00:09:59They marvel at not just the highs and hellos in public to people you don't know, but frankly, the percentage of people who pay their taxes, honestly, to the IRS and are not looking for tax scams.0.99
00:10:12A lot of countries in the world, you try to cheat the taxman any way you can because you just all those people are bastards.0.99
00:10:18The whole thing's right. We have achieved a level of trust in institution.0.98
00:10:24everything i'm saying doesn't feel true today but i think if you take a longer view we achieved a
00:10:29thing right and i thought about that phrase anonymous trust a couple years ago you must
00:10:34remember this there were a few there was a spate of killings where people like someone drove down
00:10:40the wrong driveway by accident do you remember this and someone just like shot at them yeah
00:10:45from their house and someone else it's a couple kids playing someone just shot
00:10:49And I wrote about this crisis of anonymous trust in this country because it is easy to trust people you are the same as, right?
00:10:58It's easy to trust people who share a last name with you, the same clan, same whatever, kinship networks.
00:11:04Our achievement is that we have built over time institutions and systems and a culture that allows us to trust people we don't know.
00:11:12Maybe even, to quote a phrase from Bernie Sanders some years ago, fight for people we don't know.
00:11:17And that is what feels most at stake to me in this era of America that we are living in.
00:11:23So what was the essence of this biopsy that is America, this framework that society becomes how we behave, which I think is your meta point about Trump and why Trump now?
00:11:35I mean, man in the mirror, this notion of having agency, but you obviously were very intentional in the title because it goes to the heart of an impersonator that ultimately lost his life in that six minutes by a chokehold by a Marine, an African-American victim, a Marine, this Rorschach test.
00:15:41all the things that were sort of evacuated out of that story when we treated it that way.
00:15:48I wanted to understand an issue I know you have spent a lot of time
00:15:51thinking about, wrestling with, puzzling over, which is the homelessness crisis in this country.
00:15:56Jordan Neely was chronically homeless, was severely mentally ill, sometimes lived on the
00:16:02street, sometimes lived in the subway, sometimes went to shelter, sometimes didn't last in shelter,
00:16:07sometimes went to er's sometimes walked out of them sometimes was kicked out of them because
00:16:12he didn't have blue chip insurance in the united states of america he went through what is called
00:16:17the revolving door right where i'm sure you hear from constituents all the time who think
00:16:23that nothing is being done when they see someone on the street who thinks there's no compassion
00:16:27in fact there's a vast apparatus as you know a vast apparatus and amazing caring compassionate
00:16:36of people who I spent so much time with reporting this book, who go every day to people on the
00:16:41street, invite them into shelter, invite them to services, who know the names. I spent an overnight
00:16:46in Penn Station with outreach workers. 300 people live in Penn Station all the time. I didn't know
00:16:53that until I reported this book. I spent an overnight with these outreach workers. They know
00:16:58every name of everybody in Penn Station who's homeless. They know when they see someone,
00:17:02They call to mind each of these outreach workers, a file, all the places they've been in the city, which places worked, which didn't, what their needs are, what their wants are, what their fears are.
00:17:15And yet we continue to have a crisis in this country because, I think, one, our systems are very bad at talking to each other.
00:17:23There is a silo crisis that is particularly acute on this issue where you need 360-degree visibility about a person and longitudinal understanding of a person.
00:17:34And second, and the harder issue, which I know you've wrestled with, is even if we got all the silos right,
00:17:40there is a moral and philosophical conundrum here about autonomy and when does when do you
00:17:51respect the autonomy of someone's body wanting to be where it is when do you assert the primacy of
00:17:58public space needing to have someone not in a place that belongs to the public when when is
00:18:06honoring someone's autonomy actually curdle into abandoning them? When is the humane thing to do
00:18:12to listen to what someone wants? When is the humane thing to do to refuse what they're telling
00:18:18you and do something else instead? There are many questions that I explored in this book,
00:18:23but probably those questions, the questions that as I write, you know, what allowed Daniel Penny
00:18:32to feel both the need and the right to do what he did the need and the right we have to take both
00:18:41those things seriously um and jordan neely's own family 11 days after this incident came forward
00:18:48and said he should have been kept in some of these hospitals he should have been committed
00:18:52they shouldn't have let him go even against his will that he should have been kept and a lot of
00:18:57the activists fighting alongside them deeply disagree with that. Do not want more involuntary
00:19:04commitment. So that is just within one faction, one side, one team on this issue. And so I wanted
00:19:12to explore that. I also wanted to explore the permission structure of violence that Donald
00:19:17Trump has created. I wanted to explore how the Marine Corps and other services have a very
00:19:25rigorous training for getting people into their ranks, for getting people socialized in the ways
00:19:33that you need to look at the world in order to be able to do what they're going to ask you to do in
00:19:38some far-flung place. And then sometimes the way those services don't spend as much energy
00:19:44thinking about how you're going to transition back to the F train from Fallujah. And so these
00:19:52are all the things that I that I that I tried to understand. And did you say it's so interesting
00:19:57there's so many threads to pull there including Neely's own mother and obviously testimony as
00:20:02relates to experts in the Marines and how they are trained to to control situations chokeholds
00:20:10themselves what what Jordan or Daniel did or didn't do but. Nowadays it seems the modern
00:20:18shopping experience is made for those who know exactly what they're looking for. But where's
00:20:23the discovery, the inspiration, the treasure hunt? Instead, what if you could find that special item
00:20:30at a great price, help save the environment, and make a lasting impact in your community?
00:20:37Well, now you can. Shop, donate, volunteer at your local Habitat Restore today.
00:20:43The first thing I hate about eulogies is that they never actually tell the Turks.
00:20:50I'm Dave, and I've been an a***** through my life.
00:20:54In October 2021, my brother David was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer.
00:21:00A year later, he convinced me to make a podcast with him.
00:23:38I have found in 20, 21 years of working as a journalist and writer and book author for
00:23:48most of that period. You know, like you, I communicate lots of different ways, right?
00:23:55There's short form, there's fast form, there's long form, there's written, there's spoken.
00:24:00We live in an era in which you got to, you got to do everything to try to reach people, right?
00:24:05But I have learned that at least for me, so many of the ways of communicating that are available
00:24:12to me um are not really effective for actually moving and altering people right they do other
00:24:19things they may they may make you feel i can i can rally my base when i deliver a fiery
00:24:25line against donald trump on morning joe um that's something i'll get some nice i'll get
00:24:32some nice mentions online and i'll get people telling me you really you really stuck it to
00:24:37that time and i know you get a thousand times more of those but am i altering anybody yeah you
00:24:44know there's this great improv teacher one of the great gods of uh of the improv theater keith
00:24:50johnstone said you know all drama is about alter people altering each other and i would say all
00:24:54democracy is about people altering each other the capacity of us to alter each other through speech
00:24:59through ideas through experiences of each other and i realized a lot of these things i'm doing
00:25:05aren't altering anybody they're just going into the soup and what i have learned actually can
00:25:12alter people is when you zoom all the way in to one human life and another and another a few human
00:25:20lives and you show what reality actually looks like at that cellular level um because here's
00:25:29what happens and i i'm going to describe this almost as as if a brain science which is not
00:25:34proven, but I think there would be something to this. If I were to say to you, as someone who's
00:25:41thought a lot about these things, if I were to say to you, start talking to you about homeless
00:25:45encampments at a kind of general level. Here's some homeless encampments, people say they want
00:25:53to stay here for X, Y, Z reasons, whatever. Talking to you about it in that level of abstraction.
00:25:57My guess is what happens in your brain is that your brain essentially goes to the shelf
00:26:04wherever gavin newsom's book of his position on that issue is and your brain retrieves that book
00:26:11and begins kind of reading it to itself your your stock staple standard off the shelf
00:26:18position that you have that we all have about everything
00:26:20my guess is on the other hand if i tell you about choco yep my character in the book yeah which i
00:26:30could tell you about right now in that context well done he's sitting on east fifth street i
00:26:37think it is in manhattan he grew up five six decades earlier on that same block but in an
00:26:43apartment now he's living on the sidewalk of the street he grew up in as a boy 50 60 years ago
00:26:52he's got an encampment with one other guy he's got all these possessions i tell you all the
00:26:58possessions that he has that i kind of itemized in my chapter about him if i tell you about
00:27:04his experiences he's had with shelters what happened to him with shelters how he lost a
00:27:10couple toes to frostbite last year so that really limits the number of shelters he is able to access
00:27:15because of stairs and how these people are not honest always about whether there's going to be
00:27:19stairs which is a big terror for him if i were to tell you about the photographs that the
00:27:28nypd just blithely took from him and how he'd been collecting those photographs since he was a little
00:27:33boy and he had one of him as a ring bearer when he was five or six years old and a little suit
00:27:37and how precious it was to him and how he keeps all his photographs in order because so much of
00:27:42his life is chaos but he keeps them in order because it's the order he can create i would bet
00:27:50anybody in america hearing choco's story their brain would go to that other part of the brain
00:27:56almost a childlike part of their, our brains, where we are open, where new information can
00:28:02penetrate us, where we are allowed to, we allow ourselves to say, huh, let me put this together
00:28:08with this. Let me think about this. And so I've done the other kind of thing. I've written a
00:28:13polemic book before, and I've done these things with some success at times, but I became convinced
00:28:20as I thought about writing this book that I wanted to reach people by zooming all the way in
00:28:27and reviving, I think, through this kind of construction of a book, almost the artistry
00:28:35of this kind of approach of trying to get behind the eyes. I think Richard Ben Kramer wrote What
00:28:40It Takes, had that phrase of getting behind the eyes, which he did so well in that book.
00:28:46I wanted to get behind the eyes because I thought that would make for the best book, but because I wanted to role model that for readers, for citizens.
00:28:58We are not getting behind each other's eyes in this moment in American life.
00:29:03And again, I'm not talking about you versus MAGA.
00:29:06I'm talking about omnidirectionally, everybody to everybody.
00:29:09You see this DSA versus Democratic establishment, right?
00:29:13These people are, you know, big apart on some things, minorly apart on other things.
00:44:14We are not okay, and we have gotten the leadership to prove it.
00:44:22You know, it's interesting, the Zoran example, the mayor's example that you use, you wrote extensively in Persuaders, if I recall, about AOC and how she focused not on policy, but people's worth, I think is the way you described it.
00:44:37And I think that it goes to a core, again, the thread you're pulling here as well.
00:44:43And so, you know, I want to continue on the story here, not just those six minutes, the aftermath of those six minutes, but the biopsy is important.
00:44:52And it's so interesting just in our politics.
00:44:56And, you know, I challenge this notion that of our better angels, because right now it doesn't feel like anyone's –
00:45:02the incentives are not aligned in terms of the short-termism for this kind of deeper
00:45:09mining of meaning and humanity. We all need to be loved. We all need to love this notion of,
00:45:18you know, the superpowers being empathy, care, and compassion. Right now, it's just about power
00:45:22dominance, it seems, aggression, and how quick we are to judge and dismiss. And you made a point.
00:45:27It's interesting just how many times in our politics, you know, I don't want to, it's not anti-DSA, but how people say what's disqualifying if you don't agree with this adjective to describe something or one word that somehow now you can't be, you're not even worth reasoning with or listening to or rationalizing.
00:45:48Nowadays, it seems the modern shopping experience is made for those who know exactly what they're looking for.
00:45:54But where's the discovery, the inspiration, the treasure hunt?
00:46:00Instead, what if you could find that special item at a great price,
00:46:04help save the environment, and make a lasting impact in your community?
00:48:31is its intent to start to change the conversation,0.99
00:48:36to have all of us look in that damn mirror?0.96
00:48:38I mean, is that, I mean, is it, is that what it's, what are you, what's the action actionable? What's, what's, what's, you know, the sort of new epilogue?0.98
00:48:48I like that. I'll say this, and I'm not saying this as a, in a, in a braggy way, but I, I think I have over the years been early to some things that I've been trying to say to folks.
00:49:04um my first book was about india in 2011 and it was about how extraordinary growth and promise and
00:49:12and transformed lives were also leading to a kind of moral void and people not quite knowing where
00:49:18they stood and i think india ended up with a grasping for moral certainty that that has like
00:49:25destroyed the the beautiful pluralism of 70 years of post-independent history my second book 2014
00:49:31was warning about the rise of downwardly mobile white resentment in this country and i think
00:49:37prefigured you know the kind of thing we saw with trump i'm not saying i got early warning but you
00:49:42know if you follow these threads of what's going on with people things come up and you know my
00:49:47winners take all in 2018 was warning about oligarchy in america and a lot of democrats0.95
00:49:51thought i was like an asshole to write a book that you know didn't only go after the coke brothers0.98
00:49:56but said, you know, Bill Gates is a problem1.00
00:50:23is the next incarnation of my you know grabbing america by the lapels um having worked in those
00:50:31other modes given those other types of warnings i think the warning now is to say donald trump
00:50:37is still the president but i think we're leaving the trump era and the trump culture soon you know
00:50:44and he's not just been a president he has been a culture i think we're turning the page on it we'll
00:50:48see of the election results in a couple weeks bear that out in in the near term but this is not
00:50:53the permanent culture of the united states there is a next culture and a next era and i think in
00:51:00some ways although this book is about a very specific story and a very specific occurrence
00:51:04i think it is my attempt to nudge us in the direction of what that next culture can be
00:51:10And it's not a kumbaya thing. I am suggesting that a democracy in which we have almost no capacity to imagine the experience of what it is like to be other people is sort of begging to not be a democracy.
00:51:27democracy is premised on the quality of our horizontal relations if we don't have horizontal
00:51:39relations if we don't have these social ties then we're all just tied to the leader right the leader
00:51:46just wants us all a leader like this just wants us all to be tied upward to him right Tocqueville
00:51:52came to america in the 18th 19th century what he found as a french aristocrat from a dying order
00:51:59that he knew was a dying order he wanted to go see what the next thing was journalist at heart
00:52:04and he found in america wow when these people have a problem when they find a problem in their
00:52:11community they start a club in france when they have a problem they write a letter to the king
00:52:17he noticed this new thing in human history right he's noticed this other thing that book is so
00:52:23powerful you know he said when a master and servant in america you know 455 i'm paraphrasing
00:52:30455 p.m they're in the house and they're behaving in this hierarchical way the servant's bowing and
00:52:36being apologetic about his existence and then they meet on the street at 505 p.m after the
00:52:42terms of the contract they act like two gentlemen and he'd never seen that this is a new thing in
00:52:48human history that he was spotting and telling the world um i think we need to get to a place
00:52:56again where there is a capacity to imagine the other and that means if you have a house
00:53:02being able to make the imaginative leap into the mind of someone who doesn't instead of just
00:53:08projecting. Why are they ruining the sidewalks of Los Angeles and San Francisco? Why are they
00:53:15wasting their lives with drugs? Instead of projecting, try to understand that life.
00:53:21And if you are someone who's constantly complaining about the government not doing anything,
00:53:27I have a big strand of this book that's the New York City Health Commissioner, Ashwin Vasan,
00:53:31at the time taking you deep inside why it is so hard to make mental health policy it is not about
00:53:40having the right document that someone can sign these are the hardest moral questions
00:53:47about when a society gets to say it knows more about what's good for you
00:53:52than you do this is something as you know that every family in this country or every other family
00:53:58knows intimately. What do you do when the people you love, when love is not enough
00:54:03for the people you love? What does a state do when listening to your vision for what you want
00:54:11to happen for your care is not going to actually lead you to be cared for? These are hard questions.
00:54:19And so I think the, you know, the next place we need to get, if we want to turn the page on Trump,
01:00:02I have devoted my life to this kind of work
01:00:06because I think it is one of the only tools we have
01:00:10to enlarge people's ability to see the other
01:00:16and to know who they share a country with.
01:00:19It's very hard to keep a democracy if you have no idea who you live among, if you know nothing about them beyond the incredibly reduced picture you see on social media or the very glamorous vacation photos you see.
01:00:42if you have no sense of the texture and complexity and doubts of other people
01:00:49it's very difficult and the kind of work i'm doing i feel like i'm
01:00:55explaining a thing that doesn't even need to be explained like this kind of non-fiction work it's
01:00:59not like i invented this this has a rich and venerable tradition i think of books like
01:01:04katherine booze behind the beautiful forevers and adrian nicole blanc's random family and
01:02:24but he managed to get a partnership at Andreessen Horowitz.
01:02:29And Jordan is yet another person that systems, you know, just those cracks, going back to this notion of autonomy, coercive care versus supportive care, going back to the history, by the way, a lot of history was made in this room.
01:02:49I'm in Ronald Reagan's old building right now, his personal residence, at least shortly, as Governor Reagan.
01:02:57And you write about 1967, the Lantern Petra Short Act, and the process here in California to accelerate what was already underway,
01:03:06deinstitutionalizing our psychiatric hospitals, not only here in the state, but across the country.
01:03:14You referenced what former President Kennedy did in 1963, a few years prior, as it relates to Community Health Services Act, in terms of trying to build those cottage settings, those supportive and scattered sites all across this country, because the whole process of deinstitutionalization, both from the left and the right, was being adjudicated and was playing out.
01:03:38And over the course of a few decades, as you write about and I think most understand, we saw mass deinstitutionalization and that promise never fulfilled in terms of providing those alternative sites.
01:03:55And today we continue to pay that price. And Jordan is a perfect example of that price that was paid. And society continues to pay that price.
01:04:05Talk to me a little bit about your journey, your exploration as it relates to the history of mental health in this country, where we've been, where we are, where you think we should be going.0.62
01:04:20I mean, the story you tell is exactly right.
01:04:22And it's a perfect example of how change often happens, you know, and it's a frustrating story of how change often happens.
01:04:31You know, I think there was a quote from Guy de Montaigne, who, you know, the inventor of the of the essay, who said, you know, to straighten a bent stick, you bend it backwards.
01:04:44Right. And that is so often how, as you know, policy gets done, even if it's not the best way for it to be done.
01:04:50That's in a world where public opinion is the is the is the source material.
01:18:04And so I think this is sort of a collapsing of deeper understanding of how deeply anxious we've become, not just our kids, all of us and all the stacking of stress and the grace we haven't given ourselves going through COVID and supply chains and social unrest.
01:18:19going through all of the highs and lows and algorithms and AI, you know, all the lack of
01:18:25truth, trust, deinstitutional apathy, all of it. And so this is such a foundational issue of our
01:18:33time. And it's interesting just, you know, but for what it's worth, you know, I think one of the
01:18:37things that took me some time back to sort of understanding as opposed to being understood,
01:18:43I was so quick and I'm glad we had a chance to talk about it and you filled in the blanks
01:18:48to illuminate people, that this was truly a bipartisan endeavor, this notion of
01:18:53deinstitutionalization. And for the right reasons, precisely as you described them,
01:18:58there were deep abuses, and the left was trying to reconcile that. It wasn't just the right
01:19:03and some tax revolt that we didn't want to pay for it. And that's too neat a story. And there
01:19:09was a very, not infamous, but very important Supreme Court decision, O'Connor versus Donaldson,
01:19:15I think it was 1975, that literally stated you could not keep someone exclusively behind bars or behind a locked door for a behavioral health reason.
01:19:28And so it also compelled a process of deinstitutionalization.
01:19:34I did a Mental Health Service Act reform in California a couple years ago.
01:19:37we did a $6.38 billion bond to fulfill the vision of remanteling, as you describe it,
01:19:46that system. And we're actually, coincidentally this week, highlighting some of the progress and
01:19:51doing a number of ribbon cuttings, not just groundbreakings on that. But we were at 37,000
01:19:59psychiatric beds in 1957. Two years ago, we were down to 5,500, for a population twice the size.0.72
01:20:10Just think about that. Populations doubled. And we go from 37,000 to roughly 5,500.
01:20:17And so is it any wonder you add cost of living in these, and you talk, and I appreciate you
01:20:24write about this, you also have been talking about it. We're also absorbing a lot of the national
01:20:30issues in these big blue cities that tend to be abundant in their support structures. As inadequate
01:20:36as they often are, they're still disproportionately abundant compared to other geographic parts of our
01:20:42country as well. And so by definition, that becomes attractive. Yeah, and I should say,
01:20:47And I'm not just saying this to give you a pass from some of your critics, but it actually infuriates me.
01:20:58I've heard people say, you know, can Gavin Newsom run for this or that because will people hang California around his neck?
01:21:05I mean, without being disrespectful to other places and other parts, and I try to have respect for everybody in this country.
01:21:17But I think it is ridiculous to the point of offensive the way California or New York or other cities, urban areas in particular, L.A., San Francisco, Seattle for sure.
01:21:33the way these cities and the and the the real issues that no one is denying
01:21:39the way that is weaponized to suggest that real quote-unquote real america has no problem that
01:21:47is great at taking care of its own oh god and that only our cities are failing to hold people
01:21:56And I think it has to be very clearly stated that actually our cities are holding all kinds of people, all manner of Americans that other places fail to love and tolerate, that other families fail to love and tolerate.
01:22:16go down the street in san francisco and ask how many people started in some other part of this
01:22:24country where mom or dad or the pastor had a problem yep with who they were who they loved
01:22:34who they were becoming what sport they didn't want to play same in new york same in a lot of
01:22:40cities in this country i am very proud to live in a city where we hold those people
01:22:47and we hold them so well that they make amazing art they start companies they do their thing here
01:22:54they find love here and the idea that again not to minimize the problem you said it very well
01:23:06We have problems in our systems of care, but we are caring for the sheer number of people we are caring for in cities because of all the people who thought it would be better and safer and they would be freer to live in a congested, expensive place than to risk their humanity being unseen, unheard, and squeezed out somewhere else.
01:23:34Well, I certainly appreciate that as a practitioner in this space.
01:23:38And, you know, just, you know, and also deeply mindful what's going on in spaces all across the United States.
01:23:45I mean, look at Trump administration's own data that shows exploding populations of unsheltered homeless in red states, hardly just blue states.
01:23:53Some of the fastest growing parts of this country in those red states, not just blue cities.
01:23:58And some of the fastest declines are most significant and steep declines in homelessness in cities like San Francisco.
01:24:06Unsheltered homeless now down to about where it was in 2011.
01:24:10Progress being made in California, back-to-back years in California.
01:24:13The first governor that can lay claim to this to see back-to-back declines in unsheltered homeless.
01:24:21So some real progress is being made as stubborn and difficult as it is.
01:24:27And so, look, your point on all of this is, again, just, and I think it's so foundational to your work, is if we're going to be repairers of the breach in the spirit of Isaiah and turn the page on the toxicity that defines so much of this moment in our politics and our lives and our inner actions and personal, a lack of personal connection, then, again, this notion of seeing the world from a different set of eyes.
01:24:57and having the grace to do that. And again, just sort of foundationally coming back to the man
01:25:05in the mirror and this notion of hope and struggle and belonging that is the subtitle.
01:25:11What are you holding on to the hope in terms of this project and the work that you've laid out
01:25:21here you know my hope is and i think this conversation has covered this so beautifully
01:25:27that on the one hand you and i are talking about what could be seen as a very extreme
01:25:34set of issues touching a small number of people right if you if you say this is about
01:25:38folks experiencing mental illness living on the street encampments in our cities that's you know
01:25:45someone listening to this might say well that's pretty niche right it's a problem but it doesn't
01:25:49touch me it doesn't affect me hope struggle and belonging are in that subtitle because i didn't
01:25:57want to let anybody get away with the notion that this is about some exotic and specific phenomenon
01:26:03happening to 5 000 or 10 000 or 100 000 people in our country the crisis of mental illness
01:28:20There's a lot of reasons to feel mocked by the future.
01:28:22the ads in san francisco the billboards everywhere telling you there will be no
01:28:29place for you same thing in the subway in new york there will be no place for you in the ai
01:28:34future that's coming imagine human beings being told every day while driving to work
01:28:38giving their labor to companies being on the subway giving their labor to companies leaving
01:28:42their kids at home organizing child care to go do some job for some company and the ads are just
01:28:47telling you there's no place for you in the future um i think we have lost a basic
01:28:56cultural equation of people feeling that they matter that they are connected to a lot of other
01:29:04people and that frankly to for lack of better language that they're going to be okay um
01:29:11And not to trivialize or minimize or put an overly rosy cast on the very real and serious issues we face.
01:29:21None of this is to take away from the deadly seriousness of ICE agents in the streets or, you know, tax cuts that have gutted working class families to enrich rich people or, you know, shady corruption and everything else.
01:29:38but my eyes are always i keep an eye on what's happening up at the top but my eyes are
01:29:45on my people on my fellow citizens on my neighbors um and i think we can do so much better by each
01:29:54other um and i think we can whoever and it's not just gonna be one person the next crop of leaders
01:30:02in this country their job's not just gonna be to pass laws i would argue it's probably gonna be
01:30:08the secondary task of that next leadership group.
01:30:11It is gonna be to usher in the next culture.
01:30:15We have to get out of this entire culture that we've been in,0.99