watch the NFL through the NFL's official broadcast or a pirated version
00:22:32.920
if you're young, but you're watching the official commentators, uh, for e-sports, it doesn't
00:22:37.940
They make an official broadcast and then a million people will restream it and all their
00:22:42.140
And those guys get way more viewers than the official broadcast.
00:22:45.740
And we're starting to see that happen with sports where they'll have like the Manning
00:22:49.160
cast for the NFL who a lot of rights issues are in the way, but eventually they're going
00:22:52.800
to crack the code because the average person wants to see this stuff filtered through someone
00:22:58.480
And it's speaking to them like a regular person, right?
00:23:02.500
The democratization of all of this stuff is happening and it is reaching sports now.
00:23:08.300
And it's going to, it's going to happen to things you understand as well.
00:23:10.720
But, um, yeah, it's weird seeing it live, you know, gaming has been on the cutting edge
00:23:15.800
of this because I, again, back to my original point, it's just where people are finding
00:23:19.360
friends and connections where they can find it.
00:23:25.160
And we'll go back to your reference, sort of this, these moments that sort of mark the
00:23:29.640
And obviously COVID was just off the charts in terms of just people trying to connect,
00:23:34.520
feeling totally isolated, disconnected, and they can find those relationships online.
00:23:40.400
They can, they can literally develop friendships and relationships online that they otherwise
00:23:45.300
wouldn't have had necessarily the opportunity, particularly during COVID.
00:23:48.420
Talk to me about, you know, those years, you talk about 2021 representing sort of a peak
00:23:54.740
But what, what, what do you see start to really take shape during those COVID years?
00:23:58.900
I mean, so after 2020, there's a lot of new money, both from Trump and Biden floating around
00:24:07.500
They both did a lot of stimulus and printing and that went into tech startups and that went
00:24:13.080
into, uh, e-sports and that went into Twitch and that went into all this stuff.
00:24:19.520
There was, uh, you know, I remember, um, there was the GameStop stock craze and everyone wanted
00:24:25.400
And that was, these things became cultural flashpoints that were taking place entirely
00:24:29.860
And then after 2021, we started to get inflation, a lot of inflation that made doing things
00:24:36.240
that weren't online more expensive and more difficult.
00:24:40.600
And so these things, I think, combined to push people more into online spaces than perhaps
00:24:51.740
You know, as a content creator, COVID was, uh, uh, exposure to an entirely new audience.
00:24:56.540
It grew a lot bigger, but it's not, I wouldn't say it was a good thing for overall.
00:25:04.420
I mean, the unhealthy aspects are what you try to get offline so you can get back into
00:25:09.700
a line and reconnect with people back in the real world.
00:25:12.240
I mean, well, in what way was it, was it, what I'm saying is I think people, people want
00:25:17.940
to do that naturally, they just can't, they just, it is just more difficult.
00:25:22.480
You know, I, I don't know if we want to get to it now, but I, I do want to start talking
00:25:26.880
about Gen Z men and, uh, the issue I'm seeing, not all of them are like, it's a broad, diverse
00:25:34.660
And, and it's a huge point in my audience and I'm hearing them, I'm hearing their, their
00:25:45.100
And the nihilism is what's coming is what I sense growing a little bit where they're
00:25:50.740
You know, I think around 22, three, four, you probably saw this on the political side.
00:25:55.860
They drifted more conservative because they thought that would be the solution.
00:26:00.000
And as Donald Trump has proven to be not the answer to any of their problems.
00:26:02.800
And in fact, making a lot of them worse, making the inflation worse, making the economy
00:26:05.940
worse, making, then they are now just drifting into open nihilism.
00:26:10.840
And I'm not to, to blame that on the, the methods they're using to try and not be that
00:26:25.960
Together we're launching The Moment, a new podcast about what it means to live through a time
00:26:34.440
I would be the first immigrant mayor in generations, but 40% of New Yorkers were born outside of
00:26:47.320
This individual might lose the faith, but there's an institution that doesn't lose faith.
00:26:54.700
To bring you depth and analysis from a unique Latino perspective.
00:26:57.920
There's not a single day that Paula and I don't call or text each other, sharing news
00:27:03.040
and thoughts about what's happening in the country.
00:27:05.480
This new podcast will be a way to make that ongoing intergenerational conversation public.
00:27:11.160
Listen to The Moment with Jorge Ramos and Paula Ramos as part of the My Cultura podcast network
00:27:18.120
on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:27:22.540
Hi there, this is Josh Clark from the Stuff You Should Know podcast.
00:27:26.460
If you've been thinking, man alive, I could go for some good true crime podcast episodes,
00:27:32.600
Stuff You Should Know just released a playlist of 12 of our best true crime episodes of all
00:27:37.540
There's a shootout in broad daylight, people using axes in really terrible ways, disappearances,
00:27:45.420
So check out the Stuff You Should Know true crime playlist on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts,
00:27:56.000
All I know is what I've been told, and that to have truth is a whole lie.
00:28:01.520
For almost a decade, the murder of an 18-year-old girl from a small town in Graves County, Kentucky,
00:28:09.520
went unsolved until a local homemaker, a journalist, and a handful of girls came forward with a story.
00:28:20.620
A story that law enforcement used to convict six people, and that got the citizen investigator
00:28:28.660
Through sheer persistence and nerve, this Kentucky housewife helped give justice to Jessica Curran.
00:28:37.400
I'm a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist, producer, and I wouldn't be here if the truth were that
00:28:45.240
I did not know her, and I did not kill her, or rape, or burn, or any of that other stuff
00:28:51.340
They literally made me say that I took a match and struck and threw it on her.
00:28:57.200
From Lava for Good, this is Graves County, a show about just how far our legal system will
00:29:11.880
Bad things happen to good people in small towns.
00:29:17.120
Listen to Graves County in the Bone Valley feed on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or
00:29:26.940
And to binge the entire season ad-free, subscribe to Lava for Good Plus on Apple Podcasts.
00:29:32.120
Hey, I'm Jay Shetty, and I'm the host of the On Purpose Podcast.
00:29:51.220
Emma Watson has announced she's retiring from acting.
00:29:53.460
Has anyone else noticed that we haven't seen Emma Watson in anything in several years?
00:29:57.640
Emma Watson is opening up the truth behind her five-year break from acting.
00:30:04.840
Was acting always something you were going to do?
00:30:07.380
I was using acting as a way of escaping to feel free.
00:30:11.180
My parents, it wasn't just the divorce, it was just like the continuing situation of living
00:30:16.160
between two different houses and two different lives and two different sets of values, the
00:30:32.680
Listen to On Purpose with Jay Shetty on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever
00:30:39.440
In early 1988, federal agents raced to track down the gang they suspect of importing millions
00:30:48.200
of dollars worth of heroin into New York from Asia.
00:30:51.840
We had 30 agents ready to go with shotguns and rifles and you name it.
00:31:01.520
Basically, your stay-at-home moms were picking up these large amounts of heroin.
00:31:08.000
They go, oh, you may not see her for like 25 years.
00:31:14.720
Caught between a federal investigation and the violent gang who recruited them, the women
00:31:20.160
must decide who they're willing to protect and who they dare to betray.
00:31:26.200
Once I saw the gun, I tried to take his hand and I saw the flash of light.
00:31:30.400
Listen to the Chinatown Sting on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or anywhere you get your podcasts.
00:31:36.960
But it does beg sort of the larger consciousness that came out of the Trump campaign as it relates
00:31:47.060
to, you're right, he obviously dominated, particularly with young men, but outperformed
00:31:52.540
in ways that I think surprised a lot of folks and invested a lot of time and energy into
00:31:57.640
spaces where a lot of young men were and where a lot of young men are.
00:32:03.140
We talk about this sort of manosphere, broadly defined, which is something that needs to
00:32:08.120
But he did invest that time and energy to meet people, quote unquote, where they are.
00:32:15.760
And we didn't see that commensurate investment from the Democratic Party.
00:32:27.260
But, you know, I saw a piece from Hester Klein the other day where he talked about how it's
00:32:33.120
seems like, and again, I'm going to be candid here.
00:32:35.640
It seems like the DNC as a whole is trying to run a very similar playbook that didn't
00:32:42.260
work and is wondering why they're not getting different results.
00:32:45.260
It is shocking to me that with as bad as Trump is doing, and it really is.
00:32:51.780
Again, if I want to be your Gen Z whisperer for a second, again, I'm a millennial.
00:33:00.980
They are turning on Donald Trump in a way that will come apparent pretty soon.
00:33:09.280
But they're not turning towards the Democratic Party.
00:33:13.360
They're equally as upset with them, which is what I think the problem is.
00:33:17.120
And it's kind of crazy that it's not being capitalized on more.
00:33:21.740
I think what you have been doing is kind of breaking through the noise.
00:33:24.620
It's showing a little bit of, I don't know, a spine of a willingness to stand up to what
00:33:29.440
he's doing, but if I can be honest, all right, here's what I'll say.
00:33:36.880
And you haven't announced anything, and this is not, but there's a theoretical world where
00:33:50.560
And if I can get somebody who's not militarizing the National Guard and somebody who's not
00:34:00.460
shutting down TV shows that disagree with them and somebody who's not threatening free
00:34:09.420
But, you know, realistically, from the audience that I'm talking about, because again, I
00:34:21.940
They will continue to grow more upset and populist and nihilistic unless things seriously change.
00:34:30.460
Like, they have to change on a more fundamental level.
00:34:32.780
Look, so let's start to unpack this, because, I mean, I love the clarity as you painted this
00:34:39.520
I mean, it's, you know, it's pretty black and white terms, as you painted it.
00:34:43.040
I mean, just like this notion of nihilism, of just like not giving a shit about anything
00:34:49.780
And the most extreme example would be someone like Tyler Robinson.
00:34:51.960
If you look at, you know, his, and I'm not a psychoanalyst, I'm not an expert, but there
00:34:55.800
seems to be a nihilism to these kind of actions and from young people in general that is rising
00:35:00.560
where it just feels like, if I can't get a house, if you're a young man, I can't get
00:35:04.400
a partner, I can't find a way to be up, to feel roots in the society that I'm in, then
00:35:16.540
In fact, I would say that one of the healthiest things they can do is gaming and Discord, because
00:35:22.840
The Discord chats that I'm in are not making me or radicalize.
00:35:29.940
I don't know if you've heard about what happened in Nepal recently.
00:35:34.580
So Nepal, their Gen Z youth was deeply upset about rising youth unemployment, rising poverty.
00:35:42.000
And they were posting about it on social media and they were getting angry.
00:35:49.780
That's when they're going crazy, because these are the last outlets people have.
00:35:54.320
So I just want to give that perspective here, is that if Congress is going to haul Discord
00:36:00.260
and Twitch and Reddit up there and think that restricting them or banning them is going
00:36:11.140
No, look, I think what you're saying is profoundly important.
00:36:15.280
And I'm not trying to go back, but I want to paint this picture because I want to land
00:36:22.800
Because I think what you're saying needs to be said, because there were these trend lines
00:36:28.240
that predate all of this for decades and decades.
00:36:31.700
And we have the first generation, this Gen Z, that literally is poised to do much worse
00:36:37.980
This is the first generation in our lifetime, my lifetime certainly, but literally in American
00:36:51.240
And these guys are screaming, disproportionately men in some respects, and no one's paying
00:37:00.760
We're looking at the platforms and not the underlying damn issues.
00:37:05.040
But I want to get to, and I want you to hold those stats because I think they're incredibly
00:37:08.600
But I want to go back just so, again, just because so many people want to understand,
00:37:13.820
and these are not root causes, but they're component parts of this larger conversation.
00:37:23.200
This is an investment that I think Trump and the Republicans made into spaces that are not
00:37:30.800
They are spaces where people are talking about wrestling or UFC or video games or just finding
00:37:39.760
connection, often with other men, and just trying to understand similar experiences in
00:37:47.300
Also on the side, let's stop the woke mind virus.
00:37:53.380
It would be, Kamala Harris is not going to help you out.
00:37:57.160
And they would mix that in with things people already like.
00:38:02.160
And what's crazy, I don't think it's that hard for the Democrats to join these spaces.
00:38:12.080
And I think, again, I can't overstate how it feels like a ball somewhere is being dropped
00:38:17.740
when you can't speak even semi-authentically to people that are not from a different world.
00:38:31.320
Listen, we're going to fight in this country about social issues left and right forever,
00:38:37.280
And I really noticed that in the wake of this Charlie Kirk thing where it's just an endless
00:38:47.900
And nobody's making any progress and no one's making any forward motion.
00:38:51.700
But what I'll say is the main thing that I am seeing and feeling was a deep resentment
00:39:03.660
And I truly think whichever side can solve those problems will dictate, not dictate, but
00:39:12.520
People will go whatever direction is going to offer them solutions on that.
00:39:16.400
And because Trump has not done that, like he promised, there's already a reverse boomerang
00:39:21.800
OK, it's going to go the other way, regardless of whether or not anyone reaches out to podcasts,
00:39:27.940
But if it goes this way and that isn't solved again, it'll be an even stronger.
00:39:38.760
So you're talking, I mean, it's, you know, unpacking this a little bit.
00:39:43.180
I mean, you talk about nihilism or broadly defined.
00:39:50.180
And so, you know, one thing as a goal of mine on this podcast is to try and get you
00:40:03.000
You have to represent more than just some individual base.
00:40:06.060
And I think what you're doing, talking to people politically different than you is a
00:40:13.180
Um, and gain, understand more and understanding.
00:40:18.760
I mean, Charlie Kirk on this show is when we launched this podcast is the first.
00:40:24.800
I, and you know, what's funny is, is, uh, I respected more for that.
00:40:28.940
I, I, I tried to do some research and watch some of these.
00:40:31.040
Some of the comments are, are brutal on you and you did it anyway.
00:40:34.900
But so, um, I'm not here to like push you in a direction that is going to make it harder
00:40:42.320
I think politicians should for try to represent people that aren't directly aligned with them.
00:40:45.980
What I'm trying to get you to understand is like, uh, I think I want to push you a little
00:40:51.740
bit more economically on, you know, in this country from like the forties to the eighties,
00:40:57.100
we had an extremely low Gini coefficient of inequality.
00:41:00.840
It was, it was low and flat for years, a strong rising middle class and people broadly feeling
00:41:12.760
It wasn't, you know, it was a capitalist country and businesses could thrive, but people felt
00:41:18.860
And since we've allowed this increased consolidation, since we've continually used government funds
00:41:25.560
to prop up the stocks and housing of elderly boomers that own it all, it is, it has become
00:41:31.340
more, it's a ladder that is fewer and fewer rungs to get on.
00:41:34.520
And, uh, so if, if there isn't substantive change on that front, nothing else matters.
00:41:46.440
Um, and I understand that, you know, these boomers vote too.
00:41:50.060
I, I, again, people give you a lot of crap for California housing.
00:41:54.860
The more I look into it, it's, I used to be someone who just threw around blame really
00:41:58.540
And now I read more, it gets me depressed because it's like, it's an impossible complex problem.
00:42:02.840
People that have the housing, they put their life savings into it.
00:42:06.800
If you try to bring housing prices down, well, then now this person's mad.
00:42:14.320
This is an angry nihilistic generation that wants change badly.
00:42:17.540
No, and what was the, quote unquote, California housing crisis going back decades and decades
00:42:21.700
to supply demand imbalance, nimbyism, issues around localism.
00:42:25.720
Now it's one, now it's across the board, all across the United States.
00:42:30.860
And that's why I think, as you brought up Ezra Klein a moment ago, we had him on the
00:42:34.740
podcast too, the whole abundance agenda and focusing on away from process paralysis and
00:42:41.300
lawfare and all of the nimbyism to a yimby yes in my backyard, not no in my backyard mindset
00:42:47.160
in order to break through that and to start to address that supply demand imbalance to lower
00:42:53.660
costs, to ultimately provide more points of opportunity.
00:42:59.840
And I think it's only reinforced the broader analysis by the fact there's a lot of Trump
00:43:04.460
supporters that otherwise would be Bernie supporters as well or vice versa.
00:43:09.660
So there's this sort of notion of populism and not in the pejorative sense, but truly representative
00:43:14.740
sense, recognizing what's missing and giving voice to that.
00:43:19.500
Now, the question is the prescriptions that Trump's offering, as you suggest, I couldn't
00:43:23.960
agree with you more, are sort of proven to do precisely the opposite.
00:43:28.060
I mean, the largest tax increase on middle class and working folks, i.e. tariffs, inflation
00:43:33.380
that's now starting to go back up in Fed policy that is actually not accelerating in terms of
00:43:40.580
But because of those uncertainties, particularly as it relates to pressure and inflation, now
00:43:46.540
is not necessarily moving as quickly to lower borrowing costs as we had otherwise hoped.
00:43:57.840
When I was at NVIDIA, I was in Scott's class, and he's one of the people.
00:44:00.900
The way he spoke, not even the content of what he said, the way he presented, I was like,
00:44:05.400
that is something I can learn from, and I took to that to when I was starting to stream,
00:44:11.080
And Scott, for those that don't know, we also have out in the pod as well.
00:44:15.320
He's, I mean, he really speaks to the Gen Z generation.
00:44:22.020
You look at this big, beautiful bill and all this massive tax cuts that are burdening
00:44:27.880
the generation that is increasingly already feeling like no one gives a damn about them.
00:44:32.820
So it just reinforces, I think, the called arms that you're suggesting here in terms
00:44:37.560
of consciousness, that is, as it relates to the moment.
00:44:40.620
And again, you know, I think these trends were in a bad direction before Trump, but he
00:44:51.420
It is a massive multi-trillion dollar credit card swipe that we younger people are going
00:44:56.380
And I don't know, it, it, it, it's, it, I'm not suggesting, um, getting rid of social
00:45:04.140
security or anything, but it is, it is frustrating as a young working person that the biggest line
00:45:09.500
item on the government budget is checks to older people, many of whom have houses and
00:45:13.900
have a paycheck to afford, you know, it is just, I think we are not seeing enough go to
00:45:20.940
people that are trying to get started in this, in the country and, and, and get on the ladder.
00:45:28.240
Together we're launching The Moment, a new podcast about what it means to live through a time
00:45:37.020
I would be the first immigrant mayor in generations, but 40% of New Yorkers were born outside of this
00:45:49.560
This individual might lose the faith, but there's an institution that doesn't lose faith.
00:45:56.940
To bring you depth and analysis from a unique Latino perspective.
00:46:00.800
There's not a single day that Paula and I don't call or text each other, sharing news and thoughts
00:46:07.680
This new podcast will be a way to make that ongoing intergenerational conversation public.
00:46:13.360
Listen to The Moment with Jorge Ramos and Paula Ramos as part of the My Cultura podcast
00:46:19.820
network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:46:25.260
Hi there, this is Josh Clark from the Stuff You Should Know podcast.
00:46:28.700
If you've been thinking, man alive, I could go for some good true crime podcast episodes,
00:46:34.820
Stuff You Should Know just released a playlist of 12 of our best true crime episodes of all
00:46:41.140
People using axes in really terrible ways, disappearances, legendary heists, the whole
00:46:47.640
So check out the Stuff You Should Know true crime playlist on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts,
00:46:54.320
For almost a decade, the murder of an 18-year-old girl from a small town in Graves County,
00:47:10.840
Kentucky went unsolved until a local homemaker, a journalist, and a handful of girls came forward
00:47:22.840
A story that law enforcement used to convict six people, and that got The Citizen Investigator
00:47:30.880
Through sheer persistence and nerve, this Kentucky housewife helped give justice to Jessica Curran.
00:47:39.260
I'm a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist, producer, and I wouldn't be here if the truth were that
00:47:48.280
I did not know her, and I did not kill her, or rape, or burn, or any of that other stuff
00:47:53.360
They literally made me say that I took a match and struck and threw it on her.
00:47:59.440
From Lava for Good, this is Graves County, a show about just how far our legal system will
00:48:14.100
Bad things happen to good people in small towns.
00:48:20.600
Listen to Graves County in the Bone Valley feed on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts,
00:48:28.600
And to binge the entire season ad-free, subscribe to Lava for Good Plus on Apple Podcasts.
00:48:41.660
Hey, I'm Jay Shetty, and I'm the host of the On Purpose podcast.
00:48:53.460
Emma Watson has announced she's retiring from acting.
00:48:55.560
Has anyone else noticed that we haven't seen Emma Watson in anything?
00:48:59.820
Emma Watson is opening up the truth behind her five-year break from acting.
00:49:07.100
Was acting always something you were going to do?
00:49:09.600
I was using acting as a way of escaping to feel free.
00:49:13.420
My parents, it wasn't just the divorce, it was just like the continuing situation of living
00:49:18.380
between two different houses and two different lives and two different sets of values.
00:49:22.640
The career and the life that looks like the dream, but are you really happy?
00:49:34.060
Listen to On Purpose with Jay Shetty on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:49:44.460
In early 1988, federal agents raced to track down the gang they suspect of importing millions
00:49:50.420
of dollars worth of heroin into New York from Asia.
00:49:53.580
We had 30 agents ready to go with shotguns and rifles and you name it.
00:50:03.780
Basically, your stay-at-home moms were picking up these large amounts of heroin.
00:50:10.240
They go, oh, you may not see her for like 25 years.
00:50:13.980
Caught between a federal investigation and the violent gang who recruited them, the women
00:50:22.400
must decide who they're willing to protect and who they dare to betray.
00:50:28.340
Once I saw the gun, I tried to take his hand and I saw the flash of light.
00:50:32.720
Listen to The Chinatown Sting on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or anywhere you get your podcasts.
00:50:39.180
And do you see it from, I mean, so there's tax policy that's obviously profound and outsized.
00:50:52.000
And, you know, he was arguing for progressive tax policy.
00:50:55.220
I said at a certain point, I said, Steve, you sound like your governor of California,
00:50:59.260
arguing for California's progressive tax policy.
00:51:06.120
And I want to, I wanted to push that with you as well.
00:51:07.900
Listen, those years I'm talking about, those low inequality years in America,
00:51:14.360
again, probably golden years of America, maybe social policy we can improve,
00:51:19.460
The key things of that era, we had strong unions.
00:51:22.620
We had a progressive tax policy that had high tax rates on the richest people.
00:51:28.280
We had an antitrust enforcement that stopped constant consolidation.
00:51:33.820
Again, this Jimmy Kimmel thing, people aren't talking enough about how it's so clearly Nexstar
00:51:39.380
trying to merge with Tegna to get an inordinate amount of affiliates in this country.
00:51:44.420
And they are just saying whatever Trump wants to hear so that they can get this bill signed.
00:51:49.360
It all comes back to economics is what I'm trying to really get across.
00:51:55.120
And it's a core part of my content is we can fight forever on social issues and we always will.
00:52:02.580
And in a social media area, I just realized how useless it is because algorithms will give you the opinion you want and the one you hate.
00:52:10.500
And they'll give you the comments that support you.
00:52:16.160
And so I just think we have to just, we got to really focus in on the economics because that's where we're going to make a difference.
00:52:37.300
If you guys could get in California, the high-speed rail built.
00:52:40.660
I know it's, I know it's like an impossible legal challenge and everyone blocks it every step.
00:52:52.300
But I can, I have to be accountable to the present.
00:52:56.420
We're finally moving forward on the damn project.
00:52:59.200
2,270 parcels had to be procured through eminent domain and other means.
00:53:05.200
Decade of just, just moving, you know, like in quicksand.
00:53:10.380
And then all the environment, all that now is behind us, finally moving to lay the damn
00:53:16.660
And I want to say, when someone gets on that train and rides it and it makes their life
00:53:29.080
So let's say you talk about housing, rents, rents too damn high.
00:53:39.020
Unemployment for Gen Z men who are college graduates is the same as those that haven't graduated
00:53:44.240
They're getting this degree and getting no material benefit in terms of the stats.
00:53:54.760
And now for the first time with these remarkable, it's, this was not quote unquote, as people
00:53:59.680
said, oh, you've got this sort of useless philosophy degree and you can't get a real
00:54:04.760
No, these are folks with actual degrees in computer science and they can't.
00:54:10.060
And, and by the way, philosophy is not useless.
00:54:12.440
In fact, in many ways, philosophy is the preferred course.
00:54:18.100
Um, no, so, so yeah, they are, they are, um, sorry.
00:54:27.860
Oh, now people don't even want to go to college.
00:54:31.920
So look, not only did they not getting the premium from going to college, college has
00:54:36.540
never been more expensive for these young men, especially for these Gen Z people who had
00:54:42.720
I can't tell you what a sucker punch it has to be to pay way more than your parents ever
00:54:52.140
And, and this is not, you know, we talk about discord and Reddit and gaming changing the
00:54:56.880
I got to talk to you as well as well about, uh, AI and, and chat GPT.
00:55:02.100
Listen, governor, I, I don't know if someone else that your staff is telling you this every
00:55:06.180
high school in California, and there's great ones.
00:55:08.280
Every college in California, people are cheating with chat GPT.
00:55:12.100
Professors are writing rubrics, chat GPT, and then grading with chat GPT.
00:55:15.800
People are paying absurd amounts of money to get, to do not to, it's all a farce.
00:55:21.960
People are very smart and learning, but this is happening.
00:55:24.400
And, uh, we have, again, this is a bigger problem with Trump, but our secretary of education
00:55:34.920
I think you're making that up actually was the co-founder.
00:55:39.800
And I see a speech with her and she's talking about how these kids need to learn about a
00:55:44.540
She doesn't even know what a, she can't even pronounce it.
00:55:47.140
And this is changing literally education rapidly.
00:55:50.100
So again, I, I, I, I hate to put it all on you.
00:55:54.020
You're one person in it, but I'm just, this is my, my id screaming out to the void that
00:55:58.360
I'm hearing is like, things are changing rapidly.
00:56:01.000
And I don't feel like the DNC particularly is like throwing out the old playbook.
00:56:10.100
And, and are you, and when you, when you, when folks that you're interacting with, are
00:56:14.920
they, I'm, is this a gender issue as well from the perspective?
00:56:22.100
It feels like young women are adapting more to the society we have now.
00:56:25.720
They are just finding a way to get to college, get on the corporate ladder.
00:56:29.580
And, you know, I think Scott Galloway talks about this.
00:56:32.620
There's an idea generally that, uh, men are fine dating socioeconomically equal or down
00:56:41.720
So it reduces the amount of partners available for men who can't get on the economic ladder,
00:56:46.660
which makes them more disengaged and more, you know, it's a, it's a snowball effect.
00:56:51.600
Again, it's not women's fault, but this is, this is what's happening.
00:56:54.060
And, and it creates this, um, this simmering, uh, misogyny in online spaces.
00:57:00.160
And it creates this, but it comes back to economics is all I can say over and over again
00:57:05.140
And again, if I could spoil it down to one word, it's like radicalism is when no house,
00:57:10.980
if you can't get a house, if you don't see a path to get a house.
00:57:17.120
Some of them are working, they're working decent jobs.
00:57:19.920
It's not even feasible in a lot of these cities to ever get a house.
00:57:24.500
You can't save up enough without taking on an absurd amount of debt ever.
00:57:29.760
And, uh, and if you picked one thing to focus in on, that would be it because they, that's
00:57:36.440
the biggest thing to put you as part of society or outside of society.
00:57:39.920
If once you feel like you can get on that ladder, you're okay.
00:57:43.840
You can find a party, you can vote, but if you can't see that, it's what's the point?
00:57:58.940
I, I, no, no, I look, I, again, I appreciate it.
00:58:01.580
And, and, and again, bouncing back and forth because it's, I think it's important.
00:58:05.180
You, you talk about, you, you brought up the frame was the word misogyny.
00:58:09.340
And, and finding back to the sort of manosphere, it comes in many forms and manifestations.
00:58:14.300
So I think there's sort of a laziness, quote unquote, the manosphere, what it means or doesn't
00:58:17.920
mean, but there are misogynistic aspects of the manosphere.
00:58:22.180
And there are people that have been very successful in that space.
00:58:25.780
The sort of Andrew Tate's of the world in some respects.
00:58:29.760
I mean, the fair, unfair, Adrian Ross and, uh, you know, the Joel Peterson type.
00:58:34.280
Um, I mean, what, what do you, what do you make of that in the context of the vernacular
00:58:37.800
of the world that, uh, you, you've been navigating and generationally, uh, what you're sort of
00:58:44.660
I'll tell you the worst part about content creation.
00:58:53.680
He, uh, not, not a Trumper, thank God, but, but he, uh, so I don't think he's the world's
00:58:58.460
biggest Gavin Newsom fan, maybe, but I did a very small, uh, uh, interview with you a while ago,
00:59:03.540
like a live stream and, uh, I called you Gavin.
00:59:16.220
I could handle Gavin better than new scum, which, uh, the six year olds used to call me.
00:59:21.440
Hell of a thing when an 86 year old's calling me that.
00:59:28.420
Here's the thing about consecration is you have a direct financial incentive at all times
00:59:34.540
to feed into people's resentment and to feed into their anger and to feed into it is just
00:59:42.420
I thought about this deeply in the wake of Charlie Kirk.
00:59:45.880
And I was looking around the internet and I realized it doesn't matter what I say.
00:59:48.720
It'll just be fed to the person that agrees with me.
00:59:52.120
If I say something that pisses somebody off, they'll never see it again.
00:59:56.560
We are going through an algorithm that just decides what you want to see.
01:00:00.320
So in that case, there is a strong financial incentive to tell people who can't find a
01:00:05.860
house or a partner that it's immigrants fault or it's women's fault, or it's, uh, you know,
01:00:10.960
whoever it's, or it's the woke mind virus or what they'll tell you it's someone's fault.
01:00:17.880
If you're in that spot to have an enemy, to have someone you can rally around and get
01:00:22.180
angry at, and, uh, again, on the space I'm in and Twitch, the most right wing aspects
01:00:27.940
of Twitch are mostly talking about how, man, these woke people are ruining gaming, you know,
01:00:34.000
They'll be like, Oh, there's, there's these female characters lead it in leading the game.
01:00:38.880
And it's like, again, this is a tiny problem, but it unites these people.
01:00:47.900
It's a, it's a symptom is what I'll say though, is that misogyny, I mean, it's probably amplified
01:00:51.700
by this, but it's because they are resentful and someone is going to fill that void and
01:00:57.040
So is that, I mean, is that why tell me, I mean, a lot of these spaces, I mean, then there's
01:01:02.540
sort of that echo chamber, then you get that confirmation bias, the algorithms reinforcing
01:01:07.000
that your worldview is colored in, it's amplified, it becomes bigger, uh, and you become more
01:01:12.860
convinced or ideological in that space at the same time.
01:01:16.260
And in some places that leads you, uh, to, uh, you know, comfortable place, other places
01:01:21.660
can leave you a radicalized place, uh, which could manifest offline and pretty, you know,
01:01:29.860
What I'll say is people have gotten radicalized in human history without these platforms.
01:01:35.880
And it's because it's, you know, it's usually when inequality has reached a breaking point.
01:01:40.600
You go to the twenties and thirties or whatever in, in, uh, Germany.
01:01:44.320
I don't think they were, I don't think Germans were a different people.
01:01:50.000
They had bad economic problems and it led to radicalization.
01:01:58.060
I do think that the internet has made it faster.
01:02:05.400
I, I, I, there's a danger to that, but it's not the, it's not the core of the problem.
01:02:14.300
And the example of Nepal is a cautionary tale in that respect.
01:02:22.400
I mean, just look that up and to see what happened and have just an almost just, they lit a match.
01:02:28.260
And how almost overnight, uh, that radically has changed the course of the direction.
01:02:32.320
It's actually incredible because, uh, you know, I'm in Nepalese, their Gen Z movement
01:02:37.760
is all in a giant 800,000 person discord server.
01:02:41.840
And they're voting to decide the next prime minister, which they interim prime minister,
01:02:45.240
they're gonna have an actual vote, but it's, it is a wild, uh, count, small example of how
01:02:50.900
the internet is going to fuse with these actual resentments to create change, whether people
01:02:58.160
What do you just, in terms of addressing more broadly what's going on in the internet, what's
01:03:03.820
your sort of broader sense of social media's responsibility in that space to police itself,
01:03:09.400
to police, to police, um, well, speech, uh, to deal with the extremes, to, uh, to have
01:03:22.940
Uh, if things, I mean, or is it just complete, it's a very tough question.
01:03:27.900
I don't know if I have the answer to it because the answer everyone will give you is obviously
01:03:33.320
there's some speech that is too far, but nobody knows, you know, people have such different
01:03:39.020
And so, uh, one person's, this is a totally normal, fair thing to say is the other person
01:03:47.580
Now we've seen people that are really mad about, uh, the way Twitter handled itself during
01:03:53.720
COVID are now hyper-defending the president's right to take down a late night host for making
01:03:59.400
a mild jab in his direct, I mean, it's, people are very hypocritical on this front because
01:04:03.580
free speech sounds great when it's the speech you like.
01:04:06.380
So I don't, I don't, I don't have the, I'm not the guy to give you the right answer on
01:04:09.860
I would just say, um, you know, human history has shown time and time again, the censorship
01:04:15.800
is, is, is a tool for people that cannot win in the public sphere.
01:04:21.140
They can't find a way to, to get their point across.
01:04:29.020
Together we're launching The Moment, a new podcast about what it means to live through a time
01:04:37.340
I would be the first immigrant mayor in generations, but 40% of New Yorkers were born outside of
01:04:50.380
This individual might lose the faith, but there's an institution that doesn't lose faith.
01:04:57.760
To bring you depth and analysis from a unique Latino perspective.
01:05:01.400
There's not a single day that Paula and I don't call or text each other sharing news and
01:05:06.280
thoughts about what's happening in the country.
01:05:08.500
This new podcast will be a way to make that ongoing intergenerational conversation public.
01:05:14.900
Listen to The Moment with Jorge Ramos and Paula Ramos as part of the My Cultura podcast
01:05:20.640
network on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:05:25.580
Hi there, this is Josh Clark from the Stuff You Should Know podcast.
01:05:29.500
If you've been thinking, man alive, I could go for some good true crime podcast episodes,
01:05:35.660
Stuff You Should Know just released a playlist of 12 of our best true crime episodes of all
01:05:40.600
There's a shootout in broad daylight, people using axes in really terrible ways, disappearances,
01:05:48.460
So check out the Stuff You Should Know true crime playlist on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts,
01:05:59.060
All I know is what I've been told, and that to have truth is a whole lie.
01:06:04.560
For almost a decade, the murder of an 18-year-old girl from a small town in Graves County, Kentucky,
01:06:13.900
Until a local homemaker, a journalist, and a handful of girls came forward with a story.
01:06:23.660
A story that law enforcement used to convict six people, and that got the citizen investigator
01:06:31.680
Through sheer persistence and nerve, this Kentucky housewife helped give justice to Jessica Curran.
01:06:40.080
I'm a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist, producer, and I wouldn't be here if the truth were that easy to find.
01:06:51.180
Or rape, or burn, or any of that other stuff that y'all said.
01:06:54.120
They literally made me say that I took a match and struck and threw it on her.
01:07:00.240
From Lava for Good, this is Graves County, a show about just how far our legal system will go
01:07:14.920
Bad things happen to good people in small towns.
01:07:20.180
Listen to Graves County in the Bone Valley feed on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever
01:07:30.000
And to binge the entire season ad-free, subscribe to Lava for Good Plus on Apple Podcasts.
01:07:42.340
Hey, I'm Jay Shetty, and I'm the host of the On Purpose podcast.
01:07:54.240
Emma Watson has announced she's retiring from acting.
01:07:56.540
Has anyone else noticed that we haven't seen Emma Watson in anything in several years?
01:08:00.660
Emma Watson is opening up the truth behind her five-year break from acting.
01:08:07.960
Was acting always something you were going to do?
01:08:10.420
I was using acting as a way of escaping to feel free.
01:08:14.240
My parents, it wasn't just the divorce, it was just like the continuing situation of
01:08:18.700
living between two different houses and two different lives and two different sets of
01:08:23.660
The career and the life that looks like the dream.
01:08:34.880
Listen to On Purpose with Jay Shetty on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:08:42.480
In early 1988, federal agents raced to track down the gang they suspect of importing millions
01:08:51.240
of dollars worth of heroin into New York from Asia.
01:08:54.880
We had 30 agents ready to go with shotguns and rifles and you name it.
01:09:04.600
Basically, your stay-at-home moms were picking up these large amounts of heroin.
01:09:11.060
They go, oh, you may not see her for like 25 years.
01:09:17.740
Caught between a federal investigation and the violent gang who recruited them, the women
01:09:23.220
must decide who they're willing to protect and who they dare to betray.
01:09:27.720
Once I saw the gun, I tried to take his hand and I saw the flash of light.
01:09:33.560
Listen to The Chinatown Sting on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or anywhere you get your podcasts.
01:09:42.860
What about, let's go back to just AI generally.
01:09:47.620
And I'm just curious in terms of just what's happening in the gaming space as well, more broadly.
01:09:56.520
How, I mean, and how it just seems to me that's sort of an iterative part of all of this as well.
01:10:04.620
It sort of seems like they're moving more and more in that direction.
01:10:14.520
Yeah, I would love to talk to you about, you know, people are talking about how video games are the problems with young men.
01:10:20.480
I'll tell you, the biggest two things that are destroying young men's ability to get financially on their feet is crypto and gambling, sports gambling particularly.
01:10:29.300
These two things are a viral cancer that are just ripping these people's ability to get a financial leg up apart.
01:10:37.740
Young men are attacked with ads nonstop on offering.
01:10:43.200
Because, again, if you are financially stuck, if you don't see a path to, with your normal wages, getting a house, then you have to take that 100x bet.
01:10:53.220
And whether that's punting all your money on a weird meme coin and praying, or it's putting it on a seven-leg parlay on DraftKings, that is why they're doing this.
01:11:03.240
And that is just stealing their money every day, and it's making them more frustrated and depressed.
01:11:14.960
These buy now, pay later companies are just offering people the ability to buy things they cannot afford and putting them on stuck in debt cycles early, on small purchases.
01:11:27.860
And all these three things, yeah, crypto, gambling, I'm glad you bought this out.
01:11:32.140
These things are what I'm seeing among Gen Z the most are just attacking them financially.
01:11:37.260
And at the time when they really don't need it, more than any, boomers can take this.
01:11:42.640
Gen Z cannot take loss of this month's paycheck on a crypto.
01:11:49.060
And so, yeah, I am strongly, I mean, it's so crazy because we barely regulated crypto under Biden.
01:11:59.980
I mean, the president made $5 billion off a meme coin.
01:12:04.500
I find it so deeply frustrating when I see these crypto grifters or David Sachs as a crypto czar with all these business interests.
01:12:11.980
It's so frustrating to see them just milk regular people dry on crypto.
01:12:19.740
And then every sports thing you watch is 500 gambling ads.
01:12:27.600
Those two things actually I'm very passionate about because I don't see the upside.
01:12:31.660
I don't see who's benefiting outside of, you know, putting a casino in everybody's pocket is just a stupid idea.
01:12:37.100
No, look, I mean, I'm dealing with my son right now, that 13-year-old is like, Dad, why are you working?
01:12:51.360
You know, I'm making, I made, you know, 50 bucks.
01:12:53.400
Look at this, 15 minutes, you know, and look at what now I'm down to three bucks.
01:12:58.420
Like, he literally is like an addict waking up late at night, giving me the phone, giving me the phone, just one second to see if he's up.
01:13:09.640
And that idea of like, why the hell would I work?
01:13:14.700
No, he thinks I'm the biggest idiot in the world.
01:13:19.580
You know, I talk finances to my audience a lot.
01:13:21.340
It's a big part of my content is business and finances.
01:13:22.940
And, man, they just, they're being fed this idea that like, saving money is stupid.
01:13:38.000
I made the mistake of buying, getting YouTube videos of Warren Buffett, bored.
01:13:44.720
Getting him then coloring books that are versions of Warren Buffett's lessons.
01:13:53.660
There's this dude that's online, man, that just told me, like literally, I don't even
01:13:57.700
remember who his financial advisor is, but he's some guy, like literally some YouTube
01:14:01.560
guy that is, luckily, we only have a thousand bucks that he's been able to say, so we'll
01:14:12.260
Look, I appreciate the lesson, though, you're trying to preach here, at least express, is
01:14:17.660
a deeper understanding of these more systemic issues and that we can get caught up in finding
01:14:23.160
We can get caught up in finding conspiracy theories or just the easy out.
01:14:27.100
And as you suggest, I mean, if the oversight, if the lessons on what is alleged to have
01:14:33.140
occurred with this tragedy with Charlie Kirk is to then haul up people on Discord and the
01:14:40.760
CEOs of Twitch and all of these things, we're missing a deeper, deeper point.
01:14:45.240
I think it's a massive wrong direction that is just going to lead to more of what we're
01:14:51.480
already seeing, more spiraling, more anger, more feel like the politicians don't hear
01:14:57.700
You know, if they want to haul up these CEOs and ask them about how the platforms work,
01:15:03.840
But if they're there to like point the finger that Discord caused this or Twitch caused this,
01:15:15.540
They'll go, they'll go, they'll go deeper into the internet.
01:15:19.500
These are relatively safe, moderated platforms.
01:15:23.480
This is, it's just people using the internet to try and find connection where they can't
01:15:27.880
find it in real life because there's, there's not opportunities.
01:15:36.220
Is it, is it to illuminate an entrepreneurial mindset?
01:15:40.720
Many of our first business experiences was selling lemonade, differentiating our brand,
01:15:46.680
decommoditizing a commodity, uh, selling it for an extra five cents, 25 cents, or, you
01:15:58.200
It's, uh, myself, my friend Aiden and my friend Doug, all of them are content creators.
01:16:02.200
Doug, Doug, Doug, Doug, you know, you're doing your homework, buddy.
01:16:04.780
Uh, and the idea was we are three guys who are only qualified to run a lemonade stand.
01:16:09.700
We're not, we're not bringing deep expertise here.
01:16:15.680
We've started these media, these small media companies, but really we're, we are just going
01:16:19.600
to do our best to understand and read about what's going on and present it in a way with
01:16:24.080
the lingo and the slang and the, of what this audience wants to hear it in.
01:16:29.260
We're not going to be right about everything, but we're not going to be, uh, trying to sway
01:16:37.300
We're just interested in, in talking about it with each other.
01:16:41.260
Well, it was fun to talk about everything we just talked about with each other.
01:16:44.680
I appreciate you bringing your authentic voice and perspective on this.
01:16:48.220
And I also appreciate your stubbornness on, uh, pay attention to the thing that is the
01:16:55.400
And that are these sort of tectonic plates of wealth and income inequality, uh, that are
01:17:01.440
growing and growing in a divide, uh, that is not just a political divide, uh, that is
01:17:07.360
And unless we address, uh, forget which party you're associated with, uh, but the whole fabric
01:17:27.180
Together we're launching The Moment, a new podcast about what it means to live through
01:17:33.800
We sit down with politicians, artists, and activists to bring you depth and analysis from
01:17:40.960
The Moment is a space for the conversations we've been having as father and daughter for
01:17:45.420
Listen to The Moment with Jorge Ramos and Paola Ramos on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts,
01:17:55.220
This is Josh Clark from the Stuff You Should Know podcast.
01:17:57.900
If you've been thinking, man alive, I could go for some good true crime podcast episodes,
01:18:04.020
Stuff You Should Know just released a playlist of 12 of our best true crime episodes of all
01:18:08.820
There's a shootout in broad daylight, people using axes in really terrible ways, disappearances,
01:18:16.840
So check out the Stuff You Should Know true crime playlist on the iHeartRadio app, Apple
01:18:23.520
The murder of an 18-year-old girl in Graves County, Kentucky went unsolved for years, until
01:18:34.260
a local housewife, a journalist, and a handful of girls came forward with a story.
01:18:42.880
Bad things happen to good people in small towns.
01:18:48.160
Listen to Graves County on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your
01:18:58.840
And to binge the entire season ad-free, subscribe to Lava for Good Plus on Apple Podcasts.
01:19:06.280
Hey, I'm Jay Shetty, and I'm the host of the On Purpose podcast.
01:19:16.100
Emma Watson has announced she's retiring from acting.
01:19:18.560
Has anyone else noticed that we haven't seen Emma Watson in anything in several years?
01:19:22.740
Emma Watson is opening up the truth behind her five-year break from acting.
01:19:29.600
Listen to On Purpose with Jay Shetty on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever
01:19:37.100
In early 1988, federal agents raced to track down the gang they suspect of importing millions
01:19:42.620
of dollars worth of heroin into New York from Asia.
01:19:46.100
Had 30 agents ready to go with shotguns and rifles and you know it.
01:19:55.740
Basically, your stay-at-home moms were picking up these large amounts of heroin.
01:20:04.960
Once I saw the gun, I tried to take his hand, and I saw the flash of light.
01:20:08.040
Listen to the Chinatown Sting on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or anywhere you get your