True Patriot Love - November 19, 2026


[Best of TPL] Canada Has the Oil. So Why Are We Falling Behind? ft. Morgan Downey

Carney’s China Gamble: Did Canada Blow Its LNG Chance?

Episode Stats


Length

9 minutes

Words per minute

163.21

Word count

1,512

Sentence count

36

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Morgan Downey is Irish-born and based in New York City and the author of a great book called
00:00:05 Oil 101. Today on TPL Media, we're lucky enough to have Morgan Downey. He's the founder and CEO
00:00:12 of Boxwood, a hedge fund booking system of commodities. He's held the desk at major
00:00:19 trading companies of commodities such as Bloomberg, Citibank. Today, outspoken, always friendly,
00:00:27 nice to listen to but very blunt about the situation of canadians oil and gas industry
00:00:32 we're lucky enough to have him on tpl media so stay tuned and enjoy the show
00:00:41 morgan downey thanks for taking the time this morning really appreciate you coming aboard
00:00:46 thank you paul great to be here so um you know i really wanted to talk to you know you're you're
00:00:52 an author of oil 101 uh you traded you know you've done commodities trading in your new york
00:00:59 most of your career from what i can see irish born uh went to new york uh you know cut your teeth uh
00:01:05 with with many trading houses ran the the desk at bloomberg um so you know i really wanted to pick
00:01:13 your brain today about canada because it's interesting i mean you and i started before
00:01:18 the show and having a conversation about canada and you know who we are as a nation and um you
00:01:24 know oil is such a big part of who we are we we talk about it we very proud of it um you know we
00:01:32 fight about it we have referendums over it you know we want to separate over it uh it's the topic
00:01:38 of the town it's a talk of every city in canada um but yet we don't understand it very well so
00:01:45 So it's interesting. Before I started doing this TPL Media and started this podcast, I wasn't very knowledgeable and I'm still learning.
00:01:53 Every day I learn more and more about it. But it's interesting because we are relying on it.
00:02:01 We understand that, you know, back in the 80s, we basically oil was the only thing that pulled us through the collapse of the country.
00:02:09 we were we were we were in really bad shape we we lent heavily on alberta to kind of drag us
00:02:15 through a bad time in our economy um and then we got to 2015 all of a sudden we thought okay great
00:02:23 we have a new government justin trudeau trudeau got in you know the prime minister of canada the
00:02:29 liberal government we had 10 years of we didn't like oil anymore we you know we were going to go
00:02:34 away from we really were going to go to we were going to go to electrify we basically doubled up
00:02:41 our federal debt we went from one trillion to two over two trillion in federal debt our productivity
00:02:48 levels fell we are number five uh per capita and total debt uh to gdp uh we we exceeded a hundred
00:02:56 percent so a lot of things happened to us in that decade and now you know new prime minister
00:03:03 uh trying to figure out a new strategy on energy policy trying to figure out what to do with the
00:03:08 war in iran but i really today wanted to talk to you about how does the rest of the world see
00:03:15 canada because it's interesting we see it from our lens and sometimes you can be myopic how does
00:03:21 the rest of the world see canada yeah that's a very interesting way of looking at it because
00:03:25 oil has kind of, it does define certain economies. I mean, an example is Norway, kind of Norway
00:03:35 as an economy has been, I mean, they've done things to kind of make them less a single
00:03:42 industry with oil. They've got that offshore, that fund, strategic investment fund. But Canada
00:03:53 has actually been defined quite a lot by oil, especially, you know, even this year when we had
00:03:59 Maduro and Venezuela, you know, there were a lot of kind of misconceptions about Venezuelan oil
00:04:05 put out there in January of 2026 of this year. And one of the biggest things that I thought was
00:04:12 kind of interesting was that, you know, it was seen as kind of a direct competitor to Canada,
00:04:16 that the US was kind of divorcing, if you will, energy-wise Canada and was marrying a new South
00:04:22 American energy partner Venezuela and it was good but it was kind of an interesting thing I
00:04:28 kind of I didn't realize you know because when you're outside of Canada you don't realize that
00:04:31 how kind of people inside Canada were kind of a little bit miffed by that it was kind of an
00:04:36 interesting kind of thing but I think how the world sees Canada from a trading desk people see
00:04:41 Canada as a reliable very large supplier you know almost six million barrels per day of heavy crude
00:04:48 which for most of its history has only been has had to sell to one customer the united states
00:04:55 and that's why you know canada has had to kind of when you've got no competition in customers
00:05:00 you tend to get not that great pricing so you've had to sell at a discount to the u.s for years
00:05:06 and trans mountain was the first real second customer and potentially asia so from the trading
00:05:13 desk the commodities trading desk people see canada as being a non-controversial supplier of
00:05:19 energy which is great from a trading desk because it just quietly hums around long kind of baseload
00:05:25 supplier no no kind of you're not going to wake up in the morning and see headlines canada is
00:05:30 threatening to shut down you know us supply or or constrain it it's a very reliable supplier which
00:05:36 is a very important thing for buyers and Canada itself. From Asia, China especially's perspective,
00:05:47 Canada is a new seller. More than 65% of the tankers loaded at the Trans Mountain
00:05:53 Terminal since May 2024 went to Asia and China has become the largest buyer.
00:05:59 So Asia looks at Canada as being, you know, I don't think Asia really wants to get involved
00:06:04 Canadian politics or Canadian any controversy necessarily. China and Asia just want cheap 0.90
00:06:10 crude, cheap energy, as cheap as possible. So I think it's a very pragmatic, non-ideological
00:06:17 relationship. So Asia looks at Canada as being a relatively, in the same way the US looks at,
00:06:25 a relatively stable uh provider of of and a new provider of energy um from europe um canada is
00:06:34 seen as kind of a a country with a lot of nat gas but no just like the us no way to ship it across
00:06:40 the atlantic when needed when it was needed in 2022 there's still no lng liquefied nat gas
00:06:47 export terminal on the east coast of canada which there should be because uh going forward over time
00:06:54 And that's going to be a not just economically important, but strategically important exit route for Canada to have to sell LNG, liquefied net gas to Europe.
00:07:05 So Europe kind of looks at Canada as a potential.
00:07:08 So you've got the trading desk in the US looks at it as a stable current provider.
00:07:12 Asia looks at Canada as being a kind of a new provider of energy, also stable.
00:07:18 Europe looks at the potential of Canada in the future, if Canada does build and hopefully will build an LNG export terminal on the East Coast.
00:07:26 And on uranium, it's a top two producer from Saskatchewan's Athabasca Basin with reactor technology at home.
00:07:39 You've got a small modular reactors at Darlington, the Can-Do SMR.
00:07:45 So it's kind of looked at as being not just an important, important on the oil side, but also potentially a nat gas and nuclear on the uranium side.
00:07:54 So I think that Canada has been in a good way viewed as being very stable.
00:08:01 The view from the world has been viewed as being very stable, but is kind of now becoming more non-US looking, looking to China for Asia,
00:08:13 looking to Europe potentially for LNG exports.
00:08:16 I think it's becoming a lot more dynamic, I guess,
00:08:19 or as a kind of a potential source of international influence.
00:08:24 So Canada has been one-dimensional
00:08:26 until the last three or four years, five years.
00:08:30 Now it's becoming kind of multi,
00:08:32 kind of like in strategic terms, multi-polar.
00:08:35 You've got now Canada, China, the US, and Europe,
00:08:38 which is great because Canada can hopefully
00:08:40 try and play those a little bit off against each other a very quick favor before we continue a
00:08:47 large percentage of you who watch or listen to tpl media every week aren't subscribed yet our
00:08:54 simple commitment to you is that if you find value there if these discussions make you think
00:09:00 if you want our uncensored debates deeper dives and extended sit downs head over to tplmedia.ca
00:09:06 and subscribe there directly.
00:09:09 It takes just five seconds, costs nothing, keeps you informed.
00:09:13 So thank you.
00:09:14 Now back to the show.