True Patriot Love - May 23, 2026


Has Canada Outsourced Its Government to Consultants?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Canada & The World Happiness Report ft. John Helliwell Is Victimhood Tearing Society Apart? ft. Mark Milke

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

178.37

Word count

7,712

Sentence count

302

Harmful content

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we talk about the growing role of consultants in Canada, and why they re a problem, and what they can do to fix it. We also talk about why it s a good thing that Canada outsourced government.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Canada has built an entire political culture around one strange assumption that elected
00:00:05 officials are somehow experts. They're not. The minister of health usually isn't a doctor. The
00:00:10 minister of defense often never served. The immigration minister may never have worked
00:00:14 the border. Yet somehow we pretend these people are qualified to manage multi-trillion dollar
00:00:20 systems because they won an election. So what happens? Quietly behind the scenes,
00:00:25 the country is increasingly being run by consultants. McKinsey, Deloitte, Accenture,
00:00:30 KPMG, outside experts writing policy, frameworks, restructuring departments,
00:00:36 building digital systems, even advising government on how government itself should function.
00:00:41 And maybe the real question isn't whether there are too many consultants. Maybe the real question
00:00:46 is whether there are not enough. Because if politicians are essentially temporary brand
00:00:52 ambassadors rotating through ministries they barely understand, then who actually has the
00:00:56 expertise to run a modern country? Career consultants, technocrats, specialists, data
00:01:03 analysts, former industry leaders? We're told consultants are the problem, but what if consultants
00:01:08 are actually the symptom? The symptom of a political system that increasingly rewards
00:01:12 optics over competence. This time on TPL Media, has Canada outsourced government because government
00:01:18 no longer knows how to govern itself or should experts, not politicians, play an even larger role in running the country?
00:01:30 Okay, the question is, is Ottawa outsourcing expertise, accountability, and even decision-making,
00:01:36 and do we even know what they're up to? Paul Micucci, thanks for having this discussion with me.
00:01:40 Yeah, thanks, Mike. Definitely.
00:01:43 Okay, the answer is yes.
00:01:45 So, consulting fees last year, $23.1 billion.
00:01:49 Yep.
00:01:50 $20 billion, right?
00:01:53 So, if you look at it.
00:01:54 That's pretty significant, yes.
00:01:55 Yeah, that's a lot, right?
00:01:57 So, really, what we've done is, whether it be systems, whether it be consulting, any major industry right now or ministry has a consulting team side by side with that minister or that bureaucratic team.
00:02:13 Now, for those of you, a lot of us know politics and we know politics in Canada was set up to basically the premise of parliamentary politics is to have the bureaucracy basically not fight, but to provide the tension against the government or the political people in the counterbalance, if you will.
00:02:33 Our counterbalance in parliamentary politics is supposed to be that.
00:02:37 And the state ongoing knowledge in the government is supposed to sit with the bureaucrats.
00:02:43 So they're supposed to be your ongoing mainstay.
00:02:45 So regardless of the policies of the government, which change off and on, there's supposed to be a counterbalance fight that maintains the state of the direction of the country for the good of the country.
00:02:59 And that's why the counterbalance between bureaucracy and politics exists.
00:03:03 Well, okay. So then you and I have this discussion, good or bad, indifferent. Well,
00:03:10 you know, what is $24 billion going out the door? And that was annually, I think you said,
00:03:16 is that correct?
00:03:17 Yeah, that's the annual number.
00:03:18 So over the course of the term of a government that hangs in for four years, you know, you're
00:03:23 looking at a pretty significant number there, you know?
00:03:27 Now can I add just a couple of things, Mike, on that? That doesn't include IT services.
00:03:31 It doesn't include what they call management, consultant, engineering, or temporary help.
00:03:38 Well, and it's interesting that you say that because on the top list, governments increasingly rely on outside firms for, when I did my research, IT, digital transformation, procurement, HR, cybersecurity, data analysis.
00:03:53 All of this is outside of that budget, you're saying?
00:03:56 Yes.
00:03:56 That's another $12-ish billion on top of the $23 billion.
00:04:01 and then you add a couple more billion for consulting you know we all know the the liberal
00:04:08 famous consulting contracts that went out which became justin trudeau's probably then one of the
00:04:14 key factors to his demise was you know going through that and then um you know the temporary
00:04:20 outsourcing just for jobs i think a lot okay so now you take a look at this and the critics will
00:04:26 say, okay, this kind of consulting creates a dependency ongoing. And I think that's obviously
00:04:33 illustrated. I can tell you that the names of the top six consulting firms, and we all know the
00:04:41 names. It's the KPMGs of the world, IBMs, Pricewaterhouse, Coopers, all of these big name
00:04:47 companies and consulting firms, of course, are big ticket winners of these contracts.
00:04:54 It reduces in-house expertise to some degree, the critics will say.
00:04:59 The critics will say it weakens accountability because there's no, you know, it's tough.
00:05:04 And we've seen this time and time again that when they try to, the government tried to remove $500 million from the budget, as I recall, on consulting fees.
00:05:12 But the problem was they didn't have the accounting backup to actually find where they could save that money.
00:05:18 So I do remember that.
00:05:19 And then the other thing that creates a problem, the critics will say, is it's a revolving door influence.
00:05:26 In other words, whatever consulting firms in there at the day will have an influence based on their other client base and so on and so forth.
00:05:34 I think those are all fair.
00:05:36 And I think that we've seen this illustrated.
00:05:38 But may I offer a counterpoint to this, to the critics?
00:05:42 Yeah.
00:05:43 Okay. 0.79
00:05:43 Shoot.
00:05:44 I can name seven or eight members of parliament that have ministerial positions in our cabinet 0.89
00:05:51 that have no idea what they're doing.
00:05:53 I mean, I could start to point fingers at our safety and immigration and resources.
00:05:59 These are individuals that really have no expertise.
00:06:02 And so I say to you, no, I don't want to reduce consultancy.
00:06:06 I want to increase it.
00:06:08 Okay. I would like to see it be the majority of the expertise that runs our government because I
00:06:15 don't want non-experts that come in and MPs will say this, Paul, I've said it to you. They feel
00:06:21 like they're drinking from a fire hose for the first six months that they're there. They finally
00:06:25 settle in, you know, coming around in a year and what happens to them? They get moved to another
00:06:30 post or they get demoted and they end up a backbencher. What good is that to anybody? What
00:06:36 I think is, and I don't know that it's been done, but if there's a rupture in the system
00:06:42 of accountability, let's handle that. Okay. First and foremost, let's create a system
00:06:47 that is so ironclad that as a consultant, almost to the point of a citizen looking it up,
00:06:54 we can see what you're getting paid for. And then let's run our government on the basis of
00:07:00 what the politicians say they'll do with the consultants. Lay out your consultant plan for
00:07:06 me if we're spending okay if we're spending north of 200 billion dollars on consultants while you're
00:07:12 in office show me your consultant firms show me what they're doing show me the experts that are
00:07:16 on the on the payroll there and and and look i'll take your newsletter every six months with what
00:07:22 the experts are reporting back but let's put experts in and not politicians all right so you
00:07:29 i get where you're going you're you're saying to solve the challenge is to actually start to vote
00:07:34 not only for the politician but his list of consultants yeah so you're you're basically
00:07:39 saying what they'll do with them not even just a list but this can we're going to bring consultants
00:07:42 in from this firm that do this at this price right wow okay well that's interesting so a
00:07:48 couple things i just want to back up because i think um this has been a major problem going on
00:07:53 for decades right i think we both agree this has been something that we've seen the increase in
00:07:58 consulting costs i even was one of them quite frankly we used to sit around i i remember sitting
00:08:04 around the table at one of the big consulting companies and we used to say, okay, what projects
00:08:08 are we going to put together? And we used to come up with these crazy buzzwords for projects that
00:08:12 we could actually sell to the government, sell to the private sector. We would go out with a
00:08:17 marketing firm, we would package them, we'd go to them and we, you know, whether it be a Y2K or
00:08:23 whatever, and we would actually create whole programs that we could outsource and sell
00:08:28 to government agencies. I can see these meetings now. Guys, I've got this idea. Now it's a crazy
00:08:32 acronym is called EBITDA oh yeah no no but we would do pitches yeah so then we they would they
00:08:38 would take us and they would uh we would get trained to pitch and they'd be pitch teams they
00:08:44 would go in and they'd pitch projects to the government and to private sector based on where
00:08:48 we were going and and you know interesting idea um and it was because in those days government was so
00:08:55 poorly paid so ministers were so poorly paid so one of the things that we kind of filled in the
00:09:01 the gap when this really took off and this was uh crepes i'm aging myself but this was in maybe the
00:09:07 late 80s early 90s this really kind of became the craze because governments were finding there was
00:09:12 a brain drain there wasn't enough people that they could pull into government that had the
00:09:17 the wherewithal to run these crazy projects that we were pitching and they were crazy projects and
00:09:23 there were some smart guys like i'm not saying the guys around me were brilliant some of them
00:09:27 on the consulting side and they really did have skill sets the government couldn't replace right
00:09:32 but now over the last you know few decades every year we see politicians coming in and they say
00:09:39 okay let's give ourselves a 10 raise let's give ourselves a 20 raise so now we did a show recently
00:09:45 i was shocked how much at the municipal provincial and federal level that a politician makes oh it's
00:09:53 a good paycheck oh yeah so now you know it's interesting i'm just gonna uh i did a an article
00:09:59 in a newspaper in mississauga recently and i did uh on what they make uh mayor makes 300 plus
00:10:07 thousand uh the counselors if they're you know on the peel board and also on the board the mayor
00:10:13 makes 300 000 plus dollars per year yes just wanted to unders underscore that it's you know
00:10:20 how many people run for mayor it's not a huge group the voting base is not huge and we hand
00:10:25 over three hundred thousand dollars and often the mayor mayor scar pity for example i mean he's built
00:10:30 an empire by the sounds of the highest paid mayor in canada i think at this point we're well above
00:10:35 the 300 and and then you have uh counselors making 200 plus so say 230 so now you know you're getting
00:10:43 into the point where everyone's so now so the consultants and the politicians are in the same
00:10:48 snack bracket uh they are now i'll be totally transparent if you're a highly performing
00:10:55 consultant like that and you're at the senior management senior management level or partner
00:11:01 level you're making double or more than that you're doing really well so if you catch a like
00:11:06 in in my career um i was on the first bond offering for the greater toronto airports authority
00:11:12 i was the acting cfo of the gtaa at that time it was very interesting gig i did very well by it
00:11:20 quite frankly it was a you know it was a good gig quite frankly we got the project going
00:11:26 you know it was a whole political shuffle and then one day we were just given the airport
00:11:32 and then we had to restart rebuilding it with new terminals and everything so
00:11:35 if you're if you're a good performing and you're a lucky consultant and you get on the right
00:11:40 projects, you can bonus really well. So, so the consulting teams do really well. The political
00:11:47 teams are starting, you know, they're getting up there. They were really lowly paid. Like I said,
00:11:52 now they're getting up into the decent zone. So now we should start to put the onus on not only
00:11:59 the voters, but the politicians to be up to speed on a file. So, you know, like a consultant. So if
00:12:06 you've, you know, I give you more money. I say, here's more money. You need to be there.
00:12:10 You need to be there now. So I guess the, the old, you know, you mentioned, I've heard it a
00:12:16 million times. I'm drinking out of a fire hose. Yeah. No, no, I'm paying you to drink from the
00:12:21 fire hose. Drink, drink, drink, drink quickly. Yeah. Right. Cause that's why you're starting
00:12:25 to get paid so much. So, you know, that's a, I just wanted to go back and know, but I,
00:12:29 and I agree with that point entirely. Yeah. Uh, I do, I do see consultancy firms as fat cats to
00:12:35 some degree oh yeah but you know we rely on them I guess for for the expertise that's not there
00:12:41 what I think is concerning to me is the lack of transparency that comes with consulting so I would
00:12:46 almost rather and I of course I've had a wackadoodle idea here potentially but the the mission
00:12:53 behind it and the sentiment behind it is probably consistent with many Canadians which is okay if
00:12:59 you're going to do something at least let us see behind the curtain what you're doing right because
00:13:04 it would be better for all of us you would probably get better support from people we would
00:13:10 see that you're employing people yeah you know what i mean i i really think that the other thing
00:13:16 is if i was a politician i would want this i would want this because i would constantly be
00:13:20 able to blame the consultants well you know the consultants yeah sure you know it gives you a
00:13:27 safety net. Yeah. But you're being, I guess, in the, you know, our government is voted in not for
00:13:35 safety nets. It's voted in to make decisions. So the more consultants we hire, the less we're,
00:13:41 you know, they can go back and say that we were advised to do this. Well, we have, and I just
00:13:47 checked before I came into the show, we have 448,000 approximate public service members.
00:13:52 Okay. So, you know, half a million people in public service. We had a lot of smart people
00:13:58 in public service. Right. And again, that tug and pull is supposed to be between government
00:14:02 and bureaucracy. That's, that's what keeps us on a straight and narrow path in the parliamentary
00:14:07 political system that we're in today. We have to have that tug and pull now. And as you point out,
00:14:12 government jobs are paying better at the consultancy and executive level. Sure. Now,
00:14:16 Now, you know, if you look at and I've done this and math before I've done the calculation, if you look at like and when I was a consultant, great gig, I paid into a benefit plan that was set up and there was a match to the benefit plan and everything else.
00:14:33 If you look at a government pension plan, your argument that you're not making as much money as the consulting team is a misnomer, to tell you the truth.
00:14:47 So if your average age is, say you live to 80, quite frankly, you retire at 60-something because you factored out.
00:14:55 Government workers traditionally factor out at three times the average of three times their last salary, times a factor.
00:15:02 I've watched it in my own family.
00:15:03 So if you, you basically get a factor 80, so you get, uh, you know, 80% of your last average three
00:15:10 years. If you go out at 200,000, you're making 160,000 in your retirement plus a full benefit
00:15:16 package. Your total package lifetime is, is pretty damn good and pretty close to probably
00:15:22 what that consultant who's making more money at the beginning. So the argument now that
00:15:27 we don't have enough skilled, I think all those arguments back in the nineties and late eighties
00:15:32 were good arguments i think we passed those and i know we passed them because when you do the
00:15:37 calculation of what everyone makes now i don't think you can actually have those discussions
00:15:42 anymore politicians make too much it has to be commensurate right to some degree you get nobody
00:15:47 or you get the worst right right the brain drain draws everybody away yeah yeah well what's uh
00:15:54 sevens higher fives right yeah so even what you do is you start to get a bunch of people inside
00:15:59 government to hire people less talented than themselves. Sevens hire fives is the name of
00:16:03 this episode, Brady. Let's write that down. I like that. So, so now, okay, let's walk through
00:16:09 your scenario. So you go out and it's election time. Yeah. You come to the table and you, you
00:16:15 know, my name's Bill, I'm running for ward, whatever seat. Um, you know, I'm going to run
00:16:21 with uh abc efg company because i want to be the minister of housing and they have the most skill
00:16:31 sets okay you okay at the basic level yeah but i would hope that they would be like yeah here's
00:16:38 the projects that i want to address right and here are the consultants associated and here's
00:16:42 what they're already giving me estimates right okay okay that does sound a little crazy now that
00:16:48 i've said it out loud i understand but that that is my but it isn't very interesting because if
00:16:53 you're if you are using consultants to this extent to run your government you are really voting for
00:17:02 that group like i understand where you're going i do i it does so it's so funny but yes that's
00:17:09 what i would prefer yeah i don't know why i've given up on the i'm so sorry i guess what i'm
00:17:14 saying is i've given up on that political front right but okay so then um a little bit of a
00:17:24 challenge and i think you you hit on it at the beginning of this show the memory of your
00:17:29 government erodes yeah the you know the basically that tug and pull i talked about the why things
00:17:38 were done the direction of the government the the the history will start to erode because now
00:17:44 you're actually replacing it with a third party a third party which quite frankly might have you
00:17:51 know we did for example the consulting firm I worked for we did projects across the world so
00:17:57 we had like team members in Africa Egypt you know part of how I ended up getting into the you know
00:18:06 the business I did when I was a young man was I went on a consulting gig in the U.S. and I ended
00:18:13 up falling in love with an industry and that's how i started but you know the problem was those
00:18:20 companies are far and wide and they have a lot of objectives they look at a global scenario so when
00:18:26 we used to go to our annual meetings we didn't look at canada we didn't look at the u.s we didn't
00:18:30 look we looked at the globe it was really and for a young man it was really interesting because we
00:18:34 used to have our annual conference when they became a senior manager and they used to fly us
00:18:39 to all these crazy over to europe and we go to england we you know go to paris and maybe all
00:18:45 different for the for the annual conferences and they would they would have um business leaders
00:18:50 from the organization across the world wow and they would talk about how they globally saw the
00:18:55 world these consulting firms they didn't talk about specifically and then we'd have we'd have
00:19:00 a canadian arm and off we go so you have to remember is the world is being controlled they're
00:19:07 They're a big part of the strategy for the world for different governments.
00:19:12 And I think sometimes we don't think about that, right?
00:19:14 That is true.
00:19:15 Yeah.
00:19:16 Now, is that a benefit or is it a real problem maybe?
00:19:20 Oh, it's a definite problem.
00:19:22 I saw it as a kid.
00:19:23 I'd be like, okay, the direction I'm getting to do a project here,
00:19:27 is it based on a global strategy of this company
00:19:30 or is it based on a Canadian strategy?
00:19:34 And that's where you have to be careful
00:19:35 Because once you start to, you know, once you start to outsource the government, you're outsourcing it to companies that have then, you know, created their own globals.
00:19:45 They want, you know, if you're an IT company, now, and especially in this day and age with like AI, Quafer, think about it.
00:19:52 I'm an AI company.
00:19:54 I have global services.
00:19:56 You know, I was listening to Elon Musk yesterday.
00:19:59 His vision of the world is wild.
00:20:01 It is pretty different.
00:20:02 different yeah he's talking about ai data centers and uh being built on like on the moon now like
00:20:09 it's crazy this conversation yesterday i was watching and i'm thinking to myself wow this
00:20:13 is a little scary you know he's going to build it all up there and i'm and i'm thinking to myself
00:20:17 what is his vision of the globe so now he's the guy who's going to come in and give you consulting
00:20:23 services on starlink or something else like these are all interesting ideas no you raise a good
00:20:27 point the perspective coming from another if i was in dubai creating a project my perspective would
00:20:34 be from dubai right and with influence on wherever i'm doing business or you know diplomacy yeah
00:20:44 yeah you raise a good point i get it so essentially look we can be we can be directing
00:20:50 global efforts that don't really benefit us at home through these consultant firms
00:20:55 I can see that.
00:20:57 Well, they're coming to the table. 0.66
00:20:57 I mean, the last thing you want is to bring a finance and banking consultant from another country in to run your country.
00:21:03 Yeah.
00:21:04 Do you?
00:21:07 I'm not going.
00:21:07 That was just for fun.
00:21:09 That was just for fun.
00:21:10 No, no, but it is a very interesting scenario that we have to watch out for.
00:21:13 So then, you know, so this is the interesting part, and I'm going to go off on it for a minute.
00:21:19 We've not done, we've not looked at it that way, which I find totally bizarre at this point.
00:21:24 So we've kind of said, okay, we're going to allow third parties to come in, provide us advice.
00:21:29 We're going to take advice from them.
00:21:31 We're going to go in a direction.
00:21:32 And I think part of that is kind of why we get some of our wacky decisions. 0.76
00:21:37 And wacky to the point where we'll go over, we'll come up with an immigration policy that actually started in France somewhere, lasted 30 days, was a total bomb. 0.58
00:21:49 And we take it, we put it into Canada, and we leave it.
00:21:52 and we don't touch it again because some consulting firm put their name on it and we're like oh that's
00:21:57 okay they put their name on it like so i think the two things nobody wants to admit failure and
00:22:01 secondly well that's the policy we chose it did not work over there it didn't and a lot of times
00:22:07 we find in canada right now is these policies that we got from these consulting firms that
00:22:12 we transferred over to our own country they've already stale dated in the other country they
00:22:16 bombed and we let them go and we serve it and we let them go because we actually got comfortable
00:22:22 that someone else's name was on that so we'd like yeah my name's not on let it run right i'm still
00:22:28 getting my six weeks vacation i'm still getting my pension i'm still getting there so i don't have
00:22:32 to worry about it and we've done a lot of that in the last 10 years right it's been that is true
00:22:36 it's been a it's been a real travesty on how we've done it once again kind of behind the curtain
00:22:41 yeah yeah we've done about it but but you know mike before the show i went in and i started
00:22:46 looking around i said who has managed this really well so and and what i mean manage this so i'm
00:22:52 gonna uh but who is actually took a look at their uh contracts and their outsourcing of projects
00:23:00 really well and of course a country that we talk about quite a bit uh on the energy front which is
00:23:06 Norway um has done it exceptional so I want to talk to you I feel badly that the more we talk 0.55
00:23:12 about uh this country the more I feel like we're jinxing them everybody stay away from Norway okay
00:23:17 they've got it they've got it right many well I know my next trip I mentioned before the show I
00:23:21 am going there I think it's fascinating an amazing country actually it is well you well you know as
00:23:26 you look at this oil crisis and we go through it in everywhere around the world now it's impacting
00:23:31 you see this country which is not a huge country population wise you know it's about a quarter our
00:23:36 size um they just took a direction when uh the rest of the world didn't you know back in the 80s
00:23:43 in the late early 80s and they started to strategize on an eight-year cycle so they didn't
00:23:50 they didn't stick to the four-year election cycle right they started to create plans that were eight
00:23:55 you know eight years long now we you know uh u.s president was just in china and there was a lot
00:24:04 discussion on the airwaves about the difference between a communist and a you know a democratic
00:24:09 and free capitalist society um and one of the discussions that you heard a lot about is how
00:24:15 the long-term vision for china is the goal no matter who the leader is right norway have this
00:24:21 long 100 year plan 100 year plan and they work at it and they're not in a hurry they don't have to
00:24:26 you know you hear all these things norway is not the same it's a democratic society but but quite
00:24:32 frankly, they take a longer approach and they do that through the way they've structured their
00:24:38 government, which is interesting. So, and I took a look at a couple of things. So IT projects.
00:24:44 So their IT projects are only outsourced to companies to add on to their centralized backbone.
00:24:52 Okay. So what does that mean? That they already have created their own policy, procedures,
00:24:57 uh process yes well and they they basically have so the government is there's one department that
00:25:05 handles all the system systems for every ministry of government okay so and then the add-ons are
00:25:11 projects the plugins are into that system so consultants are hired but they're hired like
00:25:18 for example if we have the ministry of transportation and they're it actually reports
00:25:25 all into the central hub which is the backbone system of the government and there's an uh there's
00:25:31 an app or an addition or an extension of that system to take care of air traffic control to
00:25:37 take care of highway planning to take care of all those things that system works within the same
00:25:42 backbone and is secured the same by the bureaucracy of the country it's not outsource i understand so
00:25:49 the systematic outsourcing is transparent to that system. Yes. And likely only hired on once the
00:25:58 government has begun a project or has budgeted for this one specific part. They're not blanket
00:26:05 handing off ministries by and large to consultants. Right. You know, we talked about the 448,000
00:26:12 civil servants that we have on the federal level in Canada right now. I don't know. It's we did a
00:26:19 thing on the show and i'm probably going to get the number wrong so forgive me but the project
00:26:24 for payroll a new payroll system has gone on for a decade it's it's incredible tens of millions
00:26:30 over budget and it has no apparent end again outsourced quite frankly has been a runaway
00:26:39 program not getting to the end these are these are why our projects go the norwegians have taken
00:26:46 another approach they have a longer term planning cycle for all their programs like i said the eight
00:26:51 years they centralize their key technology and and it works for them the other thing they do that i
00:26:57 thought was really interesting they have labor laws that only allow let's call it a one-for-one
00:27:05 replacement of government workers so you can only replace one government worker with one consultant
00:27:11 or international yes and so if you have a if you have a key uh government worker go off leave
00:27:17 pregnancy whatever quite frankly you can bring in a consultant um i did that role i actually uh with
00:27:23 the one company i was with uh which was it was for bad accountants who were outsourced to become
00:27:28 cfos of companies who had lost their cfo okay so you can get a new cfo but you get one
00:27:34 until that other new cfo gets located rehired or comes back so they have very strict laws
00:27:41 uh the norwegians about how they don't get a team yes you get a person they're protecting
00:27:48 the institutional memory of the state i love that line that's a great line it is a great line and
00:27:53 very important to your uh because again the goals of your state won't necessarily align with the
00:28:00 goals of the outsourced consulting companies. In other words, what's good for Norway stays
00:28:07 what's good for Norway and doesn't necessarily have to plug into where consultants are in other
00:28:11 parts of the world trying to handle scenarios for those countries. Exactly. State authored
00:28:18 contracts. This is a really interesting approach. So we have the same thing. We don't use it. I
00:28:23 don't know why we don't use it. Sorry, we don't do this? No, no. So for some reason, again,
00:28:28 And I'm going to go off on a tangent for a minute, but a little bit of the outsourcing government.
00:28:33 You have to ask yourself, and when I'm reading through this, I'm thinking, okay, our governments go on a large number of trips, so abroad and conferences to learn about other governments.
00:28:50 so you think at some point in our history in our canadian history we would have figured out quite
00:28:55 frankly that we need to approach this a little differently but we obviously decided not to do it
00:29:01 and you got to ask yourself why do we like it the way it is because we know the way it is doesn't
00:29:07 work very efficiently like we're not uh our productivity in canada isn't like raging we're
00:29:13 We're not doing anything on a world record, world-breaking scale when it comes to manufacturing or mining or housing or anything else.
00:29:23 So we've got to ask ourselves, is it the system of choice by the governments over the last 50, 100 years?
00:29:34 Has it basically been something we've liked because it gives us more power on the political side?
00:29:43 There has to be a rationale for it because no rational mind would think that the way
00:29:47 we run this is the right state.
00:29:51 When we threw this show idea, my initial reaction was to hate the consulting thing
00:29:56 overall because of the transparency factor.
00:30:00 Right.
00:30:01 Then I started to think about the politicians that I've met over the years, and I thought,
00:30:05 oh boy, we really do need some experts.
00:30:07 Yeah.
00:30:07 As you and I talked, the one, I mean, I did point out that it was a bit of a whack-a-doodle idea that I had to illustrate a point.
00:30:15 It's a solution.
00:30:16 It's not the whole solution.
00:30:18 I think the solution that I hear in all of this, Paul, is that eight-year institutional memory.
00:30:26 that the institution of the government
00:30:31 remains beholden to this system
00:30:34 and we stick to it.
00:30:38 I think what happens in Canada
00:30:40 is we could have the same glory.
00:30:42 We could be having the same story right now.
00:30:44 Paul, like, okay, we, you know, one for one,
00:30:47 you know, we have a system by which
00:30:50 we only bring consultants in at this point.
00:30:51 We know exactly what they're doing.
00:30:53 We've made sure that there's nobody
00:30:55 that we could hire on full-time to do this in the government but we've lost control of that with
00:30:59 only two times more of the population so i think there is where the problem stems now how do you
00:31:09 unring the consulting bell how do you unring it well i guess you have to get people to commit to
00:31:16 it you know and that's if the intention is i guess you know and i think as canadians as we
00:31:20 get into the next phase of of what's going to happen in the country i think we have to ask
00:31:25 ourself do we need to do that now like i think that's the question we have to ask of our
00:31:31 governments do we need to stop this and do we need to internalize the talent and basically
00:31:36 create the institutional state uh memory um here at home um you know still using consulting firms
00:31:46 I'm not saying they're not, I was, I did it, I understand it, I think it does have value in places, but quite frankly, we can't dumb down our bureaucracy to the point where it doesn't have any powers or rights or, quite frankly, ability to alter change, figure out a long-term strategy for the country and enact it when we have a four-year voting cycle and we have consultants changing to and fro.
00:32:14 otherwise what we're doing is we're just creating a we're creating a sub industry of government
00:32:19 what we're doing is we're creating two two government industries one is an outsourced
00:32:24 which is almost as big as the insourced and therefore the two are battling constantly
00:32:30 the institutional memory is lost quite frankly because you got to think about it like i've
00:32:35 talked about my story i left the i left the country it's right i picked up and decided okay
00:32:40 i've seen that now i've globally understood what's going on i've decided to move off and
00:32:45 do other things you know before i came back and so you know as a young man it only made sense to
00:32:50 me that i had to learn more about the world so are these people that we're actually bringing in
00:32:55 to actually outsource to and they're creating these reports and projects and make things go
00:33:00 forward are they going to leave and and that's not good for canada that's the brain drain that
00:33:04 that we're trying to avoid. And that's really, we have no view on that. We have no eyeballs on
00:33:11 who comes and goes from a consulting firm because it is private. I think maybe somewhere in the
00:33:17 middle here, Paul, between my wackadoodle idea and how nicely it's been executed in Norway,
00:33:24 we have to find our way back to that center where we are. There is more transparency. We have
00:33:31 a longer institutional memory that would be a great thing for the next government to bring in
00:33:37 instead of telling us that you want more privacy for the conversations between government officials
00:33:42 and less privacy for Canadians why don't we focus on we're going to create something that gives us
00:33:48 longevity like Norway not something that's a flash in the pan idea that we're taking from
00:33:53 some country that helps us maintain a better UV rating I don't know yeah why don't we take
00:34:00 and reset this a little bit right in front of the eyes of Canadians saying here's where we've been
00:34:07 here's what we need to do to create it here's where it's working and here here are the pain
00:34:12 points to get us there but we're going to do it over eight years and we're going to pass it into
00:34:17 law so that no matter who comes in after us they're going to continue that strategy right well 0.67
00:34:22 it's interesting and also your contracting scenario so this is something the Norwegians
00:34:28 do really well they have a public and financial management board that forces vendors to standardize
00:34:37 risk shifting contracts so what they do it's a little different than we do so you sign a contract
00:34:42 with the government and for example arrive can that's one you sign a government that goes to a
00:34:49 centralized now we did have you know we do have this we don't do it very well and it's probably
00:34:54 because of discipline versus structure, but we don't do it very well. They do it very well. So
00:34:59 they centralize their contracts. They offload the risk. So as a consultant, you can get paid very
00:35:05 well, but you have to perform very well. So you couldn't have this payroll scenario where the
00:35:10 payroll system never gets built. You can't have this arrive can scenario where it starts at 64,000
00:35:16 or hands at a hundred million dollars, right? None of these can happen because you would not get
00:35:21 paid right these contracts are these contracts are very well written very preferred they're
00:35:26 centralized right so they come out of a centralized source um and they go forward so you know this has
00:35:32 been traditionally what they've done that's interesting because you know why paul if a
00:35:36 contract goes bad the same division of the government's going to handle it in court they're
00:35:42 going to have experts that know how to handle that on behalf of the government yes it becomes a very
00:35:47 tidy fairly transparent process for outsourcing yeah that's a really clever idea yeah no and but
00:35:57 but again these are around right and each of these now the interesting part is is it's is
00:36:02 it's assigned to a outsourced group and the norwegians actually assign a project manager to
00:36:09 it from the central source so not only does the the ministry that's working with the consulting
00:36:16 team but there's someone who comes in this i've seen this on the premier level a few times in
00:36:22 canada and i've seen premiers do this effectively where they create like these a team of people
00:36:27 yes and they assign them to major projects as they assign them to their ministries i think this
00:36:33 is an excellent idea it's an excellent idea when you want to get stuff done on a on a fast-paced
00:36:39 basis and and not in a crazy over budget you know bad timeline where do these people come from
00:36:45 They usually come from consulting firms, so they usually are older gentlemen and ladies that actually have retired or are retiring, have moved on and are finishing their career, and they come to work inside governments.
00:37:01 They can be lawyers, accountants, doctors, people kind of at the end of their career.
00:37:06 They have no axe to grind.
00:37:08 They've made their money.
00:37:09 I was going to say.
00:37:09 They're doing it for the public good before they retire, and they get a good salary.
00:37:13 I'm not saying they do it for free.
00:37:15 They get well paid, but they also manage projects to their retirement and then they go off.
00:37:20 And I think that that's done really well in other countries.
00:37:23 The Norwegians just do an excellent job.
00:37:26 The other thing Norwegians actually do really well that we need to take a lesson from,
00:37:31 their technology and monitoring and compliance as each of these projects are rolling out for their software in each of these projects
00:37:39 have really intense security systems that they can monitor.
00:37:43 So these aren't just projects they cast out into the world and let run out.
00:37:47 You know, they surveil them.
00:37:49 They track them.
00:37:50 They CRM them.
00:37:52 They do us.
00:37:52 So there's a whole system.
00:37:54 Like, by having central surveillance on the projects, they actually run the projects in an organized way like you would in a business, which, you know, our prime minister.
00:38:02 Sort of at 30,000 feet, but with a full view.
00:38:04 Yeah.
00:38:05 Now, our prime minister knows this.
00:38:07 Like, quite frankly, he's, you know, he has been a business person.
00:38:09 You could make the argument previously that some of our prime ministers probably didn't have the skill sets, right?
00:38:15 No, but the acumen of this guy is...
00:38:17 He would know this, right?
00:38:18 Corporate structure and organization.
00:38:20 He would know centralized systems.
00:38:22 He would know contracting.
00:38:23 He would know security.
00:38:24 He had been around major security firms that would have overseen projects on a national and on a provincial level.
00:38:31 So we know this as Canadians, but we decide not to do it.
00:38:36 And that's the crazy part of what's going on in the country right now.
00:38:39 now the worry i have this you know so because this can go on listen you know this debacle can
00:38:45 go on for as long as we want to go to go on as canadians the world's changing so i think what
00:38:51 all these people need to ask is the world change is this system sustainable like can you run a
00:38:59 decentralized system by ministry have them go just you know we've we've become um uh desensitized
00:39:08 we have to these to these messes that constantly we hear about so on a weekly monthly basis we
00:39:15 hear okay here's another runaway train this project took off never completed this another
00:39:20 so we got desensitized to these projects and to these things going on as they were outsourced and
00:39:27 they were put in the hands and reported on and you know money was put towards the budgets and
00:39:31 we started building them and constructing them we got desensitized but now it's eroded our
00:39:38 efficiency in our production in the country in a time that we have to pick back up again so now we
00:39:43 have to pick back up and and start to get people employed producing things and making things again
00:39:48 can we afford to keep doing this and that's my i guess i come back to that not a lot of shows mike
00:39:53 but my worry about the way we're doing this is is it sustainable well i mean we'll take a look at
00:40:00 the you know over the course of carney's uh four years uh you know let's assume that he he does a
00:40:07 four-year run as prime minister, this is hundreds of billions of dollars in consulting, both
00:40:14 internally, externally, on the main line and below the line, probably much, much more. So yeah,
00:40:21 I do agree that we need to do something about how we handle consulting. I guess what I'm worried
00:40:27 about, and I would put out there, Paul, this is conjecture, but I would put out there that if I
00:40:32 was voting in Norway, I would be voting for somebody with a lot more scrutiny in my heart
00:40:37 than I've probably done as a, somebody here in Ontario, because I'm desensitized because I see
00:40:43 the system is broken often. Right. But if you are in Norway and you saw this institutional memory,
00:40:50 well, you know, look at it's yours to protect and who you elect is who will protect. That's
00:40:57 a little rhyme I came up with for Norway. Yeah. Yeah. No, no, I get you. You know,
00:41:01 And when we go to the happiness shows, it always pops up of one of the happiest countries in the world.
00:41:06 It does, yeah.
00:41:07 Because housing, security, you know, the oil and gas scenario has created a wealth fund that has made them secure.
00:41:16 Their political system does seem well thought out and quite structured and planned.
00:41:22 So all these things, the comfort that you give to your country based on the things you're doing makes for happiness, right?
00:41:29 So the country is a happy country because, quite frankly, they're doing all these things to structure their government.
00:41:36 And I'm not saying get rid of consultants.
00:41:38 Just so we're on the same page.
00:41:40 I'm not saying get rid of consulting contracts.
00:41:44 I'm saying adopt some of these things.
00:41:47 Make the consulting contracts risk-based.
00:41:50 Have them absorb some of the risk.
00:41:52 Let's create a long-term strategy as well.
00:41:55 Centralize the contracts.
00:41:57 like we we should have been doing from day one quite frankly make them more driven to the
00:42:03 performance of the major projects that we're doing so listen if a bunch of smart people uh in uh
00:42:10 engineering firms go out and figure out amazing ways to mine things that makes us uh the world
00:42:15 leader yeah they should be compensated i would agree the wazoo yeah right but that's in the field
00:42:21 that's not doing a report to government that's actually executing a project the major project
00:42:27 It's a project. You're the third arm on that project that's going to go make sure that project
00:42:32 gets done on a timely basis. And that's where our money should be reallocated now. Our money
00:42:37 should be reallocated into infield performance for these companies. I feel like I got schooled,
00:42:43 Paul. No, you didn't. No, no, I really do. Because I think that you're right. I think that
00:42:47 many of the things that we could do, we just haven't done. And these were good suggestions.
00:42:53 And so poor Norway, man, we, they really are the test case for us. 0.97
00:42:58 Aren't they? They are. Uh, I hope you enjoy your vacation. Uh,
00:43:00 you won't need sunscreen. Thanks for joining us. Uh,
00:43:04 we'll catch you next time right here. Don't forget. You can subscribe,
00:43:07 tell your friends to do so you're supporting the network when you do that.
00:43:10 And you also get the full program, Paul. Thanks. I appreciate that.
00:43:13 Thanks Mike.