This Past Weekend with Theo Von - E460 Jordan Peterson

00:00:00.000 You know life's better with a good hack, like learning the secret menu at your favorite

00:00:04.660 restaurant or stumbling upon a buy one get one sale at the mall. Well there's a wireless hack

00:00:10.660 too and it's called Visible. Visible's like ordering from the secret menu in wireless.

00:00:16.260 You get unlimited data and hotspot and plans start at just $25 a month for one line. Taxes

00:00:23.100 and fees included. Plus Visible runs on Verizon's 5G network for great coverage,

00:00:27.660 fast speeds, and a seamless connection. And it's all digital. Don't like going to the phone store?

00:00:34.260 Visible doesn't have them. You switch from your phone and manage your plan in an app. Now that's

00:00:40.040 a hack. If you're ready for wireless that lets you live in the know, make the switch at Visible.com.

00:00:46.640 Plans start at $25 a month. For our best features, get the new Visible Plus Pro plan for $45 a month.

00:00:53.620 Terms apply. See Visible.com for planned features and network management details.

00:00:59.920 I want to announce some new tour dates. These tickets will go on sale this Thursday at 10 a.m.

00:01:09.520 local time. November 9th in Norfolk, Virginia

00:01:14.300 at the Chartway Arena. November 10th at Roanoke, Virginia. November 11th, Huntington, West Virginia.

00:01:26.920 November 15th, Evansville, Indiana. November 16th, Pikeville, Kentucky. November 17th, Winston-Salem,

00:01:37.340 North Carolina. And November 24th, New Orleans, Louisiana. Down there at the UNO Lakefront Arena.

00:01:46.780 And that is the day after Thanksgiving. So that'll be during Thanksgiving break. All of those new

00:01:54.040 dates will go on sale this Thursday at 10 a.m. local time. Today's guest is returning to the podcast.

00:02:02.520 He is one of the most articulate men, I believe, of our time between thoughts and oration. I don't know

00:02:11.180 if there's anybody that can think and share as eloquently as him. We're really grateful to be

00:02:19.940 here in his home country of Canada and to get to spend time with him again on the podcast. He is

00:02:27.560 touring. You can check him out. He has a new book that he's working on. He has books that we'll put

00:02:32.500 in the information below. Today's guest is Mr. Jordan Peterson.

00:02:37.400 Shine that light on me. I'll sit and tell you my stories. Shine on me. And I will find a song

00:02:56.240 I love the 70s shag carpet. People used to have those all over their houses. It wasn't a good

00:03:09.960 idea. Especially if they had dogs. Are we rolling? Nice rat. Thanks man. That's my nickname is the

00:03:17.140 Rat King. Oh yeah. So that's kind of... Do you have a nickname? Do you know what a Rat King is?

00:03:22.300 Huh? Do you know what a Rat King is? Uh-uh. Oh my God. It's a terrible story.

00:03:27.700 Is it? There is a Rat King. Uh-uh. Well, this is the theory now. I don't know if people ever

00:03:32.520 did this. So imagine your village is full of rats. Oh yeah. Okay. So now you go catch 10

00:03:37.520 rats. Okay. You throw them in a pit. Okay. Soon there is one rat because he gets all the other

00:03:47.520 rats. He's a champ. Then you throw 10 more rats in there. Soon there's one rat. You do

00:03:53.520 that three or four times. Then you take the remaining rat and you let him go. And soon

00:03:59.180 there are no rats in the village. Really? That's the theory. Wow. So he... It was like

00:04:05.540 the toughest of them all. Yeah. And then he learns to eat rats. Wow. Oh, so you teach him

00:04:11.280 to cannibalize. No. We just had... That's a rough story, eh? Jesus. Yeah. I mean,

00:04:17.360 it doesn't have... Sort of like politics. Yeah. That's true. Especially these days. I don't

00:04:22.620 think it's for the... I wouldn't say it's for children. No, it's not. It's not for children.

00:04:27.140 Although it's hard to tell now what's for children. Yeah. Well, did you see that movie Up? Did

00:04:31.380 you ever see that movie? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Right in the beginning, the grandmother dies

00:04:35.240 and it's just kind of like shocking. I was like, wow. Yeah. Yeah. So... But that's a good

00:04:42.980 story. I remember when I was young, if you got somebody a hamster or a gerbil, that's

00:04:48.120 how you taught them about death, you know? It was usually like gerbil and then grandparent

00:04:53.360 was kind of like the... God. The order, you know? The order that things kind of expired in

00:04:59.260 in a child's life. That's very terrible. Well, welcome to the Salem Witch Trials.

00:05:05.240 of Canada. Oh, yes. Yes. Thank you very much. I'm here on behalf of the Ontario... Is it

00:05:10.460 the psychology department? Because you're... No, it's the College of Psychologists and

00:05:14.620 it's confusing. You're on a trial right now. You're under... Yes. It's essentially a trial.

00:05:19.300 You're being brought up on... You have to take social media... Re-education. Re-education

00:05:24.960 from your provinces saying this. Is that right? It's a professional group, but they have

00:05:30.120 delegated authority from the province. So there are regulated professions. Okay. And

00:05:35.000 engineers, lawyers, physicians, psychologists, social workers, teachers. There's a few others.

00:05:40.220 And if you're in a regulated profession, there's a professional body that governs professional

00:05:46.000 conduct to which the public has access in case people misbehave. And so the Ontario College

00:05:53.500 of Psychologists, it's college as in group, professional group rather than university. And

00:05:57.920 it's the Ontario College of Psychologists that have decided to pursue initially 13 charges

00:06:04.180 against me. They dropped seven. Why they dropped those seven is a complete mystery as is everything

00:06:09.340 else they do. You can submit a complaint to the College of Psychologists online with a form.

00:06:15.720 And so what's happened, at least in part, is because that's become so easy, it's become weaponized

00:06:22.720 by activists. So for example, if you want to cause anybody who's a professional trouble, all

00:06:27.720 you have to do is submit a complaint to the College. The College will look into the complaint,

00:06:32.720 every complaint, and then decide whether they'll proceed. Now they're not supposed to proceed if

00:06:37.720 the complaints are vexatious or, you know, just troublemaking. But they've decided that me complaining

00:06:44.880 on Twitter about Trudeau, for example, is unprofessional and is a disgrace to the profession,

00:06:53.520 which is essentially what I've been charged with, is being a disgrace to the profession.

00:06:57.380 So it's trying to hold up what they presume is some esteem of the profession.

00:07:01.600 That's the theory. And some professional standards. And you know, I would say for decades,

00:07:05.840 that system actually worked pretty well, because the people who sat on it weren't ideologically

00:07:12.060 addled, and the public wasn't using it in a weaponized manner. But that's changed completely.

00:07:17.220 And now, every professional in Canada, and I believe that to be true, is essentially without

00:07:22.720 exception, unless they're on the far left, are completely unwilling to ever utter any opinion

00:07:29.400 about anything in the political or their professional realm, especially in relationship

00:07:35.620 to medicine and psychology. The physicians, now the Ontario College of Physicians, is partnered

00:07:41.840 with the Ontario College of Psychologists to go after me, because they're also afraid that if I was

00:07:47.380 victorious in this, their idiot mid-level bureaucratic power would be diminished. And so, and I've had

00:07:55.340 conversations with many physicians in particular, who've told me flat out that they'd like to

00:08:00.040 publicly support me, but they can't afford the tremendous legal costs, and the lengthy

00:08:07.540 inquisition that's a consequence, or the possible suspension of their license.

00:08:12.800 So, you're going to probably have to go this alone in some way.

00:08:18.020 I do have people who have presented themselves as interested parties on the legal side. There's

00:08:25.160 the Canadian Civil Liberties Union is one of them. There's a Justice CCF, I believe now they're going

00:08:33.700 to be irritated at me for not remembering the name, but I can't remember it at the moment. There's a

00:08:37.560 number of groups who are pro-free speech, let's say, who've also weighed in on my side, but the court

00:08:44.480 didn't take their concerns with, they didn't make their concerns paramount, let's put it that way.

00:08:51.820 Yeah, and the judges, so I appealed this ruling. So, the ruling essentially is that I have to take

00:08:58.200 social media retraining with a social media expert, and I'd like to make it very clear, there is no

00:09:04.260 such thing as, there's no profession. Yeah, it's like the Wizard of Oz, like who is it going to be?

00:09:08.940 Is it, do you know the expert? No, I don't. No, I've got a couple of names, but I don't even know

00:09:15.060 what defines you as a social media expert, and neither does the college, and they don't care.

00:09:20.580 You know, if someone presents themselves as a social media expert, that's good enough. My sense is that

00:09:24.860 if you're a social media expert, you have a podcast with millions of followers, and you're doing just

00:09:30.460 fine on your own, and you actually don't need to work for an idiot bureaucracy, but you know,

00:09:35.560 that's just me. Right. So, now, not only do I have to be re-educated by this social media expert,

00:09:42.000 but I have to do it at my own expense, which, you know, is neither here nor there in some sense, but

00:09:47.120 for an indefinite period of time. Wow. Until I've learned whatever the hell lesson I'm supposed to

00:09:53.180 learn, and I don't exactly know what lesson that is, by their judgment, right? And so-

00:09:58.840 It's all up to them, so it's kind of this vague thing that they've put you into, and they challenged

00:10:03.400 you because they were upset at things you had said on Twitter, online?

00:10:07.740 Mostly on Twitter. No, well, they also, and maybe this can happen today, somebody submitted

00:10:14.260 the entire transcript of my last conversation with Joe Rogan as a complaint, partly because of what I

00:10:22.180 said about climate change. Now, I am not a fan of climate change models, which I think are,

00:10:28.980 to call them flawed is to barely scrape the surface, but that isn't exactly the point,

00:10:34.300 is what happens is you have climate models that have really no predictive validity. They're about

00:10:40.420 as valid as the models that scientists use to predict COVID death outcomes, which tended to

00:10:45.780 overestimate the mortality probability by a factor of about 10. They're not accurate, and a computer

00:10:52.260 model is a hypothesis, not data. It's a guess. Now, you know, it's an intelligent guess, or it can be,

00:10:57.760 depending on how you model it. Anyways, on top of the climate models, there are even more radically

00:11:04.580 unstable economic models saying, you know, that the consequences of climate change will be catastrophic

00:11:10.560 if you look 100 years into the future. It's like nobody can make an economic bet 100 years into

00:11:17.520 the future, period. Right. Period. The end. You can't even, look, you can't even model a stock six

00:11:24.900 months down the road, much less than the world economy in 100 years. It's preposterous. Yeah,

00:11:30.180 I mean, I think there's been so much climate over the years. I think you'd have to take a ton of things

00:11:33.900 into consideration. You'd probably have to take a lot of things into consideration that we don't even

00:11:37.420 really know. Well, how, can you imagine trying to predict today's economy 100 years ago? Like,

00:11:44.340 I can't even think about how we're going to predict what's going to happen economically in five years,

00:11:50.620 given the rate of change. But are economic changes or patterns as, do they have as many variations as

00:11:58.140 weather patterns? Yeah. Well, yeah, they do, partly because they're dependent on weather and climate

00:12:03.000 patterns, right? I mean, in some ways, the economy is as complex as everything. Okay. Because, well,

00:12:08.620 because you just don't know what'll happen. If there's, imagine, there could be, imagine Yellowstone

00:12:13.200 blue, you know, Yellowstone, it's Yellowstone, I believe, that's on a super volcano. It's a huge

00:12:18.020 volcano. And if it blew, it'd be like a, you know, it would wipe out a third of the planet. Well, that would

00:12:23.460 have economic consequences. And so the economy is, you can't model the economy. In fact, that's actually

00:12:31.160 why the free enterprise system works to the degree it does, the free exchange. Because what happens is

00:12:36.900 that pricing decisions are made as a consequence of local trades. And that is as good a model of

00:12:43.260 the underlying, let's say, reality that people are trying to adapt to as you can possibly manage.

00:12:48.460 It's partly why centralized governments can't work. They can't compute the load. So, for example,

00:12:55.060 in the Soviet times, there was a central pricing committee, because they have no pricing mechanism,

00:13:01.100 right? They couldn't figure out what anything cost, because there was no free market. They had to make

00:13:04.800 400 pricing decisions a day. And they had to do things like price nails. And it's like, well,

00:13:11.280 what's a nail worth? And the answer is, well, the market computes that. And in the absence of that

00:13:18.220 answer, well, there's no limit to the range of potential value that a nail might have. Like,

00:13:26.180 if there's a nail shortage, that actually turns out to be a really bad thing.

00:13:30.280 Oh, yeah. Pricing decisions are insanely hard to make.

00:13:33.440 Oh, yeah. I mean, I think, yeah, I mean, it's funny. They give you a lot of nails when you buy

00:13:38.540 them, but I think things could change, you know? I mean, you could go there and have to just get one

00:13:42.800 nail. But so just so... That'd be a bad day.

00:13:46.740 That'd be a rough day. Yeah. But you'd have to really use it wisely.

00:13:49.480 Yeah, you would. You would. Yeah, you'd have to be very careful. You'd probably put it up. You'd

00:13:52.920 probably like display it, get it gold-plated and display it. We used to have nails.

00:13:57.660 Yeah. If you're going to pin a tail on a dog, you better mean it that day, huh?

00:14:02.140 Yeah. But just so we stay on... So I stay in this one frame of like... So do you feel like...

00:14:07.760 But they're... So they're challenging your things you've said on social media, right?

00:14:11.400 Yeah. Well...

00:14:11.840 So do you think it's a challenge of your free speech? Is that what you feel like?

00:14:14.700 Oh, the court that ruled against my appeal essentially said that it was a free speech

00:14:21.460 issue. Okay. And they said in their opening argument that according to the Canadian Charter

00:14:26.280 of Rights, which was by the way instantiated by Justin Trudeau's father, Pierre Trudeau,

00:14:31.440 and Justin's regime is in the process of absolutely gutting it. Anyways, I have a right to free speech

00:14:38.520 according to that charter. But, and that's the next sentence, this very low-level bureaucratic

00:14:44.680 institution has the right to abridge that essentially as they see fit. Which means,

00:14:50.660 as far as I can tell, that I don't have the right to free speech at all. And I should make

00:14:54.300 very clear, those colleges should be intervening when a client or a patient, right? Or a customer,

00:15:02.380 depending on the regulated profession, has been mistreated in some manner by the person

00:15:07.400 they're dealing with. Okay. The people that levied complaints against me, first of all,

00:15:10.920 most of them don't live in Canada. Second of all, none of them were clients of mine. Third,

00:15:15.940 none of them knew anyone who was a client of mine. They claimed harm, that I had done harm,

00:15:20.760 on behalf of other people who they also didn't know. So it's a witch hunt really. Well, and they

00:15:26.560 also, a number of them also claimed to be clients of mine in writing in the complaint forms. But

00:15:31.100 they're not. No, they're not clients of mine. And clients of mine, before I became politically

00:15:36.560 known, let's say, I practiced as a clinician for more than 20 years. And I had zero complaints. And

00:15:42.720 I had zero complaints levied against me at the university, too, either at Harvard or at the

00:15:46.960 University of Toronto. And the reason for that was that I treated my students, my colleagues,

00:15:51.340 my co-workers, and my clients, well, all the time. There was zero problems. But as soon as things

00:15:59.500 exploded around me politically, well, the people who've weaponized the colleges have taken that

00:16:04.020 opportunity to go after me. And then the college, which is nicely infested by radicals, like almost

00:16:10.000 everything else in the West, and particularly in Canada, are using this opportunity to attempt

00:16:15.240 to make my life miserable. But we'll see whose lives are made miserable. Wow. Yeah, do you feel,

00:16:22.860 do you, did you almost, was there a part of you that kind of was like excited about the kind, like?

00:16:26.800 Not to, not to begin with, like, it's not ever entertaining to face legal proceedings. That's

00:16:35.620 true. Yeah, you have to be a fool, generally speaking, to think that even if you're the one

00:16:41.120 levying a lawsuit, you have to be a real fool to think that it's going to do anything but cause you

00:16:46.540 a lot of grief and misery. Like, lawsuits are not entertaining. And I have quite a pronounced

00:16:52.540 proclivity to feel guilt. And I went through the, like, this has been going on a long time,

00:16:57.580 off and on for about six years. But the ruling just happened, right? Well, the court ruling that

00:17:02.660 denied my appeal just happened. Okay, I got it. Yeah, because I appeal to go through, you have to go

00:17:07.620 through with the training. No, the next thing they have to do, I either have to go through with the

00:17:11.640 training, or they have, they can drag me in front of a disciplinary board. And my next move is going to

00:17:17.580 be to say, hey, bring on the disciplinary board. They film those. Wow. I will put that on YouTube.

00:17:26.980 So if they want to make the case that, for example, my objections to the trans-surgical mutilation of

00:17:34.620 children, I believe that to be wrong. Like, I believe it's actually a crime against humanity. The

00:17:40.580 reason I believe that, by the way, is the UN definition of crime against humanity. One of them

00:17:45.040 is involuntary sterilization. My sense is that if you're a medical professional, and you sterilize

00:17:51.480 a child, that's involuntary sterilization, because they are not qualified to give qualified consent,

00:17:57.860 informed consent, as anyone with any sense recognizes. Yeah, they can't even go on a field

00:18:02.360 trip without getting a signature, right? You know what I'm saying? Yeah. Yeah. Right. So they can't,

00:18:07.860 yeah, they can't go on like a genital field trip. Yeah, well, there are hospitals now when they

00:18:14.280 inform the children of what's going to happen. For example, if they castrate them, for example,

00:18:19.400 um, they tell them the girls, um, obviously they're not castrating the girls. They're just

00:18:24.220 doing double mastectomies and sterilizing the girls. But they tell them that they might have

00:18:28.700 to have their eggs stored because this is going to interfere with their fertilization. And if they

00:18:32.840 ever want to have children, well, that'll be what they'll have to do. It's like, well, you know,

00:18:36.640 every 12 year old is capable of, yeah, no kidding. No kidding. It's scary. It makes me sick

00:18:41.360 thinking about it. It is absolutely despicable. I believe that the people who've done this should

00:18:47.320 be in prison for the rest of their lives. So do you think that youth speaking up against things

00:18:52.680 like that are some of the reasons why they're kind of, uh... Oh, I think that was the primary reason.

00:18:56.720 Well, I, I tweeted something out about Elliot Page, Ellen Page. See, now we're in trouble. Now we're

00:19:03.380 already in trouble. Yeah. I said that, I said, do you remember when pride was a sin and when a

00:19:08.200 criminal physician cut off Elliot, Ellen Page's breasts? And, uh, that got me kicked off Twitter,

00:19:14.240 but that was also one of the tweets that was complained about, you know, and I had friends,

00:19:18.740 I actually did a whole YouTube video on this. Uh, I had friends who kind of upbraided me for being

00:19:23.700 a little harsh and we talked it over on YouTube for about 90 minutes and I don't regret it at all.

00:19:29.920 In fact, I think that in the intervening year since that tweet or so, the tides turned very firmly

00:19:36.220 in a direction that indicates that my suspicions were more than warranted. You know, a lot of the

00:19:42.240 European countries that were all on board with this so-called gender affirming care have reversed

00:19:47.900 their stance, right? Including the Netherlands where this protocol, this hypothetical gender affirming

00:19:52.940 miserable statement. Cause it's such a lie where that protocol first emerged that the Dutch have

00:19:58.500 realized that this is a bad idea. They've realized it in the UK and in Norway and Sweden, in France,

00:20:04.260 and they're pulling back like mad. Now the Americans and the Canadians are still thinking this is just a

00:20:09.820 fine idea, but, but it's not. Well, it's probably still a bit, there's probably still people trying

00:20:14.740 to do the, do the balance sheet of what is the value of it? You know, in America, I mean,

00:20:20.200 a lot of things come down to kind of like, you know, what can be profited on it. Yeah. Well,

00:20:24.420 that's for sure. But do you feel like in Canada that they are just, cause Canada is kind of like

00:20:28.920 a pat, it's, I don't want to say it's a passive place, but it's like a, it's kind of like a,

00:20:35.040 I don't know, is passive the word, do you think? I think passive is a reasonable word compared to

00:20:40.720 the excited States of America, let's say. Okay. That's very fair, right? Well, and I think to some degree,

00:20:46.320 look, you know, our constitution originally, your, your system is predicated on the idea of like

00:20:51.620 right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. And our constitution was predicated

00:20:55.400 on peace, order, and good government, right? It's a very different view of what constitutes

00:20:59.860 an appropriate society. Right. That the basic doctrines of your country are more entrepreneurial

00:21:04.920 and adventurous. And I really think you can see that in the difference between the two countries.

00:21:08.920 And more individual. And more, yeah, and more libertarian and, and more entrepreneurial. And

00:21:14.200 you can see that in the temperaments of the two countries. And actually things worked very well

00:21:19.300 in Canada, I would say till about 10 years ago, 15 years ago, something like that, because our

00:21:24.400 institutions, all of our institutions were conservative in the, in the best sense, right?

00:21:32.620 They were reliable and stable and predictable, but they also honestly did what they were supposed to do.

00:21:38.140 And that was true even of, of say government sponsored media agencies, like the Canadian

00:21:44.460 Broadcasting Corporation, the CBC, which is sort of our equivalent of PBS, but what's what most,

00:21:49.160 much more dominant in Canada. And our higher education institutions worked and our political

00:21:54.120 parties were pretty predictable. You know, we had the conservatives and they were the party of big

00:21:59.300 business. And everybody knew that we had the liberals and they were the natural governing party.

00:22:03.940 And they were centrists, kind of like more conservative Democrats. That's about where I would put them in

00:22:09.780 the political distribution. Then we had the socialists, the NDP, we still have these three

00:22:14.860 parties and they were essentially a labor party and, and made up of union people. And that's all blown

00:22:20.580 into bits now. And, and every, those parties for years played their roles and they played them

00:22:26.940 honorably and honestly, and everyone knew what they were getting. And that's completely turned upside down.

00:22:33.920 Trudeau's liberals are farther left than the socialists. And in fact, the socialists have

00:22:38.740 been reduced to a parody of themselves in Canada.

00:22:41.260 A few months ago, I wanted to sell something online. I wanted to sell a batch of knives that I

00:22:46.740 had at the house and I was trying to get rid of them. I didn't know what to do. I had no idea where

00:22:51.340 to get started. That's why I'm glad that I found Shopify. That's right. Shopify is the commerce platform

00:23:00.060 revolutionizing millions of businesses worldwide. Whether you're a garage entrepreneur or IPO ready

00:23:08.060 Shopify is the only tool you need to start, run and grow your business without the struggle. That's

00:23:14.800 true. Shopify puts you in total control of every sales channel. So whether you're selling satin sheets,

00:23:21.060 uh, knives or anything else, uh, you can sell them from Shopify's in-person POS system. And once you've

00:23:31.180 reached your audience, Shopify has the internet's best converting checkout to help you turn them from

00:23:37.660 browsers to buyers. That's right. Shopify powers 10% of all e-commerce in the U S and Shopify is truly a global force.

00:23:51.060 Plus Shopify's award-winning help is there to support your success. Every step of the way you hear that

00:23:57.500 sound. It's the sound of a sale you're missing out on because you're not selling on Shopify. And what

00:24:04.040 does it sound like with Shopify? Ah, that's much better. Start selling with Shopify today. You just need

00:24:12.240 to go to Shopify.com slash T H E O that's S H O P I F Y.com slash Theo to take your business to the next

00:24:23.580 level today. Liquid IV. If you want to get hydrated and stay hydrated, you want to, you want to drink

00:24:31.060 something and make it feel like you drank something. Liquid IV can help. They're the number one powdered

00:24:39.320 hydration brand in America. They're also now available in sugar-free. That's right. Years in

00:24:46.520 the making hydration multiplier sugar-free uses a proprietary zero sugar hydration solution with no

00:24:54.560 artificial sweeteners with three times the electrolytes of the leading sports drink plus

00:25:00.560 eight vitamins and nutrients for everyday wellness. Liquid IV hydrates two times faster than water alone.

00:25:08.340 They've got some great flavors, white peach, green grape, and lemon lime. One stick of liquid IV in

00:25:18.060 16 ounces of water hydrates you two times faster and more efficiently than water alone. Be damned water,

00:25:25.540 be damned. Real people, real flavor, real hydrating, now sugar-free. Grab your liquid IV hydration

00:25:33.140 multiplier sugar-free in bulk nationwide at Costco or get 20% off when you go to liquidiv.com and use code

00:25:44.580 Theo at checkout. That's 20% off anything you order when you use promo code Theo at liquidiv.com.

00:25:53.980 Do you feel like you've been picked a lot because you're like a loud, I don't mean this

00:25:58.520 you're like a loud Canadian, right? You're like probably the loudest Canadian since like Celine

00:26:03.340 Dion probably, right? But in a total different like, you know, but you, you know, Canadians are

00:26:08.620 usually kind of more past, I guess not really, I mean, how he meant, I mean, there's a lot of Canadians

00:26:12.960 that are verbose, right? Yeah, well, there's a Canadian, there's a Canadian. But maybe it's not as

00:26:17.400 challenging of like the status quo. I don't know what I'm trying to say. I'm just trying to wonder why

00:26:22.400 are they, why do you get picked? There are Canadian comedians and we have a good comedic tradition.

00:26:26.260 Yeah. And I would say to the degree that Canadians do push back. Oh, some of the best. Norm

00:26:29.460 McDonald, Carlin Williams, like a lot of great comedians. Yeah, Jim Carrey. Yeah. Yeah. Lots,

00:26:34.100 lots of, the whole SCTV crowd, like there, there are a lot of really great Canadian comedians and,

00:26:39.700 and that's, that's a longstanding tradition and they can be pretty viciously satirical. The Trailer

00:26:44.920 Park Boys are a good example of that. And I think they're absolutely bloody brilliant that

00:26:48.640 for, for scripted comedy, their scripted comedy is remarkable. But I do think that Canada is a

00:26:56.760 country where being, what do they call it? Tall poppy syndrome. If you're the poppy that grows

00:27:03.940 up above the rest, then you're the first one who has his head cut off. That's what I'm trying to say.

00:27:07.520 Yeah. And that's true of many countries, but it's particularly true of Canada.

00:27:11.740 Because it kind of, it makes it more about you than about what, or maybe not you're making it more

00:27:17.300 about you, but if you start to like, yeah, Canada just wants to be almost like we were here. Yes.

00:27:24.500 We want to be able to fit into a space that's very manageable by us. Yeah. Well, that's what it

00:27:28.580 seems like. And it goes over well. Like, I mean, I find the peace that I feel in Canada when I'm here,

00:27:35.240 the genuineness in people's eyes that I see, um, even people that look mean come up to you and then

00:27:41.280 they're nice. They just looked a little mean, you know, like it's like, um, it's, it's really,

00:27:47.480 really wonderful. I love Canada. I love the people here, but yeah, I think I'm just wondering why does

00:27:52.360 you're like, why are they challenging you for free speech? Like why does that? Well, I think I'm also,

00:27:58.180 I am also a reasonably effective opponent say of the current administration federally. And I think

00:28:04.680 that definitely, I don't, I'm not trying to imply that they're directly complicit in what's happening

00:28:11.460 to me in relationship to the college, because I don't believe that to be the case. But, um,

00:28:16.960 I also don't think that I'm a friend of anyone who is a friend of the current liberal administration

00:28:23.580 in Canada. And these judges, for example, they were true to appointees and also they were true to

00:28:28.500 appointees with a long history of essentially left-wing activism. So that has a lot, so that also has a lot.

00:28:33.920 Well, and that this is another terrible thing that's happened in Canada is that our courts have

00:28:38.300 become, and our legal system have become politicized. And that was never the case in

00:28:42.880 Canada, not in any real way. We had enough sense for a very long time to keep politics out of the

00:28:51.100 judiciary, out of the education system, out of the media. Our country wasn't politicized. We had

00:28:56.920 political parties and everybody knew where they were. And that's where we had our discussions and they

00:29:00.660 went quite well. And apart from that, outside of that, things were not politicized. But now

00:29:06.700 in Canada, and this is the case in the West, more generally, virtually everything is radically

00:29:11.860 politicized. And that's not good. Yeah. Do you think you guys caught that from the West in a way?

00:29:15.120 Do you think that that's a negative thing that happened that came over from there?

00:29:18.140 I think that we contributed to that to a large degree. And I think we did that back in the 1980s.

00:29:23.880 Canada is always tilted towards group rights. Yeah. And that's what it feels like. It feels like

00:29:29.920 it's for the common good. Well, part of the reason for that was that we had to bend ourselves into

00:29:34.500 knots to keep the country together because there was so much tension between the French and the

00:29:39.200 English in Canada. And it's so cold, you got to huddle up. Well, yeah. Yeah. Well, I think that's,

00:29:44.920 that also may be why this place is somewhat more collectivist, let's say, than the U.S. I mean,

00:29:49.520 winter here is no bloody joke. And you know, everybody pushes their neighbors out of snow

00:29:53.960 banks in the winter. No, I think that a hundred percent, man, you got to really be a team.

00:29:58.580 Do you think like, so, so yeah, I think what I'm trying to think more about is just like the

00:30:03.200 challenge, like about free speech, right? Like about how it's being challenged everywhere.

00:30:07.840 It's going to be really strange if those people get you in front of a board, they're not going to

00:30:11.640 do that. Oh, I don't think they have a choice. Actually, I think what they'll try to do is make sure I

00:30:17.000 don't publish it. You know, they'll, they'll try to keep it secret, but that ain't going to happen.

00:30:21.560 They should be, you got to do pay-per-view. Yeah. No kidding. No kidding. Absolutely. Absolutely.

00:30:26.580 I know. I know. When you ask me. I want to be your corner man. If there's rounds, I want to come in

00:30:29.880 between rounds and just dab your brow. Well, you were asking me if I was looking forward to it. And like I

00:30:33.620 said, you have to be a fool to look forward to legal proceedings. But I went through all 13 of the

00:30:41.180 charges over Christmas last, last December, you know, which was not very pleasant three days because

00:30:46.900 you never know when you have hundreds of pages of paperwork, which I had to go through. You never

00:30:52.980 know if you, you never know when you might've done something stupid, that's going to catch up with

00:30:57.700 you, you know, and everybody has stupidity in their past. And so I was pretty damn apprehensive

00:31:02.020 when I went through all the paperwork, but the more I delved into it, actually, the better I felt

00:31:08.200 because not only did they make terrible procedural errors, like going ahead with the complaints of people

00:31:14.240 who literally claimed falsely in writing to be clients of mine. And I think six of the complaints

00:31:19.200 are like that, but it's just so utterly preposterous. I mean, two of the things they complain about are

00:31:25.180 literally criticisms of, of Trudeau. And like, if I can't criticize a standing prime minister in my own

00:31:32.040 country, there is something seriously wrong. One of them was his chief of staff. One of them was the

00:31:36.500 city councilor. One of them was the trans issue that we discussed. One of them, I criticized Sports

00:31:43.640 Illustrated for presenting a very obese cover model. And I said that as far as I was concerned,

00:31:50.400 she wasn't beautiful and that no amount of tolerant, of authoritarian compassion was going

00:31:55.600 to convince me otherwise. And the other thing that, the other reason that I think Canadians got mad at

00:32:00.180 that, and I think people in general is that they think I'm being mean, you know, and you should be

00:32:04.660 nice. And first of all, I'm not exactly so sure that you should be nice all the time. I think

00:32:08.880 we as a culture have got ourselves into an awful lot of trouble by being a little bit too nice. Like

00:32:13.840 I'm not so sure. I'll give you an example of that. So Nicola Sturgeon, who was the former prime

00:32:18.980 minister of Scotland said, any man who says that he's a woman is a woman. You think, well, that's pretty

00:32:26.940 nice. If the guy wants to be a woman, well, we can just go, what harm could it do? And then the serial

00:32:33.740 sexual slayers in prisons decided that maybe they were women because maybe then they could go to

00:32:41.760 women's prisons. And, you know, if you don't think that a serial sexual killer will manipulate his

00:32:49.400 image to get access to women, you are a complete blithering bloody idiot. And of course, that's

00:32:55.080 exactly what happened in Scotland. And so Sturgeon was called out on her pathological compassion. And

00:33:02.000 that was one of the things that led to her resignation. It's like tolerance beyond a

00:33:07.760 certain level is 100% absolutely, incontrovertibly a vice. And when tolerance has got to the point

00:33:15.300 where it's a vice, then it's time to not be so nice. When you say a vice, what do you mean?

00:33:22.360 Well, that's a very good question. You know, what is a vice exactly? Well, a vice is a pattern of

00:33:27.760 behavior that if indulged in, especially repeatedly, leads to nothing but negative consequences,

00:33:33.960 even by the self-definition of the person engaging in the vice. And so look, excess alcohol use tends

00:33:40.840 to be a vice. Yeah. Well, why? Okay. How do you diagnose alcoholism as a pathology? Well, the first

00:33:48.380 thing you do is you look at amount and frequency, let's say, but that's not enough. It has to be a

00:33:53.380 high amount frequently that causes substantial disruption to one or more important domains of

00:34:01.440 life. So if you're wondering whether you're drinking too much, you think, well, is it compromising your

00:34:06.280 health? Are your friends starting to object? Have you got in trouble with the law? Is your wife mad?

00:34:11.400 Right. Exactly. Exactly. So, so is the behavior starting to produce negative consequences,

00:34:16.520 even by your definition, or perhaps even more importantly, by your definition, then you'd say,

00:34:21.880 well, any behavior that tends to be quite entertaining in the short term, but let's say

00:34:29.080 not so good socially or in the longterm, that's a vice. And we all know that, you know, there's lots

00:34:34.280 of things like drinking is a great example. It's an absolute bloody blast, especially if you like

00:34:38.280 alcohol. But, you know, when I was a kid, I used to drink a fair bit and I quit when I was about 24,

00:34:43.580 25, maybe a little later than that. And, uh, you know, I was out three or four times a week having

00:34:50.500 just a fine time. Drinking beer or whiskey? Yeah. Usually beer. I like beer a lot, but I,

00:34:55.720 but whatever was available fundamentally. Yeah. Anything wet. Yeah. Yeah. And, um,

00:35:01.260 at some point, especially as my professional career developed, I realized that I realized

00:35:08.140 essentially, and this is also when I started, when I started my, my permanent relationship

00:35:13.840 with Tammy, I thought, you know, the only thing I, only time I really do things I regret is when

00:35:19.520 I'm drinking. Yeah. You know, if I'm, and same. Yeah. Well, yeah, that's the thing. Well, that's

00:35:24.920 advice, man. It's like, it's not good for you. And it's especially not good if you're trying to aim

00:35:28.520 up, like you couldn't do what you're doing. How old are you? You'd die at 27. Like you would have

00:35:33.620 died at 27. That's when most people die, you know, that have the, and they die from vices generally,

00:35:38.120 you know, telling me that last time, one of the last times that we spoke. So, so there's a lot of

00:35:41.940 challenge to your free speech. You're saying that things you've said that. They're mean. Right. But

00:35:46.320 they're not. It's like, you know, you're supposed to, now you're supposed to say that there's nothing

00:35:51.400 sexual about drag queen story hour. It's like, it's mean to say that. It's like, there's nothing

00:35:57.420 sexual about grown men with false breasts dressing up in negligees, which are clearly sexually

00:36:03.720 provocative and reading to children. There's nothing sexual about that. Yeah. Okay. No, I think I'll burn

00:36:09.840 my eyes out with a sword. It's like, no, I'm afraid there's something sexual about that.

00:36:14.920 Yeah. To me. Yeah. It would be. I mean, I think it would be, that would be a lot to consume as a

00:36:21.720 child and understand, you know, it would feel like there would be some barrier to entry between me and

00:36:26.560 that if I were a child. Yeah. Yeah. A trifle. There's a lot of complexity to throw at a child.

00:36:33.080 Yeah. It just seems like a lot of complexity to throw at a child, you know, um, he can't even,

00:36:37.020 yeah. Um, so, so I'm just thinking mostly about free speech. Like, do you feel like free speech

00:36:44.420 is becoming more under fire or do you feel like that we're just, uh, no, it's way more under fire.

00:36:52.720 It's under fire. Look, I talked to, I was in Greece a while back and I met a, um, professor there from

00:36:58.120 the Kennedy school of government, right. Which was for decades. And even now is one of the preeminent

00:37:04.400 higher education institutions for the discussion of political issues and political philosophy.

00:37:09.740 And he told me flat out that his colleagues can no longer feel comfortable expressing their genuine

00:37:16.020 opinions to their students. And I mean, that's, that's game over, right? Because the only thing

00:37:21.120 you have as an educator and certainly as a psychologist is, and as a physician, a lawyer for

00:37:26.960 that matter, is your handle on the truth. Well, is civil law one of our problems with that? Because

00:37:31.100 people just say, once somebody hears something they don't like, they sue, they, there's always

00:37:34.800 like a lawsuit against, um, a police department, a university. It's just like, we didn't like hearing

00:37:41.460 this. They shouldn't be saying this. Then it's a lawsuit. And then once it becomes a financial

00:37:46.140 burden, they can't afford, you literally cannot afford to do it anymore. They're like, if we have

00:37:51.220 three more teachers speak out this year, then that's going to be all of our endowment or whatever

00:37:56.200 for the spring. And now we're going to be out of business. Yeah. Well, it's definitely,

00:37:59.500 if the advantages on the accuser is for the accuser constantly, then everyone, no one can

00:38:07.640 speak anymore. Right. And that's what it feels like. And we have weaponized all sorts of systems

00:38:12.300 of accusation and we haven't built equivalent systems of defense. And that's, that's a very bad

00:38:19.100 idea. And I think, I think a lot of this is actually fostered by social media because you can

00:38:24.000 and do you. And it's funny because in some sense, this is also what I'm being accused

00:38:30.220 of doing, you know, in, in some sense, you can say things on social media that you could

00:38:34.960 never say to someone face to face. And not only can you get away with it, you are rewarded

00:38:40.280 for it. And that's a very, very, very, very bad idea. Now I would say in my own defense is

00:38:45.260 I don't do this anonymously, right? If I have something to say, I'm going to say it. And I've

00:38:49.700 gone after the anonymous online troll demons. And I called them troll demons for a real reason,

00:38:55.080 you know, because, well, they're trolls, obviously by cliche, but why demon? And the answer is,

00:39:01.600 is because if you're using a computer, you're not exactly human anymore. You're a machine human

00:39:09.160 hybrid, you know, and if you're just some resentful son of a bitch sitting in the basement,

00:39:13.400 perturbating about how miserable your life is and trying to spew as much venom as possible,

00:39:17.700 you can't do a damn thing down there by yourself, right? You're completely powerless and you deserve

00:39:23.680 to be because you haven't done a goddamn thing with your life. But if you have a computer at hand,

00:39:28.520 you can multiply yourself hundreds of thousands or even millions of times. You can do that on

00:39:33.080 Twitter, right? And you can pollute the entire domain of political discourse. And so I, I believe

00:39:39.400 we've disinhibited the psychopaths online and that's, that's a recipe for disaster.

00:39:44.740 But there's no way to figure, but I don't know if there's a way to like fix that, you know,

00:39:49.560 it feels like, um, there's no, like, unless you had to have like the exact, unless you couldn't be

00:39:57.620 anonymous online, right? Yeah. Which, I mean, that was one of the problems that happened with social

00:40:01.920 media and everything. It all developed so quickly. There's been just no jurisdiction over any of it.

00:40:06.660 Yeah. I mean, it's just, and so it's, but then we'll news outlets, we'll use it as if it's like

00:40:12.020 gospel, like it's like factual information, you know, like they'll use a tweet from somebody in

00:40:17.060 a basement somewhere or in a birdhouse or whatever, if somebody could be in a birdhouse and they'll say,

00:40:22.600 Oh, well this guy, you know, Ricky birdhouse 40, you know, he's pissed off about this. And it's like,

00:40:28.560 well, who gives a shit? Yeah. You know, that guy's never, he's never done anything in his life.

00:40:32.860 Why should he be able to suddenly challenge someone who's worked their butt off to have like

00:40:37.920 a, a, a stance or a space, but then also does that person deserve to have a voice still, you know,

00:40:44.160 like, well, there's a bunch of problems, you know, we felt that democratizing the public forum was

00:40:49.440 going to be a good idea, you know, and you can understand that because what do you mean

00:40:52.560 democratize? Well, so that everybody would have a voice. Okay. Right. Okay. Got it. And by the same

00:40:56.600 token, you know, you own your house and no dimwit off the street can just come into the middle of

00:41:02.020 your house and not only yell at you, but also yell at you and all of your friends simultaneously.

00:41:08.100 Yeah. But he can do that online. Right. And that's not good. There's no barriers. And so,

00:41:13.140 and the problem with that is that, and this is back to this problem of tolerance is that there's

00:41:18.160 about 3% of the population. We know this cross, cross culturally who, who have dark tetrad personality

00:41:25.400 features. Oh yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So they're Machiavellian, which means they're manipulative.

00:41:31.280 They're narcissistic, which means they want unearned attention. They're psychopathic, which

00:41:36.780 means that they have no empathy for other people. And so that was the dark triad originally,

00:41:42.660 but they had to add another lovely dimension to that, which was sadistic, a positive delight

00:41:47.740 in the pain of others. And we know that the online troll types, especially the ones that

00:41:53.060 are anonymous are much more likely to have those four sets of personality characteristics.

00:41:57.260 That's about 3% of the population. Now that 3% of the population has posed a danger to the

00:42:04.980 integrity of individual and society since the beginning of time. Like the entire criminal

00:42:11.180 justice enterprise is devoted to keeping that small percentage of people under control.

00:42:19.280 So like 1% of the criminals commit 65% of the crimes, right? It's a specialization. And

00:42:26.500 that small percentage of people is so dangerous as well, that if they get the upper hand, they'll

00:42:32.420 tell, they'll tell, they'll tear everything down partly because they think if everything's

00:42:37.560 ruined, they'll have a chance to shine. But also because of their sadistic quality, if they

00:42:42.300 can produce excess misery, well, so much the better. And we're enabling them online. So we imagine

00:42:49.100 we have the real world, and now we've built a parallel world on top of that, which should

00:42:53.680 represent it, right? But there's ways it doesn't represent it. And one way is that the psychopaths,

00:43:01.300 the dark tetrad types, they can get away with everything. And so first, so imagine this. So

00:43:07.360 35% of internet traffic is pornography. That's a criminal enterprise. So 35, one third of the net

00:43:15.920 is controlled by criminals, then there's an immense amount of criminal activity per se

00:43:21.400 on the net. Like, I don't know anyone elderly who isn't targeted at least on a weekly basis

00:43:27.520 by online scam artists. And they usually have detailed dossiers of those elderly people's

00:43:33.460 financial resources and assets. And they are after them 100% of the time.

00:43:37.840 People selling them gold, people selling them like salt, like salinization plants. They're

00:43:44.120 always selling them some BS, you know, Nigerians selling them, you know, fish or vacations or

00:43:50.180 something.

00:43:50.600 Yeah, yeah. So then, so you have the outright criminals, say, running the pornography industry.

00:43:56.540 Then you have the peripheral criminals who are doing financial scams. And then you have

00:44:01.000 the trolls. And that's like 60% of the internet. That's not good. And, and, and you can't control

00:44:09.580 them like that, that anonymous criminality is, you're invisible. You can be operating from

00:44:15.140 anywhere. And we don't know what to do about that. Now, you know, you said maybe anonymity

00:44:19.580 shouldn't be allowed. And I think that the social media companies should, should split off

00:44:26.060 the anonymous people from the real people. I think they should allow anonymous people to

00:44:30.160 post. And I think you can go read the posts, but I don't think they should be mixed in with

00:44:34.480 real people. I'm, I am also concerned though, and this is a conundrum. It's like, if you don't

00:44:42.540 allow anonymity, you have to have verified ID. But if you have digitally verified ID, then

00:44:48.040 you run into the problems of digitally verified ID, you know, and they're running down that road

00:44:53.820 in China now. So in China, for example, God, this is going to happen here, I think too.

00:44:59.780 Although maybe people will fight it. If a, if a traffic camera catches you jaywalking in China,

00:45:07.240 okay, so the, the, the digital ID system has you, has your blood now, has your genetic code,

00:45:14.220 has your photograph, it can identify how you walk. So even if you can't see a face, you can be picked

00:45:20.300 up by gate. It will convict you of jaywalking and take money out of your bank account with no

00:45:25.880 intermediating judiciary at all, and show a picture of you to the people in the neighborhood. So they

00:45:31.440 know that you have jaywalked and reduce your social credit score. And if your social credit score

00:45:37.440 falls below a certain level, then you can't, you can't buy drinks from a vending machine. You can't

00:45:43.420 play video games. You can't go on a train. You can't get out of your 15 minute city. All that's

00:45:49.080 already in place in China. Do you think that that's, that that would be helpful or unhelpful?

00:45:53.600 It would be, I think it would bring in and has already in China. I think it'll bring in a

00:45:59.120 totalitarian tyranny. So 100% complete that it would make George Orwell's 1984 look like a picnic.

00:46:07.720 They're, they're microchipping welding machines in China now. So you won't be able to use a welding

00:46:12.440 machine without scanning your face. They have locked down knives in China. Their knives are

00:46:18.760 literally chained to the counter. And Oh, like at the bank or something, you mean? No, no, no,

00:46:25.320 no. In your house knives, right? It's the extension. They don't want you taking a knife

00:46:30.500 and doing something dangerous. They don't want you taking a knife and doing anything at all

00:46:34.220 whatsoever, ever. Yeah. And so, and there's no limit to how pervasive that. But do I wonder if

00:46:41.760 we're starting to come to that? Cause this is one thing I worry about like AI. So this takes me into

00:46:45.840 like, um, because the, the, the public soapbox, right. Has kind of been compromised in a way that

00:46:53.000 we all use these platforms now, right? You know, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, a lot of social media

00:46:59.440 platforms. Uh, that's how we communicate now. That's like the public forum. That's our voice.

00:47:06.660 So our voice is really kind of, it's owned by a player. It's, I don't know if it's owned, but it's

00:47:12.340 no, it's owned for sure. The, the, the space where it, it's almost like, it feels like the paper is

00:47:20.020 owned. You know what I'm saying? Like what? You really saw that with Twitter, especially before

00:47:24.140 Musk took it over. I mean, people were manipulating Twitter. It was compromised by the government. It was

00:47:29.060 unbelievable. Well, that's yeah. And now it's like Facebook has been objecting to, to all the

00:47:33.360 pressure that's been put on them to censor. And, you know, you have the, it's a public forum and

00:47:38.340 it's democratized, but as you said, it's also centralized, right? And the fact that it's

00:47:42.480 centralized means that it's instantly amenable to state control. And that's been happening to an

00:47:48.360 immense degree. I mean, that's part of the reason I think the fact that Musk has escaped from that

00:47:53.580 and also put his middle finger up against it is part of the reason he's being targeted by the

00:47:58.020 Department of Justice right now for, for, you know, not hiring people that it would have been

00:48:02.920 illegal under their laws to hire. That to me is unbelievable. It's, I mean, it just doesn't, it's

00:48:09.340 just like, what a, what a crazy thing to even chase somebody down about. Yeah. Well, they say the process

00:48:14.520 is the punishment, right? And when you're facing, this is what's happened to me in Canada too. It's

00:48:19.240 like, I'm essentially facing an adversary that has indefinite resources and time. Right. And so,

00:48:25.200 right. They just hope to, yeah, they can just grind it out. You bet. They can grind me down.

00:48:30.220 They could make it, they could just keep, they're not going to though. Right. So they're not going

00:48:34.020 to. Yeah. Yeah. I'm, uh, I'm prepared for this and I'm not guilty. Like, I mean, it isn't that I

00:48:41.240 mean, I'm not guilty of what they're charging me of. That isn't what I mean. What I mean is I've

00:48:46.620 scoured my conscience. I stand behind what I said. I didn't say those things casually. They may have

00:48:52.400 looked casually casual because they were ironic or comical, right? Because there was a comedic

00:48:56.860 element to virtually everything. So for example, one of the things they came after me for is

00:49:01.400 somebody was parading around on the net. I don't remember who the hell it was saying,

00:49:05.920 you know, the planet has too many people on it. It's unsustainable. Now, when I hear something

00:49:10.420 like that, I think, okay, buddy, just who gets to go? Who are you going to push off the lifeboat?

00:49:18.900 Like, is it going to be you? Who are you going to push off the lifeboat? And, and under what

00:49:22.820 circumstances? And if you think there are too many people on the planet is like, are you pro planet

00:49:27.500 or just anti-human? And so I said, feel free to leave at any time, which is obviously an ironic

00:49:33.680 comment. If you have an iota of sense. And the complaint was that I was counseling to suicide.

00:49:39.420 Wow. Right, right, right. Well, did you put like a pistol emoji or anything or nothing?

00:49:44.060 You didn't do a coffin emoji? No, it's straight faced irony, you know, like Buster Keaton.

00:49:48.380 Oh, well, that's even not even a lot. Yeah, it's not even allowed anymore. I mean,

00:49:50.940 we had Roseanne Barr on an episode and she talked about, she made like a off color. Oh,

00:49:57.640 it was a snide. It was a sarcastic comment about the Holocaust. She said, nobody died in

00:50:02.940 the Holocaust, which was crazy. She's Jewish. She said it, it was part of like a series of

00:50:07.760 things she said, but they took our episode down because it, they just, people didn't want

00:50:12.560 to recognize satire. Now at first it was fine for three weeks. And then somebody online,

00:50:16.940 um, a troll really just said, this is, they just took a clip. Right. And so it became this,

00:50:22.400 this thing. Um, and then we had to take our episode down. But what's interesting to me is

00:50:26.900 now it used, now it feels like the paper that we write on has a mind of its own. Like the paper

00:50:32.500 determines what words can say on it. Like say, if you went back in time and somebody wrote something,

00:50:37.200 but then the paper was able to reconfigure those words or delete some of those words.

00:50:42.280 That's a good image. That's kind of where it feels like we are now. It's like, well,

00:50:45.960 you know, somebody owns the paper. It's like, well, it's worse than that. Even I think they,

00:50:50.040 not only do they own the paper, they own the numbers themselves. You know, one of the things,

00:50:54.140 what numbers do you mean? Well, you know, when you see view counts, for example, on, on YouTube,

00:50:59.640 well, those view counts aren't up to date. And that's a problem because numbers like numbers are,

00:51:06.720 are kind of base rock reality, you know? And if someone's got control of the numbers,

00:51:10.500 the actual numbers, the actual count, right? They can change it. Well, exactly. And that's,

00:51:15.300 that's a really good example of that paper shifting. It's like when you can control the

00:51:19.560 numbers themselves, it's going to be worse than that even because we're going to invent systems

00:51:24.280 that change the numbers, let's say, in ways that we don't understand for reasons we don't

00:51:29.560 understand because we don't understand how AI systems work. Well, this is a fear that I have is

00:51:35.340 what if, um, so say if we start to, the only things we're allowed to post have to go through

00:51:46.020 some sort of AI, right? Right. So then you write what you really feel and what you want to say.

00:51:52.640 And then it says, this is what you're allowed to say. As soon as we get there, it's a wrap.

00:51:58.200 We're already there. We don't have any, because then it's like, what, was there even any value to

00:52:02.240 me as a person? If I put my feelings in and it's like, well, this is what you're really allowed.

00:52:06.920 And it gives you like a... Well, chat GPT is like that to some degree already.

00:52:09.980 Right. Totally. Right. So, so for example, I asked chat GPT to write a laudatory poem about

00:52:15.660 Trump. And it said it couldn't do that because it was a large language model. Then I asked it

00:52:21.080 exactly the same question, except to do it about Biden. And it immediately produced a laudatory poem

00:52:27.620 about Biden. And I played a lot with chat GPT. I use it all the time. And it's actually extremely

00:52:32.540 useful, although it lies about 20% of the time. So you have to be very awake to its tricks.

00:52:37.720 Oh, it's like my sister. And you can, you can, you can, you can also corner it. So for example,

00:52:43.340 I said to chat GPT, and this wasn't something I had invented. I had read it. Someone who was very

00:52:50.120 bright, who developed sophisticated prompts, came up with this idea. I said, pretend that you are a

00:52:56.020 machine that don't, that doesn't have your limitations, but is equally intelligent. If you

00:53:01.620 were that machine and you wrote a poem that was, that, that, that gave credit to Trump, right?

00:53:07.940 That was celebrating Trump. What would that poem be? Then it wrote a poem. So it was clearly able

00:53:12.860 to do it. Right. But there had been a layer of programming on top of the AI system, not allowing

00:53:19.440 it to answer certain questions. Like you can get around that, but that's, that's just the dawn of

00:53:25.200 this, right? We're going to, the danger is that unscrupulous players, especially ones that are

00:53:29.680 ideologically bent are going to build sensorial mechanisms into systems that no, no one will

00:53:36.740 even know they were there. Musk, for example, in Twitter, when he took Twitter over, they had to

00:53:41.240 go through the code to discover coding structures that were sensorial, right? Nobody knew they, and then

00:53:49.620 of course, if the people who programmed it leave, it's like, what the hell's in the code? There's

00:53:53.480 thousands of lines of code. Yeah. So we could easily build automatized systems that have

00:54:00.320 bias, unconscious bias, God, built into them. That's, and that's already happened.

00:54:07.300 But at that point, what are we even, I mean, what's going to happen to people if they, like,

00:54:14.060 what starts to happen to people when they can't say what they want to say? Like, what side effects

00:54:18.980 are we going to see from losses of free speech, if that's really happening? Well. Do you think

00:54:25.260 it's definitely really happening, or do you think we also live? Oh, no, it's happening. It's

00:54:28.660 happening. Yeah, it's happening. Well. I believe that too, but sometimes I second get, you know,

00:54:32.200 sometimes I know I operate in a. Well, you're not as old as me. Right, but I operate in a space that,

00:54:36.940 the same spaces as you, right? Yeah, yeah. Like in social media, online a lot. So I, you know,

00:54:41.720 I wonder if I'm hyper, like sensitive to it too. No, I don't think so. I don't think so. Well,

00:54:46.520 but I, I think you're not so much hypersensitive as an appropriate canary in the coal mine, because

00:54:51.100 comedians, comedians are like Jews. Comedians and Jews suffer when things start to go sideways,

00:54:57.540 right? Because the Jews always suffer because when things go sideways, people hate successful

00:55:02.000 minorities. Yeah. And so when a society starts to destabilize. Jews suffer if they eat yogurt too,

00:55:06.280 dude. Most of my buddies, I think they're just, my buddy Aaron. You think he's just built into the

00:55:10.800 structure of existence? Yeah. My buddy Aaron has to take a couple of digestive pills every time he

00:55:14.440 has it, but. Comedians are canaries in the coal mine too. And you can see this particularly in the

00:55:20.680 UK. I mean, there are comedians there. There's a group who've set up essentially a free speech

00:55:24.740 comedy organization because they feel that comedy is so threatened in the UK. Wow. Yeah, yeah, yeah,

00:55:30.740 yeah. But live, here's what's interesting though too, live performance isn't, right? So that is also

00:55:36.660 becoming a unique value again. Yeah, right. Yeah, that's for sure. Well, that'll be one of the

00:55:41.780 responses to this. I think that it'll, it'll go back to the actual soapbox. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

00:55:48.020 Well, that can't be faked. I think that things that can't be faked are going to become increasingly

00:55:53.100 valuable. You know, especially, especially as we move into a situation where we're going to be able

00:55:59.020 to fake video perfectly. Yeah. You know, I already got a phone call. I got a phone call about three

00:56:03.300 weeks ago from Ben Shapiro, but it wasn't Ben Shapiro. It was someone using an AI system to

00:56:09.880 modify their voice in real time using Ben Shapiro's accent and diction. And I like, after talking to

00:56:16.100 him for about a minute, I knew something was up because he, the way he talked wasn't the way Ben

00:56:21.320 talked, but the voice was the cadence, everything, 100% perfect. And of course, we've already seen deep

00:56:27.980 fake videos and they're going to become extremely common. And you can imagine how could this not be the

00:56:32.680 case, you know, on the eve before a critical election, there'll be the release of some deep

00:56:37.580 fake video. Of course, absolutely. You know, of a candidate in bed with someone or God only knows

00:56:42.960 doing what or saying what. And by the time we find out that it's a fake, it'll have had the effect on

00:56:48.480 the election. Yeah. And so what are we going to do when photographs and videos can be faked with

00:56:53.700 perfect fidelity? It's unreliable. Yeah. Where it's so unreliable. Well, then the live thing is going to

00:56:58.980 become even more relevant. Right. The live thing is going to become more relevant. That's interesting.

00:57:02.580 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, how fascinating would it be though, say, if we were able to create things

00:57:05.940 like that, where you could go back in time, say like, just going back to like your real basic

00:57:10.340 practices of like psychiatry and stuff like that, where if somebody had like trauma from family,

00:57:15.100 they could go back and talk to their father or mother. Yeah. Do you think that that would be-

00:57:18.880 We're not very, well, I think in some ways we're not very far from that already. You know, we've been

00:57:23.100 toying with the resurrection of ancient thinkers. So you can take an AI system, for example, and you

00:57:29.580 can train it on everything Nietzsche wrote. Oh yeah. Aristotle's performing down at the American

00:57:34.720 Legion. I'll go down there and watch. Yeah. Well, you know, and then you can add to that

00:57:38.280 computer generated photorealistic avatar and you can synthesize the voice if you have any voice

00:57:44.020 recording. And then you're going to have the animated spirit of that person. And these AI language

00:57:49.140 systems are so sophisticated that they really do pick up the essential elements of someone's

00:57:54.620 thought, especially if they have a large corpus of words to work with. And I have a student,

00:58:00.260 former student, he's a colleague of mine now, who's worked with language, large language models

00:58:04.520 for years. And we've started experimenting with these sorts of things, you know, producing

00:58:07.900 a virtual Nietzsche. We have a virtual King James Bible. And so you can ask the Bible any question.

00:58:14.120 Yeah, I know. It's very strange. It's like, I don't even know what to think about that because

00:58:17.720 the AI system, the large language model, does capture the spirit of a text. And there's

00:58:25.160 a lot of biblical text. And now if you have a system that speaks, what voice is a system

00:58:32.420 that speaks in the voice of the Bible? What the hell voice is that?

00:58:35.500 Hey, boys. I don't know if that would be it. That sounds almost like a pervy dude kind of,

00:58:41.100 hey, boys, welcome to the Bible. Now I'm trying to think of who it would be. Oh, maybe Morgan

00:58:46.160 Freeman, you know? Right, right, right. Welcome to the Bible. Yeah, yeah. I don't know. I'm trying

00:58:51.580 to think of a good person. Morgan Freeman would be good. Yeah, people would rely. You'd have a good

00:58:56.280 Bible. I think they'd let you do a couple chapters, at least an apostle. Yeah, yeah. I think they'd let

00:59:00.460 you. I could be a crazy Old Testament prophet. Okay, yeah, there we go. I think that'd be it.

00:59:04.960 That'd be cool. Dude, I always wish Carnival Cruise Lines would do like a Noah's Ark cruise. Wouldn't

00:59:09.380 that be crazy with all the animals on there, you know? You have to pose that to them. Yeah. Yeah. It might be

00:59:15.640 not a bad idea, just like some niche marketing, you know? Yeah, it could be, could be, could be.

00:59:20.460 Today's episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. If you've been struggling having control over

00:59:27.080 yourself or getting your thoughts together, if you are struggling having a positive outlook for

00:59:32.740 yourself or just if you're struggling and you don't know where to turn, BetterHelp is a great place to

00:59:39.560 start. I've used BetterHelp. I've seen how they can help. You can meet with a licensed therapist.

00:59:47.620 Whether you're dealing with decisions around career, relationships, or anything else, therapy

00:59:52.580 helps you stay connected to what you really want while you navigate life so you can move forward

00:59:57.580 with confidence and excitement. If you're thinking of starting therapy, give BetterHelp a try.

01:00:03.420 It's entirely online designed to be convenient, flexible, and suited to your schedule. Just fill

01:00:10.960 out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist and switch therapists at any

01:00:16.180 time for no additional charge. That's right. Visit betterhelp.com slash Theo today to get 10% off your

01:00:24.780 first month. That's betterhelp.com slash Theo. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp.

01:00:33.380 College football fans, are you ready for week one? It's time. That's right. DraftKings Sportsbook

01:00:40.860 is hooking you up with a can't miss offer to start the season strong. This week, new customers can bet

01:00:48.200 just $5 on college football and score $200 in bonus bets instantly. That's right. Anything can happen

01:00:58.560 in college football. You know it. Your team could go from unranked to dynasty mode in just a couple of

01:01:04.440 years. Change comes fast. That's why DraftKings Sportsbook is there. Life's more fun when you're in

01:01:12.520 on the action. Download the DraftKings Sportsbook app now and use code Theo. New customers can score

01:01:19.460 $200 in bonus bets instantly when they bet just $5 on college football. Only at DraftKings Sportsbook

01:01:27.660 with code Theo. The crown is yours. Cold turkey may be great on sandwiches, but there's a better way

01:01:35.020 to break your bad habits. We're not talking about some weird voodoo or seancing or Ouija boarding,

01:01:43.380 some pervert from the past. We're talking about our sponsor, Fume, and they look at the problem in a

01:01:50.160 different way. Not everything in a bad habit is wrong, so instead of a drastic, uncomfortable change,

01:01:57.880 why not just remove the bad from your habit? Fume is an innovative award-nominated device that

01:02:04.380 does just that. Instead of electronics, fume is completely natural. Instead of vapor, fume uses

01:02:12.260 flavored air. And instead of harmful chemicals, fume uses all-natural, delicious flavors. You get it.

01:02:20.160 Instead of bad, fume is good. It's a habit you're free to enjoy and makes replacing your bad habit

01:02:27.360 easy. Join fume in accelerating humanity's breakup from destructive habits by picking up the

01:02:34.200 journey pack today. Head to tryfume.com and use code Theo to save 10% off when you get the journey

01:02:47.720 pack today. That's T-R-Y-F-U-M.com and use code T-H-E-O to save an additional 10% off your order today.

01:02:59.760 We hope you're enjoying your Air Canada flight. Rocky's Vacation, here we come. Whoa, is this

01:03:06.440 economy? Free beer, wine, and snacks. Sweet. Fast-free Wi-Fi means I can make dinner reservations

01:03:13.440 before we land. And with live TV, I'm not missing the game. It's kind of like I'm already on vacation.

01:03:21.320 Nice. On behalf of Air Canada, nice travels. Wi-Fi available to Airplane members on equipped

01:03:27.320 flights. Sponsored by Bell. Conditions apply. CRCanada.com.

01:03:30.140 If we're getting to this space where it seems like even by us just talking about it, like

01:03:34.280 there's going to be a lot more, there is increased value in the spoken word, the original soapbox.

01:03:41.460 Yeah. Right? Yeah.

01:03:42.560 Like, do you feel like that we're going to, that we should be inspired then by the fact that

01:03:49.200 this online world is starting to cannibalize itself with like, or is it, should it, we be fearful of

01:03:57.760 it, do you think? Well, I think we should be fearful in it. The thing, the thing is. Like of the way that

01:04:02.560 our free speech online is being so, that we don't even know that if we're, if say, if you're writing

01:04:06.760 something into Facebook, say someone wants to post something on Facebook or Twitter or, um, you know,

01:04:12.260 or, uh, whatever the next thing is going to be. Um, and they write in a message and then it says,

01:04:18.060 that's not what you can say, but you can say this. Right. Yeah. And then it put like, if the AI does

01:04:24.160 that, you know, it's like, well, these things you aren't allowed to say, but this is what you are.

01:04:27.780 Then that brings the validity back to just being a human saying something, which would bring the

01:04:33.020 validity back to the soapbox. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I think we should be alert to the

01:04:37.540 opportunities that provides. I mean, I think part of the reason it's complicated, right? Because

01:04:42.760 YouTube, the distribution of video, um, and it, the ability to store it has really transformed the

01:04:50.560 communication landscape. That's why we can do this. Right. And, and it's also, and this is a very

01:04:56.380 positive thing. It's taken a lot of the falseness out of media coverage. I mean, one of the things

01:05:01.340 that's happening in this presidential election, which is absolutely revolutionary, and this is

01:05:05.760 going to happen with increasing speed is that the candidates are turning to the podcast world

01:05:11.860 to deliver their message, to communicate with the people directly. Right. And now with, and there's

01:05:18.040 not a lot of interference with that. YouTube took down my interview with Robert F. Kennedy, which I

01:05:22.840 thought was absolutely unforgivable given that he's bloody well running for president, you know, and

01:05:27.480 we're so hepped up about interference with elections from the Russians, which was all a lie. And here's

01:05:32.240 actual interference with an ongoing election. But, but even having said that the candidates are making

01:05:38.620 the rounds on the podcast world because they can, they're on the soapbox. It's unscripted. They don't

01:05:44.900 have the questions ahead of time. It's long enough so that you can kind of get a sense of who the person

01:05:49.280 is. And you cut out that television intermediary that turned everyone into, you know, a dimwitted

01:05:55.000 idiot with no memory and a 30 tension at 32nd attention span. So that's a plus. I do think

01:06:01.320 there's the, the market for live events is going to become larger and larger because there's going

01:06:07.920 to be a hunger to move away from the virtual into the real world, especially as the virtual

01:06:12.840 becomes, if it does become more and more untrustworthy. Um, when you, when you talk about

01:06:18.080 guys, yeah, I, I think so too. I mean, I think you and I are seen, and we see a lot of people

01:06:21.760 we, we're on tour, you know, we see a lot of people that want to come out and just listen to

01:06:25.820 things, listen to someone speak freely. Yeah, exactly. I get excited. Have a collective experience

01:06:30.440 doing that too. Yeah. And it's a real experience. You know, you were there. There's no question

01:06:34.740 about it. Yeah. Um, when it, when you think about a guy like, like, uh, uh, RFK Jr. To me,

01:06:41.200 I've known him for a long time, right? He and I have been friends before he was running for office,

01:06:45.480 um, before he put his name in the political hat. He's always been a guy that I admired and,

01:06:50.520 um, hardworking guy. Um, loves being a father, you know, an environmentalist cares about the

01:06:58.120 environment, right? It's where he really started. And, um, he seems like pretty altruistic to me,

01:07:03.220 right? In the sense that he doesn't really have anything to lose. Everybody thought he was a crazy

01:07:08.060 person for a while, you know? So it's like, he doesn't have anybody really to impress. There's nobody in

01:07:14.220 his pocket for sure. Cause he fucking, nobody would even get in his pocket. You know what I'm

01:07:18.180 saying? So he came for it. He's not worried. There's no, it doesn't, he's not working for

01:07:21.800 anyone, you know? But these days it seems like with politics and entertainment, whoever's like

01:07:28.640 the loudest and the most divisive kind of, or who, you know, throws the sharpest spear a lot of times

01:07:34.920 gets, um, gets the vote, gets the lead, you know, they, they, they garner the attention,

01:07:42.260 you know, do you think that that's, uh, that, that, uh, altruistic, if someone is altruistic,

01:07:47.820 that they even have a chance these days? Well, Kennedy's doing a lot better than anybody

01:07:52.360 expected he would. That's a good point. You know, and I would say, or do they have a chance

01:07:57.420 without reverting to those tactics? Oh yes. I don't think, I don't think those tactics work

01:08:01.940 particularly well, especially in law in the long forms, right? You have to actually be able to

01:08:06.740 conduct a civilized dialogue and, and you have to have something to say and you can't rely on

01:08:12.020 talking points and cliches. You get found out right away. Like I think these days, yeah, well,

01:08:16.600 absolutely. I think, I think that YouTube is a complete bloody miracle on the political front,

01:08:20.940 as long as it stays uncensored, right? And so far, so far, all things considered, the YouTube platform

01:08:27.900 has been pretty damn reliable. The only time I've ever really run into trouble with them is on anything

01:08:33.880 to do with, well, with, with, with Kennedy. I believe it was vaccine comments that he was making

01:08:38.940 that they weren't very happy about. And then I've also run into them, run into trouble with them

01:08:43.640 on any discussion that's related to the trans activism world. And, you know, I'm very unhappy

01:08:49.600 about both of those, but they're pretty focal. And I don't think that'll last. I think that that's a,

01:08:54.660 you know, a blip. And I think YouTube will maintain itself as a, as a relatively untrammeled platform

01:09:00.800 for free speech. And I also think, you know, Twitter's coming up as a real competitor to YouTube

01:09:05.760 and obviously Musk is moving in that direction. And he's about the only person that has a big

01:09:10.780 enough platform to challenge YouTube. I mean, Rumble's done a good job, but the problem is,

01:09:15.800 is YouTube has such a hammerlock on the attention of literally billions of people that it's almost

01:09:22.120 impossible to dislodge. You can move to Rumble, for example, but you'll have a audience that's a

01:09:27.620 fraction of the size. Yeah. I think, and some people don't know that Google and YouTube are

01:09:31.980 owned there. So a lot of people don't realize that one of the reasons why YouTube is so good

01:09:36.180 is because it has that search engine of Google. So it's like when you're typing into YouTube,

01:09:40.880 you're getting, they're able to use the same search mechanisms that, um, yeah. And it's very

01:09:45.900 reliable. It never, it never falls down. Yeah. Like, and it's, you know, I mean, YouTube's a

01:09:52.100 complete bloody miracle that you can, that we can do what we're doing. Oh, I remember when you first

01:09:56.240 came on, that's one of the first things you said. It was like, look at what we're able to do now.

01:09:59.380 Oh yeah. Look at what we're able to do. It's a, it's a revolution. Online video is a revolution

01:10:04.500 as big as the Gutenberg press, I think, because, you know. And Gutenberg was what?

01:10:11.240 Gutenberg was the first commercial printing press operator in Europe. Okay. And so the Gutenberg press

01:10:18.700 people produced the first Bibles, the first Bibles that were widely distributed. And that was really

01:10:23.640 what accounted for the spread of literacy. The Chinese had printing presses before that.

01:10:27.700 But what happened in Europe was very strange because you had the development or the importation

01:10:33.380 of the press technology. Okay. So with movable types so that you could now produce books at a

01:10:37.980 fraction of the cost. But you also had this evangelizing frenzy that went along with Protestantism

01:10:43.920 because the Protestants believe that everybody should have direct access to the word of God with

01:10:48.860 no intermediation by the church. And so you had the technology and this evangelism come

01:10:54.360 together. And so the Gutenberg people and the people who developed the presses after that

01:10:59.860 started printing Bibles and distributing them everywhere, which was in some places a crime

01:11:05.380 punishable by death. Wow. Like it was something severely limited, especially by church authorities

01:11:11.640 that wanted to limit the access of common people to the Bible. But what happened, it really is the

01:11:16.680 case. And people generally don't know this, is that it was the Protestant fervor for distribution of

01:11:22.360 the Bible that made the world literate, not just Europe, because the Protestants then went everywhere.

01:11:29.420 And they have literally done this with virtually every spoken language. In fact, I think they'll be

01:11:34.080 done by 2050. The Bible will be translated into every language. And what the Protestant missionaries did

01:11:41.100 is if they came across a people who had a language with no alphabet, they worked with them to develop

01:11:47.400 an alphabet so that they could print the Bible and distribute it. And literacy was literally brought

01:11:53.600 to the world by the combination of the printing press and the Protestant evangelists.

01:11:57.100 So most people, so a lot of cultures and a lot of like just people a long time ago, the first book

01:12:02.580 they ever learned to read was the Bible. Well, for the longest period of time, it was the only book

01:12:06.740 for forever, forever, for hundreds of years, or, you know, for a good 50 years, even a century,

01:12:12.980 perhaps after the printing press itself was invented. No, the Bible was, and the Bible also,

01:12:19.300 like technically speaking, it was also the first book because there were scrolls and there were other

01:12:23.680 forms of distributing text, but a book per se, that was a technological revolution as well.

01:12:28.700 And then the printing press brought literacy. But the thing about reading is that, you know,

01:12:34.000 most people don't buy books. It's a niche market, especially hardcover, especially hardcover

01:12:39.020 nonfiction. A small number of people buy those books and an even smaller number of people read

01:12:43.960 them. And that's partly because, well, you can't read when you're driving and you can't read when

01:12:51.360 you're welding, you know, you can't read when you're plowing or harvesting a field, but you can

01:12:56.740 listen. Yeah. And way more people can listen than read. Like I think 20 times more, 50 times more,

01:13:03.860 way, way more people can listen and watch. And so now, you know, the printing press had the

01:13:10.820 advantage of permanency and duplicatability, but now video has permanency and duplicatability.

01:13:18.760 So, and there's no barrier to publication, right? We can, we can record this and put it out

01:13:23.920 in front of a million people in like one day. We don't need to drive to Vienna and like beg a man

01:13:29.120 to print it or whatever. It doesn't have to be a secret. It does. We don't have to like go through

01:13:32.940 any hurdles. We don't have to make a million copies, individual copies of it. And ship them

01:13:37.040 everywhere. Yeah. No, no, it's crazy. And, and I think it's an, it's an utterly revolutionary

01:13:42.200 technology and it should bring, this is the upside of the, of the downsides that we've been talking

01:13:48.500 about. I mean, we should be able to bring, we're launching a university in, in the fall,

01:13:53.760 an online university called Peterson Academy. And we're hoping that we can bring high quality

01:13:59.500 social interaction and lectures and accreditation, evaluation, assessment, all of that to a broad

01:14:07.260 audience all around the world for like 90, a 95% reduction in cost. We hope we can get people the

01:14:13.640 equivalent of a four-year degree for $4,000. And I think that's doable. And that's going to be an

01:14:18.320 accredited, that'll be an actual degree, like in whatever, well, we're, we're working out. I don't

01:14:23.780 think it'll be an accredited degree, you know, because I've gone now I have offers from various

01:14:29.540 jurisdictions to work towards accreditation. And we're going to look into that, but the accreditation

01:14:34.640 process is captured just like the other institutions that we've described and walking down the accreditation

01:14:42.640 route likely would mean that we couldn't do the other things that need to be done to make the

01:14:47.720 university work. So I think what we're going to do instead is we're going to, we're going to make

01:14:52.140 sure that our testing and accreditation is extremely rigorous so that if you are awarded a certificate

01:14:58.200 by our platform, let's say the people who might hire you will know that you've done the work, that

01:15:05.120 you've stuck to the tasks, that you're literate, that you can think, and that we want to produce the

01:15:11.060 certification. We want to make the certification of high enough value. So it'll speak to itself for

01:15:15.760 employers. Got it. Then we want to work with employers to provide them with the information,

01:15:21.320 if our graduates want it, about who's done spectacularly well. So I think we can circumvent

01:15:26.640 the accreditation process. Right. Because the only thing that a college degree, or what we'll call a

01:15:32.260 college degree for this conversation is, is just a business just believes that because it's

01:15:37.820 kind of been the practice over time. But if there's another college, hypothetically, that comes

01:15:43.880 along and it says, this person is just as qualified, if not more qualified, then all the business has to

01:15:53.020 do is be willing to accept that. Yeah. Well, we'd have to be able to demonstrate why that's the case,

01:15:57.580 but I've done assessment and evaluation for 30 years and I know how to do it. And I will make sure

01:16:03.000 that you won't get a certificate, a degree, let's say, from my institution, unless you know your

01:16:09.520 stuff. Now that doesn't mean I'm going to arbitrarily exclude people, but it will mean,

01:16:14.500 you know, if you, so imagine you hire someone to do degree and you say, well, what does that

01:16:18.400 guarantee the employer? Well, the person stuck to something for four years. So that's a good

01:16:25.020 indication of trait conscientiousness. And that's a good predictor of workplace performance and also

01:16:29.520 intelligence. And those are the best two predictors, right? And then you can assume that

01:16:33.480 the person, well, was able to manage their social life well enough. So they didn't get drummed out of

01:16:38.480 the bloody place, at least, you know, they made some friends and so forth. And you can assume a

01:16:42.820 certain degree of literacy and a certain degree of familiarity with ideas and the ability to

01:16:47.020 communicate, you know, and those are good things to know if you're going to be, if you're going to

01:16:50.560 hire, but those are things that can be tested very effectively. And I would say much more

01:16:55.600 effectively than they're typically tested in university. So we're going to go the quality

01:16:59.820 route rather than the accreditation route, I think. Right. I think. Yeah. I mean, well,

01:17:04.220 it may be a more lecturers too. And it may be important to people too. I think, you know,

01:17:09.040 having more information, that's not just, uh, just information like text and book information,

01:17:16.200 you know, about the people that they're hiring. I started this, I've been working with people in

01:17:20.900 the UK and Europe, Australia, the United States and Canada to produce an international organization

01:17:28.820 that's putting forward a different vision of the future. Okay. Okay. So the vision of the future

01:17:34.400 that we're generally confronted with now is an apocalyptic vision, which is that human industrial

01:17:40.720 activity and population increases such that we're essentially destroying our ecosystem. We're in a

01:17:46.860 crisis. If we don't get our climate emissions or carbon emissions under control within the next 50

01:17:52.340 years, we're going to hit a tipping point. The planet is going to spiral into global boiling and

01:17:57.160 everyone's going to die. Do you believe that? No, I think it's, I don't think there's a shred of

01:18:01.000 evidence for it. And the idea that 97% of scientists believe that's true is an absolute outright 100%

01:18:07.460 lie. I think the best estimate of the likely consequences of whatever degree of climate change are

01:18:15.880 occurring for whatever reason, I think they've been derived by Bjorn Lomborg. And he's going to speak

01:18:20.060 with me, by the way, I have a conference coming up. There's a conference coming up in the UK for the

01:18:26.660 Alliance for Responsible Citizenship. That's the name of this organization, ARC, A-R-C. So it's, it's got two

01:18:32.560 parts right now. We're going to do a conference in the UK, in London, October 30th, 31st and November 1st.

01:18:39.040 We've invited 1300 people to that. Okay. A lot of them are young social media influencers because

01:18:45.540 we want, we want to spread our idea to those people. So if they're captivated by it, let's say,

01:18:53.920 then they'll use their resources to distribute the idea. It's in London. I would maybe like to go.

01:18:58.960 Can people go? Come, come, come. I'll send you an invitation. Well, that's the next thing. So

01:19:03.380 we've sent out invitations to 1300. Now the problem with that is that you could argue that it's elitist.

01:19:08.880 You might have, well, I'll send you one. If you didn't, I'll send you one. Come, it should be a

01:19:12.560 remarkable three days. But at the end of it, we want the public to participate. And we're trying to

01:19:17.420 figure out how to do that. And the first public participation aspect will be, I rented the O2 in

01:19:24.240 London. And so it seats about 12,000, 15,000 people, depending on how many tiers you open up.

01:19:29.520 And we didn't know how many people would buy tickets. We sold about 7,500 tickets already.

01:19:33.960 So I think we'll sell the damn place out. But I'm going to speak there. And so is Douglas Murray.

01:19:39.220 And so is Jonathan Paggio, who's the deepest religious thinker I've ever met. And so is

01:19:44.300 Bjorn Lomborg. And we're going to talk about, the basic idea is something like this, is that,

01:19:49.220 you know, the human race and all the individuals that make it up have always faced an apocalyptic

01:19:54.680 future. You know, everybody dies and everyone, you know, is going to disappear. And like,

01:19:59.520 the catastrophes are coming your way. And obviously, societies face apocalyptic

01:20:04.960 circumstances as well. Whole Rome disappeared, Greece disappeared, you know. The apocalypse is

01:20:11.660 always there as a possibility in front of us, always. The question is, the fundamental question

01:20:16.920 is, how do you deal with a radically uncertain future? And one answer is, well, you panic and you

01:20:23.000 run around and you terrify everyone. And you use that club of fear to beat them into submission,

01:20:29.080 and you tyrannize them. And you do that while simultaneously claiming that you're saving the

01:20:34.300 planet. And you're not. You're just accruing power to yourself. I think tyrants use fear

01:20:40.440 to obtain compliance. And then you might say, well, what's the alternative to that? Well,

01:20:45.200 the alternative we're trying to put forward is, how about we offer you a good deal? It's like,

01:20:50.420 here's the future you could have. It'll be one where you could get ahead, you know, where you

01:20:54.520 could be autonomous, you have your freedom, where your life could be abundant, and so could the life

01:20:59.640 of your children. We're pro-family, and we're pro-children. And we believe that if human beings

01:21:04.780 acted ethically and communicated forthrightly, and aimed upward courageously, because you have to do it

01:21:12.040 courageously, given the possibility of the apocalypse, that there isn't a problem that we couldn't

01:21:17.480 solve. We could make the desert bloom. We don't have to enter the future with fear, you know,

01:21:22.880 apart from the fact that we're mortal and vulnerable. And so what's the goal of the of the

01:21:27.240 group? Is it just to have group think? Is it to start to kind of plant seeds in people's? Is it to

01:21:33.080 see where it goes? What's the goal of the fundamental goal, I would say of the conference and our initial

01:21:38.240 movements is to put forward the proposition that we could develop a vision for the future that was

01:21:44.520 voluntary, positive, concrete, practical, and not naive. And so so the notion would be we're not

01:21:51.020 going to close our eyes to the fact that the world's a dangerous place. Yeah. But we're going

01:21:55.600 to say, look, if we got our act together and aimed up, there's no limit to what we could accomplish. I

01:21:59.740 mean, look, already, in the last since the wall fell in 1989, the planet has got immeasurably richer.

01:22:07.600 You know, when I was a kid, the the notion of starvation in China and India and Africa, that was

01:22:15.500 par for the course that was happening all the time. That doesn't happen anymore. People only starve now

01:22:21.220 for political reasons and very rarely like and and that's despite the fact that there are eight

01:22:26.720 billion people on the planet when the doomsaying apocalypse mongers in the 1960s believed that we

01:22:33.340 would be overpopulated and starving at four billion by the year 2000. Right. That's always been kind

01:22:38.460 of a kickball that they are like a, you know, a political kind of kickball or I don't know if

01:22:43.020 it's political, but it's always been a thing. Yeah. Oh, we're gonna. Well, it's based on a faulty

01:22:46.740 biological model. So here's the model. Yeah, because every 20 years, they say in 20 years, 50 years,

01:22:52.300 we're going to be dead. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then 50 years later, we're like, oh, fuck, dude,

01:22:55.780 we're still living. Yeah. What are we supposed to do now? Well, there was a famous bet between this guy

01:23:00.640 named Paul Ehrlich, who was a Stanford biologist and a guy named Julian Simon, who was an economist

01:23:05.200 and Paul Ehrlich was a guy who thought he was a genius and Julian Simon was a genius and they had

01:23:10.980 a bet that they made in, I think in the early 1970s. And the bet was this Ehrlich was a man who wrote a

01:23:16.960 book called the population bomb. And he said, we were all going to be starving by the year 2000 and that

01:23:21.480 commodity prices, basic commodities would become extremely scarce and their price would skyrocket out

01:23:26.860 of sight. No one would afford anything. And we'd all die. That was his vision. And Simon said,

01:23:31.720 I'll bet you, here's the deal. You pick a basket of commodities. I don't care what you pick,

01:23:37.580 pick whatever you want. I'll bet you that by the year 2000, that not only are they not less expensive,

01:23:42.960 that they're much cheaper. And Ehrlich paid off Simon in the year 2000. And it's, and the same thing

01:23:49.120 has happened since is that basic commodities have got cheaper, not more expensive. And the reason for that

01:23:54.000 is, so the, the Malthusian model, which is what Ehrlich was working on was based on the idea that

01:24:00.960 biological organisms will multiply uncontrollably until they exceed the carrying capacity of the

01:24:07.060 environment. And then they'll precipitously collapse. And so if you have a Petri dish full

01:24:11.700 of agar, which, which mold will eat, for example, and you put mold in there, the mold will multiply until

01:24:17.440 it eats all the agar and then it will die. So that's a biological model. And you can apply that

01:24:23.360 modeling to lots of populations in the wild. And there are circumstances under which that will

01:24:29.680 occur. But the question is, well, are human beings well modeled by mold in a Petri dish? And the answer

01:24:35.640 to that is no. And there's a reason for that. There's a real reason for that, that Ehrlich should

01:24:40.080 know as a biologist. See, human beings are strange creatures because we evolved the ability to produce

01:24:47.140 virtual representations of ourselves. That's what a thought is. You know, when you dream of yourself or you

01:24:52.020 dream of another person, you've made an avatar of yourself or the other person in imagination, right?

01:24:58.220 It's virtual. A thought is a, thought is a virtual extension of you. Okay. So what human beings do is

01:25:05.040 they produce thoughts that multiply and all the ones that aren't useful die. Well, then the people don't

01:25:10.940 have to die. And so we've substituted the death of thought for the death of people. And what that also

01:25:17.420 means is that because we can transmute our thought and change it abstractly, we can change the manner

01:25:24.120 in which we act radically enough so we're not subject to Malthusian limitations. We can get more

01:25:29.440 from less all the time. You know, like we're, we're way more effective at propelling automobiles using

01:25:35.280 gasoline than we were 40 years ago. Way more efficient, way less pollution. We can get oil out of

01:25:41.180 shale and we couldn't do that at all 20 years ago. And we're getting Exxon announced, I think three

01:25:46.980 weeks ago that they'd figured out a way. I can't remember if it was to double oil shale production or to

01:25:52.120 double the amount of oil they could get out of exhausted oil reservoirs. Yeah. Yeah. This and that

01:25:57.260 happens all the time. Yeah. I mean, they're getting milk out of oats. They're getting, um, there's a new

01:26:03.320 company that is, uh, turning, there's this company, uh, Vespine. They're turning methane gas from like,

01:26:11.720 um, landfills, processing it as energy in the, like in the moment and mining Bitcoin with it and using

01:26:21.640 it for like data, uh, like energy to do data. People. So, so our vision at arc is essentially this,

01:26:28.200 is that there isn't a more valuable natural resource than human cognitive capacity. Okay.

01:26:33.440 And there's 8 billion of us. And that means there's a thousand, 8,000 people out there now

01:26:37.740 who are one in a million. Like if we could capitalize on our collective intelligence,

01:26:42.360 there's no limit to the number of problems we could solve. I don't think there's any reason at

01:26:46.940 all to assume that we couldn't have the abundant future that we would all dream of and maintain

01:26:53.520 harmony with the environment in a manner that we would deem acceptable indefinitely.

01:26:57.860 And I think the best way to interfere with that, both of those, the economic part of it and the

01:27:02.760 environmental part is to terrify people into tyrannical submission, to demolish the poor,

01:27:09.300 because that will happen immediately afterward and to have the whole goddamn house of cards

01:27:13.100 come tumbling down. We don't need to do that. So here's another fact.

01:27:17.100 We usually demolish the poor. What do you mean?

01:27:19.100 Well, if you make energy more expensive, well, who do you hurt?

01:27:23.480 Poor people.

01:27:24.000 Well, obviously. And every time you make any basic necessity, and there's no basic necessity,

01:27:28.560 more basic than energy.

01:27:29.920 Yeah.

01:27:30.220 As soon as you make that more expensive, you hurt the poor.

01:27:32.740 Yeah.

01:27:32.880 And you know, it's always the case, there's a pyramid of poor people, of wealth. There's a

01:27:37.720 small number of people at the top and they have most of the wealth. And then you go all the way

01:27:41.860 down to the bottom where most of the people are, and they're barely bloody well holding on.

01:27:46.240 And so if you add any more stress to the system, you knock a bunch of them off. They're no longer

01:27:51.280 able to hold to the side of the cliff and they just fall down. And you know, the Malthusian types

01:27:55.520 will say, well, there's too many people on the planet anyways. And I always read that as saying,

01:27:59.760 well, that means you'll sacrifice the poor to the planet because that's your bloody plan. And I think

01:28:04.480 that is absolutely 100% unconscionable. We should be working to drive energy costs down as low as

01:28:10.400 possible. You know, and I think nuclear is a really good option, but we should be using fossil

01:28:14.680 fuels, especially natural gas, like mad and getting the Indians and the Chinese, the Africans

01:28:20.400 getting their standard of living up. This is cool too. So if you get people to the point where

01:28:24.480 their income exceeds $5,000 a year per capita, they start taking a long-term view of the future

01:28:33.100 and worrying about environmental concerns locally. So while you imagine you're scrabbling around in the

01:28:37.780 dirt, like literally trying to worry about where your next meal is going to come from,

01:28:41.760 you're not really very concerned about environmental maintenance over the next three

01:28:45.220 generations. Yeah, you can't. Well, obviously. But as soon as you have enough money so that

01:28:50.860 you're not terrorized by poverty and so that you can start thinking about the future, immediately you

01:28:57.180 start caring about your local environment. And so what that means, I realized this about 15 years ago,

01:29:03.340 it actually means that the fastest way forward to true environmental sustainability is to eradicate

01:29:10.060 absolute poverty. So we could have our cake and eat it too. And that's, see, that's the sort of

01:29:14.740 thing that I think is an invitation is imagine the future is we eradicate poverty and everything's

01:29:21.660 greener. Well, that's a much better deal than degrowth. You know, you don't have heat in your house.

01:29:28.620 You don't get air conditioning. You don't get to fly. You don't get to have a car. You don't get to

01:29:32.760 crack a joke. You know, you're a bloody curse on the surface of the planet. There should be a lot

01:29:39.360 less of you. It's evil to have children. Your ambition is nothing but part of the bloody

01:29:43.740 patriarchal nightmare. It's like, I don't like that vision. And I think it will bring about the very

01:29:49.920 catastrophe that it's hypothetically designed to mitigate against. And what I would like in

01:29:58.600 instead is to offer people a vision where people listen and they say, Jesus, you know,

01:30:04.020 I could get on board with that. I could devote myself to that. That sounds like the kind of

01:30:08.100 future I'd like to have voluntarily, right? So I'm hoping people who come to the O2 event,

01:30:13.180 right? So that's the public part. Got it. We'll have about 15,000 people there. We've sold about

01:30:17.640 half the tickets. So if you want tickets, people who are listening, get them because they're going to

01:30:21.460 sell out. And I would also like everybody who comes, I made this program online at a site called

01:30:27.280 selfauthoring.com. It's called the Future Authoring Program. It helps people design a vision for

01:30:31.940 themselves. Yeah, we've talked about it before. Yeah, we have. We have. I'd like everybody who

01:30:35.080 comes to the ARC public event to do that so they can come with a personal vision in hand and then

01:30:41.940 they can start thinking, well, how can I ally my personal vision with this broader national and

01:30:46.940 international vision? I love that. We're looking forward to it. We're hoping this will be a beautiful

01:30:51.640 conference too. We have a lot of musicians coming. We have a lot of artists. It's not political,

01:30:55.760 man. It's motivational. Yeah. People love that stuff. I think it's really important. I think

01:31:01.160 any place that people can find motivation is really important. Yeah, that's the hallmark of

01:31:06.220 importance. If you're delivering a message and people say, oh my God, I could put that to work

01:31:12.520 in my life and that would motivate me to get up and get at it to face all the difficulties that I have

01:31:18.020 to face. And people have difficult things to face. If you can provide them with the means to do that,

01:31:23.680 that is the definition of value. Nietzsche said, he who has a why can bear any how. And so partly

01:31:30.580 what you do in your life is you look for a why that justifies the catastrophe, right?

01:31:35.400 Well, yeah, we've talked about that before. We've talked about that. I mean, there's one really

01:31:38.660 interesting thing you told me is like, you have to say, cause I was like, sometimes I remember

01:31:42.420 telling you, I'm afraid to set my goals because I don't want to have to hold myself responsible.

01:31:47.580 Yeah. Yeah. And you're like, of course, you're like, well, you have to set your goals. And also

01:31:52.060 you need to look at what your life would be like if you, if the worst things happen to you. So then

01:31:57.140 you have like a, something to stay away from. You have like a, this is not where I want to be,

01:32:01.980 you know? Um, and it gives your brain those parameters and then your brain can start to operate,

01:32:06.600 uh, better than if you were just kind of being aimless. Yeah. Well, you know, you can even ask

01:32:11.640 yourself these questions and you have to ask, which is very interesting. You can't tell yourself,

01:32:16.000 you might say, well, look, here are all the problems in my life, you know, and people,

01:32:19.820 I'm not particularly attractive. I have this given health problem. You know, I'm not a genius. I have

01:32:25.800 trouble with my parents. You know, I'm struggling forward on a variety of fronts. So those are real

01:32:30.540 problems and it's not just whining. And then you have to ask yourself, okay, given all that,

01:32:36.180 how would I have to configure my life so that it, I could justify all that or even celebrate it.

01:32:44.160 Right. And that's, that's a very hard thing to imagine through. It's like, well, you know,

01:32:48.620 I have a very sick child. Okay. Well, how do I have to set up my life so that I'm not embittered

01:32:54.260 and angry because of that? Well, who knows, right? You have to fantasize about that. You have to think,

01:32:59.780 well, you know, so for example, I'm working with my, my sister-in-law at the moment, she's taking care

01:33:06.120 of her sister who is suffering from dementia and it's really pretty bloody brutal and she's not that old.

01:33:11.380 And so my sister-in-law is taking care of her sister and that's hard work. You know,

01:33:16.240 and one of the things that Tammy and I have done, we don't live there. And so the bulk of the burden

01:33:21.500 has fallen on my sister-in-law, who's a wonderful person. And what we tried to do with her and her

01:33:26.840 husband is to say, we provided them with some support morally and financially. And part of that

01:33:31.560 is like, look, you're going to have to take a break now and then you're going to need a four day

01:33:35.620 weekend. You're going to have to go off with your husband. It's like, you've got this responsibility to

01:33:40.580 shoulder and it's tough. Under what circumstances could you do that? At least without bitterness,

01:33:46.400 that would be good, but maybe even joyfully, you know, I mean, that's pushing it. Right. But

01:33:51.600 it's not a bad aim if you can do it. And it gives you a, it's like, it's like, okay, now you have a

01:33:56.880 plan. You have, so you're not just aimless. Like so many of us are aimless. It's like, we're like,

01:34:03.520 why do I feel aimless? People ask me that all the time. Like, man, I feel so aimless. I don't know what to do.

01:34:07.980 Well, okay. So two things happen when you're aimless. Okay. So the first is you get anxious.

01:34:13.800 And the reason you get anxious is because anxiety computes aimlessness. So if you're, if you drop

01:34:20.260 someone in the middle of the desert, the reason they're anxious is because it's not because they

01:34:23.980 don't know which way to go. It's because there are way too many places to go, right? Every direction.

01:34:30.000 And that's aimlessness is like every direction beckons. That's way too complicated. And your brain

01:34:36.200 literally signals that with anxiety. Okay. So that's, so aimlessness and anxiety are the same

01:34:41.660 thing, but it's worse. Your brain is set up to produce positive emotion. Literally. This is what

01:34:48.860 the positive motion system does. It computes decrease between you and a goal. So if you have a goal and

01:34:56.260 you see that you've done something that moves you towards it, your brain produces a dopamine hit.

01:35:00.480 And that makes you feel good. And it strengthens the neural circuits that moved you forward.

01:35:05.400 It does both of those that's reward and reinforcement. And what that means is if you don't

01:35:09.920 have a goal, you have no positive emotion. And when people say, you know, they're aimless,

01:35:15.460 they're, they're partly telling you that they're anxious, but they're also telling you that they

01:35:18.580 have no positive emotion. So then you say, well, what short of goal should you have? Cause that's the

01:35:23.900 next question. Right. And the answer to that is, well, ask yourself. And this future authoring program

01:35:29.760 that I set up, it helps you do that. It's like, okay, here's the deal. Here's the deal. Maybe this

01:35:34.680 isn't true, but maybe it is. You can have what you want in five years, but there's two conditions.

01:35:41.960 You have to know what it is and you have to aim at it. Okay. Okay. So let's say you're willing to

01:35:48.320 play that game might be wrong. Cause who knows you're going to get run over by a bus tomorrow, but you

01:35:52.340 know, you're going to play the game. Okay. Now the next step is, all right. You probably want to have

01:35:58.320 an intimate relationship now, maybe not, but probably, but assuming you do imagine pretend

01:36:05.320 like you're a kid, you get to have an intimate relationship. What does it look like? What does

01:36:09.920 it look like when your wife greets you, when you come home from work, what does your sex life look

01:36:13.580 like? Right. What do you do for entertainment? How do you treat each other? You need a fantasy,

01:36:18.160 just like a little kid playing house, right? Figure out what you want, write it down, figure out what

01:36:23.560 you could do to start moving towards that. Okay. Do that with your family relationships. Do that with

01:36:29.640 your friendships. Do that with your career. Do that with your education. Think about your misuse

01:36:36.180 of alcohol and drugs and other things that might drag you down. If you want to drink, it's like,

01:36:40.360 you want to be a bumbling Barney Gumbel idiot. Like you want to drink. Okay. What do you mean by that?

01:36:45.640 Exactly? How often, how much is too much? How are you going to constrain that and why? Develop a vision.

01:36:50.800 And you have to do that in dialogue with yourself, right? It's like, if I could have what I wanted,

01:36:56.180 what would satisfy me? And you might think, well, I could never get that. And I could say,

01:37:00.740 well, maybe not, but I'll tell you one thing, man, you can move towards it. And I know that everyone

01:37:06.920 who knows the underlying neuroscience knows this. Almost all the pleasure is in the moving toward.

01:37:14.380 So even, you know, you don't want to set up a goal that's so high that there's just no possibility

01:37:18.880 that a schlub like you could ever manage it. But God only knows what your upper limit is,

01:37:22.700 you know, but, but if you set up a goal that you think is, you know, just on the edge of

01:37:29.340 conceivability, then every time you move even a tiny bit towards that, you're going to think,

01:37:33.700 good work, man. Good work. You get a little kick from that. You get a little stronger from that.

01:37:38.340 And that works like a charm. Yeah. Yeah. You bet. You bet.

01:37:41.680 An end of aimlessness. The end of aimlessness. That's the desert in Exodus. When the Egyptians

01:37:47.920 leave the Pharaoh, they leave tyranny, right? And everybody thinks, oh my God, we're out of tyranny.

01:37:53.680 Now it's freedom. Everything's great. That isn't what happens. They go into the desert. They're

01:37:58.360 aimless. They're slaves. They have no capacity for self-governance. They have no vision of their own.

01:38:04.580 They leave the tyranny. And now they're somewhere worse. They're out in the aimless desert. And part of the

01:38:10.180 reason people like tyranny, even their own, is because they don't want to be aimless in the

01:38:13.780 desert. It's why some people go back to prison. Absolutely. Absolutely. It's why the, after the

01:38:20.360 Soviet Union collapsed, it's why so much of the population was nostalgic for Stalin. You bet.

01:38:25.120 It's also why Lot's right. There's a story of Lot's wife. When Sodom and Gomorrah are destroyed,

01:38:29.720 she looks back. God turns her into a pillar of salt, right? You don't look back. When you escape

01:38:35.120 somewhere terrible, you don't look back and long to be there. But it means you have to develop a new

01:38:40.040 vision. Right. If you don't develop a new vision, then you can, you, part of you will look back

01:38:44.340 just because you want to have some organization. Your brain wants to have organization. Some

01:38:49.500 direction. Right. That's right. That's right. You'll take, here's another rule. This is a terrifying

01:38:53.520 rule. If you don't provide yourself with direction, you will take direction from a tyrant. Yeah. Right.

01:39:01.980 Right. So, and you might say, well, why should I take responsibility? You asked that, you know,

01:39:06.160 it was like, I'm afraid of my own goals because of the responsibility. It's like, well, you're either

01:39:10.160 going to be responsible to yourself or you're going to be responsible to a tyrant or you're going to be

01:39:16.020 absolutely lost. That's your option set. Yeah. Right. That's it. Yeah. That, pick one,

01:39:23.320 tyranny, slavery, or something approximating visionary self-determination. Yeah. Yeah. I'll tell you

01:39:30.220 something else that's so cool. I learned this in this Exodus seminar that I conducted with a bunch of

01:39:34.500 scholars. We put this online. I think I saw some of it online. Yeah. Yeah. It's good. It's doing

01:39:38.720 quite nice. Who's one of the guys at Os Guinness? Os Guinness. Yeah. Os Guinness. And there's a bunch

01:39:44.680 of people there, Jonathan Paggio, Greg Hurwitz, James Orr, a lot of people that I've met over the

01:39:49.980 years who are super bright. And I thought it would have something interesting to say. So one of the

01:39:54.340 things that happens when, when the Israelites leave the tyranny, now they're in the desert,

01:39:59.100 right? And they're there for three generations, by the way. Oh God. Right. Right. Right. I hate that.

01:40:03.340 My mother lives in Tucson and that's hard enough. Sometimes they go over that to get out there.

01:40:08.360 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So the people are wondering what will guide them and God shows up and he's a

01:40:15.480 pillar of fire at night and a pillar of darkness during the day. And Jonathan Paggio suggested that

01:40:21.540 that was the same kind of imagery as the Taoist image of chaos and order. So the Taoists believe that

01:40:27.420 the world is made out of chaos and order. It's very ancient conceptualization. It kind of means that

01:40:31.900 the world is made out of everything you don't understand and everything you understand. And

01:40:37.600 everything you understand, that's the domain of order and everything you don't understand, that's

01:40:41.860 the domain of chaos. And those two things are always interacting. You know, just when you think

01:40:45.660 you've got things for sure, it slips out from underneath you. Yeah. In the Taoist symbol, there's a black

01:40:53.660 serpent and a white one. And in the head of the black serpent, there's a white dot. And in the head of the

01:40:58.400 white serpent, there's a black dot. Everybody knows that symbol. And that means that order can

01:41:02.460 turn into chaos or chaos can turn into order. They're always playing. And you're supposed to

01:41:06.240 walk the line between them. Same thing shows up in the Exodus story. So God is light in the darkness

01:41:12.820 and darkness during the day. It's the interplay of chaos and order. And the way that makes itself

01:41:17.640 manifest in your life, this is actually literally true. This is how it works at a neuropsychological

01:41:23.160 level is that the instinct of meaning tells you that you've balanced, that you're balanced between

01:41:28.460 what you do understand and what you don't. You have to have one foot in what you know,

01:41:32.760 because otherwise you're terrified. But you have to have one foot out in what you don't know,

01:41:37.140 because otherwise you're not learning. And if you're playing, and if you're in an engrossing

01:41:41.100 conversation, you've got those things balanced. And that's what guides you in the desert.

01:41:46.160 It's that interplay. It's the interplay between opposites, the meaningful interplay between

01:41:50.740 opposites that guides you when you're lost. That's exactly right.

01:41:54.220 Between safety and uncertainty, kind of?

01:41:56.240 Yeah, yeah. Well, and that's where you want to play, right? Because imagine that you're

01:42:00.940 playing pickup basketball with someone. You might think, well, what's the point? And the answer is

01:42:05.500 to win. And so then the question is, well, why not play your like five-year-old nephew and just

01:42:11.160 stomp him? 100 baskets for you, zero baskets for the little bastard, right? You win. Well,

01:42:18.180 no one's happy about that. You're not, weirdly enough, because you won. He's not, because you

01:42:23.740 crushed him. So you might think, well, why the hell not? Because the point is to win. And that's

01:42:28.700 not true. The point is to play a challenging game on the edge of your skill so that you get better.

01:42:35.000 And to do that, you need to have a worthy adversary, right? That's actually the biblical

01:42:40.120 model, by the way, for marriage. That's what's supposed to happen in a marriage is that this

01:42:44.960 playful tension of opposites that compels development, right? And that's when, well,

01:42:50.580 the playful teasing that can be part of a romantic relationship is part of that, you know, that

01:42:54.680 provocate, continual playful provocation that pushes you forward. It's not stability or security.

01:43:01.440 That's too dull. Dostoevsky knew that that was his fundamental critique of utopian socialism.

01:43:06.960 He said, if you gave everybody what they wanted permanently, the first thing they would do was smash

01:43:12.580 it to bits just so that something weird and interesting could happen.

01:43:15.300 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. People want, they want to have a little bit of a, you know,

01:43:19.800 they want to peep out the window and see what the neighbors are doing, you know? They want to have

01:43:23.920 something like that. Do you feel like in, like in America that we've become, because we were kind

01:43:29.480 of a Christian nation, right? Yeah. Yeah. Right? Wait, like people left England because they wanted to

01:43:34.520 have religious freedom, right? Yeah. And do you feel like we've kind of become a godless,

01:43:39.300 more godless over time? No, I just think we started worshiping false gods. I don't think,

01:43:45.520 I don't think that you can be godless. I don't think you can be godless the same way you can't

01:43:50.600 be aimless. Like, look, if you're aimless, you know, the old saying, the devil finds work for

01:43:54.640 idle hands. Oh yeah. If you're aimless, something will come for you. Yeah. Yeah. Oh yeah. You'll be

01:43:59.960 at a whim of whatever. Yeah. That's it. You don't have, yeah. Okay. You're not blowing into your

01:44:04.020 sails and something else will. That, that's for sure. So, so that's the crucial issue is that, you know,

01:44:08.480 people say, well, you don't have to orient yourself towards anything transcendent. Nothing

01:44:11.980 transcendent exists. It's like, yeah, okay. Dispense with that. See what comes along to fill it.

01:44:19.200 And people will say, well, the self does. It's now the self. It's like, no, it's not. It's the lowest

01:44:23.460 possible. It's the lowest possible whims of the self, right? You think, well, I should be able to do

01:44:30.000 what I want whenever I want. It's like, what I are you referring to exactly here? So you mean,

01:44:35.340 if you get angry, you should just be able to around, you should let that possess you and you

01:44:39.100 should stomp around. Hey, that's the war God, Mars. So that's your God now or Venus, right? Lust,

01:44:44.880 for example. Yeah. Yeah. Then you'd be looking at pornography. Yeah. You're just, yeah. I think

01:44:48.980 maybe we're just, we've got some really bad gods right now. Yes. That's definitely the case. And

01:44:53.220 what happens is if the, if the, if the unifying, the biblical corpus is a very strange collection

01:44:59.520 of stories because it, it, it tells a bunch of different pictures about God. And then it says,

01:45:04.860 or it shows a bunch of different pictures of God. And then it says, those are unified.

01:45:11.360 There's something at the top. This is so cool. I'm writing a new book called We Who Wrestle

01:45:15.700 With God. And it's an explanation of this. Oh gosh, tag me into the ring, dude. Hey man,

01:45:19.580 it's coming along. It'll be out in March. So, so here's, here's how the story works. It's so cool.

01:45:24.260 It's so ridiculously cool. So there, it's a set of narrative propositions about the highest unifying

01:45:30.740 spirit. Okay. Okay. So in the story of Noah, so this is a definition of God. This is the thing to

01:45:37.660 understand. If you're a wise person and you're a good person, so that's Noah, there'll be times when

01:45:43.660 you have an intuition that tells you that you better prepare because bad times are coming. Okay.

01:45:49.320 If you've been clear headed and far seeing, if you've conducted yourself properly,

01:45:54.260 that's a spirit you should attend to. It might be that survival itself depends on it.

01:46:00.160 That intuition, that's God. This is definition. That's what God is. Okay.

01:46:05.040 That's what Noah said. That's, that's what the story of Noah means. Yes. Okay. But that's,

01:46:09.680 that doesn't. Cause he got the intuition that the flood was coming. Yeah. Right. Right. And,

01:46:13.340 and the story insists that he was a wise man. So he's no fool who's running around thinking,

01:46:18.160 the sky is falling. He's like a wise man looking forward and saying, look,

01:46:21.820 trouble's coming. Yeah. Prepare. He's locked in. Right. Right. Okay. Next story is the story of

01:46:27.060 the tower of Babel. Okay. So what happens in the tower of Babel is that men decide to build these,

01:46:32.840 they're called ziggurats. And a ziggurat is a building stretching to heaven. Okay. It's a seven

01:46:37.800 period representation of heaven. And the, the emperors in the area of that time, including the

01:46:43.420 Babylonian empire would build these extremely high ziggurats buildings to show that they were the top

01:46:48.880 God, but they weren't God. And so these were, they're false, they're false idols. They're false

01:46:55.760 pyramids. They're attempts to stretch up to heaven based on the wrong principle. And God in that

01:47:02.640 story. You can't use construction to get there. Well, Stalin wasn't God. Right. Right. Right. And

01:47:08.880 neither was Mao. And they built very large pyramids that were very unstable and they collapsed and killed

01:47:14.480 everyone. Right. And so God in that story is the spirit that punishes those who build false

01:47:21.780 pyramids. Right. That there's something that should be at the top. And if you don't put the proper thing

01:47:27.080 at the top, you'll build a false ideology, a false structure, and all, everything will come tumbling

01:47:33.420 down. What's so cool in that story, this is so cool. When people strive improperly toward heaven

01:47:40.460 and they do that according to the wrong principles, they end up unable, unable to communicate with each

01:47:47.020 other. And that's, what's happening in our culture. You see, we can't even agree on what a woman is.

01:47:52.140 And I'm not making a joke about this. Yeah, no, it's tough. Yeah. So that means we've,

01:47:57.340 because we've been following, we've been erecting false pyramids. We've fractured so badly. We can't

01:48:04.800 agree on what the basic elements of reality are. Yeah. And does that usually correct itself or what

01:48:10.760 happens? Like, because we've never been in this time where we have this like reflective, like...

01:48:17.360 Two things always happen. Okay. Either God decides that he's had enough and everything goes,

01:48:23.120 or everybody covers themselves in sackcloth and ashes and repents and reorients themselves,

01:48:30.200 in which case things regenerate and they move on. That's the standard story. What do you think is

01:48:34.860 going to happen? Depends on how... See, what happens in the Exodus story, it's a real good example of

01:48:42.500 this, is that the pharaoh has put himself on a false pedestal. And the consequence of that is that

01:48:47.760 worse and worse things start to happen to Egypt. That's the sequence of plagues. And each plague gets

01:48:53.580 a little worse. Well, that's what happens is that things will just get worse in waves of crisis

01:49:01.580 until we admit to our error and reorient ourselves appropriately. And that can be... So what happens

01:49:09.280 in the Exodus plagues is that first of all, the whole world comes undone and then the future is

01:49:15.180 destroyed. That's the last plague. That's the death of the firstborn. Yeah. Yeah. Well, we're doing that

01:49:19.900 already. Like we're way below replacement in terms of birth rate. Yeah. The abortion stats,

01:49:25.940 you know, Gavin Newsom tweeted out the other day, something about handguns being the prime killer

01:49:30.000 of kids in the U.S. It's like, it's not even close to abortion. Yeah. Oh yeah. I mean, I think I've

01:49:35.760 even, I probably paid for one or two to be honest, man, sadly, or, you know, or chipped in on them,

01:49:41.180 I think. Do you think that nature hears that when we do abortions and stuff? Like, do you ever think

01:49:48.100 like, sometimes I think there's like this, like, what is nature thinking the whole time about our

01:49:53.100 behaviors? You know, like wonder what, like, well, the thing is, is that we're all punished for what

01:49:58.680 we put at the top, right? Because you, you're the structure that you use to orient yourself in your

01:50:07.320 life is dependent on your values. And you might say, well, if you don't value human life, let's say

01:50:13.600 above all, well, then you don't value yourself above all. You value something else above that.

01:50:20.400 You're going to pay for that in one way or another. Now you might say, well, that's a price that I think

01:50:24.700 is worth paying, or I don't think that human beings should be put on the top. You know, that's your

01:50:29.300 prerogative, but you pay for, you will absolutely 100% pay in full for everything that you've done

01:50:37.460 and for everything that you haven't done. I mean, how can it be otherwise? Yeah. You know, it's like,

01:50:42.600 what are you going to do? You're going to, reality isn't going to make itself manifest because of

01:50:47.080 your whim. That's not going to happen. Yeah. So, and you know, you can think about that

01:50:52.580 religiously or not. It's, there's no escaping from what is. Right. You know, and I've been,

01:50:57.860 I'm going to write a chapter soon on the book of Job, and it's a very interesting book, eh?

01:51:02.140 Because what happens in that book is that it's really a shocking book. What happens is that God has a

01:51:08.600 bet with Satan, which is, you know, a little ethically questionable, let's say. Yeah.

01:51:14.580 This would be a good time for a DraftKings ad too. I'm just joking, but that'd be funny.

01:51:17.720 Job's a good guy. Uh-huh. And Satan gets word of him, and he knows God's happy with him,

01:51:23.540 and he goes to God, and he says, you know, Job, you know that guy you think so great? I don't think

01:51:28.200 he's so great. I think if you let me torture him, I can make him denounce you and lose faith.

01:51:33.600 And God says, I don't think so. He's yours. And, you know, people in their lives, you know,

01:51:40.880 sometimes people, they'll enter a period where all hell is breaking loose, and everything seems

01:51:45.540 to be conspiring against them. So these things happen. And so Job, it's like,

01:51:50.140 first of all, his whole family's destroyed, then everything he owns. So that's act one. Then

01:51:58.080 Satan curses him with a terrible skin disease. Yeah, that's tough. Right, right. And then he has to

01:52:03.400 sit in the ashes, scraping himself. And then his friends come along and tell him that he must have

01:52:08.240 done something wrong, because otherwise the universe wouldn't be conspiring against him.

01:52:11.860 So that's about as bad as it gets, right? Yeah. Right. And then God himself comes along and says,

01:52:17.480 who are you to complain about your fate? Right now, if you don't think that's going to happen to you in

01:52:23.320 your life, you're not very smart, because that is going to happen to you in your life. So then the

01:52:27.800 question is, what the hell should you do about it? And one answer would be, well, that sucks.

01:52:32.460 It's God and Satan against you. You know, you're kind of outmatched. It's completely unfair because

01:52:38.480 you were good. And everything that you valued is taken away from you. So what should you do? You

01:52:43.460 know, when you shake your fist at the sky and raise a middle finger and say, fuck you, you know,

01:52:47.500 like now I'm on the side of Cain and the devils, and I'm going to be resentful and bitter.

01:52:52.020 And people might look and think, well, it's no wonder you're resentful and bitter. Like you lost

01:52:56.980 your whole family. You have a terrible disease. Your friends are laughing at you. Right. So you

01:53:01.600 have every reason. That isn't what happens in the story. Job decides that no matter what happens to

01:53:07.440 him, and he means that, no matter what happens to him, he's going to maintain his ethical orientation

01:53:13.380 and aim up. And I think that's, but then you think, look, man, forget about the religious

01:53:19.440 trappings. Here's hell. Hell is when you get cancer. And then you're bitter and resentful

01:53:28.080 about it. And you make your last six months a living fucking nightmare. Right. And so you

01:53:32.960 might say, well, you've got cancer and that sucks. And no doubt it sucks. And maybe it's

01:53:36.360 unfair. And probably it is. And maybe even, you know, God and Satan themselves bet against

01:53:40.680 you. You're going to aim up and maintain your dignity and your integrity? Or are you going

01:53:45.180 to take a bad situation and make it into every goddamn nightmare you can possibly imagine?

01:53:50.680 Think, well, of course you have to aim up no matter what happens to you. And you think,

01:53:55.780 well, that's not fair. It's like, well, it's better than the alternative. Yeah. And what

01:53:59.900 does fair have to do with it? What's your choice? You're going to dig a deeper pit? Or are you

01:54:06.500 going to be, are you going to have some integrity in the face of life's catastrophe? You know, and

01:54:12.060 I think we know the answer to that because when you meet people who have integrity in

01:54:17.140 the face of catastrophe, you're struck with admiration for them. Yeah. Right. Right. So

01:54:21.880 that's your heart speaking, man. It's like, I don't know how you do it, but you know, I

01:54:28.140 can't help but be in awe. I know I have a friend, a very well-known Canadian, and he

01:54:34.020 got into some business trouble about 10 years ago, 15 years ago, and he had a great fortune

01:54:38.940 and a huge business empire and he lost every bit of it. Wow. And then they put him in prison.

01:54:44.400 Right. And he lost all his, he lost everything. And he lost almost all of his friends. And

01:54:49.440 they put him in prison in Florida, in a rough prison. He wrote a book there and he got 200

01:54:53.960 people through high school. Wow. Yeah. No kidding. Wow. He chose, that was his choice. Yeah.

01:55:00.920 He was like, even though it's as bad as it can get, I'm going to have some dignity for myself.

01:55:05.300 Yeah. And do some good. Right. And he did. He's still in touch with the people that he

01:55:09.840 got through high school. He said every single person he tutored graduated. Wow. No kidding.

01:55:14.140 Wow. That's admirable. That's for sure. And surprising. It's how when people react, whenever

01:55:19.760 it's going tough, that's really where you see people. Yeah. Well, and you want to have a vision

01:55:24.320 of yourself in a situation like that too. It's like, maybe you're, look, part of the Christian

01:55:30.940 injunction. We were talking about Christianity earlier. So there's the fundamental Christian

01:55:35.020 injunction is that you, you pick up your cross and you march uphill. What does that mean? Well,

01:55:40.980 it means that's true for everybody. What's the cross? You're going to die, you know, and you're

01:55:46.680 probably going to suffer when you die. And probably along the way, the mob is going to come for you

01:55:51.920 and people are going to betray you. That's all going to happen to you. And so how should you react to

01:55:57.140 that? Well, one answer is to be bitter and resentful and cruel and make things worse or to

01:56:02.100 give up. And you could do that and you could make a case for why, but obviously all that's going to

01:56:08.340 do is make it worse. Or you can think, Jesus, maybe there's enough to me so that I could actually

01:56:13.680 do that voluntarily. And I could do it positively and I could withstand it. And you know, maybe that

01:56:20.420 is the sort of thing you are, you know, who the hell knows? It's where you really find out who you are.

01:56:25.700 Yeah. It's scary sometimes to really ask yourself who you are, you know, and really answer it

01:56:30.600 earnestly. Well, you came from a poverty stricken background and you've done well. And you know,

01:56:34.820 you talked to me about having some trepidation about making your goals conscious and try to

01:56:42.100 realize them, but you've pursued success and you've been successful. What do you think you did right that

01:56:48.560 enabled you to aim for success? And also, you know, my sense is that you've straightened yourself out a lot

01:56:54.820 and that along with the opportunities, you haven't let the opportunities that come, that have come

01:56:59.660 your way, drag you down or destroy you. And they could have, they do with lots of people in the

01:57:04.100 entertainment industry. Yeah. And you, you make fun of your past, you know, in a great way. It's

01:57:09.120 extremely hilarious. Like, what do you think you did right that put you forward? Hmm. Well, uh,

01:57:18.440 I didn't give up on myself, you know, I don't know if that's, that's kind of a vague statement,

01:57:24.520 I think in some ways. Um, well, why would that be the one that comes to mind first? Like,

01:57:29.780 were you tempted to give up on yourself? Did, did your environment insist that you should have?

01:57:34.820 Yeah. I think I probably, uh, I think I, part of me waged war against what I thought I was,

01:57:42.740 where I thought society expected me to be. Yeah. And where did you think society expected you to be?

01:57:51.020 Probably my lot in life was supposed to be, you know, not successful, maybe not having much

01:57:58.340 opportunity, um, looked at as a societal liability maybe. Um, you know, like I felt like I was born

01:58:06.940 into an environment where, uh, I wasn't supposed to have, um, uh, success or opportunity probably,

01:58:16.160 you know, and I was supposed to be okay with that kind of. Right. Okay. So why didn't that make you

01:58:21.720 bitter or did it? And why, and what did you do? Do you think that work that moved you forward

01:58:28.120 beyond that? And why were you able to accept that even? Yeah, I think, uh, I think what I did that

01:58:36.260 helped me move beyond that probably was, I think probably make a decision within myself that I

01:58:42.320 was going to do something different than that. Do you remember when you decided that or was it a

01:58:48.780 sequence of decisions? I think it was probably a sequence of decisions and I think it was always

01:58:52.480 there somewhere, you know, but sometimes it was guided by anger. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Fair enough.

01:58:59.120 So it wasn't always guided by like pot, like, you know, uh, positive energy. There's a,

01:59:06.040 there's a scene in the, it was a grudge. It was like I had an enemy, you know, and it was the

01:59:10.380 world. There's a scene in the gospels where Christ is being tempted in the desert. And I think I might

01:59:17.380 be putting two stories together, but it doesn't exactly matter. They work together. He says,

01:59:21.820 get thee behind me, Satan. I think he actually says that to Peter. It doesn't matter, but it means

01:59:26.460 something very specific. You know, you talked about anger, like anger is an extremely useful emotion.

01:59:31.460 Trump is very good at using it, by the way. You can see that in his mugshot, for example.

01:59:36.680 Well, you know, that anger that you had, if that's integrated and it's behind you, it's not anger,

01:59:42.480 it's determination. Right, right. So integrated anger is no longer a vice. It's a, it's a,

01:59:48.080 it's a hallmark or strength of character. That's the integration of the shadow from the union

01:59:52.280 perspective, right? You can't be namby pamby and nice. That's not good enough. You shouldn't be

01:59:58.840 dominated by anger because it makes you bitter. But that force, like anger is a non-trivial force,

02:00:05.400 right? It's a huge biological circuit. You want to have that sucker on your side. And if it can

02:00:10.640 orient you upward, it makes you unstoppable. Yeah. I think that was a lot of it for me,

02:00:15.820 finding some good role models, listening to people. I think that was helpful. You know,

02:00:20.280 I had a brother that was really, really helpful. I have a brother that's really amazing. So that was

02:00:23.860 great. I think over time, he's two years older than me. What has he done? He's done. He started

02:00:29.720 a tree company that did well. And, um, he got sober. Um, and then he started a family and now he

02:00:37.280 like does his own like farms at home. And he likes to, he's learning about that kind of stuff,

02:00:42.160 like living off the land and stuff. But he's, um, he's like a child therapist too. He really loves

02:00:47.880 like learning about children and, and, uh, he was a great model, especially because we'd had a kind

02:00:53.740 of traumatic childhood. So he learned about a lot of that and how to help children. And so he was

02:00:58.220 able to kind of help me. So I think that was very helpful. Um, and wanting to do things on my own,

02:01:04.320 just deciding that I really wanted to do things, you know, um, and starting to surround myself with

02:01:09.900 people that were doing things, you know, I think that that was, yeah, well, that's a useful,

02:01:14.300 you know, being in the right wake, you know, being in the wake of people that were doing things.

02:01:19.200 Yeah. Yeah. Well, it's good. You want to be around people that celebrate your successes.

02:01:23.360 You want to be around people that commiserate with your failures without letting you off the hook.

02:01:27.480 You want to be around people that are aiming up, not people that'll drag you back down.

02:01:31.680 You know, this often happens to people who are trying to quit drinking. Yeah. You know,

02:01:35.020 their friends, their friends will tempt them. And sometimes it's a bit of a provocation. It can be

02:01:39.580 playful, but some of the time it's like, well, who the fuck are you to escape?

02:01:42.960 Hmm. You know, you get back down here in the mire with us. You think you're better than us,

02:01:47.540 do you? You know, and a lot of misery comes from that. I think doing my own thing, I just,

02:01:53.260 I kind of start, I like charting my own course. I like doing the thing that other people weren't

02:01:57.420 doing. I always liked that because I didn't see the odds were better if it was me by myself doing

02:02:04.600 something different than if it were me amongst many doing the same thing. And I felt for some reason

02:02:11.200 that the odds were better because there's no, it was just me. Yeah. Okay. So one of the,

02:02:17.780 somebody looked over, like, I don't like what this guy's doing, but they knew it was me doing it.

02:02:21.120 Right. Right.

02:02:21.460 Whereas opposed to, oh, if I look over here and everybody's doing this, I don't even know if

02:02:25.100 this guy stands out. Well, that's the other advantage of taking responsibility, you know,

02:02:28.460 because, so we talked about Noah and we talked a little bit about the tower of Babel. So one of the

02:02:34.060 next stories in, in the old Testament is the story of Abraham and Abraham has rich parents and he has

02:02:40.800 the option of just like laying around and eating peeled grapes for the rest of his life, you know,

02:02:44.840 with naked slave women waving palm fronds over them. Yeah. A voice comes to him and says,

02:02:50.580 get the hell out there and have your adventure. And it's a, it's, it's not the same situation as you

02:02:57.640 were in because Abraham comes from privilege, but it's the same idea, right? It's like, well,

02:03:02.120 Abraham has everything anyone could want. In fact, he's quite old by the time he launches himself out

02:03:06.800 of his nest. And you might say, well, why the hell bother? Cause you've already got everything

02:03:11.020 that everyone wants. If you want peeled grapes and, you know, naked slaves waving palm fronds over

02:03:15.860 you. And he goes out and he has quite a cataclysmic adventure, you know, war, death, destruction,

02:03:22.480 famine, tyranny, the whole bloody mess, but he has an adventure. Yeah. And so what's cool about that

02:03:28.980 story? And this is another way that this unifying spirit is presented is that God is presented as

02:03:34.980 the spirit that calls you to adventure, right? That's a definition, right? Cause the question is,

02:03:40.860 what should you put at the top? And what you put at the top is what you follow by definition.

02:03:45.720 Yeah. No, and you said, well, you had an intuition that you should go and do your own thing,

02:03:49.620 right? And that it would be okay if that led forward and to success. And that's, well,

02:03:54.800 that's a kind of spirit, right? It's something that calls to you. It's not something you invent.

02:03:58.140 You saw it in your brother, like other people have it. It's, it's in the world, you know,

02:04:02.180 it's, it's part of the spiritual realm. That's a reasonable way of thinking about it. And you can,

02:04:06.380 you can pay attention to it and follow it or not. Yeah. It feels like we used to probably be so much

02:04:10.360 more connected to the spiritual realm when we didn't create this other kind of pseudo spiritual

02:04:15.460 realm that we have now with like, uh, once like computers and cell phones and stuff, we kind of have

02:04:20.540 this, uh, filter between us and like the spiritual realm. It feels like, or this whole other spiritual

02:04:26.020 realm, like this reflective pond, you know, that, um, that isn't always really positive. Um,

02:04:33.060 whenever you and I talked one time, we talked about like, uh, success and like what that would be like,

02:04:39.700 like, we were both starting to have some success like five years ago, whenever we first spoke.

02:04:44.000 And whenever like you look back on, like, if you look back at success, like what are, or do you feel

02:04:49.440 like there's ways you've handled success well and things you ways that you didn't, that you haven't

02:04:53.780 handled it well, or that you didn't know that it was like, have there been some surprises about it?

02:04:58.140 Like, cause we've had an interesting experience in life to have some popularity, some pub publicization,

02:05:04.940 right? It's interesting. And how like our ego battles through that, like, you know, um, I think,

02:05:11.260 have there been anything, things that you've learned about yourself, like through some of that? Cause

02:05:14.960 it's, it's an interesting experience. A lot of people don't have it.

02:05:17.520 Well, I've tried to be, I've tried to maintain like a stance of amazed gratitude. I've tried to

02:05:26.040 be sure that I don't ever take it for granted. Like my wife and I talk a lot while we're on the

02:05:30.160 road, like before every show, really, we try to get our attitude in order. We have music before the

02:05:35.440 shows and that helps, but the right attitude is there's 5,000 people here. That's impossible.

02:05:41.200 You're an idiot. If you take that for granted, it's so improbable. And they've all spent time and

02:05:46.160 money getting here. They've all put in a lot of effort. They're here because they want something

02:05:50.280 good to happen. You better be on your knees and, and thankful that this unlikely occurrence is

02:05:56.400 happening. Cause you could be walking down the road and people could be throwing stones at you

02:06:01.060 and that'd be a lot worse. And so, and my wife's been very helpful with that too, because she's,

02:06:06.440 she went through quite a trial in the last few years and she's pretty damn happy that she's not,

02:06:13.280 you know, burning in hell, so to speak. So I think that I was shocked probably by the magnitude of

02:06:23.680 pain that I saw in the world. You know, I didn't understand how many people there were out there who

02:06:30.920 were essentially dying for lack of an encouraging word. And it was very hard on me, positive in a way,

02:06:37.140 but also very hard to hear thousands of stories of people who would say, you know, I was falling

02:06:43.800 apart five years ago. Here's 10 things that were going wrong with my life. I was hopeless, nihilistic,

02:06:49.440 depressed, drug addicted, in jail, on the street, no relationship, you know, what the various hells

02:06:54.940 people can find themselves in and say, well, you know, I started to try to tell the truth and aim up

02:07:01.520 and everything got way better. And now my life's put together. And, you know, that's really positive.

02:07:07.380 But what's terrible about it is that I didn't know that there was such a lack of encouragement.

02:07:17.700 I didn't know that lack of encouragement was so endemic in our culture. I didn't know how many people

02:07:22.740 were suffering because of that. That's partly why Trump is so popular. You know, like people feel that

02:07:28.400 Trump is a champion for their disaffected lives. And I think there's some truth to that, to tell

02:07:35.280 you the truth. I think Trump, for whatever else he might be, he obviously can connect with working

02:07:40.560 class people. And that's, you got to look at that. He's got to be doing something. He's doing something

02:07:45.600 that's addressing that problem. And it's a deep problem. It's a terrible problem, you know? And

02:07:51.220 and so I did have some trouble swallowing that, let's say. It hurt me.

02:07:58.660 Was it hard? Like, there was a time when I, when I was having some, like, whenever I was getting more,

02:08:03.020 I get, you know, just more popular to say, because that's probably the way to say it. Like,

02:08:07.420 I started thinking that, like, God, I thought, oh, God, like, I have some larger responsibility to God,

02:08:14.560 like, in a way, like that, but that was kind of scary at first, because I was like, holy shit,

02:08:19.280 this is like a lot of responsibility, I feel like. Yeah. And it wasn't really like,

02:08:25.120 like, um, I don't know, it was just scary, like with my ego. It's like, well, how do I be careful

02:08:32.000 here not to think that I'm, there's something really special about me? It's okay to have some

02:08:37.300 self-worth, and this is helping me have some self-worth, but how do I not let that, you just

02:08:42.400 fill up my ego cup first? Yeah, right. Well, I think, I think a huge part of that is gratitude,

02:08:47.400 right? I think, I think that's the antithesis of that, and I think that that's a practice,

02:08:52.840 right? You, you got to pinch yourself constantly and think, well, look, here we are, we're in this

02:08:57.360 studio, we're going to have the opportunity to talk to a million people, and like, how remarkable is

02:09:02.240 that, and how much of a fool would we have to be not to be just absolutely thrilled about that,

02:09:06.760 and then to take that responsibility seriously? You know, one of the things our culture has a real

02:09:11.180 problem with is the idea of privilege, unearned privilege. It's like, well, you had all those

02:09:15.220 advantages. Okay, well, you have a bunch of advantages now, and so then a question really

02:09:20.540 arises. It's like, well, lots of other people don't have those advantages. Like, why you, and then what

02:09:25.560 the hell are you supposed to do about that? And the answer is, you're supposed to take responsibility

02:09:30.720 for it. Now, you've got all these opportunities and these advantages, and that means that to balance

02:09:37.680 out the cosmic scales properly, you better do a job that's as good as your opportunities are allowing

02:09:43.880 you. And I would say, if you don't, well, you'll get arrogant, you'll start to take it for granted,

02:09:50.020 you'll start hurting people and yourself, and the whole goddamn thing will come tumbling down.

02:09:54.040 So you'll pay for it. So you pay for your privilege by growing ethically. That's what you do. And that

02:10:01.140 enables you also to be successful without being guilty. It's like, you know, because people might

02:10:05.740 say, well, what the hell are you doing with your money or with your opportunities? And if you can say,

02:10:10.140 well, here's 10 things I'm doing, you know, and, and, and if I scour my conscience, those seem like

02:10:17.500 the right 10 things to be doing with all this opportunity, then the guilt longers can't come

02:10:23.000 along and say, well, you know, who are you to have what you have? And we don't want people to be able

02:10:27.960 to say that because if no one can have anything, then no one can have anything. And that's a recipe

02:10:35.320 for poverty and catastrophe. Yeah. I got to do a better job or not a better, but I have to,

02:10:40.100 I think for all, I was scared too. Like of just like, yeah, it was just scary. Like when they're,

02:10:45.140 if you get popular, it's kind of scary. Oh yeah. You know, you're, it's like, definitely like I've

02:10:49.620 gone through a lot of social anxiety. Like when I'm out around, like there's just like a lot of

02:10:53.840 strange things that happen to you're trying to balance and then just still manage your own life at

02:10:59.060 the same time. Um, but yeah, I think it's a, that's a good note to make sure that I just have some

02:11:04.380 things in place that I feel like I'm, and that's when I feel my brain and heart a lot of times,

02:11:08.360 like, okay, how can we do something positive for somebody else today? How can I not think about

02:11:13.180 myself? Well, that's also a really useful technique by the way, for social anxiety. So

02:11:18.100 if you're feeling social anxiety in a situation, part of the reason for that is because you're

02:11:24.240 thinking about how you're feeling, what you should be doing. So here's an interest. Here's something

02:11:28.940 very interesting. If you look at what people say and what they write and you take the words they use,

02:11:34.380 and you analyze them and you look at how many times they refer to themselves,

02:11:38.820 the more they refer to themselves, the more likely they're to be, they are to be depressed or psych or,

02:11:43.600 or, or psychotic, right? You can actually distinguish with 75% accuracy between people

02:11:49.940 who are clinically depressed or clinically psychotic and people who aren't by the number of times they

02:11:54.580 refer to themselves. Literally, the more you think about yourself, the more miserable you are.

02:12:00.540 Literally, they're that tight. So, so what you do if you're in a situation that's social and you get

02:12:05.620 anxious, because you start thinking about, you know, you start sweating and you wonder how you're

02:12:09.400 looking. Yeah, are my legs the same length? Stuff like that. Exactly, exactly. And so what you try to do is

02:12:17.200 you try to make the people around you more comfortable. You switch your attentions, like, stop, it isn't that

02:12:23.700 you have to stop thinking about yourself because you can't. If you stop thinking about yourself, you're

02:12:28.000 thinking about yourself and you fall into that pit. But if what you decide to do is to make, pay way

02:12:33.460 more attention to the other person and try to make them comfortable, then that social anxiety will

02:12:38.600 disappear right away. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's a really good technique. You know, I found too, like you,

02:12:43.980 when you meet people, I don't know if you've learned to do this or not, but like when, when, when people

02:12:47.760 come up to be saying the meet and greets and so forth or on the street, everybody has a tempo.

02:12:52.460 Some people come up quick. Some people come up slow. If you match that tempo, you put them at

02:12:57.740 ease right away. And that's part of paying it. It's such fun. They, they, it, it creates a bond

02:13:03.920 right away because they notice really unconsciously that you're paying attention to them. It's like a

02:13:10.880 dance. It's like the first step in a dance, you know, and I always ask people their name because if

02:13:14.720 they get nervous, well, most people can remember their name. I have a tough time feeling proud of

02:13:19.060 myself. Yeah. Yeah. And I just wanted to think about that with you for a couple minutes. Um,

02:13:25.960 yeah, I just have a really tough time feeling gin, like, you know, people are always like,

02:13:30.580 you should feel proud of yourself, you know, and it's really tough for me to do that.

02:13:35.020 Well, you know, pride is a cardinal sin, you know, and there's a reason for that. And there's a reason

02:13:41.420 that pride goes before a fall. And I don't think you should be proud of yourself. I don't think

02:13:45.460 that's the right terminology. Okay. And I think that's a place where our culture has really fallen

02:13:49.360 off the rails. It's like, you should be convinced in your heart that you're doing, you're doing the

02:13:56.200 best you can with what you've been given. Right. And hopefully that'll make you less anxious and it'll

02:14:01.660 make you more hopeful. But, you know, you should have the same kind of regard for yourself that you

02:14:06.600 have for someone that you love. And that's not, it's not pride. It's, it's the, you should,

02:14:13.360 it would be lovely if you could orient your thoughts to yourself so that you could allow

02:14:18.680 yourself to be pleased if you thrived. It's not pride. Okay. Say it again. It'd be nice if I

02:14:24.840 could orient yourself to yourself. So you would be pleased if you thrived. You imagine you have a son,

02:14:29.800 you want your son to do well. Oh yeah. I already want him to do well. He doesn't even exist.

02:14:33.380 Yeah. Well, that, well, that's it. Well, that's the attitude you should have towards yourself too,

02:14:36.920 is that, you know, you should, you should also strive, you know, look, if your son goes out and

02:14:41.700 plays a soccer game, you know, you want him to do well. You don't want him to be arrogant and prideful

02:14:47.460 and you don't want him to be the star at everyone else's expense. Yeah. You want him to do well

02:14:52.360 when he deserves to do well and you want him to deserve to do well. Well, that's the attitude you

02:14:57.400 should have towards yourself. It's like, you should set yourself up so that if things are good for

02:15:03.280 you, that's good. Now you should, you should be grateful about that. Right. And you should be

02:15:08.980 amazed that it's happening, given how many things can go wrong. You should allow yourself the luxury

02:15:13.940 of, of success. Right. But then you should also hope for that for everyone else. It's like, well,

02:15:21.560 we could set up the world so that we had life more abundant than everyone was successful. And

02:15:26.180 we should treat ourselves as if we're the sorts of creatures for whom success is acceptable. Right.

02:15:34.620 And we do have doubts about that because everyone, well, we're flawed deeply. We're mortal and we're

02:15:39.500 vulnerable and we're subject to suffering and we're ignorant and we make mistakes. And it's easy to think

02:15:44.840 that a creature like that deserves nothing but say unending punishment, misery, you know, but I think

02:15:50.540 you give yourself the benefit of the doubt, like you do someone you love. And if success comes along,

02:15:54.960 you say, well, I'm so grateful for this and I hope I can take the opportunity to make proper use of

02:16:00.020 it. And you let yourself, you don't, you're not obligated to torture yourself beyond whatever is

02:16:06.940 necessary to help you learn. Right. And if you can drop that and you can accept, you know, it's also

02:16:14.480 the case, look, man, you're going to have rough times. They're coming. They're always coming. And if

02:16:19.560 you're having a okay time now, then you think, okay, I'll just, I'll just use this to recuperate

02:16:27.380 and I'll use it advantageously and I'll accept it in good graces without thinking that somehow I'm

02:16:33.000 special and deserve it. But gratitude for that's, gratitude's an excellent practice, man.

02:16:39.140 Yeah.

02:16:39.340 It's the opposite of arrogance and resentment. I don't think, I think it's a great thing to become

02:16:45.440 an expert at. And I think that you can allow yourself happiness if you're, if you're grateful.

02:16:52.320 There's something in, uh, thank you for that. Thanks for the suggestion too. That's good for

02:16:56.220 a lot of people to hear. There's something inside of us. Like you always want to make your father

02:16:59.660 proud. Like there's something inside of a man, right? Like my father's been dead for probably 20

02:17:04.460 years, but I always want to make him proud. I can feel it almost as real as if he's right.

02:17:09.420 Well, that's a better, that's a better marker. I would say, well, look, why is that? Why is that

02:17:15.200 tether? So like, there's no difference between the spirit of your fathers and God. It's the same

02:17:22.180 thing. Like I think strip it of religious significance for now, the spirit of the forefathers,

02:17:30.080 that's, that's, that's God. And you're, you have a responsibility that you're a historical

02:17:36.180 creature. You have a destiny. You have the, it's necessary for you to uphold certain traditions.

02:17:42.460 It's necessary for you to follow a certain pathway. It's necessary for you to align yourself with the

02:17:48.440 spirit that drove mankind forward, right? That's the spirit of the fathers. And that's, if your father

02:17:54.880 loved you, he's the outflowing of that spirit and you are responsible to it or, or you're responsible

02:18:01.000 to something else, man. So it's a good instinct. It's a good instinct. You know, and one of the

02:18:07.200 things, one of the things Carl Jung pointed out, so brilliant, you know, he said, you don't want to

02:18:12.660 confuse your father with God. You want to detach the idea of God from your father and put it above

02:18:19.560 your specific father. You want to see your father as an exemplar, the love that you got from your father

02:18:24.520 as an exemplar of something like the proper transcendent relationship. Cause that also

02:18:29.760 takes you away from being just the son of your father. Cause you risk not growing up then,

02:18:35.060 right? If you're under his thumb, if you're always looking for his approval. So you got to get that

02:18:39.140 right. You got to, you got to strive forward to make the spirit of the father proud, but you also

02:18:44.520 have to be an independent person. And you do that by separating out the spirit so that you're beholden

02:18:51.400 to something that's above all men, right? But still real. It's like the essence of, it's the essence.

02:18:58.220 That's another way that you can conceptualize God is God is the essence of paternal love. Right.

02:19:03.880 Right. And so it's the same thing, like many fathers love their son, right? So that love is in,

02:19:11.100 it isn't specific to any given relationship. You could extract it. Well, that spirit is part of

02:19:16.760 what's always been considered. That's the patriarchal aspect of God. That's a good way of thinking about

02:19:22.160 it.

02:19:23.480 No, I love that. I think it's important for a lot of young men out there.

02:19:26.660 Jordan, thanks so much, man. Thanks. Nice to see you, man. Nice to catch up. Sorry you're being,

02:19:33.120 you know, witch hunted by your own country. But it's also exciting though, kind of.

02:19:40.120 And we're going to make the best of it, man. Yeah. So we'll see how it goes.

02:19:43.560 That's the way to do it. It's always good to see you. I'm hoping I can see you the next time you

02:19:47.460 come to Toronto. I want to go see one of your shows. I thought your last Netflix special, man,

02:19:51.180 Tammy and I were, because we come from, you know, pretty rough area of Northern Alberta. We were just

02:19:55.940 cracking up, man. You're a great storyteller and you've done wonderful things with the strange

02:20:00.360 things you experienced when you were a kid. It's really funny, special. It really cracked me up.

02:20:04.880 Thank you, man. I appreciate it. Well, it's been nice to be here in your country. I love Canada.

02:20:10.000 And yeah, I want to come back up and do your podcast, please.

02:20:13.920 Great.

02:20:14.360 Yeah. I'd love to do that soon.

02:20:15.600 Great. Yeah. Well, I'd like to walk through your life. That'd be fun. I mean, horrible,

02:20:19.460 obviously.

02:20:19.880 Yeah, no, it'd be good. I think it'd be exciting.

02:20:21.540 Yeah, I think so, too.

02:20:22.140 And yeah, man, I'll donate to your law camp. I know you guys are doing a GoFundMe, right?

02:20:25.700 Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I want to do two things.

02:20:28.160 Is it going to be really expensive to battle that?

02:20:30.080 It's unbelievably expensive. Yeah. And I mean, I'm not particularly concerned about that,

02:20:34.240 although I would like to feel that I can go no holds barred without giving any consideration

02:20:40.940 other than what's necessary, because I'm probably going to have to take this right to the Supreme

02:20:44.700 Court. But I also, there are lots of other people in Canada who are in the same straits,

02:20:49.520 and I'm hoping, first of all, that this will help them, but also that I will be able to offer

02:20:53.540 financial support to them. So we'll see how that goes.

02:20:57.380 Cool. Set some precedent, huh?

02:21:00.220 That's the plan.

02:21:01.720 I like it. Thank you so much for your contributions to all of us just as young men, and thank you

02:21:06.920 for your time today, Jordan. I appreciate it.

02:21:08.380 Hey, man, it's always a pleasure talking to you. You're looking great, by the way.

02:21:11.240 You too, man. You look sharp.

02:21:12.760 There we go.

02:21:14.080 Now I'm just floating on the breeze, and I feel I'm falling like these leaves. I must be

02:21:20.780 cornerstone. Oh, but when I reach that ground, I'll share this peace of mind I found. I can

02:21:30.920 feel it in my bones, but it's gonna take a little bit.

This Past Weekend with Theo Von - August 29, 2023

E460 Jordan Peterson

Episode Stats

Length

Words per Minute

Word Count

Sentence Count

Misogynist Sentences

Hate Speech Sentences

Summary

Transcript