00:01:00.000The Odyssey and How the Culture War Broke Everyone's Brain
00:01:03.320For the last few days, I've been watching an unfolding debate about Christopher Nolan's
00:01:11.920movie adaptation of The Odyssey on social media. I say debate, but in reality, it's mainly people
00:01:18.880delivering fairly predictable takes based on their pre-existing views and cultural affiliations,
00:01:24.540rather than engaging with each other's arguments. Those who opposed DEI were outraged
00:01:29.860by the woke casting decisions whereby Elliot Page, formerly known as Ellen Page, was chosen to play
00:01:36.440Sinon, an Ithacan warrior, while the roles of Helen and her sister Clytemnestra are both played
00:01:42.220by Lupita Nyong'o, who is black. In response to this news, Elon Musk declared that Nolan had
00:01:47.580desecrated the epic long before the movie was even released. Others who think representation
00:01:53.100in entertainment is the most important thing since Gaza, about which most of them are now0.84
00:01:57.400conveniently forgotten, obviously thought the casting was a triumph. It is pride season after
00:02:02.660all, and as we all know, the ancient Greeks did have an affinity for at least some sections of
00:02:07.020the LGBTQ community. Much of the response to the movie has been expressed in explicitly political
00:02:12.740terms, which seems to me to say a lot more about the times we live in than the movie itself. Sure,
00:02:18.200having a small friend-looking trans man play the role of a warrior doesn't look credible on paper,0.63
00:02:22.920But this is negated by both the role in the story and the fact that we are mercifully spared a violation of our voluntary suspension of disbelief
00:02:31.920by the fact that Page's character does not go around destroying Trojan warriors by the dozen with the viciousness only artificial testosterone can deliver.
00:02:42.400Nor are we taken out of the story to be educated about how the ancient Greeks really were that dogmatic about the idea that trans men are men.
00:02:50.560Page just plays a minor male part well.