TRIGGERnometry - July 01, 2026


The 100 Years' War with Historian Dan Jones

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
DEBATE: Has Trump Surrendered To Iran? - Melanie Phillips What the AirCon Debate Says About Britain's Climate Insanity - Konstantin Kisin

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 18 minutes

Words per minute

159.73

Word count

12,571

Sentence count

623

Harmful content

Misogyny

15

sentences flagged

Toxicity

22

sentences flagged

Hate speech

40

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the first episode of The Hundred Years War, we take a deep dive into the history of the English-French conflict, and look at why we hate the French. We're joined by historian Dan Jones to talk about Joan of Arc and her role in the conflict.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I have people in my life who depend on me.
00:00:02 Most of you listening do too.
00:00:04 And if you're honest with yourself,
00:00:05 you've probably had that moment where you think,
00:00:08 what happens to them if I'm not around tomorrow?
00:00:10 It's not a fun question,
00:00:12 but ignoring it does not make it go away.
00:00:14 This is why I think today's sponsor
00:00:16 is worth paying attention to.
00:00:17 Through Ethos, you apply in minutes,
00:00:20 receive a quote instantly,
00:00:21 and get same-day coverage.
00:00:23 No medical exam,
00:00:24 you just answer a few simple health questions.
00:00:26 The whole process is 100% online
00:00:28 and you can get up to $3 million in coverage
00:00:30 with some policies starting as low as $30 a month.
00:00:34 Ethos has 4.8 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot
00:00:37 with over 4,000 reviews.
00:00:38 Take 10 minutes to get covered today
00:00:40 with life insurance through Ethos.
00:00:42 Get your free quote at ethos.com slash trigger.
00:00:46 That's E-T-H-O-S dot com slash trigger.
00:00:50 Application times may vary.
00:00:51 Rates may vary too.
00:00:55 The Hundred Years War, is that why we hate the French?
00:00:59 The Hundred Years' War is a shaking out of what these realms are going to be.
00:01:07 In 1328, when there was a succession crisis in the French crown,
00:01:12 the young king of England, Edward III, got into his head that one way around this
00:01:19 might be to claim to be the king of France himself.
00:01:24 That's the fundamental deep-down reason English kings are saying,
00:01:28 we should be kings of promise. 0.95
00:01:30 So, Dan, as you know, we're massive feminists on the show, 0.99
00:01:32 and so is all of our audience. 1.00
00:01:34 Yes, yes.
00:01:34 And it strikes me that we haven't addressed
00:01:36 the central figure in this whole story,
00:01:38 which is, of course, Joan of Arc.
00:01:42 Dan Jones, welcome back.
00:01:43 Thank you for having me.
00:01:44 It's great to have you on.
00:01:45 We're going to talk about the Hundred Year War.
00:01:47 It's going to be a great conversation.
00:01:49 And I was just saying to you before we started,
00:01:51 the last one we did about the Crusades
00:01:52 is absolutely smashed.
00:01:53 It was really, really fun,
00:01:56 and our audience enjoyed it.
00:01:57 So it's wonderful to have you back.
00:01:58 Thanks for coming. 0.93
00:02:00 The Hundred Years' War, is that why we hate the French?
00:02:04 Well, I suppose it's one of the ways that the relations between England and France are shaped.
00:02:11 I mean, if you think about any sporting occasion, I mean, we're recording this before the World Cup.
00:02:16 I don't know if England will play France in the World Cup or not.
00:02:19 But I guarantee that if they were to play France in the Soccer World Cup,
00:02:22 you would see some sort of montage before the event that referenced like the Battle of Agincourt
00:02:29 when the plucky English took on the might of the French stability and won. So it's like it's a sort
00:02:33 of, it's a common analogy for English-French relations. Is it why we hate the French? I don't
00:02:41 know if it's the specific cause, but it's definitely part of the kind of material that's
00:02:46 around. Yeah. I mean, I was only joking. I guess what, to give it the serious treatment that I
00:02:51 think the subject deserves. I think the best thing to do is to start by explaining actually
00:02:55 what we mean by England and France. Because I imagine at this point, countries don't really
00:03:00 exist in the way that we think about them now. These are more personal fiefdoms. And so is that
00:03:05 really where we should start with this? Yeah, that's probably a good place to start.
00:03:09 And in a sense, the Hundred Years' War is a shaking out of what these realms are going to be.
00:03:18 so if we go back before them into so just just by way of framing at the top usually when we talk
00:03:27 about the hundred years war we're talking from the about 1337 through to 1453 now you can extend
00:03:33 those in either direction mike livingston the great military historian has just written a book
00:03:37 called the 200 years war but by and large that's the core of the conflict we're talking about
00:03:41 now if you go before that you're absolutely right these are these are largely personal
00:03:46 fiefdoms. There's a fact of geography, which is since the last ice age, you know, Britain has been
00:03:51 an island and England is the sort of the dominant kingdom within that island archipelago. But if you
00:04:00 go back to the sort of the early into the high middle ages, the notion of what exact, which
00:04:10 bits are ruled by whom is not fixed. So, at the beginning of the Plantagenet era,
00:04:16 so it's after the Norman Conquest, 1154, Henry II takes over as King of England.
00:04:21 He rules England, Normandy, which is inherited effectively because of the Norman Conquest,
00:04:28 Anjou, Maine, Touraine, south of Normandy. There's a claim over Brittany and, by marriage,
00:04:34 the Duchy of Aquitaine, a huge sprawl of southwest France. Now, that adds up to about a third of the
00:04:38 territorial landmass of modern France, plus almost the entire Western seaboard. Now that
00:04:45 all answers ultimately to Henry II, King of England. But he's King of England and he's also
00:04:51 Duke or Count of a bunch of different places. So this is very much a sort of personal,
00:04:56 it's a set of fiefdoms held together by him. However, even at the beginning of the Hundred
00:05:03 Year's War, the early 14th century, you still have kings of England who are Dukes of Aquitaine
00:05:08 or Gascony, depending what you want to call it. So they still have this strong claim to
00:05:12 southwest France, centred on the capital of Bordeaux. They've got a kind of pipe dream
00:05:17 that really they ought to be ruling Normandy as Dukes of Normandy because of their descent
00:05:21 from William the Conqueror. And all of that is constantly in negotiation between English
00:05:27 and French kings. Who rules what and how and why? And it's only through the Hundred Years' War,
00:05:34 really, that you get to a situation where pretty much, even though Henry VIII might have still
00:05:40 fantasized that he was king of France, he's not. Not in the way that Henry V almost was and Henry
00:05:46 VI actually was. So the Hundred Years' War is like the kind of shaking out of those two kingdoms.
00:05:52 So the personal fiefdoms being critical here, who are the key players at the outset and prior to the outset of the Hundred Years' War?
00:06:00 Well, ultimately, it's the kings of England and kings of France.
00:06:04 So kings of England, well, from the 10th century onwards, there'd been a king of England rather than the heptarchy or whatever in the Anglo-Saxon period.
00:06:16 A king of England who rules, call it what England roughly looks like today.
00:06:22 um then you've got the kings of france whose whose situation is a little bit more complicated
00:06:30 you go all the way back to the time of charlemagne you know it's the late 8th century early 9th
00:06:34 century king of the franks well charlemagne ruled what's now france germany austria luxembourg
00:06:39 belgium the netherlands northern italy so on so on you know like the ec for the union more or less
00:06:45 well that's still in the dream of the european union there's a charlemagne prize given out every
00:06:49 year. That's the legacy of the rulers of Germany and the rulers of France. So it's in the minds
00:06:55 of the kings of France that they really ought to sort of be at least rulers of Western Francia,
00:07:02 as had been. So that's like, if we call Paris the capital, it's what we now call France.
00:07:10 But in reality, in the later Middle Ages, certainly the sort of early 13th century,
00:07:16 the kings of France didn't rule that much. Their power extended to a little island outside Paris.
00:07:22 And beyond that, it was just theoretical claim of sovereignty over all of these different powerful
00:07:28 lords within France. And the drive of French policy from the late 12th century, early 13th
00:07:35 century, Philip II Augustus is the king who really has the great vision, is to start expanding the
00:07:41 power of the kings of France back over France and to directly rule and to sort of squash down
00:07:51 the independence of these counts and dukes and rule directly. And that's a process that takes
00:07:55 a long time. Philip II goes some way towards doing it. At the beginning, just before the
00:08:01 Hundred Years' War, Philip IV gets a lot further. And then by the end of the Hundred Years' War,
00:08:08 with Charles VII, and then certainly by the time you get to Louis XI,
00:08:12 France is starting to look like what France is now.
00:08:15 So the power of the kings has really been extended properly
00:08:18 over those two kingdoms.
00:08:20 But part of that process for France means kicking the English out
00:08:24 because it's a very awkward situation for a French king
00:08:28 to have in his nobility a Duke of Aquitaine slash Gascony in particular
00:08:34 who's also the king of England.
00:08:36 because, I mean, the resources of that lord are at least equal
00:08:41 to the resources of the king of France.
00:08:43 So it becomes a not very biddable person within your realm.
00:08:46 So like from the French point of view,
00:08:48 getting the English out of the kingdom in their capacity as nobles
00:08:52 is a big part of this longer drive to create a greater France.
00:08:57 And how does that manifest itself in the war actually starting?
00:09:00 Well, the war starts over a very specific incident.
00:09:04 there'd been for decades generations these kind of squabbles between the kings of England and the
00:09:12 kings of France specifically over Gascony this bit in the southwest because as dukes of Gascony
00:09:20 English kings were technically obliged to come to the kings of France and pay homage to them you
00:09:27 kneel before them hands in theirs you know swear I will be your liege man and obey you because I'm
00:09:31 a noble of the French mobility. Now, no English king was, by and large, going to agree to do that.
00:09:37 So this had always been a point of great friction between the two kings. To try and resolve that,
00:09:43 in 1328, when there was a succession crisis in the French crown, the young king of England,
00:09:53 and Edward III got into his head that one way around this might be to claim to be the King of
00:10:02 France himself. Now it took a little while for him to put that into action as policy, but 1328 you
00:10:07 have the succession crisis, and just under a decade later the young King of England, Edward III, is
00:10:12 like, right, in order to secure my position in Gascony and stop the threat of it being taken
00:10:20 away from me because I won't pay homage to the king of France. I myself am going to claim to
00:10:25 be king of France and that's going to be my excuse to kind of go for an expansive war
00:10:30 and the claim to be king of France is then something I can sort of use as a bargaining
00:10:35 chip to gain more and more and more within the kingdom of France and from that point it's like
00:10:41 well let's see how much we can actually get. So from Succession Crisis 28, from 1337 onwards
00:10:48 Kings of England register their claim to be King of France
00:10:52 and perpetually are going to war ostensibly to try and enforce that claim.
00:10:59 Now we can get into the question of what they really want out of it,
00:11:01 but that's the fundamental deep down reason English kings are saying
00:11:05 we should be kings of France.
00:11:06 And they make that claim by reference to a family tree.
00:11:11 boring you too much in 1328 the possible claimants for the kings of france amounted to edward the
00:11:19 third on the one hand and philip the sixth of france as it became philip of valois on the other
00:11:23 so so this is the the moment in the family tree which everyone's pointed to and saying the english
00:11:29 the val the house of valois should be the kings of france and i'm really glad that we've started
00:11:34 talking about edward the third because i was reading your book about the plantagenet and he is
00:11:38 just the most incredible historical figure,
00:11:42 particularly where he took England from
00:11:45 with the reign of Edward II,
00:11:47 which I think we should touch on,
00:11:49 to how he ascended to the throne.
00:11:52 Let's talk about Edward III briefly.
00:11:54 Yeah, Edward III is a pretty extraordinary character,
00:11:57 particularly, as you say,
00:11:59 being the eldest son of Edward II.
00:12:02 It was the opposite, right?
00:12:04 Edward II was somewhat the opposite.
00:12:05 I mean, Edward II was in a way the opposite.
00:12:08 There are several candidates for this, for the worst medieval king of England,
00:12:12 but Edward II's got to shout.
00:12:15 Edward II was in many ways the kind of the opposite of what you should be as a king.
00:12:21 Fundamentally just didn't understand what the office involved.
00:12:27 And his reign was politically dominated by a succession of,
00:12:32 a short succession, but a succession of favourites.
00:12:34 Piers Gaveston, early in the reign, his kind of adopted brother, possible lover, certainly his obsession, without whom he would basically do nothing, and with whom he was obsessed.
00:12:51 A series of crises at the beginning of Edward II's reign, where the barons of England couldn't stand having Gaveston around.
00:12:57 and they kept constantly trying to kick him out.
00:13:00 And Edward would try every devious mean to get him back
00:13:03 until Gaveston was murdered by the Barons of England.
00:13:06 Later, Edward took revenge for this.
00:13:08 And then, around the same time,
00:13:10 he fell under the spell of another favourite,
00:13:15 Hugh Dispencer the Younger.
00:13:18 Eventually, Edward was deposed,
00:13:21 forced to abdicate by his estranged wife,
00:13:25 Isabella of France, the daughter of
00:13:27 King of France, Philip IV,
00:13:29 and her lover, Roger Mortimer, a dissident
00:13:31 English noble, Anglo-Welsh noble.
00:13:33 They kicked Edward II
00:13:35 off the throne,
00:13:37 murdered him, 0.99
00:13:39 had him murdered in
00:13:41 Barclay Castle in 1328,
00:13:45 and
00:13:45 put his young, his teenage
00:13:47 son, Edward III, on the throne.
00:13:49 For the first three years, Edward III was kind of
00:13:51 a puppet.
00:13:53 He was a teenager, but in 1330, Edward III, aged 17, 18, took control of the kingdom in his own name.
00:14:04 And he did so with a group of young, kind of youngish nobles of his own generation around him.
00:14:10 And as that generation grew up, they kind of pieced back together politics.
00:14:17 You know, politics had been deeply fractured for a whole generation by the kind of old guard, Edward II and his kind of cronies on the one hand, his cousin Thomas Earl of Lancaster, other rebel lords on the other, and this deep division got into the bones of English politics.
00:14:35 And it took a long time to sort of start piecing them back together.
00:14:38 one of the means that edward the third found to bind together the new nobility the new generation
00:14:47 of nobles who were sort of his friends his allies his uh his you know his comrades was foreign war
00:14:55 um and it's in a sense it's one of the oldest stories in the historical book isn't it you've
00:15:01 got problems at home what do you do go go and go fight abroad um we see it every day and in every
00:15:08 historical era. Certainly it worked for Edward III. So he latches on seven years into his
00:15:15 independent reign in 1337 to this fact that he has this claim to the French crown that he wants
00:15:20 to go and enforce. And from that point on, his reign is really a succession of phases of
00:15:27 campaigning in France, which are miraculously successful. And I kind of use that word advisedly
00:15:34 because it does seem like, for a very long time,
00:15:36 God is smiling on Edward III's wish to be king of France.
00:15:41 He wins these spectacular, against-the-odds battlefield victories
00:15:47 at Crecy in 1346,
00:15:48 on his son, the Black Prince, Poitiers in 1356,
00:15:52 at C in 1350 at the Battle of Winchelsea.
00:15:56 It seems like he can't lose for a long time,
00:15:59 and he is this dashing, glamorous figure.
00:16:01 holds these great parties um you know creates the order of the garter as a you know elite
00:16:08 aristocratic club for his mates i mean he really he kind of he just has this instinctive understanding
00:16:15 for bringing people along with him and seeing the the english aristocracy as his allies and as i say
00:16:23 his friends as people with whom he has a common interest rather than kind of devious nobles who
00:16:29 are bound to be out to stab him in the back the minute he switches off.
00:16:35 Most of the useful information I get in a week doesn't come from reading.
00:16:39 It comes from conversations, meetings, calls, interviews.
00:16:42 The problem is that spoken information disappears
00:16:45 unless you're stopping to write things down,
00:16:48 which means you're not actually in the conversation anymore.
00:16:51 That's a problem Plaud solves.
00:16:53 It's a compact device that captures conversations
00:16:56 and turns them into searchable notes, summaries, and insights you can actually use later.
00:17:02 You can ask it a specific question like, what were the actual points from that call?
00:17:06 And it pulls the moment and the summary instantly.
00:17:09 It also recognizes individual voices.
00:17:12 So once you've labeled who's speaking, it tracks them across every future recording.
00:17:16 It's about the size of a credit card, so it's easy to carry and always available when conversation matters.
00:17:23 This thing has solved a real problem for me.
00:17:25 I was skeptical at first, another AI gadget, but the case is straightforward enough that it
00:17:31 actually works. You stop trying to document while you're thinking and it turns out you think
00:17:36 considerably better when you're not. Whether it's a meeting, interview, consultation or call,
00:17:41 the notes are there when you need them without having to choose between listening and writing.
00:17:46 Get up to 20% off at plaud.ai using the code TRIGGER at checkout or click the link in the
00:17:53 the description. Thank you to Plourde for sponsoring today's episode. Because it's a
00:17:58 remarkable transformation in the fortunes of England when you look at Edward II, who was
00:18:05 essentially deposed, constantly at war with the barons. England was broke to where it was under
00:18:12 Edward III, who was this incredibly charismatic ruler, and then went and then stuffed the French
00:18:19 battle after battle after battle.
00:18:21 And can you talk also a little bit about,
00:18:23 you talk about against the odds,
00:18:24 I think it's worth explaining that piece of it as well.
00:18:28 Yes, I mean, it is a remarkable transformation.
00:18:30 And there's no doubt that if you take Edward's reign
00:18:32 at its highest point, let's say 1360
00:18:35 after the Treaty of Brittany,
00:18:37 where he effectively trades away the claim
00:18:40 to the French crown for a massive territorial grant
00:18:42 of Aquitaine in full sovereignty,
00:18:44 of other bits of France as well.
00:18:47 I mean, that's a hell of a turnaround in 30-odd years.
00:18:53 Sorry, what was your question, Constantine?
00:18:55 About the odds.
00:18:56 Yeah, and he does it against the odds victory.
00:19:00 I mean, the signature piece is the Battle of Crecy in 1346.
00:19:05 So, Edward's campaigns to France sort of get going in the early 1340s.
00:19:11 and in the summer of 1346 he decides to go for a really really you know a grand sally out against
00:19:21 the french so he lands on the beaches of normandy on the 12th of july 1346 15 000 men you've got a
00:19:28 picture a sort of medieval d-day of this enormous landing i mean on roughly on the same but not on
00:19:34 uh i don't think it was it wasn't a d-day beach but uh savalogue just up from utah beach on the
00:19:40 Cotetan Peninsula. He lands this huge army and they march off into France. The English tactics
00:19:48 at this point are what's usually described as chevauché tactics. It's the flying columns of
00:19:54 people burning, destroying, killing everything in their path. It's a war of terror. But the point
00:20:00 of the war of terror is to try and convince the people of Normandy in this case that resistance
00:20:05 is futile, that their king, Philip VI, is incapable of protecting them, and that actually, if they've
00:20:11 got any sense, they'll show their allegiance to the rival king, Edward III of England.
00:20:18 This campaign goes on through the second half of July into August, but as it goes on, Edward finds
00:20:24 his lines stretched more and more and more, and he's losing men by a sort of basic attrition as
00:20:30 they besiege cities, as they, you know, as they fight skirmishes and so on. Philip's men fall back
00:20:37 and refuse to engage. They break the bridges over the River Seine. They break the bridges once the
00:20:43 English cross the Seine. Eventually they break the bridges over the River Somme. And eventually 0.68
00:20:46 they just wear the English down until things look pretty perilous for Edward because his lines are
00:20:52 overstretched and he's been in enemy territory for too long. And this all comes to a head in a
00:20:59 battle between the English and the French at Crecy, in which the French have sort of bided
00:21:07 their time and marshaled their resources well and bring up a far larger army than Edward has
00:21:12 and a far fresher army than Edward has, stuffed to the gills with knights, whereas Edward is now
00:21:19 quite heavily reliant on archers, you know, people of peasant stock, you know, inferior troops.
00:21:29 And yet Edward wins this extraordinary victory over the French, demolishes the French, kills hundreds of their knights, cream of French chivalry destroyed on the field, humiliates Philip and seems to draw down. 0.98
00:21:44 And this is something that's important, I think, throughout the Hundred Years' War, seems to draw down evidence of God's favour.
00:21:51 You win in battle in the Middle Ages. It's a form of trial.
00:21:57 I mean, you're asking,
00:21:58 there's very few battles
00:21:59 that are fought in the Middle Ages
00:22:01 for the reason that there is
00:22:02 enormous jeopardy in fighting a battle.
00:22:05 You fight a battle,
00:22:05 you're basically asking God
00:22:07 to judge your cause.
00:22:08 And that can go badly wrong
00:22:12 or it can go for you.
00:22:14 And at Crecy,
00:22:15 where Edward is by and large
00:22:16 forced to fight,
00:22:18 wins this miraculous victory.
00:22:19 It looks a lot like
00:22:20 God is smiling on his cause.
00:22:21 And it's a terrible humiliation 1.00
00:22:23 for the French.
00:22:24 Edward then goes,
00:22:25 having won this victory and fights another very very difficult battle of a totally different
00:22:31 sort this is a very this is a long winter siege um over the uh over the winter of 1346-7
00:22:38 um at Calais and so he besieges the coastal town of Calais obviously the nearest port between
00:22:44 on the French coast to England um besieges it for almost a year in really difficult conditions
00:22:52 but manages to break Calais as well
00:22:55 and so comes away from this Cressy campaign
00:22:57 with a bridgehead on the French coast
00:22:59 and this kind of burgeoning reputation
00:23:03 as the coming man of Western European politics.
00:23:07 He's proved himself against the odds
00:23:09 and it's the beginning of a succession of victories
00:23:11 throughout the 1350s then
00:23:13 with the interruption of the Black Death in 1348.
00:23:17 Obviously quite disruptive to campaign,
00:23:21 although they do campaign throughout the Black Death.
00:23:23 I say quite disruptive, but I do mean quite disruptive
00:23:26 because it doesn't shut, there's not mass lockdowns
00:23:30 of the way that we think in COVID terms. 0.92
00:23:32 I mean, people do get on with stuff in the Black Death,
00:23:34 albeit under somewhat difficult conditions.
00:23:39 So through the 1350s, Edward was dominant.
00:23:42 And the more dominant he is, the richer he gets.
00:23:44 You know, because one of the things that happens
00:23:47 if you win a lot of battles is you typically take a lot of prisoners.
00:23:51 valuable prisoners. It's not the done thing to kill knights, generally speaking, on the battlefield.
00:23:55 You've taken prisoner and there's a whole ransom market, a whole sort of secondary market in
00:24:02 ransoms. So you can mortgage people, you can, you know, they're third-party ransom agents,
00:24:08 so there's a huge financial market in ransoms. And you start to see across England places like
00:24:15 Warwick Castle, if you've ever been to Warwick Castle. It's a lovely day out these days but I
00:24:21 mean the grandeur of Warwick Castle owes a lot to the high point of the Hundred Years' War where the
00:24:26 earls of Warwick were big players in the Hundred Years' War and just came back, you know, laden
00:24:31 with gold. And the massive influx of wealth into the country was also helped after the Battle of
00:24:38 Poitiers in 1346 where the French King Jean II was taken prisoner himself and ransomed for millions
00:24:43 of billions and millions of gold echoes. And one thing that we haven't touched on is the technology
00:24:50 because the English had superior technology, didn't they? And that's probably the main reason
00:24:56 why they won. Superior, yes, although it looks inferior. So the longbow is the critical weapon
00:25:04 on the English side for most of the Hundred Years' War. Battle of Cressey, 1346, you do actually see
00:25:12 handguns on the field for the first
00:25:14 probably for the first time in Europe
00:25:15 but very, very crude handguns
00:25:17 and it's not much more than fireworks
00:25:20 really, it makes a lot of noises
00:25:21 it scares the horses but it's not
00:25:24 there's not Passchendaele
00:25:26 do you know what I mean?
00:25:27 So the battles
00:25:30 like Crecy in particular
00:25:31 later under Henry V, Agincourt are won by
00:25:34 English longbowmen
00:25:35 Now you look at a longbow
00:25:37 it's a simple, apparently simple
00:25:40 piece of technology it's a long piece of you um with a taut string and it shoots arrows which
00:25:47 it's not complicated um you sometimes hear described as the ak-47 of the middle ages which
00:25:55 is it's completely wrong because an ak-47 this is the success of the kalashnikov right is that 0.94
00:26:01 any idiot can pick up an ak-47 and fire and it's pretty reliable just point and shoot 0.98
00:26:07 almost nobody who hasn't well no nobody who has not trained for years can pick up a longbow and 1.00
00:26:15 shoot it if you ever tried to shoot a longbow it's um you just can't do it i mean you unless
00:26:23 you've trained a long time because the the longbows great advantages range and um
00:26:30 it means it's very hard to draw so in order to draw you can't like muscle a longbow you have
00:26:37 to get right inside it and you have to have like extraordinarily strong back muscles in order to
00:26:42 get inside and fire this and shoot this weapon effectively. So under Edward III, the English
00:26:49 do something quite smart, which is they make it mandatory for everybody on a Sunday to practice
00:26:55 shooting a longbow. So you have a whole population that's trained to use this simple and cheap
00:27:01 weapon. So when they go into the field in France, for generation after generation, they've got these 0.96
00:27:08 ranks upon ranks of cheap troops who can shoot a cheap weapon, which is absolutely deadly.
00:27:18 It's got a longer range than a crossbow, which is a more expensive and more, you know, and more
00:27:23 temperamental piece of technology because it's got more moving parts. And deployed correctly,
00:27:29 ranks of longbowmen 0.76
00:27:32 are very effective
00:27:34 against a cavalry charge as well
00:27:36 horses don't like charging into
00:27:38 hail of longbow shot
00:27:41 and you can keep
00:27:43 a bigger range, I mean there's all sorts
00:27:45 of advantages but yeah the critical
00:27:46 piece of technology
00:27:48 for most of the 100 years on the English side
00:27:50 is the longbow and you see these victories all the way
00:27:52 from 1346, Crecy
00:27:53 Ashentor is the famous one, 1415 but
00:27:56 even 1424
00:27:58 or you've still got great longbow victories for the English.
00:28:02 And is that the reason that the French don't just go,
00:28:05 oh, longbow, that looks good, we'll do that?
00:28:08 Because it takes a lot of training.
00:28:09 Or is it ideological on their part?
00:28:11 Because, you know, the knights, chivalry, you know, 1.00
00:28:15 charging down the plebs, it sounds like fun. 0.99
00:28:17 It's a bit of both.
00:28:18 It's a bit of both.
00:28:18 I think there's an ideological preference for cavalry,
00:28:25 a bit on the French side.
00:28:26 And I think that going back to what we talked about with the kings of France still being in this phase where they're trying to extend their authority directly over their own realm, it's much harder for them to institute policies that in England you can institute quite directly.
00:28:42 If the king says, and if the king says, I want everyone to train with a longbow in England on a Sunday and pass a parliamentary statute, that gets done.
00:28:55 The power concentrated in English king's hands at this point and mediated through parliament and national gathering is considerable.
00:29:06 And so there's a higher degree, I suppose, of centralized authority in England.
00:29:12 relative to France.
00:29:14 That's really interesting.
00:29:15 And so far for me to be sceptical
00:29:17 of Guards' involvement in all of this,
00:29:18 but you mentioned that in that moment,
00:29:20 in that time,
00:29:21 it would have been a huge part
00:29:23 of how people perceived the successes
00:29:25 that Edward III is having on the field.
00:29:27 Absolutely.
00:29:29 Other than Guards' involvement
00:29:30 and the longbow,
00:29:31 are there other reasons why in that phase
00:29:33 the English are as successful as they are,
00:29:36 as you said, against the odds?
00:29:39 Or is it just those two?
00:29:42 Just God and the Longbow.
00:29:44 That's all it means.
00:29:45 What else do you need?
00:29:48 Connected to this centralised authority,
00:29:51 the English are also probably better at taxing the realm.
00:29:56 So the relatively early development of Parliament in England
00:30:03 in the Middle Ages, stemming to the 13th century,
00:30:07 out of Magna Carta through the reforms of the middle of Henry III's reign
00:30:11 in the 1250s and 1260s create a relationship in which there's a kind of a negotiation mechanism
00:30:18 between the whole realm and the king which is part which are these irregularly called parliaments
00:30:25 where the king when things are functioning well says okay I want to fight a war calls a parliament
00:30:30 sets out the case for war parliaments effectively appropriates the funds um they're quite efficiently
00:30:37 collected and the king has has easier access to the wealth of his own kingdom so it becomes i mean
00:30:44 of course every time there's a war everyone's constantly complaining about the tax in fact
00:30:48 every time there's any tax of any sort everyone's constantly complaining of course they are except
00:30:53 when people are winning so if you look at say henry v who had a very successful um time of the
00:30:58 100 years war in his reigns early 15th century uh he he england is probably under the highest
00:31:06 tax burden
00:31:08 it ever is in the Middle Ages,
00:31:11 if I can think.
00:31:13 But Henry just keeps winning
00:31:15 and winning and winning and winning.
00:31:16 So people are generally happier
00:31:18 to pay for a war win than winning.
00:31:19 But in answer to your question,
00:31:21 English kings have a somewhat better access
00:31:23 to their own tax base.
00:31:25 And they also
00:31:27 have fewer things to think about,
00:31:30 in a sense, because there's
00:31:31 there's something that pertains to the physical geography, I think,
00:31:40 that also really matters.
00:31:42 And this is a much bigger point about English and British history
00:31:48 from the Middle Ages onwards.
00:31:50 There are so many advantages to specifically where this big island
00:31:54 and archipelago lies.
00:31:56 The defensibility, you know, the relative, you know, the few borders, the dominance of the English by and large over their neighbours, with the exception of the Scots, who typically ally with the French.
00:32:12 But even in that case, England is heavily dominant. You never see Scotland until, you know, James VI comes along, you never see Scotland conquer England.
00:32:22 so whereas France 0.65
00:32:27 I mean the French have much more
00:32:29 to think about than just the English
00:32:31 I think this is also
00:32:33 to return to your joke at the beginning 1.00
00:32:35 the French kind of live 0.92
00:32:37 rent free in the English heads 0.99
00:32:39 in a way that I don't
00:32:40 it's not necessarily the same
00:32:44 the other way around
00:32:45 because you know
00:32:45 let's just take one example
00:32:46 well they have the Germans next to them 0.90
00:32:48 they have the Germans next to them 0.67
00:32:50 I mean there's the question 0.85
00:32:51 of what's going on
00:32:51 on the Italian border
00:32:52 Like, what's the relationship with the papacy and where should, you know, at the same time as the Hundred Years War, you've got this debate about whether the papacy should be in Rome or in Avignon, not technically in France, but basically in France.
00:33:05 You've got questions about sovereignty in Flanders.
00:33:08 There's a whole ton of stuff going on for French kings to think about in which the English are only one. 0.85
00:33:15 I think, you know, maybe we talked about this when we talked about the Crusades, and there's something analogous there, which is, you know, in the Crusaders' minds, going out and conquering the kingdom of Jerusalem and kicking the Muslims out and doing them over is like, that's the number one thing. 0.55
00:33:29 Sort of, the Muslims in the Middle East are like, yeah, okay, but we're quite busy fighting the sectarian war between Sunni and Shia here, and it's like way more to think about than just you lot. 0.56
00:33:39 So, perhaps something similar is going on. 0.99
00:33:41 All right, so the English have this structural advantage
00:33:44 in terms of centralised power, taxation.
00:33:47 They've got the technological advantage with the longbow.
00:33:50 God clearly is on England's side, as we've established.
00:33:52 Until he's not.
00:33:53 And this is where I'm going with this.
00:33:55 How do the wheels come off the bandwagon?
00:33:57 You've got Edward III, brilliant.
00:34:00 The son is a badass by all accounts, the Black Prince.
00:34:03 How does the whole thing turn?
00:34:05 Because ultimately, the Hundred Years' War is not a success for the English, right?
00:34:08 No, and ultimately, the Hundred Years' War is a massive failure.
00:34:10 The Hundred Years' War shakes out so that the English are completely kicked out of France, with the exception of Calais.
00:34:16 But it depends where you stop the tape, you know.
00:34:19 So Edward III, up until you have these victories we've talked about.
00:34:23 Crecy, Poitiers, others.
00:34:28 1360, there's a settlement, Treaty of Bretigny.
00:34:31 From that point on, the French start chipping away at the Bretigny settlement.
00:34:36 Edward III is succeeded in 1377 not by his badass son, the Black Prince,
00:34:41 who dies shortly before him of an illness picked up on campaign in Spain,
00:34:47 but by his grandson, Richard II, who has no interest in fighting the French War whatsoever
00:34:52 and is perfectly happy to, you know, if you asked him,
00:34:56 he would have re-signed away everything that England had ever won.
00:34:59 It's just not his cup of tea at all.
00:35:01 He's deposed in 1399.
00:35:03 Henry IV, his cousin, picks things up.
00:35:07 Henry V then launches a kind of really retro campaign,
00:35:16 modelled in large part on Edward III's great victories,
00:35:20 although strategically somewhat different,
00:35:23 and wins a startling succession of victories between 1415,
00:35:30 the Agincourt campaign, and his own sudden death in 1422.
00:35:36 Henry V is taking advantage of a civil war in France
00:35:39 between two factions called the Burgundians and the Armagnacs,
00:35:42 who are at war because the French king has gone mad, Charles VI.
00:35:46 So Henry VI kind of inserts the English into this war,
00:35:49 teams up eventually with the Burgundians, destroys French armies, conquers Normandy,
00:35:57 gets all the way to the walls of Paris and forces in 1420 a treaty on the French called the Treaty
00:36:02 of Troyes by which Henry V of England becomes, quote, heir and regent to the crown of France.
00:36:09 When mad Charles VI dies, Henry V is going to be not only king of England, the king of France
00:36:13 as well. Sort of like he's beaten the ultimate boss. Then Henry V dies at the age of 35 of
00:36:20 dysentery and leaving an infant son, not even one year old, as his successor. So that's 1422. Now,
00:36:30 things don't go immediately wrong for the English, which is remarkable, really. In fact, they stay 0.96
00:36:36 pretty okay until 1429 when Joan of Arc comes along. But at the moment Joan of Arc rises in
00:36:45 1429, the English, with Burgundy in support, have sort of conquered everything in France down to the
00:36:50 River Loire. And it's not unthinkable, the Siege of Orleans, that if they take Orleans, they're going
00:36:56 to enter southern France, and the full conquest of France is on the cards. However, in 1435,
00:37:05 the Burgundians switch up on them and France reunites under the king Joan of Arcade helped
00:37:13 Charles VII and from that point on England is at a increasingly at a disadvantage partly because
00:37:22 largely because the king of England Henry VI and your fifth son who'd been an infant in 1422
00:37:29 has grown up to be absolutely uninterested in war absolutely incapable of domestic or foreign
00:37:35 government, shell-shocked in the face of the reality of power, completely hopeless England 0.90
00:37:42 dissolves into a sort of leaderless crisis of its own and the French start to chip, chip, chip away 0.57
00:37:49 at all the English possessions in France, in Normandy in particular, they take Maine back
00:37:55 until in 1453, the Battle of Castillon,
00:38:02 not only have they won back Normandy,
00:38:04 they also have shrunk Gascony, that bit in the southwest,
00:38:08 down to almost nothing, destroy the English in Gascony,
00:38:10 take Bordeaux, and it's all over.
00:38:12 There's nothing left except for Calais by 1453.
00:38:17 And that then sparks in England the Wars of the Roses,
00:38:21 The civil war, the dynastic wars between what becomes known as the House of Lancaster and the House of York.
00:38:27 And from that point on, there's vanishingly little possibility of the English doing anything whatsoever except defending Calais.
00:38:34 There's a late stage hurrah in 1475 under Edward IV, Yorkist king, who tries to do a little bit of Henry V cosplay,
00:38:43 raises a big army for 13,000 men, takes it over to France.
00:38:46 But as soon as he gets there, he realises, I'm not really into this.
00:38:50 I'd rather be at home kind of squiring wenches and eating cakes, basically. 0.98
00:38:55 And so signed a deal with the French where they agreed to pay the English to just off and leave them alone. 0.77
00:39:01 Treaty of Piquigny of 1475.
00:39:05 The claim to the Kingdom of France is not dropped.
00:39:08 So Henry VIII, early in his reign, 1413, he's a young man, comes to the throne, decides he's going to do his own Henry V cosplay.
00:39:16 But again, it comes to nothing.
00:39:18 With the benefit of hindsight, 1453 is the end. 0.89
00:39:22 Once the English are being kicked out, 0.87
00:39:23 they're really not coming back in any meaningful sense. 1.00
00:39:29 You know how at the beginning of every year,
00:39:31 people say, this is a year things change.
00:39:34 Then by February, everything looks the same.
00:39:37 If you've been sitting on a business idea for months or even years,
00:39:41 2026 is your line in the sand.
00:39:44 The most common thing that separates people who talk about building something
00:39:47 from the people who actually do it is taking the first step.
00:39:51 And if you want this to be the year you finally launch,
00:39:54 the smartest move you can make is starting your business with Shopify.
00:39:59 2026 is the year you launch your business,
00:40:02 the year you transform into an entrepreneur, founder, or boss.
00:40:05 One powerful move puts your future firmly in your hands,
00:40:09 starting a business with Shopify.
00:40:11 Maybe you've got a product you can't stop thinking about,
00:40:13 a skill everyone tells you to monetize,
00:40:16 or a store you've already imagined in your head.
00:40:19 Shopify is how you make that real.
00:40:22 Shopify provides everything you need to sell online and in person.
00:40:25 Millions of entrepreneurs have already made this leap.
00:40:28 From household names to people launching their first ever business.
00:40:32 Shopify gives you all the tools to build your dream store easily.
00:40:36 You can choose from hundreds of beautiful templates
00:40:39 and customize everything to match your brand.
00:40:42 Set up is fast thanks to Shopify's built-in AI tools.
00:40:46 They write product descriptions and headlines for you and even help you edit your product photos.
00:40:51 Marketing is built in too.
00:40:53 You can create email and social campaigns that reach customers wherever they scroll.
00:40:58 As you grow, Shopify grows with you.
00:41:00 Handle more orders, expand into new markets and manage everything from one simple dashboard.
00:41:05 In 2026, stop waiting and start selling with Shopify.
00:41:09 Sign up for your £1 a month trial and start selling today at shopify.co.uk slash trigger.
00:41:16 Go to shopify.co.uk slash trigger.
00:41:20 That's shopify.co.uk slash trigger. 1.00
00:41:25 Dan, as you know, we're massive feminists on the show and so is all of our audience.
00:41:30 And it strikes me that we haven't addressed the central figure in this whole story, which is, of course, Joan of Arc.
00:41:35 Of course.
00:41:35 A miraculous character, genuinely one of the miraculous characters of history.
00:41:42 Yeah, an extraordinary character.
00:41:48 It's so difficult to disentangle, maybe this is true of a lot of characters, but it's extremely
00:41:54 true of Joan, to disentangle the real person from the shroud of myth and storytelling that
00:42:02 kind of that sits over the top of her but makes a material difference at this pivot point in the
00:42:10 hundred years war you know it's the siege of orleans 1429 the english seem to be ascendant
00:42:14 the direction of travel seems to be relentlessly south as in the english is pushing further and
00:42:20 further and further into what what remains of french held france and then suddenly this you
00:42:26 know, peasant girl from this weird bit of Eastern France turns up, you know, waving the flag and
00:42:32 saying, you know, God's spoken to me. I'm going to lead the Dauphin to his coronation around and 0.98
00:42:39 we're going to take back France. And then it actually happens. Well, not only does it happen, 0.55
00:42:46 but she plays an active role. She plays an active role. She's never been trained as a knight goes
00:42:50 into combat, leads men into battle. I mean, is there an... I ask this question genuinely. Is
00:42:56 Is there an explanation that does not include the divine
00:42:59 that actually can tell us what happened?
00:43:03 Yes.
00:43:03 I mean, I don't know how much sports fan you are,
00:43:06 but this idea of momentum and belief.
00:43:09 Like we talk about this in sports all the time,
00:43:10 that something will galvanize a team.
00:43:14 Sure, but isn't what happened a little bit more
00:43:17 like me turning up, persuading Pep Guardiola
00:43:20 that I should play up front, and then he sticks me up front
00:43:23 and we start smashing them in?
00:43:24 Isn't it a bit more like that?
00:43:26 No, because Joan wasn't smashing them in, you see.
00:43:31 It's like having this...
00:43:33 In a manner of speaking.
00:43:36 I'm sure you would be.
00:43:38 It's like having this incredible kind of mascot just suddenly.
00:43:42 But you can't disentangle it from the divine.
00:43:44 I know that you want to.
00:43:46 I'm not. I don't want to.
00:43:47 I'm asking if it's even possible.
00:43:50 No, I don't think you can.
00:43:51 You can't disentangle Joan of Arc's effect on the French.
00:43:56 at Orléans and for a little while thereafter, from the medieval worldview that God is active
00:44:04 in the world and through people at times. You just can't. There's a whole set of language
00:44:16 that is a modern language that we could use to describe Joan of Arc, and some of it would come
00:44:21 from the language of mental illness, and some of it would come from a sort of, you could use the
00:44:27 language of sort of the woo-woo realm, or sports psychology, or any of those things. I've just
00:44:34 picked the sports psychology one and tried that out, and you, ineffectively, as it turned out.
00:44:40 It's no good. You have to use the terms of the time, and the terms of the time are like,
00:44:44 there was this moment when God intervened. That's how it was understood by everybody at the time,
00:44:50 And so that's the best explanation.
00:44:52 It didn't last very long because God's intervention was time-limited through Joan.
00:44:59 She outlived her usefulness and the end of her story is a tragedy, really. 0.91
00:45:04 I mean, discarded by the French and then treated pretty appallingly
00:45:09 and in just basic human terms by the Burgundians and subsequently the English.
00:45:14 but then revived later.
00:45:19 Her revival is as much of a part of her story
00:45:23 as what actually happened at the time.
00:45:25 And this 19th, 20th century revival of Joan of Arc
00:45:30 as a symbol of Frenchness
00:45:32 and of the kind of miraculous,
00:45:37 the providential within the French character is important.
00:45:41 And, you know, you introduced her with a comment about feminism, 0.61
00:45:44 That's a part of Joan as well. 0.99
00:45:46 She drifts through different types of being an icon. 1.00
00:45:51 At the moment, she's a sort of partially feminist icon. 1.00
00:45:54 And it's not hard to see why, because she dons the male armour 1.00
00:45:59 and she comes into a man's world and she seems to materially affect it. 1.00
00:46:03 And she satisfies a lot of the yearnings of modern feminism. 1.00
00:46:07 But she also used to satisfy a lot of the yearnings 0.94
00:46:10 of modern French nationalism. 0.97
00:46:12 She's just a, she's a palimpsest. 1.00
00:46:13 You can write your own story onto her 1.00
00:46:15 and she still looks good standing there
00:46:17 with a helmet on and a flag on her.
00:46:19 So what you're saying is she's Claudio Ranieri
00:46:21 at Leicester City.
00:46:22 I knew that that was what I was looking for.
00:46:25 She's Claudio.
00:46:26 And now we've reduced the number of people
00:46:28 who get the references down to about three.
00:46:30 Well, at least three.
00:46:31 At least three.
00:46:32 But from a historian's perspective,
00:46:34 in a practical sense,
00:46:36 do you believe that the turnaround
00:46:37 in French fortune happens
00:46:39 if Joan of Arc doesn't come along
00:46:41 when she does?
00:46:42 Oh, what a great counterfactual.
00:46:44 Probably, eventually.
00:46:45 Really?
00:46:46 Probably.
00:46:47 How much further could the English
00:46:49 have pushed realistically?
00:46:50 I mean, behind the scenes,
00:46:53 Henry VI by this stage
00:46:54 was coming on for his eighth birthday.
00:46:59 Within five years,
00:47:01 it would be pretty clear
00:47:01 that this was not going to be
00:47:03 a military leader of any sort whatsoever.
00:47:06 So, I mean, the English willingness
00:47:09 to finance effectively a civil war in France,
00:47:13 which is what the English...
00:47:14 So the English kings, up until the Treaty of Troyes in 1420,
00:47:18 when Henry V signs this treaty that says,
00:47:20 I'm the heir and regents of the crown of France,
00:47:23 it's the war from the English taxpayers' perspective
00:47:26 is we're paying to win back what's ours by right.
00:47:32 Once the English king starts to make reality
00:47:36 of becoming the king of France,
00:47:38 so that it's the possibility he's going to wear these two crowns.
00:47:41 The English taxpayers get very cold feet and say,
00:47:44 well, if you're king of France, tax your French subjects
00:47:47 to pay to conquer the whole of your realm of France
00:47:49 because that ain't our concern anymore.
00:47:51 The whole calculus of the war shifts.
00:47:54 So to return to the question of the 1420s into 1430s,
00:47:59 had Joan of Arc not come along, and now I realize I'm flicked
00:48:01 and flicking back to be more of a structuralist than a great man.
00:48:03 person but deep down you wouldn't the English would not have had a the king was growing up to
00:48:11 be absolutely uninterested in war the English taxpayer would probably not have stomached much
00:48:16 more of this making the French pay for their own conquest was difficult at some point something had
00:48:24 to give and probably would have but Joan is this she's the spark right she's a spark and she gives
00:48:32 the French the belief momentarily that they can win this critical siege at Orléans and then the
00:48:40 momentum shifts. There you go. You believe in the great man of history unless it's a woman.
00:48:45 I believe in the great woman. I believe in the great woman. I'm just messing with you. 1.00
00:48:49 The more I read about history, particularly English history, the more I realise
00:48:54 it's really dependent on the king. Edward II, terrible, England was in the doldrums. I know
00:49:00 this is a simplistic view of it, Edward III, great king, England rose again. And you look at,
00:49:07 for instance, the Black Prince, who I think he developed dropsy, didn't he? Yeah. And you think, 0.99
00:49:12 how different would England have been if he hadn't have got sick and he could have ruled for
00:49:18 a longer period of time as Edward III? And maybe that would have deferred Richard II coming to the
00:49:24 who made a complete what's-it of it.
00:49:27 Yeah, this is right.
00:49:29 I mean, the quote-unquote great man theory of history
00:49:33 goes in and out of fashion, right?
00:49:36 When I was growing up, when I was studying,
00:49:38 it was well out of fashion, and everything was structuralist,
00:49:40 and the whole belief was really this concentration
00:49:44 on the character of leaders is for the birds.
00:49:48 It doesn't really make much difference.
00:49:49 That the history is the product of grander forces than this.
00:49:56 And here we are in the sort of early 2020s. 0.99
00:49:59 I think that you'd be a fool, right? 0.76
00:50:02 You know, we're living in an age where the personalities of the rulers of their superpowers are critical to the state of the world and this historical pivot point which we seem to be living. 0.97
00:50:17 If you take Tai Chi and China, I mean, his conception of Chinese history, his personal belief about how China should be and what it looks like, vitally important to Chinese policy.
00:50:29 Trump in the US, his disinterest in most of history, his kind of personal peccadilloes and notions of how things should be, absolutely critical to America's developments of power and Putin and Russia and so on and so on.
00:50:44 So, to take that back to the kings and queens of England, yeah, it does matter that Richard II was a sort of petulant kind of pacifist with a narcissistic personality disorder.
00:50:59 That's of material importance to English history, to your counterfactual. What if the Black Prince had not gone sick at Nehra and had succeeded as Edward IV? Things could have looked different. 0.65
00:51:13 I mean, that doesn't necessarily mean better. Of course, it could be a different kind of bad. The Black Prince was a fantastic general, but he probably lacked some of the kind of easy flexibility, the diplomatic kind of smarts that his father had.
00:51:36 He's a more rigid kind of militaristic leader. 0.52
00:51:40 That could or couldn't have been the best thing at that time.
00:51:45 Another good counterfactual is what if Henry V hadn't died
00:51:47 at the age of 35 in 1422?
00:51:52 What if Henry VI had had an apprenticeship?
00:51:54 Henry V's great advantage was that he became king at 26,
00:51:57 or one of his great advantages, king at 26,
00:51:59 after a long, difficult 13-year apprenticeship
00:52:02 where he was fighting, where he was standing in for his father,
00:52:05 when he was ruling as regent effectively when his father was ill.
00:52:08 He came to the throne like a complete politician.
00:52:13 Henry VI came to the throne at nine months old
00:52:16 and had to grow up as king.
00:52:18 You see a rough pattern across English history
00:52:21 of kings who have become kings as children
00:52:24 having a really difficult time.
00:52:26 They never have this opportunity to make mistakes.
00:52:29 They're growing up way too close to power.
00:52:33 So yes, there are all these counterfactuals
00:52:35 we can run. But I think that to your point, yeah, really, it does matter who exactly these people
00:52:42 are. And there are some advantages in this period to having a hereditary monarchy based
00:52:49 on primogeniture. In theory, it cuts down the likelihood of a gigantic civil war every time
00:52:57 you need to change care, because the rule is the rule is the rule. But it also introduces this
00:53:02 massive genetic lottery to uh to government like who've we got next oh christ oh or who've
00:53:13 got next yay the by chance i've always wondered about this dan though because you know there is
00:53:18 a saying the apple doesn't fall far from the tree like i'm not exactly like my dad but i've inherited
00:53:22 quite a bit from him i'm sure the same will be with my son but but what the story you tell it's
00:53:27 almost like, you know, the son is Nigel Farage, the father is Zach Polanski, and you just,
00:53:33 you go from Trump to Biden within one family. How does that happen?
00:53:38 Well, we've all seen this happen in families. It depends, you know, that,
00:53:42 it sounds like you've, you know, you admire your father from that.
00:53:46 Sure. Somewhat. Sure. In some ways. Yeah.
00:53:50 And, but there are, you know, we often see these cases where the child wants to become the opposite
00:53:56 of the parent, right?
00:53:58 Or the child takes after the other parent
00:54:02 or, you know, whatever it might be.
00:54:03 You know, we don't create these identicates
00:54:06 of our children.
00:54:08 And then, you know, you also have 0.99
00:54:09 the spoiled brat phenomenon, right?
00:54:11 It's like the kid who grows up
00:54:13 not having to struggle.
00:54:15 This is a sort of trope,
00:54:17 a mainstay of history.
00:54:20 I'm not just talking about kings and queens,
00:54:21 but I can't remember who someone's written about this.
00:54:26 you know, one of those oldie-timey Malcolm Gladwell-type people, you know, John Ronson
00:54:32 or someone wrote a study of, you know, kids of successful people. They don't have to,
00:54:36 or very seldom do they have to really struggle themselves, and sometimes it's the struggle
00:54:41 that makes you. So, I mean, there are all sorts of reasons why, oh, you know, if you take Edward
00:54:48 II as an example, well, he was the younger kid. He was the baby of the family. He was like the
00:54:53 14th or 16th kid to be born, right?
00:54:55 And we were supposed to have King Alfonso,
00:54:58 his elder brother, Henry VIII,
00:55:01 who was supposed to be King Arthur.
00:55:03 And then King Arthur was no more,
00:55:06 and it was the younger son who was sort of the spare,
00:55:08 who was thrust into the limelight,
00:55:11 having grown up preparing for something totally different.
00:55:14 So, I mean, this is what makes it fascinating.
00:55:18 And I'm glad, to slightly rehearse an earlier point,
00:55:21 I'm glad that we're back in this age
00:55:23 in which people are taking personality and history seriously
00:55:26 because it just makes it more approachable and meaningful
00:55:32 and this faceless era of total structuralism within history
00:55:39 I found quite depressing.
00:55:41 I like the people.
00:55:43 Taking the historian's eye and looking at our society
00:55:47 and our civilisation, there's been a lot of talk about
00:55:50 the West is in decline, all of that kind of stuff. From your perspective, what do you see then? Do you
00:55:55 think we are in a lull, in a bit of a dip, or do you see it as being terminal? Is the West in decline?
00:56:03 No, I don't. I mean, I think these sort of grand arguments are really attractive, right? We love
00:56:12 to talk in epic terms. The idea that increasingly, and this is a sort of sidebar, but increasingly
00:56:20 with the hybridization of human thinking and machine thinking, we like to think in binaries
00:56:29 as well. It's this or it's this. We're in decline or we're in ascendancy. Well, history
00:56:34 We don't want too much like that.
00:56:36 But it seems fairly likely that right now we're living at an inflection point.
00:56:46 And the future, because of the technological revolution we're living through,
00:56:54 which is being applied across the board from warfare to employment to, I mean,
00:56:59 you know, almost every facet of life is undergoing rapid change, that this is an era of opportunity.
00:57:10 And I think in some ways, it's being thought about at a leadership level more seriously in
00:57:20 the East than in the West. I think, you know, I mentioned she earlier on, I think
00:57:28 he may not be right in his analysis of history
00:57:32 or his assessment of Chinese likely superiority.
00:57:41 I don't know that he is completely right in that,
00:57:43 and I don't think that his assessment of American weakness
00:57:45 is totally accurate either.
00:57:48 But he's certainly thinking seriously
00:57:51 about the historical moment.
00:57:55 I think that in the West,
00:57:57 there's a recognition that oh something's up but it's not being necessarily gripped
00:58:05 hard by anyone at the moment um in government i think it's being gripped pretty hard by
00:58:13 people at the top of the tech industry and there's a strong argument to say that the people at the
00:58:19 top of the big tech companies at the moment are the effective rulers of the world in many ways
00:58:24 by proxy um and i i think that we will certainly look back on this period
00:58:34 um mining it for all sorts of clues about how the world that we that whatever unfolds by say 2050
00:58:41 comes to look like but this talk of is the you know is the western terminal decline
00:58:46 it's very tempting but it's things don't really work well you added the terminal part i think the
00:58:52 terminal is where the that's where it becomes a bit of a tenuous claim yeah but i think if you
00:58:58 were to look at the civilizations that you outlined and their relative positions and
00:59:04 directions of travel you can hardly look the europe in particular and say this is western
00:59:08 europe and this and this is a oh there are a lot of metrics that are very worrying yeah of course
00:59:13 are up. Birth rate, the growing inequality gaps, the basic ability of young people to
00:59:24 find a stake in the essential bits of society as a matter of course.
00:59:35 The grand problem of the size of the state that now afflicts so many Western countries,
00:59:41 is the basic unaffordability of what's been set up
00:59:45 and the lack of a seriously, clearly stated alternative
00:59:51 for the post-war settlement.
00:59:52 That's part of the story of our times.
00:59:54 What are we now?
00:59:56 June, we're talking in the UK, 0.96
01:00:00 in a period where the Prime Minister is a sort of lame duck.
01:00:06 There's no political arithmetic that should allow for this,
01:00:10 but has completely failed to articulate any policy vision
01:00:15 of how this country should move into the future,
01:00:19 has just sort of said, well, we'll just kind of see what happens.
01:00:23 And there's a clear awareness among, you know,
01:00:27 you don't have to be a student of politics,
01:00:28 you can just be any gazing down the pub who could just say,
01:00:32 well, where are we going? What are we doing?
01:00:35 What are we going to do about all of these obvious problems 1.00
01:00:40 which are, you know, the failure seriously to tackle the social dislocations of immigration.
01:00:48 The, as I say, you know, the employment opportunities of young people coming into the world.
01:00:56 What are we doing about it?
01:00:58 So there's a decline in the quality of leadership and there are some pretty worrying metrics out there.
01:01:06 Well, this is what I was going to say.
01:01:07 If we take your comments about the great man of history theory,
01:01:12 it sort of feels like we've got 10 duds in a row, basically.
01:01:18 Well, yes, I agree.
01:01:19 I do agree.
01:01:21 There's not a lack of people with ideas out there.
01:01:25 Not a lot of them want to go into frontline politics
01:01:27 for reasons we can discuss.
01:01:30 us, something else that's happened in the UK, not so much in America, well, possibly in the States
01:01:38 as well, that does have a medieval analogy. And I promise that I don't believe everything has a
01:01:43 medieval analogy, but this does. In the Wars of the Roses, which is that English civil war I
01:01:48 mentioned, which follows on from the Hundred Years' War, which we've been discussing, after about a
01:01:54 generation of polarized politics, as we'd call it, of like factionalism and of the decay of
01:02:02 central authority and growing lawlessness and social dislocation and economic drift.
01:02:10 The smart analyses of the time all tended to say what's happened is that we've introduced what
01:02:19 they call variance into our politics, which is to say there's a toxicity in the political process
01:02:27 which is the irreconcilability of factions, which is the bitter quality of politics,
01:02:35 which is the negativity. That in itself is the problem. And the constant churn of leaders
01:02:41 is in itself the problem. And I think if you look at British politics over the last
01:02:47 10 years, let's say, or even let's say, yeah, certainly 10 years of Brexit, but maybe going
01:02:53 back to 2008, a financial crisis, you could say that the problem in itself is now the kind of
01:03:01 the writhing and the disaffection, that that self-perpetuates. And the moment that you,
01:03:07 you know, we're looking at ditching the Prime Minister, because as the chant goes, 0.99
01:03:12 Keir Starmer as a wanker. 0.95
01:03:14 That's like, everyone thinks that. 0.98
01:03:17 But then the next reaction to that is, 1.00
01:03:19 well, fuck off and get someone else. 1.00
01:03:21 Right. 1.00
01:03:22 And as soon as that person hits a sticky patch, 1.00
01:03:26 fuck off and get someone else. 1.00
01:03:26 They become the wanker. 1.00
01:03:27 They become the wanker. 1.00
01:03:28 And the reaction to the wanker is to ditch them straight away. 0.95
01:03:32 And so what you then have is a politics that,
01:03:35 on a sort of pragmatic level, can go nowhere
01:03:38 because it never gets beyond, like, its first trimester or whatever.
01:03:44 You know, like, the government can't develop, grow,
01:03:46 institute policies, have people in charge of departments
01:03:49 that can do the really sensible, boring stuff
01:03:52 and kind of turn departments around.
01:03:55 If you think about the success stories in British politics
01:03:58 over the time we're talking about,
01:04:00 they tend to be where someone stuck around for a bit in a job.
01:04:03 You know, while Michael Gove was in charge of education,
01:04:05 you know there was there was there was the possibility of serious reform slow reform but
01:04:09 what we're about to see in the uk is you change change the i mean already the health secretary
01:04:15 where street and quit having actually started to make slow progress on on the big problems of the
01:04:20 nhs and then quit because of factional politics within the party and so now someone else will
01:04:25 come in and it all starts again so so these constant restarting the variance that's in the
01:04:30 politics is a is now a central part of the problem and it shouldn't be at the moment because in the
01:04:37 uk you have a government which was elected with a gigantic parliamentary majority fume is a
01:04:45 flavored air device designed to help people quit vaping and smoking by breaking the hand-to-mouth
01:04:50 pattern it's simple natural and honestly kind of genius no nicotine no batteries no vapor
01:04:56 just weighted, twisty, fidget-friendly tool that gives your hands something better to reach for
01:05:02 when cravings show up. I used to be the person standing outside in the cold telling myself I'd
01:05:07 quit next week. You know exactly what I mean. You want to stop. You intend to stop, but you've got
01:05:13 nothing to replace the habit with. If that sounds familiar, pay attention. The thing that changed
01:05:19 things for me was having something to reach for in those moments. I've noticed that when the urge
01:05:24 shows up. Using fume interrupts the loop instead of letting it spiral. That's a difference. You're
01:05:29 not just trying to stop a habit, you're redirecting it. The flavors are intentionally lighter than
01:05:35 vaping. Think flavored water compared to soda. Crisp mint is the strongest option and suits
01:05:40 heavier users. Raspberry is tangy and slightly sweet. Don't just try to quit. Upgrade the habit
01:05:46 loop. Fume has already helped over 700,000 people take steps towards better habits. Use code
01:05:53 Trig to get a free gift with your journey pack. Head to Trifume.com and use code Trig.
01:06:01 That site again is T-R-Y-F-U-M.com and use code Trig to claim your free gift today.
01:06:09 Yeah, I'm in two minds about all of those points because on the last point, yes, it's true they got
01:06:14 a massive majority, but they only got it because reform destroyed the Conservative Party, my
01:06:19 subjective opinion. And then on the other stuff, I mean, the toxicity of politics is something that
01:06:24 I think everyone is really concerned about. But I also think, I imagine someone else sitting here
01:06:29 making the opposite argument and saying the toxicity of politics is the consequence of the
01:06:34 fact of where the country's at. And then, of course, you add the technological piece on top
01:06:40 of that, which is we now, I mean, I've given this example a thousand times, but I really do think
01:06:45 It just explains everything.
01:06:48 On YouTube, I was many years ago sitting later than I watching YouTube
01:06:52 because I didn't have kids then.
01:06:53 Oh, you'll soon be doing that, but you'll be watching Cocoa Mellon with him.
01:06:57 Well, what I was watching was William Hague and John Prescott
01:07:00 having a parliamentary debate when they were both deputy to the leader.
01:07:06 And it's a game.
01:07:07 It's a playful game because the social media isn't there.
01:07:12 They're not trying to get a hit on TV yet quite.
01:07:16 So William Hague takes the piss out of John Prescott basically not being able to speak
01:07:20 properly.
01:07:21 And John Prescott doesn't say, look at these snobby Tories abusing the hard work and working 0.51
01:07:27 classes.
01:07:28 He says, on this side of the house, we may get the words wrong, but we get the judgment 0.61
01:07:31 right.
01:07:32 In other words, it's a game that's played according to a set of respectful rules, even
01:07:35 if the parties are, they're not enemies, they're opponents, right?
01:07:39 and then you have technology like we have now,
01:07:42 which changes that completely.
01:07:43 And now everyone stands up in Parliament
01:07:45 so that they get a clip on Twitter or on whatever.
01:07:50 And I think that's why it's...
01:07:53 I hear and agree with people when they say politics is toxic,
01:07:57 but then I kind of go, well, A, you've got the technological piece, 0.61
01:08:02 and then the country is kind of f***ed, 0.87
01:08:04 and you have to unf*** it for people to become untoxic about it. 0.98
01:08:07 I think we probably agree.
01:08:08 I mean, I think that the part of the toxicity of politics is that it's now optimising for a different set of media.
01:08:15 And just as, I mean, Haig and Prescott in the example you've given were probably somewhat, somewhere, maybe optimising for the parliamentary sketch writers up in the gallery.
01:08:26 That's right.
01:08:26 And maybe a bit on the news, but who knows.
01:08:31 Whereas now it would all have been thinking about optimising for a totally different media, which rewards a totally different style of thing.
01:08:37 And the obsession, that obsession with optimizing for social media, for all sorts of reasons, one of which is it gives you like definable metrics, which, you know, it's jobs worthiness.
01:08:52 that's part of the poison
01:08:54 part of the
01:08:57 reason why it's incredibly
01:08:59 hard for anyone to actually do anything
01:09:01 in politics
01:09:03 because all the front line politicians
01:09:05 are just thinking about how this is going to
01:09:07 clip up for Instagram
01:09:08 you have behind the scenes
01:09:11 the blob
01:09:13 as it's often called
01:09:15 but a civil service which is
01:09:16 dominated by a completely different set of thinking
01:09:19 and knows it can just dig its heels in
01:09:21 and not be bid and can run a completely different set of policies
01:09:25 and vanishing and then you plug in the lack of appeal
01:09:31 of a political career to really elite, forceful thinkers.
01:09:37 I mean, there are tons of problems with politics at the moment
01:09:40 and to sort of plug this into the great man theory,
01:09:45 one of the superficially appealing, but I think probably troubling trends that I hear a lot is
01:09:59 people saying, well, what we need is a benign dictator. Because they're so disillusioned with
01:10:03 the failure of political process that they want an easy answer. They want, okay, well, give me a
01:10:08 great man. Give me somebody who's going to come in and just ride roughshod over process.
01:10:15 that's part of the appeal of of trump this you know this outsider who rides into politics and
01:10:22 it's part of the appeal of farage as well he said i'm gonna you know i'm outside all this i don't
01:10:26 deal with all this i just come in and speak straight sense and we get on with it well yes to
01:10:32 an extent but um do we even need to rehearse the dangers of creating dictatorship maybe we do
01:10:44 Maybe that's another part of what we're grappling with at the moment is the receding out of living memory of the 1930s and 40s and the 20s, for that matter.
01:11:00 the sort of the disappearance into sort of abstraction of what was the what was the world
01:11:05 like last time that there was you know it's that all the international kind of institutions were
01:11:12 sort of discarded and you know the falling into spheres of interest became the the way that
01:11:19 politics well what what was it actually like what happened that's now something that's in
01:11:24 the history books to which most people let's be honest don't pay attention my grandma died
01:11:29 earlier this year at nearly the age of 100
01:11:32 and when my mum was clearing out her house
01:11:34 she found the handwritten war memories.
01:11:37 My grandfather, who'd been 15 or 16 years old
01:11:40 when he went to sea with the Merchant Navy
01:11:41 in the Second World War, the outbreak of the Second World War.
01:11:44 12 or 14 pages.
01:11:46 And this is memories of sailing around the Atlantic.
01:11:48 I mean, we sailed around the whole world
01:11:50 in the Merchant Navy being pursued by U-boats,
01:11:53 blown up in the Thames by German mines, survived that.
01:11:56 You know, all sorts of adventures.
01:11:57 and I remember him telling not not telling many of those stories but I remember him I remember him
01:12:05 as being somebody who still who's and my grandmother both my grandmothers spoke about
01:12:12 the second world war and it was within it was not within my memory it was not within my parents
01:12:16 memory but it was in our family's memory everybody knew somebody who'd served or been affected by the
01:12:21 second world war who'd been affected by this set of um of disastrous political unravelings
01:12:29 that the whole of the post-war settlement was designed to mitigate against happening again
01:12:35 and now all of that how many you know vanishingly few veterans left and most most nobody knows one
01:12:42 so all of that has receded and it's like that settlement is clearly you know looking pretty
01:12:50 tattie and there needs to be a new one for a new world with new technologies and new modes of
01:12:56 thought. However, to lean back on things that were tried and tested to destruction in the 30s and 40s.
01:13:08 No, I definitely agree with you that that sentiment is rising. I'm not sure I quite
01:13:11 agree that Farage is attempting to be a dictator. No, I don't agree with that either. But I agree
01:13:16 that part of his appeal is being the outsider.
01:13:20 Let me be really clear.
01:13:21 I don't think Farage has those dictatorial instincts.
01:13:25 In fact, I think he actively doesn't.
01:13:26 Quite the opposite, I agree.
01:13:28 But I think that his appeal is that he seems to be,
01:13:33 you know, if I go down to the pub,
01:13:36 not many people talk about reform policies,
01:13:41 but they know Nigel, like Nigel.
01:13:43 It's Nigel.
01:13:44 and it's this idea that there's a guy out there
01:13:47 who gets it, put him in charge, that'll do.
01:13:52 Now, I don't know that it will do.
01:13:55 We'll find out.
01:13:57 We will probably find out.
01:13:59 We'll probably find out.
01:14:00 Sorry, were you going to jump in?
01:14:01 No, because I was going to say that
01:14:04 reading your book about the Plantagenets,
01:14:08 it just opened my eyes to strong and weak leadership.
01:14:12 Yeah.
01:14:12 And I look at Keir Starmer and what's happening with the West Streetings of the world and his ministers, and it just reminds me of Edward II and the nobles.
01:14:23 Let's hope he doesn't end up the same way.
01:14:27 The way that read was quite brutal.
01:14:30 I've never thought about, for all that Keir Starmer is a wanker, I've never thought about him as Edward II.
01:14:36 But I'll say this, the effective leaders are the Edward III's who understand how to bring people with them and who are able to galvanize and empower people around them.
01:14:51 I don't necessarily think that that's the leadership that we've got at the moment.
01:14:55 and the key to whoever is the leader
01:15:01 that stands a chance of really delivering
01:15:05 some meaningful change in this country
01:15:07 will be somebody who has the strength of character
01:15:10 to bring a strong team along with them
01:15:14 and if not to do the serious thinking themselves,
01:15:20 to have that among them.
01:15:21 I know you're going to talk to my old pal David Starkey
01:15:24 soon enough and that's some of the thinking he's doing right at the moment um you know the the
01:15:29 awareness that it's it's quite likely that the next but one leader of this country or next but
01:15:36 two or whatever after the next general election will be Nigel Farage not unimaginable at all
01:15:42 um the work has to be in place for that there's a moral responsibility for the work to be in place
01:15:49 to make that a serious government,
01:15:51 a serious government with serious thought running through
01:15:54 and a serious analysis and a clearly explained
01:15:59 and defined set of policies that go beyond the personality.
01:16:05 Because the strong leadership thing,
01:16:09 a lot of that is vested in personality,
01:16:10 but personality is just not enough.
01:16:13 Personality has to come along with
01:16:15 and be able to be a vehicle to articulate policy.
01:16:20 Yeah, no, that's completely true.
01:16:22 And from your lips to God's ears,
01:16:23 and frankly, whoever is elected,
01:16:25 I would hope that is all true, right?
01:16:27 Whether it's Frank Polanski or Nigel Farage.
01:16:30 Final question is always the same.
01:16:32 What's the one thing that we're not talking about?
01:16:34 We really should be.
01:16:36 What's the one thing we're not talking about
01:16:38 that we really should be?
01:16:40 Castles.
01:16:41 I never...
01:16:41 I genuinely love a castle.
01:16:44 I'm glad you love a castle.
01:16:45 I love a castle as well, and we were talking before we came on
01:16:48 that there was a piece of YouGov research done in 2024
01:16:51 that said 77% of people think castles are the best thing
01:16:56 in the whole of the Middle Ages, and I would count myself among them.
01:17:00 You've written a book about them.
01:17:01 I've written a book about them.
01:17:02 It's castles in the biggest, broadest sense.
01:17:05 3,000 years of history goes from the Bronze Age.
01:17:07 The origins of castles starts with Troy, the citadel,
01:17:12 siege of the wars, not only the birth
01:17:14 of what becomes castles, but the birth of Western
01:17:16 literature. It charts its way all the way
01:17:18 through to nuclear bunkers. So it's like, it's the
01:17:20 big, it's the big history
01:17:22 of, it's the history
01:17:24 of structures, but it also asks a kind of
01:17:26 deeper question, which is
01:17:27 how do we protect the things that we love
01:17:29 and care about? Wonderful. Well, I
01:17:32 haven't had a chance to read it, but I definitely
01:17:34 look forward to it. Thanks, man. Thanks for coming
01:17:36 back on. Pleasure. Head on over
01:17:38 to triggerpod.co.uk where
01:17:40 Dan's going to answer your questions.
01:17:42 How much were common soldiers paid, if you're a longbowman in the English army, let's say,
01:17:47 how much would you be paid, or was the promise of loot your only reward?
01:18:12 We'll be right back.