In this episode, Dr. Phil sits down with Gavin Newsom to discuss his new book, "We've Got Issues: How We Can All Be Better Together," and how we can all work together to make the world a better place.
00:06:07.140Well, when I went to school a long time ago, but we always, if somebody was coming that we disagreed with, I always wanted to go hear what they had to say.
00:06:19.800So I had ammunition to debate them with or their positions with.
00:06:26.760And you never grow until you disprove yourself, until you find something wrong with the way you look at it.
00:06:34.420But it seems like in California, we've got the heckler's veto.
00:06:40.500It's like boo them down or block them from coming.
00:06:50.580And it just seems like, how are we ever going to broaden our perspectives if we don't get out of the bubble and at least listen to the other side?
00:07:00.440And you may find out, that's exactly why I don't agree with that SOB.
00:07:13.520That's why I've been calling out all these book bans.
00:07:15.8804,240 books and titles were banned last year in this country.
00:07:20.840I mean, we're censoring, you know, speech in the boardroom, not just in the classroom.
00:07:25.740You've got folks are rewriting history.
00:07:27.560You've talked a lot about that, but on both sides of the aisle, I mean, they were trying to, one textbook in Florida, tried to take out Rosa Parks' race and said, oh, no, she was just a woman who wanted to move, needed to move her seat.
00:08:02.440In 2013, Governor Brown signed a bill allowing for people to participate.
00:08:09.680As you know, that issue is very raw and emotional.
00:08:14.920And it's obviously very pointed at this moment because of some state championships.
00:08:20.400There was two bills in the California legislature, Dr. Phil, just a few weeks ago.
00:08:26.180Neither got out of the committee to change that rule.
00:08:29.780So it currently is law in the state of California.
00:08:33.440And a CIF that does the intercollegiate, does all the sports, they're trying to find some accommodation that addresses the legitimate concerns around fairness.
00:08:46.620And I say legitimate concerns about fairness and make sure that those that may have been displaced because they were outperformed by a transgender athlete have the opportunity to still participate and be recognized for that participation.
00:09:05.560We're also just trying to balance some grace, some humility, some humanity, particularly with transgender youth that just want to survive and don't want to be belittled and demeaned at the same time.
00:09:22.900I think you've done it reasonably thoughtfully.
00:09:24.820I think you've tried to find the nuances here, but it's an incredibly difficult issue.
00:09:30.560And I say this as someone who's been an advocate for trans rights, but I do not think it's fair, these athletic competitions.
00:09:38.800And I've made that point of view very, very public.
00:09:42.160Well, this is one of the things where I say that I believe that activists are pushing an agenda.
00:09:50.440And I've had so many transgender individuals on the show over the last 25 years.
00:10:01.920And I can tell you that they have said to me on the air and off, mostly off the air, that they'd wish those people would shut up.
00:10:20.020These shrill activists that are pushing these extreme positions, they're not speaking for us.
00:10:26.020They're not speaking for the community at large.
00:10:28.140And they say, look, we're living our lives, and there are enough challenges as it is, without them pushing these extreme controversial issues that we don't particularly ascribe to, they're not helping us.
00:10:50.180That's something that they're just trying to rewrite biology on, or they're trying to make a battleground.
00:11:15.000She was just reporting, did a meta-analysis on, I think it was 50-plus studies, of others that had looked at the biological markers to see whether or not you could balance the playing field among elite athletes.
00:11:34.740And she looked at, if you have testosterone blockers, if you have hormone suppression therapy, and for the required two years, before and after puberty, looked at every possible way.
00:11:54.440And the meta-analysis conclusion for good methodology with good in, you know, right number of subjects, and they concluded, you just can't get there.
00:12:08.740I mean, even if it's 10% difference in swimming competition among elite athletes, as you know.
00:12:17.820They measure that by hundreds of a second off a time, fingernail touching the wall.
00:12:23.820And in a four-lap race, 10%, they can be down there kicking off the wall, and they're standing there with their arms crossed, waiting for them to make the last lap.
00:12:34.980No, it wasn't, and forgive me, wasn't she admonished by the administration over there as well for just concluding those?
00:12:45.120Completely drummed out of the university.
00:12:46.840They're transphobic, spawning hate speech.
00:12:52.380Well, doctor, trust me, I know a thing or two about this.
00:13:06.640And, you know, I appreciate they felt hurt.
00:13:09.200They felt that a point of view was, you know, somehow diminishing.
00:13:13.640I, as someone who's been an advocate that I put up against any other elected official, I mean, I have a very strong record.
00:13:20.240As you know, I think the first time I was on your show was on the issue of LGBT rights.
00:13:26.000And I've been an advocate for decades and decades.
00:13:29.120But on the issue of sports and what you just, you know, you laid out as it relates to many different factors that are unique, regardless of puberty blockers.
00:13:39.980I just think this issue we have to address and, and to not address, we are in denial.
00:13:47.540Well, that's a good point, because I remember when you were there and you and I agreed on that.
00:13:51.580We, we were both advocates for LGBTQ rights, but this is, this is a bridge too far.
00:13:59.800This is, you have these, these elite athletes.
00:14:05.800These are kids that get up oftentimes an hour or two before school.
00:14:13.160I mean, they're up at four and five o'clock in the morning working out before school for years.
00:31:37.900And people talk about we have this inequality of income.
00:31:41.460I think the problem is we have a quality of income.
00:31:43.840If you look at all the giveaway programs, and I hear people talking about they want a quality of outcome versus the quality of opportunity.
00:35:51.380Every Friday, we will be diving into the biggest stories in business, taking a look at what's going on,
00:35:56.820why it matters, and how it shows up in our everyday lives.
00:35:59.920But guests like Business Week editor Brad Stone, sports reporter Randall Williams, and consumer spending expert Amanda Mull will take you inside the boardrooms, the backrooms, even the signal chats that make our economy tick.
00:36:47.120And I'm honored to tell you the stories of these heroes on the new season of Medal of Honor, Stories of Courage, from Pushkin Industries, and iHeart Podcast.
00:36:58.060From Robert Blake, the first black sailor to be awarded the medal, to Daniel Daly, one of only 19 people to have received the Medal of Honor twice.
00:37:07.560These are stories about people who have distinguished themselves by acts of valor, going above and beyond the call of duty.
00:37:14.660You'll hear about what they did, what it meant, and what their stories tell us about the nature of courage and sacrifice.
00:37:23.740Listen to Medal of Honor on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:37:32.460Look, there's so much, Doctor, to talk about, and I appreciate the spirit to which you've engaged with me and our audience.
00:37:40.980And one of the things I loved about your book, which I did have a chance to read, but more importantly, there's a lot of good life lessons in there.
00:37:48.560And one of those statements that you made in the book that sort of spoke to me is, be who you are on purpose, which is a good way to describe you, this notion of intentionality.
00:38:01.460But I think that's an important life lesson, is to be authentic, learn from, don't follow others, have some humility and grace, but stand your ground, but also recognize we need to find common ground.
00:38:15.420And I hope we found a little bit today, and I appreciate your efforts to try to find more of that with Merit Street Media.
00:38:23.620Well, I appreciate having the opportunity to talk about these things.
00:38:28.880I think, like I say, you and I might be on a different side of certain issues and the same side on certain issues.
00:38:39.300But I think if people could sit down and have civil conversations like this, I mean, that's what it's all about to me.