E562 Richard Reeves
Episode Stats
Length
2 hours and 3 minutes
Words per Minute
207.27617
Hate Speech Sentences
109
Summary
Richard Rees is a writer, a social scientist, and a dual citizen. He's the President of the American Institute for Boys and Men and was born in the UK, but became a U.S. citizen in 2016.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
We hope you're enjoying your Air Canada flight.
00:00:10.720
Fast-free Wi-Fi means I can make dinner reservations before we land.
00:00:25.260
Wi-Fi available to Airplane members on Equipped Flight.
00:00:29.760
Today's guest is a writer and a social scientist.
00:00:35.140
He's the president of the American Institute for Boys and Men.
00:00:45.940
Richard Rees, thanks for joining us today, brother.
00:01:06.060
You want to move that in a little bit for me if you don't mind?
00:01:21.920
And you're the president for the American Institute for Boys and Men.
00:01:26.340
Like, God knows we need more think tanks, right?
00:01:30.600
It's like more scholars sitting in think tanks, producing charts.
00:01:33.720
Honestly, I was in another think tank for 10 years before that, the Brookings Institution.
00:01:41.120
And I got to tell you, it was not in my life plan.
00:01:48.780
But what that means is you basically just get paid good money to write stuff and say stuff
00:01:54.300
And what happens to a lot of that information from think tanks?
00:01:58.320
If you ask the critics, they say it just gathers dust on people's shelves.
00:02:08.260
And so there is this whole thing now that think tanks used to produce policy papers
00:02:12.080
and then grateful legislators, members of Congress, would say, thank you.
00:02:22.000
And so the whole question of how do you influence law?
00:02:29.460
And so there's a big question mark against this whole idea about quotes think tank.
00:02:38.800
And that's one of the reasons, yeah, that I wanted to get to talk to you today.
00:02:41.260
Because, you know, a lot of our listeners are men and boys.
00:02:44.920
I know Scott Galloway was on and he had mentioned that you were kind of his godfather of information
00:02:50.520
or somebody that he really looked up to, you know.
00:02:52.280
And I did also see you were born on the 4th of July.
00:02:56.800
Do they kick you out of Britain if you're on the one?
00:03:00.860
Everyone who's born on the 4th of July gets automatic U.S. citizenship,
00:03:08.080
But it's kind of weird because I've always had that.
00:03:11.020
And then I actually came to the U.S. in the 90s for the Guardian newspaper.
00:03:20.820
Do you think it was because of your birthday at all or no?
00:03:27.240
But if you think there's no such thing as a coincidence,
00:03:30.240
I've always loved the fact that I was born on the 4th of July and now I'm here.
00:03:37.880
And actually, one of the things that I've really thought about as an immigrant, right?
00:03:41.360
And I don't, when you say immigrant, you probably don't think of someone like me,
00:03:45.860
Is that people who are born here don't actually appreciate what it means sometimes to be a citizen.
00:03:52.360
And my citizenship ceremony, which I did in a hurry, actually,
00:03:55.900
because I wanted to be able to vote and wanted to get into the whole civic life.
00:04:06.300
There's people from Afghanistan, Iraq, whatever.
00:04:11.820
Mexico, and they're waving their flags, saying the Pledge of Allegiance.
00:04:17.880
And there wasn't really a dry eye laugh by the end of it.
00:04:21.860
And so I actually now think that every high schooler in the U.S. should go to a citizenship ceremony.
00:04:29.560
Because I don't think if you're born here, you can take it a bit for granted what it means to be a citizen.
00:04:35.100
But to go and experience what it's like for people to become a citizen, I expected it to be more.
00:04:42.540
And I thought, yeah, but I want to be a citizen as well.
00:04:44.740
I actually was incredibly moved by the whole experience.
00:04:47.400
And, yeah, you don't think about the gift of your own citizenship, right?
00:04:51.380
And you don't think about what others go through to get it.
00:04:53.960
And, yeah, they used to have – I know whenever I was growing up, you had the Pledge of Allegiance.
00:04:58.480
There was definitely a lot more – even though the Pledge of Allegiance was like a small thing, it's one of those traditional things that made you feel like a part of something, right?
00:05:06.300
It was like a traditional practice that created a commonality between kids.
00:05:12.060
Because we kind of thought it was lame sometimes, but sometimes you didn't, you know, like at certain points of the year or if certain things were going on in the culture, it meant more to you.
00:05:28.340
It's not just like you can overthink what the words mean.
00:05:33.500
But there's something about just the ritual of it.
00:05:36.060
So my son is at the University of Tennessee, and he explains –
00:05:41.160
But actually when his friends come down to a Tennessee game, and they're, say, at a Northeastern college or a small liberal arts college, what really strikes them is less the game.
00:05:50.900
And it's more the fact that there's the Pledge of Allegiance, that there's a prayer, that the jets go over, that there's fireworks, that they come out through the tea.
00:05:57.420
There's a whole bunch of ritual around it, which is actually really beautiful.
00:06:02.240
And I think sometimes we overthink the content of the ritual and don't actually just recognize it's the fact of the ritual that really, really matters.
00:06:09.260
Yeah, it's like, yeah, people start looking at, well, what are the words of the Pledge of Allegiance?
00:06:19.400
If you live in a country and you're a member of it, to pledge allegiance to that country, I feel like –
00:06:32.380
Like what's your real modus operandi then, I guess?
00:06:38.600
And when he came, he gave up his Israeli citizenship because he believes that you cannot have more than one citizenship.
00:06:47.120
You cannot have – dual citizenship is a contradiction because you can only be pledging your allegiance to one sovereign nation.
00:06:54.660
I love that too and I will confess that I have kept my British passport.
00:07:04.980
I mean there's a reason why everyone really wants to come here.
00:07:14.460
But that would be a great idea if every class had to go watch that, had to go watch that ceremony.
00:07:19.040
They always need volunteers of them as well to like help out with the paperwork and stuff like that.
00:07:22.640
And so you could just have like some going every time.
00:07:27.940
Like high school, like – and I would just say to anyone who's listening, right, if you're thinking about a good, cool thing to do, like volunteer at your local citizenship center and watch the people go through the process of becoming a U.S. citizen.
00:07:38.800
And that might make you appreciate it a bit more.
00:07:40.280
I can't believe that it's not mandatory like in classes or in school that you have to go see that.
00:07:46.740
Maybe that's something that one of these think tanks could change, you know?
00:07:49.320
Well, I proposed it, but let's see if it will change.
00:07:55.260
You're the president for the American Institute for Men and Boys.
00:08:03.220
So what we're trying to do is – the basic premise here is there are a lot of ways in which boys and men are struggling in our country right now.
00:08:11.540
And there are no institutions, there's no organizations whose job it is to basically wake up every day and draw attention to that with data, with facts, in a way that will hopefully raise awareness of it.
00:08:28.860
So when the pandemic hit, there were a lot of reports about how it was going to affect women and girls.
00:08:35.100
There was a lot of concern about employment, domestic violence, a whole bunch of real concerns.
00:08:42.000
And those were perfectly legitimate, coming from women's think tanks, from the UN, from the White House, et cetera.
00:08:48.880
But I noticed that actually the college enrollment for men had dropped seven times more than for women in the first year of the pandemic.
00:09:04.800
And it's partly because the men were more likely to be going to like trade school and stuff, which you just couldn't do online.
00:09:11.860
It was just – it hit male education harder than female education, number one.
00:09:17.660
Number two, men were dying a lot more from COVID.
00:09:22.580
You mean the actual disease or just like the loneliness or the –
00:09:31.120
Last time I checked, we'd lost at least 100,000 more men than women.
00:09:35.100
And that's not to be expected because actually it affected older people, right?
00:09:44.040
So if anything, you just think it would go the other way, right?
00:09:45.960
But it didn't because actually men were much, much more vulnerable to the disease.
00:09:57.220
And it really occurred to me that that was because it was no one's job, right?
00:10:02.740
There wasn't an American Institute for Boys and Men.
00:10:05.120
But I can assure you that if we'd existed then, we'd have been pushing out lots of information about how COVID was affecting boys' education and men's education and also killing men in massively higher numbers.
00:10:17.040
Well, for sure, because I think also you – I don't know if ever in my life there's been like a lot of organizations where it's like, hey, men need help, you know?
00:10:28.000
It's like everything is that women need help with this, children, you know, and certainly that makes sense.
00:10:34.840
I always think back to like women and children first, like when the Titanic was sinking or something, you know, in something like that.
00:10:41.220
And that's probably what most men would want as well.
00:10:43.280
But at a certain point, you're like, hey, we exist.
00:10:49.080
What was your like – what was your first relationship like with your dad or something like when you were – like how did you – like just so we have some personal attachment to this conversation as well.
00:10:59.860
What was it like with your dad when you were a kid?
00:11:02.300
Because that's usually people's first male role model, yeah?
00:11:04.900
Yeah, my dad was amazing and just amazing and is an amazing granddad to my sons as well.
00:11:13.800
And so I just – I was given the greatest gift that I think anybody can ever get, which is two parents who both loved me, still together, still loving us.
00:11:28.240
And that sense of – somebody wants – this sounds like a bit of a –
00:11:31.900
It's crazy that I'm shocked, you know, that it's – it's crazy that it's becoming this world that that's a shocking thing.
00:11:36.800
Yeah, and it's not like – not like they were perfect, to be clear.
00:11:40.160
But it's like – like parenting is never going to be about perfection.
00:11:46.120
It's like a – I think you almost get like a parental grade point average, right, across the whole decades it takes to raise a kid, right?
00:11:53.800
You're going to have bad days and good days and you're going to get some days where you get a really bad grade, isn't it, right?
00:12:01.260
He like said some stuff he shouldn't have said, did some stuff he shouldn't have done to me.
00:12:05.600
But then like you got a B the next day and an A.
00:12:12.740
And I've come to realize that that is the most extraordinary gift.
00:12:16.460
I was going to say it sounds like a bit of a brag, but I remember –
00:12:19.080
Someone came up to me once after I'd done a talk or something like that and –
00:12:36.520
And I was like, I don't know that you can just – there's something in people, men, who were loved by their dads.
00:12:46.600
There's no chart you could ever make about that.
00:12:48.460
But I have – I've never doubted my father's love for me.
00:12:59.640
And I had this moment with my dad that made a huge impression on me where –
00:13:04.960
because of his generation, he had to be the breadwinner.
00:13:11.900
He worked in manufacturing during the 80s, which was a tough time, you know, in the UK and the US.
00:13:17.780
And there was a time he was unemployed for quite a long time.
00:13:20.260
But every morning he got up and he shaved and he put on a shirt and a tie.
00:13:27.160
His concession was he didn't put a jacket on, right?
00:13:30.840
Because he was trying to get a white-collar job.
00:13:35.400
I said, Dad, you're going into the spare room to type out, like, resumes to try and get a job.
00:13:46.360
And he looked at me and he said, I do have a job.
00:13:49.620
My job is to get another job so that I can take care of you.
00:13:53.360
And he worked as hard at getting a job as he ever had at his job because he knew that we needed him.
00:13:59.440
And although I think that fatherhood has really changed, it's been different for me, right?
00:14:03.860
Because the economic relationship between men and women has changed so dramatically, which is a huge liberation, I think.
00:14:10.060
I was able to be a stay-at-home dad for a few years in a way that he would never have been able to do.
00:14:16.300
But that basic idea that, like, okay, you have this purpose in life now, which is I have to take care of you, it just changes you.
00:14:28.040
Yeah, and just seeing that example, like, okay, what does a man do every day?
00:14:34.840
And he moves forward in the world in some process.
00:14:38.480
You know, like, yeah, no, I think that that's...
00:15:01.180
I mean, some people would say that the Welsh are bad.
00:15:09.940
Yeah, everybody's like, the Scottish are over there eating their own teeth, you know?
00:15:16.600
No, I love the UK because everybody just rips on the other group, you know?
00:15:30.400
You go on stage in Ireland, you're like, fuck England, and they just...
00:15:35.960
So, like, if you're in rugby or soccer or something, like, everybody will...
00:15:40.160
It's like, if England's playing Germany, the Welsh will support the Germans, right?
00:15:46.560
I mean, and we have a history with the Germans, but it's like, even then, it's basically anybody
00:15:52.280
Oh, so the English and the Welsh are against each other even.
00:15:57.080
Yeah, not quite as much as the Scots, probably.
00:16:00.840
I mean, and also, of course, they have deep histories.
00:16:07.240
And so there is always going to be that difference.
00:16:12.160
It always just seems so much fun over there is how passionate they are about it.
00:16:15.720
I mean, it's a kind of tribalism can be good or bad.
00:16:29.100
My dad was 70 when I was born, so he was an older guy.
00:16:32.060
So I think I had this almost like fear all the time that my dad was going to be hurt or
00:16:42.300
Because it was always just kind of scary, you know, like, you know, like he would drive
00:16:47.680
and he would ask us where we're going or if we could turn.
00:16:52.000
I'd be standing on the passenger chair and we're standing up and like getting up and like
00:16:56.680
looking at the lights and I'd be like, it's good, you know, it's green or bad or something.
00:17:01.760
And I remember one time I got it wrong and he just drove right out.
00:17:04.280
You were literally having to be his eyes while he was driving.
00:17:06.980
Yeah, I was helping out, you know, because sometimes he would park too close under the lights
00:17:11.480
So he'd waited at an intersection in the middle of the intersection, you know, he's just old,
00:17:14.780
you know, he was just, you know, he was like 80 something at that point.
00:17:18.100
And so it was just bizarre, you know, I think it was a very bizarre kind of like probably
00:17:26.500
And so then at that point, yeah, you kind of start to, and then my dad didn't live with
00:17:34.820
And so, you know, then you're kind of like in this, you don't even realize it as a kid,
00:17:39.160
you're just a kid, but you're in this starvation space for where do you get probably role models.
00:17:45.720
And where do you, who do you look to, you know?
00:17:48.420
And I had my brother around for a couple of years and then I was like a huge wrestling
00:17:53.320
And like, I really idolized a lot of those guys.
00:17:58.260
No, I got into steroids, but I never did the wrestling.
00:18:06.480
Yes, I guess, you know, but yeah, I mean, I remember collecting all the figurines and
00:18:11.640
I had a neighbor and his dad was a, his dad was like kind of dialed in.
00:18:17.820
What did he was almost like a dad to you as well?
00:18:23.740
I think you can get your father, you can get your father little pieces from different
00:18:28.120
You can, I believe that like, um, you had a basketball coach that, you know, showed me
00:18:32.640
like care and affection and, um, included me in things that his family was doing.
00:18:36.560
And then I ended up moving out and living with a different family when I was like 14
00:18:39.820
and that family had a stable father in the home.
00:18:42.340
And so that, uh, that helped a lot, but yeah, not trying to like make it about me.
00:18:46.720
I'm just trying to like, um, put both of our stories out there.
00:18:51.660
But my, like my, one of the things my dad also did, he was a coach, like he was a, he
00:18:56.480
And I've had, I think particularly in the U S I've become really interested in the role
00:19:01.840
So my basic view is that coaches, especially for boys, we're actually seeing like sports,
00:19:09.740
Boys are less likely to play sports than in the past.
00:19:14.380
The Aspen Institute, uh, has a really good project called project play where they, they
00:19:22.260
Now it's always been higher for boys, but sports participation is going down for boys.
00:19:27.060
One reason for that is coaches, like you need coaches to do that.
00:19:31.360
And, uh, and we can maybe get into male teachers because actually one of the things that male
00:19:35.400
teachers do, and my son has just become a teacher.
00:19:39.660
Uh, uh, he's teaching fifth grade in Baltimore and like within a day of starting someone
00:19:46.100
heard his accent because he's still got a British accent, heard his accent.
00:19:49.340
He's a soccer coach now, uh, and he actually is a good soccer player, but the point is he's
00:19:54.640
And I think that coaches are basically mental health professionals in disguise, right?
00:20:01.380
Uh, I think they're doing a lot of the work that you'd otherwise do in terms of mental
00:20:04.940
And you can kind of see like there's, there'll be a line, uh, from, from the Aspen.
00:20:10.020
It says, uh, oh, we have fewer boys are playing sports in 2013, half of boys age six to 17
00:20:16.920
According to SFIA data, only 41% of boys did in 2023.
00:20:23.220
Um, girls age six to 12 had 34% and 13 to 17 age girls were 38% played at higher levels
00:20:35.400
Some of that could be attributed to, to also a lot more boys are like,
00:20:38.720
they choose to become gamers and that sort of thing, but more sedentary things.
00:20:42.580
It could be, which is not necessarily a good thing.
00:20:45.360
I mean, ideally you'd want to do a bit of both, but then the question is like, why are
00:20:54.560
I'd love to see something like a coach for America program.
00:20:58.300
You know, there's this teach for America program, which gets people into teaching
00:21:01.680
because I think there's a lot of men who are struggling to know how to kind of
00:21:05.380
connect with their community or what they can do.
00:21:07.980
Some of the older institutions, maybe they used to do that with like through church
00:21:16.520
And so if there was a way to kind of plug those men into a coaching role, I think
00:21:20.000
that's important because when I, when you, when you, I mean, maybe this is your, maybe
00:21:24.520
your experience, but like, I think if you look at the, the image of a coach sitting
00:21:28.460
on a bench, like with a student, you know, a boy or a young man sitting next to him and
00:21:40.860
Is you kind of, that's counseling, that's therapy, but you're just not calling it that.
00:21:47.900
And the other thing is critically, you're doing it shoulder to shoulder.
00:21:51.680
Do you know this thing about the difference in communication style between men and women
00:22:07.120
Because guys don't usually look at each other when they're sharing information that much.
00:22:10.380
No, because actually that's a little bit of a threatening, that's a threatening stance
00:22:15.220
Like if men go face to face, that's, that might indicate something, some aggression or some
00:22:20.200
like you're, it's a bit like you're, you're intimidating each other a little bit.
00:22:24.980
Uh, when you talk to someone, you rarely stand and look directly.
00:22:29.420
So my, we learned this the hard way, like even before I had any of the data and God,
00:22:33.540
I wish I'd had this data when we were raising our kids.
00:22:36.280
But my wife would like, our kids would come home from school, all boys.
00:22:39.840
Uh, uh, and the two that were in high school and middle school at the time, they'd come
00:22:43.020
home and they'd like sit across the breakfast bar from her.
00:22:45.720
And she'd be feeding them stuff, like she'd feeding them protein, have some protein.
00:22:49.140
And then she'd stare at them like this and be like, how was your day?
00:22:59.180
And then later on, we'd be driving with them somewhere or watching a game or video game
00:23:06.580
or just something, something like that shoulder to shoulder.
00:23:08.820
And they would say, uh, you know, this weird thing happened today, dad or mom, right?
00:23:17.180
And what we now know is that that's very, very common.
00:23:21.740
That actually the communication style that men are most comfortable with is less face
00:23:29.420
Now think about this fishing, road trips, watching sports, sitting on the bench, shoulder
00:23:37.240
It is the only explanation I have for the existence of golf.
00:23:45.420
I'd be willing to play it, but I just, I can't even calm down right now.
00:23:48.780
But it's like, again, men have to be doing something else and they have to be doing it
00:23:55.600
like just, so if you go to a party now, you, you, you will not be able to unsee this.
00:24:00.640
Watch how the men stand in relation to each other.
00:24:02.620
And there are people who've done whole PhDs on measuring the angle.
00:24:05.540
We always stand on a bit catty corner, like a little bit of an angle, because I thought
00:24:10.900
Now, women on the other hand, very comfortable face to face.
00:24:13.820
Walk into a coffee shop and count up how many people are sitting opposite each other, staring
00:24:18.460
each other in the face, and then see what the gender is of them.
00:24:26.320
But what you don't want is a mental health profession, like psychology or whatever it
00:24:31.460
is, based on the presumption that we're all supposed to sit like this.
00:24:34.100
And so a lot of male therapists now, they're taking their male patients out for a walk.
00:24:44.980
Yeah, Mike's girlfriend's a therapist now, and she and I, whenever we really needed to
00:24:49.940
discuss stuff, we go on a walk, because you're in motion already.
00:24:53.880
There's a part of you that feels like it's moving forward, even if you're sharing something
00:24:58.200
that's troubling, because sometimes you're sitting in a sedentary, you're just sitting
00:25:07.820
But on a walk, you're making progress no matter what, even by just staying in motion.
00:25:15.180
But they've now got this physiological element to it, too, which is that just how you're
00:25:19.460
relating to each other physically, especially for men, it's just very important that we
00:25:23.740
I'm going to try that next time I'm with my therapist in a room.
00:25:25.780
It's like, yeah, why do we get, yeah, like, maybe it's easier if I'm just able to share
00:25:31.520
I remember one time I was talking to my brother, and I didn't know that this had been important
00:25:36.920
in my life, but he said, hey, man, I can just, I was having a tough day, man.
00:25:43.260
I was like, just, I was kind of like falling apart a little bit.
00:25:47.060
And he's like, hey, man, I can just sit here on the phone with you.
00:25:54.980
And I'd never, he's like, I have some time, right?
00:26:07.880
And man, I just, I mean, it was like a dam inside of me broke, you know?
00:26:12.120
It was like, literally, there was tears coming out of my toenails, you know?
00:26:16.380
Like, it was just like, you didn't realize all the time you needed someone just to be
00:26:27.360
I didn't need to hear a response to anything, no judgment, nothing.
00:26:34.260
And it was like, I mean, it's, I mean, it like, I remember my hands vibrating.
00:26:41.180
That idea of being, like, with somebody, not necessarily for them.
00:26:46.100
I think sometimes we think, like, we've got to be for them.
00:26:51.580
Like, somehow, we've got to be doing something.
00:26:57.240
And for them to know that you're with, I'm with you, right?
00:27:04.140
And one of the things that has really motivated my work around boys and men, which I didn't
00:27:11.020
ever expect really to be doing, was just this sense that I had that so many boys and men
00:27:17.420
now don't have that feeling that we are with you, that we have your back.
00:27:23.560
We've noticed that you're struggling, and we are, we're with you.
00:27:28.100
And instead, there's sometimes been a sense a lot of men have felt, which is being neglected
00:27:33.040
or sometimes even blamed for their own problems.
00:27:39.900
Do you find yourself watching porno for longer periods of time and having trouble stopping?
00:27:47.020
Is porn affecting your relationship or dating life?
00:27:54.280
Watching pornography has become so commonplace today, and oftentimes men use porn to numb the
00:28:00.700
pain of loneliness, boredom, anxiety, and depression.
00:28:04.420
Shame and stigma prevent men from talking about these issues and getting help for them.
00:28:13.240
Steve is the founder of Valor Recovery, a program to help men overcome porn abuse and sexual compulsivity.
00:28:21.060
Steve is a long-term sexual recovery member and has personally overcame the emotional and
00:28:25.960
spiritual despair of abusing pornography and has dedicated his life to empowering men to
00:28:33.080
Steve is an amazing person, and he is a close friend of mine.
00:28:39.520
Valor Recovery helps men to develop the tools necessary to have a healthier sex life.
00:28:44.120
Their coaches are in long-term recovery and will be your partner, mentor, and spiritual guide
00:28:53.260
To learn more about Valor Recovery, please visit them at www.valorrecoverycoaching.com or
00:29:03.520
email them at admin at valorrecoverycoaching.com.
00:29:11.040
You all know I like to keep things cool, even in the winter, and nothing is cooler than a
00:29:20.080
I'm fortunate enough to have one at home, and let me tell you, it's like baptizing your
00:29:25.060
soul, baby, getting that little crispy bucket, baby.
00:29:28.900
It gets rid of them demons we all have and makes you feel great for seven or eight hours
00:29:35.320
My buddy Thomas Schiffer, the genius behind Blue Cube, and I go way back, and he just launched
00:29:41.480
a pre-sale for their new stand-up cold plunges.
00:29:45.460
These things are the Cadillacs of cold plunge therapy.
00:29:49.280
American-made, full immersion, weatherproof frames, and built like a Sherman tank.
00:29:56.240
And because you're listening to me, you can get a sweet discount when you mention my name.
00:30:02.780
Just tell them Theo sent you, and they'll knock a good bit off the price.
00:30:07.840
So if you're ready to boost your metabolism, eliminate inflation, and blast away your anxiety,
00:30:14.580
Head over to their website, bluecubebaths.com, and dive into the details.
00:30:26.020
I am grateful for the one that I have, and I feel honestly thankful to be able to have one.
00:30:30.760
I know they're not in everybody's price range, and that's understandable.
00:30:34.720
But at the same time, I want to support my friend and his amazing company.
00:30:41.580
So I know you talked to Scott Galloway about some of these issues.
00:30:46.960
But the suicide rate among men under the age of 30 has risen by 40% since 2010.
00:30:58.580
Look, the American Institute for Boys and Men did a suicide trends analysis.
00:31:05.800
And if you go down, you can then see the shift in—so up until 2010, it was much more older men who were—
00:31:21.140
If male suicide rates had been the same as women's from 1999 to 2023, we would have lost 546,000 fewer men.
00:31:29.160
So men are—since 2010, suicide rates have risen by 30%.
00:31:38.960
So it was really interesting about the suicide—
00:31:51.540
And since 2010, it's all shifted to being younger men, right?
00:31:55.100
So the rise—up until 2010, the rise was middle-aged men, really.
00:32:05.700
But since 2010, the rise has been among younger men.
00:32:15.580
I think it's more just a lot of these young men feeling lost, feeling unseen.
00:32:30.480
But, yeah, we have to have something to feel a part of.
00:32:32.480
Man, I remember there was a guy I went skydiving with,
00:32:35.260
and he'd listen to this podcast when it first started out.
00:32:40.480
and we connected on some emotional levels talking about life and stuff.
00:32:46.120
And then there were a couple times he'd messaged me,
00:32:48.440
and I didn't get back to him over like six months or something.
00:32:59.580
Not that I had, you know, nothing I probably could have done.
00:33:03.520
But just like, man, it's just like, oh, I just like sometimes that's –
00:33:13.760
And one of the things that stopped me in my tracks,
00:33:17.840
so I, for a living, like I'm reading research reports
00:33:22.600
But I've also been racing, you know, three boys.
00:33:26.320
sometimes you get a finding that just stops you
00:33:32.240
And there's one study that looked at men who'd taken their own lives
00:33:36.020
and then looked at the words they'd used to describe themselves
00:33:41.180
And the two most commonly used words that men were using about themselves
00:33:55.960
of genuinely feeling like maybe my family, my community
00:34:10.480
If you then look at drugs, you look at substance abuse,
00:34:13.320
you look at what's happening in the employment market,
00:34:29.440
if you think about, like, the script that my dad had, right,
00:34:34.280
let's look at some previous scripts so we can examine those, right?
00:34:46.820
that she was mostly going to be the homemaker and the mom.
00:34:51.760
But my dad knew that he was going to be the breadwinner, right,
00:35:10.260
And that's the problem that the women's movement
00:35:12.200
successfully, to a large extent, set out to solve, right?
00:35:16.260
But my dad was also quite emotionally dependent on my mom, right?
00:35:22.740
But I do think it was like it's a two-way street.
00:35:29.060
you don't have to be a housewife and mother anymore,
00:35:47.260
provided a new one about empowerment and independence and you, go, girl.
00:35:53.120
which is you're going to be the provider and the protector.
00:35:59.980
So basically, we've gone from having some kind of script to improvisation.
00:36:08.120
And so it's hard because the good news here is what's happened to women, right?
00:36:11.320
Like nobody wants to roll back the economic gains of women.
00:36:14.980
But I think it's incredibly irresponsible and naive of us
00:36:19.220
to think that that doesn't have consequences for how we think about the role of men.
00:36:23.080
We've got to be able to think both of those thoughts at once.
00:36:38.720
It's good to like, and it's really, it makes perfect sense, right?
00:36:41.880
And it's like, you want to have a reason, right?
00:36:45.460
And sometimes I think women, yes, they didn't have the access to money.
00:36:51.520
And in a capitalistic society, money is power, right?
00:36:54.000
But also, I think there was a missing respect there, right?
00:36:57.080
There wasn't all, I think if women had been, if it had been totally respected,
00:37:01.780
the sacrifices that they made and the just intrinsic value of who they are
00:37:08.480
as mothers and as caretakers and as bridges of empathy and affection
00:37:14.760
and as homemakers, no matter where they are, whether they're in a home
00:37:18.780
or whether they're in a conversation, just being able to have that ability to create peace,
00:37:23.560
I think if women had, if that had been more respected,
00:37:26.680
then maybe they never would have felt as much of a movement
00:37:30.480
or as much of a desire to have so much of a movement.
00:37:35.240
Right, and the power, and the money is the power.
00:37:37.280
Yeah, so that's what that, the women's movement had a huge fight about that
00:37:41.360
because there were some people in the women's movement saying,
00:37:43.460
no, no, no, it's called the wages for housework movement,
00:37:46.700
which was basically what we need to do is pay women to do the traditional women's role.
00:37:55.040
Bring that up, the wages for housework movement?
00:37:57.080
Yeah, there's a big split in the women's movement
00:37:59.420
between the ones who are saying we need to value care and value care work,
00:38:04.360
And then there's another movement, which is like,
00:38:09.620
The wages for housework campaign was a 1970s international movement
00:38:13.480
that demanded governments recognize the value of unpaid domestic labor
00:38:19.820
The founders were Silvia Federici, Selma James,
00:38:29.400
Their goals were to change the dependency of domestic workers,
00:38:32.680
reverse power relations, and redistribute wealth.
00:38:37.540
That's another way we could have gone, in theory at least, right?
00:38:40.720
And I'm not saying that women didn't deserve to have all the jobs
00:38:44.320
I'm just saying if there had been a different level of respect,
00:38:48.180
and this makes perfect sense, and some financial equality,
00:38:57.360
No, well, this is a really interesting question
00:39:00.080
because I now think we're at a point where a lot of men and women
00:39:12.580
Both parents are so stressed out that they can't even have a relationship anymore.
00:39:18.040
We want to raise our own kids, by and large, right?
00:39:22.600
So one of the ways I think about this is like you had this old family system,
00:39:25.300
which was breadwinner father, homemaker mother,
00:39:32.880
but it was also pretty stable and very clear what everyone's role is,
00:39:41.100
So we've replaced that with a different model now
00:39:45.420
So we're going to – both men and women are going to work.
00:39:51.180
and maybe that relationship is hard to sustain,
00:39:53.840
which means it might end up separating, which is not good for kids.
00:39:59.560
You don't know who's getting certain things done.
00:40:10.300
I mean, it's like everybody knows that it makes more sense.
00:40:12.480
Like you're in charge of X, I'm in charge of Y.
00:40:14.420
So you get really good at X, and I get really good at Y.
00:40:16.880
And the interesting path we took instead was like,
00:40:28.380
I don't imagine a world where the Wages for Housework movement,
00:40:31.700
like huge government subsidies to people who are staying at home,
00:40:36.280
And there's all kinds of problems with that idea.
00:40:38.820
But it's an interesting idea but thought behind it,
00:40:41.780
which is are we doing enough to support the people
00:40:54.820
which is to change the way the workplace works,
00:40:59.980
And J.D. Vance has supported like a child tax credit,
00:41:05.420
to give more money to people who've got kids in the house.
00:41:11.560
but it's in the direction of actually valuing care
00:41:28.160
And it certainly wouldn't be aimed just at women anymore.
00:41:41.120
and not just to parents who are in the workplace.
00:42:11.780
Men are more likely to say that getting married
00:42:16.160
And so that's a really interesting moment in history
00:42:38.500
until we can get both of the parties to be aligned,
00:43:06.460
I thought you meant you were going to get 25 wives.
00:43:13.180
We would need a change in the law for that, Theo.
00:43:56.940
Converting to Islam is very easy to process and can be done online in privacy.
00:44:25.900
I think most human societies have been polygamous,
00:44:30.380
It's like 95% of known human societies have been polygamous and almost always.
00:44:39.640
which means men are allowed to have multiple wives,
00:44:55.460
we have twice as many female ancestors as male ancestors.
00:45:11.920
There are twice as many women in human history as there are men.
00:45:18.540
modern humans have approximately twice as many female ancestors as male ancestors.
00:45:24.260
I love the fact that you're checking everything I say.
00:45:26.120
This makes me feel much more confident about saying it because then you're going to check it.
00:45:32.680
That's one of my goals this year is just to have a better,
00:45:36.060
because sometimes I just assume everything is true.
00:45:38.380
And a lot of this stuff is just helpful information,
00:45:45.380
You're just saying that two thirds of the people that have ever existed have been female.
00:45:55.480
So obviously she's going to want more kind of babes around hanging out on her.
00:46:17.820
So I think it makes sense that you're going to have more women around probably.
00:46:27.680
I just think women are the ones who like keep things together.
00:46:32.740
So I think you're going to need more of that probably to keep the world functioning.
00:46:58.520
who wants a bunch of dudes loitering around anyway?
00:47:13.440
are there more women because mother earth wants,
00:47:18.340
she's obviously going to have a probably like definitely,
00:47:21.840
Maybe mother earth is very jealous and she doesn't want women around.
00:47:32.480
They're jerking off in the parking lot or whatever.
00:48:04.600
are they NBA players well known for having lots of children?
00:48:22.560
That's what Scott Galloway was saying that like the top 1% of men.
00:48:29.860
I actually showed that Tinder data to an evolutionary psychologist.
00:48:44.420
But 50% of men across human history didn't have kids at all.
00:48:59.960
And that we basically have to kind of send out a few people to survive.
00:49:03.980
And there's this passing comment because the earth's going to be destroyed.
00:49:11.160
which is like most of the colonists will have to be female.
00:49:14.620
And the reason for that is the ones we're talking about,
00:49:17.800
which is you need a lot of wombs to keep the human race going,
00:49:35.320
and this is going to get me back to your skydiving.
00:49:48.600
50% of men have not reproduced in human history.
00:49:54.900
And it's the lower status men who are not going to have kids,
00:49:58.240
Because the higher status men have multiple wives.
00:50:08.880
there's a good chance that you're just not going to reproduce at all,
00:50:17.540
you will risk almost anything to raise your status.
00:50:25.080
Do anything to try and get yourself up that hierarchy
00:50:39.500
You only got a 50-50 chance of having a kid anyway,
00:50:46.100
you're almost certainly not going to have a kid.
00:50:48.180
so you take crazy risks to raise up the hierarchy.
00:51:25.480
so you're going to have to get your fact checker in the sky to check,
00:51:29.980
But I know for sure that smoke jumpers are almost entirely men.
00:51:42.740
so you'd know if you were from out kind of West,
00:51:47.280
the number of men and women who try tandem skydiving is roughly equal to the sport of skydiving
00:51:53.320
only about 14% of professional skydivers in the United States are women.
00:52:04.440
And women may be perceived as less interested in taking risks.
00:52:12.400
you are highly incentivized to protect your own body,
00:52:28.040
if you've only historically had like a 50-50 chance,
00:52:35.820
who cares if you're nuts land out in the desert or whatever,
00:52:44.040
Smoke jumpers are highly trained firefighters who parachute from airplanes in a remote areas to fight wildfires.
00:52:56.640
because these are people who have chosen for a job.
00:53:05.220
even when there's nothing wrong with the airplane,
00:53:10.760
they jump out of the airplane into a blazing inferno in the middle of nowhere,
00:53:15.980
and stay there for days on end fighting that fire.
00:53:39.380
There is no big feminist movement to get more women into smoke jumping.
00:54:01.640
Because there are times when you want people to be willing to take risks,
00:54:05.800
or to kind of try a new venture or something like that.
00:54:09.220
And there are times when it's a really bad idea,
00:54:13.920
or to jump too high off a bridge or whatever it is.
00:54:17.180
And so there's ways in which those differences between men and women can either become good or bad.
00:54:22.200
But we don't get anywhere by denying that they exist.
00:54:33.800
and they're a lot more risk-taking when they're young,
00:54:35.620
if they're a bit more potential for physical aggression,
00:54:45.660
and we see that playing out in all kinds of ways,
00:54:48.840
it doesn't do any good to just say that's not true,
00:54:56.160
So what do we do about that as a culture and as a society?
00:54:58.700
How do we kind of take those differences responsibly and not fall into the trap of saying one is good or one is bad?
00:55:04.700
We used to think that somehow the male attributes,
00:55:19.280
but we also don't want a society where the male,
00:55:22.140
the more male leaning attributes are seen as intrinsically bad.
00:55:24.900
It's one of the reasons why I hate the term toxic masculinity,
00:55:36.300
getting your sweat on might seem like hard work,
00:55:44.780
Premium custom saunas for your home or business,
00:55:51.640
I just got myself a symmetry sauna and I'm sweating out bad decisions.
00:56:32.100
made with Aspen wood from ancient Estonian forests.
00:56:43.420
Learn more about how to get your own premium home sauna from symmetry sauna at symmetry sauna.com slash T-H-E-O.
00:57:00.760
there's uncertainty is what it means to be a man.
00:57:05.300
masculinity with this new femininity kind of being defined.
00:57:16.580
What do you feel like is causing that these days?
00:57:25.060
And I think that's really important thing to say,
00:57:26.920
because that sometimes is what feels like might be the case.
00:57:35.340
which is women have risen significantly economically in terms of education.
00:57:49.740
maybe the struggles of men are the result of the rise of women.
00:57:57.520
So a lot of the jobs that men used to be able to do,
00:57:59.840
especially without maybe that much education in manufacturing and steelworks and mining and
00:58:07.620
are they gone for good or they've just gone away from America?
00:58:14.660
And there's no serious prospect of those male jobs that required like strong physical labor.
00:58:33.840
It's just those jobs that men used to be able to do that their dad maybe did just,
00:58:39.460
that was a lot of the commercials when I was a kid.
00:58:44.000
There was that commercial of like somebody made something.
00:58:46.620
And I remember my grandfather worked at the plant in his town and they made elevators
00:58:51.620
They made parts for elevators and it was a small town,
00:58:53.680
but he worked there and my grandma would take him lunch over there at the weekend during lunchtime.
00:58:58.560
And they had a lunch whistle in town and there was just these little things,
00:59:15.660
to a town called Bliner Fustinjog in North Wales.
00:59:28.620
They will not be able to even spell Bliner Fustinjog.
00:59:32.340
you was the biggest producer of slate for a long time.
00:59:34.920
And generations of my family have worked in that slate mine.
00:59:44.200
And went down into the mine and spent some time that had a big effect on them.
00:59:58.680
My mom was a part-time industrial nurse for a while.
01:00:06.760
because we would hear the factory hooter horn horn.
01:00:13.620
So it's almost like as men were out of the minds now,
01:00:22.340
So we went down to the bottom of the slate mine and there are these little huts in the
01:00:27.560
And they would go in there for like 30 minutes at lunchtime and they would sing.
01:00:37.540
And then they'd go back up and start coming out of the mine.
01:00:46.020
I went to those huts and I sat in there like with my boys and we're kind of sitting there and
01:00:50.120
thinking about like seven generations of our family being down there.
01:00:53.560
And actually this is going to sound a bit weird,
01:00:57.880
but almost being a little bit envious of what it was like for those men to go down there and
01:01:05.400
And then of course you catch yourself and you think you're an idiot,
01:01:19.200
especially was the sense of like male solidarity,
01:01:22.940
that visceral sense of like it did structure life,
01:01:32.760
all the wives would come out and the kind of children and stand silently.
01:01:38.400
So they stood silently while the men went down into the mine.
01:01:43.980
And so there's something very beautiful and nostalgic about that.
01:01:59.700
great grandfather did and your great grandfather and your grandfather.
01:02:06.960
even if we wanted to reconstruct that kind of world,
01:02:09.540
but I do think we should be honest about the fact that the collapse of that structure and
01:02:14.440
those scripts has really left a lot of men incredibly uncertain about,
01:02:33.020
And so it's no longer the case that women are now like looking for a man.
01:02:51.100
she said the point of the women's movement is to make marriage a choice for women,
01:03:04.060
It was the only way who's going to pay for dinner.
01:03:09.920
And so the whole point is to make it a choice so that women have enough economic power to
01:03:14.180
choose marriage rather than being forced into it.
01:03:22.580
But she got married partly because same-sex marriage is legal now.
01:03:26.580
And because she said we've made enough progress that marriage,
01:03:28.880
she used to describe marriage as this patriarchal citadel,
01:03:48.480
the long single Steinem married for the first time in a Cherokee ceremony in Oklahoma.
01:03:55.180
entrepreneur and activist David Bale sadly died of lymphoma four years later.
01:04:01.860
even Gloria Steinem felt like it was okay to get married,
01:04:08.100
marriage was no longer this kind of trap for women economically.
01:04:23.380
but we're now in this world where there's a lot more freedom of choice.
01:04:30.100
But it's also created a huge amount of uncertainty,
01:04:34.620
I think a lot of men feel now that they've been told a bunch of things that they know they shouldn't be.
01:04:48.920
I sometimes think that we had a long list of don'ts for men.
01:05:00.980
but everybody's going to need to pair up because the way that the,
01:05:06.680
you needed each other because you needed someone to be in the home.
01:05:18.440
And what I fear now is that there are some more reactionary forces,
01:05:27.660
to actually for men to find purpose is to go back because it's very recently
01:05:33.840
which was the world we just escaped from where women were economically
01:05:37.640
And so I could totally understand why this is happening,
01:05:41.500
we used to know what our role was when women were economically reliant on us.
01:05:53.100
but that doesn't mean we shouldn't be doing more to help men move forward
01:05:56.920
and actually having a bit of empathy for the fact that this is a difficult
01:06:03.220
And so rather than kind of pointing fingers at them,
01:06:05.860
we should maybe offering them the occasional helping hand.
01:06:08.220
And I think that lack of empathy and understanding and awareness of the
01:06:12.540
genuine suffering of many of our men has created a huge vacuum in our
01:06:20.900
Otherwise we're going to lose more and more of our men.
01:06:26.240
So one thing you have to start to look at is then where do men start to,
01:06:31.760
or where do men continue to find these building blocks,
01:06:44.440
and even like you're saying shoulder to shoulder,
01:06:46.200
like things that experiences that I've had that have been the best.
01:06:50.940
like even when I used to go to a Brazilian Jiu Jitsu and take classes there,
01:07:02.660
It's trying to help people trying to help each other,
01:07:15.280
love and compassion that comes along with having great instructors.
01:07:18.740
And a lot of times it's just the guy next to you who's your best
01:07:36.620
they call it like sex and love addiction and stuff,
01:07:38.280
but it's really just like intimacy disorders or connection disorders or
01:07:46.100
And sometimes you base it off of your relationship with women or you
01:07:48.860
can look at your relationship with women to see how you're doing on
01:07:53.280
Are there men and women in those groups or is it just me?
01:08:01.780
I can be able to share openly if I'm struggling with a certain thing or how
01:08:11.680
slurp on any of the chicks that are in there either.
01:08:15.080
which would seem bad given the nature of the problems that many of the
01:08:19.700
It'd be like holding an AA meeting in a bar or something.
01:08:31.440
And sometimes they'll say something in like my body will just go like
01:08:39.820
It's an exhale that I didn't even know I needed to take.
01:08:42.640
It's an exhale that has just been running in the back of my subconscious
01:08:55.760
And I needed to hear another man's voice say it.
01:09:21.460
I think we sometimes don't pay enough attention to them.
01:09:24.500
It's actually something like I go on road trips with more,
01:09:27.300
my best friend or every year I get together with my male buddies and we go hiking so that
01:09:32.740
we're shoulder to shoulder and just talk and catch up.
01:09:38.860
one of the damaging trends in recent years has been a suspicion of male spaces,
01:09:44.900
Of like the boys weekend or even some of the institutions.
01:09:47.720
So if you actually go through the institutions now,
01:09:49.520
like the Boy Scouts is not the Boy Scouts anymore.
01:09:55.100
but I used to run a scout group over in the UK and I was a scout,
01:10:12.440
But Boy Scouts has become scouting for America.
01:10:22.960
no one really thinks about the M in YMCA anymore.
01:10:33.100
And I think there's one other one I'm thinking of.
01:10:35.940
it's not that there's always bad for things to be co-ed.
01:10:38.580
It's not that you also don't want institutions for girls and women.
01:10:41.840
But what we've got now is a situation where we're actually really very often
01:10:45.700
applauding having these spaces for girls and kind of women to have female solidarity,
01:10:59.760
we've actually deconstructed a lot of these institutions where actually boys could learn
01:11:06.840
And so I think that turning the Boy Scouts into Scouting for America and taking,
01:11:25.680
but actually the fact that I was able to go to Scouts and it would be guys there
01:11:32.180
I actually think that male spaces are where you can help men to learn some of the not
01:11:37.180
traditionally male attributes like caring and nurturing and love and expressing that
01:11:54.060
but kind of learning some of those skills that maybe go against the stereotype about girls,
01:12:01.620
you generally don't have to encourage a bunch of boys to compete with each other.
01:12:16.580
but a lot of that was military based type stuff.
01:12:24.200
I know we have conflicts and we've had some smaller wars,
01:12:27.340
but I know we have it since we haven't had such a huge conflict.
01:12:29.940
There hasn't been that big band of brothers type of vibe.
01:12:50.480
A lot of times it feels like by the media is like a loser as part of the problem,
01:12:56.060
I don't think a lot of that energy is also good in our country.
01:13:04.640
you can't make also white males feel like they don't exist,
01:13:09.080
Because also a lot of white people didn't have a lot of like,
01:13:15.000
you didn't fucking feel any privilege sometimes.
01:13:19.080
I would get looked at personally as why the fuck don't you have anything?
01:13:30.640
but you fuck your family can't even get shit together enough.
01:13:43.420
You're not allowed to speak up for your own group just because of,
01:13:54.520
I've learned a lot about the history of racism in this country and particularly for black Americans.
01:14:03.980
But if I'm just playing fantasy football and trying to take care of a family,
01:14:09.280
I think the way I see this is that it's part of a more general problem,
01:14:13.620
which is to be able to hold two thoughts in your head at the same time,
01:14:18.020
it is true that America has this history of racism and that there are still some racial issues that we need to deal with.
01:14:31.860
Who was the first slave ever in the history of time?
01:14:38.720
The U.S. has a uniquely terrible history when it comes to slavery.
01:15:05.820
particularly from a low-income background right now,
01:15:07.800
you're actually at the highest risk of suicide.
01:15:10.920
And your economic prospects compared to your father