TRIGGERnometry - February 17, 2022


An Honest Conversation With Nigel Farage


Episode Stats

Length

1 hour and 9 minutes

Words per Minute

169.39435

Word Count

11,720

Sentence Count

786

Misogynist Sentences

6

Hate Speech Sentences

40


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Nigel Farage is a former Prime Minister of the United Kingdom who served as Prime Minister between 1997 and 2017, when the country voted to leave the European Union. In this episode of Trigonometry, Francis and Constantine talk to Nigel about the reasons why he voted "leave" in the referendum, and why he thinks we should have open borders.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.700 Broadway's smash hit, the Neil Diamond Musical, A Beautiful Noise, is coming to Toronto.
00:00:06.520 The true story of a kid from Brooklyn destined for something more, featuring all the songs you love,
00:00:11.780 including America, Forever in Blue Jeans, and Sweet Caroline.
00:00:15.780 Like Jersey Boys and Beautiful, the next musical mega hit is here, the Neil Diamond Musical, A Beautiful Noise.
00:00:22.660 April 28th through June 7th, 2026, the Princess of Wales Theatre.
00:00:27.120 Get tickets at Mirvish.com.
00:00:30.660 Hey Francis, do you need new investment ideas?
00:00:33.740 No thanks, I've got all my cash tied up in Venezuelan crypto.
00:00:37.860 Ah, how is GringoCoin doing?
00:00:39.700 It's pronounced GringoCoin. My portfolio is now worth a billion Venezuelan bolivars.
00:00:45.900 That's about three quid then.
00:00:47.380 Er, you're right, I should have got new investment ideas.
00:00:50.500 Well, if you want to take back control of your finances, then Fortune and Freedom is for you.
00:00:55.560 It was founded by Nigel Farage, who has over 40 years of experience in finance and politics.
00:01:01.300 Fortune and Freedom is published by South Bank Investment Research and is for the investor looking to access a wide range of informed opinions on lots of different investing opportunities.
00:01:12.640 Their brilliant newsletter covers everything from causes and the impact of inflation to the rise of cryptocurrencies, gold investing and much more besides.
00:01:22.800 Through their daily news commentary and special reports, Fortune and Freedom can give you more confidence in making informed decisions about what to do with your money.
00:01:31.040 Simply go to fortuneandfreedom.com. That's fortuneandfreedom.com and sign up for a free newsletter that will help your money work for you.
00:01:42.000 The link is in the description.
00:01:43.920 I still don't think people understand what's about to happen.
00:01:53.020 Hello and welcome to Trigonometry. I'm Francis Foster.
00:01:57.000 I'm Constantine Kisham.
00:01:58.060 And this is a show for you if you want honest conversations with fascinating people.
00:02:03.640 Our brilliant and returning guest needs very little introduction.
00:02:06.980 Nigel Farage, welcome back to Trigonometry.
00:02:08.700 It's good to be here and not doing it via bloomin' Zoom.
00:02:11.720 I couldn't agree with you more. It's a real pleasure.
00:02:13.960 So good to have you back.
00:02:15.480 Let's get straight into it, Nigel.
00:02:16.840 One of the questions that I've been meaning to ask you, because as you know, Francis and I will both remain voters, but very open to the democratic argument.
00:02:22.880 And by the way, I've been persuaded by some of the arguments guests have made on the show in the past about it.
00:02:27.900 Would you vote remain today?
00:02:30.220 I doubt it.
00:02:31.460 I wouldn't. No.
00:02:32.340 No, I doubt it.
00:02:33.480 I doubt it.
00:02:34.180 I think we've seen that the economic disaster that is happening is happening for other reasons now that we were promised.
00:02:43.040 You know, we still got sandwiches.
00:02:44.320 I thought we were going to lose those.
00:02:45.660 Yeah.
00:02:45.860 And look, I think this is the issue I was going to ask you about, because the one thing that Brexit hasn't delivered, which I think a lot of people thought it would, is the reduction in immigration, right?
00:02:55.440 And I've always been in favour of a sensible immigration policy as an immigrant myself.
00:02:59.380 I don't see why we should have open borders or people should be able to come without doing the checks and all of that.
00:03:05.140 But that hasn't happened, Nigel, has it?
00:03:07.040 Do you know, despite the way that I was portrayed for year after year after year for even daring to discuss the subject and kind of Enoch Powell did the immigration argument huge harm all the way back in the mists of 1968,
00:03:22.300 that after that moment in time, it became almost the unacceptable subject to discuss in British politics.
00:03:28.600 Thatcher talked a little bit about it, but generally you couldn't talk about it.
00:03:33.360 I'd always argued that we had a discriminatory immigration system.
00:03:38.680 We were in favour of anybody from the continent of Europe, and we put barriers up to the rest of the world.
00:03:44.300 So I was making the argument that we should have a points-based style system, regardless of where you came from.
00:03:52.860 And that we absolutely should not discriminate against the Commonwealth.
00:03:56.460 You know, people with whom we have a lot of shared history, common language, you know, all of those things.
00:04:03.660 What was really interesting when the referendum finally came, and the referendum finally came because of the surge in the UKIP vote,
00:04:12.040 and the immigration argument, or actually the impact on people's lives of uncontrolled mass immigration on a scale Britain had never seen,
00:04:21.200 when it came to the referendum, the Conservatives and Labour MPs that joined Vote Leave did not want to discuss this subject.
00:04:33.120 Didn't want to discuss it.
00:04:34.280 All too difficult, all too awkward, not popular at Notting Hill dinner parties.
00:04:39.840 And in the end, they realised, to win the referendum, it couldn't just be us talking about it, myself and Aaron Banks.
00:04:47.480 They had to be involved.
00:04:48.780 There was a lovely cartoon, when they first mentioned Australian style points system,
00:04:52.520 a lovely cartoon in the Telegraph, and it was me drinking a pint.
00:04:56.400 It was quite normal, but drinking a pint of Australian points system beer.
00:05:01.460 Sounds like a photograph, not a cartoon.
00:05:03.180 Well, it could have been, and there was Boris and Gove saying,
00:05:06.180 Barman, we'll have the same as he's having.
00:05:08.200 So in the end, they talked about it, but never with any sincerity.
00:05:12.300 And whenever Boris has been asked about immigration since the referendum,
00:05:15.520 oh, well, it's absolutely marvellous, because we're getting back control of who comes into Britain.
00:05:19.660 But never, ever has he begun to hint that it would be a reduction of numbers.
00:05:24.560 So you've actually got a Conservative Party who, on the immigration theme,
00:05:29.920 and frankly, for most of them, on Brexit, just embraced it for a career opportunity.
00:05:34.840 Never actually really believed in it, and numbers are not reducing.
00:05:39.540 But of course, it's the illegal immigration that's leading to the anger.
00:05:42.320 It's what's happening in the English Channel.
00:05:44.100 And that was the story that I really picked up on right at the start of lockdown.
00:05:48.080 And I started going out into the English Channel, filming what was going on,
00:05:53.620 getting roundly condemned.
00:05:55.520 But actually, I think I did help make that a much bigger media issue than it is.
00:06:00.000 So yeah, any thought that because we voted Brexit,
00:06:03.500 immigration's been dealt with, and it's therefore no longer a political issue,
00:06:07.020 is for the birds.
00:06:08.940 So yes, I'm disappointed.
00:06:10.660 The problem is, Nigel, is that people voted for this
00:06:13.800 in the expectation that immigration was going to be lowered.
00:06:16.780 It hasn't been.
00:06:18.280 So where do we go from here?
00:06:21.080 Yeah, as I say, I, you know, the Conservative Party is a pretty vile organisation.
00:06:27.120 You know, they cynically, I mean, you know, it took them a long time.
00:06:31.220 It took them to the summer of 2019 to really embrace the narrative,
00:06:35.800 but not the delivery.
00:06:37.440 I think we are at a moment with British politics
00:06:41.280 where our levels of disenchantment with the system and with the people
00:06:46.220 are even worse than they were before the insurgency
00:06:50.960 that led to the referendum in the first place.
00:06:54.820 I don't know is the answer to that.
00:06:56.540 I genuinely don't know.
00:06:57.940 I mean, I think at some point Boris goes.
00:07:00.740 All right?
00:07:01.600 At some...
00:07:02.220 Please, dear God.
00:07:03.640 I know, it's agony, isn't it?
00:07:04.920 You know, wait for the Sue Gray report,
00:07:07.380 wait for the Metropolitan Police, whatever it is.
00:07:09.960 My anger with Boris actually isn't the passes.
00:07:12.020 No.
00:07:12.180 I mean, I'm annoyed.
00:07:15.180 My anger is the betrayal of what so many people wanted.
00:07:20.600 And you've raised the immigration question,
00:07:22.300 but actually that's part of something bigger.
00:07:26.340 Brexit led people to believe that a new type of politics was coming.
00:07:30.920 A real hope, an anticipation of a new kind of politics.
00:07:34.660 And we've gone back to the old Etonian, Oxbridge, PPE degree,
00:07:39.960 chumocracy of upper-middle-class people,
00:07:43.880 rabbiting on about net zero.
00:07:45.980 Well, if you live in Richmond in a £5 million house,
00:07:48.560 net zero is absolutely marvellous, darling.
00:07:51.180 Because, you know, it doesn't matter to us,
00:07:53.500 it costs £25,000 to put a heat pump on the side of the house,
00:07:56.020 or, oh, we'll have a new Tesla.
00:07:58.040 You know, I mean, that's the kind of government it's become.
00:08:00.980 So I think what will happen is this.
00:08:02.900 Boris will go.
00:08:05.820 My sense of it is that the 5th of May will be a disaster.
00:08:10.620 That's the local elections where, you know,
00:08:12.860 councils they hold like Wandsworth, Westminster,
00:08:15.120 are really seriously in play.
00:08:17.580 The next Conservative leadership election
00:08:19.620 will be an existential battle
00:08:21.220 for the future of Conservatism in this country.
00:08:23.940 You know, it'll be Rishi on one side,
00:08:26.120 representing tax and spend, big state, social democracy.
00:08:30.000 I mean, you know, literally not, you know,
00:08:33.760 a Ritzler paper between him and Keir Starmer,
00:08:36.300 really, on the big issues of the day.
00:08:38.180 And then there'll be somebody standing up for what I think
00:08:42.340 and understand Conservatism to be,
00:08:44.480 mainly, you know, individual responsibility,
00:08:47.980 opportunity, and the state not controlling your life.
00:08:51.360 And if that battle's lost, I don't know where we go.
00:08:55.180 You see, Brexit happened because of an insurgency.
00:08:59.360 And there was a means by which that could be expressed.
00:09:02.860 Breaking the first-past-the-post electoral system,
00:09:05.480 I mean, changing anything in this country
00:09:07.340 is really very, very difficult.
00:09:10.880 You know, in fact, in some ways,
00:09:11.820 I look at Brexit almost as a miracle.
00:09:13.240 Well, given the mass battalions that were there on the side
00:09:17.820 of not even having a conversation about it 10 years ago.
00:09:20.880 So we're in a very difficult place.
00:09:23.380 If you could go back to the 2019 general election,
00:09:26.200 because you didn't put forward candidates
00:09:28.860 from the Brexit party in constituencies
00:09:31.920 where Conservatives were.
00:09:33.700 Do you think, looking at the way Brexit has happened,
00:09:36.420 do you think that was a mistake now, Nigel?
00:09:37.920 That is a very good question.
00:09:40.640 And I'm not saying that's just a play for time.
00:09:43.060 Which is what they normally do.
00:09:45.900 I've thought a lot about that.
00:09:49.880 I've thought a lot about that.
00:09:53.460 I could have put candidates up
00:09:57.200 against all the sitting MPs.
00:10:00.560 I could have gone round the country rubbishing the deal,
00:10:05.060 saying that it will split Northern Ireland off from the country.
00:10:07.560 It's an economic and environmental catastrophe
00:10:10.760 for our fisheries.
00:10:11.860 I could have done that.
00:10:13.420 I could have rubbished the whole thing.
00:10:16.160 But, you know, in that particular election,
00:10:20.360 2015, UKIP took more Labour votes than Tory votes.
00:10:24.220 We actually helped the Tories.
00:10:25.460 I mean, they weren't bright enough to understand it then.
00:10:27.840 And I've never been thankful, but I wouldn't expect that.
00:10:30.820 But in 2019, it was different.
00:10:32.340 And if I had gone ahead with that strategy,
00:10:36.940 I think it would have led to 40 or 50 Lib Dem seats.
00:10:40.760 Particularly in...
00:10:41.520 I think, frankly, from Isha through to Land's End,
00:10:46.240 there would have been an orange wool.
00:10:49.740 A Lib Dem wool.
00:10:52.140 They thought that too.
00:10:53.540 In fact, she admitted after the election
00:10:55.100 that my decision had just poleaxed the Lib Dems.
00:10:58.620 So what I feared was a Labour, Lib Dem, SNP majority
00:11:03.200 in the House of Commons,
00:11:05.400 taking us back into a second referendum,
00:11:07.380 and goodness knows what,
00:11:08.860 and a breakdown of trust far more serious
00:11:11.680 than what we're talking about sitting here this morning.
00:11:14.620 On balance, it was the right thing to do.
00:11:16.960 I am disappointed in Johnson.
00:11:22.080 I mean, not that I've ever really believed in him.
00:11:24.480 Well, no, I mean, it's not about...
00:11:26.100 For him, it's all about rank, title, position.
00:11:29.900 It's not really about policy.
00:11:31.380 It's not really about principle.
00:11:33.080 But no, looking back, despite everything,
00:11:35.340 it was still the right thing to do.
00:11:37.120 And Nigel, you wrote an article recently,
00:11:38.600 I think, in The Telegraph,
00:11:39.500 about there's a brewing revolt on the right.
00:11:41.360 And I think you do say that you're ready to be part of it.
00:11:43.880 Now, you're obviously doing great work on GB News.
00:11:46.120 You've got a very popular show on there.
00:11:47.960 Would you consider coming back
00:11:49.980 and trying to create some kind of other insurgency?
00:11:52.660 And let me ask you...
00:11:53.360 Well...
00:11:53.660 Let me explain why I'm asking this question,
00:11:55.240 because everything you've said so far
00:11:56.680 suggests to me that, OK,
00:11:58.620 someone like you can come along
00:11:59.960 and you can lead a movement
00:12:00.860 that will inspire people to vote for something.
00:12:03.320 But at the end of the day,
00:12:04.100 it's going to be one of the two major parties
00:12:05.600 delivering whatever it is that you inspire,
00:12:09.660 and they're not going to do the thing
00:12:10.980 that a lot of people voted for.
00:12:12.280 It's difficult for me.
00:12:13.040 I mean, look, number one,
00:12:15.680 I did it for a hell of a long time.
00:12:18.360 Yeah.
00:12:18.960 I mean, I was in the front lines,
00:12:21.000 you know, for year after year after year.
00:12:24.840 European elections, no problem.
00:12:27.720 Proportional representation,
00:12:29.420 no question what the issue was.
00:12:31.320 And I led parties that won in 2014 and 2019.
00:12:35.260 Two national election victories
00:12:36.920 leading two different parties.
00:12:38.680 No one's ever done that before.
00:12:39.560 But in 2015,
00:12:42.160 when I put my heart and soul
00:12:43.460 into a general election campaign
00:12:44.960 and get four million votes and one seat,
00:12:48.480 it's quite tough to ask me to do that again.
00:12:51.220 You know, could I go around the country,
00:12:53.200 you know, and really ferment
00:12:55.540 another big political insurgency?
00:12:58.260 Could I get even more votes
00:13:00.000 than I got in 2015?
00:13:02.440 Probably.
00:13:04.040 But what would it lead to?
00:13:06.180 And for me to do that again is very, very difficult.
00:13:09.660 Did it take a lot out of you?
00:13:11.460 Well, I've given a fair bit already to this.
00:13:13.160 But, but, so, I think that,
00:13:18.620 and you were going to mention GB News,
00:13:20.400 but whether it's GB News,
00:13:22.300 whether it's 3.3 million people
00:13:24.320 following on social media,
00:13:26.660 whether it's things that I write for The Telegraph
00:13:29.400 or whatever it is,
00:13:31.580 I still think I can move the needle.
00:13:34.700 I still think I can shift the centre of gravity
00:13:36.460 of public opinion on issues.
00:13:39.620 I'm honorary president of Reform UK.
00:13:42.980 It's a bit like sort of being pushed upstairs.
00:13:46.460 And Richard Tice has got the energy
00:13:48.700 to go out there and do it.
00:13:50.400 So he's got my full support.
00:13:52.040 I mean, I'll be honest with you,
00:13:54.560 every day I get emails saying,
00:13:58.160 you've got to come back,
00:13:59.000 you've got to come back,
00:13:59.840 you've got to come back.
00:14:01.340 It's not top of my bucket list,
00:14:03.140 having done it for all those years.
00:14:04.920 But you know what?
00:14:06.460 Never say never.
00:14:07.460 Oh.
00:14:08.620 Well, if, and I've said already to you
00:14:11.540 that when Boris goes, as and when that is,
00:14:14.540 there is going to be this battle.
00:14:16.880 Is the Conservative Party going to become
00:14:18.840 just a social Democrat party?
00:14:21.060 Are we going to stick in the Osborne-Cameron mould?
00:14:26.760 Is it going to be a party that looks after those
00:14:28.600 that already have plenty?
00:14:30.060 Or is it going to be that kind of aspirational,
00:14:33.120 ambitious party that wants to support enterprise,
00:14:35.840 energy, social advancement?
00:14:39.600 And if it does go back to that social Democrat centre,
00:14:43.000 and if the choice between, you know,
00:14:45.820 Starmer and Sunak, let's say,
00:14:48.360 in 2024, was negligible,
00:14:51.420 then I can't rule it out.
00:14:53.140 It's not what I want to do,
00:14:54.680 but I'll be honest with you,
00:14:56.020 I enjoyed so much of what I did in politics,
00:15:01.320 despite the nastiness.
00:15:02.660 And there's barely a photograph of me touring the country
00:15:04.780 where I'm not having a laugh,
00:15:06.440 or meeting people and having fun.
00:15:08.900 But it's a pretty tough place to be.
00:15:13.580 It's not an easy place to be.
00:15:16.260 And the trouble with it is,
00:15:19.180 you're not responsible just for yourself.
00:15:23.680 You're responsible for what the branch chairman
00:15:26.120 of some obscure suburb of Sheffield
00:15:29.140 said on Twitter at quarter past two in the morning
00:15:32.180 after five glasses of red wine.
00:15:33.660 Whereas what I do now,
00:15:36.480 I'm directly accountable.
00:15:38.860 If I make a mess of things,
00:15:40.260 that's down to me.
00:15:41.680 So, I mean, I'm enjoying life now.
00:15:43.280 I've enjoyed, you know,
00:15:45.040 since the referendum of 16,
00:15:46.400 I've enjoyed getting into broadcasting,
00:15:48.500 something I'd never done before.
00:15:50.040 And I'm enjoying that.
00:15:51.560 I've enjoyed, you know,
00:15:54.080 not having to be hands-on
00:15:56.620 and living on the road six days a week,
00:15:59.240 which I did for 20 years.
00:16:01.000 I mean, literally six days a week on the road,
00:16:03.200 and I'm enjoying not doing that.
00:16:05.320 I've enjoyed being able,
00:16:07.200 after almost 20 years out of it,
00:16:09.320 to get back to where I started
00:16:10.760 in financial markets, you know,
00:16:13.520 and putting together, you know,
00:16:16.160 as a daily email,
00:16:17.140 fortune and freedom goes to 85,000 people.
00:16:19.620 Well, I'm trying to help people
00:16:20.860 not get ripped off
00:16:22.140 by the financial services industry.
00:16:24.300 So there are lots of things that I've done
00:16:25.900 in the last few years
00:16:27.400 that means, you know,
00:16:28.280 life is pretty cool.
00:16:31.460 Life is pretty good,
00:16:32.300 but never say never.
00:16:33.880 Nigel,
00:16:35.020 do you think we're in political crisis now?
00:16:37.020 This is a question I ask most of our guests.
00:16:39.520 And when I started asking it,
00:16:41.520 I wasn't sure,
00:16:42.980 but I think we are.
00:16:44.180 What do you think?
00:16:45.880 I,
00:16:47.000 trust is a very important word.
00:16:49.820 As I say,
00:16:50.640 Brexit raised the hopes.
00:16:52.880 Some were in despair over Brexit,
00:16:55.220 but they're quite a small,
00:16:56.500 they're quite a small minority.
00:16:58.420 You know,
00:16:58.640 and guys like you that voted Remain,
00:16:59.980 well,
00:17:00.160 now you see it differently
00:17:01.080 and that's fine.
00:17:03.640 But for a lot of people,
00:17:05.900 there was this sort of new dawn
00:17:07.780 that Brexit was going to bring
00:17:09.800 a different kind of politics.
00:17:10.760 It hasn't happened.
00:17:12.480 And so,
00:17:12.800 yes,
00:17:13.020 I think it is a breakdown of trust,
00:17:15.100 a belief that the system doesn't serve us.
00:17:18.000 And,
00:17:18.380 you know,
00:17:18.560 I can look right through the whole thing.
00:17:20.280 I mean,
00:17:20.500 the House of Lords is an abomination.
00:17:22.860 You know,
00:17:23.120 just stuff full of mates
00:17:24.120 of prime ministers
00:17:24.800 and party donors.
00:17:25.820 The whole thing's a disgrace.
00:17:27.980 The electoral system,
00:17:29.700 even when you get radical shifts
00:17:31.640 in general elections,
00:17:32.800 two thirds of seats in Britain are safe.
00:17:35.060 You know,
00:17:35.240 if you live in somewhere
00:17:36.300 with a massive Labour majority
00:17:37.540 or a massive Tory majority,
00:17:39.200 they're quite voting,
00:17:39.940 is there?
00:17:41.140 We can't change anything.
00:17:42.920 You know,
00:17:43.100 an older generation would say...
00:17:44.460 But what about the Red Wall,
00:17:45.440 Nigel?
00:17:45.880 I mean,
00:17:46.120 that went,
00:17:46.600 didn't it,
00:17:46.820 in the 2019?
00:17:47.760 You had lots of constituents.
00:17:48.680 Well,
00:17:48.800 the Red Wall went years before that.
00:17:50.940 The Red Wall all voted UKIP
00:17:52.440 and the Brexit Party.
00:17:53.660 The Red Wall was crumbling
00:17:54.960 in 2013.
00:17:57.160 You know,
00:17:57.460 they were the Labour voters
00:17:58.720 that were coming to me
00:18:00.180 and coming to UKIP
00:18:00.940 in very large numbers.
00:18:02.700 You know,
00:18:03.000 I was the gateway drug
00:18:04.080 through to what happened
00:18:06.180 in 2019.
00:18:07.560 So,
00:18:08.060 yes,
00:18:08.900 there are places
00:18:10.020 where you can get change,
00:18:11.320 but there are still
00:18:11.860 vast parts of this country
00:18:13.820 where your vote
00:18:14.700 makes no difference at all,
00:18:16.080 where there is no degree
00:18:17.060 of proportionality
00:18:18.000 in Westminster
00:18:19.100 whatsoever.
00:18:20.000 We have a postal voting system
00:18:22.620 that,
00:18:24.100 frankly,
00:18:25.600 just leaves us wide open
00:18:26.920 to fraud,
00:18:28.120 abuse,
00:18:28.520 intimidation
00:18:29.160 in the big cities.
00:18:31.260 So,
00:18:31.720 I mean,
00:18:31.860 I'm a radical about this,
00:18:33.180 a genuine radical
00:18:34.440 in the 18th century
00:18:35.420 use of that word.
00:18:36.880 You know,
00:18:37.180 I would like to see
00:18:37.980 complete root and branch reform
00:18:39.720 of our entire system
00:18:41.080 of governance.
00:18:42.180 I think Brexit
00:18:42.740 has got us back control
00:18:43.940 of our country.
00:18:45.020 It's now for us
00:18:45.780 to make sure
00:18:46.160 the country's actually
00:18:47.040 run properly.
00:18:48.080 And I think
00:18:49.240 to have a system
00:18:49.820 in England
00:18:50.240 where it's just
00:18:51.820 two parties
00:18:52.520 and there's no way
00:18:54.080 anybody else
00:18:54.900 can break through.
00:18:56.560 And even if they get close,
00:18:57.820 the establishment
00:18:58.280 just cheats.
00:19:00.100 Yeah,
00:19:00.700 I think there is
00:19:01.400 a crisis there.
00:19:02.500 And I,
00:19:04.360 the trouble is,
00:19:05.380 in the past,
00:19:07.300 when people ask me
00:19:07.960 questions like that,
00:19:09.360 I always had an answer
00:19:10.540 as to how I thought
00:19:12.500 we could break this up.
00:19:13.920 And right now,
00:19:14.600 I haven't got that answer.
00:19:16.020 Well,
00:19:16.180 the problem you have
00:19:17.000 is if you talk about
00:19:17.840 proportion representation,
00:19:19.100 forget about the merits
00:19:19.920 of the system.
00:19:20.360 How are you going to get it
00:19:21.500 if you've got two parties
00:19:22.680 that are massively invested
00:19:23.940 in keeping things
00:19:24.580 where they are?
00:19:24.960 And that's why
00:19:25.720 changing anything is difficult.
00:19:26.960 I mean,
00:19:27.260 equally,
00:19:28.340 we don't have open primaries.
00:19:31.500 You know,
00:19:31.720 if the Labour
00:19:32.240 and Conservative parties
00:19:33.280 had genuine open primaries,
00:19:34.660 we might get
00:19:36.560 a very different
00:19:37.340 kind of leadership.
00:19:38.720 I'll be honest with you,
00:19:40.200 if and when Boris goes,
00:19:41.520 if there were open primaries
00:19:42.720 in this country,
00:19:43.640 I would put my name forward.
00:19:44.920 Broadway's smash hit
00:19:47.060 The Neil Diamond Musical
00:19:48.360 A Beautiful Noise
00:19:49.740 is coming to Toronto.
00:19:51.500 The true story
00:19:52.260 of a kid from Brooklyn
00:19:53.320 destined for something more
00:19:54.860 featuring all the songs
00:19:56.000 you love,
00:19:56.760 including America,
00:19:58.060 Forever in Blue Jeans
00:19:59.080 and Sweet Caroline.
00:20:00.760 Like Jersey Boys
00:20:01.720 and Beautiful,
00:20:02.560 the next musical
00:20:03.500 mega hit is here.
00:20:04.820 The Neil Diamond Musical
00:20:06.140 A Beautiful Noise.
00:20:07.580 Now through June 7th,
00:20:08.860 2026
00:20:09.620 at the Princess of Wales Theatre.
00:20:11.760 Get tickets at
00:20:12.480 Mirvish.com
00:20:13.680 Nigel Farage,
00:20:17.880 Prime Minister,
00:20:18.480 Leader of Conservative Party.
00:20:19.180 No, I would put my name forward.
00:20:20.620 Yeah, yeah, I can see that.
00:20:21.800 Then you'd have a lot of support.
00:20:23.000 No, OK,
00:20:23.360 we're not a presidential system.
00:20:24.680 I get that.
00:20:25.360 But, you know,
00:20:26.420 the idea,
00:20:27.760 you love me or hate me,
00:20:28.620 but the idea that someone like me
00:20:29.640 is completely excluded from this.
00:20:32.240 I mean,
00:20:32.600 the Conservative Party
00:20:33.440 wouldn't even have me
00:20:34.060 as a member.
00:20:35.760 It's bizarre.
00:20:37.180 It's a very interesting...
00:20:38.440 It's bizarre.
00:20:38.920 It's a very...
00:20:39.620 I mean,
00:20:40.740 PR does have a lot of disadvantages.
00:20:42.520 I mean,
00:20:42.700 David Starkey,
00:20:43.380 who you've spoken with as well,
00:20:45.080 he made this point
00:20:45.740 when we had him on
00:20:46.380 a long time ago
00:20:47.220 that the one thing
00:20:48.540 about first past the post
00:20:50.400 is it prevents extremism
00:20:51.960 being reflected.
00:20:53.400 So,
00:20:54.080 that is a concern
00:20:56.200 where you might get,
00:20:57.440 you know,
00:20:57.720 BNP getting 5%,
00:20:59.020 not today,
00:21:00.380 but 10 years ago,
00:21:01.380 whenever we were in.
00:21:01.740 Do you know something?
00:21:02.360 I don't buy that.
00:21:03.340 I just don't buy that
00:21:04.260 because the BNP
00:21:05.300 did achieve that.
00:21:07.160 They got a million votes, yeah.
00:21:08.080 In the European elections of 2009,
00:21:10.760 the BNP did that.
00:21:12.520 And once they had
00:21:13.140 elected representatives,
00:21:14.440 look what happened.
00:21:15.560 You know,
00:21:15.680 it's very interesting
00:21:16.420 that when you put
00:21:17.500 a bit of sunlight
00:21:18.160 onto organisations like this,
00:21:20.200 they actually divide
00:21:21.740 and wither away
00:21:22.380 fairly quickly.
00:21:23.520 Of course,
00:21:24.160 there has to be a threshold,
00:21:26.280 you know,
00:21:26.460 a sensible threshold.
00:21:28.060 But why shouldn't,
00:21:29.980 if there's a big view
00:21:30.980 in this country,
00:21:32.280 why shouldn't that have
00:21:33.300 a degree of representation?
00:21:34.120 And the argument
00:21:36.120 against PR systems
00:21:38.080 is that it leads
00:21:39.300 to weak government.
00:21:40.200 Well,
00:21:40.320 frankly,
00:21:41.200 Germany since 1945
00:21:42.280 has pretty much had coalitions
00:21:44.140 all the way through.
00:21:44.980 And from what I can see,
00:21:45.640 they've done quite well.
00:21:47.660 So I,
00:21:48.380 you know,
00:21:49.720 first past the post
00:21:50.700 worked
00:21:51.300 when it genuinely
00:21:53.040 was a two-party system.
00:21:55.960 But even up until 1900,
00:21:58.480 we had multi-member wards.
00:22:00.240 Do you see?
00:22:02.160 It wasn't just one MP
00:22:04.140 that would represent
00:22:04.800 a district.
00:22:05.600 It was often two or three.
00:22:07.560 And that led,
00:22:08.520 despite the establishment
00:22:09.520 of political parties
00:22:10.900 and the Whigs
00:22:11.560 and the Tories,
00:22:12.280 the Liberals,
00:22:12.760 all that,
00:22:13.980 but it still allowed
00:22:15.100 for independents
00:22:16.320 to come through the system.
00:22:17.960 You know,
00:22:18.180 for other parties
00:22:19.120 like Joe Chamberlain's party
00:22:20.380 to win seats in Parliament.
00:22:22.600 We've got the worst
00:22:23.480 of all worlds here
00:22:24.400 where it's not
00:22:25.380 multi-member constituencies
00:22:26.700 and it's that rigid
00:22:27.780 first past the post.
00:22:28.900 So,
00:22:29.160 so look,
00:22:29.800 I do understand
00:22:31.140 that the link
00:22:31.640 between the man or woman
00:22:33.100 and Guilford
00:22:33.740 or wherever it is
00:22:35.100 is quite important.
00:22:37.000 But equally,
00:22:38.160 if you had a degree
00:22:39.260 of proportionality
00:22:40.140 in our system,
00:22:41.260 you get a much broader
00:22:42.660 range of debate
00:22:43.500 and arguments
00:22:44.160 happening in Parliament.
00:22:45.420 You get much more
00:22:46.440 interesting people
00:22:47.220 actually coming into politics
00:22:49.000 and doing it
00:22:49.940 because they believed
00:22:50.500 in causes
00:22:51.160 and not just for careers.
00:22:53.680 So I think a degree,
00:22:54.740 I said this earlier,
00:22:56.160 a degree of proportionality.
00:22:58.000 I'm not calling
00:22:58.660 for the whole thing
00:22:59.560 to be PR,
00:23:00.740 but a degree
00:23:01.280 of proportionality.
00:23:02.560 I think it'd be very good.
00:23:04.380 And as I say,
00:23:04.860 I think the House of Lords
00:23:05.720 is completely past
00:23:07.080 its sell-by date
00:23:07.900 that we have to have
00:23:09.120 some form of election
00:23:10.200 for the upper chamber.
00:23:12.580 And if that means
00:23:13.280 people get elected
00:23:13.860 for eight years,
00:23:14.500 ten years
00:23:14.920 and could just serve
00:23:15.460 one term,
00:23:16.740 so be it.
00:23:17.760 Speaking of proportionality
00:23:18.980 and sort of moving on
00:23:19.940 a little bit, Nigel,
00:23:20.520 we've obviously gone through
00:23:21.500 a very strange period
00:23:22.620 in the history of this country
00:23:23.860 and the world
00:23:24.360 over the last couple of years.
00:23:26.140 And we've seen,
00:23:27.080 you know,
00:23:27.320 I don't think you're
00:23:27.940 a big government guy.
00:23:31.160 I'm not a big government guy.
00:23:33.200 And yet we have seen,
00:23:34.080 I mean, on the continent,
00:23:35.060 you talk about Germany
00:23:36.000 and Austria, et cetera,
00:23:37.220 locking unvaccinated people
00:23:38.560 in their homes,
00:23:39.340 fining, et cetera.
00:23:40.420 But even in this country,
00:23:41.600 I mean,
00:23:42.040 I love this country.
00:23:43.760 I've made my home here.
00:23:44.760 And one of the reasons
00:23:45.460 I love it is
00:23:46.240 that you're free to do
00:23:47.880 what you think
00:23:48.440 is the right thing,
00:23:49.260 whatever the situation is.
00:23:50.840 And you're free
00:23:51.420 to have your opinion
00:23:52.120 until recently
00:23:52.980 and so on and so forth.
00:23:54.740 And over the last two years,
00:23:56.460 we have seen the state
00:23:58.180 attempting to interfere
00:23:59.440 in things that I just don't think
00:24:01.240 it has a role in,
00:24:02.200 you know.
00:24:03.240 What have you made
00:24:04.020 over the last two years
00:24:04.820 the sort of authoritative
00:24:05.800 vaccine passports,
00:24:07.340 the idea of vaccine mandates,
00:24:08.720 all of that?
00:24:09.100 I've been horrified
00:24:09.920 by it all.
00:24:11.620 And in the first 18 months
00:24:14.220 of this,
00:24:15.380 astonished
00:24:16.060 at the lack of pushback.
00:24:18.860 You know,
00:24:19.200 YouGov,
00:24:19.800 do a poll,
00:24:20.400 and, you know,
00:24:22.140 64% agree with lockdown
00:24:24.000 and 20% want to go further,
00:24:25.460 right?
00:24:25.680 Ah,
00:24:26.340 what's going on?
00:24:28.700 Do you know what?
00:24:29.640 In the end,
00:24:31.060 actually,
00:24:32.400 the good common sense
00:24:34.600 allied to a free press
00:24:37.080 have won the day.
00:24:39.500 Well,
00:24:39.680 let's remember,
00:24:40.200 we're sitting here
00:24:40.920 in the second week of February.
00:24:43.640 Mid-December,
00:24:45.580 we had Valance,
00:24:47.420 Witty,
00:24:48.340 the Brothers Grimm.
00:24:49.140 We have,
00:24:50.580 we have,
00:24:51.500 we have,
00:24:52.140 I'm going to steal that.
00:24:53.860 That is very good.
00:24:53.900 Well,
00:24:54.080 just seeing them
00:24:54.900 is so depressing,
00:24:56.140 isn't it?
00:24:58.140 We had Boris Johnson
00:24:59.520 do a Sunday night
00:25:00.460 address to the nation
00:25:01.700 in which he used
00:25:03.500 the word emergency
00:25:04.360 four times
00:25:05.280 about Omicron.
00:25:06.920 All the while,
00:25:08.860 we have the South Africans
00:25:10.160 where this variant
00:25:12.540 had developed,
00:25:15.360 telling the rest of the world,
00:25:16.960 unlike the Chinese,
00:25:17.780 but telling the rest
00:25:19.080 of the world
00:25:19.660 what was coming our way
00:25:21.080 and explaining
00:25:22.220 that it was much milder
00:25:23.660 than anything
00:25:24.760 that had gone before
00:25:25.740 and in the end
00:25:26.700 would help to build
00:25:27.340 natural immunity
00:25:28.100 and might actually,
00:25:29.540 oddly,
00:25:30.480 on balance,
00:25:31.060 be a good thing.
00:25:32.720 So,
00:25:33.220 mid-December,
00:25:34.400 emergency,
00:25:35.500 lockdowns,
00:25:36.440 catastrophe,
00:25:37.460 the end is nigh.
00:25:39.580 Second week of February
00:25:40.660 and restrictions
00:25:41.900 about to end
00:25:42.820 completely.
00:25:43.840 how did that happen?
00:25:46.300 Well,
00:25:46.400 it happened
00:25:46.880 because we have
00:25:47.860 commentators,
00:25:49.920 press,
00:25:50.320 you know,
00:25:50.560 free press commentators
00:25:51.580 arguing enough's enough.
00:25:53.220 It happened
00:25:54.120 because there was
00:25:54.560 a backbench rebellion.
00:25:56.360 I mean,
00:25:56.940 the same mob,
00:25:58.120 the same mob
00:25:59.640 that fought Theresa May
00:26:00.700 over Brussels
00:26:01.520 and all these things
00:26:03.360 and the good
00:26:05.620 common sense
00:26:06.760 of the British people
00:26:07.440 has come into play
00:26:08.280 and that's put Boris
00:26:09.340 into line.
00:26:11.080 Interesting,
00:26:11.720 isn't it,
00:26:11.960 that the second country
00:26:13.020 to follow this route
00:26:14.400 is Denmark,
00:26:15.840 also a country
00:26:16.600 that hasn't joined
00:26:17.260 the Euro,
00:26:18.120 is deeply Eurosceptic
00:26:19.480 and will no doubt
00:26:20.020 leave the European Union.
00:26:20.580 All roads lead to Berlin
00:26:21.660 with Nassau down there.
00:26:22.900 Well,
00:26:23.440 but you can't deny it,
00:26:24.700 you know.
00:26:25.520 So,
00:26:26.160 so actually,
00:26:27.840 this is a good sign.
00:26:29.460 The fact that we've gone
00:26:30.600 in the space of a few weeks
00:26:31.900 from looking like more lockdowns
00:26:34.080 to where we are
00:26:34.840 is a very,
00:26:35.800 very good sign
00:26:36.440 that actually good common sense
00:26:37.500 in the end
00:26:37.980 does prevail in this country.
00:26:40.240 As for,
00:26:41.200 you know,
00:26:41.960 what is happening
00:26:42.980 in Australia
00:26:43.980 and countries like that,
00:26:45.900 I just,
00:26:46.280 New Zealand,
00:26:47.220 I just can't get a handle on it.
00:26:48.640 But it's not just those two,
00:26:49.620 it's Austria,
00:26:50.340 it's Germany,
00:26:51.120 it's Italy,
00:26:51.820 it's France.
00:26:52.720 Spain.
00:26:53.320 Spain,
00:26:53.760 it's,
00:26:54.520 it's a developed world.
00:26:56.280 Well,
00:26:56.600 thank God we've left
00:26:57.340 the European Union.
00:26:59.120 No,
00:26:59.780 I mean,
00:27:00.100 you know,
00:27:00.260 the vaccine rollout,
00:27:01.220 all these things are actually...
00:27:02.400 That was despicable,
00:27:03.060 their behaviour was despicable
00:27:04.260 with the vaccine rollout.
00:27:05.640 Stunning,
00:27:06.600 you know,
00:27:06.920 stunning.
00:27:07.960 I mean,
00:27:08.520 the way they behaved
00:27:09.560 and,
00:27:09.920 you know,
00:27:10.680 the Guardian telling us
00:27:11.940 that if we left
00:27:12.480 the European Medicines Agency
00:27:13.900 it would prove that Brexit
00:27:14.920 was a death cult,
00:27:15.800 but it's all wrong.
00:27:17.420 Yeah,
00:27:17.680 look,
00:27:17.900 I'm very worried
00:27:18.560 about this growth
00:27:19.180 of huge government,
00:27:20.820 but I see in Canada,
00:27:22.880 as we speak,
00:27:24.300 it's day 13 of a protest.
00:27:25.920 I generally
00:27:26.540 am pretty appalled
00:27:28.980 by mob rule,
00:27:30.700 but I don't see it
00:27:31.860 as mob rule.
00:27:33.280 Everything indicates to me
00:27:35.200 that the truckers
00:27:36.320 and their supporters
00:27:37.160 are behaving peacefully,
00:27:40.260 behaving well,
00:27:42.000 that the attempts
00:27:42.840 by Trudeau and others
00:27:43.940 to smear them
00:27:44.660 as being far-right extremists
00:27:46.640 simply aren't working.
00:27:48.380 And this is a really big stand.
00:27:51.180 And rather like,
00:27:52.220 we've won the battle
00:27:53.360 on the NHS,
00:27:54.640 vaccine mandate,
00:27:55.640 and I've been banging on
00:27:56.740 about this on my show
00:27:57.660 night after night for weeks.
00:27:59.020 What's happening in Canada?
00:28:01.440 I think the pendulum
00:28:02.320 is beginning to turn back,
00:28:04.580 and I think it will start
00:28:05.320 to turn back
00:28:06.120 in other countries.
00:28:08.240 But we've seen
00:28:09.220 the tendency,
00:28:10.000 haven't we,
00:28:10.340 of governments
00:28:10.860 to use any excuse,
00:28:13.140 any crisis
00:28:13.860 to build their power.
00:28:16.340 And so,
00:28:17.220 you know,
00:28:17.560 that's the next big battle,
00:28:18.680 isn't it?
00:28:19.180 This is a battle
00:28:19.880 genuinely for liberty,
00:28:21.180 for freedom,
00:28:21.800 for individual choice.
00:28:23.680 And I am going to stick
00:28:25.240 to my theme
00:28:25.980 of the last 30 years,
00:28:27.880 which is
00:28:28.600 globalist structures.
00:28:31.580 Whether it is
00:28:32.680 the European Union,
00:28:34.840 whether it is
00:28:35.640 the United Nations,
00:28:37.300 whether it is
00:28:38.040 the World Health Organization,
00:28:40.420 will always seek
00:28:41.020 to expand.
00:28:42.220 They seek to expand,
00:28:43.500 well, look at NATO
00:28:44.220 in the Ukraine.
00:28:45.280 They seek to expand
00:28:46.060 geographically.
00:28:46.520 We're going to have
00:28:46.900 a big argument
00:28:47.400 about that.
00:28:48.860 They seek to expand,
00:28:50.660 but they seek to expand
00:28:51.920 their own powers.
00:28:52.860 And actually,
00:28:54.100 the antedate to this
00:28:55.320 are democratically run
00:28:57.040 nation states
00:28:57.720 with directly accountable
00:28:58.540 politicians.
00:28:59.300 I honestly believe
00:29:00.240 this all fits in
00:29:01.120 to the whole theme
00:29:02.220 of my political life.
00:29:03.980 Nigel,
00:29:04.380 do you not feel that
00:29:05.520 with all the lockdowns,
00:29:07.460 the draconian measures
00:29:08.460 that we've seen,
00:29:09.340 what we've actually done
00:29:10.400 is open a Pandora's box.
00:29:11.720 So next time
00:29:12.300 there is a particularly
00:29:13.660 bad flu season,
00:29:14.960 for example,
00:29:16.520 you know,
00:29:16.880 well,
00:29:17.040 we're going to have
00:29:17.440 a few restrictions,
00:29:18.420 otherwise the NHS
00:29:19.120 is going to be overwhelmed
00:29:20.220 if there's a new variant
00:29:21.700 next year,
00:29:22.540 et cetera, et cetera.
00:29:23.700 Yeah, climate lockdowns.
00:29:25.360 Why not?
00:29:26.700 I mean,
00:29:27.100 Sadiq Khan seems to be
00:29:28.160 very keen to drive
00:29:28.900 every car off the roads
00:29:29.920 of London.
00:29:30.940 What if the,
00:29:31.860 you know,
00:29:32.720 particle per million parts
00:29:35.480 of nitrous oxide
00:29:36.880 reaches a certain level
00:29:38.240 in East London
00:29:39.060 and they decide,
00:29:40.200 you know,
00:29:40.460 no more cars for a week?
00:29:41.680 Yeah, no,
00:29:42.420 I do worry
00:29:43.340 I do worry
00:29:44.680 that that precedent's
00:29:45.520 been set,
00:29:46.300 but I do worry
00:29:48.100 about that,
00:29:48.760 but I still think
00:29:49.840 that this victory
00:29:52.420 of common sense
00:29:54.220 that we've achieved
00:29:55.320 over the last couple
00:29:56.060 of months in the UK,
00:29:57.440 I think that'll stand
00:29:58.240 us in quite good stead.
00:29:59.780 I hope it'll stand
00:30:00.740 us in quite good stead.
00:30:02.340 But as for,
00:30:03.280 you know,
00:30:04.620 Austria,
00:30:05.460 Germany,
00:30:06.120 New Zealand,
00:30:08.120 maybe it's gone.
00:30:08.880 It's funny,
00:30:09.320 isn't it?
00:30:10.560 We seem to
00:30:11.300 have a younger generation,
00:30:12.580 not all of them,
00:30:13.600 but a younger generation,
00:30:14.460 many of whom
00:30:14.960 seem to think
00:30:16.620 that values
00:30:17.800 matter more
00:30:20.620 than freedom
00:30:21.640 and liberty.
00:30:23.160 And safety.
00:30:24.800 And safety
00:30:25.820 and the rule of law.
00:30:28.820 I mean,
00:30:30.300 how a jury,
00:30:31.420 how a jury
00:30:32.660 in the trial
00:30:34.120 of the Colston Four
00:30:35.120 could decide
00:30:36.280 that what happened
00:30:36.880 wasn't criminal damage
00:30:37.920 kind of shows you
00:30:39.460 what I'm saying.
00:30:40.640 Yeah.
00:30:41.640 And when you start
00:30:42.960 to believe in these values,
00:30:45.400 and these values
00:30:46.360 become a substitute
00:30:47.160 for religion,
00:30:48.860 you know,
00:30:49.100 whether it's
00:30:49.700 the fight against
00:30:50.840 global warming,
00:30:52.060 the fight against
00:30:53.020 racism,
00:30:54.660 historic wrongs,
00:30:55.840 it's a list
00:30:56.260 as long as your arm,
00:30:57.980 and you start
00:30:59.020 to believe
00:30:59.720 that your view
00:31:01.780 has a
00:31:03.140 moral superiority
00:31:05.260 over people
00:31:07.220 with another view,
00:31:08.680 that's when you
00:31:09.300 start to throw
00:31:09.920 things like liberty,
00:31:11.400 freedom,
00:31:12.420 justice,
00:31:13.100 rule of law
00:31:13.640 out of the window.
00:31:14.760 So these are
00:31:15.160 very big challenges
00:31:16.100 going ahead.
00:31:17.680 And I,
00:31:18.920 I mean,
00:31:21.220 I think longer term,
00:31:22.660 one of the big issues
00:31:23.960 that we're going
00:31:24.300 to have to address
00:31:25.040 if we really
00:31:26.700 do care
00:31:27.300 about the size
00:31:28.800 of a state,
00:31:29.740 about individual
00:31:30.360 freedom,
00:31:31.540 is the way
00:31:32.280 young people
00:31:32.760 are being educated.
00:31:35.020 And I think
00:31:35.840 that is the real
00:31:36.880 cancer in society.
00:31:40.400 I mean,
00:31:40.780 I think that,
00:31:42.860 and it starts
00:31:43.440 at primary school.
00:31:44.820 This isn't just
00:31:45.500 university.
00:31:46.760 This isn't just
00:31:47.220 a few sort of
00:31:47.880 wacky lefty
00:31:48.980 professors.
00:31:49.640 This is actually
00:31:50.400 right through
00:31:51.280 the education system.
00:31:53.380 And we seem
00:31:53.780 to have stopped
00:31:54.500 teaching critical
00:31:56.260 thinking.
00:31:58.000 Stop teaching,
00:31:58.680 stop teaching people
00:31:59.940 that, you know,
00:32:00.800 here's a potential
00:32:01.500 problem,
00:32:02.380 here are two
00:32:02.920 approaches to it,
00:32:04.100 they're both valid,
00:32:05.740 and you make your
00:32:06.440 mind up which of
00:32:07.240 these you think
00:32:07.980 is the right way
00:32:08.940 to deal with
00:32:09.440 society.
00:32:10.960 And that's kind
00:32:11.720 of been replaced
00:32:12.300 by, well,
00:32:12.840 this one's,
00:32:13.760 you know,
00:32:14.960 good and moral
00:32:16.500 and this one's evil.
00:32:18.060 So,
00:32:19.180 that does pose,
00:32:22.040 you know,
00:32:23.000 a big,
00:32:23.580 a big problem.
00:32:24.500 problem in the
00:32:25.500 years to come.
00:32:26.360 But I'm still,
00:32:27.040 I'm still confident.
00:32:29.980 I'm still bullish.
00:32:31.260 I still,
00:32:31.940 I still think
00:32:33.180 common sense is
00:32:33.960 there.
00:32:34.460 I still think
00:32:34.920 there is a,
00:32:35.940 when push comes
00:32:36.520 to shove,
00:32:37.320 a silent majority
00:32:38.300 who are for good
00:32:39.500 things and sensible
00:32:40.300 things.
00:32:40.840 I still think we
00:32:41.640 have,
00:32:42.620 particularly with
00:32:43.020 Brexit,
00:32:43.880 an important
00:32:44.520 leadership role
00:32:45.380 that we can be
00:32:46.600 an example to
00:32:47.800 others in the
00:32:48.300 world.
00:32:48.900 So,
00:32:49.520 yeah,
00:32:49.880 I can't help it.
00:32:50.960 I still come out
00:32:51.740 as the eternal
00:32:52.220 optimist.
00:32:54.340 Hey,
00:32:54.920 Constantine,
00:32:55.780 do you love
00:32:56.480 Trigonometry?
00:32:57.320 Of course.
00:32:58.180 Incredible interviews,
00:32:59.680 hilarious live streams,
00:33:01.240 hard-hitting satire,
00:33:02.760 plus my handsome
00:33:03.880 jawline.
00:33:04.520 Whatever takes away
00:33:05.420 from your hairline.
00:33:06.540 But if you do love
00:33:07.480 Trigonometry and you
00:33:08.660 want to support us,
00:33:09.840 there's only one place
00:33:11.120 to do that,
00:33:12.060 and that's on
00:33:12.840 Locals.
00:33:13.420 Yes,
00:33:13.960 Locals is a
00:33:14.820 brilliant platform
00:33:15.600 that has been
00:33:16.300 incredibly supportive
00:33:17.360 to our show
00:33:18.260 and other
00:33:18.980 problematic creators.
00:33:20.900 The great thing
00:33:21.520 about Locals is
00:33:22.480 that it's a
00:33:22.920 community for
00:33:23.760 people who
00:33:24.540 love Trigonometry.
00:33:25.700 That's right,
00:33:26.180 it's a place for
00:33:26.800 you to hang out
00:33:27.480 with like-minded
00:33:28.140 people,
00:33:28.720 share thoughts,
00:33:29.480 memes,
00:33:29.780 and discuss the
00:33:30.440 show.
00:33:30.900 You can enjoy
00:33:31.520 it for free,
00:33:32.500 but it also
00:33:33.200 gives you the
00:33:33.800 option of
00:33:34.320 supporting us
00:33:35.000 for as little
00:33:36.040 as $7 a month.
00:33:37.580 And if you
00:33:37.880 want to give
00:33:38.360 more,
00:33:38.880 you can.
00:33:39.500 We have
00:33:39.880 incredible
00:33:40.420 rewards for
00:33:41.100 our higher-tier
00:33:41.700 supporters as well.
00:33:42.840 We've got
00:33:43.140 everything from
00:33:43.780 mugs,
00:33:44.260 monthly group
00:33:44.900 calls,
00:33:45.340 and one-on-two
00:33:46.460 chats with
00:33:47.100 me and
00:33:47.480 KK.
00:33:47.920 Get in.
00:33:48.840 Join our
00:33:49.360 community by
00:33:50.320 hitting the
00:33:50.840 link in the
00:33:51.440 description and
00:33:52.380 the pinned
00:33:52.700 comment below.
00:33:53.540 See you there,
00:33:54.260 guys.
00:33:55.780 We're talking
00:33:56.520 about optimism,
00:33:57.500 but to me,
00:33:58.380 it seems we're
00:33:59.400 in for quite a
00:34:00.480 bleak year in
00:34:01.440 terms of
00:34:01.840 economics,
00:34:02.380 in terms of
00:34:02.840 inflation.
00:34:03.860 If you look at
00:34:04.820 the challenges
00:34:05.400 the ordinary
00:34:06.180 person is facing
00:34:07.280 when it comes to
00:34:07.880 heating bills,
00:34:09.840 I mean,
00:34:10.100 that's a real
00:34:11.280 worry,
00:34:11.840 isn't it?
00:34:12.580 Let's deal
00:34:12.960 with those
00:34:13.200 separately.
00:34:15.060 Inflation,
00:34:15.540 a disease
00:34:17.160 of money
00:34:17.680 caused by
00:34:19.120 government.
00:34:20.440 All right?
00:34:20.720 Now, you
00:34:20.980 get inflationary
00:34:21.740 shocks,
00:34:22.300 you get
00:34:22.560 commodity price
00:34:23.280 rises or
00:34:24.160 whatever,
00:34:25.120 but you also
00:34:25.620 get monetary
00:34:26.120 inflation.
00:34:26.900 Monetary
00:34:27.220 inflation is
00:34:27.800 caused by
00:34:28.580 governments.
00:34:29.600 It's a miracle
00:34:30.240 to many of
00:34:30.860 us that
00:34:31.680 inflation didn't
00:34:32.340 kick in
00:34:32.660 earlier,
00:34:33.560 because we've
00:34:34.000 seen since
00:34:34.440 2008 all
00:34:36.040 sorts of
00:34:36.420 astonishing
00:34:37.000 money creation
00:34:38.280 measures,
00:34:39.200 entire
00:34:41.000 economies,
00:34:41.700 frankly,
00:34:42.060 propped up
00:34:42.500 by massive
00:34:43.160 government
00:34:43.520 borrowing and
00:34:44.080 spending and
00:34:45.160 increasing in
00:34:45.840 debt.
00:34:47.040 So I'm not in
00:34:47.920 the least bit
00:34:48.520 surprised inflation
00:34:49.400 has come back,
00:34:50.080 and it's one of
00:34:50.540 the things,
00:34:51.680 you know,
00:34:51.960 with my newsletter,
00:34:52.700 we've been
00:34:52.960 calling this out
00:34:53.500 every day for a
00:34:54.300 year.
00:34:55.320 And fascinating,
00:34:56.860 if you go back
00:34:57.200 to this time last
00:34:58.000 year,
00:34:58.980 the sheer
00:34:59.400 complacency of
00:35:00.360 central banks,
00:35:01.940 the complacency
00:35:02.640 of politicians.
00:35:03.540 Boris in
00:35:03.980 October was
00:35:05.800 telling the
00:35:06.140 House of Commons
00:35:06.700 inflation is not
00:35:07.740 a problem.
00:35:08.420 Ha!
00:35:09.200 But it's not
00:35:11.280 just him,
00:35:11.860 they've all
00:35:12.300 had it wrong.
00:35:12.780 I know.
00:35:13.420 They've all
00:35:14.140 had it wrong.
00:35:15.280 Just as none
00:35:16.200 of them saw
00:35:16.740 the crash
00:35:17.160 coming in
00:35:17.680 2008,
00:35:18.940 none of
00:35:19.500 them have
00:35:20.880 seen inflation
00:35:21.520 coming.
00:35:22.640 And I'm
00:35:23.360 pleased to say
00:35:23.880 that, you
00:35:24.220 know,
00:35:24.380 I've been
00:35:24.740 there with
00:35:25.660 my team
00:35:26.100 calling this,
00:35:26.880 predicting this
00:35:27.380 all the way
00:35:27.800 through.
00:35:27.940 We've been
00:35:28.200 talking about
00:35:28.660 it for
00:35:28.880 years,
00:35:29.240 Nigel.
00:35:29.460 We've had
00:35:29.900 people right
00:35:30.440 at the
00:35:30.660 beginning
00:35:30.860 of lockdown
00:35:31.300 saying,
00:35:32.200 well,
00:35:32.320 maybe we
00:35:32.640 should think
00:35:33.080 about how
00:35:33.640 much this is
00:35:34.260 going to
00:35:34.520 cost and how
00:35:35.400 we're going
00:35:35.660 to pay for
00:35:36.260 it.
00:35:36.560 And no one's
00:35:39.200 but there's
00:35:39.520 a secret
00:35:39.840 truth here,
00:35:40.360 isn't there?
00:35:42.040 Inflation
00:35:42.480 suits governments.
00:35:44.500 Governments
00:35:44.940 that have
00:35:45.180 built up
00:35:45.540 massive debts,
00:35:46.940 inflation
00:35:47.380 devalues the
00:35:48.180 size of
00:35:48.580 those debts.
00:35:50.700 I'm not
00:35:51.240 being a
00:35:51.520 conspiracy
00:35:51.840 theorist,
00:35:52.540 but it
00:35:52.720 almost is
00:35:53.140 a way
00:35:53.420 out.
00:35:54.200 And then
00:35:54.520 central banks
00:35:55.900 can't put
00:35:56.880 interest rates
00:35:57.540 up enough
00:35:58.260 to dampen
00:35:59.440 down inflation
00:36:00.280 because we're
00:36:01.000 so bloomin'
00:36:01.500 indebted at
00:36:02.040 every level,
00:36:03.040 whether it's
00:36:03.600 national debt,
00:36:04.260 corporate debt,
00:36:04.880 personal debt,
00:36:05.800 that if you
00:36:06.180 put up rates
00:36:06.740 too much too
00:36:07.320 quickly,
00:36:07.620 the whole thing
00:36:08.040 falls to pieces.
00:36:09.200 So I do
00:36:09.760 think actually
00:36:10.220 inflation offers
00:36:10.780 governments a
00:36:11.320 way of getting
00:36:12.160 themselves out
00:36:12.980 of debt.
00:36:13.860 And the people
00:36:14.500 that pay the
00:36:14.920 price in
00:36:15.760 inflation are
00:36:16.480 ordinary decent
00:36:17.320 folk who see
00:36:18.120 what they work
00:36:18.760 for and save
00:36:19.840 for disappearing.
00:36:21.240 So you're now
00:36:22.660 being told by the
00:36:23.380 experts,
00:36:24.060 don't worry,
00:36:24.680 you're poor
00:36:25.040 little heads.
00:36:26.220 It will hit
00:36:27.000 7.25% in the
00:36:28.600 UK, the inflation
00:36:29.500 rate in April,
00:36:30.580 but it'll fall
00:36:31.300 away by the end
00:36:31.900 of the year.
00:36:32.220 Well, I'm not
00:36:32.580 so sure.
00:36:33.000 on the fuel
00:36:36.580 bill side of
00:36:38.860 things, which
00:36:39.440 is just, I
00:36:40.740 still don't
00:36:41.380 think people
00:36:41.820 understand what's
00:36:42.500 about to happen.
00:36:43.980 I really don't
00:36:44.900 think they
00:36:45.240 understand the
00:36:45.800 first week of
00:36:46.240 April when
00:36:47.180 those bills
00:36:47.660 hit the
00:36:48.040 mat for
00:36:49.500 their Q1
00:36:50.180 gas and
00:36:51.960 electricity bills.
00:36:52.900 There's going to
00:36:53.240 be absolute
00:36:53.820 shock and
00:36:54.340 outrage.
00:36:55.240 Number one,
00:36:56.340 massive mistake,
00:36:57.200 the Conservatives
00:36:57.800 adopted price
00:36:58.660 caps.
00:36:58.940 Can you
00:36:59.740 believe it?
00:37:01.280 Can you
00:37:01.860 believe that a
00:37:03.240 Conservative
00:37:03.660 government,
00:37:04.560 I mean, why
00:37:05.060 not set a
00:37:05.480 price for a
00:37:05.860 loaf of
00:37:06.100 bread?
00:37:07.140 I miss what
00:37:07.460 the Marxists
00:37:08.000 did.
00:37:10.040 Nuts policy.
00:37:11.380 It never
00:37:11.980 works.
00:37:12.860 It's nearly
00:37:13.320 always
00:37:13.640 counterproductive.
00:37:16.220 But it leads
00:37:17.020 to a much
00:37:17.380 bigger question.
00:37:19.820 Net zero
00:37:20.380 is, in
00:37:21.920 economic terms,
00:37:23.720 I think the
00:37:24.400 most self-destructive
00:37:25.300 policy that has
00:37:26.460 ever been put
00:37:27.220 forward by a
00:37:28.420 British government
00:37:28.940 in the history
00:37:29.840 of the nation.
00:37:31.240 That doesn't
00:37:32.040 mean that I'm
00:37:33.500 against finding
00:37:34.620 ways of
00:37:35.580 producing energy
00:37:36.940 that emit less
00:37:38.840 CO2 and cause
00:37:40.020 less environmental
00:37:40.740 damage, but I'm a
00:37:42.060 pragmatist.
00:37:43.120 You know, we
00:37:43.460 still burn four
00:37:44.960 and a half million
00:37:45.480 tons of coal a
00:37:46.220 year in this
00:37:46.660 country.
00:37:47.060 We have to to
00:37:47.580 make steel.
00:37:48.720 Do you know
00:37:48.980 what?
00:37:49.180 We import it
00:37:49.740 all.
00:37:50.580 We're importing
00:37:51.480 50% of our
00:37:53.220 natural gas when
00:37:55.140 we've got vast
00:37:56.120 reserves, possibly as
00:37:57.920 much as a
00:37:58.360 trillion pounds
00:38:00.340 worth of
00:38:00.780 natural gas in
00:38:01.520 Lancashire and
00:38:02.060 Cumbria alone.
00:38:03.380 Hey, that's
00:38:04.020 half the national
00:38:04.600 debt.
00:38:05.440 It's quite
00:38:05.960 interesting when
00:38:06.480 you look at
00:38:06.740 somebody's numbers.
00:38:07.260 And a lot of
00:38:07.440 jobs, too.
00:38:08.440 Tens of
00:38:09.040 thousands of
00:38:09.660 well-paid jobs.
00:38:11.040 And if you're
00:38:11.380 going to use the
00:38:12.640 blooming stuff
00:38:13.120 anyway, you
00:38:14.480 might as well
00:38:14.820 make it here.
00:38:16.020 The Americans
00:38:16.660 rethought their
00:38:19.060 energy policy five,
00:38:21.000 six years ago.
00:38:23.080 And the price of
00:38:24.040 natural gas in
00:38:24.720 America is half
00:38:25.720 the price that it
00:38:26.520 is here.
00:38:28.020 We then have
00:38:29.380 walked onto
00:38:30.020 people's bills.
00:38:33.200 Incredibly, 25% of
00:38:36.140 your electricity
00:38:36.700 bill is green
00:38:37.220 subsidies.
00:38:38.100 Money that goes
00:38:38.960 to rich landowners.
00:38:40.340 Money that goes to
00:38:41.000 large foreign
00:38:42.000 companies building
00:38:43.260 wind farms.
00:38:44.480 We've put so much
00:38:45.600 faith in wind
00:38:46.280 energy, or if
00:38:47.380 truth be told, so
00:38:48.660 much money has been
00:38:49.340 made out of wind
00:38:50.740 energy by those in
00:38:52.340 the elites that we
00:38:53.660 leave ourselves
00:38:54.120 vulnerable at some
00:38:55.600 point of a not-too-distant
00:38:56.400 future to blackouts.
00:38:58.580 So, yes, commodity
00:39:00.160 prices globally have
00:39:01.600 gone up, but we've
00:39:02.820 left ourselves
00:39:03.540 absolutely exposed,
00:39:05.180 not just to world
00:39:06.160 markets, but left
00:39:07.520 ourselves exposed.
00:39:09.540 You know, 9% of our
00:39:10.860 electricity comes from
00:39:12.980 France through an
00:39:14.160 interconnector.
00:39:15.460 You know, so I think
00:39:16.280 we should be self-sufficient
00:39:17.340 in energy.
00:39:18.140 We should be aiming
00:39:19.080 with areas like gas to
00:39:21.620 get people's bills
00:39:22.380 down.
00:39:22.780 I don't think a penny
00:39:23.920 piece should go to
00:39:26.980 massive global
00:39:28.380 industries in the
00:39:29.620 form of green
00:39:30.100 subsidy.
00:39:31.220 So I think this, I've
00:39:33.600 got a feeling,
00:39:34.220 actually, that the
00:39:35.260 energy debate and the
00:39:36.880 net zero debate is
00:39:38.580 going to be huge.
00:39:39.660 And Boris stands up
00:39:40.660 and says, isn't it
00:39:41.280 marvellous?
00:39:42.140 We've cut our CO2
00:39:43.480 output by 44% since
00:39:44.920 1990.
00:39:46.040 Well, if you close
00:39:46.740 down nearly all of
00:39:48.440 your chemical plants,
00:39:49.840 your aluminium
00:39:50.400 smelters, your
00:39:51.540 refiners, and you
00:39:53.160 move steel plants
00:39:54.520 from Red Card to
00:39:55.200 India, and then
00:39:57.000 import the products
00:39:58.400 back, you yourself
00:40:00.360 may be producing
00:40:01.860 less CO2, but
00:40:03.020 globally, the net
00:40:05.500 game is even more
00:40:06.540 CO2 is being
00:40:07.420 produced.
00:40:08.020 So I think we've
00:40:08.980 got this hopelessly,
00:40:11.020 catastrophically wrong.
00:40:12.840 And I think it's a
00:40:14.680 function of, and by
00:40:17.400 the way, Labour are
00:40:18.120 just as bad on this,
00:40:19.140 if not worse.
00:40:20.620 And I think it's a
00:40:21.300 function of career
00:40:22.460 politicians, a
00:40:23.740 function of people
00:40:24.660 living inside
00:40:25.680 metropolitan bubbles
00:40:26.600 in London, prey to
00:40:29.120 the lobbying influences
00:40:30.940 of some people who are
00:40:32.440 rather good at this,
00:40:34.600 and utterly disconnected
00:40:36.520 from the real world.
00:40:37.980 And it's about to blow
00:40:38.680 up this year.
00:40:39.660 It's about to blow up.
00:40:40.480 Nigel, there is a
00:40:43.180 left-wing argument,
00:40:44.080 which actually I have
00:40:45.000 quite a lot of sympathy
00:40:45.820 for, was saying,
00:40:46.720 isn't Thatcher partly
00:40:48.260 responsible for this,
00:40:49.720 for privatising our
00:40:51.340 energy companies?
00:40:52.560 And actually, if the
00:40:54.340 government was in charge
00:40:55.280 of this, we wouldn't
00:40:56.320 be, I mean, they'd make
00:40:58.020 a mess because they
00:40:58.580 always do, but we
00:40:59.820 wouldn't be in this
00:41:00.700 mess.
00:41:01.440 Privatisation works where
00:41:02.700 you can create
00:41:03.180 competition.
00:41:04.380 I was always sceptical
00:41:05.700 about privatising the
00:41:06.600 railways.
00:41:07.460 It seemed to be, you
00:41:08.280 know, how could you
00:41:10.300 provide a proper
00:41:10.960 competitive network
00:41:11.920 within that?
00:41:13.240 With energy, it's
00:41:13.980 different, actually,
00:41:15.080 because different
00:41:16.040 energy suppliers can
00:41:17.280 supply to your home
00:41:18.560 and you can go out
00:41:20.100 and game the market
00:41:20.980 and swap and change.
00:41:22.240 So, no, I don't have
00:41:23.900 a problem at all
00:41:24.640 with that.
00:41:26.100 But what I have a
00:41:26.720 massive problem with
00:41:27.820 is green subsidy,
00:41:29.600 which is put on by
00:41:30.300 government, not by
00:41:32.040 energy providers.
00:41:33.760 Smart meters, which,
00:41:36.020 again, is a
00:41:37.380 government directive
00:41:38.220 to energy companies,
00:41:40.440 which will lead to,
00:41:41.980 you know, peak flow
00:41:43.800 pricing and goodness
00:41:44.860 knows what else.
00:41:46.740 So, and what I have a
00:41:48.060 massive problem with is
00:41:49.480 the very concept of
00:41:50.260 price caps, which, of
00:41:51.460 course, has actually
00:41:51.840 bankrupted, as it
00:41:53.140 turned out, many of the
00:41:54.700 smaller providers.
00:41:55.980 So, no, look, there are
00:41:57.800 limits to privatisation.
00:42:00.960 There are limits to it.
00:42:02.240 But where you can create
00:42:03.340 genuine competition,
00:42:04.500 that is better than it
00:42:05.380 being state-run.
00:42:06.500 And, Nigel, you bring up
00:42:07.740 energy security.
00:42:09.300 And so, I'm going to
00:42:10.380 butter you up a little
00:42:11.180 bit before we get into
00:42:12.200 a big disagreement about
00:42:13.560 NATO and Ukraine and
00:42:14.880 all that, because I do
00:42:15.580 want to talk about
00:42:16.180 geopolitics a little bit.
00:42:17.940 But I think this actually
00:42:19.180 plays into your motif more
00:42:20.880 than anything else, which
00:42:21.980 is globalisation.
00:42:24.280 It's the idea, oh, yeah,
00:42:25.480 we can buy our
00:42:26.320 electricity from this, and
00:42:27.780 we can buy our steel from
00:42:28.840 that, and we can buy it.
00:42:30.000 And before you know it,
00:42:31.000 Germany's importing its
00:42:32.240 gas from Russia, and even
00:42:34.160 if the West wanted to do
00:42:35.620 something there, I mean,
00:42:37.220 you're being held hostage.
00:42:37.960 Yeah, the just-in-time
00:42:40.180 supply chain.
00:42:41.540 Don't vote Brexit, or
00:42:43.660 you'll destroy the just-in-time
00:42:45.620 supply chain.
00:42:46.540 Well, the just-in-time
00:42:47.280 supply chain suits giant
00:42:49.160 multinational global
00:42:50.820 corporations, but does
00:42:52.360 away with any concept of
00:42:54.240 nation, does away with any
00:42:56.220 concept of a common good
00:42:57.660 for a collective group of
00:42:59.720 people in that nation.
00:43:01.220 And this has been very much
00:43:02.060 exposed.
00:43:03.500 The German thing's
00:43:04.780 incredible.
00:43:05.880 I mean, utterly incredible.
00:43:06.940 There they were, saying
00:43:09.140 Brexit was funded by the
00:43:10.680 Russians, Trump, you know,
00:43:12.820 is in Putin's pocket.
00:43:14.280 It was Germany all the time.
00:43:16.460 I mean, they've made
00:43:16.940 themselves wholly
00:43:18.160 dependent, and that, of
00:43:20.420 course, means that our
00:43:21.160 threat of sanctions against
00:43:22.960 Putin are completely and
00:43:25.560 utterly hollow and
00:43:26.860 meaningless, because he can
00:43:28.520 hurt the West far more than
00:43:29.540 we can hurt him.
00:43:30.280 So let's talk about
00:43:32.100 geopolitics.
00:43:32.880 Now, look, I've just
00:43:33.480 written a book called An
00:43:34.260 Immigrant's Love Letter to the
00:43:35.340 West, and it's mainly about
00:43:36.500 why I think what we have is
00:43:38.000 actually pretty good, and we
00:43:38.940 should stop beating
00:43:39.440 ourselves up about it.
00:43:40.400 But part of my argument is
00:43:41.780 also is the more we focus
00:43:43.600 internally, the more time we
00:43:45.200 spend talking about, you
00:43:47.000 know, this comedian made this
00:43:48.300 joke, and now we're all very
00:43:49.440 upset for three days and
00:43:50.480 whatever, the more we take
00:43:52.180 eye off the ball, and that's
00:43:53.300 why China is expanding into
00:43:54.840 the South China Sea, it's
00:43:56.480 getting bullish on Taiwan, you
00:43:58.140 see what's happened in
00:43:58.980 Hong Kong, and Russia
00:44:00.300 likewise, you know.
00:44:02.240 Do you think the West
00:44:05.120 needs to rediscover its kind
00:44:07.080 of ability to project power
00:44:08.720 around the world?
00:44:09.300 Because you seem concerned
00:44:10.240 that NATO is expanding
00:44:11.240 eastwards and all of that.
00:44:12.020 Oh, look, look, I think
00:44:13.380 we've made some massive
00:44:14.380 geopolitical mistakes since
00:44:16.360 1990.
00:44:17.620 You know, the Berlin Wall
00:44:18.680 had come down, and we
00:44:20.500 decided that NATO and the
00:44:22.300 European Union would expand
00:44:24.020 ever eastwards.
00:44:25.620 You know, empires that are
00:44:26.820 struggling for a role,
00:44:28.140 continue expanding.
00:44:29.560 It's a good way to even go.
00:44:31.680 I know you just go into
00:44:32.740 answer, and I never
00:44:33.500 interrupt guests generally,
00:44:34.820 but let me just put a small
00:44:35.980 counter-argument.
00:44:36.940 The reason NATO is
00:44:37.720 expanding eastwards is
00:44:38.660 because Estonia, Lithuania,
00:44:40.640 Latvia, and Ukraine feel
00:44:42.100 terrified, rightly so, because
00:44:43.520 only 70 years ago the
00:44:44.660 Soviets invaded, massacred
00:44:45.860 their elites, took over their
00:44:47.200 country.
00:44:47.820 They don't want that to
00:44:48.500 happen again.
00:44:49.020 It's not some bureaucrat in
00:44:50.480 Brussels that's making that
00:44:51.540 happen.
00:44:52.060 It's those countries fearing for
00:44:53.580 their survival.
00:44:54.020 Just because they want to
00:44:55.300 join doesn't mean it's a
00:44:57.520 clever geopolitical move for
00:44:59.500 us to say yes to that.
00:45:00.180 I'm saying the motivation
00:45:01.060 for expansion is not...
00:45:02.180 Look, if I was Polish, I
00:45:05.560 would have wanted to join
00:45:06.500 NATO.
00:45:07.300 If I was Polish, I'd have
00:45:09.280 crossed my fingers and voted
00:45:11.080 to join the European Union,
00:45:12.400 probably.
00:45:13.120 I get that.
00:45:14.800 But let's just think, let's
00:45:16.060 just go back a bit further,
00:45:18.000 you know, go back over the
00:45:19.440 last couple of hundred years
00:45:20.440 of the, you know, formal
00:45:22.540 existence of nation states
00:45:25.220 around the world.
00:45:26.260 The concept of a buffer zone
00:45:28.040 is actually quite an
00:45:29.640 intelligent concept, okay?
00:45:33.900 In the case of NATO, this
00:45:36.620 ever eastwards expansion is,
00:45:40.260 has been a deliberately
00:45:41.840 provocative move against a
00:45:44.180 Russia which has always been
00:45:45.480 paranoid.
00:45:46.900 You know, the Cold War, Russia
00:45:48.880 was far more scared of us
00:45:50.220 than we were of Russia.
00:45:52.540 And sometimes, I mean, if
00:45:54.500 you want to resolve a
00:45:55.360 conflict, right, sometimes
00:45:57.300 what you have to do is to
00:45:59.080 put yourself in the mind of
00:45:59.980 the other person.
00:46:01.320 It's rather like solving that
00:46:02.140 crossword puzzle.
00:46:03.080 You've got to think, you
00:46:04.060 know, whoever wrote this,
00:46:05.080 what were they hinting at?
00:46:07.860 So we know Russia's
00:46:08.880 paranoid.
00:46:09.840 We know that the old
00:46:11.760 traditional, you know,
00:46:13.240 encirclement idea, invasion
00:46:15.120 idea of Russia is something
00:46:16.260 that motivates them very
00:46:17.180 deeply.
00:46:17.540 By the way, I don't doubt
00:46:19.060 for a moment that Putin does
00:46:20.800 have expansionist tendencies.
00:46:23.460 However, here we are as we
00:46:24.980 sit here today with 130,000
00:46:27.560 Russian troops massed on the
00:46:29.820 border.
00:46:31.000 He's making one key demand,
00:46:33.100 which is that we say that the
00:46:35.680 Ukraine will not join NATO,
00:46:37.280 okay?
00:46:38.320 We have Antony Blink in the
00:46:39.740 US Secretary of State, Boris
00:46:40.940 Johnson, some woman called
00:46:42.660 Liz Truss who's become
00:46:43.680 Foreign Secretary, God
00:46:44.860 knows how, but anyway, there we
00:46:46.100 are, and they're all saying,
00:46:48.120 no, no, no, no, no, no.
00:46:49.320 If the Ukraine wants to join
00:46:50.440 NATO, they can.
00:46:51.980 I suggest right now we say
00:46:53.600 Ukraine will not be joining
00:46:55.440 NATO.
00:46:56.460 We do understand the
00:46:58.440 concerns in Moscow about
00:47:00.580 Ever-Eastwood expansion.
00:47:02.100 It has come to an end, and we
00:47:03.740 now ask President Putin to
00:47:05.480 stand his troops down on that
00:47:07.240 border.
00:47:07.560 We remove from him his
00:47:11.260 causus belli.
00:47:12.280 We take away from him any
00:47:14.200 possible reason that he could
00:47:16.400 have to mount an invasion, and
00:47:19.520 we remember that by not doing
00:47:20.920 this earlier, we've driven
00:47:23.220 Putin into the arms of the
00:47:26.240 communist Chinese government.
00:47:28.380 How blooming stupid can we
00:47:30.760 possibly be?
00:47:31.440 There is no advantage or
00:47:34.900 interest to us in Ukraine
00:47:36.580 joining NATO.
00:47:38.060 If we make this concession at
00:47:40.240 this stage in the aim of
00:47:42.780 bringing peace, do you know
00:47:44.420 something?
00:47:45.100 It might just work.
00:47:46.620 Nigel, what would you say a few
00:47:49.880 years down the line when Russia
00:47:52.000 takes the rest of Ukraine, which
00:47:53.980 it will do?
00:47:54.620 Well, if you want us to go to the
00:47:55.960 Third World War, if you want them
00:47:57.760 to join NATO and send British
00:47:59.140 troops there, that's fine.
00:48:00.020 I mean, look, look, look, I
00:48:01.900 am not saying, absolutely, I
00:48:07.260 have a cast-iron guarantee that
00:48:10.120 I can stop the outbreak of war
00:48:12.520 in the Ukraine.
00:48:13.320 What I can say, I've got a much
00:48:14.740 brighter idea than anybody else
00:48:16.400 who was sticking to the same
00:48:17.740 formula they've had for 30
00:48:19.340 years, which I believe to be a
00:48:20.820 geopolitical mistake.
00:48:21.940 And one of the reasons I say
00:48:23.240 this is in 2014, we had the
00:48:25.380 Orange Revolution in Kiev.
00:48:28.120 Do you remember all the people in
00:48:29.200 the square who were part of that
00:48:31.340 coup that brought down a
00:48:33.540 democratically elected leader of
00:48:35.780 the Ukraine?
00:48:36.520 Yeah, that's where you're
00:48:37.460 starting to lose me.
00:48:37.940 Maybe a corrupt country.
00:48:39.080 Yeah.
00:48:40.420 He may have been a corrupt guy,
00:48:42.080 but he was a democratically
00:48:43.080 elected leader brought down by
00:48:44.960 people in the squares in Kiev
00:48:46.300 waving European Union flags
00:48:48.880 because the European Union had
00:48:51.120 pumped in pre-accession aid and
00:48:54.980 it was the stated aim that they
00:48:56.440 wanted Ukraine to join the European
00:48:58.320 Union.
00:48:59.120 Far from being an organisation that
00:49:00.680 guarantees peace in Europe, I
00:49:02.340 think where we are today was
00:49:03.440 provoked in large part actually by
00:49:06.000 Brussels and its expansionist
00:49:07.920 tendencies.
00:49:08.720 We've made some big mistakes here.
00:49:10.120 And I made those arguments back in
00:49:12.120 2014 to be condemned by everybody
00:49:16.420 that somehow I was Putin's puppet.
00:49:18.460 I'm not.
00:49:18.940 But I just think sometimes that
00:49:21.120 concept of buffer states is
00:49:23.940 actually a brighter thing to do
00:49:25.500 than a line that we've been
00:49:27.240 pursuing.
00:49:27.660 Here's where I think there's a
00:49:28.440 flaw in your argument, with all
00:49:30.160 possible respect, of course.
00:49:31.160 I'm sure there is one.
00:49:33.760 I think the flaw in your argument
00:49:35.260 is if what we need is a buffer
00:49:37.160 zone, and if Russia is so
00:49:39.560 desperate to have a buffer between
00:49:40.960 itself and NATO, why is Russia
00:49:42.280 expanding westwards?
00:49:43.240 Because he sees an historic coming
00:49:48.420 together of the Russian peoples and
00:49:49.860 all the rest of it.
00:49:50.520 And we have to make it clear to
00:49:52.000 him.
00:49:52.380 There's some historical parallels
00:49:54.020 there.
00:49:54.460 Well, let's take away from him any
00:49:56.120 possible excuse he can have, any
00:49:57.840 validation he can have.
00:49:59.420 Firstly, with his own population,
00:50:01.840 you know, and secondly, with all the
00:50:03.740 rest of us.
00:50:04.840 I think it's the right thing.
00:50:06.180 So what would you like to do?
00:50:08.420 So Ukraine joins NATO.
00:50:09.680 That's your wish list.
00:50:11.120 No, I'm not necessarily saying
00:50:13.240 suggesting that Ukraine should
00:50:14.460 join NATO.
00:50:15.580 I think what I see in the broader
00:50:18.120 geopolitical, that's why I brought
00:50:19.240 China into this.
00:50:20.300 The West is weak, and it's showing
00:50:22.200 weakness.
00:50:22.780 Well, we saw that in Kabul last
00:50:24.320 year, didn't we?
00:50:24.840 Right.
00:50:26.120 And the people who, and you'll
00:50:27.660 understand this because you
00:50:28.660 understand how the real world
00:50:29.660 works.
00:50:29.940 You know, in the West we talk
00:50:31.100 about, you know, equality and
00:50:32.620 diversity and political, whatever.
00:50:35.500 In the real world, people don't
00:50:36.900 operate on that basis.
00:50:37.820 They operate on land, money,
00:50:40.640 finance, weapons, technology,
00:50:43.480 spy, espionage, right?
00:50:44.700 Oil, water, all these things.
00:50:46.960 Coinness.
00:50:48.000 Yeah, exactly.
00:50:49.240 Yeah.
00:50:49.540 Human rights.
00:50:50.740 So what this looks like from the
00:50:53.360 outside to me, as I look at it from
00:50:55.540 a non-Western perspective, is the
00:50:57.600 West is distracted, the West is
00:50:59.700 weak, and all the things that we
00:51:02.060 would always would have quite liked
00:51:03.220 to have done, right?
00:51:04.340 If we, you know, if you're China,
00:51:05.680 well, yeah, you want to expand this
00:51:07.000 way and you want to take over Hong
00:51:08.120 Kong and you want to do this.
00:51:09.320 So from my perspective, it
00:51:11.400 depends on what people in the
00:51:12.460 West want.
00:51:12.960 If you want the managed decline of
00:51:14.940 the West, this is what you're
00:51:16.120 going to get.
00:51:16.420 I have a feeling if Donald Trump
00:51:17.800 was in the White House, we
00:51:18.800 wouldn't see a little rocket man
00:51:19.900 firing off all these rockets.
00:51:21.460 I don't think China would be
00:51:22.500 quite as bellicose about Taiwan as
00:51:24.580 they are.
00:51:24.720 But that's my point.
00:51:25.480 And I, no, no.
00:51:26.180 I mean, look, you know, Biden
00:51:27.760 has been a catastrophe.
00:51:30.720 The unilateral withdrawal from
00:51:32.360 Afghanistan was a complete
00:51:33.740 disaster.
00:51:34.860 Right.
00:51:35.040 And far from America is back,
00:51:37.880 they've actually retreated away.
00:51:39.500 Clearly.
00:51:40.020 And the West is now without
00:51:41.360 leadership.
00:51:41.920 But that's my point, Nigel.
00:51:43.160 By advocating for the position
00:51:44.960 you're advocating for, that's
00:51:46.980 part of the same sort of, well,
00:51:48.540 we just need to, you know, appease
00:51:50.180 these people.
00:51:50.920 And instead of the West coming
00:51:52.160 out and going, look, we are the
00:51:54.220 world superpower.
00:51:55.640 We are.
00:51:56.060 We're not embarrassed about our
00:51:57.540 values.
00:51:57.960 Our values are better than yours.
00:51:59.520 Right.
00:51:59.940 Freedom, democracy.
00:52:00.880 These are all good things.
00:52:01.940 And we are going to spread them
00:52:03.600 around the world because this is
00:52:04.720 who we are.
00:52:05.380 And we are the strongest thing.
00:52:07.180 If you think China and Russia,
00:52:09.040 if they were the dominant
00:52:09.940 hegemony in the world, they
00:52:11.180 wouldn't do that.
00:52:12.060 You're insane.
00:52:12.760 No, I know.
00:52:13.480 I just see that being seen to
00:52:16.660 make something of a concession
00:52:17.800 right now, gaining the moral
00:52:20.960 upper ground in this whole
00:52:23.480 diplomatic standoff that is
00:52:25.260 currently going on over the
00:52:27.000 Ukraine, when, as I say, it's
00:52:28.340 not in our interest for them to
00:52:30.840 join anyway.
00:52:31.680 If he still goes to war, he
00:52:33.260 still goes to war.
00:52:34.720 We'd then be much more united
00:52:35.960 against him because we would
00:52:37.360 have been seen to have done the
00:52:38.440 right thing.
00:52:39.180 As it is, we're carrying on with
00:52:40.940 a policy that's a mistake.
00:52:43.460 Nigel, and we touched on
00:52:45.380 Biden.
00:52:46.240 We touched on Trump.
00:52:47.140 So let's just move and turn our
00:52:48.820 eye to the United States.
00:52:50.860 Why do you think Biden has been a
00:52:53.060 disaster, number one?
00:52:54.900 And number two, do you think we're
00:52:56.700 going to see a comeback for Trump?
00:52:58.480 So Biden wasn't fit to do the job
00:53:00.580 anyway.
00:53:01.140 And the Democrats are in a real
00:53:03.220 mess as a party.
00:53:04.160 Why do you say that?
00:53:05.060 Because this is somebody who's had
00:53:06.240 a very long, very distinguished
00:53:07.360 political career.
00:53:08.020 No, he's had a very long career.
00:53:10.500 He's not had a distinguished
00:53:11.960 career.
00:53:12.980 I mean, nobody in Washington would
00:53:14.540 tell you that for a moment.
00:53:18.780 I'm not going to rehash November
00:53:21.000 the 3rd, 2020.
00:53:22.500 I'm not going to rehash 100 million
00:53:23.880 postal votes.
00:53:25.260 The fact that the scandals involving
00:53:27.140 his son.
00:53:28.600 I love how he's not rehashing it.
00:53:29.980 The money.
00:53:30.840 I'm not going to go there.
00:53:33.100 Shut up, you.
00:53:36.940 He's not mentally fit for the job.
00:53:40.200 But the Democrats have a huge
00:53:41.520 problem because they've got the new
00:53:42.760 left.
00:53:43.280 They've got their own
00:53:43.920 Corbynistas.
00:53:44.860 It's very, very difficult for them
00:53:46.260 to be an effective political party.
00:53:48.500 So not up to the job.
00:53:50.760 No clear, coherent policy
00:53:54.000 positions on anything.
00:53:56.140 I mean, literally on anything.
00:53:58.560 And you've seen America's reputation
00:54:00.720 on the world stage collapse
00:54:03.600 since Afghanistan.
00:54:05.060 And we've just discussed some of the
00:54:06.500 knock-on effects from that.
00:54:08.460 And internally, well, you've seen
00:54:12.280 a Democrat party under Biden
00:54:15.820 effectively take the knee
00:54:17.800 to a dangerous
00:54:20.720 Marxist organization
00:54:22.980 intent on destroying
00:54:24.980 Western democracy
00:54:27.060 and replacing it with something else.
00:54:29.640 And that's called BLM.
00:54:31.180 Black Lives Matter.
00:54:32.200 And we're all supposed to say,
00:54:33.020 oh, what a love.
00:54:33.740 I mean, you know, a really,
00:54:34.900 really, really bad organization
00:54:37.400 with massive spikes in lawlessness
00:54:40.300 in American cities.
00:54:41.800 I mean, the likes of which
00:54:42.460 we simply can't believe.
00:54:44.700 How can New York
00:54:46.040 be going back to the bad old days
00:54:47.880 of when I first went there
00:54:48.920 back in the 80s?
00:54:50.480 And go out west.
00:54:52.320 Go out west and see
00:54:53.660 what's happening
00:54:54.240 in many of those cities.
00:54:55.220 I mean, you simply can't believe it.
00:54:57.080 So at every level,
00:54:58.920 a Democrat party that is there
00:55:00.920 because it's not Donald Trump,
00:55:02.960 a Democrat party that stands
00:55:04.200 for almost nothing,
00:55:05.760 and a Democrat party
00:55:06.840 that's in big trouble.
00:55:09.180 Cross to be Republicans.
00:55:12.460 I mean, Donald Trump's grip
00:55:14.440 on the Republican party
00:55:17.160 is very, very strong, indeed.
00:55:20.160 The country club Republicans
00:55:22.060 have been pretty marginalized.
00:55:24.480 You know, the Mitt Romneys,
00:55:26.020 the Mitch McConnells,
00:55:27.800 the sort of Rishi Sunaks,
00:55:29.880 if you like,
00:55:30.460 of the Republican party
00:55:32.840 have been marginalized
00:55:33.540 and Trump's in control.
00:55:36.400 He's 75,
00:55:38.060 but he's lost about 20 pounds
00:55:40.420 since the last election.
00:55:41.840 He's playing golf
00:55:42.380 pretty much every day.
00:55:43.820 I've seen him a couple of times
00:55:45.140 in the last year.
00:55:46.340 He's in pretty good form.
00:55:48.060 Physically,
00:55:48.600 in pretty good form.
00:55:50.000 Clearly, DeSantis,
00:55:51.520 who has done all the things
00:55:53.280 that you would approve of
00:55:54.060 in Florida
00:55:54.540 in terms of not allowing
00:55:55.960 the state
00:55:56.480 to take over too much.
00:55:59.100 Clearly, DeSantis
00:56:00.060 is the up-and-coming guy.
00:56:02.480 If Trump wants the nomination,
00:56:04.080 it's his.
00:56:05.460 Okay?
00:56:06.040 It's as simple as that.
00:56:07.640 We're still some way off that.
00:56:10.080 All I would say is this.
00:56:12.220 My concern,
00:56:16.880 having been at Mar-a-Lago
00:56:17.980 at the end of November,
00:56:20.460 is that the people around Trump
00:56:22.980 are looking back too much
00:56:26.420 at November the 3rd,
00:56:29.180 are talking constantly
00:56:30.740 about the stolen election,
00:56:32.560 keep talking about the events
00:56:34.800 of the 6th of January.
00:56:38.280 And it's really interesting.
00:56:40.300 How do you win elections?
00:56:41.860 How do you win referendums?
00:56:43.320 Is it through negative messaging?
00:56:45.620 Or is it through positive messaging?
00:56:48.600 And there's a time
00:56:49.160 and a place for both.
00:56:51.100 But generally,
00:56:52.880 I think to win elections,
00:56:54.520 you've got to have
00:56:55.340 a positive message.
00:56:56.740 You have to see that
00:56:57.500 Churchill vision
00:56:58.280 of the suddenly uplands
00:57:00.040 and that we're heading off
00:57:01.900 to a better place.
00:57:03.700 So I think the Trump team
00:57:04.640 need to get out
00:57:05.500 of this current gear.
00:57:06.700 If they leave themselves stuck
00:57:08.360 in this looking back
00:57:10.240 full of regret,
00:57:12.000 as opposed to,
00:57:13.300 we're going to make sure
00:57:13.920 America has the best,
00:57:15.640 most valid electoral system
00:57:17.640 in the Western world,
00:57:18.760 which is the way
00:57:19.340 of turning a negative
00:57:20.120 into a positive.
00:57:22.160 So that's my reservation.
00:57:23.800 Right now,
00:57:24.800 in his head,
00:57:25.560 he's running.
00:57:26.000 Broadway's smash hit,
00:57:29.340 The Neil Diamond Musical,
00:57:30.740 A Beautiful Noise,
00:57:32.160 is coming to Toronto.
00:57:33.620 The true story
00:57:34.380 of a kid from Brooklyn
00:57:35.440 destined for something more,
00:57:37.140 featuring all the songs
00:57:38.120 you love,
00:57:38.880 including America,
00:57:40.160 Forever in Blue Jeans,
00:57:41.340 and Sweet Caroline.
00:57:42.880 Like Jersey Boys
00:57:43.840 and Beautiful,
00:57:44.680 the next musical
00:57:45.640 mega hit is here,
00:57:46.960 The Neil Diamond Musical,
00:57:48.520 A Beautiful Noise,
00:57:49.700 now through June 7th,
00:57:50.960 2026,
00:57:51.740 at the Princess of Wales Theatre.
00:57:53.620 Do you not worry,
00:57:58.700 Nigel,
00:57:59.220 that,
00:58:00.200 because I'm not a fan
00:58:01.200 of the Democrats,
00:58:02.060 I'm certainly not a fan
00:58:03.240 of BLM,
00:58:04.320 but I look at Trump
00:58:05.800 and I think that he's
00:58:07.400 too divisive a figure
00:58:09.160 to be a truly unifying force
00:58:11.280 for America,
00:58:11.920 which is what it needs
00:58:12.940 right now.
00:58:14.820 Well,
00:58:15.020 Biden's not unified them either.
00:58:18.020 And these divisions
00:58:20.780 that we've talked about
00:58:21.540 in this chat,
00:58:22.680 this values-based,
00:58:25.080 this values-based,
00:58:27.580 we are morally superior
00:58:28.920 to yours,
00:58:29.760 none of this
00:58:30.280 is going to be solved easily.
00:58:32.060 None of this
00:58:32.420 is going to be solved quickly.
00:58:34.020 And as the universities,
00:58:36.080 which have become
00:58:36.520 the sort of madrassas
00:58:38.080 for Marxism,
00:58:39.400 churn out thousands,
00:58:40.640 tens of thousands,
00:58:41.400 hundreds of thousands
00:58:42.060 of more young people
00:58:43.240 every year
00:58:43.800 with that mindset,
00:58:45.200 none of this
00:58:45.600 is going away in a hurry.
00:58:46.680 I do get the fact
00:58:47.860 that Trump can be
00:58:48.560 very divisive.
00:58:49.260 I do get the fact
00:58:50.160 that Trump is a,
00:58:51.480 you know,
00:58:51.760 a real fighting
00:58:52.700 puncher.
00:58:55.320 And as with all
00:58:56.340 political leaders,
00:58:57.180 as with all human beings,
00:58:58.920 you know,
00:58:59.140 you've got to see
00:58:59.520 the good side
00:59:00.720 and the less good side.
00:59:02.180 And the less good side
00:59:03.360 is perhaps that aggression.
00:59:05.400 You know,
00:59:05.720 I'd like to see him
00:59:06.660 more in public
00:59:07.320 as he is in private.
00:59:08.220 I'd like to see
00:59:09.600 more of that sort
00:59:10.160 of lighter,
00:59:10.980 more humorous side.
00:59:12.260 Yet we never,
00:59:12.860 ever do.
00:59:13.820 But I do think
00:59:15.520 Trump's period
00:59:17.440 in office,
00:59:19.320 I think his foreign policy
00:59:20.560 was far better
00:59:22.120 than anything
00:59:22.620 we've seen
00:59:23.080 from American presidents
00:59:24.060 for a very,
00:59:24.700 very long time.
00:59:26.720 I saw the other week
00:59:28.020 the head of Saudi Arabia
00:59:31.240 and Israel
00:59:31.720 meet together in Riyadh.
00:59:33.580 There was the Israeli flag,
00:59:35.120 the Israeli national anthem.
00:59:36.140 I mean, unthinkable.
00:59:39.440 And that was a direct result
00:59:40.860 of the Abraham Accords.
00:59:43.820 Had that been done
00:59:44.720 by Obama
00:59:45.420 or anybody else,
00:59:47.440 they'd have been up
00:59:47.820 for a Nobel Peace Prize.
00:59:49.360 Because it's Trump,
00:59:50.340 it's been ignored.
00:59:51.560 You know,
00:59:51.740 when Trump called out
00:59:52.780 the virus
00:59:53.740 as having leaked
00:59:54.660 from the Wuhan lab,
00:59:55.840 the whole world ignored it
00:59:56.900 because he'd said it.
00:59:58.200 So yeah,
00:59:59.020 he is provocative.
01:00:00.580 He can be very divisive.
01:00:01.780 I get all of that.
01:00:03.420 But I think his instincts
01:00:04.440 on the really big,
01:00:05.580 important thing
01:00:06.120 is that face the world
01:00:06.860 right now
01:00:07.280 are the right ones.
01:00:08.280 Nigel,
01:00:08.560 if you get a call
01:00:09.280 in the middle of the night
01:00:10.200 and Donald Trump
01:00:10.960 is having a bit
01:00:11.520 of a crisis of confidence
01:00:12.660 about whether he should run
01:00:13.980 or maybe hand it off
01:00:14.980 to like a DeSantis
01:00:15.940 or someone,
01:00:17.480 Dan Crenshaw,
01:00:18.380 there's really strong candidates
01:00:20.120 actually,
01:00:20.600 in my opinion,
01:00:21.140 on the Republican side.
01:00:22.940 What would you say to him?
01:00:26.200 I...
01:00:26.560 Do you anoint a successor?
01:00:28.340 I may have had
01:00:28.980 that conversation
01:00:29.580 with him already,
01:00:30.080 but I can't remember.
01:00:32.780 What might you have said
01:00:34.200 had you had it?
01:00:34.660 What might I say?
01:00:35.460 You see,
01:00:37.940 I have met DeSantis
01:00:38.880 and he's really impressive.
01:00:41.800 And I think the job
01:00:42.760 he's done in Florida
01:00:43.420 is phenomenal.
01:00:44.860 Agreed.
01:00:45.440 Because last May,
01:00:46.620 I was in Florida
01:00:47.620 and I was in California.
01:00:49.740 So I saw two countries,
01:00:51.780 both big populations,
01:00:53.280 similar climates,
01:00:54.380 different approaches
01:00:55.100 and very different outcomes,
01:00:57.580 you know,
01:00:57.780 economically,
01:00:59.120 socially
01:00:59.420 and everything else.
01:01:00.240 to win the American election,
01:01:04.580 you've got to win
01:01:06.580 every state
01:01:08.520 from the Atlantic coast
01:01:10.740 of Pennsylvania
01:01:11.860 through the Great Lakes
01:01:14.280 to Wisconsin.
01:01:15.720 They're the states that matter.
01:01:18.300 They're the states that determine
01:01:19.280 who wins and loses
01:01:20.140 the American presidential election.
01:01:22.700 And they're the states
01:01:24.220 where you've got
01:01:25.280 the mining areas.
01:01:27.380 They're the states
01:01:28.640 where you've got
01:01:29.060 the heavy manufacturing areas.
01:01:31.800 They're the states
01:01:32.520 with their bits of rust belt
01:01:34.220 and some bits of renewal.
01:01:37.060 And they're states
01:01:40.360 with a huge number
01:01:41.220 of Democrat voters in them.
01:01:43.420 But what's interesting
01:01:44.000 in the polling
01:01:44.540 is that roughly 50%
01:01:46.540 of Democrats
01:01:47.300 do not like
01:01:48.560 the leftward social drift,
01:01:50.980 do not like the AOC stuff,
01:01:52.880 are very uncomfortable
01:01:53.900 with some of the new
01:01:55.180 trans gender stuff
01:01:57.080 that's being endlessly
01:01:57.880 talked about,
01:01:59.240 hate the fact
01:02:00.500 that there are Democrats
01:02:03.940 condemning American history,
01:02:06.060 tearing down statues
01:02:07.560 of the founding fathers,
01:02:09.240 telling them they should
01:02:09.880 be ashamed to be American.
01:02:11.080 They're proud to be American.
01:02:13.220 They're proud of what
01:02:14.060 their grandma and granddad
01:02:15.500 did in World War II.
01:02:16.780 They're proud.
01:02:18.020 At whatever stage
01:02:18.780 their country have come
01:02:19.720 and adopted it,
01:02:21.160 you know,
01:02:21.420 they're proud of being part of it.
01:02:23.980 And so it's how do you get
01:02:25.820 a larger number
01:02:27.900 of that group of people
01:02:29.560 to sort of cross,
01:02:31.260 rather like the Red Wall,
01:02:32.620 to cross over
01:02:33.540 and vote Republican.
01:02:35.560 And who is the most
01:02:36.280 likely person
01:02:37.320 to appeal to those people?
01:02:39.380 I still believe
01:02:39.960 it's Donald Trump.
01:02:41.420 I may say different
01:02:42.800 to you in two years' time.
01:02:44.080 I may say different
01:02:44.820 to you,
01:02:45.520 you know,
01:02:45.760 as things really
01:02:47.060 start to get ready.
01:02:48.860 And I guess really
01:02:50.000 it's going to be,
01:02:50.840 it'll be this time
01:02:51.340 next year,
01:02:51.740 won't it?
01:02:52.120 It'll be one year's time.
01:02:53.340 It'll be early 23
01:02:54.160 when the big decisions
01:02:55.440 about who's going to run,
01:02:57.480 who's going to put
01:02:57.920 themselves forward,
01:02:58.580 get made.
01:02:59.160 And why do you say that,
01:03:00.120 Nigel?
01:03:00.260 Why is he more able
01:03:01.860 to win those people over?
01:03:02.980 He's got the common touch.
01:03:04.740 He's got the common touch.
01:03:06.160 You know,
01:03:06.300 he speaks a language
01:03:08.020 they understand.
01:03:09.840 They feel a certain
01:03:10.560 familiarity with him.
01:03:12.300 I've watched him
01:03:13.040 at these rallies.
01:03:15.480 You know,
01:03:15.620 you guys see the bit
01:03:16.480 in front of the camera.
01:03:17.260 I've watched him
01:03:17.920 with the crowds.
01:03:18.660 I've watched him
01:03:19.160 walk through the crowds.
01:03:20.300 I've watched him
01:03:20.840 interact with people.
01:03:22.660 They love him.
01:03:23.340 There's a certain
01:03:25.640 humanity about him.
01:03:26.740 There's something
01:03:26.920 real about him.
01:03:28.680 But also,
01:03:29.480 he's been part of their
01:03:30.520 lives for decades.
01:03:32.860 You know,
01:03:33.380 big TV star.
01:03:35.240 I mean,
01:03:35.920 been in the news
01:03:37.000 for decades
01:03:37.680 with New York
01:03:38.600 and the real estate
01:03:40.020 successes and failures.
01:03:41.900 They feel they know
01:03:43.120 the guy.
01:03:45.160 Now,
01:03:45.360 DeSantis,
01:03:46.400 who's incredibly
01:03:47.100 bright and impressive,
01:03:48.820 you know,
01:03:49.120 can DeSantis
01:03:49.840 reach those people,
01:03:51.580 reach that community,
01:03:52.620 or is he just
01:03:53.380 a rich guy
01:03:53.840 from Florida?
01:03:55.900 Do you see
01:03:56.200 what I mean?
01:03:56.700 Yeah.
01:03:57.960 Trump is like
01:03:58.720 a blue-collar
01:03:59.300 billionaire.
01:04:00.240 You know,
01:04:00.840 it's fascinating
01:04:02.160 to watch it.
01:04:03.300 In a year's time,
01:04:04.740 ask me again,
01:04:05.720 I might have
01:04:06.160 changed my mind.
01:04:06.940 But at the moment,
01:04:07.560 that's what I believe.
01:04:08.660 Do you think
01:04:09.360 the events
01:04:10.060 of January the 6th,
01:04:11.980 you look back at it,
01:04:14.220 do you not think
01:04:15.160 that heavily
01:04:16.520 tarnished his reputation?
01:04:18.080 That was awful.
01:04:19.620 It was absolutely
01:04:20.560 dire.
01:04:21.200 that I'm so,
01:04:23.120 so pleased
01:04:23.820 I wasn't there.
01:04:25.700 No,
01:04:26.200 I really am.
01:04:27.180 And I...
01:04:28.240 That would make
01:04:28.940 a great photo
01:04:29.860 in the head
01:04:30.160 of just you
01:04:30.620 smashing through
01:04:31.620 the gates
01:04:32.120 of the capital.
01:04:33.620 With a bare-skin hat on.
01:04:35.620 And the horns,
01:04:36.740 that would be great.
01:04:38.160 With your top off,
01:04:39.040 that would be quite a look.
01:04:39.860 I wouldn't do that
01:04:40.020 in private.
01:04:40.760 No,
01:04:41.100 I thought the whole
01:04:44.060 thing was a mistake.
01:04:45.680 I thought the whole
01:04:46.660 thing was a mistake.
01:04:47.460 I didn't
01:04:49.500 obviously anticipate
01:04:50.560 exactly what would
01:04:51.440 happen.
01:04:53.080 Was it a full-scale
01:04:54.160 coup attempt?
01:04:54.820 No,
01:04:55.000 of course it wasn't.
01:04:55.540 No,
01:04:55.720 it wasn't.
01:04:56.120 I mean,
01:04:56.280 that's just nonsense.
01:04:56.920 But this isn't about
01:04:57.660 all of us have to condemn it.
01:04:59.300 But look,
01:04:59.400 it was terrible.
01:05:01.860 Yeah,
01:05:02.640 yeah.
01:05:03.200 Just a mistake
01:05:04.240 from start to finish.
01:05:05.560 A mistake from start to finish.
01:05:06.980 And of course,
01:05:07.840 the Democrats
01:05:08.360 are going to go through
01:05:09.080 a whole series
01:05:09.800 of show trials
01:05:11.680 as we go on
01:05:13.240 from here
01:05:13.720 to try and prove
01:05:14.880 that it was a coup attempt.
01:05:15.960 They won't succeed.
01:05:17.480 Yeah,
01:05:17.900 it was a mistake.
01:05:19.120 And I,
01:05:21.760 I mean,
01:05:22.380 look,
01:05:23.680 it's the same
01:05:24.060 with Boris's dilemma
01:05:24.880 at the moment,
01:05:25.460 isn't it?
01:05:26.840 You know,
01:05:27.740 is Carrie
01:05:28.300 over-influential
01:05:29.320 on Boris?
01:05:30.720 Has she led him
01:05:31.400 in the wrong direction?
01:05:32.340 Yes.
01:05:33.480 But ultimately,
01:05:34.360 Boris is the boss.
01:05:35.800 It's a bit the same
01:05:36.380 with Trump.
01:05:37.400 I do feel
01:05:38.160 that some of the influences
01:05:39.900 that have been around him
01:05:42.380 in the White House
01:05:44.500 perhaps weren't
01:05:45.760 all to the good.
01:05:47.280 But I was pretty certain
01:05:48.180 many of them
01:05:48.840 weren't all to the good.
01:05:50.180 But ultimately,
01:05:50.980 he's the boss.
01:05:52.080 He takes the responsibility.
01:05:53.540 So yeah,
01:05:54.200 January the 6th,
01:05:55.220 not pretty.
01:05:56.660 But don't you think
01:05:57.820 that if he goes
01:05:58.720 for election again,
01:06:00.660 that people,
01:06:01.440 it's an easy thing
01:06:02.940 to pin on him.
01:06:04.320 You know,
01:06:04.900 if you're a Democrat,
01:06:06.080 I mean,
01:06:06.360 that's an easy hit.
01:06:07.660 Yes.
01:06:08.040 Look,
01:06:08.400 there's no doubt about it.
01:06:10.000 There are no votes
01:06:11.200 to be gained
01:06:11.700 on January the 6th.
01:06:12.660 You know?
01:06:14.140 No,
01:06:14.640 yeah,
01:06:15.120 it is one of those things
01:06:16.400 that detracts,
01:06:17.860 of course.
01:06:19.020 Nigel,
01:06:19.400 it's been really great
01:06:20.300 to have you back on the show.
01:06:21.660 Always entertaining,
01:06:22.640 always a pleasure
01:06:23.160 and some very interesting insights.
01:06:24.920 And by the way,
01:06:25.980 one of the things
01:06:26.420 we talked about
01:06:27.100 before we started
01:06:27.940 is how rare it is
01:06:29.140 for people
01:06:29.500 with different political views,
01:06:30.880 people who disagree strongly
01:06:31.940 about things,
01:06:32.540 to be able to just have
01:06:33.380 a normal conversation.
01:06:34.600 So,
01:06:35.080 refreshing too.
01:06:36.300 Good.
01:06:36.500 Well,
01:06:36.660 thank you.
01:06:37.080 And I have to say,
01:06:38.400 that's what we have
01:06:38.920 to get back to.
01:06:40.240 We have to get back to
01:06:41.420 passionate,
01:06:43.020 but civilised discourse
01:06:45.080 and respecting the fact
01:06:46.660 that different people
01:06:47.160 have different opinions.
01:06:48.360 And with that,
01:06:49.060 we have got one final question
01:06:50.280 for you,
01:06:50.700 which is,
01:06:51.060 of course,
01:06:51.400 as always,
01:06:51.960 what is the one thing
01:06:52.960 that we're not talking about
01:06:54.260 that we really should be?
01:06:55.640 The class divide.
01:06:57.080 Never gets discussed.
01:06:58.960 You know,
01:06:59.200 we talk about divisions
01:06:59.980 in society.
01:07:01.420 We talk about,
01:07:02.540 you know,
01:07:03.440 ethnicity constantly.
01:07:05.400 are we being fair
01:07:06.620 to this group of people
01:07:07.940 or that group of people?
01:07:10.420 Far too little discussion
01:07:12.020 on social mobility.
01:07:15.080 And actually,
01:07:16.500 what I see
01:07:17.900 is the more governments
01:07:19.440 tax and redistribute,
01:07:21.300 the lower levels
01:07:22.920 of social mobility are.
01:07:24.820 For social mobility,
01:07:25.920 people need opportunity.
01:07:27.400 They need that
01:07:27.980 through education,
01:07:28.640 which I mentioned earlier,
01:07:29.680 I think is one of the
01:07:30.580 great challenges
01:07:31.420 ahead of us.
01:07:33.440 They need it
01:07:33.980 in the workplace.
01:07:35.720 Working from home
01:07:36.560 is not good
01:07:37.060 for young people
01:07:38.280 to get on.
01:07:40.780 And so,
01:07:41.140 yeah,
01:07:41.380 I do think,
01:07:42.200 I do think that
01:07:43.360 it's good to see,
01:07:44.760 actually,
01:07:45.040 some 2019
01:07:45.700 Red Bull Tory MPs
01:07:47.120 who come from
01:07:47.900 working class backgrounds.
01:07:49.540 But I do think
01:07:50.260 the class divide
01:07:50.880 in this country
01:07:51.480 is set in stone
01:07:52.460 far more than it ever was.
01:07:54.780 The opportunities
01:07:55.500 to break out of it
01:07:56.400 aren't there.
01:07:57.560 You know,
01:07:57.840 world wars,
01:07:58.820 ironically,
01:08:00.480 gave people
01:08:01.180 from humble backgrounds
01:08:02.340 a chance
01:08:02.940 to move up
01:08:03.980 through the ladder.
01:08:04.780 Grammar schools,
01:08:06.000 for example,
01:08:06.900 gave a lot of people
01:08:07.560 from those backgrounds
01:08:08.480 the chance to excel
01:08:09.720 and go up the ladder.
01:08:11.300 And I do ever so slightly feel
01:08:12.880 that middle class Britain
01:08:14.380 has pulled the drawbridge up.
01:08:16.680 Well,
01:08:17.320 we're going to ask you
01:08:17.860 a couple of questions
01:08:18.640 from our supporters
01:08:19.580 in a second,
01:08:20.220 but thank you so much
01:08:21.060 for coming back on the show.
01:08:22.380 And thank you for watching
01:08:23.300 and listening.
01:08:23.880 We'll see you very soon
01:08:24.660 with another brilliant episode
01:08:25.840 like this one
01:08:26.460 or our show.
01:08:27.520 All of them go out
01:08:28.260 at 7pm UK time.
01:08:29.760 And for those of you
01:08:30.400 who like your trigonometry
01:08:31.320 on the go,
01:08:32.000 it's also available
01:08:32.760 as a podcast.
01:08:33.920 Take care
01:08:34.480 and see you soon,
01:08:35.340 guys.
01:08:37.480 On the really big,
01:08:38.580 broad historical context,
01:08:40.440 yeah,
01:08:40.960 we're witnessing
01:08:41.380 the end of Empire,
01:08:42.280 aren't we?
01:08:42.540 We'll see you once more If you5000 is on the right.
01:08:52.560 So then,
01:08:52.920 I'm sorry about it.
01:08:53.740 I'm sorry about that companies
01:08:54.960 and I'll see you soon as they're not.
01:08:56.040 I know.
01:08:56.400 I'm sorry about it,
01:08:57.060 but I'm sorry about that business.
01:08:57.980 But weicki from 이제
01:08:58.540 and on the left of this top
01:08:58.980 and we I'm not.
01:08:59.500 We'll see you again.
01:09:00.480 We'll see you soon as you're doing
01:09:01.320 some opening this stuff,
01:09:02.660 and we'll see you soon.
01:09:03.580 Sweet dreams.
01:09:04.700 I'll see you soon.
01:09:05.380 Yeah,
01:09:05.940 m Wy têm that blowing
01:09:06.680 and I'll see you soon,
01:09:07.460 and we're so excited
01:09:08.240 and we'll see you soon.
01:09:08.780 Sure.
01:09:09.380 See you soon.
01:09:09.800 Ready for yourself.
01:09:10.660 It's good.