How Independent Media Is Changing Canada
Episode Stats
Words per minute
213.72647
Harmful content
Misogyny
1
sentences flagged
Toxicity
13
sentences flagged
Hate speech
1
sentences flagged
Summary
Jonathan Harvey is the co-founder of Blunder News and the creator of the award-winning podcast, BlunderNews. In this episode, we talk about how he got started in the world of social media and entrepreneurship, and how he became a voice for the voiceless and voiceless.
Transcript
00:00:00.240
Today's a big deal for me, because when I open up my email in the morning, the first thing that I open up is my Blender email with a connection to the Substack story for the day.
00:00:08.440
And often there's many of them, including a video, and that's kind of where I start.
00:00:15.900
It's my smoke detector, because when there's smoke, I find that a lot of their stories within hours, days, or maybe even a couple of weeks, there's a full burning fire on that topic.
00:00:26.800
And today we're going to talk to Jonathan Harvey.
00:00:39.800
The first email I open every day is, okay, let's see what Jonathan and Liam are up to and what kind of stories I should be watching.
00:00:50.100
Yeah, sending it out at 5.30 a.m., we end up at the top of the box for you, which is good.
00:00:55.420
If you're trying to get your content out there and you want to be competitive, let's start at 5.30 in the morning and get it out there.
00:01:02.360
So you've been on it for two and a half years now.
00:01:11.240
And then Liam jumped on board about four or five months later.
00:01:14.260
And the reason I started it is because through COVID, I started speaking out.
00:01:19.400
I was very frustrated with how the government was handling COVID, how they were handling everything, the lockdowns, you name it.
0.95
00:01:25.300
It was all kind of bullshit, to be honest with you.
0.96
00:01:28.100
And so I was speaking out against it because I owned several restaurants at the time and we were getting absolutely kneecapped.
0.98
00:01:32.820
And you actually made press at the time around those restaurants and your outrage.
00:01:46.100
I didn't have any of my videos canceled or removed from any platforms.
00:01:51.460
So, I mean, that to me says a lot given how very credible people were being taken off platforms at scale.
00:01:56.820
So, I managed to have that conversation from the alternative side of things and maintain enough balance that they couldn't cut me off.
00:02:09.060
Like, I scaled up to, you know, a hundred thousand or so users.
00:02:12.380
But what I found was everybody I met in public, everybody was super, super kind.
00:02:20.840
But they all said, you know, they appreciated what I was doing and that I was sort of,
00:02:24.800
I was sort of saying the things they were thinking that they were unable to say in a lot of cases.
00:02:32.140
I was like, okay, so this is leaving a significant impact in the community and with a lot of the right people.
00:02:41.820
So, once COVID sort of ended and I didn't have to continue talking about that anymore, I was like, what do I do with my time?
00:02:47.980
Now, I owned five restaurants at the time, just hanging on for dear life.
00:02:51.940
It was once a great business, became a very poor business quickly.
00:03:05.840
So, I started thinking, okay, what do I do next?
00:03:08.080
I've been an entrepreneur for the last 15 years.
00:03:11.500
Once you really live in the world of entrepreneurship, you don't really change gears.
00:03:14.880
You just love so much about having the freedom in it.
00:03:17.880
Comes with challenges, more responsibility, but more freedom.
00:03:20.800
So, I was like, okay, what am I going to do here?
00:03:23.780
It did make an impact, but how do I turn this into something more significant as the
00:03:28.480
So, that's where I came up with the idea for Blunder News.
00:03:30.960
And Blunder News really was like, okay, we're an independent voice for the people of Canada
00:03:36.680
And I was thinking about it economically, but more so impact.
00:03:40.120
You know, I like to use my hand as a tool when I talk about this.
00:03:44.460
Money used to be at the top as an entrepreneur, but then over time, it kind of flips.
00:03:48.620
And then all these other things become more important.
00:03:52.300
It is much more important than just making money.
00:03:54.220
So, I thought this would be a great way to positively impact the country.
00:03:59.500
So, my big goal was keep your foot on the gas until the next election.
00:04:08.280
Just make sure that you're leaving a positive impact.
00:04:10.680
And you're telling people what's really going on.
00:04:14.980
And Liam, like I said, jumped on board in December of the same year.
00:04:18.500
We've been a rather dynamic duo, if I do say so myself, since then.
00:04:26.680
And it's credible because you guys, you do your homework.
00:04:37.740
That really lends to credibility because you're not in an echo chamber.
00:04:42.020
That's the one thing I do notice about Blender.
00:04:43.940
You guys do not allow yourselves to be in an echo chamber.
00:04:46.500
I've seen you change your tune on things that were moments of honesty.
00:04:52.020
And I really do appreciate that about you and Liam.
00:04:56.400
You know, ultimately, we're truth seekers, the both of us.
00:05:01.020
We both ended up in the same room, but we took a completely different door.
00:05:06.020
Like, he's more history, philosophy, more like build the individual through learning
00:05:13.180
For me, I'm a little more of just a logic-based, number-based, objective person.
00:05:20.220
And we both kind of fell into this political space because it's what seemed to matter most.
00:05:24.220
So, when you take those two and put them together, it was interesting.
00:05:27.180
When we first met, my concern was, I was like, ah, there's going to be a lot of crossover here.
00:05:30.560
We're going to both be Kobe trying to shoot the ball.
00:05:36.920
Then the election came, and then I kind of learned a thing or two there.
00:05:42.680
We, and I don't mean to pump our tires, we had more views the month of the election than CBC News.
00:05:50.560
Like, it was bananas what our traction was like.
00:05:52.900
It seemed to me that CBC wasn't touching on any of the topics that you guys were.
00:05:56.520
By the way, I think that if you've ever sort of had a Blender experience only in passing, you might think that you guys are salacious on a topic or, but that's not the case.
00:06:11.320
You do get an even presentation of what a topic is.
00:06:15.900
But I think what is shocking to people is that they're not getting this news from their traditional media, which is, in a lot of cases, how we're building an audience as well.
00:06:24.320
People are just like, okay, well, I didn't even know that we were talking about that topic, and here it is.
00:06:31.900
Sometimes it's just one small key that unlocks several doors.
00:06:37.960
So, what I learned through the election was our goal was to try to change or at least shift the political, the winds just a little bit, even 1%, 3%, 5%, enough to make a difference.
00:06:50.580
And before, you know, the election, everybody was pointing at Polyev, he's going to be the guy, he's going to be the next prime minister, we're all set.
00:06:58.140
Trump came in, ruffled some feathers, they swapped out Carney, it was a smart move.
00:07:03.240
Carney seemed more centrist, so everybody kind of voted for him.
00:07:07.380
The independent media space really does not have, it does not carry a lot of weight.
00:07:17.320
So, one of the big reasons is because federal funding.
00:07:20.460
85% of all mainstream media, 85% of all mainstream media is funded by, at least in part, by the federal government.
00:07:27.740
My guess is about 50% to 60% of all independents are also funded by the federal government.
00:07:32.100
So, you've got the highways and the side streets.
00:07:35.020
90% of all news consumed by a Canadian comes from a subsidized source.
00:07:40.960
Do you know what people forget about it with that number?
00:07:42.960
The biggest spending advertising client on television and traditional media today is also the federal government.
00:07:50.080
So, not only do you get funding, but you get them as a client as well.
00:07:56.460
If Sleeman was a sponsor of True Patriot Love, do you think that, and they were a big spending sponsor,
00:08:04.460
do you think that we might do more articles or more presentations, podcasts, or TV shows that put drinking in a good light
00:08:15.380
Or we might diminish the effects and side effects of alcohol on our healthcare.
00:08:22.040
Of course we would, because we don't want to offend our sponsor.
00:08:25.880
And if anything, you want to get deeper into bed with them.
00:08:29.860
So, that narrative as the federal government, as that client, that's another layer.
00:08:36.700
It's not just the funding and the grant writing.
00:08:41.880
It's the same thing you see with big pharma in the United States, right?
00:08:44.280
Yes, they're buying ad space, but they're also stopping you from writing hit pieces on them, ultimately, right?
00:08:49.680
And so, we sort of unpacked all this after the election, and I was like, look,
00:08:54.440
we can't make as significant an impact as we'd like because there are not enough of us yet.
00:08:59.480
Hopefully, with things like True Patriot Love and other organizations that step up that are,
00:09:03.560
look, you're a little conservative, but you're really more centered than anything.
00:09:11.920
No, I'm disillusioned completely with party politics on the federal level, and even at
00:09:25.040
We need to see what they're actually doing with their time in their position at council,
00:09:29.620
as a premier, as a member of the legislature, whatever they are in there.
00:09:35.280
We need to watch what these people are doing and get them to work.
00:09:40.020
I mean, so when you kind of look at, if you just jump back into the media space, I totally
00:09:44.840
The challenge we have is there's no accountability, and our watchdogs, I was doing a piece on this
00:09:48.440
earlier, all the watchdogs are just bought and paid for at a total line, right?
00:09:51.880
We don't have a skeptical enough citizenry to push back, which is kind of where I'm getting
00:09:57.480
So the reason we continue to do the independent media is because there needs to be more of us.
00:10:03.040
Okay, there's not enough of us to shift elections just yet, but I think we get there over time.
00:10:07.180
And we know with the funding coming from the federal government, we have to do something
00:10:11.540
And as Canadians, in the world we live in today, we don't use physical violence or kinetic
00:10:21.440
So I hope this motivates others to do the same, and that's why we continue doing what we're
00:10:26.120
But ultimately, and to sort of go back to your point, one of the primary reasons we
00:10:31.900
do this is because you need citizens to be skeptical.
00:10:36.180
Not that they have to be skeptical of everything, not that they have to be conspiracy theorists
00:10:39.720
about everything, but you have to distrust your government at one time or another.
00:10:43.460
And I don't care, both parties, all parties, everyone, they're not always doing things
00:10:48.160
In a lot of cases, they're doing things for themselves.
00:10:50.320
Look at Trudeau, scandal after scandal after scandal.
00:10:52.780
The only reason he got away with it is because there was another bigger scandal next week.
00:11:01.500
So the other thing that I wanted to kind of, so with traditional media, by the way,
00:11:16.020
I don't, I can't tell you how many times I've looked at the camera and referenced something
00:11:19.820
that you said or something that I've watched on Juno with Candace.
00:11:23.760
You know, even Ezra is a superstar in Canada now because this non-traditional media is
00:11:30.480
so important to people and we're tired of paying for a state-run media outfit.
00:11:37.920
And that became really apparent in the last election that conservatives and liberals alike
00:11:44.400
don't like to see media so propped up financially.
00:11:48.020
Yeah, I mean, you don't want to spend $1.5 billion on CBC every year.
00:11:52.980
And we, like I said, we outpaced them during election month.
00:11:56.400
So for me, it's like you're just lighting your money on fire and paying for a propaganda
00:12:00.700
The system is very, very broken, which is why we jumped into the space.
00:12:04.040
Ultimately, we couldn't move the needle as much as we wanted to, but we still see the
00:12:09.640
And I'm glad people like you are jumping in and helping scale the independent space,
00:12:13.760
because I think this is the only way we start taking our country back.
00:12:17.480
And when people hear that, I just want to finish with something.
00:12:19.820
When people hear that, they think it means voting for the other side.
00:12:27.020
Stop operating through a lens of over-identification and ideology and believing everything you hear
00:12:32.420
and start living in a world of logic and reason again.
00:12:36.920
I just want you to have all the information and to make a logical decision.
00:12:43.560
But if you don't have all that information and you're not willing to address it in that
00:12:49.140
If you do put a, if you put a political party bag over your head, you will never see or hear
00:12:58.360
I have family members and friends that are so conservative or so liberal that they can't
00:13:04.780
hear that they're saying the same things often.
00:13:08.940
They won't, again, when you live in this emotional space, you give way to emotion over
00:13:16.260
You know, I look at the brain and it's like logic and reason, emotion, then there's function.
00:13:21.940
Like, I can't stop that by telling you it just happens.
00:13:24.620
And, and, and it kind of works in this hierarchy when you are overtaken with emotion.
00:13:28.900
When everything around you is politicized, everything, you become identified with it.
00:13:33.680
When it's part of your identity, you're emotional about it.
00:13:38.720
All my stuff is Apple, but I, I, I understand what I'm doing.
0.94
00:13:48.860
Someone's going to have it one way or another, but I know that I'm emotionally tied to the
00:13:54.720
And I know that there are superior products now.
0.95
00:13:59.740
And when you put this umbrella, now imagine we're just talking about tech and Apple.
00:14:04.320
If you throw a political umbrella over everything, because everything is politicized now, whether
00:14:08.980
it's the education system and what we're teaching kids to the economy, to you, you name it, travel,
00:14:16.840
Some, there, there is some government department overseeing everything because they're expanding
00:14:22.040
So that means everything you're looking at has got this political umbrella over it.
00:14:27.860
And it's politicized because it's often, and we have it right now in Canada, even just
00:14:32.880
not with the majority, there is a political party in charge of that fuel in the tank.
00:14:40.800
If I can get you to vote with your emotion, then I always win.
00:14:44.800
And the more people I can convince to vote with emotion, the more people I will continue
00:14:48.980
Because if anybody was using logic or reason during the last election, they would have
00:14:53.760
And I'm being, I'm being a hundred percent honest.
00:14:56.320
Again, I don't support the conservative party at all times during the last election.
00:15:02.960
So that tells me at scale, we voted with emotion.
00:15:06.140
I have to tell you that was, that's exactly how I felt and things, the tide turns so
00:15:14.760
You know, advertising, marketing can't do that.
00:15:19.400
And that's what I think what we witnessed there.
00:15:28.580
So when she came here or her family came here, and I know this from my own experience
00:15:34.800
with friends from the neighborhood I grew up in, when their grandparents came here,
00:15:38.800
the first thing they got, they didn't have a phone in Italy.
00:15:41.920
They would go up the hill to the local restaurant that had the phone and somebody called for
00:15:46.040
them and they had to wait and dah, dah, dah, dah, dah.
00:15:48.400
And they came to Canada and Bell Canada said, here, have a phone.
00:15:52.020
And they said, well, no, no, you have the phone.
00:16:01.000
So by the way, this is not paid for by Bell Canada, trust me, but it's interesting that
00:16:07.760
that brand loyalty, that emotion, I got my very own phone, not a shared phone.
00:16:18.340
So I think that that is part of the problem that we have when emotion goes up against
00:16:37.600
So if you look back at all the prime ministers you've had, the majority of them have been
00:16:47.580
We only vote conservative when we have a problem so that we can correct course.
00:16:51.460
And if the problem's not big enough, we don't vote for that person.
00:16:53.760
So what Canada is always looking for at scale, historically, is they're looking for a reason
00:17:00.480
And that's what they, that's what Carney gave them.
00:17:15.480
Having said that, it would behoove me to not let you get out of this room before I ask
00:17:20.780
you some questions about Blender because you're like my hockey hero sitting here in a lot
00:17:29.980
of ways because I do follow you guys and I've admired it for a long time.
00:17:43.820
So we built, what I did out of the gates was I built a list of resources and it's just
00:17:51.760
And so if you read the newsletter, I actually do all the curation on that still every day
00:17:56.840
I, other than, so Liam will do a couple of headliners and then I'll do everything else.
00:18:01.360
And I just go through my sources every day and I just kind of find what's hot, what's
00:18:06.020
One of the things that I found, and I don't need to pump my tires here is people have bought
00:18:13.920
And it's not just always my perspective, but it's my curation of what I think is important
00:18:18.600
So if you, as you read through the newsletter, you have your three headline stories.
00:18:26.480
So, but those aren't just like a recap of what we're hearing.
00:18:28.680
No, they're usually a completely different angle on the stories that we're missing.
00:18:35.900
So one is, you know, I don't take one source and take it as gospel.
00:18:40.280
You look for multiple sources from different angles, different sides.
00:18:42.840
Um, I think the other thing is just how we process, how we think we have a certain way
00:18:49.820
And what happens over time is there's this compound effect of the information you consume.
00:18:54.200
When you consume the news every single day around the world, what happens is you start
00:18:58.320
to understand how the whole mechanism works, not just one thing on its own.
00:19:01.940
And I think that would be what you're, what you're saying is that we understand how the
00:19:06.580
So if I see something over here, it's not isolated.
00:19:12.300
He will often take a historical or philosophical angle where I will take more current event,
00:19:17.540
but that's basically how we add more value or perspective to these stories.
00:19:22.520
That's a great description because if the alarm is ringing over here, it's having these four
00:19:27.400
effects, you guys will find one of these we're not thinking about and tie it to all four and
00:19:34.020
bring it back often before the traditional media does.
00:19:38.260
I mean, I think the thing with media is I think there's a lot of brilliant people in the space,
00:19:41.860
but they're told to go two or three steps deep, whereas we'll go eight or 10, because that's
00:19:48.900
You guys seem to eliminate, uh, three through, uh, nine often and start like, okay, here's where
00:19:55.160
we are and by the way, here's where it ends up.
00:19:59.120
Well, I think we, we trust our audience to be the type of person that is, is pretty heavily
00:20:05.000
invested in what's going on around the world and in Canada.
00:20:09.100
If you want to get more people involved in independent news, you can't go super deep because
00:20:14.820
if you explain some, if, if you have, let's say one of, one of our family members, that's
00:20:19.940
If they jump into what I'm doing and they, they, they, they sort of have to go down a rabbit
00:20:25.140
So they have to challenge a lot of their beliefs all at once.
00:20:27.940
You almost have to make it impossible for them to go no at the headline.
00:20:31.740
Well, because you don't want, you don't want to create that opposition of thought.
00:20:40.920
And if they do engage, if you go too deep, you're sort of asking too much of them.
00:20:45.660
So, you know, with our network, we have an audience where we go pretty deep because they
00:20:50.500
are the people that have invested more time into this and actually want that level of
00:21:07.700
They want to move on with their day and get their latte.
00:21:11.600
So we are not the best news organization for people to migrate from being centrist or
00:21:19.380
And the thing is, is we're not even right wing.
00:21:27.860
As I point out, I, I don't see you as politically affiliated.
00:21:33.820
We're not never taking a dime from anybody on either side of the aisle either.
00:21:38.820
No, I think that your shtick is actually health foods.
00:21:43.420
Like you guys like to live a healthy lifestyle.
00:21:53.240
I think that I don't think, I don't see blender going away over time, but I do see guys like
00:21:59.720
yourself and Liam evolving into becoming more of the, the, and maybe even some of us here
00:22:05.800
at true Patriot love becoming that mainstream face that people see.
00:22:14.160
And I don't, I'll tell you what I see is there's two things to consider here.
00:22:18.780
There's the, there's the, um, individual brand loyalty, and then there's the company brand
00:22:24.940
It's becoming harder to build company brand loyalty.
00:22:31.560
Influencers as individuals are more trustworthy.
00:22:33.600
And I'm cool with that because they actually have a lot on the line.
00:22:39.140
You just kind of move on to the next journalist.
00:22:40.820
And they just hide that person for a little while.
00:22:44.380
So as individuals, I see myself and Liam, um, probably growing beyond the national conversation
00:22:52.560
Um, I still think we'll be a part of it here, but I don't think it'll just be the primary
00:22:57.080
I know both of us have bigger ambitions and it's not a hack against Canada.
00:23:00.600
It's just when you're in this space, there are, there are levels.
00:23:05.000
There's single A, double A, triple A in the majors.
00:23:12.820
I won't be those guys because they're who they are and I'm who I am.
00:23:15.300
But it's getting into those conversations, you know, the Constantine Kissins, you know,
00:23:20.520
Canadians are good at this, by the way, historically, you know, we ship a lot of broadcasters and
00:23:26.780
Two other places in the world, the UK, the US, uh, and English speaking, uh, countries
00:23:31.940
around the world love our commentary, the way that we speak, the way that we, uh, look
00:23:39.080
I can see your brand becoming popular in America or in Britain.
00:23:46.360
Uh, I noticed the other day, he's like in Britain covering stuff and I thought to myself, well,
00:23:51.080
that's great because these are the voices that we actually want to see out there representing
00:23:56.800
And yeah, it was from his phone and yes, he had his press jacket on and he was doing the
00:24:03.240
But what I really appreciated about it was he was doing it.
00:24:08.980
I also notice among the, um, non-traditional media groups out there, like yourself or us,
00:24:14.600
uh, there is a certain kindness among us where there we're, we're not chomping at each other's
00:24:27.920
The other thing that I think adds credibility to you guys is that you, and I'll ask you this
00:24:33.480
afterward, but you tend to follow a story until the end.
00:24:40.860
Most media drops a story eight minutes in and we never hear about it again.
00:24:50.540
When, when it's time to hold somebody accountable, often those are the people paying their bills.
00:24:56.800
They'll, they'll once in a while stand up to the government to make it seem like they're
00:24:59.740
nonpartisan, but they just do it to flap their wings and just to, it's basically a
00:25:05.300
Um, to go back to sort of your question before with Blender, I see Blender continuing to be
00:25:10.460
a strong independent, um, organization in Canada and we're going to add more journalists to it in
00:25:16.100
Um, I'm actually shifting myself down to the U S to be quite honest with you.
00:25:19.400
Like, I like being an entrepreneur a lot more than I like being a journalist.
00:25:28.840
Um, I seem to have a knack for it, but it's not my say true passion.
00:25:36.860
So I'll continue to do a podcast and continue speaking out and doing things like that.
00:25:45.480
And I just jumped into the media space because that was where I thought I could use those tools.
00:25:52.980
And then I ended up becoming a little more of a journalist that I had anticipated.
00:25:57.580
I have, I have, but you know, to your question about longevity, I think the international conversation
00:26:03.560
I would like to see us expand, like you said, into other markets, scale up with more journalists
00:26:07.320
and become a, uh, at least a steady voice in the nation because we've built enough, enough
00:26:17.120
Um, but yeah, for myself, I'm a little more fluid.
00:26:20.920
I, I have a feeling whatever happens next will be, uh, equally good.
00:26:24.000
I hope you continue in the media space because, uh, we need leaders doing stuff, uh, that
00:26:33.620
And there's a lot of people out there that are looking for new ways to look at things.
00:26:40.160
What have you ever done a story and you were like, oh shit, we were so wrong about that.
0.93
00:26:53.540
Um, the, the, the one, um, and we, we corrected right away.
00:27:03.260
When, when the Epstein list thing came out, there was this story about Stephen Hawking
00:27:17.240
They did such a good job of embedding that story.
00:27:21.540
Um, and that's obviously not the stuff we usually cover anyway, but yeah, no, no, no.
00:27:28.180
Um, otherwise, yeah, no, like we've had one other thing we got wrong.
00:27:33.400
I think that it can happen more often than not.
00:27:36.860
Well, I think that has a lot to do with your research and, and just checking your sources
00:27:42.420
You've kept them safe and a lot of stuff has come out that started from Blender.
00:27:47.640
Where can people actually get connected with Blender?
00:27:52.060
Um, so you can find us at, uh, Blender news on most platforms at Blender dot report on
00:27:58.080
Instagram, because we lost our first one due to bill C 18.
00:28:04.180
Uh, and then you can find us on Spotify, Blender report.
00:28:06.700
And then if you want to sign up for our daily newsletter, go to Blender news.
00:28:12.960
It goes up five days a week and that's where you will find us.
00:28:15.840
Thank you for joining us for a conversation with the guy who starts my day every day and
00:28:22.260
Uh, I recommend that you sign up, uh, and join along with me because a lot of the stuff
00:28:26.220
that I talk about comes from this very, uh, this very newsletter, uh, that I receive every
00:28:33.720
Subscribe, like, tell a friend, hate, whatever you need to do.
00:28:38.460
If there's something that we said that you don't like or love, uh, we want to know, but