E510 Investigative Journalist Nate Halverson
Episode Stats
Length
2 hours and 15 minutes
Words per Minute
204.0073
Summary
Nate Halverson is an independent writer, journalist, and reporter. He contributed to the documentary, The Grab, which is all about the money and power controlling the food industry in America and beyond. Outside of that, he writes for the Center for Investigative Reporting.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
We hope you're enjoying your Air Canada flight.
00:00:10.720
Fast-free Wi-Fi means I can make dinner reservations before we land.
00:00:25.260
Wi-Fi available to Airplane members on Equipped Flight.
00:00:30.000
Today's guest is an independent writer, journalist, and reporter.
00:00:37.120
which is all about the money and power controlling the food industry in America and beyond.
00:00:43.120
Outside of that, he writes for the Center for Investigative Reporting.
00:00:47.060
I'm really fascinated to spend time with today's guest, Nate Halverson.
00:01:21.360
Dude, are you kidding me? Thank you so much for having me.
00:01:24.400
I watched The Grab, which is the documentary that you guys are putting out.
00:01:29.400
And just so I'm clear, what was the goal of the documentary?
00:01:34.300
Because to me, it seemed like you're trying to show that a lot of land or arable land,
00:01:44.680
A lot of land that can sustain crops is being bought up by different countries,
00:01:52.300
that it's kind of like a land grab for that land right now because they're not making more of it.
00:02:00.200
I mean, it is in the 21st century, it's looking more like oil was the commodity of the 20th century,
00:02:08.260
But in the 21st century, it looks like the rich and powerful are increasingly turning to control
00:02:13.980
food and water as, you know, like the basic necessities.
00:02:18.000
And we're just seeing a ton, whether it's foreign governments, you know, wealthy Wall Street
00:02:25.960
You know, I think now Bill Gates, his family, they're the largest farmers in the U.S., right?
00:02:31.920
Like they have, they're now the largest farmland owners in the U.S.
00:02:35.380
And that's interesting because he's obviously a guy with a lot of foresight, a guy who's
00:02:39.280
able to kind of envision the next step, obviously, from his past, from his history of being able
00:02:45.020
to like acquire companies that are doing that in different realms.
00:02:51.340
You kind of broke this story that this was happening years ago.
00:02:55.180
Yeah, because before this, I mean, before I started working on this, dude, I do nothing
00:02:59.740
Like I came into a cold turkey and I was asked to look at China's largest meat company buying
00:03:07.820
the world's largest pork company, which was based in Virginia.
00:03:12.100
And at the time, Congress was kind of freaking out, you know, like is China buying, you know,
00:03:18.040
Um, and so I started, I was asked to look into it cause I had this background and dig
00:03:23.660
it into Hong Kong financials where this meat company was publicly traded and I went to China.
00:03:30.500
I talked to folks in the U S I talked to people in the U S intelligence and it turns out, yeah,
00:03:35.180
like the Chinese government was behind, uh, this purchase that's effectively one in four
00:03:41.180
And the reason is because the Chinese government kind of clued into something before other folks,
00:03:47.080
which is that in the 21st century, food is power, right?
00:03:50.700
Like you need to control food to control your political future.
00:03:54.620
And so the Chinese government began putting into these five year plans that they put out,
00:03:59.060
um, uh, an effort to go overseas and begin buying up food and water resources, um, so that
00:04:11.180
And so they want to get the pigs because that's a source of food.
00:04:15.960
And that's a source of, you know, for China political stability, right?
00:04:20.100
If you have food, then the people will eventually follow you.
00:04:26.560
And, and, you know, like I've now traveled the world.
00:04:29.120
That was like the first one that the first food story that I looked at, you know, and
00:04:37.140
So I was surprised when I'll, you know, then I'm talking to us intelligence people.
00:04:40.920
And then I'm talking to like people in the defense department, right?
00:04:43.860
Like all of a sudden food is this like big national security.
00:04:46.820
And so as I began traveling the world, I mean, I began going to other countries where those
00:04:51.560
governments were using the food supply to control the population.
00:04:56.220
And I think that's what people are worried about going forward into the 21st century is
00:05:01.440
that by controlling the food, you can control the people.
00:05:05.100
They're just thinking, okay, how do we need to control the people next?
00:05:10.780
And they start to look at what can become a scarcity.
00:05:17.260
And so like the country I had gone to was, was Venezuela.
00:05:20.520
And Venezuela at the time was having all of these food riots, right?
00:05:23.240
Like people, people, you'd go and you'd work your nine to five job and then you'd come
00:05:27.960
home and there'd literally be a one mile line, long line to get into the grocery store.
00:05:32.900
And there's no way you're going to work like a 10 hour day and then stand in line all night.
00:05:38.280
And so, you know, I was talking to these guys that were working class that had jobs and they
00:05:50.680
And so then I went to this, you know, like secret location, this, this, this warehouse full
00:05:57.740
of food after watching people like starving people, people scraping by trying to survive
00:06:03.900
I went to this government warehouse full of food on a Sunday when it was supposed to
00:06:10.460
It was a bunch of Venezuelan military and police.
00:06:17.380
And these guys, these big buff dudes were wheeling out cartfuls of food that like I hadn't
00:06:24.240
And they were giving the authority, like the authorities were giving the police and the military, the
00:06:29.400
guys that were knocking down the population food so that they would, of course, continue
00:06:36.040
But how do you start to see that it becomes a bigger story though?
00:06:40.280
I mean, I just, it was crazy, man, because I just started seeing these dots, like these
00:06:45.280
stories that you would see around the world, you know, like, oh, this country is running
00:06:51.060
Or like this, this country just bought up, you know, like half the farmland in like Madagascar,
00:06:57.180
You know, like when I think Dai Wu out of South Korea bought up, like made like a secret deal
00:07:03.760
And then the people rise up and overthrow in the countries in civil war.
00:07:06.420
And you, you begin seeing these stories and then you begin being like, oh my God, like
00:07:10.000
all of these seemingly separate stories are all connected as part of this like bigger trend.
00:07:17.040
And that's when I began tapping into people who were beginning to follow it, like in the
00:07:23.400
Like the government, the intelligence community, others were beginning to sort of piece this
00:07:28.560
But it, for my reporting anyway, it appears that like it really was the Chinese government
00:07:34.280
was probably the first to wake up to this, to really tap into it.
00:07:38.880
I mean, the leadership of China went through the great famine, right?
00:07:43.760
Like Xi Jinping has told stories about living through the great famine, which was the late
00:07:50.080
fifties when estimates are that like, man, 37 million people died as a result of starvation
00:07:59.640
And so when you go through a period where you're looking around and dude, I've heard, I mean,
00:08:04.920
like stories I don't even like to tell because they're so awful about what it's like, you
00:08:09.780
know, if you have 37 million people that actually died as a result of starvation, that means
00:08:13.660
you got like a hundred million people that are close, right?
00:08:16.380
And people are just like doing desperate, crazy things.
00:08:19.920
And so when the leadership of China can remember that, like they are more keyed in when that
00:08:25.160
trend starts, you know, poking up its head, um, when there are these, you know, when there
00:08:30.300
are these forecasts that things are going to get more and more dire in the future, they
00:08:33.740
moved quickly to begin to sort of control food and water supplies for their population.
00:08:39.760
So they're kind of like, obviously they're a little more sensitive to it, but, um, but
00:08:43.660
you noticed that they were kind of at the head of the trend.
00:08:46.280
Um, yeah, my father grew up in Nicaragua and he grew up there like in the 1910s.
00:08:52.100
And so he would tell me stories about people starving and, um, kids in his village and
00:08:57.720
stuff, eating dirt and like their stomachs becoming distended.
00:09:00.340
And, um, literally making dirt, like people say mud pies and stuff that kids make like,
00:09:06.400
but literally making mud pies and eating them, you know, just to like be able to put something
00:09:18.940
So I'm not, I know his, some of his family was down there, um, being missionaries and
00:09:25.460
But, um, yeah, he would just tell me stories like that when I was a kid and it was just,
00:09:31.220
I mean, I've even thought I've been on a fast for a couple of days and seen, um, and this
00:09:36.800
is a little off topic, I guess, but I seen a guy at Best Buy.
00:09:42.300
I seen a guy at Best Buy and I was like, I will, I could, I could eat that guy.
00:09:51.180
It wasn't, it was like, I'd never had a thought like that before.
00:09:53.700
I've been to Best Buy probably 70 times and I'd never thought, you know what?
00:09:57.140
I could eat one of these sales attendants or whatever, but it was just in my head.
00:10:01.460
It was like a little bit of that hunger was like, what are we going to do here?
00:10:09.720
And that's the thing that like, and then people are surprised.
00:10:11.920
They're like, why are all these Venezuelans coming to our border?
00:10:17.420
They've been staring at other people thinking about eating them.
00:10:22.180
You don't even think that that's one of the reasons why people were coming up.
00:10:25.680
What are some of the other dots you start to connect?
00:10:27.480
Cause I see in the documentary, there's like land that's bought in Arizona.
00:10:31.420
There's a huge focus on land that's bought in Africa.
00:10:35.180
Like what are some of the other dots that you start to connect that really make this in
00:10:39.860
your mind, like bring it to a boil kind of besides just paranoid Chinese, like, and
00:10:50.900
It was like, you know, I began thinking, okay, so if China's focused on this, like what other,
00:10:56.560
you know, wealthy countries are focused on this.
00:11:00.080
And, and, you know, lo and behold, the kingdom of Saudi Arabia was one, right?
00:11:05.320
Because believe it or not, even though it's a desert country, it had these huge underground
00:11:11.460
water reserves, aquifers underneath the desert.
00:11:14.440
And that's why, like, you know, there are springs, you know, flowing to the surface of the desert
00:11:19.980
that are mentioned in the Bible, 2000, whatever years ago.
00:11:23.560
And starting in like the nineties, they began using their oil derricks to tap into that water
00:11:29.680
and actually use that water to grow wheat in the desert.
00:11:34.360
So this like wheat country by the nineties was the world's sixth largest exporter of wheat.
00:11:46.640
And so like those springs that are mentioned from 2000 years ago, they wouldn't dry.
00:11:50.980
And so then it's like, where are they going to go?
00:11:56.180
So like, if they drained their water with this program, like, where are they?
00:12:01.140
That's when I found them in like the Arizona desert.
00:12:04.200
I'm talking like saguaro cactuses, Wile E coyote, like desert, desert.
00:12:09.000
And they were doing the same thing, pumping up this ancient water that doesn't get replenished
00:12:14.080
Cause it's there from like the last ice age or something.
00:12:16.480
And then they use that water right there to grow alfalfa.
00:12:20.540
And then they ship the alfalfa from Arizona, basically to Los Angeles, put it on a ship
00:12:25.220
and then ship that alfalfa, which is hay all the way back to Saudi Arabia, because that's
00:12:30.980
Like you couldn't fill enough oil tankers full of water to effectively move water.
00:12:35.860
What you do is if your water short, you use the water wherever it is to grow the crops.
00:12:42.140
Cause we use 70 to 80% of our, the water, fresh water around the world.
00:12:49.100
So if one entity shows up in another space and you, and grows a crop, really what they're
00:12:55.560
That's the real resource because they could grow it at home.
00:12:58.380
If they had the water, a hundred percent, China doesn't have the water to grow enough
00:13:04.420
And even with the pigs, does that come back to water too?
00:13:09.160
Like you can, you can grow alfalfa in the Arizona desert, and then you can ship all that alfalfa
00:13:16.680
Or like when the case of pigs, you can grow all of the grain, right.
00:13:21.340
That the pigs are going to eat here in the U S and then you feed that grain to the pigs and
00:13:27.520
And so like a pig is an even more concentrated form of water.
00:13:31.620
If they call it like virtual water is what an economist would call it.
00:13:36.740
So wait, explain that part to me more time about the pig.
00:13:48.600
And then you, then you slaughter the pig here and then you send the meat back.
00:13:54.980
And so now you've used the water to grow the grain here and animals require a lot of livestock
00:14:00.700
So it takes even more grain than if like you were just eating like a, a meat free diet.
00:14:04.800
It takes just more water to eat a meat filled diet.
00:14:07.940
And so then you, you grow the grains here, you feed it to the pig, the pig, the pig craps
00:14:14.580
You end up with these like giant manure lagoons, which are toxic.
00:14:17.600
Those are here and you slaughter the pig and then you ship the meat back.
00:14:20.980
So you get stuck with the shit and they get the meat.
00:14:24.560
And so how does like, for the example in, in Arizona, how does that affect like Americans?
00:14:32.960
So like when I, when I broke that story about the Saudis in the Arizona desert in 2015, the
00:14:39.760
Like they didn't, they knew that their, their, their groundwater, the well that the, the water
00:14:44.300
that they relied on for their homes, like it was getting lower every single year.
00:14:49.080
What they didn't know was that some other country had run out of water and had come here to
00:14:53.300
And, uh, and so when I broke that story, people are like, yeah, it's like our water's been
00:14:59.860
And so what ends up happening to the people here is like, I talked to people and they were
00:15:03.520
like one woman, she was a nurse from California, worked her whole life, wanted to retire somewhere
00:15:12.960
And so she and her husband get this like little like ranch, you know, small piece of property,
00:15:20.080
They drill a well and now they got water and they got their lives.
00:15:23.540
They're going to, you know, the grandkids can come visit.
00:15:25.300
Well, what happens is these big international farmings move in.
00:15:29.080
They keep drilling deeper and deeper and pumping more and more water up.
00:15:32.940
And pretty soon these families are going like, dude, I can't pay half a million dollars to
00:15:37.220
drill a well deep enough to find the water that's still there.
00:15:40.160
And so they're at risk of losing like everything, like all their life savings that they put into
00:15:46.920
Because now their land has been sold out kind of from under them really, or their water's
00:15:52.740
But isn't there an agency that would protect the homeowners there?
00:15:57.440
No, I mean, the law is, is that if you, it's different in every region, but in this part
00:16:04.400
of Arizona, if you buy a piece of land, you can pump out as much water as you want.
00:16:11.500
So like if you're, you know, a multi-billion dollar corporation, you can go in there and
00:16:16.500
buy up land, put in the deepest well, and just suck out as much water as you want.
00:16:22.520
And, you know, the, the, the, the, the folks that live in modestly around you, their water
00:16:32.340
It says right here, according to the United Nations World Water Development Report, 2024,
00:16:36.460
2.2 billion people will still lack access to safe drinking water and 3.5 billion will
00:16:49.420
Um, cause drinking water, is that the same as water for that you're talking about?
00:16:54.640
Well, like if you're pumping water to grow crops, you're eventually going to, you could
00:16:58.320
have the potential of taking away somebody's drinking water.
00:17:01.740
But like when it turns to like quantity, like what we're actually using water for, like,
00:17:06.020
you know, cause people will say this and be like, Oh, Nestle bought up this aquifer.
00:17:11.400
But like put it in perspective, one 10th of 1%, one 10th of 1% of the fresh water we
00:17:17.460
use is for drinking 70 to 80% is for growing crops.
00:17:23.460
And so when you're talking about somebody tapping an aquifer to bottle water, like one
00:17:32.960
What we're pumping water out of aquifers for at like huge, huge rates, huge amounts
00:17:41.180
And so these are, and then like, and if, if, you know, like if it were just drinking water
00:17:45.940
that was an issue, there are ways to move around enough water to get everyone drinking
00:17:53.540
But when you start talking about food, that's when you're talking about like what people
00:17:58.100
really need to move water and they really need water for is for food.
00:18:02.200
So drinking water, we can, we have enough water for that.
00:18:06.680
I mean like the vast amount of water like you use as an individual is the food you put into
00:18:18.620
You see the, um, the issue in Arizona from Saudi Arabia.
00:18:23.240
Are there other things like that happening around America?
00:18:29.740
Like it's going through this pretty big transitionary period where like, I think like, and maybe,
00:18:35.620
I think like a lot of people still kind of have this view of like farmers as like, you
00:18:43.320
Like small, medium-sized farmers, like, you know, both of them, you know, my, my family were all
00:18:51.860
Like we kind of envision it as like these, these smaller farms.
00:18:55.700
Um, but increasingly what they are, these really large farms, um, increasingly owned by like
00:19:01.100
wall street pension funds or foreign governments or foreign corporations, right?
00:19:06.360
Like that's been the trend line is that these smaller farmers, these medium, medium-sized
00:19:11.640
farmers are getting bought out by bigger and bigger conglomerates.
00:19:15.740
Um, and so like we're in this transitionary period in the U S is to like how food is getting
00:19:23.240
And so not getting made by smaller farmers, but getting made in by larger corporations.
00:19:28.940
That could have other interests in that farm is just a, uh, passive or just a, um, placeholder.
00:19:35.420
It's a, it's a, you know, it's another profit mechanism because, you know, like if you're
00:19:39.040
a country and you're like, we need to buy up food and water resources to make sure our
00:19:42.840
people get fed and that they don't overthrow us.
00:19:46.060
And if you're, if you're wall street and you're looking at that, you're like, oh, if there
00:19:49.000
is a crunch on food in the future, food prices are going to go up.
00:19:52.880
And if food prices go up, that's a profit margin.
00:19:56.060
And so like, I've read these, these reports put out by some of the biggest, you know, investment
00:20:00.800
banks and they're, you know, they're just saying, you know, water is the new oil,
00:20:09.660
He says right here, as of December 31st, 2022, foreign entities owned about 43.4 million acres
00:20:15.240
of U S agricultural land and forest, which is about 3.4% of all agricultural land and
00:20:24.180
Well, there's two things about that is, um, cause that doesn't seem like that much.
00:20:30.180
Um, but the other thing was, is I pulled all of that data and the, when, when there's an
00:20:36.220
old law in the books, it says, if you're a foreign company, you need to register.
00:20:40.880
If you're going to buy U S farmland, some States just ban it outright.
00:20:45.040
But, um, the, the, I looked and I was like, I know that this farm is owned by a foreign
00:20:54.480
And so like the government wasn't really following up and making sure.
00:20:58.700
And so like, I have great, you know, those numbers to me come with a huge asterisk, which
00:21:07.400
And the government doesn't seem to be following up to make sure.
00:21:11.600
And then the other thing is, is like, you have huge amounts of foreign wealth that are
00:21:16.420
then put into intermediaries like BlackRock or something, right?
00:21:22.300
And I mean, what does BlackRock got $9 trillion that they manage.
00:21:25.160
And so you'll have a sovereign wealth fund from another country that'll put money there.
00:21:28.640
And then, so then BlackRock or some subsidiary of BlackRock or a subsidiary of a subsidiary
00:21:33.280
of BlackRock might own the land, but the financial backing is a foreign government.
00:21:39.260
So there's just like a lot of loopholes and, um, like hidden LLCs, that sort of thing.
00:21:45.200
Well, how much of the land in America can be used?
00:21:49.640
And even on the planet, if you know, it can be used to grow crops.
00:21:55.120
I don't know how much of the land, I mean, like what you see in the Arizona desert, it's
00:21:59.620
like, it's desert, but if you pump up the water, then you can grow alfalfa.
00:22:03.240
And so it kind of comes down to like, do you have the water there to do it?
00:22:07.000
Like what we know is what they'll say is that like, uh, some huge percent, 40 or 70%, I can't
00:22:12.920
remember off the top of my head, some huge percent of the world's, you know, remaining
00:22:19.980
And so that's why there's this huge push now for corporations to go down and to try to grab
00:22:26.140
up land in Africa, because now the, you know, they'll say, oh, Africa is going to feed the
00:22:32.940
Africa is going to feed the world, but I'm not saying no, but I'm just, I remember 20
00:22:37.440
years ago when we were having to do, they had the, wasn't there the annual music every
00:22:44.040
And, uh, um, and, and, and, and, and again, man, the problem with that, that, that thing
00:22:50.440
is, is like, so then I went to Africa, I was like, okay, so where's all of this
00:22:56.740
People had ancestrally been living on that land and they'd been farming for their needs,
00:23:03.180
And what had happened was, is these huge international corporations had come in and
00:23:09.100
And so I was visiting these places where people were literally dying, um, having had
00:23:13.800
their land taken from them by one of these international corporations that then could ship
00:23:20.460
You know, whether that was Europe, China, or Saudi Arabia, um, you know, they were literally
00:23:26.960
had their land taken from that, everything taken from them.
00:23:32.700
There's a really tough part in the documentary where there's a woman crying, really breaking
00:23:36.480
down, um, because of the fear of losing, uh, their land.
00:23:46.260
I mean, that stuff's a downer and, and, and what's, you know, and, and when I, when I
00:23:51.260
showed the film to, to people there that are fighting back against this, what they didn't
00:23:55.300
see is that it's part of this like giant international trend.
00:23:59.840
Like it, it, it, it really is where you've got like, again, like intelligence communities,
00:24:05.460
governments, like all like kind of behind this big push in this big movement.
00:24:11.100
Um, and, and like you said, it's like when you're, when you don't have access to water
00:24:16.280
because somebody upstream, let's say has damned the river to grow food and now you don't even
00:24:21.900
Um, oftentimes the thing that's going to get you as your body begins to just slowly get
00:24:26.260
sicker and sicker from not having food or good water, you just, you pick up a parasite,
00:24:30.580
you pick up a disease, your body just becomes way more vulnerable, you know?
00:24:34.220
Oh, you even, yeah, you pet a strong shrimp and you could be done, you know?
00:24:40.820
You eat one bad oyster or whatever, and it could be lights out.
00:24:45.700
Did you know that our friends over at Morgan and Morgan are the official injury law firm
00:24:52.540
Well, as America's largest injury law firm, Morgan and Morgan knows a thing or two about
00:24:58.060
fighting for the people with over $20 billion recovered for over 500,000.
00:25:04.220
and clients, Morgan and Morgan has a proven track record of fighting to get you full and
00:25:12.360
And Morgan and Morgan is back with another awesome giveaway.
00:25:15.540
They're giving one lucky listener the chance to win two tickets to UFC 303 to witness the
00:25:22.380
highly anticipated McGregor versus Chandler fight live in Las Vegas.
00:25:34.580
That's 484-373-6753 for your chance to win two tickets to UFC 303 to see McGregor versus
00:25:44.220
Chandler or click the link in the description below if you're watching on YouTube.
00:25:49.680
And if you're ever in an accident, not calling a lawyer means you could be leaving money on
00:25:56.220
Submitting an injury claim with Morgan and Morgan is so easy, it can be done in eight
00:26:06.320
Summer is right around the corner and our friends over at Chubby's are bringing the good
00:26:15.380
I had on one of their shirts the other day in Miami, man.
00:26:19.240
Chubby's is a lifestyle apparel brand that makes every moment feel like a vacation.
00:26:33.700
For a limited time, Chubby's is giving our listeners 20% off your order with our exclusive
00:26:43.520
You can experience unmatched comfort and style with the Chubby's iconic original stretch
00:26:55.140
For a limited time, Chubby's is giving our viewers 20% off your order with our code Theo
00:27:14.200
So in Africa, it's even more prevalent, you're saying?
00:27:19.780
And I think what I think, you know, it does seem to be I talked to a bunch of African investigative
00:27:25.180
journalists at this thing in D.C. and they saw the documentary and they came up after
00:27:29.540
and they're like, dude, I've been seeing this in my country.
00:27:31.940
I didn't realize it was part of this like giant international trend, right?
00:27:38.580
And that's how that was like the same revelation that I had as I started digging in deeper and
00:27:43.460
deeper was just how interconnected these things are.
00:27:46.700
Because like, you know, when you say that, like, yeah, what do you mean when you say that?
00:27:50.820
I just mean, like, I think the dude was from Sierra Leone and he was talking about a big
00:27:54.420
rice farm that had come in and plowed down the forest and moved people off their land.
00:27:58.660
And then they were exporting the rice to wherever, you know, a wealthier country.
00:28:02.680
And he's like, you know, how do I contextualize that?
00:28:12.660
And then you see, oh, it fits in that like people in Arizona are basically dealing with
00:28:17.340
the same thing, maybe not to the same degree, but all of a sudden they're finding what like
00:28:23.560
You know, and I think like, I think the, and so that's what I mean.
00:28:30.940
And these kinds of numbers are super hard to get.
00:28:34.880
Anecdotally, I would say, yeah, it appears to be happening most prevalently in Africa.
00:28:39.480
But like getting any good numbers on that, like nobody, the UN, you know, like they're
00:28:43.720
not going out and nobody's going out and like documenting every single instance.
00:28:52.080
And we, to like, just to give you a sense of what we go through, I took every single
00:28:57.660
fact that's mentioned in that documentary and I put it into a spreadsheet.
00:29:02.240
And then me and a woman who's now a fact checker at the New Yorker, we went through every single
00:29:07.420
And then we put three sources making sure it was true.
00:29:10.200
And then we hired an outside fact checker to fact check our fact check, you know, like,
00:29:15.420
like, and so like I always, and that's like, that's the value to me of good investigative
00:29:19.500
journalism is like, we're going to, we're going to put in that extra effort so that
00:29:25.360
And so, you know, I love this format because this is how, like, when I'm hanging out with
00:29:30.760
And you're like sharing knowledge and like, as humans, we sit around the campfire.
00:29:37.900
Um, but I'm always like a little hesitant because I'm like, I don't got a fact checker
00:29:42.560
They're like, Oh, Nate, you screwed that fact up.
00:29:43.960
And she doesn't have a fact checker behind her to be like, Oh no, you screwed up the
00:29:48.760
So we, yeah, you're just having a, yeah, you're just doing your best, you know, but you obviously
00:29:55.020
And what, at what point do you start to go down a trail with investigative journalism where you're
00:30:01.960
Or I have to fluff this thing up to at least make it hold the value of the weight that
00:30:25.780
You just, you're like, there's not enough here.
00:30:28.800
What often happens, man, is, is you'll be like, huh, I'm, this is what happens to me.
00:30:37.640
And that thing that I started digging into, I'll be like, oh no, actually that makes sense.
00:30:41.540
And I want, you know, like, I don't, I don't think the world needs to know more about that.
00:30:44.480
I don't think it's going to make anyone's lives better.
00:30:46.080
I don't think it's going to change anyone's perception on how they interact with the world.
00:30:49.120
But as I was doing that, like I started seeing this other thing.
00:30:53.160
And then, so then I start looking into that other thing and I'm like, well, that is pretty interesting.
00:30:56.580
But in the process of looking into that, then I'm like, holy shit, look at that thing over there.
00:31:01.520
And then I'm moving in and these things can't, are, are, are sometimes, you know, they could be totally unrelated.
00:31:07.940
And then it's that thing that I end up really going after.
00:31:11.320
And so I would never, I don't want to waste my time.
00:31:15.160
And I don't want to do an injustice to a story by being like, well, I spent time on looking into a, and now I have to do something on a, right?
00:31:21.100
Because oftentimes it's just a slowly shifts into B.
00:31:24.040
And the next thing I know, I'm like, dude, I think people need to, would want to know about C, right?
00:31:28.680
Like, I think people should take a little break from their lives and lives are tough.
00:31:33.940
I want to like, you know, I want to honor people's time, but I'm like, but I think C is probably worth their time.
00:31:39.280
What parts of this, as you went through this, did, did it start to like, um, be like, okay, this is something that makes me realize I have to keep going here.
00:31:49.120
Oh, I, you know, with this one, I think it was, it was kind of early on because again, man, you know, it's like when, when, you know, before this, I'd been doing organized crime and now I'm doing food and I was asked to do it.
00:32:02.380
You know, like, it's not going to blow my mind.
00:32:06.680
And I was just like, but then all of a sudden I'm like, wait a minute, this, you're an intelligence officer for the CIA or you were, and you're like telling me X, Y, and Z, like, that's pretty interesting.
00:32:18.100
Well, let me go talk to somebody else to try to corroborate that or get like another hot take on it, you know?
00:32:24.560
And I'm like, and then I started seeing the stakes, right?
00:32:29.160
Like, but the number of people that it was going to impact, and we're talking about like billions, you know, like we're talking about, you know,
00:32:36.560
when you have Wall Street saying this is going to be the biggest trajectory, when you have the World Economic Forum saying this is one of the top fives existential threats to our species, you start going like food and water, you know?
00:32:48.860
And you're like, this is probably worth my time and a lot of sleepless nights.
00:32:56.920
I, this is what, so can I tell you, like, when I, when we, so we made a film, right?
00:33:01.920
And I'm super lucky because I worked with this amazing director, Gabriella Copperthwaite, you know, and she knows how to tell an amazing story.
00:33:09.520
Yeah, it's just like, she made this thing like an international ripper, right?
00:33:13.340
And, and, but when we're going out and we're, we're pitching it to the studios, they're all like, well, what do you want to come of this?
00:33:18.300
And I wanted, I wanted, what I wanted to happen when people see this documentary is the same thing that happened to me.
00:33:24.280
When I started working on this stuff, it shifted my perception of how I see the world.
00:33:29.380
Like I fundamentally see the world differently now having worked on this story.
00:33:32.920
And so I wanted people to have access to that same information because I think when you begin to, when you, when you see this, and I don't know if this was your experience or not, but when you see it, you're like, oh shit, like food isn't just food.
00:33:45.700
Food has become like a power tool for, for governments to control people in other countries.
00:33:53.820
How would we see that start to show up in our daily lives?
00:34:02.200
I mean, do you remember during COVID when, when they were like, oh, everybody can stay at home except people that work in slaughterhouses.
00:34:10.180
We got to get everybody that works in slaughterhouses back.
00:34:12.620
Cause we're really worried that there's not going to be meat on the shelves.
00:34:15.880
Well, dude, as I recall during that time, pork exports to China increased.
00:34:24.060
So the executives of these big meat companies are like, oh, we got to get everybody back.
00:34:29.420
And then they were shipping more meat to China.
00:34:31.760
Well, it might've even been their, um, their farms.
00:34:36.480
Well, yeah, they own, they own, you know, this company that's in China.
00:34:40.180
Um, that was, you know, this deal that was backed by the Chinese government.
00:34:46.020
Can you bring up that article that we're talking about?
00:34:48.360
On April 28th, 2020, president Donald Trump issued an executive order invoking the defense
00:34:54.380
production act to keep meat packing plants open.
00:34:57.380
The executive order exempted plants from state and local orders to close non-essential businesses,
00:35:02.420
but did not solve plants problems with sick workers.
00:35:07.340
I mean, it's just interesting because if people are going to need to eat, people are going
00:35:14.420
You're going to need people to be able to continue to eat or they're going to freak out.
00:35:18.660
So even if they're stuck at home, as long as they can get a burger, then they're going
00:35:24.040
to, they're going to keep going until their next burger.
00:35:29.360
I mean, you're kind of like put your finger on it, man.
00:35:31.020
It's like, it is like food is that one thing, uh, that people want to keep going, right?
00:35:39.000
Um, and you know, and that's kind of, that's what takes you to the Arab spring, right?
00:35:43.080
Like when you saw all of these Middle Eastern governments getting toppled, right?
00:35:47.720
Like the Arab spring, it was like, what do you mean the Arab spring?
00:35:51.000
Arab spring was like a little over 10 years ago now.
00:35:54.640
And it was that period where you just saw civil wars breaking out across like North Africa
00:36:09.680
But increasingly the thing that the intelligence community is saying is driving those issues
00:36:18.240
You know, like you were talking about food prices here in the, where we were talking about
00:36:23.720
But like Americans, man, we only spend about 7% of, uh, our income on food, on groceries,
00:36:35.400
So whatever they're making, like half their paycheck is going to food.
00:36:39.740
And so when food prices go up for us, it's only going up on like 7% of what we're spending
00:36:51.240
Because in, in, I mean, we're just a wealthy nation, you know, and so we have bigger income.
00:36:57.740
So obviously, yeah, if you have, if you're making a hundred dollars a day, then that's
00:37:01.420
just seven bucks a day where if you're making a hundred dollars, uh, um, if you're making
00:37:09.600
And a lot of people, you know, like we're buying, we're buying food.
00:37:15.600
We're buying things you can like open a package and eat.
00:37:17.720
But a lot of people in these other countries, they're just buying like commodities like
00:37:23.360
And so when those prices, like, you know, basically double, um, all of a sudden those
00:37:29.020
people are seeing, you know, 50% of their income almost eat up their entire income and
00:37:37.780
Like, so in the Arab spring, there was a ton of that.
00:37:42.260
You know, they went to historic highs, um, and that sustained.
00:37:46.360
And people started taking to the streets, right?
00:37:49.720
A whole grievance of issues, but this was a big one.
00:37:52.580
Um, and you saw it move just across these countries.
00:37:57.660
How did they, like, what kind of catharsis did they get into?
00:38:02.760
A lot of, a lot of them just took out their leaders.
00:38:06.900
Like Egypt overthrew their leader, didn't they?
00:38:16.420
And this is the thing about the 21st century is like, that was probably the first blip that
00:38:23.500
And the forecast is for an increasing number of those.
00:38:26.860
And when countries fall apart because of civil wars, oftentimes their people then migrate
00:38:33.120
And then they put pressure on the countries around them because now they've got to feed
00:38:36.480
more people because now you've got a failed nation next to you.
00:38:42.520
And are the forecasts saying that there is going to be like less water, that there's
00:38:49.300
Like where are we getting those forecasts from?
00:38:52.120
So we could pull something up, but it's like 70% of the world's population or some number
00:38:59.320
is going to be living in some form of water scarcity by like 2050.
00:39:06.780
Of people that are dealing with water shortages.
00:39:08.900
And again, like usually you can eke out enough water for your drinking water.
00:39:14.640
But can you, do you have enough water to grow the foods you need to eat or for somebody else
00:39:22.900
And so, and then the other thing we're looking at, it's like some places are going to have,
00:39:27.780
you know, people are going to have droughts, of course, but then some places are going to
00:39:31.040
have flood floods and too much water can have the same impact as not enough water, right?
00:39:36.300
Like we just saw this in Pakistan where like their crop was wiped out by this, these massive
00:39:43.700
I used to work on a soybean and corn and cotton farm for a couple of years.
00:39:46.760
And it was amazing how like water was just, I mean, you would stand around and talk about
00:39:59.600
It was unbelievable how that was the biggest thing.
00:40:06.500
How are you going to manage your crops if it doesn't?
00:40:08.620
And then how are you going to get subsidized by the government if it doesn't happen at all?
00:40:14.480
And what happens is in those, those countries that, that are dealing with all these economic
00:40:19.180
hardships, these dictatorial leaders weren't subsidizing the farmers.
00:40:24.040
And, and what's worse is they were given like their buddies access to whatever, better, better.
00:40:30.200
That's what you're saying in Venezuela when you, you open the, and you see that the people
00:40:33.660
who are going to maintain the, the status quo of keeping starving people at bay are getting
00:40:42.680
That's crazy how quick you will become the Gestapo in that moment, you know?
00:40:52.080
Well, I was going to say something similar in Syria where, you know, a drought hits Syria
00:40:56.120
and, you know, all of these farmers are losing their crops.
00:41:04.080
And, you know, rather than being like, okay, the government being like, okay, we need to
00:41:08.900
From what I've read, I wasn't in Syria at the time, but it was like Bashir was just giving
00:41:15.860
And then you just, you're building up this, this, this, this, you're just building up a lot
00:41:22.740
It's like, and this is what the, when I, when I talk to people that are in the intelligence
00:41:27.640
It's, it's not when this, and this sounds shitty, but this is what they say.
00:41:32.100
It's not when the lowest income, the people that are the poorest can't eat that you see
00:41:37.020
a country topple because unfortunately those people have already adjusted their mental mindset
00:41:45.080
It's when the middle class can eat people that are used to being comfortable.
00:41:52.600
And then when they can't afford to eat and when they're, they're having to tell their
00:42:01.640
And then they overthrow governments, you know, and sometimes the government turns out better
00:42:05.620
and sometimes the government turns out worse and people live in violence and bloodshed
00:42:14.200
And this is kind of the, the trend line that, that we're seeing.
00:42:17.640
And you believe it's an overall trend after all your research and all your digging, you
00:42:20.720
believe that it's an overall trend that's going to continue.
00:42:23.320
It's totally, it's, I think personally, I think it's solvable.
00:42:27.260
I think it's solvable, but it is, it is the trend line that we are on it, that it, that
00:42:33.140
like, if we don't get into another lane of traffic, this is the direction that this road
00:42:38.440
And this is straight up from like the, the, the, the U S government had, you know, I keep
00:42:45.540
But there is the ODNI, the office of director of national intelligence that oversees the
00:42:50.700
CIA, the DIA, the NIC, all of these intelligence agencies.
00:42:54.540
And the highest level work product they do is something called a national intelligence
00:42:59.280
And they did a national intelligence estimate on, on water in the year 2012.
00:43:04.300
So basically they came out and the guy who was spearheading, and this is like the highest
00:43:09.800
level work product, the intelligence, U S intelligence community does said business as
00:43:23.680
But it, you know, it has, that's going to have to happen on an international level.
00:43:27.960
And like, we look at our domestic politics and we're like, there's a mess.
00:43:31.780
And you look at international politics and you're like, there's a real mess.
00:43:35.200
So, you know, we all are going to keep doing what we can and we gotta, you know, keep living.
00:43:40.860
But like, but still, this is, I mean, having foresight is, is super important, especially
00:43:45.980
in a time where it's like, we don't even, there's so much artificial site that you don't
00:43:56.960
You just, it's so hard to know what's real on March 22nd, 2012, the national intelligence
00:44:01.260
council, which you're saying is a conglomerate of all of those.
00:44:10.740
Released the unclassified report, the intelligence community assessment on global water security.
00:44:14.700
The report concludes that several regions of the world, such as North Africa, the Middle
00:44:17.900
East and South Asia will face major challenges, coping with water problems.
00:44:21.540
And that during the next 10 years, many countries important to the United States will experience
00:44:25.720
water problems that will increase the risk of instability and state failure, exacerbate
00:44:30.100
regional tensions and distract them from working with the United States on important policy
00:44:36.740
I guess if the, how you barter and trade and deal with things is going to become a lot
00:44:44.440
You mentioned Africa and you guys go into a lot in the doc.
00:44:47.520
Um, why, why, why is Africa always get screwed?
00:44:52.780
I mean, since the beginning of time, whether it's the British coming in or a foreign entity
00:44:58.400
coming in and enslaving or claiming, whether it's them enslaving each other, whether it's
00:45:03.740
the tribe that just can't get along, whether it's a government that starts up and then, um,
00:45:09.780
sells out, like, why do they have so much trauma there?
00:45:15.920
And, you know, I always try to operate from like a, uh, a place of historically informed
00:45:23.900
And, you know, what we saw was that Western Europe for some centuries just had this intense
00:45:32.400
And Africa had a lot of resources that they wanted.
00:45:36.060
Um, and they went in there and they grabbed them and they created artificial boundaries and
00:45:40.400
borders around, um, you know, that, that, that suited Western Europe.
00:45:45.180
Like Africa got carved up into territories that suited Western Europe and their treaties
00:45:50.280
so that they wouldn't fight with each other in Europe.
00:45:53.140
And, and that wasn't always the, the boundaries that of like the, of the governments in the
00:45:59.800
Um, and you know, that, and you go back even farther than when Western Europe was sort of
00:46:04.420
the, the, the, the international dominant player, right?
00:46:10.040
Genghis Khan born in the central steeps of Asia.
00:46:13.800
The dude became a slave, then went from being a slave to controlling like the entire Mongolian
00:46:20.900
Then they went into China and they took over China.
00:46:23.340
Then he pushes East and starts taking over Eastern Europe.
00:46:26.180
And then he drives down into Southern Asia, you know, the middle East dude controlled
00:46:34.660
And when he, this is the thing, and I'm getting a lot of this.
00:46:39.240
It's like the kind of in one person, but go on.
00:46:46.440
And, and I'm getting this from this, this guy, Jack Weatherford's book, Genghis Khan and
00:46:51.740
He's a historian in Minnesota, somewhere, one of those, one of those colleges.
00:46:55.120
And when Genghis Khan gets to, to, to Europe, he's looking around, he's like, these people
00:47:01.340
are too dumb and too poor for me to bother conquering.
00:47:05.240
He, you know, like they didn't even have pants at that point.
00:47:07.440
Like pants, like pants are an Asian invention, right?
00:47:11.560
Like pants came from Asia at that time in Europe, people are just wearing cloaks.
00:47:17.080
They didn't, you know, that gunpowder came from China, movable type from China.
00:47:20.460
And so Genghis Khan gets to Europe and he's like, these people are too dumb, too poor,
00:47:24.340
And he just drove South into the middle East where people were doing like algebra and
00:47:28.300
advanced math and like had all of this technology.
00:47:31.420
And then that set up these trading routes and those trading routes connected some of these
00:47:36.440
great advanced technologies from the middle East and from Asia.
00:47:40.040
And they started working their way into Europe.
00:47:42.440
And then boom, Europe has the Renaissance and boom, the Renaissance blows up into the
00:47:48.340
And then that industrial revolution, now you have like the Pope carving up the entire world
00:47:54.860
Like Portugal gets one half, Spain gets the other half, and then they're going down and
00:48:01.420
And, and then you just, you, you, you get to where we are today, which is that, you know,
00:48:06.480
Africa never had a strong say in how they were and what went on.
00:48:11.440
And in the, in the, in the last few, you know, centuries, what things did you notice when
00:48:15.240
you started to explore some of this stuff happening in Africa?
00:48:20.940
Like, I guess like the ownership, like who was doing the, like you say, land getting bought
00:48:29.920
Like who was, is it hard to know who was doing it?
00:48:33.200
Well, oftentimes it's really hard to trace back who's doing it because you can be like
00:48:38.940
It can just be these layers of LLCs and who ultimately is behind this LLC can be really
00:48:44.820
Like I can go there and be like, okay, so this is the white South African dude or white
00:48:49.200
Zimbabwean dude who now is in like Zambia and he's, you know, moved people off the historic
00:48:59.960
And, and these other people that had been there for the families have been there for
00:49:05.000
Cause they don't have access to even enough drinking water, much less enough water to
00:49:10.320
And I can, I can be, I can see that, but like, then I look at the property ownership
00:49:14.320
and it's just a jumble of LLCs and that can be pretty tough.
00:49:18.160
But, you know, in the film, one of the things we were able, we got this like trove of information
00:49:23.180
I mean, we see that in some cases it's the leaders of foreign governments that are paying
00:49:30.060
essentially mercenaries to go in and gobble up these resources.
00:49:35.560
And, and one of the ways they do it, you know, and these, these emails that we get, we see
00:49:40.720
they just talk about giving gifts to the chief.
00:49:48.680
And what is a mercenary just so everybody knows?
00:49:50.520
Well, a mercenary is effectively somebody who can provide military logistics on behalf
00:50:09.740
You brought up Rwanda just a minute ago, and I'm trying to remember the name of the actress
00:50:13.680
that was going to hire a mercenary outfit to go in.
00:50:18.160
Like when no one on the international level was stopping the Rwandan genocide, this, this
00:50:23.320
Hollywood actress wanted to hire a mercenary group to try to go in and stop it.
00:50:27.480
Like, so like she was using it potentially, like she thought of using it as this force
00:50:33.080
But so there, there, there are these examples of people wanting to use these types of groups
00:50:37.080
to like quell violence, to bring stability, right.
00:50:40.040
To, to move food into, into areas that are being controlled by warlords.
00:50:46.460
Like, so you can, you know, sometimes people make an argument that you need to meet force
00:50:52.320
And then you also see them being used by corporations to make deals with warlords, you know, to extract
00:50:59.960
And those tend to have a more deleterious or, you know, fucking create, make life shittier
00:51:07.180
Like, what were some of the things that you saw, like people struggling with?
00:51:10.220
Oh, dude, just feeding themselves, having shelter, you know, like super basic stuff,
00:51:22.500
And then, and, and, you know, it's like, it's that thing they always say, like, you,
00:51:26.120
you see these people who have done nothing wrong or just like struggling to survive, you know?
00:51:31.940
And I go in there as essentially like a storyteller and I'm like, you know,
00:51:35.900
and they're like, dude, like we need food, we need water.
00:51:38.920
And you're like, oh, you know, like, what can I, what can I do?
00:51:42.540
My role is to tell people about what's happening to you.
00:51:45.240
And then I fly back to San Francisco and I turn on the faucet and I can drink fresh water,
00:51:50.080
And you're like, you know, so these are the, these, this is, these are some of the challenges
00:51:57.180
And anyways, I went off a little bit, but like, yeah, I've seen this shit, you know?
00:52:01.760
And like, there's, you know, there are stories I've heard and there are things that I've seen
00:52:05.020
that, you know, like I, I wish, you know, which didn't happen to people.
00:52:09.320
And then I wish that I didn't have to experience firsthand, you know?
00:52:12.020
Do you feel like we're doing the same thing in other countries though?
00:52:17.100
Like, are we doing the same thing that's happening here and other places?
00:52:25.560
Well, no, I mean, I, I would say that if you're like, if, if, if you're looking at
00:52:30.920
it, like, Oh, China's a bad guy or the Saudis are the bad guys, but you know, the U S is,
00:52:38.080
Like we have massive corporations that are going in and are contributing, I think, to
00:52:42.980
this pattern of people who are living on land, losing their land or people whose water
00:52:49.460
And, and it's destabilizing the world is like the short of it.
00:52:52.560
And then you end up with a destabilized world and you end up with like mass migration and
00:52:56.900
you end up with countries being like, we don't want any more immigrants, you know?
00:53:00.120
And you're like, yeah, but they left because they were hungry.
00:53:06.840
And so you, you, you're not getting just immigrants.
00:53:08.780
You're getting starving in some cases, increasingly that is the case.
00:53:12.360
Like I, there, at one point the state department said the reason, you know, the, the number
00:53:16.100
one reason people were leaving Guatemala was because they were hungry and think about
00:53:28.880
Like it, it, it, it, um, like I think all, when you go under the stick or whatever, under
00:53:33.680
the limbata or whatever, I don't know that the limbo limbo.
00:53:39.860
Like those countries have given us so much food.
00:53:41.940
Like, how is it possible that a country that is the source of so many, like you think
00:53:46.880
of tomatoes, you're like, Oh, Italians must've invented it.
00:53:49.080
You're like, no man, that came from the Americas potatoes came from the Americas.
00:53:56.600
And how do you have now a region like that where half of the children are stunted because
00:54:02.620
they're not getting enough calories and nutrition.
00:54:05.220
And so like people are leaving Guatemala because there's not enough food.
00:54:09.440
And that's crazy because this place is growing plenty of food.
00:54:12.500
So what's happening to the food is just being exported to, to, to wealthier countries.
00:54:16.960
So do you think that we're like some of the reason for China's low water supply is because
00:54:24.540
I think China is a really interesting example, right?
00:54:34.300
Because this is like, I don't think this is well enough known, but one of the greatest
00:54:38.580
achievements in my opinion of the 20th century was what China accomplished.
00:54:43.500
And that was pulling 400 million people out of poverty in like three decades, right?
00:54:51.100
Like you, you, you'll hear people talking about all of the great achievements of our
00:54:55.220
species, you know, over the last, you know, whatever, 50 years.
00:54:59.040
And they'll be like, you know, we've reduced, uh, we reduce poverty and hunger by this much
00:55:04.420
80% of poverty reduction, as I understand it, 70 or 80% of poverty reduction in the world
00:55:12.060
One country, 400 million people they pulled out of, out of poverty in like two or three
00:55:17.800
Gosh, they now have the world's largest middle-class, right?
00:55:20.800
I think their middle-class might be bigger than the entire population of the U S the challenge
00:55:25.200
there, man, is that they want to eat diets more like our diet, right?
00:55:28.800
Like in the 1980s, you basically had a country full of vegetarians because they couldn't afford
00:55:34.200
Now you have the world's largest middle-class and they want to eat more meat, right?
00:55:39.500
And, and, and, and to have meat, you have to grow more grains, more feeds for the animals.
00:55:45.000
It's kind of an ineffect, inefficient way to, to develop a calorie and they don't have
00:55:50.260
enough water to grow enough grains to be able to feed all of the animals that the people
00:56:03.940
Probably this might even be one of the fewer places.
00:56:06.520
It's just that the U S is an agricultural superpower, right?
00:56:09.880
Like we are one of the largest exporters of food in the world.
00:56:13.360
And this, you know, then takes you to like, so who are the other ones?
00:56:16.440
And you're like, well, it turns out now Russia is, and that's not by accident.
00:56:21.220
Putin has built the country up over the last 15 years to be a food superpower.
00:56:28.440
So if, if, if, if Russia is becoming a food superpower, what does that tell me about,
00:56:35.840
Because you know what Ukraine has been known for, man?
00:56:40.900
It, it, it has for, you know, for, for centuries been considered the breadbasket of Europe.
00:56:46.040
And, and when, when, when the Nazis, they invaded Poland, but what do they do right after
00:56:50.580
The first place they invade when they go into the USSR.
00:56:52.220
Stop over to Ukraine for a little bit of bread.
00:56:54.200
And Hitler said it, we need to control food to keep our soldiers fed.
00:56:59.160
And people don't realize this, but the Nazis had what they called the hunger plan.
00:57:03.840
And by controlling Ukraine, they intended, according to these little known documents that
00:57:09.240
historians have on earth, you know, from the Nazis, they intended to starve 30 million people
00:57:18.140
And if you're the leader of like Russia, right.
00:57:21.400
And you're trying to build a food superpower, right.
00:57:27.660
And that, that country was deeply aligned to your country until like 2010.
00:57:33.660
And now all of a sudden it's moving its way to the West.
00:57:40.020
And then moving in closer to Europe and that food supply, you know, and so that historically
00:57:44.680
that food supply has been used as a weapon against Russia, right.
00:57:48.040
It's been used as a good weapon against others, right?
00:57:55.020
And so you think that that basically for water is one of the reasons why we're, why that war
00:58:01.000
I think all of these things have many facets and are super complicated, but I, when you're
00:58:05.940
saying what is Ukraine's strategic importance and it's food production of food and you see
00:58:12.340
Putin saying, you know, like in the film, I, you know, cause I went to Russia in the film,
00:58:17.080
I go to Russia and we sit down with the largest, the, the CEO of, of Russia's biggest beef company.
00:58:23.940
He said, whatever you guys need, because food and water are going to give us more strategic
00:58:29.700
power in the future than all of our weapons and oil does.
00:58:34.260
I mean, some of my fattest friends have the most guns too, to be honest with you.
00:58:40.440
I think they just, you know, if you're fat and happy, you'll start shooting.
00:58:43.620
I feel like, and if you're not happy, you'll start shooting.
00:58:50.520
It's like on this end, it's kind of fireworks, like, but on this end, it's like,
00:59:00.600
Get a big cash purchase discount of up to $12,300 on the 2025 GMC Sierra 1500 and the 2025
00:59:08.680
Sierra HD with Sierra 1500 premium interior and advanced tech or Sierra HD's impressive
00:59:16.800
You'll have everything you need to get from work to play with confidence this season.
00:59:27.300
Today's episode is brought to you by better help.
00:59:32.280
If you've been struggling with something in your brain or in your life, there's something
00:59:39.260
Maybe the way you once were, um, you're having a tough time.
00:59:43.400
You don't know who to talk to better help can help.
00:59:47.820
If you're thinking of starting therapy, give better help a try.
00:59:53.520
It's designed to be convenient, flexible, and suited to your schedule.
00:59:57.740
Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist and switch
01:00:02.340
therapists at any time for no additional charge.
01:00:05.580
That's one thing that I've enjoyed about better help is the ability to just switch to another
01:00:10.420
This therapist maybe isn't perfect or maybe this therapist is good, but I'm going to
01:00:16.860
I think learning to differentiate which therapists help and which don't for you is crucial.
01:00:22.420
It's crucial because it can only expedite, um, how quickly you can, uh, feel better.
01:00:31.280
That's all it takes to take care of yourself with better help.
01:00:35.100
Visit better help.com slash Theo to get 10% off your first month.
01:00:46.080
A lot of you guys know, we started off with, uh, our first advertiser ever was gray block
01:00:54.700
And the owner of gray block pizza, my friend Thomas evolved his business up in Oregon to
01:01:03.340
And he sent me one and it's absolutely beautiful.
01:01:07.360
A wonderful cold plunge, the best cold plunge in the market.
01:01:10.400
If you value American made and pinnacle cold exposure, this is your cold plunge blue cube
01:01:21.060
What I love is you can, you can set that temperature, get it down to, I mean, it might just, you might
01:01:29.840
I haven't put it that low, but you can set it to a place where you feel comfortable.
01:01:33.680
I'll get in around 50 degrees for about 10 or 12 minutes.
01:01:37.100
And that's what really sets me and activates me.
01:01:39.780
I've done it before podcasts to really put me in, um, just put me in my body and put
01:01:46.900
You know, the positive side effects of cold plunging are, are countless.
01:01:52.120
You can follow blue cubes, Instagram for a chance to win your own cold plunge this spring
01:02:07.100
And, uh, we wish them the best of luck, um, and thank them for supporting the podcast
01:02:14.420
And so I just think you start seeing like a bigger picture, you know, like you start seeing
01:02:19.760
Yeah, no, I look, that's what, I mean, yeah, that's cause I was watching the documentary.
01:02:26.880
And then that's why I wanted to get to talk to you.
01:02:28.900
I was like, I was just, I was like, is Nate like just creating fear here is the director
01:02:33.240
or are they, is this just a trend that they're seeing?
01:02:36.580
And is this like something that they really believe in and notice?
01:02:43.700
Cause it is like, it doesn't do anybody any good to just be afraid.
01:02:47.840
Just to like stress people out, bum people out and, and, and, um, but no, I mean, I think
01:02:53.040
like fundamentally when, when the landscape is shifting in front of us and like the most
01:02:59.160
powerful people are shifting with that landscape, like I'm a big advocate of the everyday guy.
01:03:04.340
And I'm like, dude, we got to empower ourselves with that same information.
01:03:07.620
You know, we have to know how this thing is shifting.
01:03:11.540
Because otherwise those people in Arizona, they just see this big farm come in and they're
01:03:15.960
What they don't know is that it gets part of this big international trend and they're
01:03:20.840
They don't know that their own government is, is allowing that, which in some ways are nice
01:03:26.220
things that America does allows, you know, and that we've also, we've done a ton of like
01:03:31.460
of open handedness, you know, but there does become a point where, yeah, if it gets back
01:03:35.960
to survival that, um, you're going to change your tune.
01:03:42.800
And America is, I don't know if you'll do it as a country, but you, as
01:03:45.900
an individual, you won't have a choice, but to do it.
01:03:50.940
I mean, food prices will probably continue to climb.
01:03:54.140
And people are going to have to make like real, you know, lifestyle decisions based on
01:03:58.560
Um, you know, we'll probably see food potentially becoming a bigger and bigger percentage of
01:04:05.300
Um, but you know, potentially, you know, like that's the trend line.
01:04:09.920
So I think, you know, I think, I just think it, it, information is power.
01:04:13.800
And what I'll tell you is that the most powerful have access to better information today.
01:04:18.420
I think that the disparity of information between the powerful and the everyday person
01:04:24.880
Like we always talk about income disparity and it's a real thing.
01:04:28.160
But information disparity, man, it, it might even be worse.
01:04:32.400
And even just to go to accredited news sources online, not to get information, you have to
01:04:38.760
Even to get what used to be just a newspaper, right?
01:04:43.980
So whether you even believe that it's going to be true or not to have information that's
01:04:48.180
even kind of sourced, you know, that's put together, that's formatted, that's not done
01:04:56.860
And I hope that we get back to more of that, man, because that's how it used to be when
01:05:00.140
Like you'd, you'd pay of a newspaper subscription.
01:05:04.000
I think people decided they couldn't trust the news anymore.
01:05:06.980
I think a lot of that has occurred in the past 10 years for sure.
01:05:10.840
I think I feel like the news, every time I turn it on, I feel like it is, there's some
01:05:18.060
There's some, um, you know, I mean, people say big farm all the time, but we have so many
01:05:24.320
It's like, you know, it just feel, I wouldn't be surprised if it's compromised.
01:05:31.260
I, the news industry is in a tailspin and I'll give you my two cents for what it's worth.
01:05:35.040
Cause I've been a journalist now for like 25 years, some insane amount of time.
01:05:39.940
Um, but when I started, um, as a daily newspaper reporter, like we had a nice big staff, man,
01:05:48.600
We had researchers on staff, you know, we had photographers, a sports desk, a business
01:05:54.240
And, um, and I, I think, I don't know, man, it was like, there's like a third as many
01:06:00.980
Like if there's fewer people doing anything, it's going to be a shittier job.
01:06:06.980
And so, and, and, and, and the trend line that, that gutted journalism wasn't initially
01:06:15.220
People don't trust the news like they used to, but it wasn't in the trend line.
01:06:20.220
What happened was, is that newspapers used to make huge profits from things like classified
01:06:25.420
Like, you know, we used to read the classified ads in the back, right?
01:06:28.360
Like you could meet a woman or even get a adopt a pet, get a new BMX bike or like a dirt
01:06:32.760
bike, like a new car, like it was all back there.
01:06:35.700
And that stuff, man, that subsidized the journalists.
01:06:38.940
And so of course that went away and that was like a lion's share of the profits.
01:06:46.520
And like the newspapers didn't, they didn't react in time.
01:06:52.000
And so like, you just started seeing the industry shrinking and shrinking.
01:06:55.220
And now the layoffs in the last two years have just been like brutal.
01:06:58.380
But the, the, the problem there is, man, it's like I could quit journalism.
01:07:02.400
And I could go become a private researcher doing the exact same thing I'm doing now as
01:07:08.200
But instead of giving it to the public, I would be giving it to hedge funds.
01:07:11.800
I'd be giving it to super wealthy people that would literally, I'm not shitting you, would
01:07:15.420
pay me four to five times what I'm getting paid now.
01:07:18.800
And, and, and that's actually what's happening.
01:07:21.140
And so like you, you, you have the public who is increasingly just getting not as good
01:07:26.940
as much information, especially if you're in like a local news market, right?
01:07:33.240
There are fewer journalists and then the wealthiest are paying for it still.
01:07:37.400
And they're getting incredibly in-depth information.
01:07:40.880
And now you're starting to see privatized spaces have the journalists almost on their
01:07:46.620
side, working for them to give them information that better helps them to market to the everyday
01:07:55.580
And I wouldn't say call that person a journalist, but that, that same like deep research or
01:07:59.960
investigative project, especially in tech, man.
01:08:03.500
Well, I think it's like, you know, they had, even if you look at the case of the opioid
01:08:09.460
And that there was a documentary, there was a television show.
01:08:14.640
All the beauty in the bloodshed was a doc that came out that looked super deep at the
01:08:19.960
Alex Gibney, maybe on HBO looked at the opioid epidemic too.
01:08:27.340
I mean, I don't know Hollywood, so I don't know actors and I don't know the space as well,
01:08:35.280
It's how, it's how the opioid companies pay, like basically hired people that had been
01:08:44.580
working on the food and drug administration to come and work for them so they could work the
01:08:51.220
And I'll, I mean, I'll just tell you my two cents.
01:08:53.300
The reason that we often know stories like this, like how FDA former employees were then
01:08:58.540
going is because a journalist went in and dug it out and published it.
01:09:03.140
Like these types of fictionalized versions get written off of like hard work of investigative
01:09:08.200
And there are fewer and fewer people pulling out stories like this.
01:09:11.360
And I'll tell you, man, as a journalist, like my problem 20 years ago was that I was always
01:09:17.000
worried that some other journalist was going to scoop the story and get it out.
01:09:19.900
Before me today, my problem is that people are coming to me with important stories and I don't
01:09:26.560
have the time to work on them because I'm already working on something and I don't even have another
01:09:33.320
Like we're just not getting out as many important stories like that as we used to, because there's
01:09:37.940
Like, and, and, and, and there are more people working for the lobbyists.
01:09:41.680
There are more people working for the PR firms that are spinning stuff.
01:09:44.540
And so this is, we're getting into this really imbalanced place of information and a dark time.
01:09:52.440
Because it's like, well, people are going by their gut.
01:09:55.600
People are looking to fill a void and people want some truth.
01:09:59.420
I think if you don't have truth, you can feel it.
01:10:03.560
And, and I always say, and this is the other thing, man, is for me, journalism, it's okay.
01:10:09.220
Like the, the surface of a football is imperfect, right?
01:10:16.120
Because if you, if you throw the football without spiraling it, because the surface of
01:10:24.300
And, and, and, and, but you spiral it and all of those imperfections get smoothed out.
01:10:32.480
But when you've got 10 journalists covering the same thing, you're going to get as close
01:10:36.800
to the, to the obtainable version of the truth as possible because you have 10 different
01:10:43.060
They're going to, they're, they're going to check each other.
01:10:45.120
They're going to, they're going to point out if somebody else, you know, misses something
01:10:47.680
or screw something up and you get at the closest possible obtainable version of the
01:10:52.480
Now, when you just have one person, it's like a football that's not spiraling anymore.
01:11:00.500
And, and I think that's like in a democracy when we're supposed to be an informed group of
01:11:05.300
people that are going to go to the ballot box and vote, you know, it's a problem.
01:11:08.620
If we were in China, it wouldn't matter because the government's going to tell us what to
01:11:11.680
But in a country where we're like, no, no, we need to be informed so we can go to vote.
01:11:27.160
So it's like, I wouldn't have asked me, but I thought it worked for me.
01:11:32.200
I'm easily, I'm easily susceptible to just whatever.
01:11:35.400
But, but yeah, I wonder what does that look like for us?
01:11:39.660
If we, when you get to a place where you don't trust, I wonder if it's that we don't trust
01:11:49.880
But I always thought there was this level of integrity maybe in the distance that I, maybe
01:11:56.520
I thought I'm, it's so hard for me to figure out what I feel like is missing these days.
01:12:01.040
I feel like as individuals, a lot of us are missing purpose and our purpose is being farmed
01:12:07.580
out to technology and to big corporations instead of things that are meaningful.
01:12:19.300
You don't have like a local place where everybody can even go meet up.
01:12:24.240
So there's, at that point, you're just a lot of strangers living near each other.
01:12:32.140
I wonder, you know, like what does the future of that look like?
01:12:35.880
Do we just turn into like these lemmings just waiting for the next cheeseburger?
01:12:41.220
Like, you know, I, I, I, you know, I, I've done some investigative reporting on big tech
01:12:46.820
and that's a space, you know, like that I, I, you know, like, man, my reporting has shown
01:12:52.780
me like things that just like as a human, as a person concern me, you know, like it's
01:12:58.580
like really cool because they're, they become these beautiful creative spaces.
01:13:02.500
And, and, and like as people that are artistic and like to share their stories, people get
01:13:07.460
on there and they can connect with communities and there's all these great things that happen.
01:13:11.160
But I increasingly see those spaces as a hunting ground for big tech companies to target specific
01:13:19.340
And I'll give you one of the examples I'm talking about is that I did this investigative
01:13:23.980
product where I got this investigation, um, where I got internal emails from inside of
01:13:29.760
Facebook and I got, you know, documents from inside of this company that was like a social
01:13:35.840
It was essentially like you could play games on your phone that looked like a slot machine
01:13:47.640
And if you used up all your coins that they get in the day for free, you would then have
01:13:55.160
Something like 99% of people never pay for coins.
01:14:00.200
And then it's something like one 10th of 1% drive like 97% of the revenue at that company.
01:14:06.840
And those companies that again, you can never win your money back.
01:14:10.580
We're now generating more revenue than the Las Vegas strip billions and billions of dollars.
01:14:16.220
So who were the people that were spending money?
01:14:24.180
She spent $400,000 buying virtual coins that she could never win back.
01:14:35.360
Well, it turns out that a certain slice of people, very small slight have a,
01:14:40.560
type of brain that can get super fixated on this.
01:14:47.800
And the technology companies devised algorithms.
01:14:51.620
They use artificial intelligence where the CEO of one of these companies said the first
01:14:56.080
time somebody opens that app and starts playing, they can identify them from all of the little
01:15:01.160
habits and immediately mark them as what they would call a VIP or a whale.
01:15:07.120
And they would put them down this path where they would actually get a special representative,
01:15:14.060
This woman outside of Texas who lost $400,000 when her mom died, they sent flowers to her mom's
01:15:19.360
Like they immediately identify that you have this type of brain that's going to keep spending
01:15:24.220
money that you can't, A, you can't afford and B, you'll never get back.
01:15:28.480
And they just target you and they push you and they pull as much money out of you as they
01:15:35.320
And I see this, like, I see now, like people are spending their time on there, but people
01:15:40.500
are watching you spend your time and they're building your behavior and they're looking
01:15:45.300
And as soon as they can exploit your weakness, man, they are going to grab everything they
01:15:52.780
It's what you would think of as the devil using yourself against you even.
01:15:56.580
I mean, look, what if your own shadow could fucking pick your pocket?
01:16:05.000
That's almost as bad as your football thing, but, uh, but no, bro, it's the, it's the dark
01:16:12.740
It's like the algorithm learning you and learning you and learning you massaging you and all
01:16:19.660
But is it, is it for profit or is it for control?
01:16:26.060
I just don't understand how that behooves anybody.
01:16:29.800
Like who closes their eyes at night and was like, yeah, dude, those companies that I just
01:16:36.360
talked about went from nothing in like 2009 to 2010 to being billion dollar companies.
01:16:42.000
And they were owned by a few dudes who started them up.
01:16:49.020
I found one of the women who worked at one of these companies who was pushing this woman
01:16:56.360
And I got on her Instagram, that girl was just flying around the world, living it up
01:17:10.780
And in the meantime, she's just encouraging people to lose their money.
01:17:14.860
And can we name these people or is it kind of private information?
01:17:18.380
Well, I can, you know, I mean, I wrote my story.
01:17:26.680
Is that the name of the company that was targeting?
01:17:29.520
I want to pull up the story to make sure I was getting this right, because this is the
01:17:33.100
challenge I have as an investigative journalist.
01:17:42.320
And so, you know, we can pull up the story and because I did this story now, what was
01:17:49.840
These are companies where you can't win, really.
01:17:53.660
But you people have like figured out that there's a type of person with a behavior that
01:18:06.300
It says social casinos now use behavioral analysis software to quickly identify people
01:18:09.940
who are likely to become big spenders, behaviors like increasing your bet or playing frequently
01:18:15.540
And they target these players with heavy marketing and label them proto whales as Brotons explained
01:18:21.960
to a room full of game developers back in 2015.
01:18:23.960
And if I remember correctly, that guy, Jose Brotons, was like a Stanford graduate, you know, in
01:18:29.400
like computer science or something, took that knowledge.
01:18:32.280
You know, they pair it up with like essentially like behavioral scientists, psychologists, and
01:18:38.380
then they just start getting better and better at focusing on these people who they can extract
01:18:46.700
And sometimes though, there's a part of people that go to gamble like that.
01:18:50.000
There's a part of them that wants to some, sometimes I think that there's a part of us
01:18:57.580
when I'm amazed that we don't stand up sometimes as a population, right?
01:19:05.000
I don't think we have the information to know this story.
01:19:07.680
Like how many, like that to me, that story is mind blowing that that's going on.
01:19:12.500
How many people are gambling on their phone or looking at playing solitaire and then it turns
01:19:17.400
Or how many of us are just aware in which like the patterns of ads that we see are like,
01:19:23.520
oh, because they have your behavioral profile, right?
01:19:26.540
Like you're getting a pattern this way or your newsfeed looks this way or you're getting
01:19:34.720
Like how is that affecting your everyday decisions?
01:19:37.140
And in Susie's case, it was affecting her everyday decision to the point where she was lying
01:19:41.800
She was taking out, if I recall correctly, second mortgages on her homes.
01:19:47.780
I had the emails, the messages back and forth with her and the rep from that company.
01:20:03.060
You know, if you still want to quit when you're done with that.
01:20:08.520
It's like, when would we stop allowing certain things?
01:20:23.080
But it's like at a certain point, I recognize, oh, I'm not using this safely, right?
01:20:28.040
Like I go use it when I'm feeling down or when I'm agitated or something.
01:20:40.140
I'm not disparaging any of the people that use it or that perform it.
01:20:48.940
But I wonder if overall, sometimes we know that it hurts us or like they just had that
01:20:57.760
You had this couple pushing the company and they're married and the husband was the owner
01:21:05.500
and they're saying, well, we don't cheat, but you might need to, right?
01:21:13.340
It feels like, I mean, like, why would we allow that?
01:21:17.080
Like, it seemed like if you took a vote amongst people, would we, do we want this in our lives?
01:21:25.340
But if you are tempted with it, if it comes in, like if a cat comes on your, if you tell
01:21:31.300
I'll tell you, dude, honestly, you can fuck off, right?
01:21:35.620
But if a cat keeps coming on my porch, dude, I'm gonna go out there and touch it.
01:21:41.940
Like at some point, even if I might be like, man, fuck this thing, I might be out there petting
01:21:46.780
So it's like, you know, and is that our responsibility or is that-
01:21:53.500
Carry the cat around in your pocket with you all the time.
01:21:59.460
But yeah, it's like, I guess I often wonder like, is that just our responsibility and,
01:22:06.240
or is there, should there be a, yeah, I guess you can't depend on the government, but you
01:22:11.300
would think as a society, we wouldn't want these things.
01:22:15.940
And I think part of it is like, these things are being developed in, in San Francisco,
01:22:21.120
Silicon Valley, wherever, faster than like, we can learn about them and adjust to them.
01:22:28.580
And, and, and, and, and again, like, I mean, I don't, I mean, obviously I'm biased because
01:22:33.000
I'm an investigative journalist, but like, this is the role that I think we're losing
01:22:36.220
in our society by, as journalism keeps going away is because like in that story that we
01:22:41.940
were just talking about with Susie and the social casinos, those dudes would suit me if
01:22:47.420
Like if, if, if, if, like they are going to ask for a correction, if I got something
01:22:54.000
In the end, Susie and a bunch of other people got 155 million bucks back from them.
01:23:01.960
So, you know, and, and, and like, I don't have it out against anybody, man.
01:23:05.920
I just want good information out there in the public.
01:23:09.100
You know, like it empowers all of us, even if like, dude, it could be the same piece of
01:23:14.420
And from that same accurate, good piece of information, you might decide that A is the
01:23:21.860
But to me, that's a democracy because now you and I are passionate out whether A is better
01:23:26.100
or B is better, but we're operating off the same good information.
01:23:29.080
But yeah, and if you're saying that other, but that, that information is also becoming
01:23:33.580
like what's valuable and what isn't, and that there's better information out there that
01:23:37.720
obviously corporations can afford, that they can afford the researchers now to privatize
01:23:45.580
Then yeah, for the regular person, it just gets, it gets a little interesting.
01:23:50.540
Dude, I'm never going to have good enough information to tell you who are the people
01:23:54.180
most likely to compulsively spend on something, right?
01:23:58.020
But if I, if I'm given enough time, I can probably find out what the companies are that
01:24:02.860
have that information that are targeting people like Susie, and I can at least make us aware
01:24:07.280
So we probably, as a society will never have access to that information.
01:24:10.680
We probably don't want all of us to know who the compulsive gamblers are.
01:24:13.620
But at least we want to know who the companies are that are targeting people who have that
01:24:18.520
Or targeting people for whatever their weaknesses.
01:24:24.360
And they can all just be, it can, they can almost be mathematically equated now.
01:24:31.100
And they're attacking, and then that's used to attack us.
01:24:35.320
It's like, it's like, I want to say it's like our reflection is using the fact that
01:24:51.540
And it's like, they're creating like a data profile, like a virtual one of us, like evil
01:24:59.540
And then like that person's telling them our weaknesses.
01:25:02.800
It's like, you're looking in, you're like, God, that's like a version of me they've created.
01:25:06.860
And that person is ratting me out and they're coming at me with that dude's info.
01:25:11.020
I mean, and it's getting stronger and better that technology.
01:25:15.120
And then it also makes you a little bit upset at yourself because you're the one feeding
01:25:20.120
into the same thing that's, you know, beckoning you with things that'll end up being painful
01:25:28.140
And look, I have a stoic philosophy on these things.
01:25:30.080
Like I, I, I believe that we can't control, you know, what happens outside of us, but we
01:25:37.500
And I think this is something like you and I were talking about cold plunges or like, you
01:25:41.240
know, just like how you can reset, like, and it's super uncomfortable, but like,
01:25:44.460
you can control your body and your body's like, dude, I do not want to go in that cold
01:25:52.140
Cause I know that when I get out, I'm going to feel better.
01:25:54.920
And, and part of it is personal responsibility.
01:26:03.060
Like we do have personal, but we also shouldn't be targeted in that way.
01:26:08.300
It's crazy to let somebody continue to be targeted.
01:26:11.420
It's like at a certain point, you would stop a pedophile from coming near a child, you
01:26:16.160
At a certain point, if somebody had a hatchet and somebody was just trying to sit there
01:26:19.620
and eat a sandwich, you would stop the hatchet guy from bothering the sandwich eater.
01:26:26.460
Could the sandwich eater get up and leave the restaurant, but maybe the solution is just
01:26:33.240
Instead of making this huge hullabaloo, like now every sandwich eater can only eat sandwiches
01:26:40.660
You don't, you just want to sit there and finish your sandwich.
01:26:45.020
In the end, it comes down to our own personal responsibility for now.
01:26:50.460
And I also think we should be demanding better environments for ourselves and our children.
01:26:56.260
I don't have kids, but you know, I always bring in kids cause people seem to be more
01:26:59.620
responsive, you know, but I think kids are living in.
01:27:04.740
And I don't know that though, it's, you know, I think we just need to be more proactive
01:27:08.680
about what are the environments we want as a society.
01:27:13.820
Cause it feels like everybody has kind of the same things in mind, but we never seem
01:27:18.540
And, and it feels even more like the voting is coming from the other side, like that it's
01:27:25.600
Like, you know, like tech is the new fossil fuel.
01:27:28.060
I've said that for a long time where it's like, that's the thing that's power.
01:27:35.440
It feels like they have a lot of information, man.
01:27:42.180
Well, I think like people, like the, like if all of us have better information, right?
01:27:50.180
Like again, like we can, we can push like the part, like the documentary, man, like you
01:27:55.760
Like, you know, like, I do think there's stuff in the documentary.
01:27:59.100
It's going to freak people out, freak me out when I learned about it.
01:28:02.400
So at the end of the day, it's the point of it just to freak people out.
01:28:04.680
No, it's to be like, you know, we have no national water policy in the United States.
01:28:08.480
You know that we have no national water policy.
01:28:10.600
So that means that, uh, people from anywhere or any country, whatever can move here and
01:28:20.600
It's true in some places, like different States, different counties have different laws.
01:28:26.280
But we have no, we have no national water policy that just says like, wait a minute, wait
01:28:31.260
Let's make sure that we're not using it for just like any old thing.
01:28:34.440
Let's make sure that just like as a general rule of thumb, we're using it for like the best
01:28:38.880
And let's help States and counties in these places come to the decision.
01:28:46.940
But if water is such a solid, like a, if it's so important for the future, wouldn't that
01:28:51.460
be one of the first things we would do probably.
01:28:57.080
I don't know if just like when I have to go to, when I, you know, when I go to family
01:29:00.560
reunions, I don't know that all my family knows.
01:29:02.340
And a lot of my families, they're like farmers.
01:29:04.480
But I don't know that they know that this is the trend line that's happening.
01:29:08.780
And so you put this documentary out there, not to freak people out, but so that we all
01:29:15.020
And then we can push our elected officials who, and, and, and man, you all, you, you hear
01:29:20.360
about all the different lobbies and all, you know, that push the government around the
01:29:24.620
agricultural lobby is one of the most, if not the most powerful lobby in the country.
01:29:28.420
And, and, and part for really good reasons, man, you screw up farmers, like you can really
01:29:38.560
And they should have a voice, you know, but at the same time, like communities that are
01:29:43.580
around the farms and others and who's coming in and who's controlling it, that needs to
01:29:50.200
And until people have good information, it's tough to have a good conversation.
01:29:53.280
So whether or not we're talking about tech and like people targeting you because they're
01:29:57.360
a big technology company and they know that you're going to be compulsive about this one
01:30:00.740
thing and they can extract something from you, whether it's like how you choose to behave
01:30:05.260
or how you choose to spend, or whether it's like, you know, foreign company, foreign, you
01:30:10.040
know, countries coming in or wall street coming in and pumping out water in places that really
01:30:19.860
Because it's, the days are over where people have anybody else's best interest a lot of
01:30:24.100
over, like it's where companies certainly don't cause they're not an individual.
01:30:28.820
They're thinking with a different, yes, they are.
01:30:31.120
They're thinking it's a spreadsheet trying to have a brain.
01:30:36.700
And you now have like some of the biggest sovereign wealth funds, you know, which is
01:30:44.620
Some of them got advanced degrees from college and some of them barely graduated high school.
01:30:48.580
I mean, I was somebody that barely graduated high school, but you know, they didn't go to
01:30:52.300
And, and so like, I have a huge spectrum of, of people I love and someone will tell me
01:30:57.080
about like the Illuminati, the Illuminati are controlling things.
01:30:59.540
I'm like, dude, no, but go look at sovereign wealth funds, right?
01:31:03.740
Sovereign wealth funds are countries like China that are pooling together these huge
01:31:08.700
pools of cash, trillions and trillions and trillions of dollars.
01:31:13.180
And then they can use that strategically to buy things, you know, to drive the markets
01:31:19.360
Now here in the United States, we just believe that the profit is how everything.
01:31:23.260
So like, oh, if you can make more money doing A than B, then you should go do A.
01:31:29.980
But China goes, no, no, we want to create the most jobs we can for the country.
01:31:34.640
And therefore we're going to take all of our assets.
01:31:36.680
We're going to try to create the most jobs, not the most profit, but the most jobs.
01:31:40.120
And so then what happens is you have Smithfield foods, one in four American pigs, and you
01:31:45.940
have a Chinese company and they go like, we don't care necessarily about per se driving
01:31:53.520
Like our government is saying to us that we need to go overseas and buy up food and
01:31:57.280
So we'll pay you a 30% premium over the share price.
01:32:00.460
Well, for the American company, that's like 30% premium over the share price.
01:32:03.940
Like I have a fiduciary responsibility to my shareholders.
01:32:10.100
Otherwise I can actually legally get in jeopardy here for saying no to that offer.
01:32:14.560
Because I'm, I am, I'm legally obligated to return profits to the shareholder.
01:32:18.040
Well, the Chinese company is operating under a completely different system.
01:32:22.460
And so that's where you begin to see, gosh, this is probably super in the weeds, but that's
01:32:25.820
where you begin to see like this international power play.
01:32:29.000
And like you're talking about, like where the U S is so focused on profits.
01:32:37.040
And we can manipulate you because you're super focused on profits.
01:32:40.700
Oh, because if they own a fourth of the, of the industry.
01:32:44.520
Or, or they, they just know, like the American company is always going to do whatever is
01:32:49.940
And, and, and we don't like, so we can buy that, you know, like they, they, they know
01:32:54.860
how our system works and they're getting better at manipulating that system is like right
01:33:01.040
So instead of this, of this American company saying, Hey, this is an American company, let's
01:33:06.580
It's a part of like, you know, it affects our GDP, all these sorts of things.
01:33:16.040
So it's like, let's just pay more and we'll definitely get it.
01:33:19.660
Because the way that the American companies built their shareholders would get upset if
01:33:23.220
they didn't, if they took a vote, the shareholders were like, why didn't you do it?
01:33:27.780
Not only why we didn't you, but we could sue you and probably win if you didn't return
01:33:33.640
And so China has, China has sovereign wealth funds, which are literally trillions and trillions
01:33:45.880
And the government can decide how to allocate that.
01:33:49.500
And so the, you know, if, if the U S had that, you'd always be allocating it for whatever's
01:33:56.080
China's going to be allocating it potentially for whatever gives them the most political strength,
01:34:07.000
As I understand it, I wouldn't talk to this professor, this academic at Stanford, who's
01:34:11.180
one of the foremost experts in the country on these things.
01:34:13.780
As I understand it, it's a fairly, they're fairly new.
01:34:16.300
The, the middle Eastern countries, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, UAE, they also have really big sovereign
01:34:25.980
Surprisingly, Norway has a really big sovereign wealth fund, but they can use these things
01:34:31.160
strategically, especially against like a profit driven country like the U S.
01:34:37.220
So it's crazy to think that being profitable could be your weakness.
01:34:46.220
The world's largest sovereign wealth fund as of December, 2022 was China investment corporation
01:34:50.800
managing assets, reaching around a 1.35 trillion U S dollars.
01:34:56.280
Pull up like the top 10 list of sovereign wealth funds.
01:35:01.000
GIC, the one we just talked about national welfare, I know China, China investment corporation
01:35:07.200
and Tamasek that's Singapore public investment fund could be us, but who knows?
01:35:17.160
So those are the big 10 biggest sovereign wealth funds.
01:35:19.780
So those can really, somebody's got to have a list for how much assets each of them have
01:35:23.480
at 1.7 trillion seems small to me, but we're not even on the top 10 list.
01:35:28.720
As far as I know, we, the U S doesn't operate a sovereign wealth fund like this because it's
01:35:37.600
You start to, yeah, you don't, uh, you don't think about how perspective and mindset, um,
01:35:46.800
No, the United States does not have a federal sovereign wealth fund, but several States
01:35:50.780
These funds are usually smaller than international SF, SWFs and can serve different purposes.
01:35:55.960
For example, the Alaska permanent fund corporation established in the early 1980s has roughly 67
01:36:01.540
billion in assets and was created to ensure that Alaskan citizens benefited from oil extracted
01:36:09.840
Norway's is very similar to Alaska where it's like, they, they, they are an oil wealthy
01:36:13.820
And so they created a sovereign wealth fund, um, to bet, to benefit the citizens.
01:36:19.180
Texas also, it says has two sovereign wealth funds, including the Texas permanent school
01:36:23.260
fund, which was founded in 1854 and manages 46.5 billion in assets to benefit public schools.
01:36:34.400
And they're going to think maybe I'm going to own the land, the schools on just different things
01:36:37.540
And then, so these foreign countries have these massive pools of cash that they can
01:36:45.240
You start like seeing the, the, the, the, the chess players on the board, like moving
01:36:50.960
What states are, um, are looking out for their land?
01:36:56.740
What states are kind of at the head of the forefront?
01:36:59.400
Uh, off the top of my head, you know, well, so like, I think Iowa has a law that, that
01:37:05.680
foreign companies, uh, can't own farmland in Iowa.
01:37:12.260
And, um, but like, is it, you know, like the question is, is like, does it really matter
01:37:19.100
if it's a foreign company or a domestic company if they're doing good by the local people?
01:37:33.360
Like, you know, is it like people, local people prospering?
01:37:36.700
Like, that's like, I don't know, at the end of the day, like what people are going to
01:37:40.540
Like, I think what becomes dangerous is when you see these things that are just like highly
01:37:45.280
extractive to the, to the detriment, you know, of the local folks who are seeing
01:37:50.440
their water disappear, um, who aren't seeing like a lot of job creation, you know, like
01:37:58.680
And especially if it's their space, you know, I even pulled up on that Saudi farm.
01:38:02.200
I remember, I think I pulled up visas and they were bringing in, uh, workers, if I'm
01:38:06.980
recalling correctly from the Philippines, you know, so they'd be like, well, we're creating
01:38:11.780
So you're bringing in workers from the Philippines to work on your farm.
01:38:14.960
You know, like, yeah, you probably have, yeah, you probably have farmers right in the area that
01:38:21.960
So these things are so many loopholes and stuff.
01:38:29.140
So when you look at like places not having enough water, right.
01:38:42.380
And we're in a good space, except for like these like regional examples, right?
01:38:45.380
Like places in the West and the Southwest places that are going to get potentially a lot
01:38:51.240
Um, so I, I got these classified cables answering your question.
01:38:57.380
I got these classified cables and I'm from, uh, the U S embassy that had gone.
01:39:02.440
Like, uh, diplomatic cables that the state department was sending back from its embassy in Switzerland
01:39:09.400
Sometimes that stuff goes to like CIA, the state department, other, other cables.
01:39:17.160
Um, and, uh, and so there, the, some folks from the U S embassy in Switzerland had gone
01:39:23.040
to the headquarters of Nestle and Nestle is like the world's largest food company.
01:39:28.440
And the chief economist at Nestle sort of gave them a tour and like a perspective from
01:39:33.400
the world's largest food company about how screwed up everything was.
01:39:37.320
And they talked about the regions that were going to get hit hardest by not having enough
01:39:44.720
Um, it was like India, the middle East, but it was also the Western United States, you
01:39:50.400
know, like the Western United States is in a pretty tough spot when it comes to having
01:39:54.340
enough water to keep doing all the things they're currently doing.
01:40:00.120
And that was like the hot take from Nestle was like, you know, forget about it.
01:40:04.820
At that time it was like the, the, the, it was 2009.
01:40:06.900
It was the great recession and Nestle is just like, forget about it.
01:40:12.060
The world is running out of enough water to feed everybody.
01:40:17.800
You think some of them would, I think some of them do these things like water.
01:40:21.220
People will always tell you water is super local.
01:40:24.380
And so some counties, some regions within States and some States themselves are doing better
01:40:30.440
And some countries are definitely doing better than others just in terms of like planning
01:40:38.280
That's like the thing with, with a lot of the issues that we face, you know, like we
01:40:42.180
can do, we're a super smart species, you know, like we've, we've done a lot of stuff.
01:40:47.840
We just have to move off of the trend lines that we're currently headed on, you know?
01:40:51.360
And those trend lines are more like me, me, me instead of us.
01:40:56.000
Or is it like, cause is there enough water for everybody?
01:40:58.460
Uh, there is enough water to grow enough food that everyone in the world could eat.
01:41:02.720
Not even like today, man, which we, what are we?
01:41:04.620
7 billion people or so, like there's enough water to grow enough food to feed 10 billion
01:41:12.300
It kind of goes back to what I was saying about China where it's like, they just, now they're
01:41:17.740
And, and Nestle in that, in that classified cable said like, if everyone in the world ate
01:41:23.000
as much meat per capita as Americans do, we would have run out of fresh water in the
01:41:29.880
And, and I'm not a vegetarian, I'm not a vegan, right?
01:41:32.420
I'm just like, this is what the world's largest food company is saying, you know?
01:41:36.240
And, um, I know people love beef and I know people love steak, you know?
01:41:39.960
And like it's there, but like, but that's all of it.
01:41:42.860
But when it comes to like, how can we shift, how can we take some personal responsibility
01:41:52.100
And it's not even saying like, you need to become vegetarian or vegan.
01:41:55.660
It's just like, how much meat do you need to be a healthy human?
01:41:59.400
And you got people with obesity and heart attacks, you know, and all these issues.
01:42:03.120
Oh, you got people damn snorting meat out there.
01:42:05.560
You know, you got some real, um, mammal pervs out there.
01:42:10.620
You know, people who will just cook anything that's wandered up on their porch even and
01:42:17.000
I had a buddy that had a t-shirt and this is in San Francisco.
01:42:20.940
So he definitely, he definitely pissed people off.
01:42:34.940
Um, well, you do have businesses like, um, Bill Gates is starting like a beyond meat.
01:42:44.900
There's like, yeah, beyond meat, impossible burgers.
01:42:49.460
A lot of those guys got really, they got funding.
01:42:51.460
And again, those were like, that's a way to replace meat with a less water intensive meat
01:42:57.440
substitute, you know, something that tastes like meat.
01:43:00.540
So that's one way that people could preserve water.
01:43:06.180
It just requires a lot, lot, lot less water to eat a grain than it does to feed enough
01:43:14.580
And what about other methods that people, you hear about like a desalinization, you hear
01:43:27.120
And I remember like one of my buddies, he learned I was doing this and I'd moved off
01:43:30.820
And I was looking at this, you got to look at cloud seeding.
01:43:32.480
And I was like, dude, that's some conspiracy shit you read online.
01:43:35.180
And I looked at it and I was like, oh no, people do really do cloud seeding.
01:43:38.620
Like I think the ski resorts were doing cloud seeding.
01:43:40.580
I think the Israeli government was doing cloud seeding.
01:43:44.980
It hasn't really found a practical application.
01:43:47.200
As far as I know, this isn't my area of expertise.
01:43:53.480
Cloud seeding is a weather modification technique that improves a cloud's ability to produce rain
01:43:57.340
or snow by introducing tiny ice nuclei into certain types of sub freezing clouds.
01:44:05.740
And I guess you then, it looks like just fire ice particles into it.
01:44:15.640
A four hour operation that seeds 24 clouds can cost around $5,000.
01:44:22.260
So rich people could have rain or something if they wanted to have like a Noah's art party
01:44:25.880
or like the perfect storm, if they wanted to do a perfect storm reenactment of that movie.
01:44:33.940
Per acre, cloud seeding operations can cost around $0.40 per planted acre or $10 to $15
01:44:43.500
Well, that's actually not, you know, this is not my area of expertise, but $10 to $15 for
01:44:53.100
So if that, you know, and that's in Utah specifically, right?
01:44:56.160
So they've got to have their own like climatology, their own hydrology, like so it can be super
01:45:01.460
specific, but $10 to $15 for an acre foot is really cheap for water.
01:45:07.080
Because you start talking about desalination plant and now you're talking about $2,000 per
01:45:14.860
And like we're growing tomatoes typically with like $50 per acre foot water and an acre
01:45:19.920
foot just, it's a, it's, it's actually super simple.
01:45:23.560
It's how, if an acre foot is the equivalent of flooding an acre of land with one foot of
01:45:31.180
The global cloud seeding market is estimated to have a valuation of $131.4 million in 2023
01:45:37.400
over the forecast period from 2023 to 2030, it is projected to experience substantial growth
01:45:43.000
with an estimated compound annual growth of 5.8%.
01:45:46.860
By 2030, the market is expected to reach a value of $194.4 million.
01:45:54.260
They're saying this is a market insights website.
01:45:59.060
So if, I don't know if that's legit or not, but what else does it say?
01:46:05.240
Not since, not since Charlemagne was crowned Holy Roman Emperor in 800 AD has the American
01:46:10.900
West been so dry, a recent study in nature climate change found the period 2000 to 2021
01:46:16.640
was the driest in 22 years in more than a millennium, attributing a fifth of that anomaly to human
01:46:25.900
Lake Mead and Lake Powell have reached their lowest levels ever, triggering unprecedented
01:46:31.740
Cloud seeding operations have also expanded in water stress regions outside.
01:46:39.300
Within the past two years, Idaho, Utah, Colorado, Wyoming, and California have expanded cloud
01:46:50.140
And it, I mean, I know, I remember the ski resorts doing it and people are doing it.
01:46:54.360
I wonder how much water ultimately you're going to be able to squeeze out of the atmosphere
01:47:03.940
Like if you, if you spend the money to shoot the water, to put the particles out there,
01:47:08.300
but cloud seeding should not be thought of as a response to drought.
01:47:10.880
Experts agree for one, in a drought, there are likely to be fewer seedable storms.
01:47:16.120
And when there are storms, even the estimates from cloud seeding companies themselves show
01:47:20.320
the practice increases precipitation by only around 10% in a given area.
01:47:24.760
That might be worth the effort when every acre foot counts, but it's not going to end
01:47:40.060
It's like terraforming the earth at that point.
01:47:45.120
When it becomes like air sims or whatever, it's going to get weird.
01:47:50.880
Because like basically it takes a ton of energy, like electricity, to basically push
01:47:56.660
water through what's just like a giant filter and pull out the salt or whatever it is that's
01:48:04.040
And so it ends up, the water ends up costing, you know, a hundred times what, you know, farmers
01:48:15.860
Dude, people use desal all the time for drinking water.
01:48:18.460
And, and for some industrial use, but at the price it becomes very difficult to create
01:48:27.060
Are some countries saying you can't buy land here?
01:48:31.500
They, you know, and, and, and, and they're saying you can't grow that type of crop here
01:48:37.440
There, there are people are other countries getting really selective as to how their water
01:48:42.520
is going to be used and what, what it can be used for.
01:48:45.120
It's so tough for us to think because we've manipulated so many other markets and has
01:48:49.200
done things ourselves, you know, you would go upstream from your neighbor and split that
01:48:53.880
river that split that Creek that's headed your way if you had to.
01:48:58.680
And that's, you know, people are just seeing like the river, their village relies on all
01:49:06.540
Um, and that's more and more of what you're seeing in Africa and places like that.
01:49:11.520
All Central America, like Guatemala, I think has one of the largest expanding, um, palm
01:49:18.760
We have, what do you think there's a way, a solution?
01:49:24.120
Well, first off, I think people just need to know what's happening.
01:49:28.940
And then, and then dude, we just need to empower and push our government to putting forward
01:49:34.200
Because, you know, I think like right now, basically the laws that we have on the books
01:49:38.600
for water around this country were, are from like the 1800s.
01:49:43.800
Like when water, when there were few people, there was water was plentiful.
01:49:50.120
You're like, that's, that shouldn't be in the, uh, in the, um, state doctrine, you know?
01:49:56.940
And, and, and now, and now water's tight and there's a lot more people.
01:50:00.340
And so we, you know, they need to go back onto the books and revise the laws to be like,
01:50:04.500
okay, so what do we want our water laws to look like in this place, given the realities
01:50:08.860
we have now in the 21st century and not the 19th century.
01:50:12.100
Like it's kind of, it's like all this stuff, man, it's kind of common sense, but we're just
01:50:17.380
And it's like, how is it tough to get it done when, um, a lot of the great minds,
01:50:23.740
it feels like are working on the other side of, uh, popular sentiment, like a fair statement.
01:50:32.300
Like, which like that, the best researchers and a lot of great, um, journalists and lobbyists
01:50:38.560
even are working for bigger companies, um, are in the private sector more to garner information
01:50:48.320
and learn information to give that to the private sector to better do their doings that
01:50:54.600
I think, you know, journalists are always going to try to give the information to the public.
01:50:59.160
And yeah, I think the private sector has a lot more resources to manipulate, you know,
01:51:07.040
Which oftentimes can be quarterly profits or annual profits.
01:51:10.760
Um, and we need our government to be like, okay, okay, okay.
01:51:13.740
But what's in our long-term best interest, right?
01:51:16.600
Like, what do we want for, for your, for your kids and your grandkids?
01:51:20.540
Um, and I think that's where, where we really need to be pushing folks.
01:51:24.540
And some of the, some of the companies are doing it not because they're beholding to their
01:51:28.140
stockholders who are the very people who are wishing they wouldn't, that companies
01:51:35.440
I mean, dude, you, you, you seen the duck and it's like in the duck, man.
01:51:38.500
It's like, so Holly Irwin is, is the County supervisor in Arizona that we follow.
01:51:48.080
You know, Holly is, is a Republican, like a conservative Republican.
01:51:52.120
And now she's, she's fighting for what people might be like, that's an environmental issue.
01:51:55.620
No, she's fighting for the water of the country, of the County.
01:51:59.720
And she's working with Democrats, which is great.
01:52:01.840
Like you got Republicans and Democrats coming together finally to like work on something
01:52:07.940
Um, but what I showed to Holly was, and she didn't know this, you know, she's like,
01:52:12.680
Oh, the Saudis have come, they're taking our water, you know?
01:52:15.620
And I said, but Holly, look here, this is your pension fund from the state of Arizona.
01:52:20.440
Look what it's invested in that farm right over there.
01:52:23.480
That's shipping hay to China and the UAE that was bought with your pension fund money.
01:52:30.440
Your retirement fund is, is helping export the water that you need to stay, to be here
01:52:41.620
So they had a pension fund, but the Saudis came in and bought the land.
01:52:46.520
So you got the Saudis are there, um, but there's another big farm, um, owned by, uh, uh, a company
01:52:53.780
out of North Carolina and the Arizona state pension fund gave a bunch of money to that, to
01:53:01.980
And then IFC rented it to, uh, uh, a company from the United Arab Emirates that's controlled
01:53:09.240
by like the, the brother of the ruler of the country that the, the, the, that's controlled
01:53:13.600
by a guy whose like job it is to control national security in the country.
01:53:18.540
And so like at the end of the day, Holly's pension fund, you know, she's like fighting
01:53:26.440
And then our own pension fund is financing a deal that shipping water overseas, right?
01:53:30.560
Cause it's more short-term profit than it is a long-term vision.
01:53:35.220
How do you, how do you align with Holly wants money to retire on Holly wants water for her
01:53:40.600
County to live on for the next hundred plus years.
01:53:46.460
Um, what were some other, there was some other stories that I was investigating that you
01:53:50.180
had, uh, or that I was researching that you had looked at.
01:53:53.020
Um, one that I found was interesting was this Somali pirate scenario.
01:53:58.000
So this was a guy from the intelligence community who told me this, you know, and, and, um, wasn't
01:54:01.880
the only person that told me this, but he just said, look, like Somali pirates, like we
01:54:07.280
think of them as like pirates, like they took to the high seas, you know, like, but what
01:54:12.400
They were just fishermen along the coast and foreign trawlers from other country, the
01:54:18.080
countries, I think his example was primarily China were coming in and just depleting the
01:54:24.340
So these guys that are on the Somali coast, they got pretty basic systems for fishing.
01:54:30.040
And then these big bad-ass boats come in with these super deep nets and they just scoop
01:54:37.860
The same thing you and I would do if somebody was doing that to us, we come together, we
01:54:44.780
And we're like, dude, next time one of those things come through, we're going to go out
01:54:47.800
there in our shitty little boat with some guns and take it over and tell them to stop
01:54:56.360
And so then they have a little coast guard and they're trying to fight back against these
01:54:59.960
And then they take one hostage and they're like, dude, you guys have been taking all our
01:55:03.180
Give us money and we'll give you your boat back because you've been taking all our fish.
01:55:07.460
And then they're like, well, that kind of escalates because maybe we should get a bigger, we should
01:55:11.220
hijack a bigger boat next time because now we don't have any fish.
01:55:21.500
It started as some dudes just being like, we just wanted to protect our fishing stock.
01:55:26.440
To being like, now we're taking over huge oil tankers and demanding.
01:55:29.980
And then, and then when that happened, and then the oil tankers hire mercenaries or private
01:55:33.720
security corporations to come in, oftentimes former like special forces guys.
01:55:37.460
You know, guys that have, that have a background working for, for a national military service
01:55:42.900
and they come in with guns and they're blowing everyone up.
01:55:45.200
And you're like, these dudes at the beginning of this story, these dudes just wanted their
01:55:53.120
Which is so ironic because it's really the same other, same thing we're talking about.
01:56:00.520
And when they did, when you're not eating two months later, you are a pirate.
01:56:06.680
It turns out, man, if we solve like something super basic, like just making sure everyone
01:56:10.880
around the world has enough food, we're going to see, because this is the other thing is
01:56:16.300
Again, I mean, I could go on to these stories forever, man.
01:56:19.300
It's a terrorist organization in Nigeria and in that, in that region of the world.
01:56:25.420
And if you look back on maps, satellite maps of Lake Chad, like 30 years ago, it was the
01:56:31.860
It's shrunk way down because people have been diverting the rivers that flow into it for
01:56:36.940
And the people that lived there that were fishing out of that, it was a huge lake.
01:56:40.780
Like they lost their livelihoods and then people start getting pissed.
01:56:46.780
Then like some, some people with crazy ideas start being like, well, you join my group,
01:56:52.220
People are taken from us all of a sudden, you know, just like, and it just spirals, man.
01:56:56.160
And then you just end up with these crazy groups that are abducting children that are
01:57:00.800
And like the beginning, like the, the origin of that story was like, people got thrown
01:57:06.160
into shit by not having their basic necessities met like food and then things spiral out of
01:57:17.280
So that's what like, that's what we're hoping doesn't happen.
01:57:25.740
Society has always gone on in some form or other, whether we end up in tribes or
01:57:30.780
whatever, you know, it's like, that's humanity.
01:57:34.360
You know, you start to get this idea of what humanity is based on your own childhood and
01:57:38.300
things you've heard or, and also the safety that we feel in America.
01:57:41.820
Don't you feel like we've lost our tribes, our community though?
01:57:44.140
Like everyone's got their little, like a hundred percent suburb.
01:57:47.340
They don't have to interact with anybody anymore.
01:57:49.600
And like a hundred percent, everybody's just like, like, yeah.
01:57:53.180
And it's, um, I feel like a country of loneliness, man.
01:57:56.260
I feel like half the problems we see is just cause people feel isolated and lonely and
01:58:00.360
depressed and they're not like, they're not like in a community anymore.
01:58:03.440
They're not seeing the same people every Sunday or they're not going out.
01:58:10.780
And I am so lucky to be able to go and see that same group of cool dudes and just play
01:58:16.720
And like, I think a lot of us in so much of our communities around what going out to
01:58:21.300
And like, I used to drink a lot and now I think alcohol is a shitty drug, right?
01:58:27.080
Like, you know, I think I, I view like, you know, a lot of this stuff, I think they should
01:58:33.120
It's just like sports piss almost really, you know, I mean, yeah, I don't drink.
01:58:37.880
I mean, I prefer cocaine probably, but that's not even that good for you.
01:58:41.560
And it's like, I think, um, yeah, I definitely feel you though.
01:58:47.540
I mean, I go to a recovery meeting, so I've seen people there all the time.
01:58:50.380
So you have like some semblance of groupness, but yeah, it's like everybody gets their food
01:58:57.440
It's just, you're staring at a phone, your food's getting delivered.
01:59:01.880
And it's like, how do we reinstill like a stronger community in the U S right?
01:59:07.300
Because like, I, okay, dude, I have a little cabin in a teeny town, like a hundred people.
01:59:11.520
And those people are across the board politically on the spectrum.
01:59:15.220
And it doesn't matter if somebody's voting one way and somebody else is voting the other
01:59:19.520
If somebody's like house floods, people are going to show up, right?
01:59:24.600
Like that's, that's what it is to be a good person.
01:59:26.540
It's not who you vote for or what you necessarily like your political ethos.
01:59:30.420
It's like, dude, did something bad happen to you?
01:59:35.280
And that's what I feel like we're losing, right?
01:59:37.000
We're so distracted about, I feel like petty crap right now that we're forgetting it's time.
01:59:44.040
I wonder if you're going to see more of an influx towards like religious services, even
01:59:49.900
not even entirely for religion, but for community.
01:59:53.220
It's like some of the first places you go back to for community.
01:59:56.180
Like one thing that I always loved about church was just seeing like the kids play together.
02:00:02.540
Even it's like, if you, if you're just in your own thoughts, like thinking of something
02:00:06.620
bigger than yourself, no matter what your denomination was or whatever, or yeah.
02:00:11.820
So I grew up, my dad was a Lutheran pastor and, uh, and, and I, you know, I don't, I
02:00:17.660
I don't follow those beliefs anymore, but I miss that Sunday get together, man, because
02:00:22.180
you would show up and you know, there would be like a tax preparer there and you knew you
02:00:26.820
would see them every Sunday and you could rely on them.
02:00:28.860
There was a mechanic that was there and you knew that they'd show up every Sunday and
02:00:31.960
you would rely and they weren't going to screw you.
02:00:33.580
And there was a sense of community, like in that community where people that had vocational
02:00:37.760
trades across the board and you could trust each other and you could know each other and
02:00:41.040
you could ask them questions, you could get knowledge, you could share experience, you
02:00:45.540
Like showing up to that one place every week and having that community.
02:00:49.560
That's what I feel like so much is what that's been lost.
02:00:53.200
I feel like it'll be a few generations and I feel like there will be a rebellious generation
02:00:58.240
that will throw off the VR headsets and masturbate naturally.
02:01:03.660
If there's a way to do that into the ocean or whatever and reclaim what it feels like,
02:01:09.920
or at least go in search of what it feels like to be human.
02:01:16.740
And are you talking about this with other buddies too?
02:01:18.620
Cause I feel like I'm having this conversation more and more with buddies like, dude, how do
02:01:24.040
Like, like I said, it can be as simple as like finding a good hockey team.
02:01:27.880
And just like, cause after every game, man, it doesn't matter if that game starts at 10
02:01:31.580
30 PM at night and we're not in the parking lot until midnight or like 1 AM dudes are going
02:01:35.860
to stand around and drink a beer and just catch up, have a blast, have a nice time.
02:01:40.420
It's the same after any real get together, people always kind of mill around, see what's
02:01:44.500
You and one buddy or two guys might stay late if one of them's having a problem and they'll
02:01:48.960
If everything's cool that you're out of there, kind of like one of the first couple of guys
02:01:54.500
And yeah, I think that thing is, um, I feel like we would find ways you in the end, I feel
02:02:01.840
like you just believe enough in some thing that we can't create outside of us.
02:02:08.660
That's inside of us that would lead us to victory in some sense, like some human spirit
02:02:19.720
I think it just feels like we're down maybe two rounds to one right now.
02:02:24.320
You know, I feel like it's tough for that human spirit to connect through a phone.
02:02:29.500
And I think there's a lot of like, I have to be doing something all the time.
02:02:34.980
It's interesting to think about, um, before you leave, I know you worked in organized
02:02:49.400
I went over to Macau, uh, which became like, that's by Hong Kong, huh?
02:02:59.660
Some lady I think was either flirting with me or trying to tell me I had some on my shirt
02:03:06.720
It's, it's, uh, they do more revenue than Vegas does.
02:03:10.380
When I was there, it'd become just like in a very short period, it'd become massive.
02:03:14.220
Um, and I was over there because we were looking into how, what the U S government largely
02:03:20.080
considered was organized crime, people connection to triads, et cetera, were working inside of
02:03:25.700
the casinos to bring money from mainland China that could be gambled in Macau.
02:03:29.960
Cause that time there was like, I think it was a $5,000 cap, right?
02:03:34.620
Like you could only bring 5,000 from mainland China into Macau, but then you'd go and you'd
02:03:38.520
go into the casino and people are betting like 500,000 us per hand.
02:03:44.920
And it was basically this informal credit network, which is like, we know you're good for it
02:03:52.420
But if you don't pay your debts, you're probably going to be found burned up and shot in your
02:04:00.860
And then these big U S casinos were operating in that ecosystem.
02:04:05.600
So I went over there and like my job was to try to get these guys to go on camera, to open
02:04:12.660
And as one of the U S you know, casino bosses, a white guy from America said to me, he was
02:04:17.460
like, he's like, man, that dude who's casino you're staying in for the six weeks you're
02:04:22.920
If people say stuff, he doesn't like for hanging them out their window, you know?
02:04:28.140
And, um, yeah, and it was, it was, that's a rough start.
02:04:31.880
And so it was, um, you're just down there looking and we say triads, what does that
02:04:37.340
Triads are like a British word for what they would describe as Asian organized crime networks.
02:04:42.620
Um, and, and the triads actually have this super interesting history that go back to martial
02:04:46.520
arts, um, to the Shaolin temple and to like all the way back to like the overthrow of the
02:04:53.220
It's like, it gets like, that's why the, the triad guys are known for being such badasses
02:04:58.560
It's like, I still get calls from federal prison pretty frequently from a guy named Raymond
02:05:07.820
And, uh, dude, just crazy, bad-ass martial arts guy.
02:05:12.240
Um, but, uh, yeah, he'll call, you know, he, he, I, and I, I went to him because I knew
02:05:16.980
I was going to Macau and he hadn't been arrested.
02:05:18.760
Now he's, now he's in prison doing, I think multiple life sentences.
02:05:23.620
Um, yeah, but, uh, but that's just a, that's a different world, man.
02:05:27.980
Cause you're operating, um, in a world of violence.
02:05:41.060
So it's difficult to go in as an investigative journalist into that, you know?
02:05:45.100
And so the first thing I'd always do is just tell people right away, like, I am an
02:05:49.640
I'm looking into this, you know, that's my role.
02:05:52.380
And I don't necessarily need to push people for answers right away, but like, I don't
02:05:55.800
want anybody thinking that like I'm sneaking around behind their back or like trying to
02:06:01.200
So there's a different level of respect if you come in like that over there.
02:06:05.460
Like as a journalist, if I'm working on a story, I always identify myself as a journalist
02:06:14.400
And then over there, it's like, we don't got to deal with that right away.
02:06:17.520
You can just identify me as a person, you know, in, in parts of China that I've traveled
02:06:21.940
to, one of the things people want to do when they're going to get into business with you
02:06:28.260
They just want to get hammered because they want to see what kind of drunk you are.
02:06:30.540
Are you going to be a total dick when you're drunk or are you going to still just be like
02:06:34.540
kind of funny and happy and upbeat and like honest or what kind of drunk are you?
02:06:40.900
And so sometimes you identify who you are and then you just kind of a human for a little
02:06:47.520
Yeah, I never wanted to be Chinese that much, really.
02:06:50.720
I mean, I haven't, I haven't not wanted to be it, but I haven't, I'll be honest.
02:06:55.680
I guess I would be willing to be it, but I don't, I would probably think about it a lot
02:07:04.080
Why do Chinese businessmen insist on getting you drunk?
02:07:09.000
In a culture where relationships can make or break you in business, getting drunk with a
02:07:12.840
potential business partner is often viewed as a crucial way of solidifying that relationship
02:07:27.700
Let me think, is there anything about the liquor?
02:07:32.580
Alcohol is a very long tradition in Confucian society.
02:07:35.460
Confucius, who advocated only eating at mealtimes and not in between, made an exception for wine.
02:07:41.160
And he said, only wine drinking is not limited.
02:07:53.320
Before you go, have, is there, have there been stories that you wanted to go to and you just didn't have the time?
02:07:58.460
That's like the thing that haunts me most right now.
02:08:00.120
Um, just like really important stories that people come to me and they want me to look into.
02:08:05.380
Um, and I, it's just like, it's super tough to find the time, you know, there's just too many things that I would love to be able.
02:08:16.760
And who funds like investigative reporting, who funds like guys like you?
02:08:21.320
So I work at a nonprofit called the center for investigative reporting.
02:08:29.660
When Rolling Stones used to be based in San Francisco, um, they ended up moving it to New York and a bunch of the reporters didn't want to move to the East coast.
02:08:38.060
And one of those guys was one of my mentors, Lowell Bergman, who, I don't know if you ever saw the movie Insider without Pacino, but Al Pacino was playing Lowell.
02:08:45.880
Lowell was the one that got the documents from, you know, inside the tobacco companies that showed that like the, they knew that it was a carcinogen.
02:08:53.480
They knew it was addictive and they were, they were hiding and, and not being straight up with Congress.
02:08:58.060
So I work at a nonprofit, which is a super fortunate place to be because we're not profit.
02:09:02.520
Like, you know, I worked on this documentary, that documentary could make a gazillion dollars and I'm not going to make a dime more.
02:09:11.840
You know, like, and so, um, and it's also because investigative journalism.
02:09:17.300
Um, letting me, yeah, no dude, letting me spend a year and a half diving into like, is Facebook and the social media company targeting your weakness?
02:09:27.960
Um, and so we have to get foundations and others to give us money, to give us the time and people, people donate to us to give us the time to look into this stuff.
02:09:38.620
Like it would be hugely profitable if I wanted to take that, my same skills and go work for a hedge fund.
02:09:46.240
Um, and, but, but people are willing to, to, to, to pay me to do it, you know, like a modest salary.
02:09:56.800
I love, like I used to sit in, and I was a little kid and I used to tell my, my grandma, my mom's mom, just tell me a story from your mind, you know, and she would just wax.
02:10:05.560
And, and, and now meeting people, you know, like, I just like to hear their stories.
02:10:08.920
Like what's their background, where'd they come from?
02:10:11.340
You know, it doesn't have to be like totally revelatory.
02:10:15.640
We're all so interesting, you know, but when I can spend time diving into something like Susie Kelly story, where like this crazy technology company identified that her brain had this weakness and targeted her.
02:10:27.140
Then I want to spend a bunch of time and share it with people.
02:10:30.340
Because we know it's not just happening to Susie.
02:10:32.940
I mean, and it's so sick that that would happen.
02:10:34.680
It was almost if you saw someone who was disabled and somebody, someone had a broken leg and someone kept kicking a minute, you know?
02:10:41.920
I, and, and, and that's, and I, dude, I think that's a really good analogy.
02:10:45.240
And then like, they were kicking them because it was making them money.
02:10:52.820
I'll just tell you that like fundamentally on a personal level, I don't get it.
02:10:57.520
You know, like, yeah, that's the thing that's tough.
02:10:59.960
It's like, and then sometimes I feel like, am I normal or am I the weirdo that gives a fuck about stuff?
02:11:11.280
I think, I think whatever, I think we're all broken in our own way and whatever my little
02:11:15.020
broken way has made me an investigative journalist.
02:11:20.920
Could be Paul Revere or whatever, even though somebody said he was trying to meet men.
02:11:24.080
That's the only reason he was going through town or whatever.
02:11:27.420
But, um, but to be that kind of guy who's like, you know, trying to, you know, like, yeah, we've always loved the underdog dude.
02:11:39.560
You know, like everybody's like, everybody wants a nude picture of like, um, Pam Anderson or something.
02:11:46.680
You know, I wanted a new picture of Aaron Brockovich on my wall, you know?
02:11:52.720
Uncovered a lot of stuff and got a lot of good out there in the world.
02:11:59.200
And I think it's a compliment, Aaron, but, um, what else do we have?
02:12:05.700
I don't, I feel like we covered a really good bit, Nate.
02:12:08.140
So we can, people can donate to the center for investigative research reporting.
02:12:12.540
So the center for investigative reporting, that's a legitimate company.
02:12:17.680
And, uh, you know, people can even just check it out.
02:12:24.920
We print, you know, we work with other folks and we have the documentary out.
02:12:28.300
I mean, at the end of the day, dude, just trying to get good information into people's
02:12:31.240
hands and like call to account, like people that are targeting other people, you know?
02:12:35.680
If you don't have food, you'll get so caught in the moment.
02:12:38.960
You don't even have a chance to look ahead at that point.
02:12:46.560
Then, then you're just trying to get food for you and your family and you start doing
02:12:51.080
And even people that, you know, do you ever read Cormac McCarthy?
02:13:02.740
But like, um, the road, he basically breaks it down to like, oh, are you willing to kill
02:13:07.940
if like, if it comes down to it, would you kill somebody else to eat them?
02:13:14.180
If you're willing to just like, be like, damn, I'm just going to have to starve to death
02:13:17.640
because I'm not going to murder somebody else to eat them.
02:13:19.540
Or are you going to murder somebody else to eat them?
02:13:21.420
Like kind of bifurcates humanity along that, along that track.
02:13:26.640
People get weird when the basic necessities aren't there.
02:13:31.220
But you would also say you would know I wouldn't eat out of a dumpster.
02:13:39.000
If you're about to eat a dude in Best Buy, right, like, yeah, you're going to eat out
02:14:07.660
Yeah, we're both just going to, like, mentally just redesign whatever garbage we're eating.
02:14:28.660
And then people can rent it online, and then it'll be on one of the streaming platforms in the fall.
02:14:34.780
So, The Grab, it's coming out on June 14th in theaters.
02:14:41.000
Just thought-provoking to get me to start thinking, like, yeah, what are – because you just think, oh, that's just a farm in my neighborhood.
02:14:46.860
Or you just think, like, oh, that's just the way things are.
02:14:52.960
You don't sometimes see, like, maybe the chess board that's being put together or that's already been, you know, the plays that have already been played.
02:15:02.220
Nate Halverson, thanks so much for being an investigator and for spending time with us.
02:15:06.120
Hey, Tio, thanks so much for having me on, man.
02:15:08.180
Now I'm just floating on the breeze, and I feel I'm falling like these leaves.
02:15:18.920
Oh, but when I reach that ground, I'll share this peace of mind I found.